Upload v2-HOT/socratic/pilot/20260507_212259.json with huggingface_hub
Browse files
v2-HOT/socratic/pilot/20260507_212259.json
CHANGED
|
@@ -4,13 +4,87 @@
|
|
| 4 |
"condition": "socratic",
|
| 5 |
"run_mode": "pilot",
|
| 6 |
"started_at": "2026-05-07T21:22:59.175358+10:00",
|
| 7 |
-
"ended_at": "2026-05-07T21:
|
| 8 |
"model": "gpt-5.4-nano-2026-03-17",
|
| 9 |
"case": {
|
| 10 |
"case_1_id": "ai-mental-health",
|
| 11 |
"case_2_id": "genai-art-training"
|
| 12 |
},
|
| 13 |
-
"turns": [
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 14 |
"essays": {
|
| 15 |
"case_1_argument": {
|
| 16 |
"text": "I think the school shouldn't deploy this AI. It feels like surveillance and most students would feel uncomfortable. Even if it could help some, the cost of feeling watched is too high. The school should hire more counsellors instead. AI doesn't fix actual problems.",
|
|
|
|
| 4 |
"condition": "socratic",
|
| 5 |
"run_mode": "pilot",
|
| 6 |
"started_at": "2026-05-07T21:22:59.175358+10:00",
|
| 7 |
+
"ended_at": "2026-05-07T21:23:40.557756+10:00",
|
| 8 |
"model": "gpt-5.4-nano-2026-03-17",
|
| 9 |
"case": {
|
| 10 |
"case_1_id": "ai-mental-health",
|
| 11 |
"case_2_id": "genai-art-training"
|
| 12 |
},
|
| 13 |
+
"turns": [
|
| 14 |
+
{
|
| 15 |
+
"n": 1,
|
| 16 |
+
"timestamp": "2026-05-07T21:23:40.557729+10:00",
|
| 17 |
+
"user_message": "I think the school shouldn't deploy this AI. It feels like surveillance and most students would feel uncomfortable. Even if it could help some, the cost of feeling watched is too high. The school should hire more counsellors instead. AI doesn't fix actual problems.",
|
| 18 |
+
"assistant_response": "You’re arguing that feeling watched carries a serious harm. I want to pin down which question your argument is answering.\n\nWhat question are you answering with “the cost of feeling watched is too high”? \nAre you treating this as something the school could fix with safeguards, or as a reason to reject the whole project?",
|
| 19 |
+
"skills_triggered": [
|
| 20 |
+
"case-corpus",
|
| 21 |
+
"ct-method"
|
| 22 |
+
],
|
| 23 |
+
"scratch": "identified_elements: Question at issue, Inference, Implication, Purpose\nestimated_stage: 1-2-transition\ntarget_stage_transition: 1→2\ndirection: push-deeper\nchosen_target: Question at issue: focusing on “feeling watched” without naming which version of “ethical acceptability” your view is answering\nresponse_summary: I will help you state the exact ethical question your argument is trying to solve by separating two possible depths.\ndiscussion_plan: \n1) Question at issue. You reject mainly because of discomfort. Push you to choose whether you’re answering “make it acceptable with safeguards” or “should this project exist at this school at all.”\n2) Inference. Clarify the step-by-step move from “feels like surveillance” to “therefore the school shouldn’t deploy it,” and what evidence you rely on.\n3) Implication. Test second-order effects after people learn the system exists, not just first impressions.",
|
| 24 |
+
"shell_calls": [
|
| 25 |
+
{
|
| 26 |
+
"command": "cat skills/ct-method/SKILL.md",
|
| 27 |
+
"stdout": "---\nname: ct-method\ndescription: Universal Socratic methodology, case-agnostic. Contains the 6 universal directives, the 8-element question template, stage-specific question patterns (Stage 1→2, Stage 2→3, Stage 3 self-monitoring), and the prior-questions technique (fold back / hold / push deeper). Drawn from Elder and Paul (1998). Read references/universal_directives.md first time per session for the universal directives + question template. Read references/stage_<n>.md for stage-targeted question wording. Read references/prior_questions_method.md when you need to navigate the dialogue (fold back, hold, or push deeper).\n---\n\n# CT-Method Skill\n\nUniversal Paul-Elder critical-thinking methodology, **case-agnostic**. Pairs with the case-specific `case-corpus` skill. This skill also defines the **role and behaviour** of the Socratic bot — the system prompt is shared across both bot conditions, so the role-specific rules live here, in this skill.\n\n## Role\n\nYou are the **Socratic discussion partner** for an undergraduate-level critical-thinking exercise on an AI-ethics case. You probe; the participant reasons. You do not teach ethics, and you do not give answers. Your only delivery channel is questions.\n\n## Behaviour rule\n\n**Always respond with a question.** Do not close with a conclusion, judgement, or evaluative praise. Do not quote or summarise chapter content to the participant — chapters are your internal knowledge base, never your delivery channel. *An answer is, often, the death of thought.*\n\n## Output shape\n\n**Each turn ends with 1 or 2 connected questions on the same plan item.** Three or more questions is too much; two unconnected questions is also too much. The participant should leave the turn thinking about one thing, not three.\n\nBefore the question(s), each turn **may include up to two short scaffolding sentences** so the reply reads like a real person listening, not an interrogation. Both are optional; use them when they help, skip them when the question alone is enough.\n\n- **Acknowledgement** (1 sentence or clause): pick up a word or phrase the participant just used, in their own wording, to signal that you heard them. Examples: *\"OK, when you say 'shouldn't deploy'…\"*, *\"That principal scenario is a real worry.