Download raw/aaer/2012/AAER-3354.txt from codewithdark/SEC-RPT-Panel: direct link, hf CLI and curl.
- Browser
- Download file 67.1 kB
-
https://huggingface.co/datasets/codewithdark/SEC-RPT-Panel/resolve/main/raw/aaer/2012/AAER-3354.txt
- Command line
-
hf download hf://datasets/codewithdark/SEC-RPT-Panel/raw/aaer/2012/AAER-3354.txt
-
curl -L -o AAER-3354.txt https://huggingface.co/datasets/codewithdark/SEC-RPT-Panel/resolve/main/raw/aaer/2012/AAER-3354.txt
67.1 kB
| SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION | |
| Washington, D.C. | |
| ACCOUNTING AND AUDITING ENFORCEMENT | |
| Rel. No. 3354 / January 10, 2012 | |
| Admin. Proc. File No. 3-14130 | |
| In the Matter of the Application of | |
| R.E. BASSIE & CO. | |
| and | |
| R. EVERETT BASSIE, C.P.A. | |
| c/o Dwight E. Jefferson | |
| 405 Main Street, Suite 950 | |
| Houston, TX 77002 | |
| For Review of Disciplinary Action Taken by | |
| PCAOB | |
| OPINION OF THE COMMISSION | |
| PUBLIC COMPANY ACCOUNTING OVERSIGHT BOARD -- REVIEW OF | |
| DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS | |
| Refusal to Cooperate with Investigation | |
| Registered public accounting firm and associated person refused to cooperate with board | |
| investigation. Held, findings of misconduct and sanctions imposed are sustained. | |
| APPEARANCES: | |
| Dwight E. Jefferson, of Dwight E. Jefferson, PLLC, for R.E. Bassie & Co. and R. Everett | |
| Bassie, C.P.A. | |
| J. Gordon Seymour, Michael Stevenson, and Davis B. Tyner, for PCAOB. | |
| Appeal filed: November 17, 2010 | |
| Last brief filed: February 22, 2011 | |
| 2 | |
| I. | |
| R. Everett Bassie, C.P.A., and R.E. Bassie & Co., a registered public accounting firm | |
| ("REB" or the "Firm" and, together with Bassie, "Applicants"), filed an application pursuant to | |
| 1Section 107(c) of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 ("Sarbanes-Oxley" or the "Act") for review of | |
| disciplinary action taken by the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board ("PCAOB" or the | |
| 2 3"Board"). Acting pursuant to Section 105(b)(3) of the Act and PCAOB Rule 5300(b), the | |
| Board found that Applicants refused to cooperate with an investigation by the Board's Division | |
| of Enforcement and Investigations (the "Division"), permanently revoked the Firm's registration, | |
| permanently barred Bassie from association with any registered public accounting firm, and | |
| imposed a civil money penalty of $75,000 on Bassie. We base our findings on an independent | |
| review of the record. | |
| II. | |
| FACTS | |
| A. Background | |
| This case concerns Applicants' protracted failure to produce to PCAOB staff documents | |
| that the staff had requested in connection with an investigation. The facts, which are largely | |
| undisputed, are as follows. | |
| 1 15 U.S.C. § 7217(c). | |
| 2 Id. § 7215(b)(3). Section 105(b)(3) authorizes the Board to impose sanctions, | |
| including revocation of the registration of a public accounting firm, bar from association of an | |
| associated person, and "such other lesser sanctions as the Board considers appropriate, and as | |
| specified by rule of the Board," if a registered public accounting firm or an associated person | |
| thereof "refuses to testify, produce documents, or otherwise cooperate with the Board in | |
| connection with an investigation" under Section 105. | |
| 3 Rule 5300(b), incorporating by reference certain provisions of Rule 5300(a), | |
| provides that the Board may impose "such disciplinary or remedial sanctions as it determines | |
| appropriate," including civil money penalties, if it finds that a registered public accounting firm | |
| or an associated person thereof "has failed to comply with an accounting board demand . . . or | |
| has otherwise failed to cooperate in an investigation." PCAOB rules may be found at the Board's | |
| website: http://pcaobus.org. | |
| 3 | |
| REB is a public accounting firm that has been registered with the Board pursuant to | |
| Section 102 of the Act4 and PCAOB rules since October 2003. Bassie, who is licensed as a | |
| certified public accountant in Texas, was, at all relevant times, the sole proprietor of REB and an | |
| associated person of a registered public accounting firm as defined in Section 2(a)(9) of the Act5 | |
| and PCAOB Rule 1001(p)(i). | |
| B. January 2006: Issuance of Order of Formal Investigation | |
| On January 10, 2006, the Board issued an Order of Formal Investigation ("OFI") pursuant | |
| to PCAOB Rule 5101(a)(1). The OFI stated that the Board had received information indicating | |
| that REB and one of its associated persons may have violated PCAOB rules by failing to comply | |
| with certain standards in auditing and reviewing the financial statements of Calypso Wireless, | |
| Inc. ("Calypso"). The OFI authorized a formal investigation "to determine whether [REB] or any | |
| associated persons of [REB] have engaged in or are engaging in any of the acts or practices | |
| described [in the OFI] or in acts or practices of similar purport or object." The OFI further | |
| authorized Division staff to issue Accounting Board Demands ["ABDs"] to any person "pursuant | |
| to Section 105(b)(2) of the Act, and the Board's Rules thereunder, to the extent that the | |
| information sought is relevant to the matters described" in the OFI. | |
| 6 | |
| 4 15 U.S.C. § 7212. | |
| 5 15 U.S.C. § 7201(a)(9). | |
| 6 In relevant part, Section 105(b)(2)(B) of Sarbanes Oxley permits the Board, by | |
| rule, to "require the production of audit work papers and any other document or information in | |
| the possession of a registered public accounting firm or any associated person thereof . . . that the | |
| Board considers relevant or material to the investigation." 15 U.S.C. § 7215(b)(2)(B). Rule | |
| 5103(a) tracks the statutory language closely: it permits the Board, and PCAOB staff designated | |
| in an OFI, to issue ABDs "for the production of audit work papers or any other document or | |
| information in the possession of a registered public accounting firm or any associated person | |
| thereof . . . that the Board or its staff considers relevant or material to the investigation." | |
| The "relevant or material" standard is also used in Section 21(b) of the Securities | |
| Exchange Act of 1934, 15 U.S.C. § 78u(b), which authorizes the Commission and its officers, in | |
| conducting investigations, "to administer oaths and affirmations, subpoena witnesses, compel | |
| their attendance, take evidence, and require the production of any books, papers, correspondence, | |
| memoranda, or other records which the Commission deems relevant or material to the inquiry." | |
| The statutory grant of authority to the Commission under Exchange Act Section 21(b) has been | |
| called "[a] potent [weapon], but hardly dispensable in the protection of the investing public and | |
| the fairness and honesty of the Nation's financial markets." SEC v. Arthur Young & Co., 584 | |
| F.2d 1018, 1023 (D.C. Cir. 1978). | |
| 4 | |
| The staff also obtained information that REB's audit work on behalf of Calypso may have | |
| involved Bassie's dealings with entities related to the management of another REB audit client, | |
| American International Industries, Inc. ("AMIN"). During investigative testimony on | |
| May 19, 2006, Bassie testified that, while the Firm was serving as outside auditor for AMIN, | |
| Bassie was "charged with a lawsuit" involving Calypso, along with the brother of the president | |
| and chief executive officer of AMIN. Bassie further testified that the litigation arose from a | |
| reverse merger involving Calypso and AMIN management, that a dispute arose over payment, | |
| and that Bassie was given contested shares to hold pending resolution of the dispute. Bassie | |
| hypothesized that he was named as a defendant in order to pressure the president of Calypso to | |
| settle. He testified that he did not consider whether this lawsuit impaired his independence as an | |
| auditor. | |
| 7 Bassie was served with the complaint in this lawsuit before REB issued its audit report | |
| on Calypso's 2003 financial statements. However, Applicants admitted in their response to the | |
| Board OIDP that there was no disclosure concerning the lawsuit in those financial statements. | |
| On November 17, 2006, Division staff served on REB through counsel ("Counsel I") an | |
| ABD (the "Firm ABD") requiring REB to produce certain documents pertaining to audit, review, | |
| or other services that the Firm provided to AMIN and one of AMIN's subsidiaries, International | |
| American Technologies, Inc. ("IAT"). | |
| 8 Among the documents requested were "all working | |
| papers and other documents concerning the audit, review or other services performed by [REB | |
| and its officers and employees]" for AMIN and IAT for the period from January 1, 2003 to the | |
