TestRandomization / code /case1 /results /case1_rank_analysis_console.txt
harryzhang1018's picture
Add reproduction code and README
0c3dd1d verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
5.7 kB
{
"physical_order": {
"P1_lateral": [
"MPC",
"NN-MPC",
"PID",
"NN-HD"
],
"P1_heading": [
"MPC",
"NN-MPC",
"NN-HD",
"PID"
],
"P2_lateral": [
"MPC",
"NN-MPC",
"PID",
"NN-HD"
],
"P2_heading": [
"MPC",
"NN-MPC",
"PID",
"NN-HD"
],
"P3_lateral": [
"MPC",
"PID",
"NN-MPC",
"NN-HD"
],
"P3_heading": [
"MPC",
"PID",
"NN-MPC",
"NN-HD"
]
},
"tr_minus_nominal": {
"TR minus nominal, mean tau": 0.5,
"ci95": [
0.5,
0.5
]
},
"tr_minus_nominal_tables_II_III": {
"TR minus nominal (Tables II-III), mean tau": 0.56,
"ci95": [
0.56,
0.56
],
"min": 0.56,
"share_of_replicates_gt_0": 1.0
},
"hoeffding": {
"loss": "per-start rank, bounded in [1, 4] (B = 3)",
"K": 4,
"alpha": 0.05,
"smallest_adjacent_mean_rank_gap_at_N400": 0.511,
"n_bound": 350
}
}
TR (rank rule, S2) 0.83 [0.78, 0.89] exact 3 best 6 pairs [30, 32] {'P1_lateral': 1.0, 'P1_heading': 1.0, 'P2_lateral': 1.0, 'P2_heading': 1.0, 'P3_lateral': 1.0, 'P3_heading': 1.0}
Nominal simulation 0.33 [0.28, 0.39] exact 0 best 1 pairs [21, 32] {'P1_lateral': 2.15, 'P1_heading': 1.96, 'P2_lateral': 2.65, 'P2_heading': 1.95, 'P3_lateral': 1.0, 'P3_heading': 1.1}
Nominal simulation (2024 archive) 0.28 [0.22, 0.33] exact 0 best 1 pairs [20, 32] {'P1_lateral': 2.15, 'P1_heading': 1.96, 'P2_lateral': 2.65, 'P2_heading': 1.95, 'P3_lateral': 1.0, 'P3_heading': 1.1}
Monte Carlo, start jitter (RF-A) 0.22 [0.17, 0.28] exact 0 best 0 pairs [19, 32] {'P1_lateral': 2.15, 'P1_heading': 1.96, 'P2_lateral': 2.65, 'P2_heading': 1.95, 'P3_lateral': 1.84, 'P3_heading': 1.1}
Monte Carlo, jitter + disturbances (RF-B) 0.22 [0.17, 0.28] exact 0 best 0 pairs [19, 32] {'P1_lateral': 2.15, 'P1_heading': 1.96, 'P2_lateral': 2.65, 'P2_heading': 1.95, 'P3_lateral': 1.56, 'P3_heading': 1.1}
S0 200 MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD fail {'MPC': 0.0, 'NN-MPC': 0.0, 'PID': 0.0, 'NN-HD': 0.0} tau 0.83 MPC1st 75.8
S1 200 MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD fail {'MPC': 0.5, 'NN-MPC': 0.0, 'PID': 0.0, 'NN-HD': 0.0} tau 0.83 MPC1st 89.5
S2 400 MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD fail {'MPC': 8.2, 'NN-MPC': 1.0, 'PID': 0.8, 'NN-HD': 0.0} tau 0.83 MPC1st 90.2
S3 200 MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD fail {'MPC': 4.0, 'NN-MPC': 0.5, 'PID': 0.5, 'NN-HD': 0.0} tau 0.83 MPC1st 83.9
S4 200 MPC>PID>NN-MPC>NN-HD fail {'MPC': 27.0, 'NN-MPC': 3.5, 'PID': 3.0, 'NN-HD': 18.0} tau 0.72 MPC1st 73.6
0.05 0.05 15.0 MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD 69.8 0.83
0.05 0.05 25.0 MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD 69.8 0.83
0.05 0.05 40.0 MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD 69.8 0.83
0.05 0.1 15.0 NN-MPC>MPC>PID>NN-HD 30.5 0.5
0.05 0.1 25.0 NN-MPC>MPC>PID>NN-HD 30.5 0.5
0.05 0.1 40.0 NN-MPC>MPC>PID>NN-HD 30.5 0.5
0.05 0.2 15.0 NN-MPC>MPC>PID>NN-HD 30.5 0.5
0.05 0.2 25.0 NN-MPC>MPC>PID>NN-HD 30.5 0.5
0.05 0.2 40.0 NN-MPC>MPC>PID>NN-HD 30.5 0.5
0.1 0.05 15.0 MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD 79.0 0.83
0.1 0.05 25.0 MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD 79.0 0.83
