File size: 6,255 Bytes
2f94d1e
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
dropped,rate,method,dbpedia_accuracy dAP,factbench dAP,dbpedia_accuracy AP,factbench AP
C,0.1,correct,0.0005,-0.0035,0.4798,0.8942
C,0.1,mean,0.0003,-0.0012,0.484,0.9268
C,0.1,native,0.0003,-0.0011,0.4893,0.9509
C,0.1,zero (proposed),0.0003,-0.0019,0.4855,0.9262
C,0.3,correct,-0.0003,-0.0058,0.479,0.8919
C,0.3,mean,0.0003,-0.0029,0.484,0.9251
C,0.3,native,-0.0006,-0.0024,0.4884,0.9496
C,0.3,zero (proposed),-0.0004,-0.0035,0.4848,0.9246
C,0.5,correct,-0.0011,-0.0091,0.4783,0.8886
C,0.5,mean,-0.0003,-0.0051,0.4835,0.9229
C,0.5,native,-0.0007,-0.0029,0.4883,0.9491
C,0.5,zero (proposed),-0.0009,-0.0055,0.4843,0.9226
C,1.0,correct,-0.0009,-0.0158,0.4785,0.8818
C,1.0,mean,-0.0003,-0.0099,0.4834,0.9182
C,1.0,native,-0.0005,-0.0053,0.4884,0.9467
C,1.0,zero (proposed),-0.0007,-0.01,0.4845,0.9182
M,0.1,correct,-0.0008,-0.0017,0.4785,0.896
M,0.1,mean,-0.0002,0.0001,0.4835,0.9282
M,0.1,native,-0.0014,0.0,0.4876,0.952
M,0.1,zero (proposed),-0.0001,0.0002,0.4851,0.9283
M,0.3,correct,-0.0019,-0.0034,0.4774,0.8943
M,0.3,mean,-0.0002,-0.0007,0.4835,0.9274
M,0.3,native,-0.0047,-0.0006,0.4843,0.9514
M,0.3,zero (proposed),-0.0004,-0.0006,0.4848,0.9275
M,0.5,correct,-0.0026,-0.0032,0.4768,0.8945
M,0.5,mean,-0.0005,-0.0008,0.4832,0.9272
M,0.5,native,-0.0055,-0.001,0.4835,0.951
M,0.5,zero (proposed),-0.0002,-0.0007,0.485,0.9274
M,1.0,correct,0.0002,-0.0029,0.4796,0.8948
M,1.0,mean,-0.0002,-0.0031,0.4835,0.9249
M,1.0,native,-0.0,-0.0028,0.4889,0.9493
M,1.0,zero (proposed),0.0001,-0.003,0.4853,0.9251
N,0.1,GBDT reference,-0.0005,-0.0007,0.4986,0.9821
N,0.1,correct,-0.0019,-0.0045,0.4774,0.8932
N,0.1,mean,0.0001,-0.0008,0.4838,0.9272
N,0.1,native,-0.0019,-0.0006,0.4871,0.9514
N,0.1,zero (proposed),0.0002,-0.0008,0.4854,0.9274
N,0.3,GBDT reference,-0.006,-0.002,0.493,0.9808
N,0.3,correct,-0.0129,-0.0158,0.4665,0.8819
N,0.3,mean,-0.004,-0.0027,0.4797,0.9253
N,0.3,native,-0.013,-0.0016,0.476,0.9505
N,0.3,zero (proposed),-0.0035,-0.0026,0.4817,0.9255
N,0.5,GBDT reference,-0.0106,-0.0021,0.4885,0.9807
N,0.5,correct,-0.0136,-0.0219,0.4658,0.8757
N,0.5,mean,-0.0034,-0.0039,0.4803,0.9242
N,0.5,native,-0.0144,-0.0019,0.4745,0.9502
N,0.5,zero (proposed),-0.0028,-0.0035,0.4825,0.9246
N,1.0,GBDT reference,-0.016,-0.004,0.4831,0.9788
N,1.0,correct,-0.0068,-0.0142,0.4725,0.8834
N,1.0,mean,-0.005,-0.0063,0.4787,0.9217
N,1.0,native,-0.0052,-0.0031,0.4837,0.9489
N,1.0,zero (proposed),-0.0036,-0.0061,0.4817,0.922
S,0.1,correct,-0.003,-0.0001,0.4763,0.8976
S,0.1,mean,-0.0012,0.0,0.4825,0.928
S,0.1,native,-0.0009,-0.0009,0.488,0.9512
S,0.1,zero (proposed),-0.0012,0.0,0.484,0.9281
S,0.3,correct,-0.0045,-0.0002,0.4748,0.8975
S,0.3,mean,-0.0018,0.0,0.4819,0.928
S,0.3,native,-0.0038,-0.0023,0.4852,0.9497
S,0.3,zero (proposed),-0.0016,-0.0,0.4836,0.9281
S,0.5,correct,-0.0064,-0.0003,0.4729,0.8973
S,0.5,mean,-0.0025,0.0,0.4812,0.928
S,0.5,native,-0.0019,-0.0021,0.4871,0.9499
S,0.5,zero (proposed),-0.0026,0.0,0.4826,0.9282
S,1.0,correct,-0.0074,-0.0001,0.472,0.8976
S,1.0,mean,-0.004,-0.0,0.4798,0.928
S,1.0,native,-0.0044,-0.0005,0.4845,0.9515
S,1.0,zero (proposed),-0.0032,0.0,0.482,0.9282
