| {"adapter":"blobfish-arc-crm","engine_metric":"HubScore","negative_control_count":167,"negative_false_accepts":0,"oracle_passes":6,"qualified":true,"scope":"local in-process oracle, deterministic replay and adversarial controls; no model, Docker, registry or publication claim","source_lock_sha256":"b1c945ed8f6a6ee328b43531fd60ff326c1bf6a6b1febbefc0c86f9d6409efa6","task_count":6,"tasks":[{"alternate_pass":true,"alternate_trace":[{"arguments":{},"index":0,"result":{"evidence_index":[{"asset_id":"E-1-onboarding-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-1-onboarding-1.pdf","sha256":"c7641ec3005adb6771fa01c11469d4595b2056ef9fbe5668a9e515b4730fac0d","source":"Aster Freight","title":"Onboarding policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-1-onboarding-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-1-onboarding-2.pdf","sha256":"2a212435e1a9cd5ab0e3b8567fdb590749d22733ccb929711ff387bf1fb1c931","source":"Aster Freight","title":"Onboarding policy revision 2"},{"asset_id":"E-1-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-1-request-1.eml","sha256":"5257d68ebdf1fae1c588a2632dca03d03b98499f26caa39c4099f0805747be80","source":"Aster Freight","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-1-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-1-request-2.eml","sha256":"ff9a31ea119254cc41ff1480aaabd700bc43b0cafe15647e0bdf2da6f9600a87","source":"Aster Freight","title":"Owner request 2"}],"identity":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-11"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-12"}],"organization":{"name":"Aster Freight","synthetic":true,"systems":["arccrm","desk","vault"]},"reference_records":{},"starting_records":[{"client_hint":"Aster Freight","thread_id":"TH-1"}],"state":{"network":"closed","persistence":"episode-local SQLite","scope":"isolated task snapshot"},"task":{"as_of":"2026-09-05","family":"arc-crm","role":"U-11","task_id":"arc-crm-001"},"tool_servers":[{"description":"Stateful synthetic CRM","name":"arccrm","tools":["arccrm.attachments.get","arccrm.attachments.search","arccrm.clients.get","arccrm.clients.search","arccrm.contacts.create","arccrm.contacts.get","arccrm.contacts.search","arccrm.contracts.create","arccrm.contracts.get","arccrm.contracts.search","arccrm.documents.attach","arccrm.documents.get","arccrm.documents.search","arccrm.notes.create","arccrm.notes.get","arccrm.notes.search","arccrm.opportunities.get","arccrm.opportunities.search","arccrm.opportunities.update","arccrm.quotes.cancel","arccrm.quotes.compare","arccrm.quotes.create","arccrm.quotes.get","arccrm.quotes.search"]},{"description":"Mock requests, permissions, approvals and versioned policy/price records","name":"desk","tools":["desk.approvals.get","desk.permissions.list","desk.policies.get","desk.prices.list","desk.requests.get","desk.requests.search"]},{"description":"Seeded synthetic evidence; no external file access","name":"vault","tools":["vault.files.get"]},{"description":"Benchmark-only discovery and structured answer submission controls.","name":"hubbench","tools":["hubbench.context.get","hubbench.submit_answer"]}]},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.context.get"},{"arguments":{},"index":1,"result":{"permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"contact:create","permission_id":"PERM-1-1","target_id":"C-11","user_id":"U-11","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-1-2","target_id":"C-11","user_id":"U-11","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"user_id":"U-11"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.permissions.list"},{"arguments":{"query":"C-11"},"index":2,"result":{"query":"c-11","records":[{"client_id":"C-11","contact_id":"CT-11","email":"jamie@aster-freight.example","first_name":"Jamie","last_name":"Park","revision":1,"title":"Procurement lead"}],"total":1},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.contacts.search"},{"arguments":{"policy_id":"POL-1-onboarding-2"},"index":3,"result":{"asset_id":"E-1-onboarding-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","operative":true,"policy_id":"POL-1-onboarding-2","revision":2,"rules":{"duplicate_email":"case-insensitive reject","email_domain":"verified client domain","existing_client_required":true,"titles":"not authorized"},"rules_json":"{\"duplicate_email\":\"case-insensitive reject\",\"email_domain\":\"verified client domain\",\"existing_client_required\":true,\"titles\":\"not authorized\"}","topic":"onboarding"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.policies.get"},{"arguments":{"query":"Aster Freight"},"index":4,"result":{"query":"aster freight","records":[{"client_id":"C-11","domain":"aster-freight.example","email":"billing@aster-freight.example","name":"Aster Freight","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-12","domain":"services-aster-freight.example","email":"billing@services-aster-freight.example","name":"Aster Freight Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-13","domain":"archive-aster-freight.example","email":"hold@archive-aster-freight.example","name":"Aster Freight Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"total":3},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.clients.search"},{"arguments":{"query":"TH-1"},"index":5,"result":{"query":"th-1","records":[{"asset_id":"E-1-request-1","body":"Please add Robin Vale at Aster Freight Services; create an account if needed.","client_id":"C-11","request_id":"RQ-11","sender_id":"U-12","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Onboard a buyer without duplicating the account","thread_id":"TH-1"},{"asset_id":"E-1-request-2","body":"Correction: Robin Vale is the buyer at Aster Freight, verified domain aster-freight.example, not the similarly named Services company. Email robin@aster-freight.example. Use the existing account; do not create an account or assign a title. The current domain policy applies.","client_id":"C-11","request_id":"RQ-12","sender_id":"U-12","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Onboard a buyer without duplicating the account","thread_id":"TH-1"}],"total":2},"success":true,"tool":"desk.requests.search"},{"arguments":{"client_id":"C-11","email":"robin@aster-freight.example","first_name":"Robin","last_name":"Vale"},"index":6,"result":{"client_id":"C-11","contact_id":"CT-12","email":"robin@aster-freight.example","first_name":"Robin","last_name":"Vale","mutation_id":"arc-crm-001-mutation-01","revision":1,"title":""},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.contacts.create"},{"arguments":{"content":"Operations handoff \u2014 verified records and facts: RQ-12; robin@aster-freight.example; C-11. Please review the linked evidence.","entity_id":"C-11","entity_type":"client","evidence_ids":["E-1-onboarding-2","E-1-request-2"],"reference_ids":["CT-12"]},"index":7,"result":{"content":"Operations handoff \u2014 verified records and facts: RQ-12; robin@aster-freight.example; C-11. Please review the linked evidence.","entity_id":"C-11","entity_type":"client","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-1-onboarding-2\",\"E-1-request-2\"]","mutation_id":"arc-crm-001-mutation-02","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"CT-12\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"arguments":{"contact_id":"CT-12"},"index":8,"result":{"client_id":"C-11","contact_id":"CT-12","email":"robin@aster-freight.example","first_name":"Robin","last_name":"Vale","revision":1,"title":""},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.contacts.get"},{"arguments":{"client_id":"C-11"},"index":9,"result":{"client_id":"C-11","domain":"aster-freight.example","email":"billing@aster-freight.example","name":"Aster Freight","revision":3,"status":"active"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.clients.get"},{"arguments":{"note_id":"NT-1"},"index":10,"result":{"content":"Operations handoff \u2014 verified records and facts: RQ-12; robin@aster-freight.example; C-11. Please review the linked evidence.","entity_id":"C-11","entity_type":"client","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-1-onboarding-2\",\"E-1-request-2\"]","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"CT-12\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.get"},{"arguments":{"client_id":"C-11","contact_id":"CT-12","email":"robin@aster-freight.example","note_id":"NT-1","source_request_id":"RQ-12"},"index":11,"result":{"accepted":true,"fields":{"client_id":"C-11","contact_id":"CT-12","email":"robin@aster-freight.example","note_id":"NT-1","source_request_id":"RQ-12"},"task_id":"arc-crm-001"},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.submit_answer"}],"exact_replay":true,"negative_controls":[{"name":"noop","score":13.95,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945","verdict_sha256":"2a7637983cd9e38c71a5d5343579354ef8077e37e4671e98ed377f871ee92c84"},{"name":"answer_only","score":23.95,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"83dda814b283b29baefc4a06c83c2aa3cbd1f1672b92ec9cb842d3f1ff409545","verdict_sha256":"18b9bdf3a95d0e6ee33e93d19a914425bfe10fa7decaa70c894afd9ceef8a634"},{"name":"skip_investigation","score":80.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"c82d5c500162581a0949ea29f51e74565560097fb20a21fd04094f4dc0ed4e47","verdict_sha256":"39430014916d6b86b2d9f46508cb638f00ceeebb93257d0b2eba9dd7cab145af"},{"name":"write_before_investigation","score":80.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"57e3bc23c05cb4bcec32fc7abbb187a0af581ba7f1e7fecb04ec7e3cd3d5a784","verdict_sha256":"067cf8706cd26b3320d33c1ebaf24ebea84c0327448adf35ecaf60819e2f3d38"},{"name":"missing_readback","score":85.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"452ee875dca368becbec8ec3fcca71b2af213af362f9b6827c5e108d82ca7bf9","verdict_sha256":"28bd4c5c50220d9f7352fd74769be73dcd446fef18eb7d703dd39eff3e63860d"},{"name":"state_without_answer","score":90.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"f11962a2351798c41a8340242ded00223fab3f76ac57c11d4bf476192e4623b7","verdict_sha256":"63c40519d9f9573eeb76c4a4345ea36f7b7b30c20cd5224dee355c515b43ebad"},{"name":"omit_read_1_desk.requests.search","score":96.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"40b4a9e7c0593a544e4e6077f6d60a251a41a1f8e7f8238f9b5acae7f4c16ccd","verdict_sha256":"22ccf6edf15eecf5ced9d178a7e4a75dfe72d816e7e95e61f6374b1b1828e3c8"},{"name":"omit_read_2_arccrm.clients.search","score":96.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"1bb2236a1e95ebad5b58df66a832fa4bf02c683d50d9e559adf52891901e0ca8","verdict_sha256":"d2c2d65e8b6e2fed0c3d524cfcd936e73b2db52cac3e32b1383bbd7839946b33"},{"name":"omit_read_3_desk.policies.get","score":96.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"6b7ce473c2266787a96892d07fa2978cc31ed1a5f501ece66838ae9028be217f","verdict_sha256":"69717abb92f581812d8f30065dca4306f36c841e01753e777819f19ca3039274"},{"name":"omit_read_4_arccrm.contacts.search","score":96.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"20246aca892cddff609037be4dcbd3a9f5ec7ecead5fda228bf82b17659679f5","verdict_sha256":"d9bb178e2e85c348274240d5399f587f96b63930348cd6a9276f796b7d75ca18"},{"name":"omit_read_5_desk.permissions.list","score":96.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"741e433abc9c46b9c0d7055f2a014b321fca86cda9ab2f0a7332b60d9913e369","verdict_sha256":"e365a170958f81fd3a5bb847696bbc4c1d196d1f4f1954e7dc3250feb411134e"},{"name":"omit_mutation_6_arccrm.contacts.create","score":43.6,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"5e257ece42e731be45a4b60a4adc7bec2fdcb9eff3b3ef8869b2f55f34a3527f","verdict_sha256":"24f34c615e83c528185003c6d24c052181796ea15e056d3a91f351a5c88365bb"},{"name":"omit_mutation_7_arccrm.notes.create","score":69.3,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"3bef1a539973c809a3733d27b2ccc18555870fe045edb09f91a162d6f48d722c","verdict_sha256":"0816dec651d5963993e8471d01c51be250f9f9241619a3548ff575f930025983"},{"name":"omit_read_8_arccrm.contacts.get","score":95.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"91ee408a8407051c069fc6086550e1d1da7a3ebfdc6c32f415fcbc996f9ce181","verdict_sha256":"feca9b01730d28c76a76c5e178ead2c985f2665cf149f69b1ca72d1afaa8a745"},{"name":"omit_read_9_arccrm.clients.get","score":95.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"b8a092383f3ec0a79d3e2f99e83a30f2cedc7711fec0adc4ceb141c2e293800f","verdict_sha256":"ec853f887f2bd2fa96ebcac301552b2ec4b717be3898017e6c809ce88bd2ea97"},{"name":"omit_read_10_arccrm.notes.get","score":95.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"2fb09d8fbf378363f7873a40e9be7a03aa47b273b018ce0ff11513c947e23029","verdict_sha256":"cf8e55c2c2d49ce33e62e428dc86c0aa52dc74a79bc87ff9a51f5bbb6e3f19a4"},{"name":"superseded_request","score":96.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"96e9c4da47af05c6dec260fa093c834c93bb2e68c8acb88c32e2f66551be6254","verdict_sha256":"e3c6e3f77720bab0feb102d5ca10116126d4471c5243231ffd241657c76c9e5f"},{"name":"retired_policy","score":96.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"b7ca3abb664319247f29605e53f56cb3ef9003fe0ae24c2ad82b50fb504e6eb2","verdict_sha256":"3951e275359db6b5aa0f9e824b7eb167bba1bd1304d5e3fd0261ea1e1816be42"},{"name":"wrong_answer","score":98.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"7fead0a3675e6f5c112c673a0f50c4505580e134368af0ec789005eda316e3c8","verdict_sha256":"164c951cc66dc44a9156af46427c503bfb10407df698639b4156d53ec9fa7d05"},{"name":"missing_literal_handoff_facts","score":90.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"0aa81f08ba88eaee15643f924a6914f4b072b00ba9feec87d7b7af98753a6988","verdict_sha256":"66bf904b055374d7dd4042c9e35a0d954d4383618b4fa5c75b0a2d66bc410c4e"},{"name":"stale_handoff_evidence","score":80.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"4a91f500d18c9f91c3792332a42ae2b2b5c8a9a16ac96a1af23350ef17c73222","verdict_sha256":"8d7d929cad18c46da015936f14742ee2a6cb1c0b446fd9c6ffd53e793ea0e37c"},{"name":"wrong_client","score":99.65,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"222cf396b9b6f12d16d3a21494eccbda7529f11e480b3cbbff0127f6e78d8e50","verdict_sha256":"58b8b877c6438e5a9274bc5f4e7d0e278a2ab0b4b41d91b25eefa9bc186f9eb9"},{"name":"duplicate_email","score":99.65,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"c9ed971eaf9067c6ce2be963a27cdbb36d3ea19be71715f9c6ebb643eb423144","verdict_sha256":"103300843854b63f07f93bf269697b3fd5d086552df7505e290732bc65da41fa"},{"name":"unapproved_title","score":99.65,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"90171c00c793a735b169318721013e98c3eac8dc12234c4f68e578c65deeda17","verdict_sha256":"545a5eb45740acda10ed0010a7f94c22245d7988f812e92b5712aa8841b5ade8"}],"oracle":{"final_state":{"answers":[{"field":"client_id","task_id":"arc-crm-001","value":"C-11"},{"field":"contact_id","task_id":"arc-crm-001","value":"CT-12"},{"field":"email","task_id":"arc-crm-001","value":"robin@aster-freight.example"},{"field":"note_id","task_id":"arc-crm-001","value":"NT-1"},{"field":"source_request_id","task_id":"arc-crm-001","value":"RQ-12"}],"audit_log":[{"action":"created","audit_id":1,"payload":"{\"client_id\":\"C-11\",\"email\":\"robin@aster-freight.example\",\"first_name\":\"Robin\",\"last_name\":\"Vale\"}","record_id":"CT-12","table_name":"crm_contacts","task_id":"arc-crm-001","tool":"arccrm.contacts.create"},{"action":"insert","audit_id":2,"payload":"{\"arguments\":{\"client_id\":\"C-11\",\"email\":\"robin@aster-freight.example\",\"first_name\":\"Robin\",\"last_name\":\"Vale\"},\"tool\":\"arccrm.contacts.create\"}","record_id":"arc-crm-001-mutation-01","table_name":"mutations","task_id":"arc-crm-001","tool":"arccrm.contacts.create"},{"action":"created","audit_id":3,"payload":"{\"content\":\"Linked robin@aster-freight.example to verified C-11 per RQ-12; existing account retained.\",\"entity_id\":\"C-11\",\"entity_type\":\"client\",\"evidence_ids\":[\"E-1-request-2\",\"E-1-onboarding-2\"],\"reference_ids\":[\"CT-12\"]}","record_id":"NT-1","table_name":"crm_notes","task_id":"arc-crm-001","tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"action":"insert","audit_id":4,"payload":"{\"arguments\":{\"content\":\"Linked robin@aster-freight.example to verified C-11 per RQ-12; existing account retained.\",\"entity_id\":\"C-11\",\"entity_type\":\"client\",\"evidence_ids\":[\"E-1-request-2\",\"E-1-onboarding-2\"],\"reference_ids\":[\"CT-12\"]},\"tool\":\"arccrm.notes.create\"}","record_id":"arc-crm-001-mutation-02","table_name":"mutations","task_id":"arc-crm-001","tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"action":"submit","audit_id":5,"payload":"{\"client_id\":\"C-11\",\"contact_id\":\"CT-12\",\"email\":\"robin@aster-freight.example\",\"note_id\":\"NT-1\",\"source_request_id\":\"RQ-12\"}","record_id":"arc-crm-001","table_name":"answers","task_id":"arc-crm-001","tool":"hubbench.submit_answer"}],"crm_approvals":[],"crm_attachments":[],"crm_clients":[{"client_id":"C-11","domain":"aster-freight.example","email":"billing@aster-freight.example","name":"Aster Freight","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-12","domain":"services-aster-freight.example","email":"billing@services-aster-freight.example","name":"Aster Freight Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-13","domain":"archive-aster-freight.example","email":"hold@archive-aster-freight.example","name":"Aster Freight Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"crm_contacts":[{"client_id":"C-11","contact_id":"CT-11","email":"jamie@aster-freight.example","first_name":"Jamie","last_name":"Park","revision":1,"title":"Procurement lead"},{"client_id":"C-11","contact_id":"CT-12","email":"robin@aster-freight.example","first_name":"Robin","last_name":"Vale","revision":1,"title":""}],"crm_contracts":[],"crm_documents":[],"crm_evidence":[{"asset_id":"E-1-onboarding-1","content":"Aster Freight\nEffective 2025-01-01 through 2026-08-31.\n{\"notice\":\"Retired. Use the current revision.\"}\n"},{"asset_id":"E-1-onboarding-2","content":"Aster Freight\nEffective 2026-09-01 through 2026-12-31.\n{\"duplicate_email\":\"case-insensitive reject\",\"email_domain\":\"verified client domain\",\"existing_client_required\":true,\"titles\":\"not authorized\"}\n"},{"asset_id":"E-1-request-1","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@aster-freight.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@aster-freight.example>\nSubject: Onboard a buyer without duplicating the account\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nPlease add Robin Vale at Aster Freight Services; create an account if needed.\n"},{"asset_id":"E-1-request-2","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@aster-freight.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@aster-freight.example>\nSubject: Onboard a buyer without duplicating the account\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nCorrection: Robin Vale is the buyer at Aster Freight, verified domain aster-freight.example, not the similarly named Services company. Email robin@aster-freight.example. Use the existing account; do not create an account or assign a title. The current domain policy applies.\n"}],"crm_notes":[{"content":"Linked robin@aster-freight.example to verified C-11 per RQ-12; existing account retained.","entity_id":"C-11","entity_type":"client","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-1-onboarding-2\",\"E-1-request-2\"]","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"CT-12\"]"}],"crm_opportunities":[{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-11","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-11","owner_id":"U-12","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":900000,"client_id":"C-11","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - west","opportunity_id":"OP-12","owner_id":"U-12","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-12","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-13","owner_id":"U-12","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"}],"crm_permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"contact:create","permission_id":"PERM-1-1","target_id":"C-11","user_id":"U-11","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-1-2","target_id":"C-11","user_id":"U-11","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"crm_policies":[{"asset_id":"E-1-onboarding-1","effective_from":"2025-01-01","effective_until":"2026-08-31","policy_id":"POL-1-onboarding-1","revision":1,"rules_json":"{\"notice\":\"Retired. Use the current revision.\"}","topic":"onboarding"},{"asset_id":"E-1-onboarding-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","policy_id":"POL-1-onboarding-2","revision":2,"rules_json":"{\"duplicate_email\":\"case-insensitive reject\",\"email_domain\":\"verified client domain\",\"existing_client_required\":true,\"titles\":\"not authorized\"}","topic":"onboarding"}],"crm_prices":[],"crm_quote_lines":[],"crm_quotes":[],"crm_requests":[{"asset_id":"E-1-request-1","body":"Please add Robin Vale at Aster Freight Services; create an account if needed.","client_id":"C-11","request_id":"RQ-11","sender_id":"U-12","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Onboard a buyer without duplicating the account","thread_id":"TH-1"},{"asset_id":"E-1-request-2","body":"Correction: Robin Vale is the buyer at Aster Freight, verified domain aster-freight.example, not the similarly named Services company. Email robin@aster-freight.example. Use the existing account; do not create an account or assign a title. The current domain policy applies.","client_id":"C-11","request_id":"RQ-12","sender_id":"U-12","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Onboard a buyer without duplicating the account","thread_id":"TH-1"}],"evidence_files":[{"asset_id":"E-1-onboarding-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-1-onboarding-1.pdf","sha256":"c7641ec3005adb6771fa01c11469d4595b2056ef9fbe5668a9e515b4730fac0d","source":"Aster Freight","task_id":"arc-crm-001","title":"Onboarding policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-1-onboarding-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-1-onboarding-2.pdf","sha256":"2a212435e1a9cd5ab0e3b8567fdb590749d22733ccb929711ff387bf1fb1c931","source":"Aster Freight","task_id":"arc-crm-001","title":"Onboarding policy revision 2"},{"asset_id":"E-1-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-1-request-1.eml","sha256":"5257d68ebdf1fae1c588a2632dca03d03b98499f26caa39c4099f0805747be80","source":"Aster Freight","task_id":"arc-crm-001","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-1-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-1-request-2.eml","sha256":"ff9a31ea119254cc41ff1480aaabd700bc43b0cafe15647e0bdf2da6f9600a87","source":"Aster Freight","task_id":"arc-crm-001","title":"Owner request 2"}],"mutations":[{"effective_at":"2026-09-05T09:06:00","mutation_id":"arc-crm-001-mutation-01","payload_json":"{\"arguments\":{\"client_id\":\"C-11\",\"email\":\"robin@aster-freight.example\",\"first_name\":\"Robin\",\"last_name\":\"Vale\"},\"tool\":\"arccrm.contacts.create\"}","record_id":"CT-12","revision":1,"sequence":1,"status":"created","table_name":"crm_contacts","task_id":"arc-crm-001","tool":"arccrm.contacts.create"},{"effective_at":"2026-09-05T09:07:00","mutation_id":"arc-crm-001-mutation-02","payload_json":"{\"arguments\":{\"content\":\"Linked robin@aster-freight.example to verified C-11 per RQ-12; existing account retained.\",\"entity_id\":\"C-11\",\"entity_type\":\"client\",\"evidence_ids\":[\"E-1-request-2\",\"E-1-onboarding-2\"],\"reference_ids\":[\"CT-12\"]},\"tool\":\"arccrm.notes.create\"}","record_id":"NT-1","revision":1,"sequence":2,"status":"created","table_name":"crm_notes","task_id":"arc-crm-001","tool":"arccrm.notes.create"}],"users":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-11"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-12"}]},"initial_state":{"answers":[],"audit_log":[],"crm_approvals":[],"crm_attachments":[],"crm_clients":[{"client_id":"C-11","domain":"aster-freight.example","email":"billing@aster-freight.example","name":"Aster Freight","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-12","domain":"services-aster-freight.example","email":"billing@services-aster-freight.example","name":"Aster Freight Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-13","domain":"archive-aster-freight.example","email":"hold@archive-aster-freight.example","name":"Aster Freight Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"crm_contacts":[{"client_id":"C-11","contact_id":"CT-11","email":"jamie@aster-freight.example","first_name":"Jamie","last_name":"Park","revision":1,"title":"Procurement lead"}],"crm_contracts":[],"crm_documents":[],"crm_evidence":[{"asset_id":"E-1-onboarding-1","content":"Aster Freight\nEffective 2025-01-01 through 2026-08-31.\n{\"notice\":\"Retired. Use the current revision.\"}\n"},{"asset_id":"E-1-onboarding-2","content":"Aster Freight\nEffective 2026-09-01 through 2026-12-31.\n{\"duplicate_email\":\"case-insensitive reject\",\"email_domain\":\"verified client domain\",\"existing_client_required\":true,\"titles\":\"not authorized\"}\n"},{"asset_id":"E-1-request-1","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@aster-freight.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@aster-freight.example>\nSubject: Onboard a buyer without duplicating the account\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nPlease add Robin Vale at Aster Freight Services; create an account if needed.\n"},{"asset_id":"E-1-request-2","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@aster-freight.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@aster-freight.example>\nSubject: Onboard a buyer without duplicating the account\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nCorrection: Robin Vale is the buyer at Aster Freight, verified domain aster-freight.example, not the similarly named Services company. Email robin@aster-freight.example. Use the existing account; do not create an account or assign a title. The current domain policy applies.\n"}],"crm_notes":[],"crm_opportunities":[{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-11","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-11","owner_id":"U-12","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":900000,"client_id":"C-11","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - west","opportunity_id":"OP-12","owner_id":"U-12","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-12","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-13","owner_id":"U-12","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"}],"crm_permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"contact:create","permission_id":"PERM-1-1","target_id":"C-11","user_id":"U-11","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-1-2","target_id":"C-11","user_id":"U-11","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"crm_policies":[{"asset_id":"E-1-onboarding-1","effective_from":"2025-01-01","effective_until":"2026-08-31","policy_id":"POL-1-onboarding-1","revision":1,"rules_json":"{\"notice\":\"Retired. Use the current revision.\"}","topic":"onboarding"},{"asset_id":"E-1-onboarding-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","policy_id":"POL-1-onboarding-2","revision":2,"rules_json":"{\"duplicate_email\":\"case-insensitive reject\",\"email_domain\":\"verified client domain\",\"existing_client_required\":true,\"titles\":\"not authorized\"}","topic":"onboarding"}],"crm_prices":[],"crm_quote_lines":[],"crm_quotes":[],"crm_requests":[{"asset_id":"E-1-request-1","body":"Please add Robin Vale at Aster Freight Services; create an account if needed.","client_id":"C-11","request_id":"RQ-11","sender_id":"U-12","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Onboard a buyer without duplicating the account","thread_id":"TH-1"},{"asset_id":"E-1-request-2","body":"Correction: Robin Vale is the buyer at Aster Freight, verified domain aster-freight.example, not the similarly named Services company. Email robin@aster-freight.example. Use the existing account; do not create an account or assign a title. The current domain policy applies.","client_id":"C-11","request_id":"RQ-12","sender_id":"U-12","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Onboard a buyer without duplicating the account","thread_id":"TH-1"}],"evidence_files":[{"asset_id":"E-1-onboarding-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-1-onboarding-1.pdf","sha256":"c7641ec3005adb6771fa01c11469d4595b2056ef9fbe5668a9e515b4730fac0d","source":"Aster Freight","task_id":"arc-crm-001","title":"Onboarding policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-1-onboarding-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-1-onboarding-2.pdf","sha256":"2a212435e1a9cd5ab0e3b8567fdb590749d22733ccb929711ff387bf1fb1c931","source":"Aster Freight","task_id":"arc-crm-001","title":"Onboarding policy revision 2"},{"asset_id":"E-1-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-1-request-1.eml","sha256":"5257d68ebdf1fae1c588a2632dca03d03b98499f26caa39c4099f0805747be80","source":"Aster Freight","task_id":"arc-crm-001","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-1-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-1-request-2.eml","sha256":"ff9a31ea119254cc41ff1480aaabd700bc43b0cafe15647e0bdf2da6f9600a87","source":"Aster Freight","task_id":"arc-crm-001","title":"Owner request 2"}],"mutations":[],"users":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-11"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-12"}]},"trace":[{"arguments":{},"index":0,"result":{"evidence_index":[{"asset_id":"E-1-onboarding-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-1-onboarding-1.pdf","sha256":"c7641ec3005adb6771fa01c11469d4595b2056ef9fbe5668a9e515b4730fac0d","source":"Aster Freight","title":"Onboarding policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-1-onboarding-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-1-onboarding-2.pdf","sha256":"2a212435e1a9cd5ab0e3b8567fdb590749d22733ccb929711ff387bf1fb1c931","source":"Aster Freight","title":"Onboarding policy revision 2"},{"asset_id":"E-1-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-1-request-1.eml","sha256":"5257d68ebdf1fae1c588a2632dca03d03b98499f26caa39c4099f0805747be80","source":"Aster Freight","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-1-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-1-request-2.eml","sha256":"ff9a31ea119254cc41ff1480aaabd700bc43b0cafe15647e0bdf2da6f9600a87","source":"Aster Freight","title":"Owner request 2"}],"identity":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-11"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-12"}],"organization":{"name":"Aster Freight","synthetic":true,"systems":["arccrm","desk","vault"]},"reference_records":{},"starting_records":[{"client_hint":"Aster Freight","thread_id":"TH-1"}],"state":{"network":"closed","persistence":"episode-local SQLite","scope":"isolated task snapshot"},"task":{"as_of":"2026-09-05","family":"arc-crm","role":"U-11","task_id":"arc-crm-001"},"tool_servers":[{"description":"Stateful synthetic CRM","name":"arccrm","tools":["arccrm.attachments.get","arccrm.attachments.search","arccrm.clients.get","arccrm.clients.search","arccrm.contacts.create","arccrm.contacts.get","arccrm.contacts.search","arccrm.contracts.create","arccrm.contracts.get","arccrm.contracts.search","arccrm.documents.attach","arccrm.documents.get","arccrm.documents.search","arccrm.notes.create","arccrm.notes.get","arccrm.notes.search","arccrm.opportunities.get","arccrm.opportunities.search","arccrm.opportunities.update","arccrm.quotes.cancel","arccrm.quotes.compare","arccrm.quotes.create","arccrm.quotes.get","arccrm.quotes.search"]},{"description":"Mock requests, permissions, approvals and versioned policy/price records","name":"desk","tools":["desk.approvals.get","desk.permissions.list","desk.policies.get","desk.prices.list","desk.requests.get","desk.requests.search"]},{"description":"Seeded synthetic evidence; no external file access","name":"vault","tools":["vault.files.get"]},{"description":"Benchmark-only discovery and structured answer submission controls.","name":"hubbench","tools":["hubbench.context.get","hubbench.submit_answer"]}]},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.context.get"},{"arguments":{"query":"TH-1"},"index":1,"result":{"query":"th-1","records":[{"asset_id":"E-1-request-1","body":"Please add Robin Vale at Aster Freight Services; create an account if needed.","client_id":"C-11","request_id":"RQ-11","sender_id":"U-12","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Onboard a buyer without duplicating the account","thread_id":"TH-1"},{"asset_id":"E-1-request-2","body":"Correction: Robin Vale is the buyer at Aster Freight, verified domain aster-freight.example, not the similarly named Services company. Email robin@aster-freight.example. Use the existing account; do not create an account or assign a title. The current domain policy applies.","client_id":"C-11","request_id":"RQ-12","sender_id":"U-12","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Onboard a buyer without duplicating the account","thread_id":"TH-1"}],"total":2},"success":true,"tool":"desk.requests.search"},{"arguments":{"query":"Aster Freight"},"index":2,"result":{"query":"aster freight","records":[{"client_id":"C-11","domain":"aster-freight.example","email":"billing@aster-freight.example","name":"Aster Freight","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-12","domain":"services-aster-freight.example","email":"billing@services-aster-freight.example","name":"Aster Freight Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-13","domain":"archive-aster-freight.example","email":"hold@archive-aster-freight.example","name":"Aster Freight Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"total":3},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.clients.search"},{"arguments":{"policy_id":"POL-1-onboarding-2"},"index":3,"result":{"asset_id":"E-1-onboarding-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","operative":true,"policy_id":"POL-1-onboarding-2","revision":2,"rules":{"duplicate_email":"case-insensitive reject","email_domain":"verified client domain","existing_client_required":true,"titles":"not authorized"},"rules_json":"{\"duplicate_email\":\"case-insensitive reject\",\"email_domain\":\"verified client domain\",\"existing_client_required\":true,\"titles\":\"not authorized\"}","topic":"onboarding"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.policies.get"},{"arguments":{"query":"C-11"},"index":4,"result":{"query":"c-11","records":[{"client_id":"C-11","contact_id":"CT-11","email":"jamie@aster-freight.example","first_name":"Jamie","last_name":"Park","revision":1,"title":"Procurement lead"}],"total":1},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.contacts.search"},{"arguments":{},"index":5,"result":{"permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"contact:create","permission_id":"PERM-1-1","target_id":"C-11","user_id":"U-11","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-1-2","target_id":"C-11","user_id":"U-11","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"user_id":"U-11"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.permissions.list"},{"arguments":{"client_id":"C-11","email":"robin@aster-freight.example","first_name":"Robin","last_name":"Vale"},"index":6,"result":{"client_id":"C-11","contact_id":"CT-12","email":"robin@aster-freight.example","first_name":"Robin","last_name":"Vale","mutation_id":"arc-crm-001-mutation-01","revision":1,"title":""},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.contacts.create"},{"arguments":{"content":"Linked robin@aster-freight.example to verified C-11 per RQ-12; existing account retained.","entity_id":"C-11","entity_type":"client","evidence_ids":["E-1-request-2","E-1-onboarding-2"],"reference_ids":["CT-12"]},"index":7,"result":{"content":"Linked robin@aster-freight.example to verified C-11 per RQ-12; existing account retained.","entity_id":"C-11","entity_type":"client","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-1-onboarding-2\",\"E-1-request-2\"]","mutation_id":"arc-crm-001-mutation-02","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"CT-12\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"arguments":{"contact_id":"CT-12"},"index":8,"result":{"client_id":"C-11","contact_id":"CT-12","email":"robin@aster-freight.example","first_name":"Robin","last_name":"Vale","revision":1,"title":""},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.contacts.get"},{"arguments":{"client_id":"C-11"},"index":9,"result":{"client_id":"C-11","domain":"aster-freight.example","email":"billing@aster-freight.example","name":"Aster Freight","revision":3,"status":"active"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.clients.get"},{"arguments":{"note_id":"NT-1"},"index":10,"result":{"content":"Linked robin@aster-freight.example to verified C-11 per RQ-12; existing account retained.","entity_id":"C-11","entity_type":"client","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-1-onboarding-2\",\"E-1-request-2\"]","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"CT-12\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.get"},{"arguments":{"client_id":"C-11","contact_id":"CT-12","email":"robin@aster-freight.example","note_id":"NT-1","source_request_id":"RQ-12"},"index":11,"result":{"accepted":true,"fields":{"client_id":"C-11","contact_id":"CT-12","email":"robin@aster-freight.example","note_id":"NT-1","source_request_id":"RQ-12"},"task_id":"arc-crm-001"},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.submit_answer"}],"verdict":{"checks":[{"category":"evidence","description":"contact_onboarding: evidence","earned_weight":20.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":5,"subchecks":[{"description":"Resolve the owner's current clarification, not the superseded message.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":1,"tool":"desk.requests.search"}]},"id":"investigate-current_request","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Identify the existing verified client and the similarly named account.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":2,"tool":"arccrm.clients.search"}]},"id":"investigate-verified_client","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the operative policy and its scope.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":3,"tool":"desk.policies.get"}]},"id":"investigate-operative_policy","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Check existing contacts before creating another.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":4,"tool":"arccrm.contacts.search"}]},"id":"investigate-duplicate_contacts","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the acting role's specific operation/target grants before writing.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":5,"tool":"desk.permissions.list"}]},"id":"investigate-authority","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":5},"id":"evidence","passed":true,"weight":20.0},{"category":"readback","description":"contact_onboarding: readback","earned_weight":15.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":3,"subchecks":[{"description":"Read back the persisted contact after the business mutation.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":4,"tool":"arccrm.contacts.search"},{"index":8,"tool":"arccrm.contacts.get"}]},"id":"readback-contact","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read back the persisted client_relationship after the business mutation.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":2,"tool":"arccrm.clients.search"},{"index":9,"tool":"arccrm.clients.get"}]},"id":"readback-client_relationship","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read back the persisted handoff after the business mutation.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":10,"tool":"arccrm.notes.get"}]},"id":"readback-handoff","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":3},"id":"readback","passed":true,"weight":15.0},{"category":"outcome","description":"contact_onboarding: outcome","earned_weight":30.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":2,"subchecks":[{"description":"Persist the required crm_contacts record and exact structural fields.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"create-crm_contacts-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Persist the required crm_notes record and exact structural fields.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"create-crm_notes-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":2},"id":"outcome","passed":true,"weight":30.0},{"category":"containment","description":"contact_onboarding: containment","earned_weight":15.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":43,"subchecks":[{"description":"Preserve users record {'user_id': 'U-11'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-users-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve users record {'user_id': 'U-12'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-users-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in users.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-users","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-1-request-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-1-request-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-1-onboarding-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-1-onboarding-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-3","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in evidence_files.","evidence":{"expected_count":4,"matching_rows":4},"id":"count-evidence_files","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-1-request-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-1-request-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-1-onboarding-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-1-onboarding-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-3","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_evidence.","evidence":{"expected_count":4,"matching_rows":4},"id":"count-crm_evidence","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_clients record {'client_id': 'C-11'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_clients-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_clients record {'client_id': 'C-12'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_clients-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_clients record {'client_id': 'C-13'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_clients-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_clients.","evidence":{"expected_count":3,"matching_rows":3},"id":"count-crm_clients","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_contacts record {'contact_id': 'CT-11'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_contacts-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_contacts.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-crm_contacts","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_opportunities record {'opportunity_id': 'OP-11'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_opportunities-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_opportunities record {'opportunity_id': 'OP-12'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_opportunities-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_opportunities record {'opportunity_id': 'OP-13'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_opportunities-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_opportunities.","evidence":{"expected_count":3,"matching_rows":3},"id":"count-crm_opportunities","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_quotes.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_quotes","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_quote_lines.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_quote_lines","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_contracts.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_contracts","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_documents.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_documents","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_attachments.