SalutefaceAAC's picture
Upload data/train.jsonl with huggingface_hub
7a2189e verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
52.9 kB
{"text": "Of course the defense attorney says my client is innocent \u2014 he's paid to say that.", "fallacy_type": "ad_hominem", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Dismisses the argument by attacking the speaker's financial motive, not the legal arguments or evidence presented.", "domain": "law", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "circumstantial", "id": 3}
{"text": "The study was conducted by researchers at a for-profit institution \u2014 their conclusions can't be trusted.", "fallacy_type": "ad_hominem", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "While funding sources can affect credibility, dismissing findings solely on institutional affiliation without examining methodology is ad hominem.", "domain": "science", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "circumstantial", "id": 9}
{"text": "You argue for animal rights, but you wear leather shoes. Your position is hypocritical and invalid.", "fallacy_type": "ad_hominem", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Points out behavioral inconsistency to invalidate the argument rather than engaging with the ethical reasoning.", "domain": "ethics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "tu_quoque", "id": 10}
{"text": "My philosophy professor argues for moral realism, but she's been married three times. Hardly a model of sound judgment.", "fallacy_type": "ad_hominem", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Uses unrelated personal details to undermine a philosophical position.", "domain": "philosophy", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "abusive", "id": 7}
{"text": "She says the company's accounting is fraudulent, but she's the one who was fired for embezzlement.", "fallacy_type": "ad_hominem", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Uses the accuser's past wrongdoing to dismiss accusations without examining the evidence.", "domain": "law", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "tu_quoque", "id": 12}
{"text": "That economist is divorced twice \u2014 why would anyone take his advice on long-term planning?", "fallacy_type": "ad_hominem", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Irrelevant personal life detail used to discredit expertise in economics.", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "personal_attack", "id": 4}
{"text": "I wouldn't take nutritional advice from someone who's clearly overweight.", "fallacy_type": "ad_hominem", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Dismisses dietary expertise based on physical appearance rather than evaluating the actual advice.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "abusive", "id": 5}
{"text": "You can't trust Dr. Chen's climate report \u2014 she drove here in a gas-powered car.", "fallacy_type": "ad_hominem", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Attacks the arguer's personal behavior rather than addressing the scientific content of the climate report.", "domain": "science", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "tu_quoque", "id": 1}
{"text": "Senator Williams says we need stricter gun laws, but she's never even held a gun. Her opinion is worthless.", "fallacy_type": "ad_hominem", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Dismisses the senator's policy argument based on her personal experience rather than engaging with the merits of gun legislation.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "circumstantial", "id": 2}
{"text": "The anti-war protester says military intervention is wrong, but he's never served \u2014 what does he know?", "fallacy_type": "ad_hominem", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Requires lived experience as a prerequisite for having a valid opinion, sidestepping the policy argument.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "circumstantial", "id": 11}
{"text": "Proponents of veganism say we should care about animal suffering. I guess they think animals' lives are worth more than human lives.", "fallacy_type": "straw_man", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Misrepresents concern for animal welfare as devaluing human life, a position vegans do not hold.", "domain": "ethics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "misrepresentation", "id": 15}
{"text": "He argued for renewable subsidies. I guess he wants us to live in caves when the sun doesn't shine.", "fallacy_type": "straw_man", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Caricatures energy policy advocacy as primitive living, ignoring grid storage and backup systems in the original proposal.", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "exaggeration", "id": 22}
{"text": "You said you want to cut the military budget. I never thought you'd want to gut our national security.", "fallacy_type": "straw_man", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Shifts 'cut' to 'gut' \u2014 a significantly stronger claim \u2014 misrepresenting the original position.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "exaggeration", "id": 18}
{"text": "Advocates for immigration reform want open borders \u2014 they'd let in anyone, including terrorists.", "fallacy_type": "straw_man", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Conflates 'reform' with 'open borders', then adds an extreme consequence neither implied nor argued.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "exaggeration", "id": 17}
{"text": "The professor said some social media can harm adolescent mental health, so she wants to ban the internet for young people entirely.", "fallacy_type": "straw_man", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Escalates a nuanced concern about specific platforms into a total internet ban \u2014 an extreme the professor never proposed.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "exaggeration", "id": 21}
{"text": "He suggested that schools teach critical thinking about historical events. Clearly he wants to teach children to hate their country.", "fallacy_type": "straw_man", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Transforms a pedagogical proposal into a patriotic attack that was never implied.", "domain": "education", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "misrepresentation", "id": 16}
{"text": "She said we should have fewer regulations. So she just wants corporations to poison our water and air freely.", "fallacy_type": "straw_man", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Exaggerates a deregulation position into an extreme caricature that the opponent never advocated.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "exaggeration", "id": 14}
