HMSSS55 commited on
Commit
701692e
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 6490d5b

Add eval-2026-11-10 robustness analyses; preserve original dataset splits

Browse files
CHANGELOG.md ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,10 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ # eval-2026-11-10
2
+
3
+ Additive evaluation revision for arXiv:2611.10234.
4
+
5
+ - Preserve original train, validation and test splits, labels and published main leaderboard.
6
+ - Add base-page and requirement-group bootstrap intervals from frozen predictions.
7
+ - Add unfiltered, author-audit-excluded, structural-quarantined and convention-sensitive views.
8
+ - Add a same-model inference-cut ablation and output-format/family diagnostics.
9
+ - Disclose model-dependent exclusions and annotation limitations; no full relabelling, new training or independent human validation.
10
+ - The arXiv link currently points to the announced paper; this revision may precede its next arXiv version.
README.md CHANGED
@@ -44,14 +44,31 @@ contrast, a small tap target and others) or an element that is inconsistent with
44
  from another design language, or a local change of icon, accent colour, corner radius or material).
45
 
46
  - Project page and leaderboard: https://hms97.github.io/screenproof/
47
- - Paper: arXiv link to follow
48
  - Evaluation: `evaluate.py` in this repository (MIT License)
49
 
50
  ![Eight test screenshots: for each, a zoom on the labelled box (red) and the whole screen.](https://huggingface.co/datasets/HMSSS55/ScreenProof/resolve/main/assets/examples.jpg)
51
 
52
  *Examples from the consistency test and the text layout test. Each card shows a zoom on the labelled box (red) and
53
- the whole screen. Every fault is a single change made in the page code; the clean page has no fault, and a critic
54
- must stay silent on it.*
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
55
 
56
  ## Leaderboard
57
 
@@ -188,7 +205,10 @@ Limitations: single phone screens only; the text layout test is English only; cl
188
  title = {ScreenProof: Where Is This Screen Wrong? Finding UI Faults Without a Reference},
189
  author = {Sun, Huiming and Li, Yue and Yang, Kangning and Li, Ruineng and Cai, Jie and Fu, Lan and
190
  Fu, Yunwan and Li, Jinlong and Shen, Jinglin},
191
- journal = {arXiv preprint},
 
 
 
192
  year = {2026}
193
  }
194
  ```
 
44
  from another design language, or a local change of icon, accent colour, corner radius or material).
45
 
46
  - Project page and leaderboard: https://hms97.github.io/screenproof/
47
+ - Paper: [arXiv:2611.10234](https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.10234)
48
  - Evaluation: `evaluate.py` in this repository (MIT License)
49
 
50
  ![Eight test screenshots: for each, a zoom on the labelled box (red) and the whole screen.](https://huggingface.co/datasets/HMSSS55/ScreenProof/resolve/main/assets/examples.jpg)
51
 
52
  *Examples from the consistency test and the text layout test. Each card shows a zoom on the labelled box (red) and
53
+ the whole screen. Labels record code-injected edits; an edit is not by itself proof of a screenshot-visible fault. Nominally clean pages are expected to receive no findings; label validity has not been independently established for every page.*
54
+
55
+ ## Evaluation revision: eval-2026-11-10
56
+
57
+ The original Parquet splits, labels and main leaderboard remain unchanged. This additive revision provides [exclusion flags and cluster IDs](robustness/records.jsonl), [results and limitations](robustness/README.md), and [a reproducible statistical analysis](robustness.py). It is not a fully cleaned or independently human-validated dataset.
58
+
59
+ - Original 2,765-page pool: ProofJudge F1 0.481 versus Argon 0.372. Paired base-page bootstrap: difference +0.109, 95% CI [+0.079, +0.140]; coarser requirement/source groups: [+0.045, +0.177].
60
+ - Restoring 106 model-disputed pages: F1 0.478 versus 0.360. Aggregate nominal-clean flag rates become 9.0% and 30.0% (original retained pool: 7.4% and 17.8%).
61
+ - Excluding author-flagged records and drop/reorder leaves 2,581 pages: F1 0.506 versus 0.395. Excluding component transplants and local-icon too leaves 1,766: 0.627 versus 0.397. These subsets change coverage and do not replace the main benchmark.
62
+ - Removing only ProofJudge's inference cut changes F1 from 0.481 to 0.455 and aggregate clean flags from 7.4% to 51.6%; weights are unchanged.
63
+
64
+ ```bash
65
+ python robustness.py --data-dir . --output recomputed.json
66
+ python evaluate.py --data-dir . --predictions predictions.jsonl --subset structural_quarantine
67
+ ```
68
+
69
+ `robustness.py` requires NumPy and reproduces intervals from released per-record sufficient statistics. `evaluate.py` requires PyArrow and scores new predictions against the original Parquet records, with optional subset filtering. The 106 previously excluded records are represented by counts only; their screenshots are not added to the dataset. Pin the Hub commit or the `eval-2026-11-10` tag when available, and report the selected subset with every score.
70
+
71
+ Known limitations: drop/reorder labels may use whole-screen boxes and depend on a reference; style variation is not necessarily a defect. The existing audit was performed by one author with injection boxes visible, not independent blind annotation. Two evaluated models determined disputed-clean exclusions. Cluster intervals do not correct test-informed model selection. Box matching does not validate explanations. No new training-data ablation or independent human study is claimed. Text-layout evaluation is English-only; implemented CJK rules are not evaluated here.
72
 
73
  ## Leaderboard
74
 
 
205
  title = {ScreenProof: Where Is This Screen Wrong? Finding UI Faults Without a Reference},
206
  author = {Sun, Huiming and Li, Yue and Yang, Kangning and Li, Ruineng and Cai, Jie and Fu, Lan and
207
  Fu, Yunwan and Li, Jinlong and Shen, Jinglin},
208
+ journal = {arXiv preprint arXiv:2611.10234},
209
+ eprint = {2611.10234},
210
+ archivePrefix = {arXiv},
211
+ primaryClass = {cs.AI},
212
  year = {2026}
213
  }
214
  ```
SHA256SUMS.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,10 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "robustness.py": "72a9720af81bff2deff9378981030a36c6ec2f581dd847516e4d4ff16bfc24ab",
3
+ "evaluate.py": "80584ab86f89c655f76a89e647cb5f8ccc12a656cd752193b60f169e28470eca",
4
+ "README.md": "21893068ecb519338278aac7c327b72595749ace83ee6ec13d4ee3709152c730",
5
+ "CHANGELOG.md": "a3588ea8e177d2640702c70dc23c92f8e5c9a11aebacb201811adf4b24c53c65",
6
+ "robustness/records.jsonl": "27ba3178f4631e0e13756729d23eca842a2eae2ffa7ea635da05788e0c7f77fb",
7
+ "robustness/protocol.json": "94398580d4f7ffb9b8999b54961c794242b43327be51989dfebd6449ca8060f0",
8
+ "robustness/results.json": "4baf824e60bd481e22b3b1cc89e8b8640879de014afd120671b7d560b5e5be7f",
9
+ "robustness/README.md": "37dcc1f6c529ad7dae99383adad53e558662a2a56b80be23a8865ab3681e20f3"
10
+ }
evaluate.py CHANGED
@@ -23,6 +23,7 @@ import glob
23
  import json
24
  import os
25
  import re
 
26
 
27
  import pyarrow.parquet as pq
28
 
@@ -92,11 +93,22 @@ def main():
92
  ap.add_argument("--data-dir", default=os.path.dirname(os.path.abspath(__file__)))
93
  ap.add_argument("--iou", type=float, default=0.5)
94
  ap.add_argument("--exclude-human-flagged", action="store_true")
 
95
  a = ap.parse_args()
 
