math / data /lean /OAI /Combinatorics /BinaryEdit /Distortion.lean
introvoyz045's picture
Migrated from GitHub
4a56cd6 verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
17.1 kB
import OAI.Combinatorics.BinaryEdit.Model
import Mathlib.Data.Fintype.EquivFin
import Mathlib.Tactic
namespace OAI
/-! Distortion of finite metric spaces under injective maps into real ℓ₁. -/
noncomputable section
open scoped ENNReal
namespace TreeEdit.BinaryLower
variable {X Y : Type*}
/-- The two finite sets whose maxima define distortion. -/
def expansionRatios (ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) (f : X β†’ RealL1) : Set ℝ :=
{r | βˆƒ x y, x β‰  y ∧ r = β€–f x - f yβ€– / ρ x y}
def contractionRatios (ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) (f : X β†’ RealL1) : Set ℝ :=
{r | βˆƒ x y, x β‰  y ∧ r = ρ x y / β€–f x - f yβ€–}
def embeddingDistortions (ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) : Set ℝ :=
{D | βˆƒ f : X β†’ RealL1, Function.Injective f ∧ D = distortion ρ f}
lemma expansionRatios_finite [Finite X] (ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) (f : X β†’ RealL1) :
(expansionRatios ρ f).Finite := by
apply Set.Finite.subset (Set.finite_range (fun p : X Γ— X => β€–f p.1 - f p.2β€– / ρ p.1 p.2))
rintro r ⟨x, y, _, rfl⟩
exact ⟨(x, y), rfl⟩
lemma contractionRatios_finite [Finite X] (ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) (f : X β†’ RealL1) :
(contractionRatios ρ f).Finite := by
apply Set.Finite.subset (Set.finite_range (fun p : X Γ— X => ρ p.1 p.2 / β€–f p.1 - f p.2β€–))
rintro r ⟨x, y, _, rfl⟩
exact ⟨(x, y), rfl⟩
lemma expansionRatios_nonempty [Nontrivial X] (ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) (f : X β†’ RealL1) :
(expansionRatios ρ f).Nonempty := by
obtain ⟨x, y, hxy⟩ := exists_pair_ne X
exact ⟨_, x, y, hxy, rfl⟩
lemma contractionRatios_nonempty [Nontrivial X] (ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) (f : X β†’ RealL1) :
(contractionRatios ρ f).Nonempty := by
obtain ⟨x, y, hxy⟩ := exists_pair_ne X
exact ⟨_, x, y, hxy, rfl⟩
lemma expansion_nonneg [Finite X] [Nontrivial X] (ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ)
(hρ : βˆ€ x y, 0 ≀ ρ x y) (f : X β†’ RealL1) :
0 ≀ sSup (expansionRatios ρ f) := by
obtain ⟨x, y, hxy⟩ := exists_pair_ne X
exact (div_nonneg (norm_nonneg _) (hρ x y)).trans
(le_csSup (expansionRatios_finite ρ f).bddAbove ⟨x, y, hxy, rfl⟩)
lemma contraction_nonneg [Finite X] [Nontrivial X] (ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ)
(hρ : βˆ€ x y, 0 ≀ ρ x y) (f : X β†’ RealL1) :
0 ≀ sSup (contractionRatios ρ f) := by
obtain ⟨x, y, hxy⟩ := exists_pair_ne X
exact (div_nonneg (hρ x y) (norm_nonneg _)).trans
(le_csSup (contractionRatios_finite ρ f).bddAbove ⟨x, y, hxy, rfl⟩)
lemma distortion_nonneg [Finite X] [Nontrivial X] (ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ)
