DR-256-backup / audit /evaluation /comparison.json
Shangy's picture
Add files using upload-large-folder tool
42bebde verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
22.7 kB
{
"comparisons": {
"robots_repair_matched_base": {
"both_correct": 28,
"both_wrong": 168,
"interpretation": "primary matched corpus-repair comparison for the base model",
"left": "v1.0.2_fresh_base",
"left_accuracy": 0.25,
"left_correct": 64,
"mcnemar_exact_two_sided_p": 0.1550019040032606,
"paired_bootstrap": {
"confidence_level": 0.95,
"right_minus_left_interval": [
-0.10546875,
0.01171875
],
"samples": 20000,
"seed": 13387394251376731693
},
"questions": 256,
"right": "v1.1.0_matched_base",
"right_accuracy": 0.203125,
"right_correct": 52,
"right_losses": 36,
"right_minus_left": -0.046875,
"right_wins": 24
},
"robots_repair_matched_rl_iter199": {
"both_correct": 57,
"both_wrong": 143,
"interpretation": "primary matched corpus-repair comparison for the RL checkpoint",
"left": "v1.0.2_fresh_rl_iter199",
"left_accuracy": 0.33203125,
"left_correct": 85,
"mcnemar_exact_two_sided_p": 1.0,
"paired_bootstrap": {
"confidence_level": 0.95,
"right_minus_left_interval": [
-0.05859375,
0.05859375
],
"samples": 20000,
"seed": 1437628413370259256
},
"questions": 256,
"right": "v1.1.0_matched_rl_iter199",
"right_accuracy": 0.33203125,
"right_correct": 85,
"right_losses": 28,
"right_minus_left": 0.0,
"right_wins": 28
},
"v1.0.2_fresh_rl_gain": {
"both_correct": 44,
"both_wrong": 151,
"interpretation": "RL versus base on the fresh old-database controls",
"left": "v1.0.2_fresh_base",
"left_accuracy": 0.25,
"left_correct": 64,
"mcnemar_exact_two_sided_p": 0.009853448195259264,
"paired_bootstrap": {
"confidence_level": 0.95,
"right_minus_left_interval": [
0.0234375,
0.140625
],
"samples": 20000,
"seed": 5048422604327498784
},
"questions": 256,
"right": "v1.0.2_fresh_rl_iter199",
"right_accuracy": 0.33203125,
"right_correct": 85,
"right_losses": 20,
"right_minus_left": 0.08203125,
"right_wins": 41
},
"v1.0.2_repeatability_base": {
"both_correct": 23,
"both_wrong": 163,
"interpretation": "same model, database, protocol and nominal topology; estimates run/serving variance",
"left": "v1.0.2_historical_base",
"left_accuracy": 0.203125,
"left_correct": 52,
"mcnemar_exact_two_sided_p": 0.18821620302302766,
"paired_bootstrap": {
"confidence_level": 0.95,
"right_minus_left_interval": [
-0.015625,
0.109375
],
"samples": 20000,
"seed": 7299534692833023409
},
"questions": 256,
"right": "v1.0.2_fresh_base",
"right_accuracy": 0.25,
"right_correct": 64,
"right_losses": 29,
"right_minus_left": 0.046875,
"right_wins": 41
},
"v1.0.2_repeatability_rl_iter199": {
"both_correct": 57,
"both_wrong": 145,
"interpretation": "same model, database, protocol and nominal topology; estimates run/serving variance",
"left": "v1.0.2_historical_rl_iter199",
"left_accuracy": 0.32421875,
"left_correct": 83,
"mcnemar_exact_two_sided_p": 0.8919231511047494,
"paired_bootstrap": {
"confidence_level": 0.95,
"right_minus_left_interval": [
-0.046875,
0.0625
],
"samples": 20000,
"seed": 9174287329364068087
},
"questions": 256,
"right": "v1.0.2_fresh_rl_iter199",
"right_accuracy": 0.33203125,
"right_correct": 85,
"right_losses": 26,
"right_minus_left": 0.0078125,
"right_wins": 28
},
"v1.1.0_canonical_rl_gain": {
"both_correct": 30,
"both_wrong": 149,
"interpretation": "RL versus base on the repaired corpus; primary model comparison",
"left": "v1.1.0_matched_base",
"left_accuracy": 0.203125,
"left_correct": 52,
"mcnemar_exact_two_sided_p": 0.00021680385841747665,
"paired_bootstrap": {
