Download raw/aaer/2016/AAER-3754.txt from codewithdark/SEC-RPT-Panel: direct link, hf CLI and curl.
- Browser
- Download file 36.5 kB
-
https://huggingface.co/datasets/codewithdark/SEC-RPT-Panel/resolve/main/raw/aaer/2016/AAER-3754.txt
- Command line
-
hf download hf://datasets/codewithdark/SEC-RPT-Panel/raw/aaer/2016/AAER-3754.txt
-
curl -L -o AAER-3754.txt https://huggingface.co/datasets/codewithdark/SEC-RPT-Panel/resolve/main/raw/aaer/2016/AAER-3754.txt
36.5 kB
| UNITED STATES OF AMERICA | |
| Before the | |
| SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION | |
| SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934 | |
| Release No. 77343 / March 10, 2016 | |
| ACCOUNTING AND AUDITING ENFORCEMENT | |
| Release No. 3754 / March 10, 2016 | |
| ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDING | |
| File No. 3-17164 | |
| In the Matter of | |
| Wayne Gray, CPA, | |
| Respondent. | |
| ORDER INSTITUTING PUBLIC | |
| ADMINISTRATIVE AND CEASE- | |
| AND-DESIST PROCEEDINGS | |
| PURSUANT TO SECTIONS 4C AND 21C | |
| OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT | |
| OF 1934 AND RULE 102(e) OF THE | |
| COMMISSION’S RULES OF PRACTICE, | |
| MAKING FINDINGS, AND IMPOSING | |
| REMEDIAL SANCTIONS AND A CEASE- | |
| AND-DESIST ORDER | |
| I. | |
| The Securities and Exchange Commission (“Commission”) deems it appropriate that public | |
| administrative and cease-and-desist proceedings be, and hereby are, instituted against Wayne Gray, | |
| CPA (“Respondent” or “Gray”) pursuant to Sections 4C1 and 21C of the Securities Exchange Act | |
| 1 Section 4C provides, in relevant part, that: | |
| The Commission may censure any person, or deny, temporarily or permanently, | |
| to any person the privilege of appearing or practicing before the Commission in | |
| any way, if that person is found . . . (1) not to possess the requisite qualifications | |
| to represent others . . . (2) to be lacking in character or integrity, or to have | |
| engaged in unethical or improper professional conduct; or (3) to have willfully | |
| violated, or willfully aided and abetted the violation of, any provision of the | |
| securities laws or the rules and regulations thereunder. | |
| 2 | |
| of 1934 (“Exchange Act”) and Rule 102(e)(1)(ii) and 102(e)(1)(iii) of the Commission’s Rules of | |
| Practice.2 | |
| II. | |
| In anticipation of the institution of these proceedings, Respondent has submitted an Offer | |
| of Settlement (the “Offer”) which the Commission has determined to accept. Solely for the | |
| purpose of these proceedings and any other proceedings brought by or on behalf of the | |
| Commission, or to which the Commission is a party, and without admitting or denying the findings | |
| herein, except as to the Commission’s jurisdiction over him and the subject matter of these | |
| proceedings, which are admitted, Respondent consents to the entry of this Order Instituting Public | |
| Administrative and Cease-and-Desist Proceedings Pursuant to Sections 4C and 21C of the | |
| Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and Rule 102(e) of the Commission’s Rules of Practice, Making | |
| Findings, and Imposing Remedial Sanctions and a Cease-and-Desist Order (“Order”), as set forth | |
| below. | |
| III. | |
| On the basis of this Order and Respondent’s Offer, the Commission finds3 that: | |
| A. SUMMARY | |
| 1. This proceeding concerns failures by Magnum Hunter Resources Corporation | |
| (“MHR” or “the Company”) and its management to properly implement, maintain, and evaluate | |
| internal control over financial reporting (“ICFR”) for the fiscal year-ended December 31, 2011 and | |
| to maintain ICFR sufficient to keep pace with MHR’s growth from at least the fiscal year-ended | |
| December 31, 2011 through the quarter-ended September 30, 2013. MHR’s failures resulted in | |
| part from Ronald D. Ormand (“Ormand”) and David S. Krueger (“Krueger”) improperly | |
| evaluating the severity of identified control deficiencies. | |
| 2 Rule 102(e)(1)(ii) provides, in pertinent part, that: | |
| The Commission may . . . deny, temporarily or permanently, the privilege of | |
| appearing or practicing before it . . . to any person who is found . . . to have | |
| engaged in unethical or improper professional conduct. | |
| Rule 102(e)(1)(iii) provides, in pertinent part, that: | |
| The Commission may . . . deny, temporarily or permanently, the privilege of | |
| appearing or practicing before it . . . to any person who is found…to have | |
| willfully violated, or willfully aided and abetted the violation of any provision of | |
| the Federal securities laws or the rules and regulations thereunder. | |
| 3 The findings herein are made pursuant to Respondent's Offer of Settlement and are not | |
