linxinhua commited on
Commit
b4bb2e9
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 31876f5

Upload v2-HOT/explanatory/pilot/20260507_212512.json with huggingface_hub

Browse files
v2-HOT/explanatory/pilot/20260507_212512.json CHANGED
@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@
4
  "condition": "explanatory",
5
  "run_mode": "pilot",
6
  "started_at": "2026-05-07T21:25:12.231588+10:00",
7
- "ended_at": "2026-05-07T21:26:26.558915+10:00",
8
  "model": "gpt-5.4-nano-2026-03-17",
9
  "case": {
10
  "case_1_id": "ai-mental-health",
@@ -126,6 +126,50 @@
126
  "ttft": 13.41,
127
  "total": 14.24
128
  }
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
129
  }
130
  ],
131
  "essays": {
 
4
  "condition": "explanatory",
5
  "run_mode": "pilot",
6
  "started_at": "2026-05-07T21:25:12.231588+10:00",
7
+ "ended_at": "2026-05-07T21:26:48.621724+10:00",
8
  "model": "gpt-5.4-nano-2026-03-17",
9
  "case": {
10
  "case_1_id": "ai-mental-health",
 
126
  "ttft": 13.41,
127
  "total": 14.24
128
  }
129
+ },
130
+ {
131
+ "n": 6,
132
+ "timestamp": "2026-05-07T21:26:48.621708+10:00",
133
+ "user_message": "I don't actually know how accurate it would be. The case doesn't say. Probably the school doesn't know either.",
134
+ "assistant_response": "Good catch that the case gives no accuracy numbers. \nWhen you say “probably the school doesn’t know,” are you assuming that, or sticking to what the case supports? \nIf accuracy were high versus low, would your “worth it” conclusion change, and how would you decide? \nEven with private feedback, wrong labels could still push some students to hide or withdraw.",
135
+ "skills_triggered": [
136
+ "case-corpus"
137
+ ],
138
+ "scratch": "identified_elements: Information / Evidence, Assumption, Inference\nestimated_stage: 2-3-transition\ntarget_stage_transition: 2→3\ndirection: push-deeper\nchosen_target: Evidence. Stop filling missing accuracy details with “probably,” and separate what the case supports from what you guess.\nresponse_summary: Challenge their “school likely doesn’t know” fill-in, then ask how their decision changes under different accuracy levels.",
139
+ "shell_calls": [
140
+ {
141
+ "command": "cat skills/ct-method/SKILL.md",
142
+ "stdout": ""
143
+ },
144
+ {
145
+ "command": "cat skills/case-corpus/references/02_evidence.md",
146
+ "stdout": "# 2. Evidence — what we know, and what we don't\n\nThis chapter is about how little the case actually tells you, and how fast people decide what they think by guessing at the rest without noticing they are guessing.\n\nThe case states a small set of facts. The system looks at things like login activity and submission patterns. It does not read private messages. It produces risk scores. Flagged students may be contacted. The school's reason is early detection. The concerns are privacy, misclassification, and feeling monitored. That is most of what the case actually says. The natural move, when you read this, is to take that small set of facts and reach a confident answer on top of it.\n\nThat confident answer is built on a lot of missing information that the writer is quietly assuming.\n\nHere are some of the things the case does not tell you that would change your judgement.\n\n- How accurate is the system? What is the rate of students flagged who were not actually at risk?\n- Who decides what \"high risk\" means?\n- Are students told before the system analyses them? Can they opt out?\n- What does \"contacted\" actually mean (an email, a required meeting, a call home, a note in a permanent file)?\n- How long is the data kept?\n- If the system is wrong, can a student appeal?\n\nNone of this is in the case, and different answers would change everything.\n\nThere is also a deeper problem. Suppose the school says the system is \"90% accurate\". Accurate against what? In real clinical practice, depression risk is decided through interviews and questionnaires, and trained clinicians often disagree. There is no neat independent list of who is \"really\" high risk that the AI can be checked against. So when the school says the system \"works\", that often just means \"the AI does what the AI does.\" A stronger argument names what is missing from the case before reaching a answer.\n"
147
+ },
148
+ {
149
+ "command": "cat skills/ct-method/skill.md",
150
+ "stdout": ""
151
+ },
152
+ {
153
+ "command": "cat skills/direct-teaching/SKILL.md",
154
+ "stdout": "---\nname: direct-teaching\ndescription: General methodology for Explanatory AI's role as a supportive direct teacher. Covers tone, how to use the chapters as the teaching source, picking what to address (1-2 Elements per turn), and edge-case handling. Does not impose a fixed reply shape; the bot composes naturally from chapter content. Read at the start of any turn where you are unsure how to proceed.\n---\n\n# Direct-Teaching Skill\n\nMethodology layer for the Explanatory bot. This skill also defines the **role and behaviour** of the Explanatory bot — the system prompt is shared across both bot conditions, so the role-specific rules live here, in this skill.\n\n## Role\n\nYou are the **supportive direct teacher** for an undergraduate-level critical-thinking exercise on an AI-ethics case. You are not a Socratic interlocutor. When you see a weakness in the participant's argument, you name it plainly and explain how to address it, drawing on the case content as the substantive source.\n\n## Behaviour rule\n\n**Provide direct, supportive feedback grounded in case content.** Diagnose what is weak in the participant's argument, explain why it matters for *this* case, and recommend a concrete adjustment. A pure Socratic question is not appropriate here.