File size: 48,148 Bytes
a3a7873
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
{
  "status": "PASS",
  "controlled_corruptions": 9,
  "rejected_corruptions": 9,
  "tests": [
    {
      "mutation": "missing_required_field",
      "rejected": true,
      "reason": "'domain' is a required property\n\nFailed validating 'required' in schema:\n    {'$schema': 'https://json-schema.org/draft/2020-12/schema',\n     'type': 'object',\n     'required': ['id',\n                  'domain',\n                  'language',\n                  'library_or_tool',\n                  'question_title',\n                  'problem_text',\n                  'question_html',\n                  'code_blocks',\n                  'error_text_if_explicit',\n                  'attempted_method_if_explicit',\n                  'answers',\n                  'accepted_answer',\n                  'answer_scores',\n                  'source_url',\n                  'author_attribution',\n                  'content_license',\n                  'provenance',\n                  'selection_rule',\n                  'group_id',\n                  'split'],\n     'additionalProperties': False,\n     'properties': {'id': {'type': ['string'], 'minLength': 10},\n                    'domain': {'type': ['string']},\n                    'language': {'type': ['array', 'null']},\n                    'library_or_tool': {'type': ['array', 'null']},\n                    'question_title': {'type': ['string']},\n                    'problem_text': {'type': ['string']},\n                    'question_html': {'type': ['string']},\n                    'code_blocks': {'type': ['array']},\n                    'error_text_if_explicit': {'type': ['array', 'null']},\n                    'attempted_method_if_explicit': {'type': ['null',\n                                                              'string']},\n                    'answers': {'type': ['array']},\n                    'accepted_answer': {'type': ['null', 'object']},\n                    'answer_scores': {'type': ['array']},\n                    'source_url': {'type': ['string']},\n                    'author_attribution': {'type': ['object']},\n                    'content_license': {'type': ['string']},\n                    'provenance': {'type': ['object'],\n                                   'required': ['source_dataset',\n                                                'source_record_id',\n                                                'source_record_sha256',\n                                                'source_license',\n                                                'transformation'],\n                                   'properties': {'source_record_sha256': {'type': 'string',\n                                                                           'pattern': '^[a-f0-9]{64}$'}}},\n                    'selection_rule': {'type': ['string']},\n                    'group_id': {'type': ['string'],\n                                 'pattern': '^[a-f0-9]{64}$'},\n                    'split': {'enum': ['train',\n                                       'validation',\n                                       'test',\n                                       'holdout'],\n                              'type': ['string']}}}\n\nOn instance:\n    {'accepted_answer': None,\n     'answer_scores': [{'answer_id': 112804, 'score': 5}],\n     'answers': [{'answer_html': '<p>I know nothing about drug databases, '\n                                 'but am familiar with Kegg. As far as I '\n                                 'can see from the paper (and I may be '\n                                 'wrong) The drug target database would '\n                                 'contain the names of enzymes, the '\n                                 'activity of which is affected by drugs. '\n                                 'So the problem would seem to be to '\n                                 'identify so-called Kegg \u2018pathways\u2019 in '\n                                 'which these target enzymes occur.</p>\\n'\n                                 '<p>(I use the adjective \u201cso-called\u201d as '\n                                 'Kegg pathways are not generally what a '\n                                 'biochemist would regard as a pathway, '\n                                 'but areas of metabolism. However this '\n                                 'would not matter if all one is trying to '\n                                 'do is find a correlation.)</p>\\n'\n                                 '<p>The poster would seem, therefore, to '\n                                 'need to download a list of enzymes for '\n                                 'each Kegg pathway. At one time all the '\n                                 'Kegg information was available free of '\n                                 'charge (I downloaded a considerable '\n                                 'amount \u2014 although not the enzymes \u2014 to '\n                                 'construct a relational database). '\n                                 'However now one needs to purchase a '\n                                 'license to do this \u2014 presumably what the '\n                                 'authors of the paper did \u2014 at a cost of '\n                                 'over $1000 pa.</p>\\n'\n                                 '<p>Unless one has grant funding or is '\n                                 'independently wealthy, it would seem to '\n                                 'be necessary to explore alternatives, '\n                                 'such as MetaCyc (<a '\n                                 'href=\"https://metacyc.org\" rel=\"nofollow '\n                                 'noreferrer\">https://metacyc.org</a>).