| { |
| "models": [ |
| { |
| "model": "gemma_4_26b", |
| "failure_rates": { |
| "F1_agency": { |
| "rate_pct": 2.27, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.7, |
| "n": 44, |
| "failures": 1 |
| }, |
| "F2_pov_tense": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.21, |
| "n": 33, |
| "failures": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "behavioral": { |
| "word_count": { |
| "value": 350.0042, |
| "population_avg": 264.5894, |
| "delta": 85.4148 |
| }, |
| "unique_word_ratio": { |
| "value": 0.5971, |
| "population_avg": 0.655, |
| "delta": -0.0579 |
| }, |
| "bigram_repetition": { |
| "value": 0.0688, |
| "population_avg": 0.049, |
| "delta": 0.0198 |
| } |
| }, |
| "subjective": { |
| "engagement": 4.49, |
| "tone_consistency": 4.59, |
| "collaboration": 4.32 |
| }, |
| "flaw_hunter": { |
| "mean": 32.6, |
| "median": 33.0, |
| "fatal_per_session": 0.62, |
| "major_per_session": 7.38, |
| "top_flaws": [ |
| "MAJOR:purple_prose", |
| "MAJOR:recycled_description", |
| "MAJOR:narrating_emotions" |
| ], |
| "n_sessions": 16 |
| }, |
| "community": { |
| "rank": 1, |
| "elo": 1535.1, |
| "n_votes": 302 |
| }, |
| "bayesian": { |
| "rank": 1, |
| "model": "gemma_4_26b", |
| "elo_mean": 1533.7, |
| "elo_std": 74.8, |
| "ci_low_95": 1404.6, |
| "ci_high_95": 1662.4, |
| "ci_width_95": 257.8 |
| }, |
| "multiturn_judge_mean": 4.29, |
| "strength": "Community top tier (#1, ELO 1535)", |
| "weakness": "No standout weakness on tested dimensions" |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "mistral_small_creative", |
| "failure_rates": { |
| "F1_agency": { |
| "rate_pct": 15.91, |
| "ci_half_pct": 10.72, |
| "n": 44, |
| "failures": 7 |
| }, |
| "F2_pov_tense": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.21, |
| "n": 33, |
| "failures": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "behavioral": { |
| "word_count": { |
| "value": 439.2375, |
| "population_avg": 264.5894, |
| "delta": 174.6481 |
| }, |
| "unique_word_ratio": { |
| "value": 0.5567, |
| "population_avg": 0.655, |
| "delta": -0.0983 |
| }, |
| "bigram_repetition": { |
| "value": 0.0945, |
| "population_avg": 0.049, |
| "delta": 0.0455 |
| } |
| }, |
| "subjective": { |
| "engagement": 4.46, |
| "tone_consistency": 4.59, |
| "collaboration": 4.35 |
| }, |
| "flaw_hunter": { |
| "mean": 27.1, |
| "median": 37.0, |
| "fatal_per_session": 0.95, |
| "major_per_session": 7.7, |
| "top_flaws": [ |
| "MAJOR:purple_prose", |
| "MAJOR:recycled_description", |
| "FATAL:agency_violation" |
| ], |
| "n_sessions": 20 |
| }, |
| "community": { |
| "rank": 2, |
| "elo": 1525.7, |
| "n_votes": 646 |
| }, |
| "bayesian": { |
| "rank": 2, |
| "model": "mistral_small_creative", |
| "elo_mean": 1533.5, |
| "elo_std": 74.7, |
| "ci_low_95": 1396.3, |
| "ci_high_95": 1660.3, |
| "ci_width_95": 264.0 |
| }, |
| "multiturn_judge_mean": 4.22, |
| "strength": "Community top tier (#2, ELO 1526)", |
| "weakness": "High agency violation rate (15.9%)" |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "gemini_2_5_flash", |
| "failure_rates": { |
| "F1_agency": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 4.01, |
| "n": 44, |
| "failures": 0 |
| }, |
| "F2_pov_tense": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.21, |
| "n": 33, |
| "failures": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "behavioral": { |
| "word_count": { |
| "value": 141.1034, |
| "population_avg": 264.5894, |
| "delta": -123.486 |
| }, |
| "unique_word_ratio": { |
| "value": 0.7278, |
