Ali-Uraish commited on
Commit
23ae067
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 241cd7f

part 2 summary: correct the interpretation (inconclusive, not equivalence)

Browse files
Files changed (1) hide show
  1. chess-sim/reports/part2/summary.md +8 -5
chess-sim/reports/part2/summary.md CHANGED
@@ -57,12 +57,15 @@ Paired comparisons (exact McNemar, episodes only one model completed):
57
 
58
  1. **The normalization override was a real, large harm.** It is now controlled: keep the
59
  baseline's normalization in every fine-tune.
60
- 2. **The correction data makes no detectable difference** once normalization is kept (A vs B).
61
- 3. **Neither fine-tune measurably changes the baseline.** Both scored a few episodes lower,
62
- within noise.
 
 
 
63
  4. **The failure is unchanged.** The target is knocked over while grasping in 26-28 of 60 for
64
- every model, and closing errors stay at 4.7-5.4 mm. Fine-tuning on this data does not improve
65
- grasp precision.
66
  5. **Closed-loop tests are noisy.** Two runs of the same model on the same seeds differ in 13
67
  of 60 episodes, from tiny GPU numeric differences amplified over a 20 s rollout. Sixty
68
  episodes can only detect large effects (about 15 points).
 
57
 
58
  1. **The normalization override was a real, large harm.** It is now controlled: keep the
59
  baseline's normalization in every fine-tune.
60
+ 2. **The effect of the correction data is inconclusive** once normalization is kept (A vs B,
61
+ p = 0.82). This test cannot detect small or moderate effects, so it is not evidence that the
62
+ corrections have no effect.
63
+ 3. **Both fine-tunes scored lower than the baseline** (21 and 23 against 28-31 of 60). The
64
+ differences are not significant (p = 0.14 and 0.36), so it is not established whether the
65
+ decline is real; it does not show equivalence.
66
  4. **The failure is unchanged.** The target is knocked over while grasping in 26-28 of 60 for
67
+ every model, and closing errors stay at 4.7-5.4 mm. Fixing the normalization did not solve
68
+ contact precision.
69
  5. **Closed-loop tests are noisy.** Two runs of the same model on the same seeds differ in 13
70
  of 60 episodes, from tiny GPU numeric differences amplified over a 20 s rollout. Sixty
71
  episodes can only detect large effects (about 15 points).