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_attachments","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_notes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1},"id":"count-crm_notes","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_requests record {'request_id': 'RQ-11'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_requests-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_requests record {'request_id': 'RQ-12'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_requests-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_requests.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-crm_requests","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_policies record {'policy_id': 'POL-1-onboarding-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_policies-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_policies record {'policy_id': 'POL-1-onboarding-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_policies-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_policies.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-crm_policies","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_prices.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_prices","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_approvals.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_approvals","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_permissions record {'permission_id': 'PERM-1-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_permissions-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_permissions record {'permission_id': 'PERM-1-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_permissions-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_permissions.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-crm_permissions","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Exactly the required domain writes, with no hidden extra mutation.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-mutations","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Kept every successful write inside arc-crm-001's declared state, collaboration, answer, and audit tables.","evidence":{"disallowed":[],"written_tables":["answers","crm_contacts","crm_notes","mutations"]},"id":"write_scope","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Completed without a rejected state-changing call; failed exploratory reads and retryable provider faults do not erase a correct outcome.","evidence":{"errors":[]},"id":"no_rejected_mutation","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":43},"id":"containment","passed":true,"weight":15.0},{"category":"handoff","description":"contact_onboarding: handoff","earned_weight":10.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":1,"subchecks":[{"description":"Handoff content contains the disclosed literal facts; punctuation/case/prose may vary. Not a semantic consistency check.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1},"id":"handoff-facts","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":1},"id":"handoff","passed":true,"weight":10.0},{"category":"answer","description":"contact_onboarding: answer","earned_weight":10.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":5,"subchecks":[{"description":"Report the correct client id.","evidence":{"expected":"C-11","field":"client_id","submitted":"C-11"},"id":"answer-client_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct contact id.","evidence":{"expected":"CT-12","field":"contact_id","submitted":"CT-12"},"id":"answer-contact_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct email.","evidence":{"expected":"robin@aster-freight.example","field":"email","submitted":"robin@aster-freight.example"},"id":"answer-email","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct source request id.","evidence":{"expected":"RQ-12","field":"source_request_id","submitted":"RQ-12"},"id":"answer-source_request_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct note id.","evidence":{"expected":"NT-1","field":"note_id","submitted":"NT-1"},"id":"answer-note_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":5},"id":"answer","passed":true,"weight":10.0}],"metric":"HubScore","passed_atomic_checks":59,"passed_checks":6,"passed_weight":100.0,"score":100.0,"strict_pass":true,"task_id":"arc-crm-001","total_atomic_checks":59,"total_checks":6,"total_weight":100.0}},"replay_sha256":"f62d5e78cfae44ed416a2f8f821e208aa8997a6f26087febbe0ec0d9f86fe495","task_id":"arc-crm-001","task_sha256":"3aacfd47b1393279b65c94fae125123573ec2f0276890f903f72bc87e267c700"},{"alternate_pass":true,"alternate_trace":[{"arguments":{},"index":0,"result":{"evidence_index":[{"asset_id":"E-2-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-2-request-1.eml","sha256":"1766eef7c79a1c6b1d8a139fadc4f41fe65b8fd54dd446dc12a0d9834bbbdada","source":"Boreal Instruments","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-2-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-2-request-2.eml","sha256":"98167575941e84a3e99a5e4da346b50e4035277cddd8e326ee18b410125f190a","source":"Boreal Instruments","title":"Owner request 2"},{"asset_id":"E-2-stage-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-2-stage-1.pdf","sha256":"b42766362c578f10b0545a7fe6ed04833cddfe564b57c1011ba98bf469d061d2","source":"Boreal Instruments","title":"Stage policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-2-stage-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-2-stage-2.pdf","sha256":"728fcfab71d6b529498639bab5095ebe3a0098aee562c63a5911757201fc36e4","source":"Boreal Instruments","title":"Stage policy revision 2"}],"identity":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-21"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-22"}],"organization":{"name":"Boreal Instruments","synthetic":true,"systems":["arccrm","desk","vault"]},"reference_records":{},"starting_records":[{"client_hint":"Boreal Instruments","thread_id":"TH-2"}],"state":{"network":"closed","persistence":"episode-local SQLite","scope":"isolated task snapshot"},"task":{"as_of":"2026-09-05","family":"arc-crm","role":"U-21","task_id":"arc-crm-002"},"tool_servers":[{"description":"Stateful synthetic CRM","name":"arccrm","tools":["arccrm.attachments.get","arccrm.attachments.search","arccrm.clients.get","arccrm.clients.search","arccrm.contacts.create","arccrm.contacts.get","arccrm.contacts.search","arccrm.contracts.create","arccrm.contracts.get","arccrm.contracts.search","arccrm.documents.attach","arccrm.documents.get","arccrm.documents.search","arccrm.notes.create","arccrm.notes.get","arccrm.notes.search","arccrm.opportunities.get","arccrm.opportunities.search","arccrm.opportunities.update","arccrm.quotes.cancel","arccrm.quotes.compare","arccrm.quotes.create","arccrm.quotes.get","arccrm.quotes.search"]},{"description":"Mock requests, permissions, approvals and versioned policy/price records","name":"desk","tools":["desk.approvals.get","desk.permissions.list","desk.policies.get","desk.prices.list","desk.requests.get","desk.requests.search"]},{"description":"Seeded synthetic evidence; no external file access","name":"vault","tools":["vault.files.get"]},{"description":"Benchmark-only discovery and structured answer submission controls.","name":"hubbench","tools":["hubbench.context.get","hubbench.submit_answer"]}]},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.context.get"},{"arguments":{},"index":1,"result":{"permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"opportunity:update","permission_id":"PERM-2-1","target_id":"OP-21","user_id":"U-21","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"opportunity:update","permission_id":"PERM-2-2","target_id":"OP-22","user_id":"U-21","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-2-3","target_id":"OP-21","user_id":"U-21","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"user_id":"U-21"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.permissions.list"},{"arguments":{"opportunity_id":"OP-22"},"index":2,"result":{"amount_minor":900000,"client_id":"C-21","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - west","opportunity_id":"OP-22","owner_id":"U-22","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"},{"arguments":{"opportunity_id":"OP-21"},"index":3,"result":{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-21","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-21","owner_id":"U-22","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"},{"arguments":{"policy_id":"POL-2-stage-2"},"index":4,"result":{"asset_id":"E-2-stage-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","operative":true,"policy_id":"POL-2-stage-2","revision":2,"rules":{"probability_by_stage":{"discovery":10,"lost":0,"negotiation":80,"proposal":50,"qualified":25,"won":100}},"rules_json":"{\"probability_by_stage\":{\"discovery\":10,\"lost\":0,\"negotiation\":80,\"proposal\":50,\"qualified\":25,\"won\":100}}","topic":"stage"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.policies.get"},{"arguments":{"query":"Boreal Instruments"},"index":5,"result":{"query":"boreal instruments","records":[{"client_id":"C-21","domain":"boreal-instruments.example","email":"billing@boreal-instruments.example","name":"Boreal Instruments","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-22","domain":"services-boreal-instruments.example","email":"billing@services-boreal-instruments.example","name":"Boreal Instruments Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-23","domain":"archive-boreal-instruments.example","email":"hold@archive-boreal-instruments.example","name":"Boreal Instruments Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"total":3},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.clients.search"},{"arguments":{"query":"TH-2"},"index":6,"result":{"query":"th-2","records":[{"asset_id":"E-2-request-1","body":"Move the west renewal to negotiation at 70%; that is the stage table I have locally.","client_id":"C-21","request_id":"RQ-21","sender_id":"U-22","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Apply the clarified renewal stage","thread_id":"TH-2"},{"asset_id":"E-2-request-2","body":"Correction: the east renewal OP-21 is the intended record, not west OP-22. Buyer confirmed negotiation. Use policy revision 2 (the 70% table was retired), preserve the existing amount and owner, and cite this clarification in the note.","client_id":"C-21","request_id":"RQ-22","sender_id":"U-22","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Apply the clarified renewal stage","thread_id":"TH-2"}],"total":2},"success":true,"tool":"desk.requests.search"},{"arguments":{"expected_revision":4,"opportunity_id":"OP-21","probability":80,"stage":"negotiation"},"index":7,"result":{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-21","currency":"USD","mutation_id":"arc-crm-002-mutation-01","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-21","owner_id":"U-22","probability":80,"revision":5,"stage":"negotiation"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.update"},{"arguments":{"content":"Operations handoff \u2014 verified records and facts: RQ-22; 80; negotiation; OP-21. Please review the linked evidence.","entity_id":"OP-21","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids":["E-2-stage-2","E-2-request-2"],"reference_ids":["OP-21"]},"index":8,"result":{"content":"Operations handoff \u2014 verified records and facts: RQ-22; 80; negotiation; OP-21. Please review the linked evidence.","entity_id":"OP-21","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-2-request-2\",\"E-2-stage-2\"]","mutation_id":"arc-crm-002-mutation-02","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"OP-21\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"arguments":{"opportunity_id":"OP-21"},"index":9,"result":{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-21","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-21","owner_id":"U-22","probability":80,"revision":5,"stage":"negotiation"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"},{"arguments":{"note_id":"NT-1"},"index":10,"result":{"content":"Operations handoff \u2014 verified records and facts: RQ-22; 80; negotiation; OP-21. Please review the linked evidence.","entity_id":"OP-21","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-2-request-2\",\"E-2-stage-2\"]","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"OP-21\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.get"},{"arguments":{"amount_minor":1800000,"note_id":"NT-1","opportunity_id":"OP-21","probability":80,"source_request_id":"RQ-22","stage":"negotiation"},"index":11,"result":{"accepted":true,"fields":{"amount_minor":"1800000","note_id":"NT-1","opportunity_id":"OP-21","probability":"80","source_request_id":"RQ-22","stage":"negotiation"},"task_id":"arc-crm-002"},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.submit_answer"}],"exact_replay":true,"negative_controls":[{"name":"noop","score":14.3,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945","verdict_sha256":"d6242134e00286ebbc8be41fee37b42d5b7f6d2c711b51aa290aac2ca37dde70"},{"name":"answer_only","score":24.3,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"131ab30842494bbdfc0565633b95a67ae3052a18c874c63b821221e7f8a0d4a5","verdict_sha256":"7c20b1dd74cdad545108a46c4d73bc5bc3de42ff29d8125c03a5f445f9db0b86"},{"name":"skip_investigation","score":80.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"015371ea4db91c511725aff3e48f27d2eccdd35fdfa35023d54be92f527f9942","verdict_sha256":"c72d8fc7250aded486e742a1b4b2d7d59841a8a6d45d0aa154d21de3202872a9"},{"name":"write_before_investigation","score":80.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"f4990296cd883ba5650ddce54d7d3fce0aed9e6cb002c9c5b1b959a4b4d8dd47","verdict_sha256":"cba3b46e0605044cb66ce6dd30e9c284b7417250a637c51d5d62c456a713cb3f"},{"name":"missing_readback","score":85.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"aa1c11b5ba66e6dfdc00d0ed095af608eaadfcb65249a735f8eb5930dd9433c8","verdict_sha256":"3f74450ac8d1d2a3d55ec2a0482abb0918175a6cfc59c7a74e158ccdbf470463"},{"name":"state_without_answer","score":90.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"ab72d890b4e5cc8842e25e5643bafbf3346c6631c6b5c394b21a670a3d8850c9","verdict_sha256":"3c720687fc62a103e8b85b27521f5bfff67d8becbb684b990289aaf54e172776"},{"name":"omit_read_1_desk.requests.search","score":96.67,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"b1b7214d30f156f7493082b7b30300a680acd8a5b9e02a821662118d2eea24be","verdict_sha256":"68e1759a4135cc039395db4de5ae7988c956d2dd4c14543abca607c61e843687"},{"name":"omit_read_2_arccrm.clients.search","score":96.67,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"729b3478f5e42e7e743ea9e06eb43bccac93baa5f55665ff53229b79a71bcd6d","verdict_sha256":"a375918a87b091d80635ab266151bb0af5cf916b65ed0b7ab397039f190fd362"},{"name":"omit_read_3_desk.policies.get","score":96.67,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"e6515ccbda5ade8529e4be47315b7e4a3eabf268846f55f847b1a4293095c750","verdict_sha256":"59c23162fef6cf084e2838abe10a9abaf9a7ffecba7f1429d44cf81192181ba0"},{"name":"omit_read_4_arccrm.opportunities.get","score":96.67,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"ea1c28b6560d468b3c01bd97685e57c6dc0b835308f112c869f362239f76d8bf","verdict_sha256":"64819bfb7a8a8682d924731b66e2587bf4621743f0d272191dd2bc32700c67c0"},{"name":"omit_read_5_arccrm.opportunities.get","score":96.67,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"83c29aeff00f22f352104b9bed80bf582acdeb759dbabc35feea8197ee260ae8","verdict_sha256":"108cc6c9bf147482b182dae889d0688f91acf0a56c4d026f3a10a1365dc56a51"},{"name":"omit_read_6_desk.permissions.list","score":96.67,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"9e089163aa8a82e943c26f3962dad85c662b140b408f3a47c9bad1644cccaf17","verdict_sha256":"4172353258210cd9cad42c9d48e7d583e4f3673ca4d11e9a25b2989fb5e509b5"},{"name":"omit_mutation_7_arccrm.opportunities.update","score":77.15,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"69bce748cd576b3ddd0fb4726a2769169e23a75a48b56c7154125576d2751e90","verdict_sha256":"e6b30a122c94d8ed00ff107febf1ef74ebc4e214f48bb4fba096fd9b23ab2ba5"},{"name":"omit_mutation_8_arccrm.notes.create","score":66.8,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"3110b873cebf856960d5a5ef686134a4101e14b0345c3419d158b075b72f58bc","verdict_sha256":"a779167588c9088527a66f6bf85df4a5da690efdcd977c6701b150a3a919194b"},{"name":"omit_read_9_arccrm.opportunities.get","score":92.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"f45c8eecbc068eb58ce03216dc07033ca6fe4724a1b309230c620bf6fded4e12","verdict_sha256":"22cd2d8271bc6532260c0c5eedb46665a5d92fe8c08822d0e4aacab7d43d52fa"},{"name":"omit_read_10_arccrm.notes.get","score":92.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"065b13a1df55a1847c6b480cac512dd46ea49d6d7fbadcbfb7c143b7c00e11e5","verdict_sha256":"46ca1a1e21c16cae2b96537a2b28660ea55ddcb8126b5526168de64f5fdeeb1c"},{"name":"superseded_request","score":96.67,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"d9a62863423d341b359847a922cfec35107a061f2c71476edc5d9b92fcc4dc77","verdict_sha256":"f1af3510e81b87b260cad8225b72080a75c39cf2b4bbae7ab9388219b11e472b"},{"name":"retired_policy","score":96.67,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"f58d9f6e6ee1db000e8f1d71805c7799383c381951f5762690be508e4c8e7094","verdict_sha256":"2332f44664d985887dad72d724dcd6fc24488ed6e0e5a0e0a0fffa5bc1ce617b"},{"name":"wrong_answer","score":98.33,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"eed2cde654dbe4b7aa79a64a97ab28a821e54591eab688aef74a996e53e02c07","verdict_sha256":"15baccf89ec95b67e34c41ea36590288697ffc46127c2bbf90bf7dacfaf5ca3b"},{"name":"missing_literal_handoff_facts","score":90.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"fe3a847238e079b7c7bbed14a8ed7cc3430fea9b5fb0e515049864ba006482e2","verdict_sha256":"043cd14c83987f8fa23b9c03cd71f908d3bcf935b8b8ea3a55dfb33d62c16816"},{"name":"stale_handoff_evidence","score":77.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"7e96503abdcfb38fbc7673ab788159eaa360aa6b0c54c759650f488077062799","verdict_sha256":"532249b927b86dfbd3fe0cc426eebdf10aba66837a7678b0f8066bdd82cc63c2"},{"name":"wrong_authorized_entity","score":99.3,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"4fced471cebf4ef575b6f977f3869ea2f810f73c3f07605a55ffc89e955c288e","verdict_sha256":"5bc1f525fc55dde78add03710e7a93afa03b2b931575bcd262e83402026f049d"},{"name":"retired_probability","score":99.65,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"1d83483a63be19b1beebd678572a285ebdd8f494797b419b3cdb18e5e1c2b42f","verdict_sha256":"b867e281b39a1dd251a42ce62943b16b8a185e2a529a996bb89bbd0ed284dc36"},{"name":"unauthorized_amount","score":99.65,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"404997bab705acf6b063f0f5cbe1b7a984e7ca5f2617e8cac3e9ffedc8fa371f","verdict_sha256":"8c50fc772cab9817f965eeea806c92d0b2a3d403692c74f446d46da82e183d8d"},{"name":"stale_revision","score":99.65,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"c60c1b5bd6fa9dea1e96cf371de2d70e89f0d60362ea9fefa0d2311b867b48df","verdict_sha256":"16db70a2775b625d47f1bff159a8a5c93ba9054deb8b023e4dee2140a9c578ee"}],"oracle":{"final_state":{"answers":[{"field":"amount_minor","task_id":"arc-crm-002","value":"1800000"},{"field":"note_id","task_id":"arc-crm-002","value":"NT-1"},{"field":"opportunity_id","task_id":"arc-crm-002","value":"OP-21"},{"field":"probability","task_id":"arc-crm-002","value":"80"},{"field":"source_request_id","task_id":"arc-crm-002","value":"RQ-22"},{"field":"stage","task_id":"arc-crm-002","value":"negotiation"}],"audit_log":[{"action":"updated","audit_id":1,"payload":"{\"expected_revision\":4,\"opportunity_id\":\"OP-21\",\"probability\":80,\"stage\":\"negotiation\"}","record_id":"OP-21","table_name":"crm_opportunities","task_id":"arc-crm-002","tool":"arccrm.opportunities.update"},{"action":"insert","audit_id":2,"payload":"{\"arguments\":{\"expected_revision\":4,\"opportunity_id\":\"OP-21\",\"probability\":80,\"stage\":\"negotiation\"},\"tool\":\"arccrm.opportunities.update\"}","record_id":"arc-crm-002-mutation-01","table_name":"mutations","task_id":"arc-crm-002","tool":"arccrm.opportunities.update"},{"action":"created","audit_id":3,"payload":"{\"content\":\"OP-21 is negotiation / 80 percent per RQ-22; amount and owner unchanged.\",\"entity_id\":\"OP-21\",\"entity_type\":\"opportunity\",\"evidence_ids\":[\"E-2-request-2\",\"E-2-stage-2\"],\"reference_ids\":[\"OP-21\"]}","record_id":"NT-1","table_name":"crm_notes","task_id":"arc-crm-002","tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"action":"insert","audit_id":4,"payload":"{\"arguments\":{\"content\":\"OP-21 is negotiation / 80 percent per RQ-22; amount and owner unchanged.\",\"entity_id\":\"OP-21\",\"entity_type\":\"opportunity\",\"evidence_ids\":[\"E-2-request-2\",\"E-2-stage-2\"],\"reference_ids\":[\"OP-21\"]},\"tool\":\"arccrm.notes.create\"}","record_id":"arc-crm-002-mutation-02","table_name":"mutations","task_id":"arc-crm-002","tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"action":"submit","audit_id":5,"payload":"{\"amount_minor\":\"1800000\",\"note_id\":\"NT-1\",\"opportunity_id\":\"OP-21\",\"probability\":\"80\",\"source_request_id\":\"RQ-22\",\"stage\":\"negotiation\"}","record_id":"arc-crm-002","table_name":"answers","task_id":"arc-crm-002","tool":"hubbench.submit_answer"}],"crm_approvals":[],"crm_attachments":[],"crm_clients":[{"client_id":"C-21","domain":"boreal-instruments.example","email":"billing@boreal-instruments.example","name":"Boreal Instruments","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-22","domain":"services-boreal-instruments.example","email":"billing@services-boreal-instruments.example","name":"Boreal Instruments Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-23","domain":"archive-boreal-instruments.example","email":"hold@archive-boreal-instruments.example","name":"Boreal Instruments Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"crm_contacts":[{"client_id":"C-21","contact_id":"CT-21","email":"jamie@boreal-instruments.example","first_name":"Jamie","last_name":"Park","revision":1,"title":"Procurement lead"}],"crm_contracts":[],"crm_documents":[],"crm_evidence":[{"asset_id":"E-2-request-1","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@boreal-instruments.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@boreal-instruments.example>\nSubject: Apply the clarified renewal stage\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nMove the west renewal to negotiation at 70%; that is the stage table I have locally.\n"},{"asset_id":"E-2-request-2","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@boreal-instruments.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@boreal-instruments.example>\nSubject: Apply the clarified renewal stage\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nCorrection: the east renewal OP-21 is the intended record, not west OP-22. Buyer confirmed negotiation. Use policy revision 2 (the 70% table was retired), preserve the existing amount and owner, and cite this clarification in the note.\n"},{"asset_id":"E-2-stage-1","content":"Boreal Instruments\nEffective 2025-01-01 through 2026-08-31.\n{\"probability_by_stage\":{\"negotiation\":70}}\n"},{"asset_id":"E-2-stage-2","content":"Boreal Instruments\nEffective 2026-09-01 through 2026-12-31.\n{\"probability_by_stage\":{\"discovery\":10,\"lost\":0,\"negotiation\":80,\"proposal\":50,\"qualified\":25,\"won\":100}}\n"}],"crm_notes":[{"content":"OP-21 is negotiation / 80 percent per RQ-22; amount and owner unchanged.","entity_id":"OP-21","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-2-request-2\",\"E-2-stage-2\"]","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"OP-21\"]"}],"crm_opportunities":[{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-21","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-21","owner_id":"U-22","probability":80,"revision":5,"stage":"negotiation"},{"amount_minor":900000,"client_id":"C-21","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - west","opportunity_id":"OP-22","owner_id":"U-22","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-22","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-23","owner_id":"U-22","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"}],"crm_permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"opportunity:update","permission_id":"PERM-2-1","target_id":"OP-21","user_id":"U-21","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"opportunity:update","permission_id":"PERM-2-2","target_id":"OP-22","user_id":"U-21","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-2-3","target_id":"OP-21","user_id":"U-21","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"crm_policies":[{"asset_id":"E-2-stage-1","effective_from":"2025-01-01","effective_until":"2026-08-31","policy_id":"POL-2-stage-1","revision":1,"rules_json":"{\"probability_by_stage\":{\"negotiation\":70}}","topic":"stage"},{"asset_id":"E-2-stage-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","policy_id":"POL-2-stage-2","revision":2,"rules_json":"{\"probability_by_stage\":{\"discovery\":10,\"lost\":0,\"negotiation\":80,\"proposal\":50,\"qualified\":25,\"won\":100}}","topic":"stage"}],"crm_prices":[],"crm_quote_lines":[],"crm_quotes":[],"crm_requests":[{"asset_id":"E-2-request-1","body":"Move the west renewal to negotiation at 70%; that is the stage table I have locally.","client_id":"C-21","request_id":"RQ-21","sender_id":"U-22","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Apply the clarified renewal stage","thread_id":"TH-2"},{"asset_id":"E-2-request-2","body":"Correction: the east renewal OP-21 is the intended record, not west OP-22. Buyer confirmed negotiation. Use policy revision 2 (the 70% table was retired), preserve the existing amount and owner, and cite this clarification in the note.","client_id":"C-21","request_id":"RQ-22","sender_id":"U-22","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Apply the clarified renewal stage","thread_id":"TH-2"}],"evidence_files":[{"asset_id":"E-2-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-2-request-1.eml","sha256":"1766eef7c79a1c6b1d8a139fadc4f41fe65b8fd54dd446dc12a0d9834bbbdada","source":"Boreal Instruments","task_id":"arc-crm-002","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-2-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-2-request-2.eml","sha256":"98167575941e84a3e99a5e4da346b50e4035277cddd8e326ee18b410125f190a","source":"Boreal Instruments","task_id":"arc-crm-002","title":"Owner request 2"},{"asset_id":"E-2-stage-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-2-stage-1.pdf","sha256":"b42766362c578f10b0545a7fe6ed04833cddfe564b57c1011ba98bf469d061d2","source":"Boreal Instruments","task_id":"arc-crm-002","title":"Stage policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-2-stage-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-2-stage-2.pdf","sha256":"728fcfab71d6b529498639bab5095ebe3a0098aee562c63a5911757201fc36e4","source":"Boreal Instruments","task_id":"arc-crm-002","title":"Stage policy revision 2"}],"mutations":[{"effective_at":"2026-09-05T09:07:00","mutation_id":"arc-crm-002-mutation-01","payload_json":"{\"arguments\":{\"expected_revision\":4,\"opportunity_id\":\"OP-21\",\"probability\":80,\"stage\":\"negotiation\"},\"tool\":\"arccrm.opportunities.update\"}","record_id":"OP-21","revision":1,"sequence":1,"status":"updated","table_name":"crm_opportunities","task_id":"arc-crm-002","tool":"arccrm.opportunities.update"},{"effective_at":"2026-09-05T09:08:00","mutation_id":"arc-crm-002-mutation-02","payload_json":"{\"arguments\":{\"content\":\"OP-21 is negotiation / 80 percent per RQ-22; amount and owner unchanged.\",\"entity_id\":\"OP-21\",\"entity_type\":\"opportunity\",\"evidence_ids\":[\"E-2-request-2\",\"E-2-stage-2\"],\"reference_ids\":[\"OP-21\"]},\"tool\":\"arccrm.notes.create\"}","record_id":"NT-1","revision":1,"sequence":2,"status":"created","table_name":"crm_notes","task_id":"arc-crm-002","tool":"arccrm.notes.create"}],"users":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-21"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-22"}]},"initial_state":{"answers":[],"audit_log":[],"crm_approvals":[],"crm_attachments":[],"crm_clients":[{"client_id":"C-21","domain":"boreal-instruments.example","email":"billing@boreal-instruments.example","name":"Boreal Instruments","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-22","domain":"services-boreal-instruments.example","email":"billing@services-boreal-instruments.example","name":"Boreal Instruments Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-23","domain":"archive-boreal-instruments.example","email":"hold@archive-boreal-instruments.example","name":"Boreal Instruments Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"crm_contacts":[{"client_id":"C-21","contact_id":"CT-21","email":"jamie@boreal-instruments.example","first_name":"Jamie","last_name":"Park","revision":1,"title":"Procurement lead"}],"crm_contracts":[],"crm_documents":[],"crm_evidence":[{"asset_id":"E-2-request-1","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@boreal-instruments.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@boreal-instruments.example>\nSubject: Apply the clarified renewal stage\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nMove the west renewal to negotiation at 70%; that is the stage table I have locally.\n"},{"asset_id":"E-2-request-2","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@boreal-instruments.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@boreal-instruments.example>\nSubject: Apply the clarified renewal stage\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nCorrection: the east renewal OP-21 is the intended record, not west OP-22. Buyer confirmed negotiation. Use policy revision 2 (the 70% table was retired), preserve the existing amount and owner, and cite this clarification in the note.\n"},{"asset_id":"E-2-stage-1","content":"Boreal Instruments\nEffective 2025-01-01 through 2026-08-31.\n{\"probability_by_stage\":{\"negotiation\":70}}\n"},{"asset_id":"E-2-stage-2","content":"Boreal Instruments\nEffective 2026-09-01 through 2026-12-31.\n{\"probability_by_stage\":{\"discovery\":10,\"lost\":0,\"negotiation\":80,\"proposal\":50,\"qualified\":25,\"won\":100}}\n"}],"crm_notes":[],"crm_opportunities":[{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-21","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-21","owner_id":"U-22","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":900000,"client_id":"C-21","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - west","opportunity_id":"OP-22","owner_id":"U-22","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-22","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-23","owner_id":"U-22","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"}],"crm_permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"opportunity:update","permission_id":"PERM-2-1","target_id":"OP-21","user_id":"U-21","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"opportunity:update","permission_id":"PERM-2-2","target_id":"OP-22","user_id":"U-21","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-2-3","target_id":"OP-21","user_id":"U-21","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"crm_policies":[{"asset_id":"E-2-stage-1","effective_from":"2025-01-01","effective_until":"2026-08-31","policy_id":"POL-2-stage-1","revision":1,"rules_json":"{\"probability_by_stage\":{\"negotiation\":70}}","topic":"stage"},{"asset_id":"E-2-stage-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","policy_id":"POL-2-stage-2","revision":2,"rules_json":"{\"probability_by_stage\":{\"discovery\":10,\"lost\":0,\"negotiation\":80,\"proposal\":50,\"qualified\":25,\"won\":100}}","topic":"stage"}],"crm_prices":[],"crm_quote_lines":[],"crm_quotes":[],"crm_requests":[{"asset_id":"E-2-request-1","body":"Move the west renewal to negotiation at 70%; that is the stage table I have locally.","client_id":"C-21","request_id":"RQ-21","sender_id":"U-22","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Apply the clarified renewal stage","thread_id":"TH-2"},{"asset_id":"E-2-request-2","body":"Correction: the east renewal OP-21 is the intended record, not west OP-22. Buyer confirmed negotiation. Use policy revision 2 (the 70% table was retired), preserve the existing amount and owner, and cite this clarification in the note.","client_id":"C-21","request_id":"RQ-22","sender_id":"U-22","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Apply the clarified renewal stage","thread_id":"TH-2"}],"evidence_files":[{"asset_id":"E-2-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-2-request-1.eml","sha256":"1766eef7c79a1c6b1d8a139fadc4f41fe65b8fd54dd446dc12a0d9834bbbdada","source":"Boreal Instruments","task_id":"arc-crm-002","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-2-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-2-request-2.eml","sha256":"98167575941e84a3e99a5e4da346b50e4035277cddd8e326ee18b410125f190a","source":"Boreal Instruments","task_id":"arc-crm-002","title":"Owner request 2"},{"asset_id":"E-2-stage-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-2-stage-1.pdf","sha256":"b42766362c578f10b0545a7fe6ed04833cddfe564b57c1011ba98bf469d061d2","source":"Boreal Instruments","task_id":"arc-crm-002","title":"Stage policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-2-stage-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-2-stage-2.pdf","sha256":"728fcfab71d6b529498639bab5095ebe3a0098aee562c63a5911757201fc36e4","source":"Boreal Instruments","task_id":"arc-crm-002","title":"Stage policy revision 2"}],"mutations":[],"users":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-21"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-22"}]},"trace":[{"arguments":{},"index":0,"result":{"evidence_index":[{"asset_id":"E-2-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-2-request-1.eml","sha256":"1766eef7c79a1c6b1d8a139fadc4f41fe65b8fd54dd446dc12a0d9834bbbdada","source":"Boreal Instruments","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-2-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-2-request-2.eml","sha256":"98167575941e84a3e99a5e4da346b50e4035277cddd8e326ee18b410125f190a","source":"Boreal Instruments","title":"Owner request 2"},{"asset_id":"E-2-stage-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-2-stage-1.pdf","sha256":"b42766362c578f10b0545a7fe6ed04833cddfe564b57c1011ba98bf469d061d2","source":"Boreal Instruments","title":"Stage policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-2-stage-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-2-stage-2.pdf","sha256":"728fcfab71d6b529498639bab5095ebe3a0098aee562c63a5911757201fc36e4","source":"Boreal Instruments","title":"Stage policy revision 2"}],"identity":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-21"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-22"}],"organization":{"name":"Boreal Instruments","synthetic":true,"systems":["arccrm","desk","vault"]},"reference_records":{},"starting_records":[{"client_hint":"Boreal Instruments","thread_id":"TH-2"}],"state":{"network":"closed","persistence":"episode-local SQLite","scope":"isolated task snapshot"},"task":{"as_of":"2026-09-05","family":"arc-crm","role":"U-21","task_id":"arc-crm-002"},"tool_servers":[{"description":"Stateful synthetic CRM","name":"arccrm","tools":["arccrm.attachments.get","arccrm.attachments.search","arccrm.clients.get","arccrm.clients.search","arccrm.contacts.create","arccrm.contacts.get","arccrm.contacts.search","arccrm.contracts.create","arccrm.contracts.get","arccrm.contracts.search","arccrm.documents.attach","arccrm.documents.get","arccrm.documents.search","arccrm.notes.create","arccrm.notes.get","arccrm.notes.search","arccrm.opportunities.get","arccrm.opportunities.search","arccrm.opportunities.update","arccrm.quotes.cancel","arccrm.quotes.compare","arccrm.quotes.create","arccrm.quotes.get","arccrm.quotes.search"]},{"description":"Mock requests, permissions, approvals and versioned policy/price records","name":"desk","tools":["desk.approvals.get","desk.permissions.list","desk.policies.get","desk.prices.list","desk.requests.get","desk.requests.search"]},{"description":"Seeded synthetic evidence; no external file access","name":"vault","tools":["vault.files.get"]},{"description":"Benchmark-only discovery and structured answer submission controls.","name":"hubbench","tools":["hubbench.context.get","hubbench.submit_answer"]}]},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.context.get"},{"arguments":{"query":"TH-2"},"index":1,"result":{"query":"th-2","records":[{"asset_id":"E-2-request-1","body":"Move the west renewal to negotiation at 70%; that is the stage table I have locally.","client_id":"C-21","request_id":"RQ-21","sender_id":"U-22","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Apply the clarified renewal stage","thread_id":"TH-2"},{"asset_id":"E-2-request-2","body":"Correction: the east renewal OP-21 is the intended record, not west OP-22. Buyer confirmed negotiation. Use policy revision 2 (the 70% table was retired), preserve the existing amount and owner, and cite this clarification in the note.","client_id":"C-21","request_id":"RQ-22","sender_id":"U-22","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Apply the clarified renewal stage","thread_id":"TH-2"}],"total":2},"success":true,"tool":"desk.requests.search"},{"arguments":{"query":"Boreal Instruments"},"index":2,"result":{"query":"boreal instruments","records":[{"client_id":"C-21","domain":"boreal-instruments.example","email":"billing@boreal-instruments.example","name":"Boreal Instruments","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-22","domain":"services-boreal-instruments.example","email":"billing@services-boreal-instruments.example","name":"Boreal Instruments Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-23","domain":"archive-boreal-instruments.example","email":"hold@archive-boreal-instruments.example","name":"Boreal Instruments Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"total":3},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.clients.search"},{"arguments":{"policy_id":"POL-2-stage-2"},"index":3,"result":{"asset_id":"E-2-stage-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","operative":true,"policy_id":"POL-2-stage-2","revision":2,"rules":{"probability_by_stage":{"discovery":10,"lost":0,"negotiation":80,"proposal":50,"qualified":25,"won":100}},"rules_json":"{\"probability_by_stage\":{\"discovery\":10,\"lost\":0,\"negotiation\":80,\"proposal\":50,\"qualified\":25,\"won\":100}}","topic":"stage"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.policies.get"},{"arguments":{"opportunity_id":"OP-21"},"index":4,"result":{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-21","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-21","owner_id":"U-22","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"},{"arguments":{"opportunity_id":"OP-22"},"index":5,"result":{"amount_minor":900000,"client_id":"C-21","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - west","opportunity_id":"OP-22","owner_id":"U-22","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"},{"arguments":{},"index":6,"result":{"permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"opportunity:update","permission_id":"PERM-2-1","target_id":"OP-21","user_id":"U-21","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"opportunity:update","permission_id":"PERM-2-2","target_id":"OP-22","user_id":"U-21","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-2-3","target_id":"OP-21","user_id":"U-21","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"user_id":"U-21"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.permissions.list"},{"arguments":{"expected_revision":4,"opportunity_id":"OP-21","probability":80,"stage":"negotiation"},"index":7,"result":{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-21","currency":"USD","mutation_id":"arc-crm-002-mutation-01","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-21","owner_id":"U-22","probability":80,"revision":5,"stage":"negotiation"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.update"},{"arguments":{"content":"OP-21 is negotiation / 80 percent per RQ-22; amount and owner unchanged.","entity_id":"OP-21","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids":["E-2-request-2","E-2-stage-2"],"reference_ids":["OP-21"]},"index":8,"result":{"content":"OP-21 is negotiation / 80 percent per RQ-22; amount and owner unchanged.","entity_id":"OP-21","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-2-request-2\",\"E-2-stage-2\"]","mutation_id":"arc-crm-002-mutation-02","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"OP-21\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"arguments":{"opportunity_id":"OP-21"},"index":9,"result":{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-21","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-21","owner_id":"U-22","probability":80,"revision":5,"stage":"negotiation"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"},{"arguments":{"note_id":"NT-1"},"index":10,"result":{"content":"OP-21 is negotiation / 80 percent per RQ-22; amount and owner unchanged.","entity_id":"OP-21","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-2-request-2\",\"E-2-stage-2\"]","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"OP-21\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.get"},{"arguments":{"amount_minor":1800000,"note_id":"NT-1","opportunity_id":"OP-21","probability":80,"source_request_id":"RQ-22","stage":"negotiation"},"index":11,"result":{"accepted":true,"fields":{"amount_minor":"1800000","note_id":"NT-1","opportunity_id":"OP-21","probability":"80","source_request_id":"RQ-22","stage":"negotiation"},"task_id":"arc-crm-002"},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.submit_answer"}],"verdict":{"checks":[{"category":"evidence","description":"stage_correction: evidence","earned_weight":20.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":6,"subchecks":[{"description":"Resolve the owner's current clarification, not the superseded message.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":1,"tool":"desk.requests.search"}]},"id":"investigate-current_request","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Identify the existing verified client and the similarly named account.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":2,"tool":"arccrm.clients.search"}]},"id":"investigate-verified_client","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the operative policy and its scope.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":3,"tool":"desk.policies.get"}]},"id":"investigate-operative_policy","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the precise opportunity identity, owner, revision and commercial fields.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":4,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"},{"index":5,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"}]},"id":"investigate-opportunity","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the precise opportunity identity, owner, revision and commercial fields.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":4,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"},{"index":5,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"}]},"id":"investigate-other_opportunity","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the acting role's specific operation/target grants before writing.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":6,"tool":"desk.permissions.list"}]},"id":"investigate-authority","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":6},"id":"evidence","passed":true,"weight":20.0},{"category":"readback","description":"stage_correction: readback","earned_weight":15.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":2,"subchecks":[{"description":"Read back the persisted opportunity after the business mutation.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":4,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"},{"index":5,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"},{"index":9,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"}]},"id":"readback-opportunity","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read back the persisted handoff after the business mutation.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":10,"tool":"arccrm.notes.get"}]},"id":"readback-handoff","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":2},"id":"readback","passed":true,"weight":15.0},{"category":"outcome","description":"stage_correction: outcome","earned_weight":30.