SceneBench / curation_report.json
EgoF0102's picture
SceneBench v1: frozen source-derived test benchmark and verified artifacts
7735593 verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
15.7 kB
{
"initial": 2331,
"final": 2230,
"dropped": 101,
"point_corrections": 18,
"review": {
"reviewer": "Codex visual audit; not expert medical adjudication",
"drop": {
"SCB-P01-0014": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P01-0026": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P01-0034": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P01-0039": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P01-0042": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P01-0045": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P01-0052": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P01-0063": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P01-0065": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P01-0071": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P01-0077": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0003": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0004": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0007": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0009": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0010": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0012": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0014": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0016": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0018": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0023": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0024": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0026": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0028": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0030": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0033": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0034": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0036": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0037": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0039": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0041": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0046": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0050": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0053": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0058": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0060": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0063": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0065": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0070": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0071": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0072": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0076": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P02-0077": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0003": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0005": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0009": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0024": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0028": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0031": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0034": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0036": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0038": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0040": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0043": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0047": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0048": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0055": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0056": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0061": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0063": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0064": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0067": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0068": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0074": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0077": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-P04-0080": "Visible ambiguity, incorrect/overlapping marker, duplicate instrument detection, or unclear target.",
"SCB-C04-0004": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C04-0008": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C04-0012": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C04-0013": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C04-0023": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0002": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0005": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0008": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0010": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0016": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0019": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0021": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0024": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0029": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0031": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0033": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0035": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0037": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0038": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0040": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0041": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects, missed tools or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0043": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects, missed tools or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0044": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects, missed tools or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0045": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects, missed tools or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0046": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects, missed tools or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0047": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects, missed tools or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0054": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects, missed tools or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0056": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects, missed tools or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0058": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects, missed tools or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0059": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects, missed tools or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0063": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects, missed tools or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0066": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects, missed tools or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0067": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects, missed tools or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0075": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects, missed tools or an unclear anatomical reference.",
"SCB-C06-0078": "Diagnostic overlay shows duplicate/mislocalized objects, missed tools or an unclear anatomical reference."
},
"point_patches": {
"SCB-P02-0002": [
135,
50
],
"SCB-P02-0013": [
165,
136
],
"SCB-P02-0015": [
110,
175
],
"SCB-P02-0020": [
120,
150
],
"SCB-P02-0029": [
345,
125
],
"SCB-P02-0031": [
145,
115
],
"SCB-P02-0044": [
165,
25
],
"SCB-P02-0048": [
340,
70
],
"SCB-P02-0051": [
240,
110
],
"SCB-P02-0056": [
335,
190
],
"SCB-P02-0059": [
325,
160
],
"SCB-P02-0064": [
150,
85
],
"SCB-P02-0066": [
310,
175
],
"SCB-P02-0067": [
135,
23
],
"SCB-P02-0069": [
195,
75
],
"SCB-P02-0074": [
230,
60
],
"SCB-P02-0080": [
151,
58
],
"SCB-P02-0075": [
185,
175
]
},
"fully_reviewed_tasks": [
"P01",
"P02",
"P04",
"C06"
],
"notes": "No model correctness or answer text used for curation. Final P02 marker correction completed before official baseline; three P01 API-format smoke checks are archived separately and excluded.",
"stratified_review_tasks": [
"C04",
"C05",
"V01",
"V02",
"V03",
"V04"
]
},
"replacements": [
{
"id": "SCB-V04-0001",
"old_candidate_id": "fa3e206275b6f9153ad9",
"new_candidate_id": "427c3077084d3ed4ee69",
"frame": 640,
"reason": "Same-video, late-Calot negative control"
},
{
"id": "SCB-V04-0002",
"old_candidate_id": "badc69cb8c7bf49a57d1",
"new_candidate_id": "4deda3330485969c5cfb",
"frame": 637,
"reason": "Same-video, late-Calot negative control"
},
{
"id": "SCB-V04-0004",
"old_candidate_id": "640aef86b3e1e71bfd45",
"new_candidate_id": "b347c152af3b2bf83ccd",
"frame": 643,
"reason": "Same-video, late-Calot negative control"
}
],
"tasks": {
"P01": 69,
"P02": 48,
"P03": 80,
"P04": 57,
"P05": 80,
"R01": 80,
"R02": 80,
"R03": 80,
"R04": 80,
"R05": 80,
"R06": 80,
"C01": 80,
"C02": 80,
"C03": 80,
"C04": 75,
"C05": 61,
"C06": 50,
"C07": 80,
"PR01": 300,
"V01": 90,
"V02": 60,
"V03": 60,
"V04": 9,
"D01": 80,
"D02": 71,
"D03": 80,
"D04": 80,
"D05": 80
},
"families": {
"Perception": 334,
"Relation": 480,
"Composition": 506,
"Procedure": 300,
"CVS": 219,
"Dynamic": 391
},
"scope": "Source-derived reference answers; visual screening by Codex is not expert medical validation. No baseline-model outputs were used to select or edit questions."
}