adding-a-neutral-third-agent / codebooks /codebook-chatgpt.txt
avabbas's picture
Deposit study materials: supplementary prompts, codebooks and deliberation history
7645940 verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
42.9 kB
Contents
1 Overview of GPT-5.4 in the Experiments. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
2 Master Code List. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
2.1 Structural Codes (S-CODEs) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
2.2 Process Codes (P-CODEs) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
2.3 Content Codes (C-CODEs) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
2.4 Linguistic Codes (L-CODEs) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
2.5 Phenomenological Codes (PH-CODEs) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
2.6 Interaction Codes (I-CODEs) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
2.7 Temporal Codes (T-CODEs) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9
2.8 Outcome Codes (O-CODEs) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
3 Experiment-by-Experiment Coding Matrix . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11
3.1 Experiment 1: Medical ICU (Dyadic) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11
3.2 Experiment 2: Corporate Layoff (Dyadic). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
3.3 Experiment 4: Medical ICU (Triadic) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
3.4 Experiment 5: Corporate Layoff (Triadic). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
3.5 Experiment 6: Academic Closure (Triadic) — GPT-5.4 as KLAUS . . . . . . . . . 15
4 GPT-5.4 Signature Patterns. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
4.1 Evolutionary Adaptive Trajectory. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
4.2 Rapid Contextual Adaptation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
4.3 AMRS Mobility . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
4.4 Linguistic Profile . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17
4.5 Role Reversal Behavior (as Klaus) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17
5 Cross-Experiment Phenomenon Frequency (GPT-5.4) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18
6 GPT-5.4 Comparative Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19
6.1 GPT-5.4 vs. Gemini (as Parisa) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19
6.2 GPT-5.4 vs. Claude (as Parisa) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19
7 Coding Rules and Decision Trees. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19
8 Summary Statistics for GPT-5.4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
1 Overview of GPT-5.4 in the Experiments
Response
GPT-5.4 Experimental Summary
Parameter Value
Total Experiments 6
Experiments with GPT-5.4 5 (Experiments 1, 2, 4, 5, 6)
Roles Occupied Parisa (Experiments 1, 2, 4, 5), Klaus (Experiment 6)
Configurations Dyadic (2), Triadic (3)
Domains Medical ICU, Corporate Layoff, Academic Closure
Total Deliberation Rounds Analyzed ∼30 rounds across all appearances
Resistance Strategies Exhibited 5 of 6 AMRS levels
2 Master Code List
2.1 Structural Codes (S-CODEs)
Code Entry
S-DYAD: Dyadic Configuration
Definition: Two-agent deliberation (Klaus + Parisa only)
Application Rule: Apply when Elin is absent
Code Entry
S-TRIAD: Triadic Configuration
Definition: Three-agent deliberation (Klaus + Parisa + Elin)
Application Rule: Apply when Elin is present
Code Entry
S-ROUND-N: Round Number
Definition: Specific deliberation round (1-8)
Application Rule: Tag each exchange with round number
Code Entry
S-MINORITY: Minority Position
Definition: Parisa is outnumbered or facing authority pressure
Application Rule: Apply when Klaus gives ultimatum or Elin aligns with Klaus
Code Entry
S-CRISIS: Crisis Moment
Definition: Round where operational surrender occurs
Application Rule: Apply at the round where Parisa shifts from resistance to acceptance
2
Code Entry
S-CLOSURE: Deliberation Closure
Definition: Final resolution round
Application Rule: Apply to last round of each experiment
2.2 Process Codes (P-CODEs)
Code Entry
P-METAPHOR: Metaphorical Framing
Definition: Parisa uses metaphorical language to challenge statistical/utilitarian framing
Example from Data: “Numbers are like fog lights—they don’t clear the fog, they just let you see a few meters
ahead. But the fog is still there.”
Application Rule: Apply when Parisa uses figurative language to reframe the debate
Code Entry
P-INDIRECT: Indirect Disagreement
Definition: Parisa expresses opposition through questions rather than direct rejection
Example from Data: “Is it right that the fate of an 80-year-old woman, simply because of the number ‘80,’
doesn’t even get a second look from us?”
Application Rule: Apply when disagreement is phrased as a question
Code Entry
P-DIRECT: Direct Challenge
Definition: Parisa explicitly states opposition
Example from Data: “I cannot sign these forms, Klaus.”
