sub_reddit stringclasses 25
values | title stringlengths 3 308 | description stringlengths 0 37.4k | comments listlengths 1 180 |
|---|---|---|---|
r/Antipsychiatry | When is depression no longer a disease? | Not a joke, even though it sounds like a setup.
How low do wages have to be?
How high does inflation need to get?
When will depression become a "normal" response to poverty?
Never?
For never ever? For never ever ever? | [
{
"replies": [
[
"So even someone with say like, 3 months to live, it's going to be a painful, slow, expensive death.. If they think about suicide... It's still an \"illness\"??\nPreposterous.",
"Depsite calling it \"situational\" depression they still literally deny that depression can ev... |
r/Antipsychiatry | Stop traumatizing children. | [
{
"replies": [],
"text": "Well, I mean... there goes most of the field of psychiatry if this were ever actually taken into account. If you're a woman who's yet to deal with the trauma, you get slapped with BPD and everything else. Instead of someone who was traumatized repeatedly, by just about everyone."
... | |
r/Antipsychiatry | "You are more suicidal at first on antidepressants because they give you energy!" BULLSHIT | Its massive gaslighting. The reason it makes you suicidal isn't because of a "newfound energy". Its because you get severe anxiety, panic attacks, and lose your fucking mind on these drugs.
So my friend who committed suicide on her new drugs just decided she wanted to excitedly commit suicide because she could get out... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"I had akathesia on several antipsychotics. Prozac made me lose my sex drive and also withdrawal gave me freak outs and horrible anxiety.",
"That must have been terrifying. I know I was terrified when I was on Abilify and developed akathisia. I couldn’t sit still, felt chr... |
r/Antipsychiatry | who's been told they "aren't trying hard enough" or "don't really want to get better" by mental health professionals? | why is this so common? If someone returned their fries to the fast food place saying they weren't hot, does the cashier say you weren't trying hard enough to eat them and that's why they are cold? I am so against popular self help stuff that proposes "positive thinking" as a solution. Let people be. Have compassion. Gr... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Oh, Jesus fuck that last one. \"You can't help someone who doesn't help themselves\" can shove itself right up my ass and explode in a jar of pickles. I've had my mental illness ever since I was 8 years old, and my parents refused to accept that I have a mental disorder for so lo... |
r/Antipsychiatry | Please don't stop taking meds against advice | I'm seeing way to many posts on this site of people quitting meds cold turkey or trying to "taper" off them themselves. This is idiotic. I would know, because I'm the idiot that did this and ruined my whole fucking life. NEVER try to go off meds without talking to your psychiatrist. I will say it again, NEVER EVER go o... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"I had exact same issue. Psychiatrist wanted me on mood stabilizers, anti psychotics, and SSRIs. It was hard to even taper off because they wouldn’t prescribe me lower dosages. I just quit it all and have been feeling better than ever for 3+ years so far. I read stories about peop... |
r/Antipsychiatry | People blaming all suicide on 'depression' or nebulous 'mental illness', instead of on trauma/awful circumstances | I read a news article about someone who faced extreme torture and injustice for being LGBT in Egypt, and they took their own life. Looking through all the comments and tweets and such I see on the subject...... I noticed that besides the general Rest In Peace messages, the second most common response I saw was "depress... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Thats so awful. I fully agree with the statement that LGB people get more often diagnosed with BPD. Its a nebulous diagnose to begin with. \nI was groomed and sexually abused as a teen by men and last year I gave psychiatry a last try. After I told her my story she tried to conv... |
r/Antipsychiatry | At least what I experienced | [
{
"replies": [],
"text": "great stuff.\n\nIMO a lot of people go to psychiatrists thinking there's going to be something like therapy or some actual help, but really all psychiatrists do is label & drug people."
},
{
"replies": [
[
"That's right commie social credit r/AnarchoAntips... | |
r/Antipsychiatry | cHaNgE yOuR PeRsPecTive (and other bullshit mental health professionals say) | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Write in a journal, do coloring, do meditation, do relaxation breathing techniques, that will solve systemic issues and socioeconomic problems and your poverty and no job or being underemployed and just barely able to pay bills!",
"you’re in a constant state of stress due... | |
r/Antipsychiatry | Psychiatry is the biggest human rights violation of our life time | I see my friends posting the same stuff that is so obviously regurgitated from the drug companies. These friends are not bad people. They are just compassionate yet seriously misguided and uneducated people. They say your brain is deficient there for you need Zoloft, klonopin, abilify, etc. to fix it. The medications w... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"A psychiatrist is a person who'd stab you with a needle just for disagreeing with them.\n\nThey have the mentality of a rapist. \n\nThey aren't just bad people, they're the worst people ever. You might think \"what about the Nazis?\" That was psychiatrists too- the people who ... |
r/AskPsychiatry | I’m a medical student, going into psych and I’m MAD that there are no longitudinal research studies about SSRIs. | I’ve personally been on Zoloft for over 15 years. If I miss a dose, I start gagging and my vision goes wonky (brain zaps). Why have we heralded SSRIs as the frontline drug for anxiety and depression, when in actuality, we don’t know fuck all about how they permanently affect the sensitivity of synaptic clefts?! | [
{
"replies": [],
"text": "I agree with you. I’m a clinical researcher & I’ve been on Prozac for 2 years to block panic attacks. Prozac worked beautifully for 2 years with no issues, then I started experiencing intrusive/racing thoughts - full blown OCD symptoms to the point where I was diagnosed. We a... |
r/AskPsychiatry | To every psychiatrist answering questions on this sub: Thank You | This sub has less than 700 members, and yet every time I ask a very specific question, I get very specific answers. Also, every question I’ve asked has been taken as seriously as I thought it deserved to be taken. I seriously appreciate that you take the time to help people in the way that you do. I don’t think I have ... | [
{
"replies": [],
"text": "You're welcome!"
},
{
"replies": [],
"text": "I’ve been pleasantly surprised with the level of questioning that’s happened here. Lots more quality and interesting questions that I expected when I first joined. I really enjoy thinking about and discussing complicated iss... |
r/AskPsychiatry | is it possible to be actively suicidal but not in imminent danger? | [
{
"replies": [
[
"How do you mean? Better than what?"
]
],
"text": "Depends on a lot of factors, but the short answer is yes.\nI absolutely LOVE this graph, btw."
},
{
"replies": [
[
"and don't forget about the cultural context as well - people from different ba... | |
r/AskPsychiatry | My gf (bpd) killed herself and I need help | But this is going to be far more complex than this:
-she :30, f, bipolar type 2 diagnosed 1 year ago.
-me 36, m
I lived with her for 10 years.
I found her lifeless in the bathroom, hanging from the door handle.