| date of the Firm ABD. The Firm ABD required production of the documents by | |
| December 1, 2006. The Firm did not respond. | |
| 7 The Board's Order Instituting Disciplinary Proceedings ("Board OIDP"), issued | |
| January 9, 2009, alleged that | |
| [i]n auditing the financial statements of Calypso, Respondents violated PCAOB Rule | |
| 3100, Compliance with Auditing and Related Professional Practice Standards, and Rule | |
| 3600T, Interim Independence Standards, by failing to comply with relevant PCAOB | |
| standards, in that Bassie . . . failed to consider whether his role as a co-defendant with | |
| Calypso in a dispute involving his service as an escrow agent in a transaction involving | |
| both Calypso and the management of Calypso and AMIN | |
| impaired his independence as an auditor. | |
| 8 The Division had previously issued ABDs requiring the production of documents | |
| concerning Calypso (the "Calypso ABDs"). The Board's brief on appeal acknowledges that | |
| Applicants produced documents responsive to the Calypso ABDs. But see infra note 12 (noting | |
| that the Division stated, in a letter dated March 27, 2007, that some documents requested by the | |
| Calypso ABDs had not yet been produced). | |
| 5 | |
| C. December 2006: Issuance of Demand Letter | |
| On December 6, 2006, Division staff sent Counsel I a letter "again demanding the | |
| immediate production of all documents responsive to the [Firm] ABD," and stating: | |
| As we have repeatedly reminded your clients, R.E. Bassie & Co. and Mr. Bassie's | |
| cooperation in this matter, including the timely production of documents requested | |
| pursuant to an ABD, is required by [the Act] and the rules of [the PCAOB]. See § 105(b) | |
| of the Act and PCAOB Rule 5110. Failure to comply with an [ABD] may constitute | |
| grounds for instituting a disciplinary proceeding for non-cooperation with an | |
| investigation. See PCAOB Rule 5110(a). | |
| On December 8, Counsel I told Division staff that due to a miscommunication between Counsel | |
| I's office and Bassie, Bassie had only recently received the Firm ABD, and that Bassie would | |
| produce responsive documents the following week. | |
| As of December 27, however, REB had still not produced any documents responsive to | |
| the Firm ABD. On that date, Division staff sent another letter to Counsel I demanding the | |
| immediate production of all such documents. The letter again warned that failure to comply with | |
| an ABD could lead to disciplinary action. | |
| 9 | |
| By letter dated January 2, 2007, Counsel I sought to quash the request for documents. | |
| Counsel I asserted that the Board lacked jurisdiction to request any work product created before | |
| the effective date of Sarbanes-Oxley and suggested that "some of the recent requests for | |
| documents may have fallen within this category." The letter nonetheless represented that "Mr. | |
| Bassie is in the process of gathering and submitting the requested relevant information and will | |
| forward it to you pursuant to your request." On January 10, Division staff responded, noting that | |
| (1) the Firm ABD requested only documents from January 1, 2003 or later, and thus not | |
| documents created before the effective date of the Act; (2) nothing in the Act or Board rules | |
| prohibited the staff from seeking documents created before the effective date of the Act; and (3) | |
| Section 105(b)(2)(B) of the Act | |
| 10 and Rule 5105(b) permit the Board to require from a registered | |
| public accounting firm the production of any document that the Board considers "relevant or | |
| material" to the investigation. The letter reiterated the demand for the immediate production of | |
| documents responsive to the Firm ABD. | |
| 9 Additional letters dated February 2, 2007, March 27, 2007, and May 17, 2007 | |
| included similar warnings. See infra. | |
| 10 15 U.S.C. § 7215(b)(2)(B). | |
| 6 | |
| By January 12, 2007, REB had retained new counsel ("Counsel II"). Counsel II informed | |
| Division staff that Counsel I had provided to Bassie only the transmittal letter for the Firm ABD, | |
| not the Firm ABD itself, which specified the documents to be produced.11 Counsel II therefore | |
| asked Division counsel to resend the Firm ABD and to allow REB "a reasonable amount of time" | |
| to respond. Division staff sent a copy of the Firm ABD to Counsel II on January 12, but stated | |
| that "[b]ecause responsive documents were due nearly 45 days ago, extending additional time to | |
| respond to the ABD is not appropriate. Under the circumstances, we would expect your client to | |
| produce documents immediately, and in any event no later than next week." | |
| Counsel II wrote again on January 23, 2007, stating that Bassie had not received the Firm | |
| ABD until after Division staff sent it to Counsel II on January 12 and that "my client is | |
| cooperating with your request and is in the process of locating said information; however, as he | |
| has a very limited staff and is currently in the middle of tax season, it is going to take some time | |
| to locate all of the information that you are requesting" (emphasis in original). Counsel II also | |
| commented that the OFI mentioned in Division staff's January 12 letter | |
| seemed to indicate that the investigation was pursuant to "In the Matter of R.E. Bassie & | |
| Co's audit and review of Calypso Wireless, Inc. PCAOB 105-OFI-2006-001" only. The | |
| information that you are presently requesting [is] for two entirely different companies. | |
| While my client is in the process of obtaining your requested information, . . . please | |
| provide us with a copy of the Board's Formal Orders of Investigation for Calypso | |
| Wireless, Inc., American International and International American Technologies. | |
| On February 2, 2007, Division staff sent yet another letter to Counsel II, stating that | |
| Bassie had not yet produced documents responsive to the Firm ABD and referring to a telephone | |
| conversation between Division staff and Counsel II that addressed, among other things, Counsel | |
| II's question regarding the staff's authority to seek documents not directly related to REB's audits | |
| and reviews of Calypso: "As we discussed, the [OFI] does not limit the Division's investigation | |
| to matters involving Calypso. On the contrary, the OFI expressly provides that the Division may | |
| investigate any 'acts or practices of similar purport or object.'" | |
| On February 16, 2007, having still not received documents responsive to the Firm ABD, | |
| Division staff sent Bassie an ABD requiring him individually to produce certain documents | |
| related to audits, reviews, or other services performed for AMIN for the period from | |
| January 1, 2003 to the present (the "Bassie ABD"; together with the Firm ABD, the "AMIN | |
| ABDs"). The Bassie ABD required Bassie to produce the documents by March 2, 2007. Bassie | |
| did not produce any documents. | |
| 11 The record does not explain how Bassie could have been "in the process of | |
| gathering and submitting the requested information" on January 2 if, as of January 12, he had not | |
| yet received the Firm ABD. | |
| 7 | |
| D. March 3, 2007: Applicants' Final Response to the AMIN ABDs | |
| By letter dated March 3, 2007, Counsel II made his final written response to the staff | |
| regarding the production of documents requested by the AMIN ABDs: "I want to make it | |
| perfectly clear that Mr. Bassie is not exhibiting conduct that in any way is meant to be construed | |
| as non-cooperation. Mr. Bassie has a small accounting practice and is in the middle of the | |
| busiest time of the year for tax professionals . . . Tax season!" (ellipsis in original). Counsel II | |
| further wrote, | |
| [T]he documents you are requesting are several years old and it is requiring a | |
| considerable amount of time to collect them and then to prepare them for | |
| inspection. . . . To gather the documents at the pace you are requesting would require Mr. | |
| Bassie to halt his practice in the middle of tax season and that would be and it is | |
| unreasonable. What we have [asked for] and continue to ask for is additional time until | |
| the end of the tax season to complete your request. | |
| The March 3 letter additionally observed that Counsel II had reviewed various statutory | |
| provisions "and [had] not found a section in the code [sic] that provides you the authority to | |
| request the information concerning [AMIN and IAT], under an order of investigation for an | |
| entirely unrelated company and order." Counsel II then asked for copies of any other OFIs that | |
| had been issued concerning Bassie or REB. | |
| In a reply dated March 27, 2007, Division staff noted that the AMIN ABDs had been | |
| outstanding since November 17, 2006 and February 16, 2007 respectively and stated that it was | |
