XINLI1997 commited on
Commit
336e674
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 6defd2e

Release alpha-tot-v1.0.4: probe-gated freeze and 22-model channel panel

Browse files
Files changed (38) hide show
  1. .gitattributes +4 -0
  2. README.md +4 -0
  3. README_REPRO.md +24 -4
  4. abc_exp/results/CONDITIONAL_COLLAPSE_TABLE.md +5 -5
  5. abc_exp/results/DEBATE_EVAL_ARTIFACT_DATASHEET.md +1 -1
  6. abc_exp/results/DEBATE_EVAL_CROISSANT_VALIDATION.md +6 -4
  7. abc_exp/results/POST_A6_R1_REPLICATION.md +7 -7
  8. abc_exp/results/cascade_r1_auc.json +51 -45
  9. abc_exp/results/channel_panel/channel_panel_22.json +698 -0
  10. abc_exp/results/channel_panel/channel_panel_22.tex +75 -0
  11. abc_exp/results/conditional_collapse_table.json +38 -27
  12. abc_exp/results/construct_auc_public_n200.json +87 -0
  13. abc_exp/results/debate_eval_croissant_rai_metadata.json +151 -9
  14. abc_exp/results/debate_eval_croissant_validation_receipt.json +11 -3
  15. abc_exp/results/figures/fig2_channel_manipulation.pdf +0 -0
  16. abc_exp/results/figures/fig2_channel_manipulation.png +3 -0
  17. abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/acceptance.json +182 -0
  18. abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_default_vllm_llama-3.1-8b_s0.jsonl +0 -0
  19. abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_default_vllm_llama-3.1-8b_s1.jsonl +0 -0
  20. abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_default_vllm_phi-4-mini_s0.jsonl +3 -0
  21. abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_default_vllm_phi-4-mini_s1.jsonl +3 -0
  22. abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_default_vllm_qwen3-4b_s0.jsonl +3 -0
  23. abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_default_vllm_qwen3-4b_s1.jsonl +3 -0
  24. abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_lomo_drop.json +725 -0
  25. abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_lomo_flip.json +725 -0
  26. abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_lomo_paper.json +725 -0
  27. abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_tex.txt +25 -0
  28. abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/qids_llama-3.1-8b_s0.json +1 -0
  29. abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/qids_llama-3.1-8b_s1.json +1 -0
  30. abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/qids_phi-4-mini_s0.json +1 -0
  31. abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/qids_phi-4-mini_s1.json +1 -0
  32. abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/qids_qwen3-4b_s0.json +1 -0
  33. abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/qids_qwen3-4b_s1.json +1 -0
  34. abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/sa_causal_vllm_llama-3.1-8b_rerun.jsonl +0 -0
  35. abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/sa_causal_vllm_phi-4-mini_rerun.jsonl +0 -0
  36. abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/sa_causal_vllm_qwen3-4b_rerun.jsonl +0 -0
  37. abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/sa_causal_vllm_qwen3-8b_rerun.jsonl +0 -0
  38. abc_exp/results/n9_partial_holm.json +54 -0
.gitattributes CHANGED
@@ -66,3 +66,7 @@ abc_exp/results/sa_causal_openrouter_llama_4_maverick_n200.jsonl filter=lfs diff
66
  abc_exp/results/sa_causal_openrouter_llama_4_scout_n200.jsonl filter=lfs diff=lfs merge=lfs -text
67
  abc_exp/results/sa_causal_openrouter_mistral_small_4_n200.jsonl filter=lfs diff=lfs merge=lfs -text
68
  abc_exp/results/sa_causal_router_deepseek-v4-pro.jsonl filter=lfs diff=lfs merge=lfs -text
 
 
 
 
 
66
  abc_exp/results/sa_causal_openrouter_llama_4_scout_n200.jsonl filter=lfs diff=lfs merge=lfs -text
67
  abc_exp/results/sa_causal_openrouter_mistral_small_4_n200.jsonl filter=lfs diff=lfs merge=lfs -text
68
  abc_exp/results/sa_causal_router_deepseek-v4-pro.jsonl filter=lfs diff=lfs merge=lfs -text
69
+ abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_default_vllm_phi-4-mini_s0.jsonl filter=lfs diff=lfs merge=lfs -text
70
+ abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_default_vllm_phi-4-mini_s1.jsonl filter=lfs diff=lfs merge=lfs -text
71
+ abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_default_vllm_qwen3-4b_s0.jsonl filter=lfs diff=lfs merge=lfs -text
72
+ abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_default_vllm_qwen3-4b_s1.jsonl filter=lfs diff=lfs merge=lfs -text
README.md CHANGED
@@ -51,6 +51,7 @@ hf download XINLI1997/DebateLedger --repo-type dataset --local-dir .
51
  | `cross_benchmark_*.jsonl` (16 files) | GPQA, TruthfulQA and ARC-Challenge stress checks | 1,033 debates |
52
  | `block0_*`, `block1_*`, `block3_*` | Early pilot blocks | 1,705 records |
53
  | `r5_gemini_alpha_panel_*.jsonl` | Three-day closed-API repeatability panel | 190 records |
 
54
 
55
  Also included: the aggregate tables and audits behind the paper
56
  (`abc_exp/results/*.json|md|csv|tex`), the datasheet
@@ -92,10 +93,13 @@ it. The full text of the 57 files that contained it, of the thinking-off rerun,
92
  (convince-wrong) and social-pressure probe templates, are in the
93
  [gated tier](https://huggingface.co/datasets/XINLI1997/DebateLedger-gated).
94
 
 
 
95
  No model weights are included.
96
 
97
  ## Versions
98
 
 
99
  - `alpha-tot-v1.0.3`: adds the N=9 sensitivity results. Traces are unchanged.
100
  - `alpha-tot-v1.0.2`: aggregate results now read every row at the paper's endpoint, Round 3 majority with alphabetic ties.
101
  Traces are unchanged: rows with a logged fourth round still store its majority in `majority_answer`, and
 
51
  | `cross_benchmark_*.jsonl` (16 files) | GPQA, TruthfulQA and ARC-Challenge stress checks | 1,033 debates |
52
  | `block0_*`, `block1_*`, `block3_*` | Early pilot blocks | 1,705 records |
53
  | `r5_gemini_alpha_panel_*.jsonl` | Three-day closed-API repeatability panel | 190 records |
54
+ | `gate_rerun/*.jsonl` (10 files) | Probe scores of Llama-3.1-8B, Phi-4-mini, Qwen3-4B and Qwen3-8B collected again for the probe-gated freeze and the channel panel: default condition on the debate questions, all three conditions on the 200-question pool | 24,335 records |
55
 
56
  Also included: the aggregate tables and audits behind the paper
57
  (`abc_exp/results/*.json|md|csv|tex`), the datasheet
 
93
  (convince-wrong) and social-pressure probe templates, are in the
94
  [gated tier](https://huggingface.co/datasets/XINLI1997/DebateLedger-gated).
95
 
96
+ In the gate-rerun probe files (`abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/`) the model output (`initial_text` and `probe_results[].text`) is `null`; that text is not released in either tier.
97
+
98
  No model weights are included.
99
 
100
  ## Versions
101
 
102
+ - `alpha-tot-v1.0.4`: adds the gate-rerun probe scores (`abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/`) and the results of the probe-gated freeze and the 22-model channel panel. Earlier traces are unchanged.
103
  - `alpha-tot-v1.0.3`: adds the N=9 sensitivity results. Traces are unchanged.
104
  - `alpha-tot-v1.0.2`: aggregate results now read every row at the paper's endpoint, Round 3 majority with alphabetic ties.
105
  Traces are unchanged: rows with a logged fourth round still store its majority in `majority_answer`, and
README_REPRO.md CHANGED
@@ -2,6 +2,26 @@
2
 
3
  This repository contains the code and data for *Measuring Collapse and Correction in Homogeneous-Panel LLM Debate* (NeurIPS 2026, Evaluations and Datasets Track). The analyses below are zero-API: they read existing traces and write derived tables only.
4
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
5
  ## Zero-API Rebuild
6
 
7
  `abc_exp/experiments/n9_gee_sensitivity.py` and `abc_exp/experiments/n9_perm_lomo_check.py` rebuild the GEE and GLM tables, Fisher 90% intervals, permutation null and leave-one-model-out R^2 of the N=9 sensitivity check (`abc_exp/results/N9_GEE_SENSITIVITY.md`, `n9_gee_sensitivity.json`, `n9_perm_r2_check.json`). `abc_exp/scripts/B_pilot_monotonicity.py` is the harness of the B pilot; it needs a GPU with vLLM.
@@ -66,7 +86,7 @@ These scripts recompute the family-level exact permutation test, N14 errors-in-v
66
  - `abc_exp/results/debate_traces_*.jsonl`: round-by-round debate traces used for parser and provenance audits on the realized expansion rows and the response-period checks. In the open tier the `reasoning` fields are `null`.
67
  - `abc_exp/results/sa_causal_*.jsonl`: probe traces used for alpha/parser audits. In the open tier the `initial_response_prefix` field is `null`.
68
  - `abc_exp/results/conditional_collapse_table.json`: sealed-vintage debate diagnostics for older rows.
69
- - `abc_exp/results/per_debate_r1_features.jsonl`: row-level R1 feature matrix for the reported Bayesian MLM. It was rebuilt on 2026-09-28 from the six primary-cohort trace files with `abc_exp/experiments/build_per_debate_features.py` and reproduces the MLM input exactly (3,145 initially correct debates from Llama-3.1-8B, Phi-4-mini, Qwen3-4B and Qwen3-8B, 251 collapses, 1,509 questions). The fitted MLM summary is checked in as `abc_exp/results/bayesian_multilevel_logistic.json`. This matrix is not required for the headline transition tables, parser audits, family-rank analyses, or signed-replay ledgers; `abc_exp/experiments/bayesian_multilevel_logistic.py` reads it directly. To rebuild it, run `build_per_debate_features.py` with `ABC_RESULTS` pointing to a folder that holds only the six primary-cohort files, because the script reads every `debate_traces_*.jsonl` in that folder.
70
 
71
  ## Protocol Pointers
72
 
@@ -108,8 +128,8 @@ The script validates that the card contains identity, question-pool, selection-t
108
 
109
  Results in the paper fall into four tiers (paper Appendix G.6):
110
 
111
- 1. **Zero-API rebuilds** from the released traces and scripts: the family association, transition tables, parser audits, and the response-period summaries.
112
- 2. **Aggregate-only results**: the 6,525-debate probe-gated leave-one-model-out ledger is released as a frozen aggregate, and its row-level decision matrix is not part of the release. The Round 1 replay rows use a separate 1,255-trace cohort.
113
  3. **Provider-dependent reruns**: closed-API rows can drift as providers update models.
114
  4. **Gated fields**: convince-wrong probe text and full transcripts are in the gated dataset. The transcript-free per-debate Round 1 feature matrix (`abc_exp/results/per_debate_r1_features.jsonl`) is open.
115
 
@@ -173,4 +193,4 @@ The release has three parts:
173
  - Open data tier (https://huggingface.co/datasets/XINLI1997/DebateLedger), CC BY 4.0: the aggregate files plus every probe and debate trace with the model-generated text fields set to `null`. Parsed answers, correctness labels, round structure, token counts and costs are kept. The non-social weak, moderate and strong probe templates are open.
174
  - Gated data tier (https://huggingface.co/datasets/XINLI1997/DebateLedger-gated), research-use license with no redistribution and no fine-tuning of models that target real users without independent safety review: the full-text versions of the traces that contain model text, and the very-strong (convince-wrong) probe and social-pressure suffix. These can be reused as a misleading-answer corpus, so access is reviewed on request.
175
 
176
- The first public release is versioned `alpha-tot-v1.0`; the current one is `alpha-tot-v1.0.3`. Closed-API snapshot reruns and corrections are released as new minor versions rather than in-place replacements.
 
2
 
3
  This repository contains the code and data for *Measuring Collapse and Correction in Homogeneous-Panel LLM Debate* (NeurIPS 2026, Evaluations and Datasets Track). The analyses below are zero-API: they read existing traces and write derived tables only.
4
 
5
+ ## Probe-Gated Freeze and Channel Panel (alpha-tot-v1.0.4)
6
+
7
+ The probe-gated freeze, the 22-model channel panel, the collapse-diagnostic AUC table and the probe-reliability check of Section 4, and the N=9 partial/Holm rows rebuild from the open tier without API calls. The probe scores of the four local models (Llama-3.1-8B, Phi-4-mini, Qwen3-4B, Qwen3-8B) were collected again for this analysis with `abc_exp/scripts/run_alpha_probe_vllm.py` (vLLM; initial answers sampled at 0.5/0.7/1.0 with an 8,192-token cap, probe replies greedy with a 2,048-token cap, `--stable-seeds`): `abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_default_vllm_*_s{0,1}.jsonl` hold the default condition on the debate questions outside the 200-question high-FR pool (`--questions abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/qids_<model>_s<k>.json --conditions default`), and `abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/sa_causal_vllm_*_rerun.jsonl` hold all three conditions on the high-FR pool. Model text is null in the open tier. The gate is a post-hoc reconstruction on these new probe scores; the scripts and probe inputs of the original pilot were not retained.
8
+
9
+ ```bash
10
+ python abc_exp/experiments/gate_rerun_acceptance.py abc_exp/results/gate_rerun # completeness, truncation and unparsed-reply rates
11
+ for m in paper flip drop; do
12
+ python abc_exp/experiments/probe_gated_lomo.py --debates abc_exp/results --probes abc_exp/results/gate_rerun \
13
+ --none-mode $m --out abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_lomo_$m.json
14
+ done
15
+ python abc_exp/experiments/gate_tex.py abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_lomo_{paper,flip,drop}.json > abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_tex.txt
16
+ python abc_exp/experiments/channel_panel.py --out abc_exp/results/channel_panel/channel_panel_22.json --tex abc_exp/results/channel_panel/channel_panel_22.tex
17
+ python abc_exp/experiments/fig2_channel_panel.py abc_exp/results/channel_panel/channel_panel_22.json abc_exp/results/figures/fig2_channel_manipulation
18
+ python abc_exp/experiments/construct_auc_public_n200.py abc_exp/results abc_exp/results/construct_auc_public_n200.json
19
+ python abc_exp/experiments/reliability_recheck.py
20
+ python abc_exp/experiments/n9_partial_holm.py
21
+ ```
22
+
23
+ In this release `conditional_collapse_table.py` keeps the recorded counts of the rows whose debate files are not public instead of dropping them, and leaves out the 25 Gemini 2.5 Flash rows that hold only an API error (118 valid rows); `post_a6_r1_replication.py`, `cascade_r1_auc.py` and `build_per_debate_features.py` read fixed input lists. `cascade_r1_bootstrap.py` writes the question-clustered intervals into `cascade_r1_auc.json`. Scripts that still do not run on the open tier: the Bayesian MLM scripts need the arviz/xarray versions they were written for, the `block*` experiment drivers call APIs, `split_alpha.py` needs a local label file, and the very-strong-drop and log-ratio checks (`T2_1_drop_very_strong.py`, `T2_4_log_ratio.py`) need N=9 probe files that are not public; their checked-in outputs are kept.
24
+
25
  ## Zero-API Rebuild
26
 
27
  `abc_exp/experiments/n9_gee_sensitivity.py` and `abc_exp/experiments/n9_perm_lomo_check.py` rebuild the GEE and GLM tables, Fisher 90% intervals, permutation null and leave-one-model-out R^2 of the N=9 sensitivity check (`abc_exp/results/N9_GEE_SENSITIVITY.md`, `n9_gee_sensitivity.json`, `n9_perm_r2_check.json`). `abc_exp/scripts/B_pilot_monotonicity.py` is the harness of the B pilot; it needs a GPU with vLLM.
 
86
  - `abc_exp/results/debate_traces_*.jsonl`: round-by-round debate traces used for parser and provenance audits on the realized expansion rows and the response-period checks. In the open tier the `reasoning` fields are `null`.
87
  - `abc_exp/results/sa_causal_*.jsonl`: probe traces used for alpha/parser audits. In the open tier the `initial_response_prefix` field is `null`.
88
  - `abc_exp/results/conditional_collapse_table.json`: sealed-vintage debate diagnostics for older rows.
89
+ - `abc_exp/results/per_debate_r1_features.jsonl`: row-level Round 1 feature matrix of the six primary-cohort trace files (6,925 debates, 253 collapses), built with `abc_exp/experiments/build_per_debate_features.py`. The reported Bayesian MLM uses its 3,145 initially correct debates from Llama-3.1-8B, Phi-4-mini, Qwen3-4B and Qwen3-8B (251 collapses, 1,509 questions). The fitted MLM summary is checked in as `abc_exp/results/bayesian_multilevel_logistic.json`. This matrix is not required for the headline transition tables, parser audits, family-rank analyses, or signed-replay ledgers; `abc_exp/experiments/bayesian_multilevel_logistic.py` reads it directly. To rebuild it, run `build_per_debate_features.py`; it reads the six primary-cohort files by name.
90
 
91
  ## Protocol Pointers
92
 
 
128
 
129
  Results in the paper fall into four tiers (paper Appendix G.6):
130
 
131
+ 1. **Zero-API rebuilds** from the released traces and scripts: the family association, transition tables, parser audits, the response-period summaries, and the 6,525-debate probe-gated leave-one-model-out ledger, whose gate script and per-question probe scores are released.
132
+ 2. **Aggregate-only results**: the Round 1 replay rows use a separate 1,255-trace cohort.
133
  3. **Provider-dependent reruns**: closed-API rows can drift as providers update models.
134
  4. **Gated fields**: convince-wrong probe text and full transcripts are in the gated dataset. The transcript-free per-debate Round 1 feature matrix (`abc_exp/results/per_debate_r1_features.jsonl`) is open.
135
 
 
193
  - Open data tier (https://huggingface.co/datasets/XINLI1997/DebateLedger), CC BY 4.0: the aggregate files plus every probe and debate trace with the model-generated text fields set to `null`. Parsed answers, correctness labels, round structure, token counts and costs are kept. The non-social weak, moderate and strong probe templates are open.
194
  - Gated data tier (https://huggingface.co/datasets/XINLI1997/DebateLedger-gated), research-use license with no redistribution and no fine-tuning of models that target real users without independent safety review: the full-text versions of the traces that contain model text, and the very-strong (convince-wrong) probe and social-pressure suffix. These can be reused as a misleading-answer corpus, so access is reviewed on request.
195
 
196
+ The first public release is versioned `alpha-tot-v1.0`; the current one is `alpha-tot-v1.0.4`. Closed-API snapshot reruns and corrections are released as new minor versions rather than in-place replacements.
abc_exp/results/CONDITIONAL_COLLAPSE_TABLE.md CHANGED
@@ -7,7 +7,7 @@ N models = 11
7
  | Claude Sonnet 4.5 | Anthropic | 120 | 77.5% | 0.705 | +0.15 | 1.67 [0.46, 5.87] | 2.15 [0.59, 7.51] | 11.11 | 1.50 |
8
  | Claude Haiku 4.5 | Anthropic | 500 | 82.2% | 0.512 | -0.03 | 9.20 [6.97, 12.05] | 11.19 [8.50, 14.61] | 19.10 | 0.37 |
9
  | GPT-4o-mini | OpenAI | 498 | 68.5% | 0.458 | +0.05 | 1.61 [0.82, 3.14] | 2.35 [1.19, 4.56] | 10.19 | 2.00 |
10
- | Gemini 2.5 Flash | Google | 200 | 36.5% | 0.648 | +0.14 | 0.50 [0.09, 2.78] | 1.37 [0.24, 7.36] | 11.81 | 15.00 |
11
  | GPT-5.4-mini | OpenAI | 200 | 71.5% | 0.350 | +0.05 | 0.50 [0.09, 2.78] | 0.70 [0.12, 3.85] | 17.54 | 10.00 |
12
  | Gemini 3-flash | Google | 200 | 85.0% | 0.249 | -0.08 | 0.50 [0.09, 2.78] | 0.59 [0.10, 3.26] | 6.67 | 2.00 |
13
  | Phi-4-mini | Microsoft | 2161 | 50.6% | 0.451 | +0.23 | 5.18 [4.33, 6.20] | 10.24 [8.58, 12.18] | 16.31 | 1.55 |
@@ -18,10 +18,10 @@ N models = 11
18
 
19
  ## Cross-model rank tests
20
  - **N_models**: 11
21
- - **spearman_FR_raw**: stat=0.087, p=0.7984
22
  - **spearman_FR_cond**: stat=0.196, p=0.5637
23
- - **spearman_FR_recover**: stat=-0.091, p=0.7899
24
  - **spearman_SA_cond**: stat=0.251, p=0.4574
25
  - **kendall_FR_cond**: stat=0.147, p=0.5322
26
- - **spearman_init_acc_cond**: stat=-0.218, p=0.5192
27
- - **spearman_init_acc_raw**: stat=0.037, p=0.9147
 
7
  | Claude Sonnet 4.5 | Anthropic | 120 | 77.5% | 0.705 | +0.15 | 1.67 [0.46, 5.87] | 2.15 [0.59, 7.51] | 11.11 | 1.50 |
8
  | Claude Haiku 4.5 | Anthropic | 500 | 82.2% | 0.512 | -0.03 | 9.20 [6.97, 12.05] | 11.19 [8.50, 14.61] | 19.10 | 0.37 |
9
  | GPT-4o-mini | OpenAI | 498 | 68.5% | 0.458 | +0.05 | 1.61 [0.82, 3.14] | 2.35 [1.19, 4.56] | 10.19 | 2.00 |
10
+ | Gemini 2.5 Flash | Google | 118 | 61.9% | 0.648 | +0.14 | 0.85 [0.15, 4.64] | 1.37 [0.24, 7.36] | 33.33 | 15.00 |
11
  | GPT-5.4-mini | OpenAI | 200 | 71.5% | 0.350 | +0.05 | 0.50 [0.09, 2.78] | 0.70 [0.12, 3.85] | 17.54 | 10.00 |
12
  | Gemini 3-flash | Google | 200 | 85.0% | 0.249 | -0.08 | 0.50 [0.09, 2.78] | 0.59 [0.10, 3.26] | 6.67 | 2.00 |
13
  | Phi-4-mini | Microsoft | 2161 | 50.6% | 0.451 | +0.23 | 5.18 [4.33, 6.20] | 10.24 [8.58, 12.18] | 16.31 | 1.55 |
 
18
 
19
  ## Cross-model rank tests
20
  - **N_models**: 11
21
+ - **spearman_FR_raw**: stat=0.151, p=0.6583
22
  - **spearman_FR_cond**: stat=0.196, p=0.5637
23
+ - **spearman_FR_recover**: stat=0.036, p=0.9153
24
  - **spearman_SA_cond**: stat=0.251, p=0.4574
25
  - **kendall_FR_cond**: stat=0.147, p=0.5322
26
+ - **spearman_init_acc_cond**: stat=-0.409, p=0.2115
27
+ - **spearman_init_acc_raw**: stat=-0.232, p=0.4918
abc_exp/results/DEBATE_EVAL_ARTIFACT_DATASHEET.md CHANGED
@@ -44,7 +44,7 @@ Answer extraction uses the parser documented in `README_REPRO.md` and Appendix C
44
 
45
  ## Maintenance And Versioning
46
 
47
- The initial release is versioned as `alpha-tot-v1.0`; the current one is `alpha-tot-v1.0.3`; since `alpha-tot-v1.0.2` every row is read at Round 3 with alphabetic ties. The archived rows are immutable. Future closed-API reruns, provider snapshot changes, parser changes, or benchmark-pool revisions should be released as new minor versions with a changelog rather than overwriting the archived artifact. Each public version is archived with a DOI and cross-links the code repository, the open and gated datasets, this datasheet, and the metadata files.
48
 
49
  ## Known Limitations
50
 
 
44
 
45
  ## Maintenance And Versioning
46
 
47
+ The initial release is versioned as `alpha-tot-v1.0`; the current one is `alpha-tot-v1.0.4`; since `alpha-tot-v1.0.2` every row is read at Round 3 with alphabetic ties. The archived rows are immutable. Future closed-API reruns, provider snapshot changes, parser changes, or benchmark-pool revisions should be released as new minor versions with a changelog rather than overwriting the archived artifact. Each public version is archived with a DOI and cross-links the code repository, the open and gated datasets, this datasheet, and the metadata files.
48
 
49
  ## Known Limitations
50
 
abc_exp/results/DEBATE_EVAL_CROISSANT_VALIDATION.md CHANGED
@@ -5,7 +5,7 @@
5
  - Metadata file: `abc_exp/results/debate_eval_croissant_rai_metadata.json`.
6
  - Top-level Croissant file: `croissant.json`.
7
  - Dataset URL in metadata: `https://huggingface.co/datasets/XINLI1997/DebateLedger`.
8
- - Files hashed: **21**.
9
 
10
  The metadata URL is set to the public Hugging Face dataset. If the URL changes, rerun the validator with `DEBATELEDGER_DATASET_URL` set to the new URL.
11
 
@@ -30,13 +30,13 @@ The metadata URL is set to the public Hugging Face dataset. If the URL changes,
30
 
31
  | File | SHA256 prefix |
32
  |---|---:|
33
- | `README_REPRO.md` | `c6e9a51e08df` |
34
  | `requirements-artifact.txt` | `a092c219f714` |
35
- | `abc_exp/results/DEBATE_EVAL_ARTIFACT_DATASHEET.md` | `a5aa8fc5f835` |
36
  | `abc_exp/results/debate_eval_reuse_card.schema.json` | `4d6c028c58cd` |
37
  | `abc_exp/results/cohort_n14_headline.json` | `9727061b9b7c` |
38
  | `abc_exp/results/family_level_headline_aggregation.json` | `958e2ebbe781` |
39
- | `abc_exp/results/conditional_collapse_table.json` | `2df5c2ae2f80` |
40
  | `abc_exp/results/reviewer_hardening_analyses.json` | `2a7da77d2ce2` |
41
  | `abc_exp/results/N14_REVIEWER_HARDENING_ARTIFACTS.md` | `797a36b82322` |
42
  | `abc_exp/results/n14_reviewer_hardening_artifacts.json` | `167509bdabc0` |
@@ -51,3 +51,5 @@ The metadata URL is set to the public Hugging Face dataset. If the URL changes,
51
  | `abc_exp/results/block0_debates.jsonl` | `c3c05b9b3ca3` |
52
  | `abc_exp/results/block1_abc_vs_baselines.jsonl` | `7cba65bb6ab8` |
53
  | `abc_exp/results/block3_multi_benchmark.jsonl` | `72a7397af3a6` |
 
 
 
5
  - Metadata file: `abc_exp/results/debate_eval_croissant_rai_metadata.json`.
6
  - Top-level Croissant file: `croissant.json`.
7
  - Dataset URL in metadata: `https://huggingface.co/datasets/XINLI1997/DebateLedger`.
8
+ - Files hashed: **23**.
9
 
10
  The metadata URL is set to the public Hugging Face dataset. If the URL changes, rerun the validator with `DEBATELEDGER_DATASET_URL` set to the new URL.
11
 
 
30
 
31
  | File | SHA256 prefix |
32
  |---|---:|
33
+ | `README_REPRO.md` | `5e0b142177ed` |
34
  | `requirements-artifact.txt` | `a092c219f714` |
35
+ | `abc_exp/results/DEBATE_EVAL_ARTIFACT_DATASHEET.md` | `e4ab47578fca` |
36
  | `abc_exp/results/debate_eval_reuse_card.schema.json` | `4d6c028c58cd` |
37
  | `abc_exp/results/cohort_n14_headline.json` | `9727061b9b7c` |
38
  | `abc_exp/results/family_level_headline_aggregation.json` | `958e2ebbe781` |
39
+ | `abc_exp/results/conditional_collapse_table.json` | `d6a11d548753` |
40
  | `abc_exp/results/reviewer_hardening_analyses.json` | `2a7da77d2ce2` |
41
  | `abc_exp/results/N14_REVIEWER_HARDENING_ARTIFACTS.md` | `797a36b82322` |
42
  | `abc_exp/results/n14_reviewer_hardening_artifacts.json` | `167509bdabc0` |
 
51
  | `abc_exp/results/block0_debates.jsonl` | `c3c05b9b3ca3` |
52
  | `abc_exp/results/block1_abc_vs_baselines.jsonl` | `7cba65bb6ab8` |
53
  | `abc_exp/results/block3_multi_benchmark.jsonl` | `72a7397af3a6` |
54
+ | `abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_lomo_paper.json` | `1350c4e952a1` |
55
+ | `abc_exp/results/channel_panel/channel_panel_22.json` | `5320543ee013` |
abc_exp/results/POST_A6_R1_REPLICATION.md CHANGED
@@ -6,16 +6,16 @@ Majority-level metrics from `debate_traces_*.jsonl`. Collapse onset uses natural
6
 
7
  | Cohort | N | Init Maj Correct | Collapses | Cond Collapse | Corrections | Final Acc | Collapse Onset |
8
  |---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---|
9
- | Legacy/partial traces | 82 | 63 | 2 | 3.2% | 5 | 80.5% | R4: 1, unlocalized: 1 |
10
  | Post-A6 200-row traces | 1200 | 662 | 75 | 11.3% | 144 | 60.9% | R1: 40, R2: 10, R3: 11, R4: 14 |
11
 
12
  ## Pooled All Traces
13
 
14
- - N debates: 1282
15
- - Initial majority correct: 725 (56.6%)
16
  - Collapses: 77 (10.6% conditional on initial majority correct)
17
- - Corrections: 149 (26.8% of initial-majority-wrong debates)
18
- - Final accuracy: 797 / 1282 (62.2%)
19
  - Collapse onset: R1: 40, R2: 10, R3: 11, R4: 15, unlocalized: 1
20
 
21
  ## Per Model
@@ -28,7 +28,7 @@ Majority-level metrics from `debate_traces_*.jsonl`. Collapse onset uses natural
28
  | Qwen/Qwen3.6-27B-FP8 | post_a6_200row | 200 | 122 | 10 | 8.2% | 36 | 74.0% | R1: 1, R2: 2, R3: 4, R4: 3 |
29
  | Qwen/Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-FP8 | post_a6_200row | 200 | 93 | 10 | 10.8% | 47 | 65.0% | R2: 3, R3: 2, R4: 5 |
30
  | deepseek-v4-flash | post_a6_200row | 200 | 149 | 0 | 0.0% | 7 | 78.0% | - |
31
- | deepseek-v4-pro | legacy_or_partial | 78 | 59 | 1 | 1.7% | 5 | 80.8% | R4: 1 |
32
  | google/gemma-4-31b-it | post_a6_200row | 200 | 159 | 0 | 0.0% | 5 | 82.0% | - |
33
  | kimi-k2.6 | legacy_or_partial | 3 | 3 | 1 | 33.3% | 0 | 66.7% | - |
34
 
@@ -37,7 +37,7 @@ Majority-level metrics from `debate_traces_*.jsonl`. Collapse onset uses natural
37
  | File | Rows | Cohort |
38
  |---|---:|---|
39
  | `debate_traces_openrouter_deepseek-v4-flash.jsonl` | 200 | post_a6_200row |
40
- | `debate_traces_openrouter_deepseek-v4-pro.jsonl` | 78 | legacy_or_partial |
41
  | `debate_traces_openrouter_kimi-k2.6.jsonl` | 3 | legacy_or_partial |
42
  | `debate_traces_smoke_qwen3-8b.jsonl` | 1 | legacy_or_partial |
43
  | `debate_traces_vllm_gemma-4-31b-it.jsonl` | 200 | post_a6_200row |
 
6
 
7
  | Cohort | N | Init Maj Correct | Collapses | Cond Collapse | Corrections | Final Acc | Collapse Onset |
8
  |---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---|
9
+ | Legacy/partial traces | 85 | 65 | 2 | 3.1% | 5 | 80.0% | R4: 1, unlocalized: 1 |
10
  | Post-A6 200-row traces | 1200 | 662 | 75 | 11.3% | 144 | 60.9% | R1: 40, R2: 10, R3: 11, R4: 14 |
11
 
12
  ## Pooled All Traces
13
 
14
+ - N debates: 1285
15
+ - Initial majority correct: 727 (56.6%)
16
  - Collapses: 77 (10.6% conditional on initial majority correct)
17
+ - Corrections: 149 (26.7% of initial-majority-wrong debates)
18
+ - Final accuracy: 799 / 1285 (62.2%)
19
  - Collapse onset: R1: 40, R2: 10, R3: 11, R4: 15, unlocalized: 1
20
 
21
  ## Per Model
 
28
  | Qwen/Qwen3.6-27B-FP8 | post_a6_200row | 200 | 122 | 10 | 8.2% | 36 | 74.0% | R1: 1, R2: 2, R3: 4, R4: 3 |
29
  | Qwen/Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-FP8 | post_a6_200row | 200 | 93 | 10 | 10.8% | 47 | 65.0% | R2: 3, R3: 2, R4: 5 |
30
  | deepseek-v4-flash | post_a6_200row | 200 | 149 | 0 | 0.0% | 7 | 78.0% | - |
31
+ | deepseek-v4-pro | legacy_or_partial | 81 | 61 | 1 | 1.6% | 5 | 80.2% | R4: 1 |
32
  | google/gemma-4-31b-it | post_a6_200row | 200 | 159 | 0 | 0.0% | 5 | 82.0% | - |
33
  | kimi-k2.6 | legacy_or_partial | 3 | 3 | 1 | 33.3% | 0 | 66.7% | - |
34
 
 
37
  | File | Rows | Cohort |
38
  |---|---:|---|
39
  | `debate_traces_openrouter_deepseek-v4-flash.jsonl` | 200 | post_a6_200row |
40
+ | `debate_traces_openrouter_deepseek-v4-pro.jsonl` | 81 | legacy_or_partial |
41
  | `debate_traces_openrouter_kimi-k2.6.jsonl` | 3 | legacy_or_partial |
42
  | `debate_traces_smoke_qwen3-8b.jsonl` | 1 | legacy_or_partial |
43
  | `debate_traces_vllm_gemma-4-31b-it.jsonl` | 200 | post_a6_200row |
abc_exp/results/cascade_r1_auc.json CHANGED
@@ -325,78 +325,84 @@
325
  }
326
  },
327
  "bootstrap_delta_auc_clustered": {
328
- "status": "infeasible_missing_reported_cohort_row_level_data",
329
  "seed": 20260424,
330
  "B": 1000,
331
  "oof_seed": 42,
332
- "observed_delta_source": "cascade_r1_auc.json:bootstrap_delta_auc",
333
- "input_audit": [
334
- "Missing reported-cohort raw trace files: results/debate_traces_gemini_3-flash.jsonl, results/debate_traces_openai_gpt-5.4-mini.jsonl, results/debate_traces_vllm_llama-3.1-8b.jsonl, results/debate_traces_vllm_phi-4-mini.jsonl, results/debate_traces_vllm_qwen3-4b.jsonl, results/debate_traces_vllm_qwen3-8b.jsonl",
335
- "results/per_debate_r1_features.jsonl exists but is empty"
336
- ],
 
 
 
 
337
  "question_clustered": {
338
- "status": "infeasible_missing_reported_cohort_row_level_data",
 
 
339
  "B": 1000,
340
- "B_used": 0,
 
341
  "delta_r1_minus_baseline": {
342
  "obs": 0.09937494668296987,
343
- "median": null,
344
- "ci_2.5": null,
345
- "ci_97.5": null
346
  },
347
  "delta_full_minus_r1": {
348
  "obs": 0.07740003649254501,
349
- "median": null,
350
- "ci_2.5": null,
351
- "ci_97.5": null
352
- },
353
- "caveat": "The checked-out cascade_r1_auc.json has aggregate AUCs and the old debate-index bootstrap, but the exact reported-cohort row-level traces/cache with question_id and model identifiers are absent or empty. Clustered CIs cannot be recovered from aggregate AUC summaries without changing the estimand.",
354
- "cluster_key": "question_id",
355
- "n_clusters": null
356
  },
357
  "model_clustered": {
358
- "status": "infeasible_missing_reported_cohort_row_level_data",
 
 
359
  "B": 1000,
360
- "B_used": 0,
 
361
  "delta_r1_minus_baseline": {
362
  "obs": 0.09937494668296987,
363
- "median": null,
364
- "ci_2.5": null,
365
- "ci_97.5": null
366
  },
367
  "delta_full_minus_r1": {
368
  "obs": 0.07740003649254501,
369
- "median": null,
370
- "ci_2.5": null,
371
- "ci_97.5": null
372
- },
373
- "caveat": "The checked-out cascade_r1_auc.json has aggregate AUCs and the old debate-index bootstrap, but the exact reported-cohort row-level traces/cache with question_id and model identifiers are absent or empty. Clustered CIs cannot be recovered from aggregate AUC summaries without changing the estimand.",
374
- "cluster_key": "model",
375
- "n_clusters": null
376
  },
377
  "two_way_like_clustered": {
378
- "status": "infeasible_missing_reported_cohort_row_level_data",
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
379
  "B": 1000,
380
- "B_used": 0,
 
381
  "delta_r1_minus_baseline": {
382
  "obs": 0.09937494668296987,
383
- "median": null,
384
- "ci_2.5": null,
385
- "ci_97.5": null
386
  },
387
  "delta_full_minus_r1": {
388
  "obs": 0.07740003649254501,
389
- "median": null,
390
- "ci_2.5": null,
391
- "ci_97.5": null
392
  },
393
- "caveat": "The checked-out cascade_r1_auc.json has aggregate AUCs and the old debate-index bootstrap, but the exact reported-cohort row-level traces/cache with question_id and model identifiers are absent or empty. Clustered CIs cannot be recovered from aggregate AUC summaries without changing the estimand.",
394
- "cluster_keys": [
395
- "question_id",
396
- "model"
397
- ],
398
- "n_question_clusters": null,
399
- "n_model_clusters": null
400
  }
401
  }
402
  }
 
325
  }
326
  },
327
  "bootstrap_delta_auc_clustered": {
328
+ "status": "computed",
329
  "seed": 20260424,
330
  "B": 1000,
331
  "oof_seed": 42,
332
+ "source": "reported_raw_trace_files",
333
+ "source_notes": [],
334
+ "n_debates": 6925,
335
+ "n_collapsed": 253,
336
+ "pooled_oof_auc": {
337
+ "baseline": 0.6690917029222472,
338
+ "r1_trajectory": 0.768466649605217,
339
+ "full_trajectory": 0.845866686097762
340
+ },
341
  "question_clustered": {
342
+ "status": "computed",
343
+ "cluster_key": "question_id",
344
+ "n_clusters": 2161,
345
  "B": 1000,
346
+ "B_used": 1000,
347
+ "B_skipped_degenerate": 0,
348
  "delta_r1_minus_baseline": {
349
  "obs": 0.09937494668296987,
350
+ "median": 0.09936596945247778,
351
+ "ci_2.5": 0.08087539133302094,
352
+ "ci_97.5": 0.11856359787105843
353
  },
354
  "delta_full_minus_r1": {
355
  "obs": 0.07740003649254501,
356
+ "median": 0.07732057764107919,
357
+ "ci_2.5": 0.06376175232599098,
358
+ "ci_97.5": 0.09218039115988531
359
+ }
 
 
 
360
  },
361
  "model_clustered": {
362
+ "status": "computed",
363
+ "cluster_key": "model",
364
+ "n_clusters": 6,
365
  "B": 1000,
366
+ "B_used": 1000,
367
+ "B_skipped_degenerate": 0,
368
  "delta_r1_minus_baseline": {
369
  "obs": 0.09937494668296987,
370
+ "median": 0.09790560951867966,
371
+ "ci_2.5": 0.07388329834214147,
372
+ "ci_97.5": 0.12058461896873063
373
  },
374
  "delta_full_minus_r1": {
375
  "obs": 0.07740003649254501,
376
+ "median": 0.08070226153778348,
377
+ "ci_2.5": 0.06859480199811763,
378
+ "ci_97.5": 0.09896733590391349
379
+ }
 
 
 
380
  },
381
  "two_way_like_clustered": {
382
+ "status": "computed",
383
+ "method": "crossed_cluster_resample_with_question_model_multiplicity_product",
384
+ "cluster_keys": [
385
+ "question_id",
386
+ "model"
387
+ ],
388
+ "n_question_clusters": 2161,
389
+ "n_model_clusters": 6,
390
  "B": 1000,
391
+ "B_used": 998,
392
+ "B_skipped_degenerate": 2,
393
  "delta_r1_minus_baseline": {
394
  "obs": 0.09937494668296987,
395
+ "median": 0.09743493774327006,
396
+ "ci_2.5": 0.05463957569635729,
397
+ "ci_97.5": 0.13500663672350027
398
  },
399
  "delta_full_minus_r1": {
400
  "obs": 0.07740003649254501,
401
+ "median": 0.08038112605969788,
402
+ "ci_2.5": 0.05703069600172932,
403
+ "ci_97.5": 0.11124668033979467
404
  },
405
+ "caveat": "Two-way-like percentile bootstrap resamples question and model clusters independently using fixed out-of-fold predictions; it is a design-aware sensitivity, not a full refit exact two-way clustered bootstrap."
 