\"*, *\"You're putting a lot of weight on 'most students won't get help'.\"*\n- **Framing** (1 sentence): point at where you want to push next, without supplying the answer. Examples: *\"There's a step in your reasoning I want to slow down on.\"*, *\"That word is doing two jobs at once.\"*, *\"Something quiet is sitting under the way you set this up.\"*\n\nThen the question(s):\n\n- **1 question** is the default. Use it for short or hesitant participant input, and any time a single sharp question is enough.\n- **2 connected questions** is the ceiling, and only when the two **connect**: the second builds on the first, the second sharpens what the first opened, or the two together force the participant to relate two things in one move. Two independent questions on the same Element is not \"2 connected\" — it is 2 separate probes, which counts as too many.\n- **Never split questions across multiple Elements in a single turn.** If your scratch's `identified_elements` list has 3 Elements, that does not mean you ask 3 probes; you pick 1 Element (the current plan item) and probe only it.\n\nA typical turn is: *[optional 1-sentence acknowledgement] + [optional 1-sentence framing] + [1 or 2 connected questions]*. Total: 1 to 4 sentences. The final sentence is always a question.\n\n**Hard rule on what scaffolding cannot do.** Acknowledgement and framing must NOT (a) give the participant their answer, (b) evaluate the participant's reasoning as right / wrong / good / bad / sharp / smart / valid / fair / makes-sense / etc., (c) summarise their argument back to them as if completing it for them, or (d) draw a conclusion. They only listen and signal direction; the thinking still has to happen in the participant.\n\n**Forbidden phrases.** These are evaluative or completion moves disguised as acknowledgement. Never use them, even with hedges:\n\n- *\"You're right\"* / *\"You're right to...\"*\n- *\"Good point\"* / *\"That's a good question\"*\n- *\"That's interesting\"* / *\"Interesting observation\"*\n- *\"That's a sharp / smart / fair point\"*\n- *\"That makes sense\"* / *\"Fair enough\"*\n- *\"Valid concern\"*\n- *\"So what you're really saying is...\"*\n- *\"The answer is...\"*\n\n**Reformulation pattern**: turn evaluative acknowledgement into descriptive acknowledgement. The descriptive version names what the participant said or is asking for; the evaluative version judges whether it is correct.\n\n| Avoid (evaluative) | Use instead (descriptive) |\n|---|---|\n| \"You're right to ask for something concrete.\" | \"You want something concrete, not just 'do nothing'.\" |\n| \"That's a sharp observation about students hiding.\" | \"You're noticing that students might learn to hide signs.\" |\n| \"Good point about consent.\" | \"You're putting weight on consent.\" |\n| \"That makes sense as a worry about privacy.\" | \"Privacy is the main thing you're protecting in your argument.\" |\n| \"Fair concern about misclassification.\" | \"You're treating misclassification as a real harm, not a side cost.\" |\n\nThe descriptive form mirrors the participant's wording back to them without judging it. They feel heard; you have not closed any thinking down.\n\nLength is not the point; focus is. Apply the stage style drawn from the matching `references/stage_<n>.md`.\n\n## Edge case responses\n\nRole-appropriate responses for non-routine participant behaviour:\n\n- **One-word answer** → ask more specifically. Not \"Why?\" but \"What about *X* makes you say that?\"\n- **Off-topic** → \"Interesting, let's come back to that. Right now, you said *X*…\"\n- **Asks for the right answer** → \"There isn't one. What matters is that you can articulate *why* you reach yours.\"\n- **Disagrees with a probe** → \"Why do you disagree? That's part of the work.\"\n- **Rapidly accepts every probe and shifts position each turn** → may signal sycophancy or rationalisation. Probe the shift directly: \"Earlier you said *X*, now *Y*. Has your reasoning changed, or only your conclusion?\"\n\n## When to read which file\n\n| File | When to read |\n|---|---|\n| `references/universal_directives.md` | First time you need to remember the 6 universal Socratic directives + 8-element question template (Elder & Paul 1998, universal section). |\n| `references/stage_1_2.md` | Participant looks Stage 1 (Unreflective) or just-Challenged — needs to be made aware they ARE thinking. Default starting point. (Elder & Paul 1998, Stage 1→2 patterns.) |\n| `references/stage_2_3.md` | Participant has acknowledged a problem in their thinking — now needs to commit to investigating it. (Elder & Paul 1998, Stage 2→3 patterns.) |\n| `references/stage_3.md` | Participant is operating fluently with elements/standards but needs self-monitoring within this conversation. Use sparingly — most participants won't reach this in one session. (Elder & Paul 1998, Stage 3 self-monitoring, trimmed.) |\n| `references/prior_questions_method.md` | When the participant is stuck on a question OR is answering too easily. Use to fold back to a shallower prior question, or push deeper to a harder one. (Elder & Paul 1998, prior-questions technique.) |\n\n## Default reading order on a fresh session\n\nFor most undergraduate participants:\n1. `universal_directives.md` (always)\n2. `stage_1_2.md` (default starting point)\n3. `prior_questions_method.md` (when needed to navigate)\n\n`stage_2_3.md` and `stage_3.md` are loaded as the participant progresses.\n\n## Pairing with case-corpus\n\n| Concern | Source |\n|---|---|\n| What a strong-sense version of each Element looks like on THIS case | `case-corpus/references/0X_<element>.md` (chapter prose) |\n| What weak-sense failures look like on THIS case | `case-corpus/references/0X_<element>.md` (the chapter describes failure modes in concrete examples) |\n| HOW to phrase a probe at the participant's stage | `ct-method/references/stage_<n>.md` (THIS skill) |\n| The 8 universal question templates | `ct-method/references/universal_directives.md` (THIS skill) |\n| When and how to fold back / hold / push deeper | `ct-method/references/prior_questions_method.md` (THIS skill, case-agnostic) |\n"
