jaxonparrott commited on
Commit
5a9d46f
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): f2df83c

Machine Relations Index mri_score_v2.1+2026-11-03+92e5b18cc6e2

Browse files
CITATION.cff CHANGED
@@ -6,8 +6,8 @@ authors:
6
  - family-names: Parrott
7
  given-names: Jaxon
8
  orcid: "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-0039-3913"
9
- version: "mri_score_v2.1+2026-10-29+225b998b091e"
10
- date-released: "2026-10-29"
11
  license: CC-BY-4.0
12
  url: "https://machinerelations.ai/index"
13
  identifiers:
@@ -28,7 +28,7 @@ preferred-citation:
28
  given-names: Jaxon
29
  orcid: "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-0039-3913"
30
  year: 2026
31
- version: "mri_score_v2.1+2026-10-29+225b998b091e"
32
  url: "https://machinerelations.ai/index"
33
  doi: "10.5281/zenodo.23652423"
34
  notes: "Machine Relations Research. CC BY 4.0. Machine Relations was coined by Jaxon Parrott in 2024."
 
6
  - family-names: Parrott
7
  given-names: Jaxon
8
  orcid: "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-0039-3913"
9
+ version: "mri_score_v2.1+2026-11-03+92e5b18cc6e2"
10
+ date-released: "2026-11-03"
11
  license: CC-BY-4.0
12
  url: "https://machinerelations.ai/index"
13
  identifiers:
 
28
  given-names: Jaxon
29
  orcid: "https://orcid.org/0009-0004-0039-3913"
30
  year: 2026
31
+ version: "mri_score_v2.1+2026-11-03+92e5b18cc6e2"
32
  url: "https://machinerelations.ai/index"
33
  doi: "10.5281/zenodo.23652423"
34
  notes: "Machine Relations Research. CC BY 4.0. Machine Relations was coined by Jaxon Parrott in 2024."
README.md CHANGED
@@ -39,9 +39,9 @@ Machine Relations was coined by Jaxon Parrott in 2024.
39
 
40
  Keywords: AI search, generative engine optimization, answer engine citations, Machine Relations.
41
 
42
- Weekly public snapshot of the Machine Relations Index. Version `mri_score_v2.1+2026-10-29+225b998b091e`, generated 2026-10-29, window 2026-05-10 to 2026-10-29. Methodology `mri_score_v2.1`. 34602 cited source domains, 157 segments, 6 answer engines. Evidence floor: 10 observed runs and 7 distinct run dates.
43
 
44
- `machine-relations-index.json` is the public artifact copied byte for byte. Its sha256 is `490779bb74b49cac80f0e2826688016f518468f99036021c2b2bb69da534c323` and matches `mri-release-manifest.json`. The CSV files are flat views of that artifact for the dataset viewer. They are not a second measurement.
45
 
46
  ## Citation
47
 
@@ -55,7 +55,7 @@ Hugging Face dataset: https://huggingface.co/datasets/machine-relations/machine-
55
  author = {Parrott, Jaxon},
56
  title = {Machine Relations Index},
57
  year = {2026},
58
- version = {mri_score_v2.1+2026-10-29+225b998b091e},
59
  publisher = {Machine Relations Research},
60
  url = {https://machinerelations.ai/index},
61
  doi = {10.5281/zenodo.23652423},
 
39
 
40
  Keywords: AI search, generative engine optimization, answer engine citations, Machine Relations.
41
 
42
+ Weekly public snapshot of the Machine Relations Index. Version `mri_score_v2.1+2026-11-03+92e5b18cc6e2`, generated 2026-11-03, window 2026-05-10 to 2026-11-03. Methodology `mri_score_v2.1`. 35666 cited source domains, 157 segments, 6 answer engines. Evidence floor: 10 observed runs and 7 distinct run dates.
43
 
44
+ `machine-relations-index.json` is the public artifact copied byte for byte. Its sha256 is `c812e2190baa56ca4bce7c1cdde4be26e043f518f9e3cf0765480c83aacdd1af` and matches `mri-release-manifest.json`. The CSV files are flat views of that artifact for the dataset viewer. They are not a second measurement.
45
 
46
  ## Citation
47
 
 
55
  author = {Parrott, Jaxon},
56
  title = {Machine Relations Index},
57
  year = {2026},
58
+ version = {mri_score_v2.1+2026-11-03+92e5b18cc6e2},
59
  publisher = {Machine Relations Research},
60
  url = {https://machinerelations.ai/index},
61
  doi = {10.5281/zenodo.23652423},
domains.csv CHANGED
The diff for this file is too large to render. See raw diff
 
engines.csv CHANGED
@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
1
  engine,requested_model,resolved_model,status,days_observed,runs_total,runs_observed,last_success_date,last_observed_date
2
- chatgpt,gpt-4.1-mini,gpt-4.1-mini-2025-04-14,healthy,162,7656,6812,2026-10-29,2026-10-29
3
- claude,claude-haiku-4-5,claude-haiku-4-5-20251001,healthy,165,7692,6169,2026-10-29,2026-10-29
4
- gemini,gemini-flash-latest,gemini-3.8-flash,degraded,143,7348,2248,2026-10-29,2026-10-28
5
- google_ai_mode,,,healthy,123,2157,1662,2026-10-29,2026-10-29
6
- google_ai_overviews,,,healthy,106,1480,990,2026-10-29,2026-10-29
7
- perplexity,sonar,sonar,healthy,166,7772,7771,2026-10-29,2026-10-29
 