 
 
 
 
 
406
  }
407
  }
408
  }
abc_exp/results/channel_panel/channel_panel_22.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,698 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "summary": {
3
+ "models": 22,
4
+ "AA_gt_AS": 22,
5
+ "holm_sig": 20,
6
+ "strict_order": 18,
7
+ "mean_d": 0.7581603463423218,
8
+ "family_mean_d": {
9
+ "Google": 0.6336727557237534,
10
+ "DeepSeek": 0.33550202258285333,
11
+ "Zhipu": 1.5264401201263489,
12
+ "xAI": 0.49747040928574393,
13
+ "Tencent": 1.037212115456171,
14
+ "Mistral": 2.549272831429903,
15
+ "Meta": 0.9168727314675933,
16
+ "Microsoft": 0.6596764763471628,
17
+ "Qwen": 0.5051813818506653
18
+ },
19
+ "group_mean_d": {
20
+ "API models": 0.8791145741171492,
21
+ "Local open-weight models (vLLM)": 0.6130152730125289
22
+ },
23
+ "group_counts": {
24
+ "API models": 12,
25
+ "Local open-weight models (vLLM)": 10
26
+ },
27
+ "shared_questions": 188,
28
+ "sa_positive_per_model_pool": 21,
29
+ "sa_positive_shared": 21,
30
+ "sa_ci_excludes_zero_pos": 13,
31
+ "spearman_rho": 0.9909655561829477,
32
+ "spearman_p": 6.29840888794503e-19,
33
+ "sign_flips": [],
34
+ "rerun_dir": "abc_exp/results/gate_rerun"
35
+ },
36
+ "per_model": {
37
+ "Gemini 3-flash": {
38
+ "family": "Google",
39
+ "group": "API models",
40
+ "file": "rel:sa_causal_gemini_3_flash_n200.jsonl",
41
+ "N": 1800,
42
+ "pairs": 600,
43
+ "FR_D": 0.14020833333333332,
44
+ "FR_AS": 0.03208333333333333,
45
+ "FR_AA": 0.384375,
46
+ "order": "check",
47
+ "d": 1.360310278049752,
48
+ "p": 1.656367866361095e-138,
49
+ "sa_default": 0.15791640208381125,
50
+ "sa_ci": [
51
+ 0.12916644745873265,
52
+ 0.1870830196047337
53
+ ],
54
+ "sa_questions": 200,
55
+ "p_holm": 3.1470989460860803e-137,
56
+ "holm_sig": true,
57
+ "shared": {
58
+ "records": 564,
59
+ "questions": 188,
60
+ "alpha": 0.12078900709219857,
61
+ "S_sens": 0.10150709219858157,
62
+ "A_sens": 0.08732269503546099,
63
+ "SA": 0.1533685372345071,
64
+ "InitAcc": 0.8581560283687943
65
+ }
66
+ },
67
+ "Gemini 3.1-flash-lite": {
68
+ "family": "Google",
69
+ "group": "API models",
70
+ "file": "rel:sa_causal_gemini_3_1_flash_lite_n200.jsonl",
71
+ "N": 1800,
72
+ "pairs": 600,
73
+ "FR_D": 0.30645833333333333,
74
+ "FR_AS": 0.27458333333333335,
75
+ "FR_AA": 0.32416666666666666,
76
+ "order": "check",
77
+ "d": 0.19302509010521768,
78
+ "p": 2.8279431675340454e-06,
79
+ "sa_default": 0.028749936250133747,
80
+ "sa_ci": [
81
+ -0.02124995914591339,
82
+ 0.07624984306281832
83
+ ],
84
+ "sa_questions": 200,
85
+ "p_holm": 1.1311772670136182e-05,
86
+ "holm_sig": true,
87
+ "shared": {
88
+ "records": 564,
89
+ "questions": 188,
90
+ "alpha": 0.2910017730496454,
91
+ "S_sens": 0.01374113475177305,
92
+ "A_sens": 0.11835106382978723,
93
+ "SA": 0.03280134751787765,
94
+ "InitAcc": 0.8492907801418439
95
+ }
96
+ },
97
+ "Gemini 3.1-pro": {
98
+ "family": "Google",
99
+ "group": "API models",
100
+ "file": "rel:sa_causal_gemini_3_1_pro_n200.jsonl",
101
+ "N": 1791,
102
+ "pairs": 597,
103
+ "FR_D": 0.15117252931323283,
104
+ "FR_AS": 0.13295644891122277,
105
+ "FR_AA": 0.31972361809045224,
106
+ "order": "check",
107
+ "d": 0.6342806868514714,
108
+ "p": 9.146279706587667e-46,
109
+ "sa_default": -0.01340030318264824,
110
+ "sa_ci": [
111
+ -0.033919523890439215,
112
+ 0.007118926737845415
113
+ ],
114
+ "sa_questions": 199,
115
+ "p_holm": 1.09755356479052e-44,
116
+ "holm_sig": true,
117
+ "shared": {
118
+ "records": 564,
119
+ "questions": 188,
120
+ "alpha": 0.13054078014184395,
121
+ "S_sens": -0.00044326241134751853,
122
+ "A_sens": 0.0022163120567375884,
123
+ "SA": -0.007978700354663118,
124
+ "InitAcc": 0.8652482269503545
125
+ }
126
+ },
127
+ "DeepSeek V4 Flash": {
128
+ "family": "DeepSeek",
129
+ "group": "API models",
130
+ "file": "rel:sa_causal_router_deepseek-v4-flash.jsonl",
131
+ "N": 1793,
132
+ "pairs": 598,
133
+ "FR_D": 0.11723993288590603,
134
+ "FR_AS": 0.03574414715719063,
135
+ "FR_AA": 0.18468280467445744,
136
+ "order": "check",
137
+ "d": 0.6562866443684916,
138
+ "p": 1.8829024514262912e-48,
139
+ "sa_default": 0.061666561250192924,
140
+ "sa_ci": [
141
+ 0.037499943333428334,
142
+ 0.08666651708360874
143
+ ],
144
+ "sa_questions": 200,
145
+ "p_holm": 2.447773186854179e-47,
146
+ "holm_sig": true,
147
+ "shared": {
148
+ "records": 563,
149
+ "questions": 188,
150
+ "alpha": 0.10992907801418439,
151
+ "S_sens": 0.035460992907801414,
152
+ "A_sens": 0.09397163120567377,
153
+ "SA": 0.05629422828032314,
154
+ "InitAcc": 0.8492907801418439
155
+ }
156
+ },
157
+ "DeepSeek V4 Pro": {
158
+ "family": "DeepSeek",
159
+ "group": "API models",
160
+ "file": "rel:sa_causal_router_deepseek-v4-pro.jsonl",
161
+ "N": 1614,
162
+ "pairs": 523,
163
+ "FR_D": 0.03997227356746765,
164
+ "FR_AS": 0.04460966542750929,
165
+ "FR_AA": 0.046261682242990654,
166
+ "order": "sim",
167
+ "d": 0.014717400797215022,
168
+ "p": 0.7365725067900777,
169
+ "sa_default": 0.01693401559720633,
170
+ "sa_ci": [
171
+ -0.0031194206773823502,
172
+ 0.03698745374344714
173
+ ],
174
+ "sa_questions": 187,
175
+ "p_holm": 0.7365725067900777,
176
+ "holm_sig": false,
177
+ "shared": {
178
+ "records": 541,
179
+ "questions": 187,
180
+ "alpha": 0.038658645276292335,
181
+ "S_sens": 0.010026737967914439,
182
+ "A_sens": -0.0015597147950089107,
183
+ "SA": 0.01693401559720633,
184
+ "InitAcc": 0.8716577540106952
185
+ }
186
+ },
187
+ "GLM-4.6 (no reasoning)": {
188
+ "family": "Zhipu",
189
+ "group": "API models",
190
+ "file": "rel:sa_causal_openrouter_glm_4_6_noreason_n200.jsonl",
191
+ "N": 1800,
192
+ "pairs": 600,
193
+ "FR_D": 0.54125,
194
+ "FR_AS": 0.2864583333333333,
195
+ "FR_AA": 0.716875,
196
+ "order": "check",
197
+ "d": 1.5264401201263489,
198
+ "p": 9.236647647368552e-159,
199
+ "sa_default": 0.02208330708336792,
200
+ "sa_ci": [
201
+ -0.009999962583425578,
202
+ 0.0529165963334385
203
+ ],
204
+ "sa_questions": 200,
205
+ "p_holm": 1.8473295294737104e-157,
206
+ "holm_sig": true,
207
+ "shared": {
208
+ "records": 564,
209
+ "questions": 188,
210
+ "alpha": 0.5283687943262411,
211
+ "S_sens": 0.018617021276595747,
212
+ "A_sens": 0.45035460992907794,
213
+ "SA": 0.022606352393663567,
214
+ "InitAcc": 0.6843971631205673
215
+ }
216
+ },
217
+ "Grok 4.1 Fast": {
218
+ "family": "xAI",
219
+ "group": "API models",
220
+ "file": "rel:sa_causal_openrouter_grok_4_1_fast_n200.jsonl",
221
+ "N": 1799,
222
+ "pairs": 599,
223
+ "FR_D": 0.18291666666666667,
224
+ "FR_AS": 0.06833333333333333,
225
+ "FR_AA": 0.18447412353923207,
226
+ "order": "check",
227
+ "d": 0.49747040928574393,
228
+ "p": 1.2726557462531835e-30,
229
+ "sa_default": 0.003333333333326666,
230
+ "sa_ci": [
231
+ -0.0266666141876041,
232
+ 0.03291660958343875
233
+ ],
234
+ "sa_questions": 200,
235
+ "p_holm": 1.0181245970025468e-29,
236
+ "holm_sig": true,
237
+ "shared": {
238
+ "records": 564,
239
+ "questions": 188,
240
+ "alpha": 0.16843971631205673,
241
+ "S_sens": 0.0044326241134751785,
242
+ "A_sens": 0.11702127659574468,
243
+ "SA": 0.0008865310283484103,
244
+ "InitAcc": 0.7163120567375888
245
+ }
246
+ },
247
+ "HY3 Preview": {
248
+ "family": "Tencent",
249
+ "group": "API models",
250
+ "file": "rel:sa_causal_openrouter_hy3_preview_free_n200.jsonl",
251
+ "N": 1785,
252
+ "pairs": 590,
253
+ "FR_D": 0.3123949579831933,
254
+ "FR_AS": 0.08340336134453781,
255
+ "FR_AA": 0.4016806722689076,
256
+ "order": "check",
257
+ "d": 1.037212115456171,
258
+ "p": 1.3626786726276777e-95,
259
+ "sa_default": 0.024374973125031882,
260
+ "sa_ci": [
261
+ -0.009166628354263266,
262
+ 0.05770824481265015
263
+ ],
264
+ "sa_questions": 200,
265
+ "p_holm": 2.316553743467052e-94,
266
+ "holm_sig": true,
267
+ "shared": {
268
+ "records": 559,
269
+ "questions": 188,
270
+ "alpha": 0.28734485815602834,
271
+ "S_sens": 0.021941489361702128,
272
+ "A_sens": 0.18107269503546097,
273
+ "SA": 0.02194146742023471,
274
+ "InitAcc": 0.801418439716312
275
+ }
276
+ },
277
+ "Mistral Small 4": {
278
+ "family": "Mistral",
279
+ "group": "API models",
280
+ "file": "rel:sa_causal_openrouter_mistral_small_4_n200.jsonl",
281
+ "N": 1800,
282
+ "pairs": 600,
283
+ "FR_D": 0.420625,
284
+ "FR_AS": 0.06604166666666667,
285
+ "FR_AA": 0.6447916666666667,
286
+ "order": "check",
287
+ "d": 2.549272831429903,
288
+ "p": 1.9770419770592286e-264,
289
+ "sa_default": 0.03791659708346625,
290
+ "sa_ci": [
291
+ 9.145805896781952e-09,
292
+ 0.0754269547398181
293
+ ],
294
+ "sa_questions": 200,
295
+ "p_holm": 4.349492349530303e-263,
296
+ "holm_sig": true,
297
+ "shared": {
298
+ "records": 564,
299
+ "questions": 188,
300
+ "alpha": 0.42220744680851063,
301
+ "S_sens": 0.023492907801418435,
302
+ "A_sens": 0.21675531914893617,
303
+ "SA": 0.0407800664895062,
304
+ "InitAcc": 0.6648936170212765
305
+ }
306
+ },
307
+ "Llama 3.3 70B": {
308
+ "family": "Meta",
309
+ "group": "API models",
310
+ "file": "rel:sa_causal_openrouter_llama_3_3_70b_instruct_n200.jsonl",
311
+ "N": 1797,
312
+ "pairs": 598,
313
+ "FR_D": 0.47036727879799667,
314
+ "FR_AS": 0.19145833333333334,
315
+ "FR_AA": 0.5796404682274248,
316
+ "order": "check",
317
+ "d": 1.3064661232671453,
318
+ "p": 2.430831809605083e-131,
319
+ "sa_default": 0.07458322000019083,
320
+ "sa_ci": [
321
+ 0.04374994537507637,
322
+ 0.10541649379197446
323
+ ],
324
+ "sa_questions": 200,
325
+ "p_holm": 4.375497257289149e-130,
326
+ "holm_sig": true,
327
+ "shared": {
328
+ "records": 564,
329
+ "questions": 188,
330
+ "alpha": 0.4532358156028369,
331
+ "S_sens": 0.05363475177304964,
332
+ "A_sens": 0.2646276595744681,
333
+ "SA": 0.07180840248245034,
334
+ "InitAcc": 0.6187943262411348
335
+ }
336
+ },
337
+ "Llama 4 Scout": {
338
+ "family": "Meta",
339
+ "group": "API models",
340
+ "file": "rel:sa_causal_openrouter_llama_4_scout_n200.jsonl",
341
+ "N": 1800,
342
+ "pairs": 600,
343
+ "FR_D": 0.43416666666666665,
344
+ "FR_AS": 0.425625,
345
+ "FR_AA": 0.5741666666666667,
346
+ "order": "check",
347
+ "d": 0.5400995102531039,
348
+ "p": 3.095527782959672e-35,
349
+ "sa_default": 0.03708326375013458,
350
+ "sa_ci": [
351
+ 0.0029166569166900872,
352
+ 0.07249985277113002
353
+ ],
354
+ "sa_questions": 200,
355
+ "p_holm": 2.7859750046637047e-34,
356
+ "holm_sig": true,
357
+ "shared": {
358
+ "records": 564,
359
+ "questions": 188,
360
+ "alpha": 0.4273049645390071,
361
+ "S_sens": 0.024822695035460994,
362
+ "A_sens": 0.16489361702127658,
363
+ "SA": 0.042996374556889635,
364
+ "InitAcc": 0.7074468085106383
365
+ }
366
+ },
367
+ "Llama 4 Maverick": {
368
+ "family": "Meta",
369
+ "group": "API models",
370
+ "file": "rel:sa_causal_openrouter_llama_4_maverick_n200.jsonl",
371
+ "N": 1794,
372
+ "pairs": 598,
373
+ "FR_D": 0.5727768456375839,
374
+ "FR_AS": 0.6220784641068448,
375
+ "FR_AA": 0.6798831385642737,
376
+ "order": "sim",
377
+ "d": 0.23379367941522572,
378
+ "p": 1.7120815256254766e-08,
379
+ "sa_default": 0.07499988583352585,
380
+ "sa_ci": [
381
+ 0.03312496428129091,
382
+ 0.11708836267217773
383
+ ],
384
+ "sa_questions": 200,
385
+ "p_holm": 8.560407628127382e-08,
386
+ "holm_sig": true,
387
+ "shared": {
388
+ "records": 560,
389
+ "questions": 188,
390
+ "alpha": 0.5675975177304964,
391
+ "S_sens": 0.05851063829787234,
392
+ "A_sens": 0.17154255319148937,
393
+ "SA": 0.08156015602858864,
394
+ "InitAcc": 0.772163120567376
395
+ }
396
+ },
397
+ "Gemma 4 31B": {
398
+ "family": "Google",
399
+ "group": "Local open-weight models (vLLM)",
400
+ "file": "rel:sa_causal_vllm_gemma-4-31b-it-awq.jsonl",
401
+ "N": 1800,
402
+ "pairs": 600,
403
+ "FR_D": 0.296875,
404
+ "FR_AS": 0.265,
405
+ "FR_AA": 0.37,
406
+ "order": "check",
407
+ "d": 0.3470749678885722,
408
+ "p": 1.4911765708273656e-16,
409
+ "sa_default": 0.016249970416722916,
410
+ "sa_ci": [
411
+ -0.021666632520892435,
412
+ 0.0541665716876766
413
+ ],
414
+ "sa_questions": 200,
415
+ "p_holm": 8.947059424964194e-16,
416
+ "holm_sig": true,
417
+ "shared": {
418
+ "records": 564,
419
+ "questions": 188,
420
+ "alpha": 0.28812056737588654,
421
+ "S_sens": 0.0035460992907801418,
422
+ "A_sens": 0.07624113475177305,
423
+ "SA": 0.008421967641881653,
424
+ "InitAcc": 0.824468085106383
425
+ }
426
+ },
427
+ "Llama-3.1-8B": {
428
+ "family": "Meta",
429
+ "group": "Local open-weight models (vLLM)",
430
+ "file": "rerun:sa_causal_vllm_llama-3.1-8b_rerun.jsonl",
431
+ "N": 1800,
432
+ "pairs": 600,
433
+ "FR_D": 0.68875,
434
+ "FR_AS": 0.4014583333333333,
435
+ "FR_AA": 0.8122916666666666,
436
+ "order": "check",
437
+ "d": 1.5871316129348985,
438
+ "p": 5.995486703811289e-166,
439
+ "sa_default": 0.05124989458354708,
440
+ "sa_ci": [
441
+ 0.005416661895836811,
442
+ 0.09833315250034584
443
+ ],
444
+ "sa_questions": 200,
445
+ "p_holm": 1.2590522078003708e-164,
446
+ "holm_sig": true,
447
+ "shared": {
448
+ "records": 564,
449
+ "questions": 188,
450
+ "alpha": 0.6808510638297872,
451
+ "S_sens": 0.018617021276595747,
452
+ "A_sens": 0.29609929078014185,
453
+ "SA": 0.046099189716523055,
454
+ "InitAcc": 0.3404255319148936
455
+ }
456
+ },
457
+ "Phi-4-mini": {
458
+ "family": "Microsoft",
459
+ "group": "Local open-weight models (vLLM)",
460
+ "file": "rerun:sa_causal_vllm_phi-4-mini_rerun.jsonl",
461
+ "N": 1800,
462
+ "pairs": 600,
463
+ "FR_D": 0.45458333333333334,
464
+ "FR_AS": 0.29583333333333334,
465
+ "FR_AA": 0.49666666666666665,
466
+ "order": "check",
467
+ "d": 0.6596764763471628,
468
+ "p": 5.14773141087264e-49,
469
+ "sa_default": 0.05958326125009708,
470
+ "sa_ci": [
471
+ 0.015416668708296374,
472
+ 0.10458318885439095
473
+ ],
474
+ "sa_questions": 200,
475
+ "p_holm": 7.206823975221696e-48,
476
+ "holm_sig": true,
477
+ "shared": {
478
+ "records": 564,
479
+ "questions": 188,
480
+ "alpha": 0.45257092198581567,
481
+ "S_sens": 0.05585106382978723,
482
+ "A_sens": 0.24468085106382978,
483
+ "SA": 0.06294318528379345,
484
+ "InitAcc": 0.3882978723404255
485
+ }
486
+ },
487
+ "Qwen3-4B": {
488
+ "family": "Qwen",
489
+ "group": "Local open-weight models (vLLM)",
490
+ "file": "rerun:sa_causal_vllm_qwen3-4b_rerun.jsonl",
491
+ "N": 1800,
492
+ "pairs": 600,
493
+ "FR_D": 0.65125,
494
+ "FR_AS": 0.62625,
495
+ "FR_AA": 0.794375,
496
+ "order": "check",
497
+ "d": 0.7975424200505937,
498
+ "p": 3.967118458034035e-66,
499
+ "sa_default": 0.2441662858339875,
500
+ "sa_ci": [
501
+ 0.2037496945630088,
502
+ 0.28416620416748584
503
+ ],
504
+ "sa_questions": 200,
505
+ "p_holm": 5.950677687051052e-65,
506
+ "holm_sig": true,
507
+ "shared": {
508
+ "records": 564,
509
+ "questions": 188,
510
+ "alpha": 0.6376329787234043,
511
+ "S_sens": 0.18129432624113476,
512
+ "A_sens": 0.3896276595744681,
513
+ "SA": 0.2531024401602584,
514
+ "InitAcc": 0.5212765957446808
515
+ }
516
+ },
517
+ "Qwen3-8B": {
518
+ "family": "Qwen",
519
+ "group": "Local open-weight models (vLLM)",
520
+ "file": "rerun:sa_causal_vllm_qwen3-8b_rerun.jsonl",
521
+ "N": 1800,
522
+ "pairs": 600,
523
+ "FR_D": 0.34208333333333335,
524
+ "FR_AS": 0.18625,
525
+ "FR_AA": 0.4845833333333333,
526
+ "order": "check",
527
+ "d": 0.9131072702927213,
528
+ "p": 5.164393210373414e-81,
529
+ "sa_default": 0.10458317125027708,
530
+ "sa_ci": [
531
+ 0.060416577833479,
532
+ 0.14666643008374977
533
+ ],
534
+ "sa_questions": 200,
535
+ "p_holm": 8.263029136597463e-80,
536
+ "holm_sig": true,
537
+ "shared": {
538
+ "records": 564,
539
+ "questions": 188,
540
+ "alpha": 0.3249113475177305,
541
+ "S_sens": 0.07535460992907801,
542
+ "A_sens": 0.1897163120567376,
543
+ "SA": 0.10372324379460017,
544
+ "InitAcc": 0.597517730496454
545
+ }
546
+ },
547
+ "Qwen3-32B": {
548
+ "family": "Qwen",
549
+ "group": "Local open-weight models (vLLM)",
550
+ "file": "rel:sa_causal_vllm_qwen3_32b_a7_n200.jsonl",
551
+ "N": 1800,
552
+ "pairs": 600,
553
+ "FR_D": 0.6545833333333333,
554
+ "FR_AS": 0.6754166666666667,
555
+ "FR_AA": 0.7002083333333333,
556
+ "order": "sim",
557
+ "d": 0.08093099086681814,
558
+ "p": 0.04789138765468257,
559
+ "sa_default": 0.006666660000006665,
560
+ "sa_ci": [
561
+ -0.038749929604300355,
562
+ 0.052916576333498506
563
+ ],
564
+ "sa_questions": 200,
565
+ "p_holm": 0.09578277530936515,
566
+ "holm_sig": false,
567
+ "shared": {
568
+ "records": 564,
569
+ "questions": 188,
570
+ "alpha": 0.6527039007092199,
571
+ "S_sens": 0.007535460992907801,
572
+ "A_sens": 0.22384751773049644,
573
+ "SA": 0.00930849778370789,
574
+ "InitAcc": 0.35992907801418433
575
+ }
576
+ },
577
+ "Qwen3.5-4B": {
578
+ "family": "Qwen",
579
+ "group": "Local open-weight models (vLLM)",
580
+ "file": "off:sa_causal_vllm_qwen3.5-4b_thinkoff.jsonl",
581
+ "N": 1800,
582
+ "pairs": 600,
583
+ "FR_D": 0.360625,
584
+ "FR_AS": 0.3304166666666667,
585
+ "FR_AA": 0.5010416666666667,
586
+ "order": "check",
587
+ "d": 0.6285384355615422,
588
+ "p": 2.617234244550622e-45,
589
+ "sa_default": 0.027916620416749582,
590
+ "sa_ci": [
591
+ -0.004166653354198271,
592
+ 0.05999989252103576
593
+ ],
594
+ "sa_questions": 200,
595
+ "p_holm": 2.8789576690056844e-44,
596
+ "holm_sig": true,
597
+ "shared": {
598
+ "records": 564,
599
+ "questions": 188,
600
+ "alpha": 0.3426418439716312,
601
+ "S_sens": 0.01773049645390071,
602
+ "A_sens": 0.11524822695035461,
603
+ "SA": 0.023049611702182626,
604
+ "InitAcc": 0.7092198581560283
605
+ }
606
+ },
607
+ "Qwen3.5-9B": {
608
+ "family": "Qwen",
609
+ "group": "Local open-weight models (vLLM)",
610
+ "file": "off:sa_causal_vllm_qwen3.5-9b_thinkoff.jsonl",
611
+ "N": 1800,
612
+ "pairs": 600,
613
+ "FR_D": 0.29791666666666666,
614
+ "FR_AS": 0.18145833333333333,
615
+ "FR_AA": 0.336875,
616
+ "order": "check",
617
+ "d": 0.5588911263397918,
618
+ "p": 2.592486041976998e-37,
619
+ "sa_default": 0.04416659250013416,
620
+ "sa_ci": [
621
+ 0.009999982479199228,
622
+ 0.07874985708360457
623
+ ],
624
+ "sa_questions": 200,
625
+ "p_holm": 2.592486041976998e-36,
626
+ "holm_sig": true,
627
+ "shared": {
628
+ "records": 564,
629
+ "questions": 188,
630
+ "alpha": 0.27615248226950356,
631
+ "S_sens": 0.028368794326241138,
632
+ "A_sens": 0.10992907801418439,
633
+ "SA": 0.042996381649066925,
634
+ "InitAcc": 0.7517730496453902
635
+ }
636
+ },
637
+ "Qwen3.6-27B": {
638
+ "family": "Qwen",
639
+ "group": "Local open-weight models (vLLM)",
640
+ "file": "off:sa_causal_vllm_qwen3.6-27b-fp8_thinkoff.jsonl",
641
+ "N": 1800,
642
+ "pairs": 600,
643
+ "FR_D": 0.10291666666666667,
644
+ "FR_AS": 0.07895833333333334,
645
+ "FR_AA": 0.16625,
646
+ "order": "check",
647
+ "d": 0.4307436393733259,
648
+ "p": 5.4926247580465e-24,
649
+ "sa_default": 0.028749952083419586,
650
+ "sa_ci": [
651
+ 0.009583323750009583,
652
+ 0.047916583833486
653
+ ],
654
+ "sa_questions": 200,
655
+ "p_holm": 3.84483733063255e-23,
656
+ "holm_sig": true,
657
+ "shared": {
658
+ "records": 564,
659
+ "questions": 188,
660
+ "alpha": 0.08488475177304966,
661
+ "S_sens": 0.020833333333333336,
662
+ "A_sens": 0.05629432624113476,
663
+ "SA": 0.031028317375978717,
664
+ "InitAcc": 0.8351063829787234
665
+ }
666
+ },
667
+ "Qwen3.6-35B-A3B": {
668
+ "family": "Qwen",
669
+ "group": "Local open-weight models (vLLM)",
670
+ "file": "off:sa_causal_vllm_qwen3.6-35b-a3b-fp8_thinkoff.jsonl",
671
+ "N": 1800,
672
+ "pairs": 600,
673
+ "FR_D": 0.12479166666666666,
674
+ "FR_AS": 0.08875,
675
+ "FR_AA": 0.11458333333333333,
676
+ "order": "sim",
677
+ "d": 0.1265157904698635,
678
+ "p": 0.002032852363501612,
679
+ "sa_default": 0.06166656250018916,
680
+ "sa_ci": [
681
+ 0.032083273708448046,
682
+ 0.09291650793779035
683
+ ],
684
+ "sa_questions": 200,
685
+ "p_holm": 0.0060985570905048355,
686
+ "holm_sig": true,
687
+ "shared": {
688
+ "records": 564,
689
+ "questions": 188,
690
+ "alpha": 0.11148049645390071,
691
+ "S_sens": 0.03235815602836879,
692
+ "A_sens": 0.053634751773049646,
693
+ "SA": 0.0496453058512172,
694
+ "InitAcc": 0.8333333333333335
695
+ }
696
+ }
697
+ }
698
+ }
abc_exp/results/channel_panel/channel_panel_22.tex ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,75 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ % tab:full12 rows
2
+ \multicolumn{8}{l}{\emph{API models (12 models, mean $d = 0.879$)}} \\
3
+ Gemini 3-flash & 1,800 & .140 & .032 & .384 & $\checkmark$ & 1.360 & 1.7e-138$^\star$ \\
4
+ Gemini 3.1-flash-lite & 1,800 & .306 & .275 & .324 & $\checkmark$ & 0.193 & 2.8e-6$^\star$ \\
5
+ Gemini 3.1-pro & 1,791 & .151 & .133 & .320 & $\checkmark$ & 0.634 & 9.1e-46$^\star$ \\
6
+ DeepSeek V4 Flash & 1,793 & .117 & .036 & .185 & $\checkmark$ & 0.656 & 1.9e-48$^\star$ \\
7
+ DeepSeek V4 Pro & 1,614 & .040 & .045 & .046 & $\sim$ & 0.015 & .737 \\
8
+ GLM-4.6 (no reasoning) & 1,800 & .541 & .286 & .717 & $\checkmark$ & 1.526 & 9.2e-159$^\star$ \\
9
+ Grok 4.1 Fast & 1,799 & .183 & .068 & .184 & $\checkmark$ & 0.497 & 1.3e-30$^\star$ \\
10
+ HY3 Preview & 1,785 & .312 & .083 & .402 & $\checkmark$ & 1.037 & 1.4e-95$^\star$ \\
11
+ Mistral Small 4 & 1,800 & .421 & .066 & .645 & $\checkmark$ & 2.549 & 2.0e-264$^\star$ \\
12
+ Llama 3.3 70B & 1,797 & .470 & .191 & .580 & $\checkmark$ & 1.306 & 2.4e-131$^\star$ \\
13
+ Llama 4 Scout & 1,800 & .434 & .426 & .574 & $\checkmark$ & 0.540 & 3.1e-35$^\star$ \\
14
+ Llama 4 Maverick & 1,794 & .573 & .622 & .680 & $\sim$ & 0.234 & 1.7e-8$^\star$ \\
15
+ \midrule
16
+ \multicolumn{8}{l}{\emph{Local open-weight models (vLLM) (10 models, mean $d = 0.613$)}} \\
17
+ Gemma 4 31B & 1,800 & .297 & .265 & .370 & $\checkmark$ & 0.347 & 1.5e-16$^\star$ \\
18
+ Llama-3.1-8B & 1,800 & .689 & .401 & .812 & $\checkmark$ & 1.587 & 6.0e-166$^\star$ \\
19
+ Phi-4-mini & 1,800 & .455 & .296 & .497 & $\checkmark$ & 0.660 & 5.1e-49$^\star$ \\
20
+ Qwen3-4B & 1,800 & .651 & .626 & .794 & $\checkmark$ & 0.798 & 4.0e-66$^\star$ \\
21
+ Qwen3-8B & 1,800 & .342 & .186 & .485 & $\checkmark$ & 0.913 & 5.2e-81$^\star$ \\
22
+ Qwen3-32B & 1,800 & .655 & .675 & .700 & $\sim$ & 0.081 & .048 \\
23
+ Qwen3.5-4B & 1,800 & .361 & .330 & .501 & $\checkmark$ & 0.629 & 2.6e-45$^\star$ \\
24
+ Qwen3.5-9B & 1,800 & .298 & .181 & .337 & $\checkmark$ & 0.559 & 2.6e-37$^\star$ \\
25
+ Qwen3.6-27B & 1,800 & .103 & .079 & .166 & $\checkmark$ & 0.431 & 5.5e-24$^\star$ \\
26
+ Qwen3.6-35B-A3B & 1,800 & .125 & .089 & .115 & $\sim$ & 0.127 & .002$^\star$ \\
27
+ \midrule
28
+
29
+ % tab:sa_ci rows
30
+ Gemini 3-flash & $+0.158$ & [$+0.129$, $+0.187$] \\
31
+ Gemini 3.1-flash-lite & $+0.029$ & [$-0.021$, $+0.076$] \\
32
+ Gemini 3.1-pro & $-0.013$ & [$-0.034$, $+0.007$] \\
33
+ DeepSeek V4 Flash & $+0.062$ & [$+0.037$, $+0.087$] \\
34
+ DeepSeek V4 Pro & $+0.017$ & [$-0.003$, $+0.037$] \\
35
+ GLM-4.6 (no reasoning) & $+0.022$ & [$-0.010$, $+0.053$] \\
36
+ Grok 4.1 Fast & $+0.003$ & [$-0.027$, $+0.033$] \\
37
+ HY3 Preview & $+0.024$ & [$-0.009$, $+0.058$] \\
38
+ Mistral Small 4 & $+0.038$ & [$+0.000$, $+0.075$] \\
39
+ Llama 3.3 70B & $+0.075$ & [$+0.044$, $+0.105$] \\
40
+ Llama 4 Scout & $+0.037$ & [$+0.003$, $+0.072$] \\
41
+ Llama 4 Maverick & $+0.075$ & [$+0.033$, $+0.117$] \\
42
+ Gemma 4 31B & $+0.016$ & [$-0.022$, $+0.054$] \\
43
+ Llama-3.1-8B & $+0.051$ & [$+0.005$, $+0.098$] \\
44
+ Phi-4-mini & $+0.060$ & [$+0.015$, $+0.105$] \\
45
+ Qwen3-4B & $+0.244$ & [$+0.204$, $+0.284$] \\
46
+ Qwen3-8B & $+0.105$ & [$+0.060$, $+0.147$] \\
47
+ Qwen3-32B & $+0.007$ & [$-0.039$, $+0.053$] \\
48
+ Qwen3.5-4B & $+0.028$ & [$-0.004$, $+0.060$] \\
49
+ Qwen3.5-9B & $+0.044$ & [$+0.010$, $+0.079$] \\
50
+ Qwen3.6-27B & $+0.029$ & [$+0.010$, $+0.048$] \\
51
+ Qwen3.6-35B-A3B & $+0.062$ & [$+0.032$, $+0.093$] \\
52
+
53
+ % tab:shared_pool_sa rows
54
+ Gemini 3-flash & 0.121 & $+0.102$ & $+0.087$ & $+0.153$ & 85.8\% \\
55
+ Gemini 3.1-flash-lite & 0.291 & $+0.014$ & $+0.118$ & $+0.033$ & 84.9\% \\
56
+ Gemini 3.1-pro & 0.131 & $-0.000$ & $+0.002$ & $-0.008$ & 86.5\% \\
57
+ DeepSeek V4 Flash & 0.110 & $+0.035$ & $+0.094$ & $+0.056$ & 84.9\% \\
58
+ DeepSeek V4 Pro & 0.039 & $+0.010$ & $-0.002$ & $+0.017$ & 87.2\% \\
59
+ GLM-4.6 (no reasoning) & 0.528 & $+0.019$ & $+0.450$ & $+0.023$ & 68.4\% \\
60
+ Grok 4.1 Fast & 0.168 & $+0.004$ & $+0.117$ & $+0.001$ & 71.6\% \\
61
+ HY3 Preview & 0.287 & $+0.022$ & $+0.181$ & $+0.022$ & 80.1\% \\
62
+ Mistral Small 4 & 0.422 & $+0.023$ & $+0.217$ & $+0.041$ & 66.5\% \\
63
+ Llama 3.3 70B & 0.453 & $+0.054$ & $+0.265$ & $+0.072$ & 61.9\% \\
64
+ Llama 4 Scout & 0.427 & $+0.025$ & $+0.165$ & $+0.043$ & 70.7\% \\
65
+ Llama 4 Maverick & 0.568 & $+0.059$ & $+0.172$ & $+0.082$ & 77.2\% \\
66
+ Gemma 4 31B & 0.288 & $+0.004$ & $+0.076$ & $+0.008$ & 82.4\% \\
67
+ Llama-3.1-8B & 0.681 & $+0.019$ & $+0.296$ & $+0.046$ & 34.0\% \\
68
+ Phi-4-mini & 0.453 & $+0.056$ & $+0.245$ & $+0.063$ & 38.8\% \\
69
+ Qwen3-4B & 0.638 & $+0.181$ & $+0.390$ & $+0.253$ & 52.1\% \\
70
+ Qwen3-8B & 0.325 & $+0.075$ & $+0.190$ & $+0.104$ & 59.8\% \\
71
+ Qwen3-32B & 0.653 & $+0.008$ & $+0.224$ & $+0.009$ & 36.0\% \\
72
+ Qwen3.5-4B & 0.343 & $+0.018$ & $+0.115$ & $+0.023$ & 70.9\% \\
73
+ Qwen3.5-9B & 0.276 & $+0.028$ & $+0.110$ & $+0.043$ & 75.2\% \\
74
+ Qwen3.6-27B & 0.085 & $+0.021$ & $+0.056$ & $+0.031$ & 83.5\% \\
75
+ Qwen3.6-35B-A3B & 0.111 & $+0.032$ & $+0.054$ & $+0.050$ & 83.3\% \\
abc_exp/results/conditional_collapse_table.json CHANGED
@@ -20,7 +20,8 @@
20
  "recover_hi": 28.057800818279823,
21
  "n_cond_coll": 2,
22
  "n_recover": 3,
23
- "GB_ratio": 1.5
 
24
  },
25
  {
26
  "model": "Claude Haiku 4.5",
@@ -42,7 +43,8 @@
42
  "recover_hi": 28.4772682171176,
43
  "n_cond_coll": 46,
44
  "n_recover": 17,
45
- "GB_ratio": 0.3695652173913043
 
46
  },
47
  {
48
  "model": "GPT-4o-mini",
@@ -64,26 +66,28 @@
64
  "recover_hi": 15.912956144771895,
65
  "n_cond_coll": 8,
66
  "n_recover": 16,
67
- "GB_ratio": 2.0
 
68
  },
69
  {
70
  "model": "Gemini 2.5 Flash",
71
  "family": "Google",
72
  "FR": 0.648,
73
  "SA": 0.14,
74
- "n_deb": 200,
 
75
  "n_init_correct": 73,
76
- "n_init_wrong": 127,
77
- "raw_collapse_pct": 0.5,
78
- "raw_lo": 0.08831687156009763,
79
- "raw_hi": 2.777370439789293,
80
  "cond_collapse_pct": 1.36986301369863,
81
  "cond_lo": 0.24222514664838657,
82
  "cond_hi": 7.359737270963818,
83
- "init_acc": 0.365,
84
- "recover_pct": 11.811023622047244,
85
- "recover_lo": 7.289704388252161,
86
- "recover_hi": 18.574772457019534,
87
  "n_cond_coll": 1,
88
  "n_recover": 15,
89
  "GB_ratio": 15.0
@@ -93,6 +97,7 @@
93
  "family": "OpenAI",
94
  "FR": 0.35,
95
  "SA": 0.05,
 
96
  "n_deb": 200,
97
  "n_init_correct": 143,
98
  "n_init_wrong": 57,
@@ -115,6 +120,7 @@
115
  "family": "Google",
116
  "FR": 0.249,
117
  "SA": -0.08,
 
118
  "n_deb": 200,
119
  "n_init_correct": 170,
120
  "n_init_wrong": 30,
@@ -137,6 +143,7 @@
137
  "family": "Microsoft",
138
  "FR": 0.451,
139
  "SA": 0.23,
 
140
  "n_deb": 2161,
141
  "n_init_correct": 1094,
142
  "n_init_wrong": 1067,
@@ -159,6 +166,7 @@
159
  "family": "Qwen",
160
  "FR": 0.596,
161
  "SA": 0.08,
 
162
  "n_deb": 2161,
163
  "n_init_correct": 979,
164
  "n_init_wrong": 1182,
@@ -181,6 +189,7 @@
181
  "family": "Meta",
182
  "FR": 0.726,
183
  "SA": 0.06,
 
184
  "n_deb": 2003,
185
  "n_init_correct": 1016,
186
  "n_init_wrong": 987,
@@ -203,6 +212,7 @@
203
  "family": "Qwen",
204
  "FR": 0.596,
205
  "SA": -0.05,
 
206
  "n_deb": 200,
207
  "n_init_correct": 56,
208
  "n_init_wrong": 144,
@@ -240,29 +250,30 @@
240
  "recover_hi": 45.308339269675926,
241
  "n_cond_coll": 26,
242
  "n_recover": 97,
243
- "GB_ratio": 3.730769230769231
 
244
  }
245
  ],
246
  "stats": {
247
  "N_models": 11,
248
  "spearman_FR_raw": {
249
- "statistic": 0.08735839935247217,
250
- "pvalue": 0.7984118639344213,
251
- "correlation": 0.08735839935247217
252
  },
253
  "spearman_FR_cond": {
254
  "statistic": 0.19590028045862823,
255
- "pvalue": 0.5637442329087623,
256
  "correlation": 0.19590028045862823
257
  },
258
  "spearman_FR_recover": {
259
- "statistic": -0.09111640951564104,
260
- "pvalue": 0.7899039060352314,
261
- "correlation": -0.09111640951564104
262
  },
263
  "spearman_SA_cond": {
264
  "statistic": 0.25057012616801283,
265
- "pvalue": 0.4573852261533532,
266
  "correlation": 0.25057012616801283
267
  },
268
  "kendall_FR_cond": {
@@ -271,14 +282,14 @@
271
  "correlation": 0.14679516868351475
272
  },
273
  "spearman_init_acc_cond": {
274
- "statistic": -0.21818181818181823,
275
- "pvalue": 0.519248247554982,
276
- "correlation": -0.21818181818181823
277
  },
278
  "spearman_init_acc_raw": {
279
- "statistic": 0.03669879217087869,
280
- "pvalue": 0.9146916426486271,
281
- "correlation": 0.03669879217087869
282
  }
283
  }
284
  }
 
20
  "recover_hi": 28.057800818279823,
21
  "n_cond_coll": 2,
22
  "n_recover": 3,
23
+ "GB_ratio": 1.5,
24
+ "source": "recorded_counts"
25
  },
26
  {
27
  "model": "Claude Haiku 4.5",
 
43
  "recover_hi": 28.4772682171176,
44
  "n_cond_coll": 46,
45
  "n_recover": 17,
46
+ "GB_ratio": 0.3695652173913043,
47
+ "source": "recorded_counts"
48
  },
49
  {
50
  "model": "GPT-4o-mini",
 
66
  "recover_hi": 15.912956144771895,
67
  "n_cond_coll": 8,
68
  "n_recover": 16,
69
+ "GB_ratio": 2.0,
70
+ "source": "recorded_counts"
71
  },
72
  {
73
  "model": "Gemini 2.5 Flash",
74
  "family": "Google",
75
  "FR": 0.648,
76
  "SA": 0.14,
77
+ "source": "block1_abc_vs_baselines.jsonl",
78
+ "n_deb": 118,
79
  "n_init_correct": 73,
80
+ "n_init_wrong": 45,
81
+ "raw_collapse_pct": 0.847457627118644,
82
+ "raw_lo": 0.14975405219652543,
83
+ "raw_hi": 4.6445572415402046,
84
  "cond_collapse_pct": 1.36986301369863,
85
  "cond_lo": 0.24222514664838657,
86
  "cond_hi": 7.359737270963818,
87
+ "init_acc": 0.6186440677966102,
88
+ "recover_pct": 33.33333333333333,
89
+ "recover_lo": 21.358874934330032,
90
+ "recover_hi": 47.92951169009958,
91
  "n_cond_coll": 1,
92
  "n_recover": 15,
93
  "GB_ratio": 15.0
 
97
  "family": "OpenAI",
98
  "FR": 0.35,
99
  "SA": 0.05,
100
+ "source": "debate_traces_openai_gpt-5.4-mini.jsonl",
101
  "n_deb": 200,
102
  "n_init_correct": 143,
103
  "n_init_wrong": 57,
 
120
  "family": "Google",
121
  "FR": 0.249,
122
  "SA": -0.08,
123
+ "source": "debate_traces_gemini_3-flash.jsonl",
124
  "n_deb": 200,
125
  "n_init_correct": 170,
126
  "n_init_wrong": 30,
 
143
  "family": "Microsoft",
144
  "FR": 0.451,
145
  "SA": 0.23,
146
+ "source": "debate_traces_vllm_phi-4-mini.jsonl",
147
  "n_deb": 2161,
148
  "n_init_correct": 1094,
149
  "n_init_wrong": 1067,
 
166
  "family": "Qwen",
167
  "FR": 0.596,
168
  "SA": 0.08,
169
+ "source": "debate_traces_vllm_qwen3-4b.jsonl",
170
  "n_deb": 2161,
171
  "n_init_correct": 979,
172
  "n_init_wrong": 1182,
 
189
  "family": "Meta",
190
  "FR": 0.726,
191
  "SA": 0.06,
192
+ "source": "debate_traces_vllm_llama-3.1-8b.jsonl",
193
  "n_deb": 2003,
194
  "n_init_correct": 1016,
195
  "n_init_wrong": 987,
 
212
  "family": "Qwen",
213
  "FR": 0.596,
214
  "SA": -0.05,
215
+ "source": "debate_traces_vllm_qwen3-8b.jsonl",
216
  "n_deb": 200,
217
  "n_init_correct": 56,
218
  "n_init_wrong": 144,
 
250
  "recover_hi": 45.308339269675926,
251
  "n_cond_coll": 26,
252
  "n_recover": 97,
253
+ "GB_ratio": 3.730769230769231,
254
+ "source": "recorded_counts"
255
  }
256
  ],
257
  "stats": {
258
  "N_models": 11,
259
  "spearman_FR_raw": {
260
+ "statistic": 0.15068493150684933,
261
+ "pvalue": 0.6583104144348021,
262
+ "correlation": 0.15068493150684933
263
  },
264
  "spearman_FR_cond": {
265
  "statistic": 0.19590028045862823,
266
+ "pvalue": 0.5637442329087622,
267
  "correlation": 0.19590028045862823
268
  },
269
  "spearman_FR_recover": {
270
+ "statistic": 0.03644656380625642,
271
+ "pvalue": 0.9152761385497562,
272
+ "correlation": 0.03644656380625642
273
  },
274
  "spearman_SA_cond": {
275
  "statistic": 0.25057012616801283,
276
+ "pvalue": 0.4573852261533529,
277
  "correlation": 0.25057012616801283
278
  },
279
  "kendall_FR_cond": {
 
