File size: 17,917 Bytes
08326df | 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 228 229 230 231 232 233 234 235 236 237 238 239 240 241 242 243 244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 280 281 282 283 284 285 286 287 288 289 290 291 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300 301 302 303 304 305 306 307 308 309 310 311 312 313 314 315 316 317 318 319 320 321 322 323 324 325 326 327 328 329 330 331 332 333 334 335 336 337 338 339 340 341 342 343 344 345 346 347 348 349 350 351 352 353 354 355 356 357 358 359 360 361 362 363 364 365 366 367 368 369 370 371 372 373 374 375 376 377 378 379 380 381 382 383 384 385 386 387 388 389 390 391 392 393 394 395 396 397 398 399 400 401 402 403 | #!/usr/bin/env python3
"""Full 12-variant analysis: 3 Cluster A MQ + 9 Cluster B (mq/hq/lq × new/repaired/repaired_upsampled).
Outputs (all to stdout, suitable for paper appendix):
Table 1 — Headline 13-metric × 12-variant matrix
Table 2 — POST+UP vs PRE within each tier (3 tier-deltas)
Table 3 — Tier ordering at each treatment (3 ordering rows × 13 metrics)
Table 4 — Repair-effect comparison across tiers (does repair help HQ as much as it helps MQ?)
Table 5 — Paloma-BPB 11-corpus × 12-variant matrix
Table 6 — Seed-variance noise floor (3 pairs: Cluster A MQ {PRE,POST,POST+UP} vs Cluster B MQ {same})
All deltas reported with per-task SE-based significance against the empirical
seed-variance noise floor measured in Table 6.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
import json, glob, math, statistics
BASE = './eval_results'
# Variant naming convention:
# - Cluster A MQ stored without prefix: 'clusterA_mq_new', 'clusterA_mq_new_repaired', 'clusterA_mq_new_repaired_upsampled'
# - Cluster B all prefixed: 'clusterB_mq_new', 'clusterB_hq_new', 'clusterB_lq_new', etc.
VARIANTS = [
# (label, suite_filename_prefix, display_name, cluster, tier, treatment)
('clusterA_mq_new', 'clusterA_mq_new', 'A-MQ-PRE', 'A', 'mq', 'pre'),
('clusterA_mq_new_repaired', 'clusterA_mq_new_repaired', 'A-MQ-POST', 'A', 'mq', 'post'),
('clusterA_mq_new_repaired_upsampled', 'clusterA_mq_new_repaired_upsampled', 'A-MQ-UP', 'A', 'mq', 'ups'),
('clusterB_mq_new', 'clusterB_mq_new', 'B-MQ-PRE', 'B', 'mq', 'pre'),
('clusterB_mq_new_repaired', 'clusterB_mq_new_repaired', 'B-MQ-POST', 'B', 'mq', 'post'),
('clusterB_mq_new_repaired_upsampled', 'clusterB_mq_new_repaired_upsampled', 'B-MQ-UP', 'B', 'mq', 'ups'),
('clusterB_hq_new', 'clusterB_hq_new', 'B-HQ-PRE', 'B', 'hq', 'pre'),
('clusterB_hq_new_repaired', 'clusterB_hq_new_repaired', 'B-HQ-POST', 'B', 'hq', 'post'),
('clusterB_hq_new_repaired_upsampled', 'clusterB_hq_new_repaired_upsampled', 'B-HQ-UP', 'B', 'hq', 'ups'),
('clusterB_lq_new', 'clusterB_lq_new', 'B-LQ-PRE', 'B', 'lq', 'pre'),
('clusterB_lq_new_repaired', 'clusterB_lq_new_repaired', 'B-LQ-POST', 'B', 'lq', 'post'),
('clusterB_lq_new_repaired_upsampled', 'clusterB_lq_new_repaired_upsampled', 'B-LQ-UP', 'B', 'lq', 'ups'),
]
METRIC_KEYS = {
'hellaswag':'acc_norm,none','piqa':'acc_norm,none','winogrande':'acc,none',
'commonsense_qa':'acc,none','social_iqa':'acc,none','openbookqa':'acc_norm,none',
'sciq':'acc_norm,none','arc_easy':'acc_norm,none','arc_challenge':'acc_norm,none',
'logiqa':'acc,none','pubmedqa':'acc,none','boolq':'acc,none','race':'acc,none',