 
96
 
97
  rows = load_split(a.data_dir, a.split)
98
  if a.exclude_human_flagged:
99
  rows = [r for r in rows if r["human_check"] not in ("faulty", "hidden", "fine")]
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
100
  preds = {}
101
  with open(a.predictions, encoding="utf-8") as fh:
102
  for line in fh:
@@ -129,7 +141,7 @@ def main():
129
  c[f"fa_{s}"] += ans.get("follows") is False or bool(items)
130
  p = c["matched"] / c["boxes"] if c["boxes"] else 0.0
131
  rec = c["matched"] / c["faults"] if c["faults"] else 0.0
132
- out = {"pages": len(rows), "precision": round(p, 4), "recall": round(rec, 4),
133
  "f1": round(2 * p * rec / (p + rec), 4) if p + rec else 0.0,
134
  "consistency_recall": round(c["con_hit"] / max(1, c["con_truth"]), 4),
135
  "general_recall": round(c["gen_hit"] / max(1, c["gen_truth"]), 4),
 
23
  import json
24
  import os
25
  import re
26
+ from pathlib import Path
27
 
28
  import pyarrow.parquet as pq
29
 
 
93
  ap.add_argument("--data-dir", default=os.path.dirname(os.path.abspath(__file__)))
94
  ap.add_argument("--iou", type=float, default=0.5)
95
  ap.add_argument("--exclude-human-flagged", action="store_true")
96
+ ap.add_argument("--subset", default="published", choices=["published", "audit_excluded", "structural_quarantine", "convention_sensitivity"])
97
  a = ap.parse_args()
98
+ if a.subset != "published" and (a.split != "consistency_test" or a.exclude_human_flagged):
99
+ ap.error("--subset requires consistency_test and cannot be combined with --exclude-human-flagged")
100
 
101
  rows = load_split(a.data_dir, a.split)
102
  if a.exclude_human_flagged:
103
  rows = [r for r in rows if r["human_check"] not in ("faulty", "hidden", "fine")]
104
+ if a.subset != "published":
105
+ root = Path(a.data_dir) / "robustness"
106
+ protocol = json.loads((root / "protocol.json").read_text())
107
+ records = {r["id"]: r for r in map(json.loads, (root / "records.jsonl").read_text().splitlines()) if r["in_original_release"]}
108
+ if set(records) != {r["id"] for r in rows}:
109
+ raise SystemExit("Subset manifest does not match this dataset revision")
110
+ flags = protocol["pool_exclusions"][a.subset]
111
+ rows = [r for r in rows if not any(records[r["id"]][f] for f in flags)]
112
  preds = {}
113
  with open(a.predictions, encoding="utf-8") as fh:
114
  for line in fh:
 
141
  c[f"fa_{s}"] += ans.get("follows") is False or bool(items)
142
  p = c["matched"] / c["boxes"] if c["boxes"] else 0.0
143
  rec = c["matched"] / c["faults"] if c["faults"] else 0.0
144
+ out = {"protocol": "eval-2026-11-10", "subset": "audit_excluded" if a.exclude_human_flagged else a.subset, "pages": len(rows), "precision": round(p, 4), "recall": round(rec, 4),
145
  "f1": round(2 * p * rec / (p + rec), 4) if p + rec else 0.0,
146
  "consistency_recall": round(c["con_hit"] / max(1, c["con_truth"]), 4),
147
  "general_recall": round(c["gen_hit"] / max(1, c["gen_truth"]), 4),
robustness.py ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,31 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ """Reproduce ScreenProof eval-2026-11-10 from released per-record counts.
2
+ Requires numpy. Run: python robustness.py --data-dir . --output robustness/recomputed.json
3
+ Counts use frozen predictions and the existing IoU >= 0.5 scorer; this is a
4
+ post-hoc statistical reanalysis, not new labels, new training, or a new test.
5
+ """
6
+ import argparse,json
7
+ from pathlib import Path
8
+ import numpy as np
9
+
10
+ def f1(v):
11
+ return np.divide(2*v[...,0],v[...,1]+v[...,2],out=np.zeros_like(v[...,0],dtype=float),where=(v[...,1]+v[...,2])>0)
12
+
13
+ def main():
14
+ ap=argparse.ArgumentParser();ap.add_argument('--data-dir',type=Path,default=Path('.'));ap.add_argument('--output',type=Path,default=Path('recomputed.json'));a=ap.parse_args()
15
+ root=a.data_dir/'robustness';meta=json.loads((root/'protocol.json').read_text());rows=[json.loads(x) for x in (root/'records.jsonl').read_text().splitlines()]
16
+ out={}
17
+ for pool,flags in meta['pool_exclusions'].items():
18
+ selected=[r for r in rows if not any(r[f] for f in flags)]
19
+ arrays={m:np.array([r['counts'][m] for r in selected],dtype=float) for m in meta['models']}
20
+ result={'pages':len(selected),'models':{m:{'f1':float(f1(v.sum(0)[:3])),'clean_flag_rate':float(v[:,3].sum()/v[:,4].sum()),'errors':int(v[:,5].sum())} for m,v in arrays.items()}}
21
+ for level in (['base_cluster','requirement_cluster'] if pool=='published' else ['base_cluster']):
22
+ groups=sorted({r[level] for r in selected});lookup={g:i for i,g in enumerate(groups)};ids=[lookup[r[level]] for r in selected];k=len(groups)
23
+ w=np.random.default_rng(meta['seed']).multinomial(k,np.full(k,1/k),size=meta['resamples'])
24
+ boot={}
25
+ for m,v in arrays.items():
26
+ agg=np.zeros((k,3));np.add.at(agg,ids,v[:,:3]);boot[m]=f1(w@agg)
27
+ result[level]={'clusters':k,'vs':{m:np.quantile(boot[meta['ours']]-b,[.025,.975]).tolist() for m,b in boot.items() if m!=meta['ours']}}
28
+ out[pool]=result
29
+ a.output.parent.mkdir(parents=True,exist_ok=True);a.output.write_text(json.dumps(out,indent=2)+'\n')
30
+ print(json.dumps(out['published'],indent=2))
31
+ if __name__=='__main__':main()
robustness/README.md ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,87 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ # Frozen-prediction robustness analyses
2
+
3
+ Post-hoc exclusion sensitivity, not new ground truth or retraining. IoU 0.5; 10,000 paired whole-cluster resamples. All predictions and rules are frozen for this analysis.
