File size: 9,018 Bytes
c63f7f4
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
{"text": "He argues that the new tax code is regressive, but he's a socialist, so of course he'd say that.", "fallacy_type": "ad_hominem", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Discounts the economic analysis based on perceived political label rather than examining the data.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "circumstantial", "id": 8}
{"text": "Critics of mandatory overtime say workers shouldn't have to work long hours. Basically they want people to be lazy.", "fallacy_type": "straw_man", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Opposes labor protections by characterizing them as endorsing laziness, not engaging with the actual policy.", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "misrepresentation", "id": 19}
{"text": "You either accept the proposed merger or we go bankrupt. There's no other option.", "fallacy_type": "false_dilemma", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Ignores alternative restructuring strategies, divestiture, capital raises, or renegotiation that sit between those extremes.", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "excluded_middle", "id": 29}
{"text": "The Supreme Court ruled this law constitutional, so the law must be morally just.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_authority", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Constitutional legality and moral justice are distinct; courts rule on law, not ethics.", "domain": "law", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "authority_scope", "id": 43}
{"text": "If teachers can assign homework on weekends, next they'll require students to study 24/7.", "fallacy_type": "slippery_slope", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Exaggerates a modest policy to an absurd extreme without showing the intermediate steps are likely or inevitable.", "domain": "education", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "exaggerated_endpoint", "id": 46}
{"text": "We know the free market works because free markets always produce the best outcomes.", "fallacy_type": "circular_reasoning", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Restates the claim ('works') as evidence ('produces best outcomes') without independent support.", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "self_reference", "id": 55}
{"text": "Every tech company I've interviewed at has a ping-pong table. Silicon Valley must be obsessed with ping-pong.", "fallacy_type": "hasty_generalization", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Selection bias \u2014 job seekers only encounter a slice of companies, and ping-pong tables are a well-known startup clich\u00e9, not representative of all tech.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "biased_sample", "id": 67}
{"text": "Every time I go to the beach, it rains the next day. I must be bringing bad weather.", "fallacy_type": "post_hoc", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Personal beach trips and weather patterns are independent; the correlation is purely coincidental.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "coincidence", "id": 75}
{"text": "Most people in this country support the death penalty, so it's morally acceptable.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_popularity", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Majority opinion does not determine moral truth; widespread views have historically been wrong on moral questions.", "domain": "ethics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "consensus_as_moral", "id": 84}
{"text": "You're asking about my company's carbon emissions, but have you seen the charity work we do for local schools?", "fallacy_type": "red_herring", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Charity work is a separate matter that doesn't address the environmental question being raised.", "domain": "ethics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "distraction", "id": 89}
{"text": "Being late once to work is basically the same as chronic absenteeism \u2014 rules are rules.", "fallacy_type": "false_equivalence", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Frequency, pattern, and context create meaningful distinctions in workplace policy.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "magnitude_difference", "id": 101}
{"text": "This herbal supplement is completely natural, so it must be safe and beneficial.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_nature", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Natural origin doesn't imply safety or efficacy; arsenic and cyanide are natural. Drug interactions and dosage matter.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "natural_is_good", "id": 105}
{"text": "Do you want to leave your family destitute? Then you need to buy this life insurance now.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_emotion", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Fear of leaving family destitute is used as the sole argument for purchase, bypassing comparative cost/coverage analysis.", "domain": "marketing", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "fear", "id": 116}
{"text": "We've already spent $50 million on this project. We can't stop now \u2014 we have to see it through.", "fallacy_type": "sunk_cost", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Past expenditure is irretrievable regardless; the decision to continue should be based on expected future value, not past cost.", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "past_investment", "id": 120}
{"text": "My dad smoked two packs a day and was never diagnosed with cancer. Smoking isn't that bad.", "fallacy_type": "anecdotal_evidence", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Extreme survivorship bias; thousands of population studies show high cancer risk that one anecdote can't refute.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "survivorship", "id": 133}
{"text": "Nothing is better than eternal happiness. A ham sandwich is better than nothing. Therefore a ham sandwich is better than eternal happiness.", "fallacy_type": "equivocation", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "'Nothing' means 'no thing' in the first premise, but 'something empty/absent' in the second \u2014 classic equivocation joke.", "domain": "philosophy", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "lexical_shift", "id": 137}
{"text": "No professional would make that mistake. \u2014 My professional colleague just made it. \u2014 Well, she's not really a professional.", "fallacy_type": "no_true_scotsman", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Redefines the category after the counterexample appears to preserve the original claim.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "moving_goalpost", "id": 145}
{"text": "You're telling me not to speed? You were caught speeding last year!", "fallacy_type": "tu_quoque", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Points out the accuser's past hypocrisy rather than engaging with whether the advice about speeding is correct.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "hypocrisy_charge", "id": 148}
{"text": "No study has proven that social media is NOT addictive. That proves it is.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_ignorance", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Misplaces burden of proof; positive claims of addiction require positive evidence, not absence of contrary studies.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "negative_proof", "id": 157}
{"text": "People are naturally selfish \u2014 so there's no point in building social safety nets.", "fallacy_type": "naturalistic_fallacy", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Even if selfishness were universal, that would be an 'is' \u2014 it doesn't entail that we 'should not' build cooperative institutions.", "domain": "ethics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "is_ought", "id": 162}
{"text": "Our A/B test ran for 4 weeks with 50,000 users split evenly. The new checkout flow reduced cart abandonment by 8.3% (p = 0.002). We should roll it out.", "fallacy_type": "none", "label": "sound", "explanation": "Adequate sample, appropriate duration, statistically significant result, reasonable business conclusion.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "", "id": 173}
{"text": "Two independent meta-analyses found that mindfulness-based stress reduction significantly reduced anxiety scores in clinical populations (SMD \u2248 -0.5). The effect is meaningful though modest.", "fallacy_type": "none", "label": "sound", "explanation": "Two corroborating meta-analyses, effect size reported honestly with appropriate qualification of magnitude.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "", "id": 179}
{"text": "Our survey sampled 3,200 respondents using stratified random sampling weighted to match census demographics. The margin of error is \u00b12.5% at 95% confidence. Fifty-eight percent support the policy.", "fallacy_type": "none", "label": "sound", "explanation": "Appropriate sample size, proper sampling methodology, correctly reported confidence interval and margin of error.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "", "id": 170}