text
stringlengths
0
104
the Jews are often not about the Jews
at all but about Christians in search
of their own distinct identity [...]
Having begun its life as an offspring
of Judaism and as a Jewish sect, early
Christianity was facing a set of major,
almost unsurmountable challenges
when it came to delineate its self-iden-
tity. [...] Clearly etched boundaries
became crucially important. Christian
theologians needed to succeed in
highlighting the fact that Christianity
was something altogether different
and new. [...] [As] they tried to sever
all ties from the Jewish past that had
produced them [...] [they] could do
little but engage in a considerable
amount of negative identity-forma-
tion. Judaism ended up at the receiv-
ing end of the hostile rhetoric that this
process of dissociation, separation,
and identity formation entailed and
engendered. (Rutgers 2021, 34)
Another historian, Professor Magda Teter
(2023), depicts the content of the Christian
“group lens” on Jews by showing how
Christian theology of late Antiquity cast
Jews as “children born to slavery’, and
how their supposed theological inferiority
Approaching Religion * Vol. 16, No.1 * March 2026
became inscribed into law, institutional-
izing a sense of Christian domination and
superiority. Teter (2023) found that, in Etsi
Judeos of Pope Innocent III (1205), Jews
were not allowed to have Christian serv-
ants, because they “shall recognize them-
selves as slaves to those whom Christ’s
death set free. In Cum Nimis Absurdum
(1555) of Pope Paul IV, Jews were forbid-
den to live as neighbours to Christians or
churches, because “Jews, whose own guilt
has consigned them to perpetual servi-
tude” should, “as long as they persist in
>
their errors’, “recognize through experi-
ence that they have become slaves while
Christians have been made free through
Jesus Christ”. Jews were supposed to aban-
don their religious identity and cease to
exist as Jews. Interestingly, Teter shows that
the first racist laws which were introduced
in Virginia, USA, in “An Act concerning
Servants and Slaves” (Section XI) in 1705
largely mirrored the anti-Jewish laws that
had existed for centuries.
Although “antisemitism has taken on
radically different forms and supposed
‘rationales’ in different cultures at different
times” (Johnson 2019, 17), research shows
that the core of antisemitism is rooted in
Christian theology (Brekke 2021). Many
scholars have formulated the essence
of antisemitic myths and _ stereotypes.
According to Professor of Law Anthony
Julius (2024), for example, all versions
of antisemitism libel Jews, as libels “are
damaging to the good name of the Jewish
people” (Julius 2024, 11). Julius lists five
libels as the essence of antisemitism:
The blood libel supposes that Jews enter-
tain homicidal intentions towards non-Jews
(and specifically, non-Jewish children), and
commit acts of murder, either in re-enact-
62
========== PAGE 8 ==========
ment of the Crucifixion, or to avenge their
continuing, collective punishment for that
cosmic crime.
¢ The economic libel supposes that Jews,
who are self-interested, materialist, acquis-
itive and unproductive by nature, exploit
non-Jews when they can, and seek monop-
oly power, the better to pursue their greater
objectives.
¢ The conspiracy libel supposes that Jews
act in concert, in secret pursuit of goals
inimical to the interests of non-Jews. That