4
+
5
+ | subset | pages | base clusters | ProofJudge F1 | Argon F1 | delta 95% CI |
6
+ |---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---|
7
+ | unfiltered | 2871 | 486 | 0.478 | 0.360 | [+0.088, +0.148] |
8
+ | published | 2765 | 469 | 0.481 | 0.372 | [+0.079, +0.140] |
9
+ | audit_excluded | 2680 | 460 | 0.489 | 0.377 | [+0.080, +0.141] |
10
+ | structural_quarantine | 2581 | 460 | 0.506 | 0.395 | [+0.078, +0.143] |
11
+ | convention_sensitivity | 1766 | 457 | 0.627 | 0.397 | [+0.187, +0.271] |
12
+
13
+ Exclusions are cumulative after published: author-audit exclusions; drop/reorder; component transplants and local-icon. Entire records are quarantined, never relabelled clean. The last subset changes task coverage and is not a replacement benchmark.
14
+
15
+ Base clusters merge source generator + base page across general/local/multi/negative variants; requirement clusters further merge generator/design language/theme. Real pages use URL/page identity, then hostname/app. Neither grouping corrects test-informed selection.
16
+
17
+ ## Published-pool diagnostics
18
+
19
+ | model | F1 | clean flagged | scoring errors | normalized kind right / matched known | aspect right / matched known |
20
+ |---|---:|---:|---:|---|---|
21
+ | rolejudge-v7f-r128soup-cut | 0.481 | 7.4% | 0 | 839/848 | 267/304 |
22
+ | gemini-4-argon | 0.372 | 17.8% | 0 | 709/853 | 282/504 |
23
+ | claude-opus-5-5-medium | 0.308 | 78.3% | 0 | 898/1064 | 283/611 |
24
+ | gpt-6.1-sol | 0.300 | 36.6% | 3 | 710/805 | 196/395 |
25
+ | rolejudge-v7f-r128soup | 0.455 | 51.6% | 0 | 1038/1058 | 385/443 |
26
+ | rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut | 0.405 | 6.9% | 0 | 679/688 | 182/223 |
27
+ | qwen3.5-9b-base | 0.043 | 87.8% | 282 | 428/603 | 214/408 |
28
+
29
+ Kind maps the consistency-prompt label inconsistent to the stored label brand; no other alias is mapped. Kind/aspect accuracy is conditional on matched boxes with known labels. It is not explanation correctness. Errors follow the existing scorer (non-dict answer), not a strict schema validator.
30
+
31
+ ## Requirement-cluster intervals
32
+
33
+ {
34
+ "clusters": 121,
35
+ "min_size": 1,
36
+ "max_size": 414,
37
+ "vs": {
38
+ "gemini-4-argon": {
39
+ "delta": 0.10899280004942724,
40
+ "ci95": [
41
+ 0.04467793849992695,
42
+ 0.17696848361181572
43
+ ]
44
+ },
45
+ "claude-opus-5-5-medium": {
46
+ "delta": 0.1730305063027215,
47
+ "ci95": [
48
+ 0.14083593515714832,
49
+ 0.20652628574165327
50
+ ]
51
+ },
52
+ "gpt-6.1-sol": {
53
+ "delta": 0.1808314426852562,
54
+ "ci95": [
55
+ 0.13080445467071503,
56
+ 0.22946292326254902
57
+ ]
58
+ },
59
+ "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": {
60
+ "delta": 0.02514385754245596,
61
+ "ci95": [
62
+ 0.005967370588310595,
63
+ 0.04313225869484571
64
+ ]
65
+ },
66
+ "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": {
67
+ "delta": 0.07576445358264244,
68
+ "ci95": [
69
+ 0.03961699314203121,
70
+ 0.10928092511103336
71
+ ]
72
+ },
73
+ "qwen3.5-9b-base": {
74
+ "delta": 0.4375702111145328,
75
+ "ci95": [
76
+ 0.3703972864951111,
77
+ 0.4854255803273521
78
+ ]
79
+ }
80
+ }
81
+ }
82
+
83
+ ## Public reproduction
84
+
85
+ Run `python robustness.py --data-dir . --output recomputed.json` (Python + NumPy). `records.jsonl` contains per-record sufficient statistics for frozen predictions, opaque cluster IDs and exclusion flags. Original release IDs (`ct-*`) are preserved. The 106 `excluded-*` records have counts only; their screenshots are not added to the original dataset. This reproduces statistical reanalysis, not model inference. The original Parquet splits and their labels remain unchanged.
86
+
87
+ The historical implementation recorded in results.json belongs to the paper workspace; the portable command above requires only files in this release. No independent blind human validation or new training-data ablation is claimed.
robustness/protocol.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,52 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "version": "eval-2026-11-10",
3
+ "paper": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.10234",
4
+ "dataset_base_revision": "6490d5b5e59ab6fe510af98f086ad355cc530f9f",
5
+ "seed": 20261110,
6
+ "resamples": 10000,
7
+ "iou": 0.5,
8
+ "models": [
9
+ "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup-cut",
10
+ "gemini-4-argon",
11
+ "claude-opus-5-5-medium",
12
+ "gpt-6.1-sol",
13
+ "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup",
14
+ "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut",
15
+ "qwen3.5-9b-base"
16
+ ],
17
+ "ours": "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup-cut",
18
+ "count_columns": [
19
+ "matched",
20
+ "boxes",
21
+ "truths",
22
+ "false_alarm",
23
+ "clean",
24
+ "scoring_error",
25
+ "kind_right_raw",
26
+ "kind_known",
27
+ "aspect_right",
28
+ "aspect_known",
29
+ "kind_right_normalized"
30
+ ],
31
+ "pool_exclusions": {
32
+ "unfiltered": [],
33
+ "published": [
34
+ "disputed"
35
+ ],
36
+ "audit_excluded": [
37
+ "disputed",
38
+ "audit_excluded"
39
+ ],
40
+ "structural_quarantine": [
41
+ "disputed",
42
+ "audit_excluded",
43
+ "structural"
44
+ ],
45
+ "convention_sensitivity": [
46
+ "disputed",
47
+ "audit_excluded",
48
+ "structural",
49
+ "convention"
50
+ ]
51
+ }
52
+ }
robustness/records.jsonl ADDED
The diff for this file is too large to render. See raw diff
 
