Use post-review terminology in reader-facing docs instead of the internal word

TODO.md

@@ -69,7 +69,7 @@ missing gpt-oss answers from raw traces if they survive there.
 ## 2. Three-row disagreement between two source tables
 
 `omni2_94`, `omni2_3997`, `omni2_4006` disagree on `baseline_correct` between the
-primary routing table and the rebuttal matched labels. The rebuttal labels are
+primary routing table and the post-review matched labels. The post-review labels are
 staged because they reproduce the published aggregates exactly. Cause not
 determined. See `docs/provenance.md`.
 

docs/anonymization_report.md

@@ -53,7 +53,7 @@ nothing known.
   was carried across.
 - **Scheduler artifacts.** Job scripts, job identifiers, and run logs exist in
   the source tree. None staged.
-- **Reviewer and rebuttal discussion.** The source tree contains reviewer
+- **Reviewer and post-review discussion.** The source tree contains reviewer
   response plans, strategy notes, and OpenReview drafts. None staged.
 - **Raw model responses.** The confidence-probe source table has a
   `raw_response` column of model-generated text. Dropped. Only the parsed integer

docs/provenance.md

@@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ Three source trees, all read-only at staging time.
    2026-08-14). Copied verbatim into `data/aggregate/`, with a `setting_id`
    column added. These are the authoritative published numbers.
 
-2. **Rebuttal analysis artifacts** (`results_2026-07-12` through
+2. **Post-review analysis artifacts** (`results_2026-07-12` through
    `results_2026-07-14`) — per-problem matched labels, six-setting router
    retraining, confidence-probe metrics, and the Round-2 verification tables.
    Source of `data/matched_labels.csv`, `data/splits/six_setting_splits.csv`,
@@ -53,15 +53,15 @@ validation report.
 
 ## Known discrepancies, stated rather than hidden
 
-**The primary routing benchmark and the rebuttal matched labels disagree on 3 of
+**The primary routing benchmark and the post-review matched labels disagree on 3 of
 4,181 OmniMath gpt-oss-120b problems** (`omni2_94`, `omni2_3997`, `omni2_4006`).
 In each case the primary table records `baseline_final_passed = False` while the
-rebuttal matched labels record `baseline_correct = 1`, flipping the oracle label
+post-review matched labels record `baseline_correct = 1`, flipping the oracle label
 from `single_agent` to `baseline_llm`. Aggregate impact: baseline solve rate
-56.76% (primary) versus 56.83% (rebuttal, the published number); label counts
+56.76% (primary) versus 56.83% (post-review, the published number); label counts
 differ by 3 between the two tables.
 
-This release stages the **rebuttal** labels in `data/matched_labels.csv`, because
+This release stages the **post-review** labels in `data/matched_labels.csv`, because
 those are the ones that reproduce the published `anc/` aggregates exactly. The
 primary table is used only for OmniMath problem *metadata* (tier, difficulty,
 source) and for the 423-problem split — neither of which is affected. The cause