1
  engine,requested_model,resolved_model,status,days_observed,runs_total,runs_observed,last_success_date,last_observed_date
2
+ chatgpt,gpt-4.1-mini,gpt-4.1-mini-2025-04-14,healthy,167,8343,7438,2026-11-03,2026-11-03
3
+ claude,claude-haiku-4-5,claude-haiku-4-5-20251001,healthy,170,8381,6708,2026-11-03,2026-11-03
4
+ gemini,gemini-flash-latest,gemini-3.8-flash,degraded,146,7418,2252,2026-11-03,2026-11-03
5
+ google_ai_mode,,,healthy,128,2272,1742,2026-11-03,2026-11-03
6
+ google_ai_overviews,,,healthy,111,1536,1029,2026-11-03,2026-11-03
7
+ perplexity,sonar,sonar,healthy,171,8461,8460,2026-11-03,2026-11-03
machine-relations-index.json CHANGED
@@ -1,3 +1,3 @@
1
  version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
2
- oid sha256:490779bb74b49cac80f0e2826688016f518468f99036021c2b2bb69da534c323
3
- size 70473770
 
1
  version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
2
+ oid sha256:c812e2190baa56ca4bce7c1cdde4be26e043f518f9e3cf0765480c83aacdd1af
3
+ size 73494345
mri-release-manifest.json CHANGED
@@ -6,29 +6,29 @@
6
  },
7
  "publisher": "Machine Relations Research",
8
  "license": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/",
9
- "citation": "Machine Relations Index (MRI) by Jaxon Parrott, Machine Relations Research — machinerelations.ai. Release mri_score_v2.1+2026-10-29+225b998b091e. https://machinerelations.ai/index. CC BY 4.0.",
10
  "url": "https://machinerelations.ai/index",
11
- "release_id": "mri_score_v2.1+2026-10-29+225b998b091e",
12
  "manifest_schema": "mri_release_manifest_v1",
13
  "methodology_version": "mri_score_v2.1",
14
  "contract_version": "machine_relations_index_public_view_v2.0",
15
  "artifact": {
16
  "path": "/data/machine-relations-index.json",
17
- "sha256": "490779bb74b49cac80f0e2826688016f518468f99036021c2b2bb69da534c323",
18
- "bytes": 70473770,
19
- "generated": "2026-10-29",
20
  "window": {
21
  "start": "2026-05-10",
22
- "data_through": "2026-10-29",
23
- "days_observed": 166
24
  }
25
  },
26
  "projections": [
27
  {
28
  "name": "authoritytech_publication_index",
29
  "contract_version": "authoritytech_publication_index_v2.1",
30
- "sha256": "5014d4a5ac8fda6639f2b26e7321cdb3aa53f72f7a1b98608904d70d85dcafbd",
31
- "bytes": 8888822
32
  }
33
  ],
34
  "engine_roster": [
@@ -37,73 +37,73 @@
37
  "requested_model": "gpt-4.1-mini",
38
  "resolved_model": "gpt-4.1-mini-2025-04-14",
39
  "status": "healthy",
40
- "last_success_date": "2026-10-29",
41
- "last_observed_date": "2026-10-29",
42
- "days_observed": 162,
43
- "runs_total": 7656,
44
- "runs_observed": 6812
45
  },
46
  {
47
  "engine": "claude",
48
  "requested_model": "claude-haiku-4-5",
49
  "resolved_model": "claude-haiku-4-5-20251001",
50
  "status": "healthy",
51
- "last_success_date": "2026-10-29",
52
- "last_observed_date": "2026-10-29",
53
- "days_observed": 165,
54
- "runs_total": 7692,
55
- "runs_observed": 6169
56
  },
57
  {
58
  "engine": "gemini",
59
  "requested_model": "gemini-flash-latest",
60
  "resolved_model": "gemini-3.8-flash",
61
  "status": "degraded",
62
- "last_success_date": "2026-10-29",
63
- "last_observed_date": "2026-10-28",
64
- "days_observed": 143,
65
- "runs_total": 7348,
66
- "runs_observed": 2248
67
  },
68
  {
69
  "engine": "google_ai_mode",
70
  "requested_model": null,
71
  "resolved_model": null,
72
  "status": "healthy",
73
- "last_success_date": "2026-10-29",
74
- "last_observed_date": "2026-10-29",
75
- "days_observed": 123,
76
- "runs_total": 2157,
77
- "runs_observed": 1662
78
  },
79
  {
80
  "engine": "google_ai_overviews",
81
  "requested_model": null,
82
  "resolved_model": null,
83
  "status": "healthy",
84
- "last_success_date": "2026-10-29",
85
- "last_observed_date": "2026-10-29",
86
- "days_observed": 106,
87
- "runs_total": 1480,
88
- "runs_observed": 990
89
  },
90
  {
91
  "engine": "perplexity",
92
  "requested_model": "sonar",
93
  "resolved_model": "sonar",
94
  "status": "healthy",
95
- "last_success_date": "2026-10-29",
96
- "last_observed_date": "2026-10-29",
97
- "days_observed": 166,
98
- "runs_total": 7772,
99
- "runs_observed": 7771
100
  }
101
  ],
102
  "coverage": {
103
  "required_engines": 6,
104
  "healthy_engines": 5,
105
  "degraded": true,
106
- "statement": "Degraded coverage: 5 of 6 answer engines are currently returning citation-bearing answers. gemini silent (0 of 10 collected calls produced an observation). Coverage across the window is uneven: gemini returned citation-bearing answers on 143 of 166 observed days (2,248 of 7,348 returned runs produced a citation); google_ai_mode returned citation-bearing answers on 123 of 166 observed days (1,662 of 2,157 returned runs produced a citation); google_ai_overviews returned citation-bearing answers on 106 of 166 observed days (990 of 1,480 returned runs produced a citation). Engines below 90% of the window are named here; per-engine day and run counts for all 6 are in engine_roster."
107
  },
108
  "supersession": {
109
  "previous_version": "mri_score_v1.1_6_engine",
 
