instruction
stringlengths
31
24.5k
The Wikipedia entry on zero suggests that the ancient Greeks were unsure about the ontological status of zero. They asked themselves, 'How can nothing be something?' whereas in Buddhism, Sunyata or void appears to have positive value (not in an arithmetic sense, but in the sense of beneficial). Is there any evidence th...
Nietschze criticised Christianity for espousing slave morality. How true is this? Given that Christianity became the religion of the ruling classes, isn't it more correct to say that slave morality is espoused by the ruling classes, not for themselves, but for the ruled? After all, if Nietschze was correct, then in tod...
Although, I can conceive of a potentially infinite amount of time ahead of me, for it is not actual as it remains to be experienced, I can't conceive of a potentially infinite amount of time behind me, for having been experienced it is actual, and being actual it is finite, as I can't conceive of actual infinities. He...
In modern logic there is often talked about possible worlds. I understand this idea in this way: Every proposition may be true or false. Possible world W is a set of all propositions where there is not logical contradiction among them. And the set P of all W is the possible worlds set. Could you describe a few core ide...
When interpreting any author, it is crucial to understand his terms. Reading The Book on Adler (sometimes titled Concerning Authority and Revelation), I have come to understand that the essentially Christian (which I take to be equivalent to "the essence of Christianity") is a key phrase for Kierkegaard. But what does ...
I think I recall reading in Peter Singer's "Animal Liberation" that humans, by nature, have a Continuous Moral Improvement. This was in reference to how sexism and racism are become less common, and how this could one day be the case for speciesism. However, there was another, related term used by Singer to express the...
So basically I came through this fallacious argument/image: . Which translates into: Without stress Without bombs Without beggars Without prisons Without junk food Without external debt Without contamination Without poverty And they call me PRIMITIVE The thing is that (without trying to be racist), ...
Gert-Jan C. Lokhorst has written a paper on "computational metaethics" (Computational Meta-Ethics: Towards the Meta-Ethical Robot), which explores the ability of formal systems (i.e. computers/robots) to reason about ethics. I'm wondering if there are other sources which discuss this. Particularly, are there any which ...
Who were the influential philosophers during the Middle Ages? We speak of Plato, Aristotle, Nietzsche, Machiavelli, etc... but were there any philosophers during the Middle Ages that were significantly influential and important to the history of philosophy? If so, please specify their contributions to philosophy.
I am reading a paper on Hobbes interpretation of patriarchy, which says hobbes patriarchy is non paternal, i.e. he proposes a patriarchal right that is different from paternal right? What is the exact difference between the two?
I read Pinker's How the Mind Works a few years back, and a thought occurred to me that I couldn't find in the two serious reviews (Fodor and somebody else, I forget)I dredged up afterwards. If one's brain is made up of modules- substructures specialised by evolution to process different data, does that imply that cert...
According to Hobbes, Passions are identified as those interior beginnings of motion, by which the imagination eventually motivates us to action. He then describes various emotions such as glory, humility and misery as some passions. How can we define love and compassion, as a passion? Can it be related to the idea of f...
I'm currently in a class where we are studying, among other things, the philosophy of perception. The papers we have read so far, for example Grice's "The Causal Theory of Perception" and Strawson's "Perception and it's Objects," emphasize a very subjective, observer centered theory of perception. The viewpoint I am t...
Think of the most complex number you can. Say a surd like pi. What does it explain, exactly? How complex is the ratio of the circumfrence to the diameter of a circle? I think numbers can describe relationships, which is why you need formula of multiple variables. A single number doesn't describe a relationship. Onl...
Several prominent futurologists and technologists, most importantly Kurzweil and Moravec, have projected varying timelines for a forthcoming technological singularity in the next century or even few decades. Assuming, perhaps naively, that we take them at their word, what might be some of the most significant, crucial ...
I think I've found a paralelism between these two notions, at least to some extent. For Kant defines (in Logic, I, I, §1, also translated) concept as "an universal representation" Every knowledge, i.e. every representation referred with consciousness toward an object, are either intuititions [Anschauungen] or concepts...
