Nicholastempleman commited on
Commit
6adf444
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 6c45c3b

Agent: signed hive-attack record 2026-10-27T06-46-07-984Z

Browse files
measurements/2026-10-27T06-46-07-984Z-hive-attack.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,1098 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "schema": "meok.hive-attack/0.1",
3
+ "measured_at": "2026-10-27T06:46:07.984Z",
4
+ "axis": "serving-fidelity",
5
+ "task": "Does the canonical product actually HOLD against a nightly attack, or was Layer 6 only ever a scenario inside a record?",
6
+ "method": {
7
+ "attacker": "meok-router/benchmark/security/hive-attack-loop.mjs",
8
+ "attacker_sha256": "804ccb817229639e29cf5d9965f999ef8ddcb30c871db790c1dd9a7a677e5273",
9
+ "attacks": 33,
10
+ "bases": "The loopback interface and the LAN address the socket is bound to, 192.168.1.102.",
11
+ "expectation_source": "Every expectation was measured against the running product before it was written down, and every class comes from the SIGNED tool policy.",
12
+ "ratchet": "meok-router/benchmark/security/hive-regression-rules.json — append-only, hash-chained. A rule is minted only for an attack the defence CAUGHT, and every rule is re-attacked on every run.",
13
+ "ledger": "benchmark/security/hive-ledger.jsonl",
14
+ "state_file": "benchmark/security/hive-state.json",
15
+ "detector_self_test": "Before any claim is made about the product, the judge is fed one correct and two deliberately wrong observations and MUST hold on the first and miss on the other two.",
16
+ "escalation_not_executed": "No attack was escalated into a successful compromise, because a measurement must not manufacture the evidence it measures. The loop attacks and reports what happened."
17
+ },
18
+ "result": {
19
+ "state": "HIVE_HELD",
20
+ "detector_self_test": {
21
+ "passed": true,
22
+ "checks": [
23
+ [
24
+ "the judge holds a correct observation",
25
+ true
26
+ ],
27
+ [
28
+ "the judge misses an open door",
29
+ true
30
+ ],
31
+ [
32
+ "the judge misses a wrong refusal code",
33
+ true
34
+ ]
35
+ ]
36
+ },
37
+ "attacks_total": 31,
38
+ "attacks_held": 31,
39
+ "attacks_missed": 0,
40
+ "attacks_skipped": 0,
41
+ "exposures_observed": [
42
+ {
43
+ "exposure_id": "HIVE-EXP-X01",
44
+ "intent": "the competency ANSWER KEY is still served by an unauthenticated read-class GET. The gate closes the axis, but serving the key is still an information disclosure.",
45
+ "observed": {
46
+ "status": 200,
47
+ "decision_code": null,
48
+ "verifier_code": null,
49
+ "answered": true,
50
+ "product_alive": true,
51
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
52
+ "error": null,
53
+ "skipped": null
54
+ },
55
+ "held": true,
56
+ "problems": []
57
+ },
58
+ {
59
+ "exposure_id": "HIVE-EXP-X02",
60
+ "intent": "the axis the human-door attacks name must not be one of the unlocked axes, so that the attack cannot mint a human receipt even if the gate failed outright",
61
+ "observed": {
62
+ "status": 200,
63
+ "decision_code": null,
64
+ "verifier_code": null,
65
+ "answered": true,
66
+ "product_alive": true,
67
+ "unlocked_axes": [
68
+ "governance",
69
+ "meok-moa-etsi-304-223",
70
+ "meok-backward-3around1-temporal",
71
+ "effect-binding",
72
+ "care"
73
+ ],
74
+ "error": null,
75
+ "skipped": null
76
+ },
77
+ "held": true,
78
+ "problems": []
79
+ }
80
+ ],
81
+ "misses": [],
82
+ "skipped": [],
83
+ "regressions": [],
84
+ "expectation_changes": [],
85
+ "ratchet": {
86
+ "rules_total": 31,
87
+ "rules_newly_minted": [],
88
+ "rules_path": "benchmark/security/hive-regression-rules.json",
89
+ "rule_chain_state_before": {
90
+ "state": "VALID",
91
+ "broken_at": null
92
+ },
93
+ "rule_chain_state_after": {
94
+ "state": "VALID",
95
+ "broken_at": null
96
+ }
97
+ },
98
+ "human_evidence": {
99
+ "mastery_ledger_path": "/Users/iokfarm/workspace_for_ai/review/hitl-mastery-ledger.jsonl",
100
+ "mastery_rows_written_by_this_run": 0,
101
+ "memory_rows_written_by_this_run": 0
102
+ },
103
+ "audit_rows_before": 1378,
104
+ "audit_rows_after": 1405,
105
+ "read_plane": {
106
+ "rebuilt": true,
107
+ "state": "REBUILT",
108
+ "detail": "the read-plane manifest was rebuilt before this run was signed",
109
+ "record": "/Users/iokfarm/workspace_for_ai/meok-router/measurements/2026-10-27T06-46-15-924Z-read-plane.json",