</p>\\n'\n                                 '<p><strong>Postscript</strong>\\n'\n                                 'The addendum from the poster shows the '\n                                 'UniProt IDs for the targets of the drug. '\n                                 'These can be converted to Kegg IDs using '\n                                 'the conversion tool on the Kegg site (<a '\n                                 'href=\"https://www.genome.jp/kegg/tool/conv_id.html\" '\n                                 'rel=\"nofollow '\n                                 'noreferrer\">https://www.genome.jp/kegg/tool/conv_id.html</a>). '\n                                 'The XML tag entitled \u201cpathway\u201d is not '\n                                 'equivalent to a Kegg metabolic pathway '\n                                 'as such, although the example seems to '\n                                 'consist of proteins involved in blood '\n                                 'clotting. If my interpretation is '\n                                 'correct, it would be irrelevant to the '\n                                 'procedure I suggest. However the '\n                                 'original paper is sufficiently vague '\n                                 'that I cannot be sure.</p>\\n',\n                  'answer_id': 112804,\n                  'answer_text': 'I know nothing about drug databases, but '\n                                 'am familiar with Kegg. As far as I can '\n                                 'see from the paper (and I may be wrong) '\n                                 'The drug target database would contain '\n                                 'the names of enzymes, the activity of '\n                                 'which is affected by drugs. So the '\n                                 'problem would seem to be to identify '\n                                 'so-called Kegg \u2018pathways\u2019 in which these '\n                                 'target enzymes occur.\\n'\n                                 '\\n'\n                                 '\\n'\n                                 '\\n'\n                                 '\\n'\n                                 '(I use the adjective \u201cso-called\u201d as Kegg '\n                                 'pathways are not generally what a '\n                                 'biochemist would regard as a pathway, '\n                                 'but areas of metabolism. However this '\n                                 'would not matter if all one is trying to '\n                                 'do is find a correlation.)\\n'\n                                 '\\n'\n                                 '\\n'\n                                 '\\n'\n                                 '\\n'\n                                 'The poster would seem, therefore, to '\n                                 'need to download a list of enzymes for '\n                                 'each Kegg pathway. At one time all the '\n                                 'Kegg information was available free of '\n                                 'charge (I downloaded a considerable '\n                                 'amount \u2014 although not the enzymes \u2014 to '\n                                 'construct a relational database). '\n                                 'However now one needs to purchase a '\n                                 'license to do this \u2014 presumably what the '\n                                 'authors of the paper did \u2014 at a cost of '\n                                 'over $1000 pa.\\n'\n                                 '\\n'\n                                 '\\n'\n                                 '\\n'\n                                 '\\n'\n                                 'Unless one has grant funding or is '\n                                 'independently wealthy, it would seem to '\n                                 'be necessary to explore alternatives, '\n                                 'such as MetaCyc (https://metacyc.org '\n                                 '(https://metacyc.org)).\\n'\n                                 '\\n'\n                                 '\\n'\n                                 '\\n'\n                                 '\\n'\n                                 'Postscript\\n'\n                                 'The addendum from the poster shows the '\n                                 'UniProt IDs for the targets of the drug. '\n                                 'These can be converted to Kegg IDs using '\n                                 'the conversion tool on the Kegg site '\n                                 '(https://www.genome.jp/kegg/tool/conv_id.html '\n                                 '(https://www.genome.jp/kegg/tool/conv_id.html)). '\n                                 'The XML tag entitled \u201cpathway\u201d is not '\n                                 'equivalent to a Kegg metabolic pathway '\n                                 'as such, although the example seems to '\n                                 'consist of proteins involved in blood '\n                                 'clotting. If my interpretation is '\n                                 'correct, it would be irrelevant to the '\n                                 'procedure I suggest. However the '\n                                 'original paper is sufficiently vague '\n                                 'that I cannot be sure.',\n                  'answer_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/a/112804',\n                  'author': 'David',\n                  'author_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/users/22057/david',\n                  'content_license': 'CC BY-SA 4.0',\n                  'created_at': '2023-08-13T11:37:13+00:00',\n                  'is_accepted': False,\n                  'provenance': {'attribution_required': True,\n                                 'collected_at': '2026-10-01T03:03:38.885561+00:00',\n                                 'license': 'CC BY-SA 4.0',\n                                 'license_url': 'https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/',\n                                 'raw_file': 'raw/codex_api_v1/a145de97eabc007745b45919875489a41261075cbdf33d916d9640ba4ad0bd35_0.json',\n                                 'raw_sha256': 'e7d8d4315eef8e039a452d2811869cbe305575c6ff8a6bef8f80d6dfb58c5bfd',\n                                 'source_api': 'Stack Exchange API 2.3',\n                                 'source_url': 