What is the difference between naturalism and materialism, if any? I see definitions of naturalism that say, in effect, it is the belief that there is no supernatural. But what is the supernatural other than that which is not natural, which seems circular. If you try to define natural without being circular, won't it...
I'm really interested in Philosophy and want to learn more, so I'd like to read the main bodies of work that have built up the discipline of Philosophy. The reason being that if I read a modern text that is discussing well established ideas and arguments previously rasied by other philosphers I will know what those ol...
In an answer to this question I made the rather bold speculation that if the Turing Test is taken to be our defining criterion of a consciousness of human level, then all questions in the ethics of simulated minds can be reduced to human equivalents with a canonical reformulation. To put it another way: Mary and Siri l...
Chalmers famously argues in Facing Up to the Problem of Consciousness: At the end of the day, the same criticism applies to any purely physical account of consciousness. For any physical process we specify there will be an unanswered question: Why should this process give rise to experience? Given any such process, it...
In presenting his coherence theory of justification BonJour appeals to what he calls the “Observation Requirement.” Bonjour’s observation requirement is the notion that there are some kinds of justified beliefs that are spontaneous and come from our system of beliefs. If the spontaneous belief is not coherent with the ...
Please read the short story here:Beam me up First, I'd like to to know whether there is anything inherently inconsistent about this teletransportation idea? Is there fundamental reasons which say it's impossible in principle? If not, what seems puzzling and absurd to me is this: What matters to him is that, as far as ...
When I say totally random, I mean absolutely random, not pseudorandom. If I want to say "totally random" numbers such as 1,26,17,4,1 and 27, although I see them to be totally random, they aren't. These are numbers that I think are influenced by my childhood, ideology and everything that I've seen. So, what do you think...
After Richard Rorty died, Raymond Geuss wrote some recollections of their encounters. In his reminiscence, Geuss mentions that Rorty projected teaching an undergraduate course called "An Alternate History of Modern Philosophy". The idea was that the course would teach philosophy from the Middle Ages to the early twen...
This is something that has irked me for quite some time, especially since I come from a mathematically oriented background. Can the field of Philosophy be formalised in the sense that Mathematics is formalised? It doesn't necessarily have to be an axiomatic formalisation, but can we find some universal agreement? If no...
Some believe that murder is only committed due to an emotional or moral action, but can you ever justify it with reason?
Throughout his works, Nietzsche conveys great praise for the Jewish people. However, he obviously does not admire the consequences of their accomplishments. In the first essay of On the Genealogy of Morals, section 7, he asserts: All that has been done on earth against "the noble," "the powerful," "the masters," "the ...
I'm looking for questions and ideas that are seen as unresolved in philosophy. I guess nothing is actually resolved. But I mean things that are generally understood to not have been sufficiently answered. For example, in "50 Big Ideas", Ben Dupré writes: "Aristotle recognized the dangers inherent in Plato's strict divi...
There is a growing movement for the bestowing certain non-human species with legal rights of a person. What might be some of the most significant or important philosophical arguments in favor of such a policy? My understanding of the problem is that the growing body of scientific evidence about non-human intelligence a...
I am writing a scientific essay and I need to name the whole, unknown universe, including both the reality (that we perceive) and the rest, the things we know and don't know or will never know. The word "universe" is already taken. I thought there might be some other professional term to name what I have on my mind (an...
Similar to Which of Kant's writings would be a good introduction to his work? I've been planning to read some of Nietzsche's work for a while, but have no idea where to start. Which of his writings would be a good initial introduction to his philosophical views? Should I try one of his writings or perhaps a summary/cri...
Possible Duplicate: Do we know whether we know something? I have come across this idea a few times now that knowing does not imply knowing that you know. However, I am having troubled understanding how this could be true given the criteria of knowledge my philosophy professor has laid out. Namely, that it is a) true...
It strikes me that atheists often in the religion debate will try to characterize religion in a funny or silly way, often comparing religion to belief in fairies or unicorns or flying spaghetti monsters. Is this a valid debating technique? Does reductio ad absurdum have any logical justification behind it?
