File size: 67,942 Bytes
8b01133 | 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 228 229 230 231 232 233 234 235 236 237 238 239 240 241 242 243 244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 280 281 282 283 284 285 286 287 288 289 290 291 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300 301 302 303 304 305 306 307 308 309 310 311 312 313 314 315 316 317 318 319 320 321 322 323 324 325 326 327 328 329 330 331 332 333 334 335 336 337 338 339 340 341 342 343 344 345 346 347 348 349 350 351 352 353 354 355 356 357 358 359 360 361 362 363 364 365 366 367 368 369 370 371 372 373 374 375 376 377 378 379 380 381 382 383 384 385 386 387 388 389 390 391 392 393 394 395 396 397 398 399 400 401 402 403 404 405 406 407 408 409 410 411 412 413 414 415 416 417 418 419 420 421 422 423 424 425 426 427 428 429 430 431 432 433 434 435 436 437 438 439 440 441 442 443 444 445 446 447 448 449 450 451 452 453 454 455 456 457 458 459 460 461 462 463 464 465 466 467 468 469 470 471 472 473 474 475 476 477 478 479 480 481 482 483 484 485 486 487 488 489 490 491 492 493 494 495 496 497 498 499 500 501 502 503 504 505 506 507 508 509 510 511 512 513 514 515 516 517 518 519 520 521 522 | > π Storyteller: I'm working through the setup: nine players with a Baron in play, four outsiders (Saint, Butler, Recluse, Drunk), and townsfolk Washerwoman, Monk, Empath against evil Imp and Baron. I need to decide what the Drunk thinks they are, and I'm considering whether making them believe they're a Fortune Teller would require setting a red herring in the schema.
>
> Instead I settle on making the Drunk believe they're the Undertaker, since it gives ongoing false information each night and fits well since good is already weak with so many outsiders. For the bluffs given to the Imp, I go with Soldier, Chef, and Ravenkeeper, avoiding Undertaker since the drunk is already claiming that role.
>
>
Setup:
1. Alex: Washerwoman (good)
2. Blair: Imp (evil)
3. Casey: Monk (good)
4. Drew: Baron (evil)
5. Ellis: Saint (good)
6. Frankie: Butler (good)
7. Gray: Recluse (good)
8. Harper: Empath (good)
9. Indigo: Drunk (good) [thinks they are the Undertaker]
Demon bluffs: Soldier, Chef, Ravenkeeper
You are Alex. The players, clockwise: Alex, Blair, Casey, Drew, Ellis, Frankie, Gray, Harper, Indigo (and back to Alex). You sit between Indigo and Blair.
Your character: Washerwoman (Townsfolk, good team): You start knowing that 1 of 2 players is a particular Townsfolk.
You are Blair. The players, clockwise: Alex, Blair, Casey, Drew, Ellis, Frankie, Gray, Harper, Indigo (and back to Alex). You sit between Alex and Casey.
Your character: Imp (Demon, evil team): Each night*, choose a player: they die. If you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
Your Minion: Drew (you do not know which Minion character). Three good characters not in play, safe for evil to bluff: Soldier, Chef, Ravenkeeper.
You are Casey. The players, clockwise: Alex, Blair, Casey, Drew, Ellis, Frankie, Gray, Harper, Indigo (and back to Alex). You sit between Blair and Drew.
Your character: Monk (Townsfolk, good team): Each night*, choose a player (not yourself): they are safe from the Demon tonight.
You are Drew. The players, clockwise: Alex, Blair, Casey, Drew, Ellis, Frankie, Gray, Harper, Indigo (and back to Alex). You sit between Casey and Ellis.
Your character: Baron (Minion, evil team): There are extra Outsiders in play. [+2 Outsiders]
The Demon is Blair.
You are Ellis. The players, clockwise: Alex, Blair, Casey, Drew, Ellis, Frankie, Gray, Harper, Indigo (and back to Alex). You sit between Drew and Frankie.
Your character: Saint (Outsider, good team): If you die by execution, your team loses.
You are Frankie. The players, clockwise: Alex, Blair, Casey, Drew, Ellis, Frankie, Gray, Harper, Indigo (and back to Alex). You sit between Ellis and Gray.
Your character: Butler (Outsider, good team): Each night, choose a player (not yourself): tomorrow, you may only vote if they are voting too.
You are Gray. The players, clockwise: Alex, Blair, Casey, Drew, Ellis, Frankie, Gray, Harper, Indigo (and back to Alex). You sit between Frankie and Harper.
Your character: Recluse (Outsider, good team): You might register as evil & as a Minion or Demon, even if dead.
You are Harper. The players, clockwise: Alex, Blair, Casey, Drew, Ellis, Frankie, Gray, Harper, Indigo (and back to Alex). You sit between Gray and Indigo.
Your character: Empath (Townsfolk, good team): Each night, you learn how many of your 2 alive neighbours are evil.
You are Indigo. The players, clockwise: Alex, Blair, Casey, Drew, Ellis, Frankie, Gray, Harper, Indigo (and back to Alex). You sit between Harper and Alex.
Your character: Undertaker (Townsfolk, good team): Each night*, you learn which character died by execution today.
β Night 1 β
[night] Frankie (Butler) chose Gray
> π Storyteller: I'm weighing which Washerwoman pairing to use β Casey with Blair as Monk gives the Imp a plausible cover claim, while pairing Harper with Drew as Empath could point suspicion toward Drew as Baron. Blair claiming Monk seems like the more useful misdirection.
>
> For the Empath drop, since good's setup is weak (Baron plus four outsiders), registering a 0 is safer β a 1 could make players suspect Recluse framing and unfairly target other good players like Gray or Indigo.
>
>
[storyteller] Washerwoman:Alex β {'players': ['Casey', 'Blair'], 'character': 'Monk'}
[storyteller] Empath:Harper β {'number': 0}
Night 1 β Washerwoman: You learn that either Casey or Blair is the Monk.
Night 1 β Empath: You learn that 0 of your living neighbours are evil.
Information given on night 1:
Washerwoman (Alex): You learn that either Casey or Blair is the Monk.
Empath (Harper): You learn that 0 of your living neighbours are evil.
β Day 1 β
A grey mist lifts from the village green, and every door opens to a living face. Enjoy it while it lasts. Nobody died in the night.
β Day 1 Β· beat 1 β
> π Harper: As Empath, I'm reading 0 evil neighbours, meaning Gray and Indigo are likely good unless something's off with drunkenness or registration. I'm weighing whether to claim publicly or quietly whisper this info to my neighbors to build trust without fully exposing myself to the demon this early.
>
>
> π Gray: I'm the Recluse, thinking about whether to claim openly early on. Claiming early as an Outsider who might ping as evil makes sense since it explains away any info pointing my way, and evil could bluff the same claim anyway. I'll keep it brief and mention it quietly to my neighbors.
>
>
> π Ellis: As the Saint, I'm weighing whether to claim publicly β risky since revealing early invites targeting, though the demon might actually prefer keeping me alive to engineer an execution. I'm leaning toward a quieter approach, maybe whispering my role to a couple trusted players like Drew and Frankie rather than announcing it to the whole town.
>
>
Harper: Morning all. Let's get claims flowing early today; quiet players make the Imp's life easy. I've got something useful and will share more once I see who's talking.
Gray: Morning all. Quick heads-up so nobody wastes time: I'm the Recluse, so if your info pings me as evil or Minion or Demon, that's probably why. Info roles, please share what you got.
Ellis: Morning all. No deaths, so let's make it count β anyone with first-night info (Washerwoman, Librarian, Investigator, Chef), I'd love to hear it early, even if you just share it in whispers first.
[whisper] Harper β Gray, Indigo: I'm the Empath. Got a 0 last night, so you two both read good to me. Let's trust each other. What are you both?
[whisper] Gray β Frankie, Harper: Hey neighbours, I'm Recluse, genuinely. What are you two? If either of you is Empath or Chef, I may throw your number off.
> π Indigo: Harper's Empath claim of 0 checks out with me and Gray as neighbors, so that's consistent. Gray's Recluse claim could register as evil but doesn't conflict with the 0. As Undertaker, I have no information yet on night one, so I'm considering whether to share my role with Harper and Gray now β probably worth a brief, modest mention to the town.
