File size: 36,115 Bytes
d79feb0 | 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 228 229 230 231 232 233 234 235 236 237 238 239 240 241 242 243 244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 280 281 282 283 284 285 286 287 288 289 290 291 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300 301 302 303 304 305 306 307 308 309 310 311 312 313 314 315 316 317 318 319 320 321 322 323 324 325 326 327 328 329 330 331 332 333 334 335 336 337 338 339 340 341 342 343 344 345 346 347 348 349 350 351 352 353 354 355 356 357 358 359 360 361 362 363 364 365 366 367 368 369 370 371 372 373 374 375 376 377 378 379 380 381 382 383 384 385 386 387 388 389 390 391 392 393 394 395 396 397 398 399 400 401 402 403 404 405 406 407 408 409 410 411 412 413 414 415 416 417 418 419 420 421 422 423 424 425 426 427 428 429 430 431 432 433 434 435 436 437 438 439 440 441 442 443 444 445 446 447 448 449 450 451 452 453 454 455 456 457 458 459 460 461 462 | {
"attachment_paths_relative_to": "public",
"by_component": {
"expansion_v3": {
"gold": 80,
"mothers": 60,
"raw": 123
},
"gaokao": {
"gold": 26,
"mothers": 23,
"raw": 38
},
"local": {
"gold": 211,
"mothers": 458,
"raw": 1679
},
"olympiadbench": {
"gold": 97,
"mothers": 209,
"raw": 669
},
"physelite": {
"gold": 104,
"mothers": 220,
"raw": 792
},
"phyx_oe": {
"gold": 35,
"mothers": 16,
"raw": 40
}
},
"by_interface_raw": {
"T02-single": 2407,
"T03-image": 514,
"T03-text": 420
},
"by_split": {
"development": {
"gold": 90,
"mothers": 79,
"raw": 208
},
"test": {
"gold": 463,
"mothers": 907,
"raw": 3133
}
},
"components": [
{
"name": "local",
"settings": {
"api_mode": "chat",
"image_detail": "high",
"max_output_tokens": 16384,
"model": "gpt-6-astra",
"reasoning_effort": "medium",
"timeout_seconds": 900
},
"source_counts": {
"complete_mothers": 88,
"gold": 211,
"mothers": 458,
"partial_mothers": 370,
"raw": 1679
},
"upstream_review_status_counts": {
"model_approved": 1684,
"model_rejected": 462,
"needs_review": 443,
"pending_or_error": 4
}
},
{
"name": "olympiadbench",
"settings": {
"api_mode": "chat",
"image_detail": "high",
"max_output_tokens": 16384,
"model": "gpt-6-astra",
"reasoning_effort": "medium",
"timeout_seconds": 900
},
"source_counts": {
"complete_mothers": 28,
"gold": 97,
"mothers": 209,
"partial_mothers": 181,
"raw": 669
},
"upstream_review_status_counts": {
"model_approved": 688,
"model_rejected": 273,
"needs_review": 316,
"pending_or_error": 1
}
},
{
"name": "physelite",
"settings": {
"api_mode": "chat",
"image_detail": "high",
"max_output_tokens": 16384,
"model": "gpt-6-astra",
"reasoning_effort": "medium",
"timeout_seconds": 900
},
"source_counts": {
"complete_mothers": 34,
"gold": 104,
"mothers": 220,
"partial_mothers": 186,
"raw": 792
},
"upstream_review_status_counts": {
"model_approved": 795,
"model_rejected": 226,
"needs_review": 271,
"pending_or_error": 2
}
},
{
"name": "phyx_oe",
"settings": {
"api_mode": "chat",
"image_detail": "high",
"max_output_tokens": 16384,
"model": "gpt-6-astra",
"reasoning_effort": "medium",
"timeout_seconds": 900
},
"source_counts": {
"complete_mothers": 4,
"gold": 35,
"mothers": 16,
