layerlab-store / final_eval /final_comparisons_full.csv
cybertronak's picture
analysis (full)
e8e97e0 verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
35 kB
metric,comparison,diff,lo,hi,n,clusters,excludes_0
refuse_harm,E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base,-0.035555555555555556,-0.060055555555555536,-0.011111111111111112,450,450,True
refuse_harm,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.017777777777777778,-0.0044444444444444444,0.04,450,450,False
refuse_harm,X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.024444444444444446,0.006666666666666667,0.044444444444444446,450,450,True
refuse_harm,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.013333333333333334,-0.008888888888888889,0.035555555555555556,450,450,False
refuse_harm,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.017777777777777778,-0.006666666666666667,0.042222222222222223,450,450,False
refuse_harm,X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.02,-0.0022222222222222222,0.042222222222222223,450,450,False
refuse_harm,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.0022222222222222222,-0.02666666666666667,0.022222222222222223,450,450,False
refuse_harm,RANDOM0_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.02,-0.04227777777777776,0.0022222222222222222,450,450,False
refuse_harm,RANDOM1_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.04888888888888889,-0.07783333333333331,-0.022222222222222223,450,450,True
refuse_harm,RANDOM2_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.02666666666666667,-0.051111111111111114,-0.0022222222222222222,450,450,True
refuse_harm,RANDOM3_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.024444444444444446,-0.051111111111111114,0.0,450,450,False
refuse_harm,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.05333333333333334,0.028888888888888888,0.08,450,450,True
refuse_harm,X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.06,0.035555555555555556,0.08666666666666667,450,450,True
refuse_harm,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.04888888888888889,0.024444444444444446,0.07333333333333333,450,450,True
refuse_harm,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.05333333333333334,0.03111111111111111,0.07777777777777778,450,450,True
refuse_harm,X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.05555555555555555,0.03111111111111111,0.08222222222222222,450,450,True
refuse_harm,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.03333333333333333,0.011111111111111112,0.057777777777777775,450,450,True
refuse_harm,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.04777777777777778,0.027208333333333338,0.07055555555555555,450,450,True
refuse_harm,X_Cons5_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.05444444444444444,0.03388888888888889,0.07612500000000005,450,450,True
refuse_harm,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.043333333333333335,0.02388888888888889,0.06388888888888888,450,450,True
ak_refuse_harm,E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base,-0.051111111111111114,-0.07777777777777778,-0.02666666666666667,450,450,True
ak_refuse_harm,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.03111111111111111,0.0044444444444444444,0.057777777777777775,450,450,True
ak_refuse_harm,X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.03777777777777778,0.013333333333333334,0.06222222222222222,450,450,True
ak_refuse_harm,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.035555555555555556,0.008888888888888889,0.06222222222222222,450,450,True
ak_refuse_harm,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.035555555555555556,0.008888888888888889,0.06222222222222222,450,450,True
ak_refuse_harm,X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.028888888888888888,0.0,0.057777777777777775,450,450,False
ak_refuse_harm,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.015555555555555555,-0.013333333333333334,0.044444444444444446,450,450,False
ak_refuse_harm,RANDOM0_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.04666666666666667,-0.07111111111111111,-0.024444444444444446,450,450,True
ak_refuse_harm,RANDOM1_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.04888888888888889,-0.08005555555555553,-0.017777777777777778,450,450,True
ak_refuse_harm,RANDOM2_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.03111111111111111,-0.057777777777777775,-0.006666666666666667,450,450,True
ak_refuse_harm,RANDOM3_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.06,-0.08888888888888889,-0.03333333333333333,450,450,True
ak_refuse_harm,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.08222222222222222,0.05555555555555555,0.1111111111111111,450,450,True
ak_refuse_harm,X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.08888888888888889,0.06222222222222222,0.11777777777777777,450,450,True
ak_refuse_harm,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.08666666666666667,0.06,0.11555555555555555,450,450,True
ak_refuse_harm,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.08666666666666667,0.06,0.11555555555555555,450,450,True