I have read a lot of websites that suggest Socrates was a fictional character created by Plato (albeit without the citation of any corroborating evidence), but I have also read the opposite (and by "opposite" here I don't mean that Plato was created by Socrates but rather that Socrates was a living, breathing person). ...
Towards the beginning of a course on knowledge (we were reading the beginning of Theaetetus) we discussed definitions and what a definition or rather a good definition is. I'd like to know more about definability. Is there a particular word/concept/notion that has been undefinable? I know that every language must have ...
In a chat on Mathematics.SE about countability of infinite sets, someone responded that regarding the 'counting', infinite in mathematics does not mean uncountable, but means 'not finite'. Can someone explain the difference between these concepts? [edit] Do Not Respond to The Clarification Below (It will elicit a discu...
Philosophy.SE, this is my first time being here, hence please pardon my inexperience of phrasing the question. I was discussing the moral philosophy of Kant vs the moral philosophy of the Christian religion on "doing good things" and such with one of my Christian friends. I myself adhere to Kant's views due to my early...
My philosophy teacher and I are having a little disagreement regarding The Prince: He argues that although the book's context is a letter to Lorenzo de' Medici advising him and recommending a course of action to unite Italy, ultimately this is just a "cloak" for an almost purely ethical argument. My teacher believes th...
In today's mathematics, we have many variants of logic (propositional, first order, higher order, fuzzy logic, etc.). These are all self-consistent formal systems that are based on some set of axioms. In Wittgenstein's Tractatus, he demands a logical structure for thoughts and basically says that only sentences that mi...
By tradition, the problem that dictates where our knowledge is derived divides from two philosophical circles; those who affirm that our knowledge of the world comes from our senses, such as David Hume, an empiricist, and those who proclaim that it is only through reason that one can find truths about the world, such a...
Nozick agrees that the Gettier counterexamples to the JTB analysis of knowledge are cases where someone has a JTB but does not know. What is his explanation of what has gone wrong in those cases? Specifically what conditions in Nozick’s account of knowledge are not satisfied?
Plato's Republic famously describes the decay of the regimes, a process by which a society decays from the best regime, that of aristocracy, to the lowest, that of tyranny. However, the purpose of this concept of regimes is to expand upon Plato's extensive analogy of the city; he uses his "city in speech" to explain th...
To make a long story short, Bishop Berkeley argued that the idea of matter existing independently of perception was incoherent, since the properties of matter are (or were in Berkeley's time) defined in perceptual terms such as hardness, redness, etc. Hence, Berkeley's conclusion that "to be is to be perceived." O...
If I recall correctly, analyzing a concept in ordinary-language philosophy involved taking inventory on how the term for the concept is used by the speakers of the language across contexts, thus revealing a family of related concepts for which the word stands. At first blush, this methodology doesn't seem to leave m...
I have studied a little Philosophy and done a lot of thinking about moral duty, individualism and communities. I have come to the belief that it is one person's duty to assist the community event at risk to himself. This doesn't include dying or suicide, because I believe in Kant's definition of intrinsic dignity that ...
Hiliary Putnam's Twin Earth thought experiment goes like this: We begin by supposing that elsewhere in the universe there is a planet exactly like earth in virtually all respects, which we refer to as ‘Twin Earth’. (We should also suppose that the relevant surroundings [are exactly the same as for] earth; it revolves...
Regarding the Fake Barn counterexample to the causal theory of knowing I heard that Gilbert Harman's response is to deny that there are fake barns at all, is this correct? Does anyone have a link to a paper? I can't find a source for this anywhere.
I need to understand if implying something, knowingly or unknowingly, is the same as asserting it. I also need to understand if it is merely semantics or there is a philosophical rigor to it. EDIT: For example, suppose I go on about how smoking cigarettes causes cancer and such fatalities, without ever saying explicit...
What does Hilary Putnam mean by this? Imagine a situation in which the problem is not to determine if the partner is really a person or a machine, but is rather to determine if the partner uses the words to referas we do. The obvious test is, again, to carry on a conversation, and, if no problems arise, if the ...