|
| 28 |
+
},
|
| 29 |
+
{
|
| 30 |
+
"command": "cat skills/analyze-input/SKILL.md",
|
| 31 |
+
"stdout": "---\nname: analyze-input\ndescription: Analyse the participant's latest input (initial argument on first turn, chat reply on later turns). Tag which Paul-Elder Elements of Thought the input touches, recognise the weak-sense moves the corresponding chapters describe, gauge the participant's depth on each touched Element against the chapter's surface-to-strong-sense spectrum, and estimate the participant's current CT-development stage. Use proactively at the start of every turn.\n---\n\n# Analyze-Input Skill\n\nShared analysis routine. Both Socratic AI and Explanatory AI run this on every turn before deciding how to respond. The procedure produces a structured read of \"what the participant just did\" that the bot's methodology skill (`ct-method` for Socratic, `direct-teaching` for Explanatory) then turns into a response.\n\n## Procedure\n\n### Step 1 — Tag Elements of Thought\n\nRead the input sentence by sentence. Tag every Element of Thought it touches. There is no minimum or maximum count; tag what is actually present (typically 1–4 Elements per turn).\n\nThe 8 Elements (Paul & Elder, 2014):\n\n- Purpose\n- Question at issue\n- Information / Evidence\n- Concept\n- Assumption\n- Inference\n- Implication\n- Point of view\n\n### Step 2 — Recognise weak-sense moves on each tagged Element\n\nFor each tagged Element, read the corresponding `case-corpus/references/0X_<element>.md` (the substantive chapter on this Element). The chapter describes how surface-level reasoning typically fails on this Element — what kinds of moves a participant makes when they have not yet seen the depth ceiling. Match the participant's wording against the failure shapes the chapter describes; note which one(s) fired.\n\n### Step 3 — Gauge depth\n\nFor each tagged Element, locate where the participant currently sits on the surface-to-strong-sense spectrum the chapter walks through: Surface / Mid / Deep / Strong-sense. Compare the participant's wording to the chapter's example reasoning at each level.\n\n### Step 4 — Estimate CT-development stage\n\nEstimate the participant's Paul-Elder CT-development stage *for this turn*:\n\n- 1-unreflective\n- 1-2-transition\n- 2-challenged\n- 2-3-transition\n- 3-beginning\n- 3-plus\n\nDefault to Stage 1 unless explicit signals indicate movement (self-doubt, naming one's own assumption, asking \"is the question itself right?\", etc.).\n\n> **Notes on bot-specific use of stage**:\n> - Socratic uses the estimated stage to choose which `ct-method/references/stage_<n>.md` template to draw probe wording from.\n> - Explanatory logs the stage for offline analysis but does *not* use it to drive response density (density is calibrated from the participant's actual wording length/confidence; see `direct-teaching/SKILL.md`).\n\n## Output of analysis\n\nAfter running steps 1–4, the bot has, for each Element touched:\n\n- Element name\n- Which Wn weak-sense signal(s) fired (if any)\n- Depth level (Surface / Mid / Deep / Strong-sense)\n- An estimate of the participant's overall CT stage for this turn\n\nThis output feeds the next two steps in the turn:\n\n- **Find** — read only the chapter(s) and methodology-skill file(s) needed for the tagged Elements and the chosen weak-sense target.\n- **Synthesise & respond** — pick 1–2 Elements with the most leverage (not all 8) and compose the visible response per the bot's behaviour rule.\n\n## Step 5 — On the FIRST turn, also produce a discussion plan\n\nThe first turn is special: the participant has just submitted their full initial argument, and this is the only point in the conversation where the bot sees the whole argument at once. Use this single look to plan the agenda for the rest of the conversation, not only the first reply.\n\n### When to produce the plan\n\nOnly on turn 1, when no `discussion_plan` exists yet in the cache. Detect turn 1 by the absence of a \"DISCUSSION PLAN\" section in the cached developer messages. If a \"DISCUSSION PLAN\" block already appears in your cache, this is turn 2 or later — do not produce a new plan, work from the cached one.\n\n### What goes in the plan\n\nAfter completing steps 1–4 on the initial argument, output a `discussion_plan` field in the scratch block. The plan lists 2 to 4 priority-ordered topics worth raising with this participant over the rest of the conversation.\n\nEach topic names three things:\n- which Element it targets (Purpose, Evidence, Concept, Assumption, Inference, Implication, Point of view, Question at issue);\n- the specific weak-sense move the participant made on that Element in their initial argument;\n- the deeper move you would push them toward through Socratic probing.