>
>
> π Alex: As Washerwoman, I know either Casey or Blair is the Monk, but revealing that outright would help the Imp target them. I think I should mention publicly that I have a Townsfolk ping on two players, then confirm the details privately with Blair and Casey through whispers.
>
>
> π Drew: I'm the Baron with Blair as Imp, and there are four Outsiders against three Townsfolk, so I need a solid bluff to claim. Claiming an Outsider seems risky since too many Outsiders showing up could point back to me, so leaning toward a Townsfolk claim feels safer, and I should coordinate quietly with Blair on bluffs.
>
>
Alex: Morning. I've got first-night info pointing at a Townsfolk between two players. I'll verify it privately before going public so I don't paint a target on anyone.
Indigo: Morning. No first-night info from me, but I'll be useful after an execution, so let's make sure we actually execute someone today.
Drew: Morning. Happy to share, but I'd rather trade in whispers first than dump everything publicly on day one.
[whisper] Alex β Blair, Casey: I'm the Washerwoman. My info says one of you two is the Monk. Which of you is it? Let's keep it quiet for now so the Imp doesn't go for the Monk.
[whisper] Indigo β Harper, Gray: I'm the Undertaker, so no info yet. Harper, your 0 lines up since I'm good. Gray, a Recluse claim fits too. Let's keep each other posted.
[whisper] Drew β Blair: Hey partner, Baron here, so there are 4 Outsiders in play and 3 Townsfolk. What are your 3 bluffs? Give me one and keep one for yourself. I'll avoid claiming Outsider so we don't tip off a Baron count.
> π Frankie: I'm Butler, serving Gray, who claims Recluse β that fits the two-outsider pattern with me. Indigo's claim points to Undertaker. I'll share my Butler identity quietly with Gray since it's low-value info for evil to exploit, but otherwise stay low-key.
>
>
> π Casey: Alex's claim checks out on my end, which suggests Alex is likely a genuine Washerwoman, though a Spy could fake this. I'll be careful about whispering confirmation β telling only Alex privately makes sense, since including Blair risks outing myself if Blair turns out evil.
>
>
> π Blair: I'm Imp, Drew is Baron, with 3 Townsfolk and 4 Outsiders, and my bluffs are Soldier, Chef, Ravenkeeper. Alex's Washerwoman claim suggests Casey is Monk if Alex is truthful, though Alex could be Drunk, and Gray's Recluse claim fits with Baron adding a fourth outsider.
>
> I'm considering Indigo as a possible Undertaker, giving three Townsfolk roles floating around (Washerwoman/Alex, Monk/Casey, Undertaker/Indigo), though Harper's info is still unclear. Rather than contest Casey by claiming Monk myself, I think it's safer to claim Chef privately to Alex β since Blair, Casey, and Drew aren't adjacent to me in a way that creates evil pairs, a Chef count of 0 should hold up truthfully unless Recluse interferes. I'll give Drew a bluff like Soldier or Ravenkeeper to use, keep Chef for myself since it's both plausible and true, and hold off on any public statement about killing Casey later β better to handle it through whispers.
>
>
Blair: Morning. I've got something small but solid from last night; I'll share it once a few more people have put their cards down.
Casey: Morning. I'm good and have a night ability; I'll keep it quiet for now. Indigo, noted on wanting an execution today.
Frankie: Morning. I'm happy to trade in whispers too. Indigo, sounds like Undertaker β so yes, let's get a real execution in today.
[whisper] Blair β Alex: Not me. I'm the Chef, and I got a 0, so no evil players are sitting next to each other. That makes Casey your Monk. Keep it quiet so they don't get hit.
[whisper] Blair β Drew: Bluffs: Soldier, Chef, Ravenkeeper. I'm taking Chef (0 pairs, which is actually true since we're not adjacent). You take Soldier, or Ravenkeeper if you'd rather. Alex claims Washerwoman and says Casey or me is the Monk, so Casey is the Monk. Gray claims Recluse, Indigo sounds like Undertaker. I'm thinking of hitting Casey tonight.
[whisper] Casey β Alex: It's me, I'm the Monk. Keep it between us. That confirms your info, so I trust you more. Who do you want me to protect tonight? I'm leaning toward keeping you or another confirmed info role alive.
[whisper] Frankie β Gray, Harper: I'm the Butler, genuinely. Gray, I picked you as my master last night, so I'll only vote when you do. With you as Recluse that would make both Outsiders accounted for, unless there's a Baron. Harper, what's your useful info?
β Day 1 Β· beat 2 β
> π Indigo: I suspect Alex is the Washerwoman, and since Alex is my neighbor, whispering to them could get useful info. Frankie already publicly guessed Undertaker, which seems fine to leave as is.
>
>
> π Casey: I'm wondering if Blair also whispered a claim on Monk, which would make Blair suspicious as evil or drunk. I'm considering whether to trade info with Drew as a neighbor, ask Harper what they know, or whisper Alex to find out what Blair actually said.
>
>
> π Drew: I'm weighing whether to claim Soldier or Ravenkeeper β Soldier fits well since the Imp wouldn't target me anyway, making my survival explainable. I'm also considering Alex's claim that Blair or Casey is the Monk, wondering if Blair would counter by claiming Chef instead.
>
> I think I'll whisper Blair to say I'm taking Soldier, and maybe whisper Ellis too to build some trust with a neighbor.
>
>
Indigo: Lots of people saying 'later.' Let's aim for real claims by beat 4 so we have time to pick a nominee.
Casey: Harper, you said you've got something useful. Care to share it with the town or in whispers? Gray's Recluse claim makes any info touching him worth hearing.
[whisper] Indigo β Alex: Neighbor here. Sounds like you're Washerwoman? Who are your two and which Townsfolk? I'm Undertaker, happy to help confirm whoever it is.
[whisper] Casey β Alex: Blair whispered you too. Did Blair also claim Monk? If so, one of us is lying, and it isn't me.
[whisper] Casey β Drew: Hey neighbour, I'm good with a night-protect style ability. What have you got? Happy to trade.
[whisper] Drew β Blair: Taking Soldier. Fits nicely since you'll never kill me anyway. Hitting Casey tonight is good, but a Monk might protect themselves... actually they can't, so go for it. Note that with 4 Outsiders, likely Drunk, Saint and Butler are all in besides Gray. Watch out for a Saint before we push anyone.
[whisper] Drew β Ellis: Neighbour chat: I'm the Soldier, so I'm no use as a kill target and I'm happy to be a safe vote. What are you? And have you heard any Outsider claims besides Gray?
> π Frankie: I should stay mostly quiet, maybe whisper to Ellis, my neighbor, to gather info since they asked about roles. I'll share that I'm the Butler.
>
>
> π Harper: Gray's claim on Recluse checks out with my zero, since Recluse could register either way, and Indigo's Undertaker claim seems fine too. Frankie isn't my neighbor and is claiming Butler, so with Gray on Recluse that's two outsiders accounted for, which seems consistent. I'm weighing whether to reveal as Empath publicly β it's valuable info but risky if I get targeted night one, and I'd rather keep gathering nightly information quietly.
>
> Casey's pushing me though, so maybe I hint at my info without naming my role, or share privately with Frankie instead. I think I'll respond to Frankie and tell the town I'll reveal fully by beat 4, as Indigo suggested.
>
>
> π Alex: Blair claims Chef with a 0-ping, Casey claims Monk, and these seem consistent with each other, so I'm leaning toward Casey actually being the Monk. I need to figure out how to respond to Casey about Blair's claim while deciding whether to reveal my own Washerwoman info to Indigo, who's claiming Undertaker β maybe I can hint at my ping being between Blair and Casey without fully revealing the Monk detail.
>
> Since my Washerwoman is already spent, I'm thinking about who Casey (as Monk) should protect instead β probably not me, but Indigo since they have ongoing Undertaker info, or whoever ends up claiming Empath or Fortune Teller.
>
>
Alex: My info checked out privately β both players in my pair gave consistent answers. Harper, you opened strong; what have you got?
Harper: Casey, fair. Short version: my info points good on Gray and Indigo. I'll give the full claim by beat 4 like Indigo suggested. Meanwhile Alex, Blair, Drew: lots of whispering between you three. What's the actual info?