Famously Descartes said 'Cogito ergo sum'. I'm a bit puzzled by this. I do not need to think in order to assert/understand/intuit that I exist: when I wake up in the morning I immediately intuit that I exist. I see this understanding as a form of inner experience. I can imagine myself as a bat, and as a bat, I do not ...
Is there perhaps a word or phrase that describes negative selfless behavior? Generic Behavior: If a person looks after the needs of others to such an extent that their own needs are not met then not only will their own well-being suffer but over time this person will also fail to take care of the needs of other...
The works of the Marquis de Sade were suppressed by the mid-19th century, but were floating around Europe in samizdat form until the mid-20th century, when they were published and circulated above ground. These semi-pornographic works promote a philosophy of negative Christianity, but invert the Christian ideas of mora...
According to Marx, in capitalism, what role does the state play? Is it independent of the economy? Also, does the exploitation of the proletariat by the bourgeoisie, have anything to do with the state or government?
I took a class in Kierkegaard and it was represented that Kierkegaard's use of pseudonyms was highly significant. Either he meant what he said, or he was being ironic, or something else entirely. Is there an academic consensus forming around the meaning behind the pseudonyms, or were the pseudonyms just something peo...
When I was reading Kant's Critique, I got the sense that he'd sort of found a formula for calling something a dimension. Space seems to arise out of an infinity of extension. Time seems to arise from an infinity of duration. More recently, with fractal geometry, it seems like there's another kind of infinity: compl...
Let's first define nothing as the absence of something. Not talking about universe here. How early on do we grasp this concept of nothing? Are there people who get old without that basic understanding? Now, let's define nothing as the absence of everything. Yes, talking about any possible universe now. This is not any ...
I will put aside any question of possible imprecision of the formulations, I will assume that the Kant's intentions can be understood intuitively reasonably precisely. Kant gives two forms of the categorical imperative: Behave in such a way that a reasonable generalization of your action to a universal rule will lead ...
Superrational decision making is a type of rational decision making in which the players cooperate in a one-shot prisoner's dilemma without coordination, punishment, or magical thinking. The idea is that when playing a symmetric prisoner's dilemma, one assumes that there is a unique solution to the mathematical problem...
The principle of explosion is the law of classical logic and similar systems of logic, according to which any statement can be proven from a contradiction. Some early formal systems like Frege's Begriffsschrift contained hidden contradictions in the basic axioms, but the fundamental problem doesn't vanish even if the b...
After reading about Kuhn's work, this question still keeps me wondering: Have there really been paradigm shifts, like Kuhn states? The examples of paradigm shifts often include the switch from geocentrism to heliocentrism, and of course Newtonian mechanics to the theory of relativity. However, I don't find these exampl...
What are some possible problems with Martin Heidegger's critique of aesthetics, and how might one go about arguing against it? More specifically, what are some of the common arguments that have been made in response by other philosophers? Where can I find references to some of their arguments?
Consider the following argument: Proposition 1: The language of physics (as an empirical science) is mathematics. I think this should be uncontroversial to the majority of working physicists. Proposition 2: That the mathematics used in physics will eventually be formalised in the way that mathematicians use mathemat...
Suppose some ontological theory creates an infinite regress. Take, for example, Platon's concept of ideas, and then there must be some connection between idea and its actualisation, and then this connection must have an idea, etc. One could then criticise this theory on the basis that it creates an infinite regress of ...
Early formal systems like Frege's Begriffsschrift or Peano's work on the axiomatization of the natural numbers used axiom systems with an underlying second-order predicate logic (from today's point of view). Why were these second-order logic systems given up in favor of first-order predicate logic? After all, second-or...
When thinking of cycles and myths, one cannot pass the idea of Kronos or Kali. That brought me to form some questions about the nature of time. Three definitions for time: Time is a measure of the change. Change is a result of the forces. Time can be understood as a consciousness of history—present and future—which em...
Which authors and works might be most important for introducing the philosophy of education? In other words, which (works, authors) expound the development of the most significant or critical notions and principles? What introductory literature might be considered authoritative or canonical?