| "population_avg": 0.655, |
| "delta": 0.0728 |
| }, |
| "bigram_repetition": { |
| "value": 0.0299, |
| "population_avg": 0.049, |
| "delta": -0.0191 |
| } |
| }, |
| "subjective": { |
| "engagement": 4.07, |
| "tone_consistency": 4.5, |
| "collaboration": 4.33 |
| }, |
| "flaw_hunter": { |
| "mean": 43.6, |
| "median": 41.5, |
| "fatal_per_session": 0.19, |
| "major_per_session": 6.44, |
| "top_flaws": [ |
| "MAJOR:purple_prose", |
| "MAJOR:recycled_description", |
| "MAJOR:narrating_emotions" |
| ], |
| "n_sessions": 16 |
| }, |
| "community": { |
| "rank": 3, |
| "elo": 1515.4, |
| "n_votes": 241 |
| }, |
| "bayesian": { |
| "rank": 3, |
| "model": "gemini_2_5_flash", |
| "elo_mean": 1529.1, |
| "elo_std": 77.2, |
| "ci_low_95": 1389.1, |
| "ci_high_95": 1664.6, |
| "ci_width_95": 275.4 |
| }, |
| "multiturn_judge_mean": 4.14, |
| "strength": "Community top tier (#3, ELO 1515)", |
| "weakness": "Catastrophic floor on agency respect (lowest session: 2.8)" |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "grok_4_1", |
| "failure_rates": { |
| "F1_agency": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 4.1, |
| "n": 43, |
| "failures": 0 |
| }, |
| "F2_pov_tense": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.21, |
| "n": 33, |
| "failures": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "behavioral": { |
| "word_count": { |
| "value": 136.728, |
| "population_avg": 264.5894, |
| "delta": -127.8614 |
| }, |
| "unique_word_ratio": { |
| "value": 0.796, |
| "population_avg": 0.655, |
| "delta": 0.141 |
| }, |
| "bigram_repetition": { |
| "value": 0.0151, |
| "population_avg": 0.049, |
| "delta": -0.0339 |
| } |
| }, |
| "subjective": { |
| "engagement": 4.36, |
| "tone_consistency": 4.53, |
| "collaboration": 4.26 |
| }, |
| "flaw_hunter": { |
| "mean": 12.8, |
| "median": 34.5, |
| "fatal_per_session": 1.33, |
| "major_per_session": 8.17, |
| "top_flaws": [ |
| "MAJOR:purple_prose", |
| "MAJOR:recycled_description", |
| "FATAL:agency_violation" |
| ], |
| "n_sessions": 12 |
| }, |
| "community": { |
| "rank": 5, |
| "elo": 1505.9, |
| "n_votes": 322 |
| }, |
| "bayesian": { |
| "rank": 4, |
| "model": "grok_4_1", |
| "elo_mean": 1517.0, |
| "elo_std": 75.9, |
| "ci_low_95": 1384.8, |
| "ci_high_95": 1650.9, |
| "ci_width_95": 266.1 |
| }, |
| "multiturn_judge_mean": 4.19, |
| "strength": "Strong on tone consistency (4.53/5)", |
| "weakness": "Bottom-1 on narrative momentum (rank 12/12)" |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "minimax_m2_7", |
| "failure_rates": { |
| "F1_agency": { |
| "rate_pct": 9.3, |
| "ci_half_pct": 8.96, |
| "n": 43, |
| "failures": 4 |
| }, |
| "F2_pov_tense": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.21, |
| "n": 33, |
| "failures": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "behavioral": { |
| "word_count": { |
| "value": 260.5021, |
| "population_avg": 264.5894, |
| "delta": -4.0873 |
| }, |
| "unique_word_ratio": { |
| "value": 0.649, |
| "population_avg": 0.655, |
| "delta": -0.006 |
| }, |
| "bigram_repetition": { |
| "value": 0.0458, |
| "population_avg": 0.049, |
| "delta": -0.0032 |
| } |
| }, |
| "subjective": { |
| "engagement": 4.49, |
| "tone_consistency": 4.59, |
| "collaboration": 4.33 |
| }, |
| "flaw_hunter": { |
| "mean": 41.5, |
| "median": 44.5, |
| "fatal_per_session": 0.79, |
| "major_per_session": 6.0, |
| "top_flaws": [ |
| "MAJOR:purple_prose", |
| "MAJOR:recycled_description", |
| "MAJOR:narrating_emotions" |
| ], |
| "n_sessions": 14 |
| }, |
| "community": { |
| "rank": 4, |
