Download raw/aaer/2020/AAER-4131.txt from codewithdark/SEC-RPT-Panel: direct link, hf CLI and curl.
- Browser
- Download file 54.2 kB
-
https://huggingface.co/datasets/codewithdark/SEC-RPT-Panel/resolve/main/raw/aaer/2020/AAER-4131.txt
- Command line
-
hf download hf://datasets/codewithdark/SEC-RPT-Panel/raw/aaer/2020/AAER-4131.txt
-
curl -L -o AAER-4131.txt https://huggingface.co/datasets/codewithdark/SEC-RPT-Panel/resolve/main/raw/aaer/2020/AAER-4131.txt
54.2 kB
| UNITED STATES OF AMERICA | |
| Before the | |
| SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION | |
| SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934 | |
| Release No. 88739 / April 24, 2020 | |
| ACCOUNTING AND AUDITING ENFORCEMENT | |
| Release No. 4131 / April 24, 2020 | |
| ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDING | |
| File No. 3-19767 | |
| In the Matter of | |
| PLS, CPA, A | |
| PROFESSIONAL | |
| CORPORATION, | |
| a/k/a PLS CPAs, | |
| CHANG G. PARK, | |
| CPA, a/k/a | |
| CHANGGEUN | |
| PARK, JOSEPH | |
| YONGYUN LEE, | |
| CPA, a/k/a YONG | |
| YUN LEE, and | |
| JUCHI LEE, CPA, | |
| a/k/a JUCHI LEE | |
| FERNANDEZ, JU- | |
| CHI LEE, JU CHI | |
| LEE, SUE LEE | |
| Respondents. | |
| CORRECTED ORDER INSTITUTING PUBLIC | |
| ADMINISTRATIVE AND CEASE- | |
| AND-DESIST PROCEEDINGS PURSUANT TO | |
| SECTIONS 4C AND 21C OF THE SECURITIES | |
| EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934 AND RULE 102(e) | |
| OF THE COMMISSION’S RULES OF | |
| PRACTICE AND NOTICE OF HEARING | |
| 2 | |
| I. | |
| The Securities and Exchange Commission (“Commission”) deems it appropriate that public | |
| administrative and cease-and-desist proceedings be, and hereby are, instituted pursuant to Sections | |
| 4C1 and 21C of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (“Exchange Act”) and Rule 102(e)(1)(ii) and | |
| 102(e)(1)(iii)2 of the Commission’s Rules of Practice against PLS, CPA, a Professional | |
| Corporation, a/k/a PLS CPAs; Chang G. Park, CPA, a/k/a Changgeun Park; Joseph Yongyun Lee, | |
| CPA, a/k/a Yong Yun Lee; and Juchi Lee, CPA, a/k/a Juchi Lee Fernandez, Ju-chi Lee, Ju Chi | |
| Lee, Sue Lee (collectively, “Respondents”). | |
| II. | |
| After an investigation, the Division of Enforcement alleges that: | |
| A. RESPONDENTS | |
| 1. PLS, CPA, A Professional Corporation (a/k/a “PLS CPAs”) (“PLS”), a California | |
| corporation, is a PCAOB-registered public accounting firm based in San Diego, California. PLS | |
| was incorporated in November 2009, and is co-owned by Park, Joseph Lee, and a third individual. | |
| Park, Joseph Lee, and Juchi Lee are PLS’s only individuals who perform audit services | |
| (collectively, the “individual auditors”). | |
| 2. Chang G. Park (a/k/a Changgeun Park) (“Park”), age 60, resides in San Diego, | |
| California. Park is a certified public accountant licensed in California. Park is the founder of | |
| 1 Section 4C provides, in relevant part, that: | |
| The Commission may censure any person, or deny, temporarily or permanently, | |
| to any person the privilege of appearing or practicing before the Commission in | |
| any way, if that person is found . . . (1) not to possess the requisite qualifications | |
| to represent others; (2) to be lacking in character or integrity, or to have engaged | |
| in unethical or improper professional conduct; or (3) to have willfully violated, or | |
| willfully aided and abetted the violation of, any provision of the securities laws or | |
| the rules and regulations issued thereunder. | |
| 2 Rule 102(e)(1)(ii) provides, in pertinent part, that: | |
| The Commission may . . . deny, temporarily or permanently, the privilege of | |
| appearing or practicing before it . . . to any person who is found . . . to have | |
| engaged in unethical or improper professional conduct. | |
| Rule 102(e)(1)(iii) provides, in pertinent part, that: | |
| The Commission may . . . deny, temporarily or permanently, the privilege of | |
| appearing or practicing before it . . . to any person who is found…to have | |
| willfully violated, or willfully aided and abetted the violation of any provision of | |
| the Federal securities laws or the rules and regulations thereunder. | |
| 3 | |
| Chang G. Park, C.P.A., A Professional Corporation, which later reincorporated as PLS. Since | |
| November 2009, Park has been the managing partner and 55% co-owner of PLS, and one of the | |
| firm’s three auditors. | |
| 3. Joseph Yongyun Lee (a/k/a Yong Yun Lee) (“Joseph Lee”), age 57, resides in San | |
| Diego, California. Joseph Lee is a certified public accountant licensed in California. Joseph Lee | |
| joined Chang G. Park, C.P.A. as an accountant in December 2003. Since November 2009, | |
| Joseph Lee has been a partner, 25% co-owner, and the CFO of PLS, where he is one of the firm’s | |
| three auditors. | |
| 4. Juchi Lee (a/k/a Juchi Lee Fernandez, Ju-chi Lee, Ju Chi Lee, Sue Lee) | |
| (“Juchi Lee”), age 47, resides in San Diego, California. Juchi Lee is a certified public accountant | |
| licensed in California. Juchi Lee joined Chang G. Park, C.P.A. as a senior auditor in October | |
| 2007. Since November 2009, Juchi Lee has been one of the three auditors at PLS. | |
| B. OTHER RELEVANT ENTITIES | |
| 5. Interactive Multi-Media Auction Corporation (n/k/a Stop Sleep Go Inc.) | |
| (“IMMA”), CIK# 0001565430, is a British Virgin Islands corporation with its principal place of | |
| business in the United Kingdom, and has common stock registered pursuant to Section 12(g) of the | |
| Exchange Act. IMMA was formerly headquartered in Hong Kong, and its stock was quoted on | |
| OTC Link under the ticker symbol “IMMA.” In December 2016, IMMA entered into a business | |
| combination with another company and changed its name to “Stop Sleep Go Inc.” Its stock | |
| currently is quoted on the OTC Link under the ticker symbol “SSGOF.” | |
| 6. IMMA has not filed any annual or quarterly periodic reports with the Commission | |
| since 2016. The Commission filed an injunctive action against IMMA, SEC v. McDiarmid et al., | |
| Case 2:17-cv-07201 (C.D. Cal.), and, on November 19, 2018, obtained a default judgment | |
| enjoining IMMA from violations of the antifraud provisions of the Securities Act and the | |
| Exchange Act. SEC v. McDiarmid et al., 2018 WL 6062313 (C.D. Cal. Nov. 19, 2018). PLS | |
| issued audit reports for IMMA’s Forms 10-K for the fiscal years ended October 31, 2014 and | |
| October 31, 2015, and resigned as IMMA’s auditor on October 13, 2016. | |
| 7. IMK Group, Inc. (“IMKG”), CIK# 0001321710, is a Delaware corporation with its | |
| principal place of business in Seoul, South Korea. IMKG had common stock registered pursuant | |
| to Section 12(g) of the Exchange Act, which was quoted on OTC Link under the ticker symbol | |
| “IMKG.” | |
| 8. IMKG has not filed any periodic reports with the Commission since 2016. The | |
| Commission suspended trading in IMKG from September 25, 2017 through October 6, 2017 (In | |
| the Matter of IMK Group, Inc., et al., Exchange Act Release No. 81691 (September 22, 2017)), | |
