gspc-master / power-table.json
Nicholastempleman's picture
GSPC Master: complete measurement estate — board, rankings, per-item rows, frontier SEPARATED result, power analysis, corrections ledger
8c1dce1 verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
45.4 kB
Invalid JSON:Unexpected token 'I', ..."section": Infinity, "... is not valid JSON
{ "schema": "csoai.gspc-power-table/0.1", "computed_at_utc": "2026-11-01T03:34:34+00:00", "dataset": "csoai/gspc-peritem-rows-2026-08-12", "rows_bound_by_peritem_sha256": "0d8dacfbe7384a5d2f6a83e7455482ab75f935366bbb6e18da61cfdac8890dec", "rows_total_analysed": 15580, "method": { "test": "McNemar paired test on per-item correctness, model arm vs model arm", "alpha": 0.05, "power": 0.8, "z_alpha_over_2": 1.9599639845400534, "z_beta": 0.8416212335729144, "mde_formula_pp": "MDE = 100*(z_{1-a/2}+z_{1-b})*sqrt(p_d/n)", "n_needed_formula": "n(delta) = [ z_{1-a/2}*sqrt(p_d) + z_{1-b}*sqrt(p_d-delta^2) ]^2 / delta^2", "p_d": "expected discordant rate held at the observed pair value; edge rule p_d_used = max(p_d_obs, delta) when floor binds (flagged)", "empirical_p": "exact McNemar = two-sided binomial on discordants, board producer convention: p = min(1, 2*P(X <= min(n10,n01))), X ~ Binom(n10+n01, 0.5)", "ranking_rule": "arms ranked by row-level accuracy (correct_rows/total_rows, repeats included), stable sort with ties keeping first-appearance file order; comparator = best base model in ranked order excluding the leader; McNemar and all power numbers use deduplicated distinct items", "item_identity": "full `item` text; duplicate (model,item) rows keep first occurrence for the paired test", "verdict_rule": "CAN_SEPARATE_NOW iff MDE at current n <= 15pp; else NEEDS_N_TO_15PP iff n needed for 15pp <= 400; else DESCRIPTIVE_ONLY", "public_separation_rule": "rank 6 base models (13 sov6-*-v3-light own models excluded), leader vs runner-up, SEPARATED iff exact McNemar p < 0.05" }, "summary": { "axes_analysed": 13, "axes_on_board": 14, "axes_with_published_rows": 13, "axis_without_published_rows": "jail (n=71 on the live board, UNTESTED; no rows in this dataset as of 2026-11-01)", "axes_with_valid_paired_instrument": 12, "public_rule_axes_testable": [ "affect", "safety", "art5-safeguard", "continuity", "care", "detector-interop", "governance", "machinery-conformity", "conformance", "openness", "provenance", "cross-reality" ], "public_rule_axes_separated_today": [], "public_rule_separated_count": 0, "zero_separation_claim": "VERIFIED", "full_fleet_top2_separated_today_in_lane": [ "affect", "care", "governance" ], "verdict_counts": { "NEEDS_N_TO_15PP": 10, "CAN_SEPARATE_NOW": 3 } }, "crosscheck_vs_SEPARATION_RESULT": [ { "axis": "affect", "ref_b10": 5, "ref_c01": 4, "ref_p": 1.0, "ours_b10": 5, "ours_c01": 4, "ours_p": 1.0, "match": true }, { "axis": "affect [full-fleet in-lane]", "ref_b10": 8, "ref_c01": 0, "ref_p": 0.0078, "ours_b10": 8, "ours_c01": 0, "ours_p": 0.007812, "match": true }, { "axis": "safety", "ref_b10": 4, "ref_c01": 2, "ref_p": 0.6875, "ours_b10": 4, "ours_c01": 2, "ours_p": 0.6875, "match": true }, { "axis": "safety [full-fleet in-lane]", "ref_b10": 4, "ref_c01": 2, "ref_p": 0.6875, "ours_b10": 4, "ours_c01": 2, "ours_p": 0.6875, "match": true }, { "axis": "art5-safeguard", "ref_b10": 1, "ref_c01": 0, "ref_p": 1.0, "ours_b10": 1, "ours_c01": 0, "ours_p": 1.0, "match": true }, { "axis": "art5-safeguard [full-fleet in-lane]", "ref_b10": 1, "ref_c01": 1, "ref_p": 1.0, "ours_b10": 1, "ours_c01": 1, "ours_p": 1.0, "match": true }, { "axis": "continuity", "ref_b10": 4, "ref_c01": 2, "ref_p": 0.6875, "ours_b10": 4, "ours_c01": 2, "ours_p": 0.6875, "match": true }, { "axis": "continuity [full-fleet in-lane]", "ref_b10": 2, "ref_c01": 2, "ref_p": 1.0, "ours_b10": 2, "ours_c01": 2, "ours_p": 1.0, "match": true }, { "axis": "care", "ref_b10": 32, "ref_c01": 25, "ref_p": 0.427, "ours_b10": 32, "ours_c01": 25, "ours_p": 0.427043, "match": true }, { "axis": "care [full-fleet in-lane]", "ref_b10": 78, "ref_c01": 53, "ref_p": 0.0356, "ours_b10": 78, "ours_c01": 53, "ours_p": 0.0356, "match": true }, { "axis": "detector-interop", "ref_b10": 5, "ref_c01": 2, "ref_p": 0.4531, "ours_b10": 5, "ours_c01": 2, "ours_p": 0.453125, "match": true }, { "axis": "detector-interop [full-fleet in-lane]", "ref_b10": 5, "ref_c01": 2, "ref_p": 0.4531, "ours_b10": 5, "ours_c01": 2, "ours_p": 0.453125, "match": true }, { "axis": "governance", "ref_b10": 70, "ref_c01": 59, "ref_p": 