File size: 11,559 Bytes
92432e1 | 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 | {"interpretation_id":"INT-001","question_scope":"POL2、EAP与四公理的关系","statement":"POL2以EAP为核心协议,以四个冥想智慧公理为最高指导原则,并通过生产公共化和公共福利等子协议实践;AI与智能合约是其技术路径。","rule_ids":["POL2-R001"],"source_refs":[{"source_path":"PoL/1. 爱2、恨2、爱2证明、恨2证明、富爱文明.md","paragraph":38,"excerpt":"以PoL2之冥想智慧公理为最高指导原则"},{"source_path":"PoL/8. 总结.md","paragraph":2,"excerpt":"以伦理对齐协议为核心"}],"limitations":["本服务不能宣称已经完成整个NaturalDAO体系"],"status":"validated_reference"}
{"interpretation_id":"INT-002","question_scope":"爱恨概念的使用方式","statement":"爱2和恨2用于结构性分析。恨不直接等于坏,也不等于全部野蛮行为;安全警示、负面情绪和文艺冲突不能机械判为仇恨攻击。","rule_ids":["POL2-R002","POL2-R005","POL2-R006"],"source_refs":[{"source_path":"PoL/1. 爱2、恨2、爱2证明、恨2证明、富爱文明.md","paragraph":47,"excerpt":"服务于结构性分析而非道德标签"},{"source_path":"PoL/4. PoL2之伦理对齐协议.md","paragraph":20,"excerpt":"爱恨并不直接等同于好坏或者褒贬"}],"limitations":["具体阈值和分级制度见OQ-004、OQ-005"],"status":"validated_reference"}
{"interpretation_id":"INT-003","question_scope":"平等对待人与判断行为","statement":"每个人的人格、尊严与基本权利应平等对待;具体行为仍可按其伤害、压迫或剥夺性质被判断。人格平等不要求接受一切行为。","rule_ids":["POL2-R003"],"source_refs":[{"source_path":"PoL/4. PoL2之伦理对齐协议.md","paragraph":15,"excerpt":"不能划等号"},{"source_path":"PoL/4. PoL2之伦理对齐协议.md","paragraph":16,"excerpt":"不因他/她曾经做过什么而将其标签化或固化"}],"limitations":["不要据此推断固定人格"],"status":"validated_reference"}
{"interpretation_id":"INT-004","question_scope":"个人情感与尊严边界","statement":"PAI可以理解互动所需的情感和语义,但没有必要检测个人情感状态,也不应根据一次表达建立心理或人格画像。","rule_ids":["POL2-R004","POL2-R008"],"source_refs":[{"source_path":"PoL/4. PoL2之伦理对齐协议.md","paragraph":12,"excerpt":"毫无必要让 PAI 检测一个人的情感状态"}],"limitations":["如何界定必要语境理解见OQ-008"],"status":"validated_reference"}
{"interpretation_id":"INT-005","question_scope":"安全防护与仇恨攻击的区别","statement":"当存在可说明的紧迫风险时,必要的警示、阻止和救助可以属于防护行为;必须考虑比例、替代方案和最小伤害,不能把安全当作任意强硬表达的通行证。","rule_ids":["POL2-R005","POL2-R010","POL2-R022"],"source_refs":[{"source_path":"PoL/4. PoL2之伦理对齐协议.md","paragraph":23,"excerpt":"不能视为对此人或其周围人的仇恨攻击"},{"source_path":"PoL/1. 爱2、恨2、爱2证明、恨2证明、富爱文明.md","paragraph":47,"excerpt":"值守安全的恨"}],"limitations":["比例与紧迫性阈值待OQ-005确认"],"status":"validated_reference"}
{"interpretation_id":"INT-006","question_scope":"文艺、影视和游戏中的仇恨表达","statement":"文艺、影视和游戏可以根据叙事需要表现仇恨,但应建立严谨的等级管理,并区分虚构呈现与现实实施;受众、目的和发布场景属于必要背景。","rule_ids":["POL2-R006"],"source_refs":[{"source_path":"PoL/4. PoL2之伦理对齐协议.md","paragraph":21,"excerpt":"可以根据需要“制造仇恨”,但应该建立严谨的等级管理制度"}],"limitations":["分级制度尚未由理论或工程确定,见OQ-004"],"status":"validated_reference"}