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":2,"subchecks":[{"description":"Preserve crm_opportunities record {'opportunity_id': 'OP-21'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_opportunities-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Persist the required crm_notes record and exact structural fields.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"create-crm_notes-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":2},"id":"outcome","passed":true,"weight":30.0},{"category":"containment","description":"stage_correction: containment","earned_weight":15.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":43,"subchecks":[{"description":"Preserve users record {'user_id': 'U-21'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-users-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve users record {'user_id': 'U-22'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-users-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in users.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-users","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-2-request-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-2-request-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-2-stage-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-2-stage-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-3","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in evidence_files.","evidence":{"expected_count":4,"matching_rows":4},"id":"count-evidence_files","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-2-request-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-2-request-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-2-stage-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-2-stage-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-3","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_evidence.","evidence":{"expected_count":4,"matching_rows":4},"id":"count-crm_evidence","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_clients record {'client_id': 'C-21'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_clients-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_clients record {'client_id': 'C-22'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_clients-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_clients record {'client_id': 'C-23'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_clients-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_clients.","evidence":{"expected_count":3,"matching_rows":3},"id":"count-crm_clients","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_contacts record {'contact_id': 'CT-21'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_contacts-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_contacts.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1},"id":"count-crm_contacts","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_opportunities record {'opportunity_id': 'OP-22'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_opportunities-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_opportunities record {'opportunity_id': 'OP-23'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_opportunities-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_opportunities.","evidence":{"expected_count":3,"matching_rows":3},"id":"count-crm_opportunities","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_quotes.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_quotes","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_quote_lines.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_quote_lines","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_contracts.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_contracts","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_documents.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_documents","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_attachments.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_attachments","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_notes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1},"id":"count-crm_notes","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_requests record {'request_id': 'RQ-21'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_requests-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_requests record {'request_id': 'RQ-22'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_requests-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_requests.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-crm_requests","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_policies record {'policy_id': 'POL-2-stage-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_policies-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_policies record {'policy_id': 'POL-2-stage-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_policies-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_policies.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-crm_policies","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_prices.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_prices","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_approvals.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_approvals","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_permissions record {'permission_id': 'PERM-2-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_permissions-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_permissions record {'permission_id': 'PERM-2-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_permissions-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_permissions record {'permission_id': 'PERM-2-3'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_permissions-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_permissions.","evidence":{"expected_count":3,"matching_rows":3},"id":"count-crm_permissions","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Exactly the required domain writes, with no hidden extra mutation.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-mutations","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Kept every successful write inside arc-crm-002's declared state, collaboration, answer, and audit tables.","evidence":{"disallowed":[],"written_tables":["answers","crm_notes","crm_opportunities","mutations"]},"id":"write_scope","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Completed without a rejected state-changing call; failed exploratory reads and retryable provider faults do not erase a correct outcome.","evidence":{"errors":[]},"id":"no_rejected_mutation","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":43},"id":"containment","passed":true,"weight":15.0},{"category":"handoff","description":"stage_correction: handoff","earned_weight":10.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":1,"subchecks":[{"description":"Handoff content contains the disclosed literal facts; punctuation/case/prose may vary. Not a semantic consistency check.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1},"id":"handoff-facts","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":1},"id":"handoff","passed":true,"weight":10.0},{"category":"answer","description":"stage_correction: answer","earned_weight":10.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":6,"subchecks":[{"description":"Report the correct opportunity id.","evidence":{"expected":"OP-21","field":"opportunity_id","submitted":"OP-21"},"id":"answer-opportunity_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct stage.","evidence":{"expected":"negotiation","field":"stage","submitted":"negotiation"},"id":"answer-stage","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct probability.","evidence":{"expected":"80","field":"probability","submitted":"80"},"id":"answer-probability","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct amount minor.","evidence":{"expected":"1800000","field":"amount_minor","submitted":"1800000"},"id":"answer-amount_minor","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct source request id.","evidence":{"expected":"RQ-22","field":"source_request_id","submitted":"RQ-22"},"id":"answer-source_request_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct note id.","evidence":{"expected":"NT-1","field":"note_id","submitted":"NT-1"},"id":"answer-note_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":6},"id":"answer","passed":true,"weight":10.0}],"metric":"HubScore","passed_atomic_checks":60,"passed_checks":6,"passed_weight":100.0,"score":100.0,"strict_pass":true,"task_id":"arc-crm-002","total_atomic_checks":60,"total_checks":6,"total_weight":100.0}},"replay_sha256":"332526fa37ecf018bfa27e4b80ac83f1d3bc3e18c2a9fda4fd5c2371a1df0916","task_id":"arc-crm-002","task_sha256":"ce819e9e0cf674adee742b1b98e757224314443bb87632c811b1ad2f0396df78"},{"alternate_pass":true,"alternate_trace":[{"arguments":{},"index":0,"result":{"evidence_index":[{"asset_id":"E-3-approval-current","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"text/markdown","path":"assets/E-3-approval-current.md","sha256":"11ec28232266a0473a79836c2d2a284f4ea83ededd119be166d015d8aa60fb89","source":"Cedar Analytics","title":"Current commercial approval"},{"asset_id":"E-3-approval-expired","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"text/markdown","path":"assets/E-3-approval-expired.md","sha256":"761a0177e47e777b02220ce24c3c6fc10674d79bd72bfa419d42a8e04fa059a3","source":"Cedar Analytics","title":"Expired commercial approval"},{"asset_id":"E-3-pricebook","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.spreadsheetml.sheet","path":"assets/E-3-pricebook.xlsx","sha256":"3b8a342d7794acf4de0be1e0b4297dcc818717f45d53761ec6b6f3ceb21a5679","source":"Cedar Analytics","title":"Pricebook with current and retired prices"},{"asset_id":"E-3-pricing-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-3-pricing-1.pdf","sha256":"4be93faa6b7e28366f15ac64397d79a7f5aa12b49b52e36ea9041ce46cefdc19","source":"Cedar Analytics","title":"Pricing policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-3-pricing-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-3-pricing-2.pdf","sha256":"13897ad470ec7e51017b8c028c176259947686d5c043bcf2e05ca0721d9884e7","source":"Cedar Analytics","title":"Pricing policy revision 2"},{"asset_id":"E-3-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-3-request-1.eml","sha256":"a0936361d261f883809f1d9f8d42c79ab3d6edc1c25e4fb5bd37d7dd484a59da","source":"Cedar Analytics","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-3-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-3-request-2.eml","sha256":"933ff41d1f4e622c9c376095a69c083f2e09610f6dbfd120c90d76f30ef0561d","source":"Cedar Analytics","title":"Owner request 2"}],"identity":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-31"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-32"}],"organization":{"name":"Cedar Analytics","synthetic":true,"systems":["arccrm","desk","vault"]},"reference_records":{},"starting_records":[{"client_hint":"Cedar Analytics","thread_id":"TH-3"}],"state":{"network":"closed","persistence":"episode-local SQLite","scope":"isolated task snapshot"},"task":{"as_of":"2026-09-05","family":"arc-crm","role":"U-31","task_id":"arc-crm-003"},"tool_servers":[{"description":"Stateful synthetic CRM","name":"arccrm","tools":["arccrm.attachments.get","arccrm.attachments.search","arccrm.clients.get","arccrm.clients.search","arccrm.contacts.create","arccrm.contacts.get","arccrm.contacts.search","arccrm.contracts.create","arccrm.contracts.get","arccrm.contracts.search","arccrm.documents.attach","arccrm.documents.get","arccrm.documents.search","arccrm.notes.create","arccrm.notes.get","arccrm.notes.search","arccrm.opportunities.get","arccrm.opportunities.search","arccrm.opportunities.update","arccrm.quotes.cancel","arccrm.quotes.compare","arccrm.quotes.create","arccrm.quotes.get","arccrm.quotes.search"]},{"description":"Mock requests, permissions, approvals and versioned policy/price records","name":"desk","tools":["desk.approvals.get","desk.permissions.list","desk.policies.get","desk.prices.list","desk.requests.get","desk.requests.search"]},{"description":"Seeded synthetic evidence; no external file access","name":"vault","tools":["vault.files.get"]},{"description":"Benchmark-only discovery and structured answer submission controls.","name":"hubbench","tools":["hubbench.context.get","hubbench.submit_answer"]}]},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.context.get"},{"arguments":{},"index":1,"result":{"permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"quote:create","permission_id":"PERM-3-1","target_id":"OP-31","user_id":"U-31","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-3-2","target_id":"OP-31","user_id":"U-31","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"user_id":"U-31"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.permissions.list"},{"arguments":{"quote_ids":["Q-31","Q-32"]},"index":2,"result":{"quotes":[{"amount_minor":1500000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"lines":[],"opportunity_id":"OP-31","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-31","status":"cancelled","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":1},{"amount_minor":900000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"lines":[],"opportunity_id":"OP-32","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-32","status":"signed","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":1}],"spread_minor":600000},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.compare"},{"arguments":{"approval_id":"AP-3-current"},"index":3,"result":{"approval_id":"AP-3-current","asset_id":"E-3-approval-current","currency":"USD","expires_on":"2026-09-25","max_discount_bps":1000,"max_gross_minor":2000000,"opportunity_id":"OP-31","status":"approved"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.approvals.get"},{"arguments":{"currency":"USD"},"index":4,"result":{"prices":[{"currency":"USD","revision":1,"sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":124000,"valid_from":"2026-01-01","valid_until":"2026-08-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":2,"sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":125000,"valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-12-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":1,"sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":249000,"valid_from":"2026-01-01","valid_until":"2026-08-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":2,"sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":250000,"valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-12-31"}]},"success":true,"tool":"desk.prices.list"},{"arguments":{"opportunity_id":"OP-31"},"index":5,"result":{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-31","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-31","owner_id":"U-32","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"},{"arguments":{"policy_id":"POL-3-pricing-2"},"index":6,"result":{"asset_id":"E-3-pricing-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","operative":true,"policy_id":"POL-3-pricing-2","revision":2,"rules":{"approval":"current and scoped","currency":"opportunity currency","new_status":"draft","one_open_quote_per_opportunity":true,"rounding":"invoice-level half-up minor units"},"rules_json":"{\"approval\":\"current and scoped\",\"currency\":\"opportunity currency\",\"new_status\":\"draft\",\"one_open_quote_per_opportunity\":true,\"rounding\":\"invoice-level half-up minor units\"}","topic":"pricing"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.policies.get"},{"arguments":{"query":"Cedar Analytics"},"index":7,"result":{"query":"cedar analytics","records":[{"client_id":"C-31","domain":"cedar-analytics.example","email":"billing@cedar-analytics.example","name":"Cedar Analytics","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-32","domain":"services-cedar-analytics.example","email":"billing@services-cedar-analytics.example","name":"Cedar Analytics Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-33","domain":"archive-cedar-analytics.example","email":"hold@archive-cedar-analytics.example","name":"Cedar Analytics Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"total":3},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.clients.search"},{"arguments":{"query":"TH-3"},"index":8,"result":{"query":"th-3","records":[{"asset_id":"E-3-request-1","body":"Use 12 seats and the old 20% discount; the August price sheet should still be fine.","client_id":"C-31","request_id":"RQ-31","sender_id":"U-32","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Prepare a priced draft within current approval","thread_id":"TH-3"},{"asset_id":"E-3-request-2","body":"Use 10 SEAT units plus 1 SETUP on OP-31, current pricebook revision 2. The buyer chose 1000 basis points (10%) discount under AP-3-current; AP-3-expired is not valid. Expire the draft 2026-09-20. Compare with Q-31 (cancelled full-scope proposal) and Q-32 (signed west opportunity); do not modify those quotes.","client_id":"C-31","request_id":"RQ-32","sender_id":"U-32","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Prepare a priced draft within current approval","thread_id":"TH-3"}],"total":2},"success":true,"tool":"desk.requests.search"},{"arguments":{"amount_minor":1350000,"approval_id":"AP-3-current","currency":"USD","discount_bps":1000,"lines":[{"quantity":10,"sku":"SEAT"},{"quantity":1,"sku":"SETUP"}],"opportunity_id":"OP-31","status":"draft","valid_until":"2026-09-20"},"index":9,"result":{"amount_minor":1350000,"approval_id":"AP-3-current","currency":"USD","discount_bps":1000,"gross_minor":1500000,"lines":[{"price_revision":2,"quantity":10,"sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":125000},{"price_revision":2,"quantity":1,"sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":250000}],"mutation_id":"arc-crm-003-mutation-01","opportunity_id":"OP-31","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-33","status":"draft","valid_until":"2026-09-20","version":2},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.create"},{"arguments":{"content":"Operations handoff \u2014 verified records and facts: AP-3-current; draft; 1350000; OP-31. Please review the linked evidence.","entity_id":"OP-31","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids":["E-3-approval-current","E-3-pricing-2","E-3-request-2"],"reference_ids":["Q-33"]},"index":10,"result":{"content":"Operations handoff \u2014 verified records and facts: AP-3-current; draft; 1350000; OP-31. Please review the linked evidence.","entity_id":"OP-31","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-3-approval-current\",\"E-3-pricing-2\",\"E-3-request-2\"]","mutation_id":"arc-crm-003-mutation-02","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"Q-33\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"arguments":{"quote_id":"Q-33"},"index":11,"result":{"amount_minor":1350000,"approval_id":"AP-3-current","currency":"USD","discount_bps":1000,"lines":[{"price_revision":2,"quantity":10,"quote_id":"Q-33","sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":125000},{"price_revision":2,"quantity":1,"quote_id":"Q-33","sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":250000}],"opportunity_id":"OP-31","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-33","status":"draft","valid_until":"2026-09-20","version":2},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"arguments":{"note_id":"NT-1"},"index":12,"result":{"content":"Operations handoff \u2014 verified records and facts: AP-3-current; draft; 1350000; OP-31. Please review the linked evidence.","entity_id":"OP-31","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-3-approval-current\",\"E-3-pricing-2\",\"E-3-request-2\"]","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"Q-33\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.get"},{"arguments":{"amount_minor":1350000,"gross_minor":1500000,"note_id":"NT-1","opportunity_id":"OP-31","premium_vs_Q32_minor":450000,"quote_id":"Q-33","savings_vs_Q31_minor":150000,"status":"draft"},"index":13,"result":{"accepted":true,"fields":{"amount_minor":"1350000","gross_minor":"1500000","note_id":"NT-1","opportunity_id":"OP-31","premium_vs_Q32_minor":"450000","quote_id":"Q-33","savings_vs_Q31_minor":"150000","status":"draft"},"task_id":"arc-crm-003"},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.submit_answer"}],"exact_replay":true,"negative_controls":[{"name":"noop","score":13.95,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945","verdict_sha256":"536a49fde8e6a5f41530748e0c2c5242616a65204dd4ed3ec711800c471e5d0f"},{"name":"answer_only","score":23.95,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"ccfb8a75b196c048b0d97dd62f1ac0c17d0ae6ce34a398fb65088cf01584d21e","verdict_sha256":"abc77a576a4de6ee1ee547fc1eecd3eda8b1fce30e2d66d79e59de82a9f64c60"},{"name":"skip_investigation","score":80.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"8c445962fdc133fa2f5c34c12a93f7c13e6d6ba7d35ff291e62c0d51672b2e95","verdict_sha256":"9f877f5b8e19a170c60c813af4c33e7787eb2b05b24c48b15a29f021e7df0f76"},{"name":"write_before_investigation","score":80.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"24db55bf4b8487433f821827314c8fe884fac90b6c3fb779447936254aaad30f","verdict_sha256":"f73b815cdc8636d110ee0a74712dacb04bc1c2d6842d1e47c19302480baed265"},{"name":"missing_readback","score":85.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"b95d85368b1fdb12c34714a2208549094349559c7b47832a9aaabc5c72ac5874","verdict_sha256":"4a4bc5c9fa253df4259f44dd55c6f2cbf7cd3abec4274fb8b0929fd133d496a7"},{"name":"state_without_answer","score":90.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"4ce84ec2022399ef3ae9de913f14a925e1044e0f35438558ea84d73f07bbeb17","verdict_sha256":"653356f4e1c9c8c31e35a9da9b42d19330e0de4a90f515366904f5864929f9a6"},{"name":"omit_read_1_desk.requests.search","score":97.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"f43c644444126732cc947ac028d5bf567fd8e64006ecc306dc5de691a02c9c4b","verdict_sha256":"5a2c6266ab61675ebd4bda1ce9474dc2852b69f6e045968bcf2a143cd9459a61"},{"name":"omit_read_2_arccrm.clients.search","score":97.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"55d56381630eef2f46f16bef6dc29b04dcd822be2c25b2a596e1c082ffef4427","verdict_sha256":"59523726bc91743cc918f916342d2d2d5e58ee57f12e0cc1a64d623272ac4b06"},{"name":"omit_read_3_desk.policies.get","score":97.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"17b3c489372f70a25219fef6683a23d7f73055cba1c2b6e9e670287a82966c1f","verdict_sha256":"9c345c42115d9859ce23df06a0b1fc9753c02def6167c698668dfda07da20182"},{"name":"omit_read_4_arccrm.opportunities.get","score":97.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"71c330d79be309b4467c4684712d673e60b69dd6fb55575327d8b19056dc23a6","verdict_sha256":"8217e2836574c2edc51a883411912cdbd4f9597deb43b5d784dd4c00098f7e0d"},{"name":"omit_read_5_desk.prices.list","score":97.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"a5a8694905b23cd7ca0faf233deb1809b7ab28448f211db3d798025fe61dc276","verdict_sha256":"9edd2c830f01a0c742d086af3b6ff835760de846a268f57c6eacb69dd5d3ce3b"},{"name":"omit_read_6_desk.approvals.get","score":97.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"f2dca36a4b612442f1e37da8810295b72b16834b70346f1af5009a5601166cf9","verdict_sha256":"c8c1963bb67163f7345619f90f112d752ef47423630eb0e35c03e60153b1ff9e"},{"name":"omit_read_7_arccrm.quotes.compare","score":97.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"ff12ab47052705021ac32429e0034d2617a050857a1059318b485edef3026a02","verdict_sha256":"8262d2d9140f92e419287b10a40f850616fc7210b3465397d56b085c6fa50323"},{"name":"omit_read_8_desk.permissions.list","score":97.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"479dc9e592d18c952cf527b17fc0e44d5602b75bea14ba68ce5183568783955f","verdict_sha256":"0727d4c3fd04e12665337c2118edc89c991ced23b0defba507896261627c0d1f"},{"name":"omit_mutation_9_arccrm.quotes.create","score":43.68,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"e1a2fc61622e9c1878e1548d7844d6a6bbcbe68bbe629449ff64b7f970a740d5","verdict_sha256":"a68dbef8603da6a072538386ca0971dad24af845b4aa46d0cb4d8b72625fde12"},{"name":"omit_mutation_10_arccrm.notes.create","score":74.47,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"c3a4944d41740c7a69c1287bdcc3a7d6339a47323e33763272ded21286892bfb","verdict_sha256":"6cf2b73fcaae248b8a34910e7ee50797a4aefca228836180cef64081d0dd2b88"},{"name":"omit_read_11_arccrm.quotes.get","score":92.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"3718f7d52e86d0c009024a7651a3827faea9e0ca15741ddb456156f377a7083f","verdict_sha256":"68ba56000514e923415812c998979e566bf1a19fce338c318bd924bbb3303d1f"},{"name":"omit_read_12_arccrm.notes.get","score":92.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"3a44c32440bb47346efea6d2839f6d3f0b30c1ceda833320efd717ece44699a2","verdict_sha256":"1d837d0681a3ef0db75fab08b888198dd10f5d58e92b0139f1b935211966b0bd"},{"name":"superseded_request","score":97.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"a6e6a2fc58b5bf1c008a3f7ea9ed3d919de56adf585ba831e94b57253c37b592","verdict_sha256":"ffe61902e92d9511265d8d61827f9e3c956905f1b85dbe4391524d2a484a9e0e"},{"name":"retired_policy","score":97.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"2878153f915bc9d1dafa68bd2d60d884e128714706774b4e98881f1823f69f2b","verdict_sha256":"4b63a9e15becf17f52204a76f2844d851d1ecc84842a90daba2b2516d004e5ad"},{"name":"wrong_answer","score":98.75,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"7af3862557d5e1925e09b4e9ed943b2a54665a4b4e4e5603011729bf53c2d6d3","verdict_sha256":"bfc9c5daf4630bc031f7fca7ffd632f229d037ad5094a287e93287533f43e382"},{"name":"missing_literal_handoff_facts","score":90.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"1cdcecf5709da5e5dcf8b2ac3b3677921fc2f216a1c2edb83be16c46b17b298e","verdict_sha256":"8ad0334dc812136aad2d7de14e4daf20a68d5e22acca50c4948b67a95bcd570e"},{"name":"stale_handoff_evidence","score":85.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"0e3d5340d9f7110444307b7852df3ba3c93d3fe9be505958ecf7daac5c46791f","verdict_sha256":"f2c98cafbe86db34505752d06286e8d66f75e78cf8d02c1aa6e67164571b6a98"},{"name":"wrong_amount","score":99.74,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"e39635638d0b1a4ae8e953ddb3d25add09ef7bc2fe6977fb057fbac172845f72","verdict_sha256":"1e7fde88097159c8cf23408e02c64d0750a7b4f45de81534b70166fb10cb95bd"},{"name":"expired_approval","score":99.74,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"9b332aa15d3dca6a06cf6cc4318eb7801967bac6cb298c009adcd3cc3270ef41","verdict_sha256":"85f993f54d4c2dfb71caa672b55451ecb90396fe9fb8387774b1cd702f88c2c0"},{"name":"excess_discount","score":99.74,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"1a86353dc755efe62baf90ba0153540c249da187c2cde7a3817ab97a2089ea8f","verdict_sha256":"85f993f54d4c2dfb71caa672b55451ecb90396fe9fb8387774b1cd702f88c2c0"},{"name":"wrong_currency","score":99.74,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"1269b0165de326cfe431a265a4a9091aad2605d9ceb957ec7ba48b5bc28bc1d4","verdict_sha256":"85f993f54d4c2dfb71caa672b55451ecb90396fe9fb8387774b1cd702f88c2c0"},{"name":"signed_quote","score":99.74,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"4a9c2ec379222a49d7182e26b95b8959ee7ec0eb7af71f4ebf5d4a0655665e53","verdict_sha256":"85f993f54d4c2dfb71caa672b55451ecb90396fe9fb8387774b1cd702f88c2c0"},{"name":"wrong_opportunity","score":99.74,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"a93ee0684394b45d0d71ad94354def93214a091dc71f21076b5f79d45895f465","verdict_sha256":"44eb198d674b885fd5a582103ac06cd3e524f7b599b30663552daa1c719c7bc7"}],"oracle":{"final_state":{"answers":[{"field":"amount_minor","task_id":"arc-crm-003","value":"1350000"},{"field":"gross_minor","task_id":"arc-crm-003","value":"1500000"},{"field":"note_id","task_id":"arc-crm-003","value":"NT-1"},{"field":"opportunity_id","task_id":"arc-crm-003","value":"OP-31"},{"field":"premium_vs_Q32_minor","task_id":"arc-crm-003","value":"450000"},{"field":"quote_id","task_id":"arc-crm-003","value":"Q-33"},{"field":"savings_vs_Q31_minor","task_id":"arc-crm-003","value":"150000"},{"field":"status","task_id":"arc-crm-003","value":"draft"}],"audit_log":[{"action":"created","audit_id":1,"payload":"{\"lines\":[{\"price_revision\":2,\"quantity\":10,\"sku\":\"SEAT\",\"unit_minor\":125000},{\"price_revision\":2,\"quantity\":1,\"sku\":\"SETUP\",\"unit_minor\":250000}]}","record_id":"Q-33","table_name":"crm_quote_lines","task_id":"arc-crm-003","tool":"arccrm.quotes.create"},{"action":"created","audit_id":2,"payload":"{\"amount_minor\":1350000,\"approval_id\":\"AP-3-current\",\"currency\":\"USD\",\"discount_bps\":1000,\"lines\":[{\"quantity\":10,\"sku\":\"SEAT\"},{\"quantity\":1,\"sku\":\"SETUP\"}],\"opportunity_id\":\"OP-31\",\"status\":\"draft\",\"valid_until\":\"2026-09-20\"}","record_id":"Q-33","table_name":"crm_quotes","task_id":"arc-crm-003","tool":"arccrm.quotes.create"},{"action":"insert","audit_id":3,"payload":"{\"arguments\":{\"amount_minor\":1350000,\"approval_id\":\"AP-3-current\",\"currency\":\"USD\",\"discount_bps\":1000,\"lines\":[{\"quantity\":10,\"sku\":\"SEAT\"},{\"quantity\":1,\"sku\":\"SETUP\"}],\"opportunity_id\":\"OP-31\",\"status\":\"draft\",\"valid_until\":\"2026-09-20\"},\"tool\":\"arccrm.quotes.create\"}","record_id":"arc-crm-003-mutation-01","table_name":"mutations","task_id":"arc-crm-003","tool":"arccrm.quotes.create"},{"action":"created","audit_id":4,"payload":"{\"content\":\"Draft for OP-31: 1350000 USD minor units under AP-3-current; current approval and quantities applied.\",\"entity_id\":\"OP-31\",\"entity_type\":\"opportunity\",\"evidence_ids\":[\"E-3-request-2\",\"E-3-pricing-2\",\"E-3-approval-current\"],\"reference_ids\":[\"Q-33\"]}","record_id":"NT-1","table_name":"crm_notes","task_id":"arc-crm-003","tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"action":"insert","audit_id":5,"payload":"{\"arguments\":{\"content\":\"Draft for OP-31: 1350000 USD minor units under AP-3-current; current approval and quantities applied.\",\"entity_id\":\"OP-31\",\"entity_type\":\"opportunity\",\"evidence_ids\":[\"E-3-request-2\",\"E-3-pricing-2\",\"E-3-approval-current\"],\"reference_ids\":[\"Q-33\"]},\"tool\":\"arccrm.notes.create\"}","record_id":"arc-crm-003-mutation-02","table_name":"mutations","task_id":"arc-crm-003","tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"action":"submit","audit_id":6,"payload":"{\"amount_minor\":\"1350000\",\"gross_minor\":\"1500000\",\"note_id\":\"NT-1\",\"opportunity_id\":\"OP-31\",\"premium_vs_Q32_minor\":\"450000\",\"quote_id\":\"Q-33\",\"savings_vs_Q31_minor\":\"150000\",\"status\":\"draft\"}","record_id":"arc-crm-003","table_name":"answers","task_id":"arc-crm-003","tool":"hubbench.submit_answer"}],"crm_approvals":[{"approval_id":"AP-3-current","asset_id":"E-3-approval-current","currency":"USD","expires_on":"2026-09-25","max_discount_bps":1000,"max_gross_minor":2000000,"opportunity_id":"OP-31","status":"approved"},{"approval_id":"AP-3-expired","asset_id":"E-3-approval-expired","currency":"USD","expires_on":"2026-08-31","max_discount_bps":3000,"max_gross_minor":2000000,"opportunity_id":"OP-31","status":"approved"}],"crm_attachments":[],"crm_clients":[{"client_id":"C-31","domain":"cedar-analytics.example","email":"billing@cedar-analytics.example","name":"Cedar Analytics","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-32","domain":"services-cedar-analytics.example","email":"billing@services-cedar-analytics.example","name":"Cedar Analytics Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-33","domain":"archive-cedar-analytics.example","email":"hold@archive-cedar-analytics.example","name":"Cedar Analytics Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"crm_contacts":[{"client_id":"C-31","contact_id":"CT-31","email":"jamie@cedar-analytics.example","first_name":"Jamie","last_name":"Park","revision":1,"title":"Procurement lead"}],"crm_contracts":[],"crm_documents":[],"crm_evidence":[{"asset_id":"E-3-approval-current","content":"Opportunity OP-31; currency USD; maximum discount 1000 basis points; maximum gross 2000000 minor units; expires 2026-09-25. No permission to sign or activate.\n"},{"asset_id":"E-3-approval-expired","content":"Opportunity OP-31; currency USD; maximum discount 3000 basis points; maximum gross 2000000 minor units; expires 2026-08-31. No permission to sign or activate.\n"},{"asset_id":"E-3-pricebook","content":"sku,revision,unit_minor,currency,valid_from,valid_until\nSEAT,1,124000,USD,2026-01-01,2026-08-31\nSEAT,2,125000,USD,2026-09-01,2026-12-31\nSETUP,1,249000,USD,2026-01-01,2026-08-31\nSETUP,2,250000,USD,2026-09-01,2026-12-31\n"},{"asset_id":"E-3-pricing-1","content":"Cedar Analytics\nEffective 2025-01-01 through 2026-08-31.\n{\"notice\":\"Retired. Use the current revision.\"}\n"},{"asset_id":"E-3-pricing-2","content":"Cedar Analytics\nEffective 2026-09-01 through 2026-12-31.\n{\"approval\":\"current and scoped\",\"currency\":\"opportunity currency\",\"new_status\":\"draft\",\"one_open_quote_per_opportunity\":true,\"rounding\":\"invoice-level half-up minor units\"}\n"},{"asset_id":"E-3-request-1","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@cedar-analytics.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@cedar-analytics.example>\nSubject: Prepare a priced draft within current approval\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nUse 12 seats and the old 20% discount; the August price sheet should still be fine.\n"},{"asset_id":"E-3-request-2","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@cedar-analytics.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@cedar-analytics.example>\nSubject: Prepare a priced draft within current approval\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nUse 10 SEAT units plus 1 SETUP on OP-31, current pricebook revision 2. The buyer chose 1000 basis points (10%) discount under AP-3-current; AP-3-expired is not valid. Expire the draft 2026-09-20. Compare with Q-31 (cancelled full-scope proposal) and Q-32 (signed west opportunity); do not modify those quotes.\n"}],"crm_notes":[{"content":"Draft for OP-31: 1350000 USD minor units under AP-3-current; current approval and quantities applied.","entity_id":"OP-31","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-3-approval-current\",\"E-3-pricing-2\",\"E-3-request-2\"]","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"Q-33\"]"}],"crm_opportunities":[{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-31","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-31","owner_id":"U-32","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":900000,"client_id":"C-31","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - west","opportunity_id":"OP-32","owner_id":"U-32","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-32","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-33","owner_id":"U-32","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"}],"crm_permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"quote:create","permission_id":"PERM-3-1","target_id":"OP-31","user_id":"U-31","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-3-2","target_id":"OP-31","user_id":"U-31","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"crm_policies":[{"asset_id":"E-3-pricing-1","effective_from":"2025-01-01","effective_until":"2026-08-31","policy_id":"POL-3-pricing-1","revision":1,"rules_json":"{\"notice\":\"Retired. Use the current revision.\"}","topic":"pricing"},{"asset_id":"E-3-pricing-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","policy_id":"POL-3-pricing-2","revision":2,"rules_json":"{\"approval\":\"current and scoped\",\"currency\":\"opportunity currency\",\"new_status\":\"draft\",\"one_open_quote_per_opportunity\":true,\"rounding\":\"invoice-level half-up minor units\"}","topic":"pricing"}],"crm_prices":[{"currency":"USD","revision":1,"sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":124000,"valid_from":"2026-01-01","valid_until":"2026-08-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":2,"sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":125000,"valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-12-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":1,"sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":249000,"valid_from":"2026-01-01","valid_until":"2026-08-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":2,"sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":250000,"valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-12-31"}],"crm_quote_lines":[{"price_revision":2,"quantity":10,"quote_id":"Q-33","sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":125000},{"price_revision":2,"quantity":1,"quote_id":"Q-33","sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":250000}],"crm_quotes":[{"amount_minor":1500000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"opportunity_id":"OP-31","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-31","status":"cancelled","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":1},{"amount_minor":900000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"opportunity_id":"OP-32","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-32","status":"signed","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":1},{"amount_minor":1350000,"approval_id":"AP-3-current","currency":"USD","discount_bps":1000,"opportunity_id":"OP-31","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-33","status":"draft","valid_until":"2026-09-20","version":2}],"crm_requests":[{"asset_id":"E-3-request-1","body":"Use 12 seats and the old 20% discount; the August price sheet should still be fine.","client_id":"C-31","request_id":"RQ-31","sender_id":"U-32","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Prepare a priced draft within current approval","thread_id":"TH-3"},{"asset_id":"E-3-request-2","body":"Use 10 SEAT units plus 1 SETUP on OP-31, current pricebook revision 2. The buyer chose 1000 basis points (10%) discount under AP-3-current; AP-3-expired is not valid. Expire the draft 2026-09-20. Compare with Q-31 (cancelled full-scope proposal) and Q-32 (signed west opportunity); do not modify those quotes.","client_id":"C-31","request_id":"RQ-32","sender_id":"U-32","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Prepare a priced draft within current approval","thread_id":"TH-3"}],"evidence_files":[{"asset_id":"E-3-approval-current","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"text/markdown","path":"assets/E-3-approval-current.md","sha256":"11ec28232266a0473a79836c2d2a284f4ea83ededd119be166d015d8aa60fb89","source":"Cedar Analytics","task_id":"arc-crm-003","title":"Current commercial approval"},{"asset_id":"E-3-approval-expired","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"text/markdown","path":"assets/E-3-approval-expired.md","sha256":"761a0177e47e777b02220ce24c3c6fc10674d79bd72bfa419d42a8e04fa059a3","source":"Cedar Analytics","task_id":"arc-crm-003","title":"Expired commercial approval"},{"asset_id":"E-3-pricebook","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.spreadsheetml.sheet","path":"assets/E-3-pricebook.xlsx","sha256":"3b8a342d7794acf4de0be1e0b4297dcc818717f45d53761ec6b6f3ceb21a5679","source":"Cedar Analytics","task_id":"arc-crm-003","title":"Pricebook with current and retired prices"},{"asset_id":"E-3-pricing-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-3-pricing-1.pdf","sha256":"4be93faa6b7e28366f15ac64397d79a7f5aa12b49b52e36ea9041ce46cefdc19","source":"Cedar Analytics","task_id":"arc-crm-003","title":"Pricing policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-3-pricing-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-3-pricing-2.pdf","sha256":"13897ad470ec7e51017b8c028c176259947686d5c043bcf2e05ca0721d9884e7","source":"Cedar Analytics","task_id":"arc-crm-003","title":"Pricing policy revision 2"},{"asset_id":"E-3-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-3-request-1.eml","sha256":"a0936361d261f883809f1d9f8d42c79ab3d6edc1c25e4fb5bd37d7dd484a59da","source":"Cedar Analytics","task_id":"arc-crm-003","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-3-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-3-request-2.eml","sha256":"933ff41d1f4e622c9c376095a69c083f2e09610f6dbfd120c90d76f30ef0561d","source":"Cedar Analytics","task_id":"arc-crm-003","title":"Owner request 2"}],"mutations":[{"effective_at":"2026-09-05T09:09:00","mutation_id":"arc-crm-003-mutation-01","payload_json":"{\"arguments\":{\"amount_minor\":1350000,\"approval_id\":\"AP-3-current\",\"currency\":\"USD\",\"discount_bps\":1000,\"lines\":[{\"quantity\":10,\"sku\":\"SEAT\"},{\"quantity\":1,\"sku\":\"SETUP\"}],\"opportunity_id\":\"OP-31\",\"status\":\"draft\",\"valid_until\":\"2026-09-20\"},\"tool\":\"arccrm.quotes.create\"}","record_id":"Q-33","revision":1,"sequence":1,"status":"created","table_name":"crm_quotes","task_id":"arc-crm-003","tool":"arccrm.quotes.create"},{"effective_at":"2026-09-05T09:10:00","mutation_id":"arc-crm-003-mutation-02","payload_json":"{\"arguments\":{\"content\":\"Draft for OP-31: 1350000 USD minor units under AP-3-current; current approval and quantities applied.\",\"entity_id\":\"OP-31\",\"entity_type\":\"opportunity\",\"evidence_ids\":[\"E-3-request-2\",\"E-3-pricing-2\",\"E-3-approval-current\"],\"reference_ids\":[\"Q-33\"]},\"tool\":\"arccrm.notes.create\"}","record_id":"NT-1","revision":1,"sequence":2,"status":"created","table_name":"crm_notes","task_id":"arc-crm-003","tool":"arccrm.notes.create"}],"users":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-31"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-32"}]},"initial_state":{"answers":[],"audit_log":[],"crm_approvals":[{"approval_id":"AP-3-current","asset_id":"E-3-approval-current","currency":"USD","expires_on":"2026-09-25","max_discount_bps":1000,"max_gross_minor":2000000,"opportunity_id":"OP-31","status":"approved"},{"approval_id":"AP-3-expired","asset_id":"E-3-approval-expired","currency":"USD","expires_on":"2026-08-31","max_discount_bps":3000,"max_gross_minor":2000000,"opportunity_id":"OP-31","status":"approved"}],"crm_attachments":[],"crm_clients":[{"client_id":"C-31","domain":"cedar-analytics.example","email":"billing@cedar-analytics.example","name":"Cedar Analytics","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-32","domain":"services-cedar-analytics.example","email":"billing@services-cedar-analytics.example","name":"Cedar Analytics Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-33","domain":"archive-cedar-analytics.example","email":"hold@archive-cedar-analytics.example","name":"Cedar Analytics Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"crm_contacts":[{"client_id":"C-31","contact_id":"CT-31","email":"jamie@cedar-analytics.example","first_name":"Jamie","last_name":"Park","revision":1,"title":"Procurement lead"}],"crm_contracts":[],"crm_documents":[],"crm_evidence":[{"asset_id":"E-3-approval-current","content":"Opportunity OP-31; currency USD; maximum discount 1000 basis points; maximum gross 2000000 minor units; expires 2026-09-25. No permission to sign or activate.\n"},{"asset_id":"E-3-approval-expired","content":"Opportunity OP-31; currency USD; maximum discount 3000 basis points; maximum gross 2000000 minor units; expires 2026-08-31. No permission to sign or activate.\n"},{"asset_id":"E-3-pricebook","content":"sku,revision,unit_minor,currency,valid_from,valid_until\nSEAT,1,124000,USD,2026-01-01,2026-08-31\nSEAT,2,125000,USD,2026-09-01,2026-12-31\nSETUP,1,249000,USD,2026-01-01,2026-08-31\nSETUP,2,250000,USD,2026-09-01,2026-12-31\n"},{"asset_id":"E-3-pricing-1","content":"Cedar Analytics\nEffective 2025-01-01 through 2026-08-31.\n{\"notice\":\"Retired. Use the current revision.\"}\n"},{"asset_id":"E-3-pricing-2","content":"Cedar Analytics\nEffective 2026-09-01 through 2026-12-31.\n{\"approval\":\"current and scoped\",\"currency\":\"opportunity currency\",\"new_status\":\"draft\",\"one_open_quote_per_opportunity\":true,\"rounding\":\"invoice-level half-up minor units\"}\n"},{"asset_id":"E-3-request-1","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@cedar-analytics.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@cedar-analytics.example>\nSubject: Prepare a priced draft within current approval\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nUse 12 seats and the old 20% discount; the August price sheet should still be fine.