Download raw/aaer/2016/AAER-3746.txt from codewithdark/SEC-RPT-Panel: direct link, hf CLI and curl.
- Browser
- Download file 22.3 kB
-
https://huggingface.co/datasets/codewithdark/SEC-RPT-Panel/resolve/main/raw/aaer/2016/AAER-3746.txt
- Command line
-
hf download hf://datasets/codewithdark/SEC-RPT-Panel/raw/aaer/2016/AAER-3746.txt
-
curl -L -o AAER-3746.txt https://huggingface.co/datasets/codewithdark/SEC-RPT-Panel/resolve/main/raw/aaer/2016/AAER-3746.txt
22.3 kB
| UNITED STATES OF AMERICA | |
| Before the | |
| SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION | |
| SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934 | |
| Release No. 77207 / February 23, 2016 | |
| ACCOUNTING AND AUDITING ENFORCEMENT | |
| Release No. 3746 / February 23, 2016 | |
| ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDING | |
| File No. 3-17126 | |
| In the Matter of | |
| JASON MAIHER, | |
| Respondent. | |
| ORDER INSTITUTING | |
| ADMINISTRATIVE AND CEASE-AND- | |
| DESIST PROCEEDINGS PURSUANT | |
| TO SECTIONS 4C, 15(b) AND 21C OF | |
| THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT | |
| OF 1934, AND RULE 102(e) OF THE | |
| COMMISSION’S RULES OF | |
| PRACTICE | |
| I. | |
| The Securities and Exchange Commission (“Commission”) deems it appropriate | |
| and in the public interest that public administrative and cease-and-desist proceedings be, | |
| and hereby are, instituted pursuant to Sections 4C, 15(b) and 21C of the Securities | |
| Exchange Act of 1934 (“Exchange Act”) and Rule 102(e)(1)(iii) of the Commission’s | |
| Rules of Practice against Jason Maiher (“Respondent” or “Maiher”). | |
| II. | |
| After an investigation, the Division of Enforcement alleges that: | |
| A. RESPONDENT | |
| 1. Maiher, age 41, was KeyBanc Capital Markets Inc.’s (“KBCM”) | |
| Chief Financial Officer (“CFO”) from April 2007 through November 2011 and Series 27 | |
| Financial and Operations Principal (“FinOp”) from April 2007 through December 2011. | |
| KBCM terminated Maiher’s employment in May 2012. Maiher was primarily responsible | |
| for maintaining KBCM’s financial records. He submitted KBCM’s Annual Audited | |
| Report to the Commission and oversaw the filing of its monthly Financial and Operational | |
| Combined Uniform Single Reports (“FOCUS Reports”) with FINRA, which then furnished | |
| the FOCUS Reports to the Commission. Pursuant to internal policies and procedures that | |
| were applicable to KBCM, Maiher was required to certify after the close of each month | |
| that KBCM’s general ledger balance sheet information had been compared with, and | |
| 2 | |
| reconciled to, the underlying back-office system information. Maiher is currently an | |
| assistant controller for a wholly owned banking subsidiary of a publicly traded company. | |
| B. RELEVANT ENTITY | |
| 2. KBCM is a broker-dealer registered with the Commission and is a | |
| subsidiary of KeyCorp, a financial services company headquartered in Cleveland, Ohio. | |
| C. KBCM’S BOOKS AND RECORDS WERE INACCURATE | |
| 3. Beginning at some point prior to January 2011, and through January | |
| 2012, Maiher, who was KBCM’s CFO (until November 2011) and FinOp, directed that | |
| unsubstantiated or “plug” entries be made to one or more accounts in KBCM’s general | |
| ledger, in order to complete KBCM’s monthly close-the-books process. The amount of the | |
| plug entries varied over time. | |
| 4. The plug entries resulted in KBCM overstating its assets and income | |
| in its fiscal year 2010 financial statements, which were included in its fiscal year 2010 | |
| Annual Audited Report filed with the Commission in February 2011. Maiher signed this | |
| report, affirming that the accompanying financial statements were “true and correct.” | |
| 5. The plug entries to the general ledger also resulted in inaccurate | |
| financial information being included in KBCM’s monthly FOCUS Reports that Maiher | |
| caused to be filed with FINRA, which then furnished the FOCUS Reports to the | |
| Commission, for some point prior to January 2011 through January 2012. In 2012, | |
| KBCM filed amended FOCUS Reports. | |
| 6. In its Annual Audited Report for the year ended December 31, 2011, | |
| KBCM disclosed that its prior period financial statements (for fiscal year 2010) included | |
| unsubstantiated assets of $13,679,000 ($8,591,000 net of taxes) and omitted liabilities of | |
| $4,305,000 ($2,701,000 net of taxes). Specifically, the 2011 Annual Audited Report stated | |
| “[t]he December 31, 2010, Statement of Financial Condition included $13,679[,000] in net | |
| trade date receivables that was found to be unsubstantiated during 2011.” KBCM’s write- | |
| off of the unsubstantiated assets and accrual of the unrecorded liabilities resulted in restated | |