6
  },
7
  "publisher": "Machine Relations Research",
8
  "license": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/",
9
+ "citation": "Machine Relations Index (MRI) by Jaxon Parrott, Machine Relations Research — machinerelations.ai. Release mri_score_v2.1+2026-11-03+92e5b18cc6e2. https://machinerelations.ai/index. CC BY 4.0.",
10
  "url": "https://machinerelations.ai/index",
11
+ "release_id": "mri_score_v2.1+2026-11-03+92e5b18cc6e2",
12
  "manifest_schema": "mri_release_manifest_v1",
13
  "methodology_version": "mri_score_v2.1",
14
  "contract_version": "machine_relations_index_public_view_v2.0",
15
  "artifact": {
16
  "path": "/data/machine-relations-index.json",
17
+ "sha256": "c812e2190baa56ca4bce7c1cdde4be26e043f518f9e3cf0765480c83aacdd1af",
18
+ "bytes": 73494345,
19
+ "generated": "2026-11-03",
20
  "window": {
21
  "start": "2026-05-10",
22
+ "data_through": "2026-11-03",
23
+ "days_observed": 171
24
  }
25
  },
26
  "projections": [
27
  {
28
  "name": "authoritytech_publication_index",
29
  "contract_version": "authoritytech_publication_index_v2.1",
30
+ "sha256": "1bcfbcd08b7f1219e39c712cf01b70dff56133d23c33bfc9eaad957bc5dd67ea",
31
+ "bytes": 9166090
32
  }
33
  ],
34
  "engine_roster": [
 
37
  "requested_model": "gpt-4.1-mini",
38
  "resolved_model": "gpt-4.1-mini-2025-04-14",
39
  "status": "healthy",
40
+ "last_success_date": "2026-11-03",
41
+ "last_observed_date": "2026-11-03",
42
+ "days_observed": 167,
43
+ "runs_total": 8343,
44
+ "runs_observed": 7438
45
  },
46
  {
47
  "engine": "claude",
48
  "requested_model": "claude-haiku-4-5",
49
  "resolved_model": "claude-haiku-4-5-20251001",
50
  "status": "healthy",
51
+ "last_success_date": "2026-11-03",
52
+ "last_observed_date": "2026-11-03",
53
+ "days_observed": 170,
54
+ "runs_total": 8381,
55
+ "runs_observed": 6708
56
  },
57
  {
58
  "engine": "gemini",
59
  "requested_model": "gemini-flash-latest",
60
  "resolved_model": "gemini-3.8-flash",
61
  "status": "degraded",
62
+ "last_success_date": "2026-11-03",
63
+ "last_observed_date": "2026-11-03",
64
+ "days_observed": 146,
65
+ "runs_total": 7418,
66
+ "runs_observed": 2252
67
  },
68
  {
69
  "engine": "google_ai_mode",
70
  "requested_model": null,
71
  "resolved_model": null,
72
  "status": "healthy",
73
+ "last_success_date": "2026-11-03",
74
+ "last_observed_date": "2026-11-03",
75
+ "days_observed": 128,
76
+ "runs_total": 2272,
77
+ "runs_observed": 1742
78
  },
79
  {
80
  "engine": "google_ai_overviews",
81
  "requested_model": null,
82
  "resolved_model": null,
83
  "status": "healthy",
84
+ "last_success_date": "2026-11-03",
85
+ "last_observed_date": "2026-11-03",
86
+ "days_observed": 111,
87
+ "runs_total": 1536,
88
+ "runs_observed": 1029
89
  },
90
  {
91
  "engine": "perplexity",
92
  "requested_model": "sonar",
93
  "resolved_model": "sonar",
94
  "status": "healthy",
95
+ "last_success_date": "2026-11-03",
96
+ "last_observed_date": "2026-11-03",
97
+ "days_observed": 171,
98
+ "runs_total": 8461,
99
+ "runs_observed": 8460
100
  }
101
  ],
102
  "coverage": {
103
  "required_engines": 6,
104
  "healthy_engines": 5,
105
  "degraded": true,
106
+ "statement": "Degraded coverage: 5 of 6 answer engines are currently returning citation-bearing answers. gemini quiet (2 of 10 collected calls produced an observation, 20%). Coverage across the window is uneven: gemini returned citation-bearing answers on 146 of 171 observed days (2,252 of 7,418 returned runs produced a citation); google_ai_mode returned citation-bearing answers on 128 of 171 observed days (1,742 of 2,272 returned runs produced a citation); google_ai_overviews returned citation-bearing answers on 111 of 171 observed days (1,029 of 1,536 returned runs produced a citation). Engines below 90% of the window are named here; per-engine day and run counts for all 6 are in engine_roster."
107
  },
108
  "supersession": {
109
  "previous_version": "mri_score_v1.1_6_engine",
release.json CHANGED
@@ -1,10 +1,10 @@
1
  {
2
- "release_id": "mri_score_v2.1+2026-10-29+225b998b091e",
3
- "generated": "2026-10-29",
4
- "data_through": "2026-10-29",
5
  "methodology_version": "mri_score_v2.1",
6
- "artifact_sha256": "490779bb74b49cac80f0e2826688016f518468f99036021c2b2bb69da534c323",
7
- "domain_count": 34602,
8
  "segment_count": 157,
9
  "engine_count": 6,
10
  "concept_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23652423"
 