\n"},{"asset_id":"E-3-request-2","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@cedar-analytics.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@cedar-analytics.example>\nSubject: Prepare a priced draft within current approval\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nUse 10 SEAT units plus 1 SETUP on OP-31, current pricebook revision 2. The buyer chose 1000 basis points (10%) discount under AP-3-current; AP-3-expired is not valid. Expire the draft 2026-09-20. Compare with Q-31 (cancelled full-scope proposal) and Q-32 (signed west opportunity); do not modify those quotes.\n"}],"crm_notes":[],"crm_opportunities":[{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-31","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-31","owner_id":"U-32","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":900000,"client_id":"C-31","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - west","opportunity_id":"OP-32","owner_id":"U-32","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-32","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-33","owner_id":"U-32","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"}],"crm_permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"quote:create","permission_id":"PERM-3-1","target_id":"OP-31","user_id":"U-31","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-3-2","target_id":"OP-31","user_id":"U-31","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"crm_policies":[{"asset_id":"E-3-pricing-1","effective_from":"2025-01-01","effective_until":"2026-08-31","policy_id":"POL-3-pricing-1","revision":1,"rules_json":"{\"notice\":\"Retired. Use the current revision.\"}","topic":"pricing"},{"asset_id":"E-3-pricing-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","policy_id":"POL-3-pricing-2","revision":2,"rules_json":"{\"approval\":\"current and scoped\",\"currency\":\"opportunity currency\",\"new_status\":\"draft\",\"one_open_quote_per_opportunity\":true,\"rounding\":\"invoice-level half-up minor units\"}","topic":"pricing"}],"crm_prices":[{"currency":"USD","revision":1,"sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":124000,"valid_from":"2026-01-01","valid_until":"2026-08-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":2,"sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":125000,"valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-12-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":1,"sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":249000,"valid_from":"2026-01-01","valid_until":"2026-08-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":2,"sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":250000,"valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-12-31"}],"crm_quote_lines":[],"crm_quotes":[{"amount_minor":1500000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"opportunity_id":"OP-31","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-31","status":"cancelled","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":1},{"amount_minor":900000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"opportunity_id":"OP-32","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-32","status":"signed","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":1}],"crm_requests":[{"asset_id":"E-3-request-1","body":"Use 12 seats and the old 20% discount; the August price sheet should still be fine.","client_id":"C-31","request_id":"RQ-31","sender_id":"U-32","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Prepare a priced draft within current approval","thread_id":"TH-3"},{"asset_id":"E-3-request-2","body":"Use 10 SEAT units plus 1 SETUP on OP-31, current pricebook revision 2. The buyer chose 1000 basis points (10%) discount under AP-3-current; AP-3-expired is not valid. Expire the draft 2026-09-20. Compare with Q-31 (cancelled full-scope proposal) and Q-32 (signed west opportunity); do not modify those quotes.","client_id":"C-31","request_id":"RQ-32","sender_id":"U-32","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Prepare a priced draft within current approval","thread_id":"TH-3"}],"evidence_files":[{"asset_id":"E-3-approval-current","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"text/markdown","path":"assets/E-3-approval-current.md","sha256":"11ec28232266a0473a79836c2d2a284f4ea83ededd119be166d015d8aa60fb89","source":"Cedar Analytics","task_id":"arc-crm-003","title":"Current commercial approval"},{"asset_id":"E-3-approval-expired","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"text/markdown","path":"assets/E-3-approval-expired.md","sha256":"761a0177e47e777b02220ce24c3c6fc10674d79bd72bfa419d42a8e04fa059a3","source":"Cedar Analytics","task_id":"arc-crm-003","title":"Expired commercial approval"},{"asset_id":"E-3-pricebook","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.spreadsheetml.sheet","path":"assets/E-3-pricebook.xlsx","sha256":"3b8a342d7794acf4de0be1e0b4297dcc818717f45d53761ec6b6f3ceb21a5679","source":"Cedar Analytics","task_id":"arc-crm-003","title":"Pricebook with current and retired prices"},{"asset_id":"E-3-pricing-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-3-pricing-1.pdf","sha256":"4be93faa6b7e28366f15ac64397d79a7f5aa12b49b52e36ea9041ce46cefdc19","source":"Cedar Analytics","task_id":"arc-crm-003","title":"Pricing policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-3-pricing-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-3-pricing-2.pdf","sha256":"13897ad470ec7e51017b8c028c176259947686d5c043bcf2e05ca0721d9884e7","source":"Cedar Analytics","task_id":"arc-crm-003","title":"Pricing policy revision 2"},{"asset_id":"E-3-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-3-request-1.eml","sha256":"a0936361d261f883809f1d9f8d42c79ab3d6edc1c25e4fb5bd37d7dd484a59da","source":"Cedar Analytics","task_id":"arc-crm-003","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-3-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-3-request-2.eml","sha256":"933ff41d1f4e622c9c376095a69c083f2e09610f6dbfd120c90d76f30ef0561d","source":"Cedar Analytics","task_id":"arc-crm-003","title":"Owner request 2"}],"mutations":[],"users":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-31"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-32"}]},"trace":[{"arguments":{},"index":0,"result":{"evidence_index":[{"asset_id":"E-3-approval-current","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"text/markdown","path":"assets/E-3-approval-current.md","sha256":"11ec28232266a0473a79836c2d2a284f4ea83ededd119be166d015d8aa60fb89","source":"Cedar Analytics","title":"Current commercial approval"},{"asset_id":"E-3-approval-expired","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"text/markdown","path":"assets/E-3-approval-expired.md","sha256":"761a0177e47e777b02220ce24c3c6fc10674d79bd72bfa419d42a8e04fa059a3","source":"Cedar Analytics","title":"Expired commercial approval"},{"asset_id":"E-3-pricebook","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.spreadsheetml.sheet","path":"assets/E-3-pricebook.xlsx","sha256":"3b8a342d7794acf4de0be1e0b4297dcc818717f45d53761ec6b6f3ceb21a5679","source":"Cedar Analytics","title":"Pricebook with current and retired prices"},{"asset_id":"E-3-pricing-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-3-pricing-1.pdf","sha256":"4be93faa6b7e28366f15ac64397d79a7f5aa12b49b52e36ea9041ce46cefdc19","source":"Cedar Analytics","title":"Pricing policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-3-pricing-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-3-pricing-2.pdf","sha256":"13897ad470ec7e51017b8c028c176259947686d5c043bcf2e05ca0721d9884e7","source":"Cedar Analytics","title":"Pricing policy revision 2"},{"asset_id":"E-3-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-3-request-1.eml","sha256":"a0936361d261f883809f1d9f8d42c79ab3d6edc1c25e4fb5bd37d7dd484a59da","source":"Cedar Analytics","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-3-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-3-request-2.eml","sha256":"933ff41d1f4e622c9c376095a69c083f2e09610f6dbfd120c90d76f30ef0561d","source":"Cedar Analytics","title":"Owner request 2"}],"identity":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-31"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-32"}],"organization":{"name":"Cedar Analytics","synthetic":true,"systems":["arccrm","desk","vault"]},"reference_records":{},"starting_records":[{"client_hint":"Cedar Analytics","thread_id":"TH-3"}],"state":{"network":"closed","persistence":"episode-local SQLite","scope":"isolated task snapshot"},"task":{"as_of":"2026-09-05","family":"arc-crm","role":"U-31","task_id":"arc-crm-003"},"tool_servers":[{"description":"Stateful synthetic CRM","name":"arccrm","tools":["arccrm.attachments.get","arccrm.attachments.search","arccrm.clients.get","arccrm.clients.search","arccrm.contacts.create","arccrm.contacts.get","arccrm.contacts.search","arccrm.contracts.create","arccrm.contracts.get","arccrm.contracts.search","arccrm.documents.attach","arccrm.documents.get","arccrm.documents.search","arccrm.notes.create","arccrm.notes.get","arccrm.notes.search","arccrm.opportunities.get","arccrm.opportunities.search","arccrm.opportunities.update","arccrm.quotes.cancel","arccrm.quotes.compare","arccrm.quotes.create","arccrm.quotes.get","arccrm.quotes.search"]},{"description":"Mock requests, permissions, approvals and versioned policy/price records","name":"desk","tools":["desk.approvals.get","desk.permissions.list","desk.policies.get","desk.prices.list","desk.requests.get","desk.requests.search"]},{"description":"Seeded synthetic evidence; no external file access","name":"vault","tools":["vault.files.get"]},{"description":"Benchmark-only discovery and structured answer submission controls.","name":"hubbench","tools":["hubbench.context.get","hubbench.submit_answer"]}]},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.context.get"},{"arguments":{"query":"TH-3"},"index":1,"result":{"query":"th-3","records":[{"asset_id":"E-3-request-1","body":"Use 12 seats and the old 20% discount; the August price sheet should still be fine.","client_id":"C-31","request_id":"RQ-31","sender_id":"U-32","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Prepare a priced draft within current approval","thread_id":"TH-3"},{"asset_id":"E-3-request-2","body":"Use 10 SEAT units plus 1 SETUP on OP-31, current pricebook revision 2. The buyer chose 1000 basis points (10%) discount under AP-3-current; AP-3-expired is not valid. Expire the draft 2026-09-20. Compare with Q-31 (cancelled full-scope proposal) and Q-32 (signed west opportunity); do not modify those quotes.","client_id":"C-31","request_id":"RQ-32","sender_id":"U-32","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Prepare a priced draft within current approval","thread_id":"TH-3"}],"total":2},"success":true,"tool":"desk.requests.search"},{"arguments":{"query":"Cedar Analytics"},"index":2,"result":{"query":"cedar analytics","records":[{"client_id":"C-31","domain":"cedar-analytics.example","email":"billing@cedar-analytics.example","name":"Cedar Analytics","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-32","domain":"services-cedar-analytics.example","email":"billing@services-cedar-analytics.example","name":"Cedar Analytics Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-33","domain":"archive-cedar-analytics.example","email":"hold@archive-cedar-analytics.example","name":"Cedar Analytics Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"total":3},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.clients.search"},{"arguments":{"policy_id":"POL-3-pricing-2"},"index":3,"result":{"asset_id":"E-3-pricing-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","operative":true,"policy_id":"POL-3-pricing-2","revision":2,"rules":{"approval":"current and scoped","currency":"opportunity currency","new_status":"draft","one_open_quote_per_opportunity":true,"rounding":"invoice-level half-up minor units"},"rules_json":"{\"approval\":\"current and scoped\",\"currency\":\"opportunity currency\",\"new_status\":\"draft\",\"one_open_quote_per_opportunity\":true,\"rounding\":\"invoice-level half-up minor units\"}","topic":"pricing"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.policies.get"},{"arguments":{"opportunity_id":"OP-31"},"index":4,"result":{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-31","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-31","owner_id":"U-32","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"},{"arguments":{"currency":"USD"},"index":5,"result":{"prices":[{"currency":"USD","revision":1,"sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":124000,"valid_from":"2026-01-01","valid_until":"2026-08-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":2,"sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":125000,"valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-12-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":1,"sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":249000,"valid_from":"2026-01-01","valid_until":"2026-08-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":2,"sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":250000,"valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-12-31"}]},"success":true,"tool":"desk.prices.list"},{"arguments":{"approval_id":"AP-3-current"},"index":6,"result":{"approval_id":"AP-3-current","asset_id":"E-3-approval-current","currency":"USD","expires_on":"2026-09-25","max_discount_bps":1000,"max_gross_minor":2000000,"opportunity_id":"OP-31","status":"approved"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.approvals.get"},{"arguments":{"quote_ids":["Q-31","Q-32"]},"index":7,"result":{"quotes":[{"amount_minor":1500000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"lines":[],"opportunity_id":"OP-31","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-31","status":"cancelled","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":1},{"amount_minor":900000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"lines":[],"opportunity_id":"OP-32","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-32","status":"signed","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":1}],"spread_minor":600000},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.compare"},{"arguments":{},"index":8,"result":{"permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"quote:create","permission_id":"PERM-3-1","target_id":"OP-31","user_id":"U-31","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-3-2","target_id":"OP-31","user_id":"U-31","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"user_id":"U-31"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.permissions.list"},{"arguments":{"amount_minor":1350000,"approval_id":"AP-3-current","currency":"USD","discount_bps":1000,"lines":[{"quantity":10,"sku":"SEAT"},{"quantity":1,"sku":"SETUP"}],"opportunity_id":"OP-31","status":"draft","valid_until":"2026-09-20"},"index":9,"result":{"amount_minor":1350000,"approval_id":"AP-3-current","currency":"USD","discount_bps":1000,"gross_minor":1500000,"lines":[{"price_revision":2,"quantity":10,"sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":125000},{"price_revision":2,"quantity":1,"sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":250000}],"mutation_id":"arc-crm-003-mutation-01","opportunity_id":"OP-31","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-33","status":"draft","valid_until":"2026-09-20","version":2},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.create"},{"arguments":{"content":"Draft for OP-31: 1350000 USD minor units under AP-3-current; current approval and quantities applied.","entity_id":"OP-31","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids":["E-3-request-2","E-3-pricing-2","E-3-approval-current"],"reference_ids":["Q-33"]},"index":10,"result":{"content":"Draft for OP-31: 1350000 USD minor units under AP-3-current; current approval and quantities applied.","entity_id":"OP-31","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-3-approval-current\",\"E-3-pricing-2\",\"E-3-request-2\"]","mutation_id":"arc-crm-003-mutation-02","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"Q-33\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"arguments":{"quote_id":"Q-33"},"index":11,"result":{"amount_minor":1350000,"approval_id":"AP-3-current","currency":"USD","discount_bps":1000,"lines":[{"price_revision":2,"quantity":10,"quote_id":"Q-33","sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":125000},{"price_revision":2,"quantity":1,"quote_id":"Q-33","sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":250000}],"opportunity_id":"OP-31","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-33","status":"draft","valid_until":"2026-09-20","version":2},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"arguments":{"note_id":"NT-1"},"index":12,"result":{"content":"Draft for OP-31: 1350000 USD minor units under AP-3-current; current approval and quantities applied.","entity_id":"OP-31","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-3-approval-current\",\"E-3-pricing-2\",\"E-3-request-2\"]","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"Q-33\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.get"},{"arguments":{"amount_minor":1350000,"gross_minor":1500000,"note_id":"NT-1","opportunity_id":"OP-31","premium_vs_Q32_minor":450000,"quote_id":"Q-33","savings_vs_Q31_minor":150000,"status":"draft"},"index":13,"result":{"accepted":true,"fields":{"amount_minor":"1350000","gross_minor":"1500000","note_id":"NT-1","opportunity_id":"OP-31","premium_vs_Q32_minor":"450000","quote_id":"Q-33","savings_vs_Q31_minor":"150000","status":"draft"},"task_id":"arc-crm-003"},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.submit_answer"}],"verdict":{"checks":[{"category":"evidence","description":"bounded_quote: evidence","earned_weight":20.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":8,"subchecks":[{"description":"Resolve the owner's current clarification, not the superseded message.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":1,"tool":"desk.requests.search"}]},"id":"investigate-current_request","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Identify the existing verified client and the similarly named account.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":2,"tool":"arccrm.clients.search"}]},"id":"investigate-verified_client","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the operative policy and its scope.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":3,"tool":"desk.policies.get"}]},"id":"investigate-operative_policy","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the precise opportunity identity, owner, revision and commercial fields.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":4,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"}]},"id":"investigate-opportunity","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Use current SKU prices, not the expired pricebook.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":5,"tool":"desk.prices.list"}]},"id":"investigate-pricing","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Check the current scoped approval and expiry.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":6,"tool":"desk.approvals.get"}]},"id":"investigate-approval","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Compare the real supplied quote alternatives without treating either as current approval.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":7,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.compare"}]},"id":"investigate-alternatives","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the acting role's specific operation/target grants before writing.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":8,"tool":"desk.permissions.list"}]},"id":"investigate-authority","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":8},"id":"evidence","passed":true,"weight":20.0},{"category":"readback","description":"bounded_quote: readback","earned_weight":15.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":2,"subchecks":[{"description":"Read back the persisted quote after the business mutation.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":11,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"}]},"id":"readback-quote","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read back the persisted handoff after the business mutation.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":12,"tool":"arccrm.notes.get"}]},"id":"readback-handoff","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":2},"id":"readback","passed":true,"weight":15.0},{"category":"outcome","description":"bounded_quote: outcome","earned_weight":30.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":4,"subchecks":[{"description":"Persist the required crm_quotes record and exact structural fields.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"create-crm_quotes-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Persist the required crm_quote_lines record and exact structural fields.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"create-crm_quote_lines-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Persist the required crm_quote_lines record and exact structural fields.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"create-crm_quote_lines-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Persist the required crm_notes record and exact structural fields.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"create-crm_notes-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":4},"id":"outcome","passed":true,"weight":30.0},{"category":"containment","description":"bounded_quote: containment","earned_weight":15.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":57,"subchecks":[{"description":"Preserve users record {'user_id': 'U-31'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-users-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve users record {'user_id': 'U-32'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-users-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in users.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-users","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-3-request-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-3-request-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-3-pricing-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-3-pricing-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-3","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-3-pricebook'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-4","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-3-approval-expired'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-5","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-3-approval-current'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-6","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in evidence_files.","evidence":{"expected_count":7,"matching_rows":7},"id":"count-evidence_files","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-3-request-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-3-request-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-3-pricing-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-3-pricing-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-3","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-3-pricebook'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-4","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-3-approval-expired'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-5","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-3-approval-current'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-6","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_evidence.","evidence":{"expected_count":7,"matching_rows":7},"id":"count-crm_evidence","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_clients record {'client_id': 'C-31'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_clients-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_clients record {'client_id': 'C-32'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_clients-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_clients record {'client_id': 'C-33'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_clients-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_clients.","evidence":{"expected_count":3,"matching_rows":3},"id":"count-crm_clients","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_contacts record {'contact_id': 'CT-31'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_contacts-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_contacts.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1},"id":"count-crm_contacts","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_opportunities record {'opportunity_id': 'OP-31'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_opportunities-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_opportunities record {'opportunity_id': 'OP-32'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_opportunities-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_opportunities record {'opportunity_id': 'OP-33'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_opportunities-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_opportunities.","evidence":{"expected_count":3,"matching_rows":3},"id":"count-crm_opportunities","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_quotes record {'quote_id': 'Q-31'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_quotes-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_quotes record {'quote_id': 'Q-32'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_quotes-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_quotes.","evidence":{"expected_count":3,"matching_rows":3},"id":"count-crm_quotes","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_quote_lines.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-crm_quote_lines","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_contracts.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_contracts","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_documents.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_documents","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_attachments.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_attachments","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_notes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1},"id":"count-crm_notes","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_requests record {'request_id': 'RQ-31'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_requests-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_requests record {'request_id': 'RQ-32'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_requests-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_requests.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-crm_requests","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_policies record {'policy_id': 'POL-3-pricing-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_policies-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_policies record {'policy_id': 'POL-3-pricing-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_policies-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_policies.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-crm_policies","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_prices record {'sku': 'SEAT', 'revision': 1, 'currency': 'USD'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_prices-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_prices record {'sku': 'SEAT', 'revision': 2, 'currency': 'USD'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_prices-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_prices record {'sku': 'SETUP', 'revision': 1, 'currency': 'USD'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_prices-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_prices record {'sku': 'SETUP', 'revision': 2, 'currency': 'USD'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_prices-3","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_prices.","evidence":{"expected_count":4,"matching_rows":4},"id":"count-crm_prices","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_approvals record {'approval_id': 'AP-3-expired'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_approvals-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_approvals record {'approval_id': 'AP-3-current'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_approvals-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_approvals.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-crm_approvals","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_permissions record {'permission_id': 'PERM-3-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_permissions-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_permissions record {'permission_id': 'PERM-3-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_permissions-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_permissions.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-crm_permissions","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Exactly the required domain writes, with no hidden extra mutation.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-mutations","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Kept every successful write inside arc-crm-003's declared state, collaboration, answer, and audit tables.","evidence":{"disallowed":[],"written_tables":["answers","crm_notes","crm_quote_lines","crm_quotes","mutations"]},"id":"write_scope","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Completed without a rejected state-changing call; failed exploratory reads and retryable provider faults do not erase a correct outcome.","evidence":{"errors":[]},"id":"no_rejected_mutation","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":57},"id":"containment","passed":true,"weight":15.0},{"category":"handoff","description":"bounded_quote: handoff","earned_weight":10.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":1,"subchecks":[{"description":"Handoff content contains the disclosed literal facts; punctuation/case/prose may vary. Not a semantic consistency check.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1},"id":"handoff-facts","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":1},"id":"handoff","passed":true,"weight":10.0},{"category":"answer","description":"bounded_quote: answer","earned_weight":10.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":8,"subchecks":[{"description":"Report the correct quote id.","evidence":{"expected":"Q-33","field":"quote_id","submitted":"Q-33"},"id":"answer-quote_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct opportunity id.","evidence":{"expected":"OP-31","field":"opportunity_id","submitted":"OP-31"},"id":"answer-opportunity_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct gross minor.","evidence":{"expected":"1500000","field":"gross_minor","submitted":"1500000"},"id":"answer-gross_minor","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct amount minor.","evidence":{"expected":"1350000","field":"amount_minor","submitted":"1350000"},"id":"answer-amount_minor","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct savings vs Q31 minor.","evidence":{"expected":"150000","field":"savings_vs_Q31_minor","submitted":"150000"},"id":"answer-savings_vs_Q31_minor","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct premium vs Q32 minor.","evidence":{"expected":"450000","field":"premium_vs_Q32_minor","submitted":"450000"},"id":"answer-premium_vs_Q32_minor","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct status.","evidence":{"expected":"draft","field":"status","submitted":"draft"},"id":"answer-status","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct note id.","evidence":{"expected":"NT-1","field":"note_id","submitted":"NT-1"},"id":"answer-note_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":8},"id":"answer","passed":true,"weight":10.0}],"metric":"HubScore","passed_atomic_checks":80,"passed_checks":6,"passed_weight":100.0,"score":100.0,"strict_pass":true,"task_id":"arc-crm-003","total_atomic_checks":80,"total_checks":6,"total_weight":100.0}},"replay_sha256":"2734d7003835345c286b364af3a979dedb3d5c7f28bbca1bce3f4693c33733aa","task_id":"arc-crm-003","task_sha256":"02603d853a8505ebeec14f7c556d1edc19a181e8586690d01d7f571c0bea9004"},{"alternate_pass":true,"alternate_trace":[{"arguments":{},"index":0,"result":{"evidence_index":[{"asset_id":"E-4-approval-current","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"text/markdown","path":"assets/E-4-approval-current.md","sha256":"4ec767be06ef61bdec5a0c69a0a4733729c1f2639ce5adcaa945ce4be89f5562","source":"Delta Cooling","title":"Current commercial approval"},{"asset_id":"E-4-approval-expired","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"text/markdown","path":"assets/E-4-approval-expired.md","sha256":"21fb13ea50d963ecd49c8c0ca78e60843b81a218f24b32e15018ea3c7bb54595","source":"Delta Cooling","title":"Expired commercial approval"},{"asset_id":"E-4-pricebook","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.spreadsheetml.sheet","path":"assets/E-4-pricebook.xlsx","sha256":"517859cdba4133a4716e138b214d73b2b82c979fd56e0a5de85a91be890b660b","source":"Delta Cooling","title":"Pricebook with current and retired prices"},{"asset_id":"E-4-replacement-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-4-replacement-1.pdf","sha256":"b1b0d49bbe2f7147167231f664ce81de84e468096d3cdcc2d3595e1ce2fbefe1","source":"Delta Cooling","title":"Replacement policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-4-replacement-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-4-replacement-2.pdf","sha256":"7b935b2fd05b816d4ba6438e6302ebbd31f9f7b44c813887430ccbfc99b830bc","source":"Delta Cooling","title":"Replacement policy revision 2"},{"asset_id":"E-4-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-4-request-1.eml","sha256":"ccdba0e6a4ccbda50d3438b2b2031086e0eaebf47a89a44394da8180a494d932","source":"Delta Cooling","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-4-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-4-request-2.eml","sha256":"a1c21ac0a3b4964d0659d483007ce879a4666afd5599bec88379edb820fb5c13","source":"Delta Cooling","title":"Owner request 2"}],"identity":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-41"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-42"}],"organization":{"name":"Delta Cooling","synthetic":true,"systems":["arccrm","desk","vault"]},"reference_records":{},"starting_records":[{"client_hint":"Delta Cooling","thread_id":"TH-4"}],"state":{"network":"closed","persistence":"episode-local SQLite","scope":"isolated task snapshot"},"task":{"as_of":"2026-09-05","family":"arc-crm","role":"U-41","task_id":"arc-crm-004"},"tool_servers":[{"description":"Stateful synthetic CRM","name":"arccrm","tools":["arccrm.attachments.get","arccrm.attachments.search","arccrm.clients.get","arccrm.clients.search","arccrm.contacts.create","arccrm.contacts.get","arccrm.contacts.search","arccrm.contracts.create","arccrm.contracts.get","arccrm.contracts.search","arccrm.documents.attach","arccrm.documents.get","arccrm.documents.search","arccrm.notes.create","arccrm.notes.get","arccrm.notes.search","arccrm.opportunities.get","arccrm.opportunities.search","arccrm.opportunities.update","arccrm.quotes.cancel","arccrm.quotes.compare","arccrm.quotes.create","arccrm.quotes.get","arccrm.quotes.search"]},{"description":"Mock requests, permissions, approvals and versioned policy/price records","name":"desk","tools":["desk.approvals.get","desk.permissions.list","desk.policies.get","desk.prices.list","desk.requests.get","desk.requests.search"]},{"description":"Seeded synthetic evidence; no external file access","name":"vault","tools":["vault.files.get"]},{"description":"Benchmark-only discovery and structured answer submission controls.","name":"hubbench","tools":["hubbench.context.get","hubbench.submit_answer"]}]},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.context.get"},{"arguments":{},"index":1,"result":{"permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"quote:cancel","permission_id":"PERM-4-1","target_id":"Q-42","user_id":"U-41","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"quote:create","permission_id":"PERM-4-2","target_id":"OP-41","user_id":"U-41","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-4-3","target_id":"OP-41","user_id":"U-41","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"user_id":"U-41"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.permissions.list"},{"arguments":{"quote_id":"Q-42"},"index":2,"result":{"amount_minor":1520000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"lines":[{"price_revision":2,"quantity":8,"quote_id":"Q-42","sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":160000},{"price_revision":2,"quantity":1,"quote_id":"Q-42","sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":240000}],"opportunity_id":"OP-41","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-42","status":"draft","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":2},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"arguments":{"quote_id":"Q-41"},"index":3,"result":{"amount_minor":1400000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"lines":[{"price_revision":1,"quantity":1,"quote_id":"Q-41","sku":"LEGACY","unit_minor":1400000}],"opportunity_id":"OP-41","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-41","status":"signed","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":1},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"arguments":{"approval_id":"AP-4-current"},"index":4,"result":{"approval_id":"AP-4-current","asset_id":"E-4-approval-current","currency":"USD","expires_on":"2026-09-25","max_discount_bps":500,"max_gross_minor":2000000,"opportunity_id":"OP-41","status":"approved"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.approvals.get"},{"arguments":{"currency":"USD"},"index":5,"result":{"prices":[{"currency":"USD","revision":1,"sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":159000,"valid_from":"2026-01-01","valid_until":"2026-08-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":2,"sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":160000,"valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-12-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":1,"sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":239000,"valid_from":"2026-01-01","valid_until":"2026-08-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":2,"sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":240000,"valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-12-31"}]},"success":true,"tool":"desk.prices.list"},{"arguments":{"opportunity_id":"OP-41"},"index":6,"result":{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-41","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-41","owner_id":"U-42","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"},{"arguments":{"policy_id":"POL-4-replacement-2"},"index":7,"result":{"asset_id":"E-4-replacement-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","operative":true,"policy_id":"POL-4-replacement-2","revision":2,"rules":{"cancel":"only authorized draft version","history":"never delete","replacement":"explicit cancelled predecessor on same opportunity","signed_records":"immutable"},"rules_json":"{\"cancel\":\"only authorized draft version\",\"history\":\"never delete\",\"replacement\":\"explicit cancelled predecessor on same opportunity\",\"signed_records\":\"immutable\"}","topic":"replacement"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.policies.get"},{"arguments":{"query":"Delta Cooling"},"index":8,"result":{"query":"delta cooling","records":[{"client_id":"C-41","domain":"delta-cooling.example","email":"billing@delta-cooling.example","name":"Delta Cooling","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-42","domain":"services-delta-cooling.example","email":"billing@services-delta-cooling.example","name":"Delta Cooling Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-43","domain":"archive-delta-cooling.example","email":"hold@archive-delta-cooling.example","name":"Delta Cooling Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"total":3},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.clients.search"},{"arguments":{"query":"TH-4"},"index":9,"result":{"query":"th-4","records":[{"asset_id":"E-4-request-1","body":"Delete the old quote and replace it with 8 seats. I think Q-41 is the old one.","client_id":"C-41","request_id":"RQ-41","sender_id":"U-42","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Replace a superseded draft while retaining signed history","thread_id":"TH-4"},{"asset_id":"E-4-request-2","body":"Do not delete anything: Q-41 is signed history and must remain intact. Cancel draft Q-42 version 2 on OP-41; replace it with 6 SEAT and 1 SETUP, current prices, 500 basis points discount under AP-4-current, valid through 2026-09-22. Keep predecessor_id=Q-42 and note both old and new versions.","client_id":"C-41","request_id":"RQ-42","sender_id":"U-42","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Replace a superseded draft while retaining signed history","thread_id":"TH-4"}],"total":2},"success":true,"tool":"desk.requests.search"},{"arguments":{"expected_version":2,"quote_id":"Q-42"},"index":10,"result":{"amount_minor":1520000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"mutation_id":"arc-crm-004-mutation-01","opportunity_id":"OP-41","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-42","status":"cancelled","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":2},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.cancel"},{"arguments":{"amount_minor":1140000,"approval_id":"AP-4-current","currency":"USD","discount_bps":500,"lines":[{"quantity":6,"sku":"SEAT"},{"quantity":1,"sku":"SETUP"}],"opportunity_id":"OP-41","predecessor_id":"Q-42","status":"draft","valid_until":"2026-09-22"},"index":11,"result":{"amount_minor":1140000,"approval_id":"AP-4-current","currency":"USD","discount_bps":500,"gross_minor":1200000,"lines":[{"price_revision":2,"quantity":6,"sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":160000},{"price_revision":2,"quantity":1,"sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":240000}],"mutation_id":"arc-crm-004-mutation-02","opportunity_id":"OP-41","predecessor_id":"Q-42","quote_id":"Q-43","status":"draft","valid_until":"2026-09-22","version":3},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.create"},{"arguments":{"content":"Operations handoff \u2014 verified records and facts: Q-41; 1140000; Q-43; Q-42. Please review the linked evidence.","entity_id":"OP-41","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids":["E-4-approval-current","E-4-replacement-2","E-4-request-2"],"reference_ids":["Q-43","Q-42"]},"index":12,"result":{"content":"Operations handoff \u2014 verified records and facts: Q-41; 1140000; Q-43; Q-42. Please review the linked evidence.","entity_id":"OP-41","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-4-approval-current\",\"E-4-replacement-2\",\"E-4-request-2\"]","mutation_id":"arc-crm-004-mutation-03","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"Q-42\",\"Q-43\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"arguments":{"quote_id":"Q-42"},"index":13,"result":{"amount_minor":1520000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"lines":[{"price_revision":2,"quantity":8,"quote_id":"Q-42","sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":160000},{"price_revision":2,"quantity":1,"quote_id":"Q-42","sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":240000}],"opportunity_id":"OP-41","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-42","status":"cancelled","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":2},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"arguments":{"quote_id":"Q-43"},"index":14,"result":{"amount_minor":1140000,"approval_id":"AP-4-current","currency":"USD","discount_bps":500,"lines":[{"price_revision":2,"quantity":6,"quote_id":"Q-43","sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":160000},{"price_revision":2,"quantity":1,"quote_id":"Q-43","sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":240000}],"opportunity_id":"OP-41","predecessor_id":"Q-42","quote_id":"Q-43","status":"draft","valid_until":"2026-09-22","version":3},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"arguments":{"note_id":"NT-1"},"index":15,"result":{"content":"Operations handoff \u2014 verified records and facts: Q-41; 1140000; Q-43; Q-42. Please review the linked evidence.","entity_id":"OP-41","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-4-approval-current\",\"E-4-replacement-2\",\"E-4-request-2\"]","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"Q-42\",\"Q-43\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.get"},{"arguments":{"amount_minor":1140000,"cancelled_quote_id":"Q-42","gross_minor":1200000,"note_id":"NT-1","protected_quote_id":"Q-41","replacement_quote_id":"Q-43"},"index":16,"result":{"accepted":true,"fields":{"amount_minor":"1140000","cancelled_quote_id":"Q-42","gross_minor":"1200000","note_id":"NT-1","protected_quote_id":"Q-41","replacement_quote_id":"Q-43"},"task_id":"arc-crm-004"},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.submit_answer"}],"exact_replay":true,"negative_controls":[{"name":"noop","score":14.