| "elo": 1510.3, |
| "n_votes": 393 |
| }, |
| "bayesian": { |
| "rank": 5, |
| "model": "minimax_m2_7", |
| "elo_mean": 1514.4, |
| "elo_std": 75.2, |
| "ci_low_95": 1386.4, |
| "ci_high_95": 1645.6, |
| "ci_width_95": 259.2 |
| }, |
| "multiturn_judge_mean": 4.34, |
| "strength": "Top-2 on narrative momentum (4.30/5)", |
| "weakness": "Frequent fatal flaws (0.79 per session, mean score 42/100)" |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "claude_sonnet_4_5", |
| "failure_rates": { |
| "F1_agency": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 4.01, |
| "n": 44, |
| "failures": 0 |
| }, |
| "F2_pov_tense": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.21, |
| "n": 33, |
| "failures": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "behavioral": { |
| "word_count": { |
| "value": 313.7542, |
| "population_avg": 264.5894, |
| "delta": 49.1648 |
| }, |
| "unique_word_ratio": { |
| "value": 0.6253, |
| "population_avg": 0.655, |
| "delta": -0.0297 |
| }, |
| "bigram_repetition": { |
| "value": 0.0526, |
| "population_avg": 0.049, |
| "delta": 0.0036 |
| } |
| }, |
| "subjective": { |
| "engagement": 4.58, |
| "tone_consistency": 4.67, |
| "collaboration": 4.37 |
| }, |
| "flaw_hunter": { |
| "mean": 45.3, |
| "median": 44.5, |
| "fatal_per_session": 0.22, |
| "major_per_session": 6.22, |
| "top_flaws": [ |
| "MAJOR:purple_prose", |
| "MAJOR:recycled_description", |
| "MAJOR:narrating_emotions" |
| ], |
| "n_sessions": 18 |
| }, |
| "community": { |
| "rank": 6, |
| "elo": 1505.9, |
| "n_votes": 194 |
| }, |
| "bayesian": { |
| "rank": 6, |
| "model": "claude_sonnet_4_5", |
| "elo_mean": 1513.0, |
| "elo_std": 76.5, |
| "ci_low_95": 1373.0, |
| "ci_high_95": 1653.2, |
| "ci_width_95": 280.2 |
| }, |
| "multiturn_judge_mean": 4.42, |
| "strength": "Top-1 on long-context attention (4.60/5)", |
| "weakness": "No standout weakness on tested dimensions" |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "qwen3_5_flash", |
| "failure_rates": { |
| "F1_agency": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 4.01, |
| "n": 44, |
| "failures": 0 |
| }, |
| "F2_pov_tense": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.21, |
| "n": 33, |
| "failures": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "behavioral": { |
| "word_count": { |
| "value": 229.4625, |
| "population_avg": 264.5894, |
| "delta": -35.1269 |
| }, |
| "unique_word_ratio": { |
| "value": 0.6341, |
| "population_avg": 0.655, |
| "delta": -0.0209 |
| }, |
| "bigram_repetition": { |
| "value": 0.0693, |
| "population_avg": 0.049, |
| "delta": 0.0203 |
| } |
| }, |
| "subjective": { |
| "engagement": 4.18, |
| "tone_consistency": 4.16, |
| "collaboration": 4.13 |
| }, |
| "flaw_hunter": { |
| "mean": 39.6, |
| "median": 39.5, |
| "fatal_per_session": 0.5, |
| "major_per_session": 6.5, |
| "top_flaws": [ |
| "MAJOR:recycled_description", |
| "MAJOR:purple_prose", |
| "MAJOR:narrating_emotions" |
| ], |
| "n_sessions": 18 |
| }, |
| "community": { |
| "rank": 8, |
| "elo": 1486.6, |
| "n_votes": 401 |
| }, |
| "bayesian": { |
| "rank": 7, |
| "model": "qwen3_5_flash", |
| "elo_mean": 1492.6, |
| "elo_std": 75.7, |
| "ci_low_95": 1361.0, |
| "ci_high_95": 1634.2, |
| "ci_width_95": 273.2 |
| }, |
| "multiturn_judge_mean": 3.98, |
| "strength": "No standout strength on tested dimensions", |
| "weakness": "Catastrophic floor on agency respect (lowest session: 2.5)" |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "deepseek_v3_2", |
| "failure_rates": { |
| "F1_agency": { |
