Datasets:
Tasks:
Text Classification
Modalities:
Text
Formats:
parquet
Sub-tasks:
multi-class-classification
Languages:
English
Size:
< 1K
License:
File size: 8,894 Bytes
83a08f5 | 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 | {"text": "The whistleblower filed a complaint, but he was laid off last year \u2014 he's just bitter.", "fallacy_type": "ad_hominem", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Explains away the complaint's content by imputing motive, without addressing whether the allegations are true.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "circumstantial", "id": 6}
{"text": "She questioned whether the death penalty deters crime. So she doesn't care about victims at all.", "fallacy_type": "straw_man", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Reframes an empirical question about deterrence as indifference toward victims, conflating two separate issues.", "domain": "law", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "misrepresentation", "id": 20}
{"text": "If you don't support this military action, you support letting our allies be slaughtered.", "fallacy_type": "false_dilemma", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Frames a complex geopolitical question as a binary: endorse war or endorse slaughter, omitting diplomacy and other options.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "binary_framing", "id": 25}
{"text": "Einstein believed in God, therefore religion must be compatible with science.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_authority", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Einstein's personal beliefs don't constitute evidence for a philosophical or theological claim about religion-science compatibility.", "domain": "philosophy", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "irrelevant_authority", "id": 37}
{"text": "If we lower standards for one university admission test, we'll eventually have no standards at all in higher education.", "fallacy_type": "slippery_slope", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Assumes a single adjustment in one metric leads inexorably to the complete abolition of all academic standards.", "domain": "education", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "exaggerated_endpoint", "id": 51}
{"text": "The Bible is true because it says so in the Bible.", "fallacy_type": "circular_reasoning", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Uses the conclusion (Bible is true) as the only evidence for itself \u2014 classic circular argument.", "domain": "philosophy", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "self_reference", "id": 54}
{"text": "The survey of 50 college students showed 80% support this policy. The country supports it.", "fallacy_type": "hasty_generalization", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "College students are not representative of the general population; 50 is too small a sample.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "biased_sample", "id": 69}
{"text": "I started drinking green tea and a week later my cold was gone. Green tea cured my cold.", "fallacy_type": "post_hoc", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Colds resolve on their own in 7-10 days; temporal succession doesn't establish green tea as the cause.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "temporal_succession", "id": 72}
{"text": "Students ranked Professor Kim the most popular professor \u2014 she must be the best teacher.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_popularity", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Popularity in teaching evaluations correlates with likability, not necessarily with learning outcomes or rigor.", "domain": "education", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "social_proof", "id": 88}
{"text": "Why are we debating climate policy when the economy is struggling? Jobs first!", "fallacy_type": "red_herring", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Introduces economic concern to deflect from the climate discussion, when both can be and are discussed simultaneously.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "distraction", "id": 94}
{"text": "Nuclear power and burning wood are both energy sources \u2014 why make a distinction?", "fallacy_type": "false_equivalence", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Scale, safety profile, carbon output, and infrastructure are radically different between nuclear and wood combustion.", "domain": "science", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "category_error", "id": 102}
{"text": "Homeopathic remedies are safer than drugs because they're derived from natural substances.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_nature", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Natural origin doesn't confer safety, and the claimed safety of homeopathy ignores the question of efficacy.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "natural_is_safe", "id": 108}
{"text": "Imagine how proud your parents would be if you just signed up for this course today.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_emotion", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Uses desire for family approval as a sales hook rather than presenting course quality or value.", "domain": "marketing", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "pride", "id": 119}
{"text": "I've been in this relationship for five years. I can't leave now \u2014 that's five years wasted.", "fallacy_type": "sunk_cost", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Time already spent in a relationship is sunk; whether to stay should depend on present and future prospects, not the past.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "past_investment", "id": 121}
{"text": "A friend of mine switched to a gluten-free diet and her energy levels improved. Gluten is harmful for everyone.", "fallacy_type": "anecdotal_evidence", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Placebo effect, dietary diversity, and individual variation explain single cases; population data shows most benefit only for celiacs.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "overgeneralization", "id": 132}
{"text": "Stars are known to influence events on Earth \u2014 astrology must be true.", "fallacy_type": "equivocation", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "'Stars influence events' shifts from astronomical influence (gravity, solar radiation) to astrological influence \u2014 an entirely different and unproven claim.", "domain": "science", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "lexical_shift", "id": 138}
{"text": "Real free markets never fail. \u2014 But historical examples show market failures. \u2014 Those weren't real free markets.", "fallacy_type": "no_true_scotsman", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Any failure is attributed to the market not being 'truly' free, making the claim circular and unfalsifiable.", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "moving_goalpost", "id": 143}
{"text": "You say our country violates human rights, but what about the abuses in your country?", "fallacy_type": "tu_quoque", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Whataboutism deflects the human rights criticism by pointing to an opponent's faults without addressing the original charge.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "whataboutism", "id": 147}
{"text": "Scientists haven't proven that this food additive is 100% safe \u2014 therefore it must be dangerous.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_ignorance", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Uncertainty about perfect safety doesn't establish danger; the claim requires positive evidence of harm.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "negative_proof", "id": 154}
{"text": "Dominance hierarchies exist in every culture. So inequality is morally acceptable.", "fallacy_type": "naturalistic_fallacy", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Universality of a phenomenon doesn't confer its moral justification.", "domain": "ethics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "is_ought", "id": 163}
{"text": "The contract clearly states the deadline was March 15. It is now March 20 and the work has not been delivered. The client is in breach.", "fallacy_type": "none", "label": "sound", "explanation": "Factual claim (missed deadline) paired with a legal conclusion (breach) that directly follows from the contract terms.", "domain": "law", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "", "id": 182}
{"text": "This medication has a known interaction with MAO inhibitors based on randomized trials and case reports. Patients taking both should be monitored.", "fallacy_type": "none", "label": "sound", "explanation": "Cites well-documented pharmacological evidence and gives a proportionate safety recommendation.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "", "id": 175}
{"text": "Students who attended the tutoring sessions scored on average 12 points higher, controlling for prior GPA and attendance. The tutoring program shows a positive association with performance.", "fallacy_type": "none", "label": "sound", "explanation": "Appropriate use of regression controls; conclusion is hedged as 'association' rather than claiming full causation.", "domain": "education", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "", "id": 177}
|