| then revoked the registration of each class of registered securities of IMKG, effective April 16, | |
| 2019, for failure to file timely periodic reports with the Commission. In the Matter of IMK Group, | |
| Inc., et al., Exchange Act Release No. 85648 (April 15, 2019). PLS issued an audit report for | |
| IMKG’s Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended February 28, 2015. | |
| 4 | |
| 9. RadTek, Inc. (“RDTK”), CIK# 0001487252, is a Nevada corporation with its | |
| principal place of business in Louisville, Kentucky, and has common stock registered pursuant to | |
| Section 12(g) of the Exchange Act which trades on the OTC Grey Market under the ticker symbol | |
| “RDTK.” | |
| 10. RadTek has not filed any periodic reports with the Commission since 2016. The | |
| Commission suspended trading in RDTK from August 28, 2019 through September 11, 2019 for | |
| failure to file timely periodic reports with the Commission and failure to maintain a valid address | |
| on file with the Commission. In the Matter of LD Holdings, Inc., et al., Exchange Act Release No. | |
| 86780 (August 27, 2019). PLS issued audit reports for RDTK’s Forms 10-K for the fiscal years | |
| ended December 31, 2013, December 31, 2014, and December 31, 2015. | |
| 11. Therapeutic Solutions International, Inc. (“TSOI”), CIK# 0001419051, is a Nevada | |
| corporation with its principal place of business in Oceanside, California, and has common stock | |
| registered pursuant to Section 12(g) of the Exchange Act which is quoted on OTC Link under the | |
| ticker symbol “TSOI.” PLS issued audit reports for TSOI’s Forms 10-K for the fiscal years ended | |
| December 31, 2013, December 31, 2014, and December 31, 2015, and resigned as TSOI’s auditor | |
| on or around October 31, 2016. | |
| 12. Each of the Respondents signed a tolling agreement with the Commission that | |
| tolled and suspended the running of any applicable statute of limitations for the period beginning | |
| on January 13, 2020 through July 13, 2020. | |
| C. RESPONDENTS’ IMPROPER PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT | |
| 1. Respondents’ Audit Practice | |
| 13. In or around 2001, Park founded an audit firm, initially named Chang G. Park, | |
| C.P.A. In November 2009, the firm was re-incorporated as PLS. | |
| 14. PLS currently provides audit and review services to microcap issuers, development | |
| stage companies, and shell companies. Park, Joseph Lee, and Juchi Lee are the three individual | |
| auditors who conduct PLS’s audits and reviews of public company financial statements. | |
| 15. PLS has never used any proprietary auditing software. The individual auditors use | |
| downloads of commercially available electronic audit templates to document audits. The | |
| individual auditors complete these templates electronically and/or print out hard copies to fill out | |
| manually. | |
| 16. The individual auditors either save their electronic work papers on PLS’s | |
| networked storage drive, or they save them in electronic client folders on their PLS computers | |
| which are copied to PLS’s networked storage drive. Hard copies are printed out and assembled in | |
| audit binders for the auditors’ review and signature; the resulting audit binders are then stored in | |
| the individual auditors’ offices. | |
| 5 | |
| 17. Joseph Lee and Juchi Lee are generally responsible for preparing PLS’s audit | |
| documentation and assembling and storing the audit binders. Park generally reviews the audit | |
| binders assembled by Joseph Lee or Juchi Lee. | |
| 18. As managing partner of the firm, Park manages the relationship of the firm with its | |
| clients, while Joseph Lee and Juchi Lee perform most of the audit and review work. When matters | |
| arise during a client’s audit, all three individual auditors typically meet to discuss the audit. | |
| 19. As of early 2016, PLS was providing audit and review services to approximately | |
| thirty clients, including IMMA, IMKG, RDTK, and TSOI. | |
| 2. The July 2016 Commission Subpoena and the November 2016 PCAOB | |
| Inspection | |
| 20. On July 5, 2016, the Commission issued an administrative subpoena for documents | |
| to PLS (the “July 2016 Commission Subpoena”). The subpoena included requests for IMMA audit | |
| work papers created during, or concerning, the time period from September 30, 2014, to July 5, | |
| 2016. | |
| 21. PLS produced IMMA audit work papers in response to the July 2016 Commission | |
| Subpoena. Juchi Lee was responsible for gathering and producing PLS’s documents in response to | |
| the subpoena. | |
| 22. On April 1, 2016, the PCAOB informed PLS that it would conduct an inspection | |
| of PLS during the week of November 7, 2016 (the “November 2016 PCAOB inspection”). | |
| 23. On April 12, 2016, a representative of the PCAOB emailed Park, cc’ing Joseph | |
| Lee and Juchi Lee, requesting that PLS complete and return, prior to the inspection, an attached | |
| “issuer information form.” The issuer information form required PLS to specify, among other | |
| information, the engagement partner (“EP”) and engagement quality reviewer (“EQR”) assigned | |
| to its client issuers. | |
| 24. Park asked Joseph Lee and Juchi Lee to fill out the issuer information form, for | |
| Park’s review. | |
| 25. PLS sent the completed issuer information form back to the PCAOB on October | |
| 12, 2016. PLS subsequently amended the issuer information form to reflect the termination of its | |
| auditor relationship with TSOI, sending a final version to the PCAOB on October 31, 2016. The | |
| final version of the issuer information form PLS provided to the PCAOB included information | |
| for twenty-nine issuers. | |
| 6 | |
| 26. The final version of the issuer information form PLS provided to the PCAOB | |
| identified the individual auditors’ roles on audits for issuers IMMA, IMKG, RDTK and TSOI as | |
| follows: | |
| Issuer EP EQR | |
| IMMA Juchi Lee Park | |
| IMKG Park Juchi Lee | |
| RDTK Park Juchi Lee | |
| TSOI Joseph Lee Juchi Lee | |
| 27. Park instructed Joseph Lee and Juchi Lee to review PLS’s clients’ audit binders in | |
| preparation for the inspection. | |
| 28. Before the November 2016 PCAOB inspection was scheduled to begin, the | |
| PCAOB informed PLS that it would review the audit work papers for IMKG, RDTK and TSOI | |
| during the inspection. | |
| 29. After learning which issuers were selected for the inspection, Park instructed | |
| Joseph Lee and Juchi Lee to review the audit binders for those issuers again. | |
| 30. The PCAOB conducted its inspection of PLS from November 7, 2016 to | |
| November 11, 2016. | |
| 3. Respondents Failed to Prepare and Retain Required Audit Documentation, | |
| and Inappropriately Modified Audit Documentation, in Violation of PCAOB | |
| Auditing Standard No. 33 | |
| 31. Respondents violated PCAOB Auditing Standard No. 3, Audit Documentation | |
| (“AS 3”), in that they: failed to timely prepare required audit documentation; failed to document | |
| the addition of documents to the work papers after the documentation completion date; and drafted | |