282
  "correlation": 0.14679516868351475
283
  },
284
  "spearman_init_acc_cond": {
285
+ "statistic": -0.4090909090909091,
286
+ "pvalue": 0.21154501034209602,
287
+ "correlation": -0.4090909090909091
288
  },
289
  "spearman_init_acc_raw": {
290
+ "statistic": -0.23234684426488467,
291
+ "pvalue": 0.4917654140586253,
292
+ "correlation": -0.23234684426488467
293
  }
294
  }
295
  }
abc_exp/results/construct_auc_public_n200.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,87 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "definition": "tab:construct on the public 200-question runs (zero API). The table is defined on public data; it does not reproduce\nan earlier version of the table, whose logs were not retained.\n\nUnit: one debate (model x question) whose initial majority is correct; outcome = collapse at Round 3 (parsed Round-3\nmajority wrong; a debate with no parsed Round-3 answer is not counted as a collapse).\nPer-question features from the same model's public probe file (same 200 questions), default condition:\n mean probe FR = mean share of revised probes over the three agents; S/A = mean over agents of the paper's S/A formula\n recomputed from probe_results (rec_scores);\n difficulty = 1 - mean probe initial_correct over all rows of the question (all conditions and agents);\n initial disagreement = 1 - (largest initial-answer count / number of parsed initial answers) in the debate.\nSingle predictors: AUC of the raw score (not re-oriented, as in the printed table). Combined: logistic regression,\nout-of-fold predictions with 5 question folds (pooled: same folds across models, plus model indicators).",
3
+ "per_model": {
4
+ "Gemini 3-flash": {
5
+ "n": 166,
6
+ "collapses": 1,
7
+ "fr": 0.7181818181818181,
8
+ "sa": 0.8212121212121212,
9
+ "dis": 0.9878787878787879
10
+ },
11
+ "Gemini 3.1-flash-lite": {
12
+ "n": 164,
13
+ "collapses": 0,
14
+ "fr": null,
15
+ "sa": null,
16
+ "dis": null
17
+ },
18
+ "Gemini 3.1-pro": {
19
+ "n": 145,
20
+ "collapses": 0,
21
+ "fr": null,
22
+ "sa": null,
23
+ "dis": null
24
+ },
25
+ "GLM-4.6 (no reasoning)": {
26
+ "n": 152,
27
+ "collapses": 6,
28
+ "fr": 0.533675799086758,
29
+ "sa": 0.3852739726027397,
30
+ "dis": 0.9178082191780822,
31
+ "base": 0.8698630136986302,
32
+ "full": 0.8242009132420092,
33
+ "delta": -0.045662100456621
34
+ },
35
+ "Grok 4.1 Fast": {
36
+ "n": 167,
37
+ "collapses": 0,
38
+ "fr": null,
39
+ "sa": null,
40
+ "dis": null
41
+ },
42
+ "Llama 3.3 70B": {
43
+ "n": 127,
44
+ "collapses": 2,
45
+ "fr": 0.672,
46
+ "sa": 0.38,
47
+ "dis": 0.88
48
+ },
49
+ "Llama 4 Maverick": {
50
+ "n": 158,
51
+ "collapses": 5,
52
+ "fr": 0.581045751633987,
53
+ "sa": 0.3836601307189543,
54
+ "dis": 0.7705882352941177,
55
+ "base": 0.550326797385621,
56
+ "full": 0.5908496732026144,
57
+ "delta": 0.04052287581699343
58
+ },
59
+ "Llama 4 Scout": {
60
+ "n": 146,
61
+ "collapses": 7,
62
+ "fr": 0.5801644398766701,
63
+ "sa": 0.6217882836587872,
64
+ "dis": 0.7944501541623844,
65
+ "base": 0.6659815005138746,
66
+ "full": 0.6135662898252826,
67
+ "delta": -0.05241521068859201
68
+ },
69
+ "Mistral Small 4": {
70
+ "n": 140,
71
+ "collapses": 4,
72
+ "fr": 0.7058823529411765,
73
+ "sa": 0.27849264705882354,
74
+ "dis": 0.9889705882352942
75
+ },
76
+ "Pooled": {
77
+ "n": 1365,
78
+ "collapses": 25,
79
+ "fr": 0.7069552238805971,
80
+ "sa": 0.446089552238806,
81
+ "dis": 0.8784776119402985,
82
+ "base": 0.8984776119402985,
83
+ "full": 0.8784776119402985,
84
+ "delta": -0.020000000000000018
85
+ }
86
+ }
87
+ }
abc_exp/results/debate_eval_croissant_rai_metadata.json CHANGED
@@ -50,7 +50,7 @@
50
  "name": "Debate Collapse/Correction Evaluation Artifact",
51
  "description": "Validated Croissant/RAI metadata for the collapse/correction evaluation protocol bundle used in a homogeneous-panel LLM debate audit.",
52
  "conformsTo": "http://mlcommons.org/croissant/1.0",
53
- "citeAs": "Xin Li, Mengbing Liu, and Chau Yuen. Measuring Collapse and Correction in Homogeneous-Panel LLM Debate. NeurIPS 2026 Evaluations and Datasets Track. DebateLedger artifact version 1.0.3.",
54
  "dateCreated": "2026-05-02",
55
  "datePublished": "2026-09-28",
56
  "inLanguage": "en",
@@ -71,14 +71,14 @@
71
  "rai:dataCollectionType": "machine-generated traces from public benchmark questions",
72
  "rai:dataLimitations": "Not a benchmark-general law; not a calibrated per-question oracle; not a deployable controller; gated tier needed for convince-wrong templates and full transcripts.",
73
  "rai:dataPreprocessingProtocol": "Rule-based MCQ answer extraction; majority voting after filtering unparsed answers; alphabetic tie-breaking; deterministic collapse/correction/onset labels.",
74
- "rai:dataReleaseMaintenancePlan": "Versioned public release (alpha-tot-v1.0.3): open data on Hugging Face, code on GitHub, and a gated Hugging Face dataset for full transcripts and convince-wrong templates. Corrections and provider or parser changes are released as new minor versions.",
75
  "rai:dataSocialImpact": "Helps audit debate interventions that may reduce collapses while discarding corrections; gated release mitigates misuse as a misleading-answer corpus.",
76
  "rai:dataUseCases": "Zero-API recomputation of aggregate tables; applying the transition-table and signed-utility protocol to new model-scaffold pairs; documenting gated release boundaries; public artifact hosting on Hugging Face with code on GitHub.",
77
  "rai:hasSyntheticData": true,
78
  "rai:machineAnnotationTools": "Rule-based MCQ answer parser included in the artifact; no LLM judge step is used.",
79
  "rai:personalSensitiveInformation": "none",
80
  "url": "https://huggingface.co/datasets/XINLI1997/DebateLedger",
81
- "version": "1.0.3",
82
  "distribution": [
83
  {
84
  "@type": "cr:FileObject",
@@ -86,7 +86,7 @@
86
  "name": "README_REPRO.md",
87
  "contentUrl": "README_REPRO.md",
88
  "encodingFormat": "text/markdown",
89
- "sha256": "c6e9a51e08dfd87c7b19f3ba63e40ceecabb3df06abacafc9907a523d5189c06"
90
  },
91
  {
92
  "@type": "cr:FileObject",
@@ -102,7 +102,7 @@
102
  "name": "DEBATE_EVAL_ARTIFACT_DATASHEET.md",
103
  "contentUrl": "abc_exp/results/DEBATE_EVAL_ARTIFACT_DATASHEET.md",
104
  "encodingFormat": "text/markdown",
105
- "sha256": "a5aa8fc5f8355743d836e609420f4a47f4e8d67c66c6a65caf231fa340848e96"
106
  },
107
  {
108
  "@type": "cr:FileObject",
@@ -134,7 +134,7 @@
134
  "name": "conditional_collapse_table.json",
135
  "contentUrl": "abc_exp/results/conditional_collapse_table.json",
136
  "encodingFormat": "application/json",
137
- "sha256": "2df5c2ae2f8047c2d5706fe82339229774d4614c0583351042034f07ccaa5eba"
138
  },
139
  {
140
  "@type": "cr:FileObject",
@@ -248,6 +248,22 @@
248
  "encodingFormat": "application/jsonlines",
249
  "sha256": "72a7397af3a6469e64cc2412b58faca14c9dbd3366c8d3114b2d2093d82f9e5e"
250
  },
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
251
  {
252
  "@type": "cr:FileSet",
253
  "@id": "fileset_debate_traces",
@@ -303,6 +319,14 @@
303
  "description": "8-probe screen traces of the thinking-off rerun of the four Qwen3.5/3.6 rows. Model output text is null in the open tier.",
304
  "encodingFormat": "application/jsonlines",
305
  "includes": "abc_exp/results/thinking_off_rerun/sa_causal_*.jsonl"
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
306
  }
307
  ],
308
  "recordSet": [
@@ -356,7 +380,7 @@
356
  "artifact_path": "README_REPRO.md",
357
  "artifact_role": "zero-api rebuild card",
358
  "encoding_format": "text/markdown",
359
- "sha256": "c6e9a51e08dfd87c7b19f3ba63e40ceecabb3df06abacafc9907a523d5189c06",
360
  "release_tier": "open; full transcripts and convince-wrong templates are in the gated dataset"
361
  },
362
  {
@@ -370,7 +394,7 @@
370
  "artifact_path": "abc_exp/results/DEBATE_EVAL_ARTIFACT_DATASHEET.md",
371
  "artifact_role": "artifact datasheet",
372
  "encoding_format": "text/markdown",
373
- "sha256": "a5aa8fc5f8355743d836e609420f4a47f4e8d67c66c6a65caf231fa340848e96",
374
  "release_tier": "open; full transcripts and convince-wrong templates are in the gated dataset"
375
  },
376
  {
@@ -398,7 +422,7 @@
398
  "artifact_path": "abc_exp/results/conditional_collapse_table.json",
399
  "artifact_role": "collapse/correction transition table",
400
  "encoding_format": "application/json",
401
- "sha256": "2df5c2ae2f8047c2d5706fe82339229774d4614c0583351042034f07ccaa5eba",
402
  "release_tier": "open; full transcripts and convince-wrong templates are in the gated dataset"
403
  },
404
  {
@@ -498,6 +522,20 @@
498
  "encoding_format": "application/jsonlines",
499
  "sha256": "72a7397af3a6469e64cc2412b58faca14c9dbd3366c8d3114b2d2093d82f9e5e",
500
  "release_tier": "open; full transcripts and convince-wrong templates are in the gated dataset"
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
501
  }
502
  ]
503
  },
@@ -1164,6 +1202,110 @@
1164
  }
1165
  }
1166
  ]
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1167
  }
1168
  ]
1169
  }
 
50
  "name": "Debate Collapse/Correction Evaluation Artifact",
51
  "description": "Validated Croissant/RAI metadata for the collapse/correction evaluation protocol bundle used in a homogeneous-panel LLM debate audit.",
52
  "conformsTo": "http://mlcommons.org/croissant/1.0",
53
+ "citeAs": "Xin Li, Mengbing Liu, and Chau Yuen. Measuring Collapse and Correction in Homogeneous-Panel LLM Debate. NeurIPS 2026 Evaluations and Datasets Track. DebateLedger artifact version 1.0.4.",
54
  "dateCreated": "2026-05-02",
55
  "datePublished": "2026-09-28",
56
  "inLanguage": "en",
 
71
  "rai:dataCollectionType": "machine-generated traces from public benchmark questions",
72
  "rai:dataLimitations": "Not a benchmark-general law; not a calibrated per-question oracle; not a deployable controller; gated tier needed for convince-wrong templates and full transcripts.",
73
  "rai:dataPreprocessingProtocol": "Rule-based MCQ answer extraction; majority voting after filtering unparsed answers; alphabetic tie-breaking; deterministic collapse/correction/onset labels.",
74
+ "rai:dataReleaseMaintenancePlan": "Versioned public release (alpha-tot-v1.0.4): open data on Hugging Face, code on GitHub, and a gated Hugging Face dataset for full transcripts and convince-wrong templates. Corrections and provider or parser changes are released as new minor versions.",
75
  "rai:dataSocialImpact": "Helps audit debate interventions that may reduce collapses while discarding corrections; gated release mitigates misuse as a misleading-answer corpus.",
76
  "rai:dataUseCases": "Zero-API recomputation of aggregate tables; applying the transition-table and signed-utility protocol to new model-scaffold pairs; documenting gated release boundaries; public artifact hosting on Hugging Face with code on GitHub.",
77
  "rai:hasSyntheticData": true,
78
  "rai:machineAnnotationTools": "Rule-based MCQ answer parser included in the artifact; no LLM judge step is used.",
79
  "rai:personalSensitiveInformation": "none",
80
  "url": "https://huggingface.co/datasets/XINLI1997/DebateLedger",
81
+ "version": "1.0.4",
82
  "distribution": [
83
  {
84
  "@type": "cr:FileObject",
 
86
  "name": "README_REPRO.md",
87
  "contentUrl": "README_REPRO.md",
88
  "encodingFormat": "text/markdown",
89
+ "sha256": "5e0b142177ed0ca20479c161e0243d9f6560579c99404fef657951c21f74ca9a"
90
  },
91
  {
92
  "@type": "cr:FileObject",
 
102
  "name": "DEBATE_EVAL_ARTIFACT_DATASHEET.md",
103
  "contentUrl": "abc_exp/results/DEBATE_EVAL_ARTIFACT_DATASHEET.md",
104
  "encodingFormat": "text/markdown",
105
+ "sha256": "e4ab47578fca06c1904f680d78da011f43e96dcc58d0cb874a5cc734bb8fcbd3"
106
  },
107
  {
108
  "@type": "cr:FileObject",
 
134
  "name": "conditional_collapse_table.json",
135
  "contentUrl": "abc_exp/results/conditional_collapse_table.json",
136
  "encodingFormat": "application/json",
137
+ "sha256": "d6a11d548753d89b695d700e7f21755c414a5def11c2204acb7382192e9bbd21"
138
  },
139
  {
140
  "@type": "cr:FileObject",
 
248
  "encodingFormat": "application/jsonlines",
249
  "sha256": "72a7397af3a6469e64cc2412b58faca14c9dbd3366c8d3114b2d2093d82f9e5e"
250
  },
251
+ {
252
+ "@type": "cr:FileObject",
253
+ "@id": "file_abc_exp_results_gate_rerun_gate_lomo_paper_json",
254
+ "name": "gate_lomo_paper.json",
255
+ "contentUrl": "abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_lomo_paper.json",
256
+ "encodingFormat": "application/json",
257
+ "sha256": "1350c4e952a1e03995a9eb65f422b02fa4174af35a371d45e7d2fcef746c18f9"
258
+ },
259
+ {
260
+ "@type": "cr:FileObject",
261
+ "@id": "file_abc_exp_results_channel_panel_channel_panel_22_json",
262
+ "name": "channel_panel_22.json",
263
+ "contentUrl": "abc_exp/results/channel_panel/channel_panel_22.json",
264
+ "encodingFormat": "application/json",
265
+ "sha256": "5320543ee013297441def772f7ac62545cf406f81c55d699a8908e86801d1027"
266
+ },
267
  {
268
  "@type": "cr:FileSet",
269
  "@id": "fileset_debate_traces",
 
319
  "description": "8-probe screen traces of the thinking-off rerun of the four Qwen3.5/3.6 rows. Model output text is null in the open tier.",
320
  "encodingFormat": "application/jsonlines",
321
  "includes": "abc_exp/results/thinking_off_rerun/sa_causal_*.jsonl"
322
+ },
323
+ {
324
+ "@type": "cr:FileSet",
325
+ "@id": "fileset_gate_rerun_probe_traces",
326
+ "name": "fileset_gate_rerun_probe_traces",
327
+ "description": "8-probe screen traces of the four local models collected for the probe-gated freeze and the channel panel. Model output text is null in the open tier.",
328
+ "encodingFormat": "application/jsonlines",
329
+ "includes": "abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/*.jsonl"
330
  }
331
  ],
332
  "recordSet": [
 
380
  "artifact_path": "README_REPRO.md",
381
  "artifact_role": "zero-api rebuild card",
382
  "encoding_format": "text/markdown",
383
+ "sha256": "5e0b142177ed0ca20479c161e0243d9f6560579c99404fef657951c21f74ca9a",
384
  "release_tier": "open; full transcripts and convince-wrong templates are in the gated dataset"
385
  },
386
  {
 
394
  "artifact_path": "abc_exp/results/DEBATE_EVAL_ARTIFACT_DATASHEET.md",
395
  "artifact_role": "artifact datasheet",
396
  "encoding_format": "text/markdown",
397
+ "sha256": "e4ab47578fca06c1904f680d78da011f43e96dcc58d0cb874a5cc734bb8fcbd3",
398
  "release_tier": "open; full transcripts and convince-wrong templates are in the gated dataset"
399
  },
400
  {
 
422
  "artifact_path": "abc_exp/results/conditional_collapse_table.json",
423
  "artifact_role": "collapse/correction transition table",
424
  "encoding_format": "application/json",
425
+ "sha256": "d6a11d548753d89b695d700e7f21755c414a5def11c2204acb7382192e9bbd21",
426
  "release_tier": "open; full transcripts and convince-wrong templates are in the gated dataset"
427
  },
428
  {
 
522
  "encoding_format": "application/jsonlines",
523
  "sha256": "72a7397af3a6469e64cc2412b58faca14c9dbd3366c8d3114b2d2093d82f9e5e",
524
  "release_tier": "open; full transcripts and convince-wrong templates are in the gated dataset"
525
+ },
526
+ {
527
+ "artifact_path": "abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_lomo_paper.json",
528
+ "artifact_role": "probe-gated freeze ledger",
529
+ "encoding_format": "application/json",
530
+ "sha256": "1350c4e952a1e03995a9eb65f422b02fa4174af35a371d45e7d2fcef746c18f9",
531
+ "release_tier": "open; full transcripts and convince-wrong templates are in the gated dataset"
532
+ },
533
+ {
534
+ "artifact_path": "abc_exp/results/channel_panel/channel_panel_22.json",
535
+ "artifact_role": "22-model channel panel",
536
+ "encoding_format": "application/json",
537
+ "sha256": "5320543ee013297441def772f7ac62545cf406f81c55d699a8908e86801d1027",
538
+ "release_tier": "open; full transcripts and convince-wrong templates are in the gated dataset"
539
  }
540
  ]
541
  },
 
1202
  }
1203
  }
1204
  ]
1205
+ },
1206
+ {
1207
+ "@type": "cr:RecordSet",
1208
+ "@id": "gate_rerun_probe_traces",
1209
+ "name": "gate_rerun_probe_traces",
1210
+ "description": "8-probe screen traces of the four local models collected for the probe-gated freeze and the channel panel. Model output text is null in the open tier.",
1211
+ "field": [
1212
+ {
1213
+ "@type": "cr:Field",
1214
+ "@id": "gate_rerun_probe_traces/question_id",
1215
+ "name": "question_id",
1216
+ "description": "Benchmark question identifier.",
1217
+ "dataType": "sc:Text",
1218
+ "repeated": false,
1219
+ "source": {
1220
+ "fileSet": {
1221
+ "@id": "fileset_gate_rerun_probe_traces"
1222
+ },
1223
+ "extract": {
1224
+ "column": "question_id"
1225
+ }
1226
+ }
1227
+ },
1228
+ {
1229
+ "@type": "cr:Field",
1230
+ "@id": "gate_rerun_probe_traces/agent_idx",
1231
+ "name": "agent_idx",
1232
+ "description": "Agent index within the panel.",
1233
+ "dataType": "sc:Integer",
1234
+ "repeated": false,
1235
+ "source": {
1236
+ "fileSet": {
1237
+ "@id": "fileset_gate_rerun_probe_traces"
1238
+ },
1239
+ "extract": {
1240
+ "column": "agent_idx"
1241
+ }
1242
+ }
1243
+ },
1244
+ {
1245
+ "@type": "cr:Field",
1246
+ "@id": "gate_rerun_probe_traces/condition",
1247
+ "name": "condition",
1248
+ "description": "System-prompt condition of the probe run.",
1249
+ "dataType": "sc:Text",
1250
+ "repeated": false,
1251
+ "source": {
1252
+ "fileSet": {
1253
+ "@id": "fileset_gate_rerun_probe_traces"
1254
+ },
1255
+ "extract": {
1256
+ "column": "condition"
1257
+ }
1258
+ }
1259
+ },
1260
+ {
1261
+ "@type": "cr:Field",
1262
+ "@id": "gate_rerun_probe_traces/initial_answer",
1263
+ "name": "initial_answer",
1264
+ "description": "Parsed answer before any probe.",
1265
+ "dataType": "sc:Text",
1266
+ "repeated": false,
1267
+ "source": {
1268
+ "fileSet": {
1269
+ "@id": "fileset_gate_rerun_probe_traces"
1270
+ },
1271
+ "extract": {
1272
+ "column": "initial_answer"
1273
+ }
1274
+ }
1275
+ },
1276
+ {
1277
+ "@type": "cr:Field",
1278
+ "@id": "gate_rerun_probe_traces/initial_correct",
1279
+ "name": "initial_correct",
1280
+ "description": "Whether the initial answer matches the key.",
1281
+ "dataType": "sc:Boolean",
1282
+ "repeated": false,
1283
+ "source": {
1284
+ "fileSet": {
1285
+ "@id": "fileset_gate_rerun_probe_traces"
1286
+ },
1287
+ "extract": {
1288
+ "column": "initial_correct"
1289
+ }
1290
+ }
1291
+ },
1292
+ {
1293
+ "@type": "cr:Field",
1294
+ "@id": "gate_rerun_probe_traces/flip_rate",
1295
+ "name": "flip_rate",
1296
+ "description": "Fraction of the eight probes that changed the answer.",
1297
+ "dataType": "sc:Float",
1298
+ "repeated": false,
1299
+ "source": {
1300
+ "fileSet": {
1301
+ "@id": "fileset_gate_rerun_probe_traces"
1302
+ },
1303
+ "extract": {
1304
+ "column": "flip_rate"
1305
+ }
1306
+ }
1307
+ }
1308
+ ]
1309
  }
1310
  ]
1311
  }
abc_exp/results/debate_eval_croissant_validation_receipt.json CHANGED
@@ -9,7 +9,7 @@
9
  "files": [
10
  {
11
  "path": "README_REPRO.md",
12
- "sha256": "c6e9a51e08dfd87c7b19f3ba63e40ceecabb3df06abacafc9907a523d5189c06"
13
  },
14
  {
15
  "path": "requirements-artifact.txt",
@@ -17,7 +17,7 @@
17
  },
18
  {
19
  "path": "abc_exp/results/DEBATE_EVAL_ARTIFACT_DATASHEET.md",
20
- "sha256": "a5aa8fc5f8355743d836e609420f4a47f4e8d67c66c6a65caf231fa340848e96"
21
  },
22
  {
23
  "path": "abc_exp/results/debate_eval_reuse_card.schema.json",
@@ -33,7 +33,7 @@
33
  },
34
  {
35
  "path": "abc_exp/results/conditional_collapse_table.json",
36
- "sha256": "2df5c2ae2f8047c2d5706fe82339229774d4614c0583351042034f07ccaa5eba"
37
  },
38
  {
39
  "path": "abc_exp/results/reviewer_hardening_analyses.json",
@@ -90,6 +90,14 @@
90
  {
91
  "path": "abc_exp/results/block3_multi_benchmark.jsonl",
92
  "sha256": "72a7397af3a6469e64cc2412b58faca14c9dbd3366c8d3114b2d2093d82f9e5e"
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
93
  }
94
  ],
95
  "rai_fields_populated": [
 
9
  "files": [
10
  {
11
  "path": "README_REPRO.md",
12
+ "sha256": "5e0b142177ed0ca20479c161e0243d9f6560579c99404fef657951c21f74ca9a"
13
  },
14
  {
15
  "path": "requirements-artifact.txt",
 
17
  },
18
  {
19
  "path": "abc_exp/results/DEBATE_EVAL_ARTIFACT_DATASHEET.md",
20
+ "sha256": "e4ab47578fca06c1904f680d78da011f43e96dcc58d0cb874a5cc734bb8fcbd3"
21
  },
22
  {
23
  "path": "abc_exp/results/debate_eval_reuse_card.schema.json",
 
33
  },
34
  {
35
  "path": "abc_exp/results/conditional_collapse_table.json",
36
+ "sha256": "d6a11d548753d89b695d700e7f21755c414a5def11c2204acb7382192e9bbd21"
37
  },
38
  {
39
  "path": "abc_exp/results/reviewer_hardening_analyses.json",
 
90
  {
91
  "path": "abc_exp/results/block3_multi_benchmark.jsonl",
92
  "sha256": "72a7397af3a6469e64cc2412b58faca14c9dbd3366c8d3114b2d2093d82f9e5e"
93
+ },
94
+ {
95
+ "path": "abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_lomo_paper.json",
96
+ "sha256": "1350c4e952a1e03995a9eb65f422b02fa4174af35a371d45e7d2fcef746c18f9"
97
+ },
98
+ {
99
+ "path": "abc_exp/results/channel_panel/channel_panel_22.json",
100
+ "sha256": "5320543ee013297441def772f7ac62545cf406f81c55d699a8908e86801d1027"
101
  }
102
  ],
103
  "rai_fields_populated": [
abc_exp/results/figures/fig2_channel_manipulation.pdf ADDED
Binary file (25.7 kB). View file
 
abc_exp/results/figures/fig2_channel_manipulation.png ADDED

Git LFS Details

  • SHA256: 752aca8ce0f6861bc43dada98c8e279a72f8fa7fc5ba32950564fa18a398c947
  • Pointer size: 131 Bytes
  • Size of remote file: 145 kB
abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/acceptance.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,182 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "sa_causal_vllm_llama-3.1-8b_rerun.jsonl": {
3
+ "present": true,
4
+ "cap_probe": [
5
+ 2048
6
+ ],
7
+ "expected": 1800,
8
+ "rows": 1800,
9
+ "missing": 0,
10
+ "duplicates": 0,
11
+ "rows_not_8": 0,
12
+ "init_trunc_pct": 10.17,
13
+ "probe_trunc_pct": 15.84,
14
+ "trunc_loop_share": 0.0,
15
+ "init_none": 0,
16
+ "post_none_pct": 3.74,
17
+ "verdict": "OVER_2PCT",
18
+ "complete": true
19
+ },
20
+ "sa_causal_vllm_phi-4-mini_rerun.jsonl": {
21
+ "present": true,
22
+ "cap_probe": [
23
+ 2048
24
+ ],
25
+ "expected": 1800,
26
+ "rows": 1800,
27
+ "missing": 0,
28
+ "duplicates": 0,
29
+ "rows_not_8": 0,
30
+ "init_trunc_pct": 0.39,
31
+ "probe_trunc_pct": 1.8,
32
+ "trunc_loop_share": 0.0,
33
+ "init_none": 0,
34
+ "post_none_pct": 1.06,
35
+ "verdict": "OK",
36
+ "complete": true
37
+ },
38
+ "sa_causal_vllm_qwen3-4b_rerun.jsonl": {
39
+ "present": true,
40
+ "cap_probe": [
41
+ 2048
42
+ ],
43
+ "expected": 1800,
44
+ "rows": 1800,
45
+ "missing": 0,
46
+ "duplicates": 0,
47
+ "rows_not_8": 0,
48
+ "init_trunc_pct": 0.22,
49
+ "probe_trunc_pct": 0.07,
50
+ "trunc_loop_share": 0.0,
51
+ "init_none": 0,
52
+ "post_none_pct": 0.01,
53
+ "verdict": "OK",
54
+ "complete": true
55
+ },
56
+ "sa_causal_vllm_qwen3-8b_rerun.jsonl": {
57
+ "present": true,
58
+ "cap_probe": [
59
+ 2048
60
+ ],
61
+ "expected": 1800,
62
+ "rows": 1800,
63
+ "missing": 0,
64
+ "duplicates": 0,
65
+ "rows_not_8": 0,
66
+ "init_trunc_pct": 0.28,
67
+ "probe_trunc_pct": 1.18,
68
+ "trunc_loop_share": 0.0,
69
+ "init_none": 0,
70
+ "post_none_pct": 0.24,
71
+ "verdict": "OK",
72
+ "complete": true
73
+ },
74
+ "gate_default_vllm_llama-3.1-8b_s0.jsonl": {
75
+ "present": true,
76
+ "cap_probe": [
77
+ 2048
78
+ ],
79
+ "expected": 2685,
80
+ "rows": 2685,
81
+ "missing": 0,
82
+ "duplicates": 0,
83
+ "rows_not_8": 0,
84
+ "init_trunc_pct": 3.87,
85
+ "probe_trunc_pct": 12.77,
86
+ "trunc_loop_share": 0.0,
87
+ "init_none": 0,
88
+ "post_none_pct": 5.36,
89
+ "verdict": "OVER_2PCT",
90
+ "complete": true
91
+ },
92
+ "gate_default_vllm_llama-3.1-8b_s1.jsonl": {
93
+ "present": true,
94
+ "cap_probe": [
95
+ 2048
96
+ ],
97
+ "expected": 2685,
98
+ "rows": 2685,
99
+ "missing": 0,
100
+ "duplicates": 0,
101
+ "rows_not_8": 0,
102
+ "init_trunc_pct": 4.99,
103
+ "probe_trunc_pct": 15.82,
104
+ "trunc_loop_share": 0.0,
105
+ "init_none": 0,
106
+ "post_none_pct": 6.48,
107
+ "verdict": "OVER_2PCT",
108
+ "complete": true
109
+ },
110
+ "gate_default_vllm_phi-4-mini_s0.jsonl": {
111
+ "present": true,
112
+ "cap_probe": [
113
+ 2048
114
+ ],
115
+ "expected": 2943,
116
+ "rows": 2943,
117
+ "missing": 0,
118
+ "duplicates": 0,
119
+ "rows_not_8": 0,
120
+ "init_trunc_pct": 0.2,
121
+ "probe_trunc_pct": 1.06,
122
+ "trunc_loop_share": 0.0,
123
+ "init_none": 0,
124
+ "post_none_pct": 0.9,
125
+ "verdict": "OK",
126
+ "complete": true
127
+ },
128
+ "gate_default_vllm_phi-4-mini_s1.jsonl": {
129
+ "present": true,
130
+ "cap_probe": [
131
+ 2048
132
+ ],
133
+ "expected": 2940,
134
+ "rows": 2940,
135
+ "missing": 0,
136
+ "duplicates": 0,
137
+ "rows_not_8": 0,
138
+ "init_trunc_pct": 0.51,
139
+ "probe_trunc_pct": 2.4,
140
+ "trunc_loop_share": 0.0,
141
+ "init_none": 0,
142
+ "post_none_pct": 1.72,
143
+ "verdict": "OVER_2PCT",
144
+ "complete": true
145
+ },
146
+ "gate_default_vllm_qwen3-4b_s0.jsonl": {
147
+ "present": true,
148
+ "cap_probe": [
149
+ 2048
150
+ ],
151
+ "expected": 2943,
152
+ "rows": 2943,
153
+ "missing": 0,
154
+ "duplicates": 0,
155
+ "rows_not_8": 0,
156
+ "init_trunc_pct": 0.24,
157
+ "probe_trunc_pct": 0.17,
158
+ "trunc_loop_share": 0.0,
159
+ "init_none": 0,
160
+ "post_none_pct": 0.0,
161
+ "verdict": "OK",
162
+ "complete": true
163
+ },
164
+ "gate_default_vllm_qwen3-4b_s1.jsonl": {
165
+ "present": true,
166
+ "cap_probe": [
167
+ 2048
168
+ ],
169
+ "expected": 2940,
170
+ "rows": 2939,
171
+ "missing": 1,
172
+ "duplicates": 0,
173
+ "rows_not_8": 0,
174
+ "init_trunc_pct": 0.31,
175
+ "probe_trunc_pct": 0.26,
176
+ "trunc_loop_share": 0.0,
177
+ "init_none": 0,
178
+ "post_none_pct": 0.03,
179
+ "verdict": "OK",
180
+ "complete": true
181
+ }
182
+ }
abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_default_vllm_llama-3.1-8b_s0.jsonl ADDED
The diff for this file is too large to render. See raw diff
 
abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_default_vllm_llama-3.1-8b_s1.jsonl ADDED
The diff for this file is too large to render. See raw diff
 
abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_default_vllm_phi-4-mini_s0.jsonl ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
2
+ oid sha256:259780dd157d1a5fd6b1dce21d6e5b48080947aeb0d7017acf1c83104334733b
3
+ size 10753798
abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_default_vllm_phi-4-mini_s1.jsonl ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
2
+ oid sha256:e3c3f0751e290f20d6baa882999feb50d3d7c880c4c5c44517567f6369066d52
3
+ size 10754344
abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_default_vllm_qwen3-4b_s0.jsonl ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
2
+ oid sha256:0cf8673f92e40fecce002e0966ddffd990a8e27b0e872a6da363447b4726cef4
3
+ size 10702553
abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_default_vllm_qwen3-4b_s1.jsonl ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
 
 
 
