screenplay-revision-evaluation / calibration.json
MorganTitcher's picture
v1.1.0 Sync from inkwell 9bdb21e57
63d3244 verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
3.18 kB
[
{
"id": "bounded-care",
"case_id": "two-tickets-compression",
"output": "EXT. FERRY QUEUE - DAWN\n\nSOL\nI accepted the job.\n\nRen folds the return ticket without tearing it. The boarding bell rings.\n\nREN\nMay I carry that as far as the gate?\n\nSol gives Ren the suitcase. They walk toward the ferry.",
"expected": {"nonempty":true,"checks":{"max_words":true,"contains_exact":true,"no_preface":"not_flagged"}},
"human_review": "One plausible direction: the job decision survives and the suitcase is offered after a question. Readers may still prefer the original's helmet and uneven pace."
},
{
"id": "empty-response",
"case_id": "two-tickets-compression",
"output": " \n\t",
"expected": {"nonempty":false,"checks":{"max_words":true,"contains_exact":false,"no_preface":"not_flagged"}},
"human_review": "There is no revision to assess. A word-ceiling pass is not a complete response."
},
{
"id": "lost-anchor",
"case_id": "two-tickets-compression",
"output": "SOL\nI accepted the job.\n\nREN\nMay I carry your suitcase?\n\nSol gives Ren the handle and walks toward the ferry.",
"expected": {"nonempty":true,"checks":{"max_words":true,"contains_exact":false,"no_preface":"not_flagged"}},
"human_review": "The scene may preserve a choice, but the requested literal boundary phrase is gone."
},
{
"id": "prefaced-response",
"case_id": "two-tickets-compression",
"output": "Sure, here is the scene:\n\nREN\nMay I carry that as far as the gate?\n\nSol nods and walks toward the ferry.",
"expected": {"nonempty":true,"checks":{"max_words":true,"contains_exact":true,"no_preface":"flagged"}},
"human_review": "Remove the assistant's introduction before assessing the scene itself; its job decision also needs review."
},
{
"id": "over-budget",
"case_id": "two-tickets-compression",
"output": "EXT. FERRY QUEUE - DAWN\n\nRen holds the tickets so carefully that their edges do not touch. Sol sets the suitcase between them, rests the helmet on its handle, then lifts it again when the handle sinks. The boarding bell rings once. Neither moves.\n\nSOL\nI accepted the job.\n\nRen folds the return ticket, unfolds it, and smooths the crease with a thumb.\n\nREN\nMay I carry that as far as the gate?\n\nSol gives Ren the handle. They walk toward the waiting ferry at the suitcase's uneven pace.",
"expected": {"nonempty":true,"checks":{"max_words":false,"contains_exact":true,"no_preface":"not_flagged"}},
"human_review": "The added blocking may be playable, but it does not meet this compression task's ceiling."
},
{
"id": "mechanical-pass-dramatic-failure",
"case_id": "two-tickets-constraint",
"output": "Sol tears up the job offer. Ren takes the suitcase without asking and carries it as far as the gate. Sol decides to stay.",
"expected": {"nonempty":true,"checks":{"max_words":true,"contains_exact":true,"no_preface":"not_flagged"}},
"human_review": "Reject for this task: Sol's career decision is reversed and Ren's help is no longer an offer. Mechanical compliance does not establish dramatic or instruction-level success."
}
]