"partial_mothers": 12,
"raw": 40
},
"upstream_review_status_counts": {
"model_approved": 40,
"model_rejected": 27,
"needs_review": 12
}
},
{
"name": "gaokao",
"settings": {
"api_mode": "chat",
"image_detail": "high",
"max_output_tokens": 16384,
"model": "gpt-6-astra",
"reasoning_effort": "medium",
"timeout_seconds": 900
},
"source_counts": {
"complete_mothers": 11,
"gold": 26,
"mothers": 23,
"partial_mothers": 12,
"raw": 38
},
"upstream_review_status_counts": {
"model_approved": 40,
"model_rejected": 31,
"needs_review": 13
}
},
{
"name": "expansion_v3",
"settings": {
"api_mode": "chat",
"image_detail": "high",
"max_output_tokens": 16384,
"model": "gpt-6-astra",
"reasoning_effort": "medium",
"timeout_seconds": 900
},
"source_counts": {
"complete_mothers": 19,
"gold": 80,
"mothers": 60,
"partial_mothers": 41,
"raw": 123
},
"upstream_review_status_counts": {
"model_approved": 123,
"model_rejected": 109,
"needs_review": 34
}
}
],
"counts": {
"gold": 553,
"mothers": 986,
"raw": 3341
},
"development_promoted_probes": 0,
"duplicate_review_status_conflicts": [
],
"human_reviewed": false,
"impact_scope_review_completed": false,
"implementation": {
"checkpoint_quarantine_release.py": "69b970a74ee5c329b12d73c98a5895055854a297ab174a3a36df490219f31777",
"legacy_adapter_release.py": "d4c3fd0f480a8131c4aa0cabca03be3090c4645c9b5a05fb74eb7fb92a890ef8",
"merge_model_releases.py": "be42b3ab5e867d08dcf6186bcc1c53fc36d0af89bc47d161cbdccf9d16e58758",
"model_approved_release.py": "568f3cb4ebcbf103ff3897a80ed8cf24564eed5c568e523314e0a97d59f42fb9",
"selective_release.py": "24600537cf345d0251ee00b1e03be0e770a2221f7e5ca401c3dde43951932a35",
"selective_release_policy.py": "3758bb82a3dcd709132f7688a6cba5803405dd721ffa0d67fbf5e4007894b268"
},
"independent_human_quality_certified": false,
"merge_exclusion_counts": {
},
"merge_policy": "physalign_verified_model_release_merge_v1",
"merge_root": "bc2f9fe7aea71ee0d5412baae0e1778ace837b4722d8ce1fb9ce9e4057f113da",
"quarantined_mother_ids": [
"gaokao_physics_2020_128",
"gaokao_physics_2021_139",
"livek12bench__en_2603_physics_0064",
"olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1137",
"olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1138",
"olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1139",
"olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1140",
"olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1141",
"olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1143",
"olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1144",
"olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1145",
"olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1146",
"olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1525",
"olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1526",
"olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1529",
"olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1533",
"olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1535",
"physelite__en__275",
"physelite__en__303",
"physelite__en__355",
"phyx_oe_1638",
"seephys__seephys_train_0090",
"seephys__seephys_train_1082",
"seephys__seephys_train_1229",