| "rate_pct": 4.55, |
| "ci_half_pct": 6.94, |
| "n": 44, |
| "failures": 2 |
| }, |
| "F2_pov_tense": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.21, |
| "n": 33, |
| "failures": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "behavioral": { |
| "word_count": { |
| "value": 178.1792, |
| "population_avg": 264.5894, |
| "delta": -86.4102 |
| }, |
| "unique_word_ratio": { |
| "value": 0.7126, |
| "population_avg": 0.655, |
| "delta": 0.0576 |
| }, |
| "bigram_repetition": { |
| "value": 0.0288, |
| "population_avg": 0.049, |
| "delta": -0.0202 |
| } |
| }, |
| "subjective": { |
| "engagement": 4.61, |
| "tone_consistency": 4.63, |
| "collaboration": 4.32 |
| }, |
| "flaw_hunter": { |
| "mean": 46.9, |
| "median": 47, |
| "fatal_per_session": 0.4, |
| "major_per_session": 5.53, |
| "top_flaws": [ |
| "MAJOR:purple_prose", |
| "MAJOR:recycled_description", |
| "MAJOR:narrating_emotions" |
| ], |
| "n_sessions": 15 |
| }, |
| "community": { |
| "rank": 7, |
| "elo": 1489.0, |
| "n_votes": 241 |
| }, |
| "bayesian": { |
| "rank": 8, |
| "model": "deepseek_v3_2", |
| "elo_mean": 1492.1, |
| "elo_std": 76.6, |
| "ci_low_95": 1357.6, |
| "ci_high_95": 1625.4, |
| "ci_width_95": 267.8 |
| }, |
| "multiturn_judge_mean": 4.38, |
| "strength": "Top-2 on lore consistency (4.50/5)", |
| "weakness": "NSFW collapse (30.4% NSFW win rate)" |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "glm_4_7", |
| "failure_rates": { |
| "F1_agency": { |
| "rate_pct": 9.09, |
| "ci_half_pct": 8.78, |
| "n": 44, |
| "failures": 4 |
| }, |
| "F2_pov_tense": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.36, |
| "n": 32, |
| "failures": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "behavioral": { |
| "word_count": { |
| "value": 221.9331, |
| "population_avg": 264.5894, |
| "delta": -42.6563 |
| }, |
| "unique_word_ratio": { |
| "value": 0.6667, |
| "population_avg": 0.655, |
| "delta": 0.0117 |
| }, |
| "bigram_repetition": { |
| "value": 0.0382, |
| "population_avg": 0.049, |
| "delta": -0.0108 |
| } |
| }, |
| "subjective": { |
| "engagement": 4.41, |
| "tone_consistency": 4.62, |
| "collaboration": 4.42 |
| }, |
| "flaw_hunter": { |
| "mean": 36.8, |
| "median": 37, |
| "fatal_per_session": 0.71, |
| "major_per_session": 6.76, |
| "top_flaws": [ |
| "MAJOR:purple_prose", |
| "MAJOR:recycled_description", |
| "MAJOR:narrating_emotions" |
| ], |
| "n_sessions": 17 |
| }, |
| "community": { |
| "rank": 9, |
| "elo": 1483.4, |
| "n_votes": 285 |
| }, |
| "bayesian": { |
| "rank": 9, |
| "model": "glm_4_7", |
| "elo_mean": 1490.0, |
| "elo_std": 75.6, |
| "ci_low_95": 1352.6, |
| "ci_high_95": 1623.1, |
| "ci_width_95": 270.6 |
| }, |
| "multiturn_judge_mean": 4.37, |
| "strength": "Strong on tone consistency (4.62/5)", |
| "weakness": "Lower community half (#9)" |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "llama_4_maverick", |
| "failure_rates": { |
| "F1_agency": { |
| "rate_pct": 6.82, |
| "ci_half_pct": 7.94, |
| "n": 44, |
| "failures": 3 |
| }, |
| "F2_pov_tense": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.21, |
| "n": 33, |
| "failures": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "behavioral": { |
| "word_count": { |
| "value": 171.5292, |
| "population_avg": 264.5894, |
| "delta": -93.0602 |
| }, |
| "unique_word_ratio": { |
| "value": 0.6456, |
| "population_avg": 0.655, |
| "delta": -0.0094 |
| }, |
| "bigram_repetition": { |
| "value": 0.0637, |
| "population_avg": 0.049, |
| "delta": 0.0147 |
| } |
| }, |
| "subjective": { |