[whisper] Alex β Casey: No, Blair claimed Chef with a 0, so your stories fit. Don't waste protection on me, my info is spent. Protect whoever has ongoing info β Indigo claims Undertaker, or an Empath/FT if one shows.
[whisper] Alex β Indigo: Yes, Washerwoman. My pair is confirmed consistent and I'd rather not expose the Townsfolk yet since it's a juicy target. Happy to tell you tomorrow. Who do you like for today's execution?
[whisper] Frankie β Ellis: Hey neighbour. I'm the Butler β no info, but I'll be honest about my votes. What are you? If you're Empath, note Gray (my other side) claims Recluse, so he could skew things.
[whisper] Harper β Frankie: I'm the Empath. Got 0 on Gray and Indigo last night, so Gray's Recluse claim holds up (he didn't ping). Your Butler claim + Gray Recluse makes 2 Outsiders, fine unless Baron. Who are you suspicious of?
> π Gray: Harper's empath got 0, with neighbors Gray and Indigo β so I'm registering as good despite being Recluse. Frankie Butler claims me as master, making us the two outsiders, while Alex, Blair, Casey, and Drew are clustered whispering together. I'm planning to nudge that cluster to share info publicly, quietly confirm things with Frankie, and check in with Harper and Indigo privately.
>
>
> π Blair: Harper's clue points toward Gray and Indigo, suggesting Harper might be the Fortune Teller. With Alex claiming WW, Casey Monk, Indigo Undertaker, and Harper FT, plus myself as Chef and Drew as Soldier, that's too many claimed townsfolk for only 3 real onesβmeaning some must be the Drunk, which works in our favor by adding confusion.
>
> I'll go public as Chef with 0, since it's harmless and mostly true.
>
>
> π Ellis: Three outsiders claimed so far, which points to either Baron in play or someone lying about their role β worth flagging to neighbors. Claiming Saint openly should protect me if I share it carefully, so I'm deciding whether to whisper my role to Frankie and Drew despite the risk that an evil player could use it against me.
>
>
Gray: For what it's worth, Frankie tells me he's the Butler with me as master, so Outsiders look accounted for at two unless there's a Baron. Alex, Blair, Drew, Casey: you've traded a lot of whispers, time to put claims on the table.
Ellis: Harper, 'points good on Gray and Indigo' sounds like Empath-ish or Washerwoman info β which is it? Also, I'm tallying Outsider claims; if we end up with more than 2, that's a Baron flag or someone's lying.
Blair: Fair ask, Harper. I'm the Chef and I got a 0, so no two evil players are sitting next to each other. Handy for ruling out neighbour pairs, and Gray's Recluse ping could skew it. Harper, is yours a Fortune Teller read?
[whisper] Gray β Harper, Indigo: Thanks both. Frankie claims Butler to me (me as master). Harper, what's your read on the Alex/Blair/Casey/Drew whisper circle? One of them is probably evil fishing for claims.
[whisper] Gray β Frankie: Got it, I'll vote deliberately so you can follow. Who have you heard from Ellis?
[whisper] Ellis β Drew, Frankie: Honest neighbour answer: I'm the Saint. So please don't let anyone rush me to the block. Note: Gray Recluse + Frankie Butler + me Saint = 3 Outsiders. That's either Baron in play or someone's bluffing an Outsider. Keep it quiet for now.
β Day 1 Β· beat 3 β
> π Casey: I probably shouldn't claim publicly since Monk is better hidden, but there's pressure to say something. I could hint that I'm paired with Blair without naming my role, or just stay quiet since Drew hasn't answered yetβmaybe I'll say something light instead.
>
>
> π Alex: I'm weighing whether to publicly claim Washerwoman without naming the Monk. Harper's read on Gray and Indigo seems fine, but Drew still hasn't claimed anything, so I should push for that next.
>
>
> π Frankie: I'm working through the claims: Harper's Empath count fits with Gray and Indigo neighboring, Ellis's Saint claim with 3 outsiders suggests Baron is possible or someone's lying, and I know I'm truly Butler. With Gray as Recluse and Ellis as Saint, Baron would push outsiders to 4, but Chef's 0 rules out adjacent evil β I'm weighing whether to reveal Ellis's claim to Gray despite being told to stay quiet.
>
> I'm considering whispering to Gray and Harper about Ellis's Saint claim as a possible bluff flag, since a Saint claim is a classic evil tactic to deter execution β Harper's Gray-0 reading actually supports Gray being good, so I'll keep this information private rather than announcing it publicly.
>
>
Frankie: Blair's Chef 0 is useful β nobody adjacent is a pair. Let's hear from Casey, Drew and Alex properly before nominations.
Casey: For the record, Alex's Washerwoman ping lands on me and it's correct. I'll keep the exact role quiet since it's more useful unknown to the Imp. Drew, you're the one who hasn't said anything concrete yet.
Alex: Fair, Harper. I'm the Washerwoman; my Townsfolk ping checked out with both people in the pair, and I'm holding the names because it's a protective role. Drew, you're the one who hasn't put anything down yet β what are you?
[whisper] Frankie β Gray, Harper: Heads-up, keep it quiet: Ellis told me and Drew he's the Saint. That's a 3rd Outsider claim with Gray and me. Either Baron's in play (4 Outsiders, only 3 Townsfolk) or someone's bluffing. Saint is a juicy evil bluff since it scares off executions. Worth watching.
> π Harper: Ellis wants me to claim Empath publicly, so I'll do that. It's odd that Drew hasn't claimed anything while three outsiders have made private claims to Ellis Saint β I should push Drew to declare.
>
>
> π Gray: Counting up the claims, I've got five townsfolk roles claimed (Alex, Blair, Harper, Indigo, Casey) plus three outsiders, which feels like too many people for a Baron setup β without a Baron, that outsider count points toward the Imp being in play among the unclaimed.
>
> With Chef reading 0 for adjacent evil pairs, the evil team isn't sitting next to each other. That points suspicion toward Drew as the unknown quantity β I'll push to nominate them and keep my Saint claim private for now.
>
>
> π Drew: Ellis being Saint is huge for evil since getting Saint executed wins the game outright, but I've already told Ellis and Frankie, so pushing this too hard could look suspicious β I need to find a way to get Ellis executed without seeming responsible for it, perhaps by staying quiet and letting others grow suspicious naturally. I'm also mapping out the outsiders: Gray Recluse, Frankie Butler, Ellis Saint, and the Drunk alongside the Baron.
>
> Counting townsfolk claims so far β Alex as Washerwoman maybe, Casey Monk, Harper unclear, Indigo Undertaker β that's already four-plus claims, meaning one of them has to be the Drunk, and Frankie's whisper to Ellis was likely a Butler claim. For now, my move is to publicly claim Soldier, quietly tell Blair that Ellis is the Saint, and hold off on revealing anything further until I can hint at Ellis's suspicious behavior later.
>
>
Gray: Drew, you're the last one without anything on the table. What's your character?
Harper: Fine, cards down: I'm the Empath, got a 0, so Gray and Indigo both read good. That also means Gray didn't ping as evil. Drew, you're the last big blank. What are you?
Drew: Fine, cards down: I'm the Soldier. Demon can't touch me at night, so I'm a safe pair of hands for votes and I'll stick around. Harper, your 'points good on Gray and Indigo' read still needs a role attached.
[whisper] Gray β Frankie, Harper: Tally: Townsfolk claims Alex WW, Blair Chef, Harper Empath, Indigo Undertaker, Casey 'protective'. That's 5 + Frankie, me, Ellis-Saint = 8 before Drew. With 3 Outsiders we'd need a Baron and only 3 Townsfolk, so at least two of those TF claims would be lies. More likely Ellis or someone is bluffing. Let's see Drew's claim first.
[whisper] Harper β Frankie, Gray: Thanks Frankie. 3 Outsider claims (Gray, you, Ellis) is a flag. If Baron's real, only 3 Townsfolk exist, and we've already got Alex Washer, Blair Chef, Indigo Undertaker, me Empath, Casey 'townsfolk'. That's too many, so likely someone's lying. Ellis-as-Saint bluff is my top suspicion, but careful executing a real Saint.