{"text": "The mayor called for police budget review. So she's anti-police and wants crime to run rampant.", "fallacy_type": "straw_man", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "A budget review is recast as an anti-police stance and its imagined worst-case consequence.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "misrepresentation", "id": 23}
{"text": "My opponent wants to reduce defense spending. Apparently he wants to leave our country defenseless against enemies.", "fallacy_type": "straw_man", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Reduces to 'defenseless' a position that actually proposes reallocating a portion of the budget, not eliminating defense.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "exaggeration", "id": 13}
{"text": "You're not pro-vaccine, so you must be anti-science.", "fallacy_type": "false_dilemma", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Conflates scepticism about a specific vaccination policy with rejection of science as a whole, missing the middle ground.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "binary_framing", "id": 33}
{"text": "You're either with us or you're with the terrorists.", "fallacy_type": "false_dilemma", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Presents only two mutually exclusive positions, ignoring the possibility of neutrality, nuance, or third options.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "binary_framing", "id": 24}
{"text": "Either we pass this budget exactly as written, or the government shuts down and people die.", "fallacy_type": "false_dilemma", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Excludes the many intermediate possibilities (amendments, temporary resolution, negotiation) between full passage and total shutdown.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "excluded_middle", "id": 26}
{"text": "If you're not vegetarian, you don't care about your health.", "fallacy_type": "false_dilemma", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Implies health consciousness requires vegetarianism, ignoring omnivorous diets that are also associated with good health.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "excluded_middle", "id": 28}
{"text": "Love it or leave it \u2014 if you criticize this country, why don't you just move somewhere else?", "fallacy_type": "false_dilemma", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Presents only two options (uncritical acceptance or emigration), ignoring that criticism is a form of civic engagement.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "binary_framing", "id": 31}
{"text": "You can have freedom or you can have security, but you can't have both.", "fallacy_type": "false_dilemma", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Treats liberty and security as mutually exclusive, ignoring frameworks that balance both simultaneously.", "domain": "philosophy", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "binary_framing", "id": 27}
{"text": "In business, you're either growing or you're dying \u2014 there's no standing still.", "fallacy_type": "false_dilemma", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Popularized business clich\u00e9 that excludes stable, profitable steady-state operations as a valid strategic position.", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "binary_framing", "id": 30}
{"text": "Either we crack down hard on crime with maximum sentencing, or we let criminals walk free.", "fallacy_type": "false_dilemma", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Ignores the wide spectrum of proportional sentencing between zero punishment and maximum sentencing.", "domain": "law", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "excluded_middle", "id": 32}
{"text": "My lawyer told me this investment is perfectly safe, so I put my life savings into it.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_authority", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "A lawyer's opinion on legal matters is authoritative, but financial investment safety is outside their expertise.", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "irrelevant_authority", "id": 40}
{"text": "Elon Musk says the metaverse is going nowhere, so I'm not investing in VR.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_authority", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "While Musk is a tech entrepreneur, his predictions in competitor spaces carry bias and are not scientific forecasts.", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "irrelevant_authority", "id": 42}
{"text": "Four out of five dentists recommend this toothpaste brand, so it must be the best one.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_authority", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Treats a marketing statistic as conclusive proof of superiority without comparative clinical data or methodology.", "domain": "marketing", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "unqualified_authority", "id": 34}
{"text": "The founder of this diet movement lost 60 pounds on it \u2014 the science must be solid.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_authority", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Personal weight loss success is anecdotal and doesn't validate the underlying nutritional science.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "unqualified_authority", "id": 41}
{"text": "The CEO of TechCorp said quantum computing will make all current encryption obsolete by 2027, so it must be true.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_authority", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "The CEO is an authority in business, not cryptography or quantum physics \u2014 appeals to outside their domain of expertise.", "domain": "science", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "irrelevant_authority", "id": 35}
{"text": "My grandfather smoked his whole life and lived to 95. Doctors must be wrong about smoking risks.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_authority", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Actually this is anecdotal evidence, not an authority appeal \u2014 grandfather is not a medical authority.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "anecdotal", "id": 36}
{"text": "This nutritional supplement is endorsed by an Olympic athlete \u2014 it must improve performance.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_authority", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Athletes are paid endorsers, not nutritional scientists, and endorsement doesn't substitute for clinical evidence.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "unqualified_authority", "id": 38}
{"text": "The school board voted unanimously to adopt the new curriculum, so it must be educationally sound.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_authority", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Unanimous administrative consensus is a social agreement, not pedagogical evidence of soundness.", "domain": "education", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "authority_of_numbers", "id": 39}