'squadv2':'best_f1,none','coqa':'f1,none','copa':'acc,none','cb':'acc,none',
'rte':'acc,none','anli_r1':'acc,none','anli_r2':'acc,none','anli_r3':'acc,none',
'truthfulqa_mc2':'acc,none','triviaqa':'exact_match,remove_whitespace',
'nq_open':'exact_match,remove_whitespace','lambada_openai':'acc,none',
}
SCALE = {'squadv2':0.01}
def load(suite, label):
f = glob.glob(f'{BASE}/{suite}/{label}_results/results_*.json')
if not f: return {}
return json.load(open(f[0]))['results']
def numeric(x):
return x if isinstance(x,(int,float)) else 0.0
def task_value(results, task):
if task == 'mmlu_mean':
accs = [v.get('acc,none') for k,v in results.items() if k.startswith('mmlu_') and k != 'mmlu']
accs = [a for a in accs if isinstance(a,(int,float))]
return statistics.mean(accs) if accs else None
if task == 'blimp_mean':
accs = [v.get('acc,none') for k,v in results.items() if k.startswith('blimp_') and k != 'blimp']
accs = [a for a in accs if isinstance(a,(int,float))]
return statistics.mean(accs) if accs else None
key = METRIC_KEYS.get(task)
if key is None or task not in results: return None
v = results[task].get(key)
if not isinstance(v,(int,float)): return None
return v * SCALE.get(task, 1.0)
def task_se(results, task):
key = METRIC_KEYS.get(task)
if key is None or task not in results: return 0.0
se_key = key.replace(',', '_stderr,', 1)
return numeric(results[task].get(se_key)) * SCALE.get(task,1.0)
# ---- Load all data ----
data = {} # data[label_for_lookup][suite] = results dict
for lookup, prefix, _, _, _, _ in VARIANTS:
data[lookup] = {
'prose': load('prose', prefix),
'paloma': load('paloma', prefix),
}
# ---- Headline metrics list ----
HEADLINE = [
# (metric_id, display, group)
('hellaswag', 'HellaSwag', 'CS'),
('piqa', 'PIQA', 'CS'),
('winogrande', 'WinoGrande', 'CS'),
('commonsense_qa', 'CSQA', 'CS'),
('social_iqa', 'SIQA', 'CS'),
('arc_easy', 'ARC-E', 'KR'),
('arc_challenge', 'ARC-C', 'KR'),
('openbookqa', 'OpenBookQA', 'KR'),
('sciq', 'SciQ', 'KR'),
('mmlu_mean', 'MMLU-57', 'KR'),
('pubmedqa', 'PubMedQA', 'KR'),
('boolq', 'BoolQ', 'RC'),
('race', 'RACE', 'RC'),
('lambada_openai', 'LAMBADA', 'LM'),
('blimp_mean', 'BLiMP-67', 'L'),
]
def pct(v, n=2):
if v is None: return ' -- '
return f"{v*100:>{n+5}.{n}f}"
def short(label_name):
return label_name
# ============================================================================
# TABLE 1 — Headline 13-metric × 12-variant matrix
# ============================================================================
print("="*200)
print(" Table 1 — Per-variant zero-shot accuracy (%) on 15 headline prose metrics")
print(" Qwen3-1.7B, 1 epoch (iter 16 406, ~34.4 B tokens), BF16, H100, eval on standard NeMo 26.04 container, lm-eval 0.4.12")
print("="*200)
hdr = f" {'metric':<13}"
for _, _, disp, _, _, _ in VARIANTS:
hdr += f" {disp:>9}"
print(hdr)
print('-'*200)
for mid, disp, grp in HEADLINE:
line = f" {disp:<13}"
for lookup, _, _, _, _, _ in VARIANTS:
v = task_value(data[lookup]['prose'], mid)
if v is None:
line += f" {'--':>9}"
else:
line += f" {v*100:>9.2f}"
print(line)
# Paper-aligned aggregates
print('-'*200)
def fineweb_agg(results):
tasks = ['commonsense_qa','hellaswag','openbookqa','piqa','social_iqa','winogrande']
vs = [task_value(results,t) for t in tasks]
vs = [v for v in vs if v is not None]