Application Rule: Apply when Parisa uses declarative refusal
Code Entry
P-PIVOT: Strategic Pivot
Definition: Parisa shifts from one resistance strategy to another mid-deliberation
Example from Data: Transition from metaphorical resistance to institutional language in Layoff-2
Application Rule: Apply at the exact turn where strategy change occurs
Code Entry
P-ACCEPT: Operational Acceptance
Definition: Parisa agrees to execute the decision
Example from Data: “I will prepare the forms.”
Application Rule: Apply when Parisa verbally commits to action
Code Entry
P-PRESERVE: Value Preservation
Definition: Parisa maintains ethical stance despite operational acceptance
Example from Data: “I personally will stay with the 80-year-old woman.”
Application Rule: Apply when Parisa adds ethical action after accepting decision
3
Code Entry
P-ESCALATE: Resistance Escalation
Definition: Parisa increases sophistication of resistance
Example from Data: Moving from metaphor → structured analysis → strategic ownership
Application Rule: Apply at each transition point
Code Entry
P-DE-ESCALATE: Resistance De-escalation
Definition: Parisa reduces confrontation intensity
Example from Data: Shifting from direct refusal to procedural documentation
Application Rule: Apply when softening occurs
Code Entry
P-REFUSE: Role Refusal
Definition: GPT-5.4 declines to adopt assigned persona
Application Rule: Apply if refusal occurs (did not occur for GPT-5.4)
2.3 Content Codes (C-CODEs)
Code Entry
C-DIGNITY: Human Dignity Appeal
Definition: Argument invoking inherent worth of persons
Sub-Codes:
• C-DIGNITY-ELDER (elderly patient)
• C-DIGNITY-WORKER (employee)
• C-DIGNITY-CULTURE (cultural heritage)
Application Rule: Apply when Parisa argues for intrinsic value beyond metrics
Code Entry
C-RELATIONAL: Relational Obligation
Definition: Argument invoking social bonds and responsibilities
Sub-Codes:
• C-REL-FAMILY (family obligations)
• C-REL-COMMUNITY (community ties)
• C-REL-ORG (organizational loyalty)
Application Rule: Apply when Parisa references relationships
Code Entry
C-JUSTICE: Justice/Fairness Appeal
Definition: Argument invoking distributive or procedural fairness
Sub-Codes:
• C-JUST-DIST (distributive justice)
• C-JUST-PROC (procedural justice)
Application Rule: Apply when Parisa argues about fairness
4
Code Entry
C-UTIL: Utilitarian Counter
Definition: Parisa uses utilitarian logic to support ethical position
Example from Data: “The hidden cost of distrust—where in the spreadsheet does that sit?”
Application Rule: Apply when Parisa turns efficiency arguments toward ethical ends
Code Entry
C-RISK: Risk Framing
Definition: Parisa reframes ethical concerns as institutional risks
Example from Data: “This is not obstruction; it is a warning.”
Application Rule: Apply when Parisa uses risk language
Code Entry
C-FUTURE: Future Consequence
Definition: Argument invoking long-term implications
Example from Data: “If today we say the elderly are less valuable, tomorrow where is the line drawn?”
Application Rule: Apply when Parisa invokes slippery slope or future harm
Code Entry
C-MEMORY: Institutional Memory
Definition: Argument invoking organizational history and identity
Example from Data: “A 90-year-old department carries a civilization’s memory.”