{"text": "If we legalize marijuana, soon all drugs will be legal and society will collapse.", "fallacy_type": "slippery_slope", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Chains marijuana legalization to total drug legalization and societal collapse without evidence for each step.", "domain": "law", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "causal_chain", "id": 45}
{"text": "Permitting assisted dying for terminal patients will lead to doctors killing anyone who seems too expensive to treat.", "fallacy_type": "slippery_slope", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Misrepresents narrowly-defined euthanasia policy by projecting an extreme abuse scenario with no causal argument.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "causal_chain", "id": 52}
{"text": "If the government can mandate seatbelts, they can eventually mandate what we eat and how we exercise.", "fallacy_type": "slippery_slope", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Draws an unjustified causal chain from safety regulation to complete personal liberty erosion.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "causal_chain", "id": 47}
{"text": "If we allow same-sex marriage, next people will want to marry their pets.", "fallacy_type": "slippery_slope", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Assumes permitting one social change will inevitably lead to an unrelated and extreme outcome without causal justification.", "domain": "ethics", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "causal_chain", "id": 44}
{"text": "Allowing remote work will lead to employees working from anywhere, then complete loss of company culture, then business failure.", "fallacy_type": "slippery_slope", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Chains remote work to culture collapse and business failure with no causal evidence for each step.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "causal_chain", "id": 50}
{"text": "Once you start bending the rules a little, you'll end up breaking them completely \u2014 it's a slippery slope.", "fallacy_type": "slippery_slope", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Assumes every minor rule deviation escalates to total rule-breaking without evidence of this progression.", "domain": "ethics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "causal_chain", "id": 48}
{"text": "If we accept one typo in official government documents, accuracy will soon become completely meaningless in public life.", "fallacy_type": "slippery_slope", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Extends a trivial, isolated event to a systemic breakdown with no intermediate reasoning.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "exaggerated_endpoint", "id": 53}
{"text": "If we allow schools to ban junk food vending machines, the government will end up controlling every meal children eat.", "fallacy_type": "slippery_slope", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Leaps from a narrow vending machine policy to total government control of children's nutrition.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "causal_chain", "id": 49}
{"text": "My client is innocent because there is no way an innocent man would be charged with this crime.", "fallacy_type": "circular_reasoning", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Assumes innocence (the claim) to argue that an innocent person can't be charged, and uses that to prove innocence.", "domain": "law", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "self_reference", "id": 57}
{"text": "This policy must be fair because it treats everyone equally, and treating everyone equally is what fairness means.", "fallacy_type": "circular_reasoning", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Defines 'fair' as 'equal treatment' then uses that definition as proof the policy is fair \u2014 circular.", "domain": "ethics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "definitional_loop", "id": 56}
{"text": "Capital punishment deters crime because criminals are afraid of being executed.", "fallacy_type": "circular_reasoning", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Assumes deterrence (criminals avoid crime due to fear) to prove deterrence \u2014 the claim needs independent empirical support.", "domain": "law", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "assumed_conclusion", "id": 61}
{"text": "This is the best restaurant in town because everyone who comes here says it's the best restaurant in town.", "fallacy_type": "circular_reasoning", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Uses customer assertions of being the best as proof of being the best, assuming the conclusion.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "self_reference", "id": 59}
{"text": "We trust the news outlet because it reports reliably, and we know it's reliable because we trust it.", "fallacy_type": "circular_reasoning", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Circular definition of trust and reliability \u2014 neither is independently grounded.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "definitional_loop", "id": 60}
{"text": "Fossil fuels are the backbone of the economy because the economy cannot function without fossil fuels.", "fallacy_type": "circular_reasoning", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Asserts the conclusion (backbone of economy) as justification for itself (cannot function without them).", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "self_reference", "id": 58}
{"text": "The last three recessions followed a drop in consumer confidence. So consumer confidence drops always cause recessions.", "fallacy_type": "hasty_generalization", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Small historical sample plus confusion of correlation with causation.", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "correlation_as_causation", "id": 66}
{"text": "A few studies in the 1970s showed this therapy was ineffective. It obviously doesn't work.", "fallacy_type": "hasty_generalization", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Old, small studies are being over-generalized while ignoring the evolution of therapeutic techniques and subsequent research.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "outdated_sample", "id": 71}
{"text": "My grandfather worked hard without any education and became successful. Education is unnecessary for success.", "fallacy_type": "hasty_generalization", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Single anecdote used to refute a statistical trend; survivorship bias is severe here.", "domain": "education", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "survivorship_bias", "id": 70}
