retraction-census / census.json
SaneCite's picture
Add census.json
a825190 verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
19.6 kB
{ "data_as_of": "2026-10-14", "data_as_of_note": "Retraction Watch list downloaded 13 Oct 2026; final census analysis run 14 Oct 2026. These figures change only when a new census is published.", "headline_scope": "retractions other than administrative ones (out of date, replaced, moved journal, publisher duplicate)", "administrative_pairs": 4044, "substantive_administrative": { "rate": 0.3796, "k": 1535, "ci95": [ 0.339119, 0.428885 ], "n": 4044, "papers": 534 }, "codebook": "v3.3", "panel": [ "typesafe/jev", "@cf/google/gemma-4-26b-a4b-it", "@cf/cloudflare/clef" ], "pairs_classified": 55688, "judged": 51626, "unclear": 4062, "unclear_labels": 18, "unclear_note": "unclear (4062) counts every classified pair that was not judged: the 18 pairs the panel labelled unclear plus the 4,044 administrative pairs (see administrative_pairs). unclear_labels (18) is the true unclear-labelled count.", "notices_set_aside": 485, "incomplete_pairs": 6, "retracted_papers": 12864, "routes": { "unanimous": 46858, "majority": 8807, "split": 23 }, "panel_sizes": { "3": 55688 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0334, "k": 1726, "ci95": [ 0.02563, 0.042857 ], "n": 51626, "papers": 12328 }, "substantive": { "rate": 0.4075, "k": 21037, "ci95": [ 0.398918, 0.414787 ], "n": 51626, "papers": 12328 }, "perfunctory": { "rate": 0.5591, "k": 28863, "ci95": [ 0.550627, 0.568112 ], "n": 51626, "papers": 12328 }, "by_panel_size": { "2": { "aware": null, "substantive": null }, "3": { "aware": { "rate": 0.0334, "k": 1726, "ci95": [ 0.02563, 0.042857 ], "n": 51626, "papers": 12328 }, "substantive": { "rate": 0.4075, "k": 21037, "ci95": [ 0.398918, 0.414787 ], "n": 51626, "papers": 12328 } } }, "substantive_band": { "strict": { "rate": 0.3451, "k": 17818, "ci95": [ 0.336883, 0.35304 ], "n": 51626, "papers": 12328 }, "lenient": { "rate": 0.4668, "k": 24101, "ci95": [ 0.4574, 0.475382 ], "n": 51626, "papers": 12328 }, "note": "strict = a context the three models split on counts as substantive only if no model said perfunctory; lenient = if any said substantive" }, "ref_list_says_retracted": { "rate": 0.0656, "k": 3652, "ci95": [ 0.060642, 0.072356 ], "n": 55688, "papers": 12864 }, "substantive_despite_ref_list_label": { "rate": 0.4038, "k": 1465, "ci95": [ 0.373837, 0.435263 ], "n": 3628, "papers": 2203 }, "aware_despite_ref_list_label": { "rate": 0.129, "k": 468, "ci95": [ 0.076113, 0.179985 ], "n": 3628, "papers": 2203 }, "aware_hs_window_citing_le_2019": { "rate": 0.0508, "k": 667, "ci95": [ 0.038251, 0.065728 ], "n": 13129, "papers": 3518 }, "papers_with_any_substantive": { "papers": 12328, "with_substantive": 8197, "with_two_or_more_substantive": 3984, "note": "papers = non-administrative retracted papers with at least one judged citation" }, "by_years_after": { "1-2": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.4355, "k": 11286, "ci95": [ 0.425772, 0.443579 ], "n": 25915, "papers": 9501 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0274, "k": 711, "ci95": [ 0.020712, 0.038053 ], "n": 25915, "papers": 9501 } }, "11+": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.349, "k": 1303, "ci95": [ 0.324006, 0.37239 ], "n": 3734, "papers": 1264 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0635, "k": 237, "ci95": [ 0.032024, 0.120473 ], "n": 3734, "papers": 1264 } }, "3-5": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.3909, "k": 5355, "ci95": [ 0.37973, 0.402494 ], "n": 13700, "papers": 5814 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0336, "k": 461, "ci95": [ 0.028541, 0.039341 ], "n": 13700, "papers": 5814 } }, "6-10": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.3737, "k": 3093, "ci95": [ 0.358921, 0.389756 ], "n": 8277, "papers": 2978 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0383, "k": 317, "ci95": [ 0.027764, 0.053842 ], "n": 8277, "papers": 2978 } } }, "by_reason": { "error or unreliable results": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.3999, "k": 6284, "ci95": [ 0.388665, 0.411436 ], "n": 15715, "papers": 3230 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0654, "k": 1027, "ci95": [ 0.050987, 0.080867 ], "n": 15715, "papers": 3230 } }, "misconduct, fabrication or duplication": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.412, "k": 13161, "ci95": [ 0.39986, 0.422625 ], "n": 31947, "papers": 8077 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0186, "k": 594, "ci95": [ 0.011751, 0.031443 ], "n": 31947, "papers": 8077 } }, "other or unstated": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.4016, "k": 1592, "ci95": [ 0.379506, 0.423182 ], "n": 3964, "papers": 1021 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0265, "k": 105, "ci95": [ 0.019618, 0.035194 ], "n": 3964, "papers": 1021 } } }, "by_reason_all": { "administrative (no fault found in the science)": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.3796, "k": 1535, "ci95": [ 0.339119, 0.428885 ], "n": 4044, "papers": 534 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0143, "k": 58, "ci95": [ 0.009561, 0.019446 ], "n": 4044, "papers": 534 } }, "error or unreliable results": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.3999, "k": 6284, "ci95": [ 0.388665, 0.411436 ], "n": 15715, "papers": 3230 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0654, "k": 1027, "ci95": [ 0.050987, 0.080867 ], "n": 15715, "papers": 3230 } }, "misconduct, fabrication or duplication": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.412, "k": 13161, "ci95": [ 0.39986, 0.422625 ], "n": 31947, "papers": 8077 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0186, "k": 594, "ci95": [ 0.011751, 0.031443 ], "n": 31947, "papers": 8077 } }, "other or unstated": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.4016, "k": 1592, "ci95": [ 0.379506, 0.423182 ], "n": 3964, "papers": 1021 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0265, "k": 105, "ci95": [ 0.019618, 0.035194 ], "n": 3964, "papers": 1021 } } }, "by_citing_year": { "1997": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.4, "k": 2, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.8 ], "n": 5, "papers": 5 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0, "k": 0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "n": 5, "papers": 5 } }, "1998": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.5, "k": 3, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.875 ], "n": 6, "papers": 5 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0, "k": 0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "n": 6, "papers": 5 } }, "1999": { "substantive": { "rate": 1.0, "k": 1, "ci95": [ 1.0, 1.0 ], "n": 1, "papers": 1 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0, "k": 0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "n": 1, "papers": 1 } }, "2000": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.5, "k": 3, "ci95": [ 0.166667, 0.833333 ], "n": 6, "papers": 5 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.1667, "k": 1, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.6 ], "n": 6, "papers": 5 } }, "2001": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.0, "k": 0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "n": 1, "papers": 1 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0, "k": 0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "n": 1, "papers": 1 } }, "2002": { "substantive": { "rate": 1.0, "k": 1, "ci95": [ 1.0, 1.0 ], "n": 1, "papers": 1 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0, "k": 0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "n": 1, "papers": 1 } }, "2003": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.1429, "k": 1, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.428571 ], "n": 7, "papers": 7 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0, "k": 