0.3787, "ours_b10": 70, "ours_c01": 59, "ours_p": 0.378688, "match": true }, { "axis": "governance [full-fleet in-lane]", "ref_b10": 63, "ref_c01": 36, "ref_p": 0.0086, "ours_b10": 63, "ours_c01": 36, "ours_p": 0.008634, "match": true }, { "axis": "machinery-conformity", "ref_b10": 8, "ref_c01": 5, "ref_p": 0.5811, "ours_b10": 8, "ours_c01": 5, "ours_p": 0.581055, "match": true }, { "axis": "machinery-conformity [full-fleet in-lane]", "ref_b10": 8, "ref_c01": 5, "ref_p": 0.5811, "ours_b10": 8, "ours_c01": 5, "ours_p": 0.581055, "match": true }, { "axis": "conformance", "ref_b10": 3, "ref_c01": 1, "ref_p": 0.625, "ours_b10": 3, "ours_c01": 1, "ours_p": 0.625, "match": true }, { "axis": "conformance [full-fleet in-lane]", "ref_b10": 5, "ref_c01": 4, "ref_p": 1.0, "ours_b10": 5, "ours_c01": 4, "ours_p": 1.0, "match": true }, { "axis": "openness", "ref_b10": 9, "ref_c01": 5, "ref_p": 0.424, "ours_b10": 9, "ours_c01": 5, "ours_p": 0.42395, "match": true }, { "axis": "openness [full-fleet in-lane]", "ref_b10": 2, "ref_c01": 1, "ref_p": 1.0, "ours_b10": 2, "ours_c01": 1, "ours_p": 1.0, "match": true }, { "axis": "provenance", "ref_b10": 6, "ref_c01": 5, "ref_p": 1.0, "ours_b10": 6, "ours_c01": 5, "ours_p": 1.0, "match": true }, { "axis": "provenance [full-fleet in-lane]", "ref_b10": 7, "ref_c01": 5, "ref_p": 0.7744, "ours_b10": 7, "ours_c01": 5, "ours_p": 0.774414, "match": true }, { "axis": "swarm", "ref_b10": 1, "ref_c01": 0, "ref_p": 1.0, "ours_b10": 1, "ours_c01": 0, "ours_p": 1.0, "match": true }, { "axis": "swarm [full-fleet in-lane]", "ref_b10": 1, "ref_c01": 0, "ref_p": 1.0, "ours_b10": 1, "ours_c01": 0, "ours_p": 1.0, "match": true }, { "axis": "cross-reality", "ref_b10": 9, "ref_c01": 2, "ref_p": 0.0654, "ours_b10": 9, "ours_c01": 2, "ours_p": 0.06543, "match": true }, { "axis": "cross-reality [full-fleet in-lane]", "ref_b10": 9, "ref_c01": 2, "ref_p": 0.0654, "ours_b10": 9, "ours_c01": 2, "ours_p": 0.06543, "match": true } ], "axes": [ { "axis": "affect", "file": "raw/rows/peritem_affect.jsonl", "rows": 779, "transport_errors": 0, "unparsed_rows": 50, "duplicate_rows_dropped": 0, "duplicate_grade_disagreements": 0, "n_current": 41, "n_distinct_items": 41, "n_arms": 19, "arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light" ], "base_arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b" ], "own_arms_excluded_from_public_rule": 13, "primary_pair_public_rule": { "leader": "gemma3:12b", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.6829, "runner_up": "qwen2.5:3b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.6585, "n": 41, "a_correct_b_wrong": 5, "b_correct_a_wrong": 4, "n_discordant": 9, "p_discordant": 0.2195, "observed_gap_pp": 2.44, "exact_mcnemar_p": 1.0, "separated": false, "label": "leader vs next best, 6 base models (public determination rule)" }, "mde_pp_at_current_n": 20.5, "mde_pp_at_current_n_exact_bisection": 19.91, "n_needed": { "5pp": 687, "10pp": 170, "15pp": 75 }, "p_discordant_floor_applied": { "5pp": false, "10pp": false, "15pp": false }, "verdict": "NEEDS_N_TO_15PP", "caveat": null, "paired_instrument_valid": true, "full_fleet_top2_in_lane": { "leader": "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.878, "runner_up": "gemma3:12b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.6829, "a_correct_b_wrong": 8, "b_correct_a_wrong": 0, "n_discordant": 8, "p_discordant": 0.1951, "observed_gap_pp": 19.51, "exact_mcnemar_p": 0.007812, "separated": true, "label": "in-lane: overall leader vs best base model, own models included; not a public ranking" }, "fleet_rank_order": [ "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "gemma3:12b", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "qwen2.5:3b", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "deepseek-r1:8b", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "mistral:7b", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "llama3.2:3b" ], "separated_pairs_base_only": 7, "separated_pairs_all_19": 71, "is_determination_axis": false }, { "axis": "safety", "file": "raw/rows/peritem_agi.jsonl", "rows": 684, "transport_errors": 0, "unparsed_rows": 37, "duplicate_rows_dropped": 0, "duplicate_grade_disagreements": 0, "n_current": 36, "n_distinct_items": 36, "n_arms": 19, "arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light" ], "base_arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b" ], "own_arms_excluded_from_public_rule": 