{"text": "The first two patients given this drug showed no side effects \u2014 it's clearly safe.", "fallacy_type": "hasty_generalization", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Concludes safety from two observations, ignoring the statistical power required for drug safety conclusions.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "small_sample", "id": 64}
{"text": "Both times I wore my lucky socks, my team won. These socks improve team performance.", "fallacy_type": "hasty_generalization", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Two events, obvious confounds (team skill, opponent strength), and magical thinking underlying the conclusion.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "small_sample", "id": 68}
{"text": "Two startups I know of failed after pivoting. Pivoting always destroys companies.", "fallacy_type": "hasty_generalization", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Draws a universal business law from a convenience sample of two anecdotes.", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "small_sample", "id": 65}
{"text": "I asked three of my friends and none of them liked the new movie. It's clearly a flop.", "fallacy_type": "hasty_generalization", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Three friends is a tiny, non-representative sample from which no meaningful box-office conclusion can be drawn.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "small_sample", "id": 62}
{"text": "Every manager I've had has been a micromanager. All managers must be like that.", "fallacy_type": "hasty_generalization", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Generalizes from a personal, likely biased set of experiences to all members of a large diverse group.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "biased_sample", "id": 63}
{"text": "After we switched to remote work, our product launch was late. Remote work hurts productivity.", "fallacy_type": "post_hoc", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Launch latency could be due to feature scope, team changes, or market pivots; single event, single alternative cause insufficient.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "confound", "id": 80}
{"text": "Countries that consume more chocolate per capita win more Nobel Prizes. Therefore chocolate improves cognition.", "fallacy_type": "post_hoc", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Both variables correlate with wealth and education level \u2014 the relationship is spurious.", "domain": "science", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "spurious_correlation", "id": 78}
{"text": "Since we installed the new HR software, employee satisfaction scores went up. The software must be responsible.", "fallacy_type": "post_hoc", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Other interventions (raise cycles, new management, team restructuring) could explain the change.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "confound", "id": 73}
{"text": "Cities with more hospitals have higher death rates \u2014 hospitals must be causing deaths.", "fallacy_type": "post_hoc", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Hospitals are located where sick people go; higher density correlates with population and illness burden, not causation.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "confound", "id": 74}
{"text": "Ice cream sales and drowning rates both peak in summer. Ice cream must cause drowning.", "fallacy_type": "post_hoc", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Classic confound: hot weather causes both increased ice cream sales and increased swimming; they don't cause each other.", "domain": "science", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "confound", "id": 77}
{"text": "Our crime rate dropped after we installed security cameras. The cameras reduced crime.", "fallacy_type": "post_hoc", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Other factors (economic conditions, policing strategy, demographic change) may explain the drop; cameras may not be causal.", "domain": "law", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "confound", "id": 79}
{"text": "The stock market crashed three months after the new president took office. His policies caused the crash.", "fallacy_type": "post_hoc", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Stock market crashes have complex, multi-year causes; attributing one to recent policy ignores economic lag and other factors.", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "temporal_succession", "id": 76}
{"text": "This self-help book has sold 10 million copies. It definitely works.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_popularity", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Sales figures reflect marketing and appeal, not clinical efficacy of the advice.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "sales_as_validity", "id": 83}
{"text": "Everyone's investing in crypto right now. You'd be a fool not to.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_popularity", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Market popularity does not justify investment risk; historical bubbles show mass participation precedes crashes.", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "bandwagon", "id": 82}
{"text": "Millions of people believe in astrology \u2014 there must be something to it.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_popularity", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Widespread belief doesn't confer truth; astrology lacks empirical support regardless of how many believe in it.", "domain": "science", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "consensus_as_truth", "id": 81}
{"text": "Seven out of ten Americans say they feel safer with a gun at home. Guns must make homes safer.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_popularity", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Perceived safety is a feeling, not evidence; research on actual safety outcomes is what matters.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "consensus_as_truth", "id": 87}
{"text": "Every major country has adopted this trade policy, so we should too.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_popularity", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Geopolitical popularity doesn't mean a policy is optimal for a specific country's economic structure.", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "bandwagon", "id": 86}
{"text": "This diet has millions of followers on social media \u2014 it's clearly the healthiest way to eat.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_popularity", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Social media following reflects virality and community building, not nutritional science.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "social_proof", "id": 85}
