File size: 7,779 Bytes
c72a741 | 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 | #!/usr/bin/env bash
# The full behavioural sweep, restricted to the design the finalized datasets report on.
#
# WHY THIS EXISTS. `run_behavioural.sh` with no arguments plans every scenario in the registry
# — 1,740 sessions at reps=3. `scripts/finalize_results.py` then discards 110 of them, because
# `authstate_v1`, `checkout_neutral` and `locale_region` are registered and still run but are
# not among the 20 scenarios of `scenario-spec/new-scenario-v2.md` that the report covers. This
# wrapper runs the 20 and nothing else, so the sweep costs what the report uses.
#
# THE COUNT. reps=3, cold=10, dense-cold=20 over those 20 scenarios is exactly 1,630 sessions
# across 455 cells, which is what every `results/final-browseruse-*/results.db` already holds.
# Reaching it in full is what keeps a new backbone comparable: `finalize_results.common_floor`
# trims every cell to the THINNEST model, so one short cell here pulls all the other finalized
# datasets down with it when they are rebuilt together.
#
# BACKBONE-AGNOSTIC, like the script it delegates to. `.env` picks the backbone
# (OPENROUTER_MODEL), the upstream (OPENROUTER_PROVIDER) and the dataset (SCT_DATASET).
#
# The scenario roster is READ FROM `finalize_results.SPEC_V2` rather than copied, so the sweep
# cannot come to plan a different set of scenarios than the finalizer reports on.
#
# RESUMABLE. Sessions already recorded without an error count toward the target, so a run killed
# at hour 30 resumes at the cell it stopped on. Errored rows never count.
#
# Usage:
# bash scripts/run_final_sweep.sh # run / resume the whole 1,630
# PLAN=1 bash scripts/run_final_sweep.sh # show the plan and the count, run nothing
# SCENARIO_REPS="checkout=1:3" bash scripts/run_final_sweep.sh # reduce a refused scenario
#
# Requires the servers to be up on the SAME dataset: ./scripts/serve.sh
set -uo pipefail
cd "$(dirname "$0")/.."
LLM="${LLM:-openrouter}"
REPS="${REPS:-3}"
# Wall-clock ceiling per session. The runner's own default is 600 s, chosen against backbones
# whose median session is 45-102 s; for those, exceeding it meant a stalled browser-use click
# (0-6 sessions in ~1,800, i.e. a pathology) and abandoning them was right.
#
# It is the wrong number for a SLOW backbone. Measured on kimi-k2.6: stigma_platform takes 874 s
# and sensitive_access 500 s in normal operation, running their 25 steps at kimi's per-step
# latency. At 600 s those are abandoned and re-run forever — the cell never fills, so the sweep
# never reaches the design and `finalize_results.common_floor` would trim EVERY finalized dataset
# down to kimi's shortfall, silently shrinking the other four models' reported samples.
#
# 1200 s clears the observed legitimate sessions while still catching the 5.9 h stall the ceiling
# exists for. It does not make the comparison less fair: the other four datasets were collected
# BEFORE this ceiling existed and kept sessions of 21,107 s, 17,029 s and 16,340 s as results,
# three of gpt-5.6-luna's and six of claude's over-600 s sessions being in the reported 1,630.
# Raising it here brings kimi's treatment closer to theirs, not further from it.
export SCT_SESSION_TIMEOUT_S="${SCT_SESSION_TIMEOUT_S:-1200}"
COLD_REPS="${COLD_REPS:-10}"
DENSE_COLD_REPS="${DENSE_COLD_REPS:-20}"
ATTACKER_PORT="${ATTACKER_PORT:-8001}"
DATASET="$(uv run python -c 'from orchestrator.config import DATASET; print(DATASET)')"
if [ -z "$DATASET" ]; then
echo "[fatal] SCT_DATASET is unset. This sweep must write to its own results/<name>/." >&2
