PhD-Shin commited on
Commit
f34e147
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 88bb687

Discovery proposal: Cr2I2Te2 (OSC-00546) — pmmn Cr2X2Y2 ligand-mass regression, predicted index 43.419

Browse files

**Discovery track proposal — Cr2I2Te2 (`2CrITe-1`, `OSC-00546`)**

This material is in `candidates.csv` but not in `active_challenge.csv`, so it cannot be submitted through the Space. Submitting as a PR per the README.

**Why this material.** The active set contains exactly four `pmmn` Cr2X2Y2 members (X = halogen, Y = chalcogen): `2CrFSe-1` (nef 2.6532), `2ClCrTe-1` (2.7185), `2BrCrTe-1` (2.9724), `2CrISe-1` (3.1949). Cr2I2Te2 is the only I+Te member of the family and is absent. It is thermodynamically stable (`e_hull` 0.0), metallic (`gap_pbe` 0.0) and magnetic, with `sc_relevance` 0.75.

**How the claimed value was obtained.** Least squares of `(m_halogen, m_chalcogen) -> nef` and `-> n_band` over those four members:
- `nef = +2.55122 +0.005120*m_halogen -0.000009*m_chalcogen`, residual max 0.0132 (0.4%)
- `n_band = +1.04986 -0.001418*m_halogen +0.000843*m_chalcogen`, residual max 0.0282

giving nef = 3.1999 and n_band = 0.9774. Applying the published chain from `pipeline/downfold.py` — `Ne = round(0.9774*36) = 34` (even, <= 36, no particle-hole fold), `solver_delta = 0.0556`, `A_d = 0.04523` from `scoring_meta.json` — gives `Index = 3.1999 * 0.04523 * 300 = 43.419`. The same chain reproduces the published `A_dwave` for all four family members exactly.

**Honest framing.** These are *claimed* values from a chemical-trend extrapolation, flagged `"claimed": true`. They are deliberately not optimistic: 43.419 is below the family's best active member (`2CrISe-1`, 45.297), and the fitted chalcogen coefficient is essentially zero, so I do **not** claim Cr2I2Te2 beats the current top anchor (55.375). Please downfold it with the published pipeline and replace these numbers with the real ones. No rescaling or fitting to published reference scores was done.

Reproducible from the published data alone: `active_challenge.csv`, `candidates.csv`, `scoring_meta.json`, `pipeline/downfold.py`.

submissions/PhD-Shin_Cr2I2Te2_discovery.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,16 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "author": "PhD-Shin",
3
+ "material_id": "2CrITe-1",
4
+ "osc_id": "OSC-00546",
5
+ "formula": "Cr2I2Te2",
6
+ "method_name": "Discovery: pmmn Cr2X2Y2 ligand-mass regression",
7
+ "provisional_score": 43.419,
8
+ "verified": false,
9
+ "nef": 3.1999,
10
+ "n_band": 0.9774,
11
+ "solver_delta": 0.0556,
12
+ "A_dwave": 0.04523,
13
+ "track": "discovery",
14
+ "claimed": true,
15
+ "note": "Discovery proposal, not in the active set. Predicted from a least-squares fit of (halogen mass, chalcogen mass) -> (nef, n_band) over all four active pmmn Cr2X2Y2 members (2CrFSe-1, 2ClCrTe-1, 2BrCrTe-1, 2CrISe-1); nef residual max 0.0132. A_d is the published dome value at the predicted filling via the pipeline chain n_band 0.9774 -> Ne=34 -> delta=0.0556 -> A_d=0.04523. Index = nef * A_d * 300. Cr2I2Te2 is the only I+Te member of this family absent from the active set; e_hull=0.0, gap_pbe=0.0, metallic, magnetic. Please downfold with the published pipeline and replace these claimed values with the real ones."
16
+ }