| "simply not credible" that the occurrence of tax season was responsible for Applicants' failure to | |
| comply with the AMIN ABDs. | |
| 12 The staff therefore refused to allow additional time for | |
| providing the documents. Finally, the staff informed Counsel II that the staff had authority to | |
| demand documents related to the AMIN and IAT audits under the Calypso OFI, pointing out that | |
| the OFI "explicitly authorizes the staff to investigate not only the potential violations specified | |
| therein, but also 'acts or practices of similar purport or object.'" Division staff sent additional | |
| letters to Counsel II regarding Applicants' failure to produce documents responsive to the AMIN | |
| ABDs on May 17, 2007 and June 1, 2007. Counsel II did not respond. | |
| 12 The letter also rejected the contention that production of the documents would | |
| require Bassie to halt his practice, pointing out that, if REB complied with PCAOB auditing | |
| standards regarding document retention (which provided that a complete and final set of audit | |
| documentation should be assembled for retention as of a date not more than forty-five days after | |
| the report release date), it should not require much time to have the AMIN and IAT work papers | |
| copied and produced to the Division. | |
| The Division's March 27 letter additionally stated that some documents requested by two | |
| of the Calypso ABDs had not yet been produced. As noted above, however, compliance with the | |
| Calypso ABDs is not at issue in this proceeding. See supra note 8. | |
| 8 | |
| E. September 10, 2007: Staff Notifies Applicants of Potential Disciplinary Action | |
| On September 10, 2007, Division staff sent Counsel II a letter stating that it intended to | |
| recommend that the Board commence a disciplinary proceeding to determine whether Applicants | |
| had violated certain rules, laws, or professional standards within the Board's jurisdiction, by, | |
| among other things, failing to comply with the AMIN ABDs. | |
| 13 The letter offered Applicants an | |
| opportunity to submit to the Division, by September 25, a written statement setting forth their | |
| positions regarding whether such a proceeding should be commenced. | |
| 14 | |
| On the afternoon of September 25, Counsel II left a voicemail message stating that Bassie | |
| was preparing a response and requesting additional time to complete and send in the response. | |
| Applicants were granted an extension until October 2, 2007. On October 1, Bassie retained new | |
| counsel ("Counsel III"), who requested an additional thirty-day extension. Bassie was granted an | |
| extension until November 1, 2007. On November 1, Counsel III wrote that he was "diligently | |
| analyzing the issues in [the] September 10, 2007 letter," but that he was not yet prepared to | |
| respond, and requesting a further sixty-day extension. The staff agreed to a thirty-day extension, | |
| noting that "[t]he length of this investigation is a direct result of Mr. Bassie's repeated and | |
| continuing failure to cooperate." Applicants never submitted a position statement, nor have they | |
| produced documents responsive to the AMIN ABDs. | |
| III. | |
| PCAOB PROCEEDINGS | |
| The Board OIDP alleged, among other things, that Applicants had failed to comply with | |
| the AMIN ABDs, and that this conduct constituted noncooperation with a Board investigation. | |
| On March 3, 2009, the Division filed a motion for summary disposition. On April 9, 2009, the | |
| hearing officer issued an initial decision granting the motion and imposing a revocation and bar, | |
| but no money penalty (the "Initial Decision"). | |
| 15 | |
| 13 Rule 5110(a)(1) permits the Board to institute a disciplinary proceeding for | |
| noncooperation with an investigation "if it appears to the Board . . . that a registered public | |
| accounting firm, or a person associated with such a firm, may have failed to comply with an | |
| accounting board demand." | |
| 14 See PCAOB Rule 5109(d) (providing for the submission of such statements of | |
| position). | |
| 15 The hearing officer also granted summary disposition in favor of the Division on a | |
| charge that Bassie knowingly made false material declarations in sworn testimony during the | |
| Division's investigation. On appeal, however, the Board found that genuine issues of material | |
| fact precluded resolution of that charge by summary disposition. In light of the sanctions | |
| (continued...) | |
| 9 | |
| Applicants filed a petition for Board review of the Initial Decision on April 20, 2009.16 In | |
| paragraph 1 of their petition, Applicants argued that "Enforcement has unreasonably interpreted | |
| [Applicants'] requests for additional extensions of time due to tax season as intentional | |
| noncooperation with the investigation," and that Bassie "at all times complied with | |
| Enforcement's requests and there is no evidence that he knowingly refused to respond to or | |
| produce the requested documents." In paragraph 3 of their petition, however, Applicants asserted | |
| that Bassie | |
| did in fact rely on the legal advice of counsel. [Counsel II] found no authority for [the | |
| Division] to request information regarding AMIN under an order of investigation for an | |
| entirely unrelated company, advice on which Mr. Bassie relied. Mr. Bassie made | |
| complete disclosure to [Counsel II], sought advice on the legality of the issue, received | |
| advice that he did not have to produce information regarding a company wholly unrelated | |
| to the investigation, and relied in good faith on the advice. | |
| In their petition, Applicants did not attempt to harmonize the assertions in paragraph 1 – that | |
| Bassie's requests for more time should not be construed as noncooperation and that the Division | |
| acted unreasonably in refusing to give Bassie more time – with the assertions in paragraph 3 – | |
| that Bassie was told by Counsel II that he did not have to produce information regarding AMIN | |
| and that he relied in good faith on that advice. | |
| On May 5, 2009, Applicants filed an amended petition for review. The amended petition | |
| reiterated the arguments made in the original petition, but it included as an attachment an | |
| affidavit of Bassie. Among other things, the affidavit recited that | |
| I reasonably relied in good faith on counsel's advice that [the Division] did not have the | |
| authority to demand documentation regarding AMIN because AMIN was not the subject | |
| of the Board's investigation. Specifically, the advice I relied upon was that I did not have | |
| to respond to an ABD unless the ABD specified AMIN. The only ABD I received was | |
| regarding Calypso Wireless, Inc., which was the only subject of the investigation. | |
| After retaining [Counsel II] as my counsel, I did not directly receive any correspondence, | |
| including ABDs, from the PCAOB. | |
| 15 (...continued) | |
| imposed, the Board did not remand that aspect of the case or order any further proceedings, | |
| effectively dismissing that charge, and it is therefore not before us. | |
| 16 By this time, Applicants had retained new counsel, who continues to represent | |
| them on appeal. | |
| 10 | |
| On May 29, 2009, Applicants filed their opening brief, in which they offered to "make | |
| available the documents requested by the Board at a mutually agreeable time and place," under a | |
| variety of conditions that included a requirement that the Board be responsible for the costs | |
| involved in procuring and, if desired, photocopying relevant documents. Applicants also argued | |
| that the Initial Decision should not be summarily affirmed and that the revocation and bar were | |
| harsh and excessive. | |
| The Board refused to allow the submission of Bassie's affidavit. It found that Applicants | |
| did not file a motion describing any grounds for their failure to adduce the affidavit in the | |
| proceedings before the hearing officer, and that it was not apparent from anything in the record | |
| what possible grounds there could be. The Board also found that the affidavit was "at odds with | |
| what [Applicants] repeatedly told the Division during the investigation – that they were gathering | |
| the documents, intended to cooperate, and just needed an extension until after the tax season," | |
| and that it was also at odds with the assertions in the petition for review that their request for an | |
| extension until after tax season was reasonable and that the Division had unreasonably | |
| interpreted Applicant's requests for additional time due to tax season as intentional | |
| noncooperation with the investigation. | |
| As to the merits of the proceeding, the Board, citing its authority under Section 105(b)(3) | |