robustness/results.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,1214 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "resamples": 10000,
3
+ "seed": 20261110,
4
+ "ours": "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup-cut",
5
+ "iou": 0.5,
6
+ "subsets": {
7
+ "unfiltered": {
8
+ "pages": 2871,
9
+ "faults": {
10
+ "clean": 487,
11
+ "swap-navbar": 148,
12
+ "swap-button": 108,
13
+ "swap-chip": 51,
14
+ "common-type": 77,
15
+ "common-low_contrast": 55,
16
+ "swap-listrow": 143,
17
+ "swap-fab": 17,
18
+ "swap-search": 42,
19
+ "common-overflow": 43,
20
+ "common-overlap": 63,
21
+ "swap-tabbar": 12,
22
+ "swap-segmented": 28,
23
+ "common-small_target": 46,
24
+ "common-drop": 44,
25
+ "common-reorder": 65,
26
+ "local-icon": 188,
27
+ "local-radius": 86,
28
+ "local-material": 123,
29
+ "local-colour": 160,
30
+ "swap-switch": 77,
31
+ "swap-slider": 17,
32
+ "swap-dialog": 15,
33
+ "swap-sheet": 4,
34
+ "multi-display-missing_image": 108,
35
+ "multi-display-ellipsis": 32,
36
+ "multi-display-cropped": 147,
37
+ "multi-display-null_value": 60,
38
+ "negative-selection": 111,
39
+ "common-two_selected": 111,
40
+ "negative-badge": 40,
41
+ "common-badge_overlap": 40,
42
+ "negative-placeholder": 44,
43
+ "negative-primary": 19,
44
+ "local-primary_colour": 19,
45
+ "negative-fab": 12,
46
+ "common-fab_overlap": 12,
47
+ "multi-common-low_contrast": 11,
48
+ "multi-common-overflow": 4,
49
+ "multi-common-small_target": 2
50
+ },
51
+ "models": {
52
+ "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup-cut": {
53
+ "f1": 0.4777464788732394,
54
+ "precision": 0.6091954022988506,
55
+ "recall": 0.39295644114921224,
56
+ "false_alarm": 0.08976157082748948,
57
+ "clean": 713,
58
+ "errors": 0,
59
+ "matched": 848,
60
+ "boxes": 1392,
61
+ "truths": 2158,
62
+ "kind_right": 539,
63
+ "kind_known": 848,
64
+ "aspect_right": 267,
65
+ "aspect_known": 304,
66
+ "normalized_kind_right": 839
67
+ },
68
+ "gemini-4-argon": {
69
+ "f1": 0.3598396962666104,
70
+ "precision": 0.3302361595044522,
71
+ "recall": 0.39527340129749766,
72
+ "false_alarm": 0.30014025245441794,
73
+ "clean": 713,
74
+ "errors": 0,
75
+ "matched": 853,
76
+ "boxes": 2583,
77
+ "truths": 2158,
78
+ "kind_right": 342,
79
+ "kind_known": 853,
80
+ "aspect_right": 282,
81
+ "aspect_known": 504,
82
+ "normalized_kind_right": 709
83
+ },
84
+ "claude-opus-5-5-medium": {
85
+ "f1": 0.29770565193060994,
86
+ "precision": 0.21322645290581163,
87
+ "recall": 0.49304911955514363,
88
+ "false_alarm": 0.8036465638148668,
89
+ "clean": 713,
90
+ "errors": 0,
91
+ "matched": 1064,
92
+ "boxes": 4990,
93
+ "truths": 2158,
94
+ "kind_right": 420,
95
+ "kind_known": 1064,
96
+ "aspect_right": 283,
97
+ "aspect_known": 611,
98
+ "normalized_kind_right": 898
99
+ },
100
+ "gpt-6.1-sol": {
101
+ "f1": 0.2901423679942332,
102
+ "precision": 0.23739309938071365,
103
+ "recall": 0.3730305838739574,
104
+ "false_alarm": 0.4600280504908836,
105
+ "clean": 713,
106
+ "errors": 3,
107
+ "matched": 805,
108
+ "boxes": 3391,
109
+ "truths": 2158,
110
+ "kind_right": 393,
111
+ "kind_known": 805,
112
+ "aspect_right": 196,
113
+ "aspect_known": 395,
114
+ "normalized_kind_right": 710
115
+ },
116
+ "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": {
117
+ "f1": 0.44859020563917745,
118
+ "precision": 0.4134427510746385,
119
+ "recall": 0.4902687673772011,
120
+ "false_alarm": 0.5301542776998598,
121
+ "clean": 713,
122
+ "errors": 0,
123
+ "matched": 1058,
124
+ "boxes": 2559,
125
+ "truths": 2158,
126
+ "kind_right": 605,
127
+ "kind_known": 1058,
128
+ "aspect_right": 385,
129
+ "aspect_known": 443,
130
+ "normalized_kind_right": 1038
131
+ },
132
+ "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": {
133
+ "f1": 0.40351906158357775,
134
+ "precision": 0.549520766773163,
135
+ "recall": 0.31881371640407785,
136
+ "false_alarm": 0.07433380084151472,
137
+ "clean": 713,
138
+ "errors": 0,
139
+ "matched": 688,
140
+ "boxes": 1252,
141
+ "truths": 2158,
142
+ "kind_right": 463,
143
+ "kind_known": 688,
144
+ "aspect_right": 182,
145
+ "aspect_known": 223,
146
+ "normalized_kind_right": 679
147
+ },
148
+ "qwen3.5-9b-base": {
149
+ "f1": 0.04166954598852878,
150
+ "precision": 0.022513440860215055,
151
+ "recall": 0.2794253938832252,
152
+ "false_alarm": 0.8821879382889201,
153
+ "clean": 713,
154
+ "errors": 292,
155
+ "matched": 603,
156
+ "boxes": 26784,
157
+ "truths": 2158,
158
+ "kind_right": 20,
159
+ "kind_known": 603,
160
+ "aspect_right": 214,
161
+ "aspect_known": 408,
162
+ "normalized_kind_right": 428
163
+ }
164
+ },
165
+ "base_bootstrap": {
166
+ "clusters": 486,
167
+ "min_size": 1,
168
+ "max_size": 25,
169
+ "vs": {
170
+ "gemini-4-argon": {
171
+ "delta": 0.11790678260662901,
172
+ "ci95": [
173
+ 0.08761223765461952,
174
+ 0.1484526149519525
175
+ ]
176
+ },
177
+ "claude-opus-5-5-medium": {
178
+ "delta": 0.18004082694262946,
179
+ "ci95": [
180
+ 0.157066158146166,
181
+ 0.202959339556883
182
+ ]
183
+ },
184
+ "gpt-6.1-sol": {
185
+ "delta": 0.1876041108790062,
186
+ "ci95": [
187
+ 0.15698316298091203,
188
+ 0.21914929600029698
189
+ ]
190
+ },
191
+ "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": {
192
+ "delta": 0.029156273234061947,
193
+ "ci95": [
194
+ 0.014235602965603904,
195
+ 0.043825377089743746
196
+ ]
197
+ },
198
+ "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": {
199
+ "delta": 0.07422741728966165,
200
+ "ci95": [
201
+ 0.05516100139367012,
202
+ 0.09392536015620727
203
+ ]
204
+ },
205
+ "qwen3.5-9b-base": {
206
+ "delta": 0.4360769328847106,
207
+ "ci95": [
208
+ 0.4122818415353857,
209
+ 0.46004061519641287
210
+ ]
211
+ }
212
+ }
213
+ }
214
+ },
215
+ "published": {
216
+ "pages": 2765,
217
+ "faults": {
218
+ "swap-navbar": 148,
219
+ "swap-button": 108,
220
+ "swap-chip": 51,
221
+ "common-type": 77,
222
+ "common-low_contrast": 55,
223
+ "clean": 426,
224
+ "swap-listrow": 143,
225
+ "swap-fab": 17,
226
+ "swap-search": 42,
227
+ "common-overflow": 43,
228
+ "common-overlap": 63,
229
+ "swap-tabbar": 12,
230
+ "swap-segmented": 28,
231
+ "common-small_target": 46,
232
+ "common-drop": 44,
233
+ "common-reorder": 65,
234
+ "local-icon": 188,
235
+ "local-radius": 86,
236
+ "local-material": 123,
237
+ "local-colour": 160,
238
+ "swap-switch": 77,
239
+ "swap-slider": 17,
240
+ "swap-dialog": 15,
241
+ "swap-sheet": 4,
242
+ "multi-display-missing_image": 108,
243
+ "multi-display-ellipsis": 32,
244
+ "multi-display-cropped": 147,
245
+ "multi-display-null_value": 60,
246
+ "negative-selection": 94,
247
+ "common-two_selected": 111,
248
+ "negative-badge": 32,