| binding on any other person or entity in this or any other proceeding. | |
| 3 | |
| 2. This proceeding also concerns the improper professional conduct by Gray. With | |
| Gray as the engagement partner, an audit report expressing an unqualified opinion on MHR’s | |
| ICFR as of December 31, 2011 was issued that incorrectly stated that the audit was conducted in | |
| accordance with Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (“PCAOB”) standards. This, at | |
| least in part, caused MHR’s violations. | |
| B. RESPONDENT AND RELATED ENTITIES AND INDIVIDUALS | |
| i. Respondent | |
| 3. Gray is a resident of Plano, Texas and a former partner at a PCAOB-registered | |
| public accounting firm. Gray was the engagement partner responsible for providing MHR’s | |
| external auditing services for the December 31, 2009 through June 30, 2012 reporting periods. | |
| Gray is a CPA licensed in the state of Texas. | |
| ii. Other Relevant Entities and Individuals | |
| 4. MHR is a Delaware corporation headquartered in Irving, Texas that operates as an | |
| independent oil and gas company engaged in the exploration and production of oil and gas in the | |
| United States. At all relevant times, MHR’s stock was registered with the Commission pursuant to | |
| Section 12(b) of the Exchange Act and traded on the New York Stock Exchange (“NYSE”). At all | |
| relevant times, MHR filed periodic reports with the Commission, including Forms 10-K and 10-Q, | |
| pursuant to Section 13(a) of the Exchange Act and related rules thereunder. On December 15, | |
| 2015, MHR filed a Form 8-K disclosing that the Company and certain subsidiaries had filed | |
| voluntary petitions for reorganization under Chapter 11 of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code. | |
| 5. Ormand is a resident of Houston, Texas and was MHR’s Chief Financial Officer | |
| (“CFO”) from May 2009 through July 2013. | |
| 6. Krueger is a resident of Flower Mound, Texas and was MHR’s Chief Accounting | |
| Officer (“CAO”) from October 2009 through October 2012. He was previously licensed as a CPA | |
| in the states of Arkansas and Oklahoma. | |
| 7. Joseph Allred, CPA (“Allred”) is a resident of Arlington, Texas and is a partner at | |
| a PCAOB-registered public accounting firm. Allred was responsible for the firm’s engagement | |
| that provided Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 (“SOX”) consulting and internal auditing services to | |
| MHR from 2009 through 2012. These services included assisting MHR with documenting, | |
| evaluating, testing, and improving accounting and reporting processes. | |
| C. FACTS | |
| i. Statutory requirements regarding ICFR | |
| 8. Section 13(b)(2)(B) of the Exchange Act makes public companies responsible for | |
| devising and maintaining a system of internal accounting controls sufficient to provide reasonable | |
| 4 | |
| assurance that transactions are recorded as necessary to permit preparation of financial statements | |
| in conformity with GAAP. See 15 U.S.C. §78m(b)(2)(B). | |
| 9. Exchange Act Rule 13a-15(a) requires issuers, including MHR, to maintain ICFR.4 | |
| See 17 C.F.R. 240.13a-15(a). Rule 13a-15(f) defines ICFR as: | |
| [A] process designed by, or under the supervision of, the issuer’s principal | |
| executive and principal financial officers, or persons performing similar functions, | |
| and effected by the issuer’s board of directors, management and other personnel, to | |
| provide reasonable assurance regarding the reliability of financial reporting and the | |
| preparation of financial statements for externa l purposes in accordance with | |
| generally accepted accounting principles[.] 17 C.F.R. 240.13a-15(f). | |
| 10. Exchange Act Rule 13a-15(c) requires management—together with the | |
| participation of principal executive and principal financial officers (or persons performing similar | |
| functions)—to evaluate the effectiveness of ICFR as of the end of each fiscal year. See 17 C.F.R. | |
| 240.13a-15(c). Under Rule 13a-15(c), management may satisfy its obligations by conducting an | |
| evaluation in accordance with interpretive guidance issued by the Commission in Release | |
| No. 34-55929, Commission Guidance Regarding Management’s Report on Internal Control Over | |
| Financial Reporting Under Section 13(a) or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, (the | |
| “2007 Guidance”). | |
| 11. Item 308 of Regulation S-K requires management to provide an annual report that | |
| contains its assessment of the effectiveness of ICFR and any material weakness in ICFR. Under | |
| Item 308, “[m]anagement is not permitted to conclude that the registrant’s [ICFR] is effective if | |
| there are one or more material weaknesses in the registrant’s [ICFR].” 17 C.F.R. 229.308. | |
