Scheduled Commit

German/6cf162837cec4e7f943d1eebc515f431.jsonl

@@ -4,3 +4,4 @@
 {"comparison_id": "allenai/flan_v2_converted_tmp_ids_19787::smith_vs_teacher", "source_id": "allenai/flan_v2_converted_tmp_ids_19787", "language": "German", "seed_prompt": "Consider the question. Test for natural language inference.\nPremise: \"Two men in white helmets.\"\nHypothesis: \"Standing outside a building.\"\nIs the hypothesis entailed by the premise?\nOptions:\n- yes\n- no\n- it is not possible to tell\n If the answer is 'no'; explain the reasoning:", "pair": "smith_vs_teacher", "system_left": "smith", "system_right": "teacher", "overall": "strong_a", "aspects": {"naturalness": "strong_a", "cultural_appropriateness": "strong_a", "instruction_following": "strong_a", "coherence": "strong_a"}, "comment": "A is absolutely correct.", "instance_feedback": "", "winner_system": "smith", "annotator_id": "brilliant_poincare", "session_id": "6cf162837cec4e7f943d1eebc515f431", "annotated_at": "2026-09-17T18:10:25", "duration_ms": 102992}
 {"comparison_id": "allenai/flan_v2_converted_tmp_ids_21786::smith_vs_teacher", "source_id": "allenai/flan_v2_converted_tmp_ids_21786", "language": "German", "seed_prompt": "Teacher: Pick which sentence is not logical.\nOptions:\n- Sentence A: \"Her grandfather is her grandson\"\n- Sentence B: \"Her grandfather is her mother's father\"\n\nStudent: A grandfather can't also be the grandson of the same person.\nThe answer is Sentence A.\n\nquestion in book:\nWhich of these sentences doesn't make sense?\nOptions:\n- Sentence A: \"They had walked two miles.\"\n- Sentence B: \"They had walked two meters.\"\n\nstandard solution:\nWalking two meters is a very short distance.\nThe answer is Sentence B.\n\n[TEACHER] Of the following two sentences, which one is against common sense?\nOptions:\n- Sentence A: \"flash memory is a digital recording medium\"\n- Sentence B: \"mouse is a digital recording medium\"\n\n[Student] A computer mouse is not a tool for digital recording.\nThe answer is Sentence B.\n\nTeacher: Which of the following two sentences does not make sense?\nOptions:\n- Sentence A: \"water is for putting in your car engine\"\n- Sentence B: \"oil is for putting in your car engine\"\n\nStudent: Water should not be put inside a car engine.\nThe answer is Sentence A.\n\nquestion in book:\nWhich of the following sentences is nonsensical?\nOptions:\n- Sentence A: \"If you fall, you will break a bone\"\n- Sentence B: \"If you fall, you may break a bone\"\n\nstandard solution:\nSome falls are not hard enough to break bones.\nThe answer is Sentence A.\n\nTeacher: One of the following sentences is nonsensical. Which one is it?\nOptions:\n- Sentence A: \"He chopped the tree with his axe.\"\n- Sentence B: \"He chopped the tree with his finger.\"\n\nStudent:", "pair": "smith_vs_teacher", "system_left": "smith", "system_right": "teacher", "overall": "b", "aspects": {"naturalness": "b", "cultural_appropriateness": "tie_both_good", "instruction_following": "a", "coherence": "b"}, "comment": "B is closer to real life", "instance_feedback": "A repeats itself somewhat", "winner_system": "teacher", "annotator_id": "brilliant_poincare", "session_id": "6cf162837cec4e7f943d1eebc515f431", "annotated_at": "2026-09-17T18:14:52", "duration_ms": 262855}
 {"comparison_id": "allenai/flan_v2_converted_tmp_ids_22582::smith_vs_teacher", "source_id": "allenai/flan_v2_converted_tmp_ids_22582", "language": "German", "seed_prompt": "Consider the question. Can we conclude from \"A child with a sweater is holding a pen in his mouth.\" that \"A kid thinks hard about the answers to the test.\"?\nOptions:\n- yes\n- no\n- it is not possible to tell\n If the answer is 'it is not possible to tell'; explain the reasoning:", "pair": "smith_vs_teacher", "system_left": "teacher", "system_right": "smith", "overall": "a", "aspects": {"naturalness": "a", "cultural_appropriateness": "tie_both_good", "instruction_following": "tie_both_good", "coherence": "a"}, "comment": "A with better reasoning", "instance_feedback": "B has too many grammar mistakes", "winner_system": "teacher", "annotator_id": "brilliant_poincare", "session_id": "6cf162837cec4e7f943d1eebc515f431", "annotated_at": "2026-09-17T18:17:40", "duration_ms": 161157}
+{"comparison_id": "allenai/flan_v2_converted_tmp_ids_3054::smith_vs_teacher", "source_id": "allenai/flan_v2_converted_tmp_ids_3054", "language": "German", "seed_prompt": "One of the following sentences is nonsensical. Which one is it?\nOptions:\n- Sentence A: \"wearing a party hat to attend the funeral is perfect\"\n- Sentence B: \"wearing a party hat to attend the celebration is perfect\"\n Let's reason step by step:", "pair": "smith_vs_teacher", "system_left": "smith", "system_right": "teacher", "overall": "strong_a", "aspects": {"naturalness": "strong_a", "cultural_appropriateness": "strong_a", "instruction_following": "strong_a", "coherence": "strong_a"}, "comment": "Stays in line with prompt and to the point", "instance_feedback": "", "winner_system": "smith", "annotator_id": "brilliant_poincare", "session_id": "6cf162837cec4e7f943d1eebc515f431", "annotated_at": "2026-09-17T18:19:35", "duration_ms": 93189}