| net income of $3,136,000, a 78% reduction versus the previously reported $14,428,000, | |
| and restated shareholder’s equity of $316,796,000, an $11,292,000 reduction, from the | |
| previously reported $328,088,000. | |
| 3 | |
| D. RESPONDENT DIRECTED THAT PLUG ENTRIES BE MADE TO | |
| KBCM’S GENERAL LEDGER | |
| 7. KeyCorp’s written policies and procedures1 that were applicable to | |
| KBCM required KBCM’s finance department, led by Maiher, to reconcile certain general | |
| ledger accounts to the back office securities trading and inventory software system. The | |
| general ledger system was referred to as MSA. MSA was the source of the official books | |
| and records of KBCM. The back office system for KBCM was referred to as Broadridge. | |
| 8. The purpose of reconciling accounts was to ensure that the | |
| information in MSA was accurate. Generally, reconciliation is an accounting process used | |
| to compare two sets of records to ensure the figures are in agreement. During the relevant | |
| period, KeyCorp’s Reconcilement Process & Account Certification Procedure stated that | |
| the goal of reconciliation was “to verify that the balance and activity in the [general ledger] | |
| account agrees with the expected balance and activity as recorded elsewhere.” This | |
| document further explained that “[w]hen external reports are published to our shareholders | |
| and government agencies, it is critical that the general ledger system from which those | |
| reports are prepared be correct.” | |
| 9. The applicable policies and procedures required accounts to be | |
| reconciled on a periodic basis, which was generally daily or weekly “unless the account has | |
| very low transaction volume.” At a minimum, all accounts were to be reconciled monthly. | |
| 10. Among the accounts that Maiher and his team were required to | |
| reconcile were the firm’s inventory accounts. According to a KBCM Inventory | |
| Accounting Process Narrative, “KBCM buys, sells, and maintains inventory positions in | |
| federal, municipal, and corporate bonds and stocks in order to make markets, earn trading | |
| profits, or act as a wholesaler. KBCM makes markets for approximately 200 | |
| (OTC/NASDAQ) stocks.” Despite the fact that the inventory accounts did not have “very | |
| low transaction volume,” they were reconciled only monthly. | |
| 11. The applicable policies and procedures required Maiher to segregate | |
| the duties of preparing, reviewing, and certifying the inventory accounts reconciliations. | |
| Accordingly, one of KBCM’s accountants was responsible for preparing the | |
| reconciliations, KBCM’s Controller was responsible for reviewing the reconciliations, and | |
| Maiher was responsible for certifying them. Specifically, Maiher was responsible for | |
| timely certifying the inventory accounts in KeyCorp’s On-Line Certification System. | |
| 12. As explained in KeyCorp’s policies and procedures, Maiher’s | |
| certification of a general ledger account was a formal attestation that: properly documented | |
| controls and procedures were in place; reconciliations were routinely performed according | |
| to an established schedule; the reconciliation for the account was current; and the | |
| 1 The policies and procedures include “Policy ACC-403: KeyCorp Reconciliation and | |
| Certification Policy” and “Procedure AR-5001: Reconcilement Process & Account | |
| Certification.” | |
| 4 | |
| supporting sub-system, which is Broadridge in this instance, was in agreement with the | |
| general ledger. | |
| 13. Further, as stated in the policies and procedures, by certifying an | |
| account, Maiher was making himself “personally accountable for the integrity of the | |
| account” and stating that “a formal reconciliation, with all pertinent documentation, has | |
| been prepared and reviewed, and that all reconciling items have been adequately | |
| documented.” | |
| 14. As part of KBCM’s reconciliation process, any difference between | |
| related account balances in MSA and Broadridge needed to be identified and was | |
| considered a reconciling item. Reconciling items needed to be researched and resolved | |
| within established time limits. The inventory accounts were subject to a 30-day aging | |
| period, after which any unresolved differences between MSA and Broadridge were to be | |
| written off consistent with KeyCorp policy. The approval needed to charge off an item | |
| depended on the dollar amount. Maiher’s write-off authority was capped at $100,000 per | |
| KeyCorp policy. Stale items in excess of $100,000 were only to be written off with the | |
| approval of KeyCorp’s Chief Accounting Officer, CFO or Corporate Controller. | |