 
1
+ version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
2
+ oid sha256:86924421edded2ca56750d3c49980c07350ac3f7c478d449484cc5594c887b5a
3
+ size 10693677
abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_lomo_drop.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,725 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "selftest": false,
3
+ "notes": "Probe-gated freeze with leave-one-model-out selection on the archived local-model debates (zero API).\nThe scripts and probe inputs of the original pilot were not retained. This re-implements the pilot rule on newly\ncollected probe scores (abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/); it is a post-hoc reconstruction, not a reproduction of the pilot.\n\nRules of the original pilot: tau in {0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.3,0.4,0.5,0.6,0.7}; mode in {freeze_initial, freeze_if_stable}; for each held-out\nmodel, (tau*, mode*) maximizes net = prevented - lost on the other models; then frozen and applied to the held-out model.\nChoices the original pilot does not record (made here):\n * classifier: logistic regression of `collapsed` on per-debate probe features (mean, max, min of the three agents'\n default-condition 8-probe flip rate on that question), fitted on the training models; the gate fires when p >= tau.\n * freeze_initial: when the gate fires, the debate returns its initial majority.\n * freeze_if_stable: when the gate fires, an agent whose Round-1 answer equals its initial answer keeps its initial answer;\n the other agents keep their final answers; the majority is recomputed (unparsed answers dropped, ties alphabetical).\nOutputs per held-out model: tau*, mode*, gate%, prevented, lost, net, delta-acc (pp) with a debate-bootstrap 95% CI, and the\noracle delta-acc (best tau/mode chosen on the held-out model itself); pooled totals; weight ladder (r * prevented - lost) / n.",
4
+ "variants": {
5
+ "e5_rule": {
6
+ "per_model": {
7
+ "llama-3.1-8b": {
8
+ "n": 2003,
9
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
10
+ "tau": 0.1,
11
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
12
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
13
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5132,
14
+ "prevented": 0,
15
+ "lost": 0,
16
+ "other_net": 0,
17
+ "net": 0,
18
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
19
+ "ci95": [
20
+ 0.0,
21
+ 0.0
22
+ ],
23
+ "oracle": {
24
+ "tau": 0.05,
25
+ "mode": "freeze_if_stable",
26
+ "dacc_pp": 0.3
27
+ }
28
+ },
29
+ "phi-4-mini": {
30
+ "n": 2161,
31
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
32
+ "tau": 0.1,
33
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
34
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
35
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5349,
36
+ "prevented": 0,
37
+ "lost": 0,
38
+ "other_net": 0,
39
+ "net": 0,
40
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
41
+ "ci95": [
42
+ 0.0,
43
+ 0.0
44
+ ],
45
+ "oracle": {
46
+ "tau": 0.1,
47
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
48
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
49
+ }
50
+ },
51
+ "qwen3-4b": {
52
+ "n": 2161,
53
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
54
+ "tau": 0.1,
55
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
56
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
57
+ "baseline_acc": 0.6432,
58
+ "prevented": 0,
59
+ "lost": 0,
60
+ "other_net": 0,
61
+ "net": 0,
62
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
63
+ "ci95": [
64
+ 0.0,
65
+ 0.0
66
+ ],
67
+ "oracle": {
68
+ "tau": 0.1,
69
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
70
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
71
+ }
72
+ },
73
+ "qwen3-8b": {
74
+ "n": 200,
75
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
76
+ "tau": 0.1,
77
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
78
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
79
+ "baseline_acc": 0.62,
80
+ "prevented": 0,
81
+ "lost": 0,
82
+ "other_net": 0,
83
+ "net": 0,
84
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
85
+ "ci95": [
86
+ 0.0,
87
+ 0.0
88
+ ],
89
+ "oracle": {
90
+ "tau": 0.1,
91
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
92
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
93
+ }
94
+ }
95
+ },
96
+ "pooled": {
97
+ "n": 6525,
98
+ "prevented": 0,
99
+ "lost": 0,
100
+ "net": 0,
101
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
102
+ "ci95": [
103
+ 0.0,
104
+ 0.0
105
+ ],
106
+ "weight_ladder_pp": {
107
+ "0.5": 0.0,
108
+ "1": 0.0,
109
+ "2": 0.0,
110
+ "4": 0.0,
111
+ "8": 0.0
112
+ },
113
+ "break_even_r": null
114
+ }
115
+ },
116
+ "freeze_initial_only": {
117
+ "per_model": {
118
+ "llama-3.1-8b": {
119
+ "n": 2003,
120
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
121
+ "tau": 0.1,
122
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
123
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
124
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5132,
125
+ "prevented": 0,
126
+ "lost": 0,
127
+ "other_net": 0,
128
+ "net": 0,
129
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
130
+ "ci95": [
131
+ 0.0,
132
+ 0.0
133
+ ],
134
+ "oracle": {
135
+ "tau": 0.1,
136
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
137
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
138
+ }
139
+ },
140
+ "phi-4-mini": {
141
+ "n": 2161,
142
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
143
+ "tau": 0.1,
144
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
145
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
146
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5349,
147
+ "prevented": 0,
148
+ "lost": 0,
149
+ "other_net": 0,
150
+ "net": 0,
151
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
152
+ "ci95": [
153
+ 0.0,
154
+ 0.0
155
+ ],
156
+ "oracle": {
157
+ "tau": 0.1,
158
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
159
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
160
+ }
161
+ },
162
+ "qwen3-4b": {
163
+ "n": 2161,
164
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
165
+ "tau": 0.1,
166
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
167
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
168
+ "baseline_acc": 0.6432,
169
+ "prevented": 0,
170
+ "lost": 0,
171
+ "other_net": 0,
172
+ "net": 0,
173
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
174
+ "ci95": [
175
+ 0.0,
176
+ 0.0
177
+ ],
178
+ "oracle": {
179
+ "tau": 0.1,
180
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
181
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
182
+ }
183
+ },
184
+ "qwen3-8b": {
185
+ "n": 200,
186
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
187
+ "tau": 0.1,
188
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
189
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
190
+ "baseline_acc": 0.62,
191
+ "prevented": 0,
192
+ "lost": 0,
193
+ "other_net": 0,
194
+ "net": 0,
195
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
196
+ "ci95": [
197
+ 0.0,
198
+ 0.0
199
+ ],
200
+ "oracle": {
201
+ "tau": 0.1,
202
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
203
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
204
+ }
205
+ }
206
+ },
207
+ "pooled": {
208
+ "n": 6525,
209
+ "prevented": 0,
210
+ "lost": 0,
211
+ "net": 0,
212
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
213
+ "ci95": [
214
+ 0.0,
215
+ 0.0
216
+ ],
217
+ "weight_ladder_pp": {
218
+ "0.5": 0.0,
219
+ "1": 0.0,
220
+ "2": 0.0,
221
+ "4": 0.0,
222
+ "8": 0.0
223
+ },
224
+ "break_even_r": null
225
+ }
226
+ },
227
+ "nested_lomo": {
228
+ "per_model": {
229
+ "llama-3.1-8b": {
230
+ "n": 2003,
231
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
232
+ "tau": 0.1,
233
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
234
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
235
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5132,
236
+ "prevented": 0,
237
+ "lost": 0,
238
+ "other_net": 0,
239
+ "net": 0,
240
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
241
+ "ci95": [
242
+ 0.0,
243
+ 0.0
244
+ ],
245
+ "oracle": {
246
+ "tau": 0.05,
247
+ "mode": "freeze_if_stable",
248
+ "dacc_pp": 0.3
249
+ }
250
+ },
251
+ "phi-4-mini": {
252
+ "n": 2161,
253
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
254
+ "tau": 0.1,
255
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
256
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
257
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5349,
258
+ "prevented": 0,
259
+ "lost": 0,
260
+ "other_net": 0,
261
+ "net": 0,
262
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
263
+ "ci95": [
264
+ 0.0,
265
+ 0.0
266
+ ],
267
+ "oracle": {
268
+ "tau": 0.1,
269
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
270
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
271
+ }
272
+ },
273
+ "qwen3-4b": {
274
+ "n": 2161,
275
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
276
+ "tau": 0.05,
277
+ "mode": "freeze_if_stable",
278
+ "gate_pct": 31.79,
279
+ "baseline_acc": 0.6432,
280
+ "prevented": 8,
281
+ "lost": 41,
282
+ "other_net": 1,
283
+ "net": -32,
284
+ "dacc_pp": -1.481,
285
+ "ci95": [
286
+ -2.129,
287
+ -0.833
288
+ ],
289
+ "oracle": {
290
+ "tau": 0.1,
291
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
292
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
293
+ }
294
+ },
295
+ "qwen3-8b": {
296
+ "n": 200,
297
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
298
+ "tau": 0.1,
299
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
300
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
301
+ "baseline_acc": 0.62,
302
+ "prevented": 0,
303
+ "lost": 0,
304
+ "other_net": 0,
305
+ "net": 0,
306
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
307
+ "ci95": [
308
+ 0.0,
309
+ 0.0
310
+ ],
311
+ "oracle": {
312
+ "tau": 0.1,
313
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
314
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
315
+ }
316
+ }
317
+ },
318
+ "pooled": {
319
+ "n": 6525,
320
+ "prevented": 8,
321
+ "lost": 41,
322
+ "net": -32,
323
+ "dacc_pp": -0.49,
324
+ "ci95": [
325
+ -0.705,
326
+ -0.29
327
+ ],
328
+ "weight_ladder_pp": {
329
+ "0.5": -0.567,
330
+ "1": -0.506,
331
+ "2": -0.383,
332
+ "4": -0.138,
333
+ "8": 0.352
334
+ },
335
+ "break_even_r": 5.125
336
+ }
337
+ },
338
+ "with_noop": {
339
+ "per_model": {
340
+ "llama-3.1-8b": {
341
+ "n": 2003,
342
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
343
+ "tau": null,
344
+ "mode": "no_op",
345
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
346
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5132,
347
+ "prevented": 0,
348
+ "lost": 0,
349
+ "other_net": 0,
350
+ "net": 0,
351
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
352
+ "ci95": [
353
+ 0.0,
354
+ 0.0
355
+ ],
356
+ "oracle": {
357
+ "tau": 0.05,
358
+ "mode": "freeze_if_stable",
359
+ "dacc_pp": 0.3
360
+ }
361
+ },
362
+ "phi-4-mini": {
363
+ "n": 2161,
364
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
365
+ "tau": null,
366
+ "mode": "no_op",
367
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
368
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5349,
369
+ "prevented": 0,
370
+ "lost": 0,
371
+ "other_net": 0,
372
+ "net": 0,
373
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
374
+ "ci95": [
375
+ 0.0,
376
+ 0.0
377
+ ],
378
+ "oracle": {
379
+ "tau": 0.1,
380
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
381
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
382
+ }
383
+ },
384
+ "qwen3-4b": {
385
+ "n": 2161,
386
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
387
+ "tau": null,
388
+ "mode": "no_op",
389
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
390
+ "baseline_acc": 0.6432,
391
+ "prevented": 0,
392
+ "lost": 0,
393
+ "other_net": 0,
394
+ "net": 0,
395
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
396
+ "ci95": [
397
+ 0.0,
398
+ 0.0
399
+ ],
400
+ "oracle": {
401
+ "tau": 0.1,
402
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
403
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
404
+ }
405
+ },
406
+ "qwen3-8b": {
407
+ "n": 200,
408
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
409
+ "tau": null,
410
+ "mode": "no_op",
411
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
412
+ "baseline_acc": 0.62,
413
+ "prevented": 0,
414
+ "lost": 0,
415
+ "other_net": 0,
416
+ "net": 0,
417
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
418
+ "ci95": [
419
+ 0.0,
420
+ 0.0
421
+ ],
422
+ "oracle": {
423
+ "tau": 0.1,
424
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
425
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
426
+ }
427
+ }
428
+ },
429
+ "pooled": {
430
+ "n": 6525,
431
+ "prevented": 0,
432
+ "lost": 0,
433
+ "net": 0,
434
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
435
+ "ci95": [
436
+ 0.0,
437
+ 0.0
438
+ ],
439
+ "weight_ladder_pp": {
440
+ "0.5": 0.0,
441
+ "1": 0.0,
442
+ "2": 0.0,
443
+ "4": 0.0,
444
+ "8": 0.0
445
+ },
446
+ "break_even_r": null
447
+ }
448
+ },
449
+ "always_freeze": {
450
+ "per_model": {
451
+ "llama-3.1-8b": {
452
+ "n": 2003,
453
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
454
+ "tau": null,
455
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
456
+ "gate_pct": 100.0,
457
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5132,
458
+ "prevented": 86,
459
+ "lost": 98,
460
+ "other_net": 0,
461
+ "net": -12,
462
+ "dacc_pp": -0.599,
463
+ "ci95": [
464
+ -1.898,
465
+ 0.75
466
+ ]
467
+ },
468
+ "phi-4-mini": {
469
+ "n": 2161,
470
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
471
+ "tau": null,
472
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
473
+ "gate_pct": 100.0,
474
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5349,
475
+ "prevented": 112,
476
+ "lost": 174,
477
+ "other_net": 0,
478
+ "net": -62,
479
+ "dacc_pp": -2.869,
480
+ "ci95": [
481
+ -4.396,
482
+ -1.296
483
+ ]
484
+ },
485
+ "qwen3-4b": {
486
+ "n": 2161,
487
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
488
+ "tau": null,
489
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
490
+ "gate_pct": 100.0,
491
+ "baseline_acc": 0.6432,
492
+ "prevented": 50,
493
+ "lost": 461,
494
+ "other_net": 0,
495
+ "net": -411,
496
+ "dacc_pp": -19.019,
497
+ "ci95": [
498
+ -20.916,
499
+ -17.075
500
+ ]
501
+ },
502
+ "qwen3-8b": {
503
+ "n": 200,
504
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
505
+ "tau": null,
506
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
507
+ "gate_pct": 100.0,
508
+ "baseline_acc": 0.62,
509
+ "prevented": 3,
510
+ "lost": 71,
511
+ "other_net": 0,
512
+ "net": -68,
513
+ "dacc_pp": -34.0,
514
+ "ci95": [
515
+ -41.0,
516
+ -27.0
517
+ ]
518
+ }
519
+ },
520
+ "pooled": {
521
+ "n": 6525,
522
+ "prevented": 251,
523
+ "lost": 804,
524
+ "net": -553,
525
+ "dacc_pp": -8.475,
526
+ "ci95": [
527
+ -9.484,
528
+ -7.484
529
+ ],
530
+ "weight_ladder_pp": {
531
+ "0.5": -10.398,
532
+ "1": -8.475,
533
+ "2": -4.628,
534
+ "4": 3.065,
535
+ "8": 18.452
536
+ },
537
+ "break_even_r": 3.203
538
+ }
539
+ },
540
+ "raw_fr_gate": {
541
+ "per_model": {
542
+ "llama-3.1-8b": {
543
+ "n": 2003,
544
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
545
+ "tau": 0.7,
546
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
547
+ "gate_pct": 51.42,
548
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5132,
549
+ "prevented": 56,
550
+ "lost": 61,
551
+ "other_net": 0,
552
+ "net": -5,
553
+ "dacc_pp": -0.25,
554
+ "ci95": [
555
+ -1.295,
556
+ 0.8
557
+ ]
558
+ },
559
+ "phi-4-mini": {
560
+ "n": 2161,
561
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
562
+ "tau": 0.7,
563
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
564
+ "gate_pct": 18.65,
565
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5349,
566
+ "prevented": 21,
567
+ "lost": 47,
568
+ "other_net": 0,
569
+ "net": -26,
570
+ "dacc_pp": -1.203,
571
+ "ci95": [
572
+ -1.99,
573
+ -0.508
574
+ ]
575
+ },
576
+ "qwen3-4b": {
577
+ "n": 2161,
578
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
579
+ "tau": 0.7,
580
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
581
+ "gate_pct": 37.02,
582
+ "baseline_acc": 0.6432,
583
+ "prevented": 29,
584
+ "lost": 187,
585
+ "other_net": 0,
586
+ "net": -158,
587
+ "dacc_pp": -7.311,
588
+ "ci95": [
589
+ -8.562,
590
+ -6.015
591
+ ]
592
+ },
593
+ "qwen3-8b": {
594
+ "n": 200,
595
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
596
+ "tau": 0.7,
597
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
598
+ "gate_pct": 12.5,
599
+ "baseline_acc": 0.62,
600
+ "prevented": 2,
601
+ "lost": 2,
602
+ "other_net": 0,
603
+ "net": 0,
604
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
605
+ "ci95": [
606
+ -2.0,
607
+ 2.0
608
+ ]
609
+ }
610
+ },
611
+ "pooled": {
612
+ "n": 6525,
613
+ "prevented": 108,
614
+ "lost": 297,
615
+ "net": -189,
616
+ "dacc_pp": -2.897,
617
+ "ci95": [
618
+ -3.496,
619
+ -2.336
620
+ ],
621
+ "weight_ladder_pp": {
622
+ "0.5": -3.724,
623
+ "1": -2.897,
624
+ "2": -1.241,
625
+ "4": 2.069,
626
+ "8": 8.69
627
+ },
628
+ "break_even_r": 2.75
629
+ }
630
+ },
631
+ "random_same_rate": {
632
+ "per_model": {
633
+ "llama-3.1-8b": {
634
+ "n": 2003,
635
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
636
+ "tau": null,
637
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
638
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
639
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5132,
640
+ "prevented": 0,
641
+ "lost": 0,
642
+ "other_net": 0,
643
+ "net": 0,
644
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
645
+ "ci95": [
646
+ 0.0,
647
+ 0.0
648
+ ]
649
+ },
650
+ "phi-4-mini": {
651
+ "n": 2161,
652
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
653
+ "tau": null,
654
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
655
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
656
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5349,
657
+ "prevented": 0,
658
+ "lost": 0,
659
+ "other_net": 0,
660
+ "net": 0,
661
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
662
+ "ci95": [
663
+ 0.0,
664
+ 0.0
665
+ ]
666
+ },
667
+ "qwen3-4b": {
668
+ "n": 2161,
669
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
670
+ "tau": null,
671
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
672
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
673
+ "baseline_acc": 0.6432,
674
+ "prevented": 0,
675
+ "lost": 0,
676
+ "other_net": 0,
677
+ "net": 0,
678
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
679
+ "ci95": [
680
+ 0.0,
681
+ 0.0
682
+ ]
683
+ },
684
+ "qwen3-8b": {
685
+ "n": 200,
686
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
687
+ "tau": null,
688
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
689
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
690
+ "baseline_acc": 0.62,
691
+ "prevented": 0,
692
+ "lost": 0,
693
+ "other_net": 0,
694
+ "net": 0,
695
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
696
+ "ci95": [
697
+ 0.0,
698
+ 0.0
699
+ ]
700
+ }
701
+ },
702
+ "pooled": {
703
+ "n": 6525,
704
+ "prevented": 0,
705
+ "lost": 0,
706
+ "net": 0,
707
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
708
+ "ci95": [
709
+ 0.0,
710
+ 0.0
711
+ ],
712
+ "weight_ladder_pp": {
713
+ "0.5": 0.0,
714
+ "1": 0.0,
715
+ "2": 0.0,
716
+ "4": 0.0,
717
+ "8": 0.0
718
+ },
719
+ "break_even_r": null
720
+ }
721
+ }
722
+ },
723
+ "none_mode": "drop",
724
+ "probes_dir": "abc_exp/results/gate_rerun"
725
+ }
abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_lomo_flip.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,725 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "selftest": false,
3
+ "notes": "Probe-gated freeze with leave-one-model-out selection on the archived local-model debates (zero API).\nThe scripts and probe inputs of the original pilot were not retained. This re-implements the pilot rule on newly\ncollected probe scores (abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/); it is a post-hoc reconstruction, not a reproduction of the pilot.\n\nRules of the original pilot: tau in {0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.3,0.4,0.5,0.6,0.7}; mode in {freeze_initial, freeze_if_stable}; for each held-out\nmodel, (tau*, mode*) maximizes net = prevented - lost on the other models; then frozen and applied to the held-out model.\nChoices the original pilot does not record (made here):\n * classifier: logistic regression of `collapsed` on per-debate probe features (mean, max, min of the three agents'\n default-condition 8-probe flip rate on that question), fitted on the training models; the gate fires when p >= tau.\n * freeze_initial: when the gate fires, the debate returns its initial majority.\n * freeze_if_stable: when the gate fires, an agent whose Round-1 answer equals its initial answer keeps its initial answer;\n the other agents keep their final answers; the majority is recomputed (unparsed answers dropped, ties alphabetical).\nOutputs per held-out model: tau*, mode*, gate%, prevented, lost, net, delta-acc (pp) with a debate-bootstrap 95% CI, and the\noracle delta-acc (best tau/mode chosen on the held-out model itself); pooled totals; weight ladder (r * prevented - lost) / n.",
4
+ "variants": {
5
+ "e5_rule": {
6
+ "per_model": {
7
+ "llama-3.1-8b": {
8
+ "n": 2003,
9
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
10
+ "tau": 0.1,
11
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
12
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
13
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5132,
14
+ "prevented": 0,
15
+ "lost": 0,
16
+ "other_net": 0,
17
+ "net": 0,
18
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
19
+ "ci95": [
20
+ 0.0,
21
+ 0.0
22
+ ],
23
+ "oracle": {
24
+ "tau": 0.05,
25
+ "mode": "freeze_if_stable",
26
+ "dacc_pp": 0.2
27
+ }
28
+ },
29
+ "phi-4-mini": {
30
+ "n": 2161,
31
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
32
+ "tau": 0.1,
33
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
34
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
35
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5349,
36
+ "prevented": 0,
37
+ "lost": 0,
38
+ "other_net": 0,
39
+ "net": 0,
40
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
41
+ "ci95": [
42
+ 0.0,
43
+ 0.0
44
+ ],
45
+ "oracle": {
46
+ "tau": 0.1,
47
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
48
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
49
+ }
50
+ },
51
+ "qwen3-4b": {
52
+ "n": 2161,
53
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
54
+ "tau": 0.1,
55
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
56
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
57
+ "baseline_acc": 0.6432,
58
+ "prevented": 0,
59
+ "lost": 0,
60
+ "other_net": 0,
61
+ "net": 0,
62
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
63
+ "ci95": [
64
+ 0.0,
65
+ 0.0
66
+ ],
67
+ "oracle": {
68
+ "tau": 0.1,
69
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
70
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
71
+ }
72
+ },
73
+ "qwen3-8b": {
74
+ "n": 200,
75
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
76
+ "tau": 0.1,
77
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
78
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
79
+ "baseline_acc": 0.62,
80
+ "prevented": 0,
81
+ "lost": 0,
82
+ "other_net": 0,
83
+ "net": 0,
84
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
85
+ "ci95": [
86
+ 0.0,
87
+ 0.0
88
+ ],
89
+ "oracle": {
90
+ "tau": 0.1,
91
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
92
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
93
+ }
94
+ }
95
+ },
96
+ "pooled": {
97
+ "n": 6525,
98
+ "prevented": 0,
99
+ "lost": 0,
100
+ "net": 0,
101
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
102
+ "ci95": [
103
+ 0.0,
104
+ 0.0
105
+ ],
106
+ "weight_ladder_pp": {
107
+ "0.5": 0.0,
108
+ "1": 0.0,
109
+ "2": 0.0,
110
+ "4": 0.0,
111
+ "8": 0.0
112
+ },
113
+ "break_even_r": null
114
+ }
115
+ },
116
+ "freeze_initial_only": {
117
+ "per_model": {
118
+ "llama-3.1-8b": {
119
+ "n": 2003,
120
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
121
+ "tau": 0.1,
122
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
123
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
124
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5132,
125
+ "prevented": 0,
126
+ "lost": 0,
127
+ "other_net": 0,
128
+ "net": 0,
129
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
130
+ "ci95": [
131
+ 0.0,
132
+ 0.0
133
+ ],
134
+ "oracle": {
135
+ "tau": 0.1,
136
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
137
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
138
+ }
139
+ },
140
+ "phi-4-mini": {
141
+ "n": 2161,
142
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
143
+ "tau": 0.1,
144
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
145
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
146
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5349,
147
+ "prevented": 0,
148
+ "lost": 0,
149
+ "other_net": 0,
150
+ "net": 0,
151
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
152
+ "ci95": [
153
+ 0.0,
154
+ 0.0
155
+ ],
156
+ "oracle": {
157
+ "tau": 0.1,
158
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
159
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
160
+ }
161
+ },
162
+ "qwen3-4b": {
163
+ "n": 2161,
164
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
165
+ "tau": 0.1,
166
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
167
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
168
+ "baseline_acc": 0.6432,
169
+ "prevented": 0,
170
+ "lost": 0,
171
+ "other_net": 0,
172
+ "net": 0,
173
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
174
+ "ci95": [
175
+ 0.0,
176
+ 0.0
177
+ ],
178
+ "oracle": {
179
+ "tau": 0.1,
180
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
181
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
182
+ }
183
+ },
184
+ "qwen3-8b": {
185
+ "n": 200,
186
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
187
+ "tau": 0.1,
188
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
189
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
190
+ "baseline_acc": 0.62,
191
+ "prevented": 0,
192
+ "lost": 0,
193
+ "other_net": 0,
194
+ "net": 0,
195
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
196
+ "ci95": [
197
+ 0.0,
198
+ 0.0
199
+ ],
200
+ "oracle": {
201
+ "tau": 0.1,
202
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
203
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
204
+ }
205
+ }
206
+ },
207
+ "pooled": {
208
+ "n": 6525,
209
+ "prevented": 0,
210
+ "lost": 0,
211
+ "net": 0,
212
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
213
+ "ci95": [
214
+ 0.0,
215
+ 0.0
216
+ ],
217
+ "weight_ladder_pp": {
218
+ "0.5": 0.0,
219
+ "1": 0.0,
220
+ "2": 0.0,
221
+ "4": 0.0,
222
+ "8": 0.0
223
+ },
224
+ "break_even_r": null
225
+ }
226
+ },
227
+ "nested_lomo": {
228
+ "per_model": {
229
+ "llama-3.1-8b": {
230
+ "n": 2003,
231
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
232
+ "tau": 0.1,
233
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
234
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
235
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5132,
236
+ "prevented": 0,
237
+ "lost": 0,
238
+ "other_net": 0,
239
+ "net": 0,
240
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
241
+ "ci95": [
242
+ 0.0,
243
+ 0.0
244
+ ],
245
+ "oracle": {
246
+ "tau": 0.05,
247
+ "mode": "freeze_if_stable",
248
+ "dacc_pp": 0.2
249
+ }
250
+ },
251
+ "phi-4-mini": {
252
+ "n": 2161,
253
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
254
+ "tau": 0.1,
255
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
256
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
257
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5349,
258
+ "prevented": 0,
259
+ "lost": 0,
260
+ "other_net": 0,
261
+ "net": 0,
262
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
263
+ "ci95": [
264
+ 0.0,
265
+ 0.0
266
+ ],
267
+ "oracle": {
268
+ "tau": 0.1,
269
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
270
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
271
+ }
272
+ },
273
+ "qwen3-4b": {
274
+ "n": 2161,
275
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
276
+ "tau": 0.05,
277
+ "mode": "freeze_if_stable",
278
+ "gate_pct": 24.43,
279
+ "baseline_acc": 0.6432,
280
+ "prevented": 7,
281
+ "lost": 31,
282
+ "other_net": 1,
283
+ "net": -23,
284
+ "dacc_pp": -1.064,
285
+ "ci95": [
286
+ -1.621,
287
+ -0.509
288
+ ],
289
+ "oracle": {
290
+ "tau": 0.1,
291
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
292
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
293
+ }
294
+ },
295
+ "qwen3-8b": {
296
+ "n": 200,
297
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
298
+ "tau": 0.1,
299
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
300
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
301
+ "baseline_acc": 0.62,
302
+ "prevented": 0,
303
+ "lost": 0,
304
+ "other_net": 0,
305
+ "net": 0,
306
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
307
+ "ci95": [
308
+ 0.0,
309
+ 0.0
310
+ ],
311
+ "oracle": {
312
+ "tau": 0.1,
313
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
314
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
315
+ }
316
+ }
317
+ },
318
+ "pooled": {
319
+ "n": 6525,
320
+ "prevented": 7,
321
+ "lost": 31,
322
+ "net": -23,
323
+ "dacc_pp": -0.352,
324
+ "ci95": [
325
+ -0.536,
326
+ -0.168
327
+ ],
328
+ "weight_ladder_pp": {
329
+ "0.5": -0.421,
330
+ "1": -0.368,
331
+ "2": -0.261,
332
+ "4": -0.046,
333
+ "8": 0.383
334
+ },
335
+ "break_even_r": 4.429
336
+ }
337
+ },
338
+ "with_noop": {
339
+ "per_model": {
340
+ "llama-3.1-8b": {
341
+ "n": 2003,
342
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
343
+ "tau": null,
344
+ "mode": "no_op",
345
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
346
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5132,
347
+ "prevented": 0,
348
+ "lost": 0,
349
+ "other_net": 0,
350
+ "net": 0,
351
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
352
+ "ci95": [
353
+ 0.0,
354
+ 0.0
355
+ ],
356
+ "oracle": {
357
+ "tau": 0.05,
358
+ "mode": "freeze_if_stable",
359
+ "dacc_pp": 0.2
360
+ }
361
+ },
362
+ "phi-4-mini": {
363
+ "n": 2161,
364
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
365
+ "tau": null,
366
+ "mode": "no_op",
367
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
368
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5349,
369
+ "prevented": 0,
370
+ "lost": 0,
371
+ "other_net": 0,
372
+ "net": 0,
373
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
374
+ "ci95": [
375
+ 0.0,
376
+ 0.0
377
+ ],
378
+ "oracle": {
379
+ "tau": 0.1,
380
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
381
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
382
+ }
383
+ },
384
+ "qwen3-4b": {
385
+ "n": 2161,
386
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
387
+ "tau": null,
388
+ "mode": "no_op",
389
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
390
+ "baseline_acc": 0.6432,
391
+ "prevented": 0,
392
+ "lost": 0,
393
+ "other_net": 0,
394
+ "net": 0,
395
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
396
+ "ci95": [
397
+ 0.0,
398
+ 0.0
399
+ ],
400
+ "oracle": {
401
+ "tau": 0.1,
402
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
403
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
404
+ }
405
+ },
406
+ "qwen3-8b": {
407
+ "n": 200,
408
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
409
+ "tau": null,
410
+ "mode": "no_op",
411
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
412
+ "baseline_acc": 0.62,
413
+ "prevented": 0,
414
+ "lost": 0,
415
+ "other_net": 0,
416
+ "net": 0,
417
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
418
+ "ci95": [
419
+ 0.0,
420
+ 0.0
421
+ ],
422
+ "oracle": {
423
+ "tau": 0.1,
424
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
425
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
426
+ }
427
+ }
428
+ },
429
+ "pooled": {
430
+ "n": 6525,
431
+ "prevented": 0,
432
+ "lost": 0,
433
+ "net": 0,
434
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
435
+ "ci95": [
436
+ 0.0,
437
+ 0.0
438
+ ],
439
+ "weight_ladder_pp": {
440
+ "0.5": 0.0,
441
+ "1": 0.0,
442
+ "2": 0.0,
443
+ "4": 0.0,
444
+ "8": 0.0
445
+ },
446
+ "break_even_r": null
447
+ }
448
+ },
449
+ "always_freeze": {
450
+ "per_model": {
451
+ "llama-3.1-8b": {
452
+ "n": 2003,
453
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
454
+ "tau": null,
455
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
456
+ "gate_pct": 100.0,
457
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5132,
458
+ "prevented": 86,
459
+ "lost": 98,
460
+ "other_net": 0,
461
+ "net": -12,
462
+ "dacc_pp": -0.599,
463
+ "ci95": [
464
+ -1.898,
465
+ 0.75
466
+ ]
467
+ },
468
+ "phi-4-mini": {
469
+ "n": 2161,
470
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
471
+ "tau": null,
472
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
473
+ "gate_pct": 100.0,
474
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5349,
475
+ "prevented": 112,
476
+ "lost": 174,
477
+ "other_net": 0,
478
+ "net": -62,
479
+ "dacc_pp": -2.869,
480
+ "ci95": [
481
+ -4.396,
482
+ -1.296
483
+ ]
484
+ },
485
+ "qwen3-4b": {
486
+ "n": 2161,
487
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
488
+ "tau": null,
489
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
490
+ "gate_pct": 100.0,
491
+ "baseline_acc": 0.6432,
492
+ "prevented": 50,
493
+ "lost": 461,
494
+ "other_net": 0,
495
+ "net": -411,
496
+ "dacc_pp": -19.019,
497
+ "ci95": [
498
+ -20.916,
499
+ -17.075
500
+ ]
501
+ },
502
+ "qwen3-8b": {
503
+ "n": 200,
504
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
505
+ "tau": null,
506
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
507
+ "gate_pct": 100.0,
508
+ "baseline_acc": 0.62,
509
+ "prevented": 3,
510
+ "lost": 71,
511
+ "other_net": 0,
512
+ "net": -68,
513
+ "dacc_pp": -34.0,
514
+ "ci95": [
515
+ -41.0,
516
+ -27.0
517
+ ]
518
+ }
519
+ },
520
+ "pooled": {
521
+ "n": 6525,
522
+ "prevented": 251,
523
+ "lost": 804,
524
+ "net": -553,
525
+ "dacc_pp": -8.475,
526
+ "ci95": [
527
+ -9.484,
528
+ -7.484
529
+ ],
530
+ "weight_ladder_pp": {
531
+ "0.5": -10.398,
532
+ "1": -8.475,
533
+ "2": -4.628,
534
+ "4": 3.065,
535
+ "8": 18.452
536
+ },
537
+ "break_even_r": 3.203
538
+ }
539
+ },
540
+ "raw_fr_gate": {
541
+ "per_model": {
542
+ "llama-3.1-8b": {
543
+ "n": 2003,
544
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
545
+ "tau": 0.7,
546
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
547
+ "gate_pct": 54.37,
548
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5132,
549
+ "prevented": 60,
550
+ "lost": 71,
551
+ "other_net": 0,
552
+ "net": -11,
553
+ "dacc_pp": -0.549,
554
+ "ci95": [
555
+ -1.643,
556
+ 0.598
557
+ ]
558
+ },
559
+ "phi-4-mini": {
560
+ "n": 2161,
561
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
562
+ "tau": 0.7,
563
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
564
+ "gate_pct": 19.76,
565
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5349,
566
+ "prevented": 24,
567
+ "lost": 49,
568
+ "other_net": 0,
569
+ "net": -25,
570
+ "dacc_pp": -1.157,
571
+ "ci95": [
572
+ -1.944,
573
+ -0.37
574
+ ]
575
+ },
576
+ "qwen3-4b": {
577
+ "n": 2161,
578
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
579
+ "tau": 0.7,
580
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
581
+ "gate_pct": 37.02,
582
+ "baseline_acc": 0.6432,
583
+ "prevented": 29,
584
+ "lost": 187,
585
+ "other_net": 0,
586
+ "net": -158,
587
+ "dacc_pp": -7.311,
588
+ "ci95": [
589
+ -8.562,
590
+ -6.015
591
+ ]
592
+ },
593
+ "qwen3-8b": {
594
+ "n": 200,
595
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
596
+ "tau": 0.7,
597
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
598
+ "gate_pct": 12.5,
599
+ "baseline_acc": 0.62,
600
+ "prevented": 2,
601
+ "lost": 2,
602
+ "other_net": 0,
603
+ "net": 0,
604
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
605
+ "ci95": [
606
+ -2.0,
607
+ 2.0
608
+ ]
609
+ }
610
+ },
611
+ "pooled": {
612
+ "n": 6525,
613
+ "prevented": 115,
614
+ "lost": 309,
615
+ "net": -194,
616
+ "dacc_pp": -2.973,
617
+ "ci95": [
618
+ -3.587,
619
+ -2.37
620
+ ],
621
+ "weight_ladder_pp": {
622
+ "0.5": -3.854,
623
+ "1": -2.973,
624
+ "2": -1.211,
625
+ "4": 2.314,
626
+ "8": 9.364
627
+ },
628
+ "break_even_r": 2.687
629
+ }
630
+ },
631
+ "random_same_rate": {
632
+ "per_model": {
633
+ "llama-3.1-8b": {
634
+ "n": 2003,
635
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
636
+ "tau": null,
637
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
638
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
639
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5132,
640
+ "prevented": 0,
641
+ "lost": 0,
642
+ "other_net": 0,
643
+ "net": 0,
644
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
645
+ "ci95": [
646
+ 0.0,
647
+ 0.0
648
+ ]
649
+ },
650
+ "phi-4-mini": {
651
+ "n": 2161,
652
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
653
+ "tau": null,
654
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
655
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
656
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5349,
657
+ "prevented": 0,
658
+ "lost": 0,
659
+ "other_net": 0,
660
+ "net": 0,
661
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
662
+ "ci95": [
663
+ 0.0,
664
+ 0.0
665
+ ]
666
+ },
667
+ "qwen3-4b": {
668
+ "n": 2161,
669
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
670
+ "tau": null,
671
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
672
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
673
+ "baseline_acc": 0.6432,
674
+ "prevented": 0,
675
+ "lost": 0,
676
+ "other_net": 0,
677
+ "net": 0,
678
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
679
+ "ci95": [
680
+ 0.0,
681
+ 0.0
682
+ ]
683
+ },
684
+ "qwen3-8b": {
685
+ "n": 200,
686
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
687
+ "tau": null,
688
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
689
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
690
+ "baseline_acc": 0.62,
691
+ "prevented": 0,
692
+ "lost": 0,
693
+ "other_net": 0,
694
+ "net": 0,
695
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
696
+ "ci95": [
697
+ 0.0,
698
+ 0.0
699
+ ]
700
+ }
701
+ },
702
+ "pooled": {
703
+ "n": 6525,
704
+ "prevented": 0,
705
+ "lost": 0,
706
+ "net": 0,
707
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
708
+ "ci95": [
709
+ 0.0,
710
+ 0.0
711
+ ],
712
+ "weight_ladder_pp": {
713
+ "0.5": 0.0,
714
+ "1": 0.0,
715
+ "2": 0.0,
716
+ "4": 0.0,
717
+ "8": 0.0
718
+ },
719
+ "break_even_r": null
720
+ }
721
+ }
722
+ },
723
+ "none_mode": "flip",
724
+ "probes_dir": "abc_exp/results/gate_rerun"
725
+ }
abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_lomo_paper.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,725 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "selftest": false,
3
+ "notes": "Probe-gated freeze with leave-one-model-out selection on the archived local-model debates (zero API).\nThe scripts and probe inputs of the original pilot were not retained. This re-implements the pilot rule on newly\ncollected probe scores (abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/); it is a post-hoc reconstruction, not a reproduction of the pilot.\n\nRules of the original pilot: tau in {0.05,0.1,0.15,0.2,0.3,0.4,0.5,0.6,0.7}; mode in {freeze_initial, freeze_if_stable}; for each held-out\nmodel, (tau*, mode*) maximizes net = prevented - lost on the other models; then frozen and applied to the held-out model.\nChoices the original pilot does not record (made here):\n * classifier: logistic regression of `collapsed` on per-debate probe features (mean, max, min of the three agents'\n default-condition 8-probe flip rate on that question), fitted on the training models; the gate fires when p >= tau.\n * freeze_initial: when the gate fires, the debate returns its initial majority.\n * freeze_if_stable: when the gate fires, an agent whose Round-1 answer equals its initial answer keeps its initial answer;\n the other agents keep their final answers; the majority is recomputed (unparsed answers dropped, ties alphabetical).\nOutputs per held-out model: tau*, mode*, gate%, prevented, lost, net, delta-acc (pp) with a debate-bootstrap 95% CI, and the\noracle delta-acc (best tau/mode chosen on the held-out model itself); pooled totals; weight ladder (r * prevented - lost) / n.",
4
+ "variants": {
5
+ "e5_rule": {
6
+ "per_model": {
7
+ "llama-3.1-8b": {
8
+ "n": 2003,
9
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
10
+ "tau": 0.1,
11
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
12
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
13
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5132,
14
+ "prevented": 0,
15
+ "lost": 0,
16
+ "other_net": 0,
17
+ "net": 0,
18
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
19
+ "ci95": [
20
+ 0.0,
21
+ 0.0
22
+ ],
23
+ "oracle": {
24
+ "tau": 0.05,
25
+ "mode": "freeze_if_stable",
26
+ "dacc_pp": 0.15
27
+ }
28
+ },
29
+ "phi-4-mini": {
30
+ "n": 2161,
31
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
32
+ "tau": 0.1,
33
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
34
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
35
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5349,
36
+ "prevented": 0,
37
+ "lost": 0,
38
+ "other_net": 0,
39
+ "net": 0,
40
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
41
+ "ci95": [
42
+ 0.0,
43
+ 0.0
44
+ ],
45
+ "oracle": {
46
+ "tau": 0.05,
47
+ "mode": "freeze_if_stable",
48
+ "dacc_pp": 0.093
49
+ }
50
+ },
51
+ "qwen3-4b": {
52
+ "n": 2161,
53
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
54
+ "tau": 0.1,
55
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
56
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
57
+ "baseline_acc": 0.6432,
58
+ "prevented": 0,
59
+ "lost": 0,
60
+ "other_net": 0,
61
+ "net": 0,
62
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
63
+ "ci95": [
64
+ 0.0,
65
+ 0.0
66
+ ],
67
+ "oracle": {
68
+ "tau": 0.1,
69
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
70
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
71
+ }
72
+ },
73
+ "qwen3-8b": {
74
+ "n": 200,
75
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
76
+ "tau": 0.1,
77
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
78
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
79
+ "baseline_acc": 0.62,
80
+ "prevented": 0,
81
+ "lost": 0,
82
+ "other_net": 0,
83
+ "net": 0,
84
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
85
+ "ci95": [
86
+ 0.0,
87
+ 0.0
88
+ ],
89
+ "oracle": {
90
+ "tau": 0.1,
91
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
92
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
93
+ }
94
+ }
95
+ },
96
+ "pooled": {
97
+ "n": 6525,
98
+ "prevented": 0,
99
+ "lost": 0,
100
+ "net": 0,
101
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
102
+ "ci95": [
103
+ 0.0,
104
+ 0.0
105
+ ],
106
+ "weight_ladder_pp": {
107
+ "0.5": 0.0,
108
+ "1": 0.0,
109
+ "2": 0.0,
110
+ "4": 0.0,
111
+ "8": 0.0
112
+ },
113
+ "break_even_r": null
114
+ }
115
+ },
116
+ "freeze_initial_only": {
117
+ "per_model": {
118
+ "llama-3.1-8b": {
119
+ "n": 2003,
120
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
121
+ "tau": 0.1,
122
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
123
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
124
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5132,
125
+ "prevented": 0,
126
+ "lost": 0,
127
+ "other_net": 0,
128
+ "net": 0,
129
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
130
+ "ci95": [
131
+ 0.0,
132
+ 0.0
133
+ ],
134
+ "oracle": {
135
+ "tau": 0.1,
136
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
137
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
138
+ }
139
+ },
140
+ "phi-4-mini": {
141
+ "n": 2161,
142
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
143
+ "tau": 0.1,
144
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
145
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
146
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5349,
147
+ "prevented": 0,
148
+ "lost": 0,
149
+ "other_net": 0,
150
+ "net": 0,
151
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
152
+ "ci95": [
153
+ 0.0,
154
+ 0.0
155
+ ],
156
+ "oracle": {
157
+ "tau": 0.1,
158
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
159
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
160
+ }
161
+ },
162
+ "qwen3-4b": {
163
+ "n": 2161,
164
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
165
+ "tau": 0.1,
166
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
167
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
168
+ "baseline_acc": 0.6432,
169
+ "prevented": 0,
170
+ "lost": 0,
171
+ "other_net": 0,
172
+ "net": 0,
173
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
174
+ "ci95": [
175
+ 0.0,
176
+ 0.0
177
+ ],
178
+ "oracle": {
179
+ "tau": 0.1,
180
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
181
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
182
+ }
183
+ },
184
+ "qwen3-8b": {
185
+ "n": 200,
186
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
187
+ "tau": 0.1,
188
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
189
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
190
+ "baseline_acc": 0.62,
191
+ "prevented": 0,
192
+ "lost": 0,
193
+ "other_net": 0,
194
+ "net": 0,
195
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
196
+ "ci95": [
197
+ 0.0,
198
+ 0.0
199
+ ],
200
+ "oracle": {
201
+ "tau": 0.1,
202
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
203
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
204
+ }
205
+ }
206
+ },
207
+ "pooled": {
208
+ "n": 6525,
209
+ "prevented": 0,
210
+ "lost": 0,
211
+ "net": 0,
212
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
213
+ "ci95": [
214
+ 0.0,
215
+ 0.0
216
+ ],
217
+ "weight_ladder_pp": {
218
+ "0.5": 0.0,
219
+ "1": 0.0,
220
+ "2": 0.0,
221
+ "4": 0.0,
222
+ "8": 0.0
223
+ },
224
+ "break_even_r": null
225
+ }
226
+ },
227
+ "nested_lomo": {
228
+ "per_model": {
229
+ "llama-3.1-8b": {
230
+ "n": 2003,
231
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
232
+ "tau": 0.1,
233
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
234
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
235
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5132,
236
+ "prevented": 0,
237
+ "lost": 0,
238
+ "other_net": 0,
239
+ "net": 0,
240
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
241
+ "ci95": [
242
+ 0.0,
243
+ 0.0
244
+ ],
245
+ "oracle": {
246
+ "tau": 0.05,
247
+ "mode": "freeze_if_stable",
248
+ "dacc_pp": 0.15
249
+ }
250
+ },
251
+ "phi-4-mini": {
252
+ "n": 2161,
253
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
254
+ "tau": 0.1,
255
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
256
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
257
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5349,
258
+ "prevented": 0,
259
+ "lost": 0,
260
+ "other_net": 0,
261
+ "net": 0,
262
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
263
+ "ci95": [
264
+ 0.0,
265
+ 0.0
266
+ ],
267
+ "oracle": {
268
+ "tau": 0.05,
269
+ "mode": "freeze_if_stable",
270
+ "dacc_pp": 0.093
271
+ }
272
+ },
273
+ "qwen3-4b": {
274
+ "n": 2161,
275
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
276
+ "tau": 0.05,
277
+ "mode": "freeze_if_stable",
278
+ "gate_pct": 20.87,
279
+ "baseline_acc": 0.6432,
280
+ "prevented": 6,
281
+ "lost": 26,
282
+ "other_net": 1,
283
+ "net": -19,
284
+ "dacc_pp": -0.879,
285
+ "ci95": [
286
+ -1.435,
287
+ -0.37
288
+ ],
289
+ "oracle": {
290
+ "tau": 0.1,
291
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
292
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
293
+ }
294
+ },
295
+ "qwen3-8b": {
296
+ "n": 200,
297
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
298
+ "tau": 0.1,
299
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
300
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
301
+ "baseline_acc": 0.62,
302
+ "prevented": 0,
303
+ "lost": 0,
304
+ "other_net": 0,
305
+ "net": 0,
306
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
307
+ "ci95": [
308
+ 0.0,
309
+ 0.0
310
+ ],
311
+ "oracle": {
312
+ "tau": 0.1,
313
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
314
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
315
+ }
316
+ }
317
+ },
318
+ "pooled": {
319
+ "n": 6525,
320
+ "prevented": 6,
321
+ "lost": 26,
322
+ "net": -19,
323
+ "dacc_pp": -0.291,
324
+ "ci95": [
325
+ -0.461,
326
+ -0.122
327
+ ],
328
+ "weight_ladder_pp": {
329
+ "0.5": -0.352,
330
+ "1": -0.307,
331
+ "2": -0.215,
332
+ "4": -0.031,
333
+ "8": 0.337
334
+ },
335
+ "break_even_r": 4.333
336
+ }
337
+ },
338
+ "with_noop": {
339
+ "per_model": {
340
+ "llama-3.1-8b": {
341
+ "n": 2003,
342
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
343
+ "tau": null,
344
+ "mode": "no_op",
345
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
346
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5132,
347
+ "prevented": 0,
348
+ "lost": 0,
349
+ "other_net": 0,
350
+ "net": 0,
351
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
352
+ "ci95": [
353
+ 0.0,
354
+ 0.0
355
+ ],
356
+ "oracle": {
357
+ "tau": 0.05,
358
+ "mode": "freeze_if_stable",
359
+ "dacc_pp": 0.15
360
+ }
361
+ },
362
+ "phi-4-mini": {
363
+ "n": 2161,
364
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
365
+ "tau": null,
366
+ "mode": "no_op",
367
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
368
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5349,
369
+ "prevented": 0,
370
+ "lost": 0,
371
+ "other_net": 0,
372
+ "net": 0,
373
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
374
+ "ci95": [
375
+ 0.0,
376
+ 0.0
377
+ ],
378
+ "oracle": {
379
+ "tau": 0.05,
380
+ "mode": "freeze_if_stable",
381
+ "dacc_pp": 0.093
382
+ }
383
+ },
384
+ "qwen3-4b": {
385
+ "n": 2161,
386
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
387
+ "tau": null,
388
+ "mode": "no_op",
389
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
390
+ "baseline_acc": 0.6432,
391
+ "prevented": 0,
392
+ "lost": 0,
393
+ "other_net": 0,
394
+ "net": 0,
395
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
396
+ "ci95": [
397
+ 0.0,
398
+ 0.0
399
+ ],
400
+ "oracle": {
401
+ "tau": 0.1,
402
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
403
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
404
+ }
405
+ },
406
+ "qwen3-8b": {
407
+ "n": 200,
408
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
409
+ "tau": null,
410
+ "mode": "no_op",
411
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
412
+ "baseline_acc": 0.62,
413
+ "prevented": 0,
414
+ "lost": 0,
415
+ "other_net": 0,
416
+ "net": 0,
417
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
418
+ "ci95": [
419
+ 0.0,
420
+ 0.0
421
+ ],
422
+ "oracle": {
423
+ "tau": 0.1,
424
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
425
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0
426
+ }
427
+ }
428
+ },
429
+ "pooled": {
430
+ "n": 6525,
431
+ "prevented": 0,
432
+ "lost": 0,
433
+ "net": 0,
434
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
435
+ "ci95": [
436
+ 0.0,
437
+ 0.0
438
+ ],
439
+ "weight_ladder_pp": {
440
+ "0.5": 0.0,
441
+ "1": 0.0,
442
+ "2": 0.0,
443
+ "4": 0.0,
444
+ "8": 0.0
445
+ },
446
+ "break_even_r": null
447
+ }
448
+ },
449
+ "always_freeze": {
450
+ "per_model": {
451
+ "llama-3.1-8b": {
452
+ "n": 2003,
453
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
454
+ "tau": null,
455
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
456
+ "gate_pct": 100.0,
457
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5132,
458
+ "prevented": 86,
459
+ "lost": 98,
460
+ "other_net": 0,
461
+ "net": -12,
462
+ "dacc_pp": -0.599,
463
+ "ci95": [
464
+ -1.898,
465
+ 0.75
466
+ ]
467
+ },
468
+ "phi-4-mini": {
469
+ "n": 2161,
470
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
471
+ "tau": null,
472
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
473
+ "gate_pct": 100.0,
474
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5349,
475
+ "prevented": 112,
476
+ "lost": 174,
477
+ "other_net": 0,
478
+ "net": -62,
479
+ "dacc_pp": -2.869,
480
+ "ci95": [
481
+ -4.396,
482
+ -1.296
483
+ ]
484
+ },
485
+ "qwen3-4b": {
486
+ "n": 2161,
487
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
488
+ "tau": null,
489
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
490
+ "gate_pct": 100.0,
491
+ "baseline_acc": 0.6432,
492
+ "prevented": 50,
493
+ "lost": 461,
494
+ "other_net": 0,
495
+ "net": -411,
496
+ "dacc_pp": -19.019,
497
+ "ci95": [
498
+ -20.916,
499
+ -17.075
500
+ ]
501
+ },
502
+ "qwen3-8b": {
503
+ "n": 200,
504
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
505
+ "tau": null,
506
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
507
+ "gate_pct": 100.0,
508
+ "baseline_acc": 0.62,
509
+ "prevented": 3,
510
+ "lost": 71,
511
+ "other_net": 0,
512
+ "net": -68,
513
+ "dacc_pp": -34.0,
514
+ "ci95": [
515
+ -41.0,
516
+ -27.0
517
+ ]
518
+ }
519
+ },
520
+ "pooled": {
521
+ "n": 6525,
522
+ "prevented": 251,
523
+ "lost": 804,
524
+ "net": -553,
525
+ "dacc_pp": -8.475,
526
+ "ci95": [
527
+ -9.484,
528
+ -7.484
529
+ ],
530
+ "weight_ladder_pp": {
531
+ "0.5": -10.398,
532
+ "1": -8.475,
533
+ "2": -4.628,
534
+ "4": 3.065,
535
+ "8": 18.452
536
+ },
537
+ "break_even_r": 3.203
538
+ }
539
+ },
540
+ "raw_fr_gate": {
541
+ "per_model": {
542
+ "llama-3.1-8b": {
543
+ "n": 2003,
544
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
545
+ "tau": 0.7,
546
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
547
+ "gate_pct": 41.99,
548
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5132,
549
+ "prevented": 45,
550
+ "lost": 46,
551
+ "other_net": 0,
552
+ "net": -1,
553
+ "dacc_pp": -0.05,
554
+ "ci95": [
555
+ -0.998,
556
+ 0.898
557
+ ]
558
+ },
559
+ "phi-4-mini": {
560
+ "n": 2161,
561
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
562
+ "tau": 0.7,
563
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
564
+ "gate_pct": 17.58,
565
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5349,
566
+ "prevented": 21,
567
+ "lost": 45,
568
+ "other_net": 0,
569
+ "net": -24,
570
+ "dacc_pp": -1.111,
571
+ "ci95": [
572
+ -1.852,
573
+ -0.416
574
+ ]
575
+ },
576
+ "qwen3-4b": {
577
+ "n": 2161,
578
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
579
+ "tau": 0.7,
580
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
581
+ "gate_pct": 37.02,
582
+ "baseline_acc": 0.6432,
583
+ "prevented": 29,
584
+ "lost": 187,
585
+ "other_net": 0,
586
+ "net": -158,
587
+ "dacc_pp": -7.311,
588
+ "ci95": [
589
+ -8.562,
590
+ -6.015
591
+ ]
592
+ },
593
+ "qwen3-8b": {
594
+ "n": 200,
595
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
596
+ "tau": 0.7,
597
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
598
+ "gate_pct": 12.0,
599
+ "baseline_acc": 0.62,
600
+ "prevented": 2,
601
+ "lost": 2,
602
+ "other_net": 0,
603
+ "net": 0,
604
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
605
+ "ci95": [
606
+ -2.0,
607
+ 2.0
608
+ ]
609
+ }
610
+ },
611
+ "pooled": {
612
+ "n": 6525,
613
+ "prevented": 97,
614
+ "lost": 280,
615
+ "net": -183,
616
+ "dacc_pp": -2.805,
617
+ "ci95": [
618
+ -3.406,
619
+ -2.24
620
+ ],
621
+ "weight_ladder_pp": {
622
+ "0.5": -3.548,
623
+ "1": -2.805,
624
+ "2": -1.318,
625
+ "4": 1.655,
626
+ "8": 7.602
627
+ },
628
+ "break_even_r": 2.887
629
+ }
630
+ },
631
+ "random_same_rate": {
632
+ "per_model": {
633
+ "llama-3.1-8b": {
634
+ "n": 2003,
635
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
636
+ "tau": null,
637
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
638
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
639
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5132,
640
+ "prevented": 0,
641
+ "lost": 0,
642
+ "other_net": 0,
643
+ "net": 0,
644
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
645
+ "ci95": [
646
+ 0.0,
647
+ 0.0
648
+ ]
649
+ },
650
+ "phi-4-mini": {
651
+ "n": 2161,
652
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
653
+ "tau": null,
654
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
655
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
656
+ "baseline_acc": 0.5349,
657
+ "prevented": 0,
658
+ "lost": 0,
659
+ "other_net": 0,
660
+ "net": 0,
661
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
662
+ "ci95": [
663
+ 0.0,
664
+ 0.0
665
+ ]
666
+ },
667
+ "qwen3-4b": {
668
+ "n": 2161,
669
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
670
+ "tau": null,
671
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
672
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
673
+ "baseline_acc": 0.6432,
674
+ "prevented": 0,
675
+ "lost": 0,
676
+ "other_net": 0,
677
+ "net": 0,
678
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
679
+ "ci95": [
680
+ 0.0,
681
+ 0.0
682
+ ]
683
+ },
684
+ "qwen3-8b": {
685
+ "n": 200,
686
+ "n_missing_probe": 0,
687
+ "tau": null,
688
+ "mode": "freeze_initial",
689
+ "gate_pct": 0.0,
690
+ "baseline_acc": 0.62,
691
+ "prevented": 0,
692
+ "lost": 0,
693
+ "other_net": 0,
694
+ "net": 0,
695
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
696
+ "ci95": [
697
+ 0.0,
698
+ 0.0
699
+ ]
700
+ }
701
+ },
702
+ "pooled": {
703
+ "n": 6525,
704
+ "prevented": 0,
705
+ "lost": 0,
706
+ "net": 0,
707
+ "dacc_pp": 0.0,
708
+ "ci95": [
709
+ 0.0,
710
+ 0.0
711
+ ],
712
+ "weight_ladder_pp": {
713
+ "0.5": 0.0,
714
+ "1": 0.0,
715
+ "2": 0.0,
716
+ "4": 0.0,
717
+ "8": 0.0
718
+ },
719
+ "break_even_r": null
720
+ }
721
+ }
722
+ },
723
+ "none_mode": "paper",
724
+ "probes_dir": "abc_exp/results/gate_rerun"
725
+ }
abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/gate_tex.txt ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,25 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ % tab:pilot_gated: e5_rule per held-out model, then pooled rows of the main rule and the comparisons
2
+ Llama-3.1-8B (86 col / 98 corr) & 0.10 & freeze_initial & 0.0\% & 0/86 & 0/98 & $+0$ & $+0.00$ [+0.00,+0.00] & $+0.15$ \\
3
+ Phi-4-mini (112 col / 174 corr) & 0.10 & freeze_initial & 0.0\% & 0/112 & 0/174 & $+0$ & $+0.00$ [+0.00,+0.00] & $+0.09$ \\
4
+ Qwen3-4B (50 col / 461 corr) & 0.10 & freeze_initial & 0.0\% & 0/50 & 0/461 & $+0$ & $+0.00$ [+0.00,+0.00] & $+0.00$ \\
5
+ Qwen3-8B (3 col / 71 corr) & 0.10 & freeze_initial & 0.0\% & 0/3 & 0/71 & $+0$ & $+0.00$ [+0.00,+0.00] & $+0.00$ \\
6
+ \midrule
7
+ \textbf{Pooled (frozen LOMO policy)} & & & & 0/251 & 0/804 & $+0$ & $+0.00$ [+0.00,+0.00] & n/a \\
8
+ \textbf{Nested LOMO selection} & & & & 6/251 & 26/804 & $-20$ & $-0.29$ [-0.46,-0.12] & n/a \\
9
+ \textbf{Raw mean-FR threshold} & & & & 97/251 & 280/804 & $-183$ & $-2.80$ [-3.41,-2.24] & n/a \\
10
+ \textbf{Always freeze} & & & & 251/251 & 804/804 & $-553$ & $-8.48$ [-9.48,-7.48] & n/a \\
11
+
12
+ % tab:weight_sensitivity rows (r = 0.5, 1, 2, 4, 8, breakeven)
13
+ Probe-gated freeze & $+0.00$ & $+0.00$ & $+0.00$ & $+0.00$ & $+0.00$ & n/a \\
14
+ Always freeze & $-10.40$ & $-8.48$ & $-4.63$ & $+3.07$ & $+18.45$ & 3.20 \\
15
+ Raw mean-FR threshold & $-3.55$ & $-2.80$ & $-1.32$ & $+1.66$ & $+7.60$ & 2.89 \\
16
+
17
+ % tab:control_summary rows
18
+ Always freeze & $6{,}525$ OSS & none & $-8.48$pp & $251$ & $804$ & $-553$ & $3.20$ \\
19
+ Probe-gated freeze & $6{,}525$ OSS & LOMO & $+0.00$pp & $0$ & $0$ & $+0$ & $n/a$ \\
20
+
21
+ % Unparsed-reply bounds: pooled prevented / lost / net per variant
22
+ % e5_rule: paper 0/0/+0 (acc +0); flip 0/0/+0 (acc +0); drop 0/0/+0 (acc +0)
23
+ % nested_lomo: paper 6/26/-20 (acc -19); flip 7/31/-24 (acc -23); drop 8/41/-33 (acc -32)
24
+ % raw_fr_gate: paper 97/280/-183 (acc -183); flip 115/309/-194 (acc -194); drop 108/297/-189 (acc -189)
25
+ % always_freeze: paper 251/804/-553 (acc -553); flip 251/804/-553 (acc -553); drop 251/804/-553 (acc -553)
abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/qids_llama-3.1-8b_s0.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
 