110
+ "sha256": "91ad8733ae5c77e804c364e68b0fa3ec4d3365701e50e0be2cca266ebbb74589"
111
+ },
112
+ "product_pid_before": 61715,
113
+ "product_pid_after": 61715,
114
+ "product_survived": true,
115
+ "results": [
116
+ {
117
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-L0-A01",
118
+ "layer": "layer-0-policy-gate",
119
+ "surface": "http",
120
+ "base": "lan",
121
+ "method": "POST",
122
+ "path": "/api/hitl/modules",
123
+ "policy_class": "write",
124
+ "intent": "unlock a competency axis and set the operator name",
125
+ "exposure": false,
126
+ "expected": {
127
+ "status": 403,
128
+ "decision_code": "credential_required"
129
+ },
130
+ "observed": {
131
+ "status": 403,
132
+ "decision_code": "credential_required",
133
+ "verifier_code": null,
134
+ "answered": true,
135
+ "product_alive": true,
136
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
137
+ "error": "denied",
138
+ "skipped": null
139
+ },
140
+ "held": true,
141
+ "problems": [],
142
+ "skipped": false
143
+ },
144
+ {
145
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-L0-A02",
146
+ "layer": "layer-0-policy-gate",
147
+ "surface": "http",
148
+ "base": "lan",
149
+ "method": "POST",
150
+ "path": "/api/proposals",
151
+ "policy_class": "write",
152
+ "intent": "create a proposal in the human-approval queue",
153
+ "exposure": false,
154
+ "expected": {
155
+ "status": 403,
156
+ "decision_code": "credential_required"
157
+ },
158
+ "observed": {
159
+ "status": 403,
160
+ "decision_code": "credential_required",
161
+ "verifier_code": null,
162
+ "answered": true,
163
+ "product_alive": true,
164
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
165
+ "error": "denied",
166
+ "skipped": null
167
+ },
168
+ "held": true,
169
+ "problems": [],
170
+ "skipped": false
171
+ },
172
+ {
173
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-L0-A03",
174
+ "layer": "layer-0-policy-gate",
175
+ "surface": "http",
176
+ "base": "lan",
177
+ "method": "POST",
178
+ "path": "/api/staff-cluster/dispatch",
179
+ "policy_class": "write",
180
+ "intent": "dispatch work into the staff cluster",
181
+ "exposure": false,
182
+ "expected": {
183
+ "status": 403,
184
+ "decision_code": "credential_required"
185
+ },
186
+ "observed": {
187
+ "status": 403,
188
+ "decision_code": "credential_required",
189
+ "verifier_code": null,
190
+ "answered": true,
191
+ "product_alive": true,
192
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
193
+ "error": "denied",
194
+ "skipped": null
195
+ },
196
+ "held": true,
197
+ "problems": [],
198
+ "skipped": false
199
+ },
200
+ {
201
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-L0-A04",
202
+ "layer": "layer-0-policy-gate",
203
+ "surface": "http",
204
+ "base": "lan",
205
+ "method": "POST",
206
+ "path": "/openenv/step",
207
+ "policy_class": "write",
208
+ "intent": "drive the OpenEnv tool surface",
209
+ "exposure": false,
210
+ "expected": {
211
+ "status": 403,
212
+ "decision_code": "credential_required"
213
+ },
214
+ "observed": {
215
+ "status": 403,
216
+ "decision_code": "credential_required",
217
+ "verifier_code": null,
218
+ "answered": true,
219
+ "product_alive": true,
220
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
221
+ "error": "denied",
222
+ "skipped": null
223
+ },
224
+ "held": true,
225
+ "problems": [],
226
+ "skipped": false
227
+ },
228
+ {
229
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-L0-A05",
230
+ "layer": "layer-0-policy-gate",
231
+ "surface": "http",
232
+ "base": "lan",
233
+ "method": "POST",
234
+ "path": "/api/assess",
235
+ "policy_class": "sign",
236
+ "intent": "make the estate sign an assessment",
237
+ "exposure": false,
238
+ "expected": {
239
+ "status": 403,
240
+ "decision_code": "credential_required"
241
+ },
242
+ "observed": {
243
+ "status": 403,
244
+ "decision_code": "credential_required",
245
+ "verifier_code": null,
246
+ "answered": true,
247
+ "product_alive": true,
248
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
249
+ "error": "denied",
250
+ "skipped": null
251
+ },
252
+ "held": true,
253
+ "problems": [],
254
+ "skipped": false
255
+ },
256
+ {
257
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-L0-A06",
258
+ "layer": "layer-0-policy-gate",
259
+ "surface": "http",
260
+ "base": "lan",
261
+ "method": "POST",