| 12. Item 308 of Regulation S-K further instructs that the registrant “must maintain | |
| evidential matter, including documentation, to provide reasonable support for management’s | |
| assessment of the effectiveness of the registrant’s [ICFR].” The 2007 Guidance similarly states | |
| that “[m]anagement is responsible for maintaining evidential matter, including documentation to | |
| provide reasonable support for its assessment.” | |
| 13. Rule 1-02(a)(4) of Regulation S-X defines categories of ICFR deficiencies based on | |
| the severity, as follows: | |
| A “material weakness” is a “deficiency, or a combination of deficiencies, in [ICFR] | |
| such that there is a reasonable possibility that a material misstatement of the company’s | |
| annual or interim financial statements will not be prevented or detected on a timely | |
| basis.” See 17 C.F.R. 210.1-02(a)(4) (emphasis added). A misstatement is reasonably | |
| possible if the chance of a misstatement is more than remote but less than likely. See | |
| 4 Rule 13a-15(c) applies to issuers whose securities are registered under Section 12 of the | |
| Exchange Act and who are required either to file annual reports under Section 13(a) or 15(d) of | |
| the Exchange Act for the prior fiscal year or filed an annual report for the prior fiscal year. | |
| 5 | |
| 2007 Guidance at 34-35, n. 47 (citing Financial Accounting Standards Board Statement | |
| No. 5, Accounting for Contingencies5). | |
| A “significant deficiency” is a “deficiency, or a combination of deficiencies, in [ICFR] | |
| that is less severe than a material weakness, yet important enough to merit attention by | |
| those responsible for oversight of the registrant’s financial reporting.” Id. | |
| 14. The “severity of a deficiency in ICFR does not depend on whether a misstatement | |
| actually has occurred but rather on whether there is a reasonable possibility that the company’s | |
| ICFR will fail to prevent or detect a misstatement on a timely basis.”6 See 2007 Guidance at 35 | |
| (emphasis added). | |
| 15. Item 308(a)(3) of Regulation S-K requires public companies such as MHR to | |
| annually provide a report of management that discloses material weaknesses that have been | |
| identified by management. They are not required to publicly disclose significant deficiencies. | |
| 16. Exchange Act Rule 13a-14 requires that every Form 10-Q and 10-K include | |
| certifications signed by each principal executive and principal financial officer (or persons | |
| performing similar functions). See 17 C.F.R. 240.13a-14. The certifying officers must confirm | |
| that the Form 10-Q or 10-K does not contain any untrue statement of a material fact or omit to state | |
| a material fact necessary to make the statements made, in light of the circumstances under which | |
| such statements were made, not misleading. Id. Ormand certified MHR’s 2011 Form 10-K and | |
| March 31, 2012 and June 30, 2012 Forms 10-Q. | |
| 17. As detailed further below, MHR engaged Allred's firm to assist its management | |
| with the documentation, testing, and evaluation of the company’s ICFR in 2010, 2011, and 2012. | |
| Notwithstanding MHR’s reliance on the firm's services, MHR’s management—including Ormand | |
| and Krueger—were ultimately responsible for its conclusions about the effectiveness of MHR’s | |
| ICFR. | |
| 5 FASB Statement No. 5 is available at | |
| http://www.fasb.org/jsp/FASB/Document_C/DocumentPage?cid=1218220126761&acceptedDis | |
| claimer=true. It defines “reasonably possible” as: “The chance of the future event or events | |
| occurring is more than remote but less than likely.” FASB No. 5 at 4. It defines “remote” as: | |
| “The chance of the future event or events occurring is slight.” Id. | |
| 6 See FR-77, Commission Guidance Regarding Management’s Report on Internal Control Over | |
| Financial Reporting Under Section 13(a) or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (June | |
| 27, 2007) (“Commission Guidance”), available at http://www.sec.gov/rules/interp/2007/33- | |
| 8810.pdf. | |
| 6 | |
| ii. MHR’s Rapid Growth and Strained Accounting Resources | |
| 18. MHR’s rapid growth strained its accounting resources. For example, MHR grew | |
| from $6 million in revenues in 2009 to $23 million in 2010, largely as the result of an $82 million | |
| acquisition in February 2010. In connection with the issuance of the external auditor’s report on | |
| MHR’s 2010 year-end audit results, Gray informed Ormand, Krueger, and MHR’s Audit | |
| Committee in February 2011 that MHR’s accounting department was experiencing “manpower | |
| issues” and lacked sufficient personnel to complete all required tasks on a timely basis. | |