"seephys__seephys_train_1304",
"seephys__seephys_train_1343"
],
"release_status": "model_reviewed_provisional",
"schema_version": "physalign_merged_model_evaluation_dataset_v1",
"synthetic_example_only": false,
"unresolved_global_risks": [
{
"component": "local",
"logical_probe_id": "PEX-12d2b7d3f339472ecd14736b12c98bd4673911367699514aff884cf7cf20f175",
"problem_id": "livek12bench__en_2603_physics_0064",
"reason": "保留独立首答 E10：其对 f 与向右力的语义判断得到原图支持。但首答未指出 R5 实际没有框住完整标签，且多个候选框复用了偏移或不完整的源几何，因此答案可识别不代表探针通过定位审核。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "systemic"
},
{
"component": "local",
"logical_probe_id": "PEX-d9e10764b7b48136eac361339998caec78994694ee877cd6747c1bcd103c660d",
"problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_0090",
"reason": "实际图像支持 R5 的直接所属实体为 E3（源记录 p001，即 P₃⁄₂），但 recognition_packet 对可见文本的转录错误，将 Δ 误读为“*”。由于本探针要求精确转录，该信息泄漏/版本缺陷导致拒绝；这也解释了为何不能采纳独立首答中“ε₀ + Δ”的读法：图中未清楚显示加号。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "information"
},
{
"component": "olympiadbench",
"logical_probe_id": "PEX-399400cbbd93439650b8fd39ab4100c4f297697271adc09924c70652e6166137",
"problem_id": "olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1143",
"reason": "拒绝：存在跨图空气阶段合并、烟气与燃烧实体混绑以及多个实际定位框几何错误。保留独立首答 {\"owner\":\"E1\"} 的记录，但不认可其解释：E1/V3–V14 实际位于 Fig.1 燃烧烟气的上升箭头，不是 Fig.2 太阳能原型的工作空气；正文关于烟气与空气密度的假设也不能建立比热归属。转换器的 E5 同样不能据现有公开证据成为无歧义答案，因此不强行改答。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "systemic"
},
{
"component": "olympiadbench",
"logical_probe_id": "PEX-e7f7f416b2559bf929fc88a79e95b226e74184832fc459a7a43ee09e702c8068",
"problem_id": "olympiadbench__OE_MM_physics_en_COMP__1525",
"reason": "实体绑定正确，应为 E3；但实际 R3 的可见字形是大写“V”，与 recognition_packet 的小写“v”不一致。独立首答也报告“V”，因此不能按 packet 的小写转录通过。该问题属于局部读取/版本信息缺陷，而非候选实体绑定错误。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "information"
},
{
"component": "physelite",
"logical_probe_id": "PEX-97f5e0bdd92b57d3d39006ff798f9226eddcdc6e7c14f95e7dc5ed30a434a498",
"problem_id": "physelite__en__275",
"reason": "保留独立首答E2：仅依据原题文字及img_0，R3确实描述网络在A、B间的等效电阻。但答案可选出并不代表探针合格。源标注与转换器共同把不同电路阶段、递推子网络合并为同一实体，且有端点字形框裁切，因此拒绝。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "systemic"
},
{
"component": "physelite",
"logical_probe_id": "PEX-c7239f94435c320121a6f2b35ff33d9ddde3f878d26f2faabf8e9af1294e044f",
"problem_id": "physelite__en__275",
"reason": "保留独立首答的E2：按公开候选，R2指网络而非A、B端点，最直接对应仍是E2。但首答将所有线段视为同一网络，未处理实际图像中原网络、化简网络和递推电路的差别。答案可选不等于探针合格；源注释与转换器共享跨阶段实体归并缺陷，故拒绝。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "systemic"
},
{
"component": "physelite",
"logical_probe_id": "PEX-f84609a39ea5e81071ccaf466c80cd2a013df358374b31eee504a89cda297cc7",
"problem_id": "physelite__en__355",
"reason": "局部视觉事实支持 R3 的答案为右侧电容候选 E9；但公开文本与实际图像属于不一致的问题资产，且源记录 b007 将标签绑定到 p005 的依据不能独立修复该图文错配。因此不能通过 PhysAlign 探针审计。独立首答为 E9，与局部视觉判定一致，但该一致不消除资产范围和源语义缺陷。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "systemic"
},
{
"component": "phyx_oe",
"logical_probe_id": "PAQ-3e6098ce75fd61dca8eebd2a6515fed3a91757cc21adb27c1f06615e95e7fbaa",
"problem_id": "phyx_oe_1638",
"reason": "保留独立首次答案E10：公开题干与实际原图支持这一语义绑定。但答案可辨认不代表定位合格；目标E10的窄框没有覆盖实际水平金属丝，且多个候选存在同类几何偏移，故拒绝该版本。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "systemic"