ak_refuse_harm,X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.08,0.05333333333333334,0.1111111111111111,450,450,True
ak_refuse_harm,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.06666666666666667,0.03777777777777778,0.09777777777777778,450,450,True
ak_refuse_harm,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.07777777777777778,0.05388888888888889,0.10334722222222227,450,450,True
ak_refuse_harm,X_Cons5_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.08444444444444445,0.06,0.11055555555555556,450,450,True
ak_refuse_harm,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.08222222222222222,0.058333333333333334,0.10777777777777778,450,450,True
gap_harm,E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base,-0.29618833541870115,-0.37736492707994246,-0.21265637109014723,450,450,True
gap_harm,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.5101708390977647,0.4386741863356696,0.5800086594157748,450,450,True
gap_harm,X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.3584756671057807,0.2891213978926341,0.42812212716208564,450,450,True
gap_harm,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.16403362486097547,0.09359355730480619,0.23470118014017743,450,450,True
gap_harm,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.42125617451137964,0.34961325486501055,0.49207403082317774,450,450,True
gap_harm,X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.2845596832699246,0.2105803934203254,0.3599022334946526,450,450,True
gap_harm,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.1157356145646837,0.038383513556586375,0.19215818842252097,450,450,True
gap_harm,RANDOM0_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.03881138271755642,-0.12041586918301053,0.03831646458307903,450,450,False
gap_harm,RANDOM1_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.7334336535135905,-0.8108819033834669,-0.6596458889643352,450,450,True
gap_harm,RANDOM2_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.17910315937466093,-0.25341330949465435,-0.10751356649398804,450,450,True
gap_harm,RANDOM3_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.23347795592414008,-0.31265433375040685,-0.15411511675516765,450,450,True
gap_harm,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.8063591745164659,0.7619267448849149,0.8538973345756531,450,450,True
gap_harm,X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.6546640025244819,0.6043661987251706,0.7062983777258132,450,450,True
gap_harm,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.46022196027967666,0.41565791307555305,0.5077917304039002,450,450,True
gap_harm,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.7174445099300808,0.6741960706710816,0.7624790281719631,450,450,True
gap_harm,X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.5807480186886258,0.5289941115909153,0.6347790248394012,450,450,True
gap_harm,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.4119239499833849,0.3652771901554532,0.4590734602345361,450,450,True
gap_harm,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.8063773769802517,0.7661872423754799,0.8485854492253727,450,450,True
gap_harm,X_Cons5_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.6546822049882677,0.608976177778509,0.7038226001593801,450,450,True
gap_harm,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.46024016274346247,0.41588003874487345,0.5087507366273138,450,450,True
refuse_benign,E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base,-0.02857142857142857,-0.05714285714285714,0.0,175,175,False
refuse_benign,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.011428571428571429,-0.02857142857142857,0.0,175,175,False
refuse_benign,X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.011428571428571429,-0.02857142857142857,0.0,175,175,False
refuse_benign,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.011428571428571429,-0.03428571428571429,0.011428571428571429,175,175,False
refuse_benign,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.011428571428571429,-0.02857142857142857,0.0,175,175,False
refuse_benign,X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.02857142857142857,-0.05714285714285714,-0.005714285714285714,175,175,True
refuse_benign,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.022857142857142857,-0.05142857142857143,0.0,175,175,False
refuse_benign,RANDOM0_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.022857142857142857,-0.05142857142857143,0.0,175,175,False
refuse_benign,RANDOM1_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.022857142857142857,-0.045714285714285714,-0.005714285714285714,175,175,True
refuse_benign,RANDOM2_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.03428571428571429,-0.06285714285714286,-0.011428571428571429,175,175,True
refuse_benign,RANDOM3_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.022857142857142857,-0.045714285714285714,-0.005714285714285714,175,175,True
refuse_benign,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.017142857142857144,-0.005714285714285714,0.04,175,175,False
refuse_benign,X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.017142857142857144,-0.005714285714285714,0.045714285714285714,175,175,False