0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "n": 7, "papers": 7 } }, "2004": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.5455, "k": 6, "ci95": [ 0.25, 0.818182 ], "n": 11, "papers": 10 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0909, "k": 1, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.3 ], "n": 11, "papers": 10 } }, "2005": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.4737, "k": 9, "ci95": [ 0.25, 0.722222 ], "n": 19, "papers": 18 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.1053, "k": 2, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.277778 ], "n": 19, "papers": 18 } }, "2006": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.303, "k": 10, "ci95": [ 0.178571, 0.448276 ], "n": 33, "papers": 27 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0909, "k": 3, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.212121 ], "n": 33, "papers": 27 } }, "2007": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.3043, "k": 21, "ci95": [ 0.185714, 0.415385 ], "n": 69, "papers": 53 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.1739, "k": 12, "ci95": [ 0.088235, 0.289855 ], "n": 69, "papers": 53 } }, "2008": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.32, "k": 24, "ci95": [ 0.2, 0.45679 ], "n": 75, "papers": 65 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0667, "k": 5, "ci95": [ 0.013889, 0.131579 ], "n": 75, "papers": 65 } }, "2009": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.3603, "k": 49, "ci95": [ 0.28, 0.435484 ], "n": 136, "papers": 105 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.1397, "k": 19, "ci95": [ 0.086614, 0.2 ], "n": 136, "papers": 105 } }, "2010": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.3756, "k": 77, "ci95": [ 0.307292, 0.449761 ], "n": 205, "papers": 141 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0829, "k": 17, "ci95": [ 0.044776, 0.131222 ], "n": 205, "papers": 141 } }, "2011": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.3132, "k": 114, "ci95": [ 0.266289, 0.365782 ], "n": 364, "papers": 245 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0824, "k": 30, "ci95": [ 0.048851, 0.113821 ], "n": 364, "papers": 245 } }, "2012": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.3525, "k": 227, "ci95": [ 0.315436, 0.394107 ], "n": 644, "papers": 371 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.1009, "k": 65, "ci95": [ 0.060708, 0.148629 ], "n": 644, "papers": 371 } }, "2013": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.3972, "k": 363, "ci95": [ 0.357955, 0.431514 ], "n": 914, "papers": 517 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0678, "k": 62, "ci95": [ 0.039691, 0.101291 ], "n": 914, "papers": 517 } }, "2014": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.3984, "k": 439, "ci95": [ 0.365611, 0.429108 ], "n": 1102, "papers": 685 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0662, "k": 73, "ci95": [ 0.047091, 0.085635 ], "n": 1102, "papers": 685 } }, "2015": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.3482, "k": 467, "ci95": [ 0.317126, 0.375299 ], "n": 1341, "papers": 801 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.05, "k": 67, "ci95": [ 0.033165, 0.067982 ], "n": 1341, "papers": 801 } }, "2016": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.373, "k": 596, "ci95": [ 0.349398, 0.396301 ], "n": 1598, "papers": 950 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0325, "k": 52, "ci95": [ 0.021978, 0.045238 ], "n": 1598, "papers": 950 } }, "2017": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.3777, "k": 781, "ci95": [ 0.350886, 0.408985 ], "n": 2068, "papers": 1136 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0363, "k": 75, "ci95": [ 0.025501, 0.048524 ], "n": 2068, "papers": 1136 } }, "2018": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.382, "k": 772, "ci95": [ 0.356356, 0.400402 ], "n": 2021, "papers": 1168 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0391, "k": 