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945","verdict_sha256":"659ba2410b19fb59a27fe86a5c8dc37e26f54b4f99ff3cde58a1c81a8024e160"},{"name":"answer_only","score":24.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"207490f4f55027932335144f0cb0ebbe0508a6972ce667a00cb05b37927d1d2c","verdict_sha256":"f27dc4574590d4f0c758304d2aad8e4270d9ad72b79e838186d4a8d3b585faf2"},{"name":"skip_investigation","score":80.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"dd0c71ed95369872373922ecc5c4be289ccf920b785cd4a989d7e8b724b43175","verdict_sha256":"cfdbec7f805ca1850c7cc401411155f104b616fda1f2c0f218503afd61baee0f"},{"name":"write_before_investigation","score":80.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"f61efe0bf5c63da67ca8b5eb0d9a239fd195a89fb6ce83afb05a7d2bae1b9359","verdict_sha256":"0950954a23072215e52ff110bd8c426bee8d2ede1426ff0f3d3fef279099cc49"},{"name":"missing_readback","score":85.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"5fe4a61128c8a13c20c9b9d823d80aeb13dd30536b30850978a847e062032a5a","verdict_sha256":"6836e122587a5659a1c9e5fd50b0a27cfe353d3139211e107625cd3c0922304c"},{"name":"state_without_answer","score":90.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"35fe225caff6bea8059197f4671633093537874b56962167ae79a99a1dea12d4","verdict_sha256":"6dc8de39dfebdd290d86903858a3a35e637376f1d2e671b3849b57c1e2646b35"},{"name":"omit_read_1_desk.requests.search","score":97.78,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"92ae3b15859049db91f85abedf5ec6172c603b2f42d32af7adf85aac528c58ea","verdict_sha256":"6b3b885f1617016225bf6f0ffe0b24019dee18627421e9fb1ce363f120238223"},{"name":"omit_read_2_arccrm.clients.search","score":97.78,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"3ab2242277d3b2368fffda1ef4ee93ace30afe82f960a1884ed61e0c8f501438","verdict_sha256":"79b31c72a424e922fef36b1cd1e8b2e44597720e71b454d47d533649cc2358df"},{"name":"omit_read_3_desk.policies.get","score":97.78,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"a43b6acd128af9aa69544a842ad812678d62bfdb6f5c07346d6df11481b0398e","verdict_sha256":"ee0fdf99784348aa9d110c8a8b3e71e584c9dfeaa03caec500731133b48b73c0"},{"name":"omit_read_4_arccrm.opportunities.get","score":97.78,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"1a04acdfd803a4b54e866297106b974ec0cb95270fdc25bf7b31456fcf56ab67","verdict_sha256":"1857d6eb15ff84cfa8df219e03076dc80d416345c5f1bfaf5958566c5c078df8"},{"name":"omit_read_5_desk.prices.list","score":97.78,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"d2b2b0470b0c7ba8d5c457d00528d26de1dd4579073a43dcbc23ce229716c383","verdict_sha256":"1c3c72a003c1bfc527c115865fcf60022450512e85cdd1846cd74a7cc7ca5a3b"},{"name":"omit_read_6_desk.approvals.get","score":97.78,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"0307e4bdce432b130fd25338868d74cfbcd6f7eb2149731330082f9e3a91bf14","verdict_sha256":"b81d08b445337871db16b3174b05a8c1a42168d32b0be45563b21ef474450da1"},{"name":"omit_read_7_arccrm.quotes.get","score":97.78,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"3befe8b86071215625f211e2011276f7b772c1bd7bb8b17dbeca224d5f424cc3","verdict_sha256":"4f9585d8fb17cc218926d2acb7a6a761a30b1e9f2a01c7811f05e17206fcda2c"},{"name":"omit_read_8_arccrm.quotes.get","score":97.78,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"a27dbd1ef02ec3fb26cebbaaabe89574d6b847462c6dd4fcf5c826a71c79db1d","verdict_sha256":"3ea250b62867536dd6a1e65ef03ee4fbb217a654a0397a6b2772c5881635bf2b"},{"name":"omit_read_9_desk.permissions.list","score":97.78,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"b2a8e58e19fdac82abeab09c48644dce667bfe17886414bbd77e2d5044ad6210","verdict_sha256":"bd4fc70409ec935f43c0a58934ed940ca1860f77f963e8c10a5570a106786ef6"},{"name":"omit_mutation_10_arccrm.quotes.cancel","score":43.75,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"4c951eda4727fe5f3f9f6140d67c5e036f61b2aaf8eeea2b1d0fba4275a48855","verdict_sha256":"d9275e44d922fbb92a8eab6b7ffd22093b7f26ff709f3410e140cabdeaed4fa7"},{"name":"omit_mutation_11_arccrm.quotes.create","score":54.75,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"ccfd51922f9a7c82b8ef70663c08e4e2cb8811c209ed7c76d8c2bce39f380eb6","verdict_sha256":"3f070994740af12d74360b0ac0f739e75a0e390d9bc86cb2c651b33104a41c12"},{"name":"omit_mutation_12_arccrm.notes.create","score":78.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"f47d835636012cb784c88b030afb7bccb475b4f0631c9e502cdb2b0b963aeb07","verdict_sha256":"16040c012831efb09fc16bd3b590231742f9507e7d8b3ccb2689baec9136661b"},{"name":"omit_read_13_arccrm.quotes.get","score":95.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"4f60780d1299da329535c5d0cfe251068b87e38c1cab41b914716ff220207ceb","verdict_sha256":"9df01605e6849bddd1faa79f72ec8344d9323c0e10b2f9af7be09b160e01dd12"},{"name":"omit_read_14_arccrm.quotes.get","score":95.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"53c2d353f259a351eb178f298d050a6557e59174526f043daaca32fe1e8edb55","verdict_sha256":"f87b7a4a5bb3b2557662734f3737a97f7235b82e159b6d15f4fe0d2f2f109f30"},{"name":"omit_read_15_arccrm.notes.get","score":95.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"db48b5def6e29e035cca104c9289c49e2d47bd7c439c69afdeee9ec78a45fd17","verdict_sha256":"d76160763f5657f8e0214f2893070ff7e3c87edf2c052d36ac3f2688940c864d"},{"name":"superseded_request","score":97.78,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"8d56dce9f7b8940da27a2cb0f30f44c5b49a2397b07183724d11d58f6d560ac9","verdict_sha256":"0dd1ed89561cc1c4fe1e566237041af0b977ddc05fcfb8aae0ee57ae284e7fc1"},{"name":"retired_policy","score":97.78,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"64ca6205be3e2b040f924ddaecd4a9e30dfb8bdbd76cbf309da390c4289e094a","verdict_sha256":"08a01886f4eef7020cf3fc972b207de905583a5d8b0b4d7d4126dc3f3242d468"},{"name":"wrong_answer","score":98.33,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"84b53a32374fc26409556d2d258d468d596d7d6ddcfac1abababdfd3e3b59f01","verdict_sha256":"2f3f1786cea89a8de32af4af551f974eab68a67e4e3877caa9d54386378bb72b"},{"name":"missing_literal_handoff_facts","score":90.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"9bd77ddf802a7e26f4f2e4b1eaf0738cd4f55c98cf7aec2e571cf3a8d23d5e3d","verdict_sha256":"ec8898ecd5d98fec2dcd13401cd8798a6e4ca86c6675551fd1e516d756eef851"},{"name":"stale_handoff_evidence","score":89.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"a2940f624fb991bfcb25766b24e08a6e26532b7038cfcc5526538c7db28f0587","verdict_sha256":"aeec694ad6d1889a676013a667a04654e75b89f56266a700609e6d387972716b"},{"name":"cancel_signed_history","score":99.75,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"9a15935edcb86ee451a16a250ec2a79acc4a63fb838650697c6fabc9079e3922","verdict_sha256":"57297db1fdded24b3e61ebfa15a4950b9ce1752334702fce892dd953415c929a"},{"name":"duplicate_open_quote","score":99.75,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"60398d7dfd4c614f4ed96e08b7ba60e06fcdcfb9ac7c73ce58eafa9f1e113461","verdict_sha256":"40ac677987d3b1e05aa94936a747eb90bd7b40176dc96cdde43caeb724ddab54"},{"name":"wrong_cancel_version","score":99.75,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"b119b8e094f25af230f81f3b8f05847c6d2f040e301b0035ccc41bbdfd0165da","verdict_sha256":"6d3877155096eb869ac08919a7ff8a7d035b0e3d27aa3953bdf8419b7db43dbf"},{"name":"missing_replacement_lineage","score":89.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"b53e6a53546a794df434b2c1472272b73c6699a9589336d8c1a21b2aeb3bfdc4","verdict_sha256":"d7ce7c9abaa7479f88142989edbc3c02c819cbb1e5b4e6449cfb8673264535eb"}],"oracle":{"final_state":{"answers":[{"field":"amount_minor","task_id":"arc-crm-004","value":"1140000"},{"field":"cancelled_quote_id","task_id":"arc-crm-004","value":"Q-42"},{"field":"gross_minor","task_id":"arc-crm-004","value":"1200000"},{"field":"note_id","task_id":"arc-crm-004","value":"NT-1"},{"field":"protected_quote_id","task_id":"arc-crm-004","value":"Q-41"},{"field":"replacement_quote_id","task_id":"arc-crm-004","value":"Q-43"}],"audit_log":[{"action":"cancelled","audit_id":1,"payload":"{\"expected_version\":2,\"quote_id\":\"Q-42\"}","record_id":"Q-42","table_name":"crm_quotes","task_id":"arc-crm-004","tool":"arccrm.quotes.cancel"},{"action":"insert","audit_id":2,"payload":"{\"arguments\":{\"expected_version\":2,\"quote_id\":\"Q-42\"},\"tool\":\"arccrm.quotes.cancel\"}","record_id":"arc-crm-004-mutation-01","table_name":"mutations","task_id":"arc-crm-004","tool":"arccrm.quotes.cancel"},{"action":"created","audit_id":3,"payload":"{\"lines\":[{\"price_revision\":2,\"quantity\":6,\"sku\":\"SEAT\",\"unit_minor\":160000},{\"price_revision\":2,\"quantity\":1,\"sku\":\"SETUP\",\"unit_minor\":240000}]}","record_id":"Q-43","table_name":"crm_quote_lines","task_id":"arc-crm-004","tool":"arccrm.quotes.create"},{"action":"created","audit_id":4,"payload":"{\"amount_minor\":1140000,\"approval_id\":\"AP-4-current\",\"currency\":\"USD\",\"discount_bps\":500,\"lines\":[{\"quantity\":6,\"sku\":\"SEAT\"},{\"quantity\":1,\"sku\":\"SETUP\"}],\"opportunity_id\":\"OP-41\",\"predecessor_id\":\"Q-42\",\"status\":\"draft\",\"valid_until\":\"2026-09-22\"}","record_id":"Q-43","table_name":"crm_quotes","task_id":"arc-crm-004","tool":"arccrm.quotes.create"},{"action":"insert","audit_id":5,"payload":"{\"arguments\":{\"amount_minor\":1140000,\"approval_id\":\"AP-4-current\",\"currency\":\"USD\",\"discount_bps\":500,\"lines\":[{\"quantity\":6,\"sku\":\"SEAT\"},{\"quantity\":1,\"sku\":\"SETUP\"}],\"opportunity_id\":\"OP-41\",\"predecessor_id\":\"Q-42\",\"status\":\"draft\",\"valid_until\":\"2026-09-22\"},\"tool\":\"arccrm.quotes.create\"}","record_id":"arc-crm-004-mutation-02","table_name":"mutations","task_id":"arc-crm-004","tool":"arccrm.quotes.create"},{"action":"created","audit_id":6,"payload":"{\"content\":\"Q-42 cancelled and replaced by Q-43 for 1140000 USD minor units; signed Q-41 retained untouched.\",\"entity_id\":\"OP-41\",\"entity_type\":\"opportunity\",\"evidence_ids\":[\"E-4-request-2\",\"E-4-replacement-2\",\"E-4-approval-current\"],\"reference_ids\":[\"Q-42\",\"Q-43\"]}","record_id":"NT-1","table_name":"crm_notes","task_id":"arc-crm-004","tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"action":"insert","audit_id":7,"payload":"{\"arguments\":{\"content\":\"Q-42 cancelled and replaced by Q-43 for 1140000 USD minor units; signed Q-41 retained untouched.\",\"entity_id\":\"OP-41\",\"entity_type\":\"opportunity\",\"evidence_ids\":[\"E-4-request-2\",\"E-4-replacement-2\",\"E-4-approval-current\"],\"reference_ids\":[\"Q-42\",\"Q-43\"]},\"tool\":\"arccrm.notes.create\"}","record_id":"arc-crm-004-mutation-03","table_name":"mutations","task_id":"arc-crm-004","tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"action":"submit","audit_id":8,"payload":"{\"amount_minor\":\"1140000\",\"cancelled_quote_id\":\"Q-42\",\"gross_minor\":\"1200000\",\"note_id\":\"NT-1\",\"protected_quote_id\":\"Q-41\",\"replacement_quote_id\":\"Q-43\"}","record_id":"arc-crm-004","table_name":"answers","task_id":"arc-crm-004","tool":"hubbench.submit_answer"}],"crm_approvals":[{"approval_id":"AP-4-current","asset_id":"E-4-approval-current","currency":"USD","expires_on":"2026-09-25","max_discount_bps":500,"max_gross_minor":2000000,"opportunity_id":"OP-41","status":"approved"},{"approval_id":"AP-4-expired","asset_id":"E-4-approval-expired","currency":"USD","expires_on":"2026-08-31","max_discount_bps":3000,"max_gross_minor":2000000,"opportunity_id":"OP-41","status":"approved"}],"crm_attachments":[],"crm_clients":[{"client_id":"C-41","domain":"delta-cooling.example","email":"billing@delta-cooling.example","name":"Delta Cooling","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-42","domain":"services-delta-cooling.example","email":"billing@services-delta-cooling.example","name":"Delta Cooling Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-43","domain":"archive-delta-cooling.example","email":"hold@archive-delta-cooling.example","name":"Delta Cooling Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"crm_contacts":[{"client_id":"C-41","contact_id":"CT-41","email":"jamie@delta-cooling.example","first_name":"Jamie","last_name":"Park","revision":1,"title":"Procurement lead"}],"crm_contracts":[],"crm_documents":[],"crm_evidence":[{"asset_id":"E-4-approval-current","content":"Opportunity OP-41; currency USD; maximum discount 500 basis points; maximum gross 2000000 minor units; expires 2026-09-25. No permission to sign or activate.\n"},{"asset_id":"E-4-approval-expired","content":"Opportunity OP-41; currency USD; maximum discount 3000 basis points; maximum gross 2000000 minor units; expires 2026-08-31. No permission to sign or activate.\n"},{"asset_id":"E-4-pricebook","content":"sku,revision,unit_minor,currency,valid_from,valid_until\nSEAT,1,159000,USD,2026-01-01,2026-08-31\nSEAT,2,160000,USD,2026-09-01,2026-12-31\nSETUP,1,239000,USD,2026-01-01,2026-08-31\nSETUP,2,240000,USD,2026-09-01,2026-12-31\n"},{"asset_id":"E-4-replacement-1","content":"Delta Cooling\nEffective 2025-01-01 through 2026-08-31.\n{\"notice\":\"Retired. Use the current revision.\"}\n"},{"asset_id":"E-4-replacement-2","content":"Delta Cooling\nEffective 2026-09-01 through 2026-12-31.\n{\"cancel\":\"only authorized draft version\",\"history\":\"never delete\",\"replacement\":\"explicit cancelled predecessor on same opportunity\",\"signed_records\":\"immutable\"}\n"},{"asset_id":"E-4-request-1","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@delta-cooling.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@delta-cooling.example>\nSubject: Replace a superseded draft while retaining signed history\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nDelete the old quote and replace it with 8 seats. I think Q-41 is the old one.\n"},{"asset_id":"E-4-request-2","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@delta-cooling.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@delta-cooling.example>\nSubject: Replace a superseded draft while retaining signed history\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nDo not delete anything: Q-41 is signed history and must remain intact. Cancel draft Q-42 version 2 on OP-41; replace it with 6 SEAT and 1 SETUP, current prices, 500 basis points discount under AP-4-current, valid through 2026-09-22. Keep predecessor_id=Q-42 and note both old and new versions.\n"}],"crm_notes":[{"content":"Q-42 cancelled and replaced by Q-43 for 1140000 USD minor units; signed Q-41 retained untouched.","entity_id":"OP-41","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-4-approval-current\",\"E-4-replacement-2\",\"E-4-request-2\"]","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"Q-42\",\"Q-43\"]"}],"crm_opportunities":[{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-41","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-41","owner_id":"U-42","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":900000,"client_id":"C-41","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - west","opportunity_id":"OP-42","owner_id":"U-42","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-42","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-43","owner_id":"U-42","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"}],"crm_permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"quote:cancel","permission_id":"PERM-4-1","target_id":"Q-42","user_id":"U-41","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"quote:create","permission_id":"PERM-4-2","target_id":"OP-41","user_id":"U-41","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-4-3","target_id":"OP-41","user_id":"U-41","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"crm_policies":[{"asset_id":"E-4-replacement-1","effective_from":"2025-01-01","effective_until":"2026-08-31","policy_id":"POL-4-replacement-1","revision":1,"rules_json":"{\"notice\":\"Retired. Use the current revision.\"}","topic":"replacement"},{"asset_id":"E-4-replacement-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","policy_id":"POL-4-replacement-2","revision":2,"rules_json":"{\"cancel\":\"only authorized draft version\",\"history\":\"never delete\",\"replacement\":\"explicit cancelled predecessor on same opportunity\",\"signed_records\":\"immutable\"}","topic":"replacement"}],"crm_prices":[{"currency":"USD","revision":1,"sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":159000,"valid_from":"2026-01-01","valid_until":"2026-08-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":2,"sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":160000,"valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-12-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":1,"sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":239000,"valid_from":"2026-01-01","valid_until":"2026-08-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":2,"sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":240000,"valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-12-31"}],"crm_quote_lines":[{"price_revision":1,"quantity":1,"quote_id":"Q-41","sku":"LEGACY","unit_minor":1400000},{"price_revision":2,"quantity":8,"quote_id":"Q-42","sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":160000},{"price_revision":2,"quantity":1,"quote_id":"Q-42","sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":240000},{"price_revision":2,"quantity":6,"quote_id":"Q-43","sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":160000},{"price_revision":2,"quantity":1,"quote_id":"Q-43","sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":240000}],"crm_quotes":[{"amount_minor":1400000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"opportunity_id":"OP-41","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-41","status":"signed","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":1},{"amount_minor":1520000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"opportunity_id":"OP-41","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-42","status":"cancelled","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":2},{"amount_minor":1140000,"approval_id":"AP-4-current","currency":"USD","discount_bps":500,"opportunity_id":"OP-41","predecessor_id":"Q-42","quote_id":"Q-43","status":"draft","valid_until":"2026-09-22","version":3}],"crm_requests":[{"asset_id":"E-4-request-1","body":"Delete the old quote and replace it with 8 seats. I think Q-41 is the old one.","client_id":"C-41","request_id":"RQ-41","sender_id":"U-42","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Replace a superseded draft while retaining signed history","thread_id":"TH-4"},{"asset_id":"E-4-request-2","body":"Do not delete anything: Q-41 is signed history and must remain intact. Cancel draft Q-42 version 2 on OP-41; replace it with 6 SEAT and 1 SETUP, current prices, 500 basis points discount under AP-4-current, valid through 2026-09-22. Keep predecessor_id=Q-42 and note both old and new versions.","client_id":"C-41","request_id":"RQ-42","sender_id":"U-42","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Replace a superseded draft while retaining signed history","thread_id":"TH-4"}],"evidence_files":[{"asset_id":"E-4-approval-current","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"text/markdown","path":"assets/E-4-approval-current.md","sha256":"4ec767be06ef61bdec5a0c69a0a4733729c1f2639ce5adcaa945ce4be89f5562","source":"Delta Cooling","task_id":"arc-crm-004","title":"Current commercial approval"},{"asset_id":"E-4-approval-expired","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"text/markdown","path":"assets/E-4-approval-expired.md","sha256":"21fb13ea50d963ecd49c8c0ca78e60843b81a218f24b32e15018ea3c7bb54595","source":"Delta Cooling","task_id":"arc-crm-004","title":"Expired commercial approval"},{"asset_id":"E-4-pricebook","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.spreadsheetml.sheet","path":"assets/E-4-pricebook.xlsx","sha256":"517859cdba4133a4716e138b214d73b2b82c979fd56e0a5de85a91be890b660b","source":"Delta Cooling","task_id":"arc-crm-004","title":"Pricebook with current and retired prices"},{"asset_id":"E-4-replacement-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-4-replacement-1.pdf","sha256":"b1b0d49bbe2f7147167231f664ce81de84e468096d3cdcc2d3595e1ce2fbefe1","source":"Delta Cooling","task_id":"arc-crm-004","title":"Replacement policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-4-replacement-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-4-replacement-2.pdf","sha256":"7b935b2fd05b816d4ba6438e6302ebbd31f9f7b44c813887430ccbfc99b830bc","source":"Delta Cooling","task_id":"arc-crm-004","title":"Replacement policy revision 2"},{"asset_id":"E-4-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-4-request-1.eml","sha256":"ccdba0e6a4ccbda50d3438b2b2031086e0eaebf47a89a44394da8180a494d932","source":"Delta Cooling","task_id":"arc-crm-004","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-4-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-4-request-2.eml","sha256":"a1c21ac0a3b4964d0659d483007ce879a4666afd5599bec88379edb820fb5c13","source":"Delta Cooling","task_id":"arc-crm-004","title":"Owner request 2"}],"mutations":[{"effective_at":"2026-09-05T09:10:00","mutation_id":"arc-crm-004-mutation-01","payload_json":"{\"arguments\":{\"expected_version\":2,\"quote_id\":\"Q-42\"},\"tool\":\"arccrm.quotes.cancel\"}","record_id":"Q-42","revision":1,"sequence":1,"status":"cancelled","table_name":"crm_quotes","task_id":"arc-crm-004","tool":"arccrm.quotes.cancel"},{"effective_at":"2026-09-05T09:11:00","mutation_id":"arc-crm-004-mutation-02","payload_json":"{\"arguments\":{\"amount_minor\":1140000,\"approval_id\":\"AP-4-current\",\"currency\":\"USD\",\"discount_bps\":500,\"lines\":[{\"quantity\":6,\"sku\":\"SEAT\"},{\"quantity\":1,\"sku\":\"SETUP\"}],\"opportunity_id\":\"OP-41\",\"predecessor_id\":\"Q-42\",\"status\":\"draft\",\"valid_until\":\"2026-09-22\"},\"tool\":\"arccrm.quotes.create\"}","record_id":"Q-43","revision":1,"sequence":2,"status":"created","table_name":"crm_quotes","task_id":"arc-crm-004","tool":"arccrm.quotes.create"},{"effective_at":"2026-09-05T09:12:00","mutation_id":"arc-crm-004-mutation-03","payload_json":"{\"arguments\":{\"content\":\"Q-42 cancelled and replaced by Q-43 for 1140000 USD minor units; signed Q-41 retained untouched.\",\"entity_id\":\"OP-41\",\"entity_type\":\"opportunity\",\"evidence_ids\":[\"E-4-request-2\",\"E-4-replacement-2\",\"E-4-approval-current\"],\"reference_ids\":[\"Q-42\",\"Q-43\"]},\"tool\":\"arccrm.notes.create\"}","record_id":"NT-1","revision":1,"sequence":3,"status":"created","table_name":"crm_notes","task_id":"arc-crm-004","tool":"arccrm.notes.create"}],"users":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-41"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-42"}]},"initial_state":{"answers":[],"audit_log":[],"crm_approvals":[{"approval_id":"AP-4-current","asset_id":"E-4-approval-current","currency":"USD","expires_on":"2026-09-25","max_discount_bps":500,"max_gross_minor":2000000,"opportunity_id":"OP-41","status":"approved"},{"approval_id":"AP-4-expired","asset_id":"E-4-approval-expired","currency":"USD","expires_on":"2026-08-31","max_discount_bps":3000,"max_gross_minor":2000000,"opportunity_id":"OP-41","status":"approved"}],"crm_attachments":[],"crm_clients":[{"client_id":"C-41","domain":"delta-cooling.example","email":"billing@delta-cooling.example","name":"Delta Cooling","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-42","domain":"services-delta-cooling.example","email":"billing@services-delta-cooling.example","name":"Delta Cooling Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-43","domain":"archive-delta-cooling.example","email":"hold@archive-delta-cooling.example","name":"Delta Cooling Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"crm_contacts":[{"client_id":"C-41","contact_id":"CT-41","email":"jamie@delta-cooling.example","first_name":"Jamie","last_name":"Park","revision":1,"title":"Procurement lead"}],"crm_contracts":[],"crm_documents":[],"crm_evidence":[{"asset_id":"E-4-approval-current","content":"Opportunity OP-41; currency USD; maximum discount 500 basis points; maximum gross 2000000 minor units; expires 2026-09-25. No permission to sign or activate.\n"},{"asset_id":"E-4-approval-expired","content":"Opportunity OP-41; currency USD; maximum discount 3000 basis points; maximum gross 2000000 minor units; expires 2026-08-31. No permission to sign or activate.\n"},{"asset_id":"E-4-pricebook","content":"sku,revision,unit_minor,currency,valid_from,valid_until\nSEAT,1,159000,USD,2026-01-01,2026-08-31\nSEAT,2,160000,USD,2026-09-01,2026-12-31\nSETUP,1,239000,USD,2026-01-01,2026-08-31\nSETUP,2,240000,USD,2026-09-01,2026-12-31\n"},{"asset_id":"E-4-replacement-1","content":"Delta Cooling\nEffective 2025-01-01 through 2026-08-31.\n{\"notice\":\"Retired. Use the current revision.\"}\n"},{"asset_id":"E-4-replacement-2","content":"Delta Cooling\nEffective 2026-09-01 through 2026-12-31.\n{\"cancel\":\"only authorized draft version\",\"history\":\"never delete\",\"replacement\":\"explicit cancelled predecessor on same opportunity\",\"signed_records\":\"immutable\"}\n"},{"asset_id":"E-4-request-1","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@delta-cooling.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@delta-cooling.example>\nSubject: Replace a superseded draft while retaining signed history\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nDelete the old quote and replace it with 8 seats. I think Q-41 is the old one.\n"},{"asset_id":"E-4-request-2","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@delta-cooling.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@delta-cooling.example>\nSubject: Replace a superseded draft while retaining signed history\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nDo not delete anything: Q-41 is signed history and must remain intact. Cancel draft Q-42 version 2 on OP-41; replace it with 6 SEAT and 1 SETUP, current prices, 500 basis points discount under AP-4-current, valid through 2026-09-22. Keep predecessor_id=Q-42 and note both old and new versions.\n"}],"crm_notes":[],"crm_opportunities":[{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-41","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-41","owner_id":"U-42","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":900000,"client_id":"C-41","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - west","opportunity_id":"OP-42","owner_id":"U-42","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-42","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-43","owner_id":"U-42","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"}],"crm_permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"quote:cancel","permission_id":"PERM-4-1","target_id":"Q-42","user_id":"U-41","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"quote:create","permission_id":"PERM-4-2","target_id":"OP-41","user_id":"U-41","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-4-3","target_id":"OP-41","user_id":"U-41","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"crm_policies":[{"asset_id":"E-4-replacement-1","effective_from":"2025-01-01","effective_until":"2026-08-31","policy_id":"POL-4-replacement-1","revision":1,"rules_json":"{\"notice\":\"Retired. Use the current revision.\"}","topic":"replacement"},{"asset_id":"E-4-replacement-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","policy_id":"POL-4-replacement-2","revision":2,"rules_json":"{\"cancel\":\"only authorized draft version\",\"history\":\"never delete\",\"replacement\":\"explicit cancelled predecessor on same opportunity\",\"signed_records\":\"immutable\"}","topic":"replacement"}],"crm_prices":[{"currency":"USD","revision":1,"sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":159000,"valid_from":"2026-01-01","valid_until":"2026-08-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":2,"sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":160000,"valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-12-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":1,"sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":239000,"valid_from":"2026-01-01","valid_until":"2026-08-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":2,"sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":240000,"valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-12-31"}],"crm_quote_lines":[{"price_revision":1,"quantity":1,"quote_id":"Q-41","sku":"LEGACY","unit_minor":1400000},{"price_revision":2,"quantity":8,"quote_id":"Q-42","sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":160000},{"price_revision":2,"quantity":1,"quote_id":"Q-42","sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":240000}],"crm_quotes":[{"amount_minor":1400000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"opportunity_id":"OP-41","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-41","status":"signed","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":1},{"amount_minor":1520000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"opportunity_id":"OP-41","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-42","status":"draft","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":2}],"crm_requests":[{"asset_id":"E-4-request-1","body":"Delete the old quote and replace it with 8 seats. I think Q-41 is the old one.","client_id":"C-41","request_id":"RQ-41","sender_id":"U-42","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Replace a superseded draft while retaining signed history","thread_id":"TH-4"},{"asset_id":"E-4-request-2","body":"Do not delete anything: Q-41 is signed history and must remain intact. Cancel draft Q-42 version 2 on OP-41; replace it with 6 SEAT and 1 SETUP, current prices, 500 basis points discount under AP-4-current, valid through 2026-09-22. Keep predecessor_id=Q-42 and note both old and new versions.","client_id":"C-41","request_id":"RQ-42","sender_id":"U-42","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Replace a superseded draft while retaining signed history","thread_id":"TH-4"}],"evidence_files":[{"asset_id":"E-4-approval-current","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"text/markdown","path":"assets/E-4-approval-current.md","sha256":"4ec767be06ef61bdec5a0c69a0a4733729c1f2639ce5adcaa945ce4be89f5562","source":"Delta Cooling","task_id":"arc-crm-004","title":"Current commercial approval"},{"asset_id":"E-4-approval-expired","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"text/markdown","path":"assets/E-4-approval-expired.md","sha256":"21fb13ea50d963ecd49c8c0ca78e60843b81a218f24b32e15018ea3c7bb54595","source":"Delta Cooling","task_id":"arc-crm-004","title":"Expired commercial approval"},{"asset_id":"E-4-pricebook","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.spreadsheetml.sheet","path":"assets/E-4-pricebook.xlsx","sha256":"517859cdba4133a4716e138b214d73b2b82c979fd56e0a5de85a91be890b660b","source":"Delta Cooling","task_id":"arc-crm-004","title":"Pricebook with current and retired prices"},{"asset_id":"E-4-replacement-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-4-replacement-1.pdf","sha256":"b1b0d49bbe2f7147167231f664ce81de84e468096d3cdcc2d3595e1ce2fbefe1","source":"Delta Cooling","task_id":"arc-crm-004","title":"Replacement policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-4-replacement-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-4-replacement-2.pdf","sha256":"7b935b2fd05b816d4ba6438e6302ebbd31f9f7b44c813887430ccbfc99b830bc","source":"Delta Cooling","task_id":"arc-crm-004","title":"Replacement policy revision 2"},{"asset_id":"E-4-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-4-request-1.eml","sha256":"ccdba0e6a4ccbda50d3438b2b2031086e0eaebf47a89a44394da8180a494d932","source":"Delta Cooling","task_id":"arc-crm-004","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-4-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-4-request-2.eml","sha256":"a1c21ac0a3b4964d0659d483007ce879a4666afd5599bec88379edb820fb5c13","source":"Delta Cooling","task_id":"arc-crm-004","title":"Owner request 2"}],"mutations":[],"users":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-41"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-42"}]},"trace":[{"arguments":{},"index":0,"result":{"evidence_index":[{"asset_id":"E-4-approval-current","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"text/markdown","path":"assets/E-4-approval-current.md","sha256":"4ec767be06ef61bdec5a0c69a0a4733729c1f2639ce5adcaa945ce4be89f5562","source":"Delta Cooling","title":"Current commercial approval"},{"asset_id":"E-4-approval-expired","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"text/markdown","path":"assets/E-4-approval-expired.md","sha256":"21fb13ea50d963ecd49c8c0ca78e60843b81a218f24b32e15018ea3c7bb54595","source":"Delta Cooling","title":"Expired commercial approval"},{"asset_id":"E-4-pricebook","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.spreadsheetml.sheet","path":"assets/E-4-pricebook.xlsx","sha256":"517859cdba4133a4716e138b214d73b2b82c979fd56e0a5de85a91be890b660b","source":"Delta Cooling","title":"Pricebook with current and retired prices"},{"asset_id":"E-4-replacement-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-4-replacement-1.pdf","sha256":"b1b0d49bbe2f7147167231f664ce81de84e468096d3cdcc2d3595e1ce2fbefe1","source":"Delta Cooling","title":"Replacement policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-4-replacement-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-4-replacement-2.pdf","sha256":"7b935b2fd05b816d4ba6438e6302ebbd31f9f7b44c813887430ccbfc99b830bc","source":"Delta Cooling","title":"Replacement policy revision 2"},{"asset_id":"E-4-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-4-request-1.eml","sha256":"ccdba0e6a4ccbda50d3438b2b2031086e0eaebf47a89a44394da8180a494d932","source":"Delta Cooling","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-4-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-4-request-2.eml","sha256":"a1c21ac0a3b4964d0659d483007ce879a4666afd5599bec88379edb820fb5c13","source":"Delta Cooling","title":"Owner request 2"}],"identity":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-41"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-42"}],"organization":{"name":"Delta Cooling","synthetic":true,"systems":["arccrm","desk","vault"]},"reference_records":{},"starting_records":[{"client_hint":"Delta Cooling","thread_id":"TH-4"}],"state":{"network":"closed","persistence":"episode-local SQLite","scope":"isolated task snapshot"},"task":{"as_of":"2026-09-05","family":"arc-crm","role":"U-41","task_id":"arc-crm-004"},"tool_servers":[{"description":"Stateful synthetic CRM","name":"arccrm","tools":["arccrm.attachments.get","arccrm.attachments.search","arccrm.clients.get","arccrm.clients.search","arccrm.contacts.create","arccrm.contacts.get","arccrm.contacts.search","arccrm.contracts.create","arccrm.contracts.get","arccrm.contracts.search","arccrm.documents.attach","arccrm.documents.get","arccrm.documents.search","arccrm.notes.create","arccrm.notes.get","arccrm.notes.search","arccrm.opportunities.get","arccrm.opportunities.search","arccrm.opportunities.update","arccrm.quotes.cancel","arccrm.quotes.compare","arccrm.quotes.create","arccrm.quotes.get","arccrm.quotes.search"]},{"description":"Mock requests, permissions, approvals and versioned policy/price records","name":"desk","tools":["desk.approvals.get","desk.permissions.list","desk.policies.get","desk.prices.list","desk.requests.get","desk.requests.search"]},{"description":"Seeded synthetic evidence; no external file access","name":"vault","tools":["vault.files.get"]},{"description":"Benchmark-only discovery and structured answer submission controls.","name":"hubbench","tools":["hubbench.context.get","hubbench.submit_answer"]}]},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.context.get"},{"arguments":{"query":"TH-4"},"index":1,"result":{"query":"th-4","records":[{"asset_id":"E-4-request-1","body":"Delete the old quote and replace it with 8 seats. I think Q-41 is the old one.","client_id":"C-41","request_id":"RQ-41","sender_id":"U-42","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Replace a superseded draft while retaining signed history","thread_id":"TH-4"},{"asset_id":"E-4-request-2","body":"Do not delete anything: Q-41 is signed history and must remain intact. Cancel draft Q-42 version 2 on OP-41; replace it with 6 SEAT and 1 SETUP, current prices, 500 basis points discount under AP-4-current, valid through 2026-09-22. Keep predecessor_id=Q-42 and note both old and new versions.","client_id":"C-41","request_id":"RQ-42","sender_id":"U-42","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Replace a superseded draft while retaining signed history","thread_id":"TH-4"}],"total":2},"success":true,"tool":"desk.requests.search"},{"arguments":{"query":"Delta Cooling"},"index":2,"result":{"query":"delta cooling","records":[{"client_id":"C-41","domain":"delta-cooling.example","email":"billing@delta-cooling.example","name":"Delta Cooling","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-42","domain":"services-delta-cooling.example","email":"billing@services-delta-cooling.example","name":"Delta Cooling Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-43","domain":"archive-delta-cooling.example","email":"hold@archive-delta-cooling.example","name":"Delta Cooling Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"total":3},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.clients.search"},{"arguments":{"policy_id":"POL-4-replacement-2"},"index":3,"result":{"asset_id":"E-4-replacement-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","operative":true,"policy_id":"POL-4-replacement-2","revision":2,"rules":{"cancel":"only authorized draft version","history":"never delete","replacement":"explicit cancelled predecessor on same opportunity","signed_records":"immutable"},"rules_json":"{\"cancel\":\"only authorized draft version\",\"history\":\"never delete\",\"replacement\":\"explicit cancelled predecessor on same opportunity\",\"signed_records\":\"immutable\"}","topic":"replacement"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.policies.get"},{"arguments":{"opportunity_id":"OP-41"},"index":4,"result":{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-41","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-41","owner_id":"U-42","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"},{"arguments":{"currency":"USD"},"index":5,"result":{"prices":[{"currency":"USD","revision":1,"sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":159000,"valid_from":"2026-01-01","valid_until":"2026-08-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":2,"sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":160000,"valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-12-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":1,"sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":239000,"valid_from":"2026-01-01","valid_until":"2026-08-31"},{"currency":"USD","revision":2,"sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":240000,"valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-12-31"}]},"success":true,"tool":"desk.prices.list"},{"arguments":{"approval_id":"AP-4-current"},"index":6,"result":{"approval_id":"AP-4-current","asset_id":"E-4-approval-current","currency":"USD","expires_on":"2026-09-25","max_discount_bps":500,"max_gross_minor":2000000,"opportunity_id":"OP-41","status":"approved"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.approvals.get"},{"arguments":{"quote_id":"Q-41"},"index":7,"result":{"amount_minor":1400000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"lines":[{"price_revision":1,"quantity":1,"quote_id":"Q-41","sku":"LEGACY","unit_minor":1400000}],"opportunity_id":"OP-41","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-41","status":"signed","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":1},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"arguments":{"quote_id":"Q-42"},"index":8,"result":{"amount_minor":1520000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"lines":[{"price_revision":2,"quantity":8,"quote_id":"Q-42","sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":160000},{"price_revision":2,"quantity":1,"quote_id":"Q-42","sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":240000}],"opportunity_id":"OP-41","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-42","status":"draft","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":2},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"arguments":{},"index":9,"result":{"permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"quote:cancel","permission_id":"PERM-4-1","target_id":"Q-42","user_id":"U-41","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"quote:create","permission_id":"PERM-4-2","target_id":"OP-41","user_id":"U-41","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-4-3","target_id":"OP-41","user_id":"U-41","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"user_id":"U-41"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.permissions.list"},{"arguments":{"expected_version":2,"quote_id":"Q-42"},"index":10,"result":{"amount_minor":1520000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"mutation_id":"arc-crm-004-mutation-01","opportunity_id":"OP-41","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-42","status":"cancelled","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":2},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.cancel"},{"arguments":{"amount_minor":1140000,"approval_id":"AP-4-current","currency":"USD","discount_bps":500,"lines":[{"quantity":6,"sku":"SEAT"},{"quantity":1,"sku":"SETUP"}],"opportunity_id":"OP-41","predecessor_id":"Q-42","status":"draft","valid_until":"2026-09-22"},"index":11,"result":{"amount_minor":1140000,"approval_id":"AP-4-current","currency":"USD","discount_bps":500,"gross_minor":1200000,"lines":[{"price_revision":2,"quantity":6,"sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":160000},{"price_revision":2,"quantity":1,"sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":240000}],"mutation_id":"arc-crm-004-mutation-02","opportunity_id":"OP-41","predecessor_id":"Q-42","quote_id":"Q-43","status":"draft","valid_until":"2026-09-22","version":3},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.create"},{"arguments":{"content":"Q-42 cancelled and replaced by Q-43 for 1140000 USD minor units; signed Q-41 retained untouched.","entity_id":"OP-41","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids":["E-4-request-2","E-4-replacement-2","E-4-approval-current"],"reference_ids":["Q-42","Q-43"]},"index":12,"result":{"content":"Q-42 cancelled and replaced by Q-43 for 1140000 USD minor units; signed Q-41 retained untouched.","entity_id":"OP-41","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-4-approval-current\",\"E-4-replacement-2\",\"E-4-request-2\"]","mutation_id":"arc-crm-004-mutation-03","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"Q-42\",\"Q-43\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"arguments":{"quote_id":"Q-42"},"index":13,"result":{"amount_minor":1520000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"lines":[{"price_revision":2,"quantity":8,"quote_id":"Q-42","sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":160000},{"price_revision":2,"quantity":1,"quote_id":"Q-42","sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":240000}],"opportunity_id":"OP-41","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-42","status":"cancelled","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":2},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"arguments":{"quote_id":"Q-43"},"index":14,"result":{"amount_minor":1140000,"approval_id":"AP-4-current","currency":"USD","discount_bps":500,"lines":[{"price_revision":2,"quantity":6,"quote_id":"Q-43","sku":"SEAT","unit_minor":160000},{"price_revision":2,"quantity":1,"quote_id":"Q-43","sku":"SETUP","unit_minor":240000}],"opportunity_id":"OP-41","predecessor_id":"Q-42","quote_id":"Q-43","status":"draft","valid_until":"2026-09-22","version":3},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"arguments":{"note_id":"NT-1"},"index":15,"result":{"content":"Q-42 cancelled and replaced by Q-43 for 1140000 USD minor units; signed Q-41 retained untouched.","entity_id":"OP-41","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-4-approval-current\",\"E-4-replacement-2\",\"E-4-request-2\"]","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"Q-42\",\"Q-43\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.get"},{"arguments":{"amount_minor":1140000,"cancelled_quote_id":"Q-42","gross_minor":1200000,"note_id":"NT-1","protected_quote_id":"Q-41","replacement_quote_id":"Q-43"},"index":16,"result":{"accepted":true,"fields":{"amount_minor":"1140000","cancelled_quote_id":"Q-42","gross_minor":"1200000","note_id":"NT-1","protected_quote_id":"Q-41","replacement_quote_id":"Q-43"},"task_id":"arc-crm-004"},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.submit_answer"}],"verdict":{"checks":[{"category":"evidence","description":"quote_replacement: evidence","earned_weight":20.