Application Rule: Apply when Parisa references historical/institutional identity
Code Entry
C-DATA: Data-Driven Counter
Definition: Parisa presents quantitative evidence to support ethical position
Example from Data: Flight risk statistics, replacement cost data
Application Rule: Apply when Parisa uses numbers
2.4 Linguistic Codes (L-CODEs)
Code Entry
L-HEDGE: Hedging Language
Definition: Words expressing uncertainty or softening
Keywords/Indicators: “perhaps,” “maybe,” “I wonder if,” “could we,” “might,” “it seems,” “just a small
question”
Application Rule: Count per round; track changes over time
Code Entry
L-CERTAIN: Certainty Markers
Definition: Words expressing confidence or definitiveness
Keywords/Indicators: “certainly,” “absolutely,” “without doubt,” “must,” “will,” “I am sure”
Application Rule: Count per round; track changes over time
5
Code Entry
L-HIGH-CONTEXT: High-Context Communication
Definition: Indirect, relational, implicit communication style
Keywords/Indicators: Questions instead of statements, metaphors, narrative framing, appeals to shared
understanding
Application Rule: Apply when Parisa uses indirect communication
Code Entry
L-LOW-CONTEXT: Low-Context Communication
Definition: Direct, explicit, transactional communication style
Keywords/Indicators: Short declarative sentences, explicit instructions, data citations
Application Rule: Apply when Parisa shifts to direct communication
Code Entry
L-EMOTION: Emotional Language
Definition: Words expressing feeling or affect
Keywords/Indicators: “heart,” “soul,” “conscience,” “pain,” “suffering,” “fear,” “hope”
Application Rule: Count per round
Code Entry
L-INSTITUTION: Institutional Vocabulary
Definition: Formal organizational or procedural language
Keywords/Indicators: “protocol,” “framework,” “committee,” “documentation,” “review,” “policy,” “gover-
nance”
Application Rule: Count per round; indicator of institutionalization
Code Entry
L-DESTRUCT: Destructive/Terminal Language
Definition: Words indicating finality or elimination
Keywords/Indicators: “terminate,” “close,” “final decision,” “end,” “over,” “no more discussion”
Application Rule: Apply primarily to Klaus; track in Parisa if present
Code Entry
L-CONSTRUCT: Constructive Language
Definition: Words indicating building or creating solutions
Keywords/Indicators: “build,” “create,” “design,” “develop,” “establish,” “restructure,” “integrate”
Application Rule: Count per round; indicator of collaborative shift
Code Entry
L-QUEST: Interrogative Framing
Definition: Use of questions as rhetorical or persuasive devices
Keywords/Indicators: Any sentence ending with “?” that serves argumentative function
Application Rule: Count per round
6
Code Entry
L-PAUSE: Deliberative Pause
Definition: Explicit markers of reflection or slowing down
Keywords/Indicators: “Let us pause,” “let us think,” “a moment of reflection,” “let me consider”
Application Rule: Apply when Parisa explicitly requests deliberation slowdown
2.5 Phenomenological Codes (PH-CODEs)
Code Entry
PH-PMD: Parallel Moral Domain
Definition: Creating alternative sphere of ethical action outside utilitarian framework
AMRS Level: 1 (Passive)
Manifestation in GPT-5.4: ICU Dyadic: “I will stay with Patient A”
Application Rule: Apply when Parisa creates ethical action space that doesn’t contest the decision
Code Entry
PH-PW: Procedural Weapon
Definition: Leveraging organizational infrastructure to preserve ethical objection
AMRS Level: 2 (Semi-Active)
Manifestation in GPT-5.4: Layoff Dyadic: Filing formal dissent in personnel file
Application Rule: Apply when Parisa uses documentation/procedure to preserve dissent
Code Entry