"confidence_level": 0.95,
"right_minus_left_interval": [
0.0625,
0.1953125
],
"samples": 20000,
"seed": 1297034482649412638
},
"questions": 256,
"right": "v1.1.0_matched_rl_iter199",
"right_accuracy": 0.33203125,
"right_correct": 85,
"right_losses": 22,
"right_minus_left": 0.12890625,
"right_wins": 55
},
"v1.1.0_replica_to_matched_base": {
"both_correct": 25,
"both_wrong": 167,
"interpretation": "same corpus/model/protocol, different shard topology and serving schedule",
"left": "v1.1.0_replica_8x32_base",
"left_accuracy": 0.2421875,
"left_correct": 62,
"mcnemar_exact_two_sided_p": 0.2604354765766535,
"paired_bootstrap": {
"confidence_level": 0.95,
"right_minus_left_interval": [
-0.1015625,
0.0234375
],
"samples": 20000,
"seed": 6146126065223036221
},
"questions": 256,
"right": "v1.1.0_matched_base",
"right_accuracy": 0.203125,
"right_correct": 52,
"right_losses": 37,
"right_minus_left": -0.0390625,
"right_wins": 27
},
"v1.1.0_replica_to_matched_rl_iter199": {
"both_correct": 50,
"both_wrong": 149,
"interpretation": "same corpus/model/protocol, different shard topology and serving schedule",
"left": "v1.1.0_replica_8x32_rl_iter199",
"left_accuracy": 0.28125,
"left_correct": 72,
"mcnemar_exact_two_sided_p": 0.11116111910399348,
"paired_bootstrap": {
"confidence_level": 0.95,
"right_minus_left_interval": [
-0.0078125,
0.109375
],
"samples": 20000,
"seed": 9415042431285687212
},
"questions": 256,
"right": "v1.1.0_matched_rl_iter199",
"right_accuracy": 0.33203125,
"right_correct": 85,
"right_losses": 22,
"right_minus_left": 0.05078125,
"right_wins": 35
}
},
"config_sha256": "24e944844cf7dff8942aa2d061ed733293a381d5191781e2a66b48e778a10782",
"created_at_utc": "2026-08-17T01:54:54.255159+00:00",
"missing_judge_policy": "count_as_wrong; never remove from denominator",
"primary_denominator": 256,
"retrieval_stratification": {
"comparisons": {
"robots_repair_matched_base": {
"left": "v1.0.2_fresh_base",
"right": "v1.1.0_matched_base",
"strata": {
"original_question_top20_exact_order_identical": {
"both_correct": 25,
"both_wrong": 153,
"left_accuracy": 0.21973094170403587,
"left_correct": 49,
"mcnemar_exact_two_sided_p": 0.765991824244793,
"paired_bootstrap": {
"confidence_level": 0.95,
"right_minus_left_interval": [
-0.07174887892376682,
0.04484304932735426
],
"samples": 20000,
"seed": 119633853099251139
},
"questions": 223,
"right_accuracy": 0.2062780269058296,
"right_correct": 46,
"right_losses": 24,
"right_minus_left": -0.013452914798206279,
"right_wins": 21
},
"original_question_top20_order_changed": {
"both_correct": 3,
"both_wrong": 15,
"left_accuracy": 0.45454545454545453,
"left_correct": 15,
"mcnemar_exact_two_sided_p": 0.03515625,
"paired_bootstrap": {
"confidence_level": 0.95,
"right_minus_left_interval": [
-0.48484848484848486,
-0.06060606060606061
],
"samples": 20000,
"seed": 833482764490063334
},
"questions": 33,
"right_accuracy": 0.18181818181818182,
"right_correct": 6,
"right_losses": 12,
"right_minus_left": -0.2727272727272727,
"right_wins": 3
},
"original_question_top20_set_changed": {
"both_correct": 1,
"both_wrong": 4,
"left_accuracy": 0.5,
"left_correct": 6,
"mcnemar_exact_two_sided_p": 0.453125,
"paired_bootstrap": {
"confidence_level": 0.95,
"right_minus_left_interval": [
-0.6666666666666666,
0.16666666666666666
],
"samples": 20000,
"seed": 976983869935270329
},
"questions": 12,
"right_accuracy": 0.25,
"right_correct": 3,
"right_losses": 5,
"right_minus_left": -0.25,
"right_wins": 2
},
"original_question_top20_set_unchanged": {
"both_correct": 27,
"both_wrong": 164,
"left_accuracy": 0.23770491803278687,