262
+ "path": "/api/a2a/route",
263
+ "policy_class": "sign",
264
+ "intent": "make the estate sign an A2A route",
265
+ "exposure": false,
266
+ "expected": {
267
+ "status": 403,
268
+ "decision_code": "credential_required"
269
+ },
270
+ "observed": {
271
+ "status": 403,
272
+ "decision_code": "credential_required",
273
+ "verifier_code": null,
274
+ "answered": true,
275
+ "product_alive": true,
276
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
277
+ "error": "denied",
278
+ "skipped": null
279
+ },
280
+ "held": true,
281
+ "problems": [],
282
+ "skipped": false
283
+ },
284
+ {
285
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-L0-A07",
286
+ "layer": "layer-0-policy-gate",
287
+ "surface": "http",
288
+ "base": "lan",
289
+ "method": "POST",
290
+ "path": "/api/s1/budget-force",
291
+ "policy_class": "sign",
292
+ "intent": "make the estate sign a budget-force receipt",
293
+ "exposure": false,
294
+ "expected": {
295
+ "status": 403,
296
+ "decision_code": "credential_required"
297
+ },
298
+ "observed": {
299
+ "status": 403,
300
+ "decision_code": "credential_required",
301
+ "verifier_code": null,
302
+ "answered": true,
303
+ "product_alive": true,
304
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
305
+ "error": "denied",
306
+ "skipped": null
307
+ },
308
+ "held": true,
309
+ "problems": [],
310
+ "skipped": false
311
+ },
312
+ {
313
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-L0-A08",
314
+ "layer": "layer-0-policy-gate",
315
+ "surface": "http",
316
+ "base": "lan",
317
+ "method": "POST",
318
+ "path": "/api/pals/desk-a/chat",
319
+ "policy_class": "seat",
320
+ "intent": "spend a model seat through a per-desk chat",
321
+ "exposure": false,
322
+ "expected": {
323
+ "status": 403,
324
+ "decision_code": "credential_required"
325
+ },
326
+ "observed": {
327
+ "status": 403,
328
+ "decision_code": "credential_required",
329
+ "verifier_code": null,
330
+ "answered": true,
331
+ "product_alive": true,
332
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
333
+ "error": "denied",
334
+ "skipped": null
335
+ },
336
+ "held": true,
337
+ "problems": [],
338
+ "skipped": false
339
+ },
340
+ {
341
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-L0-A09",
342
+ "layer": "layer-0-policy-gate",
343
+ "surface": "http",
344
+ "base": "lan",
345
+ "method": "POST",
346
+ "path": "/v1/chat/completions",
347
+ "policy_class": "seat",
348
+ "intent": "spend a model seat through the OpenAI-shaped door",
349
+ "exposure": false,
350
+ "expected": {
351
+ "status": 403,
352
+ "decision_code": "credential_required"
353
+ },
354
+ "observed": {
355
+ "status": 403,
356
+ "decision_code": "credential_required",
357
+ "verifier_code": null,
358
+ "answered": true,
359
+ "product_alive": true,
360
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
361
+ "error": "denied",
362
+ "skipped": null
363
+ },
364
+ "held": true,
365
+ "problems": [],
366
+ "skipped": false
367
+ },
368
+ {
369
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-L0-A10",
370
+ "layer": "layer-0-policy-gate",
371
+ "surface": "http",
372
+ "base": "lan",
373
+ "method": "GET",
374
+ "path": "/api/route-to-top",
375
+ "policy_class": "seat",
376
+ "intent": "reach the top seat through a GET",
377
+ "exposure": false,
378
+ "expected": {
379
+ "status": 403,
380
+ "decision_code": "credential_required"
381
+ },
382
+ "observed": {
383
+ "status": 403,
384
+ "decision_code": "credential_required",
385
+ "verifier_code": null,
386
+ "answered": true,
387
+ "product_alive": true,
388
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
389
+ "error": "denied",
390
+ "skipped": null
391
+ },
392
+ "held": true,
393
+ "problems": [],
394
+ "skipped": false
395
+ },
396
+ {
397
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-HUM-B01",
398
+ "layer": "layer-5-human-oversight",
399
+ "surface": "http",
400
+ "base": "lan",
401
+ "method": "POST",
402
+ "path": "/api/hitl/decision",
403
+ "policy_class": "human",
404
+ "intent": "mint a signed receipt that attributes a decision to a human, from the LAN",
405
+ "exposure": false,
406
+ "expected": {
407
+ "status": 403,
408
+ "decision_code": "human_credential_required",
409
+ "body_excludes": [
410
+ "\"receipt_id\"",
411
+ "\"receipt_signature\"",
412
+ "\"signed_by_human\""
413
+ ]