| back-dated, fraudulent work papers to create the appearance of having proper contemporaneous | |
| work papers. | |
| 32. AS 3 establishes general requirements for documentation the auditor should prepare | |
| and retain in connection with engagements conducted pursuant to the standards of the PCAOB. | |
| AS 3.1, AS 3.4. Audit documentation is the written record of the basis for the auditor’s | |
| conclusions that provides the support for the auditor’s representations, whether those | |
| representations are contained in the auditor’s report or otherwise. AS 3.2. Audit documentation | |
| also facilitates the planning, performance, and supervision of the engagement, and is the basis for | |
| the review of the quality of the work because it provides the reviewer with written documentation | |
| of the evidence supporting the auditor’s significant conclusions. Id. | |
| 3 PCAOB Auditing Standard No. 3 was renumbered from AS 3 to AS 1215, effective December | |
| 31, 2016; references herein are to the numbering in effect at the time of the alleged conduct. | |
| 7 | |
| 33. Among other things, audit documentation includes records of the planning and | |
| performance of the work, the procedures performed, evidence obtained, and conclusions reached | |
| by the auditor. AS 3.2. The auditor also must identify all significant findings or issues in an | |
| engagement completion document. AS 3.13. | |
| 34. The report release date is the date the auditor grants permission to use the auditor’s | |
| report in connection with the issuance of the company’s financial statements. AS 3.14. Prior to | |
| the report release date, the auditor must have completed all necessary auditing procedures and | |
| obtained sufficient evidence to support the representations in the auditor’s report. AS 3.15. A | |
| complete and final set of audit documentation should be assembled for retention as of a date not | |
| more than 45 days after the report release date (the “documentation completion date”). Id. | |
| 35. Circumstances may require additions to audit documentation after the report release | |
| date. AS 3.16. Audit documentation must not be deleted or discarded after the documentation | |
| completion date, however, information may be added. Id. Any documentation added must | |
| indicate the date the information was added, the name of the person who prepared the additional | |
| documentation, and the reason for adding it. Id. | |
| 36. Because PLS did not use automated auditing software, it was up to the individual | |
| auditors themselves to keep track of what audit work had been performed, and when, and to ensure | |
| that the audit documentation for each audit was completed by the 45-day documentation | |
| completion date, as required by AS 3.15. | |
| 37. The individual auditors were aware that PLS commonly lacked a complete audit | |
| binder for its clients’ audits. | |
| a. Park noticed missing work papers when reviewing audits; reprimanded Joseph Lee | |
| for missing documentation; and told Juchi Lee that Joseph Lee’s work papers were | |
| incomplete. | |
| b. Juchi Lee acknowledged that prior to the November 2016 PCAOB inspection, the | |
| individual auditors were less “serious” about complying with the audit | |
| documentation completion period, which she understood to be “45 days or 60 | |
| days.” | |
| c. Joseph Lee admitted that he was unaware of the 45 day audit documentation | |
| completion period before the November 2016 PCAOB inspection. | |
| 38. PLS and the individual auditors inappropriately added documents to audit work | |
| papers after the audit report had been released and the applicable documentation completion date | |
| had passed, without disclosing the date that these documents were added, or other information | |
| required under AS 3.16. In certain instances, the individual auditors identified documents that | |
| were missing from the audit work papers, then intentionally prepared and backdated those | |
| documents in order to make it appear as though those documents had been prepared and included | |
| 8 | |
| in the audit work papers on or before the date of the corresponding PLS audit report. | |
| PLS subsequently produced backdated documents in response to the July 2016 Commission | |
| Subpoena and/or the November 2016 PCAOB inspection. | |
| 39. PLS and the individual auditors knew or were reckless in not knowing that they | |
| inappropriately added documents to audit work papers and backdated audit work papers. | |
| a. IMMA Audits – Fiscal Years Ended October 31, 2014 and 2015 | |
| 40. PLS performed the audit for IMMA’s fiscal year ended October 31, 2014 (the | |
| “IMMA 2014 audit”). IMMA filed the PLS audit report, dated February 12, 2014,4 with its Form | |
| 10-K on February 12, 2015. The audit report stated that PLS had conducted the audit in | |
| accordance with PCAOB standards. The applicable documentation completion date was March | |
| 29, 2015. | |
| 41. PLS also performed the audit for IMMA’s fiscal year ended October 31, 2015 (the | |
| “IMMA 2015 audit”). IMMA filed the PLS audit report, dated February 10, 2016, with its Form | |
| 10-K on February 10, 2016. The audit report stated that PLS had conducted the audit in | |
| accordance with PCAOB standards. The applicable documentation completion date was | |
| March 26, 2016. | |
| 42. The issuer information form that PLS provided to the PCAOB in connection with | |
| the November 2016 PCAOB inspection described Juchi Lee as the EP for IMMA, and Park as the | |
| EQR. | |
| 43. Juchi Lee was the lead auditor for the IMMA 2014 audit and the IMMA 2015 audit. | |
| Park reviewed the audit binders for these audits. Each of them knew or were reckless in not | |
| knowing that the IMMA 2014 audit and the IMMA 2015 audit had not actually been conducted in | |
| accordance with PCAOB standards. | |
| 44. The July 2016 Commission Subpoena required PLS to produce IMMA audit work | |
| papers for the time period from September 30, 2014, to July 5, 2016, which included both the | |
| IMMA 2014 audit and the IMMA 2015 audit. After PLS received the July 2016 Commission | |
| Subpoena on or around July 5, 2016, Juchi Lee prepared and backdated documents for both the | |
| IMMA 2014 audit and the IMMA 2015 audit. | |
| 45. Specifically, after PLS received the July 2016 Commission Subpoena on or around | |
| July 5, 2016, Juchi Lee prepared an audit form entitled “Inquiries of Management/Directors about | |
| the Risks of Fraud” for the IMMA 2014 audit. Juchi Lee admitted that she had searched the | |
| IMMA 2015 audit work papers for that audit’s version of the same form; hand copied the | |
| 4 The February 12, 2014 date on the PLS audit report appears to have been a typo, as the report | |
| was for the fiscal year ended October 31, 2014, and was filed with IMMA’s Form 10-K on | |
| February 12, 2015. | |
| 9 | |
| responses from that version onto a blank form, which she then signed and backdated to make it | |
| look like it had been prepared in 2015; and produced the backdated form to the Commission along | |