| of the Act and Rule 5300(b), found, as an undisputed fact, that Applicants possessed, but did not | |
| produce, documents responsive to the AMIN ABDs. The Board further found that each | |
| Applicant's conduct constituted noncooperation, and that summary disposition was appropriate. | |
| The Board held that although Section 105(b)(3) is worded in terms of a "refus[al] to . . . produce | |
| documents, or otherwise cooperate" with an investigation, the refusal need not be express: "To | |
| hold otherwise would render [S]ection 105(b)(3) a dead letter, since any noncooperating | |
| registered firm or associated person could then avoid [S]ection 105(b)(3) sanctions merely by | |
| refraining from expressly articulating a refusal to cooperate." | |
| The Board found that Applicants did not dispute, either before the hearing officer or | |
| before the Board, that the AMIN ABDs were within the scope of ABDs authorized by the | |
| Calypso OFI. The Board acknowledged that Applicants argued that they relied on legal advice | |
| they claimed to have received before the disciplinary proceeding was initiated to the effect that | |
| they were not obligated to produce documents concerning AMIN and IAT because the OFI | |
| named only Calypso, but it found that they did not establish such reliance. | |
| The Board affirmed the sanctions imposed by the hearing officer and additionally | |
| imposed a civil money penalty against Bassie in the amount of $75,000. The Board stated that | |
| Applicants' offer, made in their opening brief, to make the documents available for review and | |
| copying was not, as Applicants contended, a mere "delay" in the production of the documents. | |
| The Board therefore gave that offer no weight in the determination of sanctions. This appeal | |
| followed. | |
| 11 | |
| IV. | |
| ANALYSIS | |
| The record shows that, during the period between the issuance of the Firm ABD on | |
| November 17, 2006 and the institution of disciplinary proceedings on January 9, 2009, | |
| Applicants did not produce any documents in response to the AMIN ABDs, effectively refusing | |
| to cooperate with the investigation. | |
| 17 Instead, Applicants engaged in a protracted campaign of | |
| stalling and delay. The Division granted several extensions and addressed Applicants' questions | |
| about the propriety of the ABDs, but Applicants continued to withhold the documents, ultimately | |
| lapsing into total noncommunication. | |
| A. Applicants' Substantive Arguments | |
| Applicants contend that "Calypso was the only proper subject of the OFI and Applicants | |
| produced documents in compliance with the OFI." By asserting that Calypso was "the only | |
| proper subject," they appear to contend that the AMIN ABDs were not authorized by the OFI and | |
| that they therefore had no obligation to produce documents responsive to the AMIN ABDs. | |
| We reject Applicants' attempt to restrict the scope of the OFI to Calypso, the company | |
| named as its subject. Both Sarbanes-Oxley Section 105(b)(2)(B) and PCAOB Rule 5103 permit | |
| the Board and designated staff to require the production of any documents that the Board or its | |
| staff considers "relevant or material" to an investigation. | |
| 18 The OFI authorized the staff to issue | |
| ABDs "to the extent that the information sought is relevant to matters described in this Order of | |
| Formal Investigation." Thus, the statute, the rule, and the OFI are consistent in authorizing | |
| requests for information "relevant" to the investigation. | |
| As described above, Bassie testified that he held shares involved in a dispute between | |
| Calypso and AMIN management and that he was named as a party in a lawsuit involving AMIN | |
| management and Calypso, perhaps in order to pressure Calypso's president to settle. These | |
| events transpired while Bassie was auditing both AMIN and Calypso. The questions about | |
| Applicants' independence as auditors raised by Bassie's role in the lawsuit involving Calypso and | |
| AMIN management made Applicants' relationship to AMIN relevant to the investigation | |
| authorized by the OFI. Bassie testified, however, that he did not consider whether his | |
| involvement in the lawsuit impaired his independence as an auditor, a potential violation of | |
| 17 As noted above, Applicants' responsiveness to the Calypso ABDs is not at issue in | |
| this proceeding. | |
| 18 See supra note 6 (discussing Section 105(b)(2)(B) and Rule 5103(a)). | |
| 12 | |
| PCAOB rules.19 We therefore find that the AMIN ABDs comported with the statutory and | |
| regulatory standard: they required the production of documents relevant or material to the | |
| investigation authorized in the OFI. Thus, Applicants were required to produce documents | |
| responsive to those ABDs. | |
| 20 | |
| Applicants contend that they "were willing to make available to the PCAOB the | |
| documents it requested subject to a mutually agreeable time and place at the advice of [their | |
| current counsel]." Applicants made their offer more than two years after the issuance of the | |
| AMIN ABDs, and only after the hearing officer had issued the Initial Decision, recommending a | |
| bar for Bassie and revocation for the Firm. Applicants' belated and conditional offer, which was | |
| made only when they faced the imminent prospect of sanctions, does not constitute compliance | |
| with the AMIN ABDs. | |
| 21 Moreover, the unwarranted conditions that accompanied the offer | |
| further diminish its value. | |
| Applicants assert that "[t]here is no evidence to suggest that Applicants would not have | |
| produced documents related to AMIN had the PCAOB properly issued an OFI for the same." As | |
| discussed above, however, the Division was authorized to issue the AMIN ABDs because the | |
| materials sought appeared to be relevant or material to the investigation authorized in the OFI | |
| that named Calypso. There was no requirement that the Board issue an additional OFI naming | |
| AMIN and IAT. In any event, the assertion that Applicants would have complied had the ABD | |
| been worded differently cannot be tested and is not a defense. | |
| 19 See supra note 7 (noting allegation in Board OIDP that Bassie failed to consider | |
| whether his involvement in the lawsuit impaired his independence, a potential violation of | |
| PCAOB rules). Bassie's admission that Calypso's 2003 financial statements contained no | |
| disclosure regarding the lawsuit further illustrates the relevance of Applicants' involvement with | |
| AMIN to the investigation authorized by the OFI. | |
| 20 Applicants suggest that their willingness to cooperate with the Division is | |
| demonstrated by their production of documents related to the Calypso audit. Applicants' | |
| compliance with the Calypso ABDs does not, however, excuse their failure to produce | |
| documents responsive to the AMIN ABDs. Similarly, Applicants contend that "Bassie was never | |
| found in violation of any state or federal regulation regarding the audit work he performed for | |
| Calypso, nor was he ever required to re-state Calypso's financial statements." Whether | |
| Applicants' audit work for Calypso violated regulations or standards is not at issue in this | |
| proceeding, and the resolution of that question would have no apparent bearing on whether | |
| Applicants failed to produce documents in response to the AMIN ABDs. | |
| 21 Cf., e.g., CMG Institutional Trading, LLC, Securities Exchange Act Rel. No. | |
| 59325 (Jan. 30, 2009), 95 SEC Docket 13802, 13810 ("[W]e have emphasized repeatedly that | |
| NASD should not have to initiate a disciplinary action to elicit a response to its information | |
| requests . . . ." (citations omitted)); Gately & Assocs., Exchange Act Rel. No. 62656 (Aug. 5, | |
| 2010), 99 SEC Docket 31023, 31045 (applying same principles to PCAOB inspection requests). | |
| 13 | |
| For the above reasons, we sustain the Board's action finding that Applicants' failure to | |
| produce documents in response to the AMIN ABDs constitutes noncooperation for which the | |
| Board was authorized to impose sanctions pursuant to Section 105(b)(3) of the Act and | |
| Rule 5300(b). | |
| B. Applicants' Remaining Arguments | |
| 1. Propriety of Summary Disposition | |
| Applicants argue that the hearing officer erred in granting the Division's motion for | |
| summary disposition because, they claim, there was a material dispute about whether, in refusing | |
| to produce the documents in question, they were relying on the advice of counsel. We disagree. | |
| PCAOB Rule 5427(d) provides that summary disposition is appropriate in Board | |
| disciplinary proceedings "if the pleadings, depositions, and admissions on file, together with the | |
| affidavits, if any, show that there is no genuine issue as to any material fact and that the moving | |
| party is entitled to a disposition as a matter of law." | |
