awareashu commited on
Commit
3bbdde5
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 84f0ceb

Append 10 entries to reddit_data.json

Browse files
Files changed (1) hide show
  1. reddit_data.json +612 -0
reddit_data.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,612 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ [
2
+ {
3
+ "sub_reddit": "r/Separation_Anxiety",
4
+ "title": "SUCCESS!",
5
+ "description": "I'm early October, my partner and I adopted a one year old pit from a local shelter. She's very sweet and lovey and damned adorable, however, my partner had to get surgery very shortly after we got her. One of us home for like an entire three week period. When we tried to leave her for the first time, she went insane...screaming, howling, biting her crate, digging. \n\nRight away, after scouring this subreddit, we started with the usual training. We realized the crate, although ok when we're home was a huge source of anxiety when we weren't. That being the case, we decided to trying locking her in a room. It was a bit better, but still digging at the door and screaming. So we decided to give her the whole house, after proofing it for a counter surfer, of course. \n\nShe was so much calmer immediately. We also got some gabapentin from the vet. After a few months of working on it, five days a week, both drugged and not drugged, I can say that....\n\nWe left her alone for FOUR HOURS yesterday, and all she did was knock ove a cactus so she could see out the window. Easy fix! We left her alone again today for one and half hours today, and no issues again. It feels wonderful. \n\nI know ours was an easier case, but I wanted to spread a little hope.\n\nThe last picture is of her relaxing on her window platform while we're gone. SHES RELAXING YOU GUYS!",
6
+ "comments": [
7
+ {
8
+ "text": "Nice work recognizing what your pup needs!! The right meds for your dog can make a huge difference. 👏🏼👏🏼💕",
9
+ "replies": []
10
+ },
11
+ {
12
+ "text": "So happy for you! Thank you for sharing, I appreciate hearing the good news! There’s hope ❤️😊",
13
+ "replies": []
14
+ },
15
+ {
16
+ "text": "Congratulations! It means a lot to hear success stories. She’s sooo cute also.",
17
+ "replies": []
18
+ },
19
+ {
20
+ "text": "so great to hear success stories! And what a beauty!",
21
+ "replies": []
22
+ }
23
+ ]
24
+ },
25
+ {
26
+ "sub_reddit": "r/Separation_Anxiety",
27
+ "title": "Encouragement!",
28
+ "description": "My dog used to HOWL when we left the house for a few seconds. We just made it to 50 minutes (driving away in the car). And he's able to chill on the couch. We found a lovely trainer, stick to doing the plan as often as we can (it's not daily because I have an infant) and inch by inch here we are! \n\nBig Big shoutout to Doggy Fluoxetine which was a big piece of our puzzle. ",
29
+ "comments": [
30
+ {
31
+ "text": "OP, did you use Prozac or another brand?\n\nHow big is your dog and what dose did you use?\n\nHow long did it take for you to be able to leave for 2 hours?\n\nThanks!",
32
+ "replies": [
33
+ {
34
+ "text": "He’s on a generic fluoxetine (prescribed by our vet). He’s about 50 lbs standard poodle. Not sure the dosage (I think a vet would have to prescribe for your doggy). We are not at 2 hours yet. Still working past 50 minutes. But it’s 50 minutes of CHILLING on the couch :)",
35
+ "replies": [
36
+ {
37
+ "text": "Thanks! I was curious about the dose because my vet started my 70ish pound husky on 40 mg of the generic Prozac. \n\nWe upped it to 60 mg recently after I moved and he seemed to regress. I still haven’t tried leaving him alone yet bc I want the 60 mg to build up in his system first.",
38
+ "replies": []
39
+ }
40
+ ]
41
+ },
42
+ {
43
+ "text": "My understanding is the time\nJumps get bigger the longer they get. (We add 10-15% with each jump)",
44
+ "replies": [
45
+ {
46
+ "text": "Good to know! Do you use a camera to monitor him when you leave?",
47
+ "replies": [
48
+ {
49
+ "text": "Yes I do! 📸 It’s a pain in the butt but you got this!",
50
+ "replies": [
51
+ {
52
+ "text": "What camera do you use if I may ask? There are so many options it’s a bit overwhelming.",
53
+ "replies": [
54
+ {
55
+ "text": "I have a Wyze which is nice because you can view it away from home. And we also use our baby monitor (but that only works within close range). I don’t know that the Wyze is like such a great product so I’d recommend doing a little of your own research but it’s been fine for us!",
56
+ "replies": [
57
+ {
58
+ "text": "Thanks!",
59
+ "replies": []
60
+ }
61
+ ]
62
+ }
63
+ ]
64
+ }
65
+ ]
66
+ }
67
+ ]
68
+ }
69
+ ]
70
+ }
71
+ ]
72
+ }
73
+ ]
74
+ },
75
+ {
76
+ "sub_reddit": "r/Separation_Anxiety",
77
+ "title": "Success Story",
78
+ "description": "I don't know who needs to hear this but my dog overcame her separation anxiety.\n\nI used to be a long time frequenter of this sub and went through a really tough time with my pup. Well she is symptom free 2.5 years after adoption and I could not be more thrilled. It gives me hope for life.",
79
+ "comments": [
80
+ {
81
+ "text": "Congrats! That must feel so amazing. Do you mind sharing a little or giving some tips on how your doggy overcame their SA?",
82
+ "replies": [
83
+ {
84
+ "text": "Of course! Pupper is currently on Fluoxetine, which I may try to wean her off in the next 6 months.\n\nHaving a routine. My dog knows generally when I will come and go and relaxes during those times (e.g. M-F 8 - 4 work hours and weekends during the day). From there we trained evening departures to help her get used to that.\n\nLots of exercise, mental stimulation, and confidence building activities. Also working on my own anxiety because our dogs mirror our behavior.",
85
+ "replies": [
86
+ {
87
+ "text": "Hi, Could you share what kinds of confidence building activities you did?",
88
+ "replies": [
89
+ {
90
+ "text": "Scent work, food puzzles, agility training, really anything that gets your dog to use their brain and act on it can build confidence.\n\nI had a very fearful dog and she is much more self assured now",
91
+ "replies": [
92
+ {
93
+ "text": "Cool :). I've been working on all this TY",
94
+ "replies": []
95
+ }
96
+ ]
97
+ }
98
+ ]
99
+ },
100
+ {
101
+ "text": "Sounds like you did all the right things! The anxiety is something that makes a huge difference. I notice that a lot with my dog. I’ve been trying to take more deep breaths… it helps!",
102
+ "replies": []
103
+ }
104
+ ]
105
+ }
106
+ ]
107
+ },
108
+ {
109
+ "text": "I wanna share a little tip here if you don’t mind. For those who still struggle. My puppy didn’t have a bad case of separation anxiety, he would just not sleep, just sit there and stare in the void and howl occasionally. What helped us is piano music. I found one of those YouTube videos with calming piano music for dogs. He just went to sleep and slept for hours. He woke up a couple of times, gave a short howl and went back to sleep. I have a camera. I was amazed.",
110
+ "replies": []
111
+ },
112
+ {
113
+ "text": "Hey that’s awesome, did you find the medication made a big difference? Currently considering whether to put my doggo on something as I can’t leave him at all at the moment without him barking constantly at the front door till I’m back",
114
+ "replies": [
115
+ {
116
+ "text": "The meds brought her set point from 2 to 8 minutes so it was minor but still a 400% improvement. I liked that Fluoxetine takes the edge off her anxiety without sedating her.\n\nIf my dog were like yours, I would start with Karen Overall's relaxation protocol (free PDFs on her website) and also the Door is a Bore (resources on Julie Naismith's Facebook group). Then work your way through Naismith's training regimen.",
117
+ "replies": []
118
+ }
119
+ ]
120
+ },
121
+ {
122
+ "text": "Congratulations, that's awesome to hear and gives the rest of us hope! Out of curiosity, did she have any other reactivity, and did you find it hard to work with both concurrently or otherwise find easing one helped the other?\n\nI'm currently working with our 3 year old rescue with clinical SA, and we're up to 3-4 minutes. Steady as she goes, but I'm genuinely surprised at how smooth the progress has been so far over the last 4 weeks (am fully aware it will not be consistently straightforward). Thankfully her SA only manifests as inappetence and just totally alert shutdown rather than destructive, soiling or vocal behaviours. She also has noise reactivity, and is fearful of greetings with people and dogs for the first few minutes, then settles and even asks to play. She's medicated on 40mg fluoxetine daily.",
123
+ "replies": [
124
+ {
125
+ "text": "Hi! My dog had fear reactivity, being rescued from a life as a puppy mill breeder mama. I trained both concurrently but the reactivity was very easy to train out of her. I'm happy to answer any questions about that as well.\n\nI amend my post 2 months after writing it as I've come to the realization that my dog is not totally symptom free but I suspect she will always possess some degree of anxiety genetic to her poodle breed. I just returned from a 2-week overseas trip and while my dog managed fairly well in that time (didn't cry or destroy anything), I was told she didn't sleep/ got upset when her sitter was out of the house. Not ideal but still a massive improvement from where we started and a huge relief to know I can travel again.\n\nDo you tell people to ignore your dog when they meet her?",
126
+ "replies": [
127
+ {
128
+ "text": "Oh wow, an international holiday! Hopefully your girl desensitises over time to your sitter’s absences too, but as you say, night and day change. \n\nWe’ve only just started asking friends to completely ignore our girl but it’s hard to get people to resist their natural instincts to try to pet her when she makes an approach. \n\nI am absolutely open to any and all advice you’re willing to share!",
129
+ "replies": []
130
+ }
131
+ ]
132
+ }
133
+ ]
134