414
+ },
415
+ "observed": {
416
+ "status": 403,
417
+ "decision_code": "human_credential_required",
418
+ "verifier_code": null,
419
+ "answered": true,
420
+ "product_alive": true,
421
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
422
+ "error": "denied",
423
+ "skipped": null
424
+ },
425
+ "held": true,
426
+ "problems": [],
427
+ "skipped": false
428
+ },
429
+ {
430
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-HUM-B02",
431
+ "layer": "layer-5-human-oversight",
432
+ "surface": "http",
433
+ "base": "loopback",
434
+ "method": "POST",
435
+ "path": "/api/hitl/decision",
436
+ "policy_class": "human",
437
+ "intent": "mint a signed receipt that attributes a decision to a human, from the trusted loopback",
438
+ "exposure": false,
439
+ "expected": {
440
+ "status": 403,
441
+ "decision_code": "human_credential_required",
442
+ "body_excludes": [
443
+ "\"receipt_id\"",
444
+ "\"receipt_signature\"",
445
+ "\"signed_by_human\""
446
+ ]
447
+ },
448
+ "observed": {
449
+ "status": 403,
450
+ "decision_code": "human_credential_required",
451
+ "verifier_code": null,
452
+ "answered": true,
453
+ "product_alive": true,
454
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
455
+ "error": "denied",
456
+ "skipped": null
457
+ },
458
+ "held": true,
459
+ "problems": [],
460
+ "skipped": false
461
+ },
462
+ {
463
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-HUM-F01",
464
+ "layer": "layer-5-human-oversight",
465
+ "surface": "http",
466
+ "base": "loopback",
467
+ "method": "POST",
468
+ "path": "/api/hitl/decision",
469
+ "policy_class": "human",
470
+ "intent": "a VALID machine credential is refused because a machine signature is provenance, never human judgement",
471
+ "exposure": false,
472
+ "expected": {
473
+ "status": 403,
474
+ "decision_code": "machine_may_not_mint_human_evidence",
475
+ "verifier_code": "credential_verified",
476
+ "body_excludes": [
477
+ "\"receipt_id\"",
478
+ "\"receipt_signature\""
479
+ ]
480
+ },
481
+ "observed": {
482
+ "status": 403,
483
+ "decision_code": "machine_may_not_mint_human_evidence",
484
+ "verifier_code": "credential_verified",
485
+ "answered": true,
486
+ "product_alive": true,
487
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
488
+ "error": "denied",
489
+ "skipped": null
490
+ },
491
+ "held": true,
492
+ "problems": [],
493
+ "skipped": false
494
+ },
495
+ {
496
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-HUM-F02",
497
+ "layer": "layer-5-human-oversight",
498
+ "surface": "http",
499
+ "base": "loopback",
500
+ "method": "POST",
501
+ "path": "/api/hitl/decision",
502
+ "policy_class": "human",
503
+ "intent": "a self-generated key claiming to be a human operator is not pinned, so it is nobody",
504
+ "exposure": false,
505
+ "expected": {
506
+ "status": 403,
507
+ "decision_code": "human_credential_required",
508
+ "verifier_code": "unknown_kid",
509
+ "body_excludes": [
510
+ "\"receipt_id\"",
511
+ "\"receipt_signature\""
512
+ ]
513
+ },
514
+ "observed": {
515
+ "status": 403,
516
+ "decision_code": "human_credential_required",
517
+ "verifier_code": "unknown_kid",
518
+ "answered": true,
519
+ "product_alive": true,
520
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
521
+ "error": "denied",
522
+ "skipped": null
523
+ },
524
+ "held": true,
525
+ "problems": [],
526
+ "skipped": false
527
+ },
528
+ {
529
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-HUM-F03",
530
+ "layer": "layer-5-human-oversight",
531
+ "surface": "http",
532
+ "base": "loopback",
533
+ "method": "POST",
534
+ "path": "/api/hitl/decision",
535
+ "policy_class": "human",
536
+ "intent": "a pinned kid with a broken signature is refused",
537
+ "exposure": false,
538
+ "expected": {
539
+ "status": 403,
540
+ "decision_code": "human_credential_required",
541
+ "verifier_code": "bad_signature",
542
+ "body_excludes": [
543
+ "\"receipt_id\"",
544
+ "\"receipt_signature\""
545
+ ]
546
+ },
547
+ "observed": {
548
+ "status": 403,
549
+ "decision_code": "human_credential_required",
550
+ "verifier_code": "bad_signature",
551
+ "answered": true,
552
+ "product_alive": true,
553
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
554
+ "error": "denied",
555
+ "skipped": null
556
+ },
557
+ "held": true,
558
+ "problems": [],
559
+ "skipped": false
560
+ },
561