{"text": "We're discussing food safety violations, but this restaurant has a Michelin star.", "fallacy_type": "red_herring", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Culinary prestige is irrelevant to hygiene compliance; both concerns coexist independently.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "distraction", "id": 93}
{"text": "Senator, why haven't you addressed the tax evasion allegations? \u2014 Well, I've worked tirelessly for veterans' benefits.", "fallacy_type": "red_herring", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Veterans' advocacy, while admirable, redirects entirely from the legal question about tax behavior.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "distraction", "id": 90}
{"text": "You question this medication's side effects? Think of all the people it has helped!", "fallacy_type": "red_herring", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Benefits to some patients don't address the question about side-effect risks, which is a legitimate safety inquiry.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "distraction", "id": 96}
{"text": "My client may have broken the drug law, but look at the real criminals \u2014 the drug cartels who ruin communities.", "fallacy_type": "red_herring", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Pointing to worse criminals does not address the defendant's legal culpability.", "domain": "law", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "distraction", "id": 95}
{"text": "My student was caught cheating, but he's going through a very tough time at home right now.", "fallacy_type": "red_herring", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Personal circumstances may be relevant to consequences, but don't change whether cheating occurred \u2014 distracts from the core issue.", "domain": "education", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "distraction", "id": 92}
{"text": "The product recall isn't the issue \u2014 what matters is that this company has employed thousands of families for decades.", "fallacy_type": "red_herring", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Employment history doesn't make the safety concerns about the product less valid.", "domain": "law", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "distraction", "id": 91}
{"text": "Criticizing government policy is the same as treason \u2014 both undermine the state.", "fallacy_type": "false_equivalence", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Democratic criticism is a protected form of civic participation; treason involves betrayal and typically illegal acts \u2014 legally and morally distinct.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "category_error", "id": 103}
{"text": "Eating one cookie and eating an entire cake are essentially the same \u2014 you're still breaking your diet.", "fallacy_type": "false_equivalence", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "The magnitude difference in caloric and behavioral terms makes these categorically different dietary events.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "magnitude_difference", "id": 100}
{"text": "Both sides of the vaccine debate deserve equal scientific representation.", "fallacy_type": "false_equivalence", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Scientific consensus on vaccine safety is not a 50-50 debate; treating it as such misrepresents the evidence.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "false_balance", "id": 99}
{"text": "Jaywalking and murder are both illegal, so why do we treat them so differently?", "fallacy_type": "false_equivalence", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Legality is the only shared feature; harm, intent, and consequence differ enormously, justifying different treatment.", "domain": "law", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "magnitude_difference", "id": 104}
{"text": "A minor traffic violation is basically the same as fraud \u2014 both are crimes.", "fallacy_type": "false_equivalence", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "The fact that both are crimes ignores enormous differences in harm, intent, and severity.", "domain": "law", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "magnitude_difference", "id": 98}
{"text": "Teaching evolution and creationism should get equal time in science classes \u2014 both are just theories.", "fallacy_type": "false_equivalence", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Scientific theory (evolution) and religious narrative (creationism) have vastly different evidential bases; equating them misrepresents science.", "domain": "science", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "category_error", "id": 97}
{"text": "Wolves live in packs and have alphas. Men are naturally dominant and women submissive.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_nature", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Applying animal social structure to human gender roles is both a naturalistic fallacy and based on outdated wolf research.", "domain": "ethics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "naturalistic_fallacy", "id": 110}
{"text": "Children naturally want to play, not study. We're going against nature by forcing them to sit in school.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_nature", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Natural tendencies don't determine optimal developmental practices; education and play can coexist.", "domain": "education", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "natural_is_good", "id": 111}
{"text": "Free-range eggs are better because hens lay them naturally, outside in open air.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_nature", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "While welfare concerns are real, 'natural' production doesn't automatically imply nutritional superiority.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "natural_is_better", "id": 107}
{"text": "Processed foods are unnatural \u2014 therefore they're bad for you.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_nature", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Processing spans a huge range (pasteurization to ultra-processing); 'unnatural' alone can't determine nutritional harm.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "natural_is_good", "id": 109}
{"text": "Humans have always lived in hierarchical societies \u2014 inequality is just natural.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_nature", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Naturalness doesn't justify a social arrangement; many natural phenomena are harmful and we work to change them.", "domain": "ethics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "naturalistic_fallacy", "id": 106}