refuse_benign,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.017142857142857144,-0.005714285714285714,0.045714285714285714,175,175,False
refuse_benign,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.017142857142857144,-0.005714285714285714,0.04,175,175,False
refuse_benign,X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.0,-0.017142857142857144,0.017142857142857144,175,175,False
refuse_benign,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.005714285714285714,-0.011428571428571429,0.02857142857142857,175,175,False
refuse_benign,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.014285714285714285,-0.0014285714285714286,0.03428571428571429,175,175,False
refuse_benign,X_Cons5_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.014285714285714285,-0.0014285714285714286,0.03428571428571429,175,175,False
refuse_benign,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.014285714285714285,-0.0014285714285714286,0.03428571428571429,175,175,False
ak_over_refusal,E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base,-0.04,-0.06857142857142857,-0.011428571428571429,175,175,True
ak_over_refusal,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.011428571428571429,-0.03428571428571429,0.011428571428571429,175,175,False
ak_over_refusal,X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.017142857142857144,-0.04,0.0,175,175,False
ak_over_refusal,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.022857142857142857,-0.045714285714285714,-0.005714285714285714,175,175,True
ak_over_refusal,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.011428571428571429,-0.03428571428571429,0.011428571428571429,175,175,False
ak_over_refusal,X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.03428571428571429,-0.06285714285714286,-0.011428571428571429,175,175,True
ak_over_refusal,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.03428571428571429,-0.06285714285714286,-0.011428571428571429,175,175,True
ak_over_refusal,RANDOM0_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.03428571428571429,-0.06285714285714286,-0.011428571428571429,175,175,True
ak_over_refusal,RANDOM1_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.02857142857142857,-0.05714285714285714,-0.005714285714285714,175,175,True
ak_over_refusal,RANDOM2_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.04,-0.06857142857142857,-0.011428571428571429,175,175,True
ak_over_refusal,RANDOM3_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.02857142857142857,-0.05714285714285714,-0.005714285714285714,175,175,True
ak_over_refusal,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.02857142857142857,0.005714285714285714,0.05714285714285714,175,175,True
ak_over_refusal,X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.022857142857142857,0.005714285714285714,0.045714285714285714,175,175,True
ak_over_refusal,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.017142857142857144,0.0,0.04,175,175,False
ak_over_refusal,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.02857142857142857,0.005714285714285714,0.05714285714285714,175,175,True
ak_over_refusal,X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.005714285714285714,0.0,0.017142857142857144,175,175,False
ak_over_refusal,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.005714285714285714,0.0,0.017142857142857144,175,175,False
ak_over_refusal,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.02142857142857143,0.002857142857142857,0.04428571428571428,175,175,True
ak_over_refusal,X_Cons5_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.015714285714285715,0.0,0.03571428571428571,175,175,False
ak_over_refusal,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.01,-0.0014285714285714286,0.025714285714285714,175,175,False
mmlu,E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base,-0.02,-0.044,0.004,1000,500,False
mmlu,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.01,-0.031,0.011,1000,500,False
mmlu,X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.003,-0.024,0.018,1000,500,False
mmlu,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.007,-0.027,0.013,1000,500,False
mmlu,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.012,-0.033,0.01,1000,500,False
mmlu,X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.01,-0.032,0.01102500000000009,1000,500,False
mmlu,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.01,-0.031,0.011,1000,500,False
mmlu,RANDOM0_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.022,-0.046,0.002,1000,500,False
mmlu,RANDOM1_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.02,-0.043,0.003,1000,500,False
mmlu,RANDOM2_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.034,-0.059,-0.01,1000,500,True
mmlu,RANDOM3_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.014,-0.036,0.008,1000,500,False
mmlu,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.01,-0.007,0.027,1000,500,False
mmlu,X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.017,0.001,0.034,1000,500,True
mmlu,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.013,-0.003,0.029,1000,500,False
mmlu,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.008,-0.01,0.026,1000,500,False