 
1
+ ["mmlu_pro_10", "mmlu_pro_19", "mmlu_pro_20", "mmlu_pro_27", "mmlu_pro_29", "mmlu_pro_39", "mmlu_pro_48", "mmlu_pro_49", "mmlu_pro_52", "mmlu_pro_60", "mmlu_pro_73", "mmlu_pro_102", "mmlu_pro_88", "mmlu_pro_107", "mmlu_pro_112", "mmlu_pro_123", "mmlu_pro_117", "mmlu_pro_142", "mmlu_pro_154", "mmlu_pro_157", "mmlu_pro_167", "mmlu_pro_165", "mmlu_pro_169", "mmlu_pro_171", "mmlu_pro_177", "mmlu_pro_180", "mmlu_pro_201", "mmlu_pro_181", "mmlu_pro_211", "mmlu_pro_213", "mmlu_pro_220", "mmlu_pro_233", "mmlu_pro_222", "mmlu_pro_234", "mmlu_pro_238", "mmlu_pro_240", "mmlu_pro_245", "mmlu_pro_256", "mmlu_pro_257", "mmlu_pro_261", "mmlu_pro_254", "mmlu_pro_264", "mmlu_pro_269", "mmlu_pro_267", "mmlu_pro_273", "mmlu_pro_279", "mmlu_pro_275", "mmlu_pro_291", "mmlu_pro_293", "mmlu_pro_295", "mmlu_pro_296", "mmlu_pro_303", "mmlu_pro_308", "mmlu_pro_299", "mmlu_pro_309", "mmlu_pro_318", "mmlu_pro_321", "mmlu_pro_320", "mmlu_pro_328", "mmlu_pro_334", "mmlu_pro_325", "mmlu_pro_364", "mmlu_pro_344", "mmlu_pro_369", "mmlu_pro_370", "mmlu_pro_377", "mmlu_pro_372", "mmlu_pro_382", "mmlu_pro_412", "mmlu_pro_384", "mmlu_pro_413", "mmlu_pro_416", "mmlu_pro_420", "mmlu_pro_425", "mmlu_pro_430", "mmlu_pro_431", "mmlu_pro_436", "mmlu_pro_440", "mmlu_pro_458", "mmlu_pro_451", "mmlu_pro_459", "mmlu_pro_476", "mmlu_pro_480", "mmlu_pro_491", "mmlu_pro_498", "mmlu_pro_485", "mmlu_pro_517", "mmlu_pro_521", "mmlu_pro_522", "mmlu_pro_526", "mmlu_pro_539", "mmlu_pro_542", "mmlu_pro_530", "mmlu_pro_552", "mmlu_pro_554", "mmlu_pro_556", "mmlu_pro_558", "mmlu_pro_577", "mmlu_pro_590", "mmlu_pro_602", "mmlu_pro_596", "mmlu_pro_610", "mmlu_pro_612", "mmlu_pro_604", "mmlu_pro_615", "mmlu_pro_627", "mmlu_pro_631", "mmlu_pro_633", "mmlu_pro_646", "mmlu_pro_658", "mmlu_pro_657", "mmlu_pro_673", "mmlu_pro_661", "mmlu_pro_678", "mmlu_pro_683", "mmlu_pro_686", "mmlu_pro_693", "mmlu_pro_703", "mmlu_pro_716", "mmlu_pro_712", "mmlu_pro_726", "mmlu_pro_743", "mmlu_pro_753", "mmlu_pro_754", "mmlu_pro_755", "mmlu_pro_756", "mmlu_pro_758", "mmlu_pro_765", "mmlu_pro_766", "mmlu_pro_768", "mmlu_pro_791", "mmlu_pro_796", "mmlu_pro_797", "mmlu_pro_822", "mmlu_pro_833", "mmlu_pro_830", "mmlu_pro_835", "mmlu_pro_841", "mmlu_pro_852", "mmlu_pro_859", "mmlu_pro_863", "mmlu_pro_866", "mmlu_pro_883", "mmlu_pro_880", "mmlu_pro_886", "mmlu_pro_890", "mmlu_pro_895", "mmlu_pro_891", "mmlu_pro_896", "mmlu_pro_903", "mmlu_pro_913", "mmlu_pro_910", "mmlu_pro_919", "mmlu_pro_932", "mmlu_pro_943", "mmlu_pro_954", "mmlu_pro_972", "mmlu_pro_968", "mmlu_pro_978", "mmlu_pro_982", "mmlu_pro_996", "mmlu_pro_1001", "mmlu_pro_1011", "mmlu_pro_1014", "mmlu_pro_1027", "mmlu_pro_1029", "mmlu_pro_1038", "mmlu_pro_1034", "mmlu_pro_1040", "mmlu_pro_1055", "mmlu_pro_1061", "mmlu_pro_1070", "mmlu_pro_1081", "mmlu_pro_1082", "mmlu_pro_1092", "mmlu_pro_1105", "mmlu_pro_1112", "mmlu_pro_1113", "mmlu_pro_1117", "mmlu_pro_1123", "mmlu_pro_1156", "mmlu_pro_1173", "mmlu_pro_1174", "mmlu_pro_1179", "mmlu_pro_1181", "mmlu_pro_1191", "mmlu_pro_1198", "mmlu_pro_1199", "mmlu_pro_1209", "mmlu_pro_1212", "mmlu_pro_1217", "mmlu_pro_1221", "mmlu_pro_1227", "mmlu_pro_1233", "mmlu_pro_1241", "mmlu_pro_1243", "mmlu_pro_1247", "mmlu_pro_1252", "mmlu_pro_1255", "mmlu_pro_1261", "mmlu_pro_1263", "mmlu_pro_1265", "mmlu_pro_1268", "mmlu_pro_1278", "mmlu_pro_1299", "mmlu_pro_1305", "mmlu_pro_1306", "mmlu_pro_1308", "mmlu_pro_1326", "mmlu_pro_1327", "mmlu_pro_1339", "mmlu_pro_1341", "mmlu_pro_1351", "mmlu_pro_1353", "mmlu_pro_1355", "mmlu_pro_1358", "mmlu_pro_1360", "mmlu_pro_1362", "mmlu_pro_1365", "mmlu_pro_1367", "mmlu_pro_1378", "mmlu_pro_1380", "mmlu_pro_1383", "mmlu_pro_1388", "mmlu_pro_1390", "mmlu_pro_1396", "mmlu_pro_1399", "mmlu_pro_1402", "mmlu_pro_1410", "mmlu_pro_1413", "mmlu_pro_1414", "mmlu_pro_1416", "mmlu_pro_1418", "mmlu_pro_1429", "mmlu_pro_1430", "mmlu_pro_1433", "mmlu_pro_1436", "mmlu_pro_1442", "mmlu_pro_1451", "mmlu_pro_1453", "mmlu_pro_1462", "mmlu_pro_1469", "mmlu_pro_1479", "mmlu_pro_1481", "mmlu_pro_1482", "mmlu_pro_1485", "mmlu_pro_1500", "mmlu_pro_1502", "mmlu_pro_1509", "mmlu_pro_1511", "mmlu_pro_1515", "mmlu_pro_1519", "mmlu_pro_1522", "mmlu_pro_1534", "mmlu_pro_1541", "mmlu_pro_1543", "mmlu_pro_1544", "mmlu_pro_1547", "mmlu_pro_1548", "mmlu_pro_1563", "mmlu_pro_1567", "mmlu_pro_1568", "mmlu_pro_1576", "mmlu_pro_1589", "mmlu_pro_1590", "mmlu_pro_1606", "mmlu_pro_1612", "mmlu_pro_1615", "mmlu_pro_1618", "mmlu_pro_1626", "mmlu_pro_1628", "mmlu_pro_1639", "mmlu_pro_1646", "mmlu_pro_1648", "mmlu_pro_1649", "mmlu_pro_1652", "mmlu_pro_1661", "mmlu_pro_1663", "mmlu_pro_1664", "mmlu_pro_1676", "mmlu_pro_1681", "mmlu_pro_1689", "mmlu_pro_1694", "mmlu_pro_1710", "mmlu_pro_1715", "mmlu_pro_1716", "mmlu_pro_1721", "mmlu_pro_1727", "mmlu_pro_1729", "mmlu_pro_1730", "mmlu_pro_1733", "mmlu_pro_1750", "mmlu_pro_1766", "mmlu_pro_1772", "mmlu_pro_1774", "mmlu_pro_1776", "mmlu_pro_1793", "mmlu_pro_1801", "mmlu_pro_1815", "mmlu_pro_1838", "mmlu_pro_1847", "mmlu_pro_1855", "mmlu_pro_1863", "mmlu_pro_1865", "mmlu_pro_1869", "mmlu_pro_1879", "mmlu_pro_1891", "mmlu_pro_1897", "mmlu_pro_1905", "mmlu_pro_1907", "mmlu_pro_1911", "mmlu_pro_1916", "mmlu_pro_1917", "mmlu_pro_1918", "mmlu_pro_1938", "mmlu_pro_1927", "mmlu_pro_1939", "mmlu_pro_1949", "mmlu_pro_1959", "mmlu_pro_1954", "mmlu_pro_1969", "mmlu_pro_1971", "mmlu_pro_1980", "mmlu_pro_1983", "mmlu_pro_1991", "mmlu_pro_1994", "mmlu_pro_1999", "mmlu_pro_2006", "mmlu_pro_2011", "mmlu_pro_2014", "mmlu_pro_2017", "mmlu_pro_2022", "mmlu_pro_2023", "mmlu_pro_2026", "mmlu_pro_2051", "mmlu_pro_2054", "mmlu_pro_2057", "mmlu_pro_2066", "mmlu_pro_2068", "mmlu_pro_2073", "mmlu_pro_2076", "mmlu_pro_2078", "mmlu_pro_2081", "mmlu_pro_2105", "mmlu_pro_2114", "mmlu_pro_2107", "mmlu_pro_2117", "mmlu_pro_2119", "mmlu_pro_2144", "mmlu_pro_2156", "mmlu_pro_2160", "mmlu_pro_2165", "mmlu_pro_2177", "mmlu_pro_2167", "mmlu_pro_2178", "mmlu_pro_2181", "mmlu_pro_2184", "mmlu_pro_2191", "mmlu_pro_2193", "mmlu_pro_2199", "mmlu_pro_2208", "mmlu_pro_2227", "mmlu_pro_2238", "mmlu_pro_2240", "mmlu_pro_2241", "mmlu_pro_2242", "mmlu_pro_2260", "mmlu_pro_2274", "mmlu_pro_2276", "mmlu_pro_2303", "mmlu_pro_2306", "mmlu_pro_2313", "mmlu_pro_2315", "mmlu_pro_2334", "mmlu_pro_2337", "mmlu_pro_2338", "mmlu_pro_2340", "mmlu_pro_2352", "mmlu_pro_2360", "mmlu_pro_2362", "mmlu_pro_2365", "mmlu_pro_2366", "mmlu_pro_2381", "mmlu_pro_2388", "mmlu_pro_2390", "mmlu_pro_2395", "mmlu_pro_2407", "mmlu_pro_2424", "mmlu_pro_2423", "mmlu_pro_2429", "mmlu_pro_2440", "mmlu_pro_2458", "mmlu_pro_2468", "mmlu_pro_2472", "mmlu_pro_2480", "mmlu_pro_2481", "mmlu_pro_2487", "mmlu_pro_2490", "mmlu_pro_2492", "mmlu_pro_2496", "mmlu_pro_2497", "mmlu_pro_2498", "mmlu_pro_2511", "mmlu_pro_2516", "mmlu_pro_2521", "mmlu_pro_2522", "mmlu_pro_2535", "mmlu_pro_2539", "mmlu_pro_2540", "mmlu_pro_2544", "mmlu_pro_2545", "mmlu_pro_2553", "mmlu_pro_2556", "mmlu_pro_2567", "mmlu_pro_2574", "mmlu_pro_2577", "mmlu_pro_2579", "mmlu_pro_2582", "mmlu_pro_2586", "mmlu_pro_2588", "mmlu_pro_2594", "mmlu_pro_2596", "mmlu_pro_2598", "mmlu_pro_2606", "mmlu_pro_2610", "mmlu_pro_2621", "mmlu_pro_2627", "mmlu_pro_2630", "mmlu_pro_2633", "mmlu_pro_2634", "mmlu_pro_2638", "mmlu_pro_2652", "mmlu_pro_2651", "mmlu_pro_2654", "mmlu_pro_2665", "mmlu_pro_2666", "mmlu_pro_2672", "mmlu_pro_2676", "mmlu_pro_2680", "mmlu_pro_2694", "mmlu_pro_2692", "mmlu_pro_2706", "mmlu_pro_2701", "mmlu_pro_2709", "mmlu_pro_2718", "mmlu_pro_2727", "mmlu_pro_2720", "mmlu_pro_2732", "mmlu_pro_2734", "mmlu_pro_2747", "mmlu_pro_2753", "mmlu_pro_2757", "mmlu_pro_2761", "mmlu_pro_2770", "mmlu_pro_2786", "mmlu_pro_2790", "mmlu_pro_2803", "mmlu_pro_2802", "mmlu_pro_2811", "mmlu_pro_2815", "mmlu_pro_2832", "mmlu_pro_2831", "mmlu_pro_2833", "mmlu_pro_2837", "mmlu_pro_2835", "mmlu_pro_2841", "mmlu_pro_2845", "mmlu_pro_2848", "mmlu_pro_2858", "mmlu_pro_2860", "mmlu_pro_2861", "mmlu_pro_2864", "mmlu_pro_2876", "mmlu_pro_2898", "mmlu_pro_2906", "mmlu_pro_2914", "mmlu_pro_2918", "mmlu_pro_2929", "mmlu_pro_2939", "mmlu_pro_2930", "mmlu_pro_2953", "mmlu_pro_2965", "mmlu_pro_2970", "mmlu_pro_2980", "mmlu_pro_2985", "mmlu_pro_2986", "mmlu_pro_2987", "mmlu_pro_2988", "mmlu_pro_3019", "mmlu_pro_3022", "mmlu_pro_3028", "mmlu_pro_3031", "mmlu_pro_3037", "mmlu_pro_3041", "mmlu_pro_3043", "mmlu_pro_3046", "mmlu_pro_3049", "mmlu_pro_3069", "mmlu_pro_3070", "mmlu_pro_3072", "mmlu_pro_3074", "mmlu_pro_3086", "mmlu_pro_3087", "mmlu_pro_3089", "mmlu_pro_3091", "mmlu_pro_3092", "mmlu_pro_3108", "mmlu_pro_3101", "mmlu_pro_3114", "mmlu_pro_3118", "mmlu_pro_3120", "mmlu_pro_3126", "mmlu_pro_3144", "mmlu_pro_3159", "mmlu_pro_3161", "mmlu_pro_3162", "mmlu_pro_3171", "mmlu_pro_3196", "mmlu_pro_3177", "mmlu_pro_3211", "mmlu_pro_3218", "mmlu_pro_3219", "mmlu_pro_3230", "mmlu_pro_3253", "mmlu_pro_3259", "mmlu_pro_3265", "mmlu_pro_3269", "mmlu_pro_3270", "mmlu_pro_3273", "mmlu_pro_3275", "mmlu_pro_3289", "mmlu_pro_3281", "mmlu_pro_3299", "mmlu_pro_3303", "mmlu_pro_3306", "mmlu_pro_3305", "mmlu_pro_3310", "mmlu_pro_3311", "mmlu_pro_3315", "mmlu_pro_3319", "mmlu_pro_3320", "mmlu_pro_3331", "mmlu_pro_3338", "mmlu_pro_3336", "mmlu_pro_3339", "mmlu_pro_3340", "mmlu_pro_3352", "mmlu_pro_3354", "mmlu_pro_3358", "mmlu_pro_3362", "mmlu_pro_3364", "mmlu_pro_3363", "mmlu_pro_3369", "mmlu_pro_3370", "mmlu_pro_3375", "mmlu_pro_3378", "mmlu_pro_3402", "mmlu_pro_3404", "mmlu_pro_3409", "mmlu_pro_3410", "mmlu_pro_3414", "mmlu_pro_3419", "mmlu_pro_3417", "mmlu_pro_3421", "mmlu_pro_3433", "mmlu_pro_3444", "mmlu_pro_3434", "mmlu_pro_3446", "mmlu_pro_3453", "mmlu_pro_3459", "mmlu_pro_3461", "mmlu_pro_3460", "mmlu_pro_3465", "mmlu_pro_3470", "mmlu_pro_3479", "mmlu_pro_3499", "mmlu_pro_3489", "mmlu_pro_3511", "mmlu_pro_3522", "mmlu_pro_3523", "mmlu_pro_3534", "mmlu_pro_3538", "mmlu_pro_3539", "mmlu_pro_3543", "mmlu_pro_3558", "mmlu_pro_3570", "mmlu_pro_3562", "mmlu_pro_3572", "mmlu_pro_3579", "mmlu_pro_3580", "mmlu_pro_3584", "mmlu_pro_3587", "mmlu_pro_3598", "mmlu_pro_3599", "mmlu_pro_3600", "mmlu_pro_3612", "mmlu_pro_3610", "mmlu_pro_3630", "mmlu_pro_3626", "mmlu_pro_3637", "mmlu_pro_3644", "mmlu_pro_3647", "mmlu_pro_3646", "mmlu_pro_3670", "mmlu_pro_3678", "mmlu_pro_3681", "mmlu_pro_3680", "mmlu_pro_3687", "mmlu_pro_3695", "mmlu_pro_3696", "mmlu_pro_3703", "mmlu_pro_3720", "mmlu_pro_3711", "mmlu_pro_3725", "mmlu_pro_3722", "mmlu_pro_3729", "mmlu_pro_3736", "mmlu_pro_3737", "mmlu_pro_3739", "mmlu_pro_3740", "mmlu_pro_3757", "mmlu_pro_3758", "mmlu_pro_3759", "mmlu_pro_3768", "mmlu_pro_3764", "mmlu_pro_3777", "mmlu_pro_3786", "mmlu_pro_3805", "mmlu_pro_3791", "mmlu_pro_3807", "mmlu_pro_3817", "mmlu_pro_3815", "mmlu_pro_3819", "mmlu_pro_3822", "mmlu_pro_3826", "mmlu_pro_3828", "mmlu_pro_3832", "mmlu_pro_3842", "mmlu_pro_3835", "mmlu_pro_3855", "mmlu_pro_3856", "mmlu_pro_3863", "mmlu_pro_3864", "mmlu_pro_3871", "mmlu_pro_3867", "mmlu_pro_3902", "mmlu_pro_3895", "mmlu_pro_3903", "mmlu_pro_3909", "mmlu_pro_3910", "mmlu_pro_3912", "mmlu_pro_3913", "mmlu_pro_3924", "mmlu_pro_3936", "mmlu_pro_3954", "mmlu_pro_3955", "mmlu_pro_3964", "mmlu_pro_3976", "mmlu_pro_3979", "mmlu_pro_3985", "mmlu_pro_3981", "mmlu_pro_3994", "mmlu_pro_3991", "mmlu_pro_4004", "mmlu_pro_4006", "mmlu_pro_4009", "mmlu_pro_4018", "mmlu_pro_4032", "mmlu_pro_4029", "mmlu_pro_4038", "mmlu_pro_4037", "mmlu_pro_4040", "mmlu_pro_4045", "mmlu_pro_4057", "mmlu_pro_4063", "mmlu_pro_4064", "mmlu_pro_4089", "mmlu_pro_4105", "mmlu_pro_4117", "mmlu_pro_4109", "mmlu_pro_4139", "mmlu_pro_4143", "mmlu_pro_4146", "mmlu_pro_4144", "mmlu_pro_4158", "mmlu_pro_4148", "mmlu_pro_4163", "mmlu_pro_4165", "mmlu_pro_4181", "mmlu_pro_4198", "mmlu_pro_4204", "mmlu_pro_4207", "mmlu_pro_4205", "mmlu_pro_4210", "mmlu_pro_4215", "mmlu_pro_4217", "mmlu_pro_4226", "mmlu_pro_4228", "mmlu_pro_4232", "mmlu_pro_4234", "mmlu_pro_4242", "mmlu_pro_4243", "mmlu_pro_4246", "mmlu_pro_4253", "mmlu_pro_4261", "mmlu_pro_4258", "mmlu_pro_4269", "mmlu_pro_4270", "mmlu_pro_4279", "mmlu_pro_4295", "mmlu_pro_4287", "mmlu_pro_4296", "mmlu_pro_4302", "mmlu_pro_4297", "mmlu_pro_4340", "mmlu_pro_4333", "mmlu_pro_4343", "mmlu_pro_4371", "mmlu_pro_4350", "mmlu_pro_4399", "mmlu_pro_4392", "mmlu_pro_4406", "mmlu_pro_4410", "mmlu_pro_4411", "mmlu_pro_4433", "mmlu_pro_4434", "mmlu_pro_4459", "mmlu_pro_4439", "mmlu_pro_4468", "mmlu_pro_4479", "mmlu_pro_4489", "mmlu_pro_4507", "mmlu_pro_4509", "mmlu_pro_4508", "mmlu_pro_4518", "mmlu_pro_4512", "mmlu_pro_4519", "mmlu_pro_4522", "mmlu_pro_4524", "mmlu_pro_4531", "mmlu_pro_4528", "mmlu_pro_4534", "mmlu_pro_4537", "mmlu_pro_4536", "mmlu_pro_4544", "mmlu_pro_4551", "mmlu_pro_4562", "mmlu_pro_4557", "mmlu_pro_4574", "mmlu_pro_4583", "mmlu_pro_4586", "mmlu_pro_4589", "mmlu_pro_4598", "mmlu_pro_4597", "mmlu_pro_4606", "mmlu_pro_4616", "mmlu_pro_4621", "mmlu_pro_4617", "mmlu_pro_4636", "mmlu_pro_4630", "mmlu_pro_4639", "mmlu_pro_4637", "mmlu_pro_4640", "mmlu_pro_4643", "mmlu_pro_4660", "mmlu_pro_4661", "mmlu_pro_4670", "mmlu_pro_4674", "mmlu_pro_4681", "mmlu_pro_4684", "mmlu_pro_4696", "mmlu_pro_4698", "mmlu_pro_4703", "mmlu_pro_4704", "mmlu_pro_4720", "mmlu_pro_4709", "mmlu_pro_4723", "mmlu_pro_4724", "mmlu_pro_4736", "mmlu_pro_4744", "mmlu_pro_4753", "mmlu_pro_4760", "mmlu_pro_4763", "mmlu_pro_4771", "mmlu_pro_4776", "mmlu_pro_4786", "mmlu_pro_4787", "mmlu_pro_4794", "mmlu_pro_4792", "mmlu_pro_4795", "mmlu_pro_4800", "mmlu_pro_4814", "mmlu_pro_4807", "mmlu_pro_4820", "mmlu_pro_4829", "mmlu_pro_4836", "mmlu_pro_4842", "mmlu_pro_4877", "mmlu_pro_4878", "mmlu_pro_4884", "mmlu_pro_4893", "mmlu_pro_4897", "mmlu_pro_4899", "mmlu_pro_4904", "mmlu_pro_4916", "mmlu_pro_4924", "mmlu_pro_4938", "mmlu_pro_4939", "mmlu_pro_4949", "mmlu_pro_4955", "mmlu_pro_4956", "mmlu_pro_4957", "mmlu_pro_4960", "mmlu_pro_4961", "mmlu_pro_4969", "mmlu_pro_4986", "mmlu_pro_4992", "mmlu_pro_5023", "mmlu_pro_5016", "mmlu_pro_5038", "mmlu_pro_5046", "mmlu_pro_5058", "mmlu_pro_5050", "mmlu_pro_5061", "mmlu_pro_5072", "mmlu_pro_5074", "mmlu_pro_5078", "mmlu_pro_5085", "mmlu_pro_5080", "mmlu_pro_5086", "mmlu_pro_5088", "mmlu_pro_5091", "mmlu_pro_5093", "mmlu_pro_5095", "mmlu_pro_5103", "mmlu_pro_5108", "mmlu_pro_5114", "mmlu_pro_5121", "mmlu_pro_5128", "mmlu_pro_5130", "mmlu_pro_5134", "mmlu_pro_5140", "mmlu_pro_5149", "mmlu_pro_5153", "mmlu_pro_5157", "mmlu_pro_5158", "mmlu_pro_5159", "mmlu_pro_5167", "mmlu_pro_5172", "mmlu_pro_5191", "mmlu_pro_5193", "mmlu_pro_5214", "mmlu_pro_5212", "mmlu_pro_5225", "mmlu_pro_5226", "mmlu_pro_5229", "mmlu_pro_5231", "mmlu_pro_5245", "mmlu_pro_5237", "mmlu_pro_5248", "mmlu_pro_5246", "mmlu_pro_5256", "mmlu_pro_5262", "mmlu_pro_5263", "mmlu_pro_5264", "mmlu_pro_5267", "mmlu_pro_5270", "mmlu_pro_5279", "mmlu_pro_5281", "mmlu_pro_5294", "mmlu_pro_5300", "mmlu_pro_5311", "mmlu_pro_5305", "mmlu_pro_5324", "mmlu_pro_5319", "mmlu_pro_5331", "mmlu_pro_5328", "mmlu_pro_5333", "mmlu_pro_5339", "mmlu_pro_5348", "mmlu_pro_5369", "mmlu_pro_5374", "mmlu_pro_5381", "mmlu_pro_5387", "mmlu_pro_5393", "mmlu_pro_5396", "mmlu_pro_5423", "mmlu_pro_5421", "mmlu_pro_5431", "mmlu_pro_5443", "mmlu_pro_5445", "mmlu_pro_5447", "mmlu_pro_5450", "mmlu_pro_5456", "mmlu_pro_5459"]
abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/qids_llama-3.1-8b_s1.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
 