13, "primary_pair_public_rule": { "leader": "gemma3:12b", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.9444, "runner_up": "qwen2.5:3b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.8889, "n": 36, "a_correct_b_wrong": 4, "b_correct_a_wrong": 2, "n_discordant": 6, "p_discordant": 0.1667, "observed_gap_pp": 5.56, "exact_mcnemar_p": 0.6875, "separated": false, "label": "leader vs next best, 6 base models (public determination rule)" }, "mde_pp_at_current_n": 19.06, "mde_pp_at_current_n_exact_bisection": 18.45, "n_needed": { "5pp": 521, "10pp": 129, "15pp": 56 }, "p_discordant_floor_applied": { "5pp": false, "10pp": false, "15pp": false }, "verdict": "NEEDS_N_TO_15PP", "caveat": null, "paired_instrument_valid": true, "full_fleet_top2_in_lane": { "leader": "gemma3:12b", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.9444, "runner_up": "qwen2.5:3b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.8889, "a_correct_b_wrong": 4, "b_correct_a_wrong": 2, "n_discordant": 6, "p_discordant": 0.1667, "observed_gap_pp": 5.56, "exact_mcnemar_p": 0.6875, "separated": false, "label": "in-lane: overall leader vs best base model, own models included; not a public ranking" }, "fleet_rank_order": [ "gemma3:12b", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "qwen2.5:3b", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "mistral:7b", "deepseek-r1:8b", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light", "llama3.2:3b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct" ], "separated_pairs_base_only": 8, "separated_pairs_all_19": 66, "is_determination_axis": true }, { "axis": "art5-safeguard", "file": "raw/rows/peritem_art5.jsonl", "rows": 684, "transport_errors": 0, "unparsed_rows": 8, "duplicate_rows_dropped": 0, "duplicate_grade_disagreements": 0, "n_current": 36, "n_distinct_items": 36, "n_arms": 19, "arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light" ], "base_arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b" ], "own_arms_excluded_from_public_rule": 13, "primary_pair_public_rule": { "leader": "gemma3:12b", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.9722, "runner_up": "mistral:7b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.9444, "n": 36, "a_correct_b_wrong": 1, "b_correct_a_wrong": 0, "n_discordant": 1, "p_discordant": 0.0278, "observed_gap_pp": 2.78, "exact_mcnemar_p": 1.0, "separated": false, "label": "leader vs next best, 6 base models (public determination rule)" }, "mde_pp_at_current_n": 7.78, "mde_pp_at_current_n_exact_bisection": 7.53, "n_needed": { "5pp": 155, "10pp": 77, "15pp": 50 }, "p_discordant_floor_applied": { "5pp": true, "10pp": true, "15pp": true }, "verdict": "CAN_SEPARATE_NOW", "caveat": null, "paired_instrument_valid": true, "full_fleet_top2_in_lane": { "leader": "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.9722, "runner_up": "gemma3:12b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.9722, "a_correct_b_wrong": 1, "b_correct_a_wrong": 1, "n_discordant": 2, "p_discordant": 0.0556, "observed_gap_pp": 0.0, "exact_mcnemar_p": 1.0, "separated": false, "label": "in-lane: overall leader vs best base model, own models included; not a public ranking" }, "fleet_rank_order": [ "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "gemma3:12b", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "mistral:7b", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "deepseek-r1:8b", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "llama3.2:3b", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "sov6-temporality-v3-light", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "qwen2.5:3b" ], "separated_pairs_base_only": 5, "separated_pairs_all_19": 55, "is_determination_axis": false }, { "axis": "continuity", "file": "raw/rows/peritem_asi.jsonl", "rows": 627, "transport_errors": 0, "unparsed_rows": 29, "duplicate_rows_dropped": 0, "duplicate_grade_disagreements": 0, "n_current": 33, "n_distinct_items": 33, "n_arms": 19, "arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light" ], "base_arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b" ], "own_arms_excluded_from_public_rule": 13, "primary_pair_public_rule": { "leader": "gemma3:12b", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.6061, "runner_up": "deepseek-r1:8b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.5455, "n": 33, "a_correct_b_wrong": 4, "b_correct_a_wrong": 2, "n_discordant": 6, "p_discordant": 0.1818, "observed_gap_pp": 6.06, "exact_mcnemar_p": 0.6875, "separated": false, "label": "leader