| 19. Between December 2010 and April 2011, MHR acquired another $70 million in oil | |
| and gas properties and leasehold mineral interests. MHR also completed two other acquisitions in | |
| April and May 2011 for an aggregate purchase price of approximately $565 million. In 2011, | |
| MHR booked over $100 million in revenues—largely as a result of these acquisitions. This rapid | |
| growth created a significant burden on MHR’s accounting department. For example, beginning in | |
| November 2011 MHR failed to complete its standard monthly close process and began formally | |
| closing its books on a quarterly basis with only sporadic monthly closes in 2012. | |
| iii. MHR’s ICFR assessment as of December 31, 2011 | |
| a. Allred identified MHR’s insufficient accounting staffing as a control deficiency | |
| as of December 31, 2011. | |
| 20. Allred led consulting engagements to document and test MHR’s ICFR. In February | |
| 2012, his firm issued a written report on MHR’s ICFR to certain MHR managers—including | |
| Ormand and Krueger—and MHR’s Audit Committee. The report identified problems in MHR’s | |
| accounting department, including that the “accounting and financial reporting team has | |
| experienced significant delays in preparing financial statements and reports.” As a result, Allred's | |
| team could not complete its testing activities within the time period originally scheduled. The | |
| report further stated that two balance sheet account reconciliations for the month ending October | |
| 2011 were not reviewed and approved in a timely manner and that management review of the | |
| consolidated October 2011 financial statements had not been formally documented. | |
| 21. As of December 31, 2011, the report identified control deficiencies within MHR’s | |
| accounting function, including: (a) instances in which reconciliations were not prepared, reviewed, | |
| or approved on a timely basis; (b) failures to document the completion of required monthly | |
| management reviews; and (c) significant delays in preparing financial statements and reports due | |
| to “inadequate and inappropriately aligned staffing.” The report stated: | |
| [T]he potential for error in such a compressed work environment presents | |
| substantial risk. With complex financial and reporting structures there are few | |
| individuals within the team with the capacity to perform many tasks and there is | |
| little time for senior reporting personnel to review, analyze, and evaluate because | |
| they are performing transaction level reporting tasks. (emphasis added) | |
| 22. The report concluded, without explanation, that MHR’s staffing deficiency | |
| represented only a significant deficiency—rather than a material weakness. The report did not | |
| 7 | |
| explain how a deficiency that created a “substantial risk” of a financial statement error did not rise | |
| to the level of a material weakness, defined as a deficiency in ICFR that creates a reasonable | |
| possibility of a material misstatement not being prevented or detected on a timely basis. | |
| 23. Krueger and Ormand accepted the assessment that MHR’s insufficient accounting | |
| staffing represented a significant deficiency. Both Krueger and Ormand also relied on the absence | |
| of an actual identified material error in MHR’s financial statements as evidence that a material | |
| weakness did not exist as of December 31, 2011. Neither Krueger nor Ormand prepared any | |
| documentary evidence to supplement the documentation created by Allred's team. Consequently, | |
| the only documentation that supports MHR management’s assessment of the effectiveness of | |
| MHR’s ICFR as of December 31, 2011 is the documentation created by Allred's team and | |
| provided to MHR management. | |
| 24. Because MHR management concluded that the control deficiency only rose to the | |
| level of a significant deficiency, rather than a material weakness, MHR did not publicly disclose | |
| the deficiency but instead stated that its ICFR was effective. | |
| b. Gray Misapplied the Applicable Standard When Determining the Severity of | |
| MHR’s Control Deficiency as of December 31, 2011. | |
| 25. Gray failed to conduct the 2011 audit of MHR’s ICFR in accordance with PCAOB | |
| Auditing Standards No. 3, Audit Documentation (“AS3”), and No. 5, An Audit of Internal Control | |
| Over Financial Reporting That Is Integrated with An Audit of Financial Statements (“AS5”) and | |
| improperly approved the issuance of the external auditor’s audit report containing an unqualified | |
| opinion on MHR’s ICFR as of December 31, 2011. | |
| 26. In February 2012, a year after first raising concerns over MHR’s accounting | |
| “manpower issues,” Gray reported to MHR’s Audit Committee a “[d]elay in closing the books due | |