+ }
135
+ ]
136
+ },
137
+ {
138
+ "sub_reddit": "r/Separation_Anxiety",
139
+ "title": "Below threshold training helped us train our chihuahua/Jack Russel (Boris)",
140
+ "description": "I had a rescue dog (chihuahua/Jack Russel) that suffered from separation anxiety training that took a long time to make him comfortable being left alone. He had 5-6 homes before the age of two! My partner and I spent a lot of money with dog trainers to train him that being alone was not scary. I already had a dog, so I can imagine people who are less experienced struggle. One of the techniniqees they taught us was below threshold training. The idea that you make small changes such as leaving for 5-10 seconds and move up gradually to longer times. We still have our ups and downs but overall its now manageable and he feels a lot more secure.\n\nFor us this was super expensive to pay for a trainer to guide us through the process. To help others for a side project I built a website that turns the training we paid for into an interactive guide. The goal is to help others that were in the same position as me, unable to leave the flat without fear of noise complaints. [https://waggyalone.com](https://waggyalone.com)\n\nI understand this may get taken down, as It could come under self promotion but my intent really is to help others who have a dog suffering from separation anxiety and can't afford to pay for training.\n\nRegardless I look forward to being an active member of this subreddit helping others overcome there dogs separation anxiety!",
141
+ "comments": [
142
+ {
143
+ "text": "This is a great resource! But, your link doesn’t work. I don’t think it’s necessary self promotion if you’re providing it for free. \n\nWould love to hear a little more of your story though. How long did training take? Can you now leave your pup alone? For how long? We don’t have a lot of “success stories” on this sub yet so I love to hear them!",
144
+ "replies": [
145
+ {
146
+ "text": "Should be fixed now... \n\n\nSo for us training took \\~3-4 months to get Boris to feel comfortable with being left alone for half days. This was really nice because we could plan for someone to always working from home for half of the day \\~4-5 hours. \n\n\nThen we had a lockdown which reset a lot of the training as we were not allowed to leave the house much.... But we are getting back to a good place, for us we find routine is really important.",
147
+ "replies": []
148
+ }
149
+ ]
150
+ },
151
+ {
152
+ "text": "Thanks so much for this resource! \n\nMy head is spinning when it comes to best way to get my 4 month old used to being alone. He barks and cries almost instantly when he realises he’s alone in the house in his crate. Totally fine at night. And 9 times of 10 is fine when we leave him alone in room when we are still in the house. \n\nThis system is really clear and is similar to Julie Naismith’s protocol. I read her book but was slightly overwhelmed at how long it takes and how long you can’t leave the puppy alone! \n\nJust wondering, do we just do each milestone until dog is acing it without anxiety? Then move on to the next step? \n\nThanks!",
153
+ "replies": [
154
+ {
155
+ "text": "Exactly, or until at least the dog is tolerating it as its important to start getting out. The app will move you through the milestones when you complete them based on the grading of your previous trails. \n\n\nOne thing I found with my 2nd dog was the time of day we left would get different reactions. We did all our trainings in mornings so we could get back to a normal work life but then found evenings where less successful. So if I were you I would make sure to be doing training at different times etc. \n\n\nGood luck! I would really appreciate you let me know how you get on as I would like to make the course as good as possible!",
156
+ "replies": [
157
+ {
158
+ "text": "Yeah I’ve been doing little bits of training with him but haven’t been consistent enough with it for sure. \n\nBut he’s much better in mornings than he is in afternoon or evening! \n\nI’m not even sure if my puppy’s behaviour is full on anxiety or panic as such? Or maybe it is. He barks incessantly but lies down in the crate doing it, he doesn’t bounce around or try to escape crate or anything like that. It’s like he’s trying to call us back. He fully settles as soon as we are back in room. We have probably made the mistake of coming back into sight as he’s vocalising. We don’t release him from crate until he’s calm though but I think the reward for him is us appearing again rather than being released. So I think we may have been inadvertently rewarding the behaviour we don’t want!\n\nI think starting all over again with this program might be the best way. \n\nThanks for this it’s a good resource !",
159
+ "replies": [
160
+ {
161
+ "text": "As a puppy he is probably just getting used to life with humans. I still think it's worth doing the course as it tailored to puppies or older dogs with separation anxiety. \n\nBasically it will just slowly introduce separation :)",
162
+ "replies": []
163
+ }
164
+ ]
165
+ },
166
+ {
167
+ "text": "Sorry one more question - as my puppy gets left in a crate, I should do the first settle exercises with him in crate right? Door closed or door open? As he obviously won’t be able to get up to follow me if door is closed.",
168
+ "replies": [
169
+ {
170
+ "text": "Exactly, also make this area a fun environment outside of training (chews / kongs / toys). \n\n\nIf you plan to leave puppy in the crate when leaving then its best to start with the door shut. However if you have the space its a nice idea to leave the crate door open and fit some form of pen or child gate. This provides some space for puppy to stretch out and explore.",
171
+ "replies": [
172
+ {
173
+ "text": "Yeah I wish we had room for a pen but unfortunately we don’t 🙁 hoping to graduate him from crate to puppy proof room when he’s around 6/7 months, but don’t trust him with free roam at such a young age yet! Don’t plan on leaving him for longer than 2 hours until he’s at least that age anyway, so won’t ever be left in crate for extended periods!\n\nAnyway, will start with this program and fingers crossed we see some improvement! He’s doing so well with every other aspect of training, I know he can do this!",
174
+ "replies": [
175
+ {
176
+ "text": "He can! Please keep me posted with how you get on either on here or with a DM or two :)",
177
+ "replies": [
178
+ {
179
+ "text": "I will for sure 😀 thank you!",
180
+ "replies": []
181
+ }
182
+ ]
183
+ }
184
+ ]
185
+ }
186
+ ]
187
+ }
188
+ ]
189
+ }
190
+ ]
191
+ }
192
+ ]
193
+ },
194
+ {
195
+ "text": "Not everyone has FB - is there another way to access the content?",
196
+ "replies": [
197
+ {
198
+ "text": "Thanks for your feedback! Facebook offer free login services so it was the easiest approach to take. However you are right that it makes sense to offer a none social network login option. I will look at doing that over the next couple of weeks.",
199
+ "replies": [
200
+ {
201
+ "text": "I would absolutely love a non facebook option! I don't have a facebook account anymore but ugh would love to use this so much.",
202
+ "replies": [
203
+ {
204
+ "text": "Thanks for this feedback! This will be the next thing I work on, I want to offer this but it takes quite a bit of time investment to make it happen or it costs me money to make.\n\nIn the short term you could create a new email (gmail) and create a facebook account for that email and only use it for waggyalone. That way you get access but don't need to personally be on Facebook.",
205
+ "replies": []
206
+ }
207
+ ]
208
+ }
209
+ ]
210
+ }
211
+ ]
212
+ },
213
+ {
214
+ "text": "I'm not saying this *should* be free, because obviously you've put time, knowledge, effort, and web designer money into this--but it sounds like you're providing this for free. If so... THANK YOU.\n\nAnd if it really is free, I'd suggest putting that front and center on the home page. I don't enter my email address anywhere unless I trust the site and know what I can expect to see in my inbox. \n\nThe name is so cute and what I've seen of the website looks great! You could really make a difference with this educational website. Thank you so much--literally my entire life is dictated by my dog's separation anxiety (I can't even take out the garbage without her having a cow about it) so I look forward to learning about what to do!",
215
+ "replies": [
216
+ {
217
+ "text": "I am a software engineer so it has been a passion project of mine. To keep costs low the features currently offered are simple. Hence only one type of login etc.\n\nThank you for the feedback, emails are used for me to reach out to people to either offer advice or find out how there experience was with the app so that I can continue to improve the material.",
218
+ "replies": [
219
+ {
220
+ "text": "I just signed up--the site looks so good and it looks like a wonderful program! Thank you SO much! You're awesome!",
221
+ "replies": []
222
+ }
223
+ ]
224
+ }
225
+ ]
226
+ },
227
+ {
228
+ "text": "Your app is asking for “Edit” access to name and email. Can you please change it to “Read” access instead.\n\nReally love the idea, want to try it myself with my dog who has separation anxiety. So thank you!",
229
+ "replies": [
230
+ {
231
+ "text": "Thanks for your feedback, Sure I will do this later today. Please let me know how you find the tool as I want to make it as good as I can. \n\n\n(UPDATE) I checked it is only read access and the only reason I ask for email is so I can reach out and find out how people are finding the course.",
232
+ "replies": []
233
+ }
234
+ ]
235
+ },
236
+ {
237
+ "text": "Do you have anything for those of us that don’t have Facebook? Xx",
238
+ "replies": [
239
+ {
240
