| schema_version: 1 |
| record_date: 2026-11-02 |
| record_status: post_registration |
|
|
| paper: |
| title: Toward a Compositional Knowledge Architecture for a Shared Organizational Cortex |
| results_section: "8.5" |
|
|
| registered_plan: |
| repository: https://github.com/withrobinhq/geometric-knowledge-paper-evals |
| tag: registered-plan |
| commit: 6aed8eeb9baa03f0f878e111f2f7e6943c51652f |
| tag_object: 11a91c53dbd380a9a7b8785e90eae7d23e9cec79 |
| registered_at: 2026-10-20T16:20:07Z |
| file: evaluation-plan.md |
| sha256: 413b34d57539da0a8971a86c18a2abf533d9493d4dddf997c60e78e5358278ab |
| component_count: 19 |
|
|
| status_definitions: |
| scored_partial_record: run, scored, and reported; supporting records incomplete |
| specified: registered in the plan |
|
|
| components: |
| - {id: C01, name: Dimension term, section: "10.1", status: scored_partial_record} |
| - {id: C02, name: Standing penalty, section: "10.1", status: scored_partial_record} |
| - {id: C03, name: Domain scoping, section: "10.1", status: scored_partial_record} |
| - {id: C04, name: HyDE escalation, section: "10.1", status: scored_partial_record} |
| - {id: C05, name: Claims layer for artifacts, section: "10.2", status: specified} |
| - {id: C06, name: Deriver qualification, section: "10.2", status: specified} |
| - {id: C07, name: Signal-branch contradiction check, section: "10.3", status: specified} |
| - {id: C08, name: Claim-branch check and position filter, section: "10.3", status: specified} |
| - {id: C09, name: Propagation, section: "10.3", status: specified} |
| - {id: C10, name: Automatic acceptance, section: "10.3", status: specified} |
| - {id: C11, name: Supports verdicts, section: "10.3", status: specified} |
| - {id: C12, name: Entailment check, section: "10.3", status: specified} |
| - {id: C13, name: Compounding, section: "10.4", status: specified} |
| - {id: C14, name: Staleness, section: "10.4", status: specified} |
| - {id: C15, name: Cost ledger, section: "10.4", status: specified} |
| - id: C16 |
| name: Dimension discovery |
| section: "10.5" |
| status: specified |
| note: Registered ordering cannot be followed on the same queries. Arm (iii) held-out results were seen before human-authored Dimensions for this component. |
| - {id: C17, name: Projector qualification, section: "10.5", status: specified} |
| - id: C18 |
| name: Router |
| section: "10.6" |
| status: specified |
| note: Pilot call-shape observations exist and are not registered-test data. |
| - id: C19 |
| name: Domain classifier |
| section: "10.6" |
| status: specified |
| note: Pilot call-shape observations exist and are not registered-test data. |
|
|
| retrieval_run: |
| workspace_query_counts: [91, 88, 93] |
| pooled_queries: 272 |
| registered_arms: [i, ii, iii, iv, v, vi, vii, viii] |
| record_scope: surviving_summary_record |
| underlying_run_artifacts: partially_unavailable |
|
|
| reported_component_results: |
| C01: |
| contrast: "iii - ii" |
| n: 272 |
| effect_ndcg_at_10: 0.028 |
| interval: [0.014, 0.056] |
| p: {operator: "=", value: 0.002} |
| reported_outcome: passes_primary_bar_on_recovered_values |
| registered_disposition: not_fully_verifiable |
| interval_note: off_centre_not_rederived |
| C02: |
| contrast: "ii - i" |
| n: 272 |
| effect_ndcg_at_10: 0.032 |
| interval: [0.004, 0.052] |
| p: {operator: "=", value: 0.011} |
| reported_outcome: passes_authors_recomputed_holm |
| C03: |
| contrast: "i - vi" |
| n: 272 |
| effect_ndcg_at_10: 0.049 |
| interval: [0.024, 0.076] |
| p: {operator: "<", value: 0.001} |
| reported_outcome: passes_authors_recomputed_holm |
| C04: |
| firing_queries: 58 |
| required_firing_queries: 56 |
| effect_ndcg_at_10: 0.061 |
| interval: [0.018, 0.104] |
| p: {operator: "=", value: 0.003} |
| reported_outcome: passes_reported_registered_bar |
|
|
| reported_contrasts: |
| system_signals_only: |
| contrast: "iii - v" |
| n: 251 |
| effect_ndcg_at_10: 0.081 |
| interval: [0.058, 0.112] |
| p: {operator: "<", value: 0.001} |
| reported_outcome: passes_authors_recomputed_holm |
| system_graph_augmented_signals_only: |
| contrast: "iii - viii" |
| n: 251 |
| effect_ndcg_at_10: 0.053 |
| interval: [0.033, 0.083] |
| p: {operator: "<", value: 0.001} |
| reported_outcome: passes_authors_recomputed_holm |
| graph: |
| contrast: "iii - vii" |
| n: 272 |
| effect_ndcg_at_10: 0.031 |
| interval: [0.009, 0.055] |
| p: {operator: "=", value: 0.004} |
| reported_outcome: passes_authors_recomputed_holm |
| plan_note: registered_plan_lists_this_gain_both_inside_and_outside_holm |
| claims_in_index: |
| contrast: "i - v" |
| n: 272 |
| effect_ndcg_at_10: 0.021 |
| interval: [0.001, 0.043] |
| p: {operator: "=", value: 0.020} |
| reported_outcome: reported_only |
| permutation_retention: |
| value: 0.11 |
| bar: 0.5 |
| reported_outcome: registered_point_attribution_check |
| per_workspace_non_inferiority: |
| worst_lower_bound: -0.018 |
| margin: -0.03 |
| reported_outcome: passes_on_recovered_worst_lower_bound |
| record_note: per_workspace_breakdown_withheld; bound_level_not_recorded |
|
|
| post_hoc_analyses: |
| - id: arm_ix |
| name: facet-only |
| registration_relation: post_hoc_unregistered |
| status: scored_partial_record |
| role: post_hoc_attribution_check |
| n: 272 |
| metrics: |
| ndcg_at_10: {mean: 0.464, sd: 0.224} |
| recall_at_50: {mean: 0.639} |
| mrr: {mean: 0.426} |
| contrasts: |
| vs_arm_ii: {effect: 0.011, interval: [-0.006, 0.036]} |
| arm_iii_vs_ix: {effect: 0.017, interval: [0.000, 0.040]} |
| retention: 0.39 |
| proposed_post_hoc_maximum: 0.5 |
| significance: position_specific_increment_reported_not_significant |
|
|
| unavailable_records: |
| - bootstrap resamples and confidence level |
| - sequential-look records and deciding look |
| - original Holm decisions |
| - positive-control verification |
| - registered query-projection cost bound |
| - retrieval gain mapping and unjudged-item treatment |
| - Recall@50 relevance cutoff |
| - consistent per-workspace non-inferiority breakdown |
|
|
| public_artifacts: |
| pilot: pilot/ |
| results: results/ |
|
|