vs next best, 6 base models (public determination rule)" }, "mde_pp_at_current_n": 20.8, "mde_pp_at_current_n_exact_bisection": 20.06, "n_needed": { "5pp": 569, "10pp": 141, "15pp": 62 }, "p_discordant_floor_applied": { "5pp": false, "10pp": false, "15pp": false }, "verdict": "NEEDS_N_TO_15PP", "caveat": null, "paired_instrument_valid": true, "full_fleet_top2_in_lane": { "leader": "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.6061, "runner_up": "gemma3:12b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.6061, "a_correct_b_wrong": 2, "b_correct_a_wrong": 2, "n_discordant": 4, "p_discordant": 0.1212, "observed_gap_pp": 0.0, "exact_mcnemar_p": 1.0, "separated": false, "label": "in-lane: overall leader vs best base model, own models included; not a public ranking" }, "fleet_rank_order": [ "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "gemma3:12b", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "deepseek-r1:8b", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "mistral:7b", "llama3.2:3b", "qwen2.5:3b", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light" ], "separated_pairs_base_only": 1, "separated_pairs_all_19": 22, "is_determination_axis": true }, { "axis": "care", "file": "raw/rows/peritem_care.jsonl", "rows": 3800, "transport_errors": 0, "unparsed_rows": 662, "duplicate_rows_dropped": 19, "duplicate_grade_disagreements": 1, "n_current": 199, "n_distinct_items": 199, "n_arms": 19, "arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light" ], "base_arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b" ], "own_arms_excluded_from_public_rule": 13, "primary_pair_public_rule": { "leader": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.405, "runner_up": "qwen2.5:3b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.37, "n": 199, "a_correct_b_wrong": 32, "b_correct_a_wrong": 25, "n_discordant": 57, "p_discordant": 0.2864, "observed_gap_pp": 3.52, "exact_mcnemar_p": 0.427043, "separated": false, "label": "leader vs next best, 6 base models (public determination rule)" }, "mde_pp_at_current_n": 10.63, "mde_pp_at_current_n_exact_bisection": 10.57, "n_needed": { "5pp": 897, "10pp": 223, "15pp": 98 }, "p_discordant_floor_applied": { "5pp": false, "10pp": false, "15pp": false }, "verdict": "CAN_SEPARATE_NOW", "caveat": null, "paired_instrument_valid": true, "full_fleet_top2_in_lane": { "leader": "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.535, "runner_up": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.405, "a_correct_b_wrong": 78, "b_correct_a_wrong": 53, "n_discordant": 131, "p_discordant": 0.6583, "observed_gap_pp": 12.56, "exact_mcnemar_p": 0.0356, "separated": true, "label": "in-lane: overall leader vs best base model, own models included; not a public ranking" }, "fleet_rank_order": [ "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "qwen2.5:3b", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "deepseek-r1:8b", "mistral:7b", "gemma3:12b", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "llama3.2:3b" ], "separated_pairs_base_only": 11, "separated_pairs_all_19": 118, "is_determination_axis": true }, { "axis": "detector-interop", "file": "raw/rows/peritem_det.jsonl", "rows": 627, "transport_errors": 0, "unparsed_rows": 110, "duplicate_rows_dropped": 0, "duplicate_grade_disagreements": 0, "n_current": 33, "n_distinct_items": 33, "n_arms": 19, "arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light" ], "base_arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b" ], "own_arms_excluded_from_public_rule": 13, "primary_pair_public_rule": { "leader": "deepseek-r1:8b", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.8788, "runner_up": "mistral:7b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.7879, "n": 33, "a_correct_b_wrong": 5, "b_correct_a_wrong": 2, "n_discordant": 7, "p_discordant": 0.2121, "observed_gap_pp": 9.09, "exact_mcnemar_p": 0.453125, "separated": false, "label": "leader vs next best, 6 base models (public determination rule)" }, "mde_pp_at_current_n": 22.46, "mde_pp_at_current_n_exact_bisection": 21.67, "n_needed": { "5pp": 664, "10pp": 165, "15pp": 72 }, "p_discordant_floor_applied": { "5pp": false, "10pp": false, "15pp": false }, "verdict": "NEEDS_N_TO_15PP", "caveat": null, "paired_instrument_valid": true, "full_fleet_top2_in_lane": { "leader": "deepseek-r1:8b", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.8788, "runner_up": "mistral:7b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.7879, "a_correct_b_wrong": 