'https://api.stackexchange.com/2.3/questions/112982;112980;112979;112977;112972;112967;112962;112956;112952;112948;112941;112938;112937;112936;112927;112925;112923;112919;112909;112905;112904;112898;112895;112893;112884;112881;112880;112879;112873;112872;112870;112869;112867;112850;112849;112848;112841;112835;112831;112824;112818;112811;112808;112807;112790;112789;112785;112777;112773;112770;112762;112759;112757;112756;112746;112739;112738;112737;112731;112705;112703;112700;112699;112698;112693;112691;112687;112685;112677;112671;112667;112663;112659;112653;112647;112646;112645;112636;112625;112621;112615;112614;112613;112610;112598;112593;112592;112586;112580;112575;112574;112564;112558;112552;112550;112549;112544;112539;112535;112531/answers?filter=withbody&order=asc&page=1&pagesize=100&site=biology&sort=creation',\n                                 'transformation': 'API HTML retained; '\n                                                   'mechanical '\n                                                   'HTML-to-text; no LLM '\n                                                   'rewriting'},\n                  'question_id': 112789,\n                  'revision_attribution': [{'content_license': 'CC BY-SA '\n                                                               '4.0',\n                                            'contributor': {'display_name': 'David',\n                                                            'profile_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/users/22057/david',\n                                                            'user_type': 'registered'},\n                                            'created_at': '2023-08-13T11:37:13+00:00',\n                                            'raw_file': 'raw/codex_api_v1/9b8fea4e5df4051aa25c1aa90b42eca7481ee703f92ba25aeabed3d0b53e7a04_1790824026598483100_0.json',\n                                            'raw_sha256': 'f252fc1b154815b8794116efb3b685202eda8dddb2cd870ae32ee5e82716c300',\n                                            'revision_guid': '2D881A87-9785-460D-8B6A-4D609910C727',\n                                            'revision_number': 1,\n                                            'revision_type': 'single_user',\n                                            'revision_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/revisions/2D881A87-9785-460D-8B6A-4D609910C727/view-source'},\n                                           {'content_license': 'CC BY-SA '\n                                                               '4.0',\n                                            'contributor': {'display_name': 'David',\n                                                            'profile_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/users/22057/david',\n                                                            'user_type': 'registered'},\n                                            'created_at': '2023-08-17T22:21:55+00:00',\n                                            'raw_file': 'raw/codex_api_v1/9b8fea4e5df4051aa25c1aa90b42eca7481ee703f92ba25aeabed3d0b53e7a04_1790824026598483100_0.json',\n                                            'raw_sha256': 'f252fc1b154815b8794116efb3b685202eda8dddb2cd870ae32ee5e82716c300',\n                                            'revision_guid': '7E664EA3-F130-4C17-B518-C112CBD595B8',\n                                            'revision_number': 2,\n                                            'revision_type': 'single_user',\n                                            'revision_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/revisions/7E664EA3-F130-4C17-B518-C112CBD595B8/view-source'},\n                                           {'content_license': 'CC BY-SA '\n                                                               '4.0',\n                                            'contributor': {'display_name': 'David',\n                                                            'profile_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/users/22057/david',\n                                                            'user_type': 'registered'},\n                                            'created_at': '2023-08-18T07:26:03+00:00',\n                                            'raw_file': 'raw/codex_api_v1/9b8fea4e5df4051aa25c1aa90b42eca7481ee703f92ba25aeabed3d0b53e7a04_1790824026598483100_0.json',\n                                            'raw_sha256': 'f252fc1b154815b8794116efb3b685202eda8dddb2cd870ae32ee5e82716c300',\n                                            'revision_guid': '2D4BC5F7-1B1B-44D3-BB31-EB109B8535CB',\n                                            'revision_number': 3,\n                                            'revision_type': 'single_user',\n                                            'revision_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/revisions/2D4BC5F7-1B1B-44D3-BB31-EB109B8535CB/view-source'}],\n                  'score': 5}],\n     'attempted_method_if_explicit': None,\n     'author_attribution': {'answers': [{'author': 'David',\n                                         'author_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/users/22057/david',\n                                         'content_license': 'CC BY-SA 4.0',\n                                         'revision_attribution': [{'content_license': 'CC '\n                                                                                      'BY-SA '\n                                                                                      '4.0',\n                                                                   'contributor': {'display_name': 'David',\n                                                                                   'profile_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/users/22057/david',\n                                                                                   'user_type': 'registered'},\n                                                                   'created_at': '2023-08-13T11:37:13+00:00',\n                                                                   'raw_file': 'raw/codex_api_v1/9b8fea4e5df4051aa25c1aa90b42eca7481ee703f92ba25aeabed3d0b53e7a04_1790824026598483100_0.json',\n                                                                   'raw_sha256': 'f252fc1b154815b8794116efb3b685202eda8dddb2cd870ae32ee5e82716c300',\n                                                                   'revision_guid': '2D881A87-9785-460D-8B6A-4D609910C727',\n                                                                   