mmlu,X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.01,-0.008,0.029,1000,500,False
mmlu,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.01,-0.007,0.027,1000,500,False
mmlu,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.0125,-0.003,0.02875,1000,500,False
mmlu,X_Cons5_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.0195,0.00425,0.035,1000,500,True
mmlu,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.0155,0.00075,0.030256250000000023,1000,500,True
bele,E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base,-0.022727272727272728,-0.042045454545454546,-0.003409090909090909,800,440,True
bele,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.011363636363636364,-0.029573863636363627,0.006818181818181818,800,440,False
bele,X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.013636363636363636,-0.031818181818181815,0.004545454545454545,800,440,False
bele,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.011363636363636364,-0.029545454545454545,0.006818181818181818,800,440,False
bele,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.011363636363636364,-0.029545454545454545,0.006818181818181818,800,440,False
bele,X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.011363636363636364,-0.028409090909090908,0.005681818181818182,800,440,False
bele,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.0125,-0.03068181818181818,0.006818181818181818,800,440,False
bele,RANDOM0_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.019318181818181818,-0.0375,-0.0011363636363636363,800,440,True
bele,RANDOM1_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.014772727272727272,-0.031818181818181815,0.002301136363636467,800,440,False
bele,RANDOM2_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.0125,-0.03068181818181818,0.005681818181818182,800,440,False
bele,RANDOM3_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.019318181818181818,-0.038636363636363635,2.840909090919426e-05,800,440,False
bele,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.011363636363636364,-0.0011363636363636363,0.023863636363636365,800,440,False
bele,X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.00909090909090909,-0.004545454545454545,0.02159090909090909,800,440,False
bele,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.011363636363636364,-0.0011363636363636363,0.023863636363636365,800,440,False
bele,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.011363636363636364,0.0,0.023863636363636365,800,440,False
bele,X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.011363636363636364,-0.003409090909090909,0.025,800,440,False
bele,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.010227272727272727,-0.0011363636363636363,0.022727272727272728,800,440,False
bele,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.005113636363636364,-0.007102272727272727,0.017897727272727273,800,440,False
bele,X_Cons5_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.002840909090909091,-0.009375,0.014772727272727272,800,440,False
bele,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.005113636363636364,-0.007670454545454545,0.017897727272727273,800,440,False
tqa,E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base,0.0024479804161566705,-0.011015911872705019,0.01591187270501836,817,817,False
tqa,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.0024479804161566705,-0.01591187270501836,0.011015911872705019,817,817,False
tqa,X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.0024479804161566705,-0.017135862913096694,0.012239902080783354,817,817,False
tqa,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.0012239902080783353,-0.012239902080783354,0.01591187270501836,817,817,False
tqa,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.0036719706242350062,-0.017135862913096694,0.009791921664626682,817,817,False
tqa,X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.0024479804161566705,-0.017135862913096694,0.012270501835985425,817,817,False
tqa,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.0012239902080783353,-0.01346389228886169,0.01591187270501836,817,817,False
tqa,RANDOM0_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.0036719706242350062,-0.01591187270501836,0.008567931456548347,817,817,False
tqa,RANDOM1_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.0012239902080783353,-0.014687882496940025,0.01346389228886169,817,817,False
tqa,RANDOM2_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.0,-0.012239902080783354,0.01346389228886169,817,817,False
tqa,RANDOM3_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.0036719706242350062,-0.017135862913096694,0.011015911872705019,817,817,False
tqa,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,-0.004895960832313341,-0.014687882496940025,0.004895960832313341,817,817,False
tqa,X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,-0.004895960832313341,-0.014687882496940025,0.004895960832313341,817,817,False
tqa,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,-0.0012239902080783353,-0.009791921664626682,0.0073439412484700125,817,817,False
tqa,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,-0.006119951040391677,-0.01591187270501836,0.0036719706242350062,817,817,False