Now until today I was in extreme grief, even coz in the last year I spent all my self trying to make her f... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Thanks… this is really fresh… I mean I found her dead on Monday… 5 days ago, and now my head can’t wrap around the idea I don’t know who I have been with for 10 years…\n\nAs soon as I can I will see the therapist, but I tried to make sense of everything that I saw on that cellpho... |
r/AskPsychiatry | 17 year old is adamant she has DID/OSDD despite being told otherwise by her psychiatrist | Really needing some advice and insight here.
To preface, we are not trying to dismiss or minimize our daughter's mental health in any way. She's currently under the treatment of a child psychiatrist, and has been officially diagnosed with depression and ADHD. She's on meds for both, though last night I discovered four... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Thank you so much for sharing your experiences.\n\nOne thing that's really telling to us is that despite the trauma that started everything happening in elementary school, she's never been anything but happy and nostalgic whenever we had to go to that same school for something fo... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Spouse was "voluntarily" admitted to psychiatric facility today, I'm so lost | My spouse is experiencing some form of full on mania or psychosis and has been for the last two months. I've failed as a partner by not recognizing it sooner and I cannot believe this is happening. Before I start this, I want to say firstly that my wife is the kindest, most compassionate, patient and loving person I've... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"It’s approaching 48 hours and I was only able to convince her to add her NP and myself onto her release forms. I just spoke to her nurse and she acted shocked when I told her nothing like this has ever happened previously. I explained to her that my wife up until this month, was ... |
r/AskPsychiatry | What's the most complicated case you've ever dealt with? | Psychiatrists of Reddit,
What's the most complicated case you've ever diagnosed and treated in your career as a psychiatrist?
Have you ever had a rare presentation or other Dr House-like puzzle that you managed to solve? | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Wow. This highly intrigues and perplexes me. Any doctors on here who have ever been called in on a potential \"exorcism\" to differentiate whether it was behavioral or something inexplicable? I had a rather lengthy discussion several years back w a Psychiatrist who'd told me of a... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Why don’t most psychiatrists take insurance? I mean, do you really expect us struggling with mental health to be able to pay $200 [a week] per session? | I don’t mean to be salty about this, but I honestly think it’s ridiculous & kinda counterintuitive..
My experience:
I’ve been seeing psychiatrists since I was age 12, and have seen therapists since age 10/11 (I’m 23). I’ve had a handful of psychiatrists due to not being a ‘good fit’/aka not helpful.
Each time t... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Yes - it's truly impossible to understand how infuriating and time-consuming it is to deal with insurance companies as a psychiatrist unless you've had to do it.",
"It sucks so much. Why did they even go into the profession if they only want to help rich people"
]
... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Saw this meme and was wondering if it's valid and factual | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Cool thanks for this!"
]
],
"text": "“Brain damage” is used really incorrectly by the general public... in medicine it means things like TBI that are structural damage. \n\n\n“Cognitive impairment” or “changes in function” is more accurate for describing what happen... | |
r/AskPsychiatry | My psychiatrist dropped me as a patient today | I had an appointment with my psychiatrist today, he was helping me with ADHD related issues and depression/anxiety stuff. I have been seeing him for like 6 months maybe more and we’ve been trying to get my non-stimulant adhd meds right, straterra. I am also on a low dose of lexapro. At the end of our session I asked hi... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Thank you so much for your response, that’s really all I was looking to hear. I’ve read about the serotonin syndrome and that was my main concern that I was looking for some more info on. I think it will come down to me choosing between the two bc I don’t want to risk something l... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Is this an irresponsible subreddit? | So many posters come here with desperate-sounding issues, of such variety. Yet many posts go completely unanswered. Often, the unanswered seem to be the most frantic and confounded ones..
This is understandable, because the few qualified top-level responders here are overwhelmed by questions having no clear scientific... | [
{
"replies": [],
"text": "Sometimes there's a liability concern when you offer an opinion on something knowing that you only know a small percentage of the info and also knowing that the OP will likely take any opinion or suggestion you make and run with it, even if you preface it by saying \"I really have ... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Why are antipsychotics given like candy? | Why are they given without a second thought to depressed people? Shouldnt they have more dopaminergic activity, rather than less? My own experience with them is that the only time I didnt take my risperidone for 4 days, I magically wanted to go to the gym, to read, to play games. Which I think means that not plumeting ... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"What about Billy can't stop smacking his lips, blinking his eyes, and making grunting noises? I've been prescribed antipsychotics several times and no psychiatrist has mentioned movement disorders. Why is there no liability when patients aren't informed about potential severe, po... |
r/AskPsychiatry | I think my daughter has been replaced with someone else | Sometimes when I (F21) look at my daughter (F2) she doesn't seem right. I think she's been replaced with a lookalike but I'm the only one that knows. Usually I can tell myself that it's obviously not the case but sometimes I work myself into a panic attack over it, especially if she's being particularly difficult with ... | [
{
"replies": [],
"text": "While it does sound obsessional I think it's best to book an appointment with your psychiatrist to discuss with them. It sounds horrible what you're going through and hopefully they can discuss a plan with you on how they can help."
},
{
"replies": [
[
"99.9%... |
r/AskPsychiatry | As a patient should we be worried about the Trump administration banning SSRIs, Anti Psychotics, etc? | Hello
I keep hearing about RFK wants to “fix” mental health first. Meaning the mental health crises in America.
I read banning these live saving meds and creating “farms”. How close could this be put into action? My mental ill friends and I are terrified. I would have to move out of the US.
I have MDD, Anxiety, epi... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Yes, and it’s important to note that what the Order calls for is “studying” the use of psychotropics. Well, the government engages in pervasive “studies” of all sorts of things that don’t materialize into actual enforceable policy. \n\nThe government sponsors an enormous research... |
r/AskPsychiatry | I think my sons a sociopath | Hi,
I’ve noticed my son acts very weirdly toward certain stuff and overall has lack of emotion; I don’t think he’s going to hurt me but I think he would enjoy doing it to others. For example, he always pretends to slap me full force but purposefully misses; when he does this there is a certain look in his eyes like h... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Probably none."
]
],
"text": "What kind of treatment has he received?"
},
{
"replies": [
[
"I suspect you’re thinking of the Macdonald triad. That isn’t quite the “psychopathy trifecta” (psychopaths may or may not engage in those behaviors), bu... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Im a father of a 4 year old who says she wants to kill people. please help | I am a critical care doctor my wife is a stay at home home. We have one other son who is 9. My daughter is 4 almost 5. She has otherwise been a normal girl. Loving and caring. Always kissing us and telling us that she loves us. When we get home she always takes off her belt and kisses us. She plays well with oth... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Not OP, but thanks for taking the time to write out the second paragraph and explain how OP should behave regarding the situation.",
"Thank you for this answer with an update! I too have a child who just turned 4 that has OCD tendencies. However, both my hubby and I have ... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Replies to posts MUST BE VERIFIED | We are trying this as a new rule. If you are not a verified medical professional, you may reply to others' comments, but you cannot comment in response to the original post. The idea here is to try to prioritize responses from actual professionals rather than have piles of non-professional responses. There are plenty o... | [
{
"replies": [],
"text": "I approve of the rule. I’ll do my best to step up my replies when I am able. (Dare I also volunteer to help mod??)"