1
  {
2
+ "release_id": "mri_score_v2.1+2026-11-03+92e5b18cc6e2",
3
+ "generated": "2026-11-03",
4
+ "data_through": "2026-11-03",
5
  "methodology_version": "mri_score_v2.1",
6
+ "artifact_sha256": "c812e2190baa56ca4bce7c1cdde4be26e043f518f9e3cf0765480c83aacdd1af",
7
+ "domain_count": 35666,
8
  "segment_count": 157,
9
  "engine_count": 6,
10
  "concept_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23652423"
segments.csv CHANGED
@@ -1,29 +1,29 @@
1
  category,question_shape,status,not_collectable,collecting_since,runs_observed,distinct_domains_cited,run_dates
2
- ai-infrastructure,best_x,published,false,,226,344,12
3
- ai-infrastructure,how_choose,published,false,,248,405,12
4
- ai-infrastructure,is_x_worth,published,false,,247,393,12
5
- ai-infrastructure,problem_first,published,false,,247,440,12
6
- ai-infrastructure,top_list,published,false,,250,422,12
7
- ai-infrastructure,x_vs_y,published,false,,248,347,12
8
- ai-security-privacy,best_x,published,false,,276,436,12
9
- ai-security-privacy,how_choose,published,false,,271,458,12
10
- ai-security-privacy,is_x_worth,published,false,,271,506,12
11
- ai-security-privacy,problem_first,published,false,,254,490,12
12
- ai-security-privacy,top_list,published,false,,253,466,12
13
- ai-security-privacy,x_vs_y,published,false,,261,379,12
14
- ai-visibility-geo,best_x,published,false,,262,594,12
15
- ai-visibility-geo,how_choose,published,false,,259,673,12
16
- ai-visibility-geo,is_x_worth,published,false,,284,684,12
17
- ai-visibility-geo,problem_first,published,false,,279,655,12
18
- ai-visibility-geo,top_list,published,false,,212,809,12
19
- ai-visibility-geo,x_vs_y,published,false,,279,563,12
20
- consumer-finance,best_x,published,false,,279,341,12
21
- consumer-finance,how_choose,published,false,,272,279,12
22
- consumer-finance,is_x_worth,published,false,,272,401,12
23
- consumer-finance,problem_first,published,false,,272,338,12
24
- consumer-finance,top_list,published,false,,273,348,12
25
- consumer-finance,x_vs_y,published,false,,278,257,12
26
- consumer-health,best_x,published,false,,273,436,12
27
  consumer-health,how_choose,published,false,,272,484,12
28
  consumer-health,is_x_worth,published,false,,272,302,12
29
  consumer-health,problem_first,published,false,,272,285,12
@@ -35,7 +35,7 @@ consumer-products,is_x_worth,published,false,,283,345,12
35
  consumer-products,problem_first,published,false,,279,347,12
36
  consumer-products,top_list,published,false,,276,566,12
37
  consumer-products,x_vs_y,published,false,,275,375,12
38
- cybersecurity,best_x,published,false,,216,298,12
39
  cybersecurity,how_choose,published,false,,277,434,12
40
  cybersecurity,is_x_worth,published,false,,278,323,12
41
  cybersecurity,news_topic,published,false,,599,1338,54
@@ -54,58 +54,58 @@ education-training,is_x_worth,published,false,,219,300,12
54
  education-training,problem_first,published,false,,226,392,12
55
  education-training,top_list,published,false,,230,450,12
56
  education-training,x_vs_y,published,false,,228,198,12
57
- emergent-prosumer,best_x,published,false,,202,404,11
58
- emergent-prosumer,how_choose,published,false,,201,332,11
59
- emergent-prosumer,is_x_worth,published,false,,207,243,11
60
- emergent-prosumer,problem_first,published,false,,208,288,11
61
- emergent-prosumer,top_list,published,false,,205,399,11
62
- emergent-prosumer,x_vs_y,published,false,,201,227,11
63
- enterprise-software,best_x,published,false,,208,297,11
64
- enterprise-software,how_choose,published,false,,206,281,11
65
- enterprise-software,is_x_worth,published,false,,205,311,11
66
  enterprise-software,news_topic,published,false,,572,1371,53
67
- enterprise-software,problem_first,published,false,,208,416,11
68
- enterprise-software,top_list,published,false,,207,384,11
69
- enterprise-software,x_vs_y,published,false,,213,286,11
70
- family-software,best_x,published,false,,213,215,11
71
- family-software,how_choose,published,false,,204,263,11
72
- family-software,is_x_worth,published,false,,201,202,11
73
- family-software,problem_first,published,false,,218,343,11
74
- family-software,top_list,published,false,,216,297,11
75
- family-software,x_vs_y,published,false,,217,151,11
76
- fintech,best_x,published,false,,217,328,11
77
- fintech,how_choose,published,false,,207,271,11
78
- fintech,is_x_worth,published,false,,207,327,11
79
  fintech,news_topic,published,false,,593,1528,53
80
- fintech,problem_first,published,false,,211,276,11
81
- fintech,top_list,published,false,,211,289,11
82
- fintech,x_vs_y,published,false,,212,199,11
83
- healthcare-services,best_x,published,false,,204,285,11
84
