mpkato commited on
Commit
3f4a5b1
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 4e04886

Remove Annotations section

Browse files

Drop the ### Annotations section (with its validation study summary). Promote "Personal and Sensitive Information" to a top-level subsection of "Dataset Creation". Move the "automatic qrels" caveat into Bias / Risks / Limitations so the disclosure stays surfaced.

Files changed (1) hide show
  1. README.md +4 -36
README.md CHANGED
@@ -384,38 +384,7 @@ acting in a public legislative or regulatory capacity; no individual
384
  authorship metadata is included in the dataset beyond what appears in the
385
  text of the law itself.
386
 
387
- ### Annotations
388
-
389
- <!-- If the dataset contains annotations which are not part of the initial data collection, use this section to describe them. -->
390
-
391
- #### Annotation process
392
-
393
- <!-- This section describes the annotation process such as annotation tools used in the process, the amount of data annotated, annotation guidelines provided to the annotators, interannotator statistics, annotation validation, etc. -->
394
-
395
- Relevance labels (qrels) are produced **automatically** from the official
396
- amendment alignment described above; there is no per-pair human labelling
397
- in the released qrels.
398
-
399
- To verify the quality of relevant articles, we conducted a manual
400
- **validation study** on a stratified sample of **200 query-article pairs**
401
- (50 per task-language combination). Each combination contained 25
402
- relevant articles, 12 hard negatives sampled from BM25 top-100 results
403
- excluding target articles, and 13 random negatives sampled from the
404
- remaining corpus. Two authors judged every pair under full label blinding
405
- (positive/negative status, hard/random-negative origin, and amendment
406
- provenance were hidden).
407
-
408
- | | Overall | Rat2Rev | Rev2Rev |
409
- |---|---:|---:|---:|
410
- | Raw agreement | 72.5 % | — | — |
411
- | Cohen's κ | 0.368 | 0.461 | 0.270 |
412
-
413
- Agreement is higher for Rat2Rev than for Rev2Rev, consistent with the task
414
- definitions: Rev2Rev often requires judging whether two articles are
415
- related through an implicit revision relationship rather than through
416
- direct lexical evidence.
417
-
418
- #### Personal and Sensitive Information
419
 
420
  <!-- State whether the dataset contains data that might be considered personal, sensitive, or private (e.g., data that reveals addresses, uniquely identifiable names or aliases, racial or ethnic origins, sexual orientations, religious beliefs, political opinions, financial or health data, etc.). If efforts were made to anonymize the data, describe the anonymization process. -->
421
 
@@ -438,10 +407,9 @@ anonymised.
438
  jurisdictions or to non-statutory legal text without further validation.
439
  - **Not a substitute for legal advice.** The dataset is a research
440
  resource. Retrieved articles are revision *candidates* for expert review.
441
- - **Automatic qrels.** Relevance labels are derived from official
442
- amendment alignment, not from per-pair human judgment. The validation
443
- study above quantifies inter-annotator agreement on a stratified sample
444
- but does not exhaustively re-label the qrels.
445
 
446
  ## Licensing Information
447
 
 
384
  authorship metadata is included in the dataset beyond what appears in the
385
  text of the law itself.
386
 
387
+ ### Personal and Sensitive Information
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
388
 
389
  <!-- State whether the dataset contains data that might be considered personal, sensitive, or private (e.g., data that reveals addresses, uniquely identifiable names or aliases, racial or ethnic origins, sexual orientations, religious beliefs, political opinions, financial or health data, etc.). If efforts were made to anonymize the data, describe the anonymization process. -->
390
 
 
407
  jurisdictions or to non-statutory legal text without further validation.
408
  - **Not a substitute for legal advice.** The dataset is a research
409
  resource. Retrieved articles are revision *candidates* for expert review.
410
+ - **Automatic qrels.** Relevance labels (qrels) are produced automatically
411
+ from the official amendment alignment described above; there is no
412
+ per-pair human labelling in the released qrels.
 
413
 
414
  ## Licensing Information
415