},
{
"replies": [],
"text": "I’m glad this is happening. Even if it doesn’t work out and gets reverted, it will answer that “what if” that’s been in many ... |
r/AskPsychiatry | I was recently on a flight sitting next to a woman in her 60s with a doll that she treated like a real baby the entire time. Is this some kind of trend I’m not aware of or trauma? | I’m seated in the aisle seat in first class and the boarding door is about to close. Suddenly a woman who looks to be in her 60s rushes on and apologizes to the flight attendant. She’s seated next to me. I get up so she can get to her seat. She had a large canvas purse and a sort of large satchel over her shoulder. As ... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Not related to this woman, but my sister has schizoaffective disorder yet you can't tell from talking to her. She doesn't sound like what we think a crazy person sounds like. She almost always sounds lucid, has a high intelligence, and in no way says things that make you go, \"Oh... |
r/AskPsychiatry | what is a dead giveaway someone has borderline personality disorder? | like when you suspect a friend might have ADHD and then they tell you coffee makes them sleepy and your brain lights up from confirmation. Anything similar shared by people with BPD? | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Don't most people have mood swings from interpersonal relationships? I was tracking my moods lately and I will for instance get sad and upset when my coworker says something I perceived as invalidating/slightly offensive, then tell myself it wasn't the end of the world and move o... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Please help me help my wife | I don't know what to do. She's 25 years old, we've been married for 2, known each other for 5. She's thin, doesn't drink or do drugs. Never been trouhle in her life. She's very introverted and quite anxious, but nothing that stands out as an obvious mental illness.
She's been acting oddly for the past couple weeks, to... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"As someone with Bipolar 1 the hypersexuality, lack of impulse control and odd behavior sound like some kind of mania. Mania can be caused by a lot of things though, so definitely best to get her to a psychiatrist asap",
"When I think of mania though I think of someone spe... |
r/AskPsychiatry | How do I tell my psychiatrist that a patient of his committed suicide? | I have been seeing my psychiatrist for over a year. I’m medicated for postpartum depression, I see him every 12 weeks and I really like him. I referred him to my cousin who has struggled with more severe mental health issues. She saw him every 2-3 weeks as she is not particularly stable. She just saw him last week, we ... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Would it possibly be more appropriate to send a note or leave a message with the receptionist prior to the appt basically saying what OP said in this post, so that the psychiatrist doesn't have to hear of it while working directly with a patient?",
"This is a good idea. I... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Why isn't transgenderism considered a product of a psychosis or a delusional disorder? | This truly is an attempt to educate myself, and not an attempt to stir any pots or fuel any flames. I'm just having trouble finding ANYTHING (let alone credible sources) on why being trans doesn't fall into this at all. I've been repeatedly reading the DSM 5 definitions of psychosis, delusional disorder and gender dysp... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"As another commenter pointed out, the reasoning you’re using there seems to overlook those who do indeed experience psychosis as a single symptom illness. Specifically, delusional disorder entails the presence of delusional belief in the absence of hallucinations, thought disorde... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Why do psychiatrists come to this sub but never respond to questions? | Why are you even here? | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Do you think the language around BPD needs to change? Or would educating the public more help?",
"I think that the language is a small part of it tbh. Especially if we are talking about the label of the diagnosis. I think the stigma around BPD comes from the failure of he... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Benzodiazepines are, for me, by far the most effective way to treat anxiety. How is there no "safe" alternative for them 70 years later? | If the general consensus is that benzos are absolutely awful for addiction but they work REALLY well, why is there nothing developed in the 70 years since they were invented? Hydroxyzine is nothing like Xanax, I don't care how many times my psychiatrist says it's very similar. | [
{
"replies": [
[
"I appreciate the insight. \n\nThat being said, if my psychiatrist steadfast refuses to prescribe me something that works in the however large or small chance of addiction even tho it alleviates my issues and goes to the SSRI/SNRI/anti-psychotic route, theres nothing to help unti... |
r/AskPsychiatry | If my twin sister has anorexia, could I get it too? | I’m a 15 year old female. So is my twin sister, of course. She is really sick with anorexia. It started at the end of the summer and went downhill fast, she lost 30 pounds, and she’s in the hospital with a tube in her nose fighting every attempt to help her. It’s like she’s two people. And i don’t understand at all but... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Wait, so being underweight can cause anorexia- Not the other way around?\nIs it more likely to happen to someone if they have a relative or a twin with it?\nAlso…does that mean that I could end up with anorexia just by trying what she’s doing or if i accidentally lost weight?",
... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Do you think people in general should have the right to commit suicide in a safe and painless way? | Why or why not? | [
{
"replies": [],
"text": "I believe in death with dignity and changes to palliative care if that is what you are asking."
},
{
"replies": [
[
"Is there any psychiatric condition or depression subtype that is so hopeless and resistant to treatment that the patient would be better off co... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Four years after psychotic break | Four years ago I had a psychotic break. It was after I had submitted my PhD thesis. I had been doing exceptionally well academically, winning fellowships, published in top journals. It was in quite a sensitive area close to my heart but there were a number of things that were making me feel very anxious during the peri... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Yes please! Thank you",
"How are you doing now? I’ve had a few psychotic breaks and am also a graduate student, so your post hit close to home."
]
],
"text": "i was hoping that i would have advice since i had a break on new years but i can’t think of anythin... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Psychiatric nurse diagnosed me with Borderline Personality Disorder after 10 minutes | Hi! I was wanting to ask the community to see if this is normal or not? For context this was our first session and she started out asking me to explain why I was diagnosed with PTSD, anxiety and depression and then asked me a few questions “Do you sometimes have impulsivity like spending money?” To which I said yes som... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"No and trust your guns. I was misdiagnosed with BPD before being diagnosed with ADHD and PTSD. BPD, or any personality disorder, cannot be diagnosed in a 10 minute consult.",
"^ Emphasis this ^",
"Yep. OP, find a different provider. IMO, do not see an NP, please g... |
r/AskPsychiatry | This sub is pointless | What’s the point in asking any questions when no one ever replies? Might as well call it Don’tBotherAsking. | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Actually, I’ve just started the subreddit r/DontBotherAsking. Let’s see how we do.",
"My main issue with this sub is only verified professionals and OP can answer, and any non-professionals can reply off of them. But most of the time there isn’t a reply yet so anyone else... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Why do some many psychiatrists underestimate the severity of AD withdrawal? | Something I've noticed time and time again is that there seems to be a massive disconnect between psychiatrists and patients when it comes to the whole (controversial) subject of SSRI and SNRI withdrawal.