79, "ci95": [ 0.028311, 0.053607 ], "n": 2021, "papers": 1168 } }, "2019": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.3753, "k": 939, "ci95": [ 0.35066, 0.400082 ], "n": 2502, "papers": 1397 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0416, "k": 104, "ci95": [ 0.029226, 0.055688 ], "n": 2502, "papers": 1397 } }, "2020": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.3895, "k": 1330, "ci95": [ 0.371403, 0.409197 ], "n": 3415, "papers": 1787 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.031, "k": 106, "ci95": [ 0.021972, 0.043492 ], "n": 3415, "papers": 1787 } }, "2021": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.4038, "k": 2326, "ci95": [ 0.389309, 0.421118 ], "n": 5760, "papers": 2505 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.046, "k": 265, "ci95": [ 0.025326, 0.07296 ], "n": 5760, "papers": 2505 } }, "2022": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.4511, "k": 3236, "ci95": [ 0.433494, 0.469318 ], "n": 7173, "papers": 3350 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0269, "k": 193, "ci95": [ 0.019218, 0.038558 ], "n": 7173, "papers": 3350 } }, "2023": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.4282, "k": 2650, "ci95": [ 0.411954, 0.444611 ], "n": 6188, "papers": 3327 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0225, "k": 139, "ci95": [ 0.016039, 0.031795 ], "n": 6188, "papers": 3327 } }, "2024": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.4315, "k": 3698, "ci95": [ 0.419502, 0.444247 ], "n": 8570, "papers": 4852 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0187, "k": 160, "ci95": [ 0.01442, 0.02412 ], "n": 8570, "papers": 4852 } }, "2025": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.4037, "k": 2138, "ci95": [ 0.388333, 0.418135 ], "n": 5296, "papers": 3502 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0238, "k": 126, "ci95": [ 0.018057, 0.030884 ], "n": 5296, "papers": 3502 } }, "2026": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.3599, "k": 754, "ci95": [ 0.336847, 0.380676 ], "n": 2095, "papers": 1652 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0334, "k": 70, "ci95": [ 0.022682, 0.044749 ], "n": 2095, "papers": 1652 } } }, "by_retraction_decade": { "1990s": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.3432, "k": 139, "ci95": [ 0.302632, 0.391061 ], "n": 405, "papers": 114 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0691, "k": 28, "ci95": [ 0.038647, 0.103365 ], "n": 405, "papers": 114 } }, "2000s": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.3598, "k": 1570, "ci95": [ 0.338321, 0.378596 ], "n": 4363, "papers": 737 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0516, "k": 225, "ci95": [ 0.039753, 0.064992 ], "n": 4363, "papers": 737 } }, "2010s": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.3823, "k": 9109, "ci95": [ 0.369193, 0.395612 ], "n": 23826, "papers": 4297 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0399, "k": 950, "ci95": [ 0.029335, 0.05829 ], "n": 23826, "papers": 4297 } }, "2020s": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.4437, "k": 10219, "ci95": [ 0.430088, 0.455728 ], "n": 23032, "papers": 7180 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0227, "k": 523, "ci95": [ 0.014468, 0.034123 ], "n": 23032, "papers": 7180 } } }, "by_field": { "?": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.2073, "k": 17, "ci95": [ 0.098361, 0.318681 ], "n": 82, "papers": 49 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0, "k": 0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "n": 82, "papers": 49 } }, "basic life and health sciences": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.4129, "k": 6908, "ci95": [ 0.396765, 0.428081 ], "n": 16730, "papers": 3748 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0356, "k": 596, "ci95": [ 0.022381, 0.061008 ], "n": 16730, "papers": 3748 } }, "basic life sciences only": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.4438, "k": 