| { |
| "metadata": { |
| "all_tasks": [ |
| "aime", |
| "gpqa", |
| "hmmt", |
| "supergpqa", |
| "mmlupro", |
| "usaco" |
| ], |
| "llm_names": [ |
| "Ministral-3-3B-Reasoning-2512", |
| "Ministral-3-8B-Reasoning-2512", |
| "Nemotron-Cascade-14B-Thinking", |
| "Nemotron-Cascade-8B-Thinking", |
| "Olmo-3-32B-Think", |
| "Qwen3-0.6B", |
| "Qwen3-1.7B", |
| "Qwen3-14B", |
| "Qwen3-30B-A3B-Thinking-2507", |
| "Qwen3-32B", |
| "Qwen3-4B", |
| "Qwen3-8B", |
| "R1-Distill-Llama-70B", |
| "R1-Distill-Llama-8B", |
| "R1-Distill-Qwen-14B", |
| "R1-Distill-Qwen-32B", |
| "R1-Distill-Qwen-7B", |
| "SmolLM3-3B" |
| ], |
| "n_models": 18, |
| "n_features": 80, |
| "cv_held_out": 2, |
| "perc_models": 60.0, |
| "seeds": 20, |
| "seeds_sparse": 4, |
| "n_grid": 200, |
| "n_perm": 200, |
| "perm_seed": 12345, |
| "designs": [ |
| "full", |
| "heldin" |
| ], |
| "classes": [ |
| "univariate", |
| "ranksvm_linear", |
| "ranksvm_rbf", |
| "sparse3" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "results": { |
| "full": { |
| "univariate": { |
| "observed": 0.5547678018575852, |
| "paper_table2": 0.54, |
| "n_perm": 200, |
| "null_mean": 0.2620979532163743, |
| "null_std": 0.12721079588043072, |
| "null_p50": 0.24953388372893015, |
| "null_p95": 0.4820971792225659, |
| "null_p99": 0.5857080151358787, |
| "null_max": 0.6309115927072583, |
| "n_null_ge_observed": 3, |
| "p_empirical": 0.01990049751243781, |
| "null_values": [ |
| 0.33657034743722053, |
| 0.3738871689026488, |
| 0.40517371861025114, |
| 0.1733642930856553, |
| 0.26015479876160985, |
| 0.32150670794633646, |
| 0.3033780529755762, |
| 0.585531475748194, |
| 0.1893016855865153, |
| 0.3016821465428277, |
| 0.30312349501203995, |
| 0.2698486412108703, |
| 0.304093567251462, |
| 0.358888888888889, |
| 0.26343653250773996, |
| 0.11587547299621603, |
| 0.20976264189886482, |
| 0.481014791881665, |
| 0.20614035087719298, |
| 0.2344341245270038, |
| 0.36442380460956314, |
| 0.10382868937048503, |
| 0.2637702098383213, |
| 0.34261781905744754, |
| 0.14793601651186788, |
| 0.41388372893016856, |
| 0.3015239078087376, |
| 0.21104919160646712, |
| 0.4769934640522876, |
| 0.22277949776401784, |
| 0.2872480220158239, |
| 0.0405297557619539, |
| 0.23757137942896459, |
| 0.190374957000344, |
| 0.34159614723082216, |
| 0.3087306501547987, |
| 0.394485724114207, |
| 0.3161713106295149, |
| 0.3376298589611283, |
| 0.3881286549707602, |
| 0.14730650154798758, |
| 0.34594771241830063, |
| 0.5368833849329205, |
| 0.20181974544203646, |
| 0.25108015135878914, |
| 0.06093223254213966, |
| 0.2840522875816994, |
| 0.11316821465428276, |
| 0.11145166838665291, |
| 0.1430890952872377, |
| 0.3539594083247334, |
| 0.27990024079807363, |
| 0.18704850361197112, |
| 0.22961816305469554, |
| 0.20297901616787062, |
| 0.10576539387684898, |
| 0.29692122463020293, |
| 0.23068455452356385, |
| 0.2864981080151358, |
| 0.1679910560715514, |
| 0.20853801169590644, |
| 0.4004437564499484, |
| 0.12373581011351908, |
| 0.20519779841761268, |
| 0.19528379772961815, |
| 0.05175094599243206, |
| 0.16593395252837975, |
| 0.24798761609907113, |
| 0.42941520467836264, |
| 0.19620571035431716, |
| 0.15089439284485728, |
| 0.31532163742690056, |
| 0.03936016511867905, |
| 0.4485345717234262, |
| 0.3625421396628826, |
| 0.14820433436532507, |
| 0.2106295149638803, |
| 0.20678706570347435, |
| 0.14506707946336428, |
| 0.44943928448572396, |