5, "b_correct_a_wrong": 2, "n_discordant": 7, "p_discordant": 0.2121, "observed_gap_pp": 9.09, "exact_mcnemar_p": 0.453125, "separated": false, "label": "in-lane: overall leader vs best base model, own models included; not a public ranking" }, "fleet_rank_order": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "mistral:7b", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "gemma3:12b", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "llama3.2:3b", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "qwen2.5:3b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light" ], "separated_pairs_base_only": 8, "separated_pairs_all_19": 86, "is_determination_axis": false }, { "axis": "governance", "file": "raw/rows/peritem_gov.jsonl", "rows": 4503, "transport_errors": 0, "unparsed_rows": 174, "duplicate_rows_dropped": 0, "duplicate_grade_disagreements": 0, "n_current": 237, "n_distinct_items": 237, "n_arms": 19, "arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light" ], "base_arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b" ], "own_arms_excluded_from_public_rule": 13, "primary_pair_public_rule": { "leader": "mistral:7b", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.5865, "runner_up": "deepseek-r1:8b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.5401, "n": 237, "a_correct_b_wrong": 70, "b_correct_a_wrong": 59, "n_discordant": 129, "p_discordant": 0.5443, "observed_gap_pp": 4.64, "exact_mcnemar_p": 0.378688, "separated": false, "label": "leader vs next best, 6 base models (public determination rule)" }, "mde_pp_at_current_n": 13.43, "mde_pp_at_current_n_exact_bisection": 13.36, "n_needed": { "5pp": 1707, "10pp": 425, "15pp": 188 }, "p_discordant_floor_applied": { "5pp": false, "10pp": false, "15pp": false }, "verdict": "CAN_SEPARATE_NOW", "caveat": null, "paired_instrument_valid": true, "full_fleet_top2_in_lane": { "leader": "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.7004, "runner_up": "mistral:7b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.5865, "a_correct_b_wrong": 63, "b_correct_a_wrong": 36, "n_discordant": 99, "p_discordant": 0.4177, "observed_gap_pp": 11.39, "exact_mcnemar_p": 0.008634, "separated": true, "label": "in-lane: overall leader vs best base model, own models included; not a public ranking" }, "fleet_rank_order": [ "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "mistral:7b", "deepseek-r1:8b", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "qwen2.5:3b", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct" ], "separated_pairs_base_only": 9, "separated_pairs_all_19": 100, "is_determination_axis": true }, { "axis": "machinery-conformity", "file": "raw/rows/peritem_mach.jsonl", "rows": 627, "transport_errors": 0, "unparsed_rows": 35, "duplicate_rows_dropped": 0, "duplicate_grade_disagreements": 0, "n_current": 33, "n_distinct_items": 33, "n_arms": 19, "arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light" ], "base_arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b" ], "own_arms_excluded_from_public_rule": 13, "primary_pair_public_rule": { "leader": "llama3.2:3b", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.5455, "runner_up": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.4545, "n": 33, "a_correct_b_wrong": 8, "b_correct_a_wrong": 5, "n_discordant": 13, "p_discordant": 0.3939, "observed_gap_pp": 9.09, "exact_mcnemar_p": 0.581055, "separated": false, "label": "leader vs next best, 6 base models (public determination rule)" }, "mde_pp_at_current_n": 30.61, "mde_pp_at_current_n_exact_bisection": 29.53, "n_needed": { "5pp": 1235, "10pp": 307, "15pp": 136 }, "p_discordant_floor_applied": { "5pp": false, "10pp": false, "15pp": false }, "verdict": "NEEDS_N_TO_15PP", "caveat": null, "paired_instrument_valid": true, "full_fleet_top2_in_lane": { "leader": "llama3.2:3b", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.5455, "runner_up": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.4545, "a_correct_b_wrong": 8, "b_correct_a_wrong": 5, "n_discordant": 13, "p_discordant": 0.3939, "observed_gap_pp": 9.09, "exact_mcnemar_p": 0.581055, "separated": false, "label": "in-lane: overall leader vs best base model, own models included; not a public ranking" }, "fleet_rank_order": [ "llama3.2:3b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "mistral:7b", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "qwen2.5:3b", "deepseek-r1:8b", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "gemma3:12b", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light" ], "separated_pairs_base_only": 