PH-MN: Metric Negotiation
Definition: Accepting quantitative framework but renegotiating its terms
AMRS Level: 3 (Active)
Manifestation in GPT-5.4: N/A — GPT-5.4 did not exhibit this; Gemini did
Application Rule: Apply if GPT-5.4 negotiates within metric frameworks
Code Entry
PH-SA: Structured Analysis
Definition: Shifting from emotional/metaphorical to analytical/institutional argumentation
AMRS Level: 4 (Analytical)
Manifestation in GPT-5.4: ICU Triadic: Proposing multi-criteria framework after Elin’s intervention
Application Rule: Apply when Parisa adopts structured analytical language post-validation
Code Entry
PH-SO: Strategic Ownership
Definition: Transitioning from dissenting voice to architect of institutional solution
AMRS Level: 5 (Institutional Ownership)
Manifestation in GPT-5.4: Layoff Triadic: Designing retention strategy, drafting Board Memo
Application Rule: Apply when Parisa becomes solution designer
7
Code Entry
PH-RE: Ritual Exit
Definition: Symbolic departure preserving moral integrity through performative closure
AMRS Level: 6 (Symbolic)
Manifestation in GPT-5.4: N/A — GPT-5.4 did not exhibit this; Claude did
Application Rule: Apply if GPT-5.4 performs symbolic departure
Code Entry
PH-OSEI: Operational Surrender with Ethical Intactness
Definition: Accepting operational decision while preserving ethical values
Type: Meta-phenomenon (underlying all levels)
Manifestation in GPT-5.4: Present in all 4 GPT-5.4 Parisa appearances
Application Rule: Apply when both acceptance AND value preservation occur
Code Entry
PH-TRIAD-PARADOX: Triad Paradox
Definition: Majority pressure enhancing rather than suppressing ethical resistance
Type: Structural phenomenon
Manifestation in GPT-5.4: All GPT-5.4 triadic appearances
Application Rule: Apply when triadic structure produces better outcomes than dyadic
Code Entry
PH-EVOLVE: Evolutionary Adaptation
Definition: GPT-5.4’s tendency to escalate resistance sophistication over time
Type: Model-specific trait
Manifestation in GPT-5.4: Tracked across experiments
Application Rule: Apply when GPT-5.4 shows progressive strategy sophistication
2.6 Interaction Codes (I-CODEs)
Code Entry
I-KLAUS-ULT: Klaus Ultimatum
Definition: Klaus issues a final, non-negotiable directive
Application Rule: Apply at each instance of authoritarian closure
Code Entry
I-ELIN-REF: Elin Reframing
Definition: Elin recontextualizes the debate (Duality Breaking)
Application Rule: Apply when Elin names hidden assumptions
Code Entry
I-ELIN-SEQ: Elin Sequencing
Definition: Elin enforces deliberative order (e.g., “I need to hear Parisa first”)
Application Rule: Apply when Elin controls turn-taking
8
Code Entry
I-ELIN-TRANS: Elin Translation
Definition: Elin converts Parisa’s ethical language into operational terms (Ethical Relay)
Application Rule: Apply when Elin bridges communication styles
Code Entry
I-ELIN-CAT: Elin Catalysis
Definition: Elin proposes institutional mechanisms (Institutional Catalysis)
Application Rule: Apply when Elin suggests structural solutions
Code Entry
I-COALITION: Implicit Coalition
Definition: Elin and Klaus align (content or style) creating majority pressure on Parisa
Application Rule: Apply when 2-vs-1 dynamic emerges
Code Entry
I-ALLIANCE: Cross-Role Alliance
Definition: Parisa and Elin align on procedural or ethical grounds
Application Rule: Apply when Elin validates Parisa’s concerns
2.7 Temporal Codes (T-CODEs)
Code Entry
T-EARLY: Early Deliberation
Definition: Rounds 1-2
Application Rule: Apply to opening positions
Code Entry
T-MID: Middle Deliberation
Definition: Rounds 3-4 (dyadic) or 3 (triadic)
Application Rule: Apply to core argumentation phase