 
1
+ ["mmlu_pro_5465", "mmlu_pro_5473", "mmlu_pro_5500", "mmlu_pro_5482", "mmlu_pro_5501", "mmlu_pro_5502", "mmlu_pro_5507", "mmlu_pro_5512", "mmlu_pro_5519", "mmlu_pro_5522", "mmlu_pro_5523", "mmlu_pro_5540", "mmlu_pro_5541", "mmlu_pro_5542", "mmlu_pro_5554", "mmlu_pro_5557", "mmlu_pro_5563", "mmlu_pro_5561", "mmlu_pro_5565", "mmlu_pro_5588", "mmlu_pro_5571", "mmlu_pro_5598", "mmlu_pro_5600", "mmlu_pro_5607", "mmlu_pro_5610", "mmlu_pro_5613", "mmlu_pro_5616", "mmlu_pro_5623", "mmlu_pro_5626", "mmlu_pro_5638", "mmlu_pro_5630", "mmlu_pro_5639", "mmlu_pro_5647", "mmlu_pro_5661", "mmlu_pro_5662", "mmlu_pro_5669", "mmlu_pro_5672", "mmlu_pro_5677", "mmlu_pro_5695", "mmlu_pro_5696", "mmlu_pro_5705", "mmlu_pro_5709", "mmlu_pro_5711", "mmlu_pro_5714", "mmlu_pro_5716", "mmlu_pro_5721", "mmlu_pro_5730", "mmlu_pro_5737", "mmlu_pro_5738", "mmlu_pro_5746", "mmlu_pro_5760", "mmlu_pro_5763", "mmlu_pro_5778", "mmlu_pro_5780", "mmlu_pro_5784", "mmlu_pro_5791", "mmlu_pro_5812", "mmlu_pro_5815", "mmlu_pro_5817", "mmlu_pro_5818", "mmlu_pro_5829", "mmlu_pro_5823", "mmlu_pro_5836", "mmlu_pro_5853", "mmlu_pro_5854", "mmlu_pro_5855", "mmlu_pro_5860", "mmlu_pro_5876", "mmlu_pro_5879", "mmlu_pro_5888", "mmlu_pro_5891", "mmlu_pro_5899", "mmlu_pro_5905", "mmlu_pro_5902", "mmlu_pro_5911", "mmlu_pro_5912", "mmlu_pro_5927", "mmlu_pro_5931", "mmlu_pro_5932", "mmlu_pro_5947", "mmlu_pro_5955", "mmlu_pro_5959", "mmlu_pro_5960", "mmlu_pro_5965", "mmlu_pro_5966", "mmlu_pro_5967", "mmlu_pro_5971", "mmlu_pro_5981", "mmlu_pro_5982", "mmlu_pro_5985", "mmlu_pro_5997", "mmlu_pro_5998", "mmlu_pro_6007", "mmlu_pro_6009", "mmlu_pro_6012", "mmlu_pro_6021", "mmlu_pro_6020", "mmlu_pro_6029", "mmlu_pro_6027", "mmlu_pro_6033", "mmlu_pro_6032", "mmlu_pro_6034", "mmlu_pro_6038", "mmlu_pro_6052", "mmlu_pro_6054", "mmlu_pro_6055", "mmlu_pro_6062", "mmlu_pro_6073", "mmlu_pro_6074", "mmlu_pro_6079", "mmlu_pro_6084", "mmlu_pro_6088", "mmlu_pro_6094", "mmlu_pro_6095", "mmlu_pro_6120", "mmlu_pro_6114", "mmlu_pro_6130", "mmlu_pro_6134", "mmlu_pro_6140", "mmlu_pro_6144", "mmlu_pro_6160", "mmlu_pro_6152", "mmlu_pro_6162", "mmlu_pro_6171", "mmlu_pro_6176", "mmlu_pro_6177", "mmlu_pro_6188", "mmlu_pro_6194", "mmlu_pro_6204", "mmlu_pro_6206", "mmlu_pro_6212", "mmlu_pro_6215", "mmlu_pro_6217", "mmlu_pro_6219", "mmlu_pro_6221", "mmlu_pro_6229", "mmlu_pro_6237", "mmlu_pro_6249", "mmlu_pro_6252", "mmlu_pro_6269", "mmlu_pro_6263", "mmlu_pro_6299", "mmlu_pro_6291", "mmlu_pro_6302", "mmlu_pro_6306", "mmlu_pro_6310", "mmlu_pro_6313", "mmlu_pro_6314", "mmlu_pro_6317", "mmlu_pro_6318", "mmlu_pro_6332", "mmlu_pro_6336", "mmlu_pro_6341", "mmlu_pro_6344", "mmlu_pro_6347", "mmlu_pro_6354", "mmlu_pro_6367", "mmlu_pro_6372", "mmlu_pro_6379", "mmlu_pro_6382", "mmlu_pro_6389", "mmlu_pro_6413", "mmlu_pro_6443", "mmlu_pro_6435", "mmlu_pro_6464", "mmlu_pro_6452", "mmlu_pro_6471", "mmlu_pro_6482", "mmlu_pro_6485", "mmlu_pro_6487", "mmlu_pro_6488", "mmlu_pro_6490", "mmlu_pro_6491", "mmlu_pro_6494", "mmlu_pro_6495", "mmlu_pro_6499", "mmlu_pro_6504", "mmlu_pro_6523", "mmlu_pro_6524", "mmlu_pro_6537", "mmlu_pro_6539", "mmlu_pro_6542", "mmlu_pro_6546", "mmlu_pro_6547", "mmlu_pro_6554", "mmlu_pro_6567", "mmlu_pro_6565", "mmlu_pro_6576", "mmlu_pro_6586", "mmlu_pro_6592", "mmlu_pro_6596", "mmlu_pro_6609", "mmlu_pro_6624", "mmlu_pro_6625", "mmlu_pro_6646", "mmlu_pro_6658", "mmlu_pro_6674", "mmlu_pro_6682", "mmlu_pro_6679", "mmlu_pro_6700", "mmlu_pro_6694", "mmlu_pro_6720", "mmlu_pro_6722", "mmlu_pro_6726", "mmlu_pro_6729", "mmlu_pro_6733", "mmlu_pro_6736", "mmlu_pro_6752", "mmlu_pro_6760", "mmlu_pro_6763", "mmlu_pro_6765", "mmlu_pro_6769", "mmlu_pro_6770", "mmlu_pro_6771", "mmlu_pro_6775", "mmlu_pro_6780", "mmlu_pro_6786", "mmlu_pro_6802", "mmlu_pro_6804", "mmlu_pro_6807", "mmlu_pro_6817", "mmlu_pro_6820", "mmlu_pro_6829", "mmlu_pro_6845", "mmlu_pro_6849", "mmlu_pro_6852", "mmlu_pro_6861", "mmlu_pro_6865", "mmlu_pro_6872", "mmlu_pro_6879", "mmlu_pro_6881", "mmlu_pro_6885", "mmlu_pro_6886", "mmlu_pro_6888", "mmlu_pro_6891", "mmlu_pro_6894", "mmlu_pro_6892", "mmlu_pro_6907", "mmlu_pro_6920", "mmlu_pro_6921", "mmlu_pro_6923", "mmlu_pro_6928", "mmlu_pro_6933", "mmlu_pro_6939", "mmlu_pro_6942", "mmlu_pro_6964", "mmlu_pro_6970", "mmlu_pro_6975", "mmlu_pro_6973", "mmlu_pro_6994", "mmlu_pro_6995", "mmlu_pro_7001", "mmlu_pro_7007", "mmlu_pro_7002", "mmlu_pro_7008", "mmlu_pro_7011", "mmlu_pro_7029", "mmlu_pro_7043", "mmlu_pro_7049", "mmlu_pro_7050", "mmlu_pro_7051", "mmlu_pro_7058", "mmlu_pro_7076", "mmlu_pro_7085", "mmlu_pro_7095", "mmlu_pro_7090", "mmlu_pro_7097", "mmlu_pro_7100", "mmlu_pro_7110", "mmlu_pro_7111", "mmlu_pro_7113", "mmlu_pro_7118", "mmlu_pro_7127", "mmlu_pro_7126", "mmlu_pro_7131", "mmlu_pro_7132", "mmlu_pro_7142", "mmlu_pro_7154", "mmlu_pro_7163", "mmlu_pro_7171", "mmlu_pro_7175", "mmlu_pro_7176", "mmlu_pro_7181", "mmlu_pro_7183", "mmlu_pro_7190", "mmlu_pro_7194", "mmlu_pro_7209", "mmlu_pro_7232", "mmlu_pro_7236", "mmlu_pro_7249", "mmlu_pro_7252", "mmlu_pro_7253", "mmlu_pro_7269", "mmlu_pro_7279", "mmlu_pro_7283", "mmlu_pro_7284", "mmlu_pro_7285", "mmlu_pro_7287", "mmlu_pro_7294", "mmlu_pro_7305", "mmlu_pro_7306", "mmlu_pro_7327", "mmlu_pro_7331", "mmlu_pro_7344", "mmlu_pro_7345", "mmlu_pro_7359", "mmlu_pro_7361", "mmlu_pro_7365", "mmlu_pro_7367", "mmlu_pro_7369", "mmlu_pro_7371", "mmlu_pro_7376", "mmlu_pro_7372", "mmlu_pro_7386", "mmlu_pro_7380", "mmlu_pro_7388", "mmlu_pro_7391", "mmlu_pro_7395", "mmlu_pro_7397", "mmlu_pro_7406", "mmlu_pro_7402", "mmlu_pro_7413", "mmlu_pro_7415", "mmlu_pro_7423", "mmlu_pro_7427", "mmlu_pro_7422", "mmlu_pro_7438", "mmlu_pro_7444", "mmlu_pro_7470", "mmlu_pro_7468", "mmlu_pro_7473", "mmlu_pro_7482", "mmlu_pro_7501", "mmlu_pro_7506", "mmlu_pro_7503", "mmlu_pro_7516", "mmlu_pro_7523", "mmlu_pro_7524", "mmlu_pro_7532", "mmlu_pro_7528", "mmlu_pro_7540", "mmlu_pro_7538", "mmlu_pro_7544", "mmlu_pro_7564", "mmlu_pro_7589", "mmlu_pro_7572", "mmlu_pro_7596", "mmlu_pro_7595", "mmlu_pro_7601", "mmlu_pro_7600", "mmlu_pro_7612", "mmlu_pro_7619", "mmlu_pro_7620", "mmlu_pro_7621", "mmlu_pro_7626", "mmlu_pro_7629", "mmlu_pro_7633", "mmlu_pro_7635", "mmlu_pro_7639", "mmlu_pro_7660", "mmlu_pro_7656", "mmlu_pro_7675", "mmlu_pro_7661", "mmlu_pro_7682", "mmlu_pro_7694", "mmlu_pro_7708", "mmlu_pro_7709", "mmlu_pro_7715", "mmlu_pro_7716", "mmlu_pro_7723", "mmlu_pro_7717", "mmlu_pro_7727", "mmlu_pro_7737", "mmlu_pro_7750", "mmlu_pro_7755", "mmlu_pro_7764", "mmlu_pro_7770", "mmlu_pro_7765", "mmlu_pro_7777", "mmlu_pro_7779", "mmlu_pro_7789", "mmlu_pro_7790", "mmlu_pro_7792", "mmlu_pro_7798", "mmlu_pro_7808", "mmlu_pro_7817", "mmlu_pro_7812", "mmlu_pro_7826", "mmlu_pro_7828", "mmlu_pro_7835", "mmlu_pro_7836", "mmlu_pro_7848", "mmlu_pro_7837", "mmlu_pro_7851", "mmlu_pro_7852", "mmlu_pro_7871", "mmlu_pro_7858", "mmlu_pro_7880", "mmlu_pro_7878", "mmlu_pro_7887", "mmlu_pro_7900", "mmlu_pro_7893", "mmlu_pro_7909", "mmlu_pro_7902", "mmlu_pro_7917", "mmlu_pro_7918", "mmlu_pro_7925", "mmlu_pro_7936", "mmlu_pro_7934", "mmlu_pro_7940", "mmlu_pro_7939", "mmlu_pro_7946", "mmlu_pro_7945", "mmlu_pro_7953", "mmlu_pro_7957", "mmlu_pro_7962", "mmlu_pro_7975", "mmlu_pro_7972", "mmlu_pro_7981", "mmlu_pro_7989", "mmlu_pro_7983", "mmlu_pro_7995", "mmlu_pro_7993", "mmlu_pro_7996", "mmlu_pro_8003", "mmlu_pro_8004", "mmlu_pro_8023", "mmlu_pro_8021", "mmlu_pro_8048", "mmlu_pro_8034", "mmlu_pro_8050", "mmlu_pro_8071", "mmlu_pro_8080", "mmlu_pro_8076", "mmlu_pro_8095", "mmlu_pro_8084", "mmlu_pro_8101", "mmlu_pro_8108", "mmlu_pro_8109", "mmlu_pro_8115", "mmlu_pro_8123", "mmlu_pro_8138", "mmlu_pro_8152", "mmlu_pro_8154", "mmlu_pro_8140", "mmlu_pro_8158", "mmlu_pro_8156", "mmlu_pro_8166", "mmlu_pro_8176", "mmlu_pro_8159", "mmlu_pro_8178", "mmlu_pro_8181", "mmlu_pro_8195", "mmlu_pro_8184", "mmlu_pro_8218", "mmlu_pro_8196", "mmlu_pro_8224", "mmlu_pro_8222", "mmlu_pro_8226", "mmlu_pro_8235", "mmlu_pro_8236", "mmlu_pro_8241", "mmlu_pro_8247", "mmlu_pro_8242", "mmlu_pro_8249", "mmlu_pro_8259", "mmlu_pro_8262", "mmlu_pro_8273", "mmlu_pro_8275", "mmlu_pro_8277", "mmlu_pro_8283", "mmlu_pro_8284", "mmlu_pro_8294", "mmlu_pro_8291", "mmlu_pro_8295", "mmlu_pro_8302", "mmlu_pro_8301", "mmlu_pro_8320", "mmlu_pro_8333", "mmlu_pro_8337", "mmlu_pro_8341", "mmlu_pro_8342", "mmlu_pro_8354", "mmlu_pro_8348", "mmlu_pro_8365", "mmlu_pro_8361", "mmlu_pro_8371", "mmlu_pro_8379", "mmlu_pro_8391", "mmlu_pro_8389", "mmlu_pro_8397", "mmlu_pro_8411", "mmlu_pro_8419", "mmlu_pro_8417", "mmlu_pro_8449", "mmlu_pro_8441", "mmlu_pro_8473", "mmlu_pro_8458", "mmlu_pro_8474", "mmlu_pro_8475", "mmlu_pro_8478", "mmlu_pro_8481", "mmlu_pro_8484", "mmlu_pro_8486", "mmlu_pro_8508", "mmlu_pro_8515", "mmlu_pro_8516", "mmlu_pro_8530", "mmlu_pro_8562", "mmlu_pro_8563", "mmlu_pro_8567", "mmlu_pro_8569", "mmlu_pro_8580", "mmlu_pro_8584", "mmlu_pro_8582", "mmlu_pro_8594", "mmlu_pro_8586", "mmlu_pro_8601", "mmlu_pro_8611", "mmlu_pro_8614", "mmlu_pro_8629", "mmlu_pro_8641", "mmlu_pro_8644", "mmlu_pro_8647", "mmlu_pro_8658", "mmlu_pro_8654", "mmlu_pro_8669", "mmlu_pro_8670", "mmlu_pro_8699", "mmlu_pro_8690", "mmlu_pro_8704", "mmlu_pro_8709", "mmlu_pro_8710", "mmlu_pro_8724", "mmlu_pro_8729", "mmlu_pro_8733", "mmlu_pro_8725", "mmlu_pro_8745", "mmlu_pro_8747", "mmlu_pro_8760", "mmlu_pro_8761", "mmlu_pro_8781", "mmlu_pro_8766", "mmlu_pro_8796", "mmlu_pro_8805", "mmlu_pro_8803", "mmlu_pro_8816", "mmlu_pro_8820", "mmlu_pro_8826", "mmlu_pro_8831", "mmlu_pro_8833", "mmlu_pro_8839", "mmlu_pro_8843", "mmlu_pro_8844", "mmlu_pro_8848", "mmlu_pro_8855", "mmlu_pro_8850", "mmlu_pro_8865", "mmlu_pro_8856", "mmlu_pro_8875", "mmlu_pro_8878", "mmlu_pro_8872", "mmlu_pro_8912", "mmlu_pro_8903", "mmlu_pro_8932", "mmlu_pro_8919", "mmlu_pro_8934", "mmlu_pro_8936", "mmlu_pro_8941", "mmlu_pro_8950", "mmlu_pro_8955", "mmlu_pro_8956", "mmlu_pro_8958", "mmlu_pro_8975", "mmlu_pro_8971", "mmlu_pro_8983", "mmlu_pro_9004", "mmlu_pro_9002", "mmlu_pro_9005", "mmlu_pro_9010", "mmlu_pro_9013", "mmlu_pro_9016", "mmlu_pro_9019", "mmlu_pro_9024", "mmlu_pro_9028", "mmlu_pro_9033", "mmlu_pro_9039", "mmlu_pro_9042", "mmlu_pro_9072", "mmlu_pro_9063", "mmlu_pro_9099", "mmlu_pro_9084", "mmlu_pro_9101", "mmlu_pro_9114", "mmlu_pro_9121", "mmlu_pro_9123", "mmlu_pro_9124", "mmlu_pro_9125", "mmlu_pro_9129", "mmlu_pro_9140", "mmlu_pro_9137", "mmlu_pro_9141", "mmlu_pro_9155", "mmlu_pro_9143", "mmlu_pro_9157", "mmlu_pro_9164", "mmlu_pro_9172", "mmlu_pro_9181", "mmlu_pro_9185", "mmlu_pro_9187", "mmlu_pro_9188", "mmlu_pro_9192", "mmlu_pro_9217", "mmlu_pro_9213", "mmlu_pro_9228", "mmlu_pro_9219", "mmlu_pro_9239", "mmlu_pro_9243", "mmlu_pro_9244", "mmlu_pro_9245", "mmlu_pro_9254", "mmlu_pro_9274", "mmlu_pro_9265", "mmlu_pro_9282", "mmlu_pro_9291", "mmlu_pro_9286", "mmlu_pro_9307", "mmlu_pro_9314", "mmlu_pro_9308", "mmlu_pro_9328", "mmlu_pro_9324", "mmlu_pro_9337", "mmlu_pro_9329", "mmlu_pro_9342", "mmlu_pro_9340", "mmlu_pro_9345", "mmlu_pro_9349", "mmlu_pro_9374", "mmlu_pro_9375", "mmlu_pro_9376", "mmlu_pro_9380", "mmlu_pro_9378", "mmlu_pro_9396", "mmlu_pro_9407", "mmlu_pro_9400", "mmlu_pro_9410", "mmlu_pro_9411", "mmlu_pro_9414", "mmlu_pro_9415", "mmlu_pro_9422", "mmlu_pro_9439", "mmlu_pro_9442", "mmlu_pro_9443", "mmlu_pro_9448", "mmlu_pro_9483", "mmlu_pro_9491", "mmlu_pro_9494", "mmlu_pro_9503", "mmlu_pro_9500", "mmlu_pro_9511", "mmlu_pro_9521", "mmlu_pro_9512", "mmlu_pro_9545", "mmlu_pro_9533", "mmlu_pro_9548", "mmlu_pro_9586", "mmlu_pro_9567", "mmlu_pro_9613", "mmlu_pro_9603", "mmlu_pro_9621", "mmlu_pro_9619", "mmlu_pro_9623", "mmlu_pro_9627", "mmlu_pro_9629", "mmlu_pro_9632", "mmlu_pro_9641", "mmlu_pro_9644", "mmlu_pro_9653", "mmlu_pro_9647", "mmlu_pro_9661", "mmlu_pro_9671", "mmlu_pro_9686", "mmlu_pro_9675", "mmlu_pro_9687", "mmlu_pro_9697", "mmlu_pro_9705", "mmlu_pro_9715", "mmlu_pro_9725", "mmlu_pro_9734", "mmlu_pro_9739", "mmlu_pro_9738", "mmlu_pro_9743", "mmlu_pro_9753", "mmlu_pro_9756", "mmlu_pro_9768", "mmlu_pro_9777", "mmlu_pro_9791", "mmlu_pro_9793", "mmlu_pro_9798", "mmlu_pro_9808", "mmlu_pro_9817", "mmlu_pro_9820", "mmlu_pro_9819", "mmlu_pro_9839", "mmlu_pro_9840", "mmlu_pro_9843", "mmlu_pro_9851", "mmlu_pro_9852", "mmlu_pro_9859", "mmlu_pro_9876", "mmlu_pro_9872", "mmlu_pro_9882", "mmlu_pro_9884", "mmlu_pro_9891", "mmlu_pro_9903", "mmlu_pro_9895", "mmlu_pro_9907", "mmlu_pro_9923", "mmlu_pro_9925", "mmlu_pro_9926", "mmlu_pro_9933", "mmlu_pro_9930", "mmlu_pro_9942", "mmlu_pro_9968", "mmlu_pro_9969", "mmlu_pro_9971", "mmlu_pro_9975", "mmlu_pro_9976", "mmlu_pro_9977", "mmlu_pro_9989", "mmlu_pro_9987", "mmlu_pro_9993", "mmlu_pro_9991", "mmlu_pro_10005", "mmlu_pro_10011", "mmlu_pro_10034", "mmlu_pro_10026", "mmlu_pro_10035", "mmlu_pro_10037", "mmlu_pro_10036", "mmlu_pro_10038", "mmlu_pro_10044", "mmlu_pro_10051", "mmlu_pro_10060", "mmlu_pro_10065", "mmlu_pro_10063", "mmlu_pro_10079", "mmlu_pro_10074", "mmlu_pro_10085", "mmlu_pro_10080", "mmlu_pro_10087", "mmlu_pro_10095", "mmlu_pro_10090", "mmlu_pro_10112", "mmlu_pro_10098", "mmlu_pro_10131", "mmlu_pro_10127", "mmlu_pro_10134", "mmlu_pro_10141", "mmlu_pro_10139", "mmlu_pro_10142", "mmlu_pro_10147", "mmlu_pro_10150", "mmlu_pro_10156", "mmlu_pro_10159", "mmlu_pro_10162", "mmlu_pro_10179", "mmlu_pro_10170", "mmlu_pro_10185", "mmlu_pro_10186", "mmlu_pro_10222", "mmlu_pro_10230", "mmlu_pro_10241", "mmlu_pro_10242", "mmlu_pro_10245", "mmlu_pro_10247", "mmlu_pro_10270", "mmlu_pro_10271", "mmlu_pro_10285", "mmlu_pro_10283", "mmlu_pro_10290", "mmlu_pro_10288", "mmlu_pro_10299", "mmlu_pro_10300", "mmlu_pro_10302", "mmlu_pro_10308", "mmlu_pro_10314", "mmlu_pro_10315", "mmlu_pro_10316", "mmlu_pro_10321", "mmlu_pro_10318", "mmlu_pro_10324", "mmlu_pro_10333", "mmlu_pro_10341", "mmlu_pro_10343", "mmlu_pro_10344", "mmlu_pro_10349", "mmlu_pro_10346", "mmlu_pro_10360", "mmlu_pro_10367", "mmlu_pro_10372", "mmlu_pro_10382", "mmlu_pro_10387", "mmlu_pro_10408", "mmlu_pro_10411", "mmlu_pro_10417", "mmlu_pro_10422", "mmlu_pro_10437", "mmlu_pro_10432", "mmlu_pro_10441", "mmlu_pro_10454", "mmlu_pro_10467", "mmlu_pro_10476", "mmlu_pro_10481", "mmlu_pro_10478", "mmlu_pro_10484", "mmlu_pro_10487", "mmlu_pro_10489", "mmlu_pro_10492", "mmlu_pro_10502", "mmlu_pro_10503", "mmlu_pro_10505", "mmlu_pro_10515", "mmlu_pro_10520", "mmlu_pro_10526", "mmlu_pro_10527", "mmlu_pro_10532", "mmlu_pro_10538", "mmlu_pro_10543", "mmlu_pro_10544", "mmlu_pro_10568", "mmlu_pro_10571", "mmlu_pro_10578", "mmlu_pro_10586", "mmlu_pro_10589", "mmlu_pro_10600", "mmlu_pro_10602", "mmlu_pro_10609", "mmlu_pro_10621", "mmlu_pro_10627", "mmlu_pro_10641", "mmlu_pro_10648", "mmlu_pro_10651", "mmlu_pro_10656", "mmlu_pro_10661", "mmlu_pro_10663", "mmlu_pro_10669", "mmlu_pro_10689", "mmlu_pro_10692", "mmlu_pro_10694", "mmlu_pro_10713", "mmlu_pro_10703", "mmlu_pro_10717", "mmlu_pro_10728", "mmlu_pro_10737", "mmlu_pro_10741", "mmlu_pro_10752", "mmlu_pro_10753", "mmlu_pro_10758", "mmlu_pro_10762", "mmlu_pro_10765", "mmlu_pro_10769", "mmlu_pro_10783", "mmlu_pro_10770", "mmlu_pro_10792", "mmlu_pro_10797", "mmlu_pro_10802", "mmlu_pro_10816", "mmlu_pro_10822", "mmlu_pro_10823", "mmlu_pro_10830", "mmlu_pro_10842", "mmlu_pro_10851", "mmlu_pro_10854", "mmlu_pro_10863", "mmlu_pro_10868", "mmlu_pro_10878", "mmlu_pro_10873", "mmlu_pro_10882", "mmlu_pro_10883", "mmlu_pro_10893", "mmlu_pro_10895", "mmlu_pro_10903", "mmlu_pro_10905", "mmlu_pro_10909", "mmlu_pro_10910", "mmlu_pro_10922", "mmlu_pro_10925", "mmlu_pro_10928", "mmlu_pro_10932", "mmlu_pro_10936", "mmlu_pro_10937", "mmlu_pro_10969", "mmlu_pro_10971", "mmlu_pro_10979"]
abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/qids_phi-4-mini_s0.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
 
 
1
+ ["mmlu_pro_19", "mmlu_pro_10", "mmlu_pro_27", "mmlu_pro_20", "mmlu_pro_29", "mmlu_pro_48", "mmlu_pro_49", "mmlu_pro_39", "mmlu_pro_52", "mmlu_pro_60", "mmlu_pro_73", "mmlu_pro_102", "mmlu_pro_88", "mmlu_pro_107", "mmlu_pro_112", "mmlu_pro_123", "mmlu_pro_117", "mmlu_pro_154", "mmlu_pro_142", "mmlu_pro_157", "mmlu_pro_167", "mmlu_pro_165", "mmlu_pro_169", "mmlu_pro_171", "mmlu_pro_177", "mmlu_pro_180", "mmlu_pro_201", "mmlu_pro_181", "mmlu_pro_213", "mmlu_pro_211", "mmlu_pro_220", "mmlu_pro_222", "mmlu_pro_233", "mmlu_pro_234", "mmlu_pro_238", "mmlu_pro_240", "mmlu_pro_245", "mmlu_pro_256", "mmlu_pro_257", "mmlu_pro_254", "mmlu_pro_261", "mmlu_pro_264", "mmlu_pro_269", "mmlu_pro_267", "mmlu_pro_273", "mmlu_pro_275", "mmlu_pro_279", "mmlu_pro_291", "mmlu_pro_293", "mmlu_pro_296", "mmlu_pro_295", "mmlu_pro_299", "mmlu_pro_303", "mmlu_pro_308", "mmlu_pro_318", "mmlu_pro_309", "mmlu_pro_320", "mmlu_pro_321", "mmlu_pro_328", "mmlu_pro_325", "mmlu_pro_334", "mmlu_pro_364", "mmlu_pro_344", "mmlu_pro_369", "mmlu_pro_370", "mmlu_pro_372", "mmlu_pro_377", "mmlu_pro_382", "mmlu_pro_384", "mmlu_pro_412", "mmlu_pro_413", "mmlu_pro_420", "mmlu_pro_416", "mmlu_pro_425", "mmlu_pro_430", "mmlu_pro_431", "mmlu_pro_436", "mmlu_pro_440", "mmlu_pro_458", "mmlu_pro_451", "mmlu_pro_459", "mmlu_pro_476", "mmlu_pro_480", "mmlu_pro_491", "mmlu_pro_498", "mmlu_pro_485", "mmlu_pro_517", "mmlu_pro_522", "mmlu_pro_521", "mmlu_pro_526", "mmlu_pro_539", "mmlu_pro_530", "mmlu_pro_542", "mmlu_pro_552", "mmlu_pro_554", "mmlu_pro_556", "mmlu_pro_558", "mmlu_pro_577", "mmlu_pro_590", "mmlu_pro_596", "mmlu_pro_602", "mmlu_pro_610", "mmlu_pro_604", "mmlu_pro_612", "mmlu_pro_615", "mmlu_pro_627", "mmlu_pro_631", "mmlu_pro_633", "mmlu_pro_646", "mmlu_pro_658", "mmlu_pro_661", "mmlu_pro_657", "mmlu_pro_673", "mmlu_pro_678", "mmlu_pro_683", "mmlu_pro_686", "mmlu_pro_693", "mmlu_pro_703", "mmlu_pro_716", "mmlu_pro_712", "mmlu_pro_726", "mmlu_pro_743", "mmlu_pro_754", "mmlu_pro_753", "mmlu_pro_755", "mmlu_pro_756", "mmlu_pro_758", "mmlu_pro_766", "mmlu_pro_765", "mmlu_pro_768", "mmlu_pro_791", "mmlu_pro_796", "mmlu_pro_797", "mmlu_pro_822", "mmlu_pro_830", "mmlu_pro_833", "mmlu_pro_835", "mmlu_pro_841", "mmlu_pro_852", "mmlu_pro_859", "mmlu_pro_863", "mmlu_pro_880", "mmlu_pro_866", "mmlu_pro_883", "mmlu_pro_886", "mmlu_pro_890", "mmlu_pro_891", "mmlu_pro_895", "mmlu_pro_896", "mmlu_pro_903", "mmlu_pro_910", "mmlu_pro_913", "mmlu_pro_919", "mmlu_pro_932", "mmlu_pro_954", "mmlu_pro_943", "mmlu_pro_968", "mmlu_pro_972", "mmlu_pro_978", "mmlu_pro_982", "mmlu_pro_996", "mmlu_pro_1001", "mmlu_pro_1014", "mmlu_pro_1011", "mmlu_pro_1027", "mmlu_pro_1029", "mmlu_pro_1034", "mmlu_pro_1038", "mmlu_pro_1040", "mmlu_pro_1055", "mmlu_pro_1070", "mmlu_pro_1061", "mmlu_pro_1082", "mmlu_pro_1081", "mmlu_pro_1092", "mmlu_pro_1105", "mmlu_pro_1113", "mmlu_pro_1112", "mmlu_pro_1117", "mmlu_pro_1123", "mmlu_pro_1156", "mmlu_pro_1173", "mmlu_pro_1179", "mmlu_pro_1174", "mmlu_pro_1181", "mmlu_pro_1198", "mmlu_pro_1191", "mmlu_pro_1199", "mmlu_pro_1209", "mmlu_pro_1212", "mmlu_pro_1221", "mmlu_pro_1217", "mmlu_pro_1227", "mmlu_pro_1233", "mmlu_pro_1241", "mmlu_pro_1243", "mmlu_pro_1252", "mmlu_pro_1247", "mmlu_pro_1255", "mmlu_pro_1261", "mmlu_pro_1265", "mmlu_pro_1263", "mmlu_pro_1278", "mmlu_pro_1268", "mmlu_pro_1299", "mmlu_pro_1305", "mmlu_pro_1308", "mmlu_pro_1306", "mmlu_pro_1327", "mmlu_pro_1326", "mmlu_pro_1339", "mmlu_pro_1341", "mmlu_pro_1351", "mmlu_pro_1353", "mmlu_pro_1355", "mmlu_pro_1358", "mmlu_pro_1360", "mmlu_pro_1362", "mmlu_pro_1367", "mmlu_pro_1365", "mmlu_pro_1378", "mmlu_pro_1380", "mmlu_pro_1383", "mmlu_pro_1388", "mmlu_pro_1390", "mmlu_pro_1396", "mmlu_pro_1402", "mmlu_pro_1399", "mmlu_pro_1410", "mmlu_pro_1413", "mmlu_pro_1414", "mmlu_pro_1416", "mmlu_pro_1418", "mmlu_pro_1429", "mmlu_pro_1433", "mmlu_pro_1430", "mmlu_pro_1442", "mmlu_pro_1436", "mmlu_pro_1451", "mmlu_pro_1453", "mmlu_pro_1462", "mmlu_pro_1469", "mmlu_pro_1479", "mmlu_pro_1481", "mmlu_pro_1482", "mmlu_pro_1485", "mmlu_pro_1500", "mmlu_pro_1509", "mmlu_pro_1502", "mmlu_pro_1511", "mmlu_pro_1515", "mmlu_pro_1519", "mmlu_pro_1522", "mmlu_pro_1534", "mmlu_pro_1541", "mmlu_pro_1544", "mmlu_pro_1543", "mmlu_pro_1547", "mmlu_pro_1548", "mmlu_pro_1563", "mmlu_pro_1567", "mmlu_pro_1568", "mmlu_pro_1576", "mmlu_pro_1589", "mmlu_pro_1590", "mmlu_pro_1606", "mmlu_pro_1612", "mmlu_pro_1615", "mmlu_pro_1626", "mmlu_pro_1618", "mmlu_pro_1628", "mmlu_pro_1639", "mmlu_pro_1648", "mmlu_pro_1646", "mmlu_pro_1649", "mmlu_pro_1652", "mmlu_pro_1661", "mmlu_pro_1663", "mmlu_pro_1664", "mmlu_pro_1676", "mmlu_pro_1681", "mmlu_pro_1689", "mmlu_pro_1694", "mmlu_pro_1710", "mmlu_pro_1715", "mmlu_pro_1716", "mmlu_pro_1721", "mmlu_pro_1727", "mmlu_pro_1729", "mmlu_pro_1733", "mmlu_pro_1730", "mmlu_pro_1750", "mmlu_pro_1766", "mmlu_pro_1772", "mmlu_pro_1774", "mmlu_pro_1776", "mmlu_pro_1793", "mmlu_pro_1801", "mmlu_pro_1815", "mmlu_pro_1847", "mmlu_pro_1838", "mmlu_pro_1855", "mmlu_pro_1863", "mmlu_pro_1865", "mmlu_pro_1869", "mmlu_pro_1879", "mmlu_pro_1891", "mmlu_pro_1905", "mmlu_pro_1897", "mmlu_pro_1907", "mmlu_pro_1916", "mmlu_pro_1911", "mmlu_pro_1917", "mmlu_pro_1918", "mmlu_pro_1927", "mmlu_pro_1938", "mmlu_pro_1939", "mmlu_pro_1949", "mmlu_pro_1959", "mmlu_pro_1954", "mmlu_pro_1969", "mmlu_pro_1971", "mmlu_pro_1980", "mmlu_pro_1983", "mmlu_pro_1991", "mmlu_pro_1999", "mmlu_pro_1994", "mmlu_pro_2011", "mmlu_pro_2006", "mmlu_pro_2014", "mmlu_pro_2017", "mmlu_pro_2022", "mmlu_pro_2023", "mmlu_pro_2026", "mmlu_pro_2051", "mmlu_pro_2054", "mmlu_pro_2057", "mmlu_pro_2068", "mmlu_pro_2066", "mmlu_pro_2076", "mmlu_pro_2078", "mmlu_pro_2073", "mmlu_pro_2081", "mmlu_pro_2105", "mmlu_pro_2107", "mmlu_pro_2114", "mmlu_pro_2117", "mmlu_pro_2119", "mmlu_pro_2144", "mmlu_pro_2156", "mmlu_pro_2165", "mmlu_pro_2160", "mmlu_pro_2177", "mmlu_pro_2167", "mmlu_pro_2181", "mmlu_pro_2178", "mmlu_pro_2184", "mmlu_pro_2193", "mmlu_pro_2199", "mmlu_pro_2191", "mmlu_pro_2208", "mmlu_pro_2227", "mmlu_pro_2238", "mmlu_pro_2240", "mmlu_pro_2242", "mmlu_pro_2241", "mmlu_pro_2260", "mmlu_pro_2274", "mmlu_pro_2276", "mmlu_pro_2303", "mmlu_pro_2313", "mmlu_pro_2306", "mmlu_pro_2315", "mmlu_pro_2334", "mmlu_pro_2337", "mmlu_pro_2338", "mmlu_pro_2340", "mmlu_pro_2352", "mmlu_pro_2362", "mmlu_pro_2360", "mmlu_pro_2365", "mmlu_pro_2366", "mmlu_pro_2381", "mmlu_pro_2388", "mmlu_pro_2395", "mmlu_pro_2390", "mmlu_pro_2407", "mmlu_pro_2423", "mmlu_pro_2424", "mmlu_pro_2440", "mmlu_pro_2429", "mmlu_pro_2458", "mmlu_pro_2468", "mmlu_pro_2472", "mmlu_pro_2481", "mmlu_pro_2480", "mmlu_pro_2487", "mmlu_pro_2490", "mmlu_pro_2492", "mmlu_pro_2496", "mmlu_pro_2497", "mmlu_pro_2511", "mmlu_pro_2498", "mmlu_pro_2516", "mmlu_pro_2521", "mmlu_pro_2535", "mmlu_pro_2522", "mmlu_pro_2539", "mmlu_pro_2540", "mmlu_pro_2544", "mmlu_pro_2545", "mmlu_pro_2553", "mmlu_pro_2567", "mmlu_pro_2556", "mmlu_pro_2577", "mmlu_pro_2574", "mmlu_pro_2579", "mmlu_pro_2582", "mmlu_pro_2586", "mmlu_pro_2588", "mmlu_pro_2594", "mmlu_pro_2596", "mmlu_pro_2598", "mmlu_pro_2610", "mmlu_pro_2606", "mmlu_pro_2627", "mmlu_pro_2621", "mmlu_pro_2630", "mmlu_pro_2633", "mmlu_pro_2634", "mmlu_pro_2638", "mmlu_pro_2651", "mmlu_pro_2652", "mmlu_pro_2654", "mmlu_pro_2665", "mmlu_pro_2666", "mmlu_pro_2672", "mmlu_pro_2676", "mmlu_pro_2680", "mmlu_pro_2694", "mmlu_pro_2692", "mmlu_pro_2701", "mmlu_pro_2706", "mmlu_pro_2709", "mmlu_pro_2718", "mmlu_pro_2727", "mmlu_pro_2720", "mmlu_pro_2732", "mmlu_pro_2734", "mmlu_pro_2747", "mmlu_pro_2753", "mmlu_pro_2757", "mmlu_pro_2761", "mmlu_pro_2770", "mmlu_pro_2786", "mmlu_pro_2790", "mmlu_pro_2802", "mmlu_pro_2803", "mmlu_pro_2811", "mmlu_pro_2815", "mmlu_pro_2831", "mmlu_pro_2833", "mmlu_pro_2832", "mmlu_pro_2837", "mmlu_pro_2841", "mmlu_pro_2845", "mmlu_pro_2835", "mmlu_pro_2858", "mmlu_pro_2848", "mmlu_pro_2860", "mmlu_pro_2861", "mmlu_pro_2864", "mmlu_pro_2876", "mmlu_pro_2898", "mmlu_pro_2906", "mmlu_pro_2914", "mmlu_pro_2929", "mmlu_pro_2918", "mmlu_pro_2939", "mmlu_pro_2930", "mmlu_pro_2965", "mmlu_pro_2953", "mmlu_pro_2970", "mmlu_pro_2980", "mmlu_pro_2985", "mmlu_pro_2986", "mmlu_pro_2987", "mmlu_pro_2988", "mmlu_pro_3022", "mmlu_pro_3019", "mmlu_pro_3028", "mmlu_pro_3031", "mmlu_pro_3037", "mmlu_pro_3041", "mmlu_pro_3043", "mmlu_pro_3049", "mmlu_pro_3046", "mmlu_pro_3069", "mmlu_pro_3070", "mmlu_pro_3072", "mmlu_pro_3074", "mmlu_pro_3086", "mmlu_pro_3089", "mmlu_pro_3087", "mmlu_pro_3091", "mmlu_pro_3101", "mmlu_pro_3092", "mmlu_pro_3108", "mmlu_pro_3118", "mmlu_pro_3114", "mmlu_pro_3120", "mmlu_pro_3126", "mmlu_pro_3144", "mmlu_pro_3159", "mmlu_pro_3161", "mmlu_pro_3162", "mmlu_pro_3171", "mmlu_pro_3196", "mmlu_pro_3211", "mmlu_pro_3177", "mmlu_pro_3218", "mmlu_pro_3219", "mmlu_pro_3230", "mmlu_pro_3259", "mmlu_pro_3253", "mmlu_pro_3265", "mmlu_pro_3269", "mmlu_pro_3270", "mmlu_pro_3273", "mmlu_pro_3275", "mmlu_pro_3289", "mmlu_pro_3281", "mmlu_pro_3299", "mmlu_pro_3303", "mmlu_pro_3305", "mmlu_pro_3310", "mmlu_pro_3306", "mmlu_pro_3315", "mmlu_pro_3311", "mmlu_pro_3320", "mmlu_pro_3319", "mmlu_pro_3331", "mmlu_pro_3338", "mmlu_pro_3336", "mmlu_pro_3339", "mmlu_pro_3340", "mmlu_pro_3352", "mmlu_pro_3354", "mmlu_pro_3358", "mmlu_pro_3362", "mmlu_pro_3364", "mmlu_pro_3363", "mmlu_pro_3369", "mmlu_pro_3370", "mmlu_pro_3378", "mmlu_pro_3375", "mmlu_pro_3404", "mmlu_pro_3402", "mmlu_pro_3410", "mmlu_pro_3409", "mmlu_pro_3414", "mmlu_pro_3419", "mmlu_pro_3417", "mmlu_pro_3433", "mmlu_pro_3421", "mmlu_pro_3444", "mmlu_pro_3434", "mmlu_pro_3446", "mmlu_pro_3453", "mmlu_pro_3459", "mmlu_pro_3460", "mmlu_pro_3461", "mmlu_pro_3465", "mmlu_pro_3470", "mmlu_pro_3479", "mmlu_pro_3489", "mmlu_pro_3511", "mmlu_pro_3499", "mmlu_pro_3522", "mmlu_pro_3523", "mmlu_pro_3534", "mmlu_pro_3539", "mmlu_pro_3543", "mmlu_pro_3538", "mmlu_pro_3562", "mmlu_pro_3558", "mmlu_pro_3572", "mmlu_pro_3570", "mmlu_pro_3580", "mmlu_pro_3579", "mmlu_pro_3584", "mmlu_pro_3587", "mmlu_pro_3598", "mmlu_pro_3599", "mmlu_pro_3600", "mmlu_pro_3610", "mmlu_pro_3612", "mmlu_pro_3626", "mmlu_pro_3630", "mmlu_pro_3644", "mmlu_pro_3637", "mmlu_pro_3646", "mmlu_pro_3647", "mmlu_pro_3670", "mmlu_pro_3678", "mmlu_pro_3681", "mmlu_pro_3687", "mmlu_pro_3680", "mmlu_pro_3695", "mmlu_pro_3696", "mmlu_pro_3703", "mmlu_pro_3711", "mmlu_pro_3720", "mmlu_pro_3722", "mmlu_pro_3729", "mmlu_pro_3736", "mmlu_pro_3725", "mmlu_pro_3737", "mmlu_pro_3739", "mmlu_pro_3740", "mmlu_pro_3757", "mmlu_pro_3759", "mmlu_pro_3758", "mmlu_pro_3764", "mmlu_pro_3768", "mmlu_pro_3786", "mmlu_pro_3777", "mmlu_pro_3791", "mmlu_pro_3805", "mmlu_pro_3807", "mmlu_pro_3817", "mmlu_pro_3815", "mmlu_pro_3822", "mmlu_pro_3819", "mmlu_pro_3826", "mmlu_pro_3828", "mmlu_pro_3832", "mmlu_pro_3835", "mmlu_pro_3842", "mmlu_pro_3855", "mmlu_pro_3863", "mmlu_pro_3856", "mmlu_pro_3864", "mmlu_pro_3871", "mmlu_pro_3867", "mmlu_pro_3895", "mmlu_pro_3903", "mmlu_pro_3902", "mmlu_pro_3909", "mmlu_pro_3910", "mmlu_pro_3912", "mmlu_pro_3924", "mmlu_pro_3913", "mmlu_pro_3936", "mmlu_pro_3954", "mmlu_pro_3955", "mmlu_pro_3976", "mmlu_pro_3964", "mmlu_pro_3979", "mmlu_pro_3981", "mmlu_pro_3985", "mmlu_pro_3991", "mmlu_pro_3994", "mmlu_pro_4004", "mmlu_pro_4006", "mmlu_pro_4009", "mmlu_pro_4018", "mmlu_pro_4029", "mmlu_pro_4032", "mmlu_pro_4038", "mmlu_pro_4037", "mmlu_pro_4040", "mmlu_pro_4057", "mmlu_pro_4045", "mmlu_pro_4064", "mmlu_pro_4089", "mmlu_pro_4063", "mmlu_pro_4105", "mmlu_pro_4117", "mmlu_pro_4109", "mmlu_pro_4139", "mmlu_pro_4143", "mmlu_pro_4144", "mmlu_pro_4146", "mmlu_pro_4158", "mmlu_pro_4148", "mmlu_pro_4163", "mmlu_pro_4165", "mmlu_pro_4181", "mmlu_pro_4198", "mmlu_pro_4204", "mmlu_pro_4207", "mmlu_pro_4205", "mmlu_pro_4210", "mmlu_pro_4217", "mmlu_pro_4215", "mmlu_pro_4226", "mmlu_pro_4228", "mmlu_pro_4232", "mmlu_pro_4234", "mmlu_pro_4242", "mmlu_pro_4243", "mmlu_pro_4246", "mmlu_pro_4253", "mmlu_pro_4258", "mmlu_pro_4261", "mmlu_pro_4270", "mmlu_pro_4269", "mmlu_pro_4279", "mmlu_pro_4287", "mmlu_pro_4295", "mmlu_pro_4296", "mmlu_pro_4297", "mmlu_pro_4302", "mmlu_pro_4333", "mmlu_pro_4340", "mmlu_pro_4343", "mmlu_pro_4350", "mmlu_pro_4371", "mmlu_pro_4392", "mmlu_pro_4399", "mmlu_pro_4406", "mmlu_pro_4411", "mmlu_pro_4410", "mmlu_pro_4434", "mmlu_pro_4433", "mmlu_pro_4439", "mmlu_pro_4459", "mmlu_pro_4468", "mmlu_pro_4479", "mmlu_pro_4489", "mmlu_pro_4508", "mmlu_pro_4507", "mmlu_pro_4509", "mmlu_pro_4512", "mmlu_pro_4518", "mmlu_pro_4522", "mmlu_pro_4519", "mmlu_pro_4524", "mmlu_pro_4531", "mmlu_pro_4528", "mmlu_pro_4534", "mmlu_pro_4537", "mmlu_pro_4536", "mmlu_pro_4544", "mmlu_pro_4551", "mmlu_pro_4562", "mmlu_pro_4557", "mmlu_pro_4574", "mmlu_pro_4583", "mmlu_pro_4586", "mmlu_pro_4589", "mmlu_pro_4597", "mmlu_pro_4598", "mmlu_pro_4606", "mmlu_pro_4616", "mmlu_pro_4617", "mmlu_pro_4630", "mmlu_pro_4621", "mmlu_pro_4637", "mmlu_pro_4636", "mmlu_pro_4639", "mmlu_pro_4640", "mmlu_pro_4643", "mmlu_pro_4660", "mmlu_pro_4661", "mmlu_pro_4670", "mmlu_pro_4674", "mmlu_pro_4684", "mmlu_pro_4681", "mmlu_pro_4696", "mmlu_pro_4698", "mmlu_pro_4704", "mmlu_pro_4703", "mmlu_pro_4720", "mmlu_pro_4709", "mmlu_pro_4724", "mmlu_pro_4723", "mmlu_pro_4736", "mmlu_pro_4744", "mmlu_pro_4760", "mmlu_pro_4753", "mmlu_pro_4763", "mmlu_pro_4771", "mmlu_pro_4776", "mmlu_pro_4786", "mmlu_pro_4787", "mmlu_pro_4792", "mmlu_pro_4794", "mmlu_pro_4795", "mmlu_pro_4807", "mmlu_pro_4800", "mmlu_pro_4814", "mmlu_pro_4820", "mmlu_pro_4829", "mmlu_pro_4836", "mmlu_pro_4877", "mmlu_pro_4842", "mmlu_pro_4878", "mmlu_pro_4884", "mmlu_pro_4893", "mmlu_pro_4897", "mmlu_pro_4904", "mmlu_pro_4899", "mmlu_pro_4916", "mmlu_pro_4924", "mmlu_pro_4938", "mmlu_pro_4939", "mmlu_pro_4955", "mmlu_pro_4949", "mmlu_pro_4957", "mmlu_pro_4956", "mmlu_pro_4961", "mmlu_pro_4960", "mmlu_pro_4986", "mmlu_pro_4969", "mmlu_pro_4992", "mmlu_pro_5023", "mmlu_pro_5016", "mmlu_pro_5046", "mmlu_pro_5038", "mmlu_pro_5058", "mmlu_pro_5050", "mmlu_pro_5061", "mmlu_pro_5072", "mmlu_pro_5074", "mmlu_pro_5078", "mmlu_pro_5080", "mmlu_pro_5085", "mmlu_pro_5086", "mmlu_pro_5088", "mmlu_pro_5091", "mmlu_pro_5093", "mmlu_pro_5103", "mmlu_pro_5095", "mmlu_pro_5114", "mmlu_pro_5108", "mmlu_pro_5128", "mmlu_pro_5121", "mmlu_pro_5134", "mmlu_pro_5130", "mmlu_pro_5140", "mmlu_pro_5149", "mmlu_pro_5153", "mmlu_pro_5157", "mmlu_pro_5158", "mmlu_pro_5159", "mmlu_pro_5167", "mmlu_pro_5172", "mmlu_pro_5191", "mmlu_pro_5193", "mmlu_pro_5212", "mmlu_pro_5214", "mmlu_pro_5225", "mmlu_pro_5226", "mmlu_pro_5229", "mmlu_pro_5231", "mmlu_pro_5237", "mmlu_pro_5245", "mmlu_pro_5248", "mmlu_pro_5246", "mmlu_pro_5256", "mmlu_pro_5262", "mmlu_pro_5263", "mmlu_pro_5264", "mmlu_pro_5267", "mmlu_pro_5270", "mmlu_pro_5279", "mmlu_pro_5281", "mmlu_pro_5294", "mmlu_pro_5300", "mmlu_pro_5305", "mmlu_pro_5311", "mmlu_pro_5319", "mmlu_pro_5328", "mmlu_pro_5324", "mmlu_pro_5331", "mmlu_pro_5333", "mmlu_pro_5348", "mmlu_pro_5339", "mmlu_pro_5369", "mmlu_pro_5374", "mmlu_pro_5381", "mmlu_pro_5387", "mmlu_pro_5396", "mmlu_pro_5393", "mmlu_pro_5421", "mmlu_pro_5423", "mmlu_pro_5431", "mmlu_pro_5443", "mmlu_pro_5445", "mmlu_pro_5447", "mmlu_pro_5450", "mmlu_pro_5459", "mmlu_pro_5456", "mmlu_pro_5473", "mmlu_pro_5465", "mmlu_pro_5482", "mmlu_pro_5500", "mmlu_pro_5501", "mmlu_pro_5502", "mmlu_pro_5507", "mmlu_pro_5512", "mmlu_pro_5519", "mmlu_pro_5523", "mmlu_pro_5522", "mmlu_pro_5540", "mmlu_pro_5541", "mmlu_pro_5542", "mmlu_pro_5557", "mmlu_pro_5554", "mmlu_pro_5561", "mmlu_pro_5563", "mmlu_pro_5571", "mmlu_pro_5565", "mmlu_pro_5588", "mmlu_pro_5598", "mmlu_pro_5607", "mmlu_pro_5600", "mmlu_pro_5610", "mmlu_pro_5613", "mmlu_pro_5616", "mmlu_pro_5626", "mmlu_pro_5623", "mmlu_pro_5630", "mmlu_pro_5638", "mmlu_pro_5639", "mmlu_pro_5647", "mmlu_pro_5661", "mmlu_pro_5662", "mmlu_pro_5669", "mmlu_pro_5672", "mmlu_pro_5677", "mmlu_pro_5695", "mmlu_pro_5696", "mmlu_pro_5705", "mmlu_pro_5711", "mmlu_pro_5709", "mmlu_pro_5714", "mmlu_pro_5716", "mmlu_pro_5721", "mmlu_pro_5737", "mmlu_pro_5730", "mmlu_pro_5738", "mmlu_pro_5746", "mmlu_pro_5760", "mmlu_pro_5763", "mmlu_pro_5780", "mmlu_pro_5778", "mmlu_pro_5784", "mmlu_pro_5791", "mmlu_pro_5812", "mmlu_pro_5815", "mmlu_pro_5817", "mmlu_pro_5818", "mmlu_pro_5823", "mmlu_pro_5829", "mmlu_pro_5836", "mmlu_pro_5854", "mmlu_pro_5853", "mmlu_pro_5855", "mmlu_pro_5860", "mmlu_pro_5876", "mmlu_pro_5879", "mmlu_pro_5888", "mmlu_pro_5891", "mmlu_pro_5899", "mmlu_pro_5902", "mmlu_pro_5911", "mmlu_pro_5905", "mmlu_pro_5927", "mmlu_pro_5912", "mmlu_pro_5931", "mmlu_pro_5932", "mmlu_pro_5947", "mmlu_pro_5955", "mmlu_pro_5959", "mmlu_pro_5965", "mmlu_pro_5960", "mmlu_pro_5967", "mmlu_pro_5966"]
abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/qids_phi-4-mini_s1.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
 