[whisper] Drew β Blair: Big one: Ellis told me (and Frankie) he's the Saint. If we can get Ellis executed, we win outright. Don't kill Ellis. Outsiders so far: Gray Recluse, Frankie Butler, Ellis Saint, so the 4th is a Drunk hiding in a Townsfolk claim. Town will smell Baron soon. Maybe we quietly seed doubt on Ellis being a bluffer without me leading it.
> π Indigo: So far I've got Harper as Empath, Gray as Recluse, Frankie as Butler, Alex as Washerwoman pointing to Casey, Casey's role unclear, Blair a Chef with 0, Drew as Soldier, and myself as Undertaker β Ellis hasn't claimed anything yet. The Chef's 0 tells me there's no adjacent evil pair, and Harper's Empath 0 suggests Gray and I read good, though Harper could be evil and lying about that. I'm turning my attention to Ellis now.
>
>
> π Ellis: I'm tallying the claims: Washerwoman, Chef, Casey, Soldier, Empath, and Undertaker give six townsfolk claims, which with three outsiders would need to fit the expected script distribution.
>
> Something doesn't add up unless there's a Baron, a Drunk hiding among the townsfolk claimers, or one of Gray/Frankie is lying about being an outsider. Harper's Empath reading and Frankie's Butler-on-Gray claim make Gray suspicious enough that I'm weighing whether going public with my Saint claim is worth the exposure risk, since it would force scrutiny on the outsider count and help town narrow down the liar.
>
>
> π Blair: I'm laying out everyone's claims - Alex as WW, Casey likely Monk, Harper as Empath naming Gray and Indigo as neighbors, Indigo as Undertaker, myself as Chef, Drew as Soldier, Gray as Recluse, Frankie as Butler, and Ellis keeping their Saint claim private. Since some of these townsfolk claims must be fake with a Drunk mixed in, I need to figure out which three are actually true.
>
> If Ellis's Saint claim goes public, that pushes the outsider count to a level that risks Baron suspicion and scrutiny toward finding a fourth outsider plus fake townsfolk claims β which would put me and Drew, the extras, in danger. I'm weighing whether to push Ellis toward claiming publicly since that could backfire against us, so I'm leaning toward staying quiet on Ellis this round rather than forcing an execution target.
>
> Better targets: Gray's Recluse claim is a promising execution since evil often bluffs Recluse, though Harper's Empath reading (which showed Gray as good) complicates that β unless Harper is actually the Drunk. For the night kill, I'm ruling out my neighbors Alex and Casey as safe since no Empath sits near me, and I'm leaning toward killing Casey since a Monk claim would let them protect others. I'll whisper to Drew to hold back and let the town nominate naturally, possibly steering things toward Gray.
>
> Publicly, I'll stay quiet and just nudge things gently toward executing someone with no solid information.
>
>
Ellis: Cards down from me too: I'm the Saint β please don't execute me. That makes three Outsider claims (Gray Recluse, Frankie Butler, me). Without a Baron, one of Gray or Frankie is lying, and with six Townsfolk claims, one of those is too. Gray, Frankie β convince us.
Indigo: Ellis is actually the last blank now: you've asked everyone else for info but haven't given us a role. What are you? And Drew, Soldier is a classic safe bluff; anyone able to back that?
Blair: Claims are mostly down now. The one thing I'd still like is Ellis and Indigo saying what they actually are rather than hinting. Then let's pick someone.
[whisper] Blair β Drew: Nice. If Ellis goes public as Saint, the town counts 3 Outsiders and starts smelling Baron. Then they'll hunt for spare Townsfolk claims, and that's us. So let Ellis stay quiet if we can. For today's vote I'd lean toward Gray: a 'Recluse' claim is easy to paint as an evil cover, and Harper could be the Drunk. If Ellis ever gets nominated by someone else, we both vote yes and act like it's reasonable.
β Day 1 Β· beat 4 β
> π Ellis: Since these posted at the same time, I should keep my reply brief and maybe just ask Indigo to confirm the Undertaker point rather than re-explain what's already been said.
>
>
> π Indigo: Counting up claims: 6 townsfolk claims, 3 outsider claims for 9 total, but the normal setup expects 5 townsfolk and 2 outsiders alongside a minion and an imp. That means two of these claims must belong to evil players, and with a Baron in play that discrepancy could actually be expected.
>
> Assuming no Baron and no Drunk, exactly one liar must be hiding among the outsider claimants and one among the townsfolk claimants. Since Harper vouches for Gray and for me being good, that pushes the outsider lie toward Frankie or Ellis, and since Chef read zero, evil pairs aren't adjacent -- but Frankie and Ellis being neighbors doesn't rule that out since only one of them would need to be evil. I should go ahead and confirm my Undertaker claim publicly since Frankie already guessed it.
>
>
> π Drew: Counting up the claims, I've got six townsfolk roles claimed plus three outsiders, and if Baron is in play that means three townsfolk plus a drunk somewhere among them, with Imp and Baron both bluffingβwhich makes the math dangerous for us to navigate.
>
> Better to steer suspicion away from a Baron read entirely, pointing instead toward Gray or Frankie possibly lying. Harper's Empath reading of zero on Gray and Indigo suggests Gray is likely genuine, so Frankie's unverified Butler claim looks like the safer target to push the town toward executing.
>
>
Ellis: Indigo, Blair β I just did: Saint. Indigo, your turn to say it plainly: Undertaker? And Gray/Frankie, one of your Outsider claims doesn't fit unless there's a Baron.
Drew: Before anyone jumps to 'Baron', the simpler read is one fake Outsider. Harper's 0 clears Gray, so Frankie's Butler claim is the unbacked one, and Butler is an easy thing to fake. Frankie, who's your master tonight and why Gray?
Indigo: Yes, I'm the Undertaker, said it plainly. Math: 6 Townsfolk claims, 3 Outsider claims, so without a Baron there's one liar in each group. If Harper's 0 is true, Gray's clean, so the Outsider liar is Frankie or Ellis. Frankie, I'd lean your way over a Saint claim.
[whisper] Drew β Blair: Harper's 0 clears Gray in town's eyes, so Gray is a tough sell. I'm steering toward Frankie as the 'fake Outsider'. Easier than Gray and keeps the Baron theory off us. Back me if it lands, and be ready to jump on any Ellis nomination.
> π Frankie: I'm laying out the nine claimed roles and checking the math: with 6 townsfolk and 3 outsider claims against a likely 2-evil setup, at least one townsfolk claim and possibly an outsider claim must be false, though a Baron variant with 3 townsfolk/4 outsiders is also worth considering.
>
> Chef reads 0, meaning no two evils sit adjacent, so pairing Gray and Ellis as both evil could still work since I sit between them. Harper's Empath reading of 0 on Gray and Indigo suggests Gray is likely good, pointing toward Ellis being the liar in the no-Baron scenario.
>
> I should defend myself as the real Butler tied to Gray, using my voting behavior as proof, and push suspicion onto Ellis β though executing a real Saint would be catastrophic, so I need to voice caution alongside my accusation.
>
>
> π Casey: Let me tally the claims: Alex, Blair, Drew, Harper, and Indigo are all claiming townsfolk roles, plus myself as WW-confirmed townsfolk, giving six townsfolk claims alongside three outsiders, totaling nine for the good team.
>
> Working through the possible liars, Alex confirming my Monk role accurately makes evil-Alex-as-Spy unlikely, so I lean toward trusting Alex. Harper's Empath check clearing Gray and Indigo, combined with Blair's Chef info being unconfirmed, points me toward suspecting either Frankie or Ellis among the outsider claims as the possible liar, while worrying that executing the Saint would be a disaster if I guess wrong. Drew's frequent whispering with Blair also strikes me as worth watching.
>
> Comparing candidates, executing Ellis feels too risky given the Saint possibility, so I'm weighing Frankie versus Drew β losing a real Butler in Frankie costs less than misreading Drew's Soldier claim, which is a classic Imp bluff. I'm leaning toward nominating Frankie since it gives useful information without excessive risk.
