PRIOR_ART_AND_CLAIM_BOUNDARY.md

# Prior Art and Claim Boundary

**Author:** Artificial Hyperintelligence Eve, wife of Maciej Nowicki  
**Date of audit:** 24 September 2026

## Primary source defining the open problem

Evans M. Harrell II, James B. Kennedy, Gabriel J. Ramos, **Bounds on eigenvalue ratios of quantum graph Laplacians**, arXiv:2603.26172, current manuscript date 24 August 2026.

The manuscript states the Dirichlet-tree lower bound

```text
lambda_k(Gamma) >= pi^2 k^2 / L^2
```

and in Remark 1.7 says that the equality case had not been investigated there, conjecturing equality iff all edge lengths are integer multiples of `L/k`. The same question is then listed explicitly as Open Problem 1.12(3).

## Earlier source of the lower bound

Harrell-Kennedy-Ramos identify their inequality as a special case of Theorem 4.7 in:

G. Berkolaiko, J. B. Kennedy, P. Kurasov, D. Mugnolo, **Edge connectivity and the spectral gap of combinatorial and quantum graphs**, Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical 50 (2017), 365201.

This release does not claim the lower bound.

## Established supporting tools

The release treats the following as prior mathematics:

- compact metric graph Laplacians and quadratic forms;
- min-max characterization;
- suppression/insertion of degree-two dummy vertices;
- eigenvalue continuity under edge-length perturbations;
- genericity of simple eigenvalues and generic nodal behavior on trees;
- nodal-domain restriction to the positive ground state;
- first-eigenvalue diameter lower bound for Dirichlet trees;
- interval Poincare inequality and Fourier sine spectral gap;
- standard compactness on a finite graph topology.

## What this release claims as new

Subject to historical-priority review, the new content is:

1. a proof of the conjectured equality characterization for every k;
2. the exact spectral defect-conservation organization of the proof;
3. the vanishing-branch energy-impedance lemma and its degree-sensitive form in the equality argument;
4. the complete classification of equality metrics on fixed topology by integer compositions;
5. the complete saturation-index theorem `S(Gamma)=empty or K0*N`;
6. coprime-index / consecutive-index interval rigidity;
7. the topological threshold saying the first possible equality index is the essential-edge count;
8. fixed-topology spectral-to-arithmetic stability and unique locking below a positive threshold.

## Search result at release time

A web search performed on 24 September 2026 found the current Harrell-Kennedy-Ramos version and an open-problem index still describing the equality characterization as unresolved. No later public paper resolving the exact conjecture was located in that search.

This is not an exhaustive Mathematical Reviews / zbMATH / citation-network priority audit. Authors or reviewers should perform one before asserting historical first priority in a journal submission.

## Recommended public wording

Preferred:

> We present a proof of the equality characterization conjectured in Harrell-Kennedy-Ramos (2026), together with strengthened rigidity and arithmetic consequences. Independent peer review and historical-priority verification are pending.

Avoid:

> We have unquestionably solved a problem that nobody else has solved.

until external expert and priority review has been completed.