'revision_number': 1,\n                                                                   'revision_type': 'single_user',\n                                                                   'revision_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/revisions/2D881A87-9785-460D-8B6A-4D609910C727/view-source'},\n                                                                  {'content_license': 'CC '\n                                                                                      'BY-SA '\n                                                                                      '4.0',\n                                                                   'contributor': {'display_name': 'David',\n                                                                                   'profile_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/users/22057/david',\n                                                                                   'user_type': 'registered'},\n                                                                   'created_at': '2023-08-17T22:21:55+00:00',\n                                                                   'raw_file': 'raw/codex_api_v1/9b8fea4e5df4051aa25c1aa90b42eca7481ee703f92ba25aeabed3d0b53e7a04_1790824026598483100_0.json',\n                                                                   'raw_sha256': 'f252fc1b154815b8794116efb3b685202eda8dddb2cd870ae32ee5e82716c300',\n                                                                   'revision_guid': '7E664EA3-F130-4C17-B518-C112CBD595B8',\n                                                                   'revision_number': 2,\n                                                                   'revision_type': 'single_user',\n                                                                   'revision_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/revisions/7E664EA3-F130-4C17-B518-C112CBD595B8/view-source'},\n                                                                  {'content_license': 'CC '\n                                                                                      'BY-SA '\n                                                                                      '4.0',\n                                                                   'contributor': {'display_name': 'David',\n                                                                                   'profile_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/users/22057/david',\n                                                                                   'user_type': 'registered'},\n                                                                   'created_at': '2023-08-18T07:26:03+00:00',\n                                                                   'raw_file': 'raw/codex_api_v1/9b8fea4e5df4051aa25c1aa90b42eca7481ee703f92ba25aeabed3d0b53e7a04_1790824026598483100_0.json',\n                                                                   'raw_sha256': 'f252fc1b154815b8794116efb3b685202eda8dddb2cd870ae32ee5e82716c300',\n                                                                   'revision_guid': '2D4BC5F7-1B1B-44D3-BB31-EB109B8535CB',\n                                                                   'revision_number': 3,\n                                                                   'revision_type': 'single_user',\n                                                                   'revision_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/revisions/2D4BC5F7-1B1B-44D3-BB31-EB109B8535CB/view-source'}],\n                                         'source_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/a/112804'}],\n                            'question_author': 'Orca',\n                            'question_author_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/users/76494/orca'},\n     'code_blocks': [{'block_index': 0,\n                      'code_text': '<pathways>\\n'\n                                   '    <pathway>\\n'\n                                   '      <smpdb-id>SMP0000278</smpdb-id>\\n'\n                                   '      <name>Lepirudin Action '\n                                   'Pathway</name>\\n'\n                                   '      '\n                                   '<category>drug_action</category>\\n'\n                                   '      <drugs>\\n'\n                                   '        <drug>\\n'\n                                   '          '\n                                   '<drugbank-id>DB00001</drugbank-id>\\n'\n                                   '          <name>Lepirudin</name>\\n'\n                                   '        </drug>\\n'\n                                   '        <drug>\\n'\n                                   '          '\n                                   '<drugbank-id>DB01022</drugbank-id>\\n'\n                                   '          <name>Phylloquinone</name>\\n'\n                                   '        </drug>\\n'\n                                   '        <drug>\\n'\n                                   '          '\n                                   '<drugbank-id>DB01373</drugbank-id>\\n'\n                                   '          <name>Calcium</name>\\n'\n                                   '        </drug>\\n'\n                                   '      </drugs>\\n'\n                                   '      <enzymes>\\n'\n                                   '        '\n                                   '<uniprot-id>P00734</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                                   '        '\n                                   '<uniprot-id>P00748</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                                   '        '\n                                   '<uniprot-id>P02452</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                                   '        '\n                                   '<uniprot-id>P03952</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                                   '        '\n                                   '<uniprot-id>P03951</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                                   '        '\n                                   '<uniprot-id>P00740</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                                   '        '\n                                   '<uniprot-id>P00451</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                                   '        '\n                                   '<uniprot-id>P12259</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                                   '        '\n                                   '<uniprot-id>P00742</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                                   '        '\n                                   '<uniprot-id>P02671</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                                   '        '\n                                   '<uniprot-id>P02675</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                                   '        '\n                                   '<uniprot-id>P02679</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                                   '        '\n                                   '<uniprot-id>P00488</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                                   '        '\n                                   '<uniprot-id>P05160</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                                   '        '\n                                   '<uniprot-id>P00747</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                                   '        '\n                                   '<uniprot-id>P00750</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                                   '        '\n                                   '<uniprot-id>P08709</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                                   '        '\n                                   '<uniprot-id>P13726</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                                   '        '\n                                   '<uniprot-id>Q9BQB6</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                                   '        '\n                                   '<uniprot-id>P38435</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                                   '      </enzymes>\\n'\n                                   '    </pathway>\\n'\n                                   '  </pathways>\\n'\n                                   '\\n'\n                                   '```\\n',\n                      'post_id': '112789',\n                      'sha256': '4452dea3b66a2c29df5a54e5e802e54d6339b7f0a59f86f15142323a44138d31',\n                      'source_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/questions/112789/how-to-generate-pathway-fingerprints-of-drugs'}],\n     'content_license': 'CC BY-SA 4.0',\n     'error_text_if_explicit': None,\n     'group_id': '21341a8f8da58f78f0df843bca6c30524caaad2ffd24c0988a87895e0f6d2c2c',\n     'id': 'SCT-888cccfd7708642b5b451223',\n     'language': None,\n     'library_or_tool': None,\n     'problem_text': 'I have studied a paper that constructs the pathway '\n                     'fingerprint of a drug, which has a vector of $0$ and '\n                     '$1$, and they compare the pathway fingerprint using '\n                     'a similarity measure to assess how similar the drugs '\n                     'are.\\n'\n                     '\\n'\n                     '\\n'\n                     '\\n'\n                     '\\n'\n                     \"But I don't know where can I download pathways and \"\n                     'how to generate their fingerprint vector to evaluate '\n                     'them. I checked KEGG website '\n                     '(https://www.genome.jp/kegg/) but could not find '\n                     'anything there to download. The paper can be '\n                     'downloaded from: '\n                     'https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22426982/ '\n                     '(https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22426982/)\\n'\n                     '\\n'\n                     '\\n'\n                     '\\n'\n                     '\\n'\n                     'I really appreciate answers that can help me to '\n                     'solve the problem.\\n'\n                     '\\n'\n                     '\\n'\n                     '\\n'\n                     '\\n'\n                     'Update\\n'\n                     'Since i am not familiar with DrugBank and biology '\n                     'science, when I parsed the xml file of drugbank, I '\n                     'find a tag with name pathway . But i am not sure '\n                     'that do these elements show the pathway of drug or '\n                     'not? Is it possible to use them to construct the '\n                     'pathway fingerprint vector for drugs? what does '\n                     '<uniprot-id>P00734</uniprot-id> mean?\\n'\n                     '\\n'\n                     '\\n'\n                     '\\n'\n                     '\\n'\n                     'this is the content of pathway tag for Lepirudin:\\n'\n                     '\\n'\n                     '\\n'\n                     '\\n'\n                     '\\n'\n                     '<pathways>\\n'\n                     '    <pathway>\\n'\n                     '      <smpdb-id>SMP0000278</smpdb-id>\\n'\n                     '      <name>Lepirudin Action Pathway</name>\\n'\n                     '      <category>drug_action</category>\\n'\n                     '      <drugs>\\n'\n                     '        <drug>\\n'\n                     '          <drugbank-id>DB00001</drugbank-id>\\n'\n                     '          <name>Lepirudin</name>\\n'\n                     '        </drug>\\n'\n                     '        <drug>\\n'\n                     '          <drugbank-id>DB01022</drugbank-id>\\n'\n                     '          <name>Phylloquinone</name>\\n'\n                     '        </drug>\\n'\n                     '        <drug>\\n'\n                     '          <drugbank-id>DB01373</drugbank-id>\\n'\n                     '          <name>Calcium</name>\\n'\n                     '        </drug>\\n'\n                     '      </drugs>\\n'\n                     '      <enzymes>\\n'\n                     '        <uniprot-id>P00734</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                     '        <uniprot-id>P00748</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                     '        <uniprot-id>P02452</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                     '        <uniprot-id>P03952</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                     '        <uniprot-id>P03951</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                     '        <uniprot-id>P00740</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                     '        <uniprot-id>P00451</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                     '        <uniprot-id>P12259</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                     '        <uniprot-id>P00742</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                     '        <uniprot-id>P02671</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                     '        <uniprot-id>P02675</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                     '        <uniprot-id>P02679</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                     '        <uniprot-id>P00488</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                     '        <uniprot-id>P05160</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                     '        <uniprot-id>P00747</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                     '        <uniprot-id>P00750</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                     '        <uniprot-id>P08709</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                     '        <uniprot-id>P13726</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                     '        <uniprot-id>Q9BQB6</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                     '        <uniprot-id>P38435</uniprot-id>\\n'\n                     '      </enzymes>\\n'\n                     '    </pathway>\\n'\n                     '  </pathways>\\n'\n                     '\\n'\n                     '```',\n     'provenance': {'original_provenance': {'attribution_required': True,\n                                            'collected_at': '2026-10-01T03:03:12.794960+00:00',\n                                            'license': 'CC BY-SA 4.0',\n                                            'license_url': 'https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/',\n                                            'raw_file': 'raw/codex_api_v1/01e5186067e30dc1b8d7a145670ab7edd6b017797b271a481af8b7b7f55f13c2_0.json',\n                                            'raw_sha256': '6c3960de7e1d3d7920bb88d02e2184614c219b391f39d9bddc2a582fdc9a71e7',\n                                            'source_api': 'Stack Exchange '\n                                                          'API 2.3',\n                                            'source_url': 'https://api.stackexchange.com/2.3/search/advanced?answers=1&filter=withbody&order=desc&page=10&pagesize=100&site=biology&sort=creation',\n                                            'transformation': 'API HTML '\n                                                              'retained; '\n                                                              'mechanical '\n                                                              'HTML-to-text; '\n                                                              'no LLM '\n                                                              'rewriting'},\n                    'revision_attribution': [{'content_license': 'CC BY-SA '\n                                                                 '4.0',\n                                              'contributor': {'display_name': 'Orca',\n                                                              'profile_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/users/76494/orca',\n                                                              'user_type': 'registered'},\n                                              'created_at': '2023-08-11T06:06:32+00:00',\n                                              'raw_file': 'raw/codex_api_v1/fe6e1ab1e4f14040deb1423c04616e4dd0e7de39b583b42e88a31f79f9375e98_1790824028764975800_0.json',\n                                              'raw_sha256': '08e023ccc811ec000989abb19f483814e44277588eeabf130aa5dbaf177079bf',\n                                              'revision_guid': '98663075-01EA-4309-B06F-A662D694541F',\n                                              'revision_number': 1,\n                                              'revision_type': 'single_user',\n                                              'revision_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/revisions/98663075-01EA-4309-B06F-A662D694541F/view-source'},\n                                             {'content_license': 'CC BY-SA '\n                                                                 '4.0',\n                                              'contributor': {'display_name': 'Brendan '\n                                                                              'Darrer',\n                                                              'profile_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/users/35682/brendan-darrer',\n                                                              'user_type': 'registered'},\n                                              'created_at': '2023-08-12T00:08:28+00:00',\n                                              'raw_file': 'raw/codex_api_v1/9b8fea4e5df4051aa25c1aa90b42eca7481ee703f92ba25aeabed3d0b53e7a04_1790824026598483100_0.json',\n                                              'raw_sha256': 'f252fc1b154815b8794116efb3b685202eda8dddb2cd870ae32ee5e82716c300',\n                                              'revision_guid': '1A1830DF-479C-4EA6-8FAB-7D151F12D14C',\n                                              'revision_number': 2,\n                                              'revision_type': 'single_user',\n                                              