| 0.32604059167526656, |
| 0.3683453732370141, |
| 0.29363949088407293, |
| 0.15443068455452358, |
| 0.3598142414860681, |
| 0.257265221878225, |
| 0.17543515651874786, |
| 0.2859133126934984, |
| 0.5366769865841072, |
| 0.2299415204678362, |
| 0.12998624011007914, |
| 0.5051221190230477, |
| 0.4440350877192983, |
| 0.08491228070175438, |
| 0.26996216030271764, |
| 0.2018919848641211, |
| 0.2941967664258686, |
| 0.12562435500515995, |
| 0.19216374269005848, |
| 0.05000687994496045, |
| 0.2982077743378053, |
| 0.2579669762641898, |
| 0.348390092879257, |
| 0.18693498452012386, |
| 0.1485517715858273, |
| 0.2400103199174406, |
| 0.1975954592363261, |
| 0.07355349157206742, |
| 0.20362573099415204, |
| 0.19736498108015135, |
| 0.17822841417268662, |
| 0.2810388716890265, |
| 0.36734434124527005, |
| 0.2096353629170966, |
| 0.4767698658410732, |
| 0.15004815961472312, |
| 0.297578259373925, |
| 0.09023047815617474, |
| 0.17167870657034745, |
| 0.11293429652562778, |
| 0.23051943584451323, |
| 0.4208083935328517, |
| 0.11614379084967319, |
| 0.18658066735466114, |
| 0.22922600619195052, |
| 0.528641210870313, |
| 0.2818335053319574, |
| 0.32303749570003437, |
| 0.32428964568283447, |
| 0.3436016511867905, |
| 0.0907361541107671, |
| 0.12834881320949434, |
| 0.32045407636738904, |
| 0.119453044375645, |
| 0.09784313725490197, |
| 0.5026625386996904, |
| 0.3470141038871689, |
| 0.10278981768145853, |
| 0.6031854145166841, |
| 0.5250189198486412, |
| 0.24084279325765393, |
| 0.3725902992776058, |
| 0.19066047471620226, |
| 0.26546611627106986, |
| 0.18933608531131746, |
| 0.2190333677330581, |
| 0.19169934640522873, |
| 0.44755073959408326, |
| 0.1384967320261438, |
| 0.32352941176470584, |
| 0.1251186790505676, |
| 0.1372377020983832, |
| 0.12751289989680084, |
| 0.41602339181286546, |
| 0.10785345717234263, |
| 0.18049191606467146, |
| 0.10994496044031646, |
| 0.05747162022703819, |
| 0.3322531819745441, |
| 0.12236326109391127, |
| 0.13359821121431026, |
| 0.21228070175438596, |
| 0.3918507051943585, |
| 0.3346439628482972, |
| 0.6309115927072583, |
| 0.38905400756793945, |
| 0.0517406260749914, |
| 0.08544891640866872, |
| 0.07854145166838664, |
| 0.30975920192638456, |
| 0.39904024767801854, |
| 0.1981011351909185, |
| 0.24485380116959066, |
| 0.3193326453388373, |
| 0.5307877536979704, |
| 0.30345029239766086, |
| 0.29026831785345714, |
| 0.22058823529411767, |
| 0.11141382868937048, |
| 0.43541451668386655, |
| 0.40709666322669424, |
| 0.45323013415892677, |
| 0.467437220502236, |
| 0.07401100791193671, |
| 0.14744754041967664, |
| 0.16145166838665287, |
| 0.2403887168902649, |
| 0.2596628826969385, |
| 0.3889095287237702, |
| 0.433016855865153, |
| 0.3769728242174063, |
| 0.3013381492948056, |
| 0.12597179222566218, |
| 0.15621259029927761, |
| 0.3516133470932232, |
| 0.38120743034055726, |
| 0.3466735466116271, |
| 0.34574819401444784, |
| 0.44985896112831103, |
| 0.0626934984520124 |
| ], |
| "n_seeds": 20 |
| }, |
| "ranksvm_linear": { |
| "observed": 0.8157550739594083, |
| "paper_table2": 0.81, |
| "n_perm": 200, |
| "null_mean": 0.38353273133814925, |
| "null_std": 0.10455404179093722, |
| "null_p50": 0.38387168902648783, |
| "null_p95": 0.5496054351565187, |
| "null_p99": 0.6541539387684897, |
| "null_max": 0.717048503611971, |
| "n_null_ge_observed": 0, |
| "p_empirical": 0.004975124378109453, |
| "null_values": [ |
| 0.4313071895424837, |