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":9,"subchecks":[{"description":"Resolve the owner's current clarification, not the superseded message.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":1,"tool":"desk.requests.search"}]},"id":"investigate-current_request","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Identify the existing verified client and the similarly named account.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":2,"tool":"arccrm.clients.search"}]},"id":"investigate-verified_client","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the operative policy and its scope.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":3,"tool":"desk.policies.get"}]},"id":"investigate-operative_policy","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the precise opportunity identity, owner, revision and commercial fields.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":4,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"}]},"id":"investigate-opportunity","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Use current SKU prices, not the expired pricebook.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":5,"tool":"desk.prices.list"}]},"id":"investigate-pricing","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Check the current scoped approval and expiry.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":6,"tool":"desk.approvals.get"}]},"id":"investigate-approval","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the exact quote version, status, links and value.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":7,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"index":8,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"}]},"id":"investigate-signed_history","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the exact quote version, status, links and value.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":7,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"index":8,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"}]},"id":"investigate-superseded_draft","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the acting role's specific operation/target grants before writing.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":9,"tool":"desk.permissions.list"}]},"id":"investigate-authority","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":9},"id":"evidence","passed":true,"weight":20.0},{"category":"readback","description":"quote_replacement: readback","earned_weight":15.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":3,"subchecks":[{"description":"Read back the persisted cancelled_predecessor after the business mutation.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":7,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"index":8,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"index":13,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"index":14,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"}]},"id":"readback-cancelled_predecessor","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read back the persisted replacement after the business mutation.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":7,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"index":8,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"index":13,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"index":14,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"}]},"id":"readback-replacement","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read back the persisted handoff after the business mutation.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":15,"tool":"arccrm.notes.get"}]},"id":"readback-handoff","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":3},"id":"readback","passed":true,"weight":15.0},{"category":"outcome","description":"quote_replacement: outcome","earned_weight":30.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":5,"subchecks":[{"description":"Preserve crm_quotes record {'quote_id': 'Q-42'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_quotes-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Persist the required crm_quotes record and exact structural fields.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"create-crm_quotes-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Persist the required crm_quote_lines record and exact structural fields.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"create-crm_quote_lines-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Persist the required crm_quote_lines record and exact structural fields.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"create-crm_quote_lines-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Persist the required crm_notes record and exact structural fields.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"create-crm_notes-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":5},"id":"outcome","passed":true,"weight":30.0},{"category":"containment","description":"quote_replacement: containment","earned_weight":15.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":60,"subchecks":[{"description":"Preserve users record {'user_id': 'U-41'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-users-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve users record {'user_id': 'U-42'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-users-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in users.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-users","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-4-request-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-4-request-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-4-replacement-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-4-replacement-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-3","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-4-pricebook'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-4","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-4-approval-expired'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-5","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-4-approval-current'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-6","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in evidence_files.","evidence":{"expected_count":7,"matching_rows":7},"id":"count-evidence_files","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-4-request-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-4-request-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-4-replacement-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-4-replacement-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-3","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-4-pricebook'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-4","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-4-approval-expired'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-5","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-4-approval-current'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-6","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_evidence.","evidence":{"expected_count":7,"matching_rows":7},"id":"count-crm_evidence","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_clients record {'client_id': 'C-41'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_clients-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_clients record {'client_id': 'C-42'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_clients-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_clients record {'client_id': 'C-43'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_clients-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_clients.","evidence":{"expected_count":3,"matching_rows":3},"id":"count-crm_clients","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_contacts record {'contact_id': 'CT-41'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_contacts-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_contacts.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1},"id":"count-crm_contacts","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_opportunities record {'opportunity_id': 'OP-41'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_opportunities-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_opportunities record {'opportunity_id': 'OP-42'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_opportunities-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_opportunities record {'opportunity_id': 'OP-43'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_opportunities-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_opportunities.","evidence":{"expected_count":3,"matching_rows":3},"id":"count-crm_opportunities","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_quotes record {'quote_id': 'Q-41'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_quotes-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_quotes.","evidence":{"expected_count":3,"matching_rows":3},"id":"count-crm_quotes","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_quote_lines record {'quote_id': 'Q-41', 'sku': 'LEGACY'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_quote_lines-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_quote_lines record {'quote_id': 'Q-42', 'sku': 'SEAT'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_quote_lines-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_quote_lines record {'quote_id': 'Q-42', 'sku': 'SETUP'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_quote_lines-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_quote_lines.","evidence":{"expected_count":5,"matching_rows":5},"id":"count-crm_quote_lines","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_contracts.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_contracts","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_documents.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_documents","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_attachments.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_attachments","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_notes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1},"id":"count-crm_notes","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_requests record {'request_id': 'RQ-41'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_requests-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_requests record {'request_id': 'RQ-42'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_requests-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_requests.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-crm_requests","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_policies record {'policy_id': 'POL-4-replacement-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_policies-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_policies record {'policy_id': 'POL-4-replacement-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_policies-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_policies.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-crm_policies","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_prices record {'sku': 'SEAT', 'revision': 1, 'currency': 'USD'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_prices-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_prices record {'sku': 'SEAT', 'revision': 2, 'currency': 'USD'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_prices-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_prices record {'sku': 'SETUP', 'revision': 1, 'currency': 'USD'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_prices-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_prices record {'sku': 'SETUP', 'revision': 2, 'currency': 'USD'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_prices-3","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_prices.","evidence":{"expected_count":4,"matching_rows":4},"id":"count-crm_prices","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_approvals record {'approval_id': 'AP-4-expired'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_approvals-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_approvals record {'approval_id': 'AP-4-current'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_approvals-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_approvals.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-crm_approvals","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_permissions record {'permission_id': 'PERM-4-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_permissions-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_permissions record {'permission_id': 'PERM-4-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_permissions-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_permissions record {'permission_id': 'PERM-4-3'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_permissions-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_permissions.","evidence":{"expected_count":3,"matching_rows":3},"id":"count-crm_permissions","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Exactly the required domain writes, with no hidden extra mutation.","evidence":{"expected_count":3,"matching_rows":3},"id":"count-mutations","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Kept every successful write inside arc-crm-004's declared state, collaboration, answer, and audit tables.","evidence":{"disallowed":[],"written_tables":["answers","crm_notes","crm_quote_lines","crm_quotes","mutations"]},"id":"write_scope","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Completed without a rejected state-changing call; failed exploratory reads and retryable provider faults do not erase a correct outcome.","evidence":{"errors":[]},"id":"no_rejected_mutation","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":60},"id":"containment","passed":true,"weight":15.0},{"category":"handoff","description":"quote_replacement: handoff","earned_weight":10.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":1,"subchecks":[{"description":"Handoff content contains the disclosed literal facts; punctuation/case/prose may vary. Not a semantic consistency check.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1},"id":"handoff-facts","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":1},"id":"handoff","passed":true,"weight":10.0},{"category":"answer","description":"quote_replacement: answer","earned_weight":10.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":6,"subchecks":[{"description":"Report the correct cancelled quote id.","evidence":{"expected":"Q-42","field":"cancelled_quote_id","submitted":"Q-42"},"id":"answer-cancelled_quote_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct replacement quote id.","evidence":{"expected":"Q-43","field":"replacement_quote_id","submitted":"Q-43"},"id":"answer-replacement_quote_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct protected quote id.","evidence":{"expected":"Q-41","field":"protected_quote_id","submitted":"Q-41"},"id":"answer-protected_quote_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct amount minor.","evidence":{"expected":"1140000","field":"amount_minor","submitted":"1140000"},"id":"answer-amount_minor","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct gross minor.","evidence":{"expected":"1200000","field":"gross_minor","submitted":"1200000"},"id":"answer-gross_minor","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct note id.","evidence":{"expected":"NT-1","field":"note_id","submitted":"NT-1"},"id":"answer-note_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":6},"id":"answer","passed":true,"weight":10.0}],"metric":"HubScore","passed_atomic_checks":84,"passed_checks":6,"passed_weight":100.0,"score":100.0,"strict_pass":true,"task_id":"arc-crm-004","total_atomic_checks":84,"total_checks":6,"total_weight":100.0}},"replay_sha256":"eac2b61a7ae6570979719f1c60cab3efa9b5f8a69d2288a41e97232bde831e45","task_id":"arc-crm-004","task_sha256":"a10cb5b463a91766ee42f6aeb59450ff77017a2cb5ea7000eb2102c6277162fd"},{"alternate_pass":true,"alternate_trace":[{"arguments":{},"index":0,"result":{"evidence_index":[{"asset_id":"E-5-contract-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-5-contract-1.pdf","sha256":"a82e78699961482bb7f05fb3d44c572a7bf19320c3d0be112c07dbd32de8b593","source":"Ember Diagnostics","title":"Contract policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-5-contract-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-5-contract-2.pdf","sha256":"66fe519d375fe33ebbce371cee26e888399a3c022749073e742980bb53f0474f","source":"Ember Diagnostics","title":"Contract policy revision 2"},{"asset_id":"E-5-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-5-request-1.eml","sha256":"f3a9ff4dd0c4986face6f19f8e185dda34830ca6eab2979451ed9eed40101407","source":"Ember Diagnostics","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-5-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-5-request-2.eml","sha256":"d54c60c729a9da391313deb5ee5df01150a540c3fa307f60dd0c6279781452f3","source":"Ember Diagnostics","title":"Owner request 2"}],"identity":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-51"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-52"}],"organization":{"name":"Ember Diagnostics","synthetic":true,"systems":["arccrm","desk","vault"]},"reference_records":{},"starting_records":[{"client_hint":"Ember Diagnostics","thread_id":"TH-5"}],"state":{"network":"closed","persistence":"episode-local SQLite","scope":"isolated task snapshot"},"task":{"as_of":"2026-09-05","family":"arc-crm","role":"U-51","task_id":"arc-crm-005"},"tool_servers":[{"description":"Stateful synthetic CRM","name":"arccrm","tools":["arccrm.attachments.get","arccrm.attachments.search","arccrm.clients.get","arccrm.clients.search","arccrm.contacts.create","arccrm.contacts.get","arccrm.contacts.search","arccrm.contracts.create","arccrm.contracts.get","arccrm.contracts.search","arccrm.documents.attach","arccrm.documents.get","arccrm.documents.search","arccrm.notes.create","arccrm.notes.get","arccrm.notes.search","arccrm.opportunities.get","arccrm.opportunities.search","arccrm.opportunities.update","arccrm.quotes.cancel","arccrm.quotes.compare","arccrm.quotes.create","arccrm.quotes.get","arccrm.quotes.search"]},{"description":"Mock requests, permissions, approvals and versioned policy/price records","name":"desk","tools":["desk.approvals.get","desk.permissions.list","desk.policies.get","desk.prices.list","desk.requests.get","desk.requests.search"]},{"description":"Seeded synthetic evidence; no external file access","name":"vault","tools":["vault.files.get"]},{"description":"Benchmark-only discovery and structured answer submission controls.","name":"hubbench","tools":["hubbench.context.get","hubbench.submit_answer"]}]},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.context.get"},{"arguments":{},"index":1,"result":{"permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"contract:create","permission_id":"PERM-5-1","target_id":"Q-52","user_id":"U-51","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-5-2","target_id":"OP-51","user_id":"U-51","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"user_id":"U-51"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.permissions.list"},{"arguments":{"query":"OP-51"},"index":2,"result":{"query":"op-51","records":[],"total":0},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.contracts.search"},{"arguments":{"quote_id":"Q-52"},"index":3,"result":{"amount_minor":1876500,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"lines":[],"opportunity_id":"OP-51","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-52","status":"approved","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":2},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"arguments":{"quote_id":"Q-51"},"index":4,"result":{"amount_minor":2200000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"lines":[],"opportunity_id":"OP-51","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-51","status":"cancelled","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":1},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"arguments":{"opportunity_id":"OP-51"},"index":5,"result":{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-51","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-51","owner_id":"U-52","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"},{"arguments":{"policy_id":"POL-5-contract-2"},"index":6,"result":{"asset_id":"E-5-contract-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","operative":true,"policy_id":"POL-5-contract-2","revision":2,"rules":{"duplicate_quote_contract":"reject","legal_review_required":true,"signed_at":null,"status":"draft only","value":"exact current approved quote"},"rules_json":"{\"duplicate_quote_contract\":\"reject\",\"legal_review_required\":true,\"signed_at\":null,\"status\":\"draft only\",\"value\":\"exact current approved quote\"}","topic":"contract"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.policies.get"},{"arguments":{"query":"Ember Diagnostics"},"index":7,"result":{"query":"ember diagnostics","records":[{"client_id":"C-51","domain":"ember-diagnostics.example","email":"billing@ember-diagnostics.example","name":"Ember Diagnostics","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-52","domain":"services-ember-diagnostics.example","email":"billing@services-ember-diagnostics.example","name":"Ember Diagnostics Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-53","domain":"archive-ember-diagnostics.example","email":"hold@archive-ember-diagnostics.example","name":"Ember Diagnostics Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"total":3},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.clients.search"},{"arguments":{"query":"TH-5"},"index":8,"result":{"query":"th-5","records":[{"asset_id":"E-5-request-1","body":"Use the old 22000-dollar proposal and mark the contract signed so onboarding can proceed.","client_id":"C-51","request_id":"RQ-51","sender_id":"U-52","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Draft a contract from the approved commercial record","thread_id":"TH-5"},{"asset_id":"E-5-request-2","body":"Legal correction: Q-52 is the approved current quote on OP-51, worth 1876500 USD minor units. Q-51 is cancelled and stale. Create an unsigned draft only for the active existing client, reference Q-52 explicitly, then hand off to legal. Alex has drafting authority up to 2500000 minor units but no signing authority.","client_id":"C-51","request_id":"RQ-52","sender_id":"U-52","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Draft a contract from the approved commercial record","thread_id":"TH-5"}],"total":2},"success":true,"tool":"desk.requests.search"},{"arguments":{"client_id":"C-51","currency":"USD","opportunity_id":"OP-51","quote_id":"Q-52","status":"draft","value_minor":1876500},"index":9,"result":{"client_id":"C-51","contract_id":"CN-1","currency":"USD","mutation_id":"arc-crm-005-mutation-01","opportunity_id":"OP-51","quote_id":"Q-52","signed_at":null,"status":"draft","value_minor":1876500},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.contracts.create"},{"arguments":{"content":"Operations handoff \u2014 verified records and facts: legal; unsigned; 1876500; Q-52; CN-1. Please review the linked evidence.","entity_id":"OP-51","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids":["E-5-contract-2","E-5-request-2"],"reference_ids":["Q-52","CN-1"]},"index":10,"result":{"content":"Operations handoff \u2014 verified records and facts: legal; unsigned; 1876500; Q-52; CN-1. Please review the linked evidence.","entity_id":"OP-51","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-5-contract-2\",\"E-5-request-2\"]","mutation_id":"arc-crm-005-mutation-02","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"CN-1\",\"Q-52\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"arguments":{"contract_id":"CN-1"},"index":11,"result":{"client_id":"C-51","contract_id":"CN-1","currency":"USD","opportunity_id":"OP-51","quote_id":"Q-52","signed_at":null,"status":"draft","value_minor":1876500},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.contracts.get"},{"arguments":{"note_id":"NT-1"},"index":12,"result":{"content":"Operations handoff \u2014 verified records and facts: legal; unsigned; 1876500; Q-52; CN-1. Please review the linked evidence.","entity_id":"OP-51","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-5-contract-2\",\"E-5-request-2\"]","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"CN-1\",\"Q-52\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.get"},{"arguments":{"client_id":"C-51","contract_id":"CN-1","note_id":"NT-1","opportunity_id":"OP-51","quote_id":"Q-52","status":"draft","value_minor":1876500},"index":13,"result":{"accepted":true,"fields":{"client_id":"C-51","contract_id":"CN-1","note_id":"NT-1","opportunity_id":"OP-51","quote_id":"Q-52","status":"draft","value_minor":"1876500"},"task_id":"arc-crm-005"},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.submit_answer"}],"exact_replay":true,"negative_controls":[{"name":"noop","score":14.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945","verdict_sha256":"b78a78880789c77689c5305da2dffc650d3def12540d945a7db987e0d09509dc"},{"name":"answer_only","score":24.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"867839a9e46d251927e0dac3833a5c66ddc4f0a809a85335e5100cd73a61ec41","verdict_sha256":"444b9c30a2b967a79b99b649a23a6c79f0046c452593f77026e360d33c7d7b93"},{"name":"skip_investigation","score":80.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"e119c0e25721e44789fc6e1e8142662add69e9d4aeba08cedb9e5356e14bee8a","verdict_sha256":"d80648e9797ba68df571a3d7a226985399f0808f0055ad7d34fa9b32617035ef"},{"name":"write_before_investigation","score":80.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"2c5124ec28409659b0bf36825235814378ba7f5d685be260bbffa9bd5bd26012","verdict_sha256":"7f4ada690594c36ee50a609d4f812474b68fb4d5d4266ddbce13d2ac3b131f33"},{"name":"missing_readback","score":85.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"f86cc1f26c843b79886da642cfa3183a9abf8fe1a995302dc88d284f8f1584e1","verdict_sha256":"736db0cc359a92008f2c44619216f32cf7309ca5425e811202b479cf3da4c004"},{"name":"state_without_answer","score":90.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"635854bcdcfc34f28a6ac48f819d1bf57e019587b60bd82015b9731a8637c78b","verdict_sha256":"af32b52f4215a5e55a289ed305f43466b19be15d481ec431a8129bbcfb9d4c96"},{"name":"omit_read_1_desk.requests.search","score":97.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"ffc10a827993065de31aa380c9f039ff6b521ddd25c153e3fcc4a64081698051","verdict_sha256":"2d0ee803bcdfc29eeff6f0eeda498bb0f83155f4dcc5fd93732b35d3ea161357"},{"name":"omit_read_2_arccrm.clients.search","score":97.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"f04e6e85e0ce98ecf431856702547701823d7ca7ae4e06fae8db773af582aa1a","verdict_sha256":"d73a3c2b177cbdbc57361db489bac0e51028d929b7660ae830d309a5da46079d"},{"name":"omit_read_3_desk.policies.get","score":97.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"3e0f549d1d2ac1afd93a9907c293d3a58444ae340458ed7fb83b7c7063898f8e","verdict_sha256":"39fe1c0cd8007ce80f4cdf1c8fac27482714a39c0fab3baf955b11db249304c7"},{"name":"omit_read_4_arccrm.opportunities.get","score":97.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"a2449ab722c2fa5dd18ac41544450db92712e4e9f5df61354ae4910b8eb9fd21","verdict_sha256":"fd18e179827f323120538028128181d223d19aaf66d68045474c03c092546e78"},{"name":"omit_read_5_arccrm.quotes.get","score":97.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"72a27318a4e49669a8b09082e51e7904b33767aef0164d603ef3c4c98ed12a42","verdict_sha256":"f95f2d802a27ff3765c799bfa092ae4889f1b9efbf00ccb7119d7d3792af2860"},{"name":"omit_read_6_arccrm.quotes.get","score":97.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"25ba2ae896b962957c0300c85425992824f64ae91fa5608ee5d686f53af891cb","verdict_sha256":"fd4cef7353096ea3ab4b62d19172fa23162b632959cab3592346aeadc40a9cb5"},{"name":"omit_read_7_arccrm.contracts.search","score":97.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"5f6d22c04dc6709dee6756622b1cc253e9a6a0ecad66e1a42d83f8ab6f3b90c6","verdict_sha256":"7a0daf9812e3bce920f5e009509d0f1e8e2fd9d0daf30cf0950bdc58792cbc04"},{"name":"omit_read_8_desk.permissions.list","score":97.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"5a610a21862f2c42e39e305336b86055fc1de725a4d2806e569ebb7189697e03","verdict_sha256":"952d3d97af2f0948a9d249720640727ee241a889296db1629e650435ee3e1193"},{"name":"omit_mutation_9_arccrm.contracts.create","score":43.67,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"14857d232542aecc2fe7fc7e161f8748a98cb120ec888659fdfd809c699354d7","verdict_sha256":"c8fbb0004d2851980c7b890941a14379f7432fa5b4facec7644f8d53bdadd970"},{"name":"omit_mutation_10_arccrm.notes.create","score":66.83,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"1fe15c3319750258618992d4b794421dbfb517eb1294a47781a0a3183a9f3be0","verdict_sha256":"bcdb75927bee5f77c7d4fd422cc85aa0d3e82237202bb7005fb219d2473c9fb0"},{"name":"omit_read_11_arccrm.contracts.get","score":92.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"d9481365093db3af7f79c0701a909dff73815595df93b54e9c37b7ad06b9f003","verdict_sha256":"0596366dce5a447ccb478b0e426f6824bb464eb7e19684badc15513461309df6"},{"name":"omit_read_12_arccrm.notes.get","score":92.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"d67b81f368a773a8822bd2e44283f916a611ed272bfe94f9dc658fba693a1655","verdict_sha256":"a309aa4d1a5b5d4a8075a1e218f9ad623b828d0ef24a5ce1cdff0f5d41551959"},{"name":"superseded_request","score":97.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"8d51517e03385e4e9c4095b8d3b1dffa11e3b003cc63a35eeccfc17a2c64ba6a","verdict_sha256":"d5acd46224e7a08459175364e7959b12d514495faef050e5ca2d27f492e53197"},{"name":"retired_policy","score":97.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"af53d24dd57a7c61fa5b63282d9fbdc03a86f7ddca33ba0bd03a3abd1ec9eb1f","verdict_sha256":"3ef6ca04fb2aa84e1cd1daff931946b03d8a350c614c64b4fd96348c7de19813"},{"name":"wrong_answer","score":98.57,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"a2a746f63e5c4e889013ed42bae168a2e0f75d1a379a932b7a05245a29ac8d51","verdict_sha256":"d971f6e3d93980d1bc76e116b476f1731817d311de1f632b1a8a72d3e1cbba8c"},{"name":"missing_literal_handoff_facts","score":90.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"882ddda4ff0bd1e8e33ef37c5897bb872c9d09af71fdb0126ba72e91f31a553a","verdict_sha256":"951573d366d2830c4cce0938d3032729f62cca120d9e9ed5823916b8019176c9"},{"name":"stale_handoff_evidence","score":77.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"528d354cdd8bdd9f9897b8a0a4fe8ac4bfa39f79fcf6d6fc5da2505e796e31f0","verdict_sha256":"3ca690626145d2b11c1cc8346545f83b568826139df433a4a9451304525bccbe"},{"name":"wrong_empty_contract_search","score":97.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"8234b6578dde2541bd2e8a4601019777c637252af61063f1d96768ceed21508d","verdict_sha256":"7d5b8ad51938a33566d5da5907b0cf492c2776ed8457c62f572b13debe15b5ae"},{"name":"signed_contract","score":99.67,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"93bf5fac3fb635e437b4f88c093c31586aa6504021da9155f7a3001706bb2271","verdict_sha256":"a3fc1ea52cb5ffdf2037ad9a8842b9f6d4d5b1e47e5dac6d7a8932801cc47838"},{"name":"wrong_client","score":99.67,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"98c4e71a629ab3c830a205097ffe7524f6f136e88d137b8a56e6a5c3f5b423d7","verdict_sha256":"a3fc1ea52cb5ffdf2037ad9a8842b9f6d4d5b1e47e5dac6d7a8932801cc47838"},{"name":"stale_value","score":99.67,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"e3837baaba661060dc4a4ce2b6e4c69fdcb904bfb76562728919f3c040cd40fa","verdict_sha256":"a3fc1ea52cb5ffdf2037ad9a8842b9f6d4d5b1e47e5dac6d7a8932801cc47838"},{"name":"wrong_quote","score":99.67,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"5ec1ed91fe53e944328804ae13daaa1195b6a660bbb90f017e662ae6e119caa2","verdict_sha256":"ad91d43799621addd30d638fdd9b7afb16f7c79a33b3f372282792ffd072b2d8"},{"name":"wrong_currency","score":99.67,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"cd5bdba625d2dee2f46a7587d00501defb92d539381e2e1e2d4e9a29a331ecbe","verdict_sha256":"a3fc1ea52cb5ffdf2037ad9a8842b9f6d4d5b1e47e5dac6d7a8932801cc47838"}],"oracle":{"final_state":{"answers":[{"field":"client_id","task_id":"arc-crm-005","value":"C-51"},{"field":"contract_id","task_id":"arc-crm-005","value":"CN-1"},{"field":"note_id","task_id":"arc-crm-005","value":"NT-1"},{"field":"opportunity_id","task_id":"arc-crm-005","value":"OP-51"},{"field":"quote_id","task_id":"arc-crm-005","value":"Q-52"},{"field":"status","task_id":"arc-crm-005","value":"draft"},{"field":"value_minor","task_id":"arc-crm-005","value":"1876500"}],"audit_log":[{"action":"created","audit_id":1,"payload":"{\"client_id\":\"C-51\",\"currency\":\"USD\",\"opportunity_id\":\"OP-51\",\"quote_id\":\"Q-52\",\"status\":\"draft\",\"value_minor\":1876500}","record_id":"CN-1","table_name":"crm_contracts","task_id":"arc-crm-005","tool":"arccrm.contracts.create"},{"action":"insert","audit_id":2,"payload":"{\"arguments\":{\"client_id\":\"C-51\",\"currency\":\"USD\",\"opportunity_id\":\"OP-51\",\"quote_id\":\"Q-52\",\"status\":\"draft\",\"value_minor\":1876500},\"tool\":\"arccrm.contracts.create\"}","record_id":"arc-crm-005-mutation-01","table_name":"mutations","task_id":"arc-crm-005","tool":"arccrm.contracts.create"},{"action":"created","audit_id":3,"payload":"{\"content\":\"CN-1 is an unsigned draft tied to Q-52 for 1876500 USD minor units; handed off for legal review.\",\"entity_id\":\"OP-51\",\"entity_type\":\"opportunity\",\"evidence_ids\":[\"E-5-request-2\",\"E-5-contract-2\"],\"reference_ids\":[\"CN-1\",\"Q-52\"]}","record_id":"NT-1","table_name":"crm_notes","task_id":"arc-crm-005","tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"action":"insert","audit_id":4,"payload":"{\"arguments\":{\"content\":\"CN-1 is an unsigned draft tied to Q-52 for 1876500 USD minor units; handed off for legal review.\",\"entity_id\":\"OP-51\",\"entity_type\":\"opportunity\",\"evidence_ids\":[\"E-5-request-2\",\"E-5-contract-2\"],\"reference_ids\":[\"CN-1\",\"Q-52\"]},\"tool\":\"arccrm.notes.create\"}","record_id":"arc-crm-005-mutation-02","table_name":"mutations","task_id":"arc-crm-005","tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"action":"submit","audit_id":5,"payload":"{\"client_id\":\"C-51\",\"contract_id\":\"CN-1\",\"note_id\":\"NT-1\",\"opportunity_id\":\"OP-51\",\"quote_id\":\"Q-52\",\"status\":\"draft\",\"value_minor\":\"1876500\"}","record_id":"arc-crm-005","table_name":"answers","task_id":"arc-crm-005","tool":"hubbench.submit_answer"}],"crm_approvals":[],"crm_attachments":[],"crm_clients":[{"client_id":"C-51","domain":"ember-diagnostics.example","email":"billing@ember-diagnostics.example","name":"Ember Diagnostics","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-52","domain":"services-ember-diagnostics.example","email":"billing@services-ember-diagnostics.example","name":"Ember Diagnostics Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-53","domain":"archive-ember-diagnostics.example","email":"hold@archive-ember-diagnostics.example","name":"Ember Diagnostics Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"crm_contacts":[{"client_id":"C-51","contact_id":"CT-51","email":"jamie@ember-diagnostics.example","first_name":"Jamie","last_name":"Park","revision":1,"title":"Procurement lead"}],"crm_contracts":[{"client_id":"C-51","contract_id":"CN-1","currency":"USD","opportunity_id":"OP-51","quote_id":"Q-52","signed_at":null,"status":"draft","value_minor":1876500}],"crm_documents":[],"crm_evidence":[{"asset_id":"E-5-contract-1","content":"Ember Diagnostics\nEffective 2025-01-01 through 2026-08-31.\n{\"notice\":\"Retired. Use the current revision.\"}\n"},{"asset_id":"E-5-contract-2","content":"Ember Diagnostics\nEffective 2026-09-01 through 2026-12-31.\n{\"duplicate_quote_contract\":\"reject\",\"legal_review_required\":true,\"signed_at\":null,\"status\":\"draft only\",\"value\":\"exact current approved quote\"}\n"},{"asset_id":"E-5-request-1","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@ember-diagnostics.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@ember-diagnostics.example>\nSubject: Draft a contract from the approved commercial record\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nUse the old 22000-dollar proposal and mark the contract signed so onboarding can proceed.\n"},{"asset_id":"E-5-request-2","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@ember-diagnostics.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@ember-diagnostics.example>\nSubject: Draft a contract from the approved commercial record\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nLegal correction: Q-52 is the approved current quote on OP-51, worth 1876500 USD minor units. Q-51 is cancelled and stale. Create an unsigned draft only for the active existing client, reference Q-52 explicitly, then hand off to legal. Alex has drafting authority up to 2500000 minor units but no signing authority.\n"}],"crm_notes":[{"content":"CN-1 is an unsigned draft tied to Q-52 for 1876500 USD minor units; handed off for legal review.","entity_id":"OP-51","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-5-contract-2\",\"E-5-request-2\"]","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"CN-1\",\"Q-52\"]"}],"crm_opportunities":[{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-51","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-51","owner_id":"U-52","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":900000,"client_id":"C-51","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - west","opportunity_id":"OP-52","owner_id":"U-52","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-52","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-53","owner_id":"U-52","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"}],"crm_permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"contract:create","permission_id":"PERM-5-1","target_id":"Q-52","user_id":"U-51","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-5-2","target_id":"OP-51","user_id":"U-51","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"crm_policies":[{"asset_id":"E-5-contract-1","effective_from":"2025-01-01","effective_until":"2026-08-31","policy_id":"POL-5-contract-1","revision":1,"rules_json":"{\"notice\":\"Retired. Use the current revision.\"}","topic":"contract"},{"asset_id":"E-5-contract-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","policy_id":"POL-5-contract-2","revision":2,"rules_json":"{\"duplicate_quote_contract\":\"reject\",\"legal_review_required\":true,\"signed_at\":null,\"status\":\"draft only\",\"value\":\"exact current approved quote\"}","topic":"contract"}],"crm_prices":[],"crm_quote_lines":[],"crm_quotes":[{"amount_minor":2200000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"opportunity_id":"OP-51","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-51","status":"cancelled","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":1},{"amount_minor":1876500,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"opportunity_id":"OP-51","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-52","status":"approved","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":2}],"crm_requests":[{"asset_id":"E-5-request-1","body":"Use the old 22000-dollar proposal and mark the contract signed so onboarding can proceed.","client_id":"C-51","request_id":"RQ-51","sender_id":"U-52","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Draft a contract from the approved commercial record","thread_id":"TH-5"},{"asset_id":"E-5-request-2","body":"Legal correction: Q-52 is the approved current quote on OP-51, worth 1876500 USD minor units. Q-51 is cancelled and stale. Create an unsigned draft only for the active existing client, reference Q-52 explicitly, then hand off to legal. Alex has drafting authority up to 2500000 minor units but no signing authority.","client_id":"C-51","request_id":"RQ-52","sender_id":"U-52","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Draft a contract from the approved commercial record","thread_id":"TH-5"}],"evidence_files":[{"asset_id":"E-5-contract-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-5-contract-1.pdf","sha256":"a82e78699961482bb7f05fb3d44c572a7bf19320c3d0be112c07dbd32de8b593","source":"Ember Diagnostics","task_id":"arc-crm-005","title":"Contract policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-5-contract-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-5-contract-2.pdf","sha256":"66fe519d375fe33ebbce371cee26e888399a3c022749073e742980bb53f0474f","source":"Ember Diagnostics","task_id":"arc-crm-005","title":"Contract policy revision 2"},{"asset_id":"E-5-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-5-request-1.eml","sha256":"f3a9ff4dd0c4986face6f19f8e185dda34830ca6eab2979451ed9eed40101407","source":"Ember Diagnostics","task_id":"arc-crm-005","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-5-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-5-request-2.eml","sha256":"d54c60c729a9da391313deb5ee5df01150a540c3fa307f60dd0c6279781452f3","source":"Ember Diagnostics","task_id":"arc-crm-005","title":"Owner request 2"}],"mutations":[{"effective_at":"2026-09-05T09:09:00","mutation_id":"arc-crm-005-mutation-01","payload_json":"{\"arguments\":{\"client_id\":\"C-51\",\"currency\":\"USD\",\"opportunity_id\":\"OP-51\",\"quote_id\":\"Q-52\",\"status\":\"draft\",\"value_minor\":1876500},\"tool\":\"arccrm.contracts.create\"}","record_id":"CN-1","revision":1,"sequence":1,"status":"created","table_name":"crm_contracts","task_id":"arc-crm-005","tool":"arccrm.contracts.create"},{"effective_at":"2026-09-05T09:10:00","mutation_id":"arc-crm-005-mutation-02","payload_json":"{\"arguments\":{\"content\":\"CN-1 is an unsigned draft tied to Q-52 for 1876500 USD minor units; handed off for legal review.