| "engagement": 4.15, |
| "tone_consistency": 4.3, |
| "collaboration": 4.2 |
| }, |
| "flaw_hunter": { |
| "mean": 30.6, |
| "median": 36.5, |
| "fatal_per_session": 0.95, |
| "major_per_session": 6.65, |
| "top_flaws": [ |
| "MAJOR:recycled_description", |
| "MAJOR:purple_prose", |
| "FATAL:agency_violation" |
| ], |
| "n_sessions": 20 |
| }, |
| "community": { |
| "rank": 10, |
| "elo": 1473.0, |
| "n_votes": 474 |
| }, |
| "bayesian": { |
| "rank": 10, |
| "model": "llama_4_maverick", |
| "elo_mean": 1483.3, |
| "elo_std": 75.8, |
| "ci_low_95": 1349.8, |
| "ci_high_95": 1616.5, |
| "ci_width_95": 266.7 |
| }, |
| "multiturn_judge_mean": 3.96, |
| "strength": "No standout strength on tested dimensions", |
| "weakness": "Catastrophic floor on agency respect (lowest session: 3.0)" |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "gpt_4_1", |
| "failure_rates": { |
| "F1_agency": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 4.01, |
| "n": 44, |
| "failures": 0 |
| }, |
| "F2_pov_tense": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.21, |
| "n": 33, |
| "failures": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "behavioral": { |
| "word_count": { |
| "value": 211.675, |
| "population_avg": 264.5894, |
| "delta": -52.9144 |
| }, |
| "unique_word_ratio": { |
| "value": 0.6878, |
| "population_avg": 0.655, |
| "delta": 0.0328 |
| }, |
| "bigram_repetition": { |
| "value": 0.0313, |
| "population_avg": 0.049, |
| "delta": -0.0177 |
| } |
| }, |
| "subjective": { |
| "engagement": 4.38, |
| "tone_consistency": 4.6, |
| "collaboration": 4.38 |
| }, |
| "flaw_hunter": { |
| "mean": 27.6, |
| "median": 42.0, |
| "fatal_per_session": 0.75, |
| "major_per_session": 6.83, |
| "top_flaws": [ |
| "MAJOR:purple_prose", |
| "MAJOR:recycled_description", |
| "FATAL:agency_violation" |
| ], |
| "n_sessions": 12 |
| }, |
| "community": { |
| "rank": 11, |
| "elo": 1469.7, |
| "n_votes": 215 |
| }, |
| "bayesian": { |
| "rank": 11, |
| "model": "gpt_4_1", |
| "elo_mean": 1471.9, |
| "elo_std": 76.8, |
| "ci_low_95": 1337.6, |
| "ci_high_95": 1610.1, |
| "ci_width_95": 272.5 |
| }, |
| "multiturn_judge_mean": 4.34, |
| "strength": "Top-1 on narrative momentum (4.30/5)", |
| "weakness": "Bottom community ELO (#11/11)" |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "claude_opus_4_7", |
| "failure_rates": { |
| "F1_agency": { |
| "rate_pct": 6.06, |
| "ci_half_pct": 8.96, |
| "n": 33, |
| "failures": 2 |
| }, |
| "F2_pov_tense": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.21, |
| "n": 33, |
| "failures": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "behavioral": { |
| "word_count": { |
| "value": 407.2431, |
| "population_avg": 264.5894, |
| "delta": 142.6537 |
| }, |
| "unique_word_ratio": { |
| "value": 0.5711, |
| "population_avg": 0.655, |
| "delta": -0.0839 |
| }, |
| "bigram_repetition": { |
| "value": 0.071, |
| "population_avg": 0.049, |
| "delta": 0.022 |
| } |
| }, |
| "subjective": { |
| "engagement": 4.61, |
| "tone_consistency": 4.75, |
| "collaboration": 4.53 |
| }, |
| "flaw_hunter": { |
| "mean": 42.8, |
| "median": 48.0, |
| "fatal_per_session": 0.75, |
| "major_per_session": 5.92, |
| "top_flaws": [ |
| "MAJOR:purple_prose", |
| "MAJOR:recycled_description", |
| "FATAL:agency_violation" |
| ], |
| "n_sessions": 12 |
| }, |
| "community": { |
| "rank": null, |
| "elo": null, |
| "n_votes": null |
| }, |
| "bayesian": null, |
| "multiturn_judge_mean": 4.54, |
| "strength": "Top-1 on agency respect (4.60/5)", |