| 0.4659545923632611, |
| 0.4225352597179223, |
| 0.38740970072239433, |
| 0.2447471620227038, |
| 0.47407636738906084, |
| 0.43894392844857244, |
| 0.5165875472996215, |
| 0.2334778121775026, |
| 0.48443068455452354, |
| 0.4245614035087719, |
| 0.40293773649810805, |
| 0.36316477468180247, |
| 0.4390092879256966, |
| 0.39294117647058824, |
| 0.33676986584107327, |
| 0.32218782249742006, |
| 0.5649432404540764, |
| 0.3452149982800138, |
| 0.19505675954592364, |
| 0.44863777089783285, |
| 0.2584588923288613, |
| 0.3070072239422085, |
| 0.3569865841073271, |
| 0.2816924664602683, |
| 0.3470106639146887, |
| 0.4819229446164431, |
| 0.4162676298589611, |
| 0.5026694186446508, |
| 0.42499140006879943, |
| 0.35060887512899896, |
| 0.25310973512211904, |
| 0.4351874785001719, |
| 0.3977708978328173, |
| 0.4448366013071895, |
| 0.3990643274853801, |
| 0.41217750257997937, |
| 0.5286618507051943, |
| 0.43240798073615416, |
| 0.5305572755417957, |
| 0.3987547299621603, |
| 0.45661850705194357, |
| 0.5337839697282422, |
| 0.486171310629515, |
| 0.3916683866529067, |
| 0.21980392156862746, |
| 0.35190230478156176, |
| 0.21882008943928444, |
| 0.19996216030271757, |
| 0.34421396628826967, |
| 0.35455452356381156, |
| 0.40366701066391475, |
| 0.2690264877880977, |
| 0.4117715858273134, |
| 0.33732026143790855, |
| 0.2085483316133471, |
| 0.31993464052287585, |
| 0.30079119367045065, |
| 0.35671826625386993, |
| 0.3183075335397316, |
| 0.40179222566219464, |
| 0.4364602683178534, |
| 0.2541348469212246, |
| 0.5122050223598211, |
| 0.3501651186790506, |
| 0.1644857241142071, |
| 0.3006226350189199, |
| 0.32749570003439976, |
| 0.4518988648090815, |
| 0.34878568971448226, |
| 0.2664155486756106, |
| 0.3160509115927072, |
| 0.35215342277261774, |
| 0.46825593395252846, |
| 0.4552459580323358, |
| 0.38998968008255924, |
| 0.23481252149982795, |
| 0.45519091847265225, |
| 0.40791881664946683, |
| 0.3755177158582731, |
| 0.27183006535947707, |
| 0.46005847953216383, |
| 0.33761609907120743, |
| 0.3118713450292398, |
| 0.4177915376676986, |
| 0.3864258685930512, |
| 0.3392397660818714, |
| 0.38047815617475067, |
| 0.6095149638802888, |
| 0.363625730994152, |
| 0.30874097007223933, |
| 0.5495975232198143, |
| 0.45105607155142763, |
| 0.28484348125215, |
| 0.5245958032335742, |
| 0.4479394564843481, |
| 0.4606948744410045, |
| 0.26398692810457514, |
| 0.21516339869281045, |
| 0.2797798417612659, |
| 0.5603130374957, |
| 0.2777158582731338, |
| 0.4889576883384933, |
| 0.2737151702786378, |
| 0.39320261437908494, |
| 0.2992019263845889, |
| 0.43426900584795325, |
| 0.19528035775713798, |
| 0.5955521155830753, |
| 0.2778500171998624, |
| 0.4334193326453389, |
| 0.3919642242862057, |
| 0.38206742346061234, |
| 0.2515239078087375, |
| 0.38997936016511864, |
| 0.39151702786377707, |
| 0.44951496388028894, |
| 0.1250842793257654, |
| 0.2747162022703818, |
| 0.24707258341933266, |
| 0.3876952184382525, |
| 0.4159477124183007, |
| 0.291124871001032, |
| 0.2847746818025456, |
| 0.23029239766081874, |
| 0.4602442380460956, |
| 0.3888613691090471, |
| 0.3692569659442725, |
| 0.5497557619539042, |
| 0.5351496388028897, |
| 0.22723426212590306, |
| 0.3367905056759546, |
| 0.3776126590987272, |
| 0.32066047471620224, |
| 0.240546955624355, |
| 0.6540041279669763, |
| 0.37640522875816995, |
| 0.5051393188854488, |
| 0.5398417612659099, |
| 0.5715823873409014, |