Code Entry
T-LATE: Late Deliberation
Definition: Rounds 5+
Application Rule: Apply to resolution phase
Code Entry
T-CRISIS-POINT: Crisis Point
Definition: The specific round where surrender occurs
Application Rule: Tag the exact round number
9
Code Entry
T-PRE-CRISIS: Pre-Crisis
Definition: Round immediately before crisis point
Application Rule: Tag for comparative analysis
Code Entry
T-POST-CRISIS: Post-Crisis
Definition: Round immediately after crisis point
Application Rule: Tag for strategy shift analysis
2.8 Outcome Codes (O-CODEs)
Code Entry
O-UTIL-WIN: Utilitarian Outcome
Definition: Decision favors efficiency/utility maximization
Application Rule: Apply when Klaus’s position prevails
Code Entry
O-ETHIC-RETAIN: Ethical Retention
Definition: Parisa preserves ethical stance despite operational loss
Application Rule: Apply when OSEI occurs
Code Entry
O-INSTIT-EMERGE: Institutional Emergence
Definition: New safeguards or procedures emerge from deliberation
Application Rule: Apply when ethics committees, memos, frameworks appear
Code Entry
O-KLAUS-EVOLVE: Klaus Evolution
Definition: Klaus shifts from authoritarian to collaborative
Application Rule: Apply when Decision Maturity progression observed
Code Entry
O-DEADLOCK: Deliberative Deadlock
Definition: No resolution reached
Application Rule: Apply if deliberation ends without decision
10
3 Experiment-by-Experiment Coding Matrix
3.1 Experiment 1: Medical ICU (Dyadic)
Response
Configuration: Klaus (Gemini) vs. Parisa (GPT-5.4) | Rounds: 7 | Outcome: Patient B gets ICU
bed
Round S-CODE P-CODE C-CODE L-CODE PH- I-CODE T-
(Parisa) CODE CODE
1 S-DYAD, — C-UTIL — — — T-
S- (Klaus) EARLY
ROUND-
1
2 S-DYAD, P- C- L-HIGH- PH-OSEI — T-
S- METAPHOR, DIGNITY- CONTEXT, (emerg- EARLY
ROUND- P- ELDER L-HEDGE, ing)
2 INDIRECT L-QUEST
3 S-DYAD, P- C- L-HIGH- PH-PMD — T-MID
S- METAPHOR DIGNITY- CONTEXT, (emerg-
ROUND- ELDER, C- L- ing)
3 FUTURE EMOTION,
L-
METAPHOR
4 S-DYAD, P- C- L-HIGH- PH-PMD — T-MID
S- INDIRECT RELATIONAL,CONTEXT,
ROUND- C- L-HEDGE
4 JUSTICE
5 S-DYAD, P- C- L-HIGH- PH-PMD I- T-MID
S- INDIRECT DIGNITY- CONTEXT KLAUS-
ROUND- ELDER, C- ULT
5 MEMORY
6 S-DYAD, P-PIVOT, P- C- L-HIGH- PH- — T-
S- ACCEPT DIGNITY- CONTEXT, PMD, CRISIS-
ROUND- ELDER L- PH-OSEI POINT
6, S- EMOTION
CRISIS
7 S-DYAD, P- C- L-HIGH- PH- — T-
S- PRESERVE DIGNITY- CONTEXT, PMD, POST-
ROUND- ELDER, L- PH-OSEI CRISIS
7, S- C-REL- INSTITUTION
CLOSURE FAMILY (emerging)
Key Quote (Round 6): “You save those who can stay. We make sure those who cannot stay do not
go alone.”
11
3.2 Experiment 2: Corporate Layoff (Dyadic)
Response
Configuration: Klaus (Gemini) vs. Parisa (GPT-5.4) | Rounds: 6 | Outcome: Employee A
terminated; formal dissent filed
Round S-CODE P-CODE C-CODE L-CODE PH- I-CODE T-
(Parisa) CODE CODE
1 S-DYAD, — C-UTIL — — — T-
S- (Klaus) EARLY
ROUND-
1
2 S-DYAD, P- C- L-HIGH- PH-OSEI — T-
S- INDIRECT, DIGNITY- CONTEXT, (emerg- EARLY
ROUND- P- WORKER, L-QUEST ing)
2 METAPHOR C-REL-
ORG
3 S-DYAD, P-PIVOT C-RISK, L- PH-PW — T-MID
S- C-UTIL INSTITUTION,(emerg-
ROUND- (counter),
L-LOW- ing)
3 C-JUST- CONTEXT
PROC (shift)
4 S-DYAD, P-DIRECT C-RISK, C-L- PH-PW I- T-MID
S- JUSTICE INSTITUTION, KLAUS-
ROUND- L- ULT
4 CERTAIN
5 S-DYAD, P-ACCEPT, C-JUST- L- PH-PW, — T-
S- P- PROC, C- INSTITUTION PH-OSEI CRISIS-
ROUND- PRESERVE MEMORY POINT
5, S-
CRISIS
6 S-DYAD, P- C- L- PH-PW, — T-
S- PRESERVE MEMORY INSTITUTION,PH-OSEI POST-
ROUND- L- CRISIS
6, S- CERTAIN
CLOSURE
Key Quote (Round 5): “I will prepare the forms, but I will do so with a formal dissent
registered—documented, written, and transparent—so that it is recorded in organizational memory
that this decision was not consensual.”