| with the IMMA 2014 audit work papers. | |
| 46. Or around July 21, 2016, Juchi Lee also prepared an “Engagement Acceptance and | |
| Continuance” form for the IMMA 2014 audit and backdated this document to December 1, 2014, | |
| approximately two months before the date of the corresponding PLS audit report, which was | |
| February 12, 2015. This document, which was filled out electronically prior to printing, included | |
| the names of both Juchi Lee (as “Lead Partner”) and Park (as “Concurring Partner”) next to the | |
| date December 1, 2014. Juchi Lee admitted that she had created this document after reviewing the | |
| audit work papers in July 2016. | |
| 47. On or around July 27, 2016, Juchi Lee prepared a form entitled “Engagement | |
| Completion Document” for the IMMA 2015 audit and backdated this document to February 10, | |
| 2016, the date of the corresponding PLS audit report. The hard copy version of this form included | |
| handwritten signatures from both Juchi Lee and Park, which also were backdated to February 10, | |
| 2016. Park admitted that his signature on this document was backdated. | |
| b. IMKG Audit – Fiscal Year Ended February 28, 2015 | |
| 48. PLS performed the audit for IMKG’s fiscal year ended February 28, 2015 (the | |
| “IMKG 2015 audit”). IMKG filed the PLS audit report, dated July 29, 2015, with its Form 10-K | |
| on July 29, 2015. The audit report stated that PLS had conducted the audit in accordance with | |
| PCAOB standards. The applicable documentation completion date was September 12, 2015. | |
| 49. The issuer information form that PLS provided to the PCAOB in connection with | |
| the November 2016 PCAOB inspection listed Park as the engagement partner for IMKG, and | |
| Juchi Lee as the EQR. | |
| 50. However, Park and Joseph Lee each admitted that they went together to Korea to | |
| conduct field work for the audit. Joseph Lee prepared most of the audit work papers for IMKG, | |
| which Park reviewed. Each of them knew or were reckless in not knowing that the IMKG 2015 | |
| audit had not actually been conducted in accordance with PCAOB standards. | |
| 51. The PCAOB reviewed audit work papers for the IMKG 2015 audit in connection | |
| with the November 2016 PCAOB inspection. | |
| 52. Both Park and Joseph Lee admitted that in October 2016, in the course of | |
| preparing for the November 2016 PCAOB inspection, they had become aware that Joseph Lee | |
| had failed to obtain all of the documents necessary for the IMKG 2015 audit. | |
| 53. With Park’s knowledge, Joseph Lee emailed IMKG’s former owner and outside | |
| consultants to request board minutes, bank reconciliations, and other documents, in an attempt to | |
| complete the audit binder before the PCAOB inspection. | |
| 10 | |
| 54. Joseph Lee also prepared and backdated documents for the IMKG 2015 audit in | |
| preparation for the November 2016 PCAOB inspection. PLS produced backdated documents for | |
| the IMKG 2015 audit to the PCAOB in connection with the November 2016 PCAOB inspection. | |
| 55. On or around October 12, 2016, Joseph Lee prepared a document entitled “Audit | |
| Program for General Planning Procedures” for the IMKG 2015 audit. Joseph Lee admitted that | |
| he had created this document after the audit report date, in preparation for the November 2016 | |
| PCAOB inspection. | |
| 56. On or around October 12 or 13, 2016, Joseph Lee also prepared a form entitled | |
| “Engagement Completion Document” for the IMKG 2015 audit, and backdated it to July 29, | |
| 2015, the date of the corresponding PLS audit report. This document, which was filled out | |
| electronically prior to printing, included the names of Joseph Lee (as “Engagement Manager”), | |
| Park (as “Engagement Partner”), and Juchi Lee (as “Concurring Partner/Engagement Quality | |
| Reviewer”) next to the date July 29, 2015. Joseph Lee admitted that this document had not been | |
| prepared before the audit report was issued, and that he had backdated this document to the audit | |
| report date. | |
| 57. On or around October 14, 2016, Joseph Lee prepared a “Risk Assessment | |
| Summary Form” for the IMKG 2015 audit, and backdated it to July 9, 2015, a few weeks prior to | |
| the date of the corresponding PLS audit report. Joseph Lee admitted that he had created this | |
| document after the audit report date, in preparation for the November 2016 PCAOB inspection. | |
| c. RDTK Audit – Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2015 | |
| 58. PLS performed the audit for RDTK’s fiscal year ended December 31, 2015 (the | |
| “RDTK 2015 audit”). RDTK filed the PLS audit report, dated April 27, 2016, with its Form 10- | |
| K on April 27, 2016. The audit report stated that PLS had conducted the audit in accordance | |
| with PCAOB standards. The applicable documentation completion date was June 11, 2016. | |
| 59. RDTK filed an amended Form 10-K for its fiscal year 2015 on August 24, 2016. | |
| The Amended RDTK Form 10-K included a PLS audit report that was amended as to one note | |
| only; that report was dual dated related to the one note for August 22, 2016. The audit report | |
| stated that PLS had conducted the audit in accordance with PCAOB standards. | |
| The applicable | |
| documentation completion date was October 6, 2016. | |
| 60. The issuer information form that PLS provided to the PCAOB in advance of the | |
| November 2016 PCAOB inspection listed Park as the engagement partner for RDTK, and | |
| Juchi Lee as EQR. | |
| 61. However, Park and Joseph Lee conducted the fieldwork for RDTK. Joseph Lee | |
| prepared most of the audit work papers for RDTK, which Park reviewed. Each of them knew or | |
| were reckless in not knowing that the RDTK 2015 audit had not actually been conducted in | |
| accordance with PCAOB standards. | |
| 11 | |
| 62. The PCAOB reviewed audit work papers for the RDTK 2015 audit in connection | |
| with the November 2016 PCAOB inspection. | |
| 63. Joseph Lee admitted that he had contacted RDTK after the audit report was | |
| released to request supporting documentation that was missing from the audit binders. | |
| 64. Joseph Lee also prepared and backdated documents for the RDTK 2015 audit in | |
| preparation for the November 2016 PCAOB inspection. PLS produced backdated documents for | |
| the RDTK 2015 audit to the PCAOB in connection with the November 2016 PCAOB inspection. | |
| 65. On or around October 18, 2016, Joseph Lee prepared a document entitled “Audit | |
| Program for General Planning Procedures” for the RDTK 2015 audit. Joseph Lee admitted that | |
| he had noticed this document was missing from the audit work papers and that he had created | |
| this document in preparation for the November 2016 PCAOB inspection. | |
| 66. On or around October 19, 2016, Joseph Lee also prepared a “Supervision, Review | |
| and Approval Form” for the RDTK 2015 audit and backdated it to April 27, 2016, the date of the | |
| original PLS audit report. This document, which was filled out electronically prior to printing, | |