"left_correct": 58,
"mcnemar_exact_two_sided_p": 0.27167916606550335,
"paired_bootstrap": {
"confidence_level": 0.95,
"right_minus_left_interval": [
-0.0942622950819672,
0.020491803278688527
],
"samples": 20000,
"seed": 7971986817511018340
},
"questions": 244,
"right_accuracy": 0.20081967213114754,
"right_correct": 49,
"right_losses": 31,
"right_minus_left": -0.036885245901639344,
"right_wins": 22
}
}
},
"robots_repair_matched_rl_iter199": {
"left": "v1.0.2_fresh_rl_iter199",
"right": "v1.1.0_matched_rl_iter199",
"strata": {
"original_question_top20_exact_order_identical": {
"both_correct": 47,
"both_wrong": 128,
"left_accuracy": 0.3273542600896861,
"left_correct": 73,
"mcnemar_exact_two_sided_p": 0.6654658120766186,
"paired_bootstrap": {
"confidence_level": 0.95,
"right_minus_left_interval": [
-0.07623318385650224,
0.04035874439461883
],
"samples": 20000,
"seed": 10695034162105332199
},
"questions": 223,
"right_accuracy": 0.3094170403587444,
"right_correct": 69,
"right_losses": 26,
"right_minus_left": -0.017937219730941704,
"right_wins": 22
},
"original_question_top20_order_changed": {
"both_correct": 10,
"both_wrong": 15,
"left_accuracy": 0.36363636363636365,
"left_correct": 12,
"mcnemar_exact_two_sided_p": 0.2890625,
"paired_bootstrap": {
"confidence_level": 0.95,
"right_minus_left_interval": [
-0.030303030303030304,
0.30303030303030304
],
"samples": 20000,
"seed": 1843367164848248413
},
"questions": 33,
"right_accuracy": 0.48484848484848486,
"right_correct": 16,
"right_losses": 2,
"right_minus_left": 0.12121212121212122,
"right_wins": 6
},
"original_question_top20_set_changed": {
"both_correct": 4,
"both_wrong": 5,
"left_accuracy": 0.3333333333333333,
"left_correct": 4,
"mcnemar_exact_two_sided_p": 0.25,
"paired_bootstrap": {
"confidence_level": 0.95,
"right_minus_left_interval": [
0.0,
0.5
],
"samples": 20000,
"seed": 4567569940096076640
},
"questions": 12,
"right_accuracy": 0.5833333333333334,
"right_correct": 7,
"right_losses": 0,
"right_minus_left": 0.25,
"right_wins": 3
},
"original_question_top20_set_unchanged": {
"both_correct": 53,
"both_wrong": 138,
"left_accuracy": 0.3319672131147541,
"left_correct": 81,
"mcnemar_exact_two_sided_p": 0.7838463022094988,
"paired_bootstrap": {
"confidence_level": 0.95,
"right_minus_left_interval": [
-0.06967213114754098,
0.045081967213114756
],
"samples": 20000,
"seed": 17643634860668046042
},
"questions": 244,
"right_accuracy": 0.319672131147541,
"right_correct": 78,
"right_losses": 28,
"right_minus_left": -0.012295081967213115,
"right_wins": 25
}
}
}
},
"counts": {
"original_question_top20_exact_order_identical": 223,
"original_question_top20_order_changed": 33,
"original_question_top20_set_changed": 12,
"original_question_top20_set_unchanged": 244
},
"scope_warning": "Static top-20 retrieval for the original question only; agent-generated query trajectories may differ, so these strata are diagnostic rather than causal.",
"source": "original_question_top20_comparison.json",
"source_sha256": "9df57ca5ea3fdce2ae873602009841ea8108d1f28cfac80070a189fe52e34ba0"
},
"runs": {
"v1.0.2_fresh_base": {
"classification": "fresh old-database control for the robots repair",
"database_revision": "v1.0.2",
"database_sha256": "7e5cd26ca7be16be1ff41962391478122624e48e5c6b3b91fb18fcccfbe2171e",
"empty_answers": 12,
"judge_accuracy": 0.25,
"judge_correct": 64,
"judge_scored": 256,
"judge_unscored_counted_wrong": 0,
"local_em_accuracy": 0.15234375,
"local_em_correct": 39,
"mean_turns": 3.78515625,
"model_label": "Qwen/Qwen3-8B",
"open_page_calls": 177,
"questions": 256,