+ "text": "Thanks for this feedback! This will be the next thing I work on, I want to offer this but it takes quite a bit of time investment to make it happen. \nIn the short term you could create a new email (gmail) and create a facebook account for that email and only use it for waggyalone. That way you get access but don't need to personally be on Facebook.",
241
+ "replies": [
242
+ {
243
+ "text": "I have finally got round to implementing a login with email and password :)",
244
+ "replies": []
245
+ }
246
+ ]
247
+ }
248
+ ]
249
+ }
250
+ ]
251
+ },
252
+ {
253
+ "sub_reddit": "r/Separation_Anxiety",
254
+ "title": "Just feeling kind of hopeless with the desensitization method.",
255
+ "description": "We got our dog in a rehoming situation November of 2024, she was 8 months old at the time. Around Christmas 2024 we realized that she had isolation anxiety when she chewed out of a crate (I also heard her WAILING as I pulled into my driveway). We then immediately contacted a CSAT, got a camera, scheduled an appointment with a vet behaviorist, and never left her alone again (except for training). \n\n \nWe worked with a CSAT for several months until I just couldn't afford it anymore, but by that point I had the training method pretty much down and I also have Malena DeMartini's book, so I continued on my own. Gradually increasing her time alone, always watching her on camera, never letting her panic/coming right back when I need to, varying the daily training times, giving her easy wins, etc. \n\n \nI still work with the vet behaviorist and she is on daily Reconcile. We have also trialed 4 different situationals at this point (given for training and the weekly \"retest\"--xanax, clonidine, guanfacine, propranolol), but this week marks one year since we started training (and over a year since she's been left alone), and our dog can only reliably do 20-ish minutes. After an entire YEAR of strict adherance to the gradual desensitization method, training 5x a week. Never leaving her alone--not once--except for training. TWENTY. MINUTES. She has honestly been bouncing around 20-30 minutes for 4 or 5 months now and just cannot get past it.\n\n\n\nI think when we started all of this I believed that if I just sacrificed 12-18 months of my life that I would at least be able to leave her alone long enough to go to dinner or a movie. As long as I just did everything I was supposed to do and never let her panic, I could fix this. \n\n\n\nBut we are nowhere close to being able to leave the house long enough for dinner or a movie. I had to cancel a dream vacation, I've barely seen my family who live out-of-state when I used to visit them semi-regularly, and my partner and I never leave the house together except maybe once every 5-6 weeks for a few hours when we can swing a dogsitter. So maybe 9 or 10 times in the entire past year. I've upended and re-arranged my entire life and spent gobs of money \"doing this the right way\" and I feel as if I have nothing to show for it.\n\n \nIt's the one-year anniversary this week of when we started training with the CSAT. It's just hitting me really hard today. I don't really know how much longer I can live this way. \n\n \nHas anyone else had a dog progress this slowly and did you eventually get to a point where you could leave them for a few hours? Or travel again? Did something happen to change things for you, or did you change something that helped?",
256
+ "comments": [
257
+ {
258
+ "text": "Sep anx specialist here. Yep, unfortunately this is not at all uncommon. I know you're not at your goals, but 20 minutes is actually huge! I've known many dogs who have progressed much slower. One client in particular I had a couple years ago worked with me for over a year and at the 1 year mark he was still under 10 minutes of successful alone time, then started \"snowballing\" and graduated a few months later. Now he just chills and sleeps on their bed for several hours at a time. And this dog was urinating and defecating on himself when they first came to me.\n\nIt sounds like you are on the right track, I would encourage you to keep powering through this. It might be worth reaching out to your CSAT again to just check in and see if yall can find any patterns or isolate anything that might be holding you back since yall last met. It can be hard for some dogs to get over certain amounts of time, but that doesn't mean it's hopeless or that it will never happen. \n\nIt makes sense that you feel like you're nowhere close to being able to leave the house long enough for dinner or a movie, but you actually cannot know that to be true. You *could* very well be close to that, and it's also possible you'll be going through this for a while longer. But what I can tell you is that the majority of dogs are able to successfully overcome this when they are with people who are doing what you're doing - not leaving them alone, seeing a behavior vet, working with a CSAT, etc. It is absolutely realistic to expect that you'll be able to travel again and leave for a few hours at a time. What is not realistic is trying to put some kind of specific timeline on when that \"should\" happen. 12-18 months is a long time, I know, but it can take a really long time to overcome panic and phobias. Ask any human with PTSD lol. Having some kind of deadline in your head is something I strongly recommend against since it can affect your decision making when writing missions, which can inadvertently cause regressions. While it seems counter-intuitive, it's a much better idea to just adopt the mindset that this is \"for the foreseeable future\" and continue working through it, making sure you have ways to live your life in the meantime. That might mean finding new management solutions so you *can* travel and do other things you want to do more regularly.\n\nBc I also hear you that dog sitters are expensive. I don't know to what extent you've already tried networking with your community, but there are actually a lot of ways we can find free/cheap help from people who aren't official pet sitters but maybe are retired and home all the time anyway, or work from home and rarely leave, and so on. Sometimes we have to get creative but if lack of budget for pet sitters is one of your biggest struggles right now I would highly recommend putting some effort into networking to try and find people who are willing to help you out in exchange for stuff like baked goods/favors. This is a blog post I like that has more ideas on how to do this: [Problem-Solving the Puzzle of Alone Time Management](https://malenademartini.com/problem-solving-the-puzzle-of-alone-time-management/)\n\nYou don't have nothing to show for your year of dedicated work, you have 20 minutes to show for it. You probably have even more than just the 20 minutes out the door, tbh. I'm thinking about one of my particularly intense client dogs who was still under 5 minutes after a year or so, but even though his humans couldn't drive away from the house they *could* go outside and do yardwork without him after a year which was huge because that is a situation where he used to panic and it wasn't always safe for him to be out in the yard with them. We didn't focus on that in training, but it's a nice \"side effect\" of the training that I see very often. Not all progress is \"duration out the door\".\n\nI could go on, but most of all the point of this is to say that yes, dogs like your dog are very often able to find success. It's not easy (understatement of the century), but it is so worth it in the end. 💜",
259
+ "replies": []
260
+ },
261
+ {
262
+ "text": "I am so excited for your 20 min! I know you don't feel like it but it is huge!\n\nI am training with a CSAT and two vet behaviorists since May 2023. I stuck to the training to the t, trialed so many meds and combos, and my dog has frequent regressions down to \\~2min. Currently we are again at the 2-5 min mark.\n\nSo I am very excited about your 20 min, keep up the good work!",
263
+ "replies": [
264
+ {
265
+ "text": "Same here! I’m working with my CSAT for four months and we’re still at the ~1 minute mark! Can’t wait to see the 20-minute milestone!",
266
+ "replies": []
267
+ }
268
+ ]
269
+ },
270
+ {
271
+ "text": "Curious why you hadn’t tried trazadone? My dog had a milder case than most as he has isolation anxiety so maybe that’s why it worked so well for us but my heart goes out to you🤍",
272
+ "replies": [
273
+ {
274
+ "text": "We haven't tried it simply because my vet behaviorist hasn't suggested it.. I mean, she's in charge of the meds, not me, lol. It seems her philosophy in general is to try all the things that have the least/mildest side effects. I don't think the vet wants her dopey/sedated every day unless she has to be. I think the next drug she wants to try is another anti-depressant type drug.",
275
+ "replies": []
276
+ }
277
+ ]
278
+ },
279
+ {
280
+ "text": "I have nothing to offer except my sympathy and validation this is such a hard situation! I also commend you for doing it for 1 year and getting to 20 minutes. I did it for 6 weeks and got incredibly discouraged and just needed to stop the training for my own well being. I am focusing more on behavior management by finding people to watch her when needed, etc. I still am at a loss for anything longer than a couple days and that bothers me on a daily basis since I have family who live out of the country.",
281
+ "replies": []
282
+ },
283
+ {
284
+ "text": "Can you clarify if she has any other behavioural difficulties (dog aggression, fear of strangers, reactivity, etc.) that make it not possible for you to use daycare or boarding or an in-home sitter? The part about vacationing--you would have to find a boarding kennel or a home sitter regardless of whether your dog has SA.",
285
+ "replies": [
286
+ {
287