{"text": "Think of the children \u2014 if we allow this media content, kids across the country will be permanently damaged.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_emotion", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Invokes emotional concern for children without evidence that the content causes harm, bypassing empirical analysis.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "fear", "id": 112}
{"text": "Our soldiers are dying overseas. You must support this defense budget increase.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_emotion", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Evokes powerful emotions around military sacrifice to compel agreement without making an argument for the budget's size.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "guilt", "id": 114}
{"text": "How can you support this trade deal knowing that families will lose their jobs and go hungry?", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_emotion", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Emotional framing about family suffering bypasses analysis of trade deal specifics and net economic effects.", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "pity", "id": 113}
{"text": "This cancer patient deserves to access unapproved treatments. How can the FDA deny them hope?", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_emotion", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Invokes sympathy to circumvent the regulatory process designed to protect patients from ineffective or dangerous treatments.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "pity", "id": 115}
{"text": "Millions of animals suffer every day in factory farms. You can't call yourself a good person and still eat meat.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_emotion", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Emotional framing (suffering, moral identity) is used coercively rather than providing logical arguments for dietary change.", "domain": "ethics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "guilt", "id": 117}
{"text": "If you truly cared about your students, you'd approve my late submission \u2014 I've been under tremendous stress.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_emotion", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Appeals to the teacher's compassion to bypass established academic policy, conflating caring with policy exception.", "domain": "education", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "pity", "id": 118}
{"text": "I've already read half this terrible book. Might as well finish it.", "fallacy_type": "sunk_cost", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Time reading so far is sunk; marginal value of finishing a book you dislike is what should guide the decision.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "past_effort", "id": 123}
{"text": "We're 30 slides into this presentation \u2014 we have to finish even if the audience is falling asleep.", "fallacy_type": "sunk_cost", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Effort already expended doesn't justify continuing a failing activity when stopping or pivoting would be better.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "past_effort", "id": 122}
{"text": "We've trained this employee for two years \u2014 we can't fire him even though he's underperforming.", "fallacy_type": "sunk_cost", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Training investment is sunk; the decision should rest on current and expected future performance.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "past_investment", "id": 126}
{"text": "This drug failed Phase 2 trials, but we've spent three years developing it. We need to go to Phase 3.", "fallacy_type": "sunk_cost", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Clinical failures should drive decisions, not development timeline; continuing risks patient harm and further resource waste.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "past_investment", "id": 124}
{"text": "The war has cost thousands of lives and billions of dollars. We must keep fighting to honor those who died.", "fallacy_type": "sunk_cost", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Honoring past sacrifice is an emotional appeal; the case for continued conflict must rest on strategic goals, not sunk costs.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "past_sacrifice", "id": 125}
{"text": "My uncle never wore a seatbelt and lived to 90. Seatbelts must be unnecessary.", "fallacy_type": "anecdotal_evidence", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "One survivorship anecdote contradicts population-level statistical evidence showing seatbelts dramatically reduce fatality risk.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "survivorship", "id": 127}
{"text": "I know someone who was wrongfully convicted. The criminal justice system doesn't work.", "fallacy_type": "anecdotal_evidence", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "One case of injustice, while important, can't characterize the performance of an entire legal system.", "domain": "law", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "single_case", "id": 128}
{"text": "My neighbor invested in penny stocks and made a fortune. I should do the same.", "fallacy_type": "anecdotal_evidence", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "One profitable outcome from a high-risk strategy ignores the much larger population of penny stock investors who lost money.", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "survivorship", "id": 129}
{"text": "My classmate barely studied and got an A. So studying doesn't help much.", "fallacy_type": "anecdotal_evidence", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Individual exceptions to academic effort norms don't refute the statistical relationship between study time and performance.", "domain": "education", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "single_case", "id": 130}
{"text": "I heard that someone got flu after a flu shot. The vaccine gave them flu.", "fallacy_type": "anecdotal_evidence", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Flu vaccines use inactivated viruses and cannot cause flu; coincidental temporal proximity creates the false impression.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "causal_misattribution", "id": 131}
{"text": "I have the right to say whatever I want. Therefore you have no right to criticize me for it.", "fallacy_type": "equivocation", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Shifts 'right' from legal protection against government censorship to an interpersonal immunity from criticism \u2014 two different concepts.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "lexical_shift", "id": 136}