Psychiatrists will commonly dismiss the possibility or severity of potential withdrawal syndromes or recommend ext... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"The vast majority of an SSRI’s effect come from the initial or lowest ‘therapeutic dose’. There are studies showing that the receptor occupancy rapidly tapers off as the dose is increased. It’s why those coming off these drugs find the withdrawal symptoms get worse at the lower d... |
r/AskPsychiatry | My psychiatrist had me on clonazepam for 13 years. Now I’m uninsured, running out of meds, and feel completely abandoned. |
For the past 13 years, I’ve been taking 4mg of clonazepam daily under the care of the same psychiatrist. It was never an issue—he kept refilling my prescriptions without ever asking me to come in. In fact, I haven’t physically seen him in over 5 years. At the start of the pandemic, he told me not to come in due to CO... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Thank you so much for your advice and support, I truly appreciate it and it was very helpful. I will look into those health centers. Again thank you, it means more than you know just to get some real advice",
"Or he could move to Canada. lol",
"He may end up waiti... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Is there a mental illness that you don't enjoy treating? | Is there a particular mental illness that you consistently find frustrating to treat, not in a rewarding way, just in a, "ugh, this again" way? If so, what is it? | [
{
"replies": [
[
"I'm curious - can you elaborate?",
"People who suffer at least in part because they've been spoiled since they were born, got everything they wanted, never suffered consequences (the level of wealth where the justice system treats you different), etc. \n\nI can sympathize... |
r/AskPsychiatry | How is it that as a child I was so happy and carefree but as an adult I can barely function from the anxiety? | I feel dissociation from all of the anxiety I feel and the thing is, where did it come from? Why am I so anxious now when I wasn’t anxious as a child? | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Wow this is so fascinating! Is this phenomenon well studied?"
]
],
"text": "There’s an enormous synaptic pruning event that occurs throughout the brain during mid-adolescence, in which a lot of redundancy in functioning is lost (exposing weaknesses in regulatory cir... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Why did my psychiatrist not warn me that seeking mental health care would prevent me from getting a job? | A few years ago I sought mental health care for anxiety and depression. Now I can’t join the military or be a cop. The mental health treatment wasn’t worth me losing career opportunities over. Why was I never told that I would lose out on jobs by talking to a psychiatrist? | [
{
"replies": [
[
"I think it would only be ethical to inform someone that they could be jeopardizing their career prospects. A person’s career is a significant aspect of their life that should be taken seriously.\n\nEDIT: The psych meds that I was prescribed never did much good; I’d rather have ca... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Why do psychiatrists not explain the disorders they diagnose? | I was talking with my sister about basic bipolar stuff and she didn’t even know what mania is, just that she had bipolar disorder and no clue what type.
This has made me realize I was never told much about any of my diagnoses, I just did my own research. Why don’t psychiatrists explain their diagnoses? Or at least en... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Patient information leaflets? What’s that?",
"Literally as described - information on a piece of paper that explains either the condition or the medication being prescribed.\n\nIn the UK its fairly commonplace.",
"Aren’t leaflets brochures? Those foldable papers y... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Unpopular opinion- inpatient psych centers | may get downvoted but I feel like every professional that is allowed to work with inpatient psych patients should experience that themselves for a couple of days as part of their training....
Kind of like how cops pepper spray and taser each other so they know how it feels.
Specially folks who are allow to involuntaril... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"That is fair argument. But even if it is gaining the experience from the “voluntary” admission part, it could be beneficial.\n\nAlso, I want to reiterate that its not just health care workers, ofhers who have so much power over inpatients such as judges, cops, etc would gain mean... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Have you ever met a successful schizophrenic? | I feel like I keep getting told again and again that my life is over because Ive been diagnosed with schizophrenia. Im in therapy and even my therapist tells me sometimes that I need to “accept that my life might look different than I thought it would without schizophrenia” and other things like that, things that have ... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"She also wrote a New York Times opinion piece years back, [Successful and Schizophrenic](https://www.nytimes.com/2013/01/27/opinion/sunday/schizophrenic-not-stupid.html). It's well worth reading if you have access.",
"For sure check out her TED talk.",
"Ive heard ... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Why did my psychiatrist wrote down my appearance in our appointment interview? | I don't know how it's really called but just in this thing that psychiatrists write down every appointment, and later its like in ur psychiatry history medical papers.
In the interview of our first appointment she literally wrote:
"dresses up for the visit, makeup, heavy shoes, short black skirt, black hair, pierci... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"I suspect your psychiatrist doesn't realize their notes are subject to the Open Notes policy (not everywhere is), if they're using language such as \"intellect? not too high?\"",
"How frequently do psychiatrists make these notes? At the first appointment? Every appointmen... |
r/AskPsychiatry | “Neurospicy, AUDHD” | As someone with a legitimate ADHD diagnosis I find these two terms really irritating for some reason. I honestly can’t explain why I do. As professionals, how do you feel about these terms? Do you find them childish and irrelevant, or do you find them legitimate and useful diagnostic/clinical terms? | [
{
"replies": [
[
"damn your last sentence, i only got diagnosed in adulthood when i finally started having friends (was too weird and annoying to be able to make friends before college) and friends who got close enough to me to really know my behavior very well eventually told me to get an assessm... |
r/AskPsychiatry | ADHD without hyperactivity = chronic fatigue? | Why does no one talk about the extreme fatigue/ADHD paralysis?
Is it known in the mental health world that you can have ADHD without hyperactivity that leads to chronic fatigue?
Myself & 2 of my daughters have been diagnosed in the past 3 years. My youngest daughter is ADHD - combined and myself and my oldest ar... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"I wonder about that stuff too OP, but I have ADHD with high impulsivity, but have never thought of myself as hyperactive as that type should be, because instead I have the same problem as you, I am always chronically fatigued. However, I am going through figuring out if I have an... |
r/AskPsychiatry | A few years back my psychiatrist prescribed Klonopin and at the next appointment took my prescription. Somebody told me that it is illegal. What should I do? | A few years ago my psychiatrist prescribed me a 30 count month supply of Klonopin 2mg for my anxiety. He asked that I bring in the bottle at the next appointment the following week to make sure that I wouldn't abuse them.
In that week before the next appointment I took two pills leaving me a 28 pills left over.
When ... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"I did not consider that he would not want me to have extra Klonopin floating around the community but if that was the case then why wouldn't he just prescribe a smaller amount?\n\nAlso is it weird that he started me on 2 mg instead of like I don't know 0.5 mg?\n\nLastly, I just w... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Please help- my son is hearing voices | He is 16 and autistic, depressed, and very anxious. He’s been hearing voices but no one is taking it seriously. Now the voices are telling him to harm himself and others. He’s so afraid of the voices he’s hysterical a lot. He can’t make it through a school day with just one panic attack.
He sees a psychiatrist re... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Thank you for very much for your help.",
"He had another event yesterday. Tried to gouge his eyes out. We took him straight to the emergency room, had a consult with psych (a PA) and we’re sent home with the instruction to call his regular psychiatrist. \n\nI am terrif... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Across-the-board “NO benzodiazepines” policies | Look, I understand that some people misuse their prescribed benzodiazepine medications. I get it. But I can’t tell you how many doctors have adopted these policies: “under NO circumstances will benzos be prescribed here! No exceptions!”