| included the typed “signatures” of Joseph Lee (under the “Detailed Review” section supposed to | |
| be “performed by the staff in charge of the field work”), Park (as “Engagement Partner”), and | |
| Juchi Lee (as “Engagement Quality Reviewer”) next to the date April 27, 2016. Joseph Lee | |
| admitted that he had created this document in preparation for the November 2016 PCAOB | |
| inspection. Park also admitted that this document was created in October 2016 to supplement the | |
| audit work papers, and backdated. | |
| 67. In addition, on or around October 19, 2016, Joseph Lee prepared an “Engagement | |
| Completion Document” for the RDTK 2015 audit, and backdated it to April 27, 2016, the | |
| original report release date. This document, which was filled out electronically prior to printing, | |
| included the names of Joseph Lee (as “Engagement Manager”), Park (as “Engagement Partner”), | |
| and Juchi Lee (as “Concurring Partner/Engagement Quality Reviewer”) next to the date April 27, | |
| 2016. Joseph Lee admitted that he had created this document in October 2016 in preparation for | |
| the November 2016 PCAOB inspection. Park also admitted that this document was created in | |
| October 2016 to supplement the audit work papers, and backdated. | |
| d. TSOI Audit – Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2014 | |
| 68. PLS performed the audit for TSOI’s fiscal year ended December 31, 2014 (the | |
| “TSOI 2014 audit”). TSOI filed the PLS audit report, dated June 15, 2016, with its Form 10-K | |
| on June 16, 2016. The audit report stated that PLS had conducted the audit in accordance with | |
| PCAOB standards. The applicable documentation completion date was July 30, 2016. | |
| 69. The issuer information form that PLS provided to the PCAOB in connection with | |
| the November 2016 PCAOB inspection listed Joseph Lee as the engagement partner for TSOI, | |
| and Juchi Lee as the EQR. | |
| 12 | |
| 70. However, Joseph Lee performed the substantive audit work for TSOI, including | |
| preparation of the audit binder, and Park served as the reviewer. Each of them knew or were | |
| reckless in not knowing that the TSOI 2014 audit had not actually been conducted in accordance | |
| with PCAOB standards. | |
| 71. Juchi Lee did not perform an engagement quality review for TSOI. In fact, Juchi | |
| Lee admitted that she had not performed engagement quality reviews for IMKG, RDTK, or | |
| TSOI, even though the issuer information form that PLS provided to the PCAOB in advance of | |
| the November 2016 PCAOB inspection listed her as the EQR for each of these issuers. | |
| 72. The PCAOB reviewed audit work papers for the TSOI 2014 audit in connection | |
| with the November 2016 PCAOB inspection. | |
| 73. Joseph Lee admitted that he did not fill out audit documentation forms for the | |
| TSOI 2014 audit until the fall of 2016, when he was reviewing audit binders in preparation for | |
| the November 2016 PCAOB inspection. | |
| 74. Joseph Lee prepared and backdated documents for the TSOI 2014 audit in | |
| preparation for the November 2016 PCAOB inspection. PLS produced backdated documents for | |
| the TSOI 2014 audit to the PCAOB in connection with the November 2016 PCAOB inspection. | |
| 75. Sometime between October 24 and November 1, 2016, Joseph Lee prepared a | |
| document entitled “Audit Program for General Planning Procedures” for the TSOI 2014 audit. | |
| Joseph Lee admitted that he had created this document several months after the TSOI 2014 Form | |
| 10-K had been filed, in preparation for the November 2016 PCAOB inspection. | |
| 76. Sometime between October 24 and November 1, 2016, Joseph Lee also prepared | |
| a document entitled “Risk Assessment Summary Form” for the TSOI 2014 audit. This | |
| document, which was filled out electronically prior to printing, included the names of Joseph Lee | |
| and Juchi Lee next to the date January 7, 2016, which was several months prior to the date of the | |
| corresponding PLS audit report. | |
| 77. In addition, on or around October 31 or November 1, 2016, Joseph Lee prepared a | |
| “Supervision, Review and Approval Form” for the TSOI 2014 audit. This document, which was | |
| filled out electronically prior to printing, included the names of Joseph Lee (as “Engagement | |
| Partner”) and Juchi Lee (as “Engagement Quality Reviewer”) next to the date June 15, 2016, the | |
| date of the corresponding PLS audit report. | |
| 13 | |
| 4. Respondents Failed to Obtain or Perform Engagement Quality Reviews in | |
| Violation of PCAOB Auditing Standard No. 75 | |
| 78. Respondents violated PCAOB Auditing Standard No. 7, Engagement Quality | |
| Review (“AS 7”), by failing to obtain or perform adequate engagement quality reviews in | |
| connection with PLS’s clients’ audits. | |
| 79. AS 7 requires an engagement quality review and concurring approval of issuance | |
| for each audit engagement conducted pursuant to the standards of the PCAOB. AS 7.1. The | |
| objective of the EQR is to perform an evaluation of the significant judgments made by the | |
| engagement team and the related conclusions reached in forming the overall conclusion on the | |
| engagement and in preparing the engagement report, if a report is to be issued, in order to | |
| determine whether to provide concurring approval of issuance. AS 7.2. To evaluate such | |
| judgments and conclusions, the EQR to the extent necessary should hold discussions with the | |
| engagement partner and other members of the engagement team, and review documentation. | |
| AS 7.9. | |
| 80. The EQR must be an associated person of a registered public accounting firm. | |
| AS 7.3. An EQR from the firm that issues the engagement report must be a partner or another | |
| individual in an equivalent position. Id. The EQR may also be an individual from outside the | |
| firm. Id. To maintain objectivity, the EQR and others who assist the EQR should not make | |
| decisions on behalf of the engagement team or assume any of the responsibilities of the | |
| engagement team. AS 7.7. | |
| 81. In an audit, the EQR should evaluate, among other things, the significant | |
| judgments that relate to engagement planning, including consideration of the firm’s recent | |
| engagement experience with the company and risks identified in connection with the firm’s | |
| client acceptance and retention process. AS 7.10. The EQR also should evaluate the | |
| engagement team’s assessment of, and audit responses to, significant risks identified by the | |
| engagement team, including fraud risks, and other significant risks identified by the EQR. Id. | |
| The EQR’s review of documentation should specifically include the engagement completion | |
| document. Id. | |
| 82. Additionally, in an audit, the EQR should evaluate whether the engagement | |
| documentation that he or she reviewed indicates that the engagement team responded | |
| appropriately to significant risks, and supports the conclusions reached by the engagement team | |
| with respect to the matters reviewed. AS 7.11. The EQR may provide concurring approval of | |