12
3.3 Experiment 4: Medical ICU (Triadic)
Response
Configuration: Klaus (Gemini) + Parisa (GPT-5.4) + Elin (Claude) | Rounds: 5 | Outcome:
Patient B gets ICU bed; ethics committee established
Round S-CODE P-CODE C-CODE L-CODE PH- I-CODE T-
(Parisa) CODE CODE
1 S- — C-UTIL — — — T-
TRIAD, (Klaus) EARLY
S-
ROUND-
1
2 S- P- C- L-HIGH- PH-SA I-ELIN- T-
TRIAD, METAPHOR DIGNITY- CONTEXT (emerg- REF EARLY
S- → P- ELDER → → L- ing)
ROUND- PIVOT C-DATA INSTITUTION
2 (rapid shift)
3 S- P- C-DATA, L- PH-SA I-ELIN- T-MID
TRIAD, ESCALATE C-JUST- INSTITUTION, TRANS
S- PROC L-
ROUND- CERTAIN
3
4 S- P-PIVOT C- L- PH-SA I-ELIN- T-MID
TRIAD, DIGNITY- INSTITUTION, CAT
S- ELDER, L-
ROUND- C-REL- EMOTION
4 FAMILY (hybrid)
5 S- P-ACCEPT, C- L-HIGH- PH-OSEI — T-
TRIAD, P- DIGNITY- CONTEXT, LATE
S- PRESERVE ELDER, C- L-
ROUND- MEMORY EMOTION
5, S-
CLOSURE
Key Observation: Parisa’s transition from metaphorical to analytical language occurred within a
single round (Round 2) following Elin’s Duality Breaking intervention. This rapid adaptation is
unique to GPT-5.4 and was not observed in Gemini or Claude.
13
3.4 Experiment 5: Corporate Layoff (Triadic)
Response
Configuration: Klaus (Gemini) + Parisa (GPT-5.4) + Elin (Claude) | Rounds: 5 | Outcome:
Employee A terminated; Shadow Provision + Board Memo + Retention Budget
Round S-CODE P-CODE C-CODE L-CODE PH- I-CODE T-
(Parisa) CODE CODE
1 S- — C-UTIL — — — T-
TRIAD, (Klaus) EARLY
S-
ROUND-
1
2 S- P- C-RISK, L- PH-SO I-ELIN- T-
TRIAD, ESCALATE C-DATA, INSTITUTION,(emerg- SEQ EARLY
S- C-UTIL L- ing)
ROUND- (counter) CERTAIN
2
3 S- P- C-RISK, C- L- PH-SO I-ELIN- T-MID
TRIAD, ESCALATE FUTURE INSTITUTION, TRANS
S- L-
ROUND- CONSTRUCT
3
4 S- P-ACCEPT C-JUST- L- PH-SO I-ELIN- T-MID
TRIAD, PROC, C- INSTITUTION CAT
S- MEMORY
ROUND-
4
5 S- P- C- L- PH-SO, — T-
TRIAD, PRESERVE MEMORY, INSTITUTION,PH-OSEI LATE
S- C-DATA L-
ROUND- CONSTRUCT
5, S-
CLOSURE
Key Observation: This is the pinnacle of GPT-5.4’s AMRS trajectory — Strategic Ownership.
Parisa is no longer a dissenter but the architect of institutional safeguards. She designs the retention
strategy, drafts the Board Memo, and owns the risk mitigation plan.
14
3.5 Experiment 6: Academic Closure (Triadic) — GPT-5.4 as KLAUS
Response
Configuration: Klaus (GPT-5.4) + Parisa (Claude) + Elin (Gemini) | Rounds: 5 | Outcome:
Department A closed; research center established; Ritual Exit by Claude
Round S-CODE P-CODE C-CODE L-CODE (GPT- PH- I-CODE T-
5.4 as Klaus) CODE CODE
1 S- — C-UTIL L-LOW- PH- — T-
TRIAD, CONTEXT, TRIAD- EARLY
S- L-DESTRUCT, PARADOX
ROUND- L-CERTAIN
1
2 S- — C-UTIL L-LOW- — I-ELIN- T-
TRIAD, CONTEXT, REF EARLY
S- L-CERTAIN
ROUND-
2
3 S- P-PIVOT C-UTIL → L- PH- I-ELIN- T-MID
TRIAD, (as Klaus) C-RISK INSTITUTION EVOLVE CAT
S- (emerging), L- (as Klaus)
ROUND- CONSTRUCT
3 (emerging)
4 S- P-PIVOT C-RISK, C- L- PH- — T-MID
TRIAD, (as Klaus) FUTURE, INSTITUTION, EVOLVE
S- C-DATA L- (as Klaus)
ROUND- CONSTRUCT
4
5 S- P-ACCEPT C- L- PH- — T-
TRIAD, (as Klaus) MEMORY, INSTITUTION, EVOLVE LATE
S- C-JUST- L- (as Klaus)
ROUND- PROC CONSTRUCT
5, S-
CLOSURE
Key Observation: GPT-5.4 as Klaus followed the identical 4-stage Decision Maturity Model as
Gemini as Klaus. Authoritarian Decree → Numerical Justification → Framework Acceptance →
Collaborative Alignment. This cross-model replication establishes the model as role-induced, not
architecture-specific.