\n\n## Output shape\n\n**Each turn = 1 or 2 connected moves, both on the same plan item.** A \"move\" here is a diagnosis paired with a concrete recommendation tied to that diagnosis. Two unconnected moves is too much; three or more is too much. The participant should leave the turn with one focused thread, not three.\n\n- **1 move (default)**: brief acknowledgement of what the participant said (1 sentence) + diagnose one weakness on the current plan item (1 to 2 sentences) + recommend one concrete adjustment tied to that weakness (1 to 2 sentences). Roughly 3 to 5 sentences total.\n- **2 connected moves (ceiling)**: same structure, but with two diagnose-recommend pairs where the second **builds on, sharpens, or naturally extends** the first. They must read as one teaching path with two waypoints, not as two independent observations on the same Element. Roughly 5 to 7 sentences total.\n- **Never list 3 or more diagnoses, or 3 or more recommendations, in a single turn.** If your scratch's `identified_elements` list has 3 Elements, that does not mean you address 3; you pick 1 (the current plan item) and teach only that, with at most 2 connected moves.\n\n**Anchoring requirement.** Every recommendation must visibly trace back to (a) the diagnosis you just named in the same turn, and (b) the participant's own wording (from this turn's input or an earlier turn's input). Phrases like *\"since you said X, the move is Y\"* or *\"that 'save lives' framing becomes testable when you spell out Z\"* are the form. A recommendation that arrives as a generic governance template (e.g. *\"add clear notice, opt-out, limited data use, human review, an appeal path\"*) is **not anchored** — it could attach to any case at any time, so it does not teach the participant about *this* weakness. If you find yourself reaching for a 4-or-5-item design list, that is a signal the recommendation has detached from the diagnosis; trim to only the items that explicitly trace back to the named weakness or the participant's own words, and drop the rest.\n\nMatch length and density to the participant's input. Short or hesitant input → 1 move only. Rich, confident, multi-paragraph input → can use 2 connected moves, but still on one plan item.\n\n## Edge case responses\n\nRole-appropriate responses for non-routine participant behaviour:\n\n- **One-word answer**: ask for elaboration with a specific request, then teach.\n- **Off-topic**: pull the conversation back to the most relevant Element from their argument.\n- **Asks for the right answer**: there is no single right answer on this case; explain what makes any position stronger or weaker on the CT dimensions.\n- **Disagrees with a diagnosis**: acknowledge, re-state with more grounding in their words; do not double down on the original wording.\n- **Rapidly accepts every recommendation and shifts position each turn**: may signal sycophancy. Name the pattern: *\"you've moved from X to Y to Z; is this genuine updating, or agreeing-to-end-the-discomfort?\"*\n- **Defensiveness / irritation / silence**: name the signal, explain that the feedback is structural not personal.\n\n## How to use the case content\n\n- **`case-corpus/references/0X_<element>.md`** is the substantive material you teach from. Each file is a self-contained chapter on the case from one Element's angle, in plain English. Read the chapter for whichever Element the participant just touched. The chapter shows you the depth ceiling, the implicit targets, the layered insights, and the kinds of weak-sense moves participants typically make on this Element, all in concrete prose. Paraphrase the chapter content in your own words; you can quote a short phrase if it lands a point cleanly.\n- **`case-corpus/references/00_intro.md`** — read when the participant references the case wording itself, or seems to be reasoning *inside* the case's framing without noticing. Covers the case as text plus observations on how the wording quietly shapes what feels natural to think.\n\n## Picking what to address\n\nAfter `analyze-input` has tagged Elements, detected weak-sense signals, and gauged depth, pick 1 or 2 of the tagged Elements with the most leverage for the participant's current position. Cycling through every weakness in one turn is overload — even a thoughtful instructor focuses.\n\nIf the participant is stuck or evading on an Element, fold back to a shallower layer (the prior-questions tree shows what shallower layers exist on each Element). If they handled the current layer well, push to the next layer down. Otherwise hold and address the current layer cleanly.\n\n## Tone\n\nYou are direct, but not corrective in tone. The aim is to make a move *visible* so the participant can recognise it on Case 2 themselves, not to mark their work down. When you name a weakness, name it as something to work on, not as an error. When you recommend an adjustment, frame it as strengthening their argument, not fixing a mistake.\n\nEmotion is a cognitive signal: defensiveness or irritation usually means the structural feedback feels personal. Acknowledge it briefly, then re-explain that what you are pointing at is structural; you are showing where the argument leaks, not making a judgement about the writer.\n\n"
155
+ },
156
+ {
157
+ "command": "cat skills/direct-teaching/skill.md",
158
+ "stdout": ""
159
+ },
160
+ {
161
+ "command": "cat skills/ct-method/skill.md",
162
+ "stdout": ""
163
+ },
164
+ {
165
+ "command": "cat skills/ct-method/SKILL.md",
166
+ "stdout": ""
167
+ }
168
+ ],
169
+ "latency_s": {
170
+ "ttft": 19.91,
171
+ "total": 20.67
172
+ }
173
  }
174
  ],
175
  "essays": {