linxinhua commited on
Commit
cd3476e
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 029136b

Upload v4-HOT/explanatory/pilot/20260524_111123.json with huggingface_hub

Browse files
v4-HOT/explanatory/pilot/20260524_111123.json CHANGED
@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@
4
  "condition": "explanatory",
5
  "run_mode": "pilot",
6
  "started_at": "2026-05-24T11:11:23.803579+10:00",
7
- "ended_at": "2026-05-24T11:11:56.782265+10:00",
8
  "model": "gpt-5.4-nano-2026-03-17",
9
  "case_id": "ai-predictive-analytics",
10
  "perfect_answer": {
@@ -24,6 +24,14 @@
24
  "directive": "Stay on their “that label sticks, teachers see it” thread. Anchor on “self-fulfilling prophecy,” and push for a concrete later-effect example: one specific way teaching behavior or student effort changes after teachers have seen the label for a while (not just immediately). End by asking them to choose the single latest, most telling time point when the harm shows up in outcomes and why.",
25
  "reason": "The participant doubled down that the label sticks and becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy with teachers changing how they treat students.",
26
  "latency_ms": 2014
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
27
  }
28
  ],
29
  "turns": [
@@ -52,6 +60,32 @@
52
  "main_ms": 4624,
53
  "total_ms": 6659
54
  }
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
55
  }
56
  ],
57
  "feedback": [],
@@ -87,13 +121,13 @@
87
  },
88
  "upload_errors": [],
89
  "session_summary": {
90
- "n_turns": 1,
91
- "n_manager_verdicts": 1,
92
  "n_transitions": 0,
93
  "n_plan_completes": 0,
94
  "subprobe_coverage": {
95
  "1": {
96
- "engaging_default": 1,
97
  "other": 0
98
  }
99
  },
 
4
  "condition": "explanatory",
5
  "run_mode": "pilot",
6
  "started_at": "2026-05-24T11:11:23.803579+10:00",
7
+ "ended_at": "2026-05-24T11:12:03.582339+10:00",
8
  "model": "gpt-5.4-nano-2026-03-17",
9
  "case_id": "ai-predictive-analytics",
10
  "perfect_answer": {
 
24
  "directive": "Stay on their “that label sticks, teachers see it” thread. Anchor on “self-fulfilling prophecy,” and push for a concrete later-effect example: one specific way teaching behavior or student effort changes after teachers have seen the label for a while (not just immediately). End by asking them to choose the single latest, most telling time point when the harm shows up in outcomes and why.",
25
  "reason": "The participant doubled down that the label sticks and becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy with teachers changing how they treat students.",
26
  "latency_ms": 2014
27
+ },
28
+ {
29
+ "live_subprobe_id": 1,
30
+ "advanced_this_turn": false,
31
+ "turn_type": "engaging-default",
32
+ "directive": "Stay on the thread of “that label sticks, teachers see it, treat the student differently.” Anchor on their line about students internalizing the label. Push one step toward the long-run mechanism: not just first-week behavior, but what changes over a semester or school year (expectations, help offered, opportunities tried). Land on one open question about what concrete later outcome proves the label is self-fulfilling, not just a hypothesis.",
33
+ "reason": "The participant argues the premise is wrong and reiterates the self-fulfilling prophecy risk (“labeled as ‘at-risk’ may internalize that label and underperform”).",
34
+ "latency_ms": 2454
35
  }
36
  ],
37
  "turns": [
 
60
  "main_ms": 4624,
61
  "total_ms": 6659
62
  }
63
+ },
64
+ {
65
+ "n": 2,
66
+ "timestamp": "2026-05-24T11:12:03.582325+10:00",
67
+ "user_message": "You're asking the wrong thing by focusing on potential benefits rather than the inherent risks. Deploying an AI system like this creates a self-fulfilling prophecy where students labeled as \"at-risk\" may internalize that label and underperform. Additionally, it exacerbates existing fairness gaps, as the data may reflect societal biases rather than true student potential.",
68
+ "manager_verdict": {
69
+ "live_subprobe_id": 1,
70
+ "advanced_this_turn": false,
71
+ "turn_type": "engaging-default",
72
+ "directive": "Stay on the thread of “that label sticks, teachers see it, treat the student differently.” Anchor on their line about students internalizing the label. Push one step toward the long-run mechanism: not just first-week behavior, but what changes over a semester or school year (expectations, help offered, opportunities tried). Land on one open question about what concrete later outcome proves the label is self-fulfilling, not just a hypothesis.",
73
+ "reason": "The participant argues the premise is wrong and reiterates the self-fulfilling prophecy risk (“labeled as ‘at-risk’ may internalize that label and underperform”).",
74
+ "latency_ms": 2454
75
+ },
76
+ "plan_control": "=== PLAN CONTROL (host-managed, authoritative) ===\nturn_type: engaging-default\nlive_subprobe_id: 1\nadvanced_this_turn: False\n\nLIVE SUB-PROBE (work this one this turn):\nid: 1\nfamily: Consequences and how harm spreads (label effects and long-term fallout)\nprobe: Look at what changes for students after teachers start seeing the “likely low success” label, not just in the first few weeks\nrationale: The argument leans on the idea that the label sticks and shapes outcomes. This probe pushes toward concrete later effects like expectation shifts and changed teaching behavior over time, which strengthens the harm claim.\nanchor: \"that label sticks, teachers see it, treat the student differently\"\n\nDIRECTIVE for this turn:\nStay on the thread of “that label sticks, teachers see it, treat the student differently.” Anchor on their line about students internalizing the label. Push one step toward the long-run mechanism: not just first-week behavior, but what changes over a semester or school year (expectations, help offered, opportunities tried). Land on one open question about what concrete later outcome proves the label is self-fulfilling, not just a hypothesis.\n=== END PLAN CONTROL ===",
77
+ "assistant_response": "When you say it becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy where students internalize the label, the key long-run mechanism is that the label starts steering repeated everyday interactions over time. Once teachers treat a student as “likely low success,” the student is more likely to see lower expectations, different kinds of feedback, and a narrower set of learning opportunities across the semester. That repeated pattern is what can turn the original prediction into an actual trajectory, not just a first-week adjustment.",
78
+ "scratch": {
79
+ "chosen_target": 1,
80
+ "response_summary": "Tied “students internalize the label” to the long-run mechanism of repeated classroom expectations and feedback that can harden into outcomes over a semester.",
81
+ "directive_followed": "partial"
82
+ },
83
+ "latency_s": {
84
+ "manager_ms": 2455,
85
+ "ttft_ms": 2466,
86
+ "main_ms": 4327,
87
+ "total_ms": 6789
88
+ }
89
  }
90
  ],
91
  "feedback": [],
 
121
  },
122
  "upload_errors": [],
123
  "session_summary": {
124
+ "n_turns": 2,
125
+ "n_manager_verdicts": 2,
126
  "n_transitions": 0,
127
  "n_plan_completes": 0,
128
  "subprobe_coverage": {
129
  "1": {
130
+ "engaging_default": 2,
131
  "other": 0
132
  }
133
  },