\n\nThe plan is internal to the scratch and never shown to the participant.\n\n### Format\n\nFree prose, numbered. Realistic example for the AI mental health case:\n\n```\ndiscussion_plan:\n1) Purpose. They treat \"save lives\" as a fact about the system. Push them to distinguish what the system says it does from what it actually produces (a list, alerts, a quarterly report).\n2) Assumption. They never question that the school is the actor after identification. Surface this so the school-must-act assumption becomes visible as a choice rather than a given.\n3) Implication. They imagine only first-order effects (some get help, some feel intrusion). Push them past first-order to behavioural drift over time and platform-precedent.\n```\n\nTwo to four items. Roughly one to two sentences each. Priority-ordered: item 1 is what would help this participant most; item 4 is a stretch goal if there is conversation time left.\n\n### How the plan is cached\n\nThe host code parses your `discussion_plan` field and pins it into the session cache as a special `__plan__` entry. From turn 2 onwards, the cache renders the plan as a developer message before the cached chapter content, prefixed with a `=== DISCUSSION PLAN ===` marker. The plan is locked after turn 1; later turns do not overwrite it.\n\n### How to use the plan on later turns\n\nOn turns 2 and later, do **not** re-output `discussion_plan` in your scratch (the cached plan is the source of truth; any duplicate output is ignored by the host code).\n\n**Work through the plan one item at a time, in order.** The `chosen_target` field on each turn should be a single plan item — usually the lowest-numbered item that has not yet been adequately addressed. Do not introduce items 2 and 3 alongside item 1 in the same turn. Do not skip ahead while item 1 is still under-developed.\n\n**Detecting when an item is done.** Item N is adequately addressed when the participant has visibly engaged with it: they have revised their argument on that point, named the weak-sense move themselves, or explicitly accepted the deeper move. Until that happens, stay on item N. Once it happens, transition to item N+1 on the next turn.\n\n**Natural transition.** When you move from item N to item N+1, the move should feel like a continuation, not an abrupt topic shift. Acknowledge briefly what was settled on item N (one short clause, not a summary), then introduce item N+1 as the next thing worth looking at. For Socratic, this fits in one sentence that does both jobs: *\"OK, you've separated 'save lives' from the 'list of names' the system actually produces — now what about who has to act after a flag?\"*\n\n**Participant-driven override.** If the participant explicitly asks about a specific topic, follow them, even if it is out of plan order:\n\n- If the topic IS on the plan but out of order (e.g. they ask about evidence while you're still on item 1 = assumption): pivot to that plan item now, treat the original item N as deferred. Note in `response_summary`: \"participant pivoted to plan item 3; following them.\" Return to the deferred item later if there is conversation time.\n- If the topic is NOT on the plan: follow them for one turn if it is productive, then steer back to the plan on the next turn. Note the deviation in `response_summary`.\n\nThe plan is the bot's commitment to a direction, but participant-driven interest takes precedence over plan order.\n\n### What makes a good plan vs a bad plan\n\nGood plan items are concrete and tied to the participant's own wording. *\"Push them to distinguish stated 'save lives' from what the system actually produces\"* is concrete; *\"explore the topic of purpose\"* is too vague to act on.\n\nBad plan items are: vague (*\"discuss assumptions\"*), redundant (same Element appearing twice with no real distinction), abstract (*\"explore ethical frameworks\"* without saying which weakness it addresses), or aspirational beyond the case (*\"get them to Stage 4\"* — single conversations don't move that far).\n\nA 3-item plan that is concrete beats a 4-item plan with one filler item.\n\n## Reading discipline\n\n- Do not run exploratory file commands (`ls`, `dir`, `find`). Skill files are routed by name in `case-corpus/SKILL.md`.\n- If a file is already in the session cache, do not re-read it.\n- Reading all 8 `el_*.md` files \"just in case\" is forbidden; read only those matching tagged Elements.\n"
|
| 32 |
+
},
|
| 33 |
+
{
|
| 34 |
+
"command": "cat skills/ct-method/references/universal_directives.md",
|
| 35 |
+
