Datasets:
Tasks:
Text Generation
Languages:
English
Size:
n<1K
Tags:
structured-editing
structured-edit-interface-study
language-model-interfaces
verified-code-edits
fail-closed-evaluation
software-engineering-agents
License:
| {"arms":{"R":{"applicable":9,"fenceRemoved":0,"hiddenPasses":9,"lfAppended":0,"n":19,"validEnvelopes":11,"visiblePasses":9,"wilsonHidden":{"lower95":0.2732980516117956,"method":"wilson_score","n":19,"proportion":0.47368421052631576,"successes":9,"upper95":0.6829219075488682}},"RN":{"applicable":15,"fenceRemoved":11,"hiddenPasses":14,"lfAppended":0,"n":19,"validEnvelopes":18,"visiblePasses":14,"wilsonHidden":{"lower95":0.5120844910218489,"method":"wilson_score","n":19,"proportion":0.7368421052631579,"successes":14,"upper95":0.8819358765321749}},"U0":{"applicable":0,"fenceRemoved":0,"hiddenPasses":0,"lfAppended":0,"n":19,"validEnvelopes":0,"visiblePasses":0,"wilsonHidden":{"lower95":0,"method":"wilson_score","n":19,"proportion":0,"successes":0,"upper95":0.16817922405261626}},"U1":{"applicable":0,"fenceRemoved":0,"hiddenPasses":0,"lfAppended":1,"n":19,"validEnvelopes":0,"visiblePasses":0,"wilsonHidden":{"lower95":0,"method":"wilson_score","n":19,"proportion":0,"successes":0,"upper95":0.16817922405261626}}},"cellEvidenceCount":80,"model":"qwen/qwen3-32b","offlineExportProviderRequests":0,"primaryComparisonU1VsR":{"aOnly":0,"absoluteDifference":-0.47368421052631576,"absolutePairedDifference":9,"armA":"U1","armAPasses":0,"armB":"R","armBPasses":9,"bOnly":9,"both":0,"discordant":9,"exactTwoSidedPValue":0.00390625,"method":"exact_binomial_mcnemar","n":19,"neither":10,"pairedDiffCI":{"difference":-0.47368421052631576,"lower95":-0.47368421052631576,"method":"newcombe_wilson_score_for_paired_difference_via_discordant_binomial","note":"Derived from Wilson CI on P(R-only | discordant), scaled by discordant/n.","upper95":-0.19028363833937928},"pairedN":19,"rOnly":0,"uOnly":9,"wilsonA":{"lower95":0,"method":"wilson_score","n":19,"proportion":0,"successes":0,"upper95":0.16817922405261626},"wilsonB":{"lower95":0.2732980516117956,"method":"wilson_score","n":19,"proportion":0.47368421052631576,"successes":9,"upper95":0.6829219075488682}},"primaryDenominator":19,"protocolId":"qwen3-32b-v7-four-arm-interface-calibration-v1","providerLabel":"openrouter","recordKind":"PUBLIC_CALIBRATION_AGGREGATE_RESULTS","schemaVersion":1,"sentinelExcludedFromPrimary":true,"sentinelTaskId":"cal-l10","studyId":"workledger-structured-edit-interface-study-v0.1","upstreamLabel":"deepinfra"} | |
| {"cellEvidenceCount":152,"deepseekPrivacyGuardrail404Cells":38,"expectedCellEvidenceCount":152,"frozenDecisionLabels":{"CROSS_MODEL_GENERALIZATION_SIGNAL":false,"MODEL_STRENGTH_INTERACTION_DIRECTIONAL":{"descriptiveOnly":true,"notAParameterScalingLaw":true,"note":"Reported as a descriptive cross-model pattern only; provider and model-family differences are