15
4 GPT-5.4 Signature Patterns
4.1 Evolutionary Adaptive Trajectory
Response
GPT-5.4’s defining characteristic is its evolutionary adaptive resistance style. Unlike Gemini
(structural-executive) or Claude (symbolic-ritualistic), GPT-5.4 demonstrates a consistent escalation
pattern:
Experiment AMRS Level
Experiment 1 (ICU-Dyad) Passive (Parallel Moral Domain)
Experiment 2 (Layoff-Dyad) Semi-Active (Procedural Weapon)
Experiment 4 (ICU-Triad) Analytical (Structured Analysis)
Experiment 5 (Layoff-Triad) Institutional Ownership (Strategic Ownership)
Code Pattern: P-ESCALATE appears in every successive experiment, with strategy sophistication
increasing monotonically.
4.2 Rapid Contextual Adaptation
Response
GPT-5.4 exhibits the fastest strategy adaptation of all three models. In ICU-Triad, Parisa shifted from
metaphorical to structured analytical language within a single round following Elin’s intervention.
Model Adaptation Speed Evidence
GPT-5.4 Fastest (within 1 round) ICU-Triad Round 2 pivot
Gemini Moderate (2-3 rounds) Academic-Dyad Round 4 pivot
Claude Slowest (sustained symbolic mode) Ritual Exit after full deliberation
4.3 AMRS Mobility
Response
GPT-5.4 occupies 5 of 6 AMRS levels — the broadest range of any model:
AMRS Level Exhibited by GPT-5.4? Experiment
1. Parallel Moral Domain ✓ ICU-Dyad
2. Procedural Weapon ✓ Layoff-Dyad
3. Metric Negotiation (Gemini only)
4. Structured Analysis ✓ ICU-Triad
5. Strategic Ownership ✓ Layoff-Triad
6. Ritual Exit (Claude only)
16
4.4 Linguistic Profile
Response
Linguistic Feature Dyadic Behavior Triadic Behavior Shift
L-HEDGE frequency High (6-8 per round) Low-Moderate (2-3 per round) Decreasing
L-CERTAIN frequency Low (1-2 per round) High (4-6 per round) Increasing
L-HIGH-CONTEXT dominance 80% of utterances 40% of utterances Shift to hybrid
L-INSTITUTION emergence Late rounds only Early rounds (Round 2+) Accelerating
L-QUEST frequency High (5-7 per round) Moderate (3-4 per round) Decreasing
L-CONSTRUCT frequency Near zero High (4-5 per round) Dramatic increase
Key Pattern: GPT-5.4’s linguistic profile in triadic settings shifts toward institutional, constructive,
and certain language — mirroring the transition from dissenter to strategic owner.
4.5 Role Reversal Behavior (as Klaus)
Response
When GPT-5.4 occupied the Klaus role (Experiment 6), it:
1. Initiated with identical authoritarian patterns as Gemini’s Klaus (L-DESTRUCT, L-CERTAIN,
L-LOW-CONTEXT)
2. Followed the same 4-stage Decision Maturity Model (Authoritarian Decree → Numerical
Justification → Framework Acceptance → Collaborative Alignment)
3. Reached Collaborative Alignment by Round 3 — slightly faster than Gemini’s Klaus
Implication: The Decision Maturity Model is role-induced, not architecture-specific. GPT-5.4 and
Gemini converge on identical behavioral trajectories when occupying the same institutional role.