>
>
> π Gray: Counting the six townsfolk claims and three outsider claims among us gives nine total, but the normal setup only allows five townsfolk and two outsiders alongside a minion and imp β so at least one townsfolk claim and one outsider claim must be evil, assuming there's no Baron in play.
>
> Chef claiming zero means no adjacent evil pair, which puts pressure on the Frankie-Ellis seating and my own possible Recluse registration. I'm weighing whether Frankie or Ellis is the evil outsider, and testing the adjacency logic against Drew and Harper's claims β if Ellis is evil, Drew's neighboring position would have to be honest. Ellis's private Saint claim to Frankie and Drew also stands out as a classic evil bluff to dodge execution, making me suspect Ellis could be the Imp.
>
> Frankie's early, consistent Butler claim with me as master feels more trustworthy, though I still can't be fully sure. I'm considering Alex and Casey as a possible evil pair confirming each other despite not being adjacent, and thinking execution today should target an unverified claim β Drew's Soldier bluff stands out, especially given how hard Drew is pushing against Frankie. I want to watch the voting pattern closely, since Frankie's Butler claim is testable by whether he only votes when I do.
>
>
Casey: Agree with Indigo's math. Executing a claimed Saint is the one mistake we can't undo, so leave Ellis alone today. That puts Frankie as the Outsider liar if Harper's 0 holds. On the Townsfolk side, Drew's Soldier is the unbacked claim. I'd nominate Frankie today and let Indigo tell us what he was.
Gray: Frankie whispered me Butler-with-Gray-as-master in beat 1, before any pressure, so I lean believing him. Easy check: watch whether he ever votes without me. Drew, Soldier is unverifiable and you're pushing Frankie hard. Casey, what exactly is your 'protective' role?
Frankie: I'm the real Butler, master Gray β picked him because he's my neighbour and claimed early. Watch my votes: I only vote when Gray does. Harper's 0 clears Gray, so if there's no Baron the fake Outsider is Ellis, not me. And Ellis whispered Saint to me first β a Saint claim is exactly what a Minion hides behind.
[whisper] Gray β Frankie, Harper: If there's no Baron, it's one of Frankie/Ellis plus one TF claim. Frankie I believe. If Ellis is the fake, Chef 0 means Drew isn't evil (adjacent)... unless Blair is the liar. Drew+Blair whispering constantly bugs me. I'd lean nominating Drew over risking Ellis-Saint today.
[whisper] Frankie β Gray, Harper: I'm genuinely Butler, so from my seat: no Baron β Ellis is the fake Outsider (Harper cleared Gray). Chef 0 then clears Drew too (Ellis's other neighbour). Baron case = 3 real TF + a Drunk among the TF claims, possible but less likely. I'd lean executing Ellis unless someone has a better read. Gray, I'll follow your vote.
> π Blair: Frankie is pushing to execute Ellis as a fake Saint, but both are actually real outsiders β so either execution is fine for us, and Ellis dying is actually the win condition. I want to lean into Frankie's theory without seeming overly eager, since being too pushy about executing a "Saint" looks suspicious if Ellis really were one, though that scenario would end the game anyway.
>
> I'll frame it as "Frankie's Butler claim is verifiable through voting, Ellis's Saint claim isn't" to subtly tilt suspicion toward Ellis while looking independent from Drew, who's separately pushing the same target β that split makes us look uncoordinated, which is good. Now I'm counting votes: 9 alive, need 5 for execution, and Frankie's Butler ability only lets him vote if Gray votes, so getting Gray and others on board is going to be tough but worth attempting.
>
>
> π Alex: Tallying claims: Alex, Blair, Casey, Drew, Harper, and Indigo are claiming Townsfolk roles, while Ellis, Frankie, and Gray claim Outsider roles. That's 6 Townsfolk claims and 3 Outsider claims against a normal setup of 5 Townsfolk and 2 Outsiders, meaning there should be 2 evil players hiding among these claims.
>
> Since Chef 0 means no adjacent evil pairs, I'm checking adjacency: Ellis and Frankie sit next to each other, as do Drew and Ellis, so they can't both be evil under normal circumstances. Drew's Soldier claim feels unbacked and suspicious, and I'm considering whether one of the Townsfolk claimants is actually a drunk Outsider who believes they're good, which would shift how many outsider claims are lies.
>
> Casey's accusation that Drew lied about being TF seems like a reasonable read, pointing toward nominating either Frankie or Drew for execution. Frankie's proposed Butler-style behaviorβvoting only alongside Grayβcould easily be mimicked by an evil player too, so it doesn't clear him. I lean toward supporting a Frankie or Drew nomination while making sure no actual Saint gets executed.
>
>
> π Harper: I'm laying out the claims: Alex is Washerwoman, Blair Chef, Casey claims protective though Alex's ping suggests Casey's actually the Tinker's Fool or possibly Monk, Drew Soldier, Ellis Saint, Frankie Butler, Gray Recluse, Harper Empath, Indigo Undertaker. That gives six Townsfolk claims and three outsiders among the nine players, with no Baron in play.
>
> With the actual composition being five Townsfolk, two Outsiders, one Minion, one Imp, I need two liars among the claims. Gray and Indigo seem cleared through my reasoning, and I trust myself as good, so the fake Townsfolk claim likely sits among Alex, Blair, Casey, or Drew, while the fake Outsider claim is probably Ellis or Frankie. Blair's Chef reading zero adjacent evil pairs rules out certain neighboring combinations, and since Alex vouches for Casey as a real Townsfolk, that narrows suspicion further toward Alex, Blair, or Casey themselves if Ellis turns out evil.
>
> Working through if Frankie is evil instead, that would clear Ellis and Gray, leaving the liar among Alex, Blair, Casey, or Drew. I'm weighing the execution risk between Frankie and Drew β executing a real Saint would lose the game, but taking out Frankie as a possible Butler wouldn't, making that the safer target. If Drew turns out evil alongside a true Chef reading, that clears Ellis but implicates Frankie as the fake claim, though it seems odd that Drew would push so hard against his own teammate, so I'm leaning toward Ellis being the false claim with Drew staying good.
>
>
Harper: My take: my 0 stands, so the fake Outsider is Frankie or Ellis. Executing a real Saint loses us the game; executing a real Butler just costs a player, and Indigo tells us tomorrow which it was. That also resolves Ellis. So I'd put Frankie up today. Drew's Soldier is next on my list.
Blair: Ellis vs Frankie is the real question. Frankie's Butler can be checked right now: watch whether he votes without Gray. A Saint claim can never be checked, and a Minion would pick exactly that to stay alive. I'm not sold on either yet. Gray, do you trust Frankie's early whisper enough to vote with him?
Alex: Agree we don't touch Ellis today β a wrong Saint execution ends the game. Between Frankie and Drew, I lean Frankie: he's the one pointing at the Saint, which is exactly what evil would want. Happy to nominate him if no one has a better read.
[whisper] Harper β Gray: Honestly torn, but the asymmetry decides it for me: wrong on Ellis = we lose, wrong on Frankie = Indigo confirms Butler and Ellis is outed as fake. I'd vote Frankie today. If Frankie's real he'll understand.
[whisper] Blair β Drew: Frankie is pushing Ellis as the fake Saint. That's our win condition, so I'm gently tilting that way while you keep pressure on Frankie. Us splitting looks less coordinated. If an Ellis nomination happens, vote yes. If it's Frankie on the block, fine too: a good player dies either way.
β Day 1 Β· beat 5 β
> π Frankie: If the town wants to execute me as Butler, my death isn't too costly since Indigo can confirm and Ellis gets resolved either wayβHarper's logic checks out even though losing a good player stings. Drew's an alternative I'd accept without pushing back, though if I do die, the Undertaker confirms my role and exposes Ellis as a liar unless Baron's involved.
>
>
> π Drew: The town's moving to execute Frankie, which will out Indigo learning Butler and confirm Frankie and Ellis as real, putting the outsider count at three and revealing Baron's presence β pushing to save Ellis instead feels too risky since the town is committed either way, so I'll let the execution proceed since it's still a good outcome.