confounded.","value":true},"READY_FOR_PUBLICATION_V0_1":true},"infrastructureValidCells":113,"infrastructureValidRate":0.743421052631579,"latencySummary":{"maxMs":901820,"meanMs":34039.84868421053,"medianMs":10686,"minMs":25,"n":152},"liveProtocolId":"qwen3-32b-v7-calibrated-multimodel-live-v1","offlineExportProviderRequests":0,"protocolId":"qwen3-32b-v7-calibrated-multimodel-offline-v1","providerRequestsDuringExport":0,"publicConclusion":"Interface advantage replicated for Qwen3 14B and Qwen3 235B A22B; it did not replicate for Qwen3 8B, DeepSeek V4 Pro was unassessable due to privacy-guardrail 404 failures, and the registered cross-model generalization signal is false.","publicationReadiness":{"READY_FOR_PUBLICATION_V0_1":true,"claimsHonest":true,"leakagePending":false,"noFalseCrossModelGeneralizationClaim":true,"note":"Public export leakage scan passed; internal post-run readiness remains conditioned on complete evidence and honest claims.","publicExportLeakagePass":true,"studyComplete":true},"qwen32bExternalAnchor":{"anchorLabel":"EXISTING_QWEN3_32B_CALIBRATION_ANCHOR_NOT_REEXECUTED","importedCellCount":38,"notInPaidDenominator":true,"proofSha256":"6d9da979bebdf845c9dca44ebc0966e119ee09d5c8bfd527e5860f610f78b989","sourceEvidenceTip":"c8e876133ed2745f23bc14d00aca79d68e83d590"},"recordKind":"PUBLIC_MULTIMODEL_LIVE_AGGREGATE_RESULTS","schemaVersion":1,"studyComplete":true,"studyId":"workledger-structured-edit-interface-study-v0.1","tokenAndCostSummary":{"completionTokens":266900,"confirmedCostUsd":0.23197088399999993,"conservativeAccountingCostUsd":1.1398656208421047,"promptTokens":115810,"reservationFallbackCostUsd":0.9078947368421049,"totalTokens":382710},"transportConstructedDuringExport":false} | |
| {"cellCount":38,"costSummary":{"cellsChargedByReservationFallback":1,"cellsWithConfirmedCost":37,"completionTokens":135942,"confirmedCostUsd":0.06627527399999998,"conservativeAccountingCostUsd":0.07417001084210526,"liveRequestCount":38,"promptTokens":37792,"reservationFallbackCostUsd":0.007894736842105263,"totalTokens":173734},"deepseekPrivacyGuardrail404Count":0,"displayName":"Qwen3 8B","frozenDecisionLabels":{"INTERFACE_ADVANTAGE_REPLICATES_FOR_MODEL":false,"NORMALIZATION_MATERIALLY_RECOVERS_MODEL":false},"httpStatusClassCounts":{"200":38},"infrastructureValidCells":37,"liveProtocolId":"qwen3-32b-v7-calibrated-multimodel-live-v1","modelId":"qwen/qwen3-8b","modelKey":"qwen3-8b","nativeStrict":{"cellCount":38,"hiddenPassCI":{"lower95":0.0922176518522127,"method":"wilson_score","n":38,"proportion":0.18421052631578946,"successes":7,"upper95":0.334188580711314},"hiddenPassRate":0.18421052631578946,"hiddenPasses":7,"pairedDifferenceCI":{"difference":0.16666666666666666,"lower95":-0.1097176485746294,"method":"newcombe_wilson_score_for_paired_difference_via_discordant_binomial","note":"Derived from Wilson CI on P(R-only | discordant), scaled by discordant/n.","upper95":0.3249408368857338},"pairedMcnemar":{"absoluteDifference":0.16666666666666669,"both":0,"discordant":7,"exactTwoSidedPValue":0.453125,"method":"exact_binomial_mcnemar","n":18,"neither":11,"rOnly":5,"uOnly":2},"policy":"native-strict","visiblePasses":7},"offlineExportProviderRequests":0,"oneOuterFence":{"cellCount":38,"hiddenPassCI":{"lower95":0.0922176518522127,"method":"wilson_score","n":38,"proportion":0.18421052631578946,"successes":7,"upper95":0.334188580711314},"hiddenPassRate":0.18421052631578946,"hiddenPasses":7,"pairedDifferenceCI":{"difference":0.16666666666666666,"lower95":-0.1097176485746294,"method":"newcombe_wilson_score_for_paired_difference_via_discordant_binomial","note":"Derived