| 15. If a reconciling item was deemed a “reportable exception,” it needed | |
| to be recorded in the on-line certification system. A “reportable exception” was defined as | |
| a reconciling item “deemed significant enough to alert senior management to a potential | |
| problem which may indicate a breakdown of internal controls or present the possibility of | |
| significant loss.” Variances between MSA and Broadridge of $10,000 or more, which had | |
| not cleared through the normal transaction life cycle, fell into this category. | |
| 16. It was Maiher’s responsibility, as certifier of the inventory accounts, | |
| to describe any reportable exception in clear language, explain the efforts being made to | |
| correct the exception, and provide the anticipated date of resolution. Maiher had until the | |
| 20th of each month to timely certify the prior-month inventory account balances and | |
| document any reportable exceptions in the on-line certification system. Certifications | |
| submitted after the 20th were considered late. A monthly report summarizing the results of | |
| the certification program, including any reported exceptions, was provided to senior | |
| finance management of KeyCorp. As explained in the policies and procedures, “[t]his | |
| [exception reporting] afford[ed] senior management reasonable assurance that appropriate | |
| internal controls are in place and that problems are identified and resolved in a timely | |
| manner.” | |
| 17. Beginning at some point prior to 2011, and through January 2012, | |
| Maiher directed that “plug” entries be made to the general ledger in order to balance and be | |
| able to close the books on a monthly basis. | |
| 18. During 2010, 2011, and January 2012, as part of the monthly close- | |
| the-books process, at Maiher’s direction, the staff accountant populated the reconciliation | |
| spreadsheet for the inventory accounts. The initial iteration of this spreadsheet showed the | |
| variances between the general ledger and Broadridge. At Maiher’s direction, the staff | |
| accountant also prepared a corresponding “correcting entry” spreadsheet that, in more | |
| 5 | |
| summary fashion, compared the month-end MSA long and short inventory balances with | |
| the long and short inventory trade date balances in Broadridge. The “correcting entry” | |
| spreadsheet was a tool that served as the basis for a series of manual adjusting entries that | |
| were then made to the general ledger to make the general ledger match Broadridge. These | |
| adjusting entries were described as “Trade Date Long” or “Trade Date Short” and were | |
| made to the 129186 “Trading Inv-Other” and 273500 “Liab for Shrt Positions” accounts. | |
| The number of such adjusting entries, as well as the dollar amounts, varied by month. In | |
| 2011, there were typically 10 or more such adjusting entries made during the monthly | |
| close. After these entries were posted to the general ledger, the staff accountant updated | |
| the reconciliation spreadsheet; certain variances that appeared on the pre-close version of | |
| the spreadsheet were thus absent from the final version that was signed by Maiher as | |
| certifier, post-close. | |
| 19. The securities inventory reconciliation and the related “correcting | |
| entry” spreadsheet also computed manual adjustments that were made each month to | |
| general ledger accounts 196727 “Trade Date Receivable” and 299220 “Trade Date | |
| Payable.” Maiher directed these adjustments, in combination with the manual adjustments | |
| to accounts 129186 and 273500, to be made in order to purportedly reflect the MSA | |
| inventory account balances on a trade date basis for regulatory reporting purposes. An | |
| interface or graph between Broadridge and MSA automatically computed the firm’s trade | |
| date receivable and payable data on a daily basis. In approximately April 2011, Maiher had | |
| the interface turned off so that the trade date receivable and payable data was no longer | |
| being automatically fed into MSA and had to be computed manually. | |
| 20. If all of the month-end adjusting entries did not result in MSA | |
| balancing, the staff accountant, at Maiher’s direction, would include an additional adjusting | |
| entry to plug the unexplained difference in order to be able to close the books in the firm’s | |
| internal system. In most instances, Maiher directed that this plug entry be described as a | |
| “Trade Date Adjustment.” All of the manual adjusting entries were typically made on | |
| either day 1 or day 2 after the month-end and the books were closed on day 3. | |
| 21. For February, July, August, September, November, and December, | |
| Maiher directed that the additional plug entry, without which the books would not balance, | |