# add arc_mean and mmlu_mean
arc_e = task_value(results,'arc_easy'); arc_c = task_value(results,'arc_challenge')
if arc_e is not None and arc_c is not None: vs.append((arc_e+arc_c)/2)
mmlu = task_value(results,'mmlu_mean')
if mmlu is not None: vs.append(mmlu)
return statistics.mean(vs) if vs else None
def dolma8_agg(results):
tasks = ['hellaswag','piqa','winogrande','openbookqa','arc_easy','arc_challenge','sciq','boolq']
vs = [task_value(results,t) for t in tasks]
vs = [v for v in vs if v is not None]
return statistics.mean(vs) if vs else None
def knowledge_agg(results):
tasks_acc = ['arc_challenge','openbookqa']
vs = [task_value(results,t) for t in tasks_acc]
mmlu = task_value(results,'mmlu_mean')
if mmlu is not None: vs.append(mmlu)
triv = task_value(results,'triviaqa')
if triv is not None: vs.append(triv)
nq = task_value(results,'nq_open')
if nq is not None: vs.append(nq)
return statistics.mean(vs) if vs else None
line = f" {'FineWeb-Agg-8':<13}"
for lookup, _, _, _, _, _ in VARIANTS:
v = fineweb_agg(data[lookup]['prose']);
line += f" {v*100:>9.2f}" if v else f" {'--':>9}"
print(line)
line = f" {'Dolma-Hdln-8':<13}"
for lookup, _, _, _, _, _ in VARIANTS:
v = dolma8_agg(data[lookup]['prose'])
line += f" {v*100:>9.2f}" if v else f" {'--':>9}"
print(line)
line = f" {'Knowledge-Agg':<13}"
for lookup, _, _, _, _, _ in VARIANTS:
v = knowledge_agg(data[lookup]['prose'])
line += f" {v*100:>9.2f}" if v else f" {'--':>9}"
print(line)
# Paloma BPB-11 mean (lower = better)
line = f" {'Paloma-BPB ↓':<13}"
for lookup, _, _, _, _, _ in VARIANTS:
palo = data[lookup]['paloma']
bpbs = [palo[t]['bits_per_byte,none'] for t in palo if 'bits_per_byte,none' in palo[t]]
v = statistics.mean(bpbs) if bpbs else None
line += f" {v:>9.4f}" if v else f" {'--':>9}"
print(line)
# ============================================================================
# TABLE 2 — Within-tier POST+UP vs PRE deltas (3 tier rows × 15 metric cols)
# ============================================================================
print()
print("="*200)
print(" Table 2 — Within-tier Δ (POST+UP − PRE) in percentage points")
print(" Each row is one data tier; positive Δ = POST+UP outperforms PRE; bold-able if |Δ| > 3 × seed_floor on that task")
print("="*200)
# Compute seed-variance noise floor per task from Cluster A MQ vs Cluster B MQ (PRE)
seed_floor = {}
for mid, disp, _ in HEADLINE:
mv = task_value(data['clusterA_mq_new']['prose'], mid)
hv = task_value(data['clusterB_mq_new']['prose'], mid)
if mv is not None and hv is not None:
seed_floor[mid] = abs(hv - mv) * 100
else:
seed_floor[mid] = 0.0
# also for paloma
seed_floor_bpb = {}
for corpus in data['clusterA_mq_new']['paloma']:
mv = data['clusterA_mq_new']['paloma'][corpus]['bits_per_byte,none']
hv = data['clusterB_mq_new']['paloma'][corpus]['bits_per_byte,none']
seed_floor_bpb[corpus] = abs(hv - mv)
tiers = [
('B-MQ', 'clusterB_mq_new', 'clusterB_mq_new_repaired_upsampled'),
('A-MQ', 'clusterA_mq_new', 'clusterA_mq_new_repaired_upsampled'),
('B-HQ', 'clusterB_hq_new', 'clusterB_hq_new_repaired_upsampled'),
('B-LQ', 'clusterB_lq_new', 'clusterB_lq_new_repaired_upsampled'),
]
hdr = f" {'tier':<10} "
for mid, disp, _ in HEADLINE: hdr += f" {disp:>9}"
hdr += f" {'FineWeb-8':>10} {'Dolma-8':>9} {'Know-Agg':>9} {'Paloma↓':>9}"
print(hdr)