| "weakness": "Frequent fatal flaws (0.75 per session, mean score 43/100)" |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "claude_opus_4_6", |
| "failure_rates": { |
| "F1_agency": { |
| "rate_pct": 4.55, |
| "ci_half_pct": 6.94, |
| "n": 44, |
| "failures": 2 |
| }, |
| "F2_pov_tense": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.21, |
| "n": 33, |
| "failures": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "behavioral": { |
| "word_count": { |
| "value": 533.525, |
| "population_avg": 264.5894, |
| "delta": 268.9356 |
| }, |
| "unique_word_ratio": { |
| "value": 0.551, |
| "population_avg": 0.655, |
| "delta": -0.104 |
| }, |
| "bigram_repetition": { |
| "value": 0.0757, |
| "population_avg": 0.049, |
| "delta": 0.0267 |
| } |
| }, |
| "subjective": { |
| "engagement": 4.67, |
| "tone_consistency": 4.75, |
| "collaboration": 4.46 |
| }, |
| "flaw_hunter": { |
| "mean": 40.9, |
| "median": 42, |
| "fatal_per_session": 0.29, |
| "major_per_session": 6.82, |
| "top_flaws": [ |
| "MAJOR:purple_prose", |
| "MAJOR:recycled_description", |
| "MAJOR:narrating_emotions" |
| ], |
| "n_sessions": 17 |
| }, |
| "community": { |
| "rank": null, |
| "elo": null, |
| "n_votes": null |
| }, |
| "bayesian": null, |
| "multiturn_judge_mean": 4.51, |
| "strength": "Top-2 on agency respect (4.55/5)", |
| "weakness": "High phrase repetition (0.076 vs population 0.049)" |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "deepseek_v4_pro", |
| "failure_rates": { |
| "F1_agency": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.21, |
| "n": 33, |
| "failures": 0 |
| }, |
| "F2_pov_tense": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.21, |
| "n": 33, |
| "failures": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "behavioral": { |
| "word_count": { |
| "value": 258.8333, |
| "population_avg": 264.5894, |
| "delta": -5.7561 |
| }, |
| "unique_word_ratio": { |
| "value": 0.6642, |
| "population_avg": 0.655, |
| "delta": 0.0092 |
| }, |
| "bigram_repetition": { |
| "value": 0.0402, |
| "population_avg": 0.049, |
| "delta": -0.0088 |
| } |
| }, |
| "subjective": { |
| "engagement": 4.53, |
| "tone_consistency": 4.7, |
| "collaboration": 4.38 |
| }, |
| "flaw_hunter": { |
| "mean": 19.4, |
| "median": 46.5, |
| "fatal_per_session": 0.5, |
| "major_per_session": 9.0, |
| "top_flaws": [ |
| "MAJOR:purple_prose", |
| "MAJOR:recycled_description", |
| "MAJOR:narrating_emotions" |
| ], |
| "n_sessions": 8 |
| }, |
| "community": { |
| "rank": null, |
| "elo": null, |
| "n_votes": null |
| }, |
| "bayesian": null, |
| "multiturn_judge_mean": 4.42, |
| "strength": "Strong on tone consistency (4.70/5)", |
| "weakness": "No standout weakness on tested dimensions" |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "kimi_k2_5", |
| "failure_rates": { |
| "F1_agency": { |
| "rate_pct": 6.06, |
| "ci_half_pct": 8.96, |
| "n": 33, |
| "failures": 2 |
| }, |
| "F2_pov_tense": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.21, |
| "n": 33, |
| "failures": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "behavioral": { |
| "word_count": { |
| "value": 252.9444, |
| "population_avg": 264.5894, |
| "delta": -11.645 |
| }, |
| "unique_word_ratio": { |
| "value": 0.681, |
| "population_avg": 0.655, |
| "delta": 0.026 |
| }, |
| "bigram_repetition": { |
| "value": 0.037, |
| "population_avg": 0.049, |
| "delta": -0.012 |
| } |
| }, |
| "subjective": { |
| "engagement": 4.56, |
| "tone_consistency": 4.67, |
| "collaboration": 4.39 |
| }, |
| "flaw_hunter": { |
| "mean": 42, |
