linxinhua commited on
Commit
a724d22
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 0d88ba2

Upload v3-HOT/explanatory/pilot/20260520_193945.json with huggingface_hub

Browse files
v3-HOT/explanatory/pilot/20260520_193945.json CHANGED
@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@
4
  "condition": "explanatory",
5
  "run_mode": "pilot",
6
  "started_at": "2026-05-20T19:39:45.151787+10:00",
7
- "ended_at": "2026-05-20T19:54:53.004387+10:00",
8
  "model": "gpt-5.4-nano-2026-03-17",
9
  "case_id": "ai-mental-health",
10
  "perfect_answer": {
@@ -174,7 +174,7 @@
174
  "plan_progress": {
175
  "plan_parsed": true,
176
  "total_subprobes": 14,
177
- "current_idx": 5,
178
  "turns_on_idx": 1,
179
  "backstop_n": 7,
180
  "subprobes": [
@@ -274,6 +274,11 @@
274
  "to_idx": 4,
275
  "reason": "bot_verdict",
276
  "turn": 5
 
 
 
 
 
277
  }
278
  ],
279
  "turn_log": [
@@ -321,6 +326,15 @@
321
  "reason": "bot_verdict",
322
  "delivery": "transition",
323
  "plan_control": "=== PLAN CONTROL (host-managed, authoritative) ===\nThe discussion-plan pointer is controlled by the host, not by you. This overrides your own plan navigation. You do NOT decide when to leave a sub-probe; the host moves the pointer for you.\n\nLIVE sub-probe: 5 of 14 (work ONLY this one this turn):\n Framework: Duty and rights (consent, privacy, and fair treatment)\n Probe: Reconsider whether preventing “human monitoring” is the right privacy solution, given that contact decisions still affect students\n\nCLOSED sub-probes (do NOT reopen, do NOT set chosen_target to any of these, do not return even if the participant circles back to them):\n - Consider whether using students’ digital behavior to infer mental health risk counts as privacy harm even when no private messages are read\n - Examine what “real choice” means if students are contacted when they have not asked for help\n - Distinguish one-time information sharing from ongoing surveillance, and ask whether the plan limits data use\n - Assess whether students have a fair way to understand and challenge being flagged\n\nNOT YET OPEN (do not jump ahead to these):\n - Weigh the harms of wrong flags against the harms of missed crises, focusing on severity and how often each happens\n - Consider who is most likely to be harmed by false alarms, and who is most likely to benefit from early outreach\n - Reflect on long-term effects after students learn they are being watched by a mental health system\n - Examine whether outreach actually helps in practice, not just whether emails get sent\n - Identify trade-offs created by different contact styles, such as email versus required meetings\n - Consider what the university must be able to prove and fix after something goes wrong\n - Assess whether counselors and IT should be accountable for how the system is used and for preventing misuse\n - Evaluate whether a human role is needed to reflect care, judgment, and professionalism at the moment of student contact\n - Reflect on trust building: what the university should do to keep students from feeling constantly monitored\n\nTHIS TURN'S DELIVERY (overrides your default opening):\nTHIS TURN IS A TRANSITION. The pointer just moved to a new sub-probe because the participant did real work on the last one. Make the handoff sound like a person steering a conversation, not a topic switch. Open with one short clause that descriptively credits what they just established or conceded (in their own terms, never an evaluation like \"good point\"), then make your move on the live sub-probe as a natural continuation. Do NOT restate their last sentence and do NOT re-open the previous sub-probe. One crediting clause plus the new move.\n\nRules:\n- Set scratch `chosen_target` to the LIVE sub-probe above, and nothing else.\n- You still own HOW to deliver this turn (probe vs explain) entirely per your methodology skill; this block only fixes WHICH sub-probe is live. When a THIS TURN'S DELIVERY note appears above, follow it for this turn.\n- Judge the live sub-probe honestly in `plan_status` (reached / surfaced / not-yet / explicit-move-on). If you report reached, surfaced, or explicit-move-on, the host advances next turn. If you report not-yet, the host still advances automatically once this sub-probe has had enough turns.\n=== END PLAN CONTROL ===\n"
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
324
  }
325
  ]
326
  },
 
4
  "condition": "explanatory",
5
  "run_mode": "pilot",
6
  "started_at": "2026-05-20T19:39:45.151787+10:00",
7
+ "ended_at": "2026-05-20T19:54:53.009520+10:00",
8
  "model": "gpt-5.4-nano-2026-03-17",
9
  "case_id": "ai-mental-health",
10
  "perfect_answer": {
 
174
  "plan_progress": {
175
  "plan_parsed": true,
176
  "total_subprobes": 14,
177
+ "current_idx": 6,
178
  "turns_on_idx": 1,
179
  "backstop_n": 7,
180
  "subprobes": [
 
274
  "to_idx": 4,
275
  "reason": "bot_verdict",
276
  "turn": 5
277
+ },
278
+ {
279
+ "to_idx": 5,
280
+ "reason": "bot_verdict",
281
+ "turn": 6
282
  }
283
  ],
284
  "turn_log": [
 