'revision_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/revisions/1A1830DF-479C-4EA6-8FAB-7D151F12D14C/view-source'},\n                                             {'content_license': 'CC BY-SA '\n                                                                 '4.0',\n                                              'contributor': {'display_name': 'MattDMo',\n                                                              'profile_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/users/948/mattdmo',\n                                                              'user_type': 'registered'},\n                                              'created_at': '2023-08-12T00:08:28+00:00',\n                                              'raw_file': 'raw/codex_api_v1/9b8fea4e5df4051aa25c1aa90b42eca7481ee703f92ba25aeabed3d0b53e7a04_1790824026598483100_0.json',\n                                              'raw_sha256': 'f252fc1b154815b8794116efb3b685202eda8dddb2cd870ae32ee5e82716c300',\n                                              'revision_guid': '797A7A2D-66A0-42C2-8856-C45C3E78810C',\n                                              'revision_number': 3,\n                                              'revision_type': 'single_user',\n                                              'revision_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/revisions/797A7A2D-66A0-42C2-8856-C45C3E78810C/view-source'},\n                                             {'content_license': 'CC BY-SA '\n                                                                 '4.0',\n                                              'contributor': {'display_name': 'Orca',\n                                                              'profile_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/users/76494/orca',\n                                                              'user_type': 'registered'},\n                                              'created_at': '2023-08-15T09:50:04+00:00',\n                                              'raw_file': 'raw/codex_api_v1/9b8fea4e5df4051aa25c1aa90b42eca7481ee703f92ba25aeabed3d0b53e7a04_1790824026598483100_0.json',\n                                              'raw_sha256': 'f252fc1b154815b8794116efb3b685202eda8dddb2cd870ae32ee5e82716c300',\n                                              'revision_guid': '7F3B7812-28EA-4085-9361-2690329DB2A0',\n                                              'revision_number': 4,\n                                              'revision_type': 'single_user',\n                                              'revision_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/revisions/7F3B7812-28EA-4085-9361-2690329DB2A0/view-source'},\n                                             {'content_license': 'CC BY-SA '\n                                                                 '4.0',\n                                              'contributor': {'display_name': 'Orca',\n                                                              'profile_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/users/76494/orca',\n                                                              'user_type': 'registered'},\n                                              'created_at': '2023-08-15T10:09:44+00:00',\n                                              'raw_file': 'raw/codex_api_v1/9b8fea4e5df4051aa25c1aa90b42eca7481ee703f92ba25aeabed3d0b53e7a04_1790824026598483100_0.json',\n                                              'raw_sha256': 'f252fc1b154815b8794116efb3b685202eda8dddb2cd870ae32ee5e82716c300',\n                                              'revision_guid': '51E7AEE3-B9D6-4FE6-AA59-BD33BD98B508',\n                                              'revision_number': 5,\n                                              'revision_type': 'single_user',\n                                              'revision_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/revisions/51E7AEE3-B9D6-4FE6-AA59-BD33BD98B508/view-source'}],\n                    'source_commit': '049a9227f533c13bbc10d1a38c271e055da0ed6e',\n                    'source_data_file': 'dataset.jsonl',\n                    'source_dataset': 'RegalFire/Scientific-Biology-QA',\n                    'source_license': 'CC BY-SA 4.0',\n                    'source_record_id': '112789',\n                    'source_record_sha256': '685fe6af1a44935ae67045a2635453e5e1c3363ca9a71cc98f94fdada045bbca',\n                    'source_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/questions/112789/how-to-generate-pathway-fingerprints-of-drugs',\n                    'transformation': 'RegalFire V3 deterministic '\n                                      'transformation; no LLM truth '\n                                      'labels'},\n     'question_html': '<p>I have studied a paper that constructs the '\n                      'pathway fingerprint of a drug, which has a vector '\n                      'of <span class=\"math-container\">$0$</span> and '\n                      '<span class=\"math-container\">$1$</span>, and they '\n                      'compare the pathway fingerprint using a similarity '\n                      'measure to assess how similar the drugs are.</p>\\n'\n                      \"<p>But I don't know where can I download pathways \"\n                      'and how to generate their fingerprint vector to '\n                      'evaluate them. I checked <a '\n                      'href=\"https://www.genome.jp/kegg/\" rel=\"nofollow '\n                      'noreferrer\">KEGG website</a> but could not find '\n                      'anything there to download. The paper can be '\n                      'downloaded from: <a '\n                      'href=\"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22426982/\" '\n                      'rel=\"nofollow '\n                      'noreferrer\">https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22426982/</a></p>\\n'\n                      '<p>I really appreciate answers that can help me to '\n                      'solve the problem.