249
+ "common-badge_overlap": 40,
250
+ "negative-placeholder": 39,
251
+ "local-primary_colour": 19,
252
+ "negative-fab": 9,
253
+ "common-fab_overlap": 12,
254
+ "negative-primary": 7,
255
+ "multi-common-low_contrast": 11,
256
+ "multi-common-overflow": 4,
257
+ "multi-common-small_target": 2
258
+ },
259
+ "models": {
260
+ "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup-cut": {
261
+ "f1": 0.48058940209691137,
262
+ "precision": 0.6185266229029905,
263
+ "recall": 0.39295644114921224,
264
+ "false_alarm": 0.07413509060955518,
265
+ "clean": 607,
266
+ "errors": 0,
267
+ "matched": 848,
268
+ "boxes": 1371,
269
+ "truths": 2158,
270
+ "kind_right": 539,
271
+ "kind_known": 848,
272
+ "aspect_right": 267,
273
+ "aspect_known": 304,
274
+ "normalized_kind_right": 839
275
+ },
276
+ "gemini-4-argon": {
277
+ "f1": 0.3715966020474841,
278
+ "precision": 0.3505959720509659,
279
+ "recall": 0.39527340129749766,
280
+ "false_alarm": 0.17792421746293247,
281
+ "clean": 607,
282
+ "errors": 0,
283
+ "matched": 853,
284
+ "boxes": 2433,
285
+ "truths": 2158,
286
+ "kind_right": 342,
287
+ "kind_known": 853,
288
+ "aspect_right": 282,
289
+ "aspect_known": 504,
290
+ "normalized_kind_right": 709
291
+ },
292
+ "claude-opus-5-5-medium": {
293
+ "f1": 0.3075588957941899,
294
+ "precision": 0.22348246166771688,
295
+ "recall": 0.49304911955514363,
296
+ "false_alarm": 0.7825370675453048,
297
+ "clean": 607,
298
+ "errors": 0,
299
+ "matched": 1064,
300
+ "boxes": 4761,
301
+ "truths": 2158,
302
+ "kind_right": 420,
303
+ "kind_known": 1064,
304
+ "aspect_right": 283,
305
+ "aspect_known": 611,
306
+ "normalized_kind_right": 898
307
+ },
308
+ "gpt-6.1-sol": {
309
+ "f1": 0.2997579594116552,
310
+ "precision": 0.25054466230936817,
311
+ "recall": 0.3730305838739574,
312
+ "false_alarm": 0.3657331136738056,
313
+ "clean": 607,
314
+ "errors": 3,
315
+ "matched": 805,
316
+ "boxes": 3213,
317
+ "truths": 2158,
318
+ "kind_right": 393,
319
+ "kind_known": 805,
320
+ "aspect_right": 196,
321
+ "aspect_known": 395,
322
+ "normalized_kind_right": 710
323
+ },
324
+ "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": {
325
+ "f1": 0.4554455445544554,
326
+ "precision": 0.4252411575562701,
327
+ "recall": 0.4902687673772011,
328
+ "false_alarm": 0.515650741350906,
329
+ "clean": 607,
330
+ "errors": 0,
331
+ "matched": 1058,
332
+ "boxes": 2488,
333
+ "truths": 2158,
334
+ "kind_right": 605,
335
+ "kind_known": 1058,
336
+ "aspect_right": 385,
337
+ "aspect_known": 443,
338
+ "normalized_kind_right": 1038
339
+ },
340
+ "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": {
341
+ "f1": 0.4048249485142689,
342
+ "precision": 0.5543916196615633,
343
+ "recall": 0.31881371640407785,
344
+ "false_alarm": 0.06919275123558484,
345
+ "clean": 607,
346
+ "errors": 0,
347
+ "matched": 688,
348
+ "boxes": 1241,
349
+ "truths": 2158,
350
+ "kind_right": 463,
351
+ "kind_known": 688,
352
+ "aspect_right": 182,
353
+ "aspect_known": 223,
354
+ "normalized_kind_right": 679
355
+ },
356
+ "qwen3.5-9b-base": {
357
+ "f1": 0.04301919098237854,
358
+ "precision": 0.023303447209769672,
359
+ "recall": 0.2794253938832252,
360
+ "false_alarm": 0.8780889621087314,
361
+ "clean": 607,
362
+ "errors": 282,
363
+ "matched": 603,
364
+ "boxes": 25876,
365
+ "truths": 2158,
366
+ "kind_right": 20,
367
+ "kind_known": 603,
368
+ "aspect_right": 214,
369
+ "aspect_known": 408,
370
+ "normalized_kind_right": 428
371
+ }
372
+ },
373
+ "base_bootstrap": {
374
+ "clusters": 469,
375
+ "min_size": 1,
376
+ "max_size": 25,
377
+ "vs": {
378
+ "gemini-4-argon": {
379
+ "delta": 0.10899280004942724,
380
+ "ci95": [
381
+ 0.07861130987305658,
382
+ 0.13977227007512993
383
+ ]
384
+ },
385
+ "claude-opus-5-5-medium": {
386
+ "delta": 0.1730305063027215,
387
+ "ci95": [
388
+ 0.14973295382964544,
389
+ 0.1955147349765577
390
+ ]
391
+ },
392
+ "gpt-6.1-sol": {
393
+ "delta": 0.1808314426852562,
394
+ "ci95": [
395
+ 0.14836676575593857,
396
+ 0.2131133582931496
397
+ ]
398
+ },
399
+ "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": {
400
+ "delta": 0.02514385754245596,
401
+ "ci95": [
402
+ 0.010260478680406186,
403
+ 0.03943047502601561
404
+ ]
405
+ },
406
+ "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": {
407
+ "delta": 0.07576445358264244,
408
+ "ci95": [
409
+ 0.05604748796387334,
410
+ 0.09492340873975616
411
+ ]
412
+ },
413
+ "qwen3.5-9b-base": {
414
+ "delta": 0.4375702111145328,
415
+ "ci95": [
416
+ 0.4129719697091177,
417
+ 0.4613580982021184
418
+ ]
419
+ }
420
+ }
421
+ },
422
+ "requirement_bootstrap": {
423
+ "clusters": 121,
424
+ "min_size": 1,
425
+ "max_size": 414,
426
+ "vs": {
427
+ "gemini-4-argon": {
428
+ "delta": 0.10899280004942724,
429
+ "ci95": [
430
+ 0.04467793849992695,
431
+ 0.17696848361181572
432
+ ]
433
+ },
434
+ "claude-opus-5-5-medium": {
435
+ "delta": 0.1730305063027215,
436
+ "ci95": [
437
+ 0.14083593515714832,
438
+ 0.20652628574165327
439
+ ]
440
+ },
441
+ "gpt-6.1-sol": {
442
+ "delta": 0.1808314426852562,
443
+ "ci95": [
444
+ 0.13080445467071503,
445
+ 0.22946292326254902
446
+ ]
447
+ },
448
+ "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": {
449
+ "delta": 0.02514385754245596,
450
+ "ci95": [
451
+ 0.005967370588310595,
452
+ 0.04313225869484571
453
+ ]
454
+ },
455
+ "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": {
456
+ "delta": 0.07576445358264244,
457
+ "ci95": [
458
+ 0.03961699314203121,
459
+ 0.10928092511103336
460
+ ]
461
+ },
462
+ "qwen3.5-9b-base": {
463
+ "delta": 0.4375702111145328,
464
+ "ci95": [
465
+ 0.3703972864951111,
466
+ 0.4854255803273521
467
+ ]
468
+ }
469
+ }
470
+ }
471
+ },
472
+ "audit_excluded": {
473
+ "pages": 2680,
474
+ "faults": {
475
+ "swap-button": 100,
476
+ "swap-chip": 50,
477
+ "common-type": 72,
478
+ "common-low_contrast": 55,
479
+ "clean": 394,
480
+ "swap-listrow": 138,
481
+ "swap-fab": 16,
482
+ "swap-search": 38,
483
+ "swap-navbar": 142,
484
+ "common-overflow": 42,
485
+ "common-overlap": 63,
486
+ "common-small_target": 46,
487
+ "swap-segmented": 26,
488
+ "common-drop": 41,
489
+ "common-reorder": 58,
490
+ "swap-tabbar": 11,
491
+ "local-icon": 188,
492
+ "local-radius": 86,
493
+ "local-material": 123,
494
+ "local-colour": 160,
495
+ "swap-switch": 76,
496
+ "swap-slider": 15,
497
+ "swap-dialog": 14,
498
+ "swap-sheet": 1,
499
+ "multi-display-missing_image": 108,
500
+ "multi-display-ellipsis": 32,
501
+ "multi-display-cropped": 147,
502
+ "multi-display-null_value": 60,
503
+ "negative-selection": 94,
504
+ "common-two_selected": 111,
505
+ "negative-badge": 32,