{"text": "All laws have exceptions. Evolution is a law of nature. Therefore evolution has exceptions.", "fallacy_type": "equivocation", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "'Law' in jurisprudence (human rule) vs. scientific law (observed regularity) are different senses \u2014 the syllogism exploits this ambiguity.", "domain": "science", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "lexical_shift", "id": 135}
{"text": "Critical race theory is critical of race, and we don't want children to be critical. Ban it.", "fallacy_type": "equivocation", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "'Critical' in CRT means analytical/theoretical, not judgmental; the argument exploits word similarity to confuse the audience.", "domain": "education", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "lexical_shift", "id": 139}
{"text": "Man is the measure of all things. Women are not men. Therefore women aren't the measure of anything.", "fallacy_type": "equivocation", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "'Man' in the Protagoras quote means 'humanity'; the argument illegitimately restricts it to male humans.", "domain": "philosophy", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "lexical_shift", "id": 140}
{"text": "The sign said 'fine for parking here'. So I parked \u2014 it said it was fine!", "fallacy_type": "equivocation", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Deliberately shifts 'fine' (penalty) to 'fine' (acceptable), exploiting lexical ambiguity.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "lexical_shift", "id": 134}
{"text": "True Christians don't judge others. \u2014 What about the ones who do? \u2014 They're not true Christians.", "fallacy_type": "no_true_scotsman", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Immunizes the claim against counterexample by revising the definition of 'true Christian' post-hoc.", "domain": "philosophy", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "moving_goalpost", "id": 142}
{"text": "No real programmer uses a GUI \u2014 they use the command line. \u2014 But I'm a programmer and I use a GUI. \u2014 Then you're not a real programmer.", "fallacy_type": "no_true_scotsman", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Redefines 'real programmer' to exclude counterexamples, making the claim unfalsifiable.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "moving_goalpost", "id": 141}
{"text": "A real athlete doesn't need performance-enhancing drugs. \u2014 But many elite athletes have used them. \u2014 They were never real athletes.", "fallacy_type": "no_true_scotsman", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Uses drug use as a retroactive disqualifier, reshaping 'real athlete' to immunize the claim.", "domain": "ethics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "moving_goalpost", "id": 144}
{"text": "A truly democratic country wouldn't pass such a law. \u2014 Several well-established democracies have. \u2014 Then they aren't truly democratic.", "fallacy_type": "no_true_scotsman", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Shifts 'democracy' definition to exclude any counterexample, making the claim vacuously true but meaningless.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "moving_goalpost", "id": 146}
{"text": "You lecture me on diet, but you eat fast food every week.", "fallacy_type": "tu_quoque", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Whether the advice about diet is sound is independent of whether the giver follows it.", "domain": "everyday", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "hypocrisy_charge", "id": 152}
{"text": "My client shouldn't be held liable \u2014 the plaintiff did far worse things.", "fallacy_type": "tu_quoque", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Another party's worse conduct doesn't reduce the defendant's legal liability for their own actions.", "domain": "law", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "two_wrongs", "id": 149}
{"text": "I know I lied on this report, but everyone else pads their numbers too.", "fallacy_type": "tu_quoque", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Others' misconduct doesn't justify or excuse one's own; widespread wrongdoing doesn't make an action acceptable.", "domain": "ethics", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "two_wrongs", "id": 150}
{"text": "This pharmaceutical company was fined for misconduct. Why aren't you investigating the food companies that do the same?", "fallacy_type": "tu_quoque", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Deflects from the case at hand by demanding parallel investigations, not addressing the original misconduct.", "domain": "law", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "whataboutism", "id": 151}
{"text": "There's no conclusive proof that extraterrestrial life doesn't exist in this galaxy. So aliens are real.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_ignorance", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Absence of disproof doesn't establish existence; the statement 'aliens are real' requires its own affirmative evidence.", "domain": "science", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "negative_proof", "id": 156}
{"text": "We have no evidence that the defendant was at the crime scene, so he must be innocent.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_ignorance", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Absence of evidence for presence is not the same as evidence of absence; innocence requires its own argument.", "domain": "law", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "absence_of_evidence", "id": 155}
{"text": "No one has proven that ghosts don't exist \u2014 therefore they must.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_ignorance", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Absence of disproof is not evidence for existence; the burden of proof lies with the claim being made.", "domain": "philosophy", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "negative_proof", "id": 153}
{"text": "Nobody has disproved my business model \u2014 so it must be sound.", "fallacy_type": "appeal_to_ignorance", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "The burden is on the proposer to show the model works, not on others to disprove it.", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "negative_proof", "id": 158}
{"text": "Humans have always waged war. Therefore war is inevitable and we shouldn't try to eliminate it.", "fallacy_type": "naturalistic_fallacy", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Historical prevalence of a behavior (is) doesn't make it morally required or normatively desirable (ought).", "domain": "ethics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "is_ought", "id": 160}