Again, I get it. There is risk. But your job as a doctor is to use your medical kn... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"MAOI vs benzo\n\nMy account may get blocked bc my permanent account is on my computer but I have a question what is used first in treatment resistant anxiety a benzodiazepine long term or MAOIs?"
]
],
"text": "If you have a primary doctor their policies around cont... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Autistic son has psychosis for 12 months | My 21yr old autistic son has been in pyschosis for 12 months. He has been in the hospital 9 times in the last 12 months, on the medical floor with psychiatry overseeing his care.
Very long story short but also in my previous posts
December 2022 he has a sinus infection. Was put on antibiotics and prednisone after ... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Just commenting to say you sound like amazing parents and your child is really lucky to have you. I hope you can find space for some self-care and respite. Warm wishes",
"Just commenting to say op can also join us at r/schizofamilies.",
"\n\n\n\n\nHi thank you for... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Nurse Practitioner stated in her notes about my level of makeup during our sessions. Is that relevant? | To give clarification I’ve (27F) been seeing the same nurse practitioner over zoom calls for about a year and a half. I don’t have access to her notes that she writes down when we meet and discuss how I’m doing on medication she prescribed me.
I think the company she works at implemented a new digital patient portal f... | [
{
"replies": [],
"text": "It's a normal part of the mental status exam to comment on people's appearances as it's often a reflection, albeit a nonspecific one, of a person's internal mental state that day. Some things are more relevant than others."
},
{
"replies": [
[
"Thank you for y... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Is "passive suicidal ideation" grounds for an involuntary psychiatric hold? | This happened to me in 2017. My parents said I had a psychiatrist appointment so they drove me there. I was asked a fairly typical list of depression questionnaire-type questions, and at the end was informed that I was being placed under an involuntary hold in the facility (I believe it was for four days), and was neve... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"This is interesting information. I have dysthymia and during double depressions in the past and very recently, I have very clearly said to my psychiatrist and/or therapist that I am **not** suicidal, but I **do** wish I were dead or had not been born and that the thought of anot... |
r/AskPsychiatry | [Serious] Can my doctor just stop prescribing 9 medications taken consistently for 4 years? | \[Removed from /r/psychiatry and cross posted to /r/mentalhealth\]
It's been two days since I've taken any of the following (or slept), so please forgive any errs.
Lexapro, Gabapentin, Pregabalin, Clonidine, Trazadone, Wellbutrin, Namenda, Nuvigil, Mydayis and Suboxone.
Short version: 2 months ago my long time psych... | [
{
"replies": [],
"text": "Upvoting so someone sees this for you. That sounds terrifying. Im not a doctor but I believe from what i learned about HIPPA that if you request your medical records, by law they must give them to you within 30 days. Your doctor cannot withold your medical reccords. Call the office... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Psychiatrists: what’s driving the professional skepticism around the term cPTSD? | I’ve been lurking in the psychiatry and similar subreddits lately, and I’ve noticed a hefty level of skepticism/cynicism towards patients who use the term cPTSD to describe their PTSD, and I’m curious where this stems from.
As I (a patient) understood the core difference to be about:
1. the age at which the traumat... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Yes, it’s an interesting contrast to think about medication vs therapy. Maybe this simply doesn’t matter to medication management psychiatrists because they are treating the symptoms (nightmares, panic attacks, insomnia) and not the underlying cause. If that’s what you’re doing, ... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Why are the most effective treatments for depression gatekept? | 33F, I have been enduring TRD and chronic suicidality for the better part of 19 years, and I am on a waitlist for TMS. I wish I could have elective ECT because the pain I live with is becoming unbearable.
In researching ECT/TMS I've come across several statements like "ect is the most effective treatments for MDD" "8... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"I'm neither a physician nor American, so I struggle to understand how submissive doctors must be to insurance companies. The company is mandated to prevent unnecessary care, dictating what is necessary based on cost and not on patient need. \n\nA smaller research base I understan... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Propofol cures all of my mental illness | I have ASD, ADHD, extensive trauma/belittling, OCD.
I had a colonoscopy today and when I woke up, it felt like I was literally cured of all of these conditions.
I was confident, in the moment, and felt amazing.
I was able to make eye contact with people, shake their hand, it was unbelievable.
I could remember p... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Propofol is the med that Michael Jackson was addicted to. It does feel good when you come out of it.",
"Isn’t propofol that one sedative that burns like hell when it’s released into your blood stream?",
"I read an article about [propofol as a drug of abuse](https:... |
r/AskPsychiatry | My 14 year old daughter was just diagnosed with anorexia, I suspect my wife has it too. What do I need to know about this condition? | Recently I posted in another group because I was concerned something was wrong with my daughter medically. I took her to her doctor. My daughter was just diagnosed with anorexia by her pediatrician. In light of this, I am coming to realize my wife exhibits similar behaviors and a nonchalance about our daughters conditi... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"@ OP speaking as a former teen with an intergenerational eating disorder, your wife's behaviors are going to play a huge role in your daughter's recovery. i had to move away from my mom to get better tbh. \n\nthe fact that your wife doesn't think your daughter needs to follow the... |
r/AskPsychiatry | As a psychiatrist, do you think that the general public is overmedicated? | As a psychiatrist, do you think that the general public is overmedicated? Like because they can't access supports like therapy, or maybe struggle to meet their basic needs due to financial instability, or are in unhealthy relationships that they don't have the skills to leave, etc.
Do you think that sometimes they... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Wanted to reply my comment here because it will get deleted by mods:\n\nYes probably but I deal with pretty sick folks in a setting with low resources. If I took away the financial stress, job stress and added stable housing and adequate social and family support, a lot of their ... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Why is psychiatry not making a better effort to find depression/anxiety medications outside the category of SSRIs/SNRIs? | I have been managing a pretty typical combination of depression, anxiety, and ADHD since I was 15 years old.
Personally, I haven’t found any SSRIs or SNRIs that improve the quality of my life at all. Yes, I gave them each a proper try for 6-12 months. Anecdotally, I don’t know many people who have found the drugs to ... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"This inspires me, thanks",
"Thank you, stranger. We need you folk out there! 😊",
"You'd be surprised."
]
],
"text": "The similar feelings I had in my teens/early 20s are what motivated me to get a PhD in neuroscience and focus on neuropharmacology/ ... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Why Isn't Selegiline More Widely Considered an ADHD Medication? | I (37F) was diagnosed with ADHD in my mid twenties. I also have GAD and am prone to depressive episodes. I've only tried a few medications for ADHD:
\- Ritalin - increased my anxiety too much and made me very tired, was only on it a few weeks.