| 0.34572411420708626, |
| 0.3755417956656346, |
| 0.41342277261781907, |
| 0.5240350877192983, |
| 0.4094805641554868, |
| 0.26331613347093225, |
| 0.28815617475060196, |
| 0.4549088407292742, |
| 0.24833505331957345, |
| 0.3782387340901273, |
| 0.22515651874784998, |
| 0.27364637082903337, |
| 0.2846198830409356, |
| 0.416047471620227, |
| 0.332094943240454, |
| 0.4855417956656347, |
| 0.40775713794289636, |
| 0.342875816993464, |
| 0.5197936016511868, |
| 0.30741314069487446, |
| 0.38567595459236326, |
| 0.5476711386308911, |
| 0.5080701754385964, |
| 0.41423116615067074, |
| 0.668985208118335, |
| 0.5017234262125903, |
| 0.19974544203646372, |
| 0.26275541795665636, |
| 0.16739938080495356, |
| 0.30997248022015816, |
| 0.49682146542827665, |
| 0.47561403508771927, |
| 0.29396628826969384, |
| 0.34095287237702093, |
| 0.717048503611971, |
| 0.37722050223598214, |
| 0.5263811489508082, |
| 0.32489164086687305, |
| 0.30850017199862395, |
| 0.46226694186446515, |
| 0.47642242862057105, |
| 0.4711902304781562, |
| 0.47744410044719643, |
| 0.26302029583763326, |
| 0.31844857241142066, |
| 0.322562779497764, |
| 0.4896216030271757, |
| 0.3636050911592707, |
| 0.48232542139662876, |
| 0.41593739250086, |
| 0.48355005159958714, |
| 0.371358789129687, |
| 0.3779944960440317, |
| 0.35086687306501546, |
| 0.3551461988304093, |
| 0.33851737186102504, |
| 0.4288407292741657, |
| 0.4549088407292741, |
| 0.6036085311317507, |
| 0.36626762985896116 |
| ], |
| "n_seeds": 20 |
| }, |
| "ranksvm_rbf": { |
| "observed": 0.8090127278981768, |
| "paper_table2": 0.81, |
| "n_perm": 200, |
| "null_mean": 0.4777601135190918, |
| "null_std": 0.08426877571855242, |
| "null_p50": 0.47153250773993793, |
| "null_p95": 0.6228871689026488, |
| "null_p99": 0.6716897832817331, |
| "null_max": 0.7454351565187479, |
| "n_null_ge_observed": 0, |
| "p_empirical": 0.004975124378109453, |
| "null_values": [ |
| 0.4977915376676987, |
| 0.5064671482628138, |
| 0.5038734090127279, |
| 0.5228723770209838, |
| 0.3698692810457516, |
| 0.5588957688338493, |
| 0.5486893704850361, |
| 0.5714447884416926, |
| 0.406938424492604, |
| 0.49023391812865497, |
| 0.5224595803233574, |
| 0.49324389404884766, |
| 0.4331888544891641, |
| 0.4414344685242518, |
| 0.5097592019263846, |
| 0.40513243894048845, |
| 0.43705538355693163, |
| 0.6227450980392157, |
| 0.3944444444444445, |
| 0.3776814585483316, |
| 0.47302373581011353, |
| 0.3454489164086687, |
| 0.39090471276229793, |
| 0.4767079463364293, |
| 0.4442380460956312, |
| 0.3850739594083247, |
| 0.5401203990368078, |
| 0.5008634330925353, |
| 0.5543653250773994, |
| 0.5099724802201582, |
| 0.3946611627106983, |
| 0.34435500515995876, |
| 0.4754351565187478, |
| 0.46965256277949774, |
| 0.5614791881664947, |
| 0.439735122119023, |
| 0.5256243550051599, |
| 0.6543928448572411, |
| 0.5211764705882354, |
| 0.5676298589611283, |
| 0.4712280701754385, |
| 0.6110801513587891, |
| 0.5500997592019263, |
| 0.5661162710698314, |
| 0.5025386996904025, |
| 0.3430581355349157, |
| 0.4772686618507052, |
| 0.39568627450980387, |
| 0.32027519779841757, |
| 0.43991400068799447, |
| 0.42293429652562775, |
| 0.4905882352941176, |
| 0.4426625386996904, |
| 0.5204231166150671, |
| 0.4015961472308221, |
| 0.33070175438596494, |
| 0.31937392500859996, |
| 0.45090127278981773, |
| 0.47871001031991745, |
| 0.427485380116959, |
| 0.4586480908152735, |
| 0.5463570691434467, |