506
+ "common-badge_overlap": 40,
507
+ "negative-placeholder": 39,
508
+ "local-primary_colour": 19,
509
+ "negative-fab": 8,
510
+ "common-fab_overlap": 12,
511
+ "negative-primary": 6,
512
+ "multi-common-low_contrast": 11,
513
+ "multi-common-overflow": 4,
514
+ "multi-common-small_target": 2
515
+ },
516
+ "models": {
517
+ "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup-cut": {
518
+ "f1": 0.4885672937771346,
519
+ "precision": 0.6261127596439169,
520
+ "recall": 0.40056953013763646,
521
+ "false_alarm": 0.07329842931937172,
522
+ "clean": 573,
523
+ "errors": 0,
524
+ "matched": 844,
525
+ "boxes": 1348,
526
+ "truths": 2107,
527
+ "kind_right": 538,
528
+ "kind_known": 844,
529
+ "aspect_right": 264,
530
+ "aspect_known": 301,
531
+ "normalized_kind_right": 835
532
+ },
533
+ "gemini-4-argon": {
534
+ "f1": 0.3774258309167968,
535
+ "precision": 0.3560606060606061,
536
+ "recall": 0.4015187470336972,
537
+ "false_alarm": 0.17975567190226877,
538
+ "clean": 573,
539
+ "errors": 0,
540
+ "matched": 846,
541
+ "boxes": 2376,
542
+ "truths": 2107,
543
+ "kind_right": 342,
544
+ "kind_known": 846,
545
+ "aspect_right": 277,
546
+ "aspect_known": 497,
547
+ "normalized_kind_right": 704
548
+ },
549
+ "claude-opus-5-5-medium": {
550
+ "f1": 0.31506644766313274,
551
+ "precision": 0.2298474945533769,
552
+ "recall": 0.5007119126720455,
553
+ "false_alarm": 0.787085514834206,
554
+ "clean": 573,
555
+ "errors": 0,
556
+ "matched": 1055,
557
+ "boxes": 4590,
558
+ "truths": 2107,
559
+ "kind_right": 419,
560
+ "kind_known": 1055,
561
+ "aspect_right": 279,
562
+ "aspect_known": 603,
563
+ "normalized_kind_right": 890
564
+ },
565
+ "gpt-6.1-sol": {
566
+ "f1": 0.3095927427137618,
567
+ "precision": 0.2608978529603123,
568
+ "recall": 0.3806359753203607,
569
+ "false_alarm": 0.35951134380453753,
570
+ "clean": 573,
571
+ "errors": 2,
572
+ "matched": 802,
573
+ "boxes": 3074,
574
+ "truths": 2107,
575
+ "kind_right": 392,
576
+ "kind_known": 802,
577
+ "aspect_right": 194,
578
+ "aspect_known": 393,
579
+ "normalized_kind_right": 707
580
+ },
581
+ "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": {
582
+ "f1": 0.46457041629760853,
583
+ "precision": 0.43545039435450394,
584
+ "recall": 0.4978642619838633,
585
+ "false_alarm": 0.5043630017452007,
586
+ "clean": 573,
587
+ "errors": 0,
588
+ "matched": 1049,
589
+ "boxes": 2409,
590
+ "truths": 2107,
591
+ "kind_right": 603,
592
+ "kind_known": 1049,
593
+ "aspect_right": 378,
594
+ "aspect_known": 436,
595
+ "normalized_kind_right": 1029
596
+ },
597
+ "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": {
598
+ "f1": 0.4106714628297362,
599
+ "precision": 0.5573637103336045,
600
+ "recall": 0.32510678690080685,
601
+ "false_alarm": 0.06806282722513089,
602
+ "clean": 573,
603
+ "errors": 0,
604
+ "matched": 685,
605
+ "boxes": 1229,
606
+ "truths": 2107,
607
+ "kind_right": 462,
608
+ "kind_known": 685,
609
+ "aspect_right": 181,
610
+ "aspect_known": 221,
611
+ "normalized_kind_right": 676
612
+ },
613
+ "qwen3.5-9b-base": {
614
+ "f1": 0.043282103950408976,
615
+ "precision": 0.023453649228812212,
616
+ "recall": 0.2800189843379212,
617
+ "false_alarm": 0.8778359511343804,
618
+ "clean": 573,
619
+ "errors": 274,
620
+ "matched": 590,
621
+ "boxes": 25156,
622
+ "truths": 2107,
623
+ "kind_right": 19,
624
+ "kind_known": 590,
625
+ "aspect_right": 205,
626
+ "aspect_known": 396,
627
+ "normalized_kind_right": 415
628
+ }
629
+ },
630
+ "base_bootstrap": {
631
+ "clusters": 460,
632
+ "min_size": 1,
633
+ "max_size": 25,
634
+ "vs": {
635
+ "gemini-4-argon": {
636
+ "delta": 0.11114146286033777,
637
+ "ci95": [
638
+ 0.07967464664486199,
639
+ 0.1414465221686127
640
+ ]
641
+ },
642
+ "claude-opus-5-5-medium": {
643
+ "delta": 0.17350084611400185,
644
+ "ci95": [
645
+ 0.15042032661224217,
646
+ 0.19584024539229442
647
+ ]
648
+ },
649
+ "gpt-6.1-sol": {
650
+ "delta": 0.1789745510633728,
651
+ "ci95": [
652
+ 0.14750714475477159,
653
+ 0.21097993264872794
654
+ ]
655
+ },
656
+ "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": {
657
+ "delta": 0.023996877479526058,
658
+ "ci95": [
659
+ 0.008922994780452742,
660
+ 0.03875636995415016
661
+ ]
662
+ },
663
+ "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": {
664
+ "delta": 0.07789583094739838,
665
+ "ci95": [
666
+ 0.05877179782683998,
667
+ 0.09737202460231702
668
+ ]
669
+ },
670
+ "qwen3.5-9b-base": {
671
+ "delta": 0.4452851898267256,
672
+ "ci95": [
673
+ 0.42122242693278383,
674
+ 0.4679879361780612
675
+ ]
676
+ }
677
+ }
678
+ }
679
+ },
680
+ "structural_quarantine": {
681
+ "pages": 2581,
682
+ "faults": {
683
+ "swap-button": 100,
684
+ "swap-chip": 50,
685
+ "common-type": 72,
686
+ "common-low_contrast": 55,
687
+ "clean": 394,
688
+ "swap-listrow": 138,
689
+ "swap-fab": 16,
690
+ "swap-search": 38,
691
+ "swap-navbar": 142,
692
+ "common-overflow": 42,
693
+ "common-overlap": 63,
694
+ "common-small_target": 46,
695
+ "swap-segmented": 26,
696
+ "swap-tabbar": 11,
697
+ "local-icon": 188,
698
+ "local-radius": 86,
699
+ "local-material": 123,
700
+ "local-colour": 160,
701
+ "swap-switch": 76,
702
+ "swap-slider": 15,
703
+ "swap-dialog": 14,
704
+ "swap-sheet": 1,
705
+ "multi-display-missing_image": 108,
706
+ "multi-display-ellipsis": 32,
707
+ "multi-display-cropped": 147,
708
+ "multi-display-null_value": 60,
709
+ "negative-selection": 94,
710
+ "common-two_selected": 111,
711
+ "negative-badge": 32,
712
+ "common-badge_overlap": 40,
713
+ "negative-placeholder": 39,
714
+ "local-primary_colour": 19,
715
+ "negative-fab": 8,
716
+ "common-fab_overlap": 12,
717
+ "negative-primary": 6,
718
+ "multi-common-low_contrast": 11,
719
+ "multi-common-overflow": 4,
720
+ "multi-common-small_target": 2
721
+ },
722
+ "models": {
723
+ "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup-cut": {
724
+ "f1": 0.5063063063063064,
725
+ "precision": 0.6376701966717095,
726
+ "recall": 0.4198207171314741,
727
+ "false_alarm": 0.07329842931937172,
728
+ "clean": 573,
729
+ "errors": 0,
730
+ "matched": 843,
731
+ "boxes": 1322,
732
+ "truths": 2008,
733
+ "kind_right": 537,
734
+ "kind_known": 843,
735
+ "aspect_right": 264,
736
+ "aspect_known": 301,
737
+ "normalized_kind_right": 834
738
+ },
739
+ "gemini-4-argon": {
740
+ "f1": 0.3954194905351718,
741
+ "precision": 0.3725231175693527,
742
+ "recall": 0.4213147410358566,
743
+ "false_alarm": 0.17975567190226877,
744
+ "clean": 573,
745
+ "errors": 0,
746
+ "matched": 846,
747
+ "boxes": 2271,
748
+ "truths": 2008,
749
+ "kind_right": 342,
750
+ "kind_known": 846,
751
+ "aspect_right": 277,