(hρ : βˆ€ x y, 0 ≀ ρ x y) (f : X β†’ RealL1) : 0 ≀ distortion ρ f :=
mul_nonneg (expansion_nonneg ρ hρ f) (contraction_nonneg ρ hρ f)
/-- Every finite set admits an injection into the full sequence space. -/
lemma exists_injective_L1 (X : Type*) [Finite X] :
βˆƒ f : X β†’ RealL1, Function.Injective f := by
classical
let := Fintype.ofFinite X
let f : X β†’ RealL1 := fun x => lp.single 1 0 ((Fintype.equivFin X x).val : ℝ)
refine ⟨f, ?_⟩
intro x y h
have hv := congrArg (fun z : RealL1 => z 0) h
simp only [f, lp.single_apply_self] at hv
apply (Fintype.equivFin X).injective
apply Fin.ext
exact_mod_cast hv
lemma embeddingDistortions_nonempty [Finite X] (ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) :
(embeddingDistortions ρ).Nonempty := by
obtain ⟨f, hf⟩ := exists_injective_L1 X
exact ⟨distortion ρ f, f, hf, rfl⟩
lemma embeddingDistortions_bddBelow [Finite X] [Nontrivial X]
(ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) (hρ : βˆ€ x y, 0 ≀ ρ x y) :
BddBelow (embeddingDistortions ρ) := by
refine ⟨0, ?_⟩
rintro D ⟨f, _, rfl⟩
exact distortion_nonneg ρ hρ f
lemma c1_nonneg [Finite X] [Nontrivial X]
(ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) (hρ : βˆ€ x y, 0 ≀ ρ x y) : 0 ≀ c1 X ρ := by
apply le_csInf (embeddingDistortions_nonempty ρ)
rintro D ⟨f, _, rfl⟩
exact distortion_nonneg ρ hρ f
lemma c1_le_distortion [Finite X] [Nontrivial X]
(ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) (hρ : βˆ€ x y, 0 ≀ ρ x y)
(f : X β†’ RealL1) (hf : Function.Injective f) : c1 X ρ ≀ distortion ρ f := by
exact csInf_le (embeddingDistortions_bddBelow ρ hρ) ⟨f, hf, rfl⟩
lemma le_c1 [Finite X] (ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) (D : ℝ)
(h : βˆ€ f : X β†’ RealL1, Function.Injective f β†’ D ≀ distortion ρ f) :
D ≀ c1 X ρ := by
apply le_csInf (embeddingDistortions_nonempty ρ)
rintro e ⟨f, hf, rfl⟩
exact h f hf
lemma expansionRatios_comp_subset (ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) (Οƒ : Y β†’ Y β†’ ℝ)
(g : X β†’ Y) (hg : Function.Injective g)
(hiso : βˆ€ x y, Οƒ (g x) (g y) = ρ x y) (f : Y β†’ RealL1) :
expansionRatios ρ (f ∘ g) βŠ† expansionRatios Οƒ f := by
rintro r ⟨x, y, hxy, rfl⟩
exact ⟨g x, g y, fun h => hxy (hg h), by simp [hiso]⟩
lemma contractionRatios_comp_subset (ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) (Οƒ : Y β†’ Y β†’ ℝ)
(g : X β†’ Y) (hg : Function.Injective g)
(hiso : βˆ€ x y, Οƒ (g x) (g y) = ρ x y) (f : Y β†’ RealL1) :
contractionRatios ρ (f ∘ g) βŠ† contractionRatios Οƒ f := by
rintro r ⟨x, y, hxy, rfl⟩
exact ⟨g x, g y, fun h => hxy (hg h), by simp [hiso]⟩
/-- Restriction to an isometric subspace cannot increase distortion. -/
lemma distortion_comp_le [Finite X] [Nontrivial X] [Finite Y] [Nontrivial Y]
(ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) (Οƒ : Y β†’ Y β†’ ℝ) (hΟƒ : βˆ€ x y, 0 ≀ Οƒ x y)
(g : X β†’ Y) (hg : Function.Injective g)
(hiso : βˆ€ x y, Οƒ (g x) (g y) = ρ x y) (f : Y β†’ RealL1) :
distortion ρ (f ∘ g) ≀ distortion Οƒ f := by
have hρ : βˆ€ x y, 0 ≀ ρ x y := fun x y => (hiso x y) β–Έ hΟƒ (g x) (g y)
apply mul_le_mul
· apply csSup_le (expansionRatios_nonempty ρ (f ∘ g))
intro r hr
exact le_csSup (expansionRatios_finite Οƒ f).bddAbove
(expansionRatios_comp_subset ρ Οƒ g hg hiso f hr)
· apply csSup_le (contractionRatios_nonempty ρ (f ∘ g))
intro r hr
exact le_csSup (contractionRatios_finite Οƒ f).bddAbove
(contractionRatios_comp_subset ρ Οƒ g hg hiso f hr)
· exact contraction_nonneg ρ hρ (f ∘ g)
· exact expansion_nonneg σ hσ f
/-- The optimal ℓ₁ distortion is monotone under injective isometries. -/
lemma c1_mono_isometry [Finite X] [Nontrivial X] [Finite Y] [Nontrivial Y]
(ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) (Οƒ : Y β†’ Y β†’ ℝ) (hΟƒ : βˆ€ x y, 0 ≀ Οƒ x y)
(g : X β†’ Y) (hg : Function.Injective g)
(hiso : βˆ€ x y, Οƒ (g x) (g y) = ρ x y) :
c1 X ρ ≀ c1 Y Οƒ := by
have hρ : βˆ€ x y, 0 ≀ ρ x y := fun x y => (hiso x y) β–Έ hΟƒ (g x) (g y)
apply le_c1
intro f hf
exact (c1_le_distortion ρ hρ (f ∘ g) (hf.comp hg)).trans
(distortion_comp_le ρ Οƒ hΟƒ g hg hiso f)
lemma c1_eq_of_equiv [Finite X] [Nontrivial X] [Finite Y] [Nontrivial Y]
(ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) (Οƒ : Y β†’ Y β†’ ℝ) (hΟƒ : βˆ€ x y, 0 ≀ Οƒ x y)
(e : X ≃ Y) (hiso : βˆ€ x y, Οƒ (e x) (e y) = ρ x y) :
c1 X ρ = c1 Y Οƒ := by
apply le_antisymm (c1_mono_isometry ρ Οƒ hΟƒ e e.injective hiso)
apply c1_mono_isometry Οƒ ρ
Β· intro x y
exact (hiso x y) ▸ hσ (e x) (e y)
Β· exact e.symm.injective
Β· intro x y
simpa using (hiso (e.symm x) (e.symm y)).symm
/-- A noncontracting embedding with expansion at most `D` gives the usual
upper bound on optimal distortion. No existence theorem is assumed here. -/
lemma c1_le_of_bounds [Finite X] [Nontrivial X]
(ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) (hρ : βˆ€ x y, 0 ≀ ρ x y)
(hpos : βˆ€ x y, x β‰  y β†’ 0 < ρ x y)
(f : X β†’ RealL1) (D : ℝ) (hD : 0 ≀ D)
(hlower : βˆ€ x y, ρ x y ≀ β€–f x - f yβ€–)
(hupper : βˆ€ x y, β€–f x - f yβ€– ≀ D * ρ x y) :
c1 X ρ ≀ D := by
have hf : Function.Injective f := by
intro x y h
by_contra hxy
have ht := hlower x y
rw [h, sub_self, norm_zero] at ht
exact (not_le_of_gt (hpos x y hxy)) ht
apply (c1_le_distortion ρ hρ f hf).trans
have he : sSup (expansionRatios ρ f) ≀ D := by
apply csSup_le (expansionRatios_nonempty ρ f)
rintro r ⟨x, y, hxy, rfl⟩
exact (div_le_iffβ‚€ (hpos x y hxy)).2 (hupper x y)
have hc : sSup (contractionRatios ρ f) ≀ 1 := by
apply csSup_le (contractionRatios_nonempty ρ f)
rintro r ⟨x, y, hxy, rfl⟩
have hn : 0 < β€–f x - f yβ€– := (hpos x y hxy).trans_le (hlower x y)