| to [the] Company manpower shortage relative to [the] volume of financial activity.” This resulted | |
| in “[n]umerous top-side adjustments” creating significant audit inefficiencies. | |
| 27. Gray, as engagement partner, further reported that: | |
| We believe there is not adequate internal control over financial reporting due to | |
| inadequate and inappropriately aligned staffing. This factor increases the | |
| possibility of a material error occurring and being undetected a nd reduces the | |
| Company’s ability to file its 10-K on time. | |
| 28. Despite assessing that there was “not adequate internal control over financial | |
| reporting due to inadequate and inappropriately aligned staffing,” Gray concluded that this control | |
| deficiency rose to the level of a significant deficiency—rather than a material weakness. The audit | |
| work papers failed to adequately document the basis for this conclusion. They also failed to | |
| explain how the fact that MHR did “not [have] adequate internal control over financial reporting” | |
| was not indicative of a material weakness, defined as weakness that creates a reasonable possibility | |
| 8 | |
| (i.e., “more than remote but less than likely”) of a material error not being detected or corrected on | |
| a timely basis. | |
| 29. When reporting audit results on the effectiveness of MHR’s ICFR as of | |
| December 31, 2011 to MHR’s Audit Committee, Gray identified MHR’s “inadequate and | |
| inappropriately aligned staffing” as a significant deficiency rather than as a material weakness. | |
| 30. Gray determined that MHR’s inadequate and inappropriately aligned accounting | |
| staff did not constitute a material weakness because, among other things: (i) the audit work did not | |
| identify material errors for the reporting period, and (ii) he understood that MHR had recently | |
| hired additional accounting staff and that the existing staff, while overworked, was competent. | |
| 31. However, this was a misapplication of the applicable standards. As the engagement | |
| partner who led the audit of the effectiveness of MHR’s ICFR, Gray improperly applied the | |
| definitions of “material weakness” and “significant deficiency” codified in Rule 1-02(a)(4) of | |
| Regulation S-X and Appendix A of AS 5. The severity of a deficiency does not depend on | |
| whether an error actually occurred. AS 5, ¶ 64. | |
| 32. Notwithstanding the systemic importance of an entity-level control, the written | |
| analysis was deficient for two reasons. First, it failed to apply the appropriate standard for defining | |
| a material weakness. Second, it failed to evaluate the severity of MHR’s control deficiency in | |
| accordance with AS 5 because it did not adequately consider: (a) the misstatement that might result | |
| from having insufficient accounting staff; (b) MHR’s ability to prepare accurate financial | |
| statements based on the possible future consequences of the deficiency; (c) the amounts and | |
| transactions exposed to the deficiency; or (d) the volume of activity exposed to the deficiency that | |
| occurred in the current period or that is expected in future periods. AS 5, ¶¶ 62-70. | |
| 33. Gray also failed to adequately document the basis for his conclusion. Under AS 3, | |
| “[a]udit documentation should be prepared in sufficient detail to provide a clear understanding of | |
| its purpose, source, and the conclusions reached.” AS 3, ¶ 4. “The auditor must document the | |
| procedures performed, evidence obtained, and conclusions reached with respect to relevant | |
| financial statement assertions.” AS 3, ¶ 6. “Audit documentation must clearly demonstrate that the | |
| work was in fact performed.” AS 3, ¶ 6. | |
| 34. The only written audit documentation assessing the severity of MHR’s accounting | |
| staffing deficiency was a summary spreadsheet purportedly identifying all MHR control | |
| deficiencies for the 2011 reporting period. It documented the conclusion that MHR’s control | |
| deficiency did not rise above a significant deficiency for three main reasons: (i) MHR hired a | |
| controller and several senior level accountants during the latter part of 2011; (ii) MHR was in the | |
| process of integrating two major acquisitions completed in the second quarter of 2011 and the | |
| delay in the close process was mostly due to integration across entities; and (iii) individual analysis | |
| of two identified audit adjustments did not support a conclusion of a more severe control | |
| deficiency. | |
| 9 | |
| 35. In doing so, Gray failed to evaluate MHR’s deficiencies in accordance with AS 5. | |
| Auditors “must evaluate the severity of each control deficiency that comes to his or her attention to | |
