SaarAI commited on
Commit
54db48a
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 7da17ac

Add comprehensive README with benchmark findings

Browse files
Files changed (1) hide show
  1. README.md +147 -0
README.md ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,147 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ # EthioTelecomBench: Amharic ASR Benchmark for Telecom Domain
2
+
3
+ ## Overview
4
+
5
+ EthioTelecomBench is a comprehensive benchmark for evaluating Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) systems on Amharic speech, with a focus on telecom customer service conversations. This dataset contains evaluation results from **12 models** across **7 evaluation splits**.
6
+
7
+ ## Text Normalization
8
+
9
+ All WER and CER metrics are computed **after applying full text normalization** to both reference and predicted transcriptions:
10
+
11
+ 1. **Number-to-Text Conversion**: Arabic numerals are converted to Amharic text (e.g., "123" → "አንድ መቶ ሃያ ሶስት")
12
+ 2. **Punctuation Removal**: All punctuation marks (including Ge'ez punctuation ፠፡።፣፤፥፦፧፨) are removed
13
+ 3. **Character Normalization**: Ge'ez character variants are normalized to canonical forms:
14
+ - ሀ/ሐ/ኅ/ኻ/ኃ → ሃ
15
+ - ሠ/ሡ/ሢ/ሣ/ሤ/ሥ/ሦ → ሰ/ሱ/ሲ/ሳ/ሴ/ስ/ሶ
16
+ - ዐ/ዑ/ዒ/ዓ/ዔ/ዕ/ዖ → አ/ኡ/ኢ/አ/ኤ/እ/ኦ
17
+ - ፀ/ፁ/ፂ/ፃ/ፄ/ፅ/ፆ → ጸ/ጹ/ጺ/ጻ/ጼ/ጽ/ጾ
18
+ - And other labialized character normalizations
19
+ 4. **Whitespace Normalization**: Multiple spaces collapsed to single space
20
+
21
+ ## Dataset Description
22
+
23
+ This benchmark evaluates ASR models on various challenging conditions:
24
+
25
+ | Split | Description |
26
+ |-------|-------------|
27
+ | `augmented` | Standard test set with data augmentation |
28
+ | `low_audio` | Low-quality audio samples |
29
+ | `over_augmented` | Heavily augmented audio |
30
+ | `over_augmented_telecom` | Heavily augmented telecom-specific audio |
31
+ | `telecom` | Real telecom customer service recordings |
32
+ | `telecom_random` | Random subset of telecom recordings |
33
+ | `train` | Training set evaluation (for reference) |
34
+
35
+ ## Evaluated Models
36
+
37
+ The benchmark includes the following model families:
38
+
39
+ ### Ethio-ASR Models (badrex)
40
+ - `badrex/Ethio-ASR-amharic` - Amharic-specific model
41
+ - `badrex/Ethio-ASR-multilingual-94M` - 94M parameter multilingual
42
+ - `badrex/Ethio-ASR-multilingual-300M` - 300M parameter multilingual
43
+ - `badrex/Ethio-ASR-multilingual-600M` - 600M parameter multilingual
44
+
45
+ ### OmniASR Models
46
+ - `omniASR_CTC_300M_v2` - CTC-based 300M
47
+ - `omniASR_CTC_1B_v2` - CTC-based 1B
48
+ - `omniASR_CTC_3B_v2` - CTC-based 3B
49
+ - `omniASR_LLM_300M_v2` - LLM-based 300M
50
+ - `omniASR_LLM_1B_v2` - LLM-based 1B
51
+ - `omniASR_LLM_3B_v2` - LLM-based 3B
52
+
53
+ ### Baseline Models
54
+ - `facebook/mms-1b-all` - Meta's Massively Multilingual Speech
55
+ - `openai/whisper-small` - OpenAI Whisper Small
56
+
57
+ ## Dataset Splits
58
+
59
+ This dataset contains three tables as different splits:
60
+
61
+ ### 1. `WER` Split
62
+ Word Error Rate (WER) scores for all models across all evaluation splits. Lower is better.