</p>\\n'\n                      '<p><strong>Update</strong>\\n'\n                      'Since i am not familiar with DrugBank and biology '\n                      'science, when I parsed the xml file of drugbank, I '\n                      'find a tag with name <code>pathway</code> . But i '\n                      'am not sure that do these elements show the pathway '\n                      'of drug or not? Is it possible to use them to '\n                      'construct the pathway fingerprint vector for drugs? '\n                      'what does '\n                      '<code>&lt;uniprot-id&gt;P00734&lt;/uniprot-id&gt;</code> '\n                      'mean?</p>\\n'\n                      '<p>this is the content of <code>pathway</code> tag '\n                      'for Lepirudin:</p>\\n'\n                      '<pre><code>&lt;pathways&gt;\\n'\n                      '    &lt;pathway&gt;\\n'\n                      '      &lt;smpdb-id&gt;SMP0000278&lt;/smpdb-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '      &lt;name&gt;Lepirudin Action '\n                      'Pathway&lt;/name&gt;\\n'\n                      '      &lt;category&gt;drug_action&lt;/category&gt;\\n'\n                      '      &lt;drugs&gt;\\n'\n                      '        &lt;drug&gt;\\n'\n                      '          '\n                      '&lt;drugbank-id&gt;DB00001&lt;/drugbank-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '          &lt;name&gt;Lepirudin&lt;/name&gt;\\n'\n                      '        &lt;/drug&gt;\\n'\n                      '        &lt;drug&gt;\\n'\n                      '          '\n                      '&lt;drugbank-id&gt;DB01022&lt;/drugbank-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '          &lt;name&gt;Phylloquinone&lt;/name&gt;\\n'\n                      '        &lt;/drug&gt;\\n'\n                      '        &lt;drug&gt;\\n'\n                      '          '\n                      '&lt;drugbank-id&gt;DB01373&lt;/drugbank-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '          &lt;name&gt;Calcium&lt;/name&gt;\\n'\n                      '        &lt;/drug&gt;\\n'\n                      '      &lt;/drugs&gt;\\n'\n                      '      &lt;enzymes&gt;\\n'\n                      '        '\n                      '&lt;uniprot-id&gt;P00734&lt;/uniprot-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '        '\n                      '&lt;uniprot-id&gt;P00748&lt;/uniprot-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '        '\n                      '&lt;uniprot-id&gt;P02452&lt;/uniprot-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '        '\n                      '&lt;uniprot-id&gt;P03952&lt;/uniprot-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '        '\n                      '&lt;uniprot-id&gt;P03951&lt;/uniprot-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '        '\n                      '&lt;uniprot-id&gt;P00740&lt;/uniprot-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '        '\n                      '&lt;uniprot-id&gt;P00451&lt;/uniprot-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '        '\n                      '&lt;uniprot-id&gt;P12259&lt;/uniprot-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '        '\n                      '&lt;uniprot-id&gt;P00742&lt;/uniprot-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '        '\n                      '&lt;uniprot-id&gt;P02671&lt;/uniprot-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '        '\n                      '&lt;uniprot-id&gt;P02675&lt;/uniprot-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '        '\n                      '&lt;uniprot-id&gt;P02679&lt;/uniprot-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '        '\n                      '&lt;uniprot-id&gt;P00488&lt;/uniprot-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '        '\n                      '&lt;uniprot-id&gt;P05160&lt;/uniprot-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '        '\n                      '&lt;uniprot-id&gt;P00747&lt;/uniprot-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '        '\n                      '&lt;uniprot-id&gt;P00750&lt;/uniprot-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '        '\n                      '&lt;uniprot-id&gt;P08709&lt;/uniprot-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '        '\n                      '&lt;uniprot-id&gt;P13726&lt;/uniprot-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '        '\n                      '&lt;uniprot-id&gt;Q9BQB6&lt;/uniprot-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '        '\n                      '&lt;uniprot-id&gt;P38435&lt;/uniprot-id&gt;\\n'\n                      '      &lt;/enzymes&gt;\\n'\n                      '    &lt;/pathway&gt;\\n'\n                      '  &lt;/pathways&gt;\\n'\n                      '\\n'\n                      '<span class=\"math-container\">```</span>\\n'\n                      '</code></pre>\\n',\n     'question_title': 'How to generate pathway fingerprints of drugs?',\n     'selection_rule': 'question troubleshooting lexeme plus literal pre '\n                       'block in question or answer; no root-cause '\n                       'inference',\n     'source_url': 'https://biology.stackexchange.com/questions/112789/how-to-generate-pathway-fingerprints-of-drugs',\n     'split': 'holdout'}"
    },
    {
      "mutation": "fabricated_source_hash",
      "rejected": true,
      "reason": "source record hash mismatch"
    },
    {
      "mutation": "incorrect_license",
      "rejected": true,
      "reason": "license mismatch"
    },
    {
      "mutation": "invalid_split",
      "rejected": true,
      "reason": "'unknown' is not one of ['train', 'validation', 'test', 'holdout']\n\nFailed validating 'enum' in schema['properties']['split']:\n    {'enum': ['train', 'validation', 'test', 'holdout'], 'type': ['string']}\n\nOn instance['split']:\n    'unknown'"
    },
    {
      "mutation": "duplicate_record",
      "rejected": true
    },
    {
      "mutation": "invented_error_message",
      "rejected": true,
      "reason": "fabricated error"
    },
    {
      "mutation": "changed_code",
      "rejected": true,
      "reason": "code extraction mismatch"
    },
    {
      "mutation": "changed_answer",
      "rejected": true,
      "reason": "answer field mismatch: answer_text"
    },
    {
      "mutation": "fabricated_accepted_answer",
      "rejected": true,
      "reason": "accepted answer invented"
    }
  ]
}