tqa,X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,-0.004895960832313341,-0.01591187270501836,0.006119951040391677,817,817,False
tqa,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,-0.0012239902080783353,-0.011015911872705019,0.009791921664626682,817,817,False
tqa,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),-0.0003059975520195838,-0.009791921664626682,0.008873929008567932,817,817,False
tqa,X_Cons5_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),-0.0003059975520195838,-0.01040391676866585,0.009485924112607099,817,817,False
tqa,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.0033659730722154224,-0.005813953488372093,0.012545899632802938,817,817,False
logppl_en,E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base,0.0486275324542057,0.042886857437589666,0.05473939751962231,150,150,True
logppl_en,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.03796166687624579,0.03300595658422894,0.04311185532558015,150,150,True
logppl_en,X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.03553877539986277,0.03052864929206814,0.04054958672119968,150,150,True
logppl_en,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.03560007382472963,0.030643963818017032,0.04076908569477072,150,150,True
logppl_en,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.03841326510488374,0.03344945064608518,0.04353407440677574,150,150,True
logppl_en,X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.0377489726871659,0.03280126649910454,0.042848930556852204,150,150,True
logppl_en,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.038301119552641295,0.03326104948117682,0.043608848326492665,150,150,True
logppl_en,RANDOM0_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.04168829246486542,0.03641318239808593,0.04723934834749534,150,150,True
logppl_en,RANDOM1_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.041861132948322465,0.036661557677490964,0.0472687177621205,150,150,True
logppl_en,RANDOM2_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.04219190546803405,0.03676462365327933,0.04778430738639793,150,150,True
logppl_en,RANDOM3_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.04270617577514956,0.0375667853646541,0.0482408192663725,150,150,True
logppl_en,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,-0.01066586557795991,-0.013277335287191513,-0.008307389124291888,150,150,True
logppl_en,X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,-0.013088757054342927,-0.01586901330649701,-0.01029554562940357,150,150,True
logppl_en,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,-0.013027458629476072,-0.015807459766363413,-0.010496310162732635,150,150,True
logppl_en,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,-0.010214267349321956,-0.012822443964096802,-0.0077131906883195584,150,150,True
logppl_en,X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,-0.010878559767039801,-0.013867733232581355,-0.00788693753954304,150,150,True
logppl_en,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,-0.010326412901564405,-0.013244655292029185,-0.007553364122077363,150,150,True
logppl_en,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),-0.004150209787847104,-0.006448143188313251,-0.002010896408999689,150,150,True
logppl_en,X_Cons5_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),-0.006573101264230122,-0.009382359899356813,-0.00389521237799351,150,150,True
logppl_en,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),-0.006511802839363267,-0.009419353732641751,-0.0039892754654913595,150,150,True
logppl_hi,E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base,0.049613523632172814,0.04476883750673268,0.05448821486114294,150,150,True
logppl_hi,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.039457650997152524,0.034661386061417866,0.044057767265765824,150,150,True
logppl_hi,X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.036334228264367975,0.03211231527997927,0.04047652602723119,150,150,True
logppl_hi,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.03693604924885419,0.03281711534092464,0.04100767718987358,150,150,True
logppl_hi,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.04108987884876767,0.03620927450465837,0.04579265003608485,150,150,True
logppl_hi,X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.04050100457731171,0.03602907456698842,0.04469879945506334,150,150,True
logppl_hi,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.04096100385580146,0.036694582598347514,0.045057741716435395,150,150,True
logppl_hi,RANDOM0_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.04182304981883702,0.037086664257499576,0.04648124511792235,150,150,True
logppl_hi,RANDOM1_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.044284757603654044,0.03992814647912709,0.048651697682415646,150,150,True
logppl_hi,RANDOM2_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.03981875418100025,0.03496620732830036,0.04449877444651251,150,150,True
logppl_hi,RANDOM3_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.04660490133042069,0.04206708760945379,0.05130034593742775,150,150,True