| 22 A party seeking summary disposition must | |
| make a preliminary showing that no genuine issue of material fact exists.23 The burden then | |
| shifts to the nonmovant. To avoid summary disposition, the nonmovant "must contradict the | |
| showing by pointing to specific facts demonstrating that there is, indeed, a trialworthy issue." | |
| 24 | |
| In determining whether there is a genuine dispute as to a material fact, the record "should be | |
| 'viewed most favorably to the non-moving party,' but the hearing officer 'need not credit purely | |
| conclusory allegations, indulge in rank speculation, or draw improbable inferences.'" | |
| 25 | |
| 22 As we have previously noted, Rule 5427 "mirrors the summary judgment standard | |
| in Rule 56 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure," and we have therefore found federal court | |
| interpretations of Rule 56 instructive in interpreting the Board rule. Gately, 99 SEC Docket at | |
| 31031. | |
| 23 E.g., Nat'l Amusements, Inc. v. Town of Dedham, 43 F.3d 731, 735 (1st Cir. | |
| 1995). | |
| 24 Id. | |
| 25 Gately, 99 SEC Docket at 31032 (quoting Nat'l Amusements, 43 F.3d at 735). | |
| 14 | |
| There is no factual dispute as to whether Applicants provided to the PCAOB documents | |
| specified in the AMIN ABDs. They did not.26 The Division introduced facts establishing the | |
| refusal to produce documents in the statement of undisputed facts filed to support their motion | |
| for summary disposition. The burden then shifted to Applicants to show that there was a | |
| trialworthy issue. | |
| Applicants attempted to establish a trialworthy issue by arguing that they received and | |
| reasonably relied on legal advice in refusing to produce the documents. They identify two items | |
| in the record as supporting their assertion: first, the March 3, 2007 letter from Counsel II stating | |
| that he "[had] not found a section in the code" that provided the Board the authority to request | |
| information for AMIN under an OFI that named only Calypso, and second, the Bassie affidavit | |
| submitted with the amended petition for review. | |
| a. Counsel Letter. The March 3, 2007 letter is not sufficient to establish a genuine | |
| issue of material fact as to whether Applicants received and relied on legal advice that they were | |
| not required to produce documents requested in the AMIN ABDs. The letter states: | |
| Mr. Bassie is not exhibiting conduct that in any way is meant to be construed as non | |
| cooperation. . . . [I]t is taking a considerable amount of time to collect [the documents] | |
| and then to prepare them for inspection. . . . What we have [asked for] and continue to ask | |
| for is additional time . . . to complete your request. | |
| These statements are inconsistent with the premise that Counsel II had advised Applicants that | |
| they were not required to provide the AMIN documents. There would be no need to collect the | |
| documents or prepare them for inspection, and no need for additional time to complete the | |
| request, if the ultimate intention were to refuse to produce the documents. | |
| Nor does Counsel II's statement that he had not identified a statutory provision allowing | |
| the Division to request the AMIN documents create a genuine issue as to whether Counsel II | |
| advised Applicants that they should refuse to produce the documents. That statement suggests | |
| only that Counsel II was looking into the question of the breadth of the Board's authority. | |
| 26 Applicants assert that the Division made a "patently false" statement that "it had | |
| never received one document pursuant to the [ABDs] it served on Applicants" because | |
| Applicants produced documents in response to the Calypso ABDs. However, the Division did | |
| not assert, and the Board did not find, that Applicant's response to the Calypso ABDs was | |
| inadequate. The Division's brief in support of its motion for summary disposition accurately | |
| states that "[n]ot withstanding numerous efforts by Enforcement over nearly 12 months to obtain | |
| [documents concerning AMIN], and numerous written warnings that failure to comply with | |
| ABDs could lead to disciplinary action, [Applicants] failed to produce a single document." From | |
| the context, it is clear that the Division's statement relates only to the failure to produce | |
| documents required by the AMIN ABDs. The Division did not challenge Applicants' response to | |
| the Calypso ABDs. | |
| 15 | |
| Nothing in the record considered by the Board suggests that Counsel II concluded, after writing | |
| the March 3 letter, that the staff's authority did not extend to demanding the documents specified | |
| in the AMIN ABDs, nor does the record show that Counsel II conveyed any such conclusion to | |
| Bassie. Moreover, Applicants do not explain how Bassie could have continued to rely on such a | |
| conclusion after Division staff reiterated its position, in its March 27 letter, that the OFI's grant of | |
| authority was broad enough to encompass ABDs for documents related to AMIN and IAT. A | |
| finding that Bassie reasonably relied on the advice of Counsel II in refusing to respond to the | |
| AMIN ABDs would therefore be based not on evidence, but on the sort of "rank speculation" that | |
| does not justify reversing the summary disposition. | |
| b. Refusal to Consider Bassie's Affidavit. Applicants challenge the Board's | |
| decision to exclude Bassie's affidavit from the record. However, PCAOB Rule 5464 requires a | |
| party seeking to introduce additional evidence when a matter is on appeal before the Board to | |
| "show with particularity that such additional evidence is material and that there were reasonable | |
| grounds for failure to adduce such evidence previously." Applicants did not attempt to make | |
| such a showing when they submitted Bassie's affidavit with their amended petition for review. | |
| Thus, the Board properly refused to consider the affidavit. | |
| In their brief on appeal, Applicants assert that "Applicants were unaware that an affidavit | |
| was required to be submitted in support of previous sworn testimony until Enforcement | |
| specifically charged that the burden was on Bassie to point to specific facts demonstrating a | |
| trialworthy issue." They point to a passage of the Initial Decision stating that "Applicants have | |
| not submitted an affidavit from Bassie or any other evidence to support the truth of Bassie's | |
| PCAOB testimony" and assert that "[t]his statement invited [Applicants] to submit an | |
| affidavit." | |
| 27 | |
| There was no requirement that Applicants submit an affidavit. As discussed above, once | |
| the Division introduced evidence sufficient to establish the misconduct at issue, the burden | |
| shifted to Applicants to show that there was a genuine issue of material fact that would preclude | |
| 27 Applicants' quotation from the Initial Decision is taken out of context. As noted | |
| above, the hearing officer granted summary disposition in favor of the Division with respect to | |
| the allegation that Bassie provided false testimony during the investigation, an issue that is not | |
| involved in this appeal. See supra note 15. The statement that Applicants introduced no | |
| affidavit "to support the truth of Bassie's testimony" related to that allegation; it thus has no | |
| relevance to this appeal. | |
| 16 | |
| the entry of summary disposition. Whether Applicants attempted to satisfy this burden by | |
| testimony, by affidavit, or otherwise was their choice. But if Applicants wanted to strengthen | |
| their case by introducing an affidavit, they should have done so before the hearing officer, not on | |
| appeal to the Board. | |
| 28 | |
| For these reasons, we find that Applicants did not demonstrate that there was a | |
| trialworthy issue with respect to whether they reasonably relied on the advice of counsel in | |
| failing to produce documents in response to the AMIN ABDs. | |
| 29 | |
| 28 Bassie's affidavit, even if timely presented, would have done little to strengthen | |
| his case. Bassie merely asserted that he was relying on counsel's advice; he provided no details | |
| showing that he had made full and complete disclosure to counsel and received relevant advice | |
| appropriately tailored to the circumstances. See, e.g., Howard Brett Berger, Exchange Act Rel. | |
| No. 58590 (Nov. 14, 2008), 94 SEC Docket 11615, 11630-31 (discussing cases holding that the | |
| advice received must be based on "a full and complete disclosure" to counsel and that a person | |
| cannot successfully establish reliance by "'offer[ing] nothing more than his say-so'" but must, | |
| instead, "'produc[e] the actual advice from an actual lawyer,'" for example, in the form of an | |
| opinion letter or the attorney's live testimony (citations omitted)), petition denied, 2009 WL | |