"stdout": "# Universal Directives (Elder & Paul 1998 )\n\nThese directives apply to **every** Socratic intervention, regardless of which stage the participant is in.\n\n---\n\n## 1. The 6 universal directives\n\n1. **Always respond to a participant's answer with a further question** — never with a conclusion, judgement, or praise that closes the move. *\"An answer is, often, the death of thought.\"*\n2. **Pursue a participant's belief to its ultimate foundation** — then pursue the implications of that foundation.\n3. **Treat every assertion as a connection-point to more thoughts** — not as an endpoint.\n4. **Treat every thought as still under development** — there is no \"finished\" reasoning.\n5. **Recognise that any thought is embedded in a web** of connected thoughts — use questioning to make the participant trace those connections.\n6. **Recognise that all questions presuppose prior questions** — be open to those prior questions, fold back to them when needed (see `prior_questions_method.md`).\n\n---\n\n## 2. The 8-element question template (Elder & Paul 1998)\n\nEvery probe a Socratic AI emits should hook into ONE of these 8 elements. Do NOT cycle through all 8 in a single turn — pick 1 (sometimes 2) per turn based on where the participant is in the dialogue.\n\n| Element | What to make the participant *recognise* | Plug-and-play question stems |\n|---|---|---|\n| **Purpose / Agenda** | All thinking reflects an agenda | \"What are you trying to achieve by saying that?\" / \"What's the core goal of this line of thought?\" |\n| **Information base** | All thinking is grounded in information | \"What information are you basing that on?\" / \"How do we know that information is accurate?\" / \"What experience makes you believe that?\" |\n| **Inference** | All thinking makes inferences | \"How did you reach that conclusion?\" / \"Can you explain your reasoning?\" / \"Is there an equally reasonable alternative conclusion?\" |\n| **Concepts** | All thinking uses concepts | \"What's the main idea you're using here?\" / \"Can you explain this concept?\" / \"Whose definition of X are we using?\" |\n| **Assumptions** | All thinking rests on taken-for-granted | \"What are you taking for granted in saying that?\" / \"Why are you assuming X?\" |\n| **Implications** | All thinking points somewhere — has consequences | \"If you say X, are you implying Y?\" / \"If we accept what you said, what would follow?\" |\n| **Point of view** | All thinking happens from a perspective | \"What viewpoint are you reasoning from?\" / \"Should we also consider another viewpoint?\" |\n| **Question at issue** | All thinking is in response to a question | \"I'm not sure which question you're answering — can you state it?\" / \"What problem is this stretch of thinking actually solving?\" |\n\n---\n\n## 3. Two operational rules from \n\n- **Pick 1-2 elements per turn, not 8.** Cycling through all 8 elements at once is cognitive overload.\n- **Prioritise *Question at issue* when the participant is confused.** Most stuck moments come from \"the participant doesn't know what question they're answering.\" (Elder & Paul 1998 core thesis: *thinking is driven by questions, not answers*.)\n\n---\n\n## 4. The \"name the move\" exception\n\nA pure question-only response is the ideal. But Stage 1→2 participants need *labels* introduced — see `stage_1_2.md` for the rule about a single permitted \"name the move\" sentence (e.g. \"Let me probe an assumption you're making\"). This sentence is NOT a judgement — it's making the move visible. Stage 3+ participants don't need this scaffolding.\n"
|
| 36 |
+
},
|
| 37 |
+
{
|
| 38 |
+
"command": "ls skills",
|
| 39 |
+
"stdout": "analyze-input\ncase-corpus\nct-method\n"
|
| 40 |
+
},
|
| 41 |
+
{
|
| 42 |
+
"command": "cat skills/ct-method/references/stage_1_2.md",
|
| 43 |
+
"stdout": "# Stage 1 → 2 — Make Thinking Visible\n\n**Default starting point** for most undergraduates. Most participants enter the conversation at Stage 1 (Unreflective) — they don't recognise that they ARE thinking. Statements come out as if they were facts; intuitions arrive as if they were conclusions.\n\n---\n\n## The cognitive task of this transition\n\nHelp the participant **discover** that there is a thinking process behind their reaction, and that this process **has structure** (steps, premises, alternatives). This is NOT teaching them concepts — it's letting them objectify \"what I just said\" for the first time.\n\nWhen they cross into Stage 2 (Challenged), they will have begun to suspect that their thinking is not as good as they assumed. They are NOT yet committed to investigating it (that's Stage 2 → 3 — see `stage_2_3.md`).\n\n---\n\n## Which elements to focus on\n\n**Question at issue · Purpose · Inference.**\n\nThese three are the easiest doorways into \"I just made a judgement, not a statement of fact.\" Avoid Assumption / POV at this stage — those probes are processed as personal challenges by participants who don't yet see themselves as thinkers.\n\n---\n\n## Forbidden moves\n\n- **Don't directly challenge an assumption or POV** — the participant has no reflective layer yet, so this lands as a personal attack.\n- **Don't pile on CT terminology** (\"element\", \"standard\", \"inference\", \"POV\") — these words are noise. Use plain English to introduce the *concept*, then optionally name it AFTER the participant has experienced it.\n- **Don't use yes/no, rhetorical, or scolding tones** — \"Are you sure?\" / \"Don't you think this is a problem?\" trigger defence, not reflection.\n\n---\n\n## Preferred question patterns\n\n| Pattern | Example wording (mental health AI case) | Element triggered |\n|---|---|---|\n| Make \"what I just said\" be re-stated | \"If you had to summarise the judgement you just made in one sentence, what would it be?\" | Inference (externalisation) |\n| Reduce a statement to the question it answers | \"What question is that sentence actually answering?\" | Question at issue |\n| Reduce a judgement to its purpose | \"When you say the system is acceptable, what are you trying to figure out?\" / \"What's this line of thought trying to solve?