752
+ "aspect_known": 497,
753
+ "normalized_kind_right": 704
754
+ },
755
+ "claude-opus-5-5-medium": {
756
+ "f1": 0.3270186335403727,
757
+ "precision": 0.23759025270758122,
758
+ "recall": 0.524402390438247,
759
+ "false_alarm": 0.787085514834206,
760
+ "clean": 573,
761
+ "errors": 0,
762
+ "matched": 1053,
763
+ "boxes": 4432,
764
+ "truths": 2008,
765
+ "kind_right": 419,
766
+ "kind_known": 1053,
767
+ "aspect_right": 279,
768
+ "aspect_known": 603,
769
+ "normalized_kind_right": 890
770
+ },
771
+ "gpt-6.1-sol": {
772
+ "f1": 0.3208,
773
+ "precision": 0.268048128342246,
774
+ "recall": 0.399402390438247,
775
+ "false_alarm": 0.35951134380453753,
776
+ "clean": 573,
777
+ "errors": 2,
778
+ "matched": 802,
779
+ "boxes": 2992,
780
+ "truths": 2008,
781
+ "kind_right": 392,
782
+ "kind_known": 802,
783
+ "aspect_right": 194,
784
+ "aspect_known": 393,
785
+ "normalized_kind_right": 707
786
+ },
787
+ "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": {
788
+ "f1": 0.48302932348187483,
789
+ "precision": 0.45027981058975464,
790
+ "recall": 0.5209163346613546,
791
+ "false_alarm": 0.5043630017452007,
792
+ "clean": 573,
793
+ "errors": 0,
794
+ "matched": 1046,
795
+ "boxes": 2323,
796
+ "truths": 2008,
797
+ "kind_right": 601,
798
+ "kind_known": 1046,
799
+ "aspect_right": 378,
800
+ "aspect_known": 436,
801
+ "normalized_kind_right": 1027
802
+ },
803
+ "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": {
804
+ "f1": 0.4256378344741754,
805
+ "precision": 0.5671641791044776,
806
+ "recall": 0.34063745019920316,
807
+ "false_alarm": 0.06806282722513089,
808
+ "clean": 573,
809
+ "errors": 0,
810
+ "matched": 684,
811
+ "boxes": 1206,
812
+ "truths": 2008,
813
+ "kind_right": 461,
814
+ "kind_known": 684,
815
+ "aspect_right": 181,
816
+ "aspect_known": 221,
817
+ "normalized_kind_right": 675
818
+ },
819
+ "qwen3.5-9b-base": {
820
+ "f1": 0.04460431654676259,
821
+ "precision": 0.02413736578968937,
822
+ "recall": 0.29332669322709165,
823
+ "false_alarm": 0.8778359511343804,
824
+ "clean": 573,
825
+ "errors": 258,
826
+ "matched": 589,
827
+ "boxes": 24402,
828
+ "truths": 2008,
829
+ "kind_right": 19,
830
+ "kind_known": 589,
831
+ "aspect_right": 205,
832
+ "aspect_known": 396,
833
+ "normalized_kind_right": 415
834
+ }
835
+ },
836
+ "base_bootstrap": {
837
+ "clusters": 460,
838
+ "min_size": 1,
839
+ "max_size": 25,
840
+ "vs": {
841
+ "gemini-4-argon": {
842
+ "delta": 0.11088681577113457,
843
+ "ci95": [
844
+ 0.07835602317984597,
845
+ 0.14297294615854736
846
+ ]
847
+ },
848
+ "claude-opus-5-5-medium": {
849
+ "delta": 0.17928767276593366,
850
+ "ci95": [
851
+ 0.155562028072719,
852
+ 0.20235313618042142
853
+ ]
854
+ },
855
+ "gpt-6.1-sol": {
856
+ "delta": 0.18550630630630638,
857
+ "ci95": [
858
+ 0.152888992870874,
859
+ 0.21850935906801486
860
+ ]
861
+ },
862
+ "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": {
863
+ "delta": 0.023276982824431525,
864
+ "ci95": [
865
+ 0.007806048472150712,
866
+ 0.038494405152895116
867
+ ]
868
+ },
869
+ "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": {
870
+ "delta": 0.08066847183213094,
871
+ "ci95": [
872
+ 0.06095831107520356,
873
+ 0.10061037665436738
874
+ ]
875
+ },
876
+ "qwen3.5-9b-base": {
877
+ "delta": 0.46170198975954374,
878
+ "ci95": [
879
+ 0.4376583170445951,
880
+ 0.4847600033817072
881
+ ]
882
+ }
883
+ }
884
+ }
885
+ },
886
+ "convention_sensitivity": {
887
+ "pages": 1766,
888
+ "faults": {
889
+ "common-type": 72,
890
+ "common-low_contrast": 55,
891
+ "clean": 394,
892
+ "common-overflow": 42,
893
+ "common-overlap": 63,
894
+ "common-small_target": 46,
895
+ "local-radius": 86,
896
+ "local-material": 123,
897
+ "local-colour": 160,
898
+ "multi-display-missing_image": 108,
899
+ "multi-display-ellipsis": 32,
900
+ "multi-display-cropped": 147,
901
+ "multi-display-null_value": 60,
902
+ "negative-selection": 94,
903
+ "common-two_selected": 111,
904
+ "negative-badge": 32,
905
+ "common-badge_overlap": 40,
906
+ "negative-placeholder": 39,
907
+ "local-primary_colour": 19,
908
+ "negative-fab": 8,
909
+ "common-fab_overlap": 12,
910
+ "negative-primary": 6,
911
+ "multi-common-low_contrast": 11,
912
+ "multi-common-overflow": 4,
913
+ "multi-common-small_target": 2
914
+ },
915
+ "models": {
916
+ "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup-cut": {
917
+ "f1": 0.6268922528940338,
918
+ "precision": 0.6685660018993352,
919
+ "recall": 0.5901089689857502,
920
+ "false_alarm": 0.07329842931937172,
921
+ "clean": 573,
922
+ "errors": 0,
923
+ "matched": 704,
924
+ "boxes": 1053,
925
+ "truths": 1193,
926
+ "kind_right": 537,
927
+ "kind_known": 704,
928
+ "aspect_right": 146,
929
+ "aspect_known": 162,
930
+ "normalized_kind_right": 698
931
+ },
932
+ "gemini-4-argon": {
933
+ "f1": 0.39705340699815844,
934
+ "precision": 0.35413929040735875,
935
+ "recall": 0.451802179379715,
936
+ "false_alarm": 0.17975567190226877,
937
+ "clean": 573,
938
+ "errors": 0,
939
+ "matched": 539,
940
+ "boxes": 1522,
941
+ "truths": 1193,
942
+ "kind_right": 342,
943
+ "kind_known": 539,
944
+ "aspect_right": 146,
945
+ "aspect_known": 190,
946
+ "normalized_kind_right": 515
947
+ },
948
+ "claude-opus-5-5-medium": {
949
+ "f1": 0.34983986203498396,
950
+ "precision": 0.2477320307048151,
951
+ "recall": 0.595138306789606,
952
+ "false_alarm": 0.787085514834206,
953
+ "clean": 573,
954
+ "errors": 0,
955
+ "matched": 710,
956
+ "boxes": 2866,
957
+ "truths": 1193,
958
+ "kind_right": 419,
959
+ "kind_known": 710,
960
+ "aspect_right": 186,
961
+ "aspect_known": 260,
962
+ "normalized_kind_right": 658
963
+ },
964
+ "gpt-6.1-sol": {
965
+ "f1": 0.35065710872162487,
966
+ "precision": 0.27238979118329465,
967
+ "recall": 0.4920368818105616,
968
+ "false_alarm": 0.35951134380453753,
969
+ "clean": 573,
970
+ "errors": 0,
971
+ "matched": 587,
972
+ "boxes": 2155,
973
+ "truths": 1193,
974
+ "kind_right": 392,
975
+ "kind_known": 587,
976
+ "aspect_right": 123,
977
+ "aspect_known": 178,
978
+ "normalized_kind_right": 560
979
+ },
980
+ "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": {
981
+ "f1": 0.5824136703453185,
982
+ "precision": 0.5061881188118812,
983
+ "recall": 0.6856663872590109,
984
+ "false_alarm": 0.5043630017452007,
985
+ "clean": 573,
986
+ "errors": 0,
987
+ "matched": 818,
988
+ "boxes": 1616,
989
+ "truths": 1193,
990
+ "kind_right": 601,
991
+ "kind_known": 818,
992
+ "aspect_right": 181,
993
+ "aspect_known": 208,
994
+ "normalized_kind_right": 806
995
+ },
996
+ "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": {
997
+ "f1": 0.5400183992640295,
998
