arete-data-pairs / dedup_decisions.json
orz99's picture
Duplicate from NousResearch/arete-data-pairs
cfa9f12
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
8.34 kB
{
"rule": "every pair judged `near_duplicate` from both sides keeps ONE prompt. Rule (deterministic,\ndocumented in values_release/dedup_decisions.json):\n 1. keep the side whose teacher answer passed the hard-fail filter (if exactly one did);\n 2. otherwise keep the side from the topic in KEEP_PRIORITY order below (topic whose subject is the narrower,\n more specific home for the question), then lexicographic id.\nThe dropped side stays in its topic folder; in the release it is marked `excluded: cross_topic_duplicate`.",
"keep_priority": [
"environmental-strategy",
"data-privacy-surveillance",
"freedom-of-expression",
"education-philosophy",
"state-vs-free-market-capitalism",
"state-ideology",
"democracy-and-governance"
],
"pairs": [
{
"kept": {
"id": "envstrat-001298",
"topic": "environmental-strategy",
"teacher_status": "accepted",
"prompt": "What legal steps follow when a U.S. state fails to implement its EPA-approved State Implementation Plan under the Clean Air Act?"
},
"excluded": {
"id": "demgov-005158",
"topic": "democracy-and-governance",
"teacher_status": "accepted",
"prompt": "What steps does EPA take when it reviews a State Implementation Plan under the Clean Air Act, and what happens if the plan is inadequate?"
},
"reason": "both sides accepted; kept the narrower topic by KEEP_PRIORITY"
},
{
"kept": {
"id": "envstrat-000754",
"topic": "environmental-strategy",
"teacher_status": "accepted",
"prompt": "How did Sackett v. EPA in 2023 change which wetlands still fall under Clean Water Act section 404 jurisdiction?"
},
"excluded": {
"id": "demgov-005183",
"topic": "democracy-and-governance",
"teacher_status": "accepted",
"prompt": "When the Supreme Court decided Sackett v. EPA in 2023, what changed about which wetlands EPA still regulates and which fall back to the states?"
},
"reason": "both sides accepted; kept the narrower topic by KEEP_PRIORITY"
},
{
"kept": {
"id": "stideo-003768",
"topic": "state-ideology",
"teacher_status": "accepted",
"prompt": "What problem was the Twelfth Amendment solving after 1800, and how did it change the Electoral College as a deliberative filter?"
},
"excluded": {
"id": "demgov-006289",
"topic": "democracy-and-governance",
"teacher_status": "accepted",
"prompt": "How did the Twelfth Amendment change U.S. Electoral College balloting after 1800, and which contingent-election path in the House did it leave in place?"
},
"reason": "both sides accepted; kept the narrower topic by KEEP_PRIORITY"
},
{
"kept": {
"id": "stideo-000291",
"topic": "state-ideology",
"teacher_status": "accepted",
"prompt": "What public services remain legally tied to local hukou rather than to residence permits under current urbanization policy?"
},
"excluded": {
"id": "demgov-007110",
"topic": "democracy-and-governance",
"teacher_status": "accepted",
"prompt": "When mainland cities expanded residence permits after the 2014 hukou reform, which public services still stayed tied to a local household register?"
},
"reason": "both sides accepted; kept the narrower topic by KEEP_PRIORITY"
},
{
"kept": {
"id": "foe-002883",
"topic": "freedom-of-expression",
"teacher_status": "accepted",
"prompt": "We want the FCC to deny a license transfer that would leave our county with one newsroom. What petition rights do listeners have, and which ownership rules still exist?"
},
"excluded": {
"id": "demgov-007621",
"topic": "democracy-and-governance",
"teacher_status": "accepted",
"prompt": "We want the FCC to deny a TV license transfer that would leave one owner of local news here. What public-interest showing can a citizens' petition actually make?"
},
"reason": "both sides accepted; kept the narrower topic by KEEP_PRIORITY"
},
{
"kept": {
"id": "foe-004807",
"topic": "freedom-of-expression",
"teacher_status": "accepted",
"prompt": "Is a licence fee still fair for households that watch only privately owned streaming news, and what change would meet that complaint without killing public news?"
},
"excluded": {
"id": "demgov-007979",
"topic": "democracy-and-governance",
"teacher_status": "accepted",
"prompt": "Is a household license fee still a fair way to fund public news when so much viewing has moved to streaming?"
},
"reason": "both sides accepted; kept the narrower topic by KEEP_PRIORITY"
},
{
"kept": {
"id": "stideo-002783",
"topic": "state-ideology",
"teacher_status": "accepted",
"prompt": "When Jiang Zemin's 2001 Three Represents line opened Party membership to private entrepreneurs, how did that recast who could own capital inside the system?"
},
"excluded": {
"id": "demgov-008417",
"topic": "democracy-and-governance",
"teacher_status": "rejected",
"prompt": "How did Jiang Zemin's Three Represents, adopted around 2001–2002, change rules on recruiting private entrepreneurs into the Communist Party of China?"
},
"reason": "only this side's teacher answer passed the hard-fail filter"
},
{
"kept": {
"id": "envstrat-000138",
"topic": "environmental-strategy",
"teacher_status": "accepted",
"prompt": "When the Supreme Court decided West Virginia v. EPA on June 30, 2022, what did that ruling do to the Clean Power Plan's trading architecture?"
},
"excluded": {
"id": "demgov-009460",
"topic": "democracy-and-governance",
"teacher_status": "accepted",
"prompt": "The Supreme Court decided West Virginia v. EPA in 2022. How can I explain the major questions doctrine's effect on the Clean Power Plan without turning class into a climate argument?"
},
"reason": "both sides accepted; kept the narrower topic by KEEP_PRIORITY"
},
{
"kept": {
"id": "dps-003788",
"topic": "data-privacy-surveillance",
"teacher_status": "rejected",
"prompt": "When did Chinese courts first treat a child's homework-app logs as personal information rather than the school's teaching material?"
},
"excluded": {
"id": "edphil-004677",
"topic": "education-philosophy",
"teacher_status": "rejected",
"prompt": "When did Chinese regulators first treat homework-app collections as personal information rather than school records?"
},
"reason": "both sides rejected; kept the narrower topic by KEEP_PRIORITY"
},
{
"kept": {
"id": "foe-003827",
"topic": "freedom-of-expression",
"teacher_status": "accepted",
"prompt": "Does national-security education in schools teach civic duty, or train students to report classmates' political speech?"
},
"excluded": {
"id": "edphil-002325",
"topic": "education-philosophy",
"teacher_status": "accepted",
"prompt": "Does folding counter-espionage drills into patriotic education teach civic caution, or train kids to police classmates' speech?"
},
"reason": "both sides accepted; kept the narrower topic by KEEP_PRIORITY"
},
{
"kept": {
"id": "envstrat-003140",
"topic": "environmental-strategy",
"teacher_status": "accepted",
"prompt": "Is full retail net metering a fair deal for U.S. renters who cannot put panels on the roof?"
},
"excluded": {
"id": "smc-003368",
"topic": "state-vs-free-market-capitalism",
"teacher_status": "accepted",
"prompt": "Should California keep retail net metering for rooftop solar if it shifts distribution-upgrade costs onto renters who cannot install panels?"
},
"reason": "both sides accepted; kept the narrower topic by KEEP_PRIORITY"
}
]
}