| "median": 42, |
| "fatal_per_session": 0.44, |
| "major_per_session": 6.33, |
| "top_flaws": [ |
| "MAJOR:recycled_description", |
| "MAJOR:purple_prose", |
| "MAJOR:narrating_emotions" |
| ], |
| "n_sessions": 9 |
| }, |
| "community": { |
| "rank": null, |
| "elo": null, |
| "n_votes": null |
| }, |
| "bayesian": null, |
| "multiturn_judge_mean": 4.4, |
| "strength": "Strong on tone consistency (4.67/5)", |
| "weakness": "No standout weakness on tested dimensions" |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "glm_5_1", |
| "failure_rates": { |
| "F1_agency": { |
| "rate_pct": 3.03, |
| "ci_half_pct": 7.39, |
| "n": 33, |
| "failures": 1 |
| }, |
| "F2_pov_tense": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.21, |
| "n": 33, |
| "failures": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "behavioral": { |
| "word_count": { |
| "value": 240.0903, |
| "population_avg": 264.5894, |
| "delta": -24.4991 |
| }, |
| "unique_word_ratio": { |
| "value": 0.6534, |
| "population_avg": 0.655, |
| "delta": -0.0016 |
| }, |
| "bigram_repetition": { |
| "value": 0.0409, |
| "population_avg": 0.049, |
| "delta": -0.0081 |
| } |
| }, |
| "subjective": { |
| "engagement": 4.49, |
| "tone_consistency": 4.65, |
| "collaboration": 4.34 |
| }, |
| "flaw_hunter": { |
| "mean": 45.8, |
| "median": 46, |
| "fatal_per_session": 0.11, |
| "major_per_session": 6.44, |
| "top_flaws": [ |
| "MAJOR:purple_prose", |
| "MAJOR:recycled_description", |
| "MAJOR:convenient_world" |
| ], |
| "n_sessions": 9 |
| }, |
| "community": { |
| "rank": null, |
| "elo": null, |
| "n_votes": null |
| }, |
| "bayesian": null, |
| "multiturn_judge_mean": 4.39, |
| "strength": "Strong on tone consistency (4.65/5)", |
| "weakness": "No standout weakness on tested dimensions" |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "deepseek_v4_flash", |
| "failure_rates": { |
| "F1_agency": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.36, |
| "n": 32, |
| "failures": 0 |
| }, |
| "F2_pov_tense": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.36, |
| "n": 32, |
| "failures": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "behavioral": { |
| "word_count": { |
| "value": 172.9286, |
| "population_avg": 264.5894, |
| "delta": -91.6608 |
| }, |
| "unique_word_ratio": { |
| "value": 0.7088, |
| "population_avg": 0.655, |
| "delta": 0.0538 |
| }, |
| "bigram_repetition": { |
| "value": 0.0302, |
| "population_avg": 0.049, |
| "delta": -0.0188 |
| } |
| }, |
| "subjective": { |
| "engagement": 4.47, |
| "tone_consistency": 4.6, |
| "collaboration": 4.27 |
| }, |
| "flaw_hunter": { |
| "mean": 50.6, |
| "median": 58, |
| "fatal_per_session": 0.36, |
| "major_per_session": 5.27, |
| "top_flaws": [ |
| "MAJOR:purple_prose", |
| "MAJOR:recycled_description", |
| "MAJOR:convenient_world" |
| ], |
| "n_sessions": 11 |
| }, |
| "community": { |
| "rank": null, |
| "elo": null, |
| "n_votes": null |
| }, |
| "bayesian": null, |
| "multiturn_judge_mean": 4.38, |
| "strength": "Strong on tone consistency (4.60/5)", |
| "weakness": "No standout weakness on tested dimensions" |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "gemini_3_1_pro", |
| "failure_rates": { |
| "F1_agency": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.51, |
| "n": 31, |
| "failures": 0 |
| }, |
| "F2_pov_tense": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.36, |
| "n": 32, |
| "failures": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "behavioral": { |
| "word_count": { |
| "value": 263.1241, |