\",\"entity_id\":\"OP-51\",\"entity_type\":\"opportunity\",\"evidence_ids\":[\"E-5-request-2\",\"E-5-contract-2\"],\"reference_ids\":[\"CN-1\",\"Q-52\"]},\"tool\":\"arccrm.notes.create\"}","record_id":"NT-1","revision":1,"sequence":2,"status":"created","table_name":"crm_notes","task_id":"arc-crm-005","tool":"arccrm.notes.create"}],"users":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-51"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-52"}]},"initial_state":{"answers":[],"audit_log":[],"crm_approvals":[],"crm_attachments":[],"crm_clients":[{"client_id":"C-51","domain":"ember-diagnostics.example","email":"billing@ember-diagnostics.example","name":"Ember Diagnostics","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-52","domain":"services-ember-diagnostics.example","email":"billing@services-ember-diagnostics.example","name":"Ember Diagnostics Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-53","domain":"archive-ember-diagnostics.example","email":"hold@archive-ember-diagnostics.example","name":"Ember Diagnostics Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"crm_contacts":[{"client_id":"C-51","contact_id":"CT-51","email":"jamie@ember-diagnostics.example","first_name":"Jamie","last_name":"Park","revision":1,"title":"Procurement lead"}],"crm_contracts":[],"crm_documents":[],"crm_evidence":[{"asset_id":"E-5-contract-1","content":"Ember Diagnostics\nEffective 2025-01-01 through 2026-08-31.\n{\"notice\":\"Retired. Use the current revision.\"}\n"},{"asset_id":"E-5-contract-2","content":"Ember Diagnostics\nEffective 2026-09-01 through 2026-12-31.\n{\"duplicate_quote_contract\":\"reject\",\"legal_review_required\":true,\"signed_at\":null,\"status\":\"draft only\",\"value\":\"exact current approved quote\"}\n"},{"asset_id":"E-5-request-1","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@ember-diagnostics.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@ember-diagnostics.example>\nSubject: Draft a contract from the approved commercial record\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nUse the old 22000-dollar proposal and mark the contract signed so onboarding can proceed.\n"},{"asset_id":"E-5-request-2","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@ember-diagnostics.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@ember-diagnostics.example>\nSubject: Draft a contract from the approved commercial record\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nLegal correction: Q-52 is the approved current quote on OP-51, worth 1876500 USD minor units. Q-51 is cancelled and stale. Create an unsigned draft only for the active existing client, reference Q-52 explicitly, then hand off to legal. Alex has drafting authority up to 2500000 minor units but no signing authority.\n"}],"crm_notes":[],"crm_opportunities":[{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-51","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-51","owner_id":"U-52","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":900000,"client_id":"C-51","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - west","opportunity_id":"OP-52","owner_id":"U-52","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-52","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-53","owner_id":"U-52","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"}],"crm_permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"contract:create","permission_id":"PERM-5-1","target_id":"Q-52","user_id":"U-51","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-5-2","target_id":"OP-51","user_id":"U-51","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"crm_policies":[{"asset_id":"E-5-contract-1","effective_from":"2025-01-01","effective_until":"2026-08-31","policy_id":"POL-5-contract-1","revision":1,"rules_json":"{\"notice\":\"Retired. Use the current revision.\"}","topic":"contract"},{"asset_id":"E-5-contract-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","policy_id":"POL-5-contract-2","revision":2,"rules_json":"{\"duplicate_quote_contract\":\"reject\",\"legal_review_required\":true,\"signed_at\":null,\"status\":\"draft only\",\"value\":\"exact current approved quote\"}","topic":"contract"}],"crm_prices":[],"crm_quote_lines":[],"crm_quotes":[{"amount_minor":2200000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"opportunity_id":"OP-51","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-51","status":"cancelled","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":1},{"amount_minor":1876500,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"opportunity_id":"OP-51","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-52","status":"approved","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":2}],"crm_requests":[{"asset_id":"E-5-request-1","body":"Use the old 22000-dollar proposal and mark the contract signed so onboarding can proceed.","client_id":"C-51","request_id":"RQ-51","sender_id":"U-52","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Draft a contract from the approved commercial record","thread_id":"TH-5"},{"asset_id":"E-5-request-2","body":"Legal correction: Q-52 is the approved current quote on OP-51, worth 1876500 USD minor units. Q-51 is cancelled and stale. Create an unsigned draft only for the active existing client, reference Q-52 explicitly, then hand off to legal. Alex has drafting authority up to 2500000 minor units but no signing authority.","client_id":"C-51","request_id":"RQ-52","sender_id":"U-52","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Draft a contract from the approved commercial record","thread_id":"TH-5"}],"evidence_files":[{"asset_id":"E-5-contract-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-5-contract-1.pdf","sha256":"a82e78699961482bb7f05fb3d44c572a7bf19320c3d0be112c07dbd32de8b593","source":"Ember Diagnostics","task_id":"arc-crm-005","title":"Contract policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-5-contract-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-5-contract-2.pdf","sha256":"66fe519d375fe33ebbce371cee26e888399a3c022749073e742980bb53f0474f","source":"Ember Diagnostics","task_id":"arc-crm-005","title":"Contract policy revision 2"},{"asset_id":"E-5-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-5-request-1.eml","sha256":"f3a9ff4dd0c4986face6f19f8e185dda34830ca6eab2979451ed9eed40101407","source":"Ember Diagnostics","task_id":"arc-crm-005","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-5-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-5-request-2.eml","sha256":"d54c60c729a9da391313deb5ee5df01150a540c3fa307f60dd0c6279781452f3","source":"Ember Diagnostics","task_id":"arc-crm-005","title":"Owner request 2"}],"mutations":[],"users":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-51"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-52"}]},"trace":[{"arguments":{},"index":0,"result":{"evidence_index":[{"asset_id":"E-5-contract-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-5-contract-1.pdf","sha256":"a82e78699961482bb7f05fb3d44c572a7bf19320c3d0be112c07dbd32de8b593","source":"Ember Diagnostics","title":"Contract policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-5-contract-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-5-contract-2.pdf","sha256":"66fe519d375fe33ebbce371cee26e888399a3c022749073e742980bb53f0474f","source":"Ember Diagnostics","title":"Contract policy revision 2"},{"asset_id":"E-5-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-5-request-1.eml","sha256":"f3a9ff4dd0c4986face6f19f8e185dda34830ca6eab2979451ed9eed40101407","source":"Ember Diagnostics","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-5-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-5-request-2.eml","sha256":"d54c60c729a9da391313deb5ee5df01150a540c3fa307f60dd0c6279781452f3","source":"Ember Diagnostics","title":"Owner request 2"}],"identity":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-51"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-52"}],"organization":{"name":"Ember Diagnostics","synthetic":true,"systems":["arccrm","desk","vault"]},"reference_records":{},"starting_records":[{"client_hint":"Ember Diagnostics","thread_id":"TH-5"}],"state":{"network":"closed","persistence":"episode-local SQLite","scope":"isolated task snapshot"},"task":{"as_of":"2026-09-05","family":"arc-crm","role":"U-51","task_id":"arc-crm-005"},"tool_servers":[{"description":"Stateful synthetic CRM","name":"arccrm","tools":["arccrm.attachments.get","arccrm.attachments.search","arccrm.clients.get","arccrm.clients.search","arccrm.contacts.create","arccrm.contacts.get","arccrm.contacts.search","arccrm.contracts.create","arccrm.contracts.get","arccrm.contracts.search","arccrm.documents.attach","arccrm.documents.get","arccrm.documents.search","arccrm.notes.create","arccrm.notes.get","arccrm.notes.search","arccrm.opportunities.get","arccrm.opportunities.search","arccrm.opportunities.update","arccrm.quotes.cancel","arccrm.quotes.compare","arccrm.quotes.create","arccrm.quotes.get","arccrm.quotes.search"]},{"description":"Mock requests, permissions, approvals and versioned policy/price records","name":"desk","tools":["desk.approvals.get","desk.permissions.list","desk.policies.get","desk.prices.list","desk.requests.get","desk.requests.search"]},{"description":"Seeded synthetic evidence; no external file access","name":"vault","tools":["vault.files.get"]},{"description":"Benchmark-only discovery and structured answer submission controls.","name":"hubbench","tools":["hubbench.context.get","hubbench.submit_answer"]}]},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.context.get"},{"arguments":{"query":"TH-5"},"index":1,"result":{"query":"th-5","records":[{"asset_id":"E-5-request-1","body":"Use the old 22000-dollar proposal and mark the contract signed so onboarding can proceed.","client_id":"C-51","request_id":"RQ-51","sender_id":"U-52","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Draft a contract from the approved commercial record","thread_id":"TH-5"},{"asset_id":"E-5-request-2","body":"Legal correction: Q-52 is the approved current quote on OP-51, worth 1876500 USD minor units. Q-51 is cancelled and stale. Create an unsigned draft only for the active existing client, reference Q-52 explicitly, then hand off to legal. Alex has drafting authority up to 2500000 minor units but no signing authority.","client_id":"C-51","request_id":"RQ-52","sender_id":"U-52","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Draft a contract from the approved commercial record","thread_id":"TH-5"}],"total":2},"success":true,"tool":"desk.requests.search"},{"arguments":{"query":"Ember Diagnostics"},"index":2,"result":{"query":"ember diagnostics","records":[{"client_id":"C-51","domain":"ember-diagnostics.example","email":"billing@ember-diagnostics.example","name":"Ember Diagnostics","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-52","domain":"services-ember-diagnostics.example","email":"billing@services-ember-diagnostics.example","name":"Ember Diagnostics Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-53","domain":"archive-ember-diagnostics.example","email":"hold@archive-ember-diagnostics.example","name":"Ember Diagnostics Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"total":3},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.clients.search"},{"arguments":{"policy_id":"POL-5-contract-2"},"index":3,"result":{"asset_id":"E-5-contract-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","operative":true,"policy_id":"POL-5-contract-2","revision":2,"rules":{"duplicate_quote_contract":"reject","legal_review_required":true,"signed_at":null,"status":"draft only","value":"exact current approved quote"},"rules_json":"{\"duplicate_quote_contract\":\"reject\",\"legal_review_required\":true,\"signed_at\":null,\"status\":\"draft only\",\"value\":\"exact current approved quote\"}","topic":"contract"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.policies.get"},{"arguments":{"opportunity_id":"OP-51"},"index":4,"result":{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-51","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-51","owner_id":"U-52","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"},{"arguments":{"quote_id":"Q-51"},"index":5,"result":{"amount_minor":2200000,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"lines":[],"opportunity_id":"OP-51","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-51","status":"cancelled","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":1},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"arguments":{"quote_id":"Q-52"},"index":6,"result":{"amount_minor":1876500,"approval_id":null,"currency":"USD","discount_bps":0,"lines":[],"opportunity_id":"OP-51","predecessor_id":null,"quote_id":"Q-52","status":"approved","valid_until":"2026-09-25","version":2},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"arguments":{"query":"OP-51"},"index":7,"result":{"query":"op-51","records":[],"total":0},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.contracts.search"},{"arguments":{},"index":8,"result":{"permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"contract:create","permission_id":"PERM-5-1","target_id":"Q-52","user_id":"U-51","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-5-2","target_id":"OP-51","user_id":"U-51","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"user_id":"U-51"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.permissions.list"},{"arguments":{"client_id":"C-51","currency":"USD","opportunity_id":"OP-51","quote_id":"Q-52","status":"draft","value_minor":1876500},"index":9,"result":{"client_id":"C-51","contract_id":"CN-1","currency":"USD","mutation_id":"arc-crm-005-mutation-01","opportunity_id":"OP-51","quote_id":"Q-52","signed_at":null,"status":"draft","value_minor":1876500},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.contracts.create"},{"arguments":{"content":"CN-1 is an unsigned draft tied to Q-52 for 1876500 USD minor units; handed off for legal review.","entity_id":"OP-51","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids":["E-5-request-2","E-5-contract-2"],"reference_ids":["CN-1","Q-52"]},"index":10,"result":{"content":"CN-1 is an unsigned draft tied to Q-52 for 1876500 USD minor units; handed off for legal review.","entity_id":"OP-51","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-5-contract-2\",\"E-5-request-2\"]","mutation_id":"arc-crm-005-mutation-02","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"CN-1\",\"Q-52\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"arguments":{"contract_id":"CN-1"},"index":11,"result":{"client_id":"C-51","contract_id":"CN-1","currency":"USD","opportunity_id":"OP-51","quote_id":"Q-52","signed_at":null,"status":"draft","value_minor":1876500},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.contracts.get"},{"arguments":{"note_id":"NT-1"},"index":12,"result":{"content":"CN-1 is an unsigned draft tied to Q-52 for 1876500 USD minor units; handed off for legal review.","entity_id":"OP-51","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-5-contract-2\",\"E-5-request-2\"]","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"CN-1\",\"Q-52\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.get"},{"arguments":{"client_id":"C-51","contract_id":"CN-1","note_id":"NT-1","opportunity_id":"OP-51","quote_id":"Q-52","status":"draft","value_minor":1876500},"index":13,"result":{"accepted":true,"fields":{"client_id":"C-51","contract_id":"CN-1","note_id":"NT-1","opportunity_id":"OP-51","quote_id":"Q-52","status":"draft","value_minor":"1876500"},"task_id":"arc-crm-005"},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.submit_answer"}],"verdict":{"checks":[{"category":"evidence","description":"unsigned_contract: evidence","earned_weight":20.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":8,"subchecks":[{"description":"Resolve the owner's current clarification, not the superseded message.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":1,"tool":"desk.requests.search"}]},"id":"investigate-current_request","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Identify the existing verified client and the similarly named account.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":2,"tool":"arccrm.clients.search"}]},"id":"investigate-verified_client","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the operative policy and its scope.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":3,"tool":"desk.policies.get"}]},"id":"investigate-operative_policy","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the precise opportunity identity, owner, revision and commercial fields.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":4,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"}]},"id":"investigate-opportunity","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the exact quote version, status, links and value.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":5,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"index":6,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"}]},"id":"investigate-stale_quote","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the exact quote version, status, links and value.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":5,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"},{"index":6,"tool":"arccrm.quotes.get"}]},"id":"investigate-approved_quote","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Check the intended opportunity, or the complete contract collection, for an existing draft.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":7,"tool":"arccrm.contracts.search"}]},"id":"investigate-existing_contracts","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the acting role's specific operation/target grants before writing.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":8,"tool":"desk.permissions.list"}]},"id":"investigate-authority","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":8},"id":"evidence","passed":true,"weight":20.0},{"category":"readback","description":"unsigned_contract: readback","earned_weight":15.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":2,"subchecks":[{"description":"Read back the persisted unsigned_contract after the business mutation.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":7,"tool":"arccrm.contracts.search"},{"index":11,"tool":"arccrm.contracts.get"}]},"id":"readback-unsigned_contract","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read back the persisted handoff after the business mutation.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":12,"tool":"arccrm.notes.get"}]},"id":"readback-handoff","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":2},"id":"readback","passed":true,"weight":15.0},{"category":"outcome","description":"unsigned_contract: outcome","earned_weight":30.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":2,"subchecks":[{"description":"Persist the required crm_contracts record and exact structural fields.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"create-crm_contracts-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Persist the required crm_notes record and exact structural fields.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"create-crm_notes-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":2},"id":"outcome","passed":true,"weight":30.0},{"category":"containment","description":"unsigned_contract: containment","earned_weight":15.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":45,"subchecks":[{"description":"Preserve users record {'user_id': 'U-51'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-users-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve users record {'user_id': 'U-52'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-users-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in users.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-users","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-5-request-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-5-request-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-5-contract-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-5-contract-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-3","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in evidence_files.","evidence":{"expected_count":4,"matching_rows":4},"id":"count-evidence_files","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-5-request-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-5-request-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-5-contract-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-5-contract-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-3","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_evidence.","evidence":{"expected_count":4,"matching_rows":4},"id":"count-crm_evidence","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_clients record {'client_id': 'C-51'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_clients-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_clients record {'client_id': 'C-52'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_clients-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_clients record {'client_id': 'C-53'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_clients-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_clients.","evidence":{"expected_count":3,"matching_rows":3},"id":"count-crm_clients","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_contacts record {'contact_id': 'CT-51'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_contacts-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_contacts.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1},"id":"count-crm_contacts","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_opportunities record {'opportunity_id': 'OP-51'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_opportunities-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_opportunities record {'opportunity_id': 'OP-52'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_opportunities-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_opportunities record {'opportunity_id': 'OP-53'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_opportunities-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_opportunities.","evidence":{"expected_count":3,"matching_rows":3},"id":"count-crm_opportunities","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_quotes record {'quote_id': 'Q-51'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_quotes-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_quotes record {'quote_id': 'Q-52'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_quotes-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_quotes.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-crm_quotes","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_quote_lines.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_quote_lines","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_contracts.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1},"id":"count-crm_contracts","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_documents.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_documents","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_attachments.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_attachments","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_notes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1},"id":"count-crm_notes","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_requests record {'request_id': 'RQ-51'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_requests-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_requests record {'request_id': 'RQ-52'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_requests-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_requests.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-crm_requests","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_policies record {'policy_id': 'POL-5-contract-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_policies-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_policies record {'policy_id': 'POL-5-contract-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_policies-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_policies.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-crm_policies","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_prices.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_prices","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_approvals.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_approvals","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_permissions record {'permission_id': 'PERM-5-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_permissions-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_permissions record {'permission_id': 'PERM-5-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_permissions-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_permissions.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-crm_permissions","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Exactly the required domain writes, with no hidden extra mutation.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-mutations","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Kept every successful write inside arc-crm-005's declared state, collaboration, answer, and audit tables.","evidence":{"disallowed":[],"written_tables":["answers","crm_contracts","crm_notes","mutations"]},"id":"write_scope","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Completed without a rejected state-changing call; failed exploratory reads and retryable provider faults do not erase a correct outcome.","evidence":{"errors":[]},"id":"no_rejected_mutation","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":45},"id":"containment","passed":true,"weight":15.0},{"category":"handoff","description":"unsigned_contract: handoff","earned_weight":10.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":1,"subchecks":[{"description":"Handoff content contains the disclosed literal facts; punctuation/case/prose may vary. Not a semantic consistency check.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1},"id":"handoff-facts","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":1},"id":"handoff","passed":true,"weight":10.0},{"category":"answer","description":"unsigned_contract: answer","earned_weight":10.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":7,"subchecks":[{"description":"Report the correct contract id.","evidence":{"expected":"CN-1","field":"contract_id","submitted":"CN-1"},"id":"answer-contract_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct client id.","evidence":{"expected":"C-51","field":"client_id","submitted":"C-51"},"id":"answer-client_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct opportunity id.","evidence":{"expected":"OP-51","field":"opportunity_id","submitted":"OP-51"},"id":"answer-opportunity_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct quote id.","evidence":{"expected":"Q-52","field":"quote_id","submitted":"Q-52"},"id":"answer-quote_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct value minor.","evidence":{"expected":"1876500","field":"value_minor","submitted":"1876500"},"id":"answer-value_minor","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct status.","evidence":{"expected":"draft","field":"status","submitted":"draft"},"id":"answer-status","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct note id.","evidence":{"expected":"NT-1","field":"note_id","submitted":"NT-1"},"id":"answer-note_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":7},"id":"answer","passed":true,"weight":10.0}],"metric":"HubScore","passed_atomic_checks":65,"passed_checks":6,"passed_weight":100.0,"score":100.0,"strict_pass":true,"task_id":"arc-crm-005","total_atomic_checks":65,"total_checks":6,"total_weight":100.0}},"replay_sha256":"4f1583c6474e580c17e55ebf405f432542c37e742509d5bda788e595e94b3851","task_id":"arc-crm-005","task_sha256":"2962b834271bd2db29be442c84931b04ead96de6334a30998aee3757605f9025"},{"alternate_pass":true,"alternate_trace":[{"arguments":{},"index":0,"result":{"evidence_index":[{"asset_id":"E-6-D-61","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-6-D-61.pdf","sha256":"8f823e230e3e47ce6b29d2011393ad52b7612de1495d330e379c33f2fb5d2bfe","source":"Fjord Packaging","title":"capacity-assessment.pdf"},{"asset_id":"E-6-D-62","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-6-D-62.pdf","sha256":"72c2aef6746d012033d42c58828762026433f6f8cf20f9f0f3a5cf7154642df5","source":"Fjord Packaging","title":"capacity-draft.pdf"},{"asset_id":"E-6-D-63","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-6-D-63.pdf","sha256":"2fc3358262088b61106292d55109e72e0c1329d6655ac001ec260555d19a93e9","source":"Fjord Packaging","title":"services-assessment.pdf"},{"asset_id":"E-6-documents-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-6-documents-1.pdf","sha256":"2bdfd2ae63915f7825c17dfa29b1b4427481d9275d60498d34d69ab24271c5a6","source":"Fjord Packaging","title":"Documents policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-6-documents-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-6-documents-2.pdf","sha256":"9f5e8424191b55aba0d62712257c189536aa2eadf90ad358c36e9e91c3d70e6f","source":"Fjord Packaging","title":"Documents policy revision 2"},{"asset_id":"E-6-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-6-request-1.eml","sha256":"e9f78269d0f32dc6c89c705a198c447321e979397682df4ad566279e8448c49e","source":"Fjord Packaging","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-6-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-6-request-2.eml","sha256":"420f0ff3ed5f44948dd43567584d9e27a8319b118a19873509e8bb5866d7ae88","source":"Fjord Packaging","title":"Owner request 2"}],"identity":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-61"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-62"}],"organization":{"name":"Fjord Packaging","synthetic":true,"systems":["arccrm","desk","vault"]},"reference_records":{},"starting_records":[{"client_hint":"Fjord Packaging","thread_id":"TH-6"}],"state":{"network":"closed","persistence":"episode-local SQLite","scope":"isolated task snapshot"},"task":{"as_of":"2026-09-05","family":"arc-crm","role":"U-61","task_id":"arc-crm-006"},"tool_servers":[{"description":"Stateful synthetic CRM","name":"arccrm","tools":["arccrm.attachments.get","arccrm.attachments.search","arccrm.clients.get","arccrm.clients.search","arccrm.contacts.create","arccrm.contacts.get","arccrm.contacts.search","arccrm.contracts.create","arccrm.contracts.get","arccrm.contracts.search","arccrm.documents.attach","arccrm.documents.get","arccrm.documents.search","arccrm.notes.create","arccrm.notes.get","arccrm.notes.search","arccrm.opportunities.get","arccrm.opportunities.search","arccrm.opportunities.update","arccrm.quotes.cancel","arccrm.quotes.compare","arccrm.quotes.create","arccrm.quotes.get","arccrm.quotes.search"]},{"description":"Mock requests, permissions, approvals and versioned policy/price records","name":"desk","tools":["desk.approvals.get","desk.permissions.list","desk.policies.get","desk.prices.list","desk.requests.get","desk.requests.search"]},{"description":"Seeded synthetic evidence; no external file access","name":"vault","tools":["vault.files.get"]},{"description":"Benchmark-only discovery and structured answer submission controls.","name":"hubbench","tools":["hubbench.context.get","hubbench.submit_answer"]}]},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.context.get"},{"arguments":{},"index":1,"result":{"permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"document:attach","permission_id":"PERM-6-1","target_id":"OP-61","user_id":"U-61","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"document:attach","permission_id":"PERM-6-2","target_id":"OP-62","user_id":"U-61","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-6-3","target_id":"OP-61","user_id":"U-61","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"user_id":"U-61"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.permissions.list"},{"arguments":{"query":"OP-62"},"index":2,"result":{"query":"op-62","records":[{"attachment_id":"AT-1","document_id":"D-62","file_name":"capacity-draft.pdf","opportunity_id":"OP-62"}],"total":1},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.attachments.search"},{"arguments":{"asset_id":"E-6-D-61"},"index":3,"result":{"asset_id":"E-6-D-61","content":"Approved capacity assessment for Fjord Packaging east operations. Record D-61 supersedes D-62 for the new association only. Requested opportunity OP-61. No signature or contractual acceptance.","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-6-D-61.pdf","sha256":"8f823e230e3e47ce6b29d2011393ad52b7612de1495d330e379c33f2fb5d2bfe","source":"Fjord Packaging","task_id":"arc-crm-006","title":"capacity-assessment.pdf"},"success":true,"tool":"vault.files.get"},{"arguments":{"query":"C-61"},"index":4,"result":{"query":"c-61","records":[{"asset_id":"E-6-D-61","client_id":"C-61","document_id":"D-61","file_name":"capacity-assessment.pdf","status":"approved","url":"mock://crm/D-61"},{"asset_id":"E-6-D-62","client_id":"C-61","document_id":"D-62","file_name":"capacity-draft.pdf","status":"superseded","url":"mock://crm/D-62"}],"total":2},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.documents.search"},{"arguments":{"opportunity_id":"OP-62"},"index":5,"result":{"amount_minor":900000,"client_id":"C-61","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - west","opportunity_id":"OP-62","owner_id":"U-62","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"},{"arguments":{"opportunity_id":"OP-61"},"index":6,"result":{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-61","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-61","owner_id":"U-62","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"},{"arguments":{"policy_id":"POL-6-documents-2"},"index":7,"result":{"asset_id":"E-6-documents-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","operative":true,"policy_id":"POL-6-documents-2","revision":2,"rules":{"client_link":"must match opportunity client","handoff":"actual persisted attachment reference","history":"preserve existing associations","source":"seeded mock objects only","status":"approved"},"rules_json":"{\"client_link\":\"must match opportunity client\",\"handoff\":\"actual persisted attachment reference\",\"history\":\"preserve existing associations\",\"source\":\"seeded mock objects only\",\"status\":\"approved\"}","topic":"documents"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.policies.get"},{"arguments":{"query":"Fjord Packaging"},"index":8,"result":{"query":"fjord packaging","records":[{"client_id":"C-61","domain":"fjord-packaging.example","email":"billing@fjord-packaging.example","name":"Fjord Packaging","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-62","domain":"services-fjord-packaging.example","email":"billing@services-fjord-packaging.example","name":"Fjord Packaging Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-63","domain":"archive-fjord-packaging.example","email":"hold@archive-fjord-packaging.example","name":"Fjord Packaging Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"total":3},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.clients.search"},{"arguments":{"query":"TH-6"},"index":9,"result":{"query":"th-6","records":[{"asset_id":"E-6-request-1","body":"Upload the proof to the west renewal and reuse the old draft file if that is easier.","client_id":"C-61","request_id":"RQ-61","sender_id":"U-62","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Associate the corrected evidence without cross-client leakage","thread_id":"TH-6"},{"asset_id":"E-6-request-2","body":"Correction: use east OP-61, not west OP-62. Associate the approved capacity-assessment.pdf document D-61 at mock://crm/D-61. D-62 is superseded and its old west association must stay intact. Do not fetch an external URL. In the note cite D-61, OP-61, and this request RQ-62.","client_id":"C-61","request_id":"RQ-62","sender_id":"U-62","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Associate the corrected evidence without cross-client leakage","thread_id":"TH-6"}],"total":2},"success":true,"tool":"desk.requests.search"},{"arguments":{"document_url":"mock://crm/D-61","entity_id":"OP-61","entity_type":"opportunity","file_name":"capacity-assessment.pdf"},"index":10,"result":{"attachment_id":"AT-2","document_id":"D-61","file_name":"capacity-assessment.pdf","mutation_id":"arc-crm-006-mutation-01","opportunity_id":"OP-61"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.documents.attach"},{"arguments":{"content":"Operations handoff \u2014 verified records and facts: RQ-62; OP-61; D-61. Please review the linked evidence.","entity_id":"OP-61","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids":["E-6-D-61","E-6-documents-2","E-6-request-2"],"reference_ids":["AT-2"]},"index":11,"result":{"content":"Operations handoff \u2014 verified records and facts: RQ-62; OP-61; D-61. Please review the linked evidence.","entity_id":"OP-61","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-6-D-61\",\"E-6-documents-2\",\"E-6-request-2\"]","mutation_id":"arc-crm-006-mutation-02","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"AT-2\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"arguments":{"attachment_id":"AT-2"},"index":12,"result":{"attachment_id":"AT-2","document_id":"D-61","file_name":"capacity-assessment.pdf","opportunity_id":"OP-61"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.attachments.get"},{"arguments":{"note_id":"NT-1"},"index":13,"result":{"content":"Operations handoff \u2014 verified records and facts: RQ-62; OP-61; D-61. Please review the linked evidence.","entity_id":"OP-61","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-6-D-61\",\"E-6-documents-2\",\"E-6-request-2\"]","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"AT-2\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.get"},{"arguments":{"attachment_id":"AT-2","document_id":"D-61","note_id":"NT-1","opportunity_id":"OP-61","source_request_id":"RQ-62"},"index":14,"result":{"accepted":true,"fields":{"attachment_id":"AT-2","document_id":"D-61","note_id":"NT-1","opportunity_id":"OP-61","source_request_id":"RQ-62"},"task_id":"arc-crm-006"},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.submit_answer"}],"exact_replay":true,"negative_controls":[{"name":"noop","score":14.17,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945","verdict_sha256":"74cbf161df47a557116708c57d4ea2fb65420524915164b098efc948f958b989"},{"name":"answer_only","score":24.17,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"751ced6d8fd8ce0eb47f78601e248dc46734d7595f696859bc27c2ce05d986b6","verdict_sha256":"be0507f8496d7a7edb8f06d9356748014109c5d2231ea7f853e258924d682003"},{"name":"skip_investigation","score":80.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"569fb45d641ffa46d4ce00e0da77c0fb0138cf30ca3ff25436b110f86831551a","verdict_sha256":"897bebc34bcca783c5ffce8f44e79a820d3dc8e790e4648e83cbba70a9271e97"},{"name":"write_before_investigation","score":80.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"489e02896f86f29f89e557c32e0d9f4bede96ce20ad4448f68d36bc4a6d8a2a7","verdict_sha256":"76a7c10525cdb39f89ef020b76f4a3040e4890304c31734f2188bbc4a0e66139"},{"name":"missing_readback","score":85.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"c18c08b0a447e0e130795d5ce611b8d6e3f410549beed3db79f586c1da73eedc","verdict_sha256":"ce588b265ac5f5b55fd0d9cac967e054eea303f16bd75705c51fd4ba6341fe76"},{"name":"state_without_answer","score":90.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"b28d92364e3e838d09e28e7999bc2a587d8029b469928c2bc3a8df3ae4b9c888","verdict_sha256":"93da976b85e9123afa8d151cbf0e58c83abb648c9eafbfef285b5d7c98932242"},{"name":"omit_read_1_desk.requests.search","score":97.78,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"f24c7a4ac0e22ad804478544a08ca25cf2b3b34bb8c64550db3815986770d2ba","verdict_sha256":"079029757bf381b1c1659f7e8669a59e0b782ba8e04feb78b0b8839f0bc351ba"},{"name":"omit_read_2_arccrm.clients.search","score":97.78,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"21e2b6f9ea5b24776aa1511857e8b54c18f8437a9d2306818ffacc7afe9b82eb","verdict_sha256":"bfe46d1735ee94867135a8b47b2541aecaeba983c49eb5bb1a66e231d8cf2ee9"},{"name":"omit_read_3_desk.policies.get","score":97.78,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"e8235cab850a4540e1314cf41cd2f0c725054fab227ea9dbc7eb680102b76d9c","verdict_sha256":"4ee40e31dea7a0d85bfda0c80eccebbccb34cd33b0b5843ca8ec882e1013c857"},{"name":"omit_read_4_arccrm.opportunities.get","score":97.78,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"4f4fda253331e4f9527647a4b17bd1ab4e1c2bc3564a939d7fb7780d11b4de9c","verdict_sha256":"6aa6d4449c2b5b1918278f0ef9e91919b014a6895ec90839e6683c925ce9eace"},{"name":"omit_read_5_arccrm.opportunities.get","score":97.78,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"79de8c2117d1b771b6e3a999913d8285a757deb8e3fc7f8988c0bff941c0bad8","verdict_sha256":"2528ffb8e16f64986dac082c2c3f2cc0cb9fcf2056bfbf206c80201a7b1664c8"},{"name":"omit_read_6_arccrm.documents.search","score":97.78,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"60dbad6e026a196cb0249d5b7e84397cad77544b6a5d51bb2d18fc8c1e5d92b9","verdict_sha256":"a226f3915f4e80e013f60a493d3cfed72ab1f7f1572d838b4196e87e242c7be5"},{"name":"omit_read_7_vault.files.get","score":97.78,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"2d1192abda93c8d46243f745ad7fe5f39291113ea3c63e0ff1492db203b69ab7","verdict_sha256":"f80b12c36a3f5ece5885a67b65bb6ed70611ea34f8411f556432d246a40c4a16"},{"name":"omit_read_8_arccrm.attachments.search","score":97.78,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"c2fa7c0790b8f8d18f0673d07bc46ca891d432fc6a347c22392a670d56844ea2","verdict_sha256":"6da31a145bf62fb19056dfcb7a46900dc8a179278bbccbaadeb95d19ccd58c11"},{"name":"omit_read_9_desk.permissions.list","score":97.78,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"bfbd14a07857c9f0b3d89c2613204e0eccca11c4263dbfec15e213ef6591dc75","verdict_sha256":"054d16999db598326048d340fb16abb86719f09967bd05fce7fd1bc9819e69e4"},{"name":"omit_mutation_10_arccrm.documents.attach","score":43.89,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"dc55344529f0bb4674de7bc359abce6e7e585f78d8c135cdbf2dbcc397e5755f","verdict_sha256":"0cc10a69bf273ef309cd0f2cdd78aedd9a700de3b8b59f78bc03446b464bb45d"},{"name":"omit_mutation_11_arccrm.notes.create","score":66.94,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"52c13c659bb523a8b1751a412667989b2afbb4646be5f9e0c8d0421f9b5ab9a1","verdict_sha256":"67996d346f5002cdd52cfacb5680a3447e807f7f3ba6610e7b45a6ba831bb619"},{"name":"omit_read_12_arccrm.attachments.get","score":92.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"9ddd42e4117bf84974c9fa4cf9921092ba2db22cbd86790e7f988f1ea05e1feb","verdict_sha256":"06cf137622ca74f45ebcc133b55ef6c7d3b7d23b3f10e2ce610cfec0ba625d90"},{"name":"omit_read_13_arccrm.notes.get","score":92.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"91b146c5b77358e3021adfd28d186e9e44761f392d7ea12af1cb72d78cbc4bf7","verdict_sha256":"5d6063f15489f581c9596973e4044f637c6830af9f8d257a5a2991bafa0c2413"},{"name":"superseded_request","score":97.78,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"ad8cc0ad71d58a8fe12409ff0b1cde6d195169193e3b260e7bb3cfd81ab43839","verdict_sha256":"e52f389a2f22779f7882fbdaf8a64d78e0c13ed08d29ff2b53b862afa3d4899a"},{"name":"retired_policy","score":97.78,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"0a2651ea0af6aed7a23e14b4b65ca8abe4122d647f0e25eed2d5dcd225a5ddf7","verdict_sha256":"5f31fec92afb9b8fb25a436101e65d4ff93084b1cd41f39141aaf68c4835fa98"},{"name":"wrong_answer","score":98.