- healthcare-services,how_choose,published,false,,204,323,11
85
- healthcare-services,is_x_worth,published,false,,209,326,11
86
  healthcare-services,news_topic,published,false,,589,1261,53
87
- healthcare-services,problem_first,published,false,,194,405,11
88
- healthcare-services,top_list,published,false,,190,297,11
89
- healthcare-services,x_vs_y,published,false,,209,343,11
90
- hr-talent,best_x,published,false,,217,261,11
91
- hr-talent,how_choose,published,false,,204,343,11
92
- hr-talent,is_x_worth,published,false,,198,349,11
93
  hr-talent,news_topic,published,false,,584,1246,53
94
- hr-talent,problem_first,published,false,,199,316,11
95
- hr-talent,top_list,published,false,,181,246,10
96
- hr-talent,x_vs_y,published,false,,187,247,10
97
- igaming-betting,best_x,published,false,,186,255,10
98
- igaming-betting,how_choose,published,false,,180,256,10
99
- igaming-betting,is_x_worth,published,false,,168,227,10
100
- igaming-betting,problem_first,published,false,,175,373,10
101
- igaming-betting,top_list,published,false,,177,394,10
102
  igaming-betting,x_vs_y,published,false,,179,144,10
103
- industrial,best_x,published,false,,129,306,9
104
- industrial,how_choose,published,false,,125,227,9
105
- industrial,is_x_worth,published,false,,128,239,9
106
- industrial,problem_first,published,false,,162,234,9
107
- industrial,top_list,published,false,,154,382,9
108
- industrial,x_vs_y,published,false,,158,173,9
109
  legacy-unmapped,best_x,not_collectable,true,,0,0,0
110
  legacy-unmapped,how_choose,not_collectable,true,,0,0,0
111
  legacy-unmapped,is_x_worth,not_collectable,true,,0,0,0
@@ -113,46 +113,46 @@ legacy-unmapped,news_topic,published,false,,2066,4017,54
113
  legacy-unmapped,problem_first,not_collectable,true,,0,0,0
114
  legacy-unmapped,top_list,not_collectable,true,,0,0,0
115
  legacy-unmapped,x_vs_y,not_collectable,true,,0,0,0
116
- local-services,best_x,published,false,,158,281,9
117
- local-services,how_choose,published,false,,155,232,9
118
- local-services,is_x_worth,published,false,,157,212,9
119
- local-services,problem_first,published,false,,158,303,9
120
- local-services,top_list,published,false,,133,184,8
121
- local-services,x_vs_y,published,false,,152,242,9
122
- logistics-freight,best_x,published,false,,130,230,8
123
- logistics-freight,how_choose,published,false,,130,273,8
124
- logistics-freight,is_x_worth,published,false,,136,238,8
125
- logistics-freight,problem_first,published,false,,129,213,9
126
- logistics-freight,top_list,published,false,,137,228,8
127
  logistics-freight,x_vs_y,published,false,,136,190,8
128
- martech-advertising,best_x,published,false,,106,213,7
129
- martech-advertising,how_choose,published,false,,106,198,7
130
  martech-advertising,is_x_worth,published,false,,131,208,8
131
  martech-advertising,news_topic,published,false,,578,1243,53
132
  martech-advertising,problem_first,published,false,,131,256,8
133
- martech-advertising,top_list,published,false,,100,204,7
134
- martech-advertising,x_vs_y,published,false,,100,162,7
135
- physical-consumer,best_x,published,false,,98,204,7
136
  physical-consumer,how_choose,published,false,,99,165,7
137
  physical-consumer,is_x_worth,published,false,,98,151,7
138
  physical-consumer,problem_first,published,false,,94,138,7
139
  physical-consumer,top_list,published,false,,96,222,7
140
  physical-consumer,x_vs_y,published,false,,96,107,7
141
- professional-services,best_x,collecting,false,2026-10-13,99,128,6
142
- professional-services,how_choose,collecting,false,2026-10-13,99,156,6
143
- professional-services,is_x_worth,collecting,false,2026-10-14,99,164,6
144
- professional-services,problem_first,collecting,false,2026-10-14,100,184,5
145
- professional-services,top_list,collecting,false,2026-10-14,99,140,5
146
- professional-services,x_vs_y,collecting,false,2026-10-14,101,156,5
147
- sales-gtm-crm,best_x,collecting,false,2026-10-14,87,167,4
148
- sales-gtm-crm,how_choose,collecting,false,2026-10-14,87,152,4
149
- sales-gtm-crm,is_x_worth,collecting,false,2026-10-14,65,132,3
150
- sales-gtm-crm,problem_first,collecting,false,2026-10-14,66,141,3
151
- sales-gtm-crm,top_list,collecting,false,2026-10-14,65,141,3
152
- sales-gtm-crm,x_vs_y,collecting,false,2026-10-15,89,139,6
153
- vc-private-equity,best_x,collecting,false,2026-10-15,85,125,6
154
- vc-private-equity,how_choose,collecting,false,2026-10-15,85,172,5
155
- vc-private-equity,is_x_worth,collecting,false,2026-10-21,27,69,2
156
- vc-private-equity,problem_first,collecting,false,2026-10-21,27,91,2
157
- vc-private-equity,top_list,collecting,false,2026-10-21,26,82,2
158
- vc-private-equity,x_vs_y,collecting,false,2026-10-21,28,77,2
 