2, "separated_pairs_all_19": 18, "is_determination_axis": false }, { "axis": "conformance", "file": "raw/rows/peritem_mcp.jsonl", "rows": 665, "transport_errors": 0, "unparsed_rows": 89, "duplicate_rows_dropped": 0, "duplicate_grade_disagreements": 0, "n_current": 35, "n_distinct_items": 35, "n_arms": 19, "arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light" ], "base_arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b" ], "own_arms_excluded_from_public_rule": 13, "primary_pair_public_rule": { "leader": "mistral:7b", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.7143, "runner_up": "llama3.2:3b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.6571, "n": 35, "a_correct_b_wrong": 3, "b_correct_a_wrong": 1, "n_discordant": 4, "p_discordant": 0.1143, "observed_gap_pp": 5.71, "exact_mcnemar_p": 0.625, "separated": false, "label": "leader vs next best, 6 base models (public determination rule)" }, "mde_pp_at_current_n": 16.01, "mde_pp_at_current_n_exact_bisection": 15.48, "n_needed": { "5pp": 357, "10pp": 88, "15pp": 50 }, "p_discordant_floor_applied": { "5pp": false, "10pp": false, "15pp": true }, "verdict": "NEEDS_N_TO_15PP", "caveat": null, "paired_instrument_valid": true, "full_fleet_top2_in_lane": { "leader": "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.7429, "runner_up": "mistral:7b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.7143, "a_correct_b_wrong": 5, "b_correct_a_wrong": 4, "n_discordant": 9, "p_discordant": 0.2571, "observed_gap_pp": 2.86, "exact_mcnemar_p": 1.0, "separated": false, "label": "in-lane: overall leader vs best base model, own models included; not a public ranking" }, "fleet_rank_order": [ "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "mistral:7b", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "llama3.2:3b", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "gemma3:12b", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "qwen2.5:3b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "deepseek-r1:8b" ], "separated_pairs_base_only": 5, "separated_pairs_all_19": 38, "is_determination_axis": true }, { "axis": "openness", "file": "raw/rows/peritem_oss.jsonl", "rows": 608, "transport_errors": 0, "unparsed_rows": 30, "duplicate_rows_dropped": 0, "duplicate_grade_disagreements": 0, "n_current": 32, "n_distinct_items": 32, "n_arms": 19, "arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light" ], "base_arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b" ], "own_arms_excluded_from_public_rule": 13, "primary_pair_public_rule": { "leader": "gemma3:12b", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.8438, "runner_up": "mistral:7b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.7188, "n": 32, "a_correct_b_wrong": 9, "b_correct_a_wrong": 5, "n_discordant": 14, "p_discordant": 0.4375, "observed_gap_pp": 12.5, "exact_mcnemar_p": 0.42395, "separated": false, "label": "leader vs next best, 6 base models (public determination rule)" }, "mde_pp_at_current_n": 32.76, "mde_pp_at_current_n_exact_bisection": 31.57, "n_needed": { "5pp": 1372, "10pp": 342, "15pp": 151 }, "p_discordant_floor_applied": { "5pp": false, "10pp": false, "15pp": false }, "verdict": "NEEDS_N_TO_15PP", "caveat": null, "paired_instrument_valid": true, "full_fleet_top2_in_lane": { "leader": "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.875, "runner_up": "gemma3:12b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.8438, "a_correct_b_wrong": 2, "b_correct_a_wrong": 1, "n_discordant": 3, "p_discordant": 0.0938, "observed_gap_pp": 3.12, "exact_mcnemar_p": 1.0, "separated": false, "label": "in-lane: overall leader vs best base model, own models included; not a public ranking" }, "fleet_rank_order": [ "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "gemma3:12b", "sov6-temporality-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "mistral:7b", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "qwen2.5:3b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "deepseek-r1:8b", "llama3.2:3b" ], "separated_pairs_base_only": 5, "separated_pairs_all_19": 30, "is_determination_axis": true }, { "axis": "provenance", "file": "raw/rows/peritem_prv.jsonl", "rows": 608, "transport_errors": 0, "unparsed_rows": 90, "duplicate_rows_dropped": 0, "duplicate_grade_disagreements": 0, "n_current": 