63
+
64
+ ### 2. `CER` Split
65
+ Character Error Rate (CER) scores for all models across all evaluation splits. Lower is better.
66
+
67
+ ### 3. `Gender_GAP` Split
68
+ Gender fairness analysis showing:
69
+ - Male WER/CER scores
70
+ - Female WER/CER scores
71
+ - Gender gap (Female - Male): Positive values indicate higher error rates for female speakers
72
+
73
+ ## Key Findings
74
+
75
+ ### Best Performing Models by Split
76
+
77
+ | Split | Best Model | WER (%) |
78
+ |-------|------------|---------|
79
+ | augmented | badrex/Ethio-ASR-amharic | 38.72 |
80
+ | low_audio | omniASR_LLM_3B_v2 | 27.26 |
81
+ | over_augmented | badrex/Ethio-ASR-amharic | 42.08 |
82
+ | over_augmented_telecom | badrex/Ethio-ASR-amharic | 74.74 |
83
+ | telecom | badrex/Ethio-ASR-amharic | 45.13 |
84
+ | telecom_random | badrex/Ethio-ASR-amharic | 46.66 |
85
+ | train | omniASR_LLM_3B_v2 | 27.29 |
86
+
87
+ ### Gender Fairness Analysis
88
+
89
+ Average WER gender gap (Female - Male) across models:
90
+
91
+ | Split | Avg Gap (%) | Interpretation |
92
+ |-------|-------------|----------------|
93
+ | augmented | +3.80 | Female disadvantaged |
94
+ | low_audio | +4.06 | Female disadvantaged |
95
+ | over_augmented | +3.77 | Female disadvantaged |
96
+ | over_augmented_telecom | +13.64 | Female disadvantaged |
97
+ | telecom | +6.89 | Female disadvantaged |
98
+ | telecom_random | +6.62 | Female disadvantaged |
99
+ | train | +4.69 | Female disadvantaged |
100
+
101
+ ### Key Observations
102
+
103
+ 1. **Domain Adaptation Matters**: Models fine-tuned on Amharic (Ethio-ASR family) significantly outperform general multilingual models on telecom domain data.
104
+
105
+ 2. **Gender Bias**: Most models show higher error rates for female speakers, indicating a systematic gender bias in ASR performance.
106
+
107
+ 3. **Audio Quality Impact**: Performance degrades significantly on low-quality and over-augmented audio, highlighting the need for robust ASR systems.
108
+
109
+ 4. **Model Size vs Performance**: Larger models (3B parameters) generally perform better, but domain-specific smaller models can be competitive.
110
+
111
+ ## Usage
112
+
113
+ ```python
114
+ from datasets import load_dataset
115
+
116
+ # Load WER scores
117
+ wer_data = load_dataset("SAARAI/EthioTelecomBench", split="WER")
118
+
119
+ # Load CER scores
120
+ cer_data = load_dataset("SAARAI/EthioTelecomBench", split="CER")
121
+
122
+ # Load Gender Gap analysis
123
+ gender_data = load_dataset("SAARAI/EthioTelecomBench", split="Gender_GAP")
124
+ ```
125
+
126
+ ## Citation
127
+
128
+ If you use this benchmark, please cite:
129
+
130
+ ```bibtex
131
+ @misc{ethiotelebench2024,
132
+ title={EthioTelecomBench: A Benchmark for Amharic ASR in Telecom Domain},
133
+ author={SAARAI},
134
+ year={2024},
135
+ publisher={Hugging Face},
136
+ url={https://huggingface.co/datasets/SAARAI/EthioTelecomBench}
137
+ }
138
+ ```
139
+
140
+ ## License
141
+
142
+ This benchmark is released under the Apache 2.0 License.
143
+
144
+ ## Links
145
+
146
+ - [Interactive Error Visualization](https://ethio-asr-error-viz.vercel.app/)
147
+ - [Source Repository](https://github.com/IsraelAbebe/Ethio-ASR)