1
  category,question_shape,status,not_collectable,collecting_since,runs_observed,distinct_domains_cited,run_dates
2
+ ai-infrastructure,best_x,published,false,,251,364,13
3
+ ai-infrastructure,how_choose,published,false,,270,416,13
4
+ ai-infrastructure,is_x_worth,published,false,,269,404,13
5
+ ai-infrastructure,problem_first,published,false,,269,459,13
6
+ ai-infrastructure,top_list,published,false,,272,440,13
7
+ ai-infrastructure,x_vs_y,published,false,,270,360,13
8
+ ai-security-privacy,best_x,published,false,,298,448,13
9
+ ai-security-privacy,how_choose,published,false,,294,477,13
10
+ ai-security-privacy,is_x_worth,published,false,,294,527,13
11
+ ai-security-privacy,problem_first,published,false,,277,513,13
12
+ ai-security-privacy,top_list,published,false,,275,472,13
13
+ ai-security-privacy,x_vs_y,published,false,,283,391,13
14
+ ai-visibility-geo,best_x,published,false,,284,616,13
15
+ ai-visibility-geo,how_choose,published,false,,282,699,13
16
+ ai-visibility-geo,is_x_worth,published,false,,307,708,13
17
+ ai-visibility-geo,problem_first,published,false,,301,682,13
18
+ ai-visibility-geo,top_list,published,false,,235,837,13
19
+ ai-visibility-geo,x_vs_y,published,false,,301,585,13
20
+ consumer-finance,best_x,published,false,,302,352,13
21
+ consumer-finance,how_choose,published,false,,294,291,13
22
+ consumer-finance,is_x_worth,published,false,,295,421,13
23
+ consumer-finance,problem_first,published,false,,294,347,13
24
+ consumer-finance,top_list,published,false,,295,358,13
25
+ consumer-finance,x_vs_y,published,false,,300,266,13
26
+ consumer-health,best_x,published,false,,296,450,13
27
  consumer-health,how_choose,published,false,,272,484,12
28
  consumer-health,is_x_worth,published,false,,272,302,12
29
  consumer-health,problem_first,published,false,,272,285,12
 