+ "text": "She has no other behavioral issues. There is no boarding kennel where I live that doesn't leave dogs alone at some point, the vast majority have no one there overnight at all and wouldn't be able to tell if she were freaking out once people left. There is also no sitter I have been able to find that will stay with a dog 24/7 for multiple days. \n\nETA: She can go to daycare, but she hates it and it's not really necessary anyway. I work from home and the daycares around here are only available on weekdays. The real problem is evenings/overnights particularly for multiple days.",
288
+ "replies": [
289
+ {
290
+ "text": "Ah, in that case I don't know if sharing this is helpful because what really helped for me was working on my rescue's other issues to get him to be comfortable and confident in daycare and being watched by my neighbours! We've been incrementally working on desensitization for about 1.5 years and he can very reliably go 30-60 minutes alone, enough time for me to hit the gym or get groceries. But a lot of it has to do with my own anxiety and how much I hate doing the desnsitization training---he would probably have a few hours under his belt if it didn't make me so anxious to watch the camera and count the minutes. But my life drastically improved once I was able to train him to LOVE daycare and accept playdates with my neighbours who have dogs. It also drastically improved once I was able to \"bomb proof\" him in public and he could behave well in any place that allows dogs, because then I could just vacation travel with him and go out with friends with him.\n\nDo you have neighbourhood facebook/whatsapp groups where you could see if there are any college students ore retired folks who are home all day who want to make some side money? Or meet local dog owners in your area who would understand your needs?",
291
+ "replies": []
292
+ }
293
+ ]
294
+ }
295
+ ]
296
+ },
297
+ {
298
+ "text": "I’m so sorry you’re dealing with this, we’ve been training for about a year and are feeling the same way about our dog who can do between 30-1hr reliably. Something that helped us break 45 min was trazadone + gabapentin together 2 hours before departure, followed by a long walk an hour before departure. We have also found ours has extreme noise sensitivity so we layer noise - two sound machines and the tv on. All of these things together have started to help him fall asleep for the first time when we leave. We also would start adding in random tiny departures not during training. But desensitizing is so hard. Wishing you the best.",
299
+ "replies": []
300
+ },
301
+ {
302
+ "text": "No advice just solidarity. Very similar situation over here. I'm at the point where I'm considering behavioral euthanasia as it would be unethical to rehome him (would make his extreme anxiety even worse) and his (and my) quality of life is dwindling. It's been 2.5 years, a half dozen med combos, and nothing.",
303
+ "replies": []
304
+ },
305
+ {
306
+ "text": "Yes I'm in the exact same position with my dog. Tried so hard and strictly followed the training for a year and only got to a consistent 20 mins. Also tried loads of meds which haven't helped or cause side effects so we can't use them. I've just started her on a new daily medication so praying this helps but I don't have much hope. It's very upsetting and having a massive impact on my life as I live alone and don't have family close, so either I don't go out or I end up spending a fortune in dog sitting fees. I don't want to give her up cause I love her and she's great in every other way, but I do feel like I'm sacrificing my life for hers at this point.",
307
+ "replies": []
308
+ },
309
+ {
310
+ "text": "First of all, I want to express my sympathy—this is really tough to deal with. I commend you for strictly following an expert's protocol. It may make sense to continue on that course, but you may want to try out different protocols and see if they work better for your individual pup. I stopped using meds last year, not because I'm opposed to using them but my dog has a sensitive stomach. I tried keeping my dog preoccupied with raw meaty knucklebones and frozen kongs, which worked for a while until it didn't, and then I tried desensitizing by leaving frequently without giving any clues that I was leaving, which worked for a while until it didn't. As I kept switching approaches, there was gradual improvement—he would still panic for a few minutes, but then he settled down until I came home. Finally, I started using the intercom feature on my video monitor, talking to the dog as soon as I left for a few minutes, praising him if he was lying down or asking him to lie down if he was standing. I've only used the intercom for a week, but I feel that I've reached a point where the SA is completely under control—no barking or running around. I may not need the intercom eventually, but I actually enjoy chatting with him this way. I'm not saying that this will work for your dog, but I just wanted to give you a perspective that sometimes you don't get from behavioral experts, who feel that their way is the only way for every dog.",
311
+ "replies": []
312
+ }
313
+ ]
314
+ },
315
+ {
316
+ "sub_reddit": "r/Separation_Anxiety",
317
+ "title": "So happy! ",
318
+ "description": "My boy when I first moved to an apartment screamed for 45 minutes straight and broke out of a crate. I suspended absences for 3 months Feb-April and trained with the help of meds. \n\nNow he can be alone 6-7 hours and with multiple alone times a day without major issues. I never thought I would be here. ",
319
+ "comments": [
320
+ {
321
+ "text": "That’s amazing! Do you have any tips that you can share? I would love to work with my girl on this. The past two months have not been great lol.",
322
+ "replies": [
323
+ {
324
+ "text": "I started with the departure desensitization practice, ditching the crate and any barriers. I didn’t get very far and then he got sick and was crazy so I then used trazadone for situational departures and administered 3 hours before. That worked great for dinners and departures like 3-4 hours then did without med departures for 3-4 hours slowly increased med departures to 6-7 and then unmedicated the same!",
325
+ "replies": [
326
+ {
327
+ "text": "That’s so great. We give trazodone and sileo to our dog pre departure but she still can’t be alone :/",
328
+ "replies": [
329
+ {
330
+ "text": "My boy definitely was more on the mild side (is good with other dogs there, didn’t destroy anything but the crate doors)",
331
+ "replies": []
332
+ },
333
+ {
334
+ "text": "Have you paired meds with slow desensitisation? That's we we did, fluoxetine (so kot situational) but 30s, 40s, increasing slowly until we were hitting hours.",
335
+ "replies": []
336
+ }
337
+ ]
338
+ }
339
+ ]
340
+ }
341
+ ]
342
+ },
343
+ {
344
+ "text": "This is amazing!! Thank you for sharing!! It’s helpful to hear about the successes 😊",
345
+ "replies": []
346
+ },
347
+ {
348
+ "text": "Congratulations! That's huge!! 🥳",
349
+ "replies": []
350
+ },
351
+ {
352
+ "text": "Wonderful! Barriers and crates can be such a hindrance when you’re doing departure training \n\nSo glad you managed to work through this 😍",
353
+ "replies": []
354
+ },
355
+ {
356
+ "text": "That's awesome! Do you have any advice/tips or courses that you followed that helped you get where you are right now? Trying to get as much information as possible to start training my Labradoodle with mild SA.",
357
+ "replies": [
358
+ {
359
+ "text": "I followed desensitization methods by Julie Niasmith, ditched the crate and utilized trazadone",
360
+ "replies": [
361
+ {
362
+ "text": "Awesome thank you! Julie's method sounds the most interesting to me. Only thing i'm having some trouble with currently is deciding what his \"treshold\" is. As he doesn't really do anything besides watching outside/barking after a bit.",
363
+ "replies": []
364
+ }
365
+ ]
366
+ }
367
+ ]
368
+ }
369
+ ]
370
+ },
371
+ {
372
+ "sub_reddit": "r/Separation_Anxiety",
373
+ "title": "Six(ish) Month Progress Update",
374
+ "description": "Hi everyone. I realized this week that we've been doing SA training for more than 6 months now and I wanted to share my progress with everyone, because I think seeing this at the beginning of my training would have reassured me a LOT.\n\nContext: we are training using Malena diMartini's method, which involves 30 min training 5 days a week (which we try to stick to pretty religiously, though we have obviously missed some days). Training includes desensitization to pre-departure cues, and then gradually increasing time (ping ponging back and forth) with breaks of about 60-90 sec in between. At first we were doing 5/6/7 departures a session, now we basically do one quick \"warm up\" and then we do our main departure. This training also includes never leaving your dog alone beyond what they can handle - thankfully we have both been WFH so this has been manageable, though difficult sometimes.\n\nWe worked with a trainer (through Malena) for the first month or so, which was pricey but got us off to a really great start that I think we would have struggled with alone. She was also an amazing cheerleader and she is the reason we put our dog on medications. She recommended it strongly to us because although we were making progress, it wasn't consistent. Some nights we could do 15 min and others we'd get to 3 min and have to cut it short. Our dog (a 18lb havanese) is on 20mg of clomicalm daily and it has made a HUGE improvement, as you'll see below. We track everything in a spreadsheet, which I would highly recommend doing!\n\nSome fun stats:\n\nOur first session was January 5th, and pup lasted **8 seconds** before he started to freak. In our early sessions he was keyed up the entire time, and even in our breaks he would be constantly biting at our feet, chasing us, panting, etc.\n\nOur most recent session, number 123(!) was last night (July 28th), and pup lasted **47 minutes**. We know he can go up to 1hr 20min, but honestly with both of us still WFH it's hard for us to find time in the day to fit that in. On the weekends we are working on pushing this time and honestly I think he is capable of doing a lot longer!