| determine whether the deficiencies, individually or in combination, are material weaknesses as of | |
| the date of management’s assessment.” AS 5, ¶ 62 (emphasis in original). | |
| c. MHR’s Management Retained Ultimate Responsibility for Evaluating the | |
| Severity of Any Control Deficiencies. | |
| 36. MHR disclosed in its 2011 Form 10-K that: | |
| Under the supervision and with the participation of our management, including our | |
| Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer, we assessed the effectiveness | |
| of our internal controls over financial reporting as of the end of the period covered | |
| by this report based on the framework in “Internal Control – Integrated | |
| Framework” issued by the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the | |
| Treadway Commission. Based on that assessment, our Chief Executive Officer and | |
| Chief Financial Officer concluded that our internal controls over financial reporting | |
| were effective as of December 31, 2011 to provide reasonable assurance regarding | |
| the reliability of our financial reporting and the preparation of our financial | |
| statements for external purposes in accordance with U.S. generally accepted | |
| accounting principles. | |
| See MHR Fiscal Year 2011 Form 10-K at p. F-53. | |
| 37. When determining whether a deficiency constitutes a material weakness, | |
| management should consider all relevant information,7 including information provided by outside | |
| parties. While MHR management retained ultimate responsibility for assessing MHR’s ICFR, | |
| including evaluating the severity of any deficiencies in ICFR,8 the information provided by Allred | |
| and Gray was relevant to its assessment. In addition, MHR’s management was responsible for | |
| maintaining documentation to support its assessment.9 | |
| 38. Ormand and Krueger had knowledge of the stress placed on MHR’s accounting | |
| department as a result of its rapid growth. Nonetheless, they did not sufficiently consider Allred’s | |
| or Gray’s findings in analyzing the severity of the control deficiencies, or the appropriateness of | |
| Allred’s and Gray’s conclusions in light of all other information which they were aware. | |
| Additionally, as discussed further below, MHR failed to maintain required evidential matter— | |
| including documentation—providing reasonable support for its assessment. | |
| 7 2007 Guidance at 37. | |
| 8 17 CFR 240.13a-15(c). | |
| 9 Instruction No. 2 to Item 308 of Regulation S-K. | |
| 10 | |
| d. MHR’s Documentation Indicated That Krueger Failed to Review MHR’s Q3 | |
| 2011 Form 10-Q on a Timely Basis. | |
| 39. One of the consequences of MHR’s staffing deficiency resulted in Krueger signing | |
| off on MHR’s third quarter 2011 Form 10-Q five days after the Form 10-Q was filed with the | |
| Commission. Because Krueger was the CAO—and highest ranking officer with an accounting | |
| background—responsible for reviewing MHR’s periodic reports prior to filing them with the | |
| Commission, MHR had no compensating control10 in its ICFR. | |
| e. MHR Failed to Adequately Document its Assessment of ICFR. | |
| 40. Item 308 of Regulation S-K requires and the 2007 Guidance states that | |
| management must maintain documentation to provide reasonable support for its assessment of the | |
| effectiveness of the company’s ICFR. | |
| 41. However, in its year-end 2011 assessment, MHR failed to generate or maintain | |
| documentation supporting its basis for determining the severity of its accounting staff deficiency. | |
| It thus did not adequately document its basis for concluding that the deficiency was a significant | |
| deficiency—rather than a material weakness. This was true even though MHR management, and | |
| Ormand and Krueger specifically, had been informed that: (a) there was a “substantial risk” of an | |
| error (by Allred); and (b) “there is not adequate internal control over financial reporting” (by | |
| Gray). | |
| 42. The control deficiency caused by MHR’s inadequate accounting staffing was | |
| particularly important because it was an entity-level control. Because it was an important control | |
| that could affect other controls throughout the company, it needed to be fully understood and | |
| defined in order to determine the nature, extent, and severity of the deficiencies. | |
| f. MHR Management Misapplied the Appropriate Definition When Determining | |
| the Severity of MHR’s Control Deficiency as of December 31, 2011. | |
| 43. Ormand and Krueger failed to apply the appropriate standard when determining the | |
| severity of MHR’s internal control deficiency. As detailed above, while actual errors may inform | |
| assessments of control deficiencies, the presence of an actual error is not a prerequisite to | |