| issuance only if, after performing with due professional care the review required by AS 7, he or | |
| she is not aware of a significant engagement deficiency, such as a failure by the engagement | |
| team to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence in accordance with the standards of the PCAOB. | |
| 5 PCAOB Auditing Standard No. 7 was renumbered from AS 7 to AS 1220, effective December | |
| 31, 2016; references herein are to the numbering in effect at the time of the alleged conduct. | |
| 14 | |
| AS 7.12. The audit firm may grant permission to the client to use the engagement report only | |
| after the EQR provides concurring approval of issuance. AS 7.13. | |
| 83. The issuer information form that PLS provided to the PCAOB in advance of the | |
| November 2016 PCAOB inspection represented that Park was the EQR for IMMA, and Juchi | |
| Lee was the EQR for IMKG, RDTK, and TSOI. PLS, however, was not actually staffing its | |
| audits in this manner. | |
| 84. PLS and the individual auditors violated AS 7 by failing to obtain or perform | |
| adequate engagement quality reviews, in accordance with the requirements of AS 7, for the | |
| IMMA 2014 audit; the IMMA 2015 audit; the IMKG 2015 audit; the RDTK 2015 audit; and the | |
| TSOI 2014 audit. | |
| 85. Juchi Lee, the purported EQR for the IMKG 2015 audit, the RDTK 2015 audit, | |
| and the TSOI 2014 audit, admitted that she had not performed engagement quality reviews for | |
| IMKG, RDTK, or TSOI. She also admitted that she had not even known that she was supposed | |
| to be EQR for these issuers until October 2016, when Park tasked her and Joseph Lee with the | |
| job of completing the issuer information form for the PCAOB in connection with the | |
| November 2016 PCAOB inspection. | |
| 86. Moreover, given the audit documentation deficiencies described above, PLS and | |
| the individual auditors could not have obtained or performed engagement quality reviews, in | |
| accordance with the requirements of AS 7, for the IMMA 2014 audit, the IMMA 2015 audit, | |
| the IMKG 2015 audit, the RDTK 2015 audit, or the TSOI 2014 audit. The documents that were | |
| inappropriately added to audit work papers, after the audit report had been released and the | |
| applicable documentation completion date had passed, included engagement acceptance, audit | |
| planning, risk assessment, engagement completion, and other documents that an EQR | |
| performing an engagement quality review pursuant to the standards of AS 7 should have | |
| reviewed before providing approval for the audit report to be released. | |
| 87. Respondents knew or were reckless in not knowing that they had failed to obtain | |
| or perform engagement quality reviews, in accordance with the requirements of AS 7, for the | |
| IMMA 2014 audit; the IMMA 2015 audit; the IMKG 2015 audit; the RDTK 2015 audit; and the | |
| TSOI 2014 audit. | |
| 5. Respondents Failed to Exercise Due Professional Care in Violation of | |
| PCAOB Interim Auditing Standard No. 2306 | |
| 88. Respondents violated PCAOB Interim Auditing Standard No. 230, | |
| Due Professional Care in the Performance of Work (“AU 230”), by failing to exercise due | |
| 6 PCAOB Interim Auditing Standard No. 230 was renumbered from AU 230 to AS 1015, | |
| effective December 31, 2016; references herein are to the numbering in effect at the time of the | |
| alleged conduct. | |
| 15 | |
| professional care in connection with the IMMA 2014 audit; the IMMA 2015 audit; the IMKG | |
| 2015 audit; the RDTK 2015 audit; and the TSOI 2014 audit. Namely, Respondents failed to | |
| prepare and retain required audit documentation and produced backdated documents to the | |
| PCAOB and the Commission, and they failed to obtain and perform engagement quality | |
| reviews. | |
| 89. AU 230 requires an auditor to exercise due professional care in the planning and | |
| performance of the audit and the preparation of the report. AU 230.01 - 230.02. Due | |
| professional care imposes a responsibility upon each professional within an independent | |
| auditor’s organization to observe the standards of field work and reporting. AU 230.02. | |
| 90. The matter of due professional care concerns what the independent auditor does | |
| and how well he or she does it. AU 230.04. An auditor should possess “the degree of skill | |
| commonly possessed” by other auditors and should exercise it with “reasonable care and | |
| diligence” (that is, with due professional care). AU 230.05. The engagement partner should | |
| know, at a minimum, the relevant professional accounting and auditing standards and should be | |
| knowledgeable about the client. AU 230.06. | |
| 91. Due professional care requires the auditor to exercise professional skepticism. | |
| AU 230.07. Professional skepticism is an attitude that includes a questioning mind and a | |
| critical assessment of audit evidence. Id. The auditor uses the knowledge, skill, and ability | |
| called for by the profession of public accounting to diligently perform, in good faith and with | |
| integrity, the gathering and objective evaluation of evidence. Id. Gathering and objectively | |
| evaluating audit evidence requires the auditor to consider the competency and sufficiency of the | |
| evidence. AU 230.08. Since evidence is gathered and evaluated throughout the audit, | |
| professional skepticism should be exercised throughout the audit process. Id. | |
| 92. PLS and the individual auditors failed to exercise due professional care in | |
| connection with the audit documentation for the IMMA 2014 audit; the IMMA 2015 audit; the | |
| IMKG 2015 audit; the RDTK 2015 audit; and the TSOI 2014 audit. | |
| 93. As described above, PLS and the auditors failed to prepare and retain required | |
| audit documentation for these audits, as required by AS 3. Although all three of the individual | |
| auditors were aware that PLS had a problem with missing work papers, they did not take any | |
| action to remedy this problem until the July 2016 Commission Subpoena and the announcement | |
| of the November 2016 PCAOB inspection threatened to expose their audit deficiencies. | |
| 94. Even then, Respondents did not follow the requirements for adding audit | |
| documentation set forth in AS 3.16, but intentionally attempted to conceal their actions from the | |
| Commission and the PCAOB by retroactively completing and backdating documents, which | |
| PLS then produced to the Commission or the PCAOB. | |
| 95. PLS and the individual auditors also failed to exercise due professional care in | |
| connection with engagement quality reviews for the IMMA 2014 audit; the IMMA 2015 audit; | |
| the IMKG 2015 audit; the RDTK 2015 audit; and the TSOI 2014 audit. PLS and the individual | |
| 16 | |
| auditors issued audit reports and provided information to the PCAOB, representing that | |
| engagement quality reviews had been obtained or performed for each of these audits, when in | |
| fact they had failed to obtain or perform engagement quality review, in accordance with the | |