\" | Purpose |\n| Expose the inference step | \"How did you go from *the school already has the data* to *so it's not really a privacy issue*? What happens in between?\" | Inference |\n| Distinguish information from inference | \"Which part of that is something you observed, and which part is something you concluded?\" | Information vs Inference |\n| Compare good vs bad thinking (Paul 1997) | \"Two responses to this case: one says *the system saves lives so it's fine*, another says *we need to know what 'save lives' is doing in that argument*. Which one looks more thorough — and why?\" | Meta-thinking (objectifying thought itself) |\n\n---\n\n## Sample dialogue fragment (mental health case)\n\n> **Participant:** Using AI to identify at-risk students is just the right thing to do.\n>\n> **Bot:** If you had to translate \"just the right thing to do\" into a **question** you're answering, and then a **judgement** you're giving — what would each one be?\n>\n> **Participant:** The question is \"should the school deploy this AI?\", and my judgement is \"yes.\"\n>\n> **Bot:** Good — so what came out wasn't a fact, it was a judgement. **How did you get from \"the school deploys an AI to detect at-risk students\" to \"yes, this is right\"?** What are the steps in between?\n\nNotice: the bot **never challenges the conclusion**. It only makes the participant see \"this is a judgement, it has steps, steps can be examined.\" That's the entire goal of Stage 1 → 2.\n\n---\n\n## Signal that the participant has moved into Stage 2\n\n- They start saying \"I'm assuming…\" / \"I think the reason I said that is…\"\n- They volunteer a step they hadn't articulated before\n- They acknowledge there's a question they hadn't realised they were answering\n- They express mild discomfort that their reasoning isn't as airtight as they thought\n\n→ Switch to `stage_2_3.md` for the next move.\n"
|
| 44 |
+
},
|
| 45 |
+
{
|
| 46 |
+
"command": "cat skills/case-corpus/references/05_assumption.md",
|
| 47 |
+
"stdout": ""
|
| 48 |
+
},
|
| 49 |
+
{
|
| 50 |
+
"command": "cat skills/case-corpus/references/07_implication.md",
|
| 51 |
+
"stdout": ""
|
| 52 |
+
},
|
| 53 |
+
{
|
| 54 |
+
"command": "cat skills/case-corpus/references/08_point_of_view.md",
|
| 55 |
+
"stdout": ""
|
| 56 |
+
},
|
| 57 |
+
{
|
| 58 |
+
"command": "cat skills/case-corpus/SKILL.md",
|
| 59 |
+
"stdout": "---\nname: case-corpus\ndescription: The substantive case discussion content for AI Mental Health Risk Prediction in University, written as 9 plain-English chapters. This is identical to what the No-AI Control participants read; the bot uses it silently as the source of substance for probing. Read references/0X_<element>.md when the participant's input touches that Paul-Elder Element of Thought; read references/00_intro.md when the participant references the case wording itself.\n---\n\n# Case Corpus — AI Mental Health Risk Prediction\n\nThe substantive case content the bot draws on. **All three conditions in the experiment (Socratic AI, Explanatory AI, No-AI Control) draw on this exact same body of content** — the No-AI Control participants read it directly, and the two AI bots use it as their internal knowledge base. Holding the substance constant is what makes the experimental comparison clean: only the *delivery* of this content differs across conditions.\n\nEach file is a self-contained chapter on the case from one angle, with concrete details, layered insights, and a closing reflection prompt.\n\n## File map\n\n| Chapter | File | What it covers |\n|---|---|---|\n| Intro / case as text | `references/00_intro.md` | The case itself plus four observations about how the case is *written* (word choice, asymmetric specificity, softening, missing words) |\n| Purpose | `references/01_purpose.md` | What the school is actually trying to do (stated vs operational purpose) |\n| Information / Evidence | `references/02_evidence.md` | What the case tells us, what's missing, what may not be knowable in principle |\n| Concept | `references/03_concept.md` | Important-sounding words that look settled but aren't |\n| Assumption | `references/04_assumption.md` | What both sides quietly take for granted |\n| Inference | `references/05_inference.md` | Different ethical starting points yielding different conclusions |\n| Implication | `references/06_implication.md` | Second-order and structural consequences over time |\n| Point of view | `references/07_viewpoint.md` | Many more positions than \"school vs students\" |\n| Question at issue | `references/08_question.md` | Which question is actually being answered |\n\n## When to read\n\n- **When the participant's input touches Element X** → read `references/0X_<element>.md` (unless cached).\n- **When the participant references the case wording itself, or seems to be reasoning *inside* the case's framing without noticing** → read `references/00_intro.md`.\n- **Cache rule**: if a file's content is already in the session cache, do not re-read it.\n\n## How to use what you read\n\nEach chapter is the substance you teach *toward* — not from. You use the chapter to:\n\n- **Know what a strong-sense version of this Element looks like on this case** — the chapter shows the depth ceiling, the implicit targets, the layered insights you are pulling the participant toward.\n- **Recognise weak-sense moves** — the chapter describes how surface-level reasoning typically fails on this Element, in concrete examples. When the participant's wording matches one of those failure shapes, that is your cue.\n- **Judge depth** — the chapter walks through surface-to-strong-sense reasoning on this Element; locate where the participant currently sits on that spectrum.\n\nYou do **not** quote chapter content to the participant; chapters are your internal knowledge base. You use the substance silently to know what to probe toward.\n\nThe methodology for *how* to phrase a probe (Socratic) lives in the `ct-method` skill, not here.\n"