exact (div_le_iffβ‚€ hn).2 (by simpa using hlower x y)
calc
distortion ρ f ≀ D * 1 :=
mul_le_mul he hc (contraction_nonneg ρ hρ f) hD
_ = D := mul_one D
/-- Comparing two metrics through a scaled bi-Lipschitz injection costs only
its ratio of expansion to contraction in the distortion product. -/
lemma distortion_comp_le_bilip [Finite X] [Nontrivial X] [Finite Y] [Nontrivial Y]
(ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) (Οƒ : Y β†’ Y β†’ ℝ)
(hρ : βˆ€ x y, 0 ≀ ρ x y) (hΟƒ : βˆ€ x y, 0 ≀ Οƒ x y)
(hpos : βˆ€ x y, x β‰  y β†’ 0 < ρ x y)
(g : X β†’ Y) (hg : Function.Injective g)
(a b : ℝ) (ha : 0 < a) (hb : 0 ≀ b)
(hlower : βˆ€ x y, a * ρ x y ≀ Οƒ (g x) (g y))
(hupper : βˆ€ x y, Οƒ (g x) (g y) ≀ b * ρ x y) (f : Y β†’ RealL1) :
distortion ρ (f ∘ g) ≀ (b / a) * distortion Οƒ f := by
have he : sSup (expansionRatios ρ (f ∘ g)) ≀ b * sSup (expansionRatios Οƒ f) := by
apply csSup_le (expansionRatios_nonempty ρ (f ∘ g))
rintro r ⟨x, y, hxy, rfl⟩
have ht := hpos x y hxy
have hs : 0 < Οƒ (g x) (g y) := (mul_pos ha ht).trans_le (hlower x y)
have hratio : β€–f (g x) - f (g y)β€– / Οƒ (g x) (g y) ≀
sSup (expansionRatios Οƒ f) :=
le_csSup (expansionRatios_finite Οƒ f).bddAbove
⟨g x, g y, fun h => hxy (hg h), rfl⟩
calc
β€–(f ∘ g) x - (f ∘ g) yβ€– / ρ x y ≀
(b * β€–f (g x) - f (g y)β€–) / Οƒ (g x) (g y) := by
apply (div_le_div_iffβ‚€ ht hs).2
have hn := norm_nonneg (f (g x) - f (g y))
change β€–f (g x) - f (g y)β€– * Οƒ (g x) (g y) ≀
b * β€–f (g x) - f (g y)β€– * ρ x y
nlinarith [mul_le_mul_of_nonneg_left (hupper x y) hn]
_ = b * (β€–f (g x) - f (g y)β€– / Οƒ (g x) (g y)) := by ring
_ ≀ b * sSup (expansionRatios Οƒ f) := mul_le_mul_of_nonneg_left hratio hb
have hc : sSup (contractionRatios ρ (f ∘ g)) ≀
(1 / a) * sSup (contractionRatios Οƒ f) := by
apply csSup_le (contractionRatios_nonempty ρ (f ∘ g))
rintro r ⟨x, y, hxy, rfl⟩
have hratio : Οƒ (g x) (g y) / β€–f (g x) - f (g y)β€– ≀
sSup (contractionRatios Οƒ f) :=
le_csSup (contractionRatios_finite Οƒ f).bddAbove
⟨g x, g y, fun h => hxy (hg h), rfl⟩
have hmetric : ρ x y ≀ Οƒ (g x) (g y) / a := by
apply (le_div_iffβ‚€ ha).2
simpa [mul_comm] using hlower x y
calc
ρ x y / β€–(f ∘ g) x - (f ∘ g) yβ€– ≀
(Οƒ (g x) (g y) / a) / β€–f (g x) - f (g y)β€– :=
div_le_div_of_nonneg_right hmetric (norm_nonneg _)
_ = (1 / a) * (Οƒ (g x) (g y) / β€–f (g x) - f (g y)β€–) := by ring
_ ≀ (1 / a) * sSup (contractionRatios Οƒ f) :=
mul_le_mul_of_nonneg_left hratio (by positivity)
calc
distortion ρ (f ∘ g) ≀
(b * sSup (expansionRatios Οƒ f)) *
((1 / a) * sSup (contractionRatios Οƒ f)) :=
mul_le_mul he hc (contraction_nonneg ρ hρ (f ∘ g))
(mul_nonneg hb (expansion_nonneg σ hσ f))
_ = (b / a) * distortion Οƒ f := by unfold distortion; unfold expansionRatios contractionRatios; ring
/-- Optimal distortion transfer through any scaled bi-Lipschitz injection.