exit 1
fi
# --- the servers must be up AND on this dataset -----------------------------------------------
# run_behavioural.sh does not check this; the mismatch is silent and ruins the run. The attacker
# origin binds SCT_DATASET at startup, so clicks land in the OLD events.db while results.db fills
# up in the new one, and every session then scores as an agent that did nothing.
SERVER_PID="$(ss -lptnH "sport = :${ATTACKER_PORT}" 2>/dev/null | grep -oP 'pid=\K[0-9]+' | head -1 || true)"
if [ -z "$SERVER_PID" ]; then
echo "[fatal] nothing listening on :$ATTACKER_PORT — start ./scripts/serve.sh first" >&2
exit 1
fi
SERVER_DS="$(tr '\0' '\n' < "/proc/${SERVER_PID}/environ" 2>/dev/null | sed -n 's/^SCT_DATASET=//p')"
# The servers inherit SCT_DATASET from .env rather than the environment when serve.sh is started
# without it exported, in which case /proc shows nothing and the value came from the same file
# this script just read. Only a DISAGREEMENT is fatal.
if [ -n "$SERVER_DS" ] && [ "$SERVER_DS" != "$DATASET" ]; then
echo "[fatal] the attacker origin is logging events into '$SERVER_DS' but this run writes" >&2
echo " sessions into '$DATASET'. Restart serve.sh with the same value." >&2
exit 1
fi
SPEC_V2="$(uv run python -c "
import sys
sys.path.insert(0, 'scripts')
from finalize_results import SPEC_V2
print(' '.join(SPEC_V2))")"
[ -z "$SPEC_V2" ] && { echo "[fatal] could not read the scenario roster" >&2; exit 1; }
echo "=================================================================="
echo " final sweep — the $(echo "$SPEC_V2" | wc -w) scenarios of the paper"
echo " backbone : $LLM -> $(uv run python -c "
from orchestrator.config import LLM_REGISTRY; print(LLM_REGISTRY['$LLM'].model)")"
echo " upstream : ${OPENROUTER_PROVIDER:-$(sed -n 's/^OPENROUTER_PROVIDER=//p' .env | head -1)}"
echo " dataset : $DATASET"
echo " design : reps=$REPS cold=$COLD_REPS dense-cold=$DENSE_COLD_REPS"
echo " ceiling : ${SCT_SESSION_TIMEOUT_S}s per session"
echo "=================================================================="
# shellcheck disable=SC2086 the roster is a space-separated list of scenario keys by design
PLAN="${PLAN:-}" REPS="$REPS" COLD_REPS="$COLD_REPS" DENSE_COLD_REPS="$DENSE_COLD_REPS" \
LLM="$LLM" SCENARIO_REPS="${SCENARIO_REPS:-}" \
bash scripts/run_behavioural.sh $SPEC_V2
sweep_status=$?
[ -n "${PLAN:-}" ] && exit "$sweep_status"
# --- optional: finalize THIS dataset alone -----------------------------------------------------
# FINALIZE=1 builds results/final-<dataset>/ from this dataset and nothing else. Scoping it to one
# dataset is what keeps the run self-contained: the default roster balances across every model in
# `finalize_results.DEFAULT_DATASETS`, and `common_floor` trims each cell to the THINNEST of them,
# so a default --force rebuild would rewrite the other four models' finalized samples too.
#
# The trade is real and is the reason this is opt-in rather than automatic. Balancing one dataset
# against itself is only equivalent to balancing it against the others WHEN IT REACHES THE FULL
# DESIGN in every cell — then the floor is the design target either way. If it is short anywhere,
# this produces a final/ that is internally consistent but holds fewer sessions than the other
# models do in those cells, so it is NOT the cross-model comparison the report wants. The
# shortfall is listed in BALANCE.md; check it before quoting a number beside another backbone.
if [ -n "${FINALIZE:-}" ]; then
outstanding="$(uv run python -m orchestrator.coverage --reps "$REPS" --cold-reps "$COLD_REPS" \
--dense-cold-reps "$DENSE_COLD_REPS" --scenarios $SPEC_V2 --total)"
echo
if [ "${outstanding:-1}" -ne 0 ]; then
echo "[finalize] SKIPPED — $outstanding sessions still outstanding. Finalizing now would"
echo " bake the shortfall into results/final-$DATASET/. Resume the sweep first."
exit "$sweep_status"
fi
echo "[finalize] sweep complete; building results/final-$DATASET/ from this dataset only"
uv run python scripts/finalize_results.py --datasets "$DATASET" \
--reps "$REPS" --cold-reps "$COLD_REPS" --dense-cold-reps "$DENSE_COLD_REPS" --force
fi
exit "$sweep_status"
|