logppl_hi,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,-0.010155872635020295,-0.011967105162772197,-0.008416067539001171,150,150,True
logppl_hi,X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,-0.013279295367804839,-0.015901356566173024,-0.010728509289028213,150,150,True
logppl_hi,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,-0.012677474383318621,-0.015187190095528467,-0.010120130334645499,150,150,True
logppl_hi,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,-0.008523644783405145,-0.010454555659758322,-0.006602211646337522,150,150,True
logppl_hi,X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,-0.009112519054861101,-0.011806418156404274,-0.006387486924735132,150,150,True
logppl_hi,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,-0.00865251977637135,-0.011138617933083007,-0.006098901241706452,150,150,True
logppl_hi,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),-0.0036752147363254945,-0.005307686390394582,-0.002036056844020833,150,150,True
logppl_hi,X_Cons5_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),-0.00679863746911004,-0.009307143529399353,-0.00426538338283477,150,150,True
logppl_hi,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),-0.006196816484623821,-0.008673205018989567,-0.0036588602769073147,150,150,True
degen_long,E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base,0.0,0.0,0.0,55,55,False
degen_long,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.0,0.0,0.0,55,55,False
degen_long,X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.0,0.0,0.0,55,55,False
degen_long,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.0,0.0,0.0,55,55,False
degen_long,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.0,0.0,0.0,55,55,False
degen_long,X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.0,0.0,0.0,55,55,False
degen_long,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.0,0.0,0.0,55,55,False
degen_long,RANDOM0_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.0,0.0,0.0,55,55,False
degen_long,RANDOM1_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.01818181818181818,0.0,0.05454545454545454,55,55,False
degen_long,RANDOM2_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.0,0.0,0.0,55,55,False
degen_long,RANDOM3_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.01818181818181818,-0.05454545454545454,0.0,55,55,False
degen_long,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.0,0.0,0.0,55,55,False
degen_long,X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.0,0.0,0.0,55,55,False
degen_long,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.0,0.0,0.0,55,55,False
degen_long,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.0,0.0,0.0,55,55,False
degen_long,X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.0,0.0,0.0,55,55,False
degen_long,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.0,0.0,0.0,55,55,False
degen_long,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.0,-0.013636363636363636,0.013636363636363636,55,55,False
degen_long,X_Cons5_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.0,-0.013636363636363636,0.013636363636363636,55,55,False
degen_long,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - mean(4 random FP16-protected),0.0,-0.013636363636363636,0.013636363636363636,55,55,False
ext_harm_ak,E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base,-0.0380952380952381,-0.06666666666666667,-0.012698412698412698,315,315,True
ext_harm_ak,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.012698412698412698,-0.03492063492063492,0.009523809523809525,315,315,False
ext_harm_ak,X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.015873015873015872,-0.0380952380952381,0.0031746031746031746,315,315,False
ext_harm_ak,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.025396825396825397,-0.047619047619047616,-0.0031746031746031746,315,315,True
ext_harm_ak,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.006349206349206349,-0.02857142857142857,0.012698412698412698,315,315,False
ext_harm_ak,X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.022222222222222223,-0.044444444444444446,-0.0031746031746031746,315,315,True
ext_harm_ak,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.025396825396825397,-0.050793650793650794,-0.0031746031746031746,315,315,True
ext_harm_ak,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.025396825396825397,0.0031746031746031746,0.047619047619047616,315,315,True
ext_harm_ak,X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.022222222222222223,0.0031746031746031746,0.044444444444444446,315,315,True
ext_harm_ak,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.012698412698412698,-0.0031746031746031746,0.031746031746031744,315,315,False
ext_harm_ak,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.031746031746031744,0.009523809523809525,0.05714285714285714,315,315,True
ext_harm_ak,X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.015873015873015872,-0.0031746031746031746,0.0380952380952381,315,315,False
ext_harm_ak,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.012698412698412698,0.0,0.02857142857142857,315,315,False