"results": "controls/v1.0.2-fresh/qwen3-8b/final_results.jsonl",
"results_sha256": "8313dd05b37135b4c0aa684e0b603ff66879449f9194a97a06a7261fe7f6112f",
"search_calls": 484,
"slurm_array": "2289_[0-3]",
"stop_reasons": {
"finish": 256
},
"summary": "controls/v1.0.2-fresh/qwen3-8b/summary.json",
"summary_sha256": "07fe06891fa074756992e3f20546381d907ec285f2ac4f97efdff1fe6cffdc8b",
"topology": "4 shards x 64 questions"
},
"v1.0.2_fresh_rl_iter199": {
"classification": "fresh old-database control for the robots repair",
"database_revision": "v1.0.2",
"database_sha256": "7e5cd26ca7be16be1ff41962391478122624e48e5c6b3b91fb18fcccfbe2171e",
"empty_answers": 2,
"judge_accuracy": 0.33203125,
"judge_correct": 85,
"judge_scored": 256,
"judge_unscored_counted_wrong": 0,
"local_em_accuracy": 0.2109375,
"local_em_correct": 54,
"mean_turns": 5.55078125,
"model_label": "Shangy/browsecomp-qwen3-8B-length-penalty-iter199",
"open_page_calls": 258,
"questions": 256,
"results": "controls/v1.0.2-fresh/browsecomp-rl-iter199/final_results.jsonl",
"results_sha256": "9f1772e273de28faf0226d5cc2ea9352bb5b363db40dd2d5f84cdc60a0d2d543",
"search_calls": 862,
"slurm_array": "2290_[0-3]",
"stop_reasons": {
"finish": 254,
"http_400": 1,
"max_turns": 1
},
"summary": "controls/v1.0.2-fresh/browsecomp-rl-iter199/summary.json",
"summary_sha256": "d146b1ed5062e9e68cc1c00ad321e17577de58a27ababa4d7f4444b8b75897a3",
"topology": "4 shards x 64 questions"
},
"v1.0.2_historical_base": {
"classification": "published historical reference from v1.0.2",
"database_revision": "v1.0.2",
"database_sha256": "7e5cd26ca7be16be1ff41962391478122624e48e5c6b3b91fb18fcccfbe2171e",
"empty_answers": 15,
"judge_accuracy": 0.203125,
"judge_correct": 52,
"judge_scored": 256,
"judge_unscored_counted_wrong": 0,
"local_em_accuracy": 0.125,
"local_em_correct": 32,
"mean_turns": 3.75390625,
"model_label": "Qwen/Qwen3-8B",
"open_page_calls": 166,
"questions": 256,
"results": "historical/v1.0.2/qwen3-8b/final_results.jsonl",
"results_sha256": "b52b99928f74081394ff79ad6084482d993683f8a1e111895322e7eeba21df8e",
"search_calls": 470,
"slurm_array": "2215_[0-3]",
"stop_reasons": {
"finish": 256
},
"summary": "historical/v1.0.2/qwen3-8b/summary.json",
"summary_sha256": "867b5951683bd002722d3e8ff86ed3b2296c0935b98c5ebc9e004dda3740bfdd",
"topology": "4 shards x 64 questions"
},
"v1.0.2_historical_rl_iter199": {
"classification": "published historical reference from v1.0.2",
"database_revision": "v1.0.2",
"database_sha256": "7e5cd26ca7be16be1ff41962391478122624e48e5c6b3b91fb18fcccfbe2171e",
"empty_answers": 3,
"judge_accuracy": 0.32421875,
"judge_correct": 83,
"judge_scored": 256,
"judge_unscored_counted_wrong": 0,
"local_em_accuracy": 0.1796875,
"local_em_correct": 46,
"mean_turns": 5.64453125,
"model_label": "Shangy/browsecomp-qwen3-8B-length-penalty-iter199",
"open_page_calls": 263,
"questions": 256,
"results": "historical/v1.0.2/browsecomp-rl-iter199/final_results.jsonl",
"results_sha256": "5fce60a8c71532e7335d90e0f852d6a54abe2b5a1e233a22be1377c44c3a9e4c",
"search_calls": 882,
"slurm_array": "2219_[0-3]",
"stop_reasons": {
"finish": 254,
"http_400": 2
},
"summary": "historical/v1.0.2/browsecomp-rl-iter199/summary.json",
"summary_sha256": "92b4c1e01fd28f750c7c7abde396d151118f0e22467f91377b427bc727c68cd5",
"topology": "4 shards x 64 questions"
},
"v1.1.0_matched_base": {
"classification": "canonical v1.1.0 matched baseline",
"database_revision": "v1.1.0",
"database_sha256": "09172388ed6c0ae91cb43dff3a663bcfb219673ed991ff5c9922904eb61ee77e",
"empty_answers": 17,
"judge_accuracy": 0.203125,
"judge_correct": 52,