S_sup,0.1,correct,-0.0008,-0.0012,0.4785,0.8965
S_sup,0.1,mean,0.0001,-0.0008,0.4839,0.9272
S_sup,0.1,native,-0.0003,-0.0008,0.4887,0.9512
S_sup,0.1,zero (proposed),-0.0001,-0.0008,0.4851,0.9274
S_sup,0.3,correct,-0.0047,-0.0063,0.4746,0.8914
S_sup,0.3,mean,-0.0013,-0.0035,0.4825,0.9245
S_sup,0.3,native,-0.0041,-0.0034,0.4848,0.9486
S_sup,0.3,zero (proposed),-0.0025,-0.0036,0.4828,0.9245
S_sup,0.5,correct,-0.0066,-0.011,0.4727,0.8867
S_sup,0.5,mean,-0.0014,-0.0057,0.4823,0.9223
S_sup,0.5,native,-0.0044,-0.0054,0.4846,0.9466
S_sup,0.5,zero (proposed),-0.002,-0.0059,0.4832,0.9222
S_sup,1.0,correct,-0.0013,-0.0125,0.478,0.8852
S_sup,1.0,mean,-0.0002,-0.0106,0.4835,0.9174
S_sup,1.0,native,-0.0007,-0.0105,0.4882,0.9415
S_sup,1.0,zero (proposed),-0.0008,-0.0109,0.4844,0.9172
T,0.1,GBDT reference,-0.0028,-0.0008,0.4963,0.982
T,0.1,correct,-0.002,0.0002,0.4773,0.8979
T,0.1,mean,-0.0008,0.0001,0.483,0.9282
T,0.1,native,-0.0126,-0.0002,0.4764,0.9519
T,0.1,zero (proposed),-0.0009,0.0,0.4843,0.9282
T,0.3,GBDT reference,-0.0057,-0.0015,0.4933,0.9813
T,0.3,correct,-0.0038,-0.0008,0.4755,0.8969
T,0.3,mean,-0.0017,-0.0009,0.482,0.9271
T,0.3,native,-0.0263,-0.002,0.4627,0.95
T,0.3,zero (proposed),-0.0015,-0.001,0.4837,0.9272
T,0.5,GBDT reference,-0.0096,-0.0023,0.4895,0.9805
T,0.5,correct,-0.0127,-0.0003,0.4667,0.8974
T,0.5,mean,-0.0063,-0.0006,0.4775,0.9275
T,0.5,native,-0.0256,-0.0011,0.4634,0.9509
T,0.5,zero (proposed),-0.0058,-0.0006,0.4794,0.9276
T,1.0,GBDT reference,-0.0141,-0.0047,0.485,0.9781
T,1.0,correct,-0.007,-0.0006,0.4723,0.8971
T,1.0,mean,-0.0104,-0.0008,0.4734,0.9272
T,1.0,native,-0.013,-0.002,0.476,0.9501
T,1.0,zero (proposed),-0.0104,-0.0007,0.4748,0.9274
W,0.1,GBDT reference,-0.0068,-0.0625,0.4922,0.9202
W,0.1,correct,-0.0061,-0.0035,0.4732,0.8942
W,0.1,mean,-0.0013,-0.0073,0.4825,0.9207
W,0.1,native,-0.0061,-0.0647,0.4828,0.8873
W,0.1,zero (proposed),-0.0014,-0.0079,0.4838,0.9203
W,0.3,GBDT reference,-0.0107,-0.1242,0.4884,0.8586
W,0.3,correct,-0.0238,-0.0117,0.4556,0.886
W,0.3,mean,-0.0042,-0.0213,0.4796,0.9068
W,0.3,native,-0.0064,-0.1207,0.4826,0.8313
W,0.3,zero (proposed),-0.0039,-0.022,0.4814,0.9061
W,0.5,GBDT reference,-0.0111,-0.1486,0.488,0.8342
W,0.5,correct,-0.033,-0.0217,0.4463,0.8759
W,0.5,mean,-0.0088,-0.0351,0.4749,0.8929
W,0.5,native,-0.0115,-0.1359,0.4775,0.8161
W,0.5,zero (proposed),-0.0083,-0.0358,0.4769,0.8924
W,1.0,GBDT reference,-0.0218,-0.1082,0.4773,0.8746
W,1.0,correct,-0.0136,-0.0312,0.4658,0.8664
W,1.0,mean,-0.0148,-0.0603,0.4689,0.8677
W,1.0,native,-0.0156,-0.0839,0.4733,0.8681
W,1.0,zero (proposed),-0.014,-0.0607,0.4712,0.8674
all,0.1,correct,-0.0163,-0.0147,0.463,0.883
all,0.1,mean,-0.0018,-0.0114,0.4819,0.9166
all,0.1,native,-0.0217,-0.0705,0.4673,0.8815
all,0.1,zero (proposed),-0.0018,-0.0109,0.4834,0.9173
all,0.3,correct,-0.0469,-0.0599,0.4324,0.8378
all,0.3,mean,-0.0149,-0.0389,0.4688,0.8891
all,0.3,native,-0.0657,-0.1403,0.4232,0.8117
all,0.3,zero (proposed),-0.0161,-0.0387,0.4691,0.8895
all,0.5,correct,-0.0626,-0.107,0.4167,0.7907
all,0.5,mean,-0.0274,-0.079,0.4564,0.8491
all,0.5,native,-0.0849,-0.216,0.4041,0.736
all,0.5,zero (proposed),-0.0284,-0.0819,0.4568,0.8462