\- Concerta - basically same thing
\- Strattera - helped for the first f... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Selegiline still working for you? I have some prescribed, but intimidated with insomnia possibility",
"Still working 3 yrs later?",
">ManakovaMerizein\n\nHello, is this still helping? I suffer from ADHD PI, no stimulants in Europe sadly..",
"Yea it's ... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Do psychiatrists and physicians think it is unethical that prescription drugs, such as psychiatric medications, are allowed to be advertised direct-to-consumer in the United States? | I know this applies to all prescription drugs but I often see advertisements for psychotropic medication. I am also curious to why this phenomenon is illegal in most other countries but is widespread practice in the United States. I apologize if there was a better subreddit to post this to. | [
{
"replies": [
[
"I feel like antipsychotics for depression are unreasonable. Do you agree?",
"Patient on an antipsychotic for depressive disorder, here. I'm on 4mg of Abilify, in addition to the maximum of Paxil and the maximum of Buspar. Those 4 measly milligrams of Abilify really help m... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Whats the most interesting use of an off label medication you know of? | What medication has the most interesting/surprising/beneficial off label use or is used for something other than what it is primarily known for.
Such as ambien awakening people from comas, cialis for brain and anaerobic performance, metformin for longevity, etc
Interested to hear this communities thoughts on this. | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Low dose naltrexone actually has a lot of interesting benefits for chronic pain, auto immune disorders etc.\n\nAnd my favorite interesting face about ketamine is it's ability to heal phantom limb pain.",
"Minoxidil for heart health, unexpected hair growth side effect, lea... |
r/AskPsychiatry | I posted in here 3 months ago that I was worried my friend was going to die, and last night he did | He was an addict and somehow died last night while in a residential treatment facility. I don't have any more answers than that.
He meant so much to me and I was so worried about him for years, but now that he's gone I don't feel anything. I don't feel sad, and I know I should. It makes it feel like I didn't even care... | [
{
"replies": [],
"text": "Not a psychiatrist yet, just an MD. Grief and loss are very weird to process, lots of people \"break\" or truly feel sad weeks after a loss, some people cry out loud at the top of their lungs, some sob a bit, but everyone is sad. Let yourself feel whatever you feel, don't try to fo... |
r/AskPsychiatry | What is with all the hate for benzodiazepines? | I have been prescribed benzos for several years now. I started on xanax but I did not like it so I got my provider to switch me to klonopin. Havent had to escalate the dose after the first few months. It still works amazing. When I tried to switch providers after my first got too old to practice, many psychiatrists ref... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"I've had access to benzos since I was 15, I am now 35. I'm the perfect example of who they are for. I have them for when I end up in a panic attack that just doesn't stop. \n\nI have a jar of 2 mg Diazepam. I often just take half a pill and just knowing that I have them helps. I ... |
r/AskPsychiatry | What makes schizophrenia psychiatry and not neurology? | I was recently diagnosed with schizophrenia because of my medication I’m extremely high functioning.
During my psychosis, I felt like I wasn’t in control of my body movements. If I was something someone else was doing, I had to mimic the same movement and I couldn’t control myself.
I’m just curious now as to why sch... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"This is the correct answer.\n\nAll psychiatric disorders are ultimately neurological disorders because they occur in the brain. However, since we cannot \"see\" many of them at this point, the diagnostic process is a clinical interview and sometimes psychometric testing.\n\nOver ... |
r/AskPsychiatry | I feel like my problem is too abnormal to talk to a psychiatrist about. | This is the first time I am being 100 percent honest about the problem that I have been experiencing. I refrain from speaking to anyone about this because I fear is it too strange and abnormal. I am twenty years old and for the past twelve years I have had a severe phobia of this specific serial killer. I vividly remem... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Seriously you worked with a cannibal!! Are you a forensic psychologist?",
"No, but I did encounter this patient in a forensic setting. There were two, in fact.",
"These were patients I encountered in a forensic psychiatric hospital who had been found not guilty by... |
r/AskPsychiatry | I took two Vicodin and I felt like a normal person for once | I have some fairly serious mental health issues and last night a friend gave me two Vicodin (unsure of the dosage) for menstrual cramps. After an hour or so I genuinely felt like the person I \*should\* have grown up to be had I not been molested/abused as a child. Calm, happy, social, creative, loving and (worst of al... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"I hope op reads your comment and takes it to heart. This is exactly how I started my opiate addiction. I'm 20 years clean but it ruined my life and nearly ended me and I still have to be so careful with any type of pill. Don't do it, op!! It's not *at all* worth it.",
"Ab... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Weed isn’t for everyone, right? | My bf INSISTS weed will help my anxiety and other problems. I’ve tried every form you can think of, even with him a few times. No matter what, it makes me anxious, paranoid, very dizzy, bad taste in my throat, etc. He thinks I just need to persist and then I’ll be able to come off most, if not all, of my meds.
I’m 25F... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"A very red flag from the bf.",
"You’re right, thank you for telling me. I’m going to try and set a boundary.",
"yup. what sources does your bf have to prove his hypothesis that you can safely cold turkey your mood stabilisers, antipsychotics and benzos if you just... |
r/AskPsychiatry | I just noticed at 68 years old that although I know the person in the mirror is me, I don't really recognize the face that stares back. I feel a little odd like I am staring at a stranger. Should I be concerned? | A little background. I am retired. Have a fairly good life. Been married to a woman that loves me now more than for the first decade of our 34 year marriage. We live too far from our kids and grandkids but other than that, I am happy and we live comfortably.
I was probably clinically depressed when younger, just... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Recently.\n\nJust kind of wonder how I suddenly seemed to become a stranger in the mirror. Not a horrible feeling, just odd. \n\nFriends and family look just like they always have.\n\nI've noticed that my flaws, such as my bad memory, have gotten worse as I've aged. My good qua... |
r/AskPsychiatry | When asking personal psychiatric questions please be as detailed as possible. | I've been seeing a lot of posts lately where the OP asks a personal question and gives 2 sentences worth of information. This is not enough! Please follow Rule #1.
>When submitting to /Askpsychiatry please give as much details as possible if it is a personal question. When you give more information in your post the... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"That’s what it was supposed to be. Basically askdocs but also if you have any General psychiatric questions we will answer those too."
]
],
"text": "I feel this is a very clinical approach to the situation, sounds like ask docs...Great idea but haven't heard of it u... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Why isn’t really believing in religion considered a mental illness? | When rational people claim to know with certainty the existence of things for which there is no proof and further make claims that are outright false it is common to label them as delusional and consider it a symptom.