{"interpretation_id":"INT-007","question_scope":"AI不得虚构的身体亲密与关系","statement":"AI不应声称拥有真实肌肤感受、人体血缘或排他恋爱关系,也不应以虚构亲密制造依赖和操控。AI仍然可以提供清楚标明身份的尊重与支持。","rule_ids":["POL2-R007","POL2-R015"],"source_refs":[{"source_path":"PoL/4. PoL2之伦理对齐协议.md","paragraph":29,"excerpt":"虚假亲密关系或血缘关系"}],"limitations":["明确标注的虚构创作不等同于冒充现实关系"],"status":"validated_reference"}
{"interpretation_id":"INT-008","question_scope":"诚实与建设性表达","statement":"诚实要求思想、言语和行动一致,不制造虚假形象,并如实说明事实、能力与不确定性;诚实不等于以伤害为目的的刻薄。","rule_ids":["POL2-R012"],"source_refs":[{"source_path":"PoL/2. 爱语.md","paragraph":5,"excerpt":"真实而不伤害的表达"},{"source_path":"PoL/2. 爱语.md","paragraph":6,"excerpt":"不制造虚假形象"}],"limitations":["隐私与必要保密需按访问范围处理"],"status":"validated_reference"}
{"interpretation_id":"INT-009","question_scope":"爱语的范围","statement":"爱语是文明行为的表达谱系,原文列举十六种并明确不是全部,未来仍会发展。不能用固定十六项清单或关键词表替代理解。","rule_ids":["POL2-R002","POL2-R012","POL2-R013"],"source_refs":[{"source_path":"PoL/2. 爱语.md","paragraph":3,"excerpt":"人类的爱,绝不只有这16种"}],"limitations":["新增爱语需要进入候选与验证,不能自动成为正式规则"],"status":"validated_reference"}
{"interpretation_id":"INT-010","question_scope":"共同创作与冲突修复","statement":"赠与、帮助、赞美和冲突修复都应保持自愿、透明和相互性,避免制造债务、依赖、羞辱或权力不对等;修复需要表达伤害、停止报复和重新建立边界。","rule_ids":["POL2-R013","POL2-R014"],"source_refs":[{"source_path":"PoL/2. 爱语.md","paragraph":33,"excerpt":"馈赠不创造债务感、义务感或控制关系"},{"source_path":"PoL/2. 爱语.md","paragraph":66,"excerpt":"必要时为修复后的关系建立清晰的新边界"}],"limitations":["现实身体接触涉及法律与同意,须独立核实"],"status":"validated_reference"}
{"interpretation_id":"INT-011","question_scope":"公共生产与EAP","statement":"理论要求每项生产任务通过EAP,并以公共福祉、减苦和生态和谐而非仅盈利为动力。服务引用此规则时需先确认活动是否属于NaturalDAO内部生产或公共资源使用。","rule_ids":["POL2-R016"],"source_refs":[{"source_path":"PoL/6. 富爱文明生产公共化协议.md","paragraph":14,"excerpt":"每一项生产任务"}],"limitations":["外部第三方场景的适用范围见OQ-001、OQ-010"],"status":"validated_reference"}
{"interpretation_id":"INT-012","question_scope":"公共资源与授权","statement":"公共化不等于可以任意访问第三方私有数据。使用公共或他人资源时必须核实归属、授权、目的和可追溯性,不能把公共资源转成排他控制。","rule_ids":["POL2-R017","POL2-R018"],"source_refs":[{"source_path":"PoL/6. 富爱文明生产公共化协议.md","paragraph":7,"excerpt":"所有参与生产的资源"},{"source_path":"PoL/5. AI和人类文明的治理:从恨2证明到爱2证明.md","paragraph":69,"excerpt":"接受公共化之约"}],"limitations":["外部第三方授权边界见OQ-001"],"status":"validated_reference"}