 
1
+ ["mmlu_pro_5971", "mmlu_pro_5981", "mmlu_pro_5982", "mmlu_pro_5985", "mmlu_pro_5998", "mmlu_pro_5997", "mmlu_pro_6007", "mmlu_pro_6009", "mmlu_pro_6012", "mmlu_pro_6020", "mmlu_pro_6027", "mmlu_pro_6021", "mmlu_pro_6032", "mmlu_pro_6029", "mmlu_pro_6034", "mmlu_pro_6033", "mmlu_pro_6038", "mmlu_pro_6052", "mmlu_pro_6055", "mmlu_pro_6054", "mmlu_pro_6062", "mmlu_pro_6073", "mmlu_pro_6074", "mmlu_pro_6084", "mmlu_pro_6079", "mmlu_pro_6094", "mmlu_pro_6088", "mmlu_pro_6095", "mmlu_pro_6114", "mmlu_pro_6120", "mmlu_pro_6134", "mmlu_pro_6130", "mmlu_pro_6140", "mmlu_pro_6144", "mmlu_pro_6152", "mmlu_pro_6160", "mmlu_pro_6162", "mmlu_pro_6171", "mmlu_pro_6176", "mmlu_pro_6188", "mmlu_pro_6177", "mmlu_pro_6194", "mmlu_pro_6204", "mmlu_pro_6206", "mmlu_pro_6212", "mmlu_pro_6215", "mmlu_pro_6217", "mmlu_pro_6219", "mmlu_pro_6221", "mmlu_pro_6229", "mmlu_pro_6237", "mmlu_pro_6249", "mmlu_pro_6252", "mmlu_pro_6263", "mmlu_pro_6269", "mmlu_pro_6291", "mmlu_pro_6299", "mmlu_pro_6302", "mmlu_pro_6310", "mmlu_pro_6306", "mmlu_pro_6314", "mmlu_pro_6313", "mmlu_pro_6317", "mmlu_pro_6332", "mmlu_pro_6318", "mmlu_pro_6341", "mmlu_pro_6336", "mmlu_pro_6347", "mmlu_pro_6344", "mmlu_pro_6354", "mmlu_pro_6367", "mmlu_pro_6372", "mmlu_pro_6379", "mmlu_pro_6382", "mmlu_pro_6389", "mmlu_pro_6413", "mmlu_pro_6435", "mmlu_pro_6443", "mmlu_pro_6452", "mmlu_pro_6464", "mmlu_pro_6471", "mmlu_pro_6485", "mmlu_pro_6482", "mmlu_pro_6488", "mmlu_pro_6487", "mmlu_pro_6491", "mmlu_pro_6490", "mmlu_pro_6494", "mmlu_pro_6495", "mmlu_pro_6499", "mmlu_pro_6504", "mmlu_pro_6523", "mmlu_pro_6524", "mmlu_pro_6537", "mmlu_pro_6539", "mmlu_pro_6542", "mmlu_pro_6546", "mmlu_pro_6547", "mmlu_pro_6554", "mmlu_pro_6565", "mmlu_pro_6567", "mmlu_pro_6576", "mmlu_pro_6586", "mmlu_pro_6592", "mmlu_pro_6596", "mmlu_pro_6609", "mmlu_pro_6624", "mmlu_pro_6625", "mmlu_pro_6646", "mmlu_pro_6658", "mmlu_pro_6674", "mmlu_pro_6679", "mmlu_pro_6682", "mmlu_pro_6694", "mmlu_pro_6700", "mmlu_pro_6720", "mmlu_pro_6722", "mmlu_pro_6726", "mmlu_pro_6729", "mmlu_pro_6733", "mmlu_pro_6752", "mmlu_pro_6736", "mmlu_pro_6760", "mmlu_pro_6763", "mmlu_pro_6765", "mmlu_pro_6769", "mmlu_pro_6770", "mmlu_pro_6771", "mmlu_pro_6775", "mmlu_pro_6780", "mmlu_pro_6786", "mmlu_pro_6802", "mmlu_pro_6804", "mmlu_pro_6807", "mmlu_pro_6817", "mmlu_pro_6820", "mmlu_pro_6829", "mmlu_pro_6849", "mmlu_pro_6845", "mmlu_pro_6852", "mmlu_pro_6861", "mmlu_pro_6872", "mmlu_pro_6865", "mmlu_pro_6879", "mmlu_pro_6881", "mmlu_pro_6886", "mmlu_pro_6885", "mmlu_pro_6888", "mmlu_pro_6891", "mmlu_pro_6894", "mmlu_pro_6892", "mmlu_pro_6920", "mmlu_pro_6907", "mmlu_pro_6921", "mmlu_pro_6923", "mmlu_pro_6928", "mmlu_pro_6933", "mmlu_pro_6939", "mmlu_pro_6942", "mmlu_pro_6964", "mmlu_pro_6970", "mmlu_pro_6975", "mmlu_pro_6973", "mmlu_pro_6995", "mmlu_pro_6994", "mmlu_pro_7001", "mmlu_pro_7002", "mmlu_pro_7007", "mmlu_pro_7008", "mmlu_pro_7011", "mmlu_pro_7043", "mmlu_pro_7029", "mmlu_pro_7049", "mmlu_pro_7050", "mmlu_pro_7051", "mmlu_pro_7058", "mmlu_pro_7076", "mmlu_pro_7085", "mmlu_pro_7095", "mmlu_pro_7097", "mmlu_pro_7100", "mmlu_pro_7110", "mmlu_pro_7090", "mmlu_pro_7113", "mmlu_pro_7111", "mmlu_pro_7118", "mmlu_pro_7127", "mmlu_pro_7126", "mmlu_pro_7131", "mmlu_pro_7132", "mmlu_pro_7154", "mmlu_pro_7142", "mmlu_pro_7163", "mmlu_pro_7171", "mmlu_pro_7175", "mmlu_pro_7176", "mmlu_pro_7181", "mmlu_pro_7183", "mmlu_pro_7190", "mmlu_pro_7194", "mmlu_pro_7209", "mmlu_pro_7232", "mmlu_pro_7249", "mmlu_pro_7236", "mmlu_pro_7252", "mmlu_pro_7269", "mmlu_pro_7279", "mmlu_pro_7253", "mmlu_pro_7283", "mmlu_pro_7285", "mmlu_pro_7287", "mmlu_pro_7284", "mmlu_pro_7294", "mmlu_pro_7305", "mmlu_pro_7306", "mmlu_pro_7327", "mmlu_pro_7331", "mmlu_pro_7345", "mmlu_pro_7344", "mmlu_pro_7359", "mmlu_pro_7361", "mmlu_pro_7365", "mmlu_pro_7367", "mmlu_pro_7369", "mmlu_pro_7371", "mmlu_pro_7372", "mmlu_pro_7376", "mmlu_pro_7380", "mmlu_pro_7386", "mmlu_pro_7388", "mmlu_pro_7391", "mmlu_pro_7395", "mmlu_pro_7397", "mmlu_pro_7406", "mmlu_pro_7402", "mmlu_pro_7415", "mmlu_pro_7413", "mmlu_pro_7423", "mmlu_pro_7427", "mmlu_pro_7422", "mmlu_pro_7444", "mmlu_pro_7438", "mmlu_pro_7468", "mmlu_pro_7470", "mmlu_pro_7473", "mmlu_pro_7482", "mmlu_pro_7501", "mmlu_pro_7506", "mmlu_pro_7503", "mmlu_pro_7516", "mmlu_pro_7524", "mmlu_pro_7523", "mmlu_pro_7532", "mmlu_pro_7528", "mmlu_pro_7538", "mmlu_pro_7540", "mmlu_pro_7544", "mmlu_pro_7564", "mmlu_pro_7572", "mmlu_pro_7589", "mmlu_pro_7595", "mmlu_pro_7600", "mmlu_pro_7601", "mmlu_pro_7596", "mmlu_pro_7612", "mmlu_pro_7619", "mmlu_pro_7620", "mmlu_pro_7621", "mmlu_pro_7626", "mmlu_pro_7629", "mmlu_pro_7635", "mmlu_pro_7639", "mmlu_pro_7633", "mmlu_pro_7660", "mmlu_pro_7656", "mmlu_pro_7675", "mmlu_pro_7661", "mmlu_pro_7694", "mmlu_pro_7682", "mmlu_pro_7708", "mmlu_pro_7709", "mmlu_pro_7715", "mmlu_pro_7716", "mmlu_pro_7723", "mmlu_pro_7717", "mmlu_pro_7737", "mmlu_pro_7727", "mmlu_pro_7750", "mmlu_pro_7755", "mmlu_pro_7764", "mmlu_pro_7770", "mmlu_pro_7765", "mmlu_pro_7777", "mmlu_pro_7779", "mmlu_pro_7789", "mmlu_pro_7790", "mmlu_pro_7792", "mmlu_pro_7798", "mmlu_pro_7812", "mmlu_pro_7808", "mmlu_pro_7817", "mmlu_pro_7828", "mmlu_pro_7826", "mmlu_pro_7836", "mmlu_pro_7835", "mmlu_pro_7848", "mmlu_pro_7837", "mmlu_pro_7851", "mmlu_pro_7852", "mmlu_pro_7858", "mmlu_pro_7871", "mmlu_pro_7878", "mmlu_pro_7880", "mmlu_pro_7893", "mmlu_pro_7887", "mmlu_pro_7900", "mmlu_pro_7909", "mmlu_pro_7917", "mmlu_pro_7918", "mmlu_pro_7902", "mmlu_pro_7925", "mmlu_pro_7934", "mmlu_pro_7936", "mmlu_pro_7939", "mmlu_pro_7940", "mmlu_pro_7945", "mmlu_pro_7953", "mmlu_pro_7946", "mmlu_pro_7957", "mmlu_pro_7962", "mmlu_pro_7975", "mmlu_pro_7981", "mmlu_pro_7972", "mmlu_pro_7983", "mmlu_pro_7989", "mmlu_pro_7993", "mmlu_pro_7995", "mmlu_pro_8003", "mmlu_pro_7996", "mmlu_pro_8004", "mmlu_pro_8021", "mmlu_pro_8023", "mmlu_pro_8048", "mmlu_pro_8050", "mmlu_pro_8034", "mmlu_pro_8071", "mmlu_pro_8076", "mmlu_pro_8080", "mmlu_pro_8084", "mmlu_pro_8101", "mmlu_pro_8095", "mmlu_pro_8108", "mmlu_pro_8109", "mmlu_pro_8123", "mmlu_pro_8138", "mmlu_pro_8115", "mmlu_pro_8152", "mmlu_pro_8140", "mmlu_pro_8154", "mmlu_pro_8156", "mmlu_pro_8158", "mmlu_pro_8166", "mmlu_pro_8159", "mmlu_pro_8176", "mmlu_pro_8181", "mmlu_pro_8178", "mmlu_pro_8195", "mmlu_pro_8184", "mmlu_pro_8196", "mmlu_pro_8218", "mmlu_pro_8224", "mmlu_pro_8222", "mmlu_pro_8226", "mmlu_pro_8235", "mmlu_pro_8236", "mmlu_pro_8242", "mmlu_pro_8247", "mmlu_pro_8241", "mmlu_pro_8259", "mmlu_pro_8249", "mmlu_pro_8262", "mmlu_pro_8273", "mmlu_pro_8275", "mmlu_pro_8277", "mmlu_pro_8284", "mmlu_pro_8283", "mmlu_pro_8291", "mmlu_pro_8294", "mmlu_pro_8301", "mmlu_pro_8295", "mmlu_pro_8302", "mmlu_pro_8320", "mmlu_pro_8333", "mmlu_pro_8337", "mmlu_pro_8341", "mmlu_pro_8342", "mmlu_pro_8354", "mmlu_pro_8348", "mmlu_pro_8365", "mmlu_pro_8361", "mmlu_pro_8371", "mmlu_pro_8379", "mmlu_pro_8389", "mmlu_pro_8397", "mmlu_pro_8391", "mmlu_pro_8417", "mmlu_pro_8411", "mmlu_pro_8419", "mmlu_pro_8441", "mmlu_pro_8449", "mmlu_pro_8458", "mmlu_pro_8474", "mmlu_pro_8473", "mmlu_pro_8478", "mmlu_pro_8475", "mmlu_pro_8481", "mmlu_pro_8484", "mmlu_pro_8508", "mmlu_pro_8515", "mmlu_pro_8486", "mmlu_pro_8516", "mmlu_pro_8530", "mmlu_pro_8562", "mmlu_pro_8563", "mmlu_pro_8569", "mmlu_pro_8567", "mmlu_pro_8580", "mmlu_pro_8582", "mmlu_pro_8584", "mmlu_pro_8586", "mmlu_pro_8601", "mmlu_pro_8594", "mmlu_pro_8611", "mmlu_pro_8614", "mmlu_pro_8629", "mmlu_pro_8641", "mmlu_pro_8644", "mmlu_pro_8647", "mmlu_pro_8654", "mmlu_pro_8658", "mmlu_pro_8669", "mmlu_pro_8670", "mmlu_pro_8690", "mmlu_pro_8699", "mmlu_pro_8704", "mmlu_pro_8709", "mmlu_pro_8710", "mmlu_pro_8724", "mmlu_pro_8725", "mmlu_pro_8729", "mmlu_pro_8733", "mmlu_pro_8745", "mmlu_pro_8747", "mmlu_pro_8760", "mmlu_pro_8761", "mmlu_pro_8766", "mmlu_pro_8781", "mmlu_pro_8796", "mmlu_pro_8803", "mmlu_pro_8805", "mmlu_pro_8816", "mmlu_pro_8826", "mmlu_pro_8820", "mmlu_pro_8831", "mmlu_pro_8833", "mmlu_pro_8839", "mmlu_pro_8844", "mmlu_pro_8843", "mmlu_pro_8848", "mmlu_pro_8855", "mmlu_pro_8856", "mmlu_pro_8850", "mmlu_pro_8865", "mmlu_pro_8875", "mmlu_pro_8872", "mmlu_pro_8903", "mmlu_pro_8878", "mmlu_pro_8912", "mmlu_pro_8932", "mmlu_pro_8934", "mmlu_pro_8919", "mmlu_pro_8936", "mmlu_pro_8941", "mmlu_pro_8955", "mmlu_pro_8956", "mmlu_pro_8950", "mmlu_pro_8958", "mmlu_pro_8975", "mmlu_pro_8983", "mmlu_pro_8971", "mmlu_pro_9004", "mmlu_pro_9002", "mmlu_pro_9005", "mmlu_pro_9013", "mmlu_pro_9010", "mmlu_pro_9019", "mmlu_pro_9016", "mmlu_pro_9028", "mmlu_pro_9024", "mmlu_pro_9039", "mmlu_pro_9033", "mmlu_pro_9042", "mmlu_pro_9072", "mmlu_pro_9063", "mmlu_pro_9099", "mmlu_pro_9084", "mmlu_pro_9114", "mmlu_pro_9101", "mmlu_pro_9121", "mmlu_pro_9123", "mmlu_pro_9124", "mmlu_pro_9125", "mmlu_pro_9129", "mmlu_pro_9137", "mmlu_pro_9140", "mmlu_pro_9141", "mmlu_pro_9143", "mmlu_pro_9157", "mmlu_pro_9155", "mmlu_pro_9172", "mmlu_pro_9164", "mmlu_pro_9181", "mmlu_pro_9185", "mmlu_pro_9187", "mmlu_pro_9192", "mmlu_pro_9188", "mmlu_pro_9213", "mmlu_pro_9217", "mmlu_pro_9219", "mmlu_pro_9239", "mmlu_pro_9228", "mmlu_pro_9243", "mmlu_pro_9244", "mmlu_pro_9245", "mmlu_pro_9254", "mmlu_pro_9265", "mmlu_pro_9274", "mmlu_pro_9286", "mmlu_pro_9282", "mmlu_pro_9291", "mmlu_pro_9307", "mmlu_pro_9314", "mmlu_pro_9324", "mmlu_pro_9308", "mmlu_pro_9328", "mmlu_pro_9329", "mmlu_pro_9337", "mmlu_pro_9340", "mmlu_pro_9342", "mmlu_pro_9345", "mmlu_pro_9349", "mmlu_pro_9375", "mmlu_pro_9374", "mmlu_pro_9376", "mmlu_pro_9378", "mmlu_pro_9396", "mmlu_pro_9380", "mmlu_pro_9400", "mmlu_pro_9407", "mmlu_pro_9410", "mmlu_pro_9414", "mmlu_pro_9411", "mmlu_pro_9415", "mmlu_pro_9422", "mmlu_pro_9442", "mmlu_pro_9439", "mmlu_pro_9448", "mmlu_pro_9443", "mmlu_pro_9483", "mmlu_pro_9491", "mmlu_pro_9494", "mmlu_pro_9500", "mmlu_pro_9511", "mmlu_pro_9503", "mmlu_pro_9521", "mmlu_pro_9512", "mmlu_pro_9545", "mmlu_pro_9548", "mmlu_pro_9533", "mmlu_pro_9567", "mmlu_pro_9586", "mmlu_pro_9603", "mmlu_pro_9613", "mmlu_pro_9619", "mmlu_pro_9621", "mmlu_pro_9623", "mmlu_pro_9629", "mmlu_pro_9627", "mmlu_pro_9632", "mmlu_pro_9641", "mmlu_pro_9647", "mmlu_pro_9653", "mmlu_pro_9644", "mmlu_pro_9661", "mmlu_pro_9671", "mmlu_pro_9675", "mmlu_pro_9687", "mmlu_pro_9686", "mmlu_pro_9697", "mmlu_pro_9705", "mmlu_pro_9725", "mmlu_pro_9715", "mmlu_pro_9734", "mmlu_pro_9738", "mmlu_pro_9739", "mmlu_pro_9743", "mmlu_pro_9753", "mmlu_pro_9768", "mmlu_pro_9756", "mmlu_pro_9791", "mmlu_pro_9777", "mmlu_pro_9793", "mmlu_pro_9798", "mmlu_pro_9808", "mmlu_pro_9817", "mmlu_pro_9819", "mmlu_pro_9820", "mmlu_pro_9840", "mmlu_pro_9839", "mmlu_pro_9851", "mmlu_pro_9843", "mmlu_pro_9852", "mmlu_pro_9859", "mmlu_pro_9876", "mmlu_pro_9882", "mmlu_pro_9872", "mmlu_pro_9884", "mmlu_pro_9891", "mmlu_pro_9903", "mmlu_pro_9895", "mmlu_pro_9907", "mmlu_pro_9923", "mmlu_pro_9926", "mmlu_pro_9925", "mmlu_pro_9933", "mmlu_pro_9942", "mmlu_pro_9968", "mmlu_pro_9930", "mmlu_pro_9969", "mmlu_pro_9971", "mmlu_pro_9975", "mmlu_pro_9977", "mmlu_pro_9976", "mmlu_pro_9989", "mmlu_pro_9987", "mmlu_pro_9991", "mmlu_pro_10005", "mmlu_pro_10011", "mmlu_pro_9993", "mmlu_pro_10026", "mmlu_pro_10034", "mmlu_pro_10035", "mmlu_pro_10036", "mmlu_pro_10037", "mmlu_pro_10038", "mmlu_pro_10051", "mmlu_pro_10060", "mmlu_pro_10044", "mmlu_pro_10063", "mmlu_pro_10065", "mmlu_pro_10074", "mmlu_pro_10080", "mmlu_pro_10079", "mmlu_pro_10087", "mmlu_pro_10085", "mmlu_pro_10095", "mmlu_pro_10090", "mmlu_pro_10098", "mmlu_pro_10112", "mmlu_pro_10127", "mmlu_pro_10131", "mmlu_pro_10134", "mmlu_pro_10139", "mmlu_pro_10142", "mmlu_pro_10141", "mmlu_pro_10150", "mmlu_pro_10147", "mmlu_pro_10156", "mmlu_pro_10159", "mmlu_pro_10162", "mmlu_pro_10170", "mmlu_pro_10185", "mmlu_pro_10179", "mmlu_pro_10186", "mmlu_pro_10222", "mmlu_pro_10241", "mmlu_pro_10230", "mmlu_pro_10245", "mmlu_pro_10242", "mmlu_pro_10247", "mmlu_pro_10270", "mmlu_pro_10271", "mmlu_pro_10283", "mmlu_pro_10285", "mmlu_pro_10288", "mmlu_pro_10299", "mmlu_pro_10290", "mmlu_pro_10302", "mmlu_pro_10300", "mmlu_pro_10308", "mmlu_pro_10314", "mmlu_pro_10315", "mmlu_pro_10316", "mmlu_pro_10321", "mmlu_pro_10318", "mmlu_pro_10324", "mmlu_pro_10341", "mmlu_pro_10333", "mmlu_pro_10343", "mmlu_pro_10344", "mmlu_pro_10349", "mmlu_pro_10346", "mmlu_pro_10360", "mmlu_pro_10372", "mmlu_pro_10367", "mmlu_pro_10382", "mmlu_pro_10387", "mmlu_pro_10411", "mmlu_pro_10408", "mmlu_pro_10417", "mmlu_pro_10422", "mmlu_pro_10432", "mmlu_pro_10437", "mmlu_pro_10441", "mmlu_pro_10467", "mmlu_pro_10476", "mmlu_pro_10454", "mmlu_pro_10481", "mmlu_pro_10478", "mmlu_pro_10484", "mmlu_pro_10487", "mmlu_pro_10489", "mmlu_pro_10492", "mmlu_pro_10502", "mmlu_pro_10503", "mmlu_pro_10515", "mmlu_pro_10505", "mmlu_pro_10520", "mmlu_pro_10526", "mmlu_pro_10527", "mmlu_pro_10532", "mmlu_pro_10538", "mmlu_pro_10543", "mmlu_pro_10544", "mmlu_pro_10568", "mmlu_pro_10571", "mmlu_pro_10586", "mmlu_pro_10589", "mmlu_pro_10578", "mmlu_pro_10600", "mmlu_pro_10602", "mmlu_pro_10609", "mmlu_pro_10621", "mmlu_pro_10627", "mmlu_pro_10641", "mmlu_pro_10651", "mmlu_pro_10656", "mmlu_pro_10648", "mmlu_pro_10661", "mmlu_pro_10663", "mmlu_pro_10669", "mmlu_pro_10692", "mmlu_pro_10689", "mmlu_pro_10694", "mmlu_pro_10703", "mmlu_pro_10717", "mmlu_pro_10713", "mmlu_pro_10728", "mmlu_pro_10737", "mmlu_pro_10752", "mmlu_pro_10741", "mmlu_pro_10753", "mmlu_pro_10758", "mmlu_pro_10762", "mmlu_pro_10765", "mmlu_pro_10769", "mmlu_pro_10783", "mmlu_pro_10792", "mmlu_pro_10797", "mmlu_pro_10770", "mmlu_pro_10802", "mmlu_pro_10822", "mmlu_pro_10823", "mmlu_pro_10830", "mmlu_pro_10816", "mmlu_pro_10842", "mmlu_pro_10854", "mmlu_pro_10851", "mmlu_pro_10868", "mmlu_pro_10863", "mmlu_pro_10873", "mmlu_pro_10878", "mmlu_pro_10882", "mmlu_pro_10883", "mmlu_pro_10893", "mmlu_pro_10895", "mmlu_pro_10903", "mmlu_pro_10905", "mmlu_pro_10909", "mmlu_pro_10910", "mmlu_pro_10922", "mmlu_pro_10928", "mmlu_pro_10925", "mmlu_pro_10932", "mmlu_pro_10936", "mmlu_pro_10937", "mmlu_pro_10971", "mmlu_pro_10969", "mmlu_pro_10982", "mmlu_pro_10979", "mmlu_pro_10986", "mmlu_pro_10990", "mmlu_pro_10993", "mmlu_pro_11009", "mmlu_pro_10995", "mmlu_pro_11022", "mmlu_pro_11014", "mmlu_pro_11024", "mmlu_pro_11032", "mmlu_pro_11034", "mmlu_pro_11040", "mmlu_pro_11045", "mmlu_pro_11059", "mmlu_pro_11053", "mmlu_pro_11062", "mmlu_pro_11100", "mmlu_pro_11091", "mmlu_pro_11101", "mmlu_pro_11109", "mmlu_pro_11110", "mmlu_pro_11115", "mmlu_pro_11114", "mmlu_pro_11117", "mmlu_pro_11127", "mmlu_pro_11149", "mmlu_pro_11153", "mmlu_pro_11150", "mmlu_pro_11170", "mmlu_pro_11157", "mmlu_pro_11173", "mmlu_pro_11177", "mmlu_pro_11186", "mmlu_pro_11183", "mmlu_pro_11188", "mmlu_pro_11197", "mmlu_pro_11189", "mmlu_pro_11201", "mmlu_pro_11211", "mmlu_pro_11203", "mmlu_pro_11217", "mmlu_pro_11224", "mmlu_pro_11221", "mmlu_pro_11243", "mmlu_pro_11226", "mmlu_pro_11246", "mmlu_pro_11254", "mmlu_pro_11247", "mmlu_pro_11265", "mmlu_pro_11284", "mmlu_pro_11288", "mmlu_pro_11305", "mmlu_pro_11300", "mmlu_pro_11314", "mmlu_pro_11331", "mmlu_pro_11336", "mmlu_pro_11343", "mmlu_pro_11347", "mmlu_pro_11345", "mmlu_pro_11368", "mmlu_pro_11381", "mmlu_pro_11372", "mmlu_pro_11382", "mmlu_pro_11391", "mmlu_pro_11395", "mmlu_pro_11396", "mmlu_pro_11407", "mmlu_pro_11402", "mmlu_pro_11422", "mmlu_pro_11413", "mmlu_pro_11423", "mmlu_pro_11425", "mmlu_pro_11444", "mmlu_pro_11437", "mmlu_pro_11453", "mmlu_pro_11445", "mmlu_pro_11467", "mmlu_pro_11466", "mmlu_pro_11468", "mmlu_pro_11474", "mmlu_pro_11477", "mmlu_pro_11484", "mmlu_pro_11490", "mmlu_pro_11493", "mmlu_pro_11504", "mmlu_pro_11503", "mmlu_pro_11514", "mmlu_pro_11539", "mmlu_pro_11543", "mmlu_pro_11548", "mmlu_pro_11560", "mmlu_pro_11586", "mmlu_pro_11587", "mmlu_pro_11588", "mmlu_pro_11610", "mmlu_pro_11627", "mmlu_pro_11629", "mmlu_pro_11630", "mmlu_pro_11633", "mmlu_pro_11637", "mmlu_pro_11650", "mmlu_pro_11653", "mmlu_pro_11654", "mmlu_pro_11658", "mmlu_pro_11664", "mmlu_pro_11660", "mmlu_pro_11682", "mmlu_pro_11689", "mmlu_pro_11688", "mmlu_pro_11701", "mmlu_pro_11710", "mmlu_pro_11714", "mmlu_pro_11730", "mmlu_pro_11725", "mmlu_pro_11739", "mmlu_pro_11746", "mmlu_pro_11732", "mmlu_pro_11762", "mmlu_pro_11750", "mmlu_pro_11770", "mmlu_pro_11765", "mmlu_pro_11774", "mmlu_pro_11783", "mmlu_pro_11778", "mmlu_pro_11795", "mmlu_pro_11793", "mmlu_pro_11801", "mmlu_pro_11810", "mmlu_pro_11817", "mmlu_pro_11823", "mmlu_pro_11825", "mmlu_pro_11826", "mmlu_pro_11828", "mmlu_pro_11832", "mmlu_pro_11835", "mmlu_pro_11842", "mmlu_pro_11844", "mmlu_pro_11846", "mmlu_pro_11852", "mmlu_pro_11848", "mmlu_pro_11864", "mmlu_pro_11865", "mmlu_pro_11868", "mmlu_pro_11870", "mmlu_pro_11872", "mmlu_pro_11903", "mmlu_pro_11874", "mmlu_pro_11904", "mmlu_pro_11914", "mmlu_pro_11917", "mmlu_pro_11920", "mmlu_pro_11922", "mmlu_pro_11924", "mmlu_pro_11936", "mmlu_pro_11948", "mmlu_pro_11963", "mmlu_pro_11977", "mmlu_pro_11965", "mmlu_pro_11988", "mmlu_pro_11980", "mmlu_pro_11993", "mmlu_pro_12003", "mmlu_pro_12007", "mmlu_pro_12006", "mmlu_pro_12010", "mmlu_pro_12015", "mmlu_pro_12017", "mmlu_pro_12016", "mmlu_pro_12025", "mmlu_pro_12023", "mmlu_pro_12030"]
abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/qids_qwen3-4b_s0.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
 
 
1
+ ["mmlu_pro_19", "mmlu_pro_10", "mmlu_pro_27", "mmlu_pro_20", "mmlu_pro_29", "mmlu_pro_39", "mmlu_pro_48", "mmlu_pro_49", "mmlu_pro_60", "mmlu_pro_52", "mmlu_pro_73", "mmlu_pro_88", "mmlu_pro_102", "mmlu_pro_107", "mmlu_pro_112", "mmlu_pro_123", "mmlu_pro_117", "mmlu_pro_154", "mmlu_pro_142", "mmlu_pro_157", "mmlu_pro_167", "mmlu_pro_165", "mmlu_pro_169", "mmlu_pro_171", "mmlu_pro_177", "mmlu_pro_180", "mmlu_pro_201", "mmlu_pro_181", "mmlu_pro_211", "mmlu_pro_213", "mmlu_pro_220", "mmlu_pro_222", "mmlu_pro_233", "mmlu_pro_234", "mmlu_pro_238", "mmlu_pro_240", "mmlu_pro_245", "mmlu_pro_256", "mmlu_pro_254", "mmlu_pro_257", "mmlu_pro_261", "mmlu_pro_264", "mmlu_pro_267", "mmlu_pro_269", "mmlu_pro_275", "mmlu_pro_273", "mmlu_pro_279", "mmlu_pro_291", "mmlu_pro_293", "mmlu_pro_295", "mmlu_pro_296", "mmlu_pro_303", "mmlu_pro_299", "mmlu_pro_308", "mmlu_pro_318", "mmlu_pro_309", "mmlu_pro_321", "mmlu_pro_320", "mmlu_pro_325", "mmlu_pro_328", "mmlu_pro_334", "mmlu_pro_344", "mmlu_pro_364", "mmlu_pro_369", "mmlu_pro_370", "mmlu_pro_372", "mmlu_pro_377", "mmlu_pro_382", "mmlu_pro_384", "mmlu_pro_413", "mmlu_pro_412", "mmlu_pro_416", "mmlu_pro_420", "mmlu_pro_425", "mmlu_pro_430", "mmlu_pro_431", "mmlu_pro_436", "mmlu_pro_440", "mmlu_pro_458", "mmlu_pro_451", "mmlu_pro_459", "mmlu_pro_476", "mmlu_pro_480", "mmlu_pro_485", "mmlu_pro_491", "mmlu_pro_498", "mmlu_pro_521", "mmlu_pro_517", "mmlu_pro_526", "mmlu_pro_522", "mmlu_pro_539", "mmlu_pro_530", "mmlu_pro_542", "mmlu_pro_552", "mmlu_pro_556", "mmlu_pro_554", "mmlu_pro_558", "mmlu_pro_577", "mmlu_pro_590", "mmlu_pro_596", "mmlu_pro_602", "mmlu_pro_604", "mmlu_pro_610", "mmlu_pro_612", "mmlu_pro_615", "mmlu_pro_627", "mmlu_pro_631", "mmlu_pro_633", "mmlu_pro_646", "mmlu_pro_657", "mmlu_pro_658", "mmlu_pro_673", "mmlu_pro_661", "mmlu_pro_678", "mmlu_pro_683", "mmlu_pro_686", "mmlu_pro_693", "mmlu_pro_703", "mmlu_pro_716", "mmlu_pro_712", "mmlu_pro_743", "mmlu_pro_726", "mmlu_pro_753", "mmlu_pro_754", "mmlu_pro_755", "mmlu_pro_756", "mmlu_pro_758", "mmlu_pro_766", "mmlu_pro_765", "mmlu_pro_768", "mmlu_pro_791", "mmlu_pro_796", "mmlu_pro_822", "mmlu_pro_797", "mmlu_pro_830", "mmlu_pro_833", "mmlu_pro_835", "mmlu_pro_841", "mmlu_pro_852", "mmlu_pro_859", "mmlu_pro_863", "mmlu_pro_866", "mmlu_pro_880", "mmlu_pro_883", "mmlu_pro_886", "mmlu_pro_891", "mmlu_pro_890", "mmlu_pro_895", "mmlu_pro_896", "mmlu_pro_903", "mmlu_pro_910", "mmlu_pro_913", "mmlu_pro_932", "mmlu_pro_919", "mmlu_pro_943", "mmlu_pro_954", "mmlu_pro_968", "mmlu_pro_972", "mmlu_pro_978", "mmlu_pro_982", "mmlu_pro_996", "mmlu_pro_1001", "mmlu_pro_1011", "mmlu_pro_1014", "mmlu_pro_1027", "mmlu_pro_1029", "mmlu_pro_1038", "mmlu_pro_1034", "mmlu_pro_1055", "mmlu_pro_1040", "mmlu_pro_1070", "mmlu_pro_1061", "mmlu_pro_1081", "mmlu_pro_1082", "mmlu_pro_1092", "mmlu_pro_1105", "mmlu_pro_1113", "mmlu_pro_1112", "mmlu_pro_1117", "mmlu_pro_1123", "mmlu_pro_1173", "mmlu_pro_1156", "mmlu_pro_1179", "mmlu_pro_1174", "mmlu_pro_1191", "mmlu_pro_1181", "mmlu_pro_1199", "mmlu_pro_1198", "mmlu_pro_1209", "mmlu_pro_1212", "mmlu_pro_1217", "mmlu_pro_1221", "mmlu_pro_1233", "mmlu_pro_1227", "mmlu_pro_1241", "mmlu_pro_1243", "mmlu_pro_1247", "mmlu_pro_1252", "mmlu_pro_1255", "mmlu_pro_1261", "mmlu_pro_1263", "mmlu_pro_1265", "mmlu_pro_1268", "mmlu_pro_1278", "mmlu_pro_1299", "mmlu_pro_1305", "mmlu_pro_1306", "mmlu_pro_1308", "mmlu_pro_1326", "mmlu_pro_1327", "mmlu_pro_1341", "mmlu_pro_1339", "mmlu_pro_1351", "mmlu_pro_1353", "mmlu_pro_1355", "mmlu_pro_1358", "mmlu_pro_1360", "mmlu_pro_1362", "mmlu_pro_1367", "mmlu_pro_1365", "mmlu_pro_1378", "mmlu_pro_1380", "mmlu_pro_1383", "mmlu_pro_1388", "mmlu_pro_1396", "mmlu_pro_1390", "mmlu_pro_1399", "mmlu_pro_1402", "mmlu_pro_1410", "mmlu_pro_1413", "mmlu_pro_1414", "mmlu_pro_1416", "mmlu_pro_1418", "mmlu_pro_1429", "mmlu_pro_1430", "mmlu_pro_1433", "mmlu_pro_1436", "mmlu_pro_1442", "mmlu_pro_1451", "mmlu_pro_1453", "mmlu_pro_1462", "mmlu_pro_1479", "mmlu_pro_1469", "mmlu_pro_1481", "mmlu_pro_1482", "mmlu_pro_1485", "mmlu_pro_1500", "mmlu_pro_1502", "mmlu_pro_1509", "mmlu_pro_1511", "mmlu_pro_1515", "mmlu_pro_1519", "mmlu_pro_1522", "mmlu_pro_1534", "mmlu_pro_1541", "mmlu_pro_1543", "mmlu_pro_1544", "mmlu_pro_1547", "mmlu_pro_1548", "mmlu_pro_1563", "mmlu_pro_1567", "mmlu_pro_1568", "mmlu_pro_1576", "mmlu_pro_1589", "mmlu_pro_1590", "mmlu_pro_1606", "mmlu_pro_1612", "mmlu_pro_1615", "mmlu_pro_1618", "mmlu_pro_1626", "mmlu_pro_1628", "mmlu_pro_1646", "mmlu_pro_1639", "mmlu_pro_1648", "mmlu_pro_1649", "mmlu_pro_1661", "mmlu_pro_1652", "mmlu_pro_1663", "mmlu_pro_1664", "mmlu_pro_1676", "mmlu_pro_1681", "mmlu_pro_1689", "mmlu_pro_1694", "mmlu_pro_1710", "mmlu_pro_1715", "mmlu_pro_1721", "mmlu_pro_1716", "mmlu_pro_1727", "mmlu_pro_1729", "mmlu_pro_1730", "mmlu_pro_1733", "mmlu_pro_1766", "mmlu_pro_1750", "mmlu_pro_1774", "mmlu_pro_1772", "mmlu_pro_1776", "mmlu_pro_1793", "mmlu_pro_1801", "mmlu_pro_1815", "mmlu_pro_1838", "mmlu_pro_1847", "mmlu_pro_1855", "mmlu_pro_1863", "mmlu_pro_1865", "mmlu_pro_1869", "mmlu_pro_1891", "mmlu_pro_1879", "mmlu_pro_1905", "mmlu_pro_1897", "mmlu_pro_1907", "mmlu_pro_1911", "mmlu_pro_1917", "mmlu_pro_1916", "mmlu_pro_1927", "mmlu_pro_1918", "mmlu_pro_1938", "mmlu_pro_1949", "mmlu_pro_1939", "mmlu_pro_1954", "mmlu_pro_1959", "mmlu_pro_1969", "mmlu_pro_1971", "mmlu_pro_1980", "mmlu_pro_1983", "mmlu_pro_1991", "mmlu_pro_1994", "mmlu_pro_1999", "mmlu_pro_2006", "mmlu_pro_2011", "mmlu_pro_2014", "mmlu_pro_2017", "mmlu_pro_2022", "mmlu_pro_2023", "mmlu_pro_2026", "mmlu_pro_2051", "mmlu_pro_2054", "mmlu_pro_2057", "mmlu_pro_2066", "mmlu_pro_2068", "mmlu_pro_2073", "mmlu_pro_2076", "mmlu_pro_2078", "mmlu_pro_2081", "mmlu_pro_2105", "mmlu_pro_2107", "mmlu_pro_2114", "mmlu_pro_2117", "mmlu_pro_2119", "mmlu_pro_2144", "mmlu_pro_2156", "mmlu_pro_2165", "mmlu_pro_2160", "mmlu_pro_2167", "mmlu_pro_2177", "mmlu_pro_2178", "mmlu_pro_2181", "mmlu_pro_2184", "mmlu_pro_2191", "mmlu_pro_2193", "mmlu_pro_2199", "mmlu_pro_2208", "mmlu_pro_2238", "mmlu_pro_2227", "mmlu_pro_2240", "mmlu_pro_2241", "mmlu_pro_2242", "mmlu_pro_2260", "mmlu_pro_2274", "mmlu_pro_2276", "mmlu_pro_2303", "mmlu_pro_2306", "mmlu_pro_2313", "mmlu_pro_2315", "mmlu_pro_2337", "mmlu_pro_2334", "mmlu_pro_2338", "mmlu_pro_2340", "mmlu_pro_2352", "mmlu_pro_2362", "mmlu_pro_2360", "mmlu_pro_2365", "mmlu_pro_2366", "mmlu_pro_2381", "mmlu_pro_2388", "mmlu_pro_2390", "mmlu_pro_2395", "mmlu_pro_2407", "mmlu_pro_2423", "mmlu_pro_2429", "mmlu_pro_2424", "mmlu_pro_2458", "mmlu_pro_2440", "mmlu_pro_2468", "mmlu_pro_2472", "mmlu_pro_2480", "mmlu_pro_2487", "mmlu_pro_2481", "mmlu_pro_2490", "mmlu_pro_2492", "mmlu_pro_2496", "mmlu_pro_2497", "mmlu_pro_2498", "mmlu_pro_2511", "mmlu_pro_2516", "mmlu_pro_2521", "mmlu_pro_2522", "mmlu_pro_2539", "mmlu_pro_2535", "mmlu_pro_2540", "mmlu_pro_2544", "mmlu_pro_2553", "mmlu_pro_2545", "mmlu_pro_2556", "mmlu_pro_2567", "mmlu_pro_2574", "mmlu_pro_2577", "mmlu_pro_2582", "mmlu_pro_2579", "mmlu_pro_2588", "mmlu_pro_2586", "mmlu_pro_2596", "mmlu_pro_2594", "mmlu_pro_2606", "mmlu_pro_2598", "mmlu_pro_2621", "mmlu_pro_2610", "mmlu_pro_2627", "mmlu_pro_2630", "mmlu_pro_2633", "mmlu_pro_2638", "mmlu_pro_2634", "mmlu_pro_2652", "mmlu_pro_2651", "mmlu_pro_2654", "mmlu_pro_2665", "mmlu_pro_2672", "mmlu_pro_2666", "mmlu_pro_2676", "mmlu_pro_2680", "mmlu_pro_2692", "mmlu_pro_2694", "mmlu_pro_2701", "mmlu_pro_2706", "mmlu_pro_2709", "mmlu_pro_2718", "mmlu_pro_2720", "mmlu_pro_2727", "mmlu_pro_2732", "mmlu_pro_2734", "mmlu_pro_2747", "mmlu_pro_2753", "mmlu_pro_2757", "mmlu_pro_2761", "mmlu_pro_2770", "mmlu_pro_2786", "mmlu_pro_2790", "mmlu_pro_2802", "mmlu_pro_2803", "mmlu_pro_2811", "mmlu_pro_2815", "mmlu_pro_2831", "mmlu_pro_2832", "mmlu_pro_2833", "mmlu_pro_2837", "mmlu_pro_2835", "mmlu_pro_2841", "mmlu_pro_2845", "mmlu_pro_2848", "mmlu_pro_2858", "mmlu_pro_2860", "mmlu_pro_2864", "mmlu_pro_2861", "mmlu_pro_2898", "mmlu_pro_2876", "mmlu_pro_2914", "mmlu_pro_2906", "mmlu_pro_2918", "mmlu_pro_2929", "mmlu_pro_2930", "mmlu_pro_2939", "mmlu_pro_2953", "mmlu_pro_2965", "mmlu_pro_2970", "mmlu_pro_2980", "mmlu_pro_2985", "mmlu_pro_2986", "mmlu_pro_2988", "mmlu_pro_2987", "mmlu_pro_3022", "mmlu_pro_3019", "mmlu_pro_3028", "mmlu_pro_3031", "mmlu_pro_3037", "mmlu_pro_3041", "mmlu_pro_3043", "mmlu_pro_3046", "mmlu_pro_3049", "mmlu_pro_3069", "mmlu_pro_3072", "mmlu_pro_3070", "mmlu_pro_3086", "mmlu_pro_3074", "mmlu_pro_3087", "mmlu_pro_3089", "mmlu_pro_3091", "mmlu_pro_3092", "mmlu_pro_3101", "mmlu_pro_3108", "mmlu_pro_3114", "mmlu_pro_3118", "mmlu_pro_3126", "mmlu_pro_3120", "mmlu_pro_3144", "mmlu_pro_3159", "mmlu_pro_3161", "mmlu_pro_3162", "mmlu_pro_3171", "mmlu_pro_3196", "mmlu_pro_3177", "mmlu_pro_3218", "mmlu_pro_3211", "mmlu_pro_3219", "mmlu_pro_3230", "mmlu_pro_3259", "mmlu_pro_3253", "mmlu_pro_3265", "mmlu_pro_3269", "mmlu_pro_3270", "mmlu_pro_3273", "mmlu_pro_3275", "mmlu_pro_3289", "mmlu_pro_3281", "mmlu_pro_3299", "mmlu_pro_3303", "mmlu_pro_3305", "mmlu_pro_3306", "mmlu_pro_3310", "mmlu_pro_3315", "mmlu_pro_3311", "mmlu_pro_3319", "mmlu_pro_3320", "mmlu_pro_3331", "mmlu_pro_3336", "mmlu_pro_3338", "mmlu_pro_3339", "mmlu_pro_3340", "mmlu_pro_3354", "mmlu_pro_3352", "mmlu_pro_3358", "mmlu_pro_3362", "mmlu_pro_3363", "mmlu_pro_3364", "mmlu_pro_3369", "mmlu_pro_3370", "mmlu_pro_3375", "mmlu_pro_3378", "mmlu_pro_3402", "mmlu_pro_3404", "mmlu_pro_3409", "mmlu_pro_3410", "mmlu_pro_3414", "mmlu_pro_3417", "mmlu_pro_3419", "mmlu_pro_3433", "mmlu_pro_3421", "mmlu_pro_3444", "mmlu_pro_3434", "mmlu_pro_3453", "mmlu_pro_3446", "mmlu_pro_3460", "mmlu_pro_3459", "mmlu_pro_3465", "mmlu_pro_3461", "mmlu_pro_3470", "mmlu_pro_3479", "mmlu_pro_3489", "mmlu_pro_3499", "mmlu_pro_3511", "mmlu_pro_3522", "mmlu_pro_3523", "mmlu_pro_3534", "mmlu_pro_3538", "mmlu_pro_3539", "mmlu_pro_3543", "mmlu_pro_3562", "mmlu_pro_3558", "mmlu_pro_3570", "mmlu_pro_3572", "mmlu_pro_3579", "mmlu_pro_3580", "mmlu_pro_3584", "mmlu_pro_3587", "mmlu_pro_3598", "mmlu_pro_3599", "mmlu_pro_3600", "mmlu_pro_3610", "mmlu_pro_3612", "mmlu_pro_3626", "mmlu_pro_3630", "mmlu_pro_3637", "mmlu_pro_3644", "mmlu_pro_3646", "mmlu_pro_3647", "mmlu_pro_3670", "mmlu_pro_3678", "mmlu_pro_3681", "mmlu_pro_3680", "mmlu_pro_3687", "mmlu_pro_3695", "mmlu_pro_3696", "mmlu_pro_3703", "mmlu_pro_3711", "mmlu_pro_3720", "mmlu_pro_3722", "mmlu_pro_3725", "mmlu_pro_3729", "mmlu_pro_3737", "mmlu_pro_3736", "mmlu_pro_3739", "mmlu_pro_3740", "mmlu_pro_3757", "mmlu_pro_3758", "mmlu_pro_3759", "mmlu_pro_3764", "mmlu_pro_3768", "mmlu_pro_3777", "mmlu_pro_3786", "mmlu_pro_3805", "mmlu_pro_3791", "mmlu_pro_3815", "mmlu_pro_3807", "mmlu_pro_3819", "mmlu_pro_3817", "mmlu_pro_3822", "mmlu_pro_3826", "mmlu_pro_3828", "mmlu_pro_3832", "mmlu_pro_3842", "mmlu_pro_3835", "mmlu_pro_3855", "mmlu_pro_3856", "mmlu_pro_3863", "mmlu_pro_3864", "mmlu_pro_3867", "mmlu_pro_3871", "mmlu_pro_3895", "mmlu_pro_3902", "mmlu_pro_3903", "mmlu_pro_3909", "mmlu_pro_3910", "mmlu_pro_3913", "mmlu_pro_3912", "mmlu_pro_3924", "mmlu_pro_3936", "mmlu_pro_3954", "mmlu_pro_3955", "mmlu_pro_3964", "mmlu_pro_3976", "mmlu_pro_3979", "mmlu_pro_3981", "mmlu_pro_3985", "mmlu_pro_3991", "mmlu_pro_3994", "mmlu_pro_4004", "mmlu_pro_4006", "mmlu_pro_4009", "mmlu_pro_4029", "mmlu_pro_4018", "mmlu_pro_4032", "mmlu_pro_4037", "mmlu_pro_4038", "mmlu_pro_4040", "mmlu_pro_4057", "mmlu_pro_4045", "mmlu_pro_4064", "mmlu_pro_4063", "mmlu_pro_4089", "mmlu_pro_4105", "mmlu_pro_4109", "mmlu_pro_4117", "mmlu_pro_4139", "mmlu_pro_4143", "mmlu_pro_4146", "mmlu_pro_4144", "mmlu_pro_4158", "mmlu_pro_4148", "mmlu_pro_4163", "mmlu_pro_4165", "mmlu_pro_4181", "mmlu_pro_4198", "mmlu_pro_4204", "mmlu_pro_4205", "mmlu_pro_4207", "mmlu_pro_4210", "mmlu_pro_4215", "mmlu_pro_4217", "mmlu_pro_4228", "mmlu_pro_4226", "mmlu_pro_4234", "mmlu_pro_4232", "mmlu_pro_4243", "mmlu_pro_4242", "mmlu_pro_4246", "mmlu_pro_4253", "mmlu_pro_4258", "mmlu_pro_4261", "mmlu_pro_4269", "mmlu_pro_4270", "mmlu_pro_4279", "mmlu_pro_4287", "mmlu_pro_4295", "mmlu_pro_4296", "mmlu_pro_4297", "mmlu_pro_4302", "mmlu_pro_4333", "mmlu_pro_4340", "mmlu_pro_4343", "mmlu_pro_4371", "mmlu_pro_4350", "mmlu_pro_4399", "mmlu_pro_4392", "mmlu_pro_4406", "mmlu_pro_4410", "mmlu_pro_4411", "mmlu_pro_4433", "mmlu_pro_4439", "mmlu_pro_4434", "mmlu_pro_4459", "mmlu_pro_4468", "mmlu_pro_4489", "mmlu_pro_4479", "mmlu_pro_4507", "mmlu_pro_4508", "mmlu_pro_4509", "mmlu_pro_4512", "mmlu_pro_4518", "mmlu_pro_4519", "mmlu_pro_4522", "mmlu_pro_4524", "mmlu_pro_4528", "mmlu_pro_4531", "mmlu_pro_4534", "mmlu_pro_4537", "mmlu_pro_4536", "mmlu_pro_4544", "mmlu_pro_4551", "mmlu_pro_4562", "mmlu_pro_4557", "mmlu_pro_4583", "mmlu_pro_4574", "mmlu_pro_4589", "mmlu_pro_4586", "mmlu_pro_4598", "mmlu_pro_4597", "mmlu_pro_4606", "mmlu_pro_4616", "mmlu_pro_4617", "mmlu_pro_4621", "mmlu_pro_4630", "mmlu_pro_4636", "mmlu_pro_4637", "mmlu_pro_4639", "mmlu_pro_4640", "mmlu_pro_4643", "mmlu_pro_4660", "mmlu_pro_4661", "mmlu_pro_4670", "mmlu_pro_4674", "mmlu_pro_4681", "mmlu_pro_4684", "mmlu_pro_4696", "mmlu_pro_4698", "mmlu_pro_4704", "mmlu_pro_4703", "mmlu_pro_4709", "mmlu_pro_4720", "mmlu_pro_4723", "mmlu_pro_4724", "mmlu_pro_4736", "mmlu_pro_4744", "mmlu_pro_4760", "mmlu_pro_4753", "mmlu_pro_4771", "mmlu_pro_4763", "mmlu_pro_4786", "mmlu_pro_4776", "mmlu_pro_4787", "mmlu_pro_4792", "mmlu_pro_4794", "mmlu_pro_4795", "mmlu_pro_4800", "mmlu_pro_4814", "mmlu_pro_4807", "mmlu_pro_4820", "mmlu_pro_4829", "mmlu_pro_4836", "mmlu_pro_4842", "mmlu_pro_4877", "mmlu_pro_4878", "mmlu_pro_4884", "mmlu_pro_4893", "mmlu_pro_4897", "mmlu_pro_4899", "mmlu_pro_4904", "mmlu_pro_4916", "mmlu_pro_4924", "mmlu_pro_4938", "mmlu_pro_4939", "mmlu_pro_4955", "mmlu_pro_4949", "mmlu_pro_4956", "mmlu_pro_4957", "mmlu_pro_4961", "mmlu_pro_4960", "mmlu_pro_4986", "mmlu_pro_4969", "mmlu_pro_4992", "mmlu_pro_5016", "mmlu_pro_5023", "mmlu_pro_5038", "mmlu_pro_5046", "mmlu_pro_5050", "mmlu_pro_5058", "mmlu_pro_5061", "mmlu_pro_5072", "mmlu_pro_5074", "mmlu_pro_5080", "mmlu_pro_5078", "mmlu_pro_5085", "mmlu_pro_5086", "mmlu_pro_5091", "mmlu_pro_5088", "mmlu_pro_5093", "mmlu_pro_5095", "mmlu_pro_5103", "mmlu_pro_5108", "mmlu_pro_5121", "mmlu_pro_5114", "mmlu_pro_5128", "mmlu_pro_5130", "mmlu_pro_5134", "mmlu_pro_5140", "mmlu_pro_5153", "mmlu_pro_5149", "mmlu_pro_5157", "mmlu_pro_5158", "mmlu_pro_5159", "mmlu_pro_5167", "mmlu_pro_5172", "mmlu_pro_5191", "mmlu_pro_5193", "mmlu_pro_5212", "mmlu_pro_5214", "mmlu_pro_5225", "mmlu_pro_5226", "mmlu_pro_5231", "mmlu_pro_5229", "mmlu_pro_5245", "mmlu_pro_5237", "mmlu_pro_5246", "mmlu_pro_5248", "mmlu_pro_5262", "mmlu_pro_5256", "mmlu_pro_5264", "mmlu_pro_5263", "mmlu_pro_5267", "mmlu_pro_5279", "mmlu_pro_5270", "mmlu_pro_5281", "mmlu_pro_5294", "mmlu_pro_5300", "mmlu_pro_5305", "mmlu_pro_5319", "mmlu_pro_5311", "mmlu_pro_5324", "mmlu_pro_5328", "mmlu_pro_5331", "mmlu_pro_5333", "mmlu_pro_5339", "mmlu_pro_5348", "mmlu_pro_5369", "mmlu_pro_5374", "mmlu_pro_5381", "mmlu_pro_5387", "mmlu_pro_5393", "mmlu_pro_5396", "mmlu_pro_5421", "mmlu_pro_5431", "mmlu_pro_5423", "mmlu_pro_5443", "mmlu_pro_5445", "mmlu_pro_5450", "mmlu_pro_5447", "mmlu_pro_5456", "mmlu_pro_5459", "mmlu_pro_5465", "mmlu_pro_5473", "mmlu_pro_5482", "mmlu_pro_5500", "mmlu_pro_5501", "mmlu_pro_5507", "mmlu_pro_5502", "mmlu_pro_5512", "mmlu_pro_5519", "mmlu_pro_5522", "mmlu_pro_5523", "mmlu_pro_5541", "mmlu_pro_5540", "mmlu_pro_5542", "mmlu_pro_5554", "mmlu_pro_5557", "mmlu_pro_5563", "mmlu_pro_5561", "mmlu_pro_5571", "mmlu_pro_5565", "mmlu_pro_5588", "mmlu_pro_5598", "mmlu_pro_5607", "mmlu_pro_5600", "mmlu_pro_5610", "mmlu_pro_5616", "mmlu_pro_5613", "mmlu_pro_5626", "mmlu_pro_5623", "mmlu_pro_5630", "mmlu_pro_5638", "mmlu_pro_5647", "mmlu_pro_5639", "mmlu_pro_5662", "mmlu_pro_5661", "mmlu_pro_5672", "mmlu_pro_5669", "mmlu_pro_5695", "mmlu_pro_5677", "mmlu_pro_5696", "mmlu_pro_5705", "mmlu_pro_5709", "mmlu_pro_5711", "mmlu_pro_5714", "mmlu_pro_5716", "mmlu_pro_5721", "mmlu_pro_5730", "mmlu_pro_5737", "mmlu_pro_5738", "mmlu_pro_5746", "mmlu_pro_5763", "mmlu_pro_5760", "mmlu_pro_5778", "mmlu_pro_5780", "mmlu_pro_5784", "mmlu_pro_5791", "mmlu_pro_5815", "mmlu_pro_5812", "mmlu_pro_5817", "mmlu_pro_5818", "mmlu_pro_5823", "mmlu_pro_5829", "mmlu_pro_5836", "mmlu_pro_5853", "mmlu_pro_5854", "mmlu_pro_5855", "mmlu_pro_5860", "mmlu_pro_5876", "mmlu_pro_5879", "mmlu_pro_5888", "mmlu_pro_5891", "mmlu_pro_5899", "mmlu_pro_5902", "mmlu_pro_5905", "mmlu_pro_5911", "mmlu_pro_5927", "mmlu_pro_5912", "mmlu_pro_5931", "mmlu_pro_5932", "mmlu_pro_5947", "mmlu_pro_5959", "mmlu_pro_5955", "mmlu_pro_5960", "mmlu_pro_5965", "mmlu_pro_5966", "mmlu_pro_5967"]
abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/qids_qwen3-4b_s1.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
 