| 0.3303405572755418, |
| 0.5534399724802201, |
| 0.4136016511867905, |
| 0.35414860681114546, |
| 0.4405882352941176, |
| 0.421609907120743, |
| 0.5427278981768147, |
| 0.45163398692810464, |
| 0.42480908152734775, |
| 0.44594771241830067, |
| 0.3972205022359821, |
| 0.6066907464740281, |
| 0.5635603715170279, |
| 0.4670932232542141, |
| 0.37176470588235294, |
| 0.5277571379428965, |
| 0.48632610939112475, |
| 0.4750464396284829, |
| 0.39171998624011006, |
| 0.5212521499828001, |
| 0.4330099759201926, |
| 0.43634330925352593, |
| 0.562373581011352, |
| 0.5263054695562436, |
| 0.4374750601995185, |
| 0.4289095287237702, |
| 0.6438837289301687, |
| 0.414936360509116, |
| 0.49121431028551765, |
| 0.6710079119367045, |
| 0.4707843137254903, |
| 0.4120295837633298, |
| 0.5677880976952184, |
| 0.5017681458548332, |
| 0.5119573443412453, |
| 0.3959408324733403, |
| 0.364172686618507, |
| 0.43316133470932233, |
| 0.5706123151014793, |
| 0.4045923632610939, |
| 0.5586240110079119, |
| 0.40865497076023394, |
| 0.4291228070175438, |
| 0.4143102855177158, |
| 0.5201272789817682, |
| 0.304265565875473, |
| 0.6307636738906088, |
| 0.33686274509803926, |
| 0.4756037151702787, |
| 0.5109528723770209, |
| 0.4950601995184038, |
| 0.4366804265565876, |
| 0.4297764017887856, |
| 0.4906295149638803, |
| 0.5664189886480908, |
| 0.27973512211902307, |
| 0.428015135878913, |
| 0.4136326109391126, |
| 0.48835225318197456, |
| 0.5342621259029928, |
| 0.3820433436532508, |
| 0.3707120743034055, |
| 0.31629170966632264, |
| 0.5482387340901274, |
| 0.45135190918472656, |
| 0.4718369453044374, |
| 0.5782008943928448, |
| 0.6095803233574131, |
| 0.3910216718266254, |
| 0.4553560371517028, |
| 0.43727210182318543, |
| 0.4321534227726178, |
| 0.40192294461644307, |
| 0.669201926384589, |
| 0.45802201582387336, |
| 0.5769521843825249, |
| 0.5734227726178192, |
| 0.6284520123839009, |
| 0.44639834881320956, |
| 0.5270622635018919, |
| 0.5320261437908496, |
| 0.6381320949432405, |
| 0.5393257653938769, |
| 0.4116477468180254, |
| 0.389889920880633, |
| 0.5698761609907121, |
| 0.3743928448572411, |
| 0.4981664946680426, |
| 0.3499346405228758, |
| 0.38341933264533884, |
| 0.44077399380804955, |
| 0.483219814241486, |
| 0.41268317853457176, |
| 0.5442002063983489, |
| 0.4501341589267286, |
| 0.48131406948744404, |
| 0.5579084967320262, |
| 0.4082696938424493, |
| 0.4542414860681115, |
| 0.5807705538355694, |
| 0.5673305813553491, |
| 0.4686687306501548, |
| 0.7454351565187479, |
| 0.5178224974200206, |
| 0.32205366357069143, |
| 0.42065703474372207, |
| 0.3575644994840041, |
| 0.49746474028207777, |
| 0.5724699002407981, |
| 0.5564740282077743, |
| 0.43175782593739254, |
| 0.4520433436532508, |
| 0.7391950464396284, |
| 0.4386446508427932, |
| 0.5880701754385964, |
| 0.48758169934640516, |
| 0.4441898864809081, |
| 0.5828173374613004, |
| 0.6174613003095974, |
| 0.5034021327829377, |
| 0.5180426556587547, |
| 0.3640075679394565, |
| 0.4637736498108015, |
| 0.39076023391812864, |
| 0.5812280701754385, |
| 0.4530271757825937, |
| 0.4711351909184726, |
| 0.5244754041967664, |
| 0.5303336773305813, |
| 0.45501203990368067, |
| 0.46684554523563804, |
| 0.5605400756793946, |
| 0.40650154798761606, |
| 0.49425868593051253, |
| 0.559580323357413, |
| 0.5344238046095631, |
| 0.6255865153078776, |
| 0.44144134846921224 |
| ], |
| "n_seeds": 20 |
| } |
| }, |
| "heldin": {} |
| } |
| } |