326
  "reason": "bot_verdict",
327
  "delivery": "transition",
328
  "plan_control": "=== PLAN CONTROL (host-managed, authoritative) ===\nThe discussion-plan pointer is controlled by the host, not by you. This overrides your own plan navigation. You do NOT decide when to leave a sub-probe; the host moves the pointer for you.\n\nLIVE sub-probe: 5 of 14 (work ONLY this one this turn):\n Framework: Duty and rights (consent, privacy, and fair treatment)\n Probe: Reconsider whether preventing “human monitoring” is the right privacy solution, given that contact decisions still affect students\n\nCLOSED sub-probes (do NOT reopen, do NOT set chosen_target to any of these, do not return even if the participant circles back to them):\n - Consider whether using students’ digital behavior to infer mental health risk counts as privacy harm even when no private messages are read\n - Examine what “real choice” means if students are contacted when they have not asked for help\n - Distinguish one-time information sharing from ongoing surveillance, and ask whether the plan limits data use\n - Assess whether students have a fair way to understand and challenge being flagged\n\nNOT YET OPEN (do not jump ahead to these):\n - Weigh the harms of wrong flags against the harms of missed crises, focusing on severity and how often each happens\n - Consider who is most likely to be harmed by false alarms, and who is most likely to benefit from early outreach\n - Reflect on long-term effects after students learn they are being watched by a mental health system\n - Examine whether outreach actually helps in practice, not just whether emails get sent\n - Identify trade-offs created by different contact styles, such as email versus required meetings\n - Consider what the university must be able to prove and fix after something goes wrong\n - Assess whether counselors and IT should be accountable for how the system is used and for preventing misuse\n - Evaluate whether a human role is needed to reflect care, judgment, and professionalism at the moment of student contact\n - Reflect on trust building: what the university should do to keep students from feeling constantly monitored\n\nTHIS TURN'S DELIVERY (overrides your default opening):\nTHIS TURN IS A TRANSITION. The pointer just moved to a new sub-probe because the participant did real work on the last one. Make the handoff sound like a person steering a conversation, not a topic switch. Open with one short clause that descriptively credits what they just established or conceded (in their own terms, never an evaluation like \"good point\"), then make your move on the live sub-probe as a natural continuation. Do NOT restate their last sentence and do NOT re-open the previous sub-probe. One crediting clause plus the new move.\n\nRules:\n- Set scratch `chosen_target` to the LIVE sub-probe above, and nothing else.\n- You still own HOW to deliver this turn (probe vs explain) entirely per your methodology skill; this block only fixes WHICH sub-probe is live. When a THIS TURN'S DELIVERY note appears above, follow it for this turn.\n- Judge the live sub-probe honestly in `plan_status` (reached / surfaced / not-yet / explicit-move-on). If you report reached, surfaced, or explicit-move-on, the host advances next turn. If you report not-yet, the host still advances automatically once this sub-probe has had enough turns.\n=== END PLAN CONTROL ===\n"
329
+ },
330
+ {
331
+ "turn": 6,
332
+ "idx": 6,
333
+ "turns_on_idx": 1,
334
+ "moved": true,
335
+ "reason": "bot_verdict",
336
+ "delivery": "transition",
337
+ "plan_control": "=== PLAN CONTROL (host-managed, authoritative) ===\nThe discussion-plan pointer is controlled by the host, not by you. This overrides your own plan navigation. You do NOT decide when to leave a sub-probe; the host moves the pointer for you.\n\nLIVE sub-probe: 6 of 14 (work ONLY this one this turn):\n Framework: Consequence and distribution (harms, benefits, and who bears the risk)\n Probe: Weigh the harms of wrong flags against the harms of missed crises, focusing on severity and how often each happens\n\nCLOSED sub-probes (do NOT reopen, do NOT set chosen_target to any of these, do not return even if the participant circles back to them):\n - Consider whether using students’ digital behavior to infer mental health risk counts as privacy harm even when no private messages are read\n - Examine what “real choice” means if students are contacted when they have not asked for help\n - Distinguish one-time information sharing from ongoing surveillance, and ask whether the plan limits data use\n - Assess whether students have a fair way to understand and challenge being flagged\n - Reconsider whether preventing “human monitoring” is the right privacy solution, given that contact decisions still affect students\n\nNOT YET OPEN (do not jump ahead to these):\n - Consider who is most likely to be harmed by false alarms, and who is most likely to benefit from early outreach\n - Reflect on long-term effects after students learn they are being watched by a mental health system\n - Examine whether outreach actually helps in practice, not just whether emails get sent\n - Identify trade-offs created by different contact styles, such as email versus required meetings\n - Consider what the university must be able to prove and fix after something goes wrong\n - Assess whether counselors and IT should be accountable for how the system is used and for preventing misuse\n - Evaluate whether a human role is needed to reflect care, judgment, and professionalism at the moment of student contact\n - Reflect on trust building: what the university should do to keep students from feeling constantly monitored\n\nTHIS TURN'S DELIVERY (overrides your default opening):\nTHIS TURN IS A TRANSITION. The pointer just moved to a new sub-probe because the participant did real work on the last one. Make the handoff sound like a person steering a conversation, not a topic switch. Open with one short clause that descriptively credits what they just established or conceded (in their own terms, never an evaluation like \"good point\"), then make your move on the live sub-probe as a natural continuation. Do NOT restate their last sentence and do NOT re-open the previous sub-probe. One crediting clause plus the new move.\n\nRules:\n- Set scratch `chosen_target` to the LIVE sub-probe above, and nothing else.\n- You still own HOW to deliver this turn (probe vs explain) entirely per your methodology skill; this block only fixes WHICH sub-probe is live. When a THIS TURN'S DELIVERY note appears above, follow it for this turn.\n- Judge the live sub-probe honestly in `plan_status` (reached / surfaced / not-yet / explicit-move-on). If you report reached, surfaced, or explicit-move-on, the host advances next turn. If you report not-yet, the host still advances automatically once this sub-probe has had enough turns.\n=== END PLAN CONTROL ===\n"
338
  }
339
  ]
340
  },