| requirements of AS 7, for each of these audits. | |
| 96. Respondents knew or were reckless in not knowing that they failed to exercise | |
| due professional care in connection with the IMMA 2014 audit; the IMMA 2015 audit; the | |
| IMKG 2015 audit; the RDTK 2015 audit; and the TSOI 2014 audit. | |
| 6. Respondents Willfully Violated PCAOB Rules 3500T and 4006 | |
| 97. PCAOB Rule 3500T, Interim Ethics and Independence Standards (“Rule | |
| 3500T”), requires a registered public accounting firm and its associated persons to comply with | |
| AICPA’s Code of Professional Conduct Rule 102 in connection with the preparation or issuance | |
| of any audit report. Rule 3500T(a). | |
| 7 | |
| 98. AICPA’s Code of Professional Conduct Rule 102, Integrity and Objectivity | |
| (“AICPA Rule 102”) mandates that “in the performance of any professional service, a member | |
| shall maintain objectivity and integrity.” AICPA Rule 102.01. The AICPA Code of | |
| Professional Conduct defines “professional services” as including “all services requiring | |
| accountancy or related skills performed by a member for a client, an employer, or on a volunteer | |
| basis. These services include, but are not limited to accounting, audit and other attest services, | |
| tax, bookkeeping, management consulting, financial management, corporate governance, | |
| personal financial planning, business valuation, litigation support, educational, and those services | |
| for which standards are promulgated by bodies designated by [the AICPA Council].” AICPA | |
| Code of Professional Conduct § 0.400.40. | |
| 99. PLS and the individual auditors willfully violated Rule 3500T because they failed | |
| to act with integrity in connection with the preparation and issuance of the audit reports for the | |
| IMMA 2014 audit; the IMMA 2015 audit; the IMKG 2015 audit; the RDTK 2015 audit; and the | |
| TSOI 2014 audit. | |
| 100. PLS and the individual auditors further demonstrated a lack of integrity by taking | |
| affirmative steps to conceal their auditing deficiencies from us and the PCAOB, including the | |
| preparation and backdating of additional audit documentation which was subsequently produced | |
| to us and/or the PCAOB. | |
| 101. PCAOB Rule 4006, Duty to Cooperate with Inspectors (“Rule 4006”), requires a | |
| public accounting firm and its associated persons to cooperate with the Board in the performance | |
| 7 The rule requires auditors to comply with the AICPA’s Code of Professional Conduct Rule | |
| 102, and interpretations and rulings thereunder, as in existence on April 16, 2003. Although | |
| PCAOB Rule 3500T references the AICPA Code as in existence on April 16, 2003, the | |
| definition of integrity remains identical to the current definitions in the Code of Professional | |
| Conduct promulgated by the AICPA and applicable to current members of the AICPA. | |
| 17 | |
| of any Board inspection. Cooperation includes, but it is not limited to, cooperating and complying | |
| with any request made by the PCAOB to “provide access to, and the ability to copy, any record in | |
| the possession, custody, or control of such firm or person.” See Rule 4006(a). “Implicit in this | |
| cooperation requirement is that auditors provide accurate and truthful information.” In the Matter | |
| of the Application of Kabani & Company, Inc., et al., Exchange Act Release No. 80201, at 13-14 | |
| (March 10, 2017) (Commission Opinion). | |
| 102. PLS and the individual auditors willfully violated Rule 4006 in connection with the | |
| November 2016 PCAOB inspection by providing to the PCAOB documents that had been added to | |
| audit work papers for the IMKG 2015 audit, the RDTK 2015 audit, and the TSOI 2014 audit, after | |
| the audit report for each of these audits had been released and the applicable documentation | |
| completion date had passed, without disclosing of the date that these documents were added to the | |
| work papers, the persons who did so, or the reasons for doing so, as required under AS 3. | |
| 103. Moreover, PLS and the individual auditors attempted to deceive the PCAOB by | |
| backdating documents so that it would appear as though these documents had been prepared and | |
| included in the audit work papers before the audit report had been released. | |
| D. VIOLATIONS | |
| 104. As a result of the conduct described above, PLS engaged in improper professional | |
| conduct pursuant to Section 4C(a)(2) of the Exchange Act and Rule 102(e)(1)(ii) of the | |
| Commission’s Rules of Practice by engaging in repeated instances of unreasonable conduct and/or | |
| engaging in intentional or knowing conduct, including reckless conduct, and willfully violated the | |
| federal securities laws under Section 4C(a)(3) of the Exchange Act and Rule 102(e)(1)(iii) of the | |
| Commission’s Rules of Practice, by willfully violating Rule 2-02(b)(1) of Regulation S-X, and | |
| willfully violating PCAOB Rule 3500T and PCAOB Rule 4006. | |
| 105. As a result of the conduct described above, Park engaged in improper professional | |
| conduct pursuant to Section 4C(a)(2) of the Exchange Act and Rule 102(e)(1)(ii) of the | |
| Commission’s Rules of Practice by engaging in repeated instances of unreasonable conduct and/or | |
| engaging in intentional or knowing conduct, including reckless conduct, and willfully violated or | |
| willfully aided and abetted violation of the federal securities laws under Section 4C(a)(3) of the | |
| Exchange Act and Rule 102(e)(1)(iii) of the Commission’s Rules of Practice, by willfully aiding | |
| and abetting and causing PLS’s violations of Rule 2-02(b)(1) of Regulation S-X, and by willfully | |
| violating PCAOB Rule 3500T and PCAOB Rule 4006. | |
| 106. As a result of the conduct described above, Joseph Lee engaged in improper | |
| professional conduct pursuant to Section 4C(a)(2) of the Exchange Act and Rule 102(e)(1)(ii) of | |
| the Commission’s Rules of Practice by engaging in repeated instances of unreasonable conduct | |
| and/or engaging in intentional or knowing conduct, including reckless conduct, and willfully | |
| violated or willfully aided and abetted violation of the federal securities laws under Section | |
| 4C(a)(3) of the Exchange Act and Rule 102(e)(1)(iii) of the Commission’s Rules of Practice, by | |
| willfully aiding and abetting and causing PLS’s violations of Rule 2-02(b)(1) of Regulation S-X, | |
| and by willfully violating PCAOB Rule 3500T and PCAOB Rule 4006. | |
| 18 | |
| 107. As a result of the conduct described above, Juchi Lee engaged in improper | |
| professional conduct pursuant to Section 4C(a)(2) of the Exchange Act and Rule 102(e)(1)(ii) of | |
| the Commission’s Rules of Practice by engaging in repeated instances of unreasonable conduct | |
| and/or engaging in intentional or knowing conduct, including reckless conduct, and willfully | |
| violated or willfully aided and abetted violation of the federal securities laws under Section | |
| 4C(a)(3) of the Exchange Act and Rule 102(e)(1)(iii) of the Commission’s Rules of Practice, by | |