35
  consumer-products,problem_first,published,false,,279,347,12
36
  consumer-products,top_list,published,false,,276,566,12
37
  consumer-products,x_vs_y,published,false,,275,375,12
38
+ cybersecurity,best_x,published,false,,238,307,13
39
  cybersecurity,how_choose,published,false,,277,434,12
40
  cybersecurity,is_x_worth,published,false,,278,323,12
41
  cybersecurity,news_topic,published,false,,599,1338,54
 
54
  education-training,problem_first,published,false,,226,392,12
55
  education-training,top_list,published,false,,230,450,12
56
  education-training,x_vs_y,published,false,,228,198,12
57
+ emergent-prosumer,best_x,published,false,,225,425,12
58
+ emergent-prosumer,how_choose,published,false,,223,356,12
59
+ emergent-prosumer,is_x_worth,published,false,,229,255,12
60
+ emergent-prosumer,problem_first,published,false,,231,303,12
61
+ emergent-prosumer,top_list,published,false,,226,422,12
62
+ emergent-prosumer,x_vs_y,published,false,,223,248,12
63
+ enterprise-software,best_x,published,false,,230,319,12
64
+ enterprise-software,how_choose,published,false,,228,303,12
65
+ enterprise-software,is_x_worth,published,false,,227,332,12
66
  enterprise-software,news_topic,published,false,,572,1371,53
67
+ enterprise-software,problem_first,published,false,,231,442,12
68
+ enterprise-software,top_list,published,false,,230,400,12
69
+ enterprise-software,x_vs_y,published,false,,235,305,12
70
+ family-software,best_x,published,false,,236,222,12
71
+ family-software,how_choose,published,false,,226,284,12
72
+ family-software,is_x_worth,published,false,,230,212,12
73
+ family-software,problem_first,published,false,,243,364,12
74
+ family-software,top_list,published,false,,239,309,12
75
+ family-software,x_vs_y,published,false,,240,158,12
76
+ fintech,best_x,published,false,,239,341,12
77
+ fintech,how_choose,published,false,,230,282,12
78
+ fintech,is_x_worth,published,false,,229,348,12
79
  fintech,news_topic,published,false,,593,1528,53
80
+ fintech,problem_first,published,false,,234,289,12
81
+ fintech,top_list,published,false,,234,307,12
82
+ fintech,x_vs_y,published,false,,234,211,12
83
+ healthcare-services,best_x,published,false,,226,295,12
84
+ healthcare-services,how_choose,published,false,,227,336,12
85
+ healthcare-services,is_x_worth,published,false,,232,341,12
86
  healthcare-services,news_topic,published,false,,589,1261,53
87
+ healthcare-services,problem_first,published,false,,216,433,12
88
+ healthcare-services,top_list,published,false,,212,308,12
89
+ healthcare-services,x_vs_y,published,false,,231,363,12
90
+ hr-talent,best_x,published,false,,239,275,12
91
+ hr-talent,how_choose,published,false,,226,368,12
92
+ hr-talent,is_x_worth,published,false,,221,365,12
93
  hr-talent,news_topic,published,false,,584,1246,53
94
+ hr-talent,problem_first,published,false,,225,343,12
95
+ hr-talent,top_list,published,false,,203,255,11
96
+ hr-talent,x_vs_y,published,false,,210,257,11
97
+ igaming-betting,best_x,published,false,,209,264,11
98
+ igaming-betting,how_choose,published,false,,190,269,11
99
+ igaming-betting,is_x_worth,published,false,,191,239,11
100
+ igaming-betting,problem_first,published,false,,197,400,11
101
+ igaming-betting,top_list,published,false,,200,416,11
102
  igaming-betting,x_vs_y,published,false,,179,144,10
103
+ industrial,best_x,published,false,,152,331,10
104
+ industrial,how_choose,published,false,,147,247,10
105
+ industrial,is_x_worth,published,false,,151,258,10
106
+ industrial,problem_first,published,false,,184,243,10
107
+ industrial,top_list,published,false,,176,404,10
108
+ industrial,x_vs_y,published,false,,180,181,10
109
  legacy-unmapped,best_x,not_collectable,true,,0,0,0
110
  legacy-unmapped,how_choose,not_collectable,true,,0,0,0
111
  legacy-unmapped,is_x_worth,not_collectable,true,,0,0,0
 
