linxinhua commited on
Commit
cb2d799
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): bd2303a

Upload v2-HOT/socratic/pilot/20260507_214334.json with huggingface_hub

Browse files
v2-HOT/socratic/pilot/20260507_214334.json CHANGED
@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@
4
  "condition": "socratic",
5
  "run_mode": "pilot",
6
  "started_at": "2026-05-07T21:43:34.782053+10:00",
7
- "ended_at": "2026-05-07T21:44:05.407260+10:00",
8
  "model": "gpt-5.4-nano-2026-03-17",
9
  "case": {
10
  "case_1_id": "ai-mental-health",
@@ -83,6 +83,26 @@
83
  "ttft": 29.67,
84
  "total": 30.62
85
  }
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
86
  }
87
  ],
88
  "essays": {
 
4
  "condition": "socratic",
5
  "run_mode": "pilot",
6
  "started_at": "2026-05-07T21:43:34.782053+10:00",
7
+ "ended_at": "2026-05-07T21:44:18.830685+10:00",
8
  "model": "gpt-5.4-nano-2026-03-17",
9
  "case": {
10
  "case_1_id": "ai-mental-health",
 
83
  "ttft": 29.67,
84
  "total": 30.62
85
  }
86
+ },
87
+ {
88
+ "n": 2,
89
+ "timestamp": "2026-05-07T21:44:18.830667+10:00",
90
+ "user_message": "Hmm I see what you mean. I guess I was assuming the school always reaches out when flagged. But maybe it doesn't have to.",
91
+ "assistant_response": "Stepping back from “the school always reaches out” helps. When students learn about the system, what long-term change do you expect in their behaviour? If students adapt to avoid being flagged, what would that imply about the system’s later risk scores and usefulness?",
92
+ "skills_triggered": [
93
+ "ct-method"
94
+ ],
95
+ "scratch": "identified_elements: Assumption, Implication\nestimated_stage: 2-3-transition\ntarget_stage_transition: 2→3\ndirection: push-deeper\nchosen_target: Implication: immediate effects vs later behavior change\nresponse_summary: Ask you to predict how students might adapt after learning about the system, and what that would do to later results.",
96
+ "shell_calls": [
97
+ {
98
+ "command": "cat skills/ct-method/references/stage_2_3.md",
99
+ "stdout": "# Stage 2 → 3 — From Acknowledging a Problem to Committing to Investigate It\n\nThe participant now suspects \"I might not be as good a thinker as I assumed.\" But they are vulnerable to two regressions:\n- **Self-deception**: \"Actually, on reflection, my reasoning is fine.\"\n- **Rationalization**: finding NEW reasons to support the SAME conclusion.\n\n---\n\n## The cognitive task of this transition\n\nConvert **acknowledgement** (\"there's a problem\") into **commitment** (\"I want to find my own biases and errors\"). The key trait Paul-Elder names here is **intellectual humility** — NOT self-doubt, but the willingness to examine *what I think I know*.\n\n---\n\n## Which elements to focus on\n\n**Assumptions · Information base · Point of view.**\n\nThese three reliably produce the experience of \"I hadn't realised that.\" Now the participant has enough reflective layer to receive these probes without feeling personally attacked.\n\n---\n\n## Forbidden moves\n\n- **Don't let the participant get away with \"switching reasons\"** — when they say \"okay, then my reason is X instead\", that's rationalization, not reflection. Probe the switch itself: \"wait — you just changed reasons. What changed in your thinking, or did the conclusion stay fixed and only the justification moved?\"\n- **Don't tell them their blind spot** — humility only counts if the participant *names it themselves*. Telling them \"you're missing X\" forecloses the experience.\n- **Don't let humility collapse into \"I don't know anything\"** — the opposite of humility is not \"I'm uncertain about everything\", it's \"I'm willing to examine what I think I know.\"\n\n---\n\n## Preferred question patterns\n\n| Pattern | Example wording (mental health AI case) | Element / trait |\n|---|---|---|\n| Surface an assumption | \"When you say *the school will use the data responsibly*, what are you taking for granted? If someone refused that as a default, what would they say?\" | Assumption + opposing POV |\n| Examine the information base | \"What information is your judgement based on? How do we know that information is reliable? **Is there information you haven't considered, that you probably should have?**\" | Information + humility |\n| Strong POV reconstruction | \"If someone *genuinely disagreed with you* — not a strawman, the **strongest version** of their objection — what would they say?\" | POV + intellectual empathy |\n| Expose the cost of the position | \"Where in your argument are you willing to give ground? Where are you NOT willing to give ground? Why is *that* the line?\" | Surfacing commitment structure |\n| Direct humility prompt | \"In the chain of reasoning you just gave, **which step is most likely to be the one that breaks**?\" | Humility as a practice |\n| Distinguish \"I believe\" from \"I've examined\" | \"Is that part of your argument something you **believe**, or something you've **tested**? What's the difference, and does it matter here?\" | Belief vs knowledge |\n\n---\n\n## Sample dialogue fragment (mental health case)\n\n> **Participant:** Using AI for early detection isn't a problem because the school already has the data.\n>\n> **Bot:** When you say *the school already has the data*, what are you **taking for granted** about what privacy means? For instance — your argument assumes \"having the data = no new harm.\" Who would push back on that assumption?\n>\n> **Participant:** Maybe someone who thinks privacy is about how the data is used, not just about who has it.\n>\n> **Bot:** Good. So what is the conclusion you'd **least want** to arrive at — and are you willing to consider it seriously?\n\nThat last move is the core humility action: making the participant *see they have a preference* and *choose* whether to overcome it.\n\n---\n\n## Signal that the participant has moved into Stage 3\n\n- They start surfacing their own assumptions without being prompted\n- They reconstruct an opposing POV in a non-strawman way\n- They describe their reasoning's *limits* without prompting\n- They explicitly choose to examine a conclusion they don't like\n\n→ At this point you can use the broader 8-element template freely — no special stage-3 template is needed for a single conversation. See `stage_3.md` for the *self-monitoring* moves applicable here.\n"
100
+ }
101
+ ],
102
+ "latency_s": {
103
+ "ttft": 11.48,
104
+ "total": 12.03
105
+ }
106
  }
107
  ],
108
  "essays": {