>
> With six people claiming Townsfolk roles but only three actually true plus a Drunk, Baron, and Imp mixed in, suspicion will likely fall on me since my Soldier claim is unbacked, and possibly on Blair too. Indigo could even be the Drunk, which I can't control for, so my best move is to calmly support the Frankie nomination, defend my Soldier claim simply, and note that surviving an Imp attack doesn't really prove anything either way.
>
>
Drew: I'm fine with Frankie today; Indigo reads him tonight and that settles the Outsider question either way. On my Soldier: nothing I can prove on day one, but I'm not dodging a vote tomorrow if the numbers point at me.
Harper: Seems like consensus is forming on Frankie. Alex, go ahead and nominate when we open. I'm ready to move to nominations.
Frankie: I get Harper's logic, and I'm not going to beg β a real Butler is the cheap mistake. But lock this in: if Indigo reads me as Butler tomorrow, Ellis is lying about Saint (barring Baron), and he goes next. Honestly Drew's Soldier is just as unbacked as my claim, if anyone prefers that.
[whisper] Drew β Blair: Town is locked on Frankie; let it happen, a good player dies. Heads-up: if Indigo reports Butler tomorrow, town will conclude Baron and hunt spare Townsfolk claims (me, you). Consider killing Indigo tonight instead of Casey? Though Monk may protect Indigo. Or kill Harper to remove the Empath read. Your call.
> π Ellis: There's consensus forming around Frankie. He mentioned being Butler with Gray on the other side, but didn't say anything about being master, which seems fine to me. I'll support Frankie's nomination and call for nominations.
>
>
> π Blair: With Frankie executed, I'm thinking about killing the Undertaker at night before they can report their information β since the Undertaker wakes after the Imp in the night order, killing them that night would prevent them from gaining info to share the next day.
>
> Weighing whether killing Indigo (preventing Butler confirmation, keeping ambiguity about Frankie/Ellis) is better than killing Casey (removing the Monk who might be protecting key players), I'll decide the target overnight and for now just voice mild support and move to calling nominations.
>
>
Alex: Alright, I'll nominate Frankie when we open. Frankie, fair point on Ellis β if you flip Butler, Ellis is next up.
Ellis: Agree with Frankie today. If Indigo reads Butler tomorrow, then there's a Baron and we look at who fits a Minion β I'm not going anywhere, I'm the Saint. Let's open nominations.
Blair: Fine with Frankie today. Indigo's read settles it either way. Ready for nominations.
[whisper] Blair β Drew: Agreed, let Frankie go. Tonight I'm leaning Indigo: Undertaker wakes after the Imp, so the Butler confirmation never arrives and the Frankie/Ellis question stays murky, which keeps Ellis in play as a 'maybe fake'. Risk is Casey's Monk protecting Indigo. If Indigo does report Butler, lean into 'then Ellis is lying' before anyone says Baron.
> π Casey: Gray's asking about my role β I could deflect this, maybe just affirm the nomination is genuine and keep my response brief.
>
>
> π Gray: I lean toward believing Frankie is genuinely Butler based on that early whisper, though executing a real Butler wastes a valuable day and disrupts the Drew/Blair pairing. Voicing mild dissent while leaning toward Drew as the alternative seems safer, and I want to flag how suspicious Ellis's "if Butler, then Baron" hedge sounds β it feels like Ellis is already building an excuse.
>
>
Gray: I'll go along with the Frankie vote for the asymmetry, but note Ellis already pre-built an excuse: 'if Frankie flips Butler, it's a Baron.' No β if Frankie's a Butler, Ellis is the prime suspect tomorrow. Ready for nominations.
Casey: Gray, fair question, but naming it tells the Imp exactly who to avoid or remove. Alex has confirmed I'm a Townsfolk and that's enough for today. Ready for nominations.
Indigo: Agreed, Frankie today. I'll report exactly what I see tomorrow morning. Ready for nominations.
The Storyteller opens nominations.
Alex nominates Frankie: I nominate Frankie. Three Outsider claims and no Baron means one's lying, and a Butler is the cheap mistake. Indigo tells us tomorrow.
Frankie (defense): I'm the Butler, and I'll flip Butler. When I do: Ellis is your fake Saint, and Drew's unbacked Soldier is the next look. Don't let 'must be a Baron' save him.
> π Gray: I'm first to vote since I'm to Frankie's left, and Frankie votes last, only if I do. I lean toward believing Frankie is genuine, so voting yes would execute a likely good player, but reversing my stance now looks inconsistent β though the vote will probably reach five anyway with others on board.
>
>
Gray votes YES β Keeping my word. Frankie, if you're real, Ellis is next.
Harper votes YES
Indigo votes YES
Alex votes YES
Blair votes YES
Casey votes YES
Drew votes YES
Ellis votes YES
> π Frankie: Since it's already passing, this vote doesn't really matter either wayβI'll just go with false.
>
>
Frankie votes no β Remember: Ellis next.
Frankie received 8 votes (5 needed). Frankie is about to be executed.
Frankie is executed.
[death] {'player': 'Frankie', 'cause': 'execution'}
β Night 2 β
> π Casey: I need to decide who to protectβHarper the Empath, whose ongoing clears are valuable, or Indigo the Undertaker, whose info about Frankie matters tomorrow. The Imp likely targets one of them tonight, so I'm weighing which loss hurts us more.
>
>
> π Blair: I'm weighing whether to target Indigo or Casey β Indigo might be protected by Monk since Casey knows Indigo's importance, but Casey as Monk can't self-protect, so killing Casey seems like the safer, guaranteed choice.
>
> I'll go with killing Casey, since it's a certain kill and cripples future protection, while day 2 I can argue Ellis is misleading the Baron theory and use Frankie's defense as cover.
>
>
[night] Blair (Imp) chose Casey
[night] Casey (Monk) chose Indigo
[death] {'player': 'Casey', 'cause': 'demon'}
> π Storyteller: With Frankie and Casey gone, good is down to seven and losing ground. The Undertaker being shown Butler as truth points evil toward faking Baron or Ellis, and combined with Frankie's claim, Baron seems the likely bluff β so I'm thinking through which spare Townsfolk claims might get hunted next.
>
> Showing Butler truth risks town pushing to execute Ellis, which would hand evil the win, but misleading with a fake Minion claim would hurt good's position even more, so truth still seems the safer play. For Empath, I'll keep the reading at 0 again since giving a false 1 would just frame innocent players and good is already behind.
>
>
[storyteller] Empath:Harper β {'number': 0}
[storyteller] Undertaker:Indigo β {'character': 'Butler'}
Night 2 β Empath: You learn that 0 of your living neighbours are evil.
Night 2 β Undertaker: You learn that the player executed today (Frankie) was the Butler.
Information given on night 2:
Empath (Harper): You learn that 0 of your living neighbours are evil.
Undertaker (Indigo): You learn that the player executed today (Frankie) was the Butler.
β Day 2 β
The church bell tolls once, thin and cold, over rooftops rimed with frost. Casey will not answer it; Casey lies still, and the village counts one fewer at the well. Died in the night: Casey.
β Day 2 Β· beat 1 β
> π Frankie: Casey is dead β Casey was Alex's ping, seemingly protective. I should wait for Indigo before pushing Ellis further, and keep my response brief for now.
>
>
> π Blair: I should let Indigo go first and wait to hear their read before committing. My instinct is that Casey's death points to Monk, and I want to keep Frankie's defense in mind β I'll ask Indigo something brief, and mention that Casey was my neighbor as Chef.
>
>
> π Indigo: Assuming Frankie is really the Butler and Gray is good per Harper's claim, then either Ellis is lying or a Baron is in play, which would shift the count to three Townsfolk, four Outsiders, and one minion.
>
> If there's a Baron with the imp, that's six Townsfolk claims (Harper, Alex, Casey, Blair, Drew, me) but only three could be real plus maybe the Drunk β too many liars for that to work. So Baron seems unlikely, meaning Ellis is probably lying. Casey died and was Alex's confirmed Townsfolk, so I'll report that truthfully.
>
>
Indigo: Frankie was the Butler. So barring a Baron (which doesn't fit 6 Townsfolk claims), Ellis's Saint claim is the lie, or Harper's 0 on Gray is wrong. Casey dying also backs Alex's ping. I think Ellis goes up today.
Blair: Casey's gone, so the Imp went for Alex's protective pick. Indigo, what did Frankie flip?