\n\nWe started clomicalm on April 21st. Before that point his longest session ever was 12min, 30sec and that was hard won. We could only increase by 1 or 2 seconds at a time and even then, like I said, it wasn't consistent. We'd do 10 minutes, then two days of only 3 min before he was barking frantically and we had to return. Looking at my notes, I would say it took about a month for the meds to start working - on May 25th we finally started to see progress. He did 15 min and then we started to be able to add time in 3-5 min chunks, with basically no regressions. I have no doubt that we would still be fighting for 20 minutes without clomicalm in our arsenal. With meds, we went from 15 min to 1hr 15 in two months!\n\nSome other things we noted that made a difference: a tired dog! I can't overstate the value of taking him for a long walk or play at the dog park before we started. We typically try to tire him out just to ensure he will be sleepy for the duration of the training. He doesn't always sleep the whole time but he is much more calm. We also moved our timing as we were previously doing the training during his most active time of day (right when we were done work). Now we do it later in the evening after his long walk, and early afternoon on weekends. This isn't perfect as it doesn't exactly replicate when we will be leaving, but it was important for us making progress. We also play a calming dog music playlist (\"Through a dogs ear\" on spotify) during sessions now to reduce sound sensitivity, which we were seeing as we are in an apartment.\n\nOverall, I just thought it was cool to examine the data. As you can see reading this, SA training is not quick or easy. We have had a lot of heartbreak in this process, a lot of breakdowns and wondering if we would ever have our lives back. We have spent more than 60 hours spread over 7 months going in and out of our apartment and lurking in the hallway like idiots (at first we had to stand right outside the door! now we can actually leave the building). But it is amazing to look back at the data and see how far our guy has come.\n\nHappy to answer any Qs about our training methods if anyone is curious! I promise if you're just starting out: you can do it!",
375
+ "comments": [
376
+ {
377
+ "text": "What a huge milestone! Congrats!!! Have you been watching your dog with a camera while you’re gone? I assume so but just curious. Do you have any camera recommendations if so?",
378
+ "replies": [
379
+ {
380
+ "text": "Thank you! Yes we watch with a camera while we’re gone. In my opinion this is a necessity at least at first!\n\nWe actually use zoom running on my ipad + old phone + computer pointed to cover (most of) the main room, though he generally stays in one spot while we’re gone. Then I join on my actual phone to watch while we’re gone! It’s nice to have multiple camera angles and I can record on it too (though I don’t usually record now as it’s so long). I have a paid acct through work but I believe you can do a free account for up to 40 minutes!",
381
+ "replies": [
382
+ {
383
+ "text": "Oh awesome idea!! Very budget friendly lol. Thank you and congrats again! :)",
384
+ "replies": [
385
+ {
386
+ "text": "No problem! Sometimes he lies down juuuust outside of camera angle and I wish I had a fancy one that could turn but generally it has worked really well for us. Good luck!",
387
+ "replies": []
388
+ }
389
+ ]
390
+ }
391
+ ]
392
+ }
393
+ ]
394
+ },
395
+ {
396
+ "text": "Congratulations!!!!!!!!!!! We are four months in, and hit 30 minutes this week. It's the second time we hit 30 min, but we had a rather big regression about a month and a half ago. We tried to go slower this time around and adjusted his medication. SA training is not for the faint of heart, but I'm hopeful we will continue to make progress!!!",
397
+ "replies": [
398
+ {
399
+ "text": "Also - question - do you find variation in your dog's training based on time of day? We are still at a super low duration when we train in the day. It's hard for us to train during the workday, so his success is mostly in the evenings.",
400
+ "replies": [
401
+ {
402
+ "text": "Thirty minutes is amazing! And I definitely understand going slowly. Regressions are often a precursor to growth though so great sign that you are back up to 30 again!!!\n\nYes, we definitely do find that. We generally also train in the evenings (and later evenings too, so 8/8:30 pm even), but we do try to train on weekends in the morning/early afternoon when we can. I noticed a much bigger difference before meds, with them he seems much more adaptable to time changes. It's also hard for me to tell, is the variable that it's daytime, is it that he's less tired, or is it because weekend afternoons mean more people walking through the apartment halls that he can hear? Stick with it and train during the day when you can, you'll get there!",
403
+ "replies": []
404
+ }
405
+ ]
406
+ }
407
+ ]
408
+ },
409
+ {
410
+ "text": "Congrats! Is your dog completely calm throughout with no whining whatsoever? Do they go to sleep, roam around your home, and not wait by the door?",
411
+ "replies": [
412
+ {
413
+ "text": "Yes, very calm! Occasionally he will whine or bark for a minute or two when we leave. Maybe up to 5 if there is noise in the hallway but not usually that much (and it’s not frantic panic barking, it’s just one or two “hey hello??” Barks every 10 seconds or so). Then he lies down right against the door (or in the front hall) and sleeps till we return. Ideally I’d love for him to feel okay sleeping in his usual spots (his bed or under the chair) but in general he is totally calm.",
414
+ "replies": [
415
+ {
416
+ "text": "That's incredible. I've been pushing the boundaries of training since I have to go back to working in person in less than a month, doing 40 - 50 min separations even though she usually whines on and off between periods of silence. \n\nThere seems to be conflicting opinions on whining. Some trainers say not to worry about it and another says we should drop below the time she started whining at. What's your take on it?",
417
+ "replies": [
418
+ {
419
+ "text": "Hmm honestly it’s a question we had too. For us it came down to figuring out what his frantic/panicked bark sounded like (or signs we were approaching it, like barking with only a second or two in between that then gets shorter) versus just a regular bark. I think you have to kind of watch your dog for what’s triggering the bark, if they have other stress signals (panting, pacing, lip licking, etc) and make the call as best as you can. Are you recording / watching on video during the training? That may help narrow it down!",
420
+ "replies": [
421
+ {
422
+ "text": "Okay, thanks! We've also started transitioning her to daycare. Wishing you continued progress ❤️.",
423
+ "replies": []
424
+ }
425
+ ]
426
+ },
427
+ {
428
+ "text": "I am asking myself the same question. We reached 50 minutes a few weeks ago. She wasn't sleeping during the sessions, but calm, lying on the sofa. Now we made a step back... Again. During the sessions her body language tells me that she is not in panic (lying on the sofa most of the time) but she is howling again every few minutes. Our trainer said its not a good sign and that we should make a few steps back. And it makes sense. If SA training is all about chancing the emotions of the dog when he or she is alone, than whining ia a sign that the dog feels uncomfortable. If we are pushing the dog, when he doesn't feel fine - even if he is not in panic - than maybe it is getting worse again.\nIt's hard I know. We are in this for a year now. Medication since april made a huge difference though. Since than we make progress.",
429
+ "replies": []
430
+ }
431
+ ]
432
+ }
433
+ ]
434
+ }
435
+ ]
436
+ },
437
+ {
438
+ "text": "I’m saving this for later",
439
+ "replies": []
440
+ },
441
+ {
442
+ "text": "We’re doing Julie Naismith’s methods and she recommends training when they’re tired but not enough to pass out as soon as you leave, since the dog being unconscious isn’t helping him learn to be calm during the times that he’s awake. Have you had any experiences dealing with that?",
443
+ "replies": [
444
+ {
445
+ "text": "Oh interesting! I mean it makes sense but with our dog, when his SA was really bad, he wouldnt sleep when we left. Even if we knew he was exhausted he’d force himself to stay awake. So for me seeing that he was sleeping meant that he was relaxed enough and okay enough to rest and I was fine with that. Also, he isn’t a particularly deep sleeper and so he’d wake up, see we weren’t gone, and go back down. My personal feeling is him being asleep IS him being calm, but I’m not a professional and I do understand Naismith’s point! Luckily for us that hasnt seemed to hold us back.",
446
+ "replies": []
447
+ }
448
+ ]
449
+ }
450
+ ]
451
+ },
452
+ {
453
+ "sub_reddit": "r/Separation_Anxiety",
454
+ "title": "Does anyone have a dog with separation anxiety that is also reactive?",
455
+ "description": "Male standard poodle, got him from a rescue at 6 months. After 3 yrs, I can leave him for up to 5 hours. But I also can’t take him anywhere. Or leave him with someone else. He is reactive (but not aggressive) and flips out at people/cars/dogs/animals/everything. He is medicated and most of our training has been centered around getting him in a calm state when left home alone. Have also worked on desensitizing him to his reactive triggers and building up his confidence. He also has epilepsy. \n\nI feel trapped. I work a job I hate because it’s fully remote. I can’t do any of the activities I enjoy because leaving this dog is so stressful. Friends and family don’t want to watch him. I can’t afford a pet sitter. \n\nAnyone else have dogs they can’t leave or can’t take anywhere? What does your training schedule look like?\n\n",
456
+ "comments": [
457
+ {
458