32, "n_distinct_items": 32, "n_arms": 19, "arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light" ], "base_arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b" ], "own_arms_excluded_from_public_rule": 13, "primary_pair_public_rule": { "leader": "llama3.2:3b", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.7188, "runner_up": "gemma3:12b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.6875, "n": 32, "a_correct_b_wrong": 6, "b_correct_a_wrong": 5, "n_discordant": 11, "p_discordant": 0.3438, "observed_gap_pp": 3.12, "exact_mcnemar_p": 1.0, "separated": false, "label": "leader vs next best, 6 base models (public determination rule)" }, "mde_pp_at_current_n": 29.04, "mde_pp_at_current_n_exact_bisection": 27.98, "n_needed": { "5pp": 1078, "10pp": 268, "15pp": 118 }, "p_discordant_floor_applied": { "5pp": false, "10pp": false, "15pp": false }, "verdict": "NEEDS_N_TO_15PP", "caveat": null, "paired_instrument_valid": true, "full_fleet_top2_in_lane": { "leader": "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.7812, "runner_up": "llama3.2:3b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.7188, "a_correct_b_wrong": 7, "b_correct_a_wrong": 5, "n_discordant": 12, "p_discordant": 0.375, "observed_gap_pp": 6.25, "exact_mcnemar_p": 0.774414, "separated": false, "label": "in-lane: overall leader vs best base model, own models included; not a public ranking" }, "fleet_rank_order": [ "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "llama3.2:3b", "gemma3:12b", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:3b", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "deepseek-r1:8b", "sov6-logic-v3-light" ], "separated_pairs_base_only": 5, "separated_pairs_all_19": 39, "is_determination_axis": true }, { "axis": "swarm", "file": "raw/rows/peritem_swarm.jsonl", "rows": 760, "transport_errors": 0, "unparsed_rows": 142, "duplicate_rows_dropped": 703, "duplicate_grade_disagreements": 16, "n_current": 3, "n_distinct_items": 3, "n_arms": 19, "arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light" ], "base_arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b" ], "own_arms_excluded_from_public_rule": 13, "primary_pair_public_rule": { "leader": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.975, "runner_up": "gemma3:12b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.475, "n": 3, "a_correct_b_wrong": 1, "b_correct_a_wrong": 0, "n_discordant": 1, "p_discordant": 0.3333, "observed_gap_pp": 33.33, "exact_mcnemar_p": 1.0, "separated": false, "label": "leader vs next best, 6 base models (public determination rule)" }, "mde_pp_at_current_n": 93.39, "mde_pp_at_current_n_exact_bisection": Infinity, "n_needed": { "5pp": 1045, "10pp": 260, "15pp": 114 }, "p_discordant_floor_applied": { "5pp": false, "10pp": false, "15pp": false }, "verdict": "NEEDS_N_TO_15PP", "caveat": "swarm rows are the retired 3-item PROTOCOL bank (40 rows/model over 3 distinct items); a paired determination is not supported regardless of these power numbers", "paired_instrument_valid": false, "full_fleet_top2_in_lane": { "leader": "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.975, "runner_up": "gemma3:12b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.475, "a_correct_b_wrong": 1, "b_correct_a_wrong": 0, "n_discordant": 1, "p_discordant": 0.3333, "observed_gap_pp": 33.33, "exact_mcnemar_p": 1.0, "separated": false, "label": "in-lane: overall leader vs best base model, own models included; not a public ranking" }, "fleet_rank_order": [ "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "qwen2.5:3b", "mistral:7b", "deepseek-r1:8b", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light" ], "separated_pairs_base_only": 0, "separated_pairs_all_19": 0, "is_determination_axis": false }, { "axis": "cross-reality", "file": "raw/rows/peritem_xr.jsonl", "rows": 608, "transport_errors": 0, "unparsed_rows": 15, "duplicate_rows_dropped": 0, "duplicate_grade_disagreements": 0, "n_current": 32, "n_distinct_items": 32, "n_arms": 19, "arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light" ], "base_arms": [ "deepseek-r1:8b", "gemma3:12b", "llama3.2:3b", "mistral:7b", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "qwen2.5:3b" ], "own_arms_excluded_from_public_rule": 13, "primary_pair_public_rule": { "leader": "mistral:7b", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.8125, "runner_up": "llama3.2:3b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.5938, "n": 32, "a_correct_b_wrong": 