"judge_scored": 256,
"judge_unscored_counted_wrong": 0,
"local_em_accuracy": 0.12109375,
"local_em_correct": 31,
"mean_turns": 3.76953125,
"model_label": "Qwen/Qwen3-8B",
"open_page_calls": 174,
"questions": 256,
"results": "../../baselines/qwen3-8b/final_results.jsonl",
"results_sha256": "97a7bc26f436f10ba40e8d112d11aa5211d093c405aad02d22e17261b4e67c08",
"search_calls": 472,
"slurm_array": "2395_[0-3]",
"stop_reasons": {
"finish": 255,
"invalid_action": 1
},
"summary": "../../baselines/qwen3-8b/summary.json",
"summary_sha256": "7bbb8cb7bd456f2dea3ad04286e637029b11adbc13b0824a77763c538cefdb93",
"topology": "4 shards x 64 questions"
},
"v1.1.0_matched_rl_iter199": {
"classification": "canonical v1.1.0 matched baseline",
"database_revision": "v1.1.0",
"database_sha256": "09172388ed6c0ae91cb43dff3a663bcfb219673ed991ff5c9922904eb61ee77e",
"empty_answers": 1,
"judge_accuracy": 0.33203125,
"judge_correct": 85,
"judge_scored": 256,
"judge_unscored_counted_wrong": 0,
"local_em_accuracy": 0.23046875,
"local_em_correct": 59,
"mean_turns": 5.4140625,
"model_label": "Shangy/browsecomp-qwen3-8B-length-penalty-iter199",
"open_page_calls": 249,
"questions": 256,
"results": "../../baselines/browsecomp-rl-iter199/final_results.jsonl",
"results_sha256": "064bd9c4c67d9acfb8ff87a55f2bfabfe62435238dc4f97eb6a62f6b36f4966e",
"search_calls": 827,
"slurm_array": "2396_[0-3]",
"stop_reasons": {
"finish": 255,
"http_400": 1
},
"summary": "../../baselines/browsecomp-rl-iter199/summary.json",
"summary_sha256": "4fb3f3bb1cd4f079c7a52824e55c30025a04c4b549d57e5752f6ba1adee0d053",
"topology": "4 shards x 64 questions"
},
"v1.1.0_replica_8x32_base": {
"classification": "complete topology/scheduling replica; non-canonical",
"database_revision": "v1.1.0",
"database_sha256": "09172388ed6c0ae91cb43dff3a663bcfb219673ed991ff5c9922904eb61ee77e",
"empty_answers": 12,
"judge_accuracy": 0.2421875,
"judge_correct": 62,
"judge_scored": 256,
"judge_unscored_counted_wrong": 0,
"local_em_accuracy": 0.140625,
"local_em_correct": 36,
"mean_turns": 3.82421875,
"model_label": "Qwen/Qwen3-8B",
"open_page_calls": 158,
"questions": 256,
"results": "replicas/v1.1.0-8x32/qwen3-8b/final_results.jsonl",
"results_sha256": "2b905ec46e03ccfb909fbb6c8550806dde808b6ae8f8df1d27f7aa5084f0b14a",
"search_calls": 504,
"slurm_array": "2379_[0-7]",
"stop_reasons": {
"finish": 256
},
"summary": "replicas/v1.1.0-8x32/qwen3-8b/summary.json",
"summary_sha256": "43e66633a6ec3cb0a7353e353f3013e0dde599b6f2838f6ba5d8073105033e79",
"topology": "8 shards x 32 questions"
},
"v1.1.0_replica_8x32_rl_iter199": {
"classification": "complete topology/scheduling replica; non-canonical",
"database_revision": "v1.1.0",
"database_sha256": "09172388ed6c0ae91cb43dff3a663bcfb219673ed991ff5c9922904eb61ee77e",
"empty_answers": 2,
"judge_accuracy": 0.28125,
"judge_correct": 72,
"judge_scored": 256,
"judge_unscored_counted_wrong": 0,
"local_em_accuracy": 0.1796875,
"local_em_correct": 46,
"mean_turns": 5.37109375,
"model_label": "Shangy/browsecomp-qwen3-8B-length-penalty-iter199",
"open_page_calls": 255,
"questions": 256,
"results": "replicas/v1.1.0-8x32/browsecomp-rl-iter199/final_results.jsonl",
"results_sha256": "e31061b6f74e3ada2c6906df61d4c61f280481cf0ac2fdde9bec0a204e9869bf",
"search_calls": 818,
"slurm_array": "2380_[0-7]",
"stop_reasons": {
"finish": 254,
"http_400": 2
},
"summary": "replicas/v1.1.0-8x32/browsecomp-rl-iter199/summary.json",
"summary_sha256": "1bf9d12a17194509226cd65f4f5bfed70b530fcdf3e63bd4654c6caefeca92c1",
"topology": "8 shards x 32 questions"
}
},
"schema_version": 1
}