In particular, `a=P/804` and `b=P` give constant distortion loss. -/
lemma c1_le_bilip_mul [Finite X] [Nontrivial X] [Finite Y] [Nontrivial Y]
(ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) (Οƒ : Y β†’ Y β†’ ℝ)
(hρ : βˆ€ x y, 0 ≀ ρ x y) (hΟƒ : βˆ€ x y, 0 ≀ Οƒ x y)
(hpos : βˆ€ x y, x β‰  y β†’ 0 < ρ x y)
(g : X β†’ Y) (hg : Function.Injective g)
(a b : ℝ) (ha : 0 < a) (hb : 0 < b)
(hlower : βˆ€ x y, a * ρ x y ≀ Οƒ (g x) (g y))
(hupper : βˆ€ x y, Οƒ (g x) (g y) ≀ b * ρ x y) :
c1 X ρ ≀ (b / a) * c1 Y Οƒ := by
have hba : 0 < b / a := div_pos hb ha
have h : c1 X ρ / (b / a) ≀ c1 Y Οƒ := by
apply le_c1
intro f hf
apply (div_le_iffβ‚€ hba).2
calc
c1 X ρ ≀ distortion ρ (f ∘ g) := c1_le_distortion ρ hρ (f ∘ g) (hf.comp hg)
_ ≀ (b / a) * distortion Οƒ f :=
distortion_comp_le_bilip ρ Οƒ hρ hΟƒ hpos g hg a b ha hb.le hlower hupper f
_ = distortion Οƒ f * (b / a) := mul_comm _ _
simpa [mul_comm] using (div_le_iffβ‚€ hba).1 h
/-- Rescaling by the maximal contraction ratio makes an injective embedding
noncontracting without changing the distortion bound. -/
lemma exists_normalized_embedding [Finite X] [Nontrivial X]
(ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) (hρ : βˆ€ x y, 0 ≀ ρ x y)
(hdiag : βˆ€ x, ρ x x = 0) (hpos : βˆ€ x y, x β‰  y β†’ 0 < ρ x y)
(f : X β†’ RealL1) (hf : Function.Injective f) :
βˆƒ g : X β†’ RealL1, Function.Injective g ∧
βˆ€ x y, ρ x y ≀ β€–g x - g yβ€– ∧ β€–g x - g yβ€– ≀ distortion ρ f * ρ x y := by
let C := sSup (contractionRatios ρ f)
let E := sSup (expansionRatios ρ f)
have hC : 0 ≀ C := contraction_nonneg ρ hρ f
let g : X β†’ RealL1 := fun x => C β€’ f x
have hnorm (x y : X) : β€–g x - g yβ€– = C * β€–f x - f yβ€– := by
dsimp [g]
rw [← smul_sub, norm_smul, Real.norm_of_nonneg hC]
have hbounds : βˆ€ x y, ρ x y ≀ β€–g x - g yβ€– ∧
β€–g x - g yβ€– ≀ distortion ρ f * ρ x y := by
intro x y
by_cases hxy : x = y
Β· subst y
simp [hdiag]
have hr : 0 < ρ x y := hpos x y hxy
have hn : 0 < β€–f x - f yβ€– := norm_pos_iff.mpr (sub_ne_zero.mpr (fun h => hxy (hf h)))
have hc : ρ x y / β€–f x - f yβ€– ≀ C :=
le_csSup (contractionRatios_finite ρ f).bddAbove ⟨x, y, hxy, rfl⟩
have he : β€–f x - f yβ€– / ρ x y ≀ E :=
le_csSup (expansionRatios_finite ρ f).bddAbove ⟨x, y, hxy, rfl⟩
constructor
Β· rw [hnorm]
exact (div_le_iffβ‚€ hn).1 hc
Β· rw [hnorm]
have ht := mul_le_mul_of_nonneg_left ((div_le_iffβ‚€ hr).1 he) hC
change C * β€–f x - f yβ€– ≀ (E * C) * ρ x y
nlinarith
refine ⟨g, ?_, hbounds⟩
intro x y h
by_contra hxy
have ht := (hbounds x y).1
rw [h, sub_self, norm_zero] at ht
exact (not_le_of_gt (hpos x y hxy)) ht