from Wilson CI on P(R-only | discordant), scaled by discordant/n.","upper95":0.3249408368857338},"pairedMcnemar":{"absoluteDifference":0.16666666666666669,"both":0,"discordant":7,"exactTwoSidedPValue":0.453125,"method":"exact_binomial_mcnemar","n":18,"neither":11,"rOnly":5,"uOnly":2},"policy":"one-outer-fence","visiblePasses":7},"parameterization":"dense 8.2B","protocolId":"qwen3-32b-v7-calibrated-multimodel-offline-v1","providerRequestsDuringExport":0,"recordKind":"PUBLIC_MULTIMODEL_MODEL_AGGREGATE_RESULTS","recoveredCells":0,"schemaVersion":1,"studyId":"workledger-structured-edit-interface-study-v0.1","terminalClassificationCounts":{"MODEL_EDIT_APPLIED_ALL_EVALUATIONS_PASS":7,"MODEL_EDIT_APPLIED_VISIBLE_FAIL":2,"MODEL_EDIT_PATH_INVALID":10,"MODEL_EDIT_TARGET_AMBIGUOUS":1,"MODEL_EMITTED_INVALID_ENVELOPE":17,"PROVIDER_TRANSPORT_FAILURE":1},"transportConstructedDuringExport":false,"transportRequestFailures":0} | |
| {"cellCount":38,"costSummary":{"cellsChargedByReservationFallback":0,"cellsWithConfirmedCost":38,"completionTokens":60172,"confirmedCostUsd":0.019124640000000002,"conservativeAccountingCostUsd":0.019124640000000002,"liveRequestCount":38,"promptTokens":39028,"reservationFallbackCostUsd":0,"totalTokens":99200},"deepseekPrivacyGuardrail404Count":0,"displayName":"Qwen3 14B","frozenDecisionLabels":{"INTERFACE_ADVANTAGE_REPLICATES_FOR_MODEL":true,"NORMALIZATION_MATERIALLY_RECOVERS_MODEL":false},"httpStatusClassCounts":{"200":38},"infrastructureValidCells":38,"liveProtocolId":"qwen3-32b-v7-calibrated-multimodel-live-v1","modelId":"qwen/qwen3-14b","modelKey":"qwen3-14b","nativeStrict":{"cellCount":38,"hiddenPassCI":{"lower95":0.23384219247155957,"method":"wilson_score","n":38,"proportion":0.3684210526315789,"successes":14,"upper95":0.5271604044299099},"hiddenPassRate":0.3684210526315789,"hiddenPasses":14,"pairedDifferenceCI":{"difference":0.631578947368421,"lower95":0.27309277690724687,"method":"newcombe_wilson_score_for_paired_difference_via_discordant_binomial","note":"Derived from Wilson CI on P(R-only | discordant), scaled by discordant/n.","upper95":0.7180935775294239},"pairedMcnemar":{"absoluteDifference":0.631578947368421,"both":0,"discordant":14,"exactTwoSidedPValue":0.0018310546875,"method":"exact_binomial_mcnemar","n":19,"neither":5,"rOnly":13,"uOnly":1},"policy":"native-strict","visiblePasses":14},"offlineExportProviderRequests":0,"oneOuterFence":{"cellCount":38,"hiddenPassCI":{"lower95":0.23384219247155957,"method":"wilson_score","n":38,"proportion":0.3684210526315789,"successes":14,"upper95":0.5271604044299099},"hiddenPassRate":0.3684210526315789,"hiddenPasses":14,"pairedDifferenceCI":{"difference":0.631578947368421,"lower95":0.27309277690724687,"method":"newcombe_wilson_score_for_paired_difference_via_discordant_binomial","note":"Derived