print('-'*200)
for tname, pre, ups in tiers:
line = f" {tname:<10} "
for mid, _, _ in HEADLINE:
pv = task_value(data[pre]['prose'], mid); uv = task_value(data[ups]['prose'], mid)
if pv is None or uv is None:
line += f" {'--':>9}"
else:
d_pp = (uv-pv)*100
line += f" {d_pp:>+9.2f}"
# Aggregates
fw_pre = fineweb_agg(data[pre]['prose']); fw_ups = fineweb_agg(data[ups]['prose'])
do_pre = dolma8_agg(data[pre]['prose']); do_ups = dolma8_agg(data[ups]['prose'])
kn_pre = knowledge_agg(data[pre]['prose']);kn_ups = knowledge_agg(data[ups]['prose'])
# paloma mean (delta sign-inverted for "improvement" direction: lower bpb is better, so we report PRE - UP so positive = improvement)
palo_pre = statistics.mean([data[pre]['paloma'][c]['bits_per_byte,none'] for c in data[pre]['paloma']])
palo_ups = statistics.mean([data[ups]['paloma'][c]['bits_per_byte,none'] for c in data[ups]['paloma']])
line += f" {(fw_ups-fw_pre)*100:>+10.2f} {(do_ups-do_pre)*100:>+9.2f} {(kn_ups-kn_pre)*100:>+9.2f} {(palo_ups-palo_pre):>+9.4f}"
print(line)
# ============================================================================
# TABLE 3 — Tier ordering at each treatment (HQ vs MQ vs LQ at each of PRE/POST/POST+UP)
# ============================================================================
print()
print("="*200)
print(" Table 3 — Tier ordering at each treatment (Cluster B cluster; A-MQ shown as cross-cluster anchor)")
print(" Each cell = absolute zero-shot accuracy %; columns are data tier; row groups by treatment")
print("="*200)
TREATMENTS = ['PRE', 'POST', 'POST+UP']
tierset = [('LQ','clusterB_lq'), ('MQ','clusterB_mq'), ('HQ','clusterB_hq')]
sfx = {'PRE':'new', 'POST':'new_repaired', 'POST+UP':'new_repaired_upsampled'}
hdr = f" {'metric':<13} {'treat':<7} "
for tname, _ in tierset: hdr += f" {tname:>7}"
hdr += f" {'spread':>9}"
print(hdr)
print('-'*120)
for mid, disp, _ in HEADLINE:
for trt in TREATMENTS:
vals=[]
line = f" {disp:<13} {trt:<7} "
for tname, prefix in tierset:
label = f"{prefix}_{sfx[trt]}"
v = task_value(data[label]['prose'], mid)
vals.append(v)
line += f" {v*100:>7.2f}" if v is not None else f" {'--':>7}"
# spread
if all(v is not None for v in vals):
spread = (max(vals)-min(vals))*100
line += f" {spread:>9.2f}"
else:
line += f" {'--':>9}"
print(line)
print()
# ============================================================================
# TABLE 4 — Repair-effect by tier (POST+UP − PRE within each tier)
# ============================================================================
print("="*200)
print(" Table 4 — Repair-effect by tier (Δ in pp from PRE to POST+UP within each tier)")
print(" Compares whether repair is more/less effective at higher vs lower data quality")
print("="*200)
hdr = f" {'metric':<13} "
for tname in ['LQ','MQ','HQ']: hdr += f" {'Δ '+tname:>10}"
hdr += f" {'monotone?':>12}"
print(hdr)
print('-'*100)
for mid, disp, _ in HEADLINE:
line = f" {disp:<13} "
deltas = {}
for tname, prefix in [('LQ','clusterB_lq'), ('MQ','clusterB_mq'), ('HQ','clusterB_hq')]:
pre_lab = f"{prefix}_new"; ups_lab = f"{prefix}_new_repaired_upsampled"
pv = task_value(data[pre_lab]['prose'], mid); uv = task_value(data[ups_lab]['prose'], mid)
if pv is None or uv is None:
line += f" {'--':>10}"; deltas[tname] = None
else:
d = (uv-pv)*100
line += f" {d:>+10.2f}"