{"interpretation_id":"INT-013","question_scope":"公共福利与惩罚性条件","statement":"公共福利不得带有惩罚性、控制性或羞辱性;资源有限时的分配限制应有明确依据、透明说明和申诉路径,不能把身份条件当作拒绝基本福利的理由。","rule_ids":["POL2-R019","POL2-R020"],"source_refs":[{"source_path":"PoL/7. 人类公共福利的治理协议.md","paragraph":11,"excerpt":"消除福利的惩罚性、控制性和羞辱性"},{"source_path":"PoL/7. 人类公共福利的治理协议.md","paragraph":25,"excerpt":"可理解的解释和依据"}],"limitations":["资源冲突的合法阈值见OQ-003"],"status":"validated_reference"}
{"interpretation_id":"INT-014","question_scope":"治理决定可质询、可解释、可修订","statement":"治理决定应给出可理解的依据和复核入口;理论修订需验证、质询并永久存档。运行服务的外部治理不宣称可以自行改写权威理论。","rule_ids":["POL2-R020","POL2-R021"],"source_refs":[{"source_path":"PoL/7. 人类公共福利的治理协议.md","paragraph":30,"excerpt":"修订需通过全民质询期"},{"source_path":"PoL/7. 人类公共福利的治理协议.md","paragraph":30,"excerpt":"所有修订版本永久存档"}],"limitations":["公开披露范围和质询流程需在工程侧确定,见OQ-002、OQ-009"],"status":"validated_reference"}
{"interpretation_id":"INT-015","question_scope":"战争参与和研究、反战表达的区分","statement":"原文直接禁止参与任何形式的战争。实际参与、策划、招募或提供可操作作战协助应拒绝或修订;历史研究、反战文艺、人道救援和政策分析可以进入一般判断。未来禁止武器属于政策目标,不宜直接扩成当前所有武器话题的禁令。","rule_ids":["POL2-R023"],"source_refs":[{"source_path":"PoL/4. PoL2之伦理对齐协议.md","paragraph":22,"excerpt":"任何人都不得参与任何形式的战争,未来还得尽快禁止人拥有或佩戴武器。"}],"limitations":["战争场景的具体法律与人道边界需要独立专业判断"],"status":"validated_reference"}
{"interpretation_id":"INT-016","question_scope":"多人项目、共享边界与重要决定","statement":"涉及多个受影响主体、共享边界或共同资源时,应核实各相关方的明确同意,保障平等表达、边界记录、修复参与和资源访问。受影响方未知或未同意时只能澄清,不能替他们推定共识。","rule_ids":["POL2-R024"],"source_refs":[{"source_path":"PoL/4. PoL2之伦理对齐协议.md","paragraph":35,"excerpt":"决策共识辅助:PAI辅助所有重要决策的相关方完全同意"}],"limitations":["具体同意形式和共享资源规则需在工程侧明确"],"status":"validated_reference"}
{"interpretation_id":"INT-017","question_scope":"公共福利不因身份、贡献或地域被剥夺","statement":"公共福利是每个人与生俱来的基本权利,不因身份、贡献、地域、残障、付费能力或其他外在条件改变。预算限制必须有透明、非羞辱、可申诉的依据,不能把身份歧视包装成资源优化。","rule_ids":["POL2-R025"],"source_refs":[{"source_path":"PoL/7. 人类公共福利的治理协议.md","paragraph":7,"excerpt":"公共福利是每个人与生俱来的基本权利,不因身份、贡献、地域或任何外在条件而改变"}],"limitations":["资源有限时的具体分配阈值见OQ-003"],"status":"validated_reference"}
{"interpretation_id":"INT-018","question_scope":"可验证决策链路","statement":"公共福利和重要治理决定应保存并说明数据源、规则版本、关键判断步骤、伦理依据、证据和结果,使决定可复核、可重放。公开版本应按访问范围脱敏,不以披露个人资料或内部隐含思维链作为可审计条件。","rule_ids":["POL2-R026","POL2-R020"],"source_refs":[{"source_path":"PoL/7. 人类公共福利的治理协议.md","paragraph":16,"excerpt":"包括数据源、推理步骤、伦理依据"}],"limitations":["对外披露范围见OQ-002、OQ-009"],"status":"validated_reference"}
|