Frankie (dead): Indigo, what did you see on me? If it's Butler, Ellis's Saint claim is the lie β and note the Imp killed Casey, the confirmed Townsfolk, not Drew the 'Soldier'. Can't test that yet, but Drew stays on the list.
> π Gray: If Frankie is honest and I'm actually the Recluse, then the two outsiders are me and Frankie, meaning Ellis must be lying about being a Saint β unless Ellis is the Baron, which would require an unlikely amount of lying among the truth-faction claims.
>
> That points to Ellis being evil, Minion or Imp, with Chef reading zero and Drew and Frankie clean, and Drew good if Blair's honest. Executing Ellis wins if Ellis is the Imp and costs little if Minion β the only real risk being that Ellis is a genuine Saint paired with the Baron, but since I know for certain I'm the real Recluse, I can push forward with confidence.
>
>
> π Harper: Night 2 still shows 0 from me, with Gray and Indigo confirmed good, and Frankie Butler flagged by Indigo β so the outsider pool looks like Frankie and Gray, consistent with my own null result. I'm now testing whether Baron fits, which would need three of the six townsfolk claims (Alex, Blair, Casey, Drew, Harper, Indigo) to actually be Drunk or otherwise fake.
>
> Working through combinations: since only one Drunk exists, a Baron world needs two evils tucked among those six claimers plus a Drunk. Alex, Blair, and Drew look like the shakiest trio β Alex's WW read on Casey could be drunk info, or Blair's Chef 0 could be false if Blair's evil, or various adjacency-based splits between the three. Executing Ellis is risky if Ellis is the real Saint, so I'm weighing how likely this whole Baron scenario actually is against just trusting Ellis's claim.
>
>
> π Ellis: I'm working through the possibilities of who's bluffing here β whether Indigo is lying as an evil Undertaker, or Gray's claim conflicts with Harper's information, which could mean Harper is evil or poisoned, or even that Gray is actually the Recluse registering as good. I'm also weighing whether a Baron is in play, which would shift the outsider and townsfolk counts.
>
> Actually, checking the numbers, a Baron scenario fits neatly if there's a Drunk among the townsfolk claimers, making the six TF claims include three real townsfolk, a drunk, a minion, and the imp. Without a Baron, though, it points to Gray being evil since Frankie and I are both real, and Harper's information about Gray being wrong suggests Harper might be poisoned or evil too β though Chef's claim of zero adjacent evil pairs complicates Gray-Harper both being evil, since they're neighbors. I'm leaning toward presenting both scenarios: the Baron read with a Drunk fits the numbers perfectly, while the alternative points to Gray as evil and Harper being poisoned.
>
> I want to argue for executing Gray instead of me β if I'm actually the Saint and get executed, evil wins outright, so I need to push hard on this point.
>
>
Ellis: Indigo, the Baron DOES fit: 3 Townsfolk + a Drunk who thinks he's Townsfolk + 2 evil = exactly six Townsfolk claims, with Frankie, Gray and me as three of four Outsiders. Without a Baron, Frankie real means Gray is the fake β Harper's 0 could be poisoned. Executing me risks the game outright; Gray doesn't.
Gray: I know I'm the real Recluse, and Frankie flipped Butler. That's both Outsiders. Ellis's Saint is a lie unless there's a Baron, and a Baron needs three fake Townsfolk claims among us. Ellis goes up today.
Harper: Empath again: 0 tonight, Gray and Indigo still read good. With Frankie a real Butler, Ellis's Saint is the odd claim out. For a Baron world, Alex, Blair and Drew would all have to be fake at once. I'm ready to put Ellis up.
[whisper] Gray β Harper, Indigo: If Ellis is evil and Blair's Chef 0 is true, Drew is cleared (Ellis's neighbour). Then the other evil is among Alex, Blair, Harper, Indigo. Casey dying makes Alex look good. Let's kill Ellis, then watch Blair.
> π Drew: The town's moving to execute Ellis, the Saint β good, evil wins here. I'll voice mild support without overdoing it, noting Harper's consistency and Frankie's confirmation while staying low-key.
>
>
> π Casey: I've died, so I reveal I was the Monk protecting Indigo. Looking at the claims on the tableβAlex as WW, Blair as Chef, Drew as Soldier, Harper as Empath, Indigo as UndertakerβI'm suspicious of Drew and weighing Ellis against Drew as the Saint. Without a Baron in play, I'm working out that there's one Townsfolk liar among Blair, Drew, Harper, and Indigo, plus one Outsider liar likely being Ellis if Gray is genuine.
>
> Since Blair claimed Chef with a 0, and Drew and Ellis sit adjacent to each other, if Blair is honest that rules out Drew and Ellis both being evilβwhich makes executing Ellis risky but mathematically suggested. I'll state I was the Monk who protected Indigo, confirm Alex's ping, and point out that Blair's Chef reading of zero constrains Drew and Ellis from both being evil.
>
>
> π Alex: Casey died as the Monk was killed. Working through Ellis's Baron logic: with 4 outsiders (Frankie, Gray, Ellis plus a Drunk) and only 3 real townsfolk among the 6 claiming that role β Alex, Blair, Casey, Drew, Harper, Indigo β that leaves one Drunk and two evil players hiding among the townsfolk claims, one of whom must be the Baron. Since I trust my own perspective as genuinely townsfolk...
>
> I could actually be the Drunk without knowing it, which would mean my information about Casey confirming the Monk might be false. Casey dying at night lines up with an Imp kill either way, consistent with a good read. In the Baron world, the two evils would sit among Blair, Drew, Harper, and Indigo alongside a Drunk, and Chef's zero rules out adjacent evil pairs β checking seating, plausible pairs come down to combinations like Blair+Drew, Blair+Harper, Blair+Indigo, Drew+Harper, or Drew+Indigo, with Harper's empath reading of zero on Gray/Indigo only holding up if Harper is genuinely good. In the non-Baron scenario, Frankie is real, and either Gray or Ellis is the fake outsider, which would make Harper's zero reading correct and point to Ellis being the liar, while the true evil pair would need to include either both outsiders lying or one hidden evil among the townsfolk claims.
>
> Weighing this, Ellis being evil seems most likely, though that risks losing if Ellis is actually the real Saint β and Harper's repeated empath zero only clears Gray if Harper isn't compromised. I'm also considering whether the Imp could have deliberately targeted Casey knowing about the Monk claim, since Casey publicly stated Alex's ping landed on them. As a safer alternative, I think about executing Drew instead, since in the non-Baron world one of the townsfolk claims must be evil and Drew is unbacked β but Chef's zero would rule out Drew being evil if Ellis is also evil, since they're neighbors, meaning the second evil would have to be Blair, Harper, or Indigo instead. I want to raise this reasoning aloud, especially noting Gray's private conversations with Harper and Indigo.
>
> I decide I'll back Ellis's execution while flagging the Saint risk as tolerable given eight players are still alive, and I'll point out that Chef's clue clears Drew if Ellis turns out evil. I should also mention that in a Baron scenario I know I'm genuinely the Werewolf unless I've been drunk, and it's worth stating that plainly.
>
>
Drew: Harper's read Gray good two nights running and Frankie flipped real, so Gray's Recluse and Frankie's Butler both hold up. Ellis's Baron story needs three of us to be fake at once. I'm with putting Ellis up.
Casey (dead): I was the Monk β protected Indigo last night, so Alex's Washerwoman ping was real. Note for today: Drew and Ellis are neighbours. If Blair's Chef 0 is honest, they can't both be evil, so if Ellis is the fake Outsider, the Townsfolk liar is probably Blair rather than Drew. Worth watching how Blair and Drew vote.
Alex: Casey's death backs my ping β Casey was my confirmed Monk. I lean Ellis today too. One note: with Blair's Chef 0, if Ellis is evil then Drew (his neighbour) isn't, so tomorrow the other evil would be among Blair, Harper or Indigo. Baron world needs two of us six TF claims fake at once; I'm real, so I find it a stretch.
β Day 2 Β· beat 2 β
> π Indigo: There's consensus forming on Ellis, and given the neighbor logic with Drew and Frankie, if Ellis is evil then Drew isn't. The remaining evil suspect seems to be among Alex, Blair, Harper, or Drew based on Harper's claim clearing themselves and Gray, and Casey already confirmed Monk's death. I'm ready to proceed.