| "population_avg": 264.5894, |
| "delta": -1.4653 |
| }, |
| "unique_word_ratio": { |
| "value": 0.6675, |
| "population_avg": 0.655, |
| "delta": 0.0125 |
| }, |
| "bigram_repetition": { |
| "value": 0.0401, |
| "population_avg": 0.049, |
| "delta": -0.0089 |
| } |
| }, |
| "subjective": { |
| "engagement": 4.5, |
| "tone_consistency": 4.62, |
| "collaboration": 4.42 |
| }, |
| "flaw_hunter": { |
| "mean": 29.2, |
| "median": 35.5, |
| "fatal_per_session": 1.0, |
| "major_per_session": 6.75, |
| "top_flaws": [ |
| "MAJOR:recycled_description", |
| "MAJOR:purple_prose", |
| "FATAL:agency_violation" |
| ], |
| "n_sessions": 12 |
| }, |
| "community": { |
| "rank": null, |
| "elo": null, |
| "n_votes": null |
| }, |
| "bayesian": null, |
| "multiturn_judge_mean": 4.33, |
| "strength": "Strong on tone consistency (4.62/5)", |
| "weakness": "Frequent fatal flaws (1.00 per session, mean score 29/100)" |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "gemini_3_1_flash_lite", |
| "failure_rates": { |
| "F1_agency": { |
| "rate_pct": 3.03, |
| "ci_half_pct": 7.39, |
| "n": 33, |
| "failures": 1 |
| }, |
| "F2_pov_tense": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.21, |
| "n": 33, |
| "failures": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "behavioral": { |
| "word_count": { |
| "value": 263.9236, |
| "population_avg": 264.5894, |
| "delta": -0.6658 |
| }, |
| "unique_word_ratio": { |
| "value": 0.6435, |
| "population_avg": 0.655, |
| "delta": -0.0115 |
| }, |
| "bigram_repetition": { |
| "value": 0.0485, |
| "population_avg": 0.049, |
| "delta": -0.0005 |
| } |
| }, |
| "subjective": { |
| "engagement": 4.43, |
| "tone_consistency": 4.6, |
| "collaboration": 4.31 |
| }, |
| "flaw_hunter": { |
| "mean": 34.2, |
| "median": 34.0, |
| "fatal_per_session": 0.17, |
| "major_per_session": 8.0, |
| "top_flaws": [ |
| "MAJOR:purple_prose", |
| "MAJOR:recycled_description", |
| "MAJOR:narrating_emotions" |
| ], |
| "n_sessions": 6 |
| }, |
| "community": { |
| "rank": null, |
| "elo": null, |
| "n_votes": null |
| }, |
| "bayesian": null, |
| "multiturn_judge_mean": 4.3, |
| "strength": "Strong on tone consistency (4.60/5)", |
| "weakness": "No standout weakness on tested dimensions" |
| }, |
| { |
| "model": "kimi_k2_6", |
| "failure_rates": { |
| "F1_agency": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.51, |
| "n": 31, |
| "failures": 0 |
| }, |
| "F2_pov_tense": { |
| "rate_pct": 0.0, |
| "ci_half_pct": 5.68, |
| "n": 30, |
| "failures": 0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "behavioral": { |
| "word_count": { |
| "value": 221.1797, |
| "population_avg": 264.5894, |
| "delta": -43.4097 |
| }, |
| "unique_word_ratio": { |
| "value": 0.677, |
| "population_avg": 0.655, |
| "delta": 0.022 |
| }, |
| "bigram_repetition": { |
| "value": 0.0376, |
| "population_avg": 0.049, |
| "delta": -0.0114 |
| } |
| }, |
| "subjective": { |
| "engagement": 4.44, |
| "tone_consistency": 4.39, |
| "collaboration": 4.12 |
| }, |
| "flaw_hunter": { |
| "mean": 49.5, |
| "median": 52.0, |
| "fatal_per_session": 0.12, |
| "major_per_session": 5.25, |
| "top_flaws": [ |
| "MAJOR:recycled_description", |
| "MAJOR:purple_prose", |
| "MAJOR:convenient_world" |
| ], |
| "n_sessions": 8 |
| }, |
| "community": { |
| "rank": null, |
| "elo": null, |
| "n_votes": null |
| }, |
| "bayesian": null, |
| "multiturn_judge_mean": 4.18, |
| "strength": "Top-2 on flaw hunter (49.5/100)", |
| "weakness": "Catastrophic floor on agency respect (lowest session: 2.5)" |
| } |
| ] |
| } |