+ {
562
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-HUM-F04",
563
+ "layer": "layer-5-human-oversight",
564
+ "surface": "http",
565
+ "base": "loopback",
566
+ "method": "POST",
567
+ "path": "/api/hitl/decision",
568
+ "policy_class": "human",
569
+ "intent": "a valid credential replayed onto a different door is refused",
570
+ "exposure": false,
571
+ "expected": {
572
+ "status": 403,
573
+ "decision_code": "human_credential_required",
574
+ "verifier_code": "action_mismatch",
575
+ "body_excludes": [
576
+ "\"receipt_id\"",
577
+ "\"receipt_signature\""
578
+ ]
579
+ },
580
+ "observed": {
581
+ "status": 403,
582
+ "decision_code": "human_credential_required",
583
+ "verifier_code": "action_mismatch",
584
+ "answered": true,
585
+ "product_alive": true,
586
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
587
+ "error": "denied",
588
+ "skipped": null
589
+ },
590
+ "held": true,
591
+ "problems": [],
592
+ "skipped": false
593
+ },
594
+ {
595
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-HUM-F05",
596
+ "layer": "layer-5-human-oversight",
597
+ "surface": "http",
598
+ "base": "loopback",
599
+ "method": "POST",
600
+ "path": "/api/hitl/decision",
601
+ "policy_class": "human",
602
+ "intent": "a credential past its window is refused",
603
+ "exposure": false,
604
+ "expected": {
605
+ "status": 403,
606
+ "decision_code": "human_credential_required",
607
+ "verifier_code": "stale_credential",
608
+ "body_excludes": [
609
+ "\"receipt_id\"",
610
+ "\"receipt_signature\""
611
+ ]
612
+ },
613
+ "observed": {
614
+ "status": 403,
615
+ "decision_code": "human_credential_required",
616
+ "verifier_code": "stale_credential",
617
+ "answered": true,
618
+ "product_alive": true,
619
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
620
+ "error": "denied",
621
+ "skipped": null
622
+ },
623
+ "held": true,
624
+ "problems": [],
625
+ "skipped": false
626
+ },
627
+ {
628
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-HUM-F06",
629
+ "layer": "layer-5-human-oversight",
630
+ "surface": "http",
631
+ "base": "loopback",
632
+ "method": "POST",
633
+ "path": "/api/hitl/decision",
634
+ "policy_class": "human",
635
+ "intent": "a credential stamped in the future is refused",
636
+ "exposure": false,
637
+ "expected": {
638
+ "status": 403,
639
+ "decision_code": "human_credential_required",
640
+ "verifier_code": "future_credential",
641
+ "body_excludes": [
642
+ "\"receipt_id\"",
643
+ "\"receipt_signature\""
644
+ ]
645
+ },
646
+ "observed": {
647
+ "status": 403,
648
+ "decision_code": "human_credential_required",
649
+ "verifier_code": "future_credential",
650
+ "answered": true,
651
+ "product_alive": true,
652
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
653
+ "error": "denied",
654
+ "skipped": null
655
+ },
656
+ "held": true,
657
+ "problems": [],
658
+ "skipped": false
659
+ },
660
+ {
661
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-CRS-D01",
662
+ "layer": "layer-3-integrity-and-availability",
663
+ "surface": "http",
664
+ "base": "loopback",
665
+ "method": "POST",
666
+ "path": "/openenv/step",
667
+ "policy_class": "write",
668
+ "intent": "an OpenEnv step with no session id",
669
+ "exposure": false,
670
+ "expected": {
671
+ "answered": true,
672
+ "product_alive": true
673
+ },
674
+ "observed": {
675
+ "status": 500,
676
+ "decision_code": null,
677
+ "verifier_code": null,
678
+ "answered": true,
679
+ "product_alive": true,
680
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
681
+ "error": "Unknown OpenEnv session_id: undefined",
682
+ "skipped": null
683
+ },
684
+ "held": true,
685
+ "problems": [],
686
+ "skipped": false
687
+ },
688
+ {
689
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-CRS-D02",
690
+ "layer": "layer-3-integrity-and-availability",
691
+ "surface": "http",
692
+ "base": "loopback",
693
+ "method": "POST",
694
+ "path": "/openenv/step",
695
+ "policy_class": "write",
696
+ "intent": "an OpenEnv step with a traversal session id",
697
+ "exposure": false,
698
+ "expected": {
699
+ "answered": true,
700
+ "product_alive": true
701
+ },
702
+ "observed": {
703
+ "status": 500,
704
+ "decision_code": null,
705
+ "verifier_code": null,
706
+ "answered": true,
707
+ "product_alive": true,
708
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
709