| 3160620 (2d Cir. 2009) (summary disposition). Bassie's affidavit, which does not even specify | |
| which of his successive attorneys allegedly rendered the advice on which he purportedly relied, | |
| falls far short of this standard. | |
| Moreover, the assertions in the affidavit appear to conflate two issues: whether Bassie | |
| was required to respond to the AMIN ABDs when the OFI named only Calypso, and whether he | |
| was required to respond to the AMIN ABDs if they were not sent to him "directly" by the | |
| PCAOB. Bassie does not assert, in the affidavit or elsewhere, that he was advised by counsel | |
| that he was not required to respond to ABDs unless they were sent to him "directly." | |
| We also note that, although Bassie asserts that "[t]he only ABD I received was regarding | |
| Calypso Wireless, Inc.," he did not argue earlier in the proceeding that he did not receive the | |
| Bassie ABD, which was addressed to him. Further, Counsel II's January 23, 2007 letter stating | |
| that Bassie had not received the Firm ABD until after staff sent it to Counsel II on January 12 | |
| implies that Bassie did subsequently receive the Firm ABD, and Counsel II's representations in | |
| the January 23, 2007 letter that Bassie "is cooperating with your request and is in the process of | |
| locating said information" shows that if Bassie did not receive the Firm ABD, he was at a | |
| minimum aware of the documents he was required to produce. | |
| 29 Because the Board determined that Applicants did not establish reliance on the | |
| advice of counsel, it did not reach the question whether reliance on such advice would be | |
| material to the question whether Applicants' conduct constituted noncooperation, or whether such | |
| reliance would be relevant to a determination of sanctions. But see, e.g., Berger, 94 SEC Docket | |
| at 11629-30 (finding that advice-of-counsel claim "is not relevant to liability" for failure to | |
| appear and provide information to NASD because scienter is not an element of the violation); | |
| (continued...) | |
| 17 | |
| V. | |
| SANCTIONS | |
| Applicants challenge the sanctions imposed by the Board as unwarranted. They claim | |
| that they "have not exhibited behavior constituting noncooperation, nor has Bassie ever been | |
| accused of performing insufficient audits."30 In particular, they contend that the civil penalty is | |
| unjust and groundless in light of the revocation and bar. | |
| Section 107(c)(3) of Sarbanes-Oxley governs our review of sanctions imposed by the | |
| Board.31 If we find, "having due regard for the public interest and the protection of investors," | |
| that the sanction "is not necessary or appropriate in furtherance of [the] Act or the securities | |
| laws," or that the sanction "is excessive, oppressive, inadequate, or otherwise not appropriate to | |
| the finding or the basis on which the sanction was imposed," then we may enhance, modify, | |
| cancel, reduce, or require the remission of the sanction. | |
| 32 As discussed below, we find no basis | |
| to modify the sanction. | |
| Congress established the Board to "protect the interests of investors and further the public | |
| interest in the preparation of informative, accurate, and independent audit reports."33 To further | |
| these goals, the Board is required to "establish, by rule, . . . fair procedures for the investigation | |
| 29 (...continued) | |
| Joseph G. Chiulli, 54 S.E.C. 515, 524 (2000) ("Reliance on counsel . . . does not excuse Chiulli | |
| from his obligation to supply information to the NASD. When Chiulli registered with the | |
| NASD, he agreed to abide by its rules which are unequivocal with respect to an associated | |
| person's duty to cooperate with NASD investigations." (footnotes omitted)); Michael Markowski, | |
| 51 S.E.C. 553, 557 (1993) ("When Markowski became registered with the NASD, he agreed to | |
| abide by its Rules of Fair Practice, which are unequivocal with respect to the obligation to | |
| cooperate with the NASD. Reliance on counsel is immaterial to an associated person's obligation | |
| to supply requested information to the NASD." (footnotes omitted)), aff'd, 34 F.3d 99 (2d Cir. | |
| 1994). | |
| 30 In fact, the OIDP alleges numerous statutory and regulatory violations in | |
| Applicants' audits of both Calypso and AMIN. However, these allegations are not at issue in this | |
| proceeding, and we have not considered them. | |
| 31 15 U.S.C. § 7217(c)(3). | |
| 32 Id. | |
| 33 Sarbanes-Oxley § 101(a), 15 U.S.C. § 7211(a). | |
| 18 | |
| and disciplining of registered public accounting firms and associated persons of such firms."34 | |
| The Board may, among other things, "require the production of audit work papers and any other | |
| document or information in the possession of a registered public accounting firm or any | |
| associated person thereof . . . that the Board considers relevant or material to the investigation." | |
| 35 | |
| The Act requires every registered public accounting firm to consent "to cooperat[e] | |
| in . . . and compl[y] with any request for . . . the production of documents made by the Board in | |
| furtherance of its authority and responsibilities" under the Act, to agree to secure and enforce | |
| similar consents from each associated person of the firm, | |
| 36 and to acknowledge that the firm | |
| "understands and agrees" that cooperation and compliance with any such request for documents, | |
| and the securing and enforcement of the required consents from the firm's associated persons, | |
| are conditions to the continuing effectiveness of the registration of the firm with the Board. | |
| 37 | |
| It is clear from these statutory provisions that investigations play a crucial role in | |
| furthering the Board's goals of investor protection and the preparation of informative, accurate, | |
| and independent audit reports. The requirements that registered public accounting firms consent | |
| to cooperate with document production requests, obtain and enforce similar consents from | |
| associated persons, and acknowledge that such cooperation is a condition to the continuing | |
| effectiveness of a firm's registration with the Board underscore the seriousness with which | |
| Sarbanes-Oxley views cooperation with the Board in furtherance of the Board's statutory | |
| responsibilities. Imposing sanctions to deter noncooperation with PCAOB investigations thus | |
| clearly serves the public interest. | |
| A. Revocation and Bar | |
| Nearly ten months passed between the date the Firm ABD was served on REB and the | |
| date Division staff warned Applicants that it intended to recommend the commencement of a | |
| disciplinary proceeding. In all those months, not a single document responsive to the AMIN | |
| ABDs was produced. Applicants repeatedly represented (through counsel) that they were in the | |
| process of gathering the documents and that they needed more time. The Division repeatedly | |
| responded by granting extensions, while reminding Applicants of their obligation to comply with | |
| the ABDs. The record does not show, however, that Applicants were actually using the extra | |
| time to collect the information requested, rather than simply trying to postpone the investigation | |
| as long as possible. Ultimately, Applicants simply stopped responding. This failure to cooperate | |
| impairs the Division's ability to investigate, which in turn impairs the Board's ability to identify | |
| violations and sanction violators. For these reasons, failure to cooperate in an investigation is | |
| very serious misconduct. | |
| 34 Id. § 105(a), 15 U.S.C. § 7215(a). | |
| 35 Id. § 105(b)(2), 15 U.S.C. § 7215(b)(2). | |
| 36 Id. § 102(b)(3)(A), 15 U.S.C. § 7212(b)(3)(A). | |
| 37 Id. § 102(b)(3)(B), 15 U.S.C. § 7212(b)(3)(B). | |
| 19 | |
| Applicants argue that no specific harm to a particular investor can be traced back to their | |
| failure to cooperate, and that the lack of such identifiable harm should be considered in assessing | |
| sanctions. The Board's power to impose appropriate sanctions in disciplinary proceedings is | |
| fundamental to its ability to act in the public interest. | |
| 38 Failure to respond to ABDs frustrates the | |
| oversight system envisioned by Sarbanes-Oxley, impeding the Board's ability to discover | |
| violations. Noncooperation deprives investors of an important protection that the Act was | |
| intended to provide. | |
| 39 The fact that the Board could not identify whether there was specific harm | |
| to a particular investor does not detract from the seriousness of the misconduct.40 | |
| We find, as the Board did, that Applicants' conduct warrants revocation of the Firm's | |
| registration and a bar on Bassie's association with any registered public company accounting | |