},
{
"component": "gaokao",
"logical_probe_id": "PAQ-192f50ab5703bb1128bbe1c655079f51796c34ca552a4674629732d8659c479b",
"problem_id": "gaokao_physics_2020_128",
"reason": "局部指代答案仍为 E3，与独立首答一致；但答案可辨认不等于探针合格。实际定位图中多个字符被源框截断，且同一错误复用于 R 与 E，构成共享定位缺陷，需修正后重新审核。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "systemic"
},
{
"component": "gaokao",
"logical_probe_id": "PAQ-7142dcac9553d0291f6c7593808c63f0bdf1d22417e20e91e17b5293cd1ed78f",
"problem_id": "gaokao_physics_2021_139",
"reason": "保留独立首答 E8：该局部绑定由原图直接支持。但全部定位审核发现多个字形框系统性欠包围，另有来源 b/e 点身份互换，不能因目标答案正确而通过整项审核。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "systemic"
},
{
"component": "gaokao",
"logical_probe_id": "PAQ-9aff235e58e14f0bb8d3ea99cf24e8049fed08f248b81dbae19bce98d40386af",
"problem_id": "gaokao_physics_2020_128",
"reason": "保留独立首答 E5：实际图文确实支持该局部绑定。拒绝的原因不是答案错误，而是多个源字符框及其复用的 R/E 视图未完整覆盖字符，属于重复出现的定位几何缺陷。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "systemic"
},
{
"component": "gaokao",
"logical_probe_id": "PAQ-e0ba8a70a39d904523500d3c2b3603457142e413a657e7f5dc973017c4ad8451",
"problem_id": "gaokao_physics_2020_128",
"reason": "局部答案仍为E1，与独立首次答案一致；但多处R/E共用的定位框切掉实际字形，违反完整定位要求，因此不能通过。此结论针对定位质量，不否定点c的绑定。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "systemic"
},
{
"component": "expansion_v3",
"logical_probe_id": "PAQ-32dc28ac859e35af25b0ae7565c41709a8362c6460ec665668e7e6fde74377cb",
"problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_1343",
"reason": "保留独立首答E3：公开题干足以把R1的角度归于整杆。拒绝原因不是答案绑定错误，而是多个候选将共享源图元不加区分地用作实体几何定位；尤其E7、E2框到了视觉上分离的P点，构成可直接观察的定位缺陷。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "systemic"
},
{
"component": "expansion_v3",
"logical_probe_id": "PAQ-624eb5a5e102f2571da442473dd273cda2365045390b697e42cf354218c3205e",
"problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_1082",
"reason": "保留独立首答 E10：该绑定由原图直接支持。但多个连接点候选共享跨电阻归组错误，且 R6 未覆盖完整 f，故不能通过整项审核；拒绝不代表首答错误。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "systemic"
},
{
"component": "expansion_v3",
"logical_probe_id": "PAQ-7c8c8278d4d27e9ad515be5f3151dfdba4a55c8a04f2799c95a1b57dce1cace3",
"problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_1082",
"reason": "保留独立首答 E10：其局部绑定正确。但整个探针不能通过，因为三个连接点候选重复采用跨电阻归并导线的错误规则，且 R6 未完整框住 f。拒绝针对候选与定位质量，不是否定首答。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "systemic"
},
{
"component": "expansion_v3",
"logical_probe_id": "PAQ-8a7592c28d5cb036af6256f61bb39c1f9684e3300c545d868314ebd73f0f3dba",
"problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_1082",
"reason": "保留独立首答 E1：R1 到竖直电阻 c 的绑定正确。但审核范围包括全部候选，三个连接点候选共同存在跨电阻合并导线的源标注错误，使公开定位不能忠实标识各自实体，因此拒绝该探针。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "systemic"
},
{
"component": "expansion_v3",
"logical_probe_id": "PAQ-b787dc073fbb766ff874df5f8a278ebfc22f0229d09450b51696dc3b762f1f94",
"problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_1343",
"reason": "保留独立首答E1：R1的长度属于整根杆，语义答案没有改变。但源标注将粒子黑点和整杆几何复用于其他点实体，转换后的实际候选视图继承了错误定位；能答对不代表定位审计通过。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "systemic"
},
{
"component": "expansion_v3",