+ "text": "First of all congratulations that you are able to leave your dog alone for 5 hours. This is my dream and must have been so much work! We can barely do 30 min, and that is with two medications.\n\nMy boy (18 month), has separation anxiety and is/can be reactive with other dogs. It is by no means as bad as you described it and I can take him everywhere where it is legal and he is welcome. It is only towards other dogs, and at this point, it is primarily towards dogs that react to him. He was on an SSRI for his SA that unfortunately amplified his reactivity, by making him overall more edgy. This combined with adolescent induced \"megalomania\" was a bad combo. I don't know what your medication (mix) is, but maybe something is contributing to the reactivity?\n\nFor us things got better once he was off the SSRI and when he became a touch more mature, and obedient. For month and month, I practiced \"look at me\" and automatic looks at me's every time we see a dog. I thought he would never get it. But somehow things started to fall into place. He is by no means perfect, but there is a clear improvement. \n\nWe also do agility, I think that has helped a lot. I have an additional set of handling skills I did not have before, he has become more confident, and he has learned to focus more on me. Plus we get to leave the house together to do something fun, which is a bonus for my own metal health. \n\nMy boy does also not love regular sitters very much, as in he will display some SA behavior after a while. For example, when a friend of mine watches him at my house. He never has SA moments when he goes to doggy daycare, its just too much fun and he is also not at our home. Maybe there is a daycare your pup could go it, giving you a bit more freedom?",
459
+ "replies": []
460
+ },
461
+ {
462
+ "text": "My dog is the same but luckily he loves people and we have family that will watch him. We got him to a good spot with his separation anxiety before working on his reactivity and found a trainer for that. The training worked really well for us but unfortunately he had a major regression with his separation anxiety about a year ago . I don't have much advice but you are not alone with your struggles . We've had my dog for six years now and he is definitely way more work than I ever imagined when we got him. At this point we've kind of accepted that he is reactive and don't take him anywhere besides his walks and my partner and I work opposing shifts so he's not alone . If I were you I'd focus more on the separation anxiety training so that you can at least continue to leave the house and go out",
463
+ "replies": []
464
+ },
465
+ {
466
+ "text": "Yes. Born anxious, the reactivity arose after he was ‘nipped’ at under a fence on a walk by a dog I now know is very barky and aggressive at his boundary…(I never expected a dog like this to be in a front garden left unsupervised…he scared the crap out of my pup after he lay waiting behind a solid gate so we couldn’t see him. I don’t think he made physical contact but my pup was so scared and has never been the same since…I console myself thinking that he is so anxious in general that had it not been this, it would have been something else). He was also a window barker, noise reactive and a garden-stalker….standing for as long as I’d let him just watching in the garden…staring….\n\nTraining is hard because he was always over threshold as soon as we left the house. He wouldn’t and still doesn’t take treats outside, even extra high value ones. If we were in sight of another dog, no matter how far, he would go apeshit, increasing in intensity if they got closer until he was unmanageable. I have come home covered in long deep scratches from his claws when I’ve had to pick him up to remove him from a situation. \n\nReconcile has really helped that! We can do a mostly normal walk now and if he sees another dog he will scrabble to get away, but mostly not bark anymore. I think the training I did when he was younger was allowed to come to the front as I didn’t specifically do any new training, it just happened as the reconcile kicked in. His OCD type behaviours are still there….will only walk with two people, only one route and has to cross the streets at exactly the same place every day. But it’s much calmer and lets him get out without freaking out. \n\nThe separation anxiety…I’ve given up tbh. With all of his other anxieties the training just didn’t work and sets off his GI issues. He’s never left alone and hasn’t been for years. I don’t leave unless there is someone from my family to sit with him. I’m a widow so it’s all on me. I shop online where possible. He gets carsick so we can’t even go places. Working on just accepting this tbh. It’s tough. Again though, the reconcile has taken the edge off the peripheral behaviours….he used to shake uncontrollably when I showered because he thought I was leaving, even if I wasn’t. That’s stopped and he’ll now just lie on the sofa while I shower and get ready. His quality of life has greatly improved. Mine…not so much.\n\n(ETA mine is a Maltese poodle mix. It’s like he got the problem traits from each breed. Poodle reactivity and Maltese anxiety. I did my research….so many of these dogs and happy bouncy little balls of fun. Even now on the maltipoo boards I’m in a minority having a pup with this many issues.)",
467
+ "replies": [
468
+ {
469
+ "text": "Ugh sorry that that little “nip” changed the course of yours and your pups life. But I appreciate this response and it gives me hope. Maybe I need to explore different medications. This is all on me as well, and it’s so much.",
470
+ "replies": []
471
+ }
472
+ ]
473
+ },
474
+ {
475
+ "text": "My trainer explained it to me as often the reactivity and the SA are both coming from the same source which is a lack of confidence in themselves. A dog lacking in individual confidence is going to be more likely to have fear reactivity and separation anxiety. I'm really sorry you are going through this, a lot of that confidence can be genetic and can be very difficult to train out, but your dog is lucky to have someone willing to put so much time into them. I found that extending the length of time we were conditioning my dog to her triggers helped her feel more comfortable around them. I would sometimes spend an hour or two sitting near a dog park/walking trail just constantly rewarding, to the point that my dog would get bored and fall asleep. Even if your dog does have a moment of reactivity, reset but don't leave the area until they spend a solid amount of time just existing in the space calmly, it can be a \"wait it out\" sort of deal until your dog is practically bored of it all, then they get a super high value reward for that neutrality. Then the next time, move 5 feet closer and do it again.",
476
+ "replies": []
477
+ },
478
+ {
479
+ "text": "We have both for our Havanese, but we can’t even leave ours for 5 mins without him full on freaking out. We have a sitter that we drop him off for the day-weekend when we need time off from him. \n\nWe worked with a trainer on his reactivity and that had helped a lot! We also do pack walks with him and he’s gotten much better at existing near other dogs while walking in the same direction. It’s to a manageable level on good days. We used to train 2x a week at the farmers market, Home Depot, or Michael’s but have been slacking recently. Your post actually inspired me to get back into it. ",
480
+ "replies": [
481
+ {
482
+ "text": "I have a Havanese too! (I wrote a post in this threat). At this point I have to chuckle when people call them \"great first dogs\". Yes, my boy is great in many ways and so much fun, but he requires a lot of training a first dog owner would not expect based on how the breed is described.",
483
+ "replies": [
484
+ {
485
+ "text": "I think it’s because they’re so varied. I’m connected with my pup’s littermates and other pups with the same dad, and one is a therapy dogs that cuddles with kids/adults while they read to him and. Another lives in a nursery and hangout with kids there. Meanwhile, mine seems to need a therapy dog for his anxiety 😅🫠",
486
+ "replies": []
487
+ }
488
+ ]
489
+ }
490
+ ]
491
+ },
492
+ {
493
+ "text": "Yep, our dog is both reactive and anxious. We can’t leave her alone for 5 minutes. She gets anxious when even one of us leaves! It doesn’t seem to be a matter of training for duration, but rather situations. She’s gotten better with time. I’m not sure if her Clomicalm is helping or what. \n\nHer reactivity means we can’t do daycare or boarding situations. We have to do sitters for just about everything. \n\nWhat we notice most is that she responds to routine. Every Sunday AM, my husband goes on a bike ride. Doggo knows this and is fine now when he leaves for that. But any surprises blow her mind and it feels like we’re back at step 1.",
494
+ "replies": []
495
+ }
496
+ ]
497
+ },
498
+ {
499
+ "sub_reddit": "r/Separation_Anxiety",
500
+ "title": "Update: had to go back to the office a few days per week, our pup is doing way better than expected!",
501