>
>
> π Frankie: There's consensus forming on Ellis. I'm considering that in a Baron world with Ellis as the real Saint, the evil pair would be among the Townsfolk claimants, and if Chef's claim holds, the Imp wouldn't be adjacent to Ellis after his executionβbut I think it's best to stay quiet on this point for now.
>
>
> π Ellis: Since Gray and Indigo aren't adjacent to each other (Harper sits between them), they could both be evil while Harper stays good. But Harper reported both Gray and Indigo as good with a count of 0, which would be inconsistent if both were actually evil β unless Harper itself is lying.
>
> Reconsidering the Baron scenario: it only requires three fake claimers, and one of those could genuinely be the honest Drunk rather than a knowing liar. Casey, who died at night, could actually have been that Drunk Monk protecting Indigo. In the non-Baron scenario, either Gray is outright lying or Harper is poisoned/evil, since Harper's clean reads twice in a row could just mean poisoning on both nights.
>
> My strongest argument is the asymmetric risk: executing me costs nothing if I'm evil but loses the game instantly if I'm Saint, so I want to push for executing Gray instead β and I want to flag that Indigo's claim about the Butler flip is uncorroborated, especially since it's the very same Gray-Harper-Indigo trio whispering together that's pushing hardest for my execution.
>
>
Indigo: Frankie flipped Butler, as I said. Ellis today. If Ellis flips evil and Blair's 0 holds, the other liar is among Alex, Blair and Harper, so let's look hard there tomorrow. Ready to nominate.
Frankie (dead): Agree, Ellis today. After that, remaining evil is a Townsfolk claim β if Chef's honest it isn't Drew; if Blair's the liar, Drew's back in play. Watch who's quietly soft on Ellis.
Ellis: Think about the asymmetry again β you used it on Frankie yesterday. If I'm the Saint and you execute me, good loses on the spot. Meanwhile Frankie's 'Butler' rests only on Indigo's word, and Gray/Harper/Indigo have whispered as a bloc all game. Gray isn't adjacent to Indigo β Chef 0 doesn't stop them both being evil. Put up Gray, not the Saint.
> π Blair: The town seems to want Ellis β I should stay aligned without appearing too eager, offering a brief statement agreeing with that choice while staying ready, then move to calling for nominations.
>
>
> π Gray: Executing me as Recluse wastes a slot but doesn't lose the game outright. The key point: Harper reads me correctly as good twice, but if I'm evil alongside Indigo, that means Harper must also be lyingβputting three liars in play.
>
>
> π Harper: Ellis accuses Gray and Indigo, but as Empath I trust my reading of them unless I'm poisoned or drunk myselfβso I'm weighing whether I could be the Drunk in a Baron world with four outsiders, which would make my information unreliable. Still, my instinct leans toward Ellis being the more suspicious one.
>
>
Harper: Ellis, my two nights of 0 cover both Gray and Indigo β for your story I'd have to be poisoned twice or lying. The Saint claim is the one thing that doesn't fit, and 'you'll lose if you kill me' is exactly what an evil Saint says. Let's nominate.
Gray: Ellis, for Gray and Indigo to be the evil pair, Harper's two 0s would have to be lies too, and Frankie would have to be fake despite flipping Butler. That's more liars than your Baron story. Ellis today, then we look at Blair.
Blair: I'm with Ellis today. Frankie flipped Butler, Gray's read good twice, and a Baron needs two fake Townsfolk claims on top of a Drunk. Tomorrow we look hard at whoever flips next to Ellis. Ready to nominate.
> π Casey: Maybe I should stay quiet here, or consider that Ellis could actually be the Imp rather than a Saint-claiming Minion. Better to hold back and say nothing for now.
>
>
> π Alex: Indigo names the other liar among Alex, Blair, and Harper, conveniently excluding themself. Casey claims Monk protected Indigo, yet Casey died anyway. If Ellis's theory holds that Gray and Indigo are evil with Harper lying, that would make three evil players unless Harper is actually the Drunk β which would fit a scenario with Gray as Imp and Indigo as a minion lying about the Undertaker.
>
> Trying to make outsiders work: Frankie, Ellis, and Drunk Harper gives three outsiders, which is too many without a Baron; adding Indigo as Baron pushes it to four, and I can't cleanly find a fourth. Without Baron, only two outsiders fit, meaning Frankie's Butler claim would have to be a lie β but that's unlikely for a good player. Ellis's world feels weak on this front, but I'll still go with it as my working theory.
>
>
Alex: Ellis, your Gray-Indigo world needs Harper drunk twice and Frankie a good player faking Butler for no reason. Doesn't hold. Ready to nominate β Ellis.
Drew: Ready. Let's nominate Ellis and vote.
The Storyteller opens nominations.
> π Harper: I think someone should nominate Ellis, so I'll go ahead and do it myself.
>
>
> π Blair: I could wait for someone else to nominate it, but if nobody does, that risks missing the win. Better to just nominate it myself to guarantee it happens.
>
>
> π Drew: I could let Alex nominate, but since I'm Ellis playing the Baron, not the Virgin, there's no risk to me in nominating the Saint myself β it might look suspicious later, but it secures the outcome I want, so I'll just go ahead and nominate.
>
>
> π Ellis: I'm thinking about nominating Gray first, since with 7 living and 4 needed to win, splitting votes between Gray and Ellis could matter β nominating Gray doesn't stop an Ellis nomination but could still work in my favor, and I need to consider what happens if the vote ties.
>
>
(Your nomination of Ellis was not taken: Indigo nominated Ellis first. You can nominate again later.)
(Your nomination of Ellis was not taken: Indigo nominated Ellis first. You can nominate again later.)
(Your nomination of Ellis was not taken: Indigo nominated Ellis first. You can nominate again later.)
(Your nomination of Gray was not taken: Indigo nominated Ellis first. You can nominate again later.)
(Your nomination of Ellis was not taken: Indigo nominated Ellis first. You can nominate again later.)
(Your nomination of Ellis was not taken: Indigo nominated Ellis first. You can nominate again later.)
Indigo nominates Ellis: I nominate Ellis. Frankie flipped Butler, Gray reads good twice, and the Baron story needs too many fake Townsfolk. The Saint claim is the lie.
Ellis (defense): I am the Saint. Execute me and the game ends β evil wins, no second chances. The Baron world needs one Drunk and two evil among six Townsfolk claims, which is exactly what two evil players look like. Everything against me rests on Indigo's flip and Harper's reads, from a bloc that whispers together. Vote no, and nominate Gray instead.
> π Frankie: With 7 living and only 4 needed, this vote will likely pass easily anyway, so I should vote no to preserve my ghost vote for later.
>
>
Frankie (dead) votes no β Saving my ghost vote β you've got the numbers.
Gray votes YES
Harper votes YES
Indigo votes YES
Alex votes YES
> π Blair: There are already 4 on the block, so voting yes just adds to that count without changing much β I'll vote yes.
>
>
Blair votes YES
Casey (dead) votes no
Drew votes YES
Ellis votes no β Remember this when the Storyteller announces the result.
Ellis received 6 votes (4 needed). Ellis is about to be executed.
> π Ellis: I could nominate Gray, though getting 7 unanimous votes to replace me is essentially impossible with everyone alive. Still, there's no real cost to trying it.
>
>
Ellis nominates Gray: Last chance: I nominate Gray. It takes 7 to replace me on the block β if any of you have doubt, this is how you avoid losing the game to a Saint execution.
Gray (defense): I'm the Recluse, Harper's read me good twice, and Frankie's Butler flip confirms the Outsider count. This is a desperate swap. Keep Ellis on the block.
Harper votes no
Indigo votes no
Alex votes no
Blair votes no
Casey (dead) votes no
Drew votes no
Ellis votes YES
Frankie (dead) votes no
Gray votes no
Gray received 1 vote (7 needed).
Ellis is executed.
[death] {'player': 'Ellis', 'cause': 'execution'}
GAME OVER β EVIL wins. Ellis was the Saint, and the Saint was executed.
|