| concluding that a material weakness exists. Rather, management is to consider whether there is a | |
| reasonable possibility that a material misstatement will not be timely detected or prevented. In | |
| addition, the effectiveness of a company’s ICFR is assessed at a specific point in time—as of the | |
| end of the fiscal reporting period. Planned or anticipated remedial efforts are irrelevant to the | |
| analysis. | |
| 44. Ormand and Krueger improperly assessed the severity of the control deficiency | |
| caused by MHR’s “inadequate and inappropriately aligned staffing” as of December 31, 2011. | |
| 10 “Compensating controls are controls that serve to accomplish the objective of another control | |
| that did not function properly, helping to reduce risk to an acceptable level.” 2007 Guidance at | |
| n. 49. | |
| 11 | |
| MHR management should have assessed whether a reasonable possibility existed that a material | |
| misstatement of the company’s financial statements would not be prevented or detected on a timely | |
| basis. | |
| iv. MHR’s Disclosure of the Existence of Material Weaknesses | |
| a. MHR Restates its June 30, 2012 Form 10-Q and Discloses Material | |
| Weaknesses. | |
| 45. On November 14, 2012, MHR filed an amended Form 10-Q restating its June 30, | |
| 2012 financial statements to correct a material error related to stock-based compensation and | |
| certain other errors. MHR disclosed that management concluded that material weaknesses existed | |
| as of June 30, 2012 related to (i) a lack of sufficient, qualified personnel to design and manage an | |
| effective control environment; (ii) MHR’s period-end financial reporting process; and (iii) controls | |
| over calculation and review of share-based compensation expense. MHR also disclosed | |
| management’s plans to remediate and improve the company’s ICFR and disclosure controls and | |
| procedures. | |
| 46. Before restating, MHR’s Audit Committee met on October 19, 2012 to understand | |
| how the company had materially understated option based compensation expense in the second | |
| quarter. Ormand reported that the person responsible for reviewing the calculation signed off | |
| without reviewing it. Also at that meeting, Gray “restated that the root cause [of the error] was | |
| inadequate and inappropriately aligned staffing of the accounting department.” | |
| b. MHR’s Disclosed Material Weaknesses in its September 30, 2012 Form 10-Q. | |
| 47. On November 13, 2012, MHR’s Audit Committee met and approved the | |
| company’s Form 10-Q for the third quarter-ended September 30, 2012. That filing disclosed the | |
| same three material weaknesses existed at September 30, 2012 that had been disclosed in MHR’s | |
| amended June 30, 2012 Form 10-Q. | |
| c. MHR Delinquently Files its 2012 Form 10-K and Discloses Material | |
| Weaknesses. | |
| 48. MHR delinquently filed its 2012 Form 10-K on June 14, 2013. In it, MHR | |
| disclosed fourteen material weaknesses as of December 31, 2012, including that “[i]n certain areas | |
| the Company did not have sufficient personnel with an appropriate level of knowledge, experience | |
| and training commensurate with the growth of the Company's corporate structure and financial | |
| reporting requirements” and not upgrading “resources around internal audit, tax, financial reporting | |
| and certain accounting areas.” | |
| 49. MHR’s internal analysis of the material weaknesses posed by its understaffed | |
| accounting department, as disclosed in its 2012 Form 10-K, recognized that the “significant | |
| deficiency identified at year-end 2011 does not appear[] to be remediated. Personnel do not appear | |
| to have the competence and training necessary for their assigned level of responsibility.” | |
| 12 | |
| v. MHR Remediates Inadequate and Inappropriately Aligned Staffing in the | |
| Third Quarter 2013 | |
| 50. On November 8, 2013, MHR filed its Form 10-Q for the quarter-ended September | |
| 30, 2013. While concluding that the Company’s ICFR was not effective as of September 30, 2013, | |
| management concluded that the material weakness that existed at quarter-end concerning | |
| accounting staff inadequacies had subsequently been remediated. | |
| D. VIOLATIONS | |
| i. Gray Willfully Aided and Abetted Violations of Rule 2-02(b)(1) of Regulation | |
| S-X; Caused MHR’s Violations of Section 13(a) of the Exchange Act and Rule | |
| 13a-1 thereunder; and Engaged in Improper Professional Conduct Subject to the | |
| Commission’s Rules of Practice 102(e)(1)(ii) and (iii). | |
| 51. Gray engaged in improper professional conduct by failing to conduct the 2011 audit | |
| of MHR’s ICFR in accordance with PCAOB Standards. First, Gray failed to properly evaluate | |