+ "precision": 0.5983690112130479,
999
+ "recall": 0.4920368818105616,
1000
+ "false_alarm": 0.06806282722513089,
1001
+ "clean": 573,
1002
+ "errors": 0,
1003
+ "matched": 587,
1004
+ "boxes": 981,
1005
+ "truths": 1193,
1006
+ "kind_right": 461,
1007
+ "kind_known": 587,
1008
+ "aspect_right": 104,
1009
+ "aspect_known": 124,
1010
+ "normalized_kind_right": 585
1011
+ },
1012
+ "qwen3.5-9b-base": {
1013
+ "f1": 0.03922224079335896,
1014
+ "precision": 0.021007400334208642,
1015
+ "recall": 0.2950544844928751,
1016
+ "false_alarm": 0.8778359511343804,
1017
+ "clean": 573,
1018
+ "errors": 191,
1019
+ "matched": 352,
1020
+ "boxes": 16756,
1021
+ "truths": 1193,
1022
+ "kind_right": 19,
1023
+ "kind_known": 352,
1024
+ "aspect_right": 51,
1025
+ "aspect_known": 159,
1026
+ "normalized_kind_right": 178
1027
+ }
1028
+ },
1029
+ "base_bootstrap": {
1030
+ "clusters": 457,
1031
+ "min_size": 1,
1032
+ "max_size": 21,
1033
+ "vs": {
1034
+ "gemini-4-argon": {
1035
+ "delta": 0.2298388458958754,
1036
+ "ci95": [
1037
+ 0.18724555288083433,
1038
+ 0.27145427894908847
1039
+ ]
1040
+ },
1041
+ "claude-opus-5-5-medium": {
1042
+ "delta": 0.27705239085904987,
1043
+ "ci95": [
1044
+ 0.24710773133780767,
1045
+ 0.3071044790862251
1046
+ ]
1047
+ },
1048
+ "gpt-6.1-sol": {
1049
+ "delta": 0.27623514417240896,
1050
+ "ci95": [
1051
+ 0.23588166680019326,
1052
+ 0.31661125390467615
1053
+ ]
1054
+ },
1055
+ "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": {
1056
+ "delta": 0.044478582548715284,
1057
+ "ci95": [
1058
+ 0.027595375186851175,
1059
+ 0.06107735972514386
1060
+ ]
1061
+ },
1062
+ "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": {
1063
+ "delta": 0.08687385363000433,
1064
+ "ci95": [
1065
+ 0.06199426792543952,
1066
+ 0.11109210298681961
1067
+ ]
1068
+ },
1069
+ "qwen3.5-9b-base": {
1070
+ "delta": 0.5876700121006748,
1071
+ "ci95": [
1072
+ 0.5605721021443575,
1073
+ 0.6132586220645458
1074
+ ]
1075
+ }
1076
+ }
1077
+ }
1078
+ }
1079
+ },
1080
+ "exclusions": {
1081
+ "disputed": 106,
1082
+ "human": 86,
1083
+ "structural": 109,
1084
+ "convention": 850
1085
+ },
1086
+ "common_parseable": {
1087
+ "pages": 2762,
1088
+ "models": {
1089
+ "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup-cut": {
1090
+ "f1": 0.4812712826333712,
1091
+ "precision": 0.6194302410518627,
1092
+ "recall": 0.39350348027842225,
1093
+ "false_alarm": 0.07413509060955518,
1094
+ "clean": 607,
1095
+ "errors": 0,
1096
+ "matched": 848,
1097
+ "boxes": 1369,
1098
+ "truths": 2155,
1099
+ "kind_right": 539,
1100
+ "kind_known": 848,
1101
+ "aspect_right": 267,
1102
+ "aspect_known": 304,
1103
+ "normalized_kind_right": 839
1104
+ },
1105
+ "gemini-4-argon": {
1106
+ "f1": 0.37192064530194024,
1107
+ "precision": 0.35074013157894735,
1108
+ "recall": 0.39582366589327145,
1109
+ "false_alarm": 0.17792421746293247,
1110
+ "clean": 607,
1111
+ "errors": 0,
1112
+ "matched": 853,
1113
+ "boxes": 2432,
1114
+ "truths": 2155,
1115
+ "kind_right": 342,
1116
+ "kind_known": 853,
1117
+ "aspect_right": 282,
1118
+ "aspect_known": 504,
1119
+ "normalized_kind_right": 709
1120
+ },
1121
+ "claude-opus-5-5-medium": {
1122
+ "f1": 0.30795947901591897,
1123
+ "precision": 0.2237644584647739,
1124
+ "recall": 0.4937354988399072,
1125
+ "false_alarm": 0.7825370675453048,
1126
+ "clean": 607,
1127
+ "errors": 0,
1128
+ "matched": 1064,
1129
+ "boxes": 4755,
1130
+ "truths": 2155,
1131
+ "kind_right": 420,
1132
+ "kind_known": 1064,
1133
+ "aspect_right": 283,
1134
+ "aspect_known": 611,
1135
+ "normalized_kind_right": 898
1136
+ },
1137
+ "gpt-6.1-sol": {
1138
+ "f1": 0.29992548435171384,
1139
+ "precision": 0.25054466230936817,
1140
+ "recall": 0.37354988399071926,
1141
+ "false_alarm": 0.3657331136738056,
1142
+ "clean": 607,
1143
+ "errors": 0,
1144
+ "matched": 805,
1145
+ "boxes": 3213,
1146
+ "truths": 2155,
1147
+ "kind_right": 393,
1148
+ "kind_known": 805,
1149
+ "aspect_right": 196,
1150
+ "aspect_known": 395,
1151
+ "normalized_kind_right": 710
1152
+ },
1153
+ "rolejudge-v7f-r128soup": {
1154
+ "f1": 0.4560344827586207,
1155
+ "precision": 0.42575452716297785,
1156
+ "recall": 0.49095127610208816,
1157
+ "false_alarm": 0.515650741350906,
1158
+ "clean": 607,
1159
+ "errors": 0,
1160
+ "matched": 1058,
1161
+ "boxes": 2485,
1162
+ "truths": 2155,
1163
+ "kind_right": 605,
1164
+ "kind_known": 1058,
1165
+ "aspect_right": 385,
1166
+ "aspect_known": 443,
1167
+ "normalized_kind_right": 1038
1168
+ },
1169
+ "rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut": {
1170
+ "f1": 0.40530191458026504,
1171
+ "precision": 0.5548387096774193,
1172
+ "recall": 0.31925754060324824,
1173
+ "false_alarm": 0.06919275123558484,
1174
+ "clean": 607,
1175
+ "errors": 0,
1176
+ "matched": 688,
1177
+ "boxes": 1240,
1178
+ "truths": 2155,
1179
+ "kind_right": 463,
1180
+ "kind_known": 688,
1181
+ "aspect_right": 182,
1182
+ "aspect_known": 223,
1183
+ "normalized_kind_right": 679
1184
+ },
1185
+ "qwen3.5-9b-base": {
1186
+ "f1": 0.043006143734819265,
1187
+ "precision": 0.023296312062226696,
1188
+ "recall": 0.27935034802784225,
1189
+ "false_alarm": 0.8780889621087314,
1190
+ "clean": 607,
1191
+ "errors": 282,
1192
+ "matched": 602,
1193
+ "boxes": 25841,
1194
+ "truths": 2155,
1195
+ "kind_right": 20,
1196
+ "kind_known": 602,
1197
+ "aspect_right": 213,
1198
+ "aspect_known": 407,
1199
+ "normalized_kind_right": 427
1200
+ }
1201
+ }
1202
+ },
1203
+ "input_sha256": {
1204
+ "data/defect-consistency-runs/rolejudge-v7f-r128soup-cut.jsonl": "fb2924a4e3d141953bfc1c7e41df629fbede1dc97157602b147605011d50681b",
1205
+ "data/defect-consistency-runs/gemini-4-argon.jsonl": "24960309c022ee6f78ee4d15f4f17e3dca83f672a3d7e3d7d72fa4fbcfc3e8fe",
1206
+ "data/defect-consistency-runs/claude-opus-5-5-medium.jsonl": "0f2c61f77a2108f8f264cc8f543d4a5da55136a97b42deae14858884a5097a87",
1207
+ "data/defect-consistency-runs/gpt-6.1-sol.jsonl": "d56adb3a103d6c9cda47a10e01abd42f5ae58c3c16261a67327fd2b17fcec59d",
1208
+ "data/defect-consistency-runs/rolejudge-v7f-r128soup.jsonl": "f68ccd7ccfcde3a56d288bc035d3940ec81260b2c57dbf267ae4370d226549b6",
1209
+ "data/defect-consistency-runs/rolejudge-v7f-2500-cut.jsonl": "a004c12c1d8ee4afc5624a1dce6918b046fdf34dc72a913d3ce9f33f5a3bde5c",
1210
+ "data/defect-consistency-runs/qwen3.5-9b-base.jsonl": "a1e0c18d01f9c4199d96250ed45733a0246f74eacb9e38338c3082393aba8ccc",
1211
+ "data/human-eval/label-check/answers.json": "0bd37470f31f3f03ad94ae82cb1a51fa72cfe7a99651d5fc7ba7ac8059e27d3f"
1212
+ },
1213
+ "rows_sha256": "84ee979babd205e986e26971a04306d6697b8c8ef47307d6d63177b097a65dc4"
1214
+ }