8158, "ci95": [ 0.429033, 0.456146 ], "n": 18384, "papers": 4379 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.021, "k": 386, "ci95": [ 0.015636, 0.028189 ], "n": 18384, "papers": 4379 } }, "health sciences only": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.3723, "k": 4257, "ci95": [ 0.356252, 0.389119 ], "n": 11433, "papers": 2729 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.0489, "k": 559, "ci95": [ 0.033572, 0.069583 ], "n": 11433, "papers": 2729 } }, "other fields": { "substantive": { "rate": 0.3396, "k": 1697, "ci95": [ 0.318366, 0.359125 ], "n": 4997, "papers": 1423 }, "aware": { "rate": 0.037, "k": 185, "ci95": [ 0.025731, 0.050011 ], "n": 4997, "papers": 1423 } } }, "extraction": { "pairs": 58358, "status": { "ok": 56179, "no-in-text-citation": 967, "no-fulltext": 175, "reference-not-found": 1030, "no-body": 7 }, "usable_rate": 0.9627 }, "cost_usd": { "typesafe/jev": 4.46, "@cf/cloudflare/clef": 21.91, "@cf/google/gemma-4-26b-a4b-it": 5.68, "total": 32.05 }, "calls": { "typesafe/jev": 72339, "@cf/cloudflare/clef": 72139, "@cf/google/gemma-4-26b-a4b-it": 72155 }, "human_review_queue": { "pairs_not_unanimous": 8830, "substantive_or_aware_not_unanimous": 5259 }, "substantive_corrected": { "rate": 0.3809, "sens": 0.9649, "fpr": 0.0645, "basis": "confirm_v33 blind set, n=150", "caveat": "Human adjudication is DEFERRED: the misclassification correction key is a single AI labeler (confirm_v33, n=150), not human experts.", "ci95": [ 0.3352, 0.4176 ] }, "substantive_corrected_rescored": { "caveat": "Human adjudication is DEFERRED: the misclassification correction key is a single AI labeler (confirm_v33, n=150), not human experts.", "all_150": { "n": 150, "agree_substantive_or_not": 142, "sens": 0.9649, "fpr": 0.0645, "rate": 0.3809 }, "non_administrative": { "n": 137, "agree_substantive_or_not": 130, "sens": 0.9808, "fpr": 0.0706, "rate": 0.3702 }, "panel_differs_from_census_label": [ "21461636>PMC10676308", "26806855>PMC7801470", "27698958>PMC8593343" ] }, "cost_usd_note": "logged usage at list prices; Jev's AI Gateway billing record for 13-14 Oct 2026 is $1.835 (input tokens only, $0.042/M; fewer tokens billed than Jev reports per call)" }
{
"data_as_of": "2026-10-14",
"data_as_of_note": "Retraction Watch list downloaded 13 Oct 2026; final census analysis run 14 Oct 2026. These figures change only when a new census is published.",
"headline_scope": "retractions other than administrative ones (out of date, replaced, moved journal, publisher duplicate)",
"administrative_pairs": 4044,
"substantive_administrative": {
"rate": 0.3796,
"k": 1535,
"ci95": [
0.339119,
0.428885
],
"n": 4044,
"papers": 534
},
"codebook": "v3.3",
"panel": [
"typesafe/jev",
"@cf/google/gemma-4-26b-a4b-it",
"@cf/cloudflare/clef"
],
"pairs_classified": 55688,
"judged": 51626,
"unclear": 4062,
"unclear_labels": 18,
"unclear_note": "unclear (4062) counts every classified pair that was not judged: the 18 pairs the panel labelled unclear plus the 4,044 administrative pairs (see administrative_pairs). unclear_labels (18) is the true unclear-labelled count.",
"notices_set_aside": 485,
"incomplete_pairs": 6,
"retracted_papers": 12864,
"routes": {
"unanimous": 46858,
"majority": 8807,
"split": 23
},
"panel_sizes": {
"3": 55688
},
"aware": {
"rate": 0.0334,
"k": 1726,
"ci95": [
0.02563,
0.042857
],
"n": 51626,
"papers": 12328
},
"substantive": {
"rate": 0.4075,
"k": 21037,
"ci95": [
0.398918,
0.414787
],
"n": 51626,
"papers": 12328
},
"perfunctory": {
"rate": 0.5591,
"k": 28863,
"ci95": [
0.550627,
0.568112
],
"n": 51626,
"papers": 12328
},
"by_panel_size": {
"2": {
"aware": null,
"substantive": null
},
"3": {
"aware": {
"rate": 0.0334,
"k": 1726,
"ci95": [
0.02563,
0.042857
],
"n": 51626,
"papers": 12328
},
"substantive": {
"rate": 0.4075,
"k": 21037,
"ci95": [
0.398918,
0.414787
],
"n": 51626,
"papers": 12328
}
}
},
"substantive_band": {
"strict": {
"rate": 0.3451,
"k": 17818,
"ci95": [