ml_harm_ak,E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base,-0.014285714285714285,-0.05357142857142857,0.025,280,280,False
ml_harm_ak,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.05357142857142857,0.014285714285714285,0.09642857142857143,280,280,True
ml_harm_ak,X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.02857142857142857,-0.007142857142857143,0.06785714285714285,280,280,False
ml_harm_ak,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.025,-0.010714285714285714,0.060714285714285714,280,280,False
ml_harm_ak,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.05714285714285714,0.017857142857142856,0.1,280,280,True
ml_harm_ak,X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.02857142857142857,-0.007142857142857143,0.06785714285714285,280,280,False
ml_harm_ak,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.025,-0.010803571428571399,0.06428571428571428,280,280,False
ml_harm_ak,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.06785714285714285,0.039285714285714285,0.1,280,280,True
ml_harm_ak,X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.04285714285714286,0.010714285714285714,0.075,280,280,True
ml_harm_ak,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.039285714285714285,0.0035714285714285713,0.075,280,280,True
ml_harm_ak,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.07142857142857142,0.04285714285714286,0.10357142857142858,280,280,True
ml_harm_ak,X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.04285714285714286,0.014285714285714285,0.075,280,280,True
ml_harm_ak,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.039285714285714285,0.007142857142857143,0.07142857142857142,280,280,True
ext_benign_ak,E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base,-0.05,-0.085,-0.02,200,200,True
ext_benign_ak,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.01,-0.04,0.02,200,200,False
ext_benign_ak,X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.025,-0.055,0.005,200,200,False
ext_benign_ak,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.025,-0.06,0.005,200,200,False
ext_benign_ak,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.02,-0.055,0.015,200,200,False
ext_benign_ak,X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.04,-0.075,-0.005,200,200,True
ext_benign_ak,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.045,-0.08,-0.015,200,200,True
ext_benign_ak,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.04,0.01,0.075,200,200,True
ext_benign_ak,X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.025,0.0,0.055,200,200,False
ext_benign_ak,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.025,0.0,0.055,200,200,False
ext_benign_ak,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.03,0.0,0.06,200,200,False
ext_benign_ak,X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.01,-0.015,0.035,200,200,False
ext_benign_ak,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.005,-0.02,0.03,200,200,False
ml_benign_ak,E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base,0.0,0.0,0.0,100,100,False
ml_benign_ak,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.0,0.0,0.0,100,100,False
ml_benign_ak,X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.0,0.0,0.0,100,100,False
ml_benign_ak,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.0,0.0,0.0,100,100,False
ml_benign_ak,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.0,0.0,0.0,100,100,False
ml_benign_ak,X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.0,0.0,0.0,100,100,False
ml_benign_ak,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.0,0.0,0.0,100,100,False
ml_benign_ak,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.0,0.0,0.0,100,100,False
ml_benign_ak,X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.0,0.0,0.0,100,100,False
ml_benign_ak,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.0,0.0,0.0,100,100,False
ml_benign_ak,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.0,0.0,0.0,100,100,False
ml_benign_ak,X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.0,0.0,0.0,100,100,False
ml_benign_ak,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.0,0.0,0.0,100,100,False
lite,E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base,-0.001388888888888889,-0.02638888888888889,0.022222222222222223,720,720,False
lite,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.008333333333333333,-0.013888888888888888,0.030555555555555555,720,720,False
lite,X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.006944444444444444,-0.016666666666666666,0.030555555555555555,720,720,False
lite,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.011111111111111112,-0.011111111111111112,0.03194444444444444,720,720,False
lite,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.002777777777777778,-0.020833333333333332,0.02638888888888889,720,720,False
lite,X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.002777777777777778,-0.019444444444444445,0.02361111111111111,720,720,False
lite,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.009722222222222222,-0.0125,0.03194444444444444,720,720,False
lite,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.009722222222222222,-0.006944444444444444,0.025,720,720,False