registry/checksums.sha256

@@ -1,8 +1,8 @@
 be06f3a4e4d079f7a34cf319636f88050fca605ca7c3f02c595e36daabd214c4  CITATION.cff
 fe34eb7ac34537c21249e1ff6c9cf7b863eb611f844c0cb212ea358576e32887  LICENSE
 37d5e9d642d6684659d096bd8ebb5ea2de7ccc487fcdb2e4479dfa073c322f23  NOTICE
-f45616e4130b5e65ca75cf8ad1f94360a0420c58a00e9aabd480f0b011e9ce7b  README.md
-b90a94d23b3a9d7ad2338acd0cac76aaaea6aaeed6b4cdc85a93dd517cc12d1c  TODO.md
+6d5a8469900a3e9659123d0047874491b2b5019b52cc2eedb47b80a3e8615a76  README.md
+d27d1195b4be7c75016ca83096d658548d1127de709c11061c733dc940e7c6e9  TODO.md
 aad9af7b8ae8cbee7a7d73ecb7393cbb5adcb6ded6d5ec924dc8d1487e34c045  data/aggregate/failure_and_protocol_value_targets.csv
 ff064f045fcfab7e352d58f56070d98c3d1461e6cf44d3dfa0c5b108713c3fa9  data/aggregate/heldout_router_evaluation.csv
 2e77e2a2fd25c7621d195a9b27686fffd1b7e82b5bd768431c9557d8c9f00771  data/aggregate/heldout_router_paired_differences.csv
@@ -27,11 +27,11 @@ ee8243acb43dac0d0ec38ff4fb5cb31d0ee4249712c9f3ebebd87b029902fa4f  data/router/si
 e1b90366deb1815c19748a53c30845c2285d1a20610c647afbf070ff1f2b6543  data/router/six_setting_text_metadata_verification.csv
 4019fa49262089d7db28c713e6cc22ccf9bc015a7e626d3ce89c0b16a0e00a67  data/splits/primary_omnimath_splits.csv
 509082a5c04ae29466c28ec96c177387f9ff66da470b99af178953056ccc1ef0  data/splits/six_setting_splits.csv
-5f29e9812f83a63f2525ff7127b35da3ecbbe1595fa579edfade82926b080f1a  docs/anonymization_report.md
+0cf04aad47ea797ebdb01b157876079dfcb0ff6410ebb5faf62b103e5abb3030  docs/anonymization_report.md
 75ba7cae77eb6bd019f5a2f0155108d73148171e5064a111fdce8c49176461c5  docs/confidence_probe_prompt.txt
 4633e3d95870ba855d07c972fefcdbf31ea22b48f35602530049abfb46872cee  docs/license_audit.md
 4069d4aaf1975279342af805c24b28c9c92617ae85c4e1d3ee6f6f37636e91bc  docs/primary_confidence_probe_prompt.txt
-ed185d33b56a0f86afb2fa120e3cdc13631803d4e0da2f22b2d883204c9e95ea  docs/provenance.md
+d87a9acf2af53272149b95d0e6cb3a80cdeb31c5bbd3c8309d4c076199e232aa  docs/provenance.md
 abcfeff67504846bd853c573170fa2650761ebc6356b241b1149bffa34417c01  docs/reconstruction.md
 869838a59adf5ece35a1a8f0c80e177c38c171321714f0e104c8e4fbaba2b257  docs/schema.md
 964edfed0886c1fc54ef447ed6adf8592b5b42063356bf5a8ba7097f82548798  registry/benchmarks.csv
@@ -39,6 +39,6 @@ abcfeff67504846bd853c573170fa2650761ebc6356b241b1149bffa34417c01  docs/reconstru
 1a97156270d9fcec83019bef45e7ce9f7eaf61befd1cbcc736f6f27800bb2187  registry/experiments.csv
 0b27a71a1bc8ce61efeadec7722cabc566286e5a335cf213fa21b05fcdc4d3c4  registry/models.csv
 e263c1473f08b37726726ee8b7c206f6799fa79e4fd1a128ee121ec3197c8ca5  registry/protocols.csv
-bc320aef5d23bd813da31bcea4345982fc8ae257802be3ee1446796b367f1b9c  registry/release_manifest.json
+09b56c1583699d9ca6915a5840cc57e0e0a882ed7e320c104f632140098767bc  registry/release_manifest.json
 3aea6a2d356a1809b69c3e8b0aaf9c54dfe05cbf73d5e2368f06e9f47c90aa70  registry/schema.json
 8e69d6584f3d059969eeb8a6515aa621305f1e223ebd4ffc501731b9f14c20b2  validate.py

registry/release_manifest.json

@@ -39,7 +39,7 @@
       "used_for": "data/aggregate/*.csv"
     },
     {
-      "name": "rebuttal_analysis_2026-07-12..14",
+      "name": "post_review_analysis_2026-07-12..14",
       "used_for": "data/matched_labels.csv, data/splits/six_setting_splits.csv, data/router/*, data/confidence/six_setting_*"
     },
     {
@@ -213,9 +213,9 @@
   ],
   "known_discrepancies": [
     {
-      "item": "3 of 4181 OmniMath gpt-oss-120b problems disagree between the primary routing table and the rebuttal matched labels (omni2_94, omni2_3997, omni2_4006)",
+      "item": "3 of 4181 OmniMath gpt-oss-120b problems disagree between the primary routing table and the post-review matched labels (omni2_94, omni2_3997, omni2_4006)",
       "effect": "baseline solve rate 56.76% vs 56.83%; oracle label flips single_agent -> baseline_llm",
-      "resolution": "the rebuttal labels are staged, because they reproduce the published anc/ aggregates exactly; cause not determined"
+      "resolution": "the post-review labels are staged, because they reproduce the published anc/ aggregates exactly; cause not determined"
     },
     {
       "item": "primary confidence probe clean-parse rate is 0.7329 (test) / 0.7380 (dev)",