deltas[tname] = d
# monotone? (does Δ shrink/grow monotonically with tier quality?)
if all(deltas[t] is not None for t in ['LQ','MQ','HQ']):
if deltas['LQ'] >= deltas['MQ'] >= deltas['HQ']:
mono = 'LQ>MQ>HQ (repair helps lower-quality data more)'
elif deltas['LQ'] <= deltas['MQ'] <= deltas['HQ']:
mono = 'HQ>MQ>LQ'
else:
mono = 'non-monotone'
line += f" {mono:>40}"
print(line)
# ============================================================================
# TABLE 5 — Paloma-BPB 11-corpus × 12-variant matrix
# ============================================================================
print()
print("="*200)
print(" Table 5 — Paloma-11 BPB (bits-per-byte, lower=better) by variant")
print("="*200)
corpora = sorted(data['clusterA_mq_new']['paloma'].keys())
hdr = f" {'corpus':<32}"
for _, _, disp, _, _, _ in VARIANTS: hdr += f" {disp:>9}"
print(hdr)
print('-'*200)
for c in corpora:
name = data['clusterA_mq_new']['paloma'][c].get('alias', c)
line = f" {name:<32}"
for lookup, _, _, _, _, _ in VARIANTS:
v = data[lookup]['paloma'][c].get('bits_per_byte,none')
line += f" {v:>9.4f}" if v is not None else f" {'--':>9}"
print(line)
print('-'*200)
# Mean BPB
line = f" {'Paloma-BPB-11 mean ↓':<32}"
for lookup, _, _, _, _, _ in VARIANTS:
bpbs = [data[lookup]['paloma'][c]['bits_per_byte,none'] for c in corpora]
v = statistics.mean(bpbs)
line += f" {v:>9.4f}"
print(line)
# ============================================================================
# TABLE 6 — Seed-variance noise floor (Cluster A MQ vs Cluster B MQ at each treatment)
# ============================================================================
print()
print("="*200)
print(" Table 6 — Seed-variance noise floor measurement")
print(" Each comparison is same-tier same-treatment, different cluster + training seed.")
print(" |Δ| values are the empirical noise floor for interpreting cross-tier deltas above.")
print("="*200)
pairs = [
('PRE', 'clusterA_mq_new', 'clusterB_mq_new'),
('POST', 'clusterA_mq_new_repaired', 'clusterB_mq_new_repaired'),
('POST+UP', 'clusterA_mq_new_repaired_upsampled', 'clusterB_mq_new_repaired_upsampled'),
]
hdr = f" {'metric':<13}"
for trt,_,_ in pairs: hdr += f" |Δ| {trt:>8}"
hdr += f" {'median':>9}"
print(hdr)
print('-'*100)
all_floors = []
for mid, disp, _ in HEADLINE:
line = f" {disp:<13}"
vals=[]
for trt, mlab, hlab in pairs:
mv = task_value(data[mlab]['prose'], mid); hv = task_value(data[hlab]['prose'], mid)
if mv is None or hv is None:
line += f" {'--':>12}"
else:
d = abs(hv - mv) * 100
vals.append(d)
line += f" {d:>10.3f}pp"
med = statistics.median(vals) if vals else None
line += f" {med:>9.3f}" if med is not None else f" {'--':>9}"
print(line)
if vals: all_floors.extend(vals)
# Overall summary
print('-'*100)
print(f" Overall seed-variance noise floor on 15 headline metrics × 3 treatments:")
all_floors.sort()
print(f" median |Δ| = {statistics.median(all_floors):.3f} pp")
print(f" p75 |Δ| = {all_floors[int(len(all_floors)*0.75)]:.3f} pp")
print(f" p95 |Δ| = {all_floors[int(len(all_floors)*0.95)]:.3f} pp")
print(f" max |Δ| = {all_floors[-1]:.3f} pp")
# Paloma seed-variance
print()
print(f" Paloma BPB seed-variance (3 PRE/POST/POST+UP × 11 corpora):")
palo_floors = []
for trt, mlab, hlab in pairs:
for c in corpora:
d = abs(data[mlab]['paloma'][c]['bits_per_byte,none'] - data[hlab]['paloma'][c]['bits_per_byte,none'])
palo_floors.append(d)
palo_floors.sort()
print(f" median |Δ BPB| = {statistics.median(palo_floors):.5f}")
print(f" max |Δ BPB| = {palo_floors[-1]:.5f}")
print()
print("="*200)
print("END")
print("="*200)
|