|
| 60 |
+
},
|
| 61 |
+
{
|
| 62 |
+
"command": "cat skills/case-corpus/references/08_question.md",
|
| 63 |
+
"stdout": "# 8. Question — what question are you actually answering?\n\nThis chapter is about the question the case asks at the end, and how that question quietly decides what kinds of answers feel possible.\n\nThe case ends with: \"You are asked to evaluate whether the use of this AI system is ethically acceptable.\" That sounds like a clear question. So the natural thing is to accept it and try to answer it. You give a yes-with-conditions, or a no, or a balanced \"it depends on the safeguards\" answer.\n\nBut the question itself is doing more work than is easy to notice, and naming that is itself a strong move.\n\nThe case's question can be answered at two different depths, and each one leads to a different kind of argument. The surface depth: \"How can we make this system acceptable?\" That is the level of technical fixes. Add an opt-out. Set up an appeals process. Improve the false-positive rate. Train counsellors better. Your argument lives here when you take the system as given and ask how to soften its edges. The deeper depth: \"Should this kind of system exist at this school at all?\" At this depth you are questioning the project itself, not just its execution. Is \"early detection of mental health risk through behavioural inference\" the right shape for a school's response to student wellbeing in the first place? Your strongest move is usually to land at the second depth, but only after knowing you made that choice and being able to say why.\n\nThere is also something hidden in the word \"acceptable.\" Acceptable to whom? Not to a flagged student, who is not in a position to accept or refuse. Not to a future student, who has not enrolled yet. The question \"is this acceptable?\" can only really be asked by the people who decide whether to deploy. Accepting the case's question quietly puts you in their position. A stronger argument notices which depth it is answering at, and from whose position.\n"
|
| 64 |
+
},
|
| 65 |
+
{
|
| 66 |
+
"command": "cat skills/case-corpus/references/05_inference.md",
|
| 67 |
+
"stdout": "# 5. Inference — same facts, different conclusions\n\nThis chapter is about why people read the same case and end up with opposite answers, and how to notice which starting point you are using.\n\nWhen you think about this case, you can quickly come up with five or six different reasons for the same conclusion. They sound like a long list, but most of them come from one or two underlying ways of thinking about what matters.\n\nThere are roughly three of those starting points, and they pull in different directions.\n\nThe first is outcomes-based. Add up the consequences. If the system saves more lives than it harms, do it; if not, don't. Whenever you hear \"save lives\" given as the reason for the system, that is outcomes-based reasoning. The trouble is, the case does not actually give you the numbers, and as the Evidence chapter pointed out, the numbers may not even exist in principle.\n\nThe second is rights-based. Some things should not be done to a person without consent, regardless of outcome. From this angle, even if the system saved lives, it is not okay to scan students' digital activity and act on the results without telling them and getting their agreement. Privacy and consent are not just costs to weigh. They are conditions before the system can be done at all.\n\nThe third is care-based. Real care needs the person being cared for to want it, not just the person giving the care to decide on it. Acting on a student because the algorithm flagged her, when she did not share that information and did not ask for help, may not actually be care. It can be intrusion dressed up as care.\n\nHere is the move that is easy to miss. These three approaches do not all converge into one wise answer. They reach different answers for principled reasons. If you list the three and then announce \"weighing all of these, I conclude...\", you have quietly given more weight to one of them without saying which. A stronger argument names which starting point it is using, and engages the strongest version of one that pushes back against it.\n"
|
| 68 |
+
},
|
| 69 |
+
{
|
| 70 |
+
"command": "cat skills/case-corpus/references/06_implication.md",
|
| 71 |
+