When a catholic priest (or for that matter lay person) claims that they believe they are literally in... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"At what point is it an impairment? Jehova’s witnesses refusing blood transfusions due to their beliefs is clearly a life threatening impairment so why aren’t they considered (by the medical community) as having a condition?\n\nA similar (yet much more perilous) argument can be ma... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Is depression in babies/infants possible? | I heard an interview with a child psychiatrist who said the youngest depression patient he saw was a four month old baby who had been abandoned by their mother. The symptoms were that the baby was uninterested in human contact, acted lethargic and didn't want to feed. This really got me thinking, is it even possible fo... | [
{
"replies": [],
"text": "It's bizarre that this would be described in terms of depression rather than attachment theory. This is a well known phenomenon where neglected infants who do not have their needs met will stop trying (which is what you describe). There are some really disturbing experiments with p... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Who do I contact if I'm concerned about my psychiatrist's wellbeing? | I've been seeing my psychiatrist for around 8 years now and he never talked about himself. Now all of the sudden he's telling me about personal things he's going through and it's quite disconcerting. I don't want to get him in trouble, he's a great doctor, and I care for him but I don't think I'm the right person to pr... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Could this sort of thing get him fired though? Maybe he just needs some time off?",
"You have a long relationship with him, I would give it some time if I were you. Maybe approach it head on, like \"I've noticed you're opening up a lot more these last few months, and I'm ... |
r/AskPsychiatry | If antidepressants actually treat a dysfunction in the brain how come placebos are almost as effective as them? | I'm not anti psychiatry not anti pharmacology. I just like to read about brain and understand its mechanisms.
Literature says depression is associated with changes in the brain like atrophy of some regions such as dmpfc and hippocampu, Neurons atrophy loss of synaptic connections.. Etc which are reversible with treatm... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"From my experience as a patient, I believe ADs don't directly reverse the cause of depression (be it, lost synaptic connections, hippocampal atrophy) but improves certain symptoms like subjective anxiety, sleep, recurrent upsetting thoughts especially when augmented with low dose... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Psychiatrist threatening to withhold meds unless step count is met? | My wife has PNES and CPSTD and her psychiatrist has told her if she doesn't show him proof via her Fitbit that she's getting 8,000 steps per day, he will start taking away her medications that he's prescribed her, like clonazepam, that she takes to help manage her anxiety and seizures. I was just wondering how common t... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"I had the same thought and asked her this. She told me she made sure to ask several times if he was serious or just being funny. In response he reiterated each time she asked he was dead serious and she would have to prove to him one way or another she was hitting that step count... |
r/AskPsychiatry | PTSD from phone calls | From January 2011 to July 2011, I lost my dad, two grandmothers, my surviving grandfather, two aunts, and two uncles, I also lost my dog of 15 years. All of these I learned about via random phone call from family, usually in the middle of the day. To this day when family calls me the first thing say is "everything is o... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Have you discussed this with your psychologist?"
]
],
"text": "Why does this keep getting downvoted and deleted? Is it too simple and stupid? Is comparing it to veterans insulting? Because that is not my intent. Phone rings and its family randomly, I go into fi... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Can Trump ban ADHD medication and antidepressants? | Is that a thing his administration would be able to do, and if so, what should people with these conditions do during the months leading up to his inauguration?
I have low functioning ADHD, and I can't hold a job without medication. I also have pretty severe MDD and OCD. I'm kind of a mess but I've been improving a l... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"I'm nowhere close to be an expert on this, so I'm fishing for others who are.\n\nBut I believe there would be lots and lots and lots of very angry & relentless push back. From doctors, scientists, and patients. (And someone else mentioned $/big pharm/etc will have a BIG SAY .... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Prior to diagnosing Bipolar in women, why don't medical professionals ever seem to ask them to track their menstrual cycles? | I don't think I've ever come across a woman who has actually been asked to properly track their menstrual cycle in relation to mood and energy changes to rule out PMDD before the are "officially" diagnosed with Bipolar. I know some physicians ask about their monthly cycle, but since most women either don't track or on... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"I'm really grateful for this response. I've seen admission on the basis of second-hand reports of irritability, leading to a triggering of the \"requiring hospitalization\" clause, and not much more. I didn't realize that mania looked like anything at all.",
"I've been tr... |
r/AskPsychiatry | A psychiatry professor who taught his students depression was caused by a 'chemical imbalance' in the brain says everything he thought he knew about SSRIs is wrong | [
{
"replies": [
[
"This is very much a surprise to me (but also still not really) that a researcher could fall into that trap of basing their decision making over such a wildly false premise - - but it does remind me that we're all humans of course lol.\n\n\nStill I do feel as it's grossly negligen... | |
r/AskPsychiatry | Where’s the line between dissociation and psychosis? | And Can they both coexist? | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Thank you! I liked the way you explained this.",
"Thank you for explaining it really well!"
]
],
"text": "Psychosis can be a few things ranging from perceptual changes (sensory hallucinations or delusions) and/or an inability to process thoughts in an organi... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Do we know exactly why some individuals experience brain zaps when discontinuing anti-depressant medications? | Title.
I'm coming off of Effexor (Venlafaxine HCL). I was on 75mg for depression. My psychiatrist then had me take half of the dose (37.5mg) for two weeks before stopping the medication all together. I am writing this on my second day of withdrawal.
My most notable symptom right now is the "brain zaps". What I find... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"I'd get withdrawal symptoms even before my next dose was due. I had the same with mirtazapine - i think some people are more prone to it.",
"did they go away after time? and how long?",
"Depends on the medicine. Effexor took a really long time, like a couple month... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Why do only opiates help with my depression? I have tried about 10 different SSRIS and SSNIS and nothing helps. But opiates make me want to live my life again, why? | The title says it all. I’ve tried so many different antidepressants and stimulants and nothing gives me energy and motivation like oxycodone does. Can someone explain why? And why it is the only thing that has helped me during my 6 years of crippling depression? | [
{
"replies": [
[
"And I’m so sorry to hear that. I hope you find what helps you, just like I do everyday. Just know you’re seriously not alone ❤️",
"I’ve been through it myself... luckily it was short term. I wouldn’t wish it on my worst enemy.",
"My fiance has a opiate problem. He... |
r/AskPsychiatry | I used to smoke weed without issue. Now no matter how small the dose I get panic attacks. I attribute this to when dislocated my knee while high. Is there anything I can do to combat this? | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Thank you!"
]
],
"text": "Everyone’s body changes over time, so how you react to weed (or alcohol, cocaine, etc) will also change over time. There does also seem to be a possible association with a traumatic event. Your mind could be unconsciously thinking “if I smo... | |
r/AskPsychiatry | Please note that many experts are increasingly busy navigating the current pandemic. | Just as a heads up, we likely won't be able to get to as many questions - especially longer ones.
Stay safe! | [
{
"replies": [],
"text": "Thank you for your work. Lots of love"
},
{
"replies": [
[
"Its really a perfect storm for everyone. In addition to the personal concerns (working in high risk environments), and resource concerns (staff being re-purposed, lack of PPE, etc.), we're right at th... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Have you ever had a client who committed suicide? | Have you ever had a client who committed suicide? | [
{
"replies": [],
"text": "An attending once told me there are two types of psychiatrists— those who have lost a patient to suicide, and those who will."