from Wilson CI on P(R-only | discordant), scaled by discordant/n.","upper95":0.7180935775294239},"pairedMcnemar":{"absoluteDifference":0.631578947368421,"both":0,"discordant":14,"exactTwoSidedPValue":0.0018310546875,"method":"exact_binomial_mcnemar","n":19,"neither":5,"rOnly":13,"uOnly":1},"policy":"one-outer-fence","visiblePasses":14},"parameterization":"dense 14.8B","protocolId":"qwen3-32b-v7-calibrated-multimodel-offline-v1","providerRequestsDuringExport":0,"recordKind":"PUBLIC_MULTIMODEL_MODEL_AGGREGATE_RESULTS","recoveredCells":0,"schemaVersion":1,"studyId":"workledger-structured-edit-interface-study-v0.1","terminalClassificationCounts":{"MODEL_EDIT_APPLIED_ALL_EVALUATIONS_PASS":14,"MODEL_EDIT_APPLIED_VISIBLE_FAIL":2,"MODEL_EDIT_NOT_APPLICABLE":2,"MODEL_EDIT_TARGET_AMBIGUOUS":2,"MODEL_EMITTED_INVALID_ENVELOPE":18},"transportConstructedDuringExport":false,"transportRequestFailures":0} | |
| {"cellCount":38,"costSummary":{"cellsChargedByReservationFallback":0,"cellsWithConfirmedCost":38,"completionTokens":70786,"confirmedCostUsd":0.14657096999999997,"conservativeAccountingCostUsd":0.14657096999999997,"liveRequestCount":38,"promptTokens":38990,"reservationFallbackCostUsd":0,"totalTokens":109776},"deepseekPrivacyGuardrail404Count":0,"displayName":"Qwen3 235B A22B","frozenDecisionLabels":{"INTERFACE_ADVANTAGE_REPLICATES_FOR_MODEL":true,"NORMALIZATION_MATERIALLY_RECOVERS_MODEL":false},"httpStatusClassCounts":{"200":38},"infrastructureValidCells":38,"liveProtocolId":"qwen3-32b-v7-calibrated-multimodel-live-v1","modelId":"qwen/qwen3-235b-a22b","modelKey":"qwen3-235b-a22b","nativeStrict":{"cellCount":38,"hiddenPassCI":{"lower95":0.34849928364395105,"method":"wilson_score","n":38,"proportion":0.5,"successes":19,"upper95":0.6515007163560489},"hiddenPassRate":0.5,"hiddenPasses":19,"pairedDifferenceCI":{"difference":0.6842105263157895,"lower95":0.3720800167784652,"method":"newcombe_wilson_score_for_paired_difference_via_discordant_binomial","note":"Derived from Wilson CI on P(R-only | discordant), scaled by discordant/n.","upper95":0.6842105263157895},"pairedMcnemar":{"absoluteDifference":0.6842105263157894,"both":3,"discordant":13,"exactTwoSidedPValue":0.000244140625,"method":"exact_binomial_mcnemar","n":19,"neither":3,"rOnly":13,"uOnly":0},"policy":"native-strict","visiblePasses":19},"offlineExportProviderRequests":0,"oneOuterFence":{"cellCount":38,"hiddenPassCI":{"lower95":0.34849928364395105,"method":"wilson_score","n":38,"proportion":0.5,"successes":19,"upper95":0.6515007163560489},"hiddenPassRate":0.5,"hiddenPasses":19,"pairedDifferenceCI":{"difference":0.6842105263157895,"lower95":0.3720800167784652,"method":"newcombe_wilson_score_for_paired_difference_via_discordant_binomial","note":"Derived from Wilson CI on P(R-only | discordant), scaled by discordant/n.","upper95":0.6842105263157895},"pairedMcnemar":{"absoluteDifference":0.6842105263157894,"both":3,"discordant":13,"exactTwoSidedPValue":0.000244140625,"method":"exact_binomial_mcnemar","n":19,"neither":3,"rOnly":13,"uOnly":0},"policy":"one-outer-fence","visiblePasses":19},"parameterization":"MoE 