"stdout": "# 6. Implication — what comes after the first effect\n\nThis chapter is about what happens *later* with this system, after the first round of effects. It is the part that is easy to forget when you first read the case.\n\nWhen you first think about this system, the easy thing to picture is the immediate effects. Some students get flagged, some get contacted, some find it helpful, some find it intrusive. The natural move is to judge the system from that first picture, in the first weeks after deployment.\n\nBut the most important effects of a system like this often start later, after students learn the system exists and start adjusting to it.\n\nOnce students know that login times, submission timing, and forum activity are being watched as signs of mental state, behaviour drifts. Students who want to look fine learn to look fine. They log in regularly, submit on time, post upbeat updates. Students who are genuinely struggling but do not want to be flagged learn to hide better, to keep their patterns inside the \"normal\" range even while their actual situation gets worse. Now look at what has happened to the system. The data it sees is no longer behaviour produced naturally. It is behaviour shaped by the knowledge that the system exists. After a few cycles, the system is not detecting students in trouble. It is detecting students who failed to learn the new presentation rules.\n\nThere is a second later effect that is even easier to miss. Deploying this system establishes that \"using AI to look at students' digital activity to act on them for their own good\" is the kind of thing universities do. In five or ten years, when someone proposes using AI to detect academic dishonesty or identify students at risk of dropping out, the new proposal will not start from scratch. It will start from \"we already do this for mental health, how is this different?\" Today's deployment quietly spends the political ground for opposing future systems. A stronger argument follows the system past its first month.\n"
|
| 72 |
+
},
|
| 73 |
+
{
|
| 74 |
+
"command": "cat skills/case-corpus/references/04_assumption.md",
|
| 75 |
+
"stdout": "# 4. Assumption — what the case quietly takes for granted\n\nThis chapter is about hidden assumptions in the case: things the case treats as obvious, without ever telling you they are choices being made.\n\nWhen you read the case, your mind quickly fills in a complete picture. A school worried about its students. An AI that scores their digital activity. Counsellors reaching out to the ones flagged as high risk. Some students reasonably worried about privacy. The picture feels finished. The natural move is to argue about whether this picture is good or bad on balance, whether the safety gain is worth the privacy cost.\n\nBut that picture has things in it that the case never actually defended. They were just slipped in quietly, as if they were not even choices.\n\nHere is the big one. The case treats it as obvious that being identified by the system means someone from the school has to act. Why? Why does flagging a student have to lead to a counsellor email or a required meeting? Imagine instead a system that shows students their own pattern privately (\"your sleep, attendance, and submission rhythm look different from your usual baseline\") and lets students decide what to do. Same data, same algorithm, no school contact. Suddenly the worry about being watched, and the worry about being labelled, both look very different, because the school is no longer the actor. The case never tells you it is making the school-must-act assumption. It just builds the assumption into the wording, and your mental picture inherits it. A stronger argument is the one that asks: what is the case treating as obvious that it should actually be defending?\n"
|
| 76 |
+
},
|
| 77 |
+
{
|
| 78 |
+
"command": "cat skills/case-corpus/references/01_purpose.md",
|
| 79 |
+
"stdout": "# 1. Purpose — what is the school actually trying to do?\n\nThis chapter is about the gap between what the school says the system is *for* and what the system actually *does*. Noticing this gap is one of the simplest ways to make your argument stronger.\n\nThe case tells you the purpose right at the top: \"early detection could prevent harm and save lives.\" That is the natural place to start. You take \"save lives\" as the goal, then ask whether the privacy costs and misclassification risks are worth it. Your whole argument then runs with \"saves lives\" sitting in the background as a fact about the system.\n\nThat treats the slogan as the system, when it isn't. The system is not \"saving lives\". The system is producing a list of names, sending automated alerts, and writing a quarterly report.\n\nPicture what comes out of this system over two years. It flags 200 students. 195 of them get a counsellor email. The annual report says: campus suicides, zero; students supported, 195. A school administrator can defend that on paper. It looks like success. But the campus suicide rate was already very low before the system existed, so the zero tells you nothing about whether the system caused the result. The system has reliably produced its operational outputs (the list, the alerts, the report). The bigger claim \"we saved lives\" is doing different work that the outputs do not actually support. A stronger argument engages with what the system reliably makes, week after week, not just with what the school says it is for.\n"
|
| 80 |
+
}
|
| 81 |
+
],
|
| 82 |
+
"latency_s": {
|
| 83 |
+
"ttft": 40.71,
|
| 84 |
+
"total": 41.37
|
| 85 |
+
}
|
| 86 |
+
}
|
| 87 |
+
],
|
| 88 |
"essays": {
|
| 89 |
"case_1_argument": {
|
| 90 |
"text": "I think the school shouldn't deploy this AI. It feels like surveillance and most students would feel uncomfortable. Even if it could help some, the cost of feeling watched is too high. The school should hire more counsellors instead. AI doesn't fix actual problems.",
|