0.1 0.05 40.0 MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD 79.0 0.83
0.1 0.1 15.0 MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD 90.2 0.83
0.1 0.1 25.0 MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD 90.2 0.83
0.1 0.1 40.0 MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD 90.2 0.83
0.1 0.2 15.0 NN-MPC>MPC>PID>NN-HD 46.5 0.5
0.1 0.2 25.0 NN-MPC>MPC>PID>NN-HD 46.5 0.5
0.1 0.2 40.0 NN-MPC>MPC>PID>NN-HD 46.5 0.5
0.2 0.05 15.0 MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD 79.0 0.83
0.2 0.05 25.0 MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD 79.0 0.83
0.2 0.05 40.0 MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD 79.0 0.83
0.2 0.1 15.0 MPC>PID>NN-MPC>NN-HD 87.0 0.72
0.2 0.1 25.0 MPC>PID>NN-MPC>NN-HD 87.0 0.72
0.2 0.1 40.0 MPC>PID>NN-MPC>NN-HD 87.0 0.72
0.2 0.2 15.0 MPC>PID>NN-MPC>NN-HD 89.8 0.72
0.2 0.2 25.0 MPC>PID>NN-MPC>NN-HD 89.8 0.72
0.2 0.2 40.0 MPC>PID>NN-MPC>NN-HD 89.8 0.72
[{'N': 10, 'p_same_order_as_400': 0.942, 'p_mpc_first': 0.974}, {'N': 25, 'p_same_order_as_400': 0.999, 'p_mpc_first': 0.999}, {'N': 50, 'p_same_order_as_400': 1.0, 'p_mpc_first': 1.0}, {'N': 100, 'p_same_order_as_400': 1.0, 'p_mpc_first': 1.0}, {'N': 200, 'p_same_order_as_400': 1.0, 'p_mpc_first': 1.0}, {'N': 400, 'p_same_order_as_400': 1.0, 'p_mpc_first': 1.0}]
D1a actuation: +0.10 s delay MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD 80.5 {'MPC': 10.5, 'NN-MPC': 1.5, 'PID': 1.5, 'NN-HD': 0.0} 0.83 {'order': ['MPC', 'NN-MPC', 'PID', 'NN-HD'], 'mean_tau_vs_physical': 0.83}
D1b actuation: +0.20 s delay NN-MPC>MPC>PID>NN-HD 51.8 {'MPC': 9.0, 'NN-MPC': 1.5, 'PID': 2.0, 'NN-HD': 0.0} 0.5 {'order': ['MPC', 'NN-MPC', 'PID', 'NN-HD'], 'mean_tau_vs_physical': 0.83}
D2a actuation: steering bias 0.013 MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD 84.8 {'MPC': 10.0, 'NN-MPC': 0.5, 'PID': 0.5, 'NN-HD': 0.0} 0.83 {'order': ['MPC', 'NN-MPC', 'PID', 'NN-HD'], 'mean_tau_vs_physical': 0.83}
D2b actuation: steering bias 0.026 MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD 81.2 {'MPC': 8.5, 'NN-MPC': 0.5, 'PID': 1.0, 'NN-HD': 0.5} 0.83 {'order': ['MPC', 'NN-MPC', 'PID', 'NN-HD'], 'mean_tau_vs_physical': 0.83}
D3a observation: pose noise 0.02 m / 0.01 rad MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD 88.5 {'MPC': 8.5, 'NN-MPC': 0.5, 'PID': 0.5, 'NN-HD': 0.0} 0.83 {'order': ['MPC', 'NN-MPC', 'PID', 'NN-HD'], 'mean_tau_vs_physical': 0.83}
D3b observation: pose noise 0.05 m / 0.03 rad MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD 71.2 {'MPC': 9.5, 'NN-MPC': 1.0, 'PID': 2.5, 'NN-HD': 0.0} 0.83 {'order': ['MPC', 'NN-MPC', 'PID', 'NN-HD'], 'mean_tau_vs_physical': 0.83}
D4a plant: friction 0.6 MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD 85.5 {'MPC': 9.0, 'NN-MPC': 0.5, 'PID': 0.0, 'NN-HD': 1.0} 0.83 {'order': ['MPC', 'NN-MPC', 'PID', 'NN-HD'], 'mean_tau_vs_physical': 0.83}
D4b plant: friction 0.4 MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD 67.5 {'MPC': 9.5, 'NN-MPC': 0.5, 'PID': 0.0, 'NN-HD': 0.0} 0.83 {'order': ['MPC', 'NN-MPC', 'PID', 'NN-HD'], 'mean_tau_vs_physical': 0.83}
D5 combined D1a + D2a + D3a MPC>NN-MPC>PID>NN-HD 71.2 {'MPC': 10.5, 'NN-MPC': 0.5, 'PID': 0.5, 'NN-HD': 0.5} 0.83 {'order': ['MPC', 'NN-MPC', 'PID', 'NN-HD'], 'mean_tau_vs_physical': 0.83}