/-- An obstruction proved for all normalized embeddings gives a lower bound
on the infimum defining `c1`. This is the passage used by the two tree routes. -/
lemma le_c1_of_normalized [Finite X] [Nontrivial X]
(ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) (hρ : βˆ€ x y, 0 ≀ ρ x y)
(hdiag : βˆ€ x, ρ x x = 0) (hpos : βˆ€ x y, x β‰  y β†’ 0 < ρ x y)
(D : ℝ)
(hobstruction : βˆ€ (g : X β†’ RealL1) (A : ℝ),
(βˆ€ x y, ρ x y ≀ β€–g x - g yβ€– ∧ β€–g x - g yβ€– ≀ A * ρ x y) β†’ D ≀ A) :
D ≀ c1 X ρ := by
apply le_c1
intro f hf
obtain ⟨g, _, hg⟩ := exists_normalized_embedding ρ hρ hdiag hpos f hf
exact hobstruction g (distortion ρ f) hg
/-- The dual normalization used verbatim by the finite-tree obstruction:
the image distance lies between `ρ / distortion` and `ρ`. -/
lemma exists_nonexpanding_embedding [Finite X] [Nontrivial X]
(ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) (hρ : βˆ€ x y, 0 ≀ ρ x y)
(hdiag : βˆ€ x, ρ x x = 0) (hpos : βˆ€ x y, x β‰  y β†’ 0 < ρ x y)
(f : X β†’ RealL1) (hf : Function.Injective f) :
0 < distortion ρ f ∧ βˆƒ g : X β†’ RealL1, Function.Injective g ∧
βˆ€ x y, ρ x y / distortion ρ f ≀ β€–g x - g yβ€– ∧ β€–g x - g yβ€– ≀ ρ x y := by
obtain ⟨g, _, hg⟩ := exists_normalized_embedding ρ hρ hdiag hpos f hf
obtain ⟨xβ‚€, yβ‚€, hxy⟩ := exists_pair_ne X
have hr := hpos xβ‚€ yβ‚€ hxy
have hD : 0 < distortion ρ f := by
have ht := (hg xβ‚€ yβ‚€).1.trans (hg xβ‚€ yβ‚€).2
nlinarith
let g' : X β†’ RealL1 := fun x => (1 / distortion ρ f) β€’ g x
have hnorm (x y : X) : β€–g' x - g' yβ€– = β€–g x - g yβ€– / distortion ρ f := by
dsimp [g']
rw [← smul_sub, norm_smul, Real.norm_of_nonneg (by positivity)]
ring
have hb : βˆ€ x y, ρ x y / distortion ρ f ≀ β€–g' x - g' yβ€– ∧
β€–g' x - g' yβ€– ≀ ρ x y := by
intro x y
rw [hnorm]
constructor
Β· exact div_le_div_of_nonneg_right (hg x y).1 hD.le
Β· apply (div_le_iffβ‚€ hD).2
simpa [mul_comm] using (hg x y).2
refine ⟨hD, g', ?_, hb⟩
intro x y h
by_contra hxy
have ht := (hb x y).1
rw [h, sub_self, norm_zero] at ht
exact (not_le_of_gt (div_pos (hpos x y hxy) hD)) ht
lemma le_c1_of_nonexpanding [Finite X] [Nontrivial X]
(ρ : X β†’ X β†’ ℝ) (hρ : βˆ€ x y, 0 ≀ ρ x y)
(hdiag : βˆ€ x, ρ x x = 0) (hpos : βˆ€ x y, x β‰  y β†’ 0 < ρ x y)
(D : ℝ)
(hobstruction : βˆ€ (g : X β†’ RealL1) (A : ℝ), 0 < A β†’
(βˆ€ x y, ρ x y / A ≀ β€–g x - g yβ€– ∧ β€–g x - g yβ€– ≀ ρ x y) β†’ D ≀ A) :
D ≀ c1 X ρ := by
apply le_c1
intro f hf
obtain ⟨hD, g, _, hg⟩ := exists_nonexpanding_embedding ρ hρ hdiag hpos f hf
exact hobstruction g (distortion ρ f) hD hg
end TreeEdit.BinaryLower
end
end OAI