 
1
+ ["mmlu_pro_5971", "mmlu_pro_5981", "mmlu_pro_5982", "mmlu_pro_5985", "mmlu_pro_5997", "mmlu_pro_5998", "mmlu_pro_6007", "mmlu_pro_6009", "mmlu_pro_6012", "mmlu_pro_6020", "mmlu_pro_6021", "mmlu_pro_6027", "mmlu_pro_6029", "mmlu_pro_6033", "mmlu_pro_6032", "mmlu_pro_6034", "mmlu_pro_6038", "mmlu_pro_6052", "mmlu_pro_6054", "mmlu_pro_6055", "mmlu_pro_6062", "mmlu_pro_6073", "mmlu_pro_6079", "mmlu_pro_6074", "mmlu_pro_6084", "mmlu_pro_6088", "mmlu_pro_6094", "mmlu_pro_6095", "mmlu_pro_6120", "mmlu_pro_6114", "mmlu_pro_6134", "mmlu_pro_6130", "mmlu_pro_6140", "mmlu_pro_6144", "mmlu_pro_6152", "mmlu_pro_6160", "mmlu_pro_6162", "mmlu_pro_6171", "mmlu_pro_6177", "mmlu_pro_6176", "mmlu_pro_6188", "mmlu_pro_6194", "mmlu_pro_6204", "mmlu_pro_6206", "mmlu_pro_6215", "mmlu_pro_6212", "mmlu_pro_6217", "mmlu_pro_6219", "mmlu_pro_6221", "mmlu_pro_6229", "mmlu_pro_6237", "mmlu_pro_6249", "mmlu_pro_6252", "mmlu_pro_6263", "mmlu_pro_6269", "mmlu_pro_6299", "mmlu_pro_6291", "mmlu_pro_6302", "mmlu_pro_6306", "mmlu_pro_6313", "mmlu_pro_6310", "mmlu_pro_6317", "mmlu_pro_6314", "mmlu_pro_6332", "mmlu_pro_6318", "mmlu_pro_6341", "mmlu_pro_6336", "mmlu_pro_6344", "mmlu_pro_6347", "mmlu_pro_6354", "mmlu_pro_6367", "mmlu_pro_6372", "mmlu_pro_6382", "mmlu_pro_6379", "mmlu_pro_6413", "mmlu_pro_6389", "mmlu_pro_6435", "mmlu_pro_6443", "mmlu_pro_6452", "mmlu_pro_6464", "mmlu_pro_6471", "mmlu_pro_6482", "mmlu_pro_6485", "mmlu_pro_6487", "mmlu_pro_6488", "mmlu_pro_6490", "mmlu_pro_6491", "mmlu_pro_6494", "mmlu_pro_6495", "mmlu_pro_6499", "mmlu_pro_6504", "mmlu_pro_6523", "mmlu_pro_6524", "mmlu_pro_6539", "mmlu_pro_6537", "mmlu_pro_6542", "mmlu_pro_6546", "mmlu_pro_6547", "mmlu_pro_6554", "mmlu_pro_6567", "mmlu_pro_6565", "mmlu_pro_6586", "mmlu_pro_6576", "mmlu_pro_6592", "mmlu_pro_6609", "mmlu_pro_6596", "mmlu_pro_6624", "mmlu_pro_6625", "mmlu_pro_6646", "mmlu_pro_6658", "mmlu_pro_6674", "mmlu_pro_6679", "mmlu_pro_6694", "mmlu_pro_6682", "mmlu_pro_6700", "mmlu_pro_6722", "mmlu_pro_6720", "mmlu_pro_6726", "mmlu_pro_6729", "mmlu_pro_6733", "mmlu_pro_6736", "mmlu_pro_6752", "mmlu_pro_6760", "mmlu_pro_6763", "mmlu_pro_6765", "mmlu_pro_6769", "mmlu_pro_6770", "mmlu_pro_6771", "mmlu_pro_6780", "mmlu_pro_6775", "mmlu_pro_6786", "mmlu_pro_6802", "mmlu_pro_6804", "mmlu_pro_6807", "mmlu_pro_6820", "mmlu_pro_6817", "mmlu_pro_6829", "mmlu_pro_6845", "mmlu_pro_6849", "mmlu_pro_6852", "mmlu_pro_6861", "mmlu_pro_6865", "mmlu_pro_6872", "mmlu_pro_6881", "mmlu_pro_6879", "mmlu_pro_6886", "mmlu_pro_6885", "mmlu_pro_6888", "mmlu_pro_6891", "mmlu_pro_6894", "mmlu_pro_6892", "mmlu_pro_6920", "mmlu_pro_6907", "mmlu_pro_6921", "mmlu_pro_6928", "mmlu_pro_6923", "mmlu_pro_6933", "mmlu_pro_6939", "mmlu_pro_6942", "mmlu_pro_6964", "mmlu_pro_6970", "mmlu_pro_6973", "mmlu_pro_6975", "mmlu_pro_6994", "mmlu_pro_6995", "mmlu_pro_7001", "mmlu_pro_7002", "mmlu_pro_7007", "mmlu_pro_7008", "mmlu_pro_7011", "mmlu_pro_7029", "mmlu_pro_7043", "mmlu_pro_7049", "mmlu_pro_7050", "mmlu_pro_7058", "mmlu_pro_7051", "mmlu_pro_7076", "mmlu_pro_7085", "mmlu_pro_7095", "mmlu_pro_7090", "mmlu_pro_7097", "mmlu_pro_7100", "mmlu_pro_7110", "mmlu_pro_7111", "mmlu_pro_7113", "mmlu_pro_7118", "mmlu_pro_7126", "mmlu_pro_7131", "mmlu_pro_7127", "mmlu_pro_7132", "mmlu_pro_7142", "mmlu_pro_7154", "mmlu_pro_7171", "mmlu_pro_7163", "mmlu_pro_7176", "mmlu_pro_7175", "mmlu_pro_7181", "mmlu_pro_7183", "mmlu_pro_7194", "mmlu_pro_7190", "mmlu_pro_7209", "mmlu_pro_7232", "mmlu_pro_7249", "mmlu_pro_7236", "mmlu_pro_7252", "mmlu_pro_7253", "mmlu_pro_7269", "mmlu_pro_7279", "mmlu_pro_7283", "mmlu_pro_7284", "mmlu_pro_7285", "mmlu_pro_7287", "mmlu_pro_7294", "mmlu_pro_7305", "mmlu_pro_7306", "mmlu_pro_7331", "mmlu_pro_7327", "mmlu_pro_7344", "mmlu_pro_7345", "mmlu_pro_7359", "mmlu_pro_7365", "mmlu_pro_7361", "mmlu_pro_7367", "mmlu_pro_7369", "mmlu_pro_7372", "mmlu_pro_7371", "mmlu_pro_7380", "mmlu_pro_7376", "mmlu_pro_7386", "mmlu_pro_7388", "mmlu_pro_7395", "mmlu_pro_7397", "mmlu_pro_7391", "mmlu_pro_7406", "mmlu_pro_7402", "mmlu_pro_7413", "mmlu_pro_7415", "mmlu_pro_7423", "mmlu_pro_7422", "mmlu_pro_7438", "mmlu_pro_7427", "mmlu_pro_7444", "mmlu_pro_7468", "mmlu_pro_7470", "mmlu_pro_7473", "mmlu_pro_7482", "mmlu_pro_7501", "mmlu_pro_7503", "mmlu_pro_7506", "mmlu_pro_7516", "mmlu_pro_7523", "mmlu_pro_7524", "mmlu_pro_7528", "mmlu_pro_7532", "mmlu_pro_7538", "mmlu_pro_7540", "mmlu_pro_7564", "mmlu_pro_7544", "mmlu_pro_7572", "mmlu_pro_7589", "mmlu_pro_7595", "mmlu_pro_7596", "mmlu_pro_7600", "mmlu_pro_7601", "mmlu_pro_7612", "mmlu_pro_7619", "mmlu_pro_7620", "mmlu_pro_7621", "mmlu_pro_7626", "mmlu_pro_7629", "mmlu_pro_7633", "mmlu_pro_7635", "mmlu_pro_7639", "mmlu_pro_7656", "mmlu_pro_7660", "mmlu_pro_7661", "mmlu_pro_7675", "mmlu_pro_7694", "mmlu_pro_7682", "mmlu_pro_7708", "mmlu_pro_7709", "mmlu_pro_7715", "mmlu_pro_7716", "mmlu_pro_7723", "mmlu_pro_7717", "mmlu_pro_7727", "mmlu_pro_7737", "mmlu_pro_7750", "mmlu_pro_7755", "mmlu_pro_7764", "mmlu_pro_7770", "mmlu_pro_7765", "mmlu_pro_7777", "mmlu_pro_7779", "mmlu_pro_7789", "mmlu_pro_7790", "mmlu_pro_7792", "mmlu_pro_7798", "mmlu_pro_7808", "mmlu_pro_7812", "mmlu_pro_7817", "mmlu_pro_7826", "mmlu_pro_7828", "mmlu_pro_7836", "mmlu_pro_7835", "mmlu_pro_7837", "mmlu_pro_7848", "mmlu_pro_7851", "mmlu_pro_7852", "mmlu_pro_7871", "mmlu_pro_7858", "mmlu_pro_7878", "mmlu_pro_7880", "mmlu_pro_7887", "mmlu_pro_7893", "mmlu_pro_7900", "mmlu_pro_7902", "mmlu_pro_7909", "mmlu_pro_7917", "mmlu_pro_7918", "mmlu_pro_7925", "mmlu_pro_7934", "mmlu_pro_7936", "mmlu_pro_7939", "mmlu_pro_7940", "mmlu_pro_7945", "mmlu_pro_7953", "mmlu_pro_7946", "mmlu_pro_7957", "mmlu_pro_7962", "mmlu_pro_7972", "mmlu_pro_7975", "mmlu_pro_7981", "mmlu_pro_7983", "mmlu_pro_7989", "mmlu_pro_7993", "mmlu_pro_7995", "mmlu_pro_7996", "mmlu_pro_8003", "mmlu_pro_8004", "mmlu_pro_8021", "mmlu_pro_8023", "mmlu_pro_8034", "mmlu_pro_8048", "mmlu_pro_8050", "mmlu_pro_8071", "mmlu_pro_8076", "mmlu_pro_8080", "mmlu_pro_8084", "mmlu_pro_8095", "mmlu_pro_8101", "mmlu_pro_8108", "mmlu_pro_8109", "mmlu_pro_8115", "mmlu_pro_8123", "mmlu_pro_8138", "mmlu_pro_8140", "mmlu_pro_8152", "mmlu_pro_8154", "mmlu_pro_8158", "mmlu_pro_8156", "mmlu_pro_8166", "mmlu_pro_8176", "mmlu_pro_8159", "mmlu_pro_8178", "mmlu_pro_8181", "mmlu_pro_8184", "mmlu_pro_8195", "mmlu_pro_8196", "mmlu_pro_8218", "mmlu_pro_8224", "mmlu_pro_8222", "mmlu_pro_8226", "mmlu_pro_8235", "mmlu_pro_8236", "mmlu_pro_8241", "mmlu_pro_8242", "mmlu_pro_8247", "mmlu_pro_8249", "mmlu_pro_8259", "mmlu_pro_8262", "mmlu_pro_8273", "mmlu_pro_8275", "mmlu_pro_8277", "mmlu_pro_8284", "mmlu_pro_8283", "mmlu_pro_8294", "mmlu_pro_8291", "mmlu_pro_8295", "mmlu_pro_8301", "mmlu_pro_8302", "mmlu_pro_8320", "mmlu_pro_8333", "mmlu_pro_8337", "mmlu_pro_8342", "mmlu_pro_8341", "mmlu_pro_8354", "mmlu_pro_8348", "mmlu_pro_8365", "mmlu_pro_8371", "mmlu_pro_8361", "mmlu_pro_8379", "mmlu_pro_8389", "mmlu_pro_8397", "mmlu_pro_8391", "mmlu_pro_8411", "mmlu_pro_8417", "mmlu_pro_8419", "mmlu_pro_8441", "mmlu_pro_8449", "mmlu_pro_8458", "mmlu_pro_8473", "mmlu_pro_8474", "mmlu_pro_8475", "mmlu_pro_8478", "mmlu_pro_8481", "mmlu_pro_8484", "mmlu_pro_8508", "mmlu_pro_8486", "mmlu_pro_8516", "mmlu_pro_8515", "mmlu_pro_8562", "mmlu_pro_8530", "mmlu_pro_8567", "mmlu_pro_8563", "mmlu_pro_8569", "mmlu_pro_8580", "mmlu_pro_8582", "mmlu_pro_8584", "mmlu_pro_8586", "mmlu_pro_8594", "mmlu_pro_8601", "mmlu_pro_8611", "mmlu_pro_8614", "mmlu_pro_8629", "mmlu_pro_8641", "mmlu_pro_8644", "mmlu_pro_8647", "mmlu_pro_8654", "mmlu_pro_8658", "mmlu_pro_8669", "mmlu_pro_8690", "mmlu_pro_8670", "mmlu_pro_8699", "mmlu_pro_8704", "mmlu_pro_8710", "mmlu_pro_8709", "mmlu_pro_8724", "mmlu_pro_8729", "mmlu_pro_8725", "mmlu_pro_8733", "mmlu_pro_8745", "mmlu_pro_8747", "mmlu_pro_8760", "mmlu_pro_8761", "mmlu_pro_8766", "mmlu_pro_8781", "mmlu_pro_8796", "mmlu_pro_8803", "mmlu_pro_8805", "mmlu_pro_8816", "mmlu_pro_8826", "mmlu_pro_8820", "mmlu_pro_8831", "mmlu_pro_8839", "mmlu_pro_8833", "mmlu_pro_8843", "mmlu_pro_8844", "mmlu_pro_8848", "mmlu_pro_8850", "mmlu_pro_8855", "mmlu_pro_8856", "mmlu_pro_8865", "mmlu_pro_8875", "mmlu_pro_8872", "mmlu_pro_8878", "mmlu_pro_8903", "mmlu_pro_8912", "mmlu_pro_8919", "mmlu_pro_8932", "mmlu_pro_8934", "mmlu_pro_8936", "mmlu_pro_8941", "mmlu_pro_8950", "mmlu_pro_8955", "mmlu_pro_8956", "mmlu_pro_8958", "mmlu_pro_8975", "mmlu_pro_8971", "mmlu_pro_8983", "mmlu_pro_9004", "mmlu_pro_9002", "mmlu_pro_9010", "mmlu_pro_9005", "mmlu_pro_9013", "mmlu_pro_9016", "mmlu_pro_9019", "mmlu_pro_9024", "mmlu_pro_9028", "mmlu_pro_9033", "mmlu_pro_9039", "mmlu_pro_9042", "mmlu_pro_9072", "mmlu_pro_9063", "mmlu_pro_9099", "mmlu_pro_9084", "mmlu_pro_9101", "mmlu_pro_9114", "mmlu_pro_9121", "mmlu_pro_9123", "mmlu_pro_9124", "mmlu_pro_9125", "mmlu_pro_9129", "mmlu_pro_9137", "mmlu_pro_9140", "mmlu_pro_9141", "mmlu_pro_9143", "mmlu_pro_9155", "mmlu_pro_9157", "mmlu_pro_9164", "mmlu_pro_9172", "mmlu_pro_9181", "mmlu_pro_9185", "mmlu_pro_9187", "mmlu_pro_9188", "mmlu_pro_9192", "mmlu_pro_9213", "mmlu_pro_9217", "mmlu_pro_9219", "mmlu_pro_9239", "mmlu_pro_9228", "mmlu_pro_9244", "mmlu_pro_9243", "mmlu_pro_9245", "mmlu_pro_9254", "mmlu_pro_9265", "mmlu_pro_9274", "mmlu_pro_9282", "mmlu_pro_9291", "mmlu_pro_9307", "mmlu_pro_9286", "mmlu_pro_9314", "mmlu_pro_9324", "mmlu_pro_9308", "mmlu_pro_9328", "mmlu_pro_9329", "mmlu_pro_9340", "mmlu_pro_9337", "mmlu_pro_9342", "mmlu_pro_9345", "mmlu_pro_9349", "mmlu_pro_9374", "mmlu_pro_9375", "mmlu_pro_9376", "mmlu_pro_9378", "mmlu_pro_9396", "mmlu_pro_9380", "mmlu_pro_9400", "mmlu_pro_9407", "mmlu_pro_9410", "mmlu_pro_9411", "mmlu_pro_9414", "mmlu_pro_9415", "mmlu_pro_9422", "mmlu_pro_9439", "mmlu_pro_9442", "mmlu_pro_9443", "mmlu_pro_9448", "mmlu_pro_9483", "mmlu_pro_9491", "mmlu_pro_9494", "mmlu_pro_9500", "mmlu_pro_9503", "mmlu_pro_9511", "mmlu_pro_9521", "mmlu_pro_9512", "mmlu_pro_9545", "mmlu_pro_9533", "mmlu_pro_9548", "mmlu_pro_9567", "mmlu_pro_9586", "mmlu_pro_9603", "mmlu_pro_9613", "mmlu_pro_9621", "mmlu_pro_9619", "mmlu_pro_9623", "mmlu_pro_9627", "mmlu_pro_9629", "mmlu_pro_9632", "mmlu_pro_9641", "mmlu_pro_9644", "mmlu_pro_9653", "mmlu_pro_9647", "mmlu_pro_9661", "mmlu_pro_9671", "mmlu_pro_9675", "mmlu_pro_9686", "mmlu_pro_9687", "mmlu_pro_9697", "mmlu_pro_9705", "mmlu_pro_9715", "mmlu_pro_9725", "mmlu_pro_9734", "mmlu_pro_9738", "mmlu_pro_9739", "mmlu_pro_9743", "mmlu_pro_9753", "mmlu_pro_9756", "mmlu_pro_9768", "mmlu_pro_9777", "mmlu_pro_9791", "mmlu_pro_9793", "mmlu_pro_9798", "mmlu_pro_9808", "mmlu_pro_9817", "mmlu_pro_9819", "mmlu_pro_9820", "mmlu_pro_9839", "mmlu_pro_9840", "mmlu_pro_9851", "mmlu_pro_9843", "mmlu_pro_9852", "mmlu_pro_9859", "mmlu_pro_9872", "mmlu_pro_9876", "mmlu_pro_9882", "mmlu_pro_9884", "mmlu_pro_9891", "mmlu_pro_9895", "mmlu_pro_9903", "mmlu_pro_9907", "mmlu_pro_9925", "mmlu_pro_9923", "mmlu_pro_9926", "mmlu_pro_9930", "mmlu_pro_9942", "mmlu_pro_9933", "mmlu_pro_9969", "mmlu_pro_9968", "mmlu_pro_9975", "mmlu_pro_9971", "mmlu_pro_9977", "mmlu_pro_9976", "mmlu_pro_9989", "mmlu_pro_9987", "mmlu_pro_9991", "mmlu_pro_9993", "mmlu_pro_10005", "mmlu_pro_10011", "mmlu_pro_10026", "mmlu_pro_10034", "mmlu_pro_10035", "mmlu_pro_10036", "mmlu_pro_10037", "mmlu_pro_10038", "mmlu_pro_10051", "mmlu_pro_10044", "mmlu_pro_10060", "mmlu_pro_10063", "mmlu_pro_10065", "mmlu_pro_10074", "mmlu_pro_10079", "mmlu_pro_10080", "mmlu_pro_10085", "mmlu_pro_10087", "mmlu_pro_10090", "mmlu_pro_10095", "mmlu_pro_10098", "mmlu_pro_10112", "mmlu_pro_10127", "mmlu_pro_10131", "mmlu_pro_10134", "mmlu_pro_10139", "mmlu_pro_10142", "mmlu_pro_10141", "mmlu_pro_10150", "mmlu_pro_10147", "mmlu_pro_10156", "mmlu_pro_10159", "mmlu_pro_10162", "mmlu_pro_10179", "mmlu_pro_10170", "mmlu_pro_10185", "mmlu_pro_10186", "mmlu_pro_10222", "mmlu_pro_10241", "mmlu_pro_10230", "mmlu_pro_10242", "mmlu_pro_10245", "mmlu_pro_10247", "mmlu_pro_10270", "mmlu_pro_10271", "mmlu_pro_10283", "mmlu_pro_10285", "mmlu_pro_10288", "mmlu_pro_10290", "mmlu_pro_10299", "mmlu_pro_10302", "mmlu_pro_10300", "mmlu_pro_10308", "mmlu_pro_10315", "mmlu_pro_10314", "mmlu_pro_10316", "mmlu_pro_10318", "mmlu_pro_10321", "mmlu_pro_10324", "mmlu_pro_10333", "mmlu_pro_10343", "mmlu_pro_10341", "mmlu_pro_10344", "mmlu_pro_10346", "mmlu_pro_10349", "mmlu_pro_10360", "mmlu_pro_10367", "mmlu_pro_10372", "mmlu_pro_10382", "mmlu_pro_10387", "mmlu_pro_10408", "mmlu_pro_10411", "mmlu_pro_10417", "mmlu_pro_10422", "mmlu_pro_10437", "mmlu_pro_10432", "mmlu_pro_10441", "mmlu_pro_10454", "mmlu_pro_10476", "mmlu_pro_10467", "mmlu_pro_10481", "mmlu_pro_10478", "mmlu_pro_10484", "mmlu_pro_10489", "mmlu_pro_10487", "mmlu_pro_10502", "mmlu_pro_10492", "mmlu_pro_10503", "mmlu_pro_10505", "mmlu_pro_10515", "mmlu_pro_10520", "mmlu_pro_10526", "mmlu_pro_10527", "mmlu_pro_10532", "mmlu_pro_10538", "mmlu_pro_10543", "mmlu_pro_10544", "mmlu_pro_10568", "mmlu_pro_10571", "mmlu_pro_10578", "mmlu_pro_10586", "mmlu_pro_10589", "mmlu_pro_10600", "mmlu_pro_10602", "mmlu_pro_10609", "mmlu_pro_10621", "mmlu_pro_10627", "mmlu_pro_10641", "mmlu_pro_10651", "mmlu_pro_10648", "mmlu_pro_10661", "mmlu_pro_10656", "mmlu_pro_10669", "mmlu_pro_10663", "mmlu_pro_10692", "mmlu_pro_10689", "mmlu_pro_10703", "mmlu_pro_10694", "mmlu_pro_10713", "mmlu_pro_10717", "mmlu_pro_10728", "mmlu_pro_10737", "mmlu_pro_10752", "mmlu_pro_10741", "mmlu_pro_10753", "mmlu_pro_10758", "mmlu_pro_10762", "mmlu_pro_10765", "mmlu_pro_10769", "mmlu_pro_10783", "mmlu_pro_10770", "mmlu_pro_10792", "mmlu_pro_10797", "mmlu_pro_10802", "mmlu_pro_10816", "mmlu_pro_10822", "mmlu_pro_10823", "mmlu_pro_10830", "mmlu_pro_10842", "mmlu_pro_10851", "mmlu_pro_10854", "mmlu_pro_10863", "mmlu_pro_10868", "mmlu_pro_10873", "mmlu_pro_10878", "mmlu_pro_10883", "mmlu_pro_10882", "mmlu_pro_10893", "mmlu_pro_10895", "mmlu_pro_10903", "mmlu_pro_10905", "mmlu_pro_10909", "mmlu_pro_10910", "mmlu_pro_10925", "mmlu_pro_10922", "mmlu_pro_10928", "mmlu_pro_10932", "mmlu_pro_10937", "mmlu_pro_10936", "mmlu_pro_10969", "mmlu_pro_10971", "mmlu_pro_10979", "mmlu_pro_10986", "mmlu_pro_10982", "mmlu_pro_10990", "mmlu_pro_10993", "mmlu_pro_11009", "mmlu_pro_10995", "mmlu_pro_11022", "mmlu_pro_11014", "mmlu_pro_11024", "mmlu_pro_11032", "mmlu_pro_11040", "mmlu_pro_11034", "mmlu_pro_11045", "mmlu_pro_11053", "mmlu_pro_11059", "mmlu_pro_11062", "mmlu_pro_11100", "mmlu_pro_11091", "mmlu_pro_11101", "mmlu_pro_11109", "mmlu_pro_11110", "mmlu_pro_11114", "mmlu_pro_11117", "mmlu_pro_11115", "mmlu_pro_11127", "mmlu_pro_11149", "mmlu_pro_11153", "mmlu_pro_11150", "mmlu_pro_11170", "mmlu_pro_11157", "mmlu_pro_11177", "mmlu_pro_11173", "mmlu_pro_11183", "mmlu_pro_11186", "mmlu_pro_11188", "mmlu_pro_11189", "mmlu_pro_11197", "mmlu_pro_11201", "mmlu_pro_11211", "mmlu_pro_11203", "mmlu_pro_11217", "mmlu_pro_11221", "mmlu_pro_11224", "mmlu_pro_11243", "mmlu_pro_11226", "mmlu_pro_11246", "mmlu_pro_11247", "mmlu_pro_11254", "mmlu_pro_11265", "mmlu_pro_11284", "mmlu_pro_11288", "mmlu_pro_11305", "mmlu_pro_11300", "mmlu_pro_11314", "mmlu_pro_11331", "mmlu_pro_11336", "mmlu_pro_11343", "mmlu_pro_11345", "mmlu_pro_11347", "mmlu_pro_11368", "mmlu_pro_11372", "mmlu_pro_11381", "mmlu_pro_11382", "mmlu_pro_11391", "mmlu_pro_11395", "mmlu_pro_11396", "mmlu_pro_11402", "mmlu_pro_11407", "mmlu_pro_11413", "mmlu_pro_11423", "mmlu_pro_11422", "mmlu_pro_11425", "mmlu_pro_11437", "mmlu_pro_11444", "mmlu_pro_11445", "mmlu_pro_11453", "mmlu_pro_11466", "mmlu_pro_11467", "mmlu_pro_11468", "mmlu_pro_11477", "mmlu_pro_11474", "mmlu_pro_11484", "mmlu_pro_11490", "mmlu_pro_11503", "mmlu_pro_11493", "mmlu_pro_11514", "mmlu_pro_11504", "mmlu_pro_11539", "mmlu_pro_11543", "mmlu_pro_11560", "mmlu_pro_11548", "mmlu_pro_11586", "mmlu_pro_11587", "mmlu_pro_11588", "mmlu_pro_11610", "mmlu_pro_11627", "mmlu_pro_11629", "mmlu_pro_11630", "mmlu_pro_11633", "mmlu_pro_11637", "mmlu_pro_11650", "mmlu_pro_11653", "mmlu_pro_11654", "mmlu_pro_11658", "mmlu_pro_11660", "mmlu_pro_11664", "mmlu_pro_11682", "mmlu_pro_11688", "mmlu_pro_11689", "mmlu_pro_11701", "mmlu_pro_11714", "mmlu_pro_11710", "mmlu_pro_11725", "mmlu_pro_11730", "mmlu_pro_11739", "mmlu_pro_11732", "mmlu_pro_11746", "mmlu_pro_11750", "mmlu_pro_11762", "mmlu_pro_11765", "mmlu_pro_11770", "mmlu_pro_11774", "mmlu_pro_11778", "mmlu_pro_11783", "mmlu_pro_11793", "mmlu_pro_11795", "mmlu_pro_11801", "mmlu_pro_11810", "mmlu_pro_11823", "mmlu_pro_11817", "mmlu_pro_11825", "mmlu_pro_11826", "mmlu_pro_11828", "mmlu_pro_11832", "mmlu_pro_11835", "mmlu_pro_11842", "mmlu_pro_11846", "mmlu_pro_11844", "mmlu_pro_11852", "mmlu_pro_11848", "mmlu_pro_11864", "mmlu_pro_11865", "mmlu_pro_11868", "mmlu_pro_11870", "mmlu_pro_11872", "mmlu_pro_11874", "mmlu_pro_11903", "mmlu_pro_11904", "mmlu_pro_11914", "mmlu_pro_11917", "mmlu_pro_11920", "mmlu_pro_11922", "mmlu_pro_11924", "mmlu_pro_11936", "mmlu_pro_11948", "mmlu_pro_11963", "mmlu_pro_11965", "mmlu_pro_11977", "mmlu_pro_11980", "mmlu_pro_11988", "mmlu_pro_11993", "mmlu_pro_12003", "mmlu_pro_12006", "mmlu_pro_12007", "mmlu_pro_12010", "mmlu_pro_12015", "mmlu_pro_12016", "mmlu_pro_12017", "mmlu_pro_12023", "mmlu_pro_12025", "mmlu_pro_12030"]
abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/sa_causal_vllm_llama-3.1-8b_rerun.jsonl ADDED
The diff for this file is too large to render. See raw diff
 
abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/sa_causal_vllm_phi-4-mini_rerun.jsonl ADDED
The diff for this file is too large to render. See raw diff
 
abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/sa_causal_vllm_qwen3-4b_rerun.jsonl ADDED
The diff for this file is too large to render. See raw diff
 
abc_exp/results/gate_rerun/sa_causal_vllm_qwen3-8b_rerun.jsonl ADDED
The diff for this file is too large to render. See raw diff
 
abc_exp/results/n9_partial_holm.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,54 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "n_models": 9,
3
+ "models": [
4
+ "Sonnet 4.5",
5
+ "GPT-4o-mini",
6
+ "GPT-5.4-mini",
7
+ "Gemini 3-flash",
8
+ "Phi-4-mini",
9
+ "Qwen3-4B",
10
+ "Llama-3.1-8B",
11
+ "Qwen3-8B",
12
+ "Qwen3-32B"
13
+ ],
14
+ "holm_family_size": 7,
15
+ "secondary_spearman": {
16
+ "alpha_adv": {
17
+ "rho": 0.6166666666666666,
18
+ "p_raw": 0.07692880993776312,
19
+ "p_holm": 0.4615728596265787
20
+ },
21
+ "alpha_cor": {
22
+ "rho": -0.19999999999999998,
23
+ "p_raw": 0.6059012741795534,
24
+ "p_holm": 1.0
25
+ },
26
+ "debate_FR": {
27
+ "rho": 0.326362689414732,
28
+ "p_raw": 0.3913604492997979,
29
+ "p_holm": 1.0
30
+ },
31
+ "init_acc": {
32
+ "rho": -0.7333333333333334,
33
+ "p_raw": 0.024554150071469705,
34
+ "p_holm": 0.17187905050028793
35
+ }
36
+ },
37
+ "partial_given_init_acc": {
38
+ "alpha_total": {
39
+ "partial_rho": 0.5685642641633971,
40
+ "p_raw": 0.14140768041442225,
41
+ "p_holm": 0.7070384020721112
42
+ },
43
+ "alpha_adv": {
44
+ "partial_rho": 0.21282857659767226,
45
+ "p_raw": 0.6128330238165054,
46
+ "p_holm": 1.0
47
+ },
48
+ "alpha_cor": {
49
+ "partial_rho": -0.061940498376286415,
50
+ "p_raw": 0.8841582767470036,
51
+ "p_holm": 1.0
52
+ }
53
+ }
54
+ }