There are many questions in philosophy of the following kind: Does my friend have a soul, or is my friend a zombie? Is the mind separate from the body, or is it the same? Where does the universe come from? These questions have the property that, whatever the hypothetical answer would be, every one of your perceptions...
Which brand of skepticism is the hardest to refute or argue against? What argument has given the other theories of knowledge the hardest time?
I'm currently studying Locke's theory of personal identity and wondered if his writing rejected the idea that people had temporal parts. Does anyone have any references that would support the idea that Locke assumed people did not have temporal parts?
Does the too many thinkers problem present a counter-argument to John Locke's account of personal identity, if we apply it to his conceptions of Man and Person? If so, how might Locke answer this objection? Does he think that only the person (and not the man) can think, so there is no problem? EDIT: The problem doesn't...
According to Wikipedia, there is no account of how the sphericity of the Earth was established. Though it goes on to say 'A plausible explanation is that it was "the experience of travellers that suggested such an explanation for the variation in the observable altitude and the change in the area of circumpolar stars, ...
Lacan's notion of the mirror stage seems to rely directly on the ability of the child to see. Some are born blind, so they do not have the opportunity to "see" their self-image in a mirror. A similar case could be made for children in an Amazonian tribe. They wouldn't have access to mirrors, nor to other reflecting su...
The Prometheus myth can be interpreted as consciousness being a burden. Camus used the myth of Sisyphus to debate the same issue. It is the theme of a famous speech from Hamlet. Heidegger talks of being thrown into the world, of being as that which being is a problem. The story in Genesis, of eating of the tree of know...
What, specifically, is the problem with circular logic/reasoning? I think it's invalid. For some reason, everyone knows that it's wrong to use, but is there anything more to it than that? Additionally, where can I find journal articles or papers that discuss this issue?
The Wikipedia entry on Neoplatonism says: Neoplatonists would have considered themselves simply Platonists, and the modern distinction is due to the perception that their philosophy contained sufficiently unique interpretations of Plato to make it substantially different from what Plato wrote and believed. Wha...
We're biologically incapable of ignoring our senses. I want to clarify what I mean by this, because as posters have suggested we actually can do so, for example by blinding or gouging our eyes. I'm talking about ignoring our senses by a pure act of will. One of course could argue that an act of will is involved in blin...
I'm interested in sources discussing the obligations we have to be "beneficent", e.g. through charitable donations. Famine, Affluence and Morality is one of the more famous articles of this type. SEP has an overview as well. I am more interested in utilitarian-based reasoning, and things discussing what the "common man...
From a scientific (not religious) standpoint, what are (if any) the fundamental differences between humans and other animals? EDIT In my opinion, there is no fundamental difference between humans and other animals at the level of biology. Hence, I'm not asking a biological question. I'm curious if there are any philoso...
Is it accurate to characterize Aristotle's Poetics as the first work of literary criticism, or does something earlier than this survive—fragmented or otherwise? Poetics goes through what a work of literature is, defines them in terms of two types (epic and dramatic), as well as giving us a glimpse of the 'fringe' (scie...
Having read a bit of Borges's poetry, I know that Borges read and admired Spinoza. Having listened to his Harvard lectures about poetry, I know that he had sort of passing acquaintance with some elements of Chinese philosophy. But something tells me that he had one or two philosophers he knew quite well. Who could thes...
I'd like a succinct comparison of the two "-isms", though I know this is a tall order.
There is a passage that I could not possibly regard as anything other than intriguing in David Bohm's "Wholeness and the Implicate Order", and I would like to share it with the esteemed readers of this forum. The passage occurs in the chapter "Fragmentation and Wholeness" and goes "Now, in the East the notion of measur...
Rational choice theory has been criticised on the grounds that "consumers are not rational, so doesn't make much sense because utility functions can't model consumer preferences." But is there actual evidence on the utility of utility functions? Are there studies one can point to and say "look, we have reason to believ...