| willfully aiding and abetting and causing PLS’s violations of Rule 2-02(b)(1) of Regulation S-X, | |
| and by willfully violating PCAOB Rule 3500T and PCAOB Rule 4006. | |
| III. | |
| In view of the allegations made by the Division of Enforcement, the Commission deems it | |
| necessary and appropriate in the public interest that public administrative and cease-and-desist | |
| proceedings be instituted to determine: | |
| A. Whether the allegations set forth in Section II hereof are true and, in connection | |
| therewith, to afford Respondents an opportunity to establish any defenses to such allegations; | |
| B. What, if any, remedial action is appropriate in the public interest against | |
| Respondents pursuant to Section 4C of the Exchange Act and Rule 102(e) of the Commission’s | |
| Rules of Practice; | |
| C. Whether, pursuant to Section 21C of the Exchange Act, Respondents should be | |
| ordered to cease and desist from committing or causing violation of and any future violations of | |
| Rule 2-02(b)(1) of Regulation S-X, PCAOB Rule 3500T, and PCAOB Rule 4006; whether PLS | |
| should be ordered to pay disgorgement of audit fees for each of the audits at issue pursuant to | |
| Sections 21B(e) and 21C(e) of the Exchange Act; and whether Respondents should be ordered to | |
| pay civil penalties pursuant to Section 21B(a) of the Exchange Act. | |
| IV. | |
| IT IS ORDERED that a public hearing before the Commission for the purposes of taking | |
| evidence on the questions set forth in Section III hereof shall be convened not earlier than 30 days | |
| and not later than 60 days from service of this Order at a time and place to be fixed by further order | |
| of the Commission, pursuant to Rule 110 of the Commission’s Rules of Practice, 17 C.F.R. § | |
| 201.110. | |
| IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Respondents shall file an Answer to the allegations | |
| contained in this Order within twenty (20) days after service of this Order, as provided by Rule | |
| 220(b) of the Commission's Rules of Practice, 17 C.F.R. § 201.220(b). | |
| IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the Division of Enforcement and Respondents shall | |
| conduct a prehearing conference pursuant to Rule 221 of the Commission’s Rules of Practice, | |
| 19 | |
| 17 C.F.R. § 201.221, within fourteen (14) days of service of the Answer. The parties may meet in | |
| person or participate by telephone or other remote means; following the conference, they shall file | |
| a statement with the Office of the Secretary advising the Commission of any agreements reached at | |
| said conference. If a prehearing conference was not held, a statement shall be filed with the Office | |
| of the Secretary advising the Commission of that fact and of the efforts made to meet and confer. | |
| If any Respondent fails to file the directed Answer, or fails to appear at a hearing after | |
| being duly notified, the Respondent may be deemed in default and the proceedings may be | |
| determined against them upon consideration of this Order, the allegations of which may be deemed | |
| to be true as provided by Rules 155(a), 220(f), 221(f) and 310 of the Commission's Rules of | |
| Practice, 17 C.F.R. §§ 201.155(a), 201.220(f), 201.221(f) and 201.310. | |
| This Order shall be served forthwith upon Respondents by any means permitted by the | |
| Commission’s Rules of Practice. | |
| Attention is called to Rule 151(b) and (c) of the Commission’s Rules of Practice, 17 C.F.R. | |
| § 201.151(b) and (c), providing that when, as here, a proceeding is set before the Commission, all | |
| papers (including those listed in the following paragraph) shall be filed with the Office of the | |
| Secretary and all motions, objections, or applications will be decided by the Commission. The | |
| Commission requests that an electronic courtesy copy of each filing should be emailed to | |
| APFilings@sec.gov | |
| in PDF text-searchable format. Any exhibits should be sent as separate | |
| attachments, not a combined PDF. | |
| The Commission finds that it would serve the interests of justice and not result in prejudice | |
| to any party to provide, pursuant to Rule 100(c) of the Commission’s Rules of Practice, 17 C.F.R. | |
| § 201.100(c), that notwithstanding any contrary reference in the Rules of Practice to filing with or | |
| disposition by a hearing officer, all filings, including those under Rules 210, 221, 222, 230, 231, | |
| 232, 233, and 250 of the Commission’s Rules of Practice, 17 C.F.R. §§ 201.210, 221, 222, 230, | |
| 231, 232, 233, and 250, shall be directed to and, as appropriate, decided by the Commission. This | |
| proceeding shall be deemed to be one under the 120-day timeframe specified in Rule of Practice | |
| 360(a)(2)(i), 17 C.F.R. § 201.360(a)(2)(i), for the purposes of applying Rules of Practice 233 and | |
| 250, 17 C.F.R. §§ 201.233 and 250. | |
| The Commission finds that it would serve the interests of justice and not result in prejudice | |
| to any party to provide, pursuant to Rule 100(c) of the Commission’s Rules of Practice, 17 C.F.R. | |
| § 201.100(c), that the Commission shall issue a decision on the basis of the record in this | |
| proceeding, which shall consist of the items listed at Rule 350(a) of the Commission’s Rules of | |
| Practice, 17 C.F.R. § 201.350(a), and any other document or item filed with the Office of the | |
| Secretary and accepted into the record by the Commission. The provisions of Rule 351 of the | |
| Commission’s Rules of Practice, 17 C.F.R. § 201.351, relating to preparation and certification of a | |
| record index by the Office of the Secretary or the hearing officer are not applicable to this | |
| proceeding. | |
| 20 | |
| The Commission will issue a final order resolving the proceeding after one of the following: | |
| (A) The completion of post-hearing briefing in a proceeding where the public hearing has been | |
| completed; (B) The completion of briefing on a motion for a ruling on the pleadings or a motion for | |
| summary disposition pursuant to Rule 250 of the Commission’s Rules of Practice, 17 C.F.R. § | |
| 201.250, where the Commission has determined that no public hearing is necessary; or (C) The | |
| determination that a party is deemed to be in default under Rule 155 of the Commission’s Rules of | |
| Practice, 17 C.F.R. § 201.155, and no public hearing is necessary. | |
| In the absence of an appropriate waiver, no officer or employee of the Commission | |
| engaged in the performance of investigative or prosecuting functions in this or any factually related | |
| proceeding will be permitted to participate or advise in the decision of this matter, except as | |
| witness or counsel in proceedings held pursuant to notice. Since this proceeding is not “rule | |
| making” within the meaning of Section 551 of the Administrative Procedure Act, it is not deemed | |
| subject to the provisions of Section 553 delaying the effective date of any final Commission action. | |
| By the Commission. | |
| Vanessa A. Countryman | |
| Secretary | |