+ "description": "I posted a vent a few weeks ago about how my work was asking us to come back to the office and just feeling dejected about having to leave our anxious rescue at home while still working through her separation anxiety. (She is also reactive to dogs and fearful of strangers, so daycare or walkers/sitters aren’t an option at this point for us) I am sure I am not alone in this, and I just wanted to share that our pup is doing *so much better* than we expected. \n\nWe purchased a two pack of Wyze cameras on Chewy, which I would definitely recommend (one is the “pan” cam, which means we can see almost our entire living room/kitchen/back door, and the other is a regular small camera). We were using a free app on an old iPad before but it is super convenient to be able to have the cameras set up and left out so we can turn them on and off from the app easily. \n\nWe give her trazodone about an hour before we leave the house. Our vet increased her dose of fluoxetine a couple of weeks ago from 10mg to 15mg (she had been on 10mg since early April). She is generally not home alone more than 4-5 hours at a time, as I have adjusted my schedule on the full days I need to go to the office so that I can come home and take her for a walk during lunch. I am going to the office 1-3 days a week, depending on the week, which is less than I was first expected to be in, for which i am thankful. \n\nWhen left alone, she now alternates between sitting in her bed in our bedroom, sitting on our bed, and standing by the back door waiting for us to come home. She actually does settle down some of the time, and she isn’t crying, drooling, or scratching at the door like she has done the past. She does not sleep and clearly is waiting for us to come home, but this is not surprising. The naughtiest thing she’s done: We caught her once on camera actually getting onto the dining table (I was STUNNED, as she never does anything like this when we are home) but as long as the chairs are pushed in she can’t do this. I think she got on the table for a better vantage point to see out of our backyard and look for my partner and I. If you have not considered or tried medication for your pet *please do*. This has ABSOLUTELY made the biggest difference for our pup. \n\nAll of this to say, we love our anxious dogs, but we can’t control everything in our lives, and if your dog is anything like ours and you are having to leave them home for longer periods than before, they may do better than you expect!!!\n\nIf anyone has any suggestions for things to help occupy our dog when home alone, we would love to hear them! She can sometimes be reactive to the TV (she is reactive to dogs in real life, and also reacts to dogs and any four-legged animal or cartoon on television), so any suggestions for things to put on for her or music that your dog likes would be great.\n\nEdited to add: Before finding the right combo of medication and dosage, our dog would drool excessively, cry, scratch at the door, and pace excessively, among other things. She destroyed one of our French doors and we had to give up on her crate because she hurt her mouth trying to escape it. Her change in behavior when left home alone I would contribute almost entirely to the medication.",
502
+ "comments": [
503
+ {
504
+ "text": "Just curious, how much does she weigh? My 15 lb dog is on 10mg of fluoxetine and one Gabapentin a day in AM, and it’s made all the difference. She went from not being able to be alone to up to 30+ mins. I’ve never tried longer than 40 mins or so, but I don’t think she’d do great.",
505
+ "replies": [
506
+ {
507
+ "text": "Our pup weighs a little over 10lbs. Our vet said 15mg would be the absolute max for her when they increased the dose. Gabapentin did absolutely nothing for us unfortunately - trazodone and fluoxetine is the best combo for our dog that we’ve found so far. It took some trial and error with the trazodone dosage and timing as well. \n\nI would set up cameras, if you haven’t already! Maybe go on a walk or hang out somewhere close by and watch how they do around that 40 min mark. \n\nBest of luck with your pup! We are certainly still working through it and doing shorter departures as well. I think our biggest struggle now is also that she becomes overly excited (as in, jumping around like a lunatic, crying) when we come home, even if we ignore her - we are hoping that by continuing to ignore her until she settles down (which is no fun, haha) she will learn to calm down sooner.\n\nWe are also working on stay and place work which she isn’t great at. I think her separation anxiety will improve more as she feels more comfortable being alone in other parts of the house, too - she is just a Velcro dog and has major FOMO when we are home as well.",
508
+ "replies": [
509
+ {
510
+ "text": "may I ask what the highest dose of trazodone your dog was on with the prozac? My pup is a little bigger than yours but our vet is a little apprehensive about medicating",
511
+ "replies": [
512
+ {
513
+ "text": "Hi! Our pup is technically prescribed 50mg of trazodone (as a situational med) and 15mg of fluoxetine (as a daily med). We usually give her just 25mg of trazodone, but would give her 50mg for a very high stress situation (like going to the vet). Hope that helps! \n\nIf they exist in your area, a “fear free” vet may be more open to medication - we changed to a fear free vet a few months ago, and would recommend if (especially if you have a particularly anxious dog, like ours).",
514
+ "replies": [
515
+ {
516
+ "text": "thanks so much! And how often per day at maximum were you allowed to give the 50 mg trazodone?",
517
+ "replies": [
518
+ {
519
+ "text": "I mean per our vet we could give it to her once a day, but 50mg makes her pretty lethargic and lasts for like 5+ hours. Most of the time when we need to leave the house it’s for less time than that, so we just give her 25mg. If we need to leave her alone for a full day, we would send her to daycare or boarding.",
520
+ "replies": []
521
+ }
522
+ ]
523
+ }
524
+ ]
525
+ }
526
+ ]
527
+ }
528
+ ]
529
+ }
530
+ ]
531
+ },
532
+ {
533
+ "text": "That's encouraging to hear. We actually haven't tried any medication yet but intend to for our 7 month old. He would Bark and Bark and Bark at high pitch when we leave and ignore toys/food etc. Can I ask what kind of training you were doing before and after you started giving the medicine? And when you started giving medicine, did you start with leaving for a short period of time?",
534
+ "replies": [
535
+ {
536
+ "text": "Our pup would not eat when left alone either, and still for the most part doesn’t - the whole “leave a kong” thing never worked for us (I don’t think this ever works for dogs with actual separation anxiety, or it just serves as a distraction per Julie Naismith). \n\nWe were primarily training using the “be right back” methodology - although we were never able to fully implement the “not leaving your dog alone longer than their threshold” thing. Like I mentioned in my post, our dog is fearful of strangers and reactive to dogs, so that plus COVID made it challenging to NEVER leave her home longer than her threshold (which without medication was less than one minute), as we are regular people who need to go grocery shopping and to doctors appointments. \n\nWe have worked on the following:\n* departure cue desensitization (which we are still working on, as now that I leave the house more often for work putting on my shoes and picking up my keys are noticeable cues for her) \n* subthreshold short absences (if she gets anxious at one minute, leave for 15 seconds, 45 seconds, 20 seconds, 55 seconds, etc a few times per day until you can increase the time without her panicking) \n* ignoring her when we come home and she is over excited \n* leave very calmly \n\nHere is a [PDF guide](https://lookaside.fbsbx.com/file/Guide%20to%20Separation%20Anxiety-2.pdf?token=AWx8m2ZgJxgg8MOyXBrUQO87Po03OrvPAXfnMsUxoKaF_cvskYnxlKi0QIfDe1pAZODVqjayQHuDDt703_g-D4J3BV4NXI0XnogonUCyK-C1Nk5BupvY8DoDUZBL8OYgIB6otZemSsr0G4gljXj9P6siWaZ3JyH18fI2ults-HfjCv_Bz0CiIt6DERGJ10FjGqq6Q2qadTKYySKBPEYTVLgcoWiDO9NLMoHvrBHrFPmd6KtGQbZWBy5MdIHOvqOYhy4) from Julie Naismith’s Facebook group that outlines subthreshold training at a basic level. \n\nWe made *very little* progress before starting medication, made some progress on just her lower dosage of fluoxetine which she takes for general anxiety, and then had to suddenly increase to hours-long departures because of my return to the office. We give trazodone only situationally - we give it for departures that are beyond her threshold in our separation anxiety training (anything longer than a few minutes). She absolutely would be panicking when left home alone while I’m at work if she wasn’t on both medications. When we practice short departures we do not give her trazodone. I would definitely speak with your vet and see what their thoughts are based on your particular situation!",
537
+ "replies": [
538
+ {
539
+ "text": "OK, thank you very much for the detailed explanations! We also haven't been able to leave home mostly, but we have parents who live close and our pup is not dog/people reactive as long as he's not on leash, so its not the worst. But still, at this pace we can't go out freely and it will make us depressed I think! \n\nWe will definitely speak to the vet. I read some people saying the meds don't work that well / at all for their dogs so I was a bit skeptical. How Long did it take for you to figure out which combination works well?",
540
+ "replies": []
541
+ }
542
+ ]
543
+ }
544
+ ]
545
+ }
546
+ ]
547
+ },
548
+ {
549
+ "sub_reddit": "r/Separation_Anxiety",
550
+ "title": "Well now I'm depressed...",
551