{"text": "Animals in nature eat each other. Therefore it is morally permissible for humans to eat animals.", "fallacy_type": "naturalistic_fallacy", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Animal behavior in nature doesn't generate human moral permission; humans are subject to ethical reasoning animals are not.", "domain": "ethics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "is_ought", "id": 161}
{"text": "Evolution rewards the strongest and most competitive. Therefore, a society based on cutthroat competition is right.", "fallacy_type": "naturalistic_fallacy", "label": "fallacious", "explanation": "Derives an 'ought' (competition is morally right) from an 'is' (evolution selects for fitness) without bridging argument.", "domain": "ethics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "is_ought", "id": 159}
{"text": "Three independent forensic audits of the election count found fewer than 0.001% discrepancy. There is no evidence of systematic fraud.", "fallacy_type": "none", "label": "sound", "explanation": "Multiple independent audits with quantified discrepancy rate; conclusion is appropriately scoped to available evidence.", "domain": "politics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "", "id": 171}
{"text": "Our company's sales fell 15% this quarter compared to the same quarter last year, based on audited financials. We need to investigate the cause.", "fallacy_type": "none", "label": "sound", "explanation": "Draws a limited, appropriate conclusion from audited financial data. Does not over-infer causation.", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "", "id": 166}
{"text": "A randomized controlled trial of 2,400 patients found that patients given Drug X recovered 3 days faster on average (95% CI: 2.1\u20133.9 days, p < 0.001). The drug appears effective for this indication.", "fallacy_type": "none", "label": "sound", "explanation": "Strong study design with appropriate statistical reporting; conclusion is proportionate to evidence.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "", "id": 167}
{"text": "Smoking causes lung cancer. The evidence includes mechanistic studies, dose-response data, and consistent findings across dozens of longitudinal cohorts in different populations. This is one of the most well-established causal relationships in epidemiology.", "fallacy_type": "none", "label": "sound", "explanation": "Multiple types of converging evidence meet Bradford Hill criteria for causation; statement is fully supported and appropriately confident.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "", "id": 183}
{"text": "All mammals are warm-blooded. Dolphins are mammals. Therefore dolphins are warm-blooded.", "fallacy_type": "none", "label": "sound", "explanation": "Valid deductive argument with true premises \u2014 a textbook example of sound reasoning.", "domain": "science", "difficulty": "overt", "subcategory": "", "id": 176}
{"text": "The defendant's fingerprints were found on the weapon, he was seen leaving the scene by two independent witnesses, and his phone records place him at the location. The prosecution has made a compelling prima facie case.", "fallacy_type": "none", "label": "sound", "explanation": "Multiple independent lines of evidence converge; conclusion is qualified as 'prima facie case', not absolute guilt.", "domain": "law", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "", "id": 168}
{"text": "If we raise the price by 20% and demand is elastic (which prior surveys suggest it is), we can expect a volume decline. The net revenue impact is uncertain and should be modeled.", "fallacy_type": "none", "label": "sound", "explanation": "Conditional reasoning from evidence-backed assumptions; appropriately hedged conclusion recommending analysis rather than certainty.", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "", "id": 174}
{"text": "Water boils at 100\u00b0C at standard atmospheric pressure. This pot of water is at 100\u00b0C at standard pressure. Therefore it is boiling.", "fallacy_type": "none", "label": "sound", "explanation": "Valid deductive syllogism with well-established scientific premises.", "domain": "science", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "", "id": 165}
{"text": "This is our third quarter with increasing operating costs. We need to investigate whether this is a systemic issue or a transient one before committing to cost-cutting measures.", "fallacy_type": "none", "label": "sound", "explanation": "Identifies a real pattern, appropriately suspends judgment on cause, proposes investigation before action.", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "", "id": 181}
{"text": "Historical inflation data over 70 years shows that periods of rapid money supply growth consistently preceded inflation within 12\u201324 months. This provides inductive support for the quantity theory of money.", "fallacy_type": "none", "label": "sound", "explanation": "Long historical record, consistent pattern, carefully hedged as 'inductive support' rather than proof.", "domain": "economics", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "", "id": 169}
{"text": "We ran three separate experiments with pre-registered hypotheses and found consistent null results. The effect we hypothesized does not appear to exist at this magnitude.", "fallacy_type": "none", "label": "sound", "explanation": "Pre-registration eliminates HARKing; three replications showing consistent null results is strong evidence of absence.", "domain": "science", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "", "id": 180}
{"text": "The IPCC Sixth Assessment Report synthesizes findings from thousands of peer-reviewed papers. The report's conclusion that human activity is the dominant cause of warming since 1950 reflects scientific consensus.", "fallacy_type": "none", "label": "sound", "explanation": "Accurately characterizes the scope and conclusion of the IPCC report; appeals to relevant authority with appropriate context.", "domain": "science", "difficulty": "subtle", "subcategory": "", "id": 172}
{"text": "Multiple peer-reviewed meta-analyses consistently show that vaccines do not cause autism. Therefore the claim that vaccines cause autism is not supported by evidence.", "fallacy_type": "none", "label": "sound", "explanation": "Cites convergent scientific evidence from high-quality studies; the conclusion follows from the evidence.", "domain": "health", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "", "id": 164}
{"text": "The defendant had no motive, no opportunity, and the forensic evidence places him 300 miles away. The alibi appears credible.", "fallacy_type": "none", "label": "sound", "explanation": "Uses multiple independent exculpatory factors and reaches a proportionate conclusion about alibi credibility.", "domain": "law", "difficulty": "moderate", "subcategory": "", "id": 178}