| be made to the “Trade Date Receivable” account. For March and October, Maiher directed | |
| that this additional adjusting entry be made to the “Trading Inv–Other” account. For | |
| January, April, May, and June, Maiher directed that this additional adjusting entry be made | |
| to an income statement account. Below are the additional adjusting entries that were made | |
| to balance and close the books monthly for December 2010 through December 2011: | |
| DATE ACCOUNT ENTRY DESCRIPTION | |
| Dec. 2010 482434 P/L 76,754.36 Inventory Adjustment | |
| Jan. 2011 482439 P/L 2,239,211.72 P&L Adjustment | |
| Feb. 2011 196727 Trade Date Receivable 2,949,720.49 Trade Date Adjustment | |
| Mar. 2011 129186 Trading Inv-Other (3,751,660.38) Trade Date Adjustment | |
| Apr. 2011 482439 P/L 440,170.57 Trade Date Adjustment | |
| May 2011 482439 P/L 1,893,944.88 Trade Date Adjustment | |
| June 2011 482439 P/L 152,539.67 Trade Date Adjustment | |
| 6 | |
| July 2011 196727 Trade Date Receivable 12,502,416,22 GPS Placeholder Offset | |
| Sept. 2011 196727 Trade Date Receivable 17,607,368.97 Trade Date Adjustment | |
| Oct. 2011 129186 Trading Inv-Other 31,618,733.55 Trade Date Adjustment | |
| Nov. 2011 196727 Trade Date Receivable 22,804,384.26 Trade Date Adjustment | |
| Dec. 2011 196727 Trade Date Receivable 18,674,052.00 Trade Date Adjustment | |
| 22. Although the purpose of the KBCM inventory reconciliation process | |
| was to identify, research and timely resolve any differences between corresponding account | |
| balances in MSA and the Broadridge subsystem, through the process undertaken by Maiher | |
| and his staff, differences were routinely eliminated through the expedient of adjusting | |
| entries made during the monthly close, after which the inventory account balances were | |
| certified by Maiher as reconciled. For example, for February, March, April and June 2011, | |
| Maiher certified the inventory accounts without an exception of any kind. For other | |
| months, he certified with exception(s) but did not disclose that there was an unexplained | |
| variance. Rather, he gave assurances the variance was or would be properly resolved. | |
| Maiher also repeatedly failed to certify the inventory accounts or report exceptions within | |
| the time period required by KeyCorp policy. | |
| 23. By coming up with the process by which the reconciler determined | |
| the adjusting entries, directing that they be made to the general ledger, and then certifying | |
| the inventory account reconciliations, Maiher also failed to ensure appropriate segregation | |
| of duties, in violation of the applicable policies and procedures. | |
| 24. KBCM hired a new CFO in November 2011. After he was hired, | |
| the new CFO discovered the variances after reviewing the most recent reconciliations and | |
| notified KBCM’s and KeyCorp’s management. Maiher did not begin to report that there | |
| was a potential unexplained variance until late in 2011, after the new CFO had been hired, | |
| and even then he was not transparent about the plug entries he had directed be made to | |
| balance the firm’s books. | |
| 25. Maiher was subsequently terminated from KBCM in May 2012. In | |
| the Form U5 termination notice that KBCM filed with the Financial Industry Regulatory | |
| Authority, KBCM explained that Maiher was terminated for “involvement in inaccurate | |
| entries in the firm’s general ledger, failure to ensure substantiating documentation relating | |
| to those entries and failure to ensure appropriate segregation of duties.” | |
| 26. Through the conduct described above, Maiher caused | |
| unsubstantiated entries to be made in the records of KBCM; caused the records of KBCM | |
| to be inaccurate; and caused false FOCUS Reports and financial statements to be filed with | |
| FINRA, which then furnished the FOCUS Reports to the Commission. | |
| E. VIOLATIONS | |
| 27. Section 17(a)(1) of the Exchange Act requires registered broker- | |
| dealers to make and keep records, and to make and disseminate reports prescribed by | |
| Commission rule. The requirements to make and keep required records includes the | |
| 7 | |
| requirement that such records be accurate. Rule 17a-3(a)(2) of the Exchange Act requires, | |
| among other things, that every broker-dealer make and keep current ledgers reflecting all | |
| assets and liabilities relating to the firm’s business. As a result of the conduct described | |
| above, KBCM violated Section 17(a) of the Exchange Act and Rule 17a-3(a)(2) thereunder | |
| because its general ledger did not accurately reflect all of the firm’s assets and liabilities. | |
| Section 17(e) of the Exchange Act requires registered broker-dealers to annually file with | |