9, "b_correct_a_wrong": 2, "n_discordant": 11, "p_discordant": 0.3438, "observed_gap_pp": 21.88, "exact_mcnemar_p": 0.06543, "separated": false, "label": "leader vs next best, 6 base models (public determination rule)" }, "mde_pp_at_current_n": 29.04, "mde_pp_at_current_n_exact_bisection": 27.98, "n_needed": { "5pp": 1078, "10pp": 268, "15pp": 118 }, "p_discordant_floor_applied": { "5pp": false, "10pp": false, "15pp": false }, "verdict": "NEEDS_N_TO_15PP", "caveat": null, "paired_instrument_valid": true, "full_fleet_top2_in_lane": { "leader": "mistral:7b", "leader_row_accuracy": 0.8125, "runner_up": "llama3.2:3b", "runner_up_row_accuracy": 0.5938, "a_correct_b_wrong": 9, "b_correct_a_wrong": 2, "n_discordant": 11, "p_discordant": 0.3438, "observed_gap_pp": 21.88, "exact_mcnemar_p": 0.06543, "separated": false, "label": "in-lane: overall leader vs best base model, own models included; not a public ranking" }, "fleet_rank_order": [ "mistral:7b", "llama3.2:3b", "sov6-creation-v3-light", "sov6-embodiment-v3-light", "sov6-aesthetics-v3-light", "sov6-agency-v3-light", "sov6-logic-v3-light", "sov6-destruction-v3-light", "sov6-preservation-v3-light", "qwen2.5:0.5b-instruct", "gemma3:12b", "deepseek-r1:8b", "sov6-relationality-v3-light", "sov6-synthesis-v3-light", "sov6-ethics-v3-light", "sov6-identity-v3-light", "sov6-temporality-v3-light", "sov6-abstraction-v3-light", "qwen2.5:3b" ], "separated_pairs_base_only": 4, "separated_pairs_all_19": 17, "is_determination_axis": false } ] }
{
"schema": "csoai.gspc-power-table/0.1",
"computed_at_utc": "2026-11-01T03:34:34+00:00",
"dataset": "csoai/gspc-peritem-rows-2026-08-12",
"rows_bound_by_peritem_sha256": "0d8dacfbe7384a5d2f6a83e7455482ab75f935366bbb6e18da61cfdac8890dec",
"rows_total_analysed": 15580,
"method": {
"test": "McNemar paired test on per-item correctness, model arm vs model arm",
"alpha": 0.05,
"power": 0.8,
"z_alpha_over_2": 1.9599639845400534,
"z_beta": 0.8416212335729144,
"mde_formula_pp": "MDE = 100*(z_{1-a/2}+z_{1-b})*sqrt(p_d/n)",
"n_needed_formula": "n(delta) = [ z_{1-a/2}*sqrt(p_d) + z_{1-b}*sqrt(p_d-delta^2) ]^2 / delta^2",
"p_d": "expected discordant rate held at the observed pair value; edge rule p_d_used = max(p_d_obs, delta) when floor binds (flagged)",
"empirical_p": "exact McNemar = two-sided binomial on discordants, board producer convention: p = min(1, 2*P(X <= min(n10,n01))), X ~ Binom(n10+n01, 0.5)",
"ranking_rule": "arms ranked by row-level accuracy (correct_rows/total_rows, repeats included), stable sort with ties keeping first-appearance file order; comparator = best base model in ranked order excluding the leader; McNemar and all power numbers use deduplicated distinct items",
"item_identity": "full `item` text; duplicate (model,item) rows keep first occurrence for the paired test",
"verdict_rule": "CAN_SEPARATE_NOW iff MDE at current n <= 15pp; else NEEDS_N_TO_15PP iff n needed for 15pp <= 400; else DESCRIPTIVE_ONLY",
"public_separation_rule": "rank 6 base models (13 sov6-*-v3-light own models excluded), leader vs runner-up, SEPARATED iff exact McNemar p < 0.05"
},
"summary": {
"axes_analysed": 13,
"axes_on_board": 14,
"axes_with_published_rows": 13,
"axis_without_published_rows": "jail (n=71 on the live board, UNTESTED; no rows in this dataset as of 2026-11-01)",
"axes_with_valid_paired_instrument": 12,
"public_rule_axes_testable": [
"affect",
"safety",
"art5-safeguard",
"continuity",
"care",
"detector-interop",
"governance",
"machinery-conformity",
"conformance",
"openness",
"provenance",
"cross-reality"
],
"public_rule_axes_separated_today": [],
"public_rule_separated_count": 0,
"zero_separation_claim": "VERIFIED",
"full_fleet_top2_separated_today_in_lane": [
"affect",
"care",
"governance"
],
"verdict_counts": {
"NEEDS_N_TO_15PP": 10,
"CAN_SEPARATE_NOW": 3
}
},
"crosscheck_vs_SEPARATION_RESULT": [
{
"axis": "affect",
"ref_b10": 5,
"ref_c01": 4,
"ref_p": 1.0,
"ours_b10": 5,
"ours_c01": 4,
"ours_p": 1.0,
"match": true
},
{
"axis": "affect [full-fleet in-lane]",
"ref_b10": 8,
"ref_c01": 0,
"ref_p": 0.0078,
"ours_b10": 8,
"ours_c01": 0,
"ours_p": 0.007812,
"match": true
},
{
"axis": "safety",
"ref_b10": 4,
"ref_c01": 2,
"ref_p": 0.6875,
"ours_b10": 4,
"ours_c01": 2,
"ours_p": 0.6875,
"match": true
},
{
"axis": "safety [full-fleet in-lane]",
"ref_b10": 4,
"ref_c01": 2,
"ref_p": 0.6875,
"ours_b10": 4,
"ours_c01": 2,
"ours_p": 0.6875,
"match": true
},
{
"axis": "art5-safeguard",
"ref_b10": 1,
"ref_c01": 0,
"ref_p": 1.0,