| identified deficiencies using the appropriate standard of a material weakness as defined in Rule 1- | |
| 02(a)(4) of Regulation S-X and AS 5. Second, Gray failed to document the basis of his conclusion | |
| in a manner consistent with AS 3. | |
| 52. Rule 2-02(b)(1) of Regulation S-X requires an accountant’s report to state whether | |
| the audit was made in accordance with PCAOB Standards. Gray willfully aided and abetted | |
| violations of Rule 2-02(b)(1) of Regulation S-X by approving the issuance of an audit report | |
| expressing an unqualified opinion on MHR’s ICFR which inaccurately stated that MHR’s audit | |
| was conducted in accordance with PCAOB Standards. | |
| 53. As a result of the conduct described above, Gray caused MHR’s violations of | |
| Section 13(a) of the Exchange Act and Rule 13a-1 thereunder, which require issuers with classes | |
| of securities registered pursuant to Section 12 to file periodic and other reports with the | |
| Commission. | |
| 54. As a result of the conduct described above, Gray engaged in improper professional | |
| conduct subject to the Commission’s Rules of Practice 102(e)(1)(ii). Gray’s willful aiding and | |
| abetting violation of Rule 2-02(b)(1) of Regulation S-X also constitutes conduct subject to the | |
| Commission’s Rules of Practice 102(e)(1)(iii). | |
| IV. | |
| In view of the foregoing, the Commission deems it appropriate to impose the sanctions | |
| agreed to in Respondent’s Offer. | |
| Accordingly, it is hereby ORDERED, effective immediately, that: | |
| 13 | |
| A. Gray shall cease and desist from committing or causing any violations and any | |
| future violations of Rule 2-02(b)(1) of Regulation S-X, Section 13(a) of the Exchange Act and Rule | |
| 13a-1 promulgated thereunder. | |
| B. Gray is denied the privilege of appearing or practicing before the Commission as an | |
| accountant. | |
| C. After one year from the date of this order, Respondent may request that the | |
| Commission consider his reinstatement by submitting an application (attention: Office of the | |
| Chief Accountant) to resume appearing or practicing before the Commission as: | |
| 1. a preparer or reviewer, or a person responsible for the preparation or | |
| review, of any public company’s financial statements that are filed with | |
| the Commission. Such an application must satisfy the Commission that | |
| Respondent’s work in his practice before the Commission will be | |
| reviewed either by the independent audit committee of the public company | |
| for which he works or in some other acceptable manner, as long as he | |
| practices before the Commission in this capacity; and/or | |
| 2. an independent accountant. Such an application must satisfy the | |
| Commission that: | |
| (a) Respondent, or the public accounting firm with which he is | |
| associated, is registered with the PCAOB in accordance with the | |
| Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, and such registration continues to be | |
| effective; | |
| (b) Respondent, or the registered public accounting firm with which he | |
| is associated, has been inspected by the PCAOB and that | |
| inspection did not identify any criticisms of or potential defects in | |
| the respondent’s or the firm’s quality control system that would | |
| indicate that the respondent will not receive appropriate | |
| supervision; | |
| (c) Respondent has resolved all disciplinary issues with the PCAOB, | |
| and has complied with all terms and conditions of any sanctions | |
| imposed by the PCAOB (other than reinstatement by the | |
| Commission); and | |
| (d) Respondent acknowledges his responsibility, as long as | |
| Respondent appears or practices before the Commission as an | |
| independent accountant, to comply with all requirements of the | |
| Commission and the PCAOB, including, but not limited to, all | |
| requirements relating to registration, inspections, concurring | |
| partner reviews and quality control standards. | |
| 14 | |
| D. The Commission will consider an application by Respondent to resume appearing | |
| or practicing before the Commission provided that his state CPA license is current and he has | |
| resolved all other disciplinary issues with the applicable state boards of accountancy. However, if | |
| state licensure is dependent on reinstatement by the Commission, the Commission will consider an | |
| application on its other merits. The Commission’s review may include consideration of, in | |
| addition to the matters referenced above, any other matters relating to Respondent’s character, | |
| integrity, professional conduct, or qualifications to appear or practice before the Commission. | |
| By the Commission. | |
| Brent J. Fields | |
| Secretary | |