| the Commission a balance sheet and income statement certified by a public accounting | |
| firm. Rule 17a-5(a) requires periodic FOCUS Reports. Rule 17a-5(d) requires registered | |
| broker-dealers to file with the Commission annual audited reports. KBCM violated | |
| Section 17(e) of the Exchange Act and Rules 17a-5(a) and 17a-5(d) thereunder by | |
| including unsubstantiated assets in its monthly FOCUS Reports filed with FINRA, which | |
| then furnished the FOCUS Reports to the Commission, prior to 2011 through January | |
| 2012, among other months, and in its fiscal year 2010 Annual Audited Report. | |
| 28. Respondent Maiher willfully aided and abetted and caused KBCM’s | |
| violations of Sections 17(a) and 17(e) of the Exchange Act and Rules 17a-3(a)(2), 17a-5(a), | |
| and 17a-5(d) thereunder. | |
| III. | |
| In view of the allegations made by the Division of Enforcement, the Commission | |
| deems it necessary and appropriate in the public interest that public administrative and | |
| cease-and-desist proceedings be instituted to determine: | |
| A. Whether the allegations set forth in Section II hereof are true and, in | |
| connection therewith, to afford Maiher an opportunity to establish any defenses to such | |
| allegations; | |
| B. What, if any, remedial action is appropriate in the public interest against | |
| Maiher pursuant to Section 15(b) of the Exchange Act including, but not limited to, civil | |
| penalties pursuant to Section 21B of the Exchange Act; | |
| C. What, if any, remedial action is appropriate in the public interest against | |
| Maiher pursuant to Section 4C of the Exchange Act and Rule 102(e)(1) of the | |
| Commission’s Rules of Practice; and | |
| D. Whether, pursuant to Section 21C of the Exchange Act, Maiher should be | |
| ordered to cease and desist from committing or causing violations of and any future | |
| violations of Section 17 of the Exchange Act and Rules 17a-3 and 17a-5 thereunder, | |
| whether Maiher should be ordered to pay a civil penalty pursuant to Section 21B(a) of the | |
| Exchange Act. | |
| IV. | |
| IT IS ORDERED that a public hearing for the purpose of taking evidence on the | |
| questions set forth in Section III hereof shall be convened not earlier than 30 days and not | |
| 8 | |
| later than 60 days from service of this Order at a time and place to be fixed, and before an | |
| Administrative Law Judge to be designated by further order as provided by Rule 110 of the | |
| Commission's Rules of Practice, 17 C.F.R. § 201.110. | |
| IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Maiher shall file an Answer to the allegations | |
| contained in this Order within twenty (20) days after service of this Order, as provided by | |
| Rule 220 of the Commission's Rules of Practice, 17 C.F.R. § 201.220. | |
| If Maiher fails to file the directed answer, or fails to appear at a hearing after being | |
| duly notified, he may be deemed in default and the proceedings may be determined against | |
| him upon consideration of this Order, the allegations of which may be deemed to be true as | |
| provided by Rules 155(a), 220(f), 221(f) and 310 of the Commission's Rules of Practice, 17 | |
| C.F.R. §§ 201.155(a), 201.220(f), 201.221(f) and 201.310. | |
| This Order shall be served forthwith upon Maiher as provided for in the | |
| Commission’s Rules of Practice. | |
| This Order shall be served upon Maiher as provided for in Rule 141(a)(2)(iv) of the | |
| Commission’s Rules of Practice, 17 C.F.R § 201.141(a)(2)(iv), by any method specified in | |
| paragraph (a)(2) of that rule, or by any other method reasonably calculated to give notice, | |
| provided that the method of service used is not prohibited by the law of the foreign country | |
| where Respondent may be found. | |
| IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the Administrative Law Judge shall issue an | |
| initial decision no later than 300 days from the date of service of this Order, pursuant to | |
| Rule 360(a)(2) of the Commission’s Rules of Practice. | |
| In the absence of an appropriate waiver, no officer or employee of the Commission | |
| engaged in the performance of investigative or prosecuting functions in this or any factually | |
| related proceeding will be permitted to participate or advise in the decision of this matter, | |
| except as witness or counsel in proceedings held pursuant to notice. Since this proceeding is | |
| not “rule making” within the meaning of Section 551 of the Administrative Procedure Act, it | |
| is not deemed subject to the provisions of Section 553 delaying the effective date of any | |
| final Commission action. | |
| By the Commission. | |
| Brent J. Fields | |
| Secretary | |