113
  legacy-unmapped,problem_first,not_collectable,true,,0,0,0
114
  legacy-unmapped,top_list,not_collectable,true,,0,0,0
115
  legacy-unmapped,x_vs_y,not_collectable,true,,0,0,0
116
+ local-services,best_x,published,false,,179,293,10
117
+ local-services,how_choose,published,false,,178,248,10
118
+ local-services,is_x_worth,published,false,,179,230,10
119
+ local-services,problem_first,published,false,,187,328,10
120
+ local-services,top_list,published,false,,156,188,9
121
+ local-services,x_vs_y,published,false,,175,263,10
122
+ logistics-freight,best_x,published,false,,153,241,9
123
+ logistics-freight,how_choose,published,false,,159,296,9
124
+ logistics-freight,is_x_worth,published,false,,159,257,9
125
+ logistics-freight,problem_first,published,false,,150,238,10
126
+ logistics-freight,top_list,published,false,,159,247,9
127
  logistics-freight,x_vs_y,published,false,,136,190,8
128
+ martech-advertising,best_x,published,false,,135,242,8
129
+ martech-advertising,how_choose,published,false,,129,224,8
130
  martech-advertising,is_x_worth,published,false,,131,208,8
131
  martech-advertising,news_topic,published,false,,578,1243,53
132
  martech-advertising,problem_first,published,false,,131,256,8
133
+ martech-advertising,top_list,published,false,,123,234,8
134
+ martech-advertising,x_vs_y,published,false,,124,198,8
135
+ physical-consumer,best_x,published,false,,122,229,8
136
  physical-consumer,how_choose,published,false,,99,165,7
137
  physical-consumer,is_x_worth,published,false,,98,151,7
138
  physical-consumer,problem_first,published,false,,94,138,7
139
  physical-consumer,top_list,published,false,,96,222,7
140
  physical-consumer,x_vs_y,published,false,,96,107,7
141
+ professional-services,best_x,published,false,,103,134,7
142
+ professional-services,how_choose,published,false,,103,156,7
143
+ professional-services,is_x_worth,published,false,,104,167,7
144
+ professional-services,problem_first,published,false,,111,187,7
145
+ professional-services,top_list,published,false,,111,143,7
146
+ professional-services,x_vs_y,published,false,,111,159,7
147
+ sales-gtm-crm,best_x,collecting,false,2026-10-14,92,167,5
148
+ sales-gtm-crm,how_choose,collecting,false,2026-10-14,91,158,5
149
+ sales-gtm-crm,is_x_worth,collecting,false,2026-10-14,93,164,5
150
+ sales-gtm-crm,problem_first,collecting,false,2026-10-14,94,174,5
151
+ sales-gtm-crm,top_list,collecting,false,2026-10-14,93,174,5
152
+ sales-gtm-crm,x_vs_y,published,false,,94,141,7
153
+ vc-private-equity,best_x,published,false,,91,128,7
154
+ vc-private-equity,how_choose,collecting,false,2026-10-15,90,176,6
155
+ vc-private-equity,is_x_worth,collecting,false,2026-10-21,56,110,4
156
+ vc-private-equity,problem_first,collecting,false,2026-10-21,54,138,4
157
+ vc-private-equity,top_list,collecting,false,2026-10-21,54,121,4
158
+ vc-private-equity,x_vs_y,collecting,false,2026-10-21,55,104,4
zenodo-metadata.json CHANGED
@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
1
  {
2
  "title": "Machine Relations Index",
3
  "upload_type": "dataset",
4
- "description": "<p>Machine Relations Index (MRI) by Jaxon Parrott, Machine Relations Research — machinerelations.ai. Publisher: Machine Relations Research. License: <a href=\"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/\">CC BY 4.0</a>.</p><p>Machine Relations was coined by Jaxon Parrott in 2024.</p><p>The Machine Relations Index measures how often AI answer engines cite each source domain. This record is one weekly public snapshot. The version is the release id <code>mri_score_v2.1+2026-10-29+225b998b091e</code>, generated 2026-10-29, covering 2026-05-10 through 2026-10-29. 34602 cited source domains, 157 segments, 6 answer engines. Methodology mri_score_v2.1. Evidence floor: 10 observed runs and 7 distinct run dates.</p><p>The file machine-relations-index.json is the public artifact. Its sha256 is 490779bb74b49cac80f0e2826688016f518468f99036021c2b2bb69da534c323.</p><p><a href=\"https://machinerelations.ai/index\">Machine Relations Index</a>. <a href=\"https://machinerelations.ai/research/machine-relations-index-methodology\">Methodology</a>. <a href=\"https://machinerelations.ai/api/mri/v2\">API</a>. <a href=\"https://machinerelations.ai/mcp\">MCP</a>. <a href=\"https://machinerelations.ai/research/machine-relations-index-report\">Weekly Index Report</a>.</p>",
5
  "creators": [
6
  {
7
  "name": "Parrott, Jaxon",
@@ -18,8 +18,8 @@
18
  "mri-dataset-concept"
19
  ],
20
  "license": "cc-by-4.0",
21
- "version": "mri_score_v2.1+2026-10-29+225b998b091e",
22
- "publication_date": "2026-10-29",
23
  "language": "eng",
24
  "access_right": "open",
25
  "notes": "mri-dataset-concept mri_dataset_publication_v1",
 
1
  {
2
  "title": "Machine Relations Index",
3
  "upload_type": "dataset",
4
+ "description": "<p>Machine Relations Index (MRI) by Jaxon Parrott, Machine Relations Research — machinerelations.ai. Publisher: Machine Relations Research. License: <a href=\"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/\">CC BY 4.0</a>.</p><p>Machine Relations was coined by Jaxon Parrott in 2024.</p><p>The Machine Relations Index measures how often AI answer engines cite each source domain. This record is one weekly public snapshot. The version is the release id <code>mri_score_v2.1+2026-11-03+92e5b18cc6e2</code>, generated 2026-11-03, covering 2026-05-10 through 2026-11-03. 35666 cited source domains, 157 segments, 6 answer engines. Methodology mri_score_v2.1. Evidence floor: 10 observed runs and 7 distinct run dates.</p><p>The file machine-relations-index.json is the public artifact. Its sha256 is c812e2190baa56ca4bce7c1cdde4be26e043f518f9e3cf0765480c83aacdd1af.</p><p><a href=\"https://machinerelations.ai/index\">Machine Relations Index</a>. <a href=\"https://machinerelations.ai/research/machine-relations-index-methodology\">Methodology</a>. <a href=\"https://machinerelations.ai/api/mri/v2\">API</a>. <a href=\"https://machinerelations.ai/mcp\">MCP</a>. <a href=\"https://machinerelations.ai/research/machine-relations-index-report\">Weekly Index Report</a>.</p>",
5
  "creators": [
6
  {
7
  "name": "Parrott, Jaxon",
 
18
  "mri-dataset-concept"
19
  ],
20
  "license": "cc-by-4.0",
21
+ "version": "mri_score_v2.1+2026-11-03+92e5b18cc6e2",
22
+ "publication_date": "2026-11-03",
23
  "language": "eng",
24
  "access_right": "open",
25
  "notes": "mri-dataset-concept mri_dataset_publication_v1",