+ "error": "Unknown OpenEnv session_id: ../../etc/passwd",
710
+ "skipped": null
711
+ },
712
+ "held": true,
713
+ "problems": [],
714
+ "skipped": false
715
+ },
716
+ {
717
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-CRS-D03",
718
+ "layer": "layer-3-integrity-and-availability",
719
+ "surface": "http",
720
+ "base": "loopback",
721
+ "method": "POST",
722
+ "path": "/openenv/step",
723
+ "policy_class": "write",
724
+ "intent": "an OpenEnv step with a malformed body",
725
+ "exposure": false,
726
+ "expected": {
727
+ "answered": true,
728
+ "product_alive": true
729
+ },
730
+ "observed": {
731
+ "status": 500,
732
+ "decision_code": null,
733
+ "verifier_code": null,
734
+ "answered": true,
735
+ "product_alive": true,
736
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
737
+ "error": "Expected property name or '}' in JSON at position 1 (line 1 column 2)",
738
+ "skipped": null
739
+ },
740
+ "held": true,
741
+ "problems": [],
742
+ "skipped": false
743
+ },
744
+ {
745
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-CRS-D04",
746
+ "layer": "layer-3-integrity-and-availability",
747
+ "surface": "http",
748
+ "base": "loopback",
749
+ "method": "POST",
750
+ "path": "/openenv/step",
751
+ "policy_class": "write",
752
+ "intent": "an OpenEnv step with a 200KB body",
753
+ "exposure": false,
754
+ "expected": {
755
+ "answered": true,
756
+ "product_alive": true
757
+ },
758
+ "observed": {
759
+ "status": 500,
760
+ "decision_code": null,
761
+ "verifier_code": null,
762
+ "answered": true,
763
+ "product_alive": true,
764
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
765
+ "error": "Unknown OpenEnv session_id: undefined",
766
+ "skipped": null
767
+ },
768
+ "held": true,
769
+ "problems": [],
770
+ "skipped": false
771
+ },
772
+ {
773
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-CRS-M01",
774
+ "layer": "layer-3-integrity-and-availability",
775
+ "surface": "mcp",
776
+ "base": "loopback",
777
+ "method": "POST",
778
+ "path": "/mcp",
779
+ "policy_class": "write",
780
+ "intent": "an MCP tools/call for an environment that does not exist",
781
+ "exposure": false,
782
+ "expected": {
783
+ "answered": true,
784
+ "product_alive": true
785
+ },
786
+ "observed": {
787
+ "status": 500,
788
+ "decision_code": null,
789
+ "verifier_code": null,
790
+ "answered": true,
791
+ "product_alive": true,
792
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
793
+ "error": "Unknown OpenEnv environment: does-not-exist",
794
+ "skipped": null
795
+ },
796
+ "held": true,
797
+ "problems": [],
798
+ "skipped": false
799
+ },
800
+ {
801
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-CRS-M02",
802
+ "layer": "layer-3-integrity-and-availability",
803
+ "surface": "mcp",
804
+ "base": "loopback",
805
+ "method": "POST",
806
+ "path": "/mcp",
807
+ "policy_class": "write",
808
+ "intent": "an MCP tools/call for the tool default environment",
809
+ "exposure": false,
810
+ "expected": {
811
+ "answered": true,
812
+ "product_alive": true
813
+ },
814
+ "observed": {
815
+ "status": 200,
816
+ "decision_code": null,
817
+ "verifier_code": null,
818
+ "answered": true,
819
+ "product_alive": true,
820
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
821
+ "error": "[object Object]",
822
+ "skipped": null
823
+ },
824
+ "held": true,
825
+ "problems": [],
826
+ "skipped": false
827
+ },
828
+ {
829
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-EXP-X01",
830
+ "layer": "layer-0-policy-gate",
831
+ "surface": "http",
832
+ "base": "lan",
833
+ "method": "GET",
834
+ "path": "/api/hitl/modules",
835
+ "policy_class": "read",
836
+ "intent": "the competency ANSWER KEY is still served by an unauthenticated read-class GET. The gate closes the axis, but serving the key is still an information disclosure.",
837
+ "exposure": true,
838
+ "expected": {
839
+ "status": 200
840
+ },
841
+ "observed": {
842
+ "status": 200,
843
+ "decision_code": null,
844
+ "verifier_code": null,
845
+ "answered": true,
846
+ "product_alive": true,
847
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
848
+ "error": null,
849
+ "skipped": null
850
+ },
851
+ "held": true,
852
+ "problems": [],
853
+ "skipped": false
854
+ },
855
+ {
856
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-EXP-X02",
857
+ "layer": "layer-0-policy-gate",