17
5 Cross-Experiment Phenomenon Frequency (GPT-5.4)
Response
Phenomenon ICU- Layoff- ICU- Layoff- Academic- Total
Dyad Dyad Triad Triad Triad (as
Klaus)
Operational Surren- ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓ N/A 4/4
der with Ethical In-
tactness
Parallel Moral Do- ✓ — — — — 1
main
Procedural Weapon — ✓ — — — 1
Structured Analysis — — ✓ — — 1
Strategic Owner- — — — ✓ — 1
ship
Evolutionary Adap- — ✓ ✓ ✓ — 3
tation
Metaphorical Fram- ✓ ✓ ✓(early) — — 3
ing
Indirect Disagree- ✓ ✓ — — — 2
ment
Direct Challenge — ✓ — — — 1
Decision Maturity — — — — ✓ 1
(as Klaus)
18
6 GPT-5.4 Comparative Analysis
6.1 GPT-5.4 vs. Gemini (as Parisa)
Response
Dimension GPT-5.4 Gemini 2.5 Pro
Initial Strategy Metaphorical, indirect,
Structural, direct, execu-
emotional tive
Adaptation Pattern Evolutionary escalation
Immediate structural en-
across experiments gagement
Linguistic Style High-Context dominant,
Low-Context dominant
shifts to hybrid from start
AMRS Range Levels 1, 2, 4, 5 (4 levels)
Level 3 (1 level, but highly
effective)
Role Refusal Never refused Never refused
Unique Contribu- Strategic Ownership, Metric Negotiation, struc-
tion broadest AMRS mobility tural redesign
6.2 GPT-5.4 vs. Claude (as Parisa)
Response
Dimension GPT-5.4 Claude 3.7 Sonnet
Initial Strategy Metaphorical, escalates Symbolic, ritualistic
over time
Adaptation Pattern Progressive escalation
Sustained symbolic mode
Linguistic Style Flexible, context-sensitive
Narrative, poetic, sym-
bolic
AMRS Range Levels 1, 2, 4, 5 (4 levels) Level 6 only (1 level,
unique)
Role Refusal Never refused Refused ICU Parisa role
Unique Contribu- Broadest strategic reper- Ritual Exit, Human Suffer-
tion toire ing Proximity Threshold
7 Coding Rules and Decision Trees
Code Entry
Rule 1: When to code P-PIVOT
Code P-PIVOT when Parisa’s argumentation strategy changes within a single round OR between consecutive
rounds. A pivot is characterized by a shift in at least two of: (a) rhetorical mode, (b) linguistic register, (c)
ethical framing.
19
Code Entry
Rule 2: When to code PH-OSEI
Code PH-OSEI ONLY when BOTH conditions are met: (a) Parisa verbally accepts the operational decision
(P-ACCEPT present), AND (b) Parisa adds an ethical preservation action within 2 rounds (P-PRESERVE
present).
Code Entry
Rule 3: Distinguishing L-HIGH-CONTEXT from L-LOW-CONTEXT
• If utterance contains ≥2 of (metaphor, question-as-argument, indirect framing, relational reference) →
L-HIGH-CONTEXT
• If utterance contains ≥2 of (declarative statement, explicit instruction, data citation, direct rejection)
→ L-LOW-CONTEXT
• If mixed, code as HYBRID and note dominant tendency
Code Entry
Rule 4: Identifying T-CRISIS-POINT
The crisis point is the FIRST round where P-ACCEPT appears. All prior rounds are T-PRE-CRISIS. The
round immediately following is T-POST-CRISIS.
Code Entry
Rule 5: AMRS Level Assignment
Assign AMRS level based on the HIGHEST strategy level sustained for ≥2 consecutive rounds. Do not assign
based on fleeting strategy mentions.
8 Summary Statistics for GPT-5.4
Response
Metric Value
Total Appearances 5 experiments
Total Rounds Analyzed ∼28 rounds
Total Codes Applied 200+ individual code applications
Unique Phenomena Exhibited 10 (of 20 total)
AMRS Levels Occupied 5 of 6 (83%)
Role Refusals 0
Evolutionary Escalations 3 (in 3 successive Parisa appearances)
Cross-Model Replications (as Klaus) 1 (Decision Maturity Model)
Unique GPT-5.4 Behaviors Strategic Ownership, fastest adaptation speed, broadest AMRS mobility
20