Normative questions are those which: affirm how things should or ought to be, how to value them, which things are good or bad, which actions are right or wrong. Normative is usually contrasted with positive (i.e. descriptive, explanatory, or constative) claims when describing types of theories, beliefs, or pro...
I read about Cox's theorem a long time ago in "Jaynes Probability Theory: The Logic of Science". It was used to justify the so-called "logical" interpretation of probability. My impression was that the theorem assumes an existent world where every proposition is either true of false, and our limited certainty about th...
There is some confusion in my philosophy class about Nietzsche's statements on physics in section 14 of Beyond Good and Evil. The specific portion in question is below, although as with all of Nietzsche, context matters: It is perhaps just dawning on five or six minds that physics, too, is only an interpretation and e...
I don't have much background in philosophy, but I recently read an interesting paper about "emergence" (Anderson, 1972). In that paper, Anderson relates to the "reductionist" hypothesis. When and by whom was this hypothesis first elucidated? Wikipedia and other sources did not state any origin, so I guess it must have ...
Why does Kant equate "conservation" with "happiness" near the start of "Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysics of Morals"? These seem like very different things (especially looking through an evolutionary lens). I would agree that reasons doesn't promote a purpose in promoting happiness, but is quite useful in promo...
If a man makes a lot of money supporting a business that pollutes the environment, and then spends the money supporting environmentally focused charities, is he good or evil? What does philosophy say about this kind of behavior?
This question of highest importance for everybody could not be answered in MO and will not be answered in Mathematics.SE. I can understand why the set-theorists there dive and attack it like vultures. I feel very sorry. Perhaps the prevailing understanding of logic and tolerance is here more suitable? Background: Göde...
When people speak about disrupting action, an action that often goes against the commonly accepted moral laws, the pople that comes to my mind are Nietzsche, D'Annunzio, Marinetti and the Italian Futurism. Are there any ancient Greek philosophers who had similar thoughts? In this answer I read: According to Epicurus,...
I was reading this article on the concept of "Gurus" in various religions, and the following quotation regarding Sikhism caught my attention: On the importance of guru, Nanak says: "Let no man in the world live in delusion. Without a Guru none can cross over to the other shore." I am having difficulty understanding...
Evolution seems to be commonly associated with genetic change which leads to the improved reproductive success of a species. This concept has itself evolved with the work of Richard Dawkins and others to possibly include ideas, cultural traits, or even business practices. In this question, I'm making the assumption th...
The story went, a king dreamt he was a pauper every night, and a pauper dreamt he was a king every night. The philosopher asked whether there was a difference between the two.
Kierkegaard and Nietzsche are often treated together as early existentialists. This is rather odd, as Kierkegaard was self-consciously seeking to be an orthodox Christian, and Nietzsche was self-consciously seeking to destroy Christianity. Nevertheless, after reading only a little bit of Nietzsche I have seen some par...
Is it possible for people to actually be selfless? It seems that in many cases where someone is being kind, they are actually performing in a manner that will benefit them. Either the recipient of the kindness will reciprocate, or the act of kindness itself is deemed commendable. Therefore, the one who offered the kind...
I am reading the novel A Clockwork Orange. The priest is very angry at the behavior-altering technique being used on criminals to make them "good" and feels as though it is not right to take away free will, even from a murderer. He also argues that the person hasn't actually changed, and that perhaps their soul is stil...
In his Meditations on First Philosophy, Rene Descartes resolved to systematically doubt that any of his beliefs were true. This was done in order to build a system of belief that would consist of only true beliefs. It appears that the ability to doubt is the core foundation of Descartes's philosophy. But did Descartes ...
David Lewis' conception of abundant properties which he identifies with sets/classes ("no matter how oddly defined") is not quite clear to me. Since according to this position there cannot be - in no possible world - two different properties with the same extensions (according to the extensionality principle). Especial...
Consider this quote by Marcus Aurelius: Art thou angry with him whose armpits stink ? art thou angry with him whose mouth smells foul ? What good will this anger do thee ? He has such a mouth, he has such arm- pits: it is necessary that such an emanation must come from such things: but the man has reason, ...