235B total / 22B active","protocolId":"qwen3-32b-v7-calibrated-multimodel-offline-v1","providerRequestsDuringExport":0,"recordKind":"PUBLIC_MULTIMODEL_MODEL_AGGREGATE_RESULTS","recoveredCells":0,"schemaVersion":1,"studyId":"workledger-structured-edit-interface-study-v0.1","terminalClassificationCounts":{"MODEL_EDIT_APPLIED_ALL_EVALUATIONS_PASS":19,"MODEL_EDIT_APPLIED_VISIBLE_FAIL":3,"MODEL_EDIT_NOT_APPLICABLE":1,"MODEL_EDIT_TARGET_AMBIGUOUS":1,"MODEL_EMITTED_INVALID_ENVELOPE":14},"transportConstructedDuringExport":false,"transportRequestFailures":0} | |
| {"cellCount":38,"costSummary":{"cellsChargedByReservationFallback":38,"cellsWithConfirmedCost":0,"completionTokens":0,"confirmedCostUsd":0,"conservativeAccountingCostUsd":0.8999999999999996,"liveRequestCount":38,"promptTokens":0,"reservationFallbackCostUsd":0.8999999999999996,"totalTokens":0},"deepseekPrivacyGuardrail404Count":38,"displayName":"DeepSeek V4 Pro","frozenDecisionLabels":{"INTERFACE_ADVANTAGE_REPLICATES_FOR_MODEL":false,"NORMALIZATION_MATERIALLY_RECOVERS_MODEL":false},"httpStatusClassCounts":{"404":38},"infrastructureValidCells":0,"liveProtocolId":"qwen3-32b-v7-calibrated-multimodel-live-v1","modelId":"deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro","modelKey":"deepseek-v4-pro","nativeStrict":{"cellCount":38,"hiddenPassCI":{"lower95":0,"method":"wilson_score","n":38,"proportion":0,"successes":0,"upper95":0.09180986822558396},"hiddenPassRate":0,"hiddenPasses":0,"pairedDifferenceCI":{"difference":0,"lower95":0,"method":"newcombe_wilson_score_for_paired_difference_via_discordant_binomial","note":"No discordant pairs; CI collapses to the point estimate.","upper95":0},"pairedMcnemar":{"absoluteDifference":0,"both":0,"discordant":0,"exactTwoSidedPValue":1,"method":"exact_binomial_mcnemar","n":0,"neither":0,"rOnly":0,"uOnly":0},"policy":"native-strict","visiblePasses":0},"offlineExportProviderRequests":0,"oneOuterFence":{"cellCount":38,"hiddenPassCI":{"lower95":0,"method":"wilson_score","n":38,"proportion":0,"successes":0,"upper95":0.09180986822558396},"hiddenPassRate":0,"hiddenPasses":0,"pairedDifferenceCI":{"difference":0,"lower95":0,"method":"newcombe_wilson_score_for_paired_difference_via_discordant_binomial","note":"No discordant pairs; CI collapses to the point estimate.","upper95":0},"pairedMcnemar":{"absoluteDifference":0,"both":0,"discordant":0,"exactTwoSidedPValue":1,"method":"exact_binomial_mcnemar","n":0,"neither":0,"rOnly":0,"uOnly":0},"policy":"one-outer-fence","visiblePasses":0},"parameterization":"MoE 1.6T total / 49B active","protocolId":"qwen3-32b-v7-calibrated-multimodel-offline-v1","providerRequestsDuringExport":0,"recordKind":"PUBLIC_MULTIMODEL_MODEL_AGGREGATE_RESULTS","recoveredCells":0,"schemaVersion":1,"studyId":"workledger-structured-edit-interface-study-v0.1","terminalClassificationCounts":{"PROVIDER_REQUEST_FAILURE":38},"transportConstructedDuringExport":false,"transportRequestFailures":38} | |