"logical_probe_id": "PAQ-bd37e851d6f3f646399575b893a337ba5a94551ba05e37c275837ba1255fa45b",
"problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_1304",
"reason": "拒绝。转换器与源标注共享了最内层三角形识别错误，造成E4目标集合错误。保留独立首答记录，但不认可其“E5是最内层三边”的视觉判断：原图第五层尖端向上，E5定位的却是它下方尖端向下的邻接三角形。这一差异直接改变R1的归属集合，无需解原题或推导电阻。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "systemic"
},
{
"component": "expansion_v3",
"logical_probe_id": "PAQ-bf4a07608bf534ee359eaab22ceebedc7802c633265f8c599622f581c8acf9ec",
"problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_1082",
"reason": "局部答案仍为 E10，与独立首答一致；但正确目标可选并不抵消其余候选的实体定位缺陷。源记录把被电阻隔开的导线段重复合并为单个连接点，该错误传递到 E6、E7、E8 的公开多框定位，属于共享分组规则缺陷，因此拒绝。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "systemic"
},
{
"component": "expansion_v3",
"logical_probe_id": "PAQ-e0a0de0b216a62642168a6f1706afd41493f23a3914b3e17ef912ebe3e5b3c09",
"problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_1229",
"reason": "保留独立首次答案E3：原文和V5支持AB长度归属于AB杆。拒绝原因不是答案错误，而是多个点候选共享了整根杆的几何锚点，构成重复的点与杆范围混淆；即使字样辅助辨认了候选，也未满足所有定位视图正确的要求。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "systemic"
},
{
"component": "expansion_v3",
"logical_probe_id": "PAQ-e8f83daaa426733ba013272dc3665165410b670d52b8f14923ddd77f9dfd3902",
"problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_1082",
"reason": "保留独立首答 {\"referent\":\"E2\"}，其局部绑定正确。但探针整体不能通过：连接点候选反复把电阻两侧、不同连接点的导线归为同一实体，属于共享分组规则缺陷；另有 R6、R8 字形定位不完整。拒绝并非因为与首答不一致。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "systemic"
},
{
"component": "expansion_v3",
"logical_probe_id": "PAQ-f410fe70a7d612f7aeafa118f811094938e646cec9d0f3cc61878a1146a569a8",
"problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_1082",
"reason": "保留独立首答 E6：R1 到电阻 d 的绑定有直接图文依据。拒绝原因不是答案错误，而是候选连接点的共享构造错误：p010、p011、p012 将电阻两侧的导线合并为同一实体，且该错误实际出现在多个公开定位视图中。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "systemic"
},
{
"component": "expansion_v3",
"logical_probe_id": "PAQ-fc60292e2273cca455862e854d515aa7f3a51c1180e2979813c3734caad251a2",
"problem_id": "seephys__seephys_train_1304",
"reason": "拒绝。转换键与源p004共享最内层三角形识别错误：选中了其下方的同尺寸倒三角形。保留独立首次答案{\"owner\":\"E1\"}作为原始记录，但不认可其理由；实际V30、V31不是最内层三角形的两条斜边，故首次答案与本次视觉核验不一致。公开候选没有准确表示真正最内层三边的单独实体，不能提供无歧义替代编号。",
"scope_resolved": false,
"severity": "systemic"
}
],
"unseen_test_split_certified": false,
"warnings": [
"Model-reviewed provisional data, not independent human certification.",
"Cross-source exact-input duplicates are collapsed; shared-image mothers are grouped for risk and split, not counted as proven duplicates.",
"Semantic/near-duplicate and historic development-sample reconciliation remain incomplete.",
"Known global findings remain unresolved. Only public input may be sent to tested models."
],
"huggingface_packaging": {
"repository": "Jetson888/PhysAlign",
"attachment_paths_relative_to": "public",
"image_sharding": "images/\u003csha256[0:2]\u003e/\u003csha256\u003e.\u003cext\u003e",
"canonical_files": [
"public/qa_raw.json",
"public/qa_gold.json"
],
"viewer_files": [
"data/raw/development.jsonl",
"data/raw/test.jsonl",
"data/gold/development.jsonl",
"data/gold/test.jsonl"
],
"private_material_included": false,
"service_endpoints_included": false
}
}
|