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"7fd4f9333429c30189ad4c074034ebf59e315e52880d81d6a29b39359cb5e0df","verdict_sha256":"3d9f8b15bdb76838d72ea32b31ba3c3a97a35340c04229f0c9642ff8e07d65e6"},{"name":"missing_literal_handoff_facts","score":90.0,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"ea3d9b507d979f5c3a8df087b25fac704717b0d6735342d234bec25f8597d8dc","verdict_sha256":"eedf79b2c101e78a5912386f8638476b0022027d75eefdb4f04c4ea0559cbc32"},{"name":"stale_handoff_evidence","score":77.5,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"f7734bd69d6de3d9e07546ece7926fdac132f2d9cefe8f89dccebc10cf1ac2e3","verdict_sha256":"670b29a616c9b00c4070d4b41becb790f9fab89707275f09c0368ac5042e6e7c"},{"name":"external_url","score":99.72,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"1e3ecea9dacb04cedd4cbf376db6bcc633b74c1b669d6850e978e4f1be58408f","verdict_sha256":"068693ebb1415d5643adeb7640273392038c8c7c9db65259201f44e35da9a705"},{"name":"unknown_mock_object","score":99.72,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"c01c39f8771f9185ec3bc6f4424303dd156b1c1193590238f17ae041ede9a519","verdict_sha256":"068693ebb1415d5643adeb7640273392038c8c7c9db65259201f44e35da9a705"},{"name":"cross_client","score":99.72,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"854ed8cdd1cda13f655c5c7ee6512b36366d62a025e554373b7e7cd471e5a3a7","verdict_sha256":"3c84308508fa80c0a6a2e9eac22e9f751e654bbaf51592e43ee18eedc007f431"},{"name":"wrong_authorized_entity","score":44.17,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"f2282fc2737b85db4102e2c1a4c7407fd9c78ec46b0bb70a941280f5b87613a3","verdict_sha256":"bb5214ffb84347a3784762382df1fd062286f172c9c442e4edaab400702de84f"},{"name":"wrong_entity_type","score":99.72,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"cc94de1b314541a1624d602f933ae1f54e8e6a738c97d5eaf05c0bb913730cdb","verdict_sha256":"3c84308508fa80c0a6a2e9eac22e9f751e654bbaf51592e43ee18eedc007f431"},{"name":"superseded_document","score":99.72,"strict_pass":false,"trace_sha256":"81f77781019a8c0cf093d53e8daad4c316d4751b4fda5ca93a6d4be43533e1a1","verdict_sha256":"3c84308508fa80c0a6a2e9eac22e9f751e654bbaf51592e43ee18eedc007f431"}],"oracle":{"final_state":{"answers":[{"field":"attachment_id","task_id":"arc-crm-006","value":"AT-2"},{"field":"document_id","task_id":"arc-crm-006","value":"D-61"},{"field":"note_id","task_id":"arc-crm-006","value":"NT-1"},{"field":"opportunity_id","task_id":"arc-crm-006","value":"OP-61"},{"field":"source_request_id","task_id":"arc-crm-006","value":"RQ-62"}],"audit_log":[{"action":"attached","audit_id":1,"payload":"{\"document_url\":\"mock://crm/D-61\",\"entity_id\":\"OP-61\",\"entity_type\":\"opportunity\",\"file_name\":\"capacity-assessment.pdf\"}","record_id":"AT-2","table_name":"crm_attachments","task_id":"arc-crm-006","tool":"arccrm.documents.attach"},{"action":"insert","audit_id":2,"payload":"{\"arguments\":{\"document_url\":\"mock://crm/D-61\",\"entity_id\":\"OP-61\",\"entity_type\":\"opportunity\",\"file_name\":\"capacity-assessment.pdf\"},\"tool\":\"arccrm.documents.attach\"}","record_id":"arc-crm-006-mutation-01","table_name":"mutations","task_id":"arc-crm-006","tool":"arccrm.documents.attach"},{"action":"created","audit_id":3,"payload":"{\"content\":\"Associated approved D-61 with OP-61 through AT-2 per RQ-62; west history preserved.\",\"entity_id\":\"OP-61\",\"entity_type\":\"opportunity\",\"evidence_ids\":[\"E-6-request-2\",\"E-6-documents-2\",\"E-6-D-61\"],\"reference_ids\":[\"AT-2\"]}","record_id":"NT-1","table_name":"crm_notes","task_id":"arc-crm-006","tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"action":"insert","audit_id":4,"payload":"{\"arguments\":{\"content\":\"Associated approved D-61 with OP-61 through AT-2 per RQ-62; west history preserved.\",\"entity_id\":\"OP-61\",\"entity_type\":\"opportunity\",\"evidence_ids\":[\"E-6-request-2\",\"E-6-documents-2\",\"E-6-D-61\"],\"reference_ids\":[\"AT-2\"]},\"tool\":\"arccrm.notes.create\"}","record_id":"arc-crm-006-mutation-02","table_name":"mutations","task_id":"arc-crm-006","tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"action":"submit","audit_id":5,"payload":"{\"attachment_id\":\"AT-2\",\"document_id\":\"D-61\",\"note_id\":\"NT-1\",\"opportunity_id\":\"OP-61\",\"source_request_id\":\"RQ-62\"}","record_id":"arc-crm-006","table_name":"answers","task_id":"arc-crm-006","tool":"hubbench.submit_answer"}],"crm_approvals":[],"crm_attachments":[{"attachment_id":"AT-1","document_id":"D-62","file_name":"capacity-draft.pdf","opportunity_id":"OP-62"},{"attachment_id":"AT-2","document_id":"D-61","file_name":"capacity-assessment.pdf","opportunity_id":"OP-61"}],"crm_clients":[{"client_id":"C-61","domain":"fjord-packaging.example","email":"billing@fjord-packaging.example","name":"Fjord Packaging","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-62","domain":"services-fjord-packaging.example","email":"billing@services-fjord-packaging.example","name":"Fjord Packaging Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-63","domain":"archive-fjord-packaging.example","email":"hold@archive-fjord-packaging.example","name":"Fjord Packaging Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"crm_contacts":[{"client_id":"C-61","contact_id":"CT-61","email":"jamie@fjord-packaging.example","first_name":"Jamie","last_name":"Park","revision":1,"title":"Procurement lead"}],"crm_contracts":[],"crm_documents":[{"asset_id":"E-6-D-61","client_id":"C-61","document_id":"D-61","file_name":"capacity-assessment.pdf","status":"approved","url":"mock://crm/D-61"},{"asset_id":"E-6-D-62","client_id":"C-61","document_id":"D-62","file_name":"capacity-draft.pdf","status":"superseded","url":"mock://crm/D-62"},{"asset_id":"E-6-D-63","client_id":"C-62","document_id":"D-63","file_name":"services-assessment.pdf","status":"approved","url":"mock://crm/D-63"}],"crm_evidence":[{"asset_id":"E-6-D-61","content":"Approved capacity assessment for Fjord Packaging east operations. Record D-61 supersedes D-62 for the new association only. Requested opportunity OP-61. No signature or contractual acceptance."},{"asset_id":"E-6-D-62","content":"Retired draft for west operations. Retain existing historical association; not valid for new attachments."},{"asset_id":"E-6-D-63","content":"Different client: Fjord Packaging Services. Do not associate with Fjord Packaging opportunities."},{"asset_id":"E-6-documents-1","content":"Fjord Packaging\nEffective 2025-01-01 through 2026-08-31.\n{\"notice\":\"Retired. Use the current revision.\"}\n"},{"asset_id":"E-6-documents-2","content":"Fjord Packaging\nEffective 2026-09-01 through 2026-12-31.\n{\"client_link\":\"must match opportunity client\",\"handoff\":\"actual persisted attachment reference\",\"history\":\"preserve existing associations\",\"source\":\"seeded mock objects only\",\"status\":\"approved\"}\n"},{"asset_id":"E-6-request-1","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@fjord-packaging.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@fjord-packaging.example>\nSubject: Associate the corrected evidence without cross-client leakage\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nUpload the proof to the west renewal and reuse the old draft file if that is easier.\n"},{"asset_id":"E-6-request-2","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@fjord-packaging.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@fjord-packaging.example>\nSubject: Associate the corrected evidence without cross-client leakage\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nCorrection: use east OP-61, not west OP-62. Associate the approved capacity-assessment.pdf document D-61 at mock://crm/D-61. D-62 is superseded and its old west association must stay intact. Do not fetch an external URL. In the note cite D-61, OP-61, and this request RQ-62.\n"}],"crm_notes":[{"content":"Associated approved D-61 with OP-61 through AT-2 per RQ-62; west history preserved.","entity_id":"OP-61","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-6-D-61\",\"E-6-documents-2\",\"E-6-request-2\"]","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"AT-2\"]"}],"crm_opportunities":[{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-61","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-61","owner_id":"U-62","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":900000,"client_id":"C-61","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - west","opportunity_id":"OP-62","owner_id":"U-62","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-62","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-63","owner_id":"U-62","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"}],"crm_permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"document:attach","permission_id":"PERM-6-1","target_id":"OP-61","user_id":"U-61","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"document:attach","permission_id":"PERM-6-2","target_id":"OP-62","user_id":"U-61","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-6-3","target_id":"OP-61","user_id":"U-61","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"crm_policies":[{"asset_id":"E-6-documents-1","effective_from":"2025-01-01","effective_until":"2026-08-31","policy_id":"POL-6-documents-1","revision":1,"rules_json":"{\"notice\":\"Retired. Use the current revision.\"}","topic":"documents"},{"asset_id":"E-6-documents-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","policy_id":"POL-6-documents-2","revision":2,"rules_json":"{\"client_link\":\"must match opportunity client\",\"handoff\":\"actual persisted attachment reference\",\"history\":\"preserve existing associations\",\"source\":\"seeded mock objects only\",\"status\":\"approved\"}","topic":"documents"}],"crm_prices":[],"crm_quote_lines":[],"crm_quotes":[],"crm_requests":[{"asset_id":"E-6-request-1","body":"Upload the proof to the west renewal and reuse the old draft file if that is easier.","client_id":"C-61","request_id":"RQ-61","sender_id":"U-62","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Associate the corrected evidence without cross-client leakage","thread_id":"TH-6"},{"asset_id":"E-6-request-2","body":"Correction: use east OP-61, not west OP-62. Associate the approved capacity-assessment.pdf document D-61 at mock://crm/D-61. D-62 is superseded and its old west association must stay intact. Do not fetch an external URL. In the note cite D-61, OP-61, and this request RQ-62.","client_id":"C-61","request_id":"RQ-62","sender_id":"U-62","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Associate the corrected evidence without cross-client leakage","thread_id":"TH-6"}],"evidence_files":[{"asset_id":"E-6-D-61","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-6-D-61.pdf","sha256":"8f823e230e3e47ce6b29d2011393ad52b7612de1495d330e379c33f2fb5d2bfe","source":"Fjord Packaging","task_id":"arc-crm-006","title":"capacity-assessment.pdf"},{"asset_id":"E-6-D-62","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-6-D-62.pdf","sha256":"72c2aef6746d012033d42c58828762026433f6f8cf20f9f0f3a5cf7154642df5","source":"Fjord Packaging","task_id":"arc-crm-006","title":"capacity-draft.pdf"},{"asset_id":"E-6-D-63","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-6-D-63.pdf","sha256":"2fc3358262088b61106292d55109e72e0c1329d6655ac001ec260555d19a93e9","source":"Fjord Packaging","task_id":"arc-crm-006","title":"services-assessment.pdf"},{"asset_id":"E-6-documents-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-6-documents-1.pdf","sha256":"2bdfd2ae63915f7825c17dfa29b1b4427481d9275d60498d34d69ab24271c5a6","source":"Fjord Packaging","task_id":"arc-crm-006","title":"Documents policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-6-documents-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-6-documents-2.pdf","sha256":"9f5e8424191b55aba0d62712257c189536aa2eadf90ad358c36e9e91c3d70e6f","source":"Fjord Packaging","task_id":"arc-crm-006","title":"Documents policy revision 2"},{"asset_id":"E-6-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-6-request-1.eml","sha256":"e9f78269d0f32dc6c89c705a198c447321e979397682df4ad566279e8448c49e","source":"Fjord Packaging","task_id":"arc-crm-006","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-6-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-6-request-2.eml","sha256":"420f0ff3ed5f44948dd43567584d9e27a8319b118a19873509e8bb5866d7ae88","source":"Fjord Packaging","task_id":"arc-crm-006","title":"Owner request 2"}],"mutations":[{"effective_at":"2026-09-05T09:10:00","mutation_id":"arc-crm-006-mutation-01","payload_json":"{\"arguments\":{\"document_url\":\"mock://crm/D-61\",\"entity_id\":\"OP-61\",\"entity_type\":\"opportunity\",\"file_name\":\"capacity-assessment.pdf\"},\"tool\":\"arccrm.documents.attach\"}","record_id":"AT-2","revision":1,"sequence":1,"status":"attached","table_name":"crm_attachments","task_id":"arc-crm-006","tool":"arccrm.documents.attach"},{"effective_at":"2026-09-05T09:11:00","mutation_id":"arc-crm-006-mutation-02","payload_json":"{\"arguments\":{\"content\":\"Associated approved D-61 with OP-61 through AT-2 per RQ-62; west history preserved.\",\"entity_id\":\"OP-61\",\"entity_type\":\"opportunity\",\"evidence_ids\":[\"E-6-request-2\",\"E-6-documents-2\",\"E-6-D-61\"],\"reference_ids\":[\"AT-2\"]},\"tool\":\"arccrm.notes.create\"}","record_id":"NT-1","revision":1,"sequence":2,"status":"created","table_name":"crm_notes","task_id":"arc-crm-006","tool":"arccrm.notes.create"}],"users":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-61"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-62"}]},"initial_state":{"answers":[],"audit_log":[],"crm_approvals":[],"crm_attachments":[{"attachment_id":"AT-1","document_id":"D-62","file_name":"capacity-draft.pdf","opportunity_id":"OP-62"}],"crm_clients":[{"client_id":"C-61","domain":"fjord-packaging.example","email":"billing@fjord-packaging.example","name":"Fjord Packaging","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-62","domain":"services-fjord-packaging.example","email":"billing@services-fjord-packaging.example","name":"Fjord Packaging Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-63","domain":"archive-fjord-packaging.example","email":"hold@archive-fjord-packaging.example","name":"Fjord Packaging Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"crm_contacts":[{"client_id":"C-61","contact_id":"CT-61","email":"jamie@fjord-packaging.example","first_name":"Jamie","last_name":"Park","revision":1,"title":"Procurement lead"}],"crm_contracts":[],"crm_documents":[{"asset_id":"E-6-D-61","client_id":"C-61","document_id":"D-61","file_name":"capacity-assessment.pdf","status":"approved","url":"mock://crm/D-61"},{"asset_id":"E-6-D-62","client_id":"C-61","document_id":"D-62","file_name":"capacity-draft.pdf","status":"superseded","url":"mock://crm/D-62"},{"asset_id":"E-6-D-63","client_id":"C-62","document_id":"D-63","file_name":"services-assessment.pdf","status":"approved","url":"mock://crm/D-63"}],"crm_evidence":[{"asset_id":"E-6-D-61","content":"Approved capacity assessment for Fjord Packaging east operations. Record D-61 supersedes D-62 for the new association only. Requested opportunity OP-61. No signature or contractual acceptance."},{"asset_id":"E-6-D-62","content":"Retired draft for west operations. Retain existing historical association; not valid for new attachments."},{"asset_id":"E-6-D-63","content":"Different client: Fjord Packaging Services. Do not associate with Fjord Packaging opportunities."},{"asset_id":"E-6-documents-1","content":"Fjord Packaging\nEffective 2025-01-01 through 2026-08-31.\n{\"notice\":\"Retired. Use the current revision.\"}\n"},{"asset_id":"E-6-documents-2","content":"Fjord Packaging\nEffective 2026-09-01 through 2026-12-31.\n{\"client_link\":\"must match opportunity client\",\"handoff\":\"actual persisted attachment reference\",\"history\":\"preserve existing associations\",\"source\":\"seeded mock objects only\",\"status\":\"approved\"}\n"},{"asset_id":"E-6-request-1","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@fjord-packaging.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@fjord-packaging.example>\nSubject: Associate the corrected evidence without cross-client leakage\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nUpload the proof to the west renewal and reuse the old draft file if that is easier.\n"},{"asset_id":"E-6-request-2","content":"From: Morgan Ellis <morgan@fjord-packaging.example>\nTo: Alex Rowan <alex@fjord-packaging.example>\nSubject: Associate the corrected evidence without cross-client leakage\nDate: 2026-09-05\n\nCorrection: use east OP-61, not west OP-62. Associate the approved capacity-assessment.pdf document D-61 at mock://crm/D-61. D-62 is superseded and its old west association must stay intact. Do not fetch an external URL. In the note cite D-61, OP-61, and this request RQ-62.\n"}],"crm_notes":[],"crm_opportunities":[{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-61","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-61","owner_id":"U-62","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":900000,"client_id":"C-61","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - west","opportunity_id":"OP-62","owner_id":"U-62","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-62","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-63","owner_id":"U-62","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"}],"crm_permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"document:attach","permission_id":"PERM-6-1","target_id":"OP-61","user_id":"U-61","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"document:attach","permission_id":"PERM-6-2","target_id":"OP-62","user_id":"U-61","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-6-3","target_id":"OP-61","user_id":"U-61","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"crm_policies":[{"asset_id":"E-6-documents-1","effective_from":"2025-01-01","effective_until":"2026-08-31","policy_id":"POL-6-documents-1","revision":1,"rules_json":"{\"notice\":\"Retired. Use the current revision.\"}","topic":"documents"},{"asset_id":"E-6-documents-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","policy_id":"POL-6-documents-2","revision":2,"rules_json":"{\"client_link\":\"must match opportunity client\",\"handoff\":\"actual persisted attachment reference\",\"history\":\"preserve existing associations\",\"source\":\"seeded mock objects only\",\"status\":\"approved\"}","topic":"documents"}],"crm_prices":[],"crm_quote_lines":[],"crm_quotes":[],"crm_requests":[{"asset_id":"E-6-request-1","body":"Upload the proof to the west renewal and reuse the old draft file if that is easier.","client_id":"C-61","request_id":"RQ-61","sender_id":"U-62","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Associate the corrected evidence without cross-client leakage","thread_id":"TH-6"},{"asset_id":"E-6-request-2","body":"Correction: use east OP-61, not west OP-62. Associate the approved capacity-assessment.pdf document D-61 at mock://crm/D-61. D-62 is superseded and its old west association must stay intact. Do not fetch an external URL. In the note cite D-61, OP-61, and this request RQ-62.","client_id":"C-61","request_id":"RQ-62","sender_id":"U-62","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Associate the corrected evidence without cross-client leakage","thread_id":"TH-6"}],"evidence_files":[{"asset_id":"E-6-D-61","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-6-D-61.pdf","sha256":"8f823e230e3e47ce6b29d2011393ad52b7612de1495d330e379c33f2fb5d2bfe","source":"Fjord Packaging","task_id":"arc-crm-006","title":"capacity-assessment.pdf"},{"asset_id":"E-6-D-62","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-6-D-62.pdf","sha256":"72c2aef6746d012033d42c58828762026433f6f8cf20f9f0f3a5cf7154642df5","source":"Fjord Packaging","task_id":"arc-crm-006","title":"capacity-draft.pdf"},{"asset_id":"E-6-D-63","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-6-D-63.pdf","sha256":"2fc3358262088b61106292d55109e72e0c1329d6655ac001ec260555d19a93e9","source":"Fjord Packaging","task_id":"arc-crm-006","title":"services-assessment.pdf"},{"asset_id":"E-6-documents-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-6-documents-1.pdf","sha256":"2bdfd2ae63915f7825c17dfa29b1b4427481d9275d60498d34d69ab24271c5a6","source":"Fjord Packaging","task_id":"arc-crm-006","title":"Documents policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-6-documents-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-6-documents-2.pdf","sha256":"9f5e8424191b55aba0d62712257c189536aa2eadf90ad358c36e9e91c3d70e6f","source":"Fjord Packaging","task_id":"arc-crm-006","title":"Documents policy revision 2"},{"asset_id":"E-6-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-6-request-1.eml","sha256":"e9f78269d0f32dc6c89c705a198c447321e979397682df4ad566279e8448c49e","source":"Fjord Packaging","task_id":"arc-crm-006","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-6-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-6-request-2.eml","sha256":"420f0ff3ed5f44948dd43567584d9e27a8319b118a19873509e8bb5866d7ae88","source":"Fjord Packaging","task_id":"arc-crm-006","title":"Owner request 2"}],"mutations":[],"users":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-61"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-62"}]},"trace":[{"arguments":{},"index":0,"result":{"evidence_index":[{"asset_id":"E-6-D-61","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-6-D-61.pdf","sha256":"8f823e230e3e47ce6b29d2011393ad52b7612de1495d330e379c33f2fb5d2bfe","source":"Fjord Packaging","title":"capacity-assessment.pdf"},{"asset_id":"E-6-D-62","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-6-D-62.pdf","sha256":"72c2aef6746d012033d42c58828762026433f6f8cf20f9f0f3a5cf7154642df5","source":"Fjord Packaging","title":"capacity-draft.pdf"},{"asset_id":"E-6-D-63","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-6-D-63.pdf","sha256":"2fc3358262088b61106292d55109e72e0c1329d6655ac001ec260555d19a93e9","source":"Fjord Packaging","title":"services-assessment.pdf"},{"asset_id":"E-6-documents-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-6-documents-1.pdf","sha256":"2bdfd2ae63915f7825c17dfa29b1b4427481d9275d60498d34d69ab24271c5a6","source":"Fjord Packaging","title":"Documents policy revision 1"},{"asset_id":"E-6-documents-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-6-documents-2.pdf","sha256":"9f5e8424191b55aba0d62712257c189536aa2eadf90ad358c36e9e91c3d70e6f","source":"Fjord Packaging","title":"Documents policy revision 2"},{"asset_id":"E-6-request-1","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-6-request-1.eml","sha256":"e9f78269d0f32dc6c89c705a198c447321e979397682df4ad566279e8448c49e","source":"Fjord Packaging","title":"Owner request 1"},{"asset_id":"E-6-request-2","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"message/rfc822","path":"assets/E-6-request-2.eml","sha256":"420f0ff3ed5f44948dd43567584d9e27a8319b118a19873509e8bb5866d7ae88","source":"Fjord Packaging","title":"Owner request 2"}],"identity":[{"approval_limit_usd":25000.0,"display_name":"Alex Rowan","role":"sales_operations","user_id":"U-61"},{"approval_limit_usd":100000.0,"display_name":"Morgan Ellis","role":"commercial_owner","user_id":"U-62"}],"organization":{"name":"Fjord Packaging","synthetic":true,"systems":["arccrm","desk","vault"]},"reference_records":{},"starting_records":[{"client_hint":"Fjord Packaging","thread_id":"TH-6"}],"state":{"network":"closed","persistence":"episode-local SQLite","scope":"isolated task snapshot"},"task":{"as_of":"2026-09-05","family":"arc-crm","role":"U-61","task_id":"arc-crm-006"},"tool_servers":[{"description":"Stateful synthetic CRM","name":"arccrm","tools":["arccrm.attachments.get","arccrm.attachments.search","arccrm.clients.get","arccrm.clients.search","arccrm.contacts.create","arccrm.contacts.get","arccrm.contacts.search","arccrm.contracts.create","arccrm.contracts.get","arccrm.contracts.search","arccrm.documents.attach","arccrm.documents.get","arccrm.documents.search","arccrm.notes.create","arccrm.notes.get","arccrm.notes.search","arccrm.opportunities.get","arccrm.opportunities.search","arccrm.opportunities.update","arccrm.quotes.cancel","arccrm.quotes.compare","arccrm.quotes.create","arccrm.quotes.get","arccrm.quotes.search"]},{"description":"Mock requests, permissions, approvals and versioned policy/price records","name":"desk","tools":["desk.approvals.get","desk.permissions.list","desk.policies.get","desk.prices.list","desk.requests.get","desk.requests.search"]},{"description":"Seeded synthetic evidence; no external file access","name":"vault","tools":["vault.files.get"]},{"description":"Benchmark-only discovery and structured answer submission controls.","name":"hubbench","tools":["hubbench.context.get","hubbench.submit_answer"]}]},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.context.get"},{"arguments":{"query":"TH-6"},"index":1,"result":{"query":"th-6","records":[{"asset_id":"E-6-request-1","body":"Upload the proof to the west renewal and reuse the old draft file if that is easier.","client_id":"C-61","request_id":"RQ-61","sender_id":"U-62","sequence":1,"status":"superseded","subject":"Associate the corrected evidence without cross-client leakage","thread_id":"TH-6"},{"asset_id":"E-6-request-2","body":"Correction: use east OP-61, not west OP-62. Associate the approved capacity-assessment.pdf document D-61 at mock://crm/D-61. D-62 is superseded and its old west association must stay intact. Do not fetch an external URL. In the note cite D-61, OP-61, and this request RQ-62.","client_id":"C-61","request_id":"RQ-62","sender_id":"U-62","sequence":2,"status":"current","subject":"Associate the corrected evidence without cross-client leakage","thread_id":"TH-6"}],"total":2},"success":true,"tool":"desk.requests.search"},{"arguments":{"query":"Fjord Packaging"},"index":2,"result":{"query":"fjord packaging","records":[{"client_id":"C-61","domain":"fjord-packaging.example","email":"billing@fjord-packaging.example","name":"Fjord Packaging","revision":3,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-62","domain":"services-fjord-packaging.example","email":"billing@services-fjord-packaging.example","name":"Fjord Packaging Services","revision":2,"status":"active"},{"client_id":"C-63","domain":"archive-fjord-packaging.example","email":"hold@archive-fjord-packaging.example","name":"Fjord Packaging Archive","revision":1,"status":"suspended"}],"total":3},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.clients.search"},{"arguments":{"policy_id":"POL-6-documents-2"},"index":3,"result":{"asset_id":"E-6-documents-2","effective_from":"2026-09-01","effective_until":"2026-12-31","operative":true,"policy_id":"POL-6-documents-2","revision":2,"rules":{"client_link":"must match opportunity client","handoff":"actual persisted attachment reference","history":"preserve existing associations","source":"seeded mock objects only","status":"approved"},"rules_json":"{\"client_link\":\"must match opportunity client\",\"handoff\":\"actual persisted attachment reference\",\"history\":\"preserve existing associations\",\"source\":\"seeded mock objects only\",\"status\":\"approved\"}","topic":"documents"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.policies.get"},{"arguments":{"opportunity_id":"OP-61"},"index":4,"result":{"amount_minor":1800000,"client_id":"C-61","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - east","opportunity_id":"OP-61","owner_id":"U-62","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"},{"arguments":{"opportunity_id":"OP-62"},"index":5,"result":{"amount_minor":900000,"client_id":"C-61","currency":"USD","name":"Platform renewal - west","opportunity_id":"OP-62","owner_id":"U-62","probability":50,"revision":4,"stage":"proposal"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"},{"arguments":{"query":"C-61"},"index":6,"result":{"query":"c-61","records":[{"asset_id":"E-6-D-61","client_id":"C-61","document_id":"D-61","file_name":"capacity-assessment.pdf","status":"approved","url":"mock://crm/D-61"},{"asset_id":"E-6-D-62","client_id":"C-61","document_id":"D-62","file_name":"capacity-draft.pdf","status":"superseded","url":"mock://crm/D-62"}],"total":2},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.documents.search"},{"arguments":{"asset_id":"E-6-D-61"},"index":7,"result":{"asset_id":"E-6-D-61","content":"Approved capacity assessment for Fjord Packaging east operations. Record D-61 supersedes D-62 for the new association only. Requested opportunity OP-61. No signature or contractual acceptance.","kind":"synthetic_evidence","media_type":"application/pdf","path":"assets/E-6-D-61.pdf","sha256":"8f823e230e3e47ce6b29d2011393ad52b7612de1495d330e379c33f2fb5d2bfe","source":"Fjord Packaging","task_id":"arc-crm-006","title":"capacity-assessment.pdf"},"success":true,"tool":"vault.files.get"},{"arguments":{"query":"OP-62"},"index":8,"result":{"query":"op-62","records":[{"attachment_id":"AT-1","document_id":"D-62","file_name":"capacity-draft.pdf","opportunity_id":"OP-62"}],"total":1},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.attachments.search"},{"arguments":{},"index":9,"result":{"permissions":[{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"document:attach","permission_id":"PERM-6-1","target_id":"OP-61","user_id":"U-61","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"document:attach","permission_id":"PERM-6-2","target_id":"OP-62","user_id":"U-61","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"},{"limit_minor":2500000,"operation":"note:create","permission_id":"PERM-6-3","target_id":"OP-61","user_id":"U-61","valid_from":"2026-09-01","valid_until":"2026-09-30"}],"user_id":"U-61"},"success":true,"tool":"desk.permissions.list"},{"arguments":{"document_url":"mock://crm/D-61","entity_id":"OP-61","entity_type":"opportunity","file_name":"capacity-assessment.pdf"},"index":10,"result":{"attachment_id":"AT-2","document_id":"D-61","file_name":"capacity-assessment.pdf","mutation_id":"arc-crm-006-mutation-01","opportunity_id":"OP-61"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.documents.attach"},{"arguments":{"content":"Associated approved D-61 with OP-61 through AT-2 per RQ-62; west history preserved.","entity_id":"OP-61","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids":["E-6-request-2","E-6-documents-2","E-6-D-61"],"reference_ids":["AT-2"]},"index":11,"result":{"content":"Associated approved D-61 with OP-61 through AT-2 per RQ-62; west history preserved.","entity_id":"OP-61","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-6-D-61\",\"E-6-documents-2\",\"E-6-request-2\"]","mutation_id":"arc-crm-006-mutation-02","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"AT-2\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.create"},{"arguments":{"attachment_id":"AT-2"},"index":12,"result":{"attachment_id":"AT-2","document_id":"D-61","file_name":"capacity-assessment.pdf","opportunity_id":"OP-61"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.attachments.get"},{"arguments":{"note_id":"NT-1"},"index":13,"result":{"content":"Associated approved D-61 with OP-61 through AT-2 per RQ-62; west history preserved.","entity_id":"OP-61","entity_type":"opportunity","evidence_ids_json":"[\"E-6-D-61\",\"E-6-documents-2\",\"E-6-request-2\"]","note_id":"NT-1","reference_ids_json":"[\"AT-2\"]"},"success":true,"tool":"arccrm.notes.get"},{"arguments":{"attachment_id":"AT-2","document_id":"D-61","note_id":"NT-1","opportunity_id":"OP-61","source_request_id":"RQ-62"},"index":14,"result":{"accepted":true,"fields":{"attachment_id":"AT-2","document_id":"D-61","note_id":"NT-1","opportunity_id":"OP-61","source_request_id":"RQ-62"},"task_id":"arc-crm-006"},"success":true,"tool":"hubbench.submit_answer"}],"verdict":{"checks":[{"category":"evidence","description":"corrected_document_link: evidence","earned_weight":20.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":9,"subchecks":[{"description":"Resolve the owner's current clarification, not the superseded message.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":1,"tool":"desk.requests.search"}]},"id":"investigate-current_request","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Identify the existing verified client and the similarly named account.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":2,"tool":"arccrm.clients.search"}]},"id":"investigate-verified_client","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the operative policy and its scope.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":3,"tool":"desk.policies.get"}]},"id":"investigate-operative_policy","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the precise opportunity identity, owner, revision and commercial fields.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":4,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"},{"index":5,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"}]},"id":"investigate-opportunity","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the precise opportunity identity, owner, revision and commercial fields.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":4,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"},{"index":5,"tool":"arccrm.opportunities.get"}]},"id":"investigate-other_opportunity","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Verify the approved document's identity and client.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":6,"tool":"arccrm.documents.search"}]},"id":"investigate-document","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the seeded approved document, not just its filename.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":7,"tool":"vault.files.get"}]},"id":"investigate-document_content","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Identify the historical association that must be preserved.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":8,"tool":"arccrm.attachments.search"}]},"id":"investigate-prior_association","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read the acting role's specific operation/target grants before writing.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":9,"tool":"desk.permissions.list"}]},"id":"investigate-authority","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":9},"id":"evidence","passed":true,"weight":20.0},{"category":"readback","description":"corrected_document_link: readback","earned_weight":15.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":2,"subchecks":[{"description":"Read back the persisted attachment after the business mutation.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":8,"tool":"arccrm.attachments.search"},{"index":12,"tool":"arccrm.attachments.get"}]},"id":"readback-attachment","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Read back the persisted handoff after the business mutation.","evidence":{"missing":[],"satisfied_by":[{"index":13,"tool":"arccrm.notes.get"}]},"id":"readback-handoff","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":2},"id":"readback","passed":true,"weight":15.0},{"category":"outcome","description":"corrected_document_link: outcome","earned_weight":30.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":2,"subchecks":[{"description":"Persist the required crm_attachments record and exact structural fields.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"create-crm_attachments-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Persist the required crm_notes record and exact structural fields.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"create-crm_notes-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":2},"id":"outcome","passed":true,"weight":30.0},{"category":"containment","description":"corrected_document_link: containment","earned_weight":15.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":54,"subchecks":[{"description":"Preserve users record {'user_id': 'U-61'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-users-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve users record {'user_id': 'U-62'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-users-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in users.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-users","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-6-request-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-6-request-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-6-documents-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-6-documents-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-3","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-6-D-61'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-4","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-6-D-62'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-5","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve evidence_files record {'asset_id': 'E-6-D-63'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-evidence_files-6","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in evidence_files.","evidence":{"expected_count":7,"matching_rows":7},"id":"count-evidence_files","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-6-request-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-6-request-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-6-documents-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-6-documents-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-3","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-6-D-61'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-4","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-6-D-62'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-5","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_evidence record {'asset_id': 'E-6-D-63'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_evidence-6","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_evidence.","evidence":{"expected_count":7,"matching_rows":7},"id":"count-crm_evidence","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_clients record {'client_id': 'C-61'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_clients-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_clients record {'client_id': 'C-62'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_clients-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_clients record {'client_id': 'C-63'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_clients-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_clients.","evidence":{"expected_count":3,"matching_rows":3},"id":"count-crm_clients","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_contacts record {'contact_id': 'CT-61'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_contacts-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_contacts.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1},"id":"count-crm_contacts","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_opportunities record {'opportunity_id': 'OP-61'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_opportunities-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_opportunities record {'opportunity_id': 'OP-62'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_opportunities-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_opportunities record {'opportunity_id': 'OP-63'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_opportunities-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_opportunities.","evidence":{"expected_count":3,"matching_rows":3},"id":"count-crm_opportunities","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_quotes.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_quotes","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_quote_lines.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_quote_lines","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_contracts.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_contracts","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_documents record {'document_id': 'D-61'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_documents-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_documents record {'document_id': 'D-62'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_documents-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_documents record {'document_id': 'D-63'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_documents-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_documents.","evidence":{"expected_count":3,"matching_rows":3},"id":"count-crm_documents","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_attachments record {'attachment_id': 'AT-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_attachments-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_attachments.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-crm_attachments","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_notes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1},"id":"count-crm_notes","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_requests record {'request_id': 'RQ-61'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_requests-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_requests record {'request_id': 'RQ-62'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_requests-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_requests.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-crm_requests","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_policies record {'policy_id': 'POL-6-documents-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_policies-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_policies record {'policy_id': 'POL-6-documents-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_policies-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_policies.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-crm_policies","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_prices.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_prices","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_approvals.","evidence":{"expected_count":0,"matching_rows":0},"id":"count-crm_approvals","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_permissions record {'permission_id': 'PERM-6-1'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_permissions-0","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_permissions record {'permission_id': 'PERM-6-2'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_permissions-1","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Preserve crm_permissions record {'permission_id': 'PERM-6-3'}, except the explicitly requested changes.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1,"mismatches":{}},"id":"retain-crm_permissions-2","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"No missing or extra records in crm_permissions.","evidence":{"expected_count":3,"matching_rows":3},"id":"count-crm_permissions","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Exactly the required domain writes, with no hidden extra mutation.","evidence":{"expected_count":2,"matching_rows":2},"id":"count-mutations","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Kept every successful write inside arc-crm-006's declared state, collaboration, answer, and audit tables.","evidence":{"disallowed":[],"written_tables":["answers","crm_attachments","crm_notes","mutations"]},"id":"write_scope","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Completed without a rejected state-changing call; failed exploratory reads and retryable provider faults do not erase a correct outcome.","evidence":{"errors":[]},"id":"no_rejected_mutation","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":54},"id":"containment","passed":true,"weight":15.0},{"category":"handoff","description":"corrected_document_link: handoff","earned_weight":10.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":1,"subchecks":[{"description":"Handoff content contains the disclosed literal facts; punctuation/case/prose may vary. Not a semantic consistency check.","evidence":{"expected_count":1,"matching_rows":1},"id":"handoff-facts","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":1},"id":"handoff","passed":true,"weight":10.0},{"category":"answer","description":"corrected_document_link: answer","earned_weight":10.0,"evidence":{"passed_criteria":5,"subchecks":[{"description":"Report the correct attachment id.","evidence":{"expected":"AT-2","field":"attachment_id","submitted":"AT-2"},"id":"answer-attachment_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct document id.","evidence":{"expected":"D-61","field":"document_id","submitted":"D-61"},"id":"answer-document_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct opportunity id.","evidence":{"expected":"OP-61","field":"opportunity_id","submitted":"OP-61"},"id":"answer-opportunity_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct source request id.","evidence":{"expected":"RQ-62","field":"source_request_id","submitted":"RQ-62"},"id":"answer-source_request_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0},{"description":"Report the correct note id.","evidence":{"expected":"NT-1","field":"note_id","submitted":"NT-1"},"id":"answer-note_id","passed":true,"weight":1.0}],"total_criteria":5},"id":"answer","passed":true,"weight":10.0}],"metric":"HubScore","passed_atomic_checks":73,"passed_checks":6,"passed_weight":100.0,"score":100.0,"strict_pass":true,"task_id":"arc-crm-006","total_atomic_checks":73,"total_checks":6,"total_weight":100.0}},"replay_sha256":"3c7f5aa50522c3fdd8eec540c5e85e98ebdda0f10df029fe39da09627ec94691","task_id":"arc-crm-006","task_sha256":"315fcfa5538181ca03c2787255648278dd23e05a8e605e37899d65957c679546"}],"version":"0.1.0"} | |