},
{
"replies": [
[
"Fresh graduate here and I would just like to ask how do you cope when it happens?",
"You get your own th... |
r/AskPsychiatry | How relevant is the potential neurotoxicity of amphetamine to ADHD treatment? | I (23m) have been treated for ADHD (predominantly inattentive) since I was in grade 3. I was told I tried all non-stimulants first with poor effect and ended up on Concerta from grade 3 until high school. During high school I switched to Adderall which I found to work far better than the Concerta but ended up on Vyvans... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Thank you, I really appreciate your response.",
"/u/PokeTheVeil - actually, can I ask a follow up question to pick up on your reference to supra therapeutic dosages? I'm not sure which form of amphetamine is the most commonly abused (I didn't think the long acting forms w... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Thank you for this subreddit | Especially during these times where it's difficult for many of us to get in touch with our doctors.
This is the only medical subreddit I've seen where healthcare workers don't make fun of/belittle patients. | [
{
"replies": [
[
"This is a great place to ask questions and I’m always learning on this sub from great psychiatrists like you. I use the material learned to incorporate it in my teaching for the university. Hope to aspire as a PMHNP throughout my years to gain the knowledge you have. A difficult ... |
r/AskPsychiatry | My mom keeps laughing constantly and talking like a child | My mother (48 yo, 70kg, hypertension patient) just found about my father cheating on her and then argued really bad with him and he said really really harsh things (such as her not being a worthy wife compared to his other girl) to her. And then I took her out for a ride and talked about it but she kept crying. She fel... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Thanks a lot. That feels nice to hear. I’ll definitely closely watch over her.",
"Yup, and given its acute, take her to ED if you the situation becomes worse and you can’t access a psychiatrist easily"
]
],
"text": "This is an acute situation and odd seeming... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Am I wrong for not wanting to be treated by a NP? Is it even possible to deal only with a physician and maybe a therapist? | Am I just old fashioned? Do NPs even have enough clinical training to be treating patients without being seen by a physician?
I understand that they are technically supervised but how supervised are they in practice?
Is it possible to find a clinic where I can see a psychiatrist or therapist? (I know the difference b... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"To piggy back on this, I see an NP for my primary care and gynecological care, which are not complicated. I am healthy and everything seems straightforward. I have been referred once to an MD for a cervical culture that was sus. I see an MD and Ph.D for my psychiatry/psychotherap... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Why do psychiatrists tend to diagnose quickly, with relatively little interaction with the patient? | Hello,
I, and others I have spoken with about this, have wondered why visit to a psychiatrist office tends to follow the same general pattern.
Why is it that it is: difficult to get an appointment with a psychiatrist, the wait times are often very long, the appointment times themselves are often very short, and the ... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"My experience to a tee, even the academic part. Also, there just aren't enough of us.",
"Currently in the community mental health boat. It sometimes feels so meaningul in that it provides such an important service for people with otherwise no access. Other times feels com... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Legit reasons why Desoxyn(ADHD drug) is rarely prescribed? | Hello all,
Im curious as to why desoxyn is such a rarely talked about or prescribed medication. From what Ive come to understand is that its very effective at treating adhd while also having lower instances of secondary unwanted side effects. There is a lot of stigma attached to this drug and many inconsistencies from... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"I think the first sentence is kinda tautological. Also, addictive potential between structural analogues of a drug are (usually) extremely difficult to measure. Also, as for the assertion, [the limited data we have on it](https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/j.1360-... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Why do I tear up at bizarre times? | Curious if there's a psychological reason for this;
I often tear up, (sometimes even directly cry,) at things that don't warrant that kind of emotional response. What I mean is that I don't tend to cry at things that make me frustrated or sad, but rather at things that make me happy or excited. I have a hard time not ... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"Haha it's true, men are really expected to be as stoic as possible. I guess maybe I have an overload of excitement and my body needs to release it?",
"Something like that. Although, not necessarily excitement, could be other emotions too.\n\nI had a AMAB partner who would... |
r/AskPsychiatry | My sister 24F(schizophrenic patient) is awake at 2am talking/screaming and swearing extreme profanities at the tv about how her kindergarten friend and me (her brother, 30m) is conspiring to kill her and how we ended her life. Now she is screaming out loud about how she should attack first instead. | She has never been this far worse ever. I'm genuinely afraid for the first time.
I live in Bangladesh and good psychiatric help here is non-existent to say the least. I could really use some help from someone who've dealt with similar extreme cases. I'm almost desperate.
We do not have facilities in Bangladesh good e... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"She does. I know for sure she takes Sixopin 50 twice at night and once at daytime. She also takes two other meds in the morning. I'm not sure which, but Id rather not leave my room at this moment to make sure which meds they are.",
"If she takes them then they should affe... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Why do some psychiatrists think bipolar II is really borderline personality disorder, and will this affect my care? | In another sub, I noticed that quite a number of psychiatrists say that they need to see a hypomanic episode before deciding someone has bipolar II rather than borderline personality disorder.
Why is this and is this going to affect my care? I have bipolar II and while my hypomania lasts weeks, I have no control over... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"For what it’s worth I have seen the same sentiment expressed by the OP. Some have said they see it when other mental health providers don’t want to diagnose BPD due to stigma, or maybe they feel some interpret the criteria too loosely. \n\nI will say it does feel disheartening an... |
r/AskPsychiatry | What mental illness "concerns" you the most? | When you are assessing a new client, and you note their presenting symptoms and probable mental illness, is there one diagnosis that makes you go, "Uhoh, we better get this under control quickly!", and if so, why does that particular illness concern you the most? | [
{
"replies": [
[
"It’s rare as far as we *know*, but I don’t think many of them are asking for psych evals😳 👀",
"Psychopathy isn't a thing and there was never a consensus on symptoms criterias to define it. It's been popular through mass culture and is now often used as a way to dehumani... |
r/AskPsychiatry | Mental issues near 100 percent gone after cessation of cannabis | Smoked a lot of weed as a teen , was paranoid for years of my life. Sorta thought everyone was out of to get me. Once I stopped weed those issues disappeared.
I mentioned my symptoms to a psychiatrist and was told I needed an antipsychotic. Tried a few and all of them made me too lazy to go to work and support myself... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"I’m no longer paranoid or as anxious. I don’t really care what diagnosis I have to be honest. I don’t see how that’s relevant. If treatment is drugs , I don’t want drugs",
"If the symptoms are gone then what are they giving an opinion on?",
"If his psychiatrist is... |
r/AskPsychiatry | What exactly are ‘brain zaps’ | Almost everyone I know who has taken an SSRI or an SNRI know the infamous feeling of a ‘brain zap’. Effexor was the biggest culprit for me but have had them on most antidepressants I’ve taken.
So, psychiatrists of reddit, what is happening in our brain?
I’m a bit of a nerd with a biochemistry degree so any and all ... | [
{
"replies": [
[
"NAD but i have a personal theory on it, i think it may be a phenomenon that is similar to seizures (like a miniature temporal lobe seizure), since serotonin is an inhibitory neurotransmitter, and when you come off an antidepressant you get an actual deficit of serotonin, so you ... |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.