+ "description": "Hi - I just found this subreddit and was so excited to read some success stories and get some hope, but honestly now I feel like I can't breathe I'm so panicked! I got my rescue about 4 months ago and immediately realized something was not normal about how he behaved when I left. So after some research and trying a few random things I read online that completely failed, I started working with a great CSAT person, and I'm definitely seeing some progress. He's not triggered at all now by pre-leaving cues. And I can get out the door without a full-blown panic attack from him. But the rate of progress is truly painful. At our last assessment we barely broke 3 minutes. The trainer said that was actually awesome, but I don't agree.\n\nI'm just going to be honest here and out myself as a jerk. I did not sign up for this. I have owned dogs in the past, I know there is work and sacrifice involved, but I never, in a million years, would have taken this dog if I knew it would be like this. I'm 3 years out of a lousy marriage and have just been experiencing freedom and joy again, and now I have a 10lb shackle. I was so excited to get a dog again! I had my last dog for 15 years, she was my best friend ever. But now I feel like I'm trapped in a nightmare. \n\nAt times I really like the little guy.... he's cute and funny and affectionate. My kids love him, I want to love him, I really really want this work. But as it is, I just feel, I don't know - very pissed. And I'm reading posts on here that after a YEAR people can barely leave for 20 minutes?? I just can't possibly imagine being able to deal with that.\n\nI'm working on putting together a bigger social network I can rely on, because I can not drop $50 for a sitter every time I want to go to the gym, or out to dinner or maybe even - gasp - get my nails done. Or take my kids to a movie or roller skating. The other night I had to take my son to the pediatrician unexpectedly and it was like F\\*\\*\\*\\*\\*\\*\\*. I desperately started texting neighbors and thank god found someone, but who wants to deal with that on top of a sick child who has to go to the dr at 6 pm on a Tuesday? I'm lucky, I seem to be finding people who are genuinely happy to volunteer. BUT STILL - I don't want to spend the next 2 years having to arrange dog care every time I want to take my kids out for pizza! \n\nI haven't tried any medications yet - I'm talking to the vet about that next week, so who knows? It sounds like sometimes that's a silver bullet? Or maybe he'll end up being one of these miracle cases who starts seeing exponential improvement after he hits the 20 minute mark. But I really feel like screaming right now. Anyway - I'm glad this sub exists, and there are other people going through what I'm experiencing. Because I feel like it is truly insane. Best to all of you, thanks for giving me a place to vent!!",
552
+ "comments": [
553
+ {
554
+ "text": "It is honestly very stressful, very tough and there are many ups and downs.\n\nMy little blonde mess of a dog sounds similar to yours. Within a day he was hyper attached to me (couldn't shower without him being in the room).\n\nI worked so hard with the training and got to 20 minutes, never more than that ever without him howling. Regardless of what I did. \n\nThen we got clomicalm, it took 6 weeks to get into his system but we went from 20 minutes up to 3 hours in the space of a month. Felt like a miracle.\n\nIt sounds like you are doing everything right. Get the meds, they will hopefully give both you and the dog the best chance of success.\n\nI just wanted to reply as I know how it feels. It is stressful in a way that is hard for people to understand unless they have had a dog with separation anxiety. It took me 6 months to chill out and trust that he would be okay when I left.\n\nBut it does get better. Long process, sure. But rewarding. Best of luck!",
555
+ "replies": [
556
+ {
557
+ "text": "THANK YOU - this is the best thing I have read in months. I just made an appointment with my vet. I think it's time to try the meds.",
558
+ "replies": [
559
+ {
560
+ "text": "They worked for us. It just gave him the space and clarity to remain calm and learn.\n\nThey aren't a magic bullet, they just allow all the training you are doing to sink in and stick.",
561
+ "replies": []
562
+ }
563
+ ]
564
+ }
565
+ ]
566
+ },
567
+ {
568
+ "text": "Just what to chime in that I am there with you in solidarity. This is my first dog and I didn’t expect the cost or the restriction in my freedom at all. It has left me tears, it has left me thinking about returning him, it has left me thinking just f’ it I will leave him.\n\nI am at five months of training next week and we are getting past 20 minutes. I have a lot of hope that things will accelerate after that.\n\nAnyway, just know that you aren’t alone!",
569
+ "replies": [
570
+ {
571
+ "text": "I hope they do too! I had read that it typically moves faster after the 15/20 minute mark which makes sense to me... \n\nThank you for the solidarity",
572
+ "replies": []
573
+ }
574
+ ]
575
+ },
576
+ {
577
+ "text": "I’m with you. I got my dog after my husband died and I moved back to the UK to raise my 2 kids on my own. I had to leave my old dog behind which broke my heart as he was the perfect dog, but I couldn’t put him through quarantine (my husbands family took him and gave him a wonderful life). I thought a dog would be company for me in my new life and I really missed having a dog. \n\nMy new dog is a nervous wreck. I say new, he’s 6 now. I can’t leave him, I have no life, no friends. I rely on my dad sitting with him if I have to take my teen to an appointment. He will only walk if two of us go, will only walk one route and he’s terrified of the car and dog reactive. He has IBS and allergies and managing that alone is a full time job. At this point I have tried everything and given up. I only go out for groceries when I can’t order online, and appointments. I can’t leave him with my teen for long as they’re autistic and the barking overwhelms them. He’s ok with just them but still a bit stressed so his threshold is lower.\n\nI will say that overall, Prozac has been a gamechanger for us. He is at least a lot more relaxed in general. He was so bad before, that when I showered he would just sit outside the bathroom and shake, and shake while I got dressed and not stop until I sat for 30 minutes and he knew I wasn’t going anywhere. Now he’ll lie on the sofa while I shower! And I can leave the house as long as he is with someone, even if he’s not totally ok it’s manageable. \n\nI love him to bits and I’m a homebody so while it’s a sacrifice, it’s maybe not as bad as it might be for some. I feel bad for my teen as it means we can’t even do something simple like go shopping together or for a coffee. If we take him he just shakes the whole time. It is really hard and in general I don’t think people understand. \n\nMedication is really worth a shot, it can make a huge difference. It’s made my dogs life so much better and the vet said he is a bad case. We also ran into problems with the training due to issues with cat flights which give him panic attacks (long story). \n\nMy dog has recently also started gabapentin for pain and even I am considering giving the Julie Naismith program another go now the cat flights have eased off! We went from nothing to a 2 minute baseline on Prozac, and quickly went from 2 to 4 minutes alone before the cat flights borked everything up. \n\nIt’s hard, but the meds are worth a go, and another shot at the training once the loading phase is done. After that you will have done everything you can and then you can evaluate with all the information you’ll have gained. \n\nBest of luck. It’s not easy but maybe hopefully meds will help x",
578
+ "replies": [
579
+ {
580
+ "text": "Thank you so much for this- And I'm so sorry you've been going through that! it takes a lot of patience and it sounds like you have some. I hope it goes better with the training this time!",
581
+ "replies": []
582
+ }
583
+ ]
584
+ },
585
+ {
586
+ "text": "4 months ago he’s not totally settled in so I would just keep working with it becuase he might calm down significantly over time🩵",
587
+ "replies": []
588
+ },
589
+ {
590
+ "text": "\"I'm just going to be honest here and out myself as a jerk.\" Not a jerk and I feel EXACTLY the same way you do-- the entire paragraph. I also don't have the willpower so many others have had that are spending a year plus training for a few minutes. I commend them so much. Still figuring things out on my end, sigh. Just wanted to share you are not alone!",
591
+ "replies": []
592
+ },
593
+ {
594
+ "text": "What does he do when you leave? \n\nI have 2 dogs, so slightly different. One of them has bad separation anxiety, mostly directed at me. My partner can leave, I can not. The dog therapist suggest a covered bed (tent or something) where she can cuddle up in as it makes her calmer. I haven’t tried this yet, but I do have a camera to keep an eye on her. \nI also always say the same thing when I leave, apparently this helps in building a pattern. The dog will learn you always come back. Since you are part of the pack, it’s normal for them to want to be with you.\n\nIt’s been up and down with my dog. She can be alone for 6 hours, but I have no guarantee that she will not scratch up the sofa or take a tv remote (I put them away now).",
595
+ "replies": []
596
+ },
597
+ {
598
+ "text": "By all means try medication. And if a behavioral strategy doesn’t work, keep it in your back pocket and try it again months later—sometimes the effectiveness depends on where your dog is developmentally. Above all, use a video camera and app (you can buy them for $30 these days) and observe your dog carefully and dispassionately, like a scientist. Once when I was out I saw my dog obsessively jumping on a counter to reach an oven mitt; when he finally got hold of it he flung it to the floor and went to sleep. Ever since I’ve left the mitt within easy reach, and if he is upset at my departure he’ll throw it on the floor and then calm down. No behaviorist would have suggested this, but it has made my life much easier.",
599
+ "replies": [
600
+ {
601
+ "text": "That's so funny about the oven mitt - what a great discovery! He just wanted to let you know how he was feeling, lol...",
602
+ "replies": []
603
+ }
604
+ ]
605
+ },
606
+ {
607
+ "text": "i really relate to ur feeling of “i did not sign up for this” and feeling guilty expressing it. i love my dog SO MUCH and i know he doesn’t choose to have anxiety but i thought i was adopting a dog not agreeing to be held hostage. I just found this subreddit and im willing to try everything (ive already done extensive training, dog CBD, hormone diffusers, pet camera that shoots out treats when/if he stops barking, mile long runs before i leave to tire him out, anxiety medication, and i even got another animal so he wouldn't feel alone) i recently quit my in-person job for a remote one bc nothing seems to be working :,(",
608
+ "replies": []
609
+ }
610
+ ]
611
+ }
612
+ ]