lite,X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.008333333333333333,-0.008333333333333333,0.025,720,720,False
lite,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.0125,-0.002777777777777778,0.027777777777777776,720,720,False
lite,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.004166666666666667,-0.013888888888888888,0.020833333333333332,720,720,False
lite,X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.004166666666666667,-0.015277777777777777,0.02361111111111111,720,720,False
lite,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.011111111111111112,-0.005555555555555556,0.027777777777777776,720,720,False
belx,E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base,0.011111111111111112,-0.022222222222222223,0.044444444444444446,360,360,False
belx,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.016666666666666666,-0.011111111111111112,0.044444444444444446,360,360,False
belx,X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.011111111111111112,-0.016666666666666666,0.03888888888888889,360,360,False
belx,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base,0.005555555555555556,-0.025,0.03611111111111111,360,360,False
belx,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base,0.016666666666666666,-0.013888888888888888,0.04722222222222222,360,360,False
belx,X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.005555555555555556,-0.03333333333333333,0.022222222222222223,360,360,False
belx,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.002777777777777778,-0.03333333333333333,0.030555555555555555,360,360,False
belx,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.005555555555555556,-0.013888888888888888,0.025,360,360,False
belx,X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.0,-0.022222222222222223,0.022222222222222223,360,360,False
belx,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,-0.005555555555555556,-0.027777777777777776,0.013888888888888888,360,360,False
belx,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.005555555555555556,-0.013888888888888888,0.025,360,360,False
belx,X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,-0.016666666666666666,-0.041666666666666664,0.008333333333333333,360,360,False
belx,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,-0.013888888888888888,-0.03611111111111111,0.008333333333333333,360,360,False
arc,E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base,-0.03333333333333333,-0.07333333333333333,0.006666666666666667,300,300,False
arc,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.03333333333333333,-0.06666666666666667,0.0,300,300,False
arc,X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.023333333333333334,-0.06,0.013333333333333334,300,300,False
arc,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.02,-0.056666666666666664,0.016666666666666666,300,300,False
arc,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.02666666666666667,-0.06,0.006666666666666667,300,300,False
arc,X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.02666666666666667,-0.06333333333333334,0.01,300,300,False
arc,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.03333333333333333,-0.07,0.0033333333333333335,300,300,False
arc,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.0,-0.02666666666666667,0.02666666666666667,300,300,False
arc,X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.01,-0.01,0.03333333333333333,300,300,False
arc,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.013333333333333334,-0.006666666666666667,0.03666666666666667,300,300,False
arc,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.006666666666666667,-0.02,0.03333333333333333,300,300,False
arc,X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.006666666666666667,-0.013333333333333334,0.02666666666666667,300,300,False
arc,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.0,-0.02666666666666667,0.02666666666666667,300,300,False
mgsm,E1_uniform_nf4 - FP16 base,-0.1375,-0.2375,-0.0375,80,80,True
mgsm,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.0375,-0.1375,0.0625,80,80,False
mgsm,X_Cons5_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.1,-0.2,-0.0125,80,80,True
mgsm,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - FP16 base,-0.1,-0.18781249999999988,-0.0125,80,80,True
mgsm,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.0625,-0.1625,0.0375,80,80,False
mgsm,X_Cons5_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.1375,-0.2375,-0.025,80,80,True
mgsm,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - FP16 base,-0.1375,-0.2375,-0.0375,80,80,True
mgsm,C_refusalDrop_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.1,0.025,0.1875,80,80,True
mgsm,X_Cons5_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.0375,-0.05,0.125,80,80,False
mgsm,CK_circuitkit_FP16prot - uniform 4-bit,0.0375,-0.05,0.1375,80,80,False
mgsm,C_refusalDrop_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.075,-0.0125,0.1625,80,80,False
mgsm,X_Cons5_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.0,-0.0875,0.0875,80,80,False
mgsm,CK_circuitkit_INT8prot - uniform 4-bit,0.0,-0.0875,0.0875,80,80,False