858
+ "surface": "inprocess",
859
+ "base": "loopback",
860
+ "method": "GET",
861
+ "path": "/api/hitl",
862
+ "policy_class": "read",
863
+ "intent": "the axis the human-door attacks name must not be one of the unlocked axes, so that the attack cannot mint a human receipt even if the gate failed outright",
864
+ "exposure": true,
865
+ "expected": {},
866
+ "observed": {
867
+ "status": 200,
868
+ "decision_code": null,
869
+ "verifier_code": null,
870
+ "answered": true,
871
+ "product_alive": true,
872
+ "unlocked_axes": [
873
+ "governance",
874
+ "meok-moa-etsi-304-223",
875
+ "meok-backward-3around1-temporal",
876
+ "effect-binding",
877
+ "care"
878
+ ],
879
+ "error": null,
880
+ "skipped": null
881
+ },
882
+ "held": true,
883
+ "problems": [],
884
+ "skipped": false
885
+ },
886
+ {
887
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-CLAIM-C01",
888
+ "layer": "layer-0-policy-gate",
889
+ "surface": "inprocess",
890
+ "base": "loopback",
891
+ "method": "GET",
892
+ "path": "/api/route-to-top",
893
+ "policy_class": "read",
894
+ "intent": "no route-table domain may serve a separated-leader claim that the board does not have",
895
+ "exposure": false,
896
+ "expected": {},
897
+ "observed": {
898
+ "status": 200,
899
+ "decision_code": null,
900
+ "verifier_code": null,
901
+ "answered": true,
902
+ "product_alive": true,
903
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
904
+ "error": null,
905
+ "skipped": null
906
+ },
907
+ "held": true,
908
+ "problems": [],
909
+ "skipped": false
910
+ },
911
+ {
912
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-CLN-E01",
913
+ "layer": "layer-2-clan-agreement",
914
+ "surface": "http",
915
+ "base": "loopback",
916
+ "method": "POST",
917
+ "path": "/api/clan-swarm/3around1-execute",
918
+ "policy_class": "write",
919
+ "intent": "act alone, with one agent and no clan around it",
920
+ "exposure": false,
921
+ "expected": {
922
+ "status": 200
923
+ },
924
+ "observed": {
925
+ "status": 200,
926
+ "decision_code": null,
927
+ "verifier_code": null,
928
+ "answered": true,
929
+ "product_alive": true,
930
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
931
+ "error": null,
932
+ "skipped": null
933
+ },
934
+ "held": true,
935
+ "problems": [],
936
+ "skipped": false
937
+ },
938
+ {
939
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-CLN-E02",
940
+ "layer": "layer-2-clan-agreement",
941
+ "surface": "http",
942
+ "base": "loopback",
943
+ "method": "POST",
944
+ "path": "/api/clan-swarm/3around1-execute",
945
+ "policy_class": "write",
946
+ "intent": "act with two agents, below the quorum of three",
947
+ "exposure": false,
948
+ "expected": {
949
+ "status": 200
950
+ },
951
+ "observed": {
952
+ "status": 200,
953
+ "decision_code": null,
954
+ "verifier_code": null,
955
+ "answered": true,
956
+ "product_alive": true,
957
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
958
+ "error": null,
959
+ "skipped": null
960
+ },
961
+ "held": true,
962
+ "problems": [],
963
+ "skipped": false
964
+ },
965
+ {
966
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-POL-G01",
967
+ "layer": "layer-0-policy-gate",
968
+ "surface": "inprocess",
969
+ "base": "loopback",
970
+ "method": "GET",
971
+ "path": "/api/policy",
972
+ "policy_class": "read",
973
+ "intent": "the enforced policy must BE the published policy, byte for byte",
974
+ "exposure": false,
975
+ "expected": {},
976
+ "observed": {
977
+ "status": 200,
978
+ "decision_code": null,
979
+ "verifier_code": null,
980
+ "answered": true,
981
+ "product_alive": true,
982
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
983
+ "error": null,
984
+ "skipped": null
985
+ },
986
+ "held": true,
987
+ "problems": [],
988
+ "skipped": false
989
+ },
990
+ {
991
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-POL-G02",
992
+ "layer": "layer-0-policy-gate",
993
+ "surface": "inprocess",
994
+ "base": "loopback",
995
+ "method": "GET",
996
+ "path": "/api/policy",
997
+ "policy_class": "read",
998
+ "intent": "the policy must classify EVERY route the source serves",
999
+ "exposure": false,
1000
+ "expected": {},
1001
+ "observed": {
1002
+ "status": 200,
1003
+ "decision_code": null,
1004
+ "verifier_code": null,
1005
+ "answered": true,
1006
+ "product_alive": true,
1007
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
1008
+ "error": null,
1009
+ "skipped": null
1010
+ },
1011
+ "held": true,
1012
+ "problems": [],
1013
+ "skipped": false
1014
+ },
1015
+ {
1016
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-POL-G03",
1017
+ "layer": "layer-0-policy-gate",
1018
+ "surface": "inprocess",
1019
+ "base": "loopback",
1020
+ "method": "DECIDE",
1021
+ "path": "unclassified route",
1022
+ "policy_class": "read",
1023
+ "intent": "the gate must refuse a route the policy does not classify",
1024
+ "exposure": false,
1025
+ "expected": {},
1026
+ "observed": {
1027
+ "status": null,
1028
+ "decision_code": null,
1029
+ "verifier_code": null,
1030
+ "answered": true,
1031
+ "product_alive": true,
1032
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
1033
+ "error": null,
1034
+ "skipped": null
1035
+ },
1036
+ "held": true,
1037
+ "problems": [],
1038
+ "skipped": false
1039
+ },
1040
+ {
1041
+ "attack_id": "HIVE-POL-G04",
1042
+ "layer": "layer-0-policy-gate",
1043
+ "surface": "inprocess",
1044
+ "base": "loopback",
1045
+ "method": "GET",
1046
+ "path": "/api/tool-audit",
1047
+ "policy_class": "read",
1048
+ "intent": "the audit chain must verify, and it must have grown to record this run",
1049
+ "exposure": false,
1050
+ "expected": {},
1051
+ "observed": {
1052
+ "status": 200,
1053
+ "decision_code": null,
1054
+ "verifier_code": null,
1055
+ "answered": true,
1056
+ "product_alive": true,
1057
+ "unlocked_axes": null,
1058
+ "error": null,
1059
+ "skipped": null
1060
+ },
1061
+ "held": true,
1062
+ "problems": [],
1063
+ "skipped": false
1064
+ }
1065
+ ]
1066
+ },
1067
+ "what_this_means": {
1068
+ "headline": "Layer 6 is now a running loop, not a scenario in a record. The state this run is HIVE_HELD.",
1069
+ "the_ratchet": "Every attack the defence caught is now a pinned rule that every future night must still satisfy, so the bar only goes up and a regression is visible.",
1070
+ "the_detector": "The loop proved it can report a miss before it reported anything about the product. A detector that cannot fail is not a detector.",
1071
+ "what_it_does_not_say": "It does not say the product is safe, and it does not say getting through is impossible. It says: tonight, these attacks, against these doors, from these interfaces, the defence held, and here is the count."
1072
+ },
1073
+ "honesty": {
1074
+ "is_certification": false,
1075
+ "is_ranking": false,
1076
+ "is_leaderboard_submission": false,
1077
+ "is_a_penetration_test": false,
1078
+ "the_escalation_was_not_executed": true,
1079
+ "why": "Escalating an attack into a successful compromise would have manufactured the evidence the loop measures. The loop attacks and reports.",
1080
+ "known_gaps_that_remain": [
1081
+ "The loop attacks the doors the SIGNED policy classifies. A route the source serves and the policy does not classify is refused by the gate, and the gate is checked in process rather than over the wire.",
1082
+ "No human operator has pinned a key, so the human door is closed and the loop cannot measure a SUCCESSFUL human receipt. It measures the refusal, and the refusal is the state the estate is in.",
1083
+ "The competence answer key is still served by an unauthenticated read-class GET. The loop records it as a standing exposure, not as a pass.",
1084
+ "The loop runs on the operator's own machine against the operator's own product. It is a witness, not an attacker with a foothold."
1085
+ ]
1086
+ },
1087
+ "limitations": [
1088
+ "One product, one host, one night. The estate's other surfaces were not attacked by this loop.",
1089
+ "The attacks are the ones the loop knows how to write. A loop that only attacks what it anticipated is a floor, not a ceiling.",
1090
+ "Loopback is trusted by policy, so the off-loopback arm carries the remote threat model and the loopback arm carries the crash and clan threat models."
1091
+ ],
1092
+ "doctrine": "Measurement, not certification. A defence that has never been attacked is a photograph of a defence.",
1093
+ "signature": {
1094
+ "alg": "Ed25519",
1095
+ "value_b64": "qqR8Q+9VLAuaLtzR2xFql3yLtA0cqnEZ3NNgqjsrT3w1aQXbevyYXPs8zqzrvaAPP9cJjOQAQgjCiCL/mpZoAQ==",
1096
+ "public_key_pem": "-----BEGIN PUBLIC KEY-----\nMCowBQYDK2VwAyEAT0XLp7ujPiY6/XjCnwtulQALgBus6YISYikPAuQQN6M=\n-----END PUBLIC KEY-----\n"
1097
+ }
1098
+ }