| Money Offered,Song,Competitor 1 (Votes),Competitor 2 (Votes) | |
| "$10,000","""Bless the Broken Road""",Agape Love Ensemble (55),Thomas Wells (46) | |
| "$10,000","""Try""",Matt Beilis (47),Joanna Jones (54) | |
| "$10,000","""The Lonely Goatherd""",[MISSING],The TBA Girls (14) | |
| "$25,000","""Bleeding Love""",Agape Love Ensemble (45),Joanna Jones (56) | |
| "$50,000","""Run to You""",Agape Love Ensemble (7),The LaFontaines (94) | |