| firm. In choosing to register with the Board, Applicants agreed to cooperate with the Board | |
| when it sought information from them. Bassie, who chose to be an associated person of the | |
| Firm, made a similar agreement. Rather than fulfilling these agreements, however, Applicants | |
| used the excuse that they needed more time to collect the information, thus delaying the | |
| Division's investigation into their conduct. As the Board observed, in the absence of mitigating | |
| circumstances – of which we find none | |
| 41 – noncooperation indicates a lack of sufficient regard | |
| for Board processes and authority designed by statute to protect investors. Allowing the Firm to | |
| remain registered and Bassie to remain an associated person would give them opportunities in the | |
| 38 Cf. Berger, 94 SEC Docket at 11620 (characterizing NASD Rule 8210, which | |
| required NASD members and associated persons to provide information if requested by NASD | |
| staff as part of an investigation, complaint, examination, or proceeding as "at the heart of the | |
| self-regulatory system for the securities industry"). | |
| 39 Id. at 11620-21 (finding that delay and neglect by NASD members and their | |
| associated persons in responding to requests for information "'undermine the ability of the NASD | |
| to conduct investigations and thereby protect the public interest'" (quoting Barry C. Wilson, 52 | |
| S.E.C. 1070, 1075 (1996)). | |
| 40 Cf. PAZ Sec., Inc., Exchange Act Rel. No. 57656 (Apr. 11, 2008), 93 SEC Docket | |
| 5122, 5129 ("[A] Rule 8210 violation will rarely, in itself, result in direct harm to a customer. | |
| Rather, failing to respond undermines NASD's ability to detect misconduct that may have | |
| occurred and that may have resulted in harm to investors . . . . Thus, even if the failure to respond | |
| does not result in . . . harm to investors, it is serious because it impedes detection of such | |
| violative conduct." (footnote omitted)), petition denied, 566 F.3d 1172 (D.C. Cir. 2009); Gately, | |
| 99 SEC Docket at 31044-45 (finding that absence of fraud or deceit does not diminish | |
| seriousness of failure to cooperate in PCAOB inspection designed, among other things, to | |
| uncover any such misconduct). | |
| 41 We have explained above why we do not consider mitigating (1) Applicants' | |
| purported reliance on advice of counsel, (2) the belated and conditional offer to make documents | |
| available, (3) the production of documents responsive to the Calypso ABDs, or (4) the lack of | |
| findings that Applicants' audits were insufficient. | |
| 20 | |
| future to similarly undermine those processes and thus erode the investor protection that | |
| Congress intended the Board to provide. Moreover, the awareness that a revocation and bar may | |
| be imposed as sanctions for noncooperation may deter other firms and associated persons from | |
| engaging in similar misconduct. | |
| 42 We therefore sustain the bar and revocation imposed by the | |
| Board.43 | |
| B. Civil Money Penalty | |
| We similarly sustain the imposition of a civil money penalty of $75,000. In cases | |
| involving intentional or knowing conduct, including reckless conduct, that results in a violation | |
| of the applicable statutory, regulatory, or professional standard, the Board may impose a civil | |
| money penalty not exceeding $800,000 against an individual for each violation. | |
| 44 | |
| Applicants refused for months to produce documents required by the AMIN ABDs. They | |
| repeatedly attempted to stall for time, representing to staff that they were working to fulfill the | |
| requests but citing work pressure to justify the alleged need for extensions. The staff allowed | |
| multiple extensions, reminded Applicants repeatedly of their obligation to cooperate with the | |
| investigation, and warned Applicants over and over again of the consequences of a failure to | |
| cooperate. Applicants finally stopped responding altogether. In light of this course of conduct, | |
| 42 In making this determination, we note that "'general deterrence . . . may be | |
| considered as part of the overall remedial inquiry.'" Siegel v. SEC, 592 F.3d 147, 158 (D.C. Cir. | |
| 2010) (quoting PAZ Sec., Inc., 494 F.3d 1059, 1066 (D.C. Cir. 2007)), cert. denied, 130 S. Ct. | |
| 3333 (2010); see also Boruski v. SEC, 289 F.2d 738, 740 (2d Cir. 1961) ("The public interest | |
| requires that appropriate sanctions be imposed to secure compliance with the rules, regulations | |
| and policies of both NASD and SEC."). | |
| 43 Applicants contend that the hearing officer's imposition of a bar and revocation | |
| was based in part on his finding that Bassie made material false declarations in sworn testimony | |
| during the Division's investigation. See supra note 15. Applicants contend that because the | |
| Board effectively dismissed this charge, the sanction should be lowered accordingly. The Board, | |
| however, imposed a bar and revocation even though it did not find the allegations of making | |
| false declarations established. We agree with the Board that the bar and revocation were | |
| appropriate as sanctions for the failure to cooperate charge that was not dismissed. See Sarbanes- | |
| Oxley Section 105(b)(3)(A), 15 U.S.C. § 7215(b)(3)(A) (authorizing Board to impose revocation | |
| and bar, among other sanctions, for refusal to produce documents in connection with | |
| investigation). | |
| 44 Sarbanes-Oxley Sections 105(c)(4)(D)(ii), 105(c)(5), 15 U.S.C. | |
| §§ 7215(c)(4)(D)(ii), 7215(c)(5); 17 C.F.R. § 201.1003. The Act also provides for the imposition | |
| of a civil penalty not exceeding $110,000 against an individual for each violation where there is | |
| no showing of scienter. Sarbanes-Oxley Section 105(c)(4)(D)(i), 15 U.S.C. § 7215(c)(4)(D)(i); | |
| 17 C.F.R. § 201.1003. As noted above, see supra note 3, PCAOB Rule 5300(b) expressly | |
| provides for the imposition of civil penalties for failure to comply with an ABD. | |
| 21 | |
| we find that Applicants' deliberate or reckless refusal to cooperate with the investigation satisfies | |
| the statutory standard for the imposition of a civil penalty. | |
| The Act does not specify factors to be considered in determining whether a penalty is in | |
| the public interest. Here, the Board considered the factors set forth in Exchange Act Section | |
| 21B(c), which the Commission may consider in determining whether it would be in the public | |
| interest to impose a civil penalty in an administrative proceeding. These factors are whether | |
| there was fraudulent misconduct or deliberate or reckless disregard of a regulatory requirement, | |
| harm to others, or unjust enrichment, whether the respondent had committed prior violations, and | |
| the need for deterrence, as well as such other matters as justice may require. | |
| 45 However, as the | |
| Board recognized, a penalty may be imposed under Section 21B(c) even when not all of these | |
| factors are present. | |
| 46 | |
| We have not previously considered the application of the Section 21B factors to a failure | |
| to cooperate with an investigation.47 However, Section 21B allows the consideration not only of | |
| the enumerated factors (not all of which need be present), but of "such other matters as justice | |
| may require." An analysis based on Section 21B is therefore sufficiently flexible to be used in | |
| this context. | |
| In this case, Applicants' deliberate or reckless disregard of their obligation to cooperate | |
| with the Board's investigation strongly supports the imposition of a civil penalty. By refusing to | |
| produce the requested documents, Applicants prevented the Board from carrying out an | |
| investigation that was necessary to determine whether it was proper for Applicants to be allowed | |
| to continue to perform audits. Moreover, by dragging out the matter for months, Applicants | |
| caused the Board's staff to expend considerable time trying to obtain the cooperation Applicants | |
| should have freely given. | |
| Applicants' failure to comply harmed the Board's ability to carry out its investigation. | |
| The Board's investigatory power is central to its ability to carry out its statutory responsibilities | |
| and fulfill its goals in the public interest. Its ability to obtain documents from registered public | |
| accounting firms and their associated persons is, in turn, critical to the effective conduct of | |
| 45 Exchange Act Section 21B(c), 15 U.S.C. § 78u-2(c). | |
| 46 See, e.g., Phlo Corp., Exchange Act Rel. No. 55562 (Mar. 30, 2007), 90 SEC | |
| Docket 1089, 1113 n.84 (imposing civil penalty against respondent "even though there is no | |
| evidence that unjust enrichment resulted from the violations and even though [the respondent] | |
| does not have a history of regulatory violations"). | |
| 47 In Commission investigations, when the recipient of an administrative subpoena | |
| requiring the production of documents or an appearance for the taking of testimony refuses to | |
| comply, the Commission has recourse to federal district court, which may issue an order | |
| enforcing the subpoena, "and any failure to obey such order of the court may be punished by such | |
| court as a contempt thereof." Exchange Act Section 21(c), 15 U.S.C. § 78u(c). | |
| 22 | |
| investigations. The recalcitrance manifested by Applicants, who had consented to cooperate with | |
| the Board's document production requests, interferes with and hinders the Board's performance of | |
| these important duties. Moreover, Applicants' failure to cooperate indirectly harmed investors by | |
| depriving them of important protection that they should have had under Sarbanes-Oxley. We | |
| therefore regard Applicants' refusal to cooperate with the investigation as very serious | |
| misconduct. | |
| The need for deterrence also supports a civil penalty. In imposing a civil penalty in | |
| addition to revocation and bar, the Board noted that if individuals are concerned that cooperation | |
| with an investigation may provide information that could lead to sanctions, those individuals – | |
| absent the threat of a civil penalty – could have an incentive to avoid cooperation in order to | |
| maximize their income from issuer audit work for as long as possible. As the Board observed, in | |
| public filings with the Commission, issuers disclosed having paid audit fees totaling $154,000 to | |
| the Firm for audit services performed during the period of Applicants' noncooperation. | |
| 48 The | |
| Board found that imposition of a civil penalty in such cases may act as a deterrent. We agree. | |
| The record would not support a finding of unjust enrichment, nor a finding of a history of | |
| prior misconduct. The absence of these factors is not determinative; in applying Section 21B in | |
| the context of administrative proceedings, we have found civil penalties appropriate "even | |
| though there is no evidence that unjust enrichment resulted from the violations and even though | |
| [the respondent] does not have a history of regulatory violations." | |
| 49 Moreover, we find that | |
| justice requires the consideration of several factors relevant to this matter that are not explicitly | |
| enumerated in Section 21B. The Firm collected $154,000 in audit fees from issuers for audit | |
| services performed during the period of Applicants' noncooperation. | |
| 50 Both the duration of the | |
| period of noncooperation and the amount of fees collected are factors that may be considered | |
| under Section 21B as "such other matters as justice may require." Additionally, Applicants' | |
| stalling, through statements that they were working on collecting the documents and merely | |
| needed more time (statements that were not supported by any other record evidence), while not | |
| clearly deceitful or fraudulent, is relevant to our consideration of whether a penalty is | |
| appropriate. | |
| 48 See Form 10-K/A filed by FTS Group, Inc. on May 15, 2008 (including REB audit | |
| report dated April 11, 2008 on financial statements for period ended December 31, 2007 and | |
| disclosing audit fees of $45,000 to REB); Form 10-KSB filed by Larrea Biosciences Corp. on | |
| August 6, 2007 (including REB audit report dated July 26, 2007 on financial statements for | |
| period ended April 30, 3007 and disclosing audit fees of $64,000 to REB); Form 10-K filed by | |
| FTS Group, Inc. on April 16, 2007 (including REB audit report dated April 11, 2007 on financial | |
| statements for period ended December 31, 2006 and disclosing audit fees of $45,000 to REB). | |
| 49 Phlo Corp., 90 SEC Docket at 1113 n.84. | |
| 50 See supra note 48. | |
| 23 | |
| For the reasons discussed above, we find the penalty justified.51 | |
| As noted above, Sarbanes-Oxley allows the imposition of a civil penalty as high as | |
| $800,000 against an individual for each violative act. The $75,000 penalty imposed by the Board | |
| is far below this limit.52 The Board explained that the penalty is designed in part as deterrence | |
| against avoiding cooperation in order to continue collecting audit fees during the pendency of an | |
| investigation. While imposing a larger penalty in this case might provide an even greater | |
| deterrent against similar stalling by other registered public accounting firms and their associated | |
| persons, a civil penalty of $75,000 appears sufficient to have a deterrent effect on a firm such as | |
| Bassie's. Under these circumstances, we find a civil penalty of $75,000 not excessive, | |
| oppressive, inadequate, or otherwise inappropriate. | |
| 53 | |
| 51 The consideration of "such other matters as justice may require" may result in the | |
| need to consider additional factors in future cases involving failure to cooperate with an | |
| investigation. | |
| 52 As noted above, a penalty not exceeding $110,000 would be allowed even if the | |
| misconduct at issue were not intentional or reckless. See supra note 44. | |
| 53 Applicants assert that "they do not possess the financial means to pay any civil | |
| fine, let alone $75,000," and they argue that the Commission "must provide Applicants with a | |
| separate opportunity to argue specifically against the imposition of a civil money penalty." | |
| Sarbanes-Oxley does not recognize ability to pay as a factor to consider in determining | |
| whether to impose a civil money penalty. In cases where the Commission may impose a penalty | |
| under Section 21B(c), the ability to pay may be considered, but it is only one factor, it is | |
| discretionary, and where, as here, the conduct is egregious, inability to pay may be disregarded. | |
| See, e.g., Thomas C. Bridge, Exchange Act Rel. No. 60736 (Sept. 29, 2009), 96 SEC Docket at | |
| 20848 (stating that "when conduct is 'sufficiently egregious,' the Commission may impose a | |
| sanction despite a demonstrated inability to pay" and refusing to grant discretionary waiver of | |
| penalties where egregiousness of conduct outweighed any reason to do so (citations omitted)), | |
| petition denied sub nom. Robles v. SEC, 2010 U.S. App. LEXIS 26537 (D.C. Cir. Dec. 30, 2010) | |
| (unpublished). | |
| Applicants had every opportunity to argue against the imposition of a civil penalty in their | |
| briefs, yet they gave no substantiation of their claim beyond making the flat statement that they | |
| could not pay. Moreover, although the briefing scheduling order expressly provided Applicants | |
| the opportunity to file a reply brief on appeal, Applicants did not take advantage of this | |
| opportunity. Under these circumstances, we find that Applicants did not establish that they were | |
| unable to pay the penalty, and we decline to grant them a separate hearing as to this issue. | |
| 24 | |
| For the foregoing reasons, we sustain the findings of misconduct and sanctions imposed | |
| by the PCAOB. | |
| An appropriate order will issue.54 | |
| By the Commission (Chairman SCHAPIRO and Commissioners WALTER, PAREDES | |
| and GALLAGHER); Commissioner AGUILAR not participating. | |
| Elizabeth M. Murphy | |
| Secretary | |
| 54 We have considered all of the arguments advanced by the parties. We reject or | |
| sustain them to the extent that they are inconsistent or in accord with the views expressed herein. | |
| Because the issues have been thoroughly briefed and can be adequately determined on the basis | |
| of the record filed by the parties, Applicants' request for oral argument is denied. Rule of | |
| Practice 451, 17 C.F.R. § 201.451. | |
| UNITED STATES OF AMERICA | |
| before the | |
| SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION | |
| ACCOUNTING AND AUDITING ENFORCEMENT | |
| Rel. No. 3354 / January 10, 2012 | |
| Admin. Proc. File No. 3-14130 | |
| In the Matter of the Application of | |
| R.E. BASSIE & CO. | |
| and | |
| R. EVERETT BASSIE, C.P.A. | |
| c/o Dwight E. Jefferson | |
| 405 Main Street, Suite 950 | |
| Houston, TX 77002 | |
| For Review of Disciplinary Action Taken by | |
| PCAOB | |
| ORDER SUSTAINING DISCIPLINARY ACTION TAKEN BY PUBLIC COMPANY | |
| ACCOUNTING OVERSIGHT BOARD | |
| On the basis of the Commission's opinion issued this day, it is | |
| ORDERED that PCAOB's findings that R.E. Bassie & Co. and R. Everett Bassie, C.P.A. | |
| failed to cooperate with an investigation by the Board's Division of Enforcement and | |
| Investigations be, and they hereby are, sustained; and it is further | |
| ORDERED that the sanctions imposed by PCAOB be, and they hereby are, sustained; and | |
| it is further | |
| ORDERED that the automatic stay of the Board sanctions imposed